Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Technology's Impact On The Marketing Function: Christopher R. Schmidt
Technology's Impact On The Marketing Function: Christopher R. Schmidt
Technology's Impact On The Marketing Function: Christopher R. Schmidt
019-028
Abstract
This paper provides an overview of classical subjects contained in the Marketing discipline, with an emphasis
on the impact of technology on the functional roles of Marketing Management within a firm. The significance of
Marketing, rooted in its power to influence customers, to increase the value and demand for an entity (or per-
son) and its service or good, create exceptional cash flow, and deliver a market premium, through differentia-
tion from the competition remains unchanged. Behind the buzz and dazzle of such huge topics as social me-
dia and internet technology, there are further reaching changes being caused by a plethora of new technolo-
gies that are being applied inside the Marketing organization. The future of technology promises to transform
traditional marketing functions. Several of these technologies and their impact on the marketing function are
reviewed and dissected in order to provide insight as to the benefits they can provide, the most significant of
which are decision support technologies, and closely behind demand planning and sales team management
tools. Specifically, to what extent is technology supplanting the “set of disciplines and responsibilities”, encom-
passed in classical marketing functions? How is the function being transformed with superior, affordable tech-
nology based processes that better target demand, allowing individuals to achieve what an entire “set of insti-
tutions” toiled to execute? These technologies are available today and the firms that master these technolo-
gies will have clear competitive advantages, ensure that the customer’s expectations are fulfilled in a more
personal, customized process, in a more efficient manner that benefits both investors and customers.
Keywords
Decision support technology, neuromarketing, market intelligence, collective intelligence, predictive analytics.
1. Analyzing markets and identifying and success at focused studies on tribe and group
opportunities behaviors conducted by staffs of sociologists,
anthropologists, and historians helping the likes of
“The aim of Marketing is to make selling super- Adidas, Lululemon, Lego better understand what
fluous” their markets want and desire, and how to secure-
(Drucker, 1974) ly place their products in these precious situation
(Madsbjerg & Rasmussen, 2014).
Marketing Analytics is a growing set of tools Analysis of the Customer in the analytical,
and processes that leverage the boom in consumer quantitative sense, is the methodical study and
data to better understand all aspects of marketing approach to making a customer recognize and
responsibilities: current and potential customers, value a product or service, and understanding the
competitors, products, services, and new ways to mechanics of the process of recognition and val-
measure the effectiveness of marketing activities ue, the psychology and the behaviors which are
themselves. The American Marketing Associa- the foundation upon which the customer makes
tion, in their 2014 edition of their annual market- their decision to value, want, and desire. Custom-
ing analytics survey found that these tools allowed er Relationship Management (CRM) is one
marketing teams to better target their marketing technology toolset that has revolutionized the
campaigns, but only 31% of firms surveyed had process of analyzing customers, both current and
fully them integrated into their marketing hopeful, using a highly sophisticated and discip-
processes (Sullivan, 2014). Julie Davis, in the lined approach to gathering both internal and ex-
AMA Marketing Insights, listed what she sees as ternal information about the customers. Predic-
the top four trends for marketing in 2015, each of tive Analytics Technology (PAT) that allow en-
them is based on the application of data driven: hanced access to sophisticated algorithms and
customer focused insights, entire teams focused data tools, such as RapidMiner, allow firms to
on obtaining the insight, and sharing within an integrate and utilize customer models in real-time.
institution, and finally, the growing impact of mo- Neuromarketing as a new approach to trying
bile technology as the source for the data and out- to understand what drives customer behavior has
let for marketing campaigns (Davis, 2014). gained popularity, with even dedicated depart-
Situational Analysis has different schools and ments such as the Neuroscience wing of Emory
advocates of different approaches to answer the University. Neuromarketing and the Buyology
same questions: where are we and what are the study conducted by Lindstrom combines market
opportunities that are available to us. Theoretical research, behavioral psychology, with the exciting
approaches, changing toolsets, and common goals field of brain scan medical imaging (Lindstrom,
make people want a product or service. Quantita- 2008). By interpreting the visual representation of
tive and qualitative analysis, the methods for each the human brain response to specific topics and
of the 5C model: collaborators, customers, com- situations, marketing gurus believe they have un-
pany, competition, context. (Ohmae, 1991) Fur- covered new techniques to understand the impact
ther, technology is also affecting the implementa- of marketing and to improve the effectiveness of
tion of Porter’s five forces approach, as well as marketing.
the classic Strengths-Weaknesses-Opportunity- Combining Neuromarketing, CRM, and Pre-
Threat (SWOT) approach to analyzing the status dictive Analytics, enables new efforts in the field
quo. of Behavioral Economics. Behavioral Economics
is dedicated to the learning and understanding
1.1. Learning about your Customer
behind the actions of customers. There is a spec-
“We find that … millions of people become simul- trum of beliefs and leading theory’s into what
taneously impressed with one delusion, and run drives most people, most of the time. This ranges
after it, till their attention is caught by some new from the rational school to the motivational ap-
folly more captivating than the first” proach. The rational approach says that the cus-
(McKay, 1852) tomer behaves in a way that follows is the Stan-
dard Economic Theory of maximizing utility and
Leading marketing organizations have re- optimization per budget constraint. The motiva-
newed their focus on understanding the motiva- tional approach says that people are more impul-
tions of customers and what has “meaning” to sive, driven by their unconscious and uncontrolled
them has driven the field of qualitative research motivations. The Behavioral approach says that
people have limited capacity for analysis, take startups are a threat to competition and stability of
short cuts by relying on the experiences of others; markets (The Economist, 2014a, 2014b).
word-of-mouth, personal referrals. Prospect Michael Porter’s Five Forces (Porter, 1979) is
Theory says that people have imbalanced sensitiv- a tool and construct that facilitates the analysis of
ities and may treat losses or bad purchases diffe- a market place and determines if it is attractive,
rently from gains or good purchases (Areily, profitable, or comfortably protected from compe-
2010). Three concepts from prospect theory are tition. Porter identifies profitability as the key
reference pricing, framing, and loss aversion criteria to measure the success of a firm, rather
(need references). Daniel Kahneman and Vernon than sheer size, and defined competition as five
Smith won the Nobel Prize for trying to explain competitive forces. Porter’s five forces are: 1)
idiosyncrasies in people’s decision making Buyers always want to pay less, 2) Suppliers want
processes (Thaler & Sunstein, 2009). to be paid more, 3) Substitute products and ser-
vices, 4) New entrants are another disturbing
1.2. Competitive Analysis force, and finally the force of your existing com-
Competitive analysis is yet another of the many petition (5).
aspects of marketing that has been transformed by The identification of competitors is a subject
technology. One form of technology dubbed unto itself that is not always correctly analyzed;
“Market Intelligence Technology” automates particularly given the impact of modern technolo-
and facilitates the collection of information from gy and every increasing availability present a
both the internet and internal sources on competi- permanent disruptive threat. Other significant fac-
tors, competitor’s products, and developments that tors such as market structure (monopoly, oligopo-
may affect a firm's prospects in the marketplace. ly, monopolistic competition, pure competition)
Market intelligence technology integrates web market type (regulated, unregulated, high barriers
news feeds RSS and XBRL machine readable, to entry, cost structure) are important to consider
web financial statements, and captures all internal in competitive analysis.
competitive information that a multinational firm
collects every day – and hosts it back to the hun- 1.3. Company Analysis
dreds of people who can benefit from better in- Most manufacturing, technology, and service
formation. The executives who have such tech- companies, when looking inwardly to understand
nologies available to them are better informed their strengths and weaknesses, will utilize the
about potential opportunities and developments, classical tools such as the four-quadrant
and are notified daily or continuously, instead of “Strength-Weakness-Opportunity-Threat”
perhaps randomly stumbling on information days (SWOT) analysis, and the application of the dis-
or weeks after the general public was informed. ciplines of Lean Management, Six-Sigma Process
Global organizations are able to gather internal Quality, and Operational Excellence and 360-
knowledge, host, and share out the information on degree evaluation programs. These programs are
their businesses obtained from all corners of the mostly internal in focus and other tools such as
world in private meetings, in ways that were im- corporate mission setting and benchmarking to
possible previously. standards are commonly used to measure one’s
Competitive analysis and a firm’s ability to performance vis-a-vis their competitors. Firms
monitor real-time positional advantages have been such as General Electric under Jack Welch led
totally transformed by data providers such as under the mantra of being top global firm of
Google. In a recent blog post and article titled choice in whatever segment it was participating
“What to change in 2015 using Google Analytics in, were well led and successful, but not without
Benchmarking”, Christopher Penn demonstrates limitations or consequences of marching to
the ease of use and instant ability to log into a achieve a single dimensional goal. This led to the
system to see immediately how your firm is com- introduction, by thought leaders such as Robert
peting against another, and areas for immediate Kaplan, of the Balanced Scorecard initiatives as
action or reinforcement of a successful strategy a way of balancing out priorities and better re-
(Penn, 2014). flecting the mission of the enterprise, using multi-
With technology of the internet and online dimensional metrics.
businesses, and speed with which these companies All of these measures of internal performance
can quickly dominate an entire national, regional, have technology products available to the firm
or global market, concerns have surfaced that tech that automates and conducts and warehouses in-
formation about process quality, quality audits, organizational decision making lies in technolo-
compliance audits, 360 degree evaluations of per- gies to assist and improve recommendations as
sonnel, management dashboards, all with real- recently predicted at the 50th anniversary of
time instant availability to literally the “palm-of- McKinsey & Co’s Quarterly journal (Dobbs et al.,
your-hand”. Big data, Data analytics, and busi- 2014). The ability of collective intelligence tools
ness analytics will transform this further, until the to span large populations and demographics
“age of brilliant machines” begins to augment presents and approach for leaders to avoid or mi-
decision making (Dobbs, Ramaswamy, tigate the “echo chamber” effects, of particular
Stephenson, & Viguerie, 2014). significance in a digital society where individuals
filter and tailor their exposure to unwanted inter-
1.4. Context: Interpretation and Decision ruptions (Jaimeson & Capella, 2008).
Making
Over the last 20 years, technology has evolved 1.5. Psychological Value and Brand Value
that is beginning to aid management and leaders “Today’s marketplace is no longer responsive to
challenge their decisions and obtain better insight the strategies that worked in the past. There are
into potential outcomes. The market leader in this just too many products, too many companies, and
technology is Hypermind.com, based on predic- too much marketing noise”
tion market technology, provides tools to leverage (Ries & Trout, 1981).
and harness the collective intelligence of the or-
ganization (Servan&Schreiber, Wolfers, Pennock, A brand is a name, symbol or sign that identi-
& Galebach, 2004). Based on mass intelligence, fies the unique attributes of a seller or service
with an automated learning capability, this deci- provider or person. The brand becomes a mutual
sion support technology is seen to be transform- shared set of expectations between the brand
ing the future of corporate leadership, including owner and the brand consumer, regarding quality,
marketing (National Public Radio, 2014). In a standard of service, and loyalty. Identification
recent study, the firm Lumenlogic found “that presupposes memory and recognition, and dis-
prediction markets provide superior results in placement or priority in recall and remembering
67% of the forecasts, reduce average error by ap- (Lindstrom, 2008) Today Brands can be designed
proximately 15 percentage points, and reduce the by competing groups of designers, from all over
error range by over 40%” (Lang, Bharadwaj, & the world, through such websources as
DiBenedetto, 2010). Additionally, these tools crowdspring.com and designcrowd.com and sur-
provide a forum and marketplace for superfore- veys and opinions can be had automatically via
casters – individuals who have an exceptional webtools such as zoomerang.com or surveymon-
ability to study a situation and accurately predict key.com.
outcomes – and a tool for the organizational lea- There are many popular quotes and examples
dership to leverage their talents (Tetlock & Gard- illustrating how brands influence customers’ per-
ner, 2016). ceptions and decision making (Ries & Trout,
An important part of the theory of customer 1981). Brand value equates to financial power and
behavior is the study of the commonly made er- reward in both the consumer marketplace as re-
rors in interpretation or decision making, due to flected in product or service pricing power and
the following errors (Hartley, 1995): also in financial markets through firm value. Con-
▪ False consensus: assuming that everyone is sumer based brand value equates to loyalty and
like you reduced price sensitivity in the consumer goods
▪ Overconfidence: believing you are more arena. Brand equity in the product market diffe-
right than you really are rentiates and builds a protective barrier against
inferior, unbranded and new entrants, and also
Tactics, structures, and strategies to help indi- enables easier entry into new markets or seg-
viduals and organizations avoid these decision ments. The financial market focuses its attention
making errors have been discussed by Marks and on well-known brands and rewards them with
Miller (Marks & Miller, 1997) and their work on generous availability of funding, higher valuations
false-consensus, and studies on reducing overcon- (Srivastava, Shervani, & Fahey, 1998) and higher
fidence (Arkes, Christensen, Lai, & Blumer, price-to-equity ratios than unbranded firms – jus-
1987). However, the state-of-the art and future of tified by the accumulated investment in establish-
ing and maintaining a brand – although subject to
volatility and difficult if not impossible to value paper on Hide and Seek in pricing, where predato-
using a single method or approach (Mizik & Ja- ry or marginal loss pricing of an increasingly
cobson, 2008, 2009). global and transparent market has an impact on
Brands are not unlike delicate plants, which the competition. In further works, Rekettye dis-
can require a specific regime of care and feeding cusses the impact of discounters mass private la-
and environmental conditions. Examples of Brand bel brands and their growth and significance in
disasters from the US such as Schlitz beer and the 2008 downturn and their impact on classical
clear brand contrast on twin products such as the premium brands as shoppers turn to value pur-
vehicles the GM Geo Prizm (Aaker, 1992) and chasing (Rekettye, 2013, 2014).
Toyota Corolla in the 1980’s – built in the same The process of creating a brand is a critical
factory with identical components, with Toyota process with regards to new product introductions.
outselling GM 5:1 (Sullivan, 1998). An excellent example of how technology is lower-
The Brand Value Pyramid created by Kevin ing the costs of entry and making branding easier
Keller and shown below can be used in strategiz- is the revolution in craft product sales and market-
ing on building brands, and brand owners can ing created by the website ETSY and its enorm-
have paths that follow either side of a two-sided ous population of trade craftspersons, each of
pyramid: the cold, technical performance path, or whom is establishing their own brands day by
the hot, emotional, psychological paths. Made of day, customer by customer (Abrahams, 2008).
four levels, Keller’s model has four layers: Brand Another example of brands being created en
Identity, Brand Meaning, Brand Responses, and masse via another web technology are the crowd-
Brand Relationships. Examples of the cold path to funding websites such as Kickstarter.com and
technical recognition can be the example of Cadil- Fundable.com which use crowdfunding to turn
lac vehicles in the US, and the hot, emotional path concepts and ideas into real products and services,
to the Mastercard “priceless” campaign (LaSalle, via advanced funding from the customers advance
& Britton, 2003). purchases, donations, and social support for their
products.
In an interview with the head of Google, Inc.’s
BrandLab, it was mentioned how all companies
that come to Google to try and learn more about
how to use Youtube to reach out to their custom-
ers, the most popular topic is the “viral video”
and finding new, exciting, amusing ways to con-
nect, and the case of the Volvo Epic video series
was an overwhelming success (Drell, 2014). Ad-
ditionally, in the US, the football superbowl
weekend holiday weekend is dedicated to video
commercials that “go viral”, as has also become a
tradition in the UK around the first of December,
Picture 1 Brand Value Pyramid with the beginning of the Christmas shopping sea-
Source: Keller, 2001 son (Taube, 2014)
zation. Each of these technologies are available Report No. 01-107.). Cambridge, Mass.: Marketing
Science Institute.
today and the firms that master these technologies
Khalifa, A. S. (2004). Customer value: a review of recent
will have clear competitive advantages, ensure literature and an integrative configuration. Management
that the customer’s expectations are fulfilled in a decision, 42 (5), 645-666.
more personal, customized process, in a more ef- Kim, E. M. (1996). The industrial organization and growth of
ficient manner that benefits both investors and the Korean chaebol: integrating development and
organizational theories. In G. G. Hamilton, Asian
customers. SM Business Networks (pp. 231-251). New York: Walter de
Gruyter.
References Kotler, P., & Keller, K. (2005). Marketing Management
11the ed. New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
Aaker, D. A. (1992). The value of brand equity. Journal of
business strategy, 13 (4), 27-32. Lang, M., Bharadwaj, N., & Di Benedetto, C. A. (2010). Can
the Emerging Prediction Market Methodology Aid in
Abrahams, S. L. (2008). Handmade online: The crafting of
Improving Demand Forecasting of New Products?
commerce, aesthetics and community on Etsy.com
American Marketing Association, Winter Educators
(Doctoral dissertation) . North Carolina: The University
Conference (p. 16). Chicago, Illinois: American
Of North Carolina At Chapel Hill.
Marketing Association.
American Marketing Association. (2016). About AMA:
LaSalle, D., & Britton, T. (2003). Priceless: Turning ordinary
Definition of Marketing. Retrieved May 28, 2015 from
products into extraordinary experiences. Harvard
American Marketing Association:
Business Press. Boston: Harvard Business School
https://www.ama.org/AboutAMA/Pages/Definition-of-
Press.
Marketing.aspx
Lindstrom, M. (2008). Buyology: Truth and Lies about Why
Ariely, D. (2010). Predictably Irrational. Hammersmith,
We Buy. New York: Doubleday business.
London: Harper.
MacKay, C. (1852). Memoirs of Extraordinary Popular
Arkes, H. R., Christensen, C., Lai, C., & Blumer, C. (1987).
Delusions and the Madness of Crowds. London:
Two methods of reducing overconfidence.
Robson, Levey, and Franklin.
Organizational Behavior and Human Decision
Processes, 39 (1), 133-144. Madsbjerg, C., & Rasmussen, M. (2014). The Moment of
Clarity: Using the Human Sciences to Solve Your
Calantone, R., & Cooper, R. G. (1981). New Product
Toughest Business Problems. Boston: Harvard
Scenarios: Prospects For Success. The Journal of
Business Review Press.
Marketing, 45 (2), 48-60.
Marks, G., & Miller, N. (1987). Ten years of research on the
Davis, J. (2014). The future of Insights: Top four trends for
false-consensus effect: An empirical and theoretical
2015. Retrieved December 15, 2014 from Marketing
review. Psychological Bulletin, 102 (1), 72-90.
Insights Newsletter. American Marketing Association:
https://www.ama.org/publications/eNewsletters/Marketi McAlexander, J. H., Schouten, J. W., & Koenig, H. F.
ngInsightsNewsletter/Pages/the-future-of-marketing- (2002). Building brand community. Journal of
insights-four-trends-for-2015.aspx marketing, 66 (1), 38-54.
Dobbs, R., Ramaswamy, S., Stephenson, E., & Viguerie, P. McCarthy, J. E. (1964). Basic Marketing. A Managerial
S. (2014). Management intuition for the next 50 years. Approach. Homewood, IL: Richard D. Irwin.
McKinsey Quarterl , 1-13. Homewood: Richard D, Irwin.
Drell, L. (2014). 10 minutes with Kim Larson. Marketing Meijer, G. R., Samuels, J., & Terpstra, F. (2002). Modeling
Insights, Sept/Oct., 42-47. user acceptance and technology adoption: Is there a
case for value added services? ITS World Conference
Drucker, P. F. (1974). Management: tasks, responsibilities,
on Intelligent Transport Systems (p. 9). Washington,
practices. New York: Harper & Row.
D.C.: The National Academies of Sciences,
Elmani, J. (2013). Growth Hack Your Way To Success, Like Engineering, and Medicine o.
Facebook, Twitter, And Linkedin Did. Retrieved
Mizik, N., & Jacobson, R. (2008). The Financial Value
December 15, 2014 from Fast Company:
Impact of Perceptual Brand Attributes. Journal of
http://www.fastcompany.com/3020363/dialed/growth-
Marketing Research, 45 (1), 15-32.
hack-your-way-to-success-just-like-facebook-twitter-
and-linkedin-have Mizik, N., & Jacobson, R. (2009). Valuing Branded
Businesses. Journal of Marketing , 73 (6), 137-153.
Fabiani, S., Druant, M., Hernando, I., Kwapil, C., Landau,
B., Loupias, C., et al. (2005). The Pricing Behaviour of Moore, G. A. (1991). Crossing the Chasm. New York:
Firms in the Euro Area (Working Paper Series. No. Harper Business.
535.). Frankfurt: European Central Bank. National Public Radio. (2014). So You Think You're Smarter
Hartley, R. (1995). Marketing Mistakes. New Caledonia: Than A CIA Agent. Retrieved December 16, 2016 from
John Wiley & Sons Australia. National Public Radio:
http://www.npr.org/blogs/parallels/2014/04/02/2978394
Huber, J., Payne, J. W., & Puto, C. (1982). Adding
29/-so-you-think-youre-smarter-than-a-cia-agent
asymmetrically dominated alternatives: Violations of
regularity and the similarity hypothesis. Journal of Ohmae, K. (1991). The Mind Of The Strategist: The Art of
Consumer Research, 9 (1), 90-98. Japanese Business. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Jamieson, K. H., & Cappella, J. N. (2008). Echo chamber: Penn, C. (2014). What to change in 2015 using Google
Rush Limbaugh and the conservative media Analytics. Retrieved December 15, 2016 from Google
establishment. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Analytics:
https://plus.google.com/+GoogleAnalytics/posts/7NATg
Keller, K. L. (2001). Building Customer Based Brand Equity:
EJDxNT
A Blueprint for Creating Strong Brands (Working Paper
Correspondence
Christopher R. Schmidt
Faculty of Business and Economics
Rákóczi út 80, 7622, Pécs, Hungary
E-mail: Schmidt.christopher@pte.hu