Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Institute of Ethiopian Studies Journal of Ethiopian Studies
Institute of Ethiopian Studies Journal of Ethiopian Studies
Institute of Ethiopian Studies Journal of Ethiopian Studies
A Modernising State and the Emergence of Modernist Arts in Ethiopia (1930s to 1970s)
with special reference to Gebre Kristos Desta (1932-1981) and Skunder Boghossian (1937-
2003)
Author(s): Shiferaw Bekele
Source: Journal of Ethiopian Studies, Vol. 37, No. 2 (December 2004), pp. 11-41, 43-44
Published by: Institute of Ethiopian Studies
Stable URL: https://www.jstor.org/stable/41966158
Accessed: 08-05-2020 09:15 UTC
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
https://about.jstor.org/terms
Institute of Ethiopian Studies is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend
access to Journal of Ethiopian Studies
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
JES, V0I.XXXVII, N0.2 (December 2004)
Shiferaw Bekele
T.S.Eliot, "Ash-Wednesday"
Gebre Kristos Desta and Skunder Boghossian were born into a fast changing society
even if the perception of their generation was rather the contrary. The general
intellectual belief, as of the turn of the 1960s, was that Ethiopia was a stagnant and
archaic society. They shared this view. This could be true for much of rural Ethiopia
and for many of the small towns, but not for Addis Ababa and the major provincial
towns like Harar and Dire Dawa, which were undergoing fast changes in many areas
- economic and cultural. Old social norms and values were beginning to crumble.
Attitudinal changes were making headway among the people. The state pursued a
vigorous policy of building cultural institutions and encouraging the growth of the
arts and literature. The 1960s witnessed, what is called, "the golden age" of Ethiopian
music, the finest years for Ethiopian arts and the most dynamic period for Ethiopian
literature. Urbanisation expanded at an increasing tempo as education, infrastructure,
the manufacturing sector and trade made significant strides. The big towns had started
to experience rapid population growth not long after the departure of the Italians. The
growth became explosion by the turn of the 1960s bringing with it all the attendant
consequences - mass poverty, urban congestion, and growing unemployment. It was
indeed a time of tension between the dying of the old world and the birth of a new
one, as the above-cited poet so well put it.
The year in which Gebre Kristos was born (1932), was the time when Mussolini
finally decided to invade Ethiopia. Ethiopia was just beginning the difficult task of
westernization. The country had some schools, which gave elementary education. A
high school was not yet opened though the idea of building up the educational
pyramid to the tertiary level was being discussed by the leaders. Ethiopia had not yet
developed a manufacturing sector worthy of the name. Infrastructural development
was undertaken by the state but the achievements were still limited. Gebre Kristos
1 This is a much expanded and revised version of an article published in the Catalogue of the Paintings of
Gebre Kristos Desta under the title, "State and Society in Ethiopia (1930s to 1970s): Contextualising
Gebre Kristos Desta".
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
12 Shi fe raw Bekele A Modernising State and Modernist Arts (1930s to 1970s:
was bora in Harar, which was linked by railway, via Dire Dawa, with Addis Ababa
and Djibouti as well as by telephone and telegraph lines. The link with Djibouti and
the geographical proximity to the outside world made it possible for Harar to be
exposed to external influences earlier than other places. The residents of Harar prided
themselves on being more "civilised" than even the people of the capital city. It was
in this city that Gebre Kristos grew up.
In 1935, the Italians invaded the country and ruled it for five years. They built some
roads, opened some factories (two of which were in Dire Dawa) and established a
handful of schools for the natives. A big section of the Ethiopian population was
pleased with Italian religious and ethnic policies; but for a sizeable proportion, the
advent of Italian rule was a traumatic experience from the very beginning. Gebre
Kristos's family belonged to the latter group.2 In their eyes, the invasion was like
Armageddon. The massive armoured army of the Italians, the indiscriminate bombing
of villages and towns, and after their occupation, their racial administrative policies -
all of these were unheard of and unprecedented both in extent and depth. It can easily
be surmised that little Gebre Kristos grew up in this situation.
Skunder comes from a very patriotic family, the Boghossians having behind them
long years of devoted service to the Ethiopian state. When Skunder saw the light of
day on July 22, 1937, his father, an officer in the Imperial Body Guard who had seen
action in the northern front in 1936, was fighting with the patriots for Ethiopian
independence and one of his uncles was an underground agent of the Patriotic
Movement. And when he became a year old, his father "was incarcerated by the
Italians... Skunder was eight years old when his father was eventually released after
seven years of imprisonment."3 It is therefore not surprising that Skunder showed in
his life such a deep attachment to Ethiopia and things Ethiopian. Gebre Kristos' sense
of deep nationalism can also be explained by the same circumstance.
There is no doubt that the liberation was a God-sent event for the families of the two
artists. It was greeted with much enthusiasm by the population at large and there was
an exhilarating euphoria of victory in the air. The leaders themselves came back from
exile with a lot of renewed energy and they set about introducing changes at a tempo
faster than the pre-war period. State modernization was among the reforms that were
given priority. In a very short period of time, Haile Selassie constructed huge civilian
administrative machinery; and he set out on the process of building up the civil
service. He put in place a police force. For the first time, Ethiopia organised a single
national army complete with ground, air and naval forces. All government employees
including top level officials were made salaried. The government declared its
2 Berhane Meskel Dejene, "Yäsäli Gäbrä-Kirstos Yäheywät Tarikna Andand Getmoö," (Senior Essay
Submitted to the Department of Ethiopian Languages and Literatures, Addis Ababa University, 1983
E.C.), pp. 24ff.
Selamawit Legesse, "Skundrizm: Art that Transcends Boundaries," Bien (First issue, 2005), p.28. She
cites Skunder' s good and old friend, Solomon Deressa, for this statement.
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
JES, V0I.XXXVII, N0.2 (December 2004)
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
14 Shiferaw Bekele A Modernising State and Modernist Arts (1930s to 1970s:
Whatever the perceptions of the subsequent generations, the fact remains that Haile
Selassie worked hard to build a developmental state. He put in place institutions that
would generate economic growth and societal change. For all its imperfections (the
least modernized arm of the state was provincial administration), this state addressed
itself to the various developmental issues facing the country and brought about a
remarkable transformation of economy, society and culture. What kind of strategy to
adopt for economic development was a subject of discussion among the top
government leaders in the 1940s and early 1950s. Consensus was reached on
introducing planning into the economy. A group of Yugoslav experts was brought to
survey the socio-economic conditions of the country in 1954. They carried out a
comprehensive survey which they published in 14 volumes.4 The data they collected
served as the basis to draft the first plan, which they were asked to do.5 The First Five
Year Plan was launched in 1957.6 On the basis of the experience gained during the
implementation of the First Plan, a better Second Five Year Plan was launched in
1963. The third came in 1969. The fourth was still born as a result of the outbreak of
the revolution in 1974.
These three plans had their achievements. The Gross Domestic Product (GDP) grew
on average between 4.2 and 4.5% for over a decade. This was a respectable
performance for an economy that was just beginning to be modern. Haile Selassie
proudly reported in 1955 that the economy was being rapidly transformed from an
essentially barter economy into a money economy. "Whereas before the war the
national budget of Ethiopia did not exceed $[Birr] 5,000,000, today [1955] it exceeds
$[Birr] 100,000,000," stated the sovereign. "The money in circulation has increased
from $[Birr] 80,000,000 in 1946 to over $[Birr] 220,000,000 in 1954."7 The rate of
monetization was very rapid in the subsequent decades. In the 1960s barter and the
use of crude media of exchange (like amole) gave way to paper currency throughout
the country. Banking spread at an impressive rate. The National Bank put in place a
market for shares, a good beginning for a future stock market if it were not for the
revolution. It can therefore be seen that, by 1974, the economy was more or less
monetized.
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
JES, VolXXXVII, No.2 (December 2004)
(Source: Asmarom K
Population Situation
What is remarkable
time. By about the m
By the 1960s, the pop
up momentum. It st
1960s posing addition
1950s increased on t
growth remained mor
2. 1% for the second
In the first half of
averaging about 1.4%
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
16 Shiferaw Bekele A Modernising State and Modernist Arts (1930s to 1970s:
The population rate of growth for urban areas was much highe
as a whole. If we take Addis Ababa, the situation was drama
Table 2 below.
9 Shiferaw Jamo, "An Overview of the Economy, 1941-74," Shiferaw Bekele (cd.) An Economic History
of Ethiopia (Dakar, 1995), p.21.
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
JES, V0I.XXXVII, N0.2 (December 2004)
2. Expansion of education
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
18 Shiferaw Hétele A Modernising State and Modernist Arts (1930s to 1970s:
12 Ibid, p.78.
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
JES, V0I.XXXVII, N0.2 (December 2004)
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
20 Shiferaw Bekele A Modernising State and Modernist Arts (1930s to 1970s:
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
JES, V0I.XXXVII, N0.2 (December 2004)
When the ministries were reopened in 1941, one of them was the Ministry of
Education and Fine Arts. The portfolio for many years was in the hands of the
Emperor himself which showed the significance the man gave to both education and
the fine arts. He set up the Department of Fine Arts in the Ministry. Abebe Wolde
Giyorgis, a sculptor educated in France before the war, was appointed the head. He
was assisted by another pre-war French-educated artist, Agegnehu Engida. In the
words of an art lover and manager of an established gallery:
18 Ayalneh Mulat, "Teyater Bä-Etyopia," Lesanä Hezb Vol. 1 No. 3 (Amharic monthly, Tekemt 1996);
Vol. 1 No. 4 (Amharic monthly, Hedar 1996).
Francis Falceto, Abyssinie Swing: A Pictorial History of Modern Ethiopian Music (Addis Ababa:
Shama Books, 2001), p.53.
Francis Falceto, "Ethiopian Music through its Record Covers" (A flyer distributed on the occasion of
the music festival called Ethiopian Music Festival II held from January 16 to 25, 2003).
Falceto, Abyssinie Swing, p. 52.
21 Ibid
™Ibid, pp. 52-53.
24 Berhanu Debotch Haile Mariam, "Major Developments in Addis Ababa, 1941-1965" (MA Thesis
submitted to the History Department, Addis Ababa University, 2005), p.86; Ayaleneh Mulat, "Teyater
Bä-Etyopia"...
Falceto, Abyssinie Swing, p. 52
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
22 Shiferaw Bekele A Modernising State and Modernist Arts (1930s to 1970s:
The traditional painters recruited into this Department made up the who-i
of artists in the 1940s like Mezmur Ze-Dawit, Belachew Yimer in addition t
director and his deputy. There were 12 other leading traditional painters in
Department.27 They were given a studio in the Parliament building. It was
an impressive collection of traditional painters who were paid by the state.
also worked on their own and sold their creative productions on the marke
resident foreigners of the town were their major clients. Thus, the 1940s w
decade of traditional painting in Ethiopia.
The three French educated artists active at the time (Abebe, Agegneh
Zerihun Dominik) were involved in the organization although they we
very productive. Abebe restricted himself to realistic sculpture while the m
promising painter of the trio, Agegnehu, continued to work as a rea
painters The leading art historian, Professor Chojnacki evaluate
contributions (or lack of it) of the three artists as follows:
The Regent's efforts to have a few promising artists trained abroad did
immediately bring about a great deal of change in artistic output... Not on
the first foreign-trained artists, not even Agáññáhu, was an outstan
exponent [of modern art], nor was there any truly representative of mo
trends in art. Their attitudes still reflected the traditional ways of thought.28
26 Kongit [5/c] Seyoum, "The History of the Addis Ababa School of Fine Arts," Time
weekly paper) (29 June - 5 July 2001), p. 1 1.
27 Berhane Meskel Deiene, p.41.
28 S. Chojnacki, "A Survey of Modern Art," Aethiopien, Zeitschrift für Kulturaus
(Stuttgart: 1973)), p.25.
Taye Tadesse, Short Biographies of Some Ethiopian Artists (Addis Ababa, 199 1), p.22.
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
JES, VoLXXXVII, No.2 (December 2004)
Ethiopian music flourished in the 1960s and the central venue was this theatre. Its
annual New Year Festival, which started in 1959 and was transmitted over the radio,
was an event that urban Ethiopians looked forward to, to usher them into the New
Year. As the time approached, excitement increased and in the night of the New
Year, most of the people (only a few could get a seat in the theatre) followed the
Festival on the radio. The Festival was the forum to launch new albums and an event
for the famous Imperial Body Guard band to perform in all its glory. The bands of the
army, the police and of the National Theatre also competed fiercely on this Festival.
It was a very exciting event.
The return from abroad of playwright Tsegaye Gebre Medhin (1960), of playwright,
director and actor Tesfaye Gessese took drama and the performing arts a major step
forward. Tsegaye was able to introduce his modern, experimental plays in this Hall.
Shakespeare's tragedies in Amharic adaptations were performed on this magnificent
stage. If it were not for its wonderful stage, acoustic, lighting and other facilities,
some of Shakespeare's tragedies would not have had the success they had. The
construction of this Theatre was the responsibility of the Hager Fiker Mahber. The
dynamic Mekonnen Habte Wold had the vision to use the occasion of the Jubilee
celebration to put up this impressive building.
The Hager Fekir Mahber, which was deeply loyal to the Emperor, conceived other
events to mark the 25th anniversary of the sovereign's coronation. One of them was
the issuance of new musical records. "They recorded and published a dozen 78s... as
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
24 Shiferaw Bekele A Modernising State and Modernist Arts (1930s to 1970s:
well as several 45s... with the principal artists of the time."34 This was a bonanza to
music lovers of Addis. It also decided that the launching of their new magazine
should coincide with the coronation anniversary. This was Mänän which had as a
subtitle, "the magazine for ladies and young women". Romane-Work Kassahun, a
woman writer who had more than one book to her name, ran this magazine. It gave
prominence to women on its pages and had columns for beauty, fashion, women's
health and cuisine. In its maiden issue, it informed its readers that on the eve of the
coronation day, the emperor gave medals and titles to no less than 36 women who
were princesses, aristocrats and other women of standing in the society. The writer,
educator and feminist Senidu Gebru was one of them.35 It also proudly reported that
an all-Ethiopian beauty contest was held as part of the celebrations on Hedar 17,
1948 (27 November 1955). 36 The two fresh artist returnees, Afewerk and Ale Felege
Selam, sat on the jury of this contest. Indeed, it was the first women's magazine in
the history of the country. In the subsequent two decades, this magazine would go on
to play a significant role as a forum for literary exchange in whose pages ideas were
articulated and reviews of books, plays and exhibitions were written.37
"The Jubilee Year 1948 (1955-56 A.D.)", writes Thomas Kane, one of the authorities
on the history of Amharic literature in the Imperial period, "saw an outpouring of
literary works as many writers wanted to render homage to their sovereign."38 The
Emperor was so grateful that he invited the writers to the palace to express his
appreciation and also to decorate them.39
The grand Silver Jubilee Fair put up for the celebrations, included a pavilion on art in
which several noted traditional artists displayed their works. The art pavilion turned
out to be an unprecedented major collective art exhibition of the post-war era. Upon
the closure of the fair, prizes were given out to the best participants in all fields. The
first prize for the arts (a gold medal) went to two artists - Afewerk Tekle and
Em'a'elaf Heruy - while the silver medal was given to 18-year old Skunder.40
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
JES, VoLXXXVII, No.2 (December 2004)
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
26 Shiferaw Bekele A Modernising State and Modernist Arts (1930s to 1970s:
45 For a report of its financial woes and other problems, see Tesfaye Ges
Merten (an illustrated monthly magazine) (March 1967), pp. 14-17. And for
interesting institution see Aboneh Ashagre, "KâKolég Eskä University M
presented on the First Annual Conference of Ethiopian Cultural Studies
See also the interesting piece of Solomon Deressa cited in the footnote abov
Birhanu Teferra, "Leisure Reading and Readership of Books: With Referen
in Bahr Dar," Ethiopian Journal of Languages and Literature, No. 9 (1999
Haile Selassie I Prize Trust, Haile Selassie I Prize Trust: 10 Year (Addis
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
JES, Vol.XXXVII, No.2 (December 2004)
It was indeed a remarkable phenomenon that the modernist artists and literary me
used the cultural institutions established by the state, or with the help of the state
4*Ibid, p.71.
49 Ibid.
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
28 Shiferaw Bekele A Modemising State and Modernist Arts (1930s to 1970s:
their forums to display their works to the public. The only priva
significant exhibitions were shown was the Belvedere Art Gallery
The generation that went into the national or foreign universities in the 1960s was
composed differently. Some of its members chose to become Marxist-Leninist and
went on to galvanize their fellow students both in the country and abroad to rise up
against the regime. In about a decade, the movement they ignited called the Ethiopian
50 The Belvedere Art Gallery was the most successful art gallery in the 1960s and early 1970s. Several
other galleries had been opened, which went bankrupt and were closed down. But Belvedere was
evidently successful in the art trade. In addition to selling works of art, it had hosted several exhibitions
in the second half of the 1960s, some of them by Gebre Kristos and Skunder. The owner was an
Armenian, Hrant Baghdassarian.
51 In contrast to these positive developments, we see the growth of the urban poor and, a phenomenon
that was new to a traditional society, the growth of homeless population in a few biu urban centres.
Mengistu Lemma, Demamu Be 'erAňa - Gil'A-Tarik (Addis Ababa, 1988 E.C.), p.216.
Tekeste Melake, pp. 54ff.
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
JES, Vol.XXXVII, No.2 (December 2004)
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
30 Shiferaw Bekele A Modernising State and Modernist Arts (1930s to 1970s :
Beauvoir. They discussed at length world literature, theatre, cinema, music and
discourses in philosophy - or trends in the arts.
The time was also different. The decade after the end of the Second World War saw
the unprecedented crumbling of the once invincible colonial empires of Britain and
France. There was a powerful stirring in Black Africa. Many students from these
colonies who were in the diaspora went back to the continent to launch the
independence movements in their respective countries when our young intellectuals
were going abroad. In France, the Negritude Movement was a powerful discourse
with Leopold Sedar Senghor from Senegal and Aime Cesaire from the West Indies
pioneering the movement. Jean Paul Sartre's existentialist philosophy and Albert
Camus' literary writings had engulfed intellectual circles. In the United States, the
Civil Rights Movement was leaving an unprecedented impact on freedom and
independence thoughts.
In the late 1950s and in the 1960s, Marxism and particularly its Maoist variety, was
very popular in the campuses of western universities. This led to the rise of a
powerful student movement in many countries around the world. In some countries
like France it was more powerful than in countries like the U.K. Nevertheless, it
became a world-wide phenomenon where its force was destined to influence
Ethiopian students of the generation that came later than the subjects of our
discussion. When Gebre Kristos and his friends were busy producing works of art or
essays, the students of Haile Selassie I University were busy ostracizing the system.
The influence of Marxism was limited or non-existent around the group under
discussion even if some of the individuals like Mengistu flirted with it in their
university days. All of them were however critical of the political and social order of
their country. Before he went to Europe, Tsegaye had written two groundbreaking
plays in a row - Yašoh A kli I (performed in 1960) and Bälg54 Although these plays
54 Tsegaye G/Medhin, Bälg (Addis Ababa, 1958 EC.); Abraham Alemu, "Yá-Amariňa Teyatre Tebäb Kä
1950 -1952 "Addis Zena ß series) 1/2/94; 8/12/94; 15/12/94.
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
JES, VoLXXXVII, No.2 (December 2004)
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
32 Shiferaw Bekele A Modernising State and Modernist Arts (1930s to 1970s:
Because the Paris critics were almost unanimous in their positive appraisal of
the exhibition which took place in January 1964, at the galerie Lambert in
Paris, I think, it had to be important to Skunder's development as an artist. It
was his first one man show in Paris and comments from established critics
were bound to make a difference.59
When Skunder returned home, his reputation had preceded him among art
circles in Addis Ababa. The art community received him with respect and
excitement. When he showed his first exhibition in November 1966, the two art
critics of the city - S. Chojnacki and Solomon Deressa - were full of praise.60
Solomon Deressa can, in my opinion, qualify as the first modernist art critic of
the country. He was at home in the latest trends in art history -surrealism and
abstract expressionism. He was familiar with art trends among African artists.
He eloquently wrote on the paintings of Gebre Kristos Desta and Skunder
Boghossian in his articles published in Ethiopia Observer.61 In his survey of the
history of modern art, Chojnacki singles out Solomon for his contributions to
art criticism.
"Ibid.
Solomon Deressa, "Skunder: In Retrospect Precociously," Ethiopia Observer Vol. X No.3 (1966), p.
175.
See the reviews of Solomon Deressa and S. Chojnacki cited in the two previous notes. A very
appreciative, yet critical review was done by an anonymous author: E.M., "Talented Ethiopian Artist's
Paintings on Display at Creative Arts Centre," Ethiopian Herald (November 6, 1966), p. 3.
See the article cited in note 59 above; and also see, "Gebre Kristos' Desta: Somber Colours and
Incantatory Words," Ethiopia Observer Vol. XI No. 3 (1967), pp. 162-175. In this article, Solomon
includes his own translation of three poems of Gebre Kristos. He has marvelously succeeded in taking to
the English language the nuances of the beautiful poems of the painter. He also wrote reviews for Addis
Reporter. See, for instance, the following piece: "A Tivoli of the Mind," Addis Reporter (May 30, 1969),
pp. 18-20 in which he reviewed the exhibitions of Wendy Kindred, a painter and art critic who taught in
the Art School at the time. See also his article entitled, "Letter from Addis Ababa," African Arts ('970).
These pieces display the author's deep knowledge of painting, his sensitivity to colour and to technique.
Some of his writings on painting and literature need to be collected and republished in book form for the
benefit of the younger generation.
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
JES, Vol.XXXVII, No.2 (December 2004)
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
34 Shi fe raw Bekele A Modernising State and Modernist Arts (1930s to 1970s:
They read the latest books and kept abreast of current developm
literature by reading English and French magazines. The t
bookshops for many years: Giannopoulos, Menno and Cosm
well-stocked with the latest foreign works of fiction, literary
social science publications, magazines and newspapers. T
compared well to its Greek-run counterpart, though it did not
works that it considered ran against Protestant morality. The b
accessible since they were located in or near Piazza, which was t
city. When their neighbourhood was demolished as part of t
plan of the Municipality in the 1960s, the Giannopoulos moved
Theatre area. Here again, they were not far from the city ce
managed to stay in Piazza until the revolution. Cosmos too w
part of the city.64
The avant garde group enjoyed the respect of the society. The y
writers, poets, painters and literary critics of the turn of the 21
whole, been appreciative of the achievements of that mod
contrary, the pioneers were very critical of themselves. Their s
that their attitudes towards themselves as a group and towar
educated Ethiopians of the 1960s and early 70s was very cri
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
JES, Vol.XXXVII, Na2 (December 2004)
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
36 Shiferaw Bekele A Modernising State and Modernist Arts (1 930s to 1970s:
not strike the reader as a great writer for all the books he surrounds himself with. The
other educated male characters are selfish, opportunistic, egotistic, petty, and
purposeless - a crowd of mediocrities. Some of them stink physically and morally.
This critical depiction is not confined to Baalu only. Tsegaye does the same in his
play, Bälg. The two major characters of the play, Abate (the writer) and Heruy (the
painter) are pathetic figures. They lack strength of character. It is very difficult for
the audience or for the reader to identify or even to sympathize with either of them.
Asfaw Damte takes up the same theme in his novel, And Lä-Amst and delivers a
devastating critique of the educated class. It is the same picture that Mengistu offers
us in his hilarious comedy, Tälfo Bâkisé ( Marriage by Abduction). He makes us laugh
at the pretensions of the highly educated characters in his play.
Paradoxically, members of the old ruling class come out in good light in some of
these works. In Admas Bašagar , Abate, the elder brother of the "hero" Abera, who is
meant to represent traditional society, shows purpose and determination. If we go
back again to the above-cited comedy of Mengistu, the father of one of the central
characters, Fitawrari Marné Taku'as, emerges as a truly impressive person, as a fine
specimen of the old warrior class - dashing, fearless, adventurous and contemptuous
of the literati. Though he started out as an intellectual with socialist predilections,
Mengistu ended up giving posterity a romantic image of the warrior class of Ethiopia.
Even if, deep down, they seemed to be critical of themselves and of their social class,
nevertheless, they harboured a profound conviction that they were on the threshold of
a new epoch. This conviction seems to have led them to a certain amount of
arrogance towards members of the older generation in the arts and literature. As
persons, they were polite and even humble; but when it came to their calling, they
showed that they were moved by a passionate missionary zeal. They believed that
they were making history.
5. The milieu
For any new art to grow and take root in a society, there is a need for an audience that
is ready to see and appreciate as well as to purchase the path-breaking works, for a
network of supporters and for critics. The Ethiopian avant garde group had all of
these, even if in small quantities.
In the years following the liberation of the country, Haile Selassie showed that he
was a true patron of the arts in Ethiopia. He assiduously encouraged literary writers,
in some cases giving money from his own pocket for the printing of their books. The
Emperor's numerous commitments did not prevent him from sparing time for cultural
activities and he presided over most of them. He went to the openings of drama and
is no sense of direction..." (p.241). Fekade Azeze, "The Intellectual in the Ethiopian Novel, 1930-1974,"
(Ph.D Thesis submitted to the University of Sheffield, UK, 1988).
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
JES, VoLXXXVII, No.2 (December 2004)
When he did not like the style of a certain work of art, he preferred to turn away his
eyes rather than to discourage the artist openly. Ethiopian arts flourished in the
country in the 1960s and early 70s as never before largely due to the benevolence of
his regime and to his patronage.
A work of art, however good, runs a small chance of success if there are no critiques
in the society who would point out to the public its qualities. It is one of those happy
coincidences of history that a couple of very capable art critics and a few competent
free lance commentators were on hand when the two modernist painters appeared on
the scene. They were S. Chojnacki and Solomon Deressa.70
70 There were, it is true, a number of people who wrote articles on exhibitions or on painters. The
following should be noted: Peatrice Plyne, W. Kindred, R. Pankhurst, David Talbot, E. Murray, Sydney
Head as well as Kefle Beseat. But they did not do it consistently (Plyne, Head, Murray, Kindred) or their
writings do not show that they have a mastery of the discipline of art criticism. Kefle Beseat had all the
makings of an art critic (training in Paris, a small book on abstract art to his name), but he did not pursue
the matter consistently by publishing reviews on the exhibitions that took place from the second half of
the 1960s to 1974. That is why I focus on Solomon and Chojnacki. For a good bibliography of the
newspaper and magazine articles of these people see Eshetu Tiruneh, "BäEtyopya Yäzämänawi Se'el
Tebäb ena YäAddis Ababa Senä Tebäb Temhert Bét Enqseqasé (1879-1983): Ačer Qeňt" (1993 EC.
(This is a typescript available in the library of the Institute of Ethiopian Studies.)
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
38 Shiferaw Bekele A Modernising State and Modernist Arts (1930s to 1970s:
Ababa. Though he never went to any art school (he did law in Paris in the 1930s),
he was deeply interested in the arts because he was a painter. He set out on a
long-drawn-out research into the history of the painting of the Ethiopian
Orthodox Tewahdo Church. His reputation in Ethiopian Studies rests on his
achievements in this research. More than any other scholar his contemporary, he
pushed forward the frontiers of knowledge of traditional Ethiopian painting. His
significant contributions to the growth of modernist arts in the country are, in the
process, overshadowed. He followed developments in this genre very closely. He
was an indefatigable attendee of exhibitions and befriended many modernist
painters.
Due to his competence, he acquired a high reputation within the art community
and among art lovers. He enjoyed the high esteem of avant garde artists. He was
asked more than once to write introductions to catalogues of exhibitions. His
influence was reflected in the selection of artists for the Haile Selassie I Prize
Award. His role in the selection process was evident. The citation of the Trust on
Skunder is so close to what Chojnacki wrote in Ethiopia Observer (1966) that it
would be fair to suspect that it was him who drafted it:
Thus Ato Skunder has demonstrated that the traditional Ethiopian art can lead to
great accomplishments by a creative attitude to it and not by passive imitation.
His hand can also be detected in the citations of Afewerk and Gebre Kristos. In any
case, he used his influence to encourage the art that he considered truly great. He was
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
JES, V0I.XXXVII, N0.2 (December 2004)
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
40 Shiferaw Bekele A Modernising State and Modernist Arts (1930s to 1970s:
who were beginning to purchase art. Some intellectuals showed that they were
interested in cultural activities apart from their professional pursuits. They made
efforts to understand works of art, followed the latest trends in culture, read literary
publications, and became generally informed about things artistic. The only
explanation that we can give to the emergence of art lovers and collectors is the
spread of (good quality) education to which we have made a reference above.
The artists were also engaged in actively developing networks of friends, supporters
and admirers. I have already made a reference to a small "club" that had been
established on the initiative of Asfaw Damte. It did not last long. Other initiatives
were taken by the artists themselves to set up associations. The Association for the
Development of Ethiopian Music and Theatre was established sometime in 1965.
Tsegaye Debalke was elected its president. In 1967 it organised a seminar on the arts,
the first of its kind, at the Creative Arts Centre. This seminar passed a set of
resolutions calling on government and society to support music and the plastic arts.74
Skunder took the initiative to organise a group of painters who were his students and
who followed in his footsteps into the "Young Artists Group"75 Eshetu Tiruneh, who
has written a very interesting account of the history of the Fine Art School, has
brought to light more than one attempt at creating a society or a club (Ethiopian
Painters Club, Ethiopian Painters Association), that unfortunately did not last long.76
Thus, the avant garde artists had their admirers, their clients, and their followers. It
was true that a certain segment of elite society strongly criticised them for their
departure from tradition. The artists and their circles tended to blow this attack out of
proportion. But if one looked at the periodicals of the times, one discovers that most
of the articles on art were written in their favour, admiring their works in most cases.
Pieces that attacked them were few and far between.77 It seems that the people who
did not like their work confined themselves, in the majority of cases, to informal
expressions of disapproval. The general picture that one gets from the published
sources was one of approval and appreciation.
74 Solomon Deressa, "Developing the Arts in Ethiopia," Menen (an illustrated monthly magazine)
(August/September, 1967), pp.34-35.
Sebhat G.Egziabher, "A Cup of Tea with Skunder," Menen (an English monthly magazine), (June,
1968), p.26.
Eshetu Tiruneh, "BäEtyopya Yäzämänawi Se'el Tebäb ena YäAddis Ababa Senä Tebäb Temhert Bét
Enqseqasé (1879-1983): Acer Qeňt" (1993 EC), pp.54-55. This is a typescript available in the library of
the Institute of Ethiopian Studies.
77 The most quoted "notorious" article is the one written by Mulugeta Lule, which in actual fact,
expresses as much bewilderment as criticism towards the structure of Gebre Kristos' poetry as to his
abstract art. See the article under his name in Yâzaréytu Etyopya 17 Genbot 1960 EC, p.3. In fact,
Mulugeta makes a point regarding a particular poem of Gebre Kristos, which he cites. But the scope of
this article does not allow me to develop my arguments.
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
JES, V0I.XXXVII, N0.2 (December 2004)
6. Conclusion
Following the suggestions of Chojnacki, one can identify some clearly demarcated
periods in the brief history of modernist art in Ethiopia.78 The starting point is 1954,
the year in which Afewerk held his first one-man exhibition. He and Ale Felege
Selam had returned from abroad that year and the latter would play a major role in
the development of the Fine Art School. Afewerk showed around one hundred
paintings in his exhibition. What was remarkable about the works was the variety of
media he used, including a few abstract paintings. Thus, he was the first Ethiopian to
introduce modern and modernist art in Ethiopia.
In the period before that, there were some attempts at doing modern (not modernist)
art. The pre-54 years (1920s to 1954) can therefore be called the proto-modern
period. In the period after 1954, the first exhibition of Gebre Kristos in 1963 marks
an important milestone. It saw a forceful introduction of abstract art into Ethiopia,
Skunder's first exhibition of 1966 was also a landmark. As of 1962, with the
graduation of an increasing number of students trained along modern lines in the art
school, modern art reached its height in the late 1960s and early 1970s. These
milestones were marked by three great exhibitions displayed in the years - 1954,
1963, 1966 - that presented and defined the new art. The modernising state provided
the framework that enabled the modernist movement to bloom in these years. With
the collapse of the imperial regime in 1974, the precipitous decline of the movement
set in.
Some lines from the "Second Coming," the famous piece of one of the great 20th
century poets, W.B. Yeats, admired by modernist artists, best capture the situation
that prevailed following the outbreak of the revolution:
Turning and turning in the widening gyre
The falcon cannot hear the falconer;
Things fall apart; the center cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all convictions, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity.
The arts paid a heavy price for all the turbulence of the revolution. The stifling
school of socialist realism was imposed. The state relentlessly used this type of
art for crude propaganda purposes. Modernist art was roundly condemned and
subsequently went underground. Thus came to an end a glorious period in the
history of modernist art in Ethiopia.
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
Gerekirstos Desta Self-Portrait, 1961 (oil on board) 70 x 50 cm
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
Gebre Kirstos Desta, Washing, 1970 (Oil on Hardboard) 100x80 cm
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
Gebre Kristos Desta discussing his works with the Emperor at the opening of the
1963 exhibition in the Hall of the Fine Arts School. (IES Collection)
This content downloaded from 18.9.61.111 on Fri, 08 May 2020 09:15:15 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms