Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Thomas Kretschmar, Martin Tzschaschel - The Power of Inner Pictures - How Imagination Can Maintain Physical and Mental Health-Karnac Books (2016)
Thomas Kretschmar, Martin Tzschaschel - The Power of Inner Pictures - How Imagination Can Maintain Physical and Mental Health-Karnac Books (2016)
CHAPTER TITLE I
THE POWER OF
INNER PICTURES
KRETSCHMAR Prelims_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:27 Page ii
KRETSCHMAR Prelims_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:27 Page iii
THE POWER OF
INNER PICTURES
How Imagination Can
Maintain Physical and
Mental Health
www.karnacbooks.com
KRETSCHMAR Prelims_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:27 Page v
CONTENTS
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS vii
INTRODUCTION xi
CHAPTER ONE
The surprising power of representations 1
CHAPTER TWO
How internal images heal us 21
CHAPTER THREE
Catathym imaginative psychotherapy 57
CHAPTER FOUR
Examples from therapy and practice:
how catathym imaginative psychotherapy helps 91
v
KRETSCHMAR Prelims_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:27 Page vi
vi CONTENTS
CHAPTER FIVE
Outlook: imagination can do even more 143
REFERENCES 147
INDEX 151
KRETSCHMAR Prelims_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:27 Page vii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
vii
KRETSCHMAR Prelims_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:27 Page viii
KRETSCHMAR Prelims_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:27 Page ix
Martin Tzschaschel, born 1954, is a journalist and has been the editor
of P.M., a popular German scientific journal, since 1981. In addition,
he has written three books, of which a book about a new version of
knowledge we learn in school is now in its fifth edition. Martin is
devoted to making complicated scientific findings understandable for
the public. Prior to this, Martin studied social pedagogy in Munich
and worked as a journalist for several journals. He lives in Hamburg,
Germany.
ix
KRETSCHMAR Prelims_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:27 Page x
KRETSCHMAR Prelims_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:27 Page xi
Introduction:
to whom is this book addressed?
xi
KRETSCHMAR Prelims_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:27 Page xii
xii INTRODUCTION
Useful methods for daily self-practice are also offered for those who
wish to gain access to their own inner powers.
The following section shows an example of a brief journey.
INTRODUCTION xiii
CHAPTER TITLE 1
CHAPTER ONE
n this chapter, you will learn the role that internal pictures play
What a rather unusual evening: two couples who are friends are
seated in a restaurant, unable to see what they are eating. Everything
is completely dark. Soft chunks—do they taste like carrots? Or are they
potatoes? “No, I believe they’re soft-boiled pears”, a woman speaks
out into the pitch-black, her voice muffled by the food inside her
mouth. She sounds uncertain.
If everyone could see the servings on her plate, their doubts would
vanish, but the friends are dining in a darkened restaurant, astonished
by the defeat of their gustatory senses.
1
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 2
We can create a big bonfire with every issue of Vogue, GQ and Details,
every image of Kate Moss, Naomi Campbell, and Cindy Crawford,
and still, images of youthful perfect bodies would take shape in our
heads and create a desire to have them. No one is immune. (Etcoff,
2001, p. 6)
that crashed into the World Trade Centre in New York City. Everyone
who saw the images for the first time will still remember what was
going on around them in that particular moment. The events of that
day are accompanied by strong feelings of anxiety and shock, which
recur to us in the form of an inner picture.
The effectiveness of a representation “depends upon emotional
intensity and quality of image”, declares Bernt Hoffmann (Hoffmann,
1997, p. 162), a medical practitioner, psychotherapist, and autogenic-
training teacher with many years of working experience. Just how
vigorous inner pictures can get, if imagination and emotion become
tightly engaged, has been described by the novelist Gustace Flaubert
(1821–1880) while writing his internationally successful novel Madame
Bovary. In a letter to Hippolyte Taine, in which Flaubert answers his
friend’s question about the nature of his great imaginative powers, he
writes,
child were to see both a snake and a rabbit for the first time, it would
be unlikely that he describes the snake as “sweet” and the rabbit as
“scary”. A collective repertoire of images, shared innately by all
humans, is our first guidance of the world. The conscious possession
of these primal pictures is not experienced.
Carl Jung, founder of analytical psychology (which developed
alongside Sigmund Freud’s psychoanalysis), termed the assemblage
of memories shared by all humans the “collective unconscious”. It is
“part of the psyche which can be negatively distinguished from a
personal unconscious by the fact that it does not, like the latter, owe
its existence to personal experience and consequently is not a personal
acquisition” (Jung, 1969, p. 42).
Jung describes his Archetypes as part of the collective unconscious.
According to his theory, they consist of predetermined structures
of our psyche, commonly shared through forms, pictures, legends,
and histories from all people of all cultures. Through some miraculous
design, they persist inside us, eternalising our ancestral memories,
thousands of years old. Examples of symbolic figures that are rooted
in the unconscious include angels, hell, the wise old woman, paradise,
and the circle as a symbol of eternity. “The archetype structures
are imprinted in the people”, says Grün (2011, translated for this
edition). “They balance the soul. They lead them to their own centre
and true self of man” (p. 24).
the self. We get in touch with our deepest feelings, strongest desires,
and darkest secrets. We can sort through ideas and notions and
process experiences, losses, and pain.
Scientists have determined that daydreams actually occur far more
often than people seem to realise. American psychologists estimate we
drift off so many times a day that, in any given hour, we submerge
into daydreams for twenty-eight out of sixty minutes. Sexual fantasies
commonly take up most of our time. This figure includes both sexes,
although men take the lead in this particular daydream: during a large
survey, conducted by the British Sexual Fantasy Research Project,
thirty-nine per cent of participants admitted fantasising about sexual
acts they would not commit in real life. This was also true for nineteen
per cent of all female participants, not to mention the estimates for
undetected cases: men and women are either unaware of their sexual
daydreams or unwilling to admit them.
Just as with “proper” (nightly) dreams, the brain does not rest dur-
ing daydreaming. On the contrary, synapses from far located regions
of the brain fire intensely and uninterruptedly, eliciting a reason why
the brain’s monologues take about twenty times the energy of a
conscious, single thought. This is the rate calculated by the neurolo-
gist Marcus Raichle according to Heiko Ernst in the German edition
of Psychology Today (Ernst, 2014, p. 45, translated for this edition). In
any case, daydreams are not always helpful. Whether or not they are,
depends entirely on the person and their current psychological state.
Positive daydreams (“I’ll apply for a new job and then things will
start looking up”) can cause an otherwise unmotivated individual to
develop an “unrealistic optimism”, scientist Thomas Langens from
the University of Wuppertal states in an interview with the authors.
In this case, the person is deceiving himself: he is convinced that he
will achieve his goal, even if he does not put in the required amount
of work. Others may, when daydreaming of an achievement, be over-
come by negativity and indifference “I’ll never make it anyway”.
On the other hand, highly motivated individuals can benefit
greatly from daydreams. For them, the imaginings act as incentives
and become internalised goals, achievable through willpower and
exercise. If they play out and repeat their prospective wins in their
fantasies, they will score noticeably higher than without mental
preparation.
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 11
of the first group had practised exercising their fingers regularly, the
second group had not used their fingers at all, and the third group
were instructed merely to imagine the finger exercise.
Their results after four weeks showed that the participants who
had exercised were able to increase their muscle power by thirty per
cent, while those that had not prepared at all displayed no significant
difference regarding their performance. Remarkably, the individuals
in the group that had only imagined the finger training were able to
improve their muscle power by sixteen per cent.
During another trial, participants were asked to lift various
weights. Depending on which weight the group leader chose to be
lifted next, the muscle tension of the participant would adjust in
preparation.
The power behind representations is not only demonstrated in
sports. The psychologist Hans Eberspächer describes the impressive
case of a pilot, who was supposed to fly a Boeing 737 from Munich to
Mallorca, in his book “Being Best, When It Counts” (2011). During
climb and shortly after take-off, the pilot notices one of the jet engines
leaking oil, resulting in total loss of function. Horrifying. However, the
captain is trained and prepared in the case of such events. Not only
has he experienced them many times in flight simulation, but during
his daily commute to work—on his bicycle. Over and over, he would
play out the event in his head, down to the smallest detail, until every
step of the emergency intervention would be etched on his brain.
During a crisis, the pilot is optimally prepared. Although he can
feel his pulse rising and his breath shortening, he is able to remember
the rules of his training. Instead of making a rash decision, he forces
himself to wait for a second and a half, just as he had practised in
training; now he needs to use the flaps of the wing’s trailing edge to
manoeuvre the aircraft out of the inclined position. Next, he performs
a slight nosedive and, with a short correction of the rudder at the rear
end, he relieves the strain on the flaps.
The aircraft is in a stable position. Calmly, the pilot turns on his
speaker to inform the passengers, “I was totally cool and relaxed
during that moment. Mentally, I was riding my bike along the river,
birds were chirping around me, and I was able to re-enact my train-
ing” (Eberspächer, 2011, p. 162, translated for this edition).
This is not the only situation where inner pictures have helped
in keeping a cool head, saving lives in an emergency situation. A
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 13
I open the lid, a strong smell will spread,” he explains. “I would like
to test how quickly you perceive it. Please clearly raise your hands as
soon as the cloud of odour has reached you.” He adds, “Short bouts
of nausea are likely.”
A short while later, a raised arm appears in the front row. More
follow behind and the longer the stench spreads in a V-shape across
the plenum, the more students raise their arm. Three people actually
rush out to the lavatories.
The professor reveals his secret a few minutes later: the flask
contained odourless water.
This experiment was repeated in different places, but the results
were always the same. Subsequent reactions included being irritated.
The participants asked, “Are we that easy to manipulate?” The answer
to this question might shake our belief in a distinctively analytical,
critically judging individual not being misled so easily, yet it leaves no
room for doubt. Inner pictures, invoked by others, can lead to unbe-
lievable effects and, in extreme cases, death.
In 2006, a twenty-six-year-old man from Mississippi decided to
commit suicide after his girlfriend left him. He swallowed twenty-nine
capsules of a strong medication he had received as a participant in
a clinical trial. As he was taken into the medical centre in Jackson, he
was in a critical condition and his blood pressure had fallen drastically.
While the doctors are fighting for his life, a hospital member
contacted the supervisor of the drug trial to ask what substances the
patient had consumed. The supervisor pulled out the files and res-
ponded: none. The patient was part of the control group that had
received placebos, a medication with no pharmacological effect.
The mere belief that he had ingested a lethal amount of pills
brought the suicidal man to the brink of death.
As soon as he had been told that the twenty-nine capsules he took
consisted entirely of starch and milk powder, his condition improved
immediately. He was able to leave the ER shortly after and return to
his home.
In both cases (of the bad odour and of the placebo), the people that
were affected had not been in charge of the representations.
Unconsciously, they had handed the control of their self to another,
who, in turn, exerted the suggestive influence.
Still, suggestions can be positive and also sought out; therapists
use them to benefit their clients, as in the case of hypnosis. In any
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 16
“Silke had a theme: ‘Easy already exists’. It was time to turn it up,”
Hatz explains in an interview with the authors. Meaning: up until
now had been easy, the hard part lay ahead. This inner conviction
allowed the runner to endure the pain and the salt in her open
wounds. Silke Seecamp had internalised the phrase before the run; it
was as if she lived and breathed it. Because of it, she knew that, no
matter what, she would make it to the end.
Athletes and coaches agree that this form of inner dialogue always
needs to be phrased positively. That is, a marathon runner should
never say, “I’m too slow”, but, instead, “I am getting faster!” This
strategy is also proliferating among the type of therapists that choose
to focus less on the negative aspects of a client’s situation than on the
positive. One core idea of solution orientated psychology promotes
finding out which methods have worked well in the past and repeat-
ing them.
Because the brain deems the inner world as equal to the outside
one, the former can just as much influence our mood and behaviour,
as well as our bodies and regenerative powers. Further yet, it is our
“headquarters”, which controls everything, as demonstrated so
impressively in the following example.
If, for instance, a trial subject repeatedly performs an exercise with
a finger of one hand, then this will mark a trail inside the brain. The
area of the brain responsible for the finger movement (motor cortex)
will begin to grow. This also happens if the subject only imagines the
exercises, rather than actually doing them.
A particularly effective way to make inner pictures release their
powers is if they are created in a state of physical relaxation, as
opposed to when being swayed by emotion. This is strongly apparent
in dreams, where two brain areas are most active: the visual centre in
the cortex, which creates our dream images, and the limbic system,
“headquarters” of our feelings. Other brain regions, as far as they are
linked to our sense of time or logical cognitive reasoning, remain rela-
tively inactive.
In the case of mild relaxation, the brain waves move (oscillate) in
a so-called alpha rhythm (see list below). If relaxation increases, they
change into the theta rhythm: this happens when we are about to drift
into sleep and our thoughts escape reality. The brain usually moves in
theta waves when it is dreaming. This state seems to be the optimum
in order for the visualisation of inner pictures to occur.
CHAPTER TWO
21
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 22
Since success rates are high and the biofeedback training is consid-
ered to be free of side effects, patients tend to react positively to the
approach. Not only does it work for curing headaches, it is also effec-
tive in affecting the outcome of the following: peristaltic bowel move-
ment (in the case of diarrhoea or constipation), breathing, pelvic floor
muscle control (for bladder weakness), productivity of sweat glands,
back pains, impulsive neuronal activity (with ADHA), abnormal heart
rate, or even high blood pressure.
Biofeedback tends to work in a more localised manner than medi-
cal drugs, which often induce side effects for the whole body rather
than targeting only the affected areas. Biofeedback, in addition, has
achieved positive outcomes for people who experienced difficulty in
mastering other relaxation exercises. Once the patients felt that they
could reclaim control over their bodies as they watched this happen
on screen (or heard it in the case of acoustic tones), this would moti-
vate them to continue. This sense of achievement would contribute
positively to the healing process.
Children often find the biofeedback training less difficult than
adults, as it is in their nature to embrace imaginative games with
fewer inhibitions and a greater capacity for fantasy. Adults with limi-
ted imagination, in particular, would find the work in biofeedback dif-
ficult, especially those who had difficulty remembering their dreams.
It seems as if creative abilities are key in binding the gap between
body and mind in the biofeedback process.
Once someone is adept at it, they realise just how substantial psy-
chic powers are in helping the body back to health, just as has been
proved by numerous medical studies.
This is also true for all other therapeutic methods that are intro-
duced in the following chapters of this book: their results are equally
impressive (although this will not be seen in the form of two bars
moving toward each other on a screen).
(Reddemann, 2007, p. 16, translated for this edition). With the use of
imagination, she was able to help a large group of patients who were
affected by deep emotional pain to achieve stability. The ability to
fantasise is an extremely effective tool, “that reaches for the regenera-
tive sources inside us” (Reddemann, 2007, p. 16, translated for this
edition). Thanks to inner pictures, says Reddemann, it is possible to
create inner spaces for solace, help, and strength, self-contained and
unimpeded by the fluctuations of our environment. Reddemann and
many other therapists know from experience that, instead of just look-
ing at the origin of problems when dealing with psychological dis-
eases, it is also important to focus on positive events of the past.
This also includes patients who have been traumatised in their
past. They, too, have reported positive situations, feelings of luck, and
emotional security. In their book, “Imagination as a Healing Power”,
Luise Reddemann and colleagues recommend holding firmly on to
such moments so that they can diffuse through the body:
Even if the pain in someone’s life might often outweigh the good, that
person will discover how regenerating it is to concentrate on more
than just the negative. The ability to heal your own pain is not
achieved by solely focusing on your illness, but on your positive feel-
ings. (Reddemann et al., 2007, p. 33, translated for this edition)
So, does that mean if we set our mind towards the positive and
only maintain our optimism, all bad energy, negativity, and every-
thing debilitating will effectively dissolve into thin air?
Such “positive thinking” is described as the universal remedy. The
first to believe this was the French pharmacist, Emile Coué, who, in
the 1920s, was able to help numerous sick people by advising them to
repeat a particular sentence to themselves. The news of the effect of
his advice spread and he was invited to speak on his ideas in various
European cities. Eventually, a society was founded in his name, to
teach the methods he advocated.
The autosuggestive sentence repeated in thought was: “I feel better
and better every day and in every aspect” (Coué, 1922, p. 11).
Yet, although this simple sentence may help certainly people, most
therapists today dismiss it; including Luise Reddemann, the psycho-
oncologist, Elmar Reuter, and the therapists of the Mind Institute
Berlin (along with its CEO, Thomas Kretschmar, one of the authors of
this book). They claim that playing make-believe is not the solution.
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 25
I can report from experience how positive thinking has helped thou-
sands overcome terrible situations, how those people have managed
to recognise the value of their thoughts and how they strove to put
them to use. On the other hand, there is no use in believing ‘I am
healthy and succeeding’ when the person knows very well that he or
she is, in actual fact, seriously ill. Thinking this ‘just to see what might
happen!’ makes doubt the prevailing emotion instead of a positive
attitude. (Freitag, 1983, p. 181, translated for this edition)
2007, p. 33, translated for this edition). Reuter believes that positive
thinking, practised in addition to the process of dealing with the grief
caused by illness, “may take root eventually—from within and not
from the outside” (Reuter, 2010, p. 170, translated for this edition).
should raise their right arms when they greeted him again later in the
afternoon.
The group present had obeyed a “post-hypnotic order”. And the
professor had proved what he had described a few hours before: a
feature of hypnotic trance is the externally induced representation, the
so-called suggestion, which exercises control on the unconscious of
the hypnotised, even after the state has ended. The vital pre-condition
being that—just as with any form of suggestion—the performer is
willing to participate. To raise the right arm in greeting must have
seemed like something the group deemed feasible.
We all have our presumptions about hypnosis, even if we have
never experienced it first-hand. Those that try it for the first time are
usually surprised after they leave the state—they expect to feel more
“anaesthetised”.
Hypnosis means being neither asleep nor awake but somewhere in
between: a dozy state of rest, wherein the conscious is not clouded, as
in dreams, but still “limited” in some ways. All attention is on the
hypnotist, who promotes this limbo (“You’ll be aware of nothing but
my voice”). The person being hypnotised is prepared for the induced
alternative state and ready to be guided into it.
This occurs if the hypnotist manages to translocate the awareness
from out to in. He imposes a state of weightlessness (or heaviness),
which the patient then begins to assume. During the hypnotic state,
the perception is canalised; one aspect is central, all others disappear.
What happens during hypnosis seems real to the experiencer, and
this can be a great aid in psychotherapy: the hypnotherapist may try
to intervene in the process and actively alter its course with the
purpose of helping the client shift, and permanently change, his views
to those of a healthier perspective.
Case example: Katharina Kramer, clarinettist in the Hamburg
orchestra, wanted hypnotherapy in order to overcome the stage-fright
that haunted her every time she performed in front of an audience. In
trance, the therapist let her play her instrument to a crowd, in perfect
tune, feeling light as a feather, and anxiety-free. Two weeks later,
during an actual performance, the musician pictured this mental
image and felt completely fearless. She played one of her best concerts
in a long time.
The medical practitioner Bernt Hoffmann remembers treating
a young woman during his intern years. She had suffered from
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 34
regurgitation for several weeks, and was weakened to the point where
she could not leave her bed without assistance. The tests showed no
signs of organ dysfunction. However, she had told Hoffmann that she
was living under the same roof as her mother-in-law, along with her
husband and her two children. The mother-in-law was treating her
poorly, causing her to lose her appetite: “I feel sick just thinking of
her” (Hoffmann, 1997, p. 183)
The doctor put her into a trance and gave her a post-hypnotic
assignment: the next morning, her appetite would be restored, she
would eat, and her sickness would disappear for good. Indeed, this
was the case, and shortly after that the patient’s living conditions
improved; the mother-in-law moved out, and she managed to stay
healthy.
Who or what exactly had caused this effect? The therapist? The
method? The hypnosis? Yes, yes, and yes, and also the client herself.
It was her compliance that triggered the effect. Had she denied the
suggestion, it would not have worked.
It has been estimated that a proportion of ten to twenty per cent of
all people are strictly resistant to hypnosis, another ten per cent,
however, are particularly amenable to it—this does not mean that they
are gullible; they simply have an active imagination.
The modern theory of hypnosis was substantially defined through
the work of the American doctor Milton H. Erickson (1901–1980). It is
to his credit that hypnotists are no longer regarded as authoritarian
rulers over powerless victims, harshly blackmailing change into
people (“If you start drinking again, you will feel sick!”). It was
Erickson’s recommendation that every therapist should adjust to the
individual needs of the clients: every person already possessed a
repertoire of experience, skill, and adjustment capabilities for solving
individual problems. A successful hypnotherapy would mean that the
therapists would merely have to access the experiences and the client
would come up with a personal solution. Erickson shifted the para-
digm from “therapy from above” to “therapy at equal level”.
That being a good hypnotherapist means more than just uttering a
few suggestions has been described in detailed accounts of the expe-
riences of Wolfgang Blohm. He was the first medical doctor to open a
specialised hypnosis clinic in Germany, on the Island of Föhr, in 1998.
In his book, “Self-Hypnosis and Hypnotherapy”, he describes the case
of a secretary who reportedly suffered through years with migraines.
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 35
Pain medication, which had been her usual remedy, had since failed
her, too, and their side effects were becoming a problem.
Several sessions later, it was clear that the thirty-eight-year-old
was an ambitious, diligent, and dependable employee, with a constant
need to demonstrate perfection. She would spend more time in her
office than with her husband. Dr Blohm decided he could not merely
make the suggestion that the patient just take things “easier”: rather
than a short command, he gave a speech. With caution, he re-told the
situation she was in through the “eyes” of the people around her.
“Your standards are high; this is all well and good”, Blohm said.
“However, one appointment is piled on top of the next”, he continued,
“and this allows little room to de-stress, so that one might feel the
pressure at some point or another, from time to time” (Blohm, 2006,
p. 96, translated for this edition).
While the patient listened to her situation being described, she felt
that she had been heard. Finally, this opened her up to the suggestion
Blohm gave next—a little mental aid she would carry around in her
imagination, ready to use when the need arose: “You may now use a
manometer that allows you to measure the pressure you feel during
your day” (Blohm, 2006, p. 96, translated for this edition). This instru-
ment, which had been “installed” in her trance, would now allow her
to become aware of the pressure she was under—something she had
not been able to feel before.
The therapy continued; more sessions followed. During another
session, the doctor suggested an idea that would appeal to his
patient’s perfectionism, elegantly turning the problem around in order
to put it to better use: from now on, she would practise being perfect
in the art of serenity.
It took some time until her migraine attacks subsided, but eventu-
ally they were reduced to one attack per year.
This is where the strength of hypnosis comes into light: it creates
a space in our imagination wherein healing, sometimes unusual, pic-
tures can be created. (This is also true for other imaginative therapy
methods that will be introduced in Chapter Three.)
Inner pictures such as the manometer can be created by the thera-
pist and also by the client: for example, in the fantasised form of “true
memories”. This way, they can be experienced as real. One patient,
who suffered from painful seizures in his ribcage for which the doc-
tors could find no medical explanation, witnessed himself in the midst
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 36
of a medieval battle scene during his trance; his ribcage had been
pierced by a spear. He was certain this was a picture from his past
life. The therapist used this notion to suggest that the spear wound
could now be recognised and the healing could begin. The pain had
vanished.
The laws of logic and reason are inoperative during hypnosis.
The capacities of real memories seem infinitely available to our
dreams, together with memories that appear real, but are actually
made up.
The American psychologist Martin Orne demonstrated the exis-
tence of such false memories when he asked a number of hypnotised
students to think back to their sixth birthday. He compared their vivid
narrations with the accounts of parents, siblings, and other family
members. The results showed that the students tended to embellish
their stories when under hypnosis. One of the male participants des-
cribed how he spoke English on his birthday, when, in fact, he had
learnt the language at an older age. For a therapy to work, however,
it is irrelevant whether or not the lifelike “memories” are true or false.
More often even, the therapist will deliberately search for pictures that
confuse or disrupt the client’s idea of logic thinking. The intention
behind this is to reveal patterns of the soul and to destabilise its
wayward habits.
What matters is whether or not a trance-induced memory is actu-
ally helping the client. This is the case more often than not. Studies
show the effectiveness of hypnosis for a range of afflictions such as
amnesia, irritable colon, eating disorders, migraines, and various
other types of pain.
This being said, it should be mentioned that hypnosis can have the
opposite effect when in the wrong hands. The following example will
demonstrate what can happen when the hypnotist misses his mark. A
student was struggling with test anxiety and wanted to alleviate his
stress in time for a forthcoming examination—an intervention method
which is usually successfully practised in hypnosis. The hypnotist
suggested that there was no need for the young man to worry about
the exam, and that he should not take matters too seriously. The
student took him at his word; he calmed down, stopped paying atten-
tion to his revision and the forthcoming test—and failed.
Thus, finding a good hypnotist is invaluable and replicating her
work can often be difficult. Yet, in some cases, practising self-hypnosis
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 37
them and thank them for carrying out their service.” The training in
visualisation had helped her achieve this communication.
Simonton’s method is less mechanical than it might appear at
first. The therapist, who died in 2009, did not have the intention of
combating cancer with picture representations à la “particles shoot
tumour cells”. Further, he explained his belief to the patients that
mental disturbances were often the root of cancer development and
that his therapy would include treating those disturbances: an effec-
tive therapy is one that regards the human “in his entirety”, and not
just as a physically ill body.
Subsequently, “the whole system of body, spirit, and emotion”
should be considered in the process of healing. If cancer can have psy-
chological causes, says Simonton, and if, for example, stress causes
tumours, then other powers within the body must be able to remove
the tumours.
To this day, the “Simonton method” is applied in mental exercises
that aim at fighting the cancerous cells. One commonly suggested way
is to let patients imagine how a cohort of knights attack and destroy
the malevolent cells. When the American patient Margaret G reported
pains in her chest, the doctors ordered scans that revealed an unusual
mass on her thymus gland. She decided to challenge her sickness
mentally and turned to a clinic that offered treatment with Simonton’s
therapy. The specialists there told her to imagine sharks that eat away
her cancer cells.
Towards the end of her stay, the patient experienced a vision
she had not expected: she pictured the tissue mass underneath her
sternum as a block of ice that began melting away unusually fast.
“Never before had I conjured such an image, so clearly, all in my
head. I knew then and there that the drops of melting ice were
tears.”
Although she had suffered in her past, Margaret had not been able
to cry, as long as she could remember. “Suddenly, all the pressure and
problems just melted away; the deaths in my family, the abuse during
my childhood, the unresolved issues with my ex-husband. All these
emotions had now been given back to me, and they were vast and
strong.”
Four months later, the MRI scanner revealed that the aggressive
mass had disappeared. Margaret had not undergone any other form
of treatment during that time.
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 45
heat up the shrunken tumours, so that they would dry up. I really
turned up the heat, I boiled them” (Erstling, 2011, p. 106)
However, he was not yet healed; new cancer cells had developed
inside the abdomen. Werner had already seen them grow and could
feel their presence before the computer scans could detect them. The
new tumour reached a size of thirteen centimetres and the doctors
began pressing for different measures, but Melle was positive: “I
knew I could do it again”. Three to five times daily, he would work on
his routine, “I gave that tumour trouble at every opportunity I had. I
pared away the tumour’s supply channels, and then treated them with
heat, again and again” (Erstling, 2011, p. 107, translated for this
edition).
The following CT inspection showed that the tumour had reduced
to eight centimetres in size. One year later, it had shrunk to the size of
a chickpea. Werner Melle looks back at his story today and concludes,
“To me, imaginative body psychotherapy is not counterfactual. In fact,
it is the reason I am still alive” (Erstling, 2011, p. 108, translated for
this edition). He has been free of cancer for over six years.
Judging from the outside, it is hard to believe that patients are able
to look into their inside and are able to see and feel the development
of new metastases. Yet it happens all the time, as doctors have
witnessed again and again. Erstling’s book is about these patients and
the use of IBP (“Treating cancer with inner pictures”, 2011). He, too,
found it hard to believe that patients were able to visualise the inside
of their bodies and see the changes as if looking at an X-ray: he used
to think something like this would be impossible.
Not every patient develops this ability, and it is not a prerequisite
for a successful therapy either. IBP therapists such as Bärbel Gühne
have seen patients’ cancer subside even without the patients being
able to see pictures of their inner body. If this specific process were to
be necessary, if we were to need a realistic, anatomically correct repre-
sentation of our bodies to apply the cancer treatment, then this exer-
cise would, by definition, no longer be imagination and we would
move on to something else entirely.
One of Bärbel Gühne’s patients described how she imagined her
thymus gland as a classroom full of students receiving an education
in cancer defence (this was probably her translated analogy of the con-
version of stem cells into white blood cells). A lot of clients experience
varying pictures and thoughts throughout their therapy. An organ can
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 50
transform into all different kinds of shapes and colours in the imagi-
nation.
For IBP and any other effective therapy, one thing is certain: every
person in therapy will have to figure out their own way to get a sense
of what is best for them. And, in order to reach this conclusion, the
patient needs guidelines and instructions to progress, before he can
continue outside of therapy. To get a better idea of imaginative body
psychotherapy, an abbreviated account of a personal session has been
chosen as an example:
Step 1. Relaxation. For example, using autogenic training. (Other
recommended methods include progressive muscle relaxation
according to Jacobson or the concentrative meditation.) The
client is seated or lying down comfortably, eyes closed.
Step 2. Picturing how the bone marrow produces stem cells in the
skullcap, the shoulder blades, the long bones of the arms and
legs, inside the spine, ribs, and in the pelvic region.
Step 3. Feel and activate the thymus gland (behind the sternum),
thereby picturing how the stem cells are being converted to T-
lymphocytes (white blood cells), and, more specifically, into
the T-killer cells and T-helper cells.
Step 4. The lymphocytes enter the blood flow and then the spleen;
here they are multiplied and stored.
Step 5. The T-helper cells now permanently circulate inside the blood
and through the body, looking out for forms of virus, bacteria,
and particularly tumorous cells. Upon detection, they signal
the activation of T-killer cells and other immune cells (natural
killer cells, B-lymphocytes).
Step 6. These cells are directed towards the cancer cells. The B-
lymphocytes engulf the cancer cells and decompose them; the
natural killer cells, blunt soldiers, attack the cancer cells by
colliding with them; the T-killer cells coat the walls of the can-
cer cell formations and inject a substance inside the cell
membrane that decomposes it.
Step 7. Cutting and sealing off blood vessels that supply the tumour
or metastases.
Step 8. Clear out the place: picturing how scavenger cells (phago-
cytes) absorb debris, dead blood cells, and deconstructed can-
cer cells, taking them to the kidneys, where they are washed
away through the urinary tract and out of the body.
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 51
times per day, usually lasting an hour each time. Helmar Tal, an editor
from Munich, underwent surgery a few years ago in which he had a
neuroendocrine tumour removed from his colon. He started IBP
several months ago and, despite the metastases in his liver, he says he
feels completely healthy and that half an hour of daily exercise
suffices him.
Helmar is even able to sense his spleen and liver very intensely
upon imagining, just a few weeks into the treatment, although he also
admits that he was as yet unable to picture his metastases or perceive
any actual physical changes in them. Still, his scan showed that the
size of the cancer had shrunk, from 5.0 centimetres to 4.2 centimetres,
and, six months along, the cancer continues to retreat. Other meta-
stases are beginning to develop dark spots, which indicates that they
are starting to decay. The IBP is the only form of therapy the patient has
undergone, meaning that no other medical treatment has contributed
to his health improvement.
The fifty-eight-year-old describes looking at tiny, sharpened knives
that represent his T-cells at one time; the next time he sees them
as spherical shapes that latch on to the cancer and destroy it. When
Helmar Tal began imagining, he saw one major problem: it was very
difficult for him to imagine how the T-cells would dissolve away the
metastases, with the result that he would see the metastases again
in his next imagination. “If something is destroyed, it’s gone”, he
thought. “How can it remain in existence the next day, as if nothing
had happened?” This notion could not be changed, and he continued
to struggle with the task. He expected to picture the destruction of all
cancerous matter and be done with the idea thereafter. He also knew
that the process would never occur that quickly and easily. But what
could be done about it? How could he resolve this inner conflict?
The solution to this problem was provided by another cancer
patient, Ehrenfried Gier, who been free of cancer thanks to the work-
ings of IBP for many years: “Don’t expect it to work that way—it has
nothing whatsoever to do with logic” (Erstling, 2011, p. 4, translated
for this edition). Helmar began to understand; now he can switch off
his mind during his imagining.
There is a difference between picturing and perceiving. The things
that are imagined may be subjective and symbolical, far from actual
(anatomical) fact. What we perceive, on the other hand, is our momen-
tary understanding of our reality. “Ideally, the pictures we take of both
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 53
nerve channels of the left hand are largely connected to the right brain
hemisphere, and vice-versa. The right hemisphere is less involved in
rational thinking and logical reasoning, and more associated with
creative and emotional processes.
In the twenty-five years that Loesch has worked with IBP, he has
come to understand that some symbols have a very dramatic reference
to the life of the person. He remembers one occasion where a female
breast cancer patient would start to scream during her imagination
sessions. She had pictured her mother’s open grave, and how she was
terrified of falling into the hole in front of her. In later therapy, doctor
and patient would come up with the following counter-imagination:
she would allow her husband and daughter to reach out to her, she
would hold on to them for support on either side, and together they
would take a step back from the grave. This was also a giant
metaphorical leap for the patient, coming to terms with the events of
her past.
At the time Loesch had suggested this picture, and the client used
it in her imagination sessions, the therapist had moved on from imag-
inative body psychotherapy and towards a different method. This
method would provide a “soft” way to help his patient, focusing more
on the soul than on the body. This method is called catathym imagi-
native psychotherapy (CIP), also referred to as guided affective
imagery (GAI). IBP is derived from the CIP method. The third and
fourth chapter of this book are dedicated to more details about the
theory of CIP.
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 56
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 57
CHAPTER THREE
Catathym imaginative
psychotherapy
n this chapter, you will find out how to treat emotional disturbances
57
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 58
wish them goodbye and they fly out of the room, through the window.
One part of your mind will sink deeper and deeper into relaxation,
while another part is wide awake, forming pictures in front of your
inner eye.”
The therapists would recommend a specific image, for instance a
meadow. This is the canvas for the following daydream. All the while
the client describes what he sees and he answers the therapist’s ques-
tions (“How does the meadow look?”), he follows his lead (“Perhaps
you can step on to the grass”), and they remain in conversation even
though the client’s eyes remain closed and his thoughts remain in his
imagination.
The meadow becomes a space in which the client can allow scenes
and fantasies to come to him. There is no right or wrong at this point.
The therapist recognises the patient’s conflicts through his inner
pictures, and he encourages the client to closely examine the symbols
and images that appear to him. This will cause a change in the appear-
ance of some images. The changes pictured in the imaginations,
voluntarily created by the client, will have a positive effect on the con-
flicts in the client’s life; they will encourage positive changes in other
situations without the client being aware that his unconscious is work-
ing out these progressions for him.
In Karlsruhe, Germany, Dr Harald Ullmann (2009) documented an
imaginative experience of one of his clients: the picture starts off with
a bay and a motorboat. The client climbs into the boat and drives out
to sea. The engine of the boat is powerful and he has fun pushing up
the speed, feeling the force of the acceleration in his hands. “Hands on
the wheel”, this idea turns out to be one of the central themes for the
client: he lets go of his passive ways, sets his different plans into action
and takes the initiative as he fights to win back his estranged wife’s
affection—with success.
Impressive as such therapy outcomes may be, they do not happen
overnight or after the first successful imagination. Multiple sessions,
as well as briefings and debriefings about the imagination sessions
and drawings, are necessary to set the framework in therapy. Draw-
ings should be done after the end of a session. This way, the client can
keep track of his imaginings and give them a literal meaning.
Repressed memories stored in the unconscious start to lose their
underlying dominance only when they are brought up to the surface,
where they can be resolved. This can happen surprisingly quickly
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 59
The patient does not need to be asleep to expect true dream images.
They already begin to appear during a state of relaxation, half-sleep,
similar to the state of hypnosis, whereby the client still remains able
to talk to the therapist. (Freitag, 1983, p. 159, translated for this edition)
the patient. The drawing is a practice picture that allows for a first,
schematic analysis. The therapist receives a picture of the client’s
creative abilities and implicit emotional constitution. The explanations
the client gives of his first drawing are equally insightful—how he
feels towards it, or if he likes the scent of the flower, for example.
A flower is a simple symbol, one that is known by everyone. It is
represented as an inner picture for everyone, though with different
ideas and preferences for each individual.
How different these ideas sometimes are was shown in the draw-
ing of a flower by a fifty-year-old client: it was blue, made of wood,
placed inside a tin can, on a table. Using the flower as a practice exer-
cise is not a requirement, however, unlike the imagination of the stan-
dard pictures.
In the following section, you will be introduced to the standard
pictures of the basic level. The therapist usually chooses one symbol
for each of her sessions. A fixed order to providing the pictures is not
necessary. However, before the next level is agreed upon, all standard
pictures of the basic level should have been completed.
First session
The symbol of “the meadow” is pictured in the same way as any
mentally healthy person would picture it: it is green, large, sunny,
and the birds are chirping. It is a warm day in the month of May (the
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 67
Second session
After a short preliminary discussion, the therapist begins the session:
“Your thoughts appear, and vanish. One part of your mind will sink
deeper and deeper into relaxation, while another part is wide awake and
helps you to find your way back to your meadow.” Andy was to imagine
a stream running through his scenery. He describes a small brook, flow-
ing with fresh, clear water. It is May, and the weather is pleasant.
(T = Therapist; C = Client)
T: What would you like to do now?
C: Bathe. In the water.
T: Then go ahead.
Andy L steps into the water, which reaches up to his calves. Then for a
while, he rides a bike along the river, until he reaches a railway bridge.
C: I’m curious. I’m going to go up there and take a look. It looks beau-
tiful, old and weathered.
T. If it’s an old bridge, it must have seen a lot. If it could talk, what would
it say?
C: It’s a good thing I’m already retired.
T: It has retired.
C: Yes, it has seen more than a bridge should have to see. War.
T: If it were to have one wish, what would it be?
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 68
Third session
Andy begins talking about a phone call he received last week. A colleague
from work had asked if he was interested in having a dinner together with
both of their wives. “This made me very happy now, when this used to
scare me before. I would have been hesitant to even pick up the phone.”
In this session’s daydream, the client walks across the meadow, over to
a forest (symbol, “edge of forest”). He describes seeing a “beautifully
mixed fauna and woodland”, with old oak trees and tall grown beeches.
The weather is “fantastic”; a fawn appears between the trunks. It looks
at him curiously.
T: You should talk to him.
C: Hey you. Are you curious? You seem friendly.
T: What’s his response?
C: “Come over,” it says, “you seem nice too.”
T: If you want to, you can follow him.
C: I have to crouch to move towards him very slowly and carefully,
because my height might scare him. It feels great. [Short pause.] I
would like to touch it, stretch out my hand.
The fawn is two weeks old. It’s doing well.
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 69
He tells the fawn how he would like to come back again for a visit. Both
happily agree. Right after the imagination session had ended, he drew a
picture of himself with the fawn, standing at the edge of the forest. He called
it “You and Me”. At last, the therapist asks Andy for an interpretation.
C: It somehow feels as if it’s possible to contact the unknown, to reach
out to the realm of the others.
The therapist explains what the fawn symbolises: “The fawn is you.” Andy
L had appeared in two forms at once in his imagination. His human form
was ready to approach someone (the fawn), and his animal form wanted
to reach out and allow someone to come closer.
In the conversation that followed, Andy had opened up to the thera-
pist. He talked a great deal about his relationship with his parents, espe-
cially his mother. The therapist circles back to the fawn, saying how
remarkable it is. He asks Andy if there was anything he had been told
about his birth, or the first months of his life.
The client remembers that before he was born, nobody knew that his
mother was carrying twins. “After the first baby was delivered, they said,
‘Oh dear, another one!’ It was me.”
Fourth session
Andy L had something to say right away. He had noticed a change in
himself: “This ever-present fear I used to have, every day, for the past
twenty years—I feel as if it has disappeared.” His constant apprehen-
sion “of being certain that something will go wrong at any minute, or
something unpleasant lies ahead” had gone. “It’s such a relief.”
The “house” is subject of his fourth session. The client pictures it
as small, with lots of windows.
T: Would you like it if you were to travel into your own body, through
an opening into the heart, sit down in a corner, to see how the
exhaustion inside your heart looks like? Try and look at it as if it were
a being. What does this being, which sits inside your heart, causing
the exhaustion, look like?
C: It looks like a little cat.
T: What does the cat do?
C: It just sits there, doing nothing.
T: Can you look into the eyes of the cat? What expression does it wear?
C: Its face is stony.
T: How does that make you feel?
C: It’s exhausting.
Andy speaks to the cat, as he did in his imagination of the fawn. He tells
her how he feels about her, then the cat glares back at him, now with
lively eyes.
T: Perhaps you can take a closer look into her eyes. Try to imagine what
it would be like, if you were her. How would you feel?
C: I want to come out of this frozen state.
T: You can let her know; “Cat, I know how you feel, and I believe you
might want to come out of your ice-block.”
C: Hello kitten, I could tell by your looks that you want to come out of
this state, and move around too. If you do, then you can move a little.
T: That’s good. Allow her to move, she will do it.
When the therapist had asked if there was anything the cat needed, the
client said that she wanted to crawl into his lap and be stroked.
T: Then lift her on to your lap and let her purr. And listen into her feel-
ings. Let her body transmit her emotions into yours.
After a short pause, the therapist wants to know if they could revisit the
house, given that Andy feels ready.
C: Yes.
T: What do you feel now as you stand in front of this house?
C: I feel much better.
What the therapist did was to take a detour from the basic symbols and
instead encourage the client to use his imagination and face his anxiety.
By using the cat, a metaphorical morphogenesis of a frozen emotional
state, he gave the client a chance to address his inner rigour and resolve
it. Andy can now return to the house, more detached and less in fear.
The therapist can return to the standard picture of the basic level.
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 71
The fact that Andy was hesitant to imagine visitors coming to his
house shows he is still afraid to interact with others, although his
commitment proves that he is getting better.
In the discussion that followed his imagining, Andy said he had the
home of his father’s parents in mind. The therapist replies, “We have
stimulated your unconscious. We’ve begun by airing your inner space.
Your soul will do the rest on its own.” Leaving the house without any
visitors did not seem to disturb the patient. “We’ve made an attempt,
but it’s just too early. The house needs to change; be remodelled. It
needs to feel more like a home to you. Then the guests will come.”
Fifth session
Andy L is given the picture of the mountain. To him, it appears “quite
big”. It is sunny, and the surrounding landscape is “all green”. He wants
to climb all the way up the mountain. Equipped with a bottle of water, he
begins to walk. It is quite strenuous exercise, but his spirits are high. “I’ll
be up there in half an hour”, he says. “What great fun.” Having reached
the peak, he stops to enjoy the view. After he returns to the room, he
draws a picture of his journey to the top.
The therapist explains the symbol of the mountain. He describes the
metaphorical relationship of climbing, success, and performance. The
client responds affirmatively, adding that he had learnt to reach his goals
in life without any help. He calls his work “Anything you’ve ever wanted”.
A few weeks later, Andy L contacts the Mind Institute Berlin to let his
therapist know what had happened. By now, he has become fairly relaxed
around other people and continues to see a new friend that he plays
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 73
guitar with. “I can feel solid ground beneath me”, he says. “I used to come
up against a wall before. Now I’ve discovered a gateway, and beyond it, a
beautiful garden.”
big, tall-grown peonies. Some are fully budded, with others already
shedding their petals. The third client sees a bush with a single rose,
already slightly wilted. Behind it he sees two large and wildly grow-
ing shoots. They make him feel uneasy. In conversation, the married
client confided he had had two past affairs, which cause him much
guilt.
Whoever has heard my clients, who have, by delving into their infi-
nite, unconscious wisdom, freed themselves from gastrointestinal
illnesses, cardiac and circulatory issues, or joint pains and headaches,
will no longer say it was a “figment”. Leading sufferers to their inner
strength, which they often see as light, is in my eyes the only real
psychotherapy. (Freitag, 1983, p. 169, translated for this edition)
Our brains consist of many neurons that are networked with one
another. One can imagine this network as a trail leading across a field.
If it is used often, it gets wider. If it is not used, it eventually becomes
overgrown and disappears.
It is similar with nerve cells in the brain: when certain thoughts
occur often, the connections between the corresponding neurons are
strengthened. If these thoughts no longer occur, the connections are
weakened. And if an event is suppressed, that is, pushed into the
subconscious, then the connections are weakened so much that an
island is created that no longer is accessible from the conscious
network of paths, roads, and streets.
If we see the emotions as a network of waterways underneath
these traffic routes, then the water and land routes are connected to
one another. If someone pours something harmful into the water net-
work, then assistance can quickly reach the contaminated point,
correct the damage, and the harmful liquid can run off. This cannot be
done on the island though, as no one can reach it. In the course of our
lives, we create many such islands through displacement of emotional
events, where contaminated water cannot run off. We then sometimes
behave strangely in everyday situations and do not know why. We are
unable to change our behaviour as well.
With the help of the imagination, we climb into the water network,
follow the contaminated water to its source, and rediscover the sup-
pressed islands. By looking at them instead of looking away, bridges
to these islands are built. The event becomes part of our consciousness
again, and we can understand why we are the way we are. The things
that burdened us can “run off”. Additionally, the connection between
conscious understanding and unconscious imagination creates new
links between both halves of the brain (of which one is more rational
and the other is more emotional). Our road network can withstand
more traffic, and it distributes itself more effectively—a boon for the
mind and the psychic balance.
“What is it doing?”), the therapist can help the client paint a concrete
picture of this place.
Visualising a place of inner peace is a technique that has already
been adopted in trauma therapy. In this field, having a retreat room
such as this is very helpful because it gives the client the opportunity
to retreat quickly and safely to this imaginary space: for example,
when processing the trauma or memories appears to be unbearable.
A child has the inherent need to be seen for who they are, to be consid-
ered and taken seriously at the core of their own activity. In contrast
to the drive of desire, this is an equally legitimate, albeit narcissistic
need, the fulfilment of which is essential in the formation of a healthy
self. “Who they are” means: Their feelings, sensations and their
expression by the infant. (Miller, 2008, p. 5)
children, who are not permitted to develop freely, do not learn how to
allow feelings and closeness, because the disappointment they felt
when their feelings were not reciprocated during childhood was
unbearable. This often gives rise to a narcissistic disorder that can
manifest in grandiosity, as well as depression.
The narcissistic disorder is so widespread that the World Health
Organization (WHO) no longer classifies it as a stand-alone condition
in their directory of diseases (ICD-10). It is listed under “other specific
personality disorders”. It has become an accepted mass phenomenon,
comparable to short-sightedness or back pain.
Narcissistic disorders became particularly widespread during the
Second World War and the post-war years. Those who were children
during the war became parents, and withheld the emotional affection
they had lacked, because of the terrible circumstances in which they
had grown up, from their children. This shaped the next generation,
who, in turn, deprived their children of whatever they had not received.
Miller claims that it can be safely assumed that any client seeking
psychotherapy will have some type of narcissistic disorder. Anyone
working with visualisations should recognise these societal develop-
ments. They should even be actively discussed by the therapist and
the client.
Working with imaginings can help the inner child in us to see how
he was shaped by his family. Imagination can also help in meeting the
needs of this inner child, giving access to emotions and allowing him
to be accepted. Last, but not least, visualisations that arise from work-
ing with the subconscious can help clients to find their true selves.
Essentially, all the motifs suggested in this chapter, on all three
levels (basic, intermediate, and advanced), can be used to access emo-
tions and the true self. Moreover, each family member, including the
client himself, can be imagined in the form of an animal or creature
in order to uncover family dynamics. A therapist might ask, for exam-
ple, “If your mother were an animal, what would it be?” Or, “What
direction is she looking towards?” An important extension of CIP is
the imaginative journey back to our childhood. In this regression, we
see the child in ourselves at different ages. The model sees the inner
child we once were in every adult. When two adults argue (read:
behave immaturely), it is often their inner children angrily throwing
themselves on the floor or using their fists. In emotionally stressful
situations, therefore, one can check on how the inner child is faring.
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 89
CHAPTER FOUR
91
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 92
T: That must be really terrible for you. I’m sorry that you had to go
over all that again for me. But let’s not dwell on the subject. Instead,
let’s try something that will help you divert the stress and eventually
find inner peace again . . .
The therapist explains briefly and using simple terms the idea behind
catathymic imaginative psychotherapy, without using this complicated-
sounding title. Mrs P is instructed to make herself comfortable in her chair
and to imagine she is taking a short nap.
T: It’s OK for you to slowly begin to relax. Just do nothing but be here
and close your eyes.
C: I can’t close my eyes. [This is often the case with victims of sexual
assault. It has no bearing on the outcome of the therapy.]
T: Leave your eyes open, that’s not a problem. It’s OK for you to say
that you can’t. If you want to close your eyes later, that’s all right as
well, and if you want to leave them open, that is too. Just try to be
here and listen to your breathing. Feel your feet on the ground, and
the way the chair is supporting you. After a while, imagine a
meadow—just a meadow, or whatever comes to mind.
C: Should I describe it?
T: Yes, if you have an idea of it, then tell me about it a bit, what it looks
like.
C: I always associate meadows with lots of flowers. A place I can take a
walk.
T: Yes.
C: And where I can play football with my grandchild.
T: Yes, a nice field for playing football, where children can play as well.
C: Exactly.
T: And the meadow you’re imagining now. Where are you now? Are
you in the meadow, or where are you?
C: I’m on the grass, yeah.
T: In the meadow, can you smell anything?
C: The flowers, the wild flowers that grow there.
T: They have a very special scent. How is the weather there?
C: Sunny.
T: Can you hear anything?
C: Hear what?
T: Mmm.
C: The field could be in my garden.
T: Aha.
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 96
C: We have flowers there too, not right in the field, but around the
edges, and birds.
T: How is it, standing in this field?
C: Pleasant, soothing and relaxing.
T: Then enjoy the field, with its smell of wild flowers and the beautiful
weather. What do you want to do now, there on the grass?
C: Play football with my grandson.
T: Aha, is he there?
C: He was with us this afternoon.
T: Perhaps you could let your grandson appear on the meadow. In our
dream world we can do anything.
C: Julian is his name.
T: Julian.
C: And whenever he’s with us, Gran has to play with him, most of the
time in the sandbox, build castles with him and streets, where cars
drive around.
T: Aha.
C: My husband is always the one who plays football with him. When
Julian is there, I’m always really happy, now anyway, when it all
happened, the little scamp helped me a lot.
T: Let’s leave that situation out of it for now; let’s just stay in the
meadow that smells so nicely of wildflowers and where the birds
chirp. Is your grandson there now?
C: What?
T: Is your grandson there now?
C: No, he’s back with his mum and papa.
T: I meant in the meadow in your imagination. Is he there at the moment?
C: No.
T: What kind of feeling is it when your grandson isn’t there?
C: Bit sad.
The therapist now tries to provide the client access to her own emotions.
He wants to achieve this by urging her to see the sadness as a being. Then
it will gain a clear form and can be observed in peace.
T: This sadness, can you find out if it might be an animal, a being, or a
thing? What is the very first thing you think of sadness as? What’s the
symbol for sadness? What colour is it, what shape? What does it look
like?
C: Grey, I always associate darkness with it.
T: Something dark. If this sadness somehow had a shape, how would
that look?
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 97
T: Turn off your logic. Try to relax and to make a fairy tale out of it. A
dark figure wants to achieve satisfaction and degrade others. That’s
the villain in our fairy tale. This degradation, what does the villain
want to achieve?
C: To be loved? [Mrs P starts to cry.]
T: That is just an action, but there must be some kind of goal behind it.
That the person who does something like that wants to attain for
himself.
C: Approval.
T: Mmm. Now we have satisfaction and approval.
C: This could be a very sick person.
T: Maybe he wants to be healthy, as well? That could be.
C: I’m sorry?
T: It could be the desire for health, if he is sick.
C: Could be, but not if he is like that.
T: But definitely satisfaction and approval. That is what this dark figure
wants. We’re not talking about the man you encountered, but rather
the dark figure that he left in your head, there’s a difference. We’re
talking only about your memory, about the creature that stays
circling in your mind. In this story, this darkness, this dark shadow
that wanders across the meadow, causing sadness, it wants satisfac-
tion and approval. If approval and satisfaction were a thing, some
symbol, something beautiful—what would it be?
[Mrs P is silent.]
T: It could be a symbol or some kind of occurrence. The first thing that
comes to you, it can also be something abstract. There are no wrong
thoughts.
[Mrs P is silent.]
T: If you were seeking satisfaction and approval for yourself, what kind
of symbol would that be? These beautiful goals. Approval and satis-
faction.
C: My work?
T: Work is not something you can visualise as a thing. Perhaps a symbol
of satisfaction and approval?
[Mrs P is silent.]
The therapist is beginning to seem stubborn with his repeated questions.
The reason for his insistence is that he is trying to find the appropriate
healing symbol for the client, with which the dark figure can be
neutralised. This remains unsuccessful as yet. It will require another trip
to the fairy-tale land to undo the knot.
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 99
T: Perhaps you could close your eyes for a few seconds, and then you
might find a clue. Just a suggestion, you don’t have to, but it really
does work sometimes. Let the story slip into the background, and
just think about yourself, about approval and satisfaction.
[Mrs P closes her eyes.]
T: Once upon a time there were two people, approval and satisfaction.
They lived in a fairy tale world. What did they look like?
C: Could be like the sun?
T: Aha. That’s a really great image, the sun. Can you picture a sun?
C: The sun warms the skin.
T: Yes, it warms up the skin beautifully. This very special sun is the sun
of approval and satisfaction. Here comes a ray of sunshine, which you
can really feel. Be with the wonderful feeling of the sun, with the
approval and satisfaction. Enjoy the good feeling.
[The therapist speaks very slowly at this point, to give the client sufficient
time to immerse herself in the scene.]
T: Could you ask the sun whether she could fly to the dark figure and
shine a little on him? Whether he also got approval and satisfaction?
Maybe he is still there somewhere, maybe just a bit further away. Do
you still sense the dark figure, or has he changed somehow?
C: No.
T: He’s still there. Can you give the sun to the dark figure, with uncon-
ditional love and warmth, and without anything in return?
C: Not just yet.
T: Mmm.
C: That still needs time. Then I could do it.
T: Mrs P, we’re not talking about the man, but rather the shadow that
is in your mind. What we are trying to do is find a way for you to
appease the spectres circling your mind, so to speak. If you can’t do
that for the man, that is perfectly fine, what happens on the outside
is not the topic of our discussion. We are only talking about the
world in our heads.
C: I could.
T: And it might be good to give the sun to the shadow that occupies
your meadow.
C: All right.
T: Give the sun with its warm rays to this dark shadow, just because, as
a gift. Look at the situation. What’s happening in the story? How does
it continue?
C: I find my peace.
T: Are you in the meadow? Is the meadow still there?
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 100
C: Yes.
T: It still smells of wildflowers?
C: Mmm.
T: This dark figure, what does he look like now?
C: Friendly.
T: Say to the figure: “You’re looking more friendly already”.
C: You’re looking more friendly already.
T: If you now look at the figure, what is it doing? Did that have any
certain effect?
C: He will leave me in peace now.
T: What kind of feeling is that?
[Mrs P cries.]
C: Very calming actually.
T: What is the figure doing now?
C: Nothing.
T: It is still there, does it look different?
C: It’s not so . . . scary looking any more, but it’s still there.
T: Maybe it’s in a good mood. It was given a gift after all.
C: The sun looks so friendly.
T: The figure, with the sun? The sun is shining with satisfaction and
approval on this figure. Even if something very strange is happening
now, just tell me what is going on. Or is nothing happening? Is it a
freeze frame?
C: Nothing’s happening.
T: Yes. But the figure is now busy with the sun; it will leave you alone
from now on. So we got the figure to back off a bit already. Would
you like some water?
C: Please.
T: I would like you to draw the picture, the last scene in the meadow.
Draw where you stand after the figure got the sun and left you alone.
Is that OK? I think this is a very good development, pushing away the
big figure. I know you can’t do magic in one session, but now the
figure is already a little isolated. It helps to draw what you saw—that
solidifies this stage of development, and we won’t have to start over
again in our next meeting.
The therapist gives Mrs P paper and a selection of crayons in various
colours.
C: But I’m not a very good artist.
T: Everyone says that. It isn’t important, you can draw stick figures or
triangles. That doesn’t matter at all. No one is being graded on their
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 101
art here. All we are looking for is for the events in your imagination
to be put on paper in some way.
C: We’re only using the good things in my mind?
T: Yes.
[Mrs P draws.]
C: This is the meadow.
The final picture shows two people; one, a man, is a bit taller than the
woman next to him. The sun is shining over the two.
T: You got some of the sun’s rays too, didn’t you?
C: Yes.
T: It actually almost looks as if two people are playing in the meadow.
Not so threatening any more.
C: Yes.
T: If this picture was given a title, what could it be?
C: Happy people?
T: Yes. Could you just write that on there with the crayon? Doesn’t
matter where.
her that her little niece, who had been visiting her, had returned home.
The therapist asks what this feeling might look like if it were a being.
C: Like a big bat that spreads its wings like a black cloak over me.
T: Can you look the bat in the eye, see its facial expression?
C: It looks more sad than anything.
T: What does that do to you, to see it so sad?
C: It makes me sad too.
T: Maybe you should tell the bat: “You look so sad, and when I see that,
it makes me sad too.”
C: It’s becoming threatening.
[The therapist suggests that this is told to the bat as well. The bat then
retreats from the image after that.]
T: Can you use the power of your thoughts to empathise with the bat
and sense what it needs?
C: Now it is falling over backward and seems as if it needs help.
T: What kind of help does it need?
C: It’s flying away now.
T: You could try to sense what it needs anyway.
C: It doesn’t want anyone to be afraid of it.
T: Then send her a few good words in parting: “I’m not afraid of you. I
know that you’re sad. I’m sad too, and you should know that I’m not
afraid of you”.
[Patricia M begins to cry. The therapist gives her paper tissues.]
T: You can now quite easily see what happens: we look at the sadness,
and it flies away, and if we don’t look at it, it stays there. There is
only one sensible way to deal with negative feelings: you must accept
them, embrace them. If you turn away, they will only grow stronger.
[The therapist indicates that this was only a little exercise.]
T: But this is something you can do at home on your own, when your
niece leaves, for example. Look at the sadness you then feel. Feel the
part of the body it sits in, and ask what it would look like if it were
a being. Then, you can look at this creature. You can talk to it. My
main advice is not to hide your feelings—observe them.
After this last session, a confident, clearly instructed client leaves the
practice. “The imagination sessions have relaxed me,” she says. Three
months later, she expresses her gratitude in a letter. She is now able to
approach deep-seated fears and make contact with them. “I am grate-
ful for this experience that taught me to use my imagination to take
the mental journey into my subconscious.”
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 105
Those affected often start out simply feeling overtaxed, but they
often find it hard to admit this to themselves. It is only some time later
that they get to a point where they are no longer able to “function” in
their workplace, feel drained and frustrated, or display symptoms
such as fatigue and apathy, which often resemble depression.
Other people, however, may work exactly as much or even more,
without ever ending up in this situation. How do they bear the load?
What distinguishes someone who has experienced burn-out from a
healthy worker? Of course, not all patients with burn-out syndrome
are equal, but some of them have a common background: they have a
pathological superego, a strictly insistent conscience. The causes for
this kind of maladaptation can usually be traced back to childhood.
More often than not, their parents were deified, as a result, they might
idealise their bosses in the same way as adults, while subordinating
themselves and their own needs. In many cases, they become unable
to feel their own emotions at all. In the case of Oliver S, his parents
were alcoholics who were so wrapped up in themselves that they
neglected their child.
During his first session, the thirty-nine-year-old physicist ex-
plained how he has been having trouble staying focused and concen-
trating at work for the past few weeks, despite having started the job
with a great deal of initial enthusiasm and engagement and working
overtime regularly. “I can’t imagine how to even continue working
there, because I feel so insecure and have withdrawn completely.”
This applies not only to his work team, in which he had taken a lead-
ing role up to this point, but also to his private circle of friends. Oliver
S even broke up with his girlfriend.
He is noticeably shaken by all of this. “I can’t sleep at night. Or I
only sleep from eleven until one or two, and then I lie awake for the
rest of the night.” His thoughts revolve primarily around work. “I had
a two-week vacation, which I hoped would make things better, but I
noticed by the first or second day that I was unable to switch off and
couldn’t stop constantly thinking about the company.”
As a computer specialist, Oliver S uses mostly the left half of his
brain for his work. He is a very rational person. His world is com-
posed of numbers and data, not feelings. This became evident in the
preliminary discussions in which the therapist explained to the him
that the forthcoming imaginative exercises would encourage the
neglected right half of his brain. Oliver S was instructed to portray
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 107
C: A wolf.
T: A wolf—this wolf represents your anxiety, which is in your body.
Where is the wolf located in your body?
C: Like . . . here. [Mr S points at his stomach.]
T: Hmm. What’s that wolf doing in there?
C: He’s trying to break out. He’s threatening.
T: Threatening, how does that make you feel?
C: Like I’d leave my own body just to get away.
T: Hmm. But right now, the wolf is here in your body. Can you tell me
what kind of expression is on the wolf’s face?
C: Yes, it’s threatening. Aggressive.
T: Could you keep a safe distance from the wolf? From where he
doesn’t appear so threatening to you, and look into his eyes?
C: I can’t do it, he’s inside of me.
[Mr S is unable to let go of his rational thinking. The therapist must try
to help him gain access to his unconscious, which is still locked away.]
T: We can do anything in our imagination. You can try going inside your
own body and looking into the wolf’s eyes.
[There is a long silence between Mr S and the therapist.]
T: What now?
C: I was just kind of distracted. I just remembered that I have a doctor’s
appointment immediately after this session, and I’ve forgotten to
bring the little sample tube of urine.
T: Did something about the wolf distract you? Did the wolf find it too
boring just to look at you?
C: No, maybe he just pointed out that I’d forgotten to bring the tube.
He showed me a problem.
T: What is the wolf trying to achieve by alerting you to a problem?
C: I think he wants to belittle me.
T: He wants to belittle you. And what does he get out of belittling you?
C: I become easier prey for him. He can maul me better.
T: And what’s in it for him?
C: He can follow his hunting instinct.
T: What colour is this hunting instinct?
C: Orange.
T: Hmm. And what shape?
C: A star.
T: Can you let an orange star appear before your mind’s eye? What
feeling does it cause within you?
C: It feels threatening.
T: Can you give this orange star to the wolf as a gift? Without any
conditions?
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 109
C: It’s good. The mountain has a reddish glow. I don’t know exactly
whether it is a morning or evening glow. It is a pleasant view, a pleas-
ant feeling.
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 111
In this fourth therapy session, the images reveal that the client has
already made significant progress. He is ready to work (he climbs the
mountain); he notices that some parts of himself (Julia, in this case)
want to go further, but he knows his limits and can discuss them.
What Oliver S still needs to learn at this point is to feel and enjoy his
situation. This was the main goal of his subsequent long-term therapy,
which went well. The positive development is also supported by a
conversation Oliver S had with his employer in which he admits he is
overwhelmed. The boss is understanding and suggests that Mr S
transfers to a different section. There, he finds a task that corresponds
with his abilities and does not exhaust him.
T: How are you eating at the moment? Do you cook for yourself,
prepare ready-cooked meals, or eat cold meals?
C: It depends. A study-buddy of mine always brings something when he
comes over, which he forces me to eat.
T: What does it feel like, when he forces you?
C: He does it just like a mother would. Tells me there’s room, and I
need to do it for some reason.
T: So you need a mother figure.
C: I do, in a way, but if I start eating more now, that’ll mess things up.
T: Have you gained weight?
C: Yes. I don’t know how much. It’s happening again, just like it did
before. At some point, I stop weighing myself and looking in the
mirror. When I take a shower I think: “Oh God, my legs are too fat”.
T: I promise you that we’ll talk about whether your legs are really too
fat in a later session. If they are, then we can think about what to do
about it, and whether we can come up with diet plan. First, I want to
find out whether there’s something else behind this.
C: OK.
T: Those legs that are too fat. Those are in your head. They’re the part
that bothers you the most, right?
C: Yes.
T: Now fully immerse yourself in this feeling: womanhood and fat legs.
What does that feel like? Don’t think about what needs to be done,
but what it feels like?
[The client does not respond, the therapist waits for a while.]
T: If you can’t get close to the feeling then say so. This is not about
meeting any expectations.
C: No. [Pause.] How can I do that? Like, I could describe how I feel
about my legs being like this.
T: In any way you want. We’re trying to cast light on the issues from as
many sides as possible. How does your understanding develop into
this feeling, what does the feeling look like? Say anything that you
need to let out.
C: Well, my understanding of it is the same as usual, I just don’t like the
way I look.
T: The feeling that this thought triggers, the thought of having legs that
are too fat, what does that feel like? Is it shame? Is it anger, fear,
disgust? There are so many feelings that could be named.
C: It’s shame, but also disgust. Sometimes there’s anger too.
T: Shame, disgust, and anger at yourself—is that it?
C: Yes, and the main component is certainly shame.
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 115
Here a spontaneous shift occurring in the mind of the client can be seen.
The plot changes, and the therapist’s job at this point is simply to draw
attention to this new image.
yourself. Try it out. Let the horse run and let it feel what you’ll allow
and what is too much. Exert as much control as necessary. Romp and
race as much as possible. Feel the flow of energy between it and you,
horse and rider. What’s that like for you?
C: We haven’t entirely become one yet.
T: Do you feel you have the horse under control? Like it knows what
you want?
C: I guess.
T: I would like to suggest something to you. How about letting the
horse run however it wants to, and you stay on top of it for as long
as you can stand. And if you tell it “that’s enough”, your horse will
slow down. Just to find out what it feels like to relinquish control.
You have the power of holding on to the horse with the strong legs
of a rider, and to hold the reins with your strong arms, and to lean
forward so you can sit securely on the horse. Then, see what that
does to you, what this triggers and what sorts of feelings emerge. Let
those feelings flow through your body. Become one with these feel-
ings. What’s that like?
[Long pause.]
C: The horse went really, really fast and did lots of jumps and stuff. At
some point I told it to stop, and it did, but only because . . . I think
it could not have gone any faster. That was OK.
Here, it can be seen to what extent the client is now ready to give up
control.
T: The horse reached its limits, right? Tuckered itself out nicely.
C: I think it would have run even further, but at some point, it got bored
too.
T: How are you feeling now?
C: I got the impression the horse was inexhaustible.
T: What does it feel like to have a horse that’s inexhaustible?
C: Good, actually. When I think back to the little reindeer, I realise it
was only strong enough to follow commands, but that’s not really
necessary any more.
T: Could you perhaps freeze this scene, get off the horse and see what
it looks like. This strong horse you just rode, with all its never-ending
energy? And the little reindeer we met earlier, maybe take another
look at it, too. Then I’d ask that you invite your dad. Can he have a
look into your dream?
C: If he must.
T: What do you call him—Papa?
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 120
C: Yes.
T: “Hi, Papa. I want to show you something. Welcome to my world.
Look at this skittish reindeer.” Observe how he looks at the reindeer.
“The reindeer is my shame. There was a time when I was big, and you
told me that I was too fat, so I became small. My personality turned
into a shy reindeer, but deep in my heart, my nature is actually quite
different.” You then walk with your father to the horse and tell him
the whole story—how you rode it, how you took care of it and
allowed it to grow, and the personality traits you gained at your
grandparents’ house. You show him how you have ridden this strong
horse, which is now a part of you, its inexhaustible energy. You then
look your father in the eyes and tell him what you see there.
C: He turns away.
T: Let your feelings out. Take as long as you need to.
[C cries.]
T: Try to understand what your father is feeling right now—what’s
wrong with him? How is he feeling right now?
C: He doesn’t want to do it. He doesn’t want to look.
T: How does that make you feel, the fact that he doesn’t want to look?
C: It makes me angry and sad.
T: Then tell him: “You don’t want to look at what I have to show you,
and that makes me angry and sad.” How does he react?
C: He has turned towards me slightly, but of course he isn’t taking my
crying seriously.
T: How does it make you feel when he doesn’t take you seriously?
C: It makes me even angrier.
T: Go ahead and tell him: “When you don’t take me seriously at all—
when I feel that way, in any case—that makes me even angrier. Look
at this horse, it’s the real me. Then take a look at this reindeer. I’m
an adult, I have a strong personality and I should expect to be taken
seriously. This is a very serious issue that we’ve got.” And now, if you
were your father—how would you feel?
C: Bad.
T: Now that you’ve tried to feel what your father is feeling, and you’ve
found out that he feels bad, how does that make you feel?
[No reply.]
T: How does it make you feel to see that your father feels bad?
C: I feel so charged with emotion that I can’t . . . [The client can no
longer speak.]
T: “I see how bad you feel and it makes me emotionally charged.” Go
ahead and tell him that. Tell him: “This is all my anger, it’s all here on
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 121
the table”. Show how charged you are with shame, disgust, and anger.
How this anger at yourself has lasted for all of your life up to now.
Now try to feel what your father is feeling. What does he feel like?
Maybe think about what he now would say right now, if he could get
a word out—what does your father need now?
C: I think that he would rather be alone right now. He’d rather deny
everything.
T: What does he hope to achieve by denying it all?
C: He wants to evade responsibility.
T: What does he have to gain by not taking responsibility? What does
your father need, what will he achieve by looking away and avoiding
responsibility, what’s he trying to get out of this?
C: Avoid confrontation.
T: If there is no confrontation, what does he get out of that? No respon-
sibility, no confrontation—what does that leave him with, in the end?
C: Nothing.
T: So what he really wants is nothing. If nothing were a thing, what
would it be?
C: A thing?
T: Yes, a symbol for nothing.
C: An apple.
T: An apple. Let a big pile of apples appear before your mind’s eye.
Could you give these apples to your father as a gift, with uncondi-
tional love and warmth, without expecting anything in return? Maybe
you could also tell him: “I see you, I see your face, I feel you, I know
how you feel and I know what you’re looking for. What you most
want to achieve above all is nothing, and this is why I’m giving you
these apples. So you can have as much nothing as you want. You can
eat them all, and if that’s not enough, I have more apples for you.”
How does he react now? What does he look like, standing there,
with his heap of apples?
C: I pity him.
T: Would you like to tell him that? You could say: “I see you standing
there and I pity you. I know what’s wrong with you now. I know how
you feel.” How does he react? [Pause.] What would you do now?
C: I’m too angry to hug him.
T: “I considered giving you a hug but frankly, I’m too angry. Look at this
anger. Take a look at my anger.” Could you perhaps ask the horse to
come and look at this scene, as you stand there with your father? He
is sad and bowed forward, and you are full of anger. What would the
horse tell you to do right now? Maybe the horse has some advice?
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 122
T: Could you show her a place, a little village perhaps, where she can
spin webs? And perhaps explain to her what she’s actually there for?
Is there such a place? How’s the spider now?
C: She feels safe.
T: Would you return to the place where you father and the horse were?
C: Mmm.
T: How does that feel now? What’s your father’s stance, how is he
looking at it?
C: He looks rather uncertain.
T: Do you think your father could take you seriously?
C: Mmm.
T: What would you like to do now? Don’t think about what’s expected
of you, but what’s inside you. What would you wish for? I know that
you’re thinking of a hug and the question of whether giving it is pos-
sible, but in the dream world there are thousands of possibilities. You
could sit down with your father and smoke a peace pipe, or go for a
walk with him. Anything is possible. Let whatever images you want
appear.
[No reply.]
T: And what now?
C: For some reason I don’t want to.
T: That’s OK. Observe the scene. The real work is done. All of you now
know what the others are thinking, how they feel. The horse stand-
ing to the side is your good friend, your power animal. You might
want to come back to this place at a later date and carry on, or you
might not. You alone can decide. So you might want to say to every
one involved: “Now I’m going to have to say goodbye and leave this
place.”
After this long session, the client went through a difficult phase full
of self-doubt for the next two weeks or so, which further therapy
sessions attempted to relieve. Subsequently, she experienced a marked
improvement. It has been several weeks now since Sophie K was last
bothered by her appearance and in this time she has been able to clear
her head for her studies. She is motivated and confident that she will
pass her tests.
T: To where is it flowing? What does the place it’s flowing to look like?
C: It looks like a stream. The current gets stronger, and along the banks
it’s all very green, with trees growing. A very luxuriant vegetation—
not like in a jungle, more like in a European climate—like in Austria
or Bavaria.
T: How do you feel by this river?
C: Very relaxed.
[The therapist speaks very slowly.]
T: Enjoy the feeling of relaxation, feel the energy that emanates from
this river, and allow this relaxation into your body. What would you
like to do now?
C: Read a book.
T: Is there a book?
C: Yes, and a picnic basket as well. It was already planned for me to be
here. The sun is shining on me, and I’m even a little tanned. It’s some-
what warming.
T: If the sun could speak, what would it say now?
C: It is happy that it can warm me.
T: What would it say now—that it is happy?
C: I am so happy that I can give you joy.
T: Hmm. It would say something like that now.
C: And she says to me: “Think positively, look through my nice warm
rays.”
Here, it becomes clear that the client has good access to her inner
resources.
T: If you look around a bit in this landscape, do you see anything or
anyone else who might say the opposite: “Think negatively”? Maybe
a tree or a fish?
C: The clouds. They try to sit in front of the sun.
T: Are the clouds there?
C: Yes.
T: What do they look like, these clouds?
C: Big and dark. And the sun is trying to defend itself against them.
T: If the clouds could speak, what would they say now?
C: They look mean. They have faces, and the sun looks happy and shines.
The clouds try to sit in front of it, but the sun keeps fighting.
T: If you look at the clouds in their faces, in the mean faces, first try to
understand what is wrong with the clouds—how are they right now?
Maybe there is a cloud that looks particularly mean or is displaying a
very distinct face—one that you could interact with.
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 128
C: It’s anger—a mixture of fear and anger. Fear is there, and anger,
because I am not able to fight it.
T: You don’t have to fight it right now. We’re only looking at it.
C: Okay, fear and anger. Because I don’t want this snake in me.
T: You’ve gone back to the logical mind. Let’s leave that now and go
back to the fairy tale. Once upon a time, there was a woman who
had a snake in her chest, and the snake was pretty and looked as if
it was powerful. And while the snake was looking at her, the woman
got angry and frightened, because she didn’t want this snake around.
Now just tell the snake: “When you look at me that way, it scares
me.”
C: When you look at me that way, it scares me.
T: What is the snake doing now?
C: It’s withdrawing. It’s curling itself up right now. I hate snakes.
T: And what kind of feeling does it give you to see it curl itself up?
C: It really prickles, because I’m afraid of snakes.
T: Yes, tell it: “When you curl yourself up like that, it makes me prickle”.
C: When you curl yourself up like that, it makes me prickle.
T: What is it doing now?
C: It’s stretching itself out. It’s making itself like a staff.
T: What does the staff look like?
C: It’s an old staff. On top, the grip is wider, and below it comes to a
point.
T: Maybe you can approach the staff and get a good look at it.
C: The handle has the teeth and the head of the snake carved into it.
T: What does it feel like to see this staff?
C: Since it’s a staff, I’m not so scared, because I know it can’t do any-
thing. It’s just a staff.
T: How about if you touch the staff and tell me how it feels?
C: I find it disgusting, because I know that it is a snake.
T: Hmm.
C: OK, I’ll touch it.
T: Now, now, now, not so fast. The feeling you had, that feeling of dis-
gust—keep that feeling in your body and imagine it being like going
into cold water: it’s uncomfortable, but you get used to it. Leave the
feeling of disgust there, don’t fight it. Allow the feeling of disgust to
flow into your body, and be with the feeling. And wait and see what
happens if you allow the feeling to occupy your body.
C: My body tries to get used to it, and it tries to fight the disgusting
feeling, but it can’t.
T: Don’t fight it.
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 131
T: Maybe tell that to the staff: “When I touch you on the head, it’s
uncomfortable”.
C: When I touch you on the head, it’s uncomfortable.
T: What do you think the staff feels when you touch it?
C: The staff doesn’t understand that. The staff changes so that I no
longer see the head of the snake. The staff is now pleasant to touch.
[Only now is the conversion completed.]
T: Go ahead and say that to it.
C: You’re now so pleasant to touch, because you have changed. Now I
can really hold you.
T: How’s that for the staff?
C: It is pleased.
T: Is there maybe something that this staff needs?
C: Yes, it needs love. It also needs warmth. Because otherwise it con-
veys the impression that it is a weapon. And it doesn’t want to be a
weapon. You can see something good in the staff, but if you see a
weapon, then that’s something evil, and the staff doesn’t want that.
T: Is there maybe a place where there is love and warmth?
C: Yes.
T: Where is it?
C: The stick must go back into the forest.
T: In the forest, or maybe even the place where our story began. At the
river, where the sun is shining, and you are there with your picnic.
C: I’ll take the staff there and put it next to a big tree.
T: How’s that for the staff?
C: Nice. I mean, the staff can’t really tell me, but I think this is the best
thing for it.
T: And if the staff could speak? What it would say?
C: It would say, “Thank you.”
T: And how is that for you, when the staff thanks you?
C: I’ve done something good, and I got the staff out of me.
T: Well, I think the staff wanted to get out itself. It needed love and
warmth. It needed someone to empathise. Someone to check what
was going on with it and what it needed. It needed someone to talk
about feelings with and someone it could talk to if it was feeling
uncomfortable or it was bothered by something. What does the sun
think about all this?
C: The clouds are gone, and the sun is happy again. The sun says that I
have done something good. I will be rewarded for it.
T: What kind of reward? What can you allow yourself?
C: To think clearly and to concentrate on my book.
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 133
T: Allow yourself to think clearly, and let the clarity into your body.
Enjoy what you have achieved, your success, the warmth of the sun,
and the power of the staff standing beside you that you were able to
befriend a little today. And with all the clarity you’ve gained, you can
dedicate yourself that much more to your book. And after a while,
when you’re ready, and in the time you need, make your way back
to the here-and-now in this room.”
The empathy training recounted here was intended to have the client
learn how to sense one’s counterpart, slowly allow closeness, and to
make positive experiences from that. The therapist made sure that the
client felt protected the entire time (“I’ll make sure nothing happens
to you”). This session led to a significant improvement. However,
additional sessions will be necessary (probably at least ten) in order to
help Eva L in the long term. One goal will be for her to learn how to
cope with the feeling of panic that arises when she enters into a new
relationship.
She will learn to see these feelings of panic as beings, in order to
encounter and embrace them.
Phobias are often only a part of a broader problem. This holds true
for Sebastian R, who initially came to the therapeutic practice not
because of his fear of spiders, but because of occasional outbursts of
anger, during which he did not have himself under control.
Soon it turns out that some time ago, Sebastian had to watch as his
father systematically destroyed himself. Despite his severe diabetes,
he ate large quantities of sweets daily and, against medical advice, did
not pay attention to his blood sugar levels, with the result that he died.
Sebastian felt helpless, and when he finds himself “blind with rage”
today, these experiences seem to be at least partially responsible.
In the sessions, which are transcribed in excerpts in the following
dialogue, the sole focus was the arachnophobia. The therapist chose
the symbol of the river or stream as the foundation, which is suitable
for this emotionally laden subject. After only one session, a clear
reduction in the fear of spiders was observed, because the conflict in
the subconscious is processed and the client additionally receives a
rational explanation for the source of his phobia.
T: Look at the spider, pay attention to your emotions and where they
sit in your body. And be with the feelings and the spider. Allow the
spider to be there. [Pause.]
C: The spider wants to go back to the cellar.
T: Cellar?
C: The cellar in the house where we used to live.
T: And is the spider allowed?
C: Yes.
T: How does the spider feel there?
C: Good.
T: And how are you with it?
C: It’s not so bad any more.
T: Could you offer the spider friendship?
C: It doesn’t know what that is.
T: You could tell it that you know what it is, and that you’re there for
it.
C: The spider wants me to protect it.
T: How about if you take the spider with you?
C: Yes, the spider would like that.
T: And maybe you can go with the spider back downstream, back to
where this story started.
C: Yes, the spider is sitting on my hand and sometimes on my shoulder.
T: And how’s that for you now?
C: Good. A liberating experience.
T: Stay a moment in this good feeling of a liberating experience. Remem-
ber how you walked back along the river, found the spider and
became friends. And after a while, in the time that you need, come
back to the here and now in this room.”
The arachnophobia was brought to light by the symbol of the river and
subsequently processed directly. In the following discussion, Sebastian
R reports an experience as a child: in the house where he lived at the
time, he found a spider in the basement. He was scared, and his
parents were not home at the time. For him, the feeling of loneliness
and abandonment was associated with the symbol of the spider.
The session lasted less than an hour. The transcript given is
abridged. The most important therapy element was nevertheless
demonstrated: simply being with a feeling. Following the river
upstream to the source represents a journey into the past. The steep
path shows the difficult access to the unconscious conflict.
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 138
Since this session, the client has felt neither fear nor disgust
towards spiders any more.
she is in doubt about her feelings and does not know if a relationship
feels “right” or not.
In the fifth hour of therapy, the client is instructed during relax-
ation to conjure the inner image of a house. It looks as if it was painted
by a child. Square, two-dimensional, with a pointed red roof. It stands
in a field. The sky is blue. The air is cool.
T: Would you like to touch the bear, stroke him or pet him a little? Is
that possible? Maybe tell him that he doesn’t need to be afraid.
C: The bear calmed down a bit.
T: How’s that for you?
C: I calm down too. [She cries.]
T: Could you imagine the bear becoming your friend?
C: I think so.
[The therapist suggests that the client should tell the story of the house
to the bear—that it looks as thin as a sheet of paper.]
T: What does the bear think of that? What is his advice?
C: He becomes quite angry and thinks that I should maybe just leave it
behind and go away from the house.
T: And what do you say to the bear when he says to leave it?
C: I say that I would have no home then.
[The therapist reminds her about the beautiful weather and suggests that
the client go with her new friend to the house. Perhaps something has
changed there in the meantime. That is indeed the case: the house has
become thicker, if only by a few centimetres; it feels as if it is made of
stone, and it even has a wooden door.]
T: Now that you’re standing in front of the house, what would you like
to do?
C: I’d like to go in. But it isn’t thick enough.
T: Then go on and try to open the door. Who knows what you might
see when you open the door.
C: It opens. But inside, everything is like . . . as if it were pressed
together. I can’t really go in.
[The therapist says that Mrs B should tell the house that it doesn’t have
to pull itself together.]
T: “I understand that there were times in which it was necessary to
contract, but you don’t have to do this any more for me. You can
make yourself bigger again. You can decide these things for yourself.”
How does the house respond now?
C: It’s a bit wider now. But it’s going very slowly. And the lawn behind
it is pushing against it.
T: Perhaps you should ask the lawn why it’s pushing against it?
C: It’s pretty angry right now.
T: And if you were the grass, how would you feel?
C: As if I were being pushed away.
T: What is it that this grass needs?
C: A place where it can spread out. [She cries.]
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 141
T: Can you conjure a place in your mind’s eye where there is no grass
yet, and invite it to spread out there? As far as it wants? And tell the
lawn that you have seen his anger and that you can imagine what it’s
like when he feels constricted. And that you’ve found the space for
him that he needs to develop.
CHAPTER FIVE
143
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 144
victims can be found at all levels. There are lonely managers as well
as frustrated and demotivated subordinates. Whether it is perfor-
mance pressure, bullying, lack of integration into decision-making
processes, boundary crossings, concealing insecurity or incompetence
coupled with pompousness, there are numerous examples of how the
professional everyday lives of employees are made so off-putting that
they become ill.
How can inner images be worked with in this environment
between desk, workbench, computer, and PowerPoint presentations?
And how can these pictures help to solve the problems outlined
above?
Classic business psychology has only limited usefulness. Its aim is
not so much the well-being of the workforce and more the optimisa-
tion of work processes and business goals. The Mind Institute has,
therefore, blazed a new trail, in close co-operation with medium-sized
companies and larger companies in Germany. Some company execu-
tives complained about an above average number of sick leaves:
hence, they were all ready to participate in an unusual experiment.
They opened their doors to methods of clinical psychology that are
otherwise applied only in a therapeutic practice.
Specifically, managers and staff participated in sessions where they
sat in the company of a therapist, undisturbed by the rest of the work-
force, closed their eyes and imagined company problems in a
daydream. They appeared during the imagination sessions in alien-
ated forms and so became visible, which otherwise would probably
not have happened. Up to that point, the conflicts had been discussed
in only very few cases.
More than thirty executives from different sectors saw their
company or themselves symbolically in the imagination. The inner
images revealed to them the state their business was in currently. They
brought its “soul” to light.
Examples: a company appeared as a ghost in a daydream of its
owner—it was a company in which, according to workers, often
“much ado about nothing” happened and in which the representa-
tions of the executives were regarded as “hot air”. A manager saw
himself as a plough horse pulling a heavy load. Another experienced
himself as a bee in the hive.
In accordance with CIP, the solutions to the conflicts in these cases
were developed in the daydreams themselves: the ghost needed
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 145
REFERENCES
147
KRETSCHMAR Book_Kretschmar 22/09/2016 09:30 Page 148
148 REFERENCES
REFERENCES 149
INDEX
151
KRETSCHMAR Index_CULLEN index - No. centre 22/09/2016 09:33 Page 152
152 INDEX
INDEX 153
82–85, 88, 96–97, 102, 106, 120, father, 61, 66, 72, 89–90, 103, 105,
126, 133–134, 137 see also: 112–113, 120–121, 123–124, 134,
unconscious 138
affection, 88 figure, 64
constitution, 63 inner, 138
counselling, 42 program, 90
desire, 59 relationship, 138
disturbances, 57 Faulstich, J., 30
effects, 20 feeling (passim)
events, 83 as a being, 84
evocations, 31 carefree, 60
experiences, 13 deepest, 10
honesty, 54 dissatisfied, xii
immersion, 82 exposed, 7
intensity, 5, 61, 74–75 good, 26, 99, 135, 137
nature, 41 happy, 68
negative, 85 intense, 74
pain, 24 light as a feather, 33
positive, 72 negative, xi, 104
prevailing, 25 of a nocturnal dream, 60
primary, 4 of anger, 84
problems, 18, 31 of discomfort, 101
processes, 55 of discontent, xii
processing, 4, 17 of disgust, 75, 130–131
response, 31 of loneliness, 137
security, 24 of luck, 24
state, 70 of panic, 133, 138
sufferings, xi of relaxation, 127
trough, 77 of restlessness, 110
Eng, V., 24–25 of sadness, 102
Epidaurus, 27, 29 of safety, 77
Ernst, H., 9 of strength, 117
Erstling, T., 48–49, 52, 54 of trepidation, 92
Etcoff, N., 2 paralysing, 136
executives, 144 pleasant, 110
positive, 24
family, 18, 30, 36, 44, 48, 66, 88, 91, responses, 42
103, 126 sorry, 30
fantasy, 3, 9–10, 13, 23, 35, 39–41, strong, 5
53, 58, 65, 68, 73 see also: tense, 47
sexual unpleasant, 86
chocolate, 13 worthless, 4
perfect, 47 Flaubert, G., 5
pictures, 38 forest, 64–65, 68–69, 94, 105, 115–116,
repressed, 39 132, 134
KRETSCHMAR Index_CULLEN index - No. centre 22/09/2016 09:33 Page 154
154 INDEX
INDEX 155
156 INDEX
INDEX 157