Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 18

Residential Insulation

Michael J. Currie
GrotonLocal.org
10 October 2007
Why we insulate?

To slow the transfer of heat --


Heat is the form of energy exchanged between objects of
different temperatures!
Outline
 Building Envelope
 R-values
 Insulation Types
 Insulation Case Study
 Other insights
 Health Factors
 Installation
 Tax incentives
 Discussion
Building Envelope -- the “skin”
of your structure
The building envelope consists of
all the surfaces that separate the
controlled space from the
uncontrolled space.

 Primary envelope is the exterior


of your home
 Secondary envelope is a
controlled space that bisects an
uncontrolled space
-- ductwork in attic, pipes in
basement, refridgerator, hot
water heater
 Thermal bridges are lossy
pathways across the envelope

To maximize efficiency of the home, all envelopes must be


properly insulated.
R-values
 Industry measurement of the resistivity to heat flow,
inverse of thermal conductivity (U)
R = 1/U
 Higher R-values (more insulation) prevent heat flow
Material
Outside Air Film
R-value
0.2
R = R1 + R2 +
Siding Wood Bevel 0.8 R3 + …
1/2” Plywood Sheathing 0.6
Fiberglass Batt 11.0
1/2” Drywall 0.5 Units: ft2 .°F.hr/BTU
Inside Air Film 0.7
Total Wall 13.8
R-values cont’d
1
"Heat = (THOT # TCOLD ) Area
R
Factor Energy Usage

R-value

Temp Difference
Amount of
energy you Area
must
supply per This is the basis for your insulation strategy!
hour
Example - Your front door
1
"Heat = (THOT # TCOLD ) Area
R
1
170 = (65 " 25) 21
BTU/hr
3.7 (3’ x 7’)

Annual heat loss is equivalent to 5 gallons of fuel oil.


(1 gallon fuel oil = 140,000 BTU)
! ! !
!
Recommended R-values
38 38

49
38

25

11 to 22

30
Band Joist

19 10 11
Types of Insulation
R per inch

3.1

2.1

2.2 - 3.7

4-6.5

various

Source: DOE Insulation Factsheet


R-value caveats
 Insulation manufacturers measure R-values in a lab, not in the real
world…
 “Center of Cavity” -- only insulation, no structure,WYSIWYG
 Clear Wall -- wall w/ minimal studs
 Whole Wall -- wall w/ windows, corners, etc.
For a 2x6 wall w/ R-19 batts and studs 24” o.c.
Center of Cavity Clear Wall Whole Wall
21.6 16.4 13.7 2/3
Source: Oak Ridge National Labs

Extreme Cold Air and Moisture degrade R-value performance of batt and loose
fill insulation
Moisture -7.5% per 1% moisture
Extreme Cold
Heating and cooling days
 Degree day captures  Heating Days
the average 6000 degree days
temperature below  Cooling Days
the typical heating 500 degree days
set-point of 65° F 1400

 Example: 10° F
1200

1000

average temperature
800

2005
600
2006

gives 55 degree days


400

200

0
Jan Mar May Jun Aug Oct Nov

-200

In New England, heating dominates energy consumption


Residential Case Study
 Built: 1978
 Living Space: 2400 sq ft.
 Perimeter: 156 ft.
 Energy Usage:
800 gallons fuel oil and 20
kWh per day-(100 million
BTU during the heating
season)
 Construction:
2x4, R-11 batts
R-19 in cathedral ceiling
Single/Double Pane Windows
No basement insulation

What are the available options?


Upgrading Windows
Case study
Type R-value BTU/year/ sq ft.
savings

Single Pane 1.0 144000 -

Single Pane w/ $16.88 per


2.0 72000
storm window

Double Pane, $5.63 per


3.0 48000
low e window

Triple Pane 4.0 36000

Payback time is 50 to 200+ years! - Very bad news

Assumes: Fuel Oil is $2.50


Insulating Basement
 8’ below ground level temperature is 50 - 55° F during the winter.
The equivalent number of degrees days during the heating season is 1800.

For 1300 square feet of floor (R-value = 1.6), the heating load is
equivalent to 300 gallons of fuel oil ($750). The actual value is higher if
the basement has drafts, i.e. the underground temperature is higher.

 How to insulate?
 Do not use fiberglass if the
area is moist. Your
investment will be ruined.
 Ceiling -- basement is
unheated, attacks the problem
at the source.
 Walls -- basement is heated,
fairly dry.
 Always insulate band joist R-
30
External Foam under clapboarding
 Can you economically add foam over siding, if you intend to
change siding?
Material Old R- New R-
value value
Outside Air Film 0.2 0.2
Siding Wood Bevel - 0.8
1” Rigid Insulation - 5
Air Pocket - 1.0
Siding Wood Bevel 0.8 0.8
1/2” Plywood Sheathing 0.6 0.6
Fiberglass Batt 11.0 11.0
1/2” Drywall 0.5 0.5
Inside Air Film 0.7 0.7
Total Wall 13.8 20.6

 Case Study: 1500 sq. ft. of siding -- savings of 53 gallons of


fuel oil or $115 per year.
 Not economical if you need to change any aspect of window
detail, most likely over 10 year pay back time!
Case Study Conclusions
 Basement Insulation would be a sure bet. Large possible
savings, with easy access on the inside.
 Replacement windows and insulation under new
clapboarding are not cost effective.
 Other options:
 For windows: R-5 insert into windows at night would yield $5 per
window per year.
 Two other elements of the heat loss equation
 Reduce square footage -- only heat required rooms
 Reduce setpoint -- 7 degree setback for overnight saves 11% across
whole structure during the heating season
 Can be achieved with programmable thermostats
Other Factors
 Health Factors
 Vermiculite fill may contain asbestos
 70% of vermiculite mined from contaminated mine in Libby, MT
 Fiberglass insulation is a skin and airway irritant, and can contain
carcinogens, formaldehyde allergens
 Wet insulation supports mold growth
 Installation
 Improper installation may degrade whole wall r-value
 Fiberglass should not be compressed, voids behind junction boxes
should be insulated, area around door/window frames
 Vapor barrier products must have vapor barrier facing high
moisture area.
 Tax Incentives
 Energy Policy Act of 2005 -- credit of 10% up to $500 for the cost
of qualifying energy efficiency purchases, i.e. insulation and
appliances
Discussion

You might also like