Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Lec-10, Ch-5, Pavement Evaluation-4 Roughness & Skid
Lec-10, Ch-5, Pavement Evaluation-4 Roughness & Skid
By:
Bishnu Prasad Devkota
Course Contents
1. Introduction to Pavement Management (2hrs)
2. Pavement Management Methods (2hrs)
3. Management Information & Data Management (2hrs)
4. Pavement Defects in Flexible & Rigid Pavement (4hrs)
5. Pavement Evaluation (12hrs)
6. Pavement Condition Prediction Models (3hrs)
7. Defects and Remedy Measures (2hrs)
8. Treatment Selection (2hrs)
9. Importance of Maintenance (2hrs)
10. Financing of Roads for Maintenance(2hrs)
11. Prioritization(2hrs)
12. Road Investment Model (The HDM-IV) (2hrs)
13. Airport Pavement Management System(2hrs)
14. Network-Level PMS - M&R Work Planning(2hrs)
15. Project-Level Management (2hrs)
16. Ride Quality and Safety and Case Studies(2hrs)
2 By: B. P. Devkota May 26, 2016
Lecture-5
Ch-5, Pavement Evaluation
Measurement & Analysis of Roughness and
Skid Data
System Descriptions
– Most road meters measure the relative movement of
the axle with respect to the vehicle body or
the vertical acceleration of the vehicle body or axle.
– Measurements reported are normally in units of
inches per mile or
meters per kilometer
which is the cumulative movement of the suspension
between the axle and the body divided by the traveled
distance.
– These systems are also referred to as RTRRMS,
23 By: 1986;
(Sayers, Gillespie, and Paterson B. P. Sayers
Devkotaand Gillespie 1986; Sayers, Gillespie, and May
Queiroz
26,1986
2016
RTRRMS
Profilographs
– A profilograph is primarily used for construction
acceptance purposes.
– A profilograph consists of a rigid beam or frame with
a system of support wheels at either end, and a
center wheel (NHI2001).
– The support wheels at the ends establish a datum
from which the deviations of the center wheel can
be evaluated.
Profilographs
– The center wheel is linked to a strip chart recorder
or a computer that records the movement of the
center wheel from the established datum.
– The profilograph is pushed along the pavement, and
3 to 5 km (2 to 3 miles) can be measured in an hour.
– Figure 5-21 is a photograph of a truss type
California profilograph.
Straightedge
– The straightedge is used primarily for construction
acceptance purposes.
– Typical smoothness specifications indicate a
maximum deviation of 3 mm (1 /8 in.) for a 3 m (10
ft) straightedge.
– Figure 5-22 shows a schematic diagram of a rolling
straightedge.
The MERLIN
Roughness
Machine
– It is a machine for
evaluating
roughness using
low cost instrument
as shown in figure-
a. (Source: DoR,
1995)
30 By: B. P. Devkota May 26, 2016
RTRRMS
Profile Filtering
– A profile consists of different wavelengths, varying
from a few inches to hundreds of feet.
– This can be achieved using a technique called the
"moving average filter," (Sayers and Gillespie 1986).
– This technique smoothes the profile at each point
by averaging the elevation over a selected base
length as shown in Figure 5-1.
Waveband Indices
– Waveband analysis is used to reduce a road profile
to several indices, each quantifying roughness over
a given waveband (range of wavelengths).
– Roughness can be analyzed over short, medium,
and long wavelengths.
Slope Variance
– The slope variance (SV) is a roughness index based
on the changes in the slope of a pavement profile. It
is described by the following equation:
SV = Σ(Xi – X)2/(n-1)
where
SV = slope variance
X i = ith slope measurement
n = number of slope measurements
X = mean slope measurement
Acceleration
– Acceleration is another indicator of pavement
roughness.
– An acceleration-versus-distance plot along a
pavement can help to locate areas that cause
extreme acceleration, so they can be smoothed out.
– This technique has been used with increasing
success in measuring airport pavement roughness.
– Several computer programs have been developed
to model the aircraft/runway profile interaction.
52 By: B. P. Devkota May 26, 2016
Skid Data Collection & Analysis
By:
Bishnu Prasad Devkota
Introduction
It is used … … …
– to identify pavement sections with low or rapidly
deteriorating levels of skid resistance.
– as a management tool to help prioritize pavement
maintenance and rehabilitation and
– to select the appropriate maintenance and
rehabilitation (M&R) alternative.
Traffic
– Two pavement sections built at the same time may
have different friction coefficients because they
have been subjected to different traffic.
– As traffic rolls over the pavement, the tires polish
the surface microtexture, Wear, dislocation, or
reorientation of aggregates may also occur
especially under heavy traffic.
Traffic
– Figure 6-2 shows the friction factor for six different
pavement sections and illustrates the effect of traffic
– All sections had the same type of surface course
and were installed at the same time, but they were
subjected to different traffic volumes (over a 3-year).
– It is found that, there is a better correlation with the
number of trucks than total number of vehicles.
Traffic
– Figure 6-3
illustrates the
fact that skid
resistance
reaches a
mean equi-
librium value
after many
applications of
traffic.
62 By: B. P. Devkota May 26, 2016
Traffic and Seasonal Variations
Seasonal
– There is no
specific value
at which it
levels off Due
to seasonal
variations of
skid
resistance
(Fig. 6-1).
63 By: B. P. Devkota May 26, 2016
Speed
Speed
– In general, the friction coefficient decreases with
increase in speed.
– It has been determined that on dry pavement, the
friction factor changes very little with change in
speed; however, on wet pavement the decrease is
significant.
– Figures 6-4 and 6-5 show the change in friction with
speed for concrete and asphalt pavements under
dry and wet conditions.
64 By: B. P. Devkota May 26, 2016
65 By: B. P. Devkota May 26, 2016
Speed
– As mentioned
earlier, on dry
surfaces the
friction factor
changes only
slightly with
speed. This may
not be the case,
however, for
asphalt surfaces
if bleeding occurs
66 (Fig. 6-6). By: B. P. Devkota May 26, 2016
Tire Pressure
Tire Pressure
– Experiments have shown that for a given wheel
load, an increase in tire pressure will cause a
decrease in friction coefficient.
– This can be attributed to the increased area of
contact at low inflation pressure—the heat created
by skidding or deceleration is distributed over a
large area, which results in a cooler tire and a high
friction coefficient
Wheel Load
– Studies using varying wheel loads have shown that
the friction coefficient decreases as the wheel load
increases (Fig. 6-7).
– One of the explanations for such a phenomenon is
that the increase in wheel load causes a decrease
in the tire contact area per unit load and therefore a
decrease in the friction coefficient.
– In contrast, it was also reported that a slight
increase in friction coefficient occurred on ice as the
68 rear axle staticBy:load was increased.
B. P. Devkota May 26, 2016
69 By: B. P. Devkota May 26, 2016
Tire Tread
Tire Tread
– Tread design has a significant influence on braking
effectiveness.
– Tire grooves provide channels through which water
at the tire-pavement interface can be displaced.
– At high speeds or in the presence of thick water
films, there is not enough time for the water to be
displaced and hydroplaning may occur.
– Figure 6-8 shows a comparison between braking
effectiveness of smooth and five-groove tires for the
70 990A aircraft tires.
By: B. P. Devkota May 26, 2016
71 By: B. P. Devkota May 26, 2016
Pavement Factors
Pavement Factors
– Surface texture can be defined in terms of
microtexture and macrotexture (see Fig.6-9).
– Microtexture is what makes an aggregate smooth or
rough to the touch.
Its contribution to friction is through adhesion with the tire.
– The macrotexture is the result of the shape, size,
and arrangement of the aggregates (for flexible
pavements), or the surface finish (for concrete
surfaces).
72 By: B. P. Devkota May 26, 2016
73 By: B. P. Devkota May 26, 2016
Friction Measurement Methods
Several methods
– Locked-Wheel Mode
– Slip Mode
– Yaw Mode
– Laboratory and Texture Measurement Methods
Locked-Wheel Mode
– Trailers having weight(L) with one or two wheels are
towed (drag, pull) at a given speed. The test wheel
is then locked and water is applied in front of it.
– After the test wheel has been sliding on the
pavement for a certain distance to stabilize the
temperature, the friction force (F) in the tire contact
patch is recorded for a specified period of time
Friction Force ( F )
Friction Factor , I ;
Normal Load ( L)
75 Skid Number , SN 100 * I May 26, 2016
Fig: Locked Wheel Skid Tester
76 By: B. P. Devkota May 26, 2016
Friction Measurement Methods
Slip Mode
– where
W0 = angular wheel speed at free rolling
W = angular wheel speed at the time of measurement.
Yaw Mode
– The yaw mode measures the sideways friction
factor by turning the test wheel (unbraked) to an
angle with the direction of motion (yaw angle).
– Since the sideways friction factor varies with the
magnitude of the yaw angle as shown in Figure 6-
17,
1. Frequency
2. Visual Survey
3. Measurement Operations
1. Frequency
– Pavement surface texture wears down over time
due to traffic tire rolling and braking.
– Therefore, friction should be measured periodically
and more frequently with heavier traffic.
– It is recommended that the airport operator should
select the next higher level of aircraft operations in
Figure 6-22 to determine the minimum survey
frequency.
1. Frequency
2. Visual Survey
– It is always beneficial to conduct visual inspection of
the surface condition in addition to the direct friction
measurement.
– During the visual survey note
The condition of pavement texture,
Evidence of drainage problems, and
Presence of distresses that could cause skidding or
hydroplaning.
2. Visual Survey
– Distresses that lead to decreased skid resistance or
increased hydroplaning potential include
Bleeding,
Depressions,
Rutting, and
Joint faulting in concrete pavements.
3. Measurement Operation
– Friction measurement should be conducted along
the wheel path.
– On highways with four or more lanes, the outside
lanes are tested, but some agencies test all four
lanes.
– Several M&R alternatives can be used if the friction
condition survey revealed skid problems or potential
problems.
Overlays
– Overlays are particularly feasible if the pavement is
structurally deficient or needs to be strengthened for
future traffic.
– Overlays are also feasible if defects are severe
enough that a surface treatment will not correct
them.
Saw-Cut Grooves
– Grooves provide a significant improvement in
friction during wet weather.
– The grooves provide channels for the water to
escape, thus allowing direct contact between the
vehicle tire and the pavement surface.
– The grooves are sawed transversely across the
highway or runway.
– Grooves are mostly used on concrete pavements
but can also be used on asphaltic concrete
94 pavements. By: B. P. Devkota May 26, 2016
Removing Contaminants
Removing Contaminants
– Contaminants include:
Rubber deposits,
Oil spills, dust, and
Any other material that may decrease skid resistance.
– Methods used to remove them are:
High pressure water,
Chemical, and
Mechanical grinding.
High velocity impact of tiny steel abrasive media against
the pavement surface
95 May 26, 2016
Model Questions