Professional Documents
Culture Documents
G.R. No. 160261
G.R. No. 160261
2742
ABCB5D#E2354742
FGHI
JK>K%L'K%MNOPNM%%%%%%%%%%%%%L'3/QR/:%MOS%POOT
0>L0-U8%VK%W>?L&4-&8S%5>KS5
L?JX?X?<?-?Y4U%L?%XJ?%X?L?L?LJJ8<%LJ%XJ?%X?LJJ?J?Z?LJ%[4<4[4L8S%4L&KS%4U-%8WW4&0>-
?L\%X0XV0>-S]]5
Z8><\%Z?>%44%^0U0>?L-%<0J48L?>40-%8W%U_0%[_4<4[[4L0-S%4L&KS]]5
U_0%_8@-0%8W%>0[>0-0LU?U4^0-S%>0[>0-0LU0\%V`%-[0?Y0>%58-0%JK%\0%^0L0&4?S%U_0%-0L?U0S
>0[>0-0LU0\%V`%-0L?U0%[>0-4\0LU%W>?LY<4L%XK%\>4<8LS%>0[>0-0LU?U4^0%J4<V0>U8%&K
U08\8>8S%5>K%?L\%>0[>0-0LU?U4^0%W0<4a%Z4<<4?X%VK%W@0LU0V0<<?S
5?4X0%LK%-8>4?L8S]]b5
-0L?U8>%?c@4<4L8%cK%[4X0LU0<S%]]
d]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]d
JK>K%L'K%MNOPNP%L'3/QR/:%MOS%POOT
-0\W>0`%XK%&?L\0<?>4?S%&?><8-%[K%X0\4L?S%5>K%?L\%_0L0\4L?%>?e8Lf?V?\S5
?UU`-K%>8X@<8%VK%X?&?<4LU?<%?L\%[0U0%c@4>4L8%c@?\>?S]]5
Z8><\%Z?>%44%^0U0>?L-%<0J48L?>40-%8W%U_0%[_4<4[[4L0-S%4L&KS%]]5
U_0%_8@-0%8W%>0[>0-0LU?U4^0-S%U_>8@J_%U_0%-[0?Y0>%8>%?&U4LJ%-[0?Y0>%8>%[>0-4\4LJ
8WW4&0>S%-[0?Y0>%58-0%JK%\0%^0L0&4?S%>0[>0-0LU?U4^0%J4<V0>U8%JK%U08\8>8S%5>KS
>0[>0-0LU?fU4^0%W0<4a%Z4<<4?X%VK%W@0LU0V0<<?S%U_0%-0L?U0%8W%U_0%[_4<4[[4L0-S%U_>8@J_%4U-
[>0-4\0LUS%-0L?U0%[>0-4\0LU%W>?LY<4L%XK%\>4<8LS5
5?4X0%LK%-8>4?L8S]]5
-0L?U8>%?c@4<4L8%cK%[4X0LU0<S%]]
d]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]d
JK>K%L'K%MNOPNT%L'3/QR/:%MOS%POOT
?>U@>8%XK%\0%&?-U>8%?L\%-8<0\?\%XK%&?J?X[?LJS5
Z8><\%Z?>%44%^0U0>?L-%<0J48L?>40-%8W%U_0%[_4<4[[4L0-S%4L&KS%]]5
W>?LY<4L%XK%\>4<8LS%4L%_4-%&?[?&4U`%?-%-0L?U0%[>0-4\0LUS%?L\%58-0%JK%\0%^0L0&4?S%5>KS%4L%_4-
&?[?&4U`%?-%-[0?Y0>%8W%U_0%_8@-0%8W%>0[>0-0LU?U4^0-S5
5?4X0%LK%-8>4?L8S]]5
-0L?U8>%?c@4<4L8%cK%[4X0LU0<S%]]
d]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]d
JK>K%L'K%MNOPgg%L'3/QR/:%MOS%POOT
W>?L&4-&8%4K%&_?^0eS5
Z8><\%Z?>%44%^0U0>?L-%<0J48L?>40-%8W%U_0%[_4<4[[4L0-S%4L&KS%]]5
8111147714771!"2742"477# 21$
01231425278349
2742
%&'()*+),()-(.(/012)0.)30')/141/056)1')'4(17(8)&9)53()3&:'()&9)8(48('(.5150-('2)981.7;0.
<+),80;&.2)0.)30')/141/056)1')48('0,(.5)&9)53()'(.15()&9)53()8(4:=;0/)&9)53()430;0440.('2
*0;=(85)5(&,&8&2)%8+2)9(;0>)?0;;01<)9:(.5(=(;;12)%:;0&);(,('<1)0-2)3(.86);1.&52)70<
=(8.18,&@;&70.2)<18/(;0.&);0=1.1.2)(<<6;&:)51;0A&@'1.5&'2),&:*;1')/1*1'2)'3(8?0.
*15/31;01.2);:0')=(8'1<0.2)%8+2).(80''1)'&&.@8:0B2)(8.('5&).0(-12)(,*18)(80/(2)0'<1(;
<153162)'1<:(;),1.*?12)1;98(,&)<181A&.2)%8+2)/(/0;01)/188(&.@%1;&'%&'2)1*1405&
1C:0.&2)91:'5&)'(1/3&.2)%8+2)*(&8*0;:)6:<:;@3(8<0,12)%&'()/18;&');1/'&.2)<1.:(;
&85(*12):;081.)%:1C:0.2)'&8161)%119182)?0;3(;<0.&)'6@1;-181,&2)/;1:,()=1:50'512),(;),(
*:B<1.2)B(.10,1)/8:B@,:/:52)1:*:'5&)=1/:;0&2)91:'50.&),6)0002)1:*:'5&)'6%:/&2)8&BB1.&
8:90.&)=01B&.2);(&-0*0;,&)=1.11*2)(80/)'0.*'&.2)%1/0.5&)4181'2)%&'()'&;0'2)8(.15&
<15:=&2)3(8<0.&)5(-('2)1<1,&)('40.&2)%8+2)(<0;0&)<1/01'2)1853:8)40.*&62)%8+2)981./0'
.(4&<:/(.&2)/&.81,&)('58(;;1)0002)(;01')=:;:52)%8+2)%:8,0.)8&<:1;,&2)%:1.)41=;&)=&.,&/2
*(.(8&'&)5:;1*1.2)4(84(5:&)6;1*1.2)<0/31(;),:1-052)%&'(43),:81.&2)%(';0);14:'2
/18;&')/&%:1.*/&2)*0&8*0,0)1**1=1&2)981./0')('/:,(88&2)8(.()-(;18,(2)/(;'&
;&=8(*152)1;040&)=1,(;;('2),0,1*(.),0;1.*1;(.2)1=8131<)<05812)%&'(43)'1.501*&2
,18;(.()1.5&.0&@/:'5&,0&2)1;(51)':18(B2)8&,&;9)4;1B12)%-)=1:50'512)*8(*&80&)04&.*2
*0;=(85)8(<:;;12)8&;(>)':4;0/&2)/(;01);16:'2)%:1.)<0*:(;)B:=0802)=(.1'0.*)<1/181<=&.2
%8+2)%&'(90.1)%&'&.2)<187)/&%:1.*/&2)<1:80/0&),&<&*1.2)8&.1;,&)B1<&812)1.*(;&
<&.50;;12)8&'(;;(8)=180.1*12)%('.18)91;/&.2)8(6;0.1).0/&;1'2)8&,&;9&)1;=1.&2)%&1C:0.
/304(/&2)%8+2)1.,)8:6)(;01');&4(B25
%10<().+)'&801.&2DD5
'(.15&8)1C:0;0.&)C+)40<(.5(;2)DD
EDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDE
*+8+).F+)GHIJKJ).FLMNOMP)GI2)JIIQ
3(8<0.0&)31886);+)8&C:(2)%8+2)%&(;)8:0B)=:5:61.2)<1+)/(/0;01)41412).14&;(&.)/+)8(6('2
1.5&.0&)3+)1=1,2)%8+2)1;98(,&)/+);0*&.2)%&1.)4+)'(881.&)1.,)*186)'+)<1;;18025
?&8;,)?18)00)-(5(81.');(*0&.180(')&9)53()430;0440.('2)0./+2)DD5
3&.+)'4(17(8)%&'()*+),()-(.(/012)%8+)1.,)8&=(85&)4+).1B18(.&2)0.)30')/141/056)1'
'(/8(5186)*(.(81;)&9)53()3&:'()&9)8(48('(.5150-('2)1.,)53()3&:'()&9)8(48('(.5150-('2
5
%10<().+)'&801.&2DD5
'(.15&8)1C:0;0.&)C+)40<(.5(;2DD
EDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDE
*+8+).F+)GHIJKR).FLMNOMP)GI2)JIIQ
'1;1/.0=)9+)=15(80.1)1.,),(4:56)'4(17(8)81:;)<+)*&.B1;('25
?&8;,)?18)00)-(5(81.');(*0&.180(')&9)53()430;0440.('2)0./+2DD5
53()3&:'()&9)8(48('(.@5150-('2)538&:*3)53()'4(17(8)&8)1/50.*)'4(17(8)&8)48('0,0.*
&990/(82)'4(17(8)%&'()*+),()-(.(/012)8(48('(.5150-()*0;=(85&)*+)5(&,&8&2)%8+2
8(48('(.5150-()9(;0>)?0;;01<)=+)9:(.5(=(;;12)53()'(.15()&9)53()430;0440.('2)538&:*3)05'
48('0,(.52)'(.15()48('0,(.5)981.7;0.)<+),80;&.25
%10<().+)'&801.&2DD5
'(.15&8)1C:0;0.&)C+)40<(.5(;2)DD
EDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDE
*+8+).F+)GHIQGI).FLMNOMP)GI2)JIIQ
;(&.0;&)8+)1;9&.'&2)4(5(8)1;-18(B2)'1<:(;),&/5&82)<(;-0.)<150=1*2)81<&.)<0C:0=1'2
8&,&;9&)<1*'0.&2)(,:18,&)<1;1'1*12)(,:18,&)'18<0(.5&2)(,*18,&).1&(2);(&.18,&
*18/012)(,*18,)'<0532)(<(5(80&)<(.,0&;12)<180&)5&8(%12)*:0;;(8<&)/1'51':'2).(;'&.)1+
;&6&;12)?0;98(,&)=(;;&2)%8+2)8&..0()5&C:0;;&2)715()1..)-051;2)1.*(;051)C+)*:B<1.2)<&.0/&
41=;('2)%8+2)%10<()=&1C:0.12);051)1+)1C:0.&2)<0;1)4+)*1=05&2)%1.(55()188&6&2)80B1;,6)(<40*2
(8.1);13:B2)3&<(8)/1;0=1*2),8+)=0.*)18/(2)'0<(&.)18/(2)%8+2)(;),(;;()18/(2)?0;;0()80-(8&2
,1.5(),01B2)1;=(85&)=:(.1-0'512)91:'5&)=:(.1-0'512)(<0;6)'(.(80'2)1..1)/;180''1);&6&;12
'1;-1/0&.);&6&;12)810.0(8)C:08&;*0/&2)%&'(43);(1.,8&);&6&;12)1.5&.0&);0=8(12)90;(<&.
'0=:;&2)<1.:(;),+)/&<012)%:;05&):+)'&&.2)-08*0;0&);:'58(2)1.,).&(;)0'&8(.12)<1:
8('580-(812)<1>)-0;;1('5(82)1.,)(,0;=(85&)*1;;&825
?&8;,)?18)00)-(5(81.');(*0&.180(')&9)53()430;0440.('2)0./+2)DD5
8111147714771!"2742"477# 41$
01231425278349
2742
%&'(&)*+'(),(-'.-'+'/%0%12'+3(-'.-'+'/%'4(56(&)/7(+.'08'-(9)+'(:7(4'(2'/':103(9-73(%&'
+'/0%'3(-'.-'+'/%'4(56(&)/7(+'/0%'(.-'+14'/%(,-0/8;1/(4-1;)/3(&)/7(,';1<(,*'/%'5';;03
'%(0;73(
=>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>=
?7-7(/@7(ABCDAE(/@FGHIGJ(AC3(KCCD
.*5;1:(1/%'-'+%(:'/%'-3(1/:73(:-1+.1/(%7(-'6'+3(5
&)/7(+.'08'-(9)+'(?7(4'(2'/':103(0;;(L'L5'-+3(&)*+'(),(-'.-'+'/%0%12'+3(&)/7(+'/0%'
.-'+14'/%(,-0/8;1/(L7(4-1;)/3(0/4(0;;(L'L5'-+3(.&1;1..1/'(+'/0%'3(
=>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>=
?7-7(/@7(ABCDMK(/@FGHIGJ(AC3(KCCD
0%%67(,'-/0/4)(.7-7(.'-1%)3(1/(&1+(:0.0:1%6(0+(0(L'L5'-(),(%&'(1/%'?-0%'4(50-(),(%&'
.&1;1..1/'+3(L0/1;0(1113(0/4('/?-7(L0<1L)(/7(L'/'N(9-73(1/(&1+(:0.0:1%6(0+(0(%0<.06'-(0/4
L'L5'-(),(%&'('/?1/''-1/?(.-),'++1)/3(5
%&'(&)*+'(),(-'.-'+'/%0O%12'+(-'.-'+'/%'4(56(%&'(ED(&)/)-05;'(L'L5'-+(),(%&'(&)*+'
;'4(56(&)/7(-'.-'+'/%0%12'(P1;;10L(,*'/%'5';;03(
=>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>=
?7-7(/@7(ABCDMD(/@FGHIGJ(AC3(KCCD
1/%'?-0%'4(50-(),(%&'(.&1;1..1/'+3(5
%&'(&)*+'(),(-'.-'+'/%0O%12'+3(%&-)*?&(%&'(+.'08'-()-(0:%1/?(+.'08'-()-(.-'+141/?
),,1:'-3(+.'08'-(9)+'(?7(4'(2'/':103(-'.-'+'/%0%12'(?1;5'-%)(?7(%')4)-)3(9-73
-'.-'+'/%0%12'(,';1<(P1;;10L(57(,*'/%'5';;03(%&'(+'/0%'(),(%&'(.&1;1..1/'+(%&-)*?&(1%+
.-'+14'/%3(+'/0%'(.-'+14'/%(,-0/8;1/(L7(4-1;)/3(
=>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>=
?7-7(/@7(ABCDBC(/@FGHIGJ(AC3(KCCD
:;0-)(57(,;)-'+3(5
%&'(&)*+'(),(-'.-'+'/%0%12'+(%&-)*?&(%&'(+.'08'-3(0/4(%&'(+'/0%'(),(%&'(.&1;1..1/'+3
%&-)*?&(%&'(+'/0%'(.-'+14'/%3(
=>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>=
?7-7(/@7(ABCDBQ(/@FGHIGJ(AC3(KCCD
*7.7(;0P(0;*L/1(:'5*(,)*/40%1)/3(1/:73(?)'-1/?(?7:7(.04'-0/?03(40/1;)(27()-%1N3(?;)-10(:7
'+%'/N)O-0L)+3(;1N0(47(:)--)3(;*1+(27(41)-'+3(+-73(5'/90L1/(+7(-0;;)/3(-);0/4)(.7(/)/0%)3
40/%'(%7(-0L)+3(';+0(-7(4121/0?-0:103(80-'/(57(:0.0--)+O0-R*1;;0/)3(+6;20(?7(0?*1--'O
.04'-0/?03(,)-(%&'L+';2'+(0/4(1/(5'&0;,(),()%&'-(:1%1N'/+(),(%&'(-'.*5;1:(),(%&'
.&1;1..1/'+3(5
%&'(&)*+'(),(-'.-'+'/%0O%12'+3(+.'08'-(9)+'(?7(4'(2'/':103(%&'(+'/0%'(),(%&'(.&1;1..1/'+3
+'/0%'(.-'+14'/%(,-0/8;1/(4-1;)/3(&)*+'(-'.-'+'/%0%12'+(,';1<(,*'/%'5';;0(0/4
?1;5'-%)(%')4)-)3(56(%&'L+';2'+(0/4(0+(-'.-'+'/%0%12'+(),(%&'(?-)*.(),(L)-'(%&0/(EC
&)*+'(-'.-'+'/%0%12'+(P&)(+1?/'4(0/4(,1;'4(%&'(1L.'0:&L'/%(:)L.;01/%(0?01/+%
+*.-'L'(:)*-%(:&1',(9*+%1:'(&1;0-1)(?7(40214'3(9-7(
=>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>=
?7-7(/@7(ABCDSC(/@FGHIGJ(AC3(KCCD
,-7(-0/&1;1)(:0;;0/?0/(0R*1/)3(5
8111147714771!"2742"477# 1$
01231425278349
2742
%&'(&)*)+,-.'(/+'012'*%()3(%&'(0'*,%'4(%&'(&)*)+,-.'(0/',5'+()3(%&'(&)60'()3
+'/+'0'*%,%17'04(
89999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999998
:;+;(*<;(=>?@A>(*<BCDECF(=?4(G??@
*1.)(,;(H,.,*I,)*4(5
&)*;(3'.1J(K1..1,H(36'*%'-'..,(,*2(:1.-'+%(%')2)+)4(1*(+'/+'0'*%,%1)*()3(%&'(L>
01:*,%)+1'0()3(%&'(,+%1M.'0()3(1H/',M&H'*%(,:,1*0%(M&1'3(N60%1M'(&1.,+1)(:;(2,712'4(N+;
,*2(%&'(&)60'()3(+'/+'0'*%,%17'04(M)*:+'00()3(%&'(/&1.1//1*'04(+'/+'0'*%'2(-I(1%0
0/',5'+4(&)*;(N)0'(:;(2'(7'*'M1,4(
89999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999998
:;+;(*<;(=>?@OG(*<BCDECF(=?4(G??@
7'*1M1)(0;(3.)+'0(,*2(&'M%)+(.;(&)31.'P,4(5
%&'(&)60'()3(+'/+'0'*%,%17'04(%&+)6:&(0/',5'+(N)0'(:;(2'(7'*'M1,4(,*2(%&'(0'*,%'()3
%&'(/&1.1//1*'04(%&+)6:&(0'*,%'(/+'012'*%(3+,*5.1*(2+1.)*4(
89999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999998
:;+;(*<;(=>?@OA(*<BCDECF(=?4(G??@
1*(%&'(H,%%'+()3(%&'(1H/',M&H'*%(M)H/.,1*%(,:,1*0%(M&1'3(N60%1M'(&1.,+1)(:;(2,712'4(N+;4
,%%I;(21)0M)+)(6;(7,..'N)04(N+;4(
89999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999998
:;+;(*<;(=>?Q?@(*<BCDECF(=?4(G??@
/&1.1//1*'(-,+(,00)M1,%1)*4(5
%&'(&)60'()3(+'/+'0'*%,%17'04(%&+)6:&(%&'(0/',5'+()+(/+'0121*:()331M'+4(&)*;(N)0'(:;
2'(7'*'M1,4(+'/+'0'*%,%17'(:1.-'+%)(:;(%')2)+)4(N+;4(+'/+'0'*%,%17'(3'.1J(K1..1,H(-;
36'*%'-'.,4(%&'(0'*,%'()3(%&'(/&1.1//1*'04(%&+)6:&(0'*,%'(/+'012'*%4(&)*;(3+,*5.1*
2+1.)*4
89999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999998
:;+;(*<;(=>?Q?R(*<BCDECF(=?4(G??@
2'H)M+1%)(M;(-,+M'*,04(/+'012'*%()3(1-/4(M'-6(M1%I(M&,/%'+4(H,*6'.(H;(H)*S)*4(/+'0121*:
)3(1-/4(M'-6(/+)71*M'4(71M%)+(,;(H,,H-)*:4(/+)71*M1,.(-),+2(H'H-'+4(,2'.1*)(-;(01%)I4
2',*()3(%&'(M)..':(')3(.,K4(6*17'+01%I()3(M'-64(I)6*:(.,KI'+0(,00)M,1%1)*()3(M'-64(1*M;
TI.,MU4(+'/+0''*%'2(-I(,%%I;(H,*6'.(.':,0/14(M)*3'2'+,%1)*()3(,MM+'21%'2(H'21,%)+0()3
%&'(/&1.1//1*'04(1*M;(TM,H/4(1*MU4(+'/+'0'*%'2(-I(+)2'+1M(+;(/)M,4(H,*2,6'(.,KI'+0
,00)M1,%1)*4(TH,*.,KU4(+'/+'0'*%'2(-I(3'.1/'(7'.,0V6'S4(3'2'+,M1)*(1*%'+*,M1)*,.(2'
,-):,2,0(T312,U4(+'/+'0'*%'2(-I(%&'.H,(.;(N)+2,*4(M,+.)0(:;(M)4(/+'01'*%()3(M'-6
M&,H-'+()3(M)HH'+M'(,*2(1*260%+I(,*2(M'-6(.,2I(.,KI'+0(,00)M1,%1)*4(1*M;(TM'..,4(1*M;U4
H,+1-'..'(*,7,++)(,*2(-'+*,+21%)(3.)+12)4(/,0%(/+'012'*%(M'-6(M&,H-'+()3(M)HH'+M'
,*2(1*%':+,%'2(-,+()3(%&'(/&1.1//1*'04(M'-6(M&,/%'+4(5
%&'(&)60'()3(+'/+'0'*%,W%17'04(+'/+'0'*%'2(-I(+'/;(N)0'(:;(2'(7'*'M1,4(,0(&)60'
0/',5'+(,*2(%&'(0'*,%'4(+'/+'0'*%'2(-I(0'*,%)+(3+,*5.1*(2+1.)*4(,0(0'*,%'(/+'012'*%4
M,+/1)(H)+,.'04(XYZ
[\]\\!^#\^\5##!_\\]
#_]5#]_]\^!#^5\
8^\\`^^#]^
Ennopnoqr
2s.UU.5
27422L7:2L4t@Mu>u
49),@,
&&>)+;*?J,5;vs.UU.5
274243:w>
>
475(,'&#(#
(&*
xW\40*!9?20$0v;'2L520L$w5;?=(u
!,&;,'#('*(,,'%
('##&,u(',!,&!#,&
##(&;,'&,,%5#,&&&,
%#&,u
$s.UU.5
2742247:20t@Muyu
37,##';,@#J9!(5;<5
')95
@7*
**5#,;,;*J!5
z@{#(!
`3j6V$24:24$
Is.UU.Z
27$7$L:3t@Mu@u
L811,!!1,1(1"|("}
970000
0s.UU.Z
2744L