Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Spinal Cord Injury and Mental Health: Christine Migliorini, Bruce Tonge, George Taleporos
Spinal Cord Injury and Mental Health: Christine Migliorini, Bruce Tonge, George Taleporos
Spinal Cord Injury and Mental Health: Christine Migliorini, Bruce Tonge, George Taleporos
Objectives: The aim of the study was to examine the mental health of adults with spinal
cord injury living in the community
Methods: The study was a representative community cross-sectional cohort self-report
survey, carried out in adults with traumatic spinal cord injury registered on the Victorian
Spinal Cord Injury Register and adults with non-traumatic spinal cord injury attending a
specialist non-traumatic spinal cord injury rehabilitation clinic. Participants (n443)
completed a self-report survey by internet, telephone or hard copy, which used reliable
and valid measures of depression, anxiety and stress (Depression, Anxiety and Stress
Scale) and post-traumatic stress disorder (Impact of Events ScaleRevised).
Results: Nearly half (48.5%) of the population with spinal cord injury suffered mental
health problems of depression (37%), anxiety (30%), clinical-level stress (25%) or post-
traumatic stress disorder (8.4%). Overall, there was a twofold or more increase in the
probability of emotional disorders compared to the general population. Of those with one
mental health disorder, 60% also had at least one other emotional disorder, representing a
substantial 56% increase over the general population in the probability of comorbidity of
psychopathology. Better health and time since injury were associated with decreasing the
risk of psychopathology.
Conclusion: The results of the present study underscore the vulnerability of the population
with spinal cord injury to emotional disorders. This study highlights the complexity of
mental health problems experienced by many individuals with spinal cord injury living in the
community. The delivery of mental health services to this vulnerable population requires
recognition of comorbidity and problems of mobility, access and stigma.
Key words: anxiety, depression, mental health, PTSD, spinal cord injury.
(n163) the time since injury was more than 2 years the Australian community. The aim of the present
(mean4.6 years; SD1.3 years) at the first mea- study was to investigate the mental health and
surement time point. In a large robust US study of phenomenology of emotional disorders in Austra-
1391 individuals averaging 9.7 years since injury lians with SCI living in the community.
(range 150 years), 48% reported clinically signifi-
cant symptoms of depression, with half of those (24%
of the total sample) suffering a probable major Method
depression [14]. In contrast, a small Australian study
found that the level of depressive symptoms in 60 Procedures
individuals who were injured 11 years previously on
average (range 533 years) indicated that they were Data were collected in 20042005. The participants were aged
as psychologically well-adjusted as non-disabled ]18 years, with a history of sudden-onset SCI and living indepen-
groups [15]. dently in the community. They were ]6 months since injury and
There have been few studies of anxiety after SCI. A on the registry of the only hospital in Victoria that treats patients
small Australian study (1 year after SCI, n 41; 2 with traumatic SCI. Individuals on the registry (n929) were
years after SCI, n31) found that depression and/or initially mailed an invitation to complete the survey by either the
anxiety was suffered by 30% of individuals with SCI internet or telephone or by mail. A hard copy of the survey
and this prevalence persisted over the first 2 years questionnaire was sent approximately 4 weeks later to anyone who
had not responded. Finally a follow-up telephone call to non-
since injury [16]. In contrast, a small UK study with a
responders was used approximately 4 weeks later. Excluding those
variable participation rate (n 104) found that the
who had died, were untraceable, had insufficient English-language
prevalence of anxiety fluctuated across the first skills, or had serious mental illness (such as dementia or schizo-
3 years after injury: the highest prevalence (60% of phrenia) that impaired their ability to complete the survey, there
n 5) was at week 48 after injury, the lowest was an overall 44% response rate.
prevalence (10% of n 40) was at 6 months after We certify that all applicable institutional and governmental
discharge, and the prevalence at 2 years after regulations concerning the ethical use of human volunteers were
discharge was 16% (n36) [8]. An Italian study followed during the course of this research. The research project
(n100) found that symptoms of anxiety and was approved by Monash University, Austin Health and Bayside
depression were 13% and 16%, respectively, within Health Ethics Committees. Each subject gave informed consent.
a cohort in which time since injury ranged from 3 The surveys were strictly confidential but not anonymous. Each
subject whose survey results indicated they were likely suffering
months to 28 years (mean 4.6 years) [7].
emotional distress, were approached and offered referral for
Despite the sudden and traumatic nature of SCI, psychological care.
the phenomenology of post-traumatic stress disorder Individuals who completed the survey did not differ significantly
(PTSD) and SCI has been less well studied. Twelve from non-responders, in current age or gender distribution (current
per cent of a cohort of 125 US veterans who averaged age t 1.546, (df927), p 0.12; gender x2 with Yates continuity
19 years since injury met the diagnostic criteria for r1.812, (df1), p 0.18). No other demographic information
current PTSD [1719]. In a small UK study (n 85) was available from the registry list.
of civilians with SCI who were 56 months since SCI, Additionally, further participants with sudden-onset SCI of a
14% scored within the clinically significant range of non-traumatic cause, such as an infection, who were not on the
intrusion and avoidance symptoms [20]. In contrast, a State SCI register were recruited through the outpatient clinic at the
small Danish study (n69) found that 20% of only other SCI unit in Victoria, specializing in non-traumatic SCI
(n32). Overall, 14% (n62) of the cohort had non-traumatic
individuals who were all less than 1 year since SCI
SCI.
suffered from PTSD [21].
A consistent finding of most studies of psycho-
pathology and SCI is that the level of SCI is not Measures
related to mental health outcomes. There were two
The reliable and valid self-report short form of the Depression,
exceptions: individuals whose SCI had resolved had
Anxiety and Stress Scale (DASS-21) was used to discriminate
significantly better mental health outcomes compared
between symptoms of depression, anxiety and clinical level of stress
to individuals with persisting SCI [11]; and veterans
using the scoring system and cut-offs published in the manual [22].
who sustained a high-level SCI (tetraplegia/quadri- Each subscale (depression, anxiety and stress) consists of seven
plegia) had a lower likelihood of current PTSD questions, has a clinical cut-off score and four levels of symptoms
[17,18]. severity (mild moderate, severe, and extremely severe). Respon-
There is a lack of large-scale studies of the long- dents are asked to indicate on a 03 scale how much each statement
term mental health of individuals with SCI living in has applied to them over the previous week.
Downloaded from anp.sagepub.com at Bobst Library, New York University on April 26, 2015
C. MIGLIORINI, B. TONGE, G. TALEPOROS 311
Normative DASS-21 data were available from a study of a large In comparison to the normative sample, the odds ratio (OR) for
adult non-clinical UK population (n1794; 815 male) with a mean any Depression was OR2.09 (95%CI 1.672.62). The OR for
age of 41.0 years (SD15.9 years, range1891 years) [23]. Parti- Anxiety was OR 2.19 (95%CI1.722.79). The OR for Stress
cipants were unpaid volunteers recruited from a wide variety of was OR1.35 (95%CI1.0571.72). The risk was consistent
sources including commercial and public service organizations [23]. across the levels of severity of psychopathology as indicated by
The Impact of Events ScaleRevised (IES-R) [24] is a reliable and the DASS-21 subcategories of mild, moderate, severe and extremely
valid self-report measure of symptoms of PTSD with a cut-off score severe. In comparison to the normative sample, the likelihood of
that indicates a likely diagnosis of PTSD [25]. experiencing any emotional disorder whether that was Depression,
The DASS, DASS-21, IES and IES-R have been successfully Anxiety or Stress was OR1.81 (95%CI1.462.23).
used within general populations [23,26], clinical populations with The risk of experiencing Depression, Anxiety or Stress did not
psychological disorders [25,27], populations with significant physi- significantly differ according to gender within the cohort. The OR
cal illnesses [28,29] and populations with physical disabilities of female subjects with SCI experiencing Depression over male
including SCI [18,30]. The terms ‘Depression’, ‘Anxiety’, ‘Stress’ subjects with SCI was OR1.55 (95%CI0.982.44), for Anxiety
and ‘PTSD’ will be used to indicate that the individual with SCI it was OR1.44 (95%CI0.902.33) and for Stress it was OR
had a score on the relevant scale that was above the published 1.19 (95%CI0.721.98).
clinical cut-off. These terms are not synonymous with a clinical When compared with the normative data, the risk of experien-
diagnosis but indicate a likelihood of such a diagnosis. cing Depression did significantly vary by gender: the odds of
Health consisted of a 110 score where higher scores indicated Depression for female subject with SCI was OR 2.74 (95%CI
better health and was derived from two questions. One question 1.794.19) and for male subjects with SCI it was OR 2.09
asked about the frequency of visits to the doctors over the previous (95%CI1.582.77). The increased risk of Anxiety compared
3 months. The other question asked for the names of medications with the normative sample also varied with gender: the odds of
taken daily. Each question was scored on 15 scale and then Anxiety for female subjects with SCI was OR 2.43 (95%CI
summed. 1.563.79) and for male subjects with SCI it was OR 2.59
(95%CI1.903.53). The risk of experiencing Stress was not
significantly different to the normative sample for female subjects
with SCI but just reached significance for male subjects: the odds of
Results Stress for female subjects with SCI was OR 1.43 (95%CI0.89
2.29) and for male subjects with SCI it was OR1.44 (95%CI
Participants 1.061.95).
Downloaded from anp.sagepub.com at Bobst Library, New York University on April 26, 2015
312 SPINAL CORD INJURY AND MENTAL HEALTH
per cent of those with PTSD also scored within the clinical range of 95%CI0.1390.753). Pseudo R2 statistics indicate that the
Depression, 78% within the clinical range of Anxiety and 78.4% independent variables accounted for only a modest portion (13
within the clinical range of Stress. To express this in another way: if 17%) of the variance in the outcome (Cox & Snell R2 0.127,
a probable case of PTSD was indicated then the odds of Depression Nagelkerke R2 0.170).
also being present was OR12.98 (95%CI4.9334.15), the odds
of Anxiety being present was OR9.96 (95%CI 4.4022.55), and
the odds of Stress being present was OR14.15 (95%CI6.23
32.10). Discussion
Downloaded from anp.sagepub.com at Bobst Library, New York University on April 26, 2015
C. MIGLIORINI, B. TONGE, G. TALEPOROS 313
distribution according to the level of injury and time physical symptoms diagnostic of psychological dis-
since injury was not equal. This is to be expected orders was conducted. The anxiety subscale was
because SCI aetiologies are not an equally distributed chosen because this scale included the highest number
phenomenon. Those with incomplete injuries were of items relating to physical symptoms (three auto-
injured significantly more recently compared to those nomic arousal items out of a total of seven items).
with complete injuries (F(3, 437) 0.6.551, p 0.000). The sample was divided into anxious and non-
What is more, individuals with a high-level complete anxious groups based on scores that passed the
quadriplegia are more likely to reside in supported published threshold. Participants in both the anxious
accommodation compared to other levels of SCI and and non-anxious group responded to the autonomic
were therefore not included in the present study of and non-autonomic items, but the anxious group
adults with SCI living independently in the commu- responded more positively to the non-autonomic
nity. Those with complete quadriplegia formed the items while the non-anxious group responded
smallest subgroup (n45 or 10%). A large propor- more positively to the autonomic items (Table 3).
tion of those with complete quadriplegia were injured The results indicated that, rather than confounding
many years ago; 45% (n 20) were injured ]20 years the results, the autonomic items played a legitimate
ago and 27% (n 12) were injured]30 years ago. But role indicating the presence of anxiety. This is
those with complete paraplegia had the highest mean congruent to previous research [12].
time since injury compared to the other levels The measures of psychopathology were self-report
(complete paraplegia mean 23.02 years, SD scales and did not include a diagnosis confirmed by
13.21; incomplete paraplegia mean 16.89 years, clinical interview, but the scales used had demon-
SD 14.03 years; complete quadriplegia mean strated good predictive and discriminatory validity
20.58 years, SD 11.77 years; incomplete quadriple- in normative and clinical populations as well as in
gia mean 17.14 years, SD 11.86 years). Therefore populations with disabilities. On the whole, the
the finding of relative mental health in those with representativeness and size of the sample should
complete quadriplegia and for the longest survivors is enhance the generalizability of the findings for Aus-
a systemic sample bias probably created by a healthy tralian people with SCI who live in the community.
survivor effect. Although there was a small to medium
effect size (h2 0.04) of injury level on time since Clinical implications
injury, the overall impact of those variables on the
likelihood of psychopathology was small. All the Although the number of people in Australia with
independent variables in the logistic regression model SCI is relatively small (estimate 2007 n 10 000) [34]
accounted for only 1317% of the variance. the suffering and the burden from clinical levels of
The present study found that many with SCI were depression, anxiety, stress and PTSD is high, affect-
remarkably resilient but there remained around 50% ing around 50% of this group. Given that 60% of the
who suffered from emotional disorders, 60% of sample could not recall receiving any specific treat-
whom suffered two or more emotional disorders. ment for their mental health problems there is a need
This is a substantial 56% increase in the likelihood of for better mental health assessment and treatment
comorbidity in emotional disorders over the general services that recognize the problems of mobility,
population. The likelihood of comorbid emotional access and stigma faced by those with SCI.
disorders has a number of consequences. It means
that any emotional disorder associated with SCI is
likely to be more complex to treat. Much of the
previous research into the emotional consequences of Table 3. Correlations of autonomic and non-
SCI focused on either depression or depression and autonomic items of anxiety subscale
anxiety [7,8,1114,24]. Treatments that focus on only
one aspect of the profile of psychopathology suffered Non-anxious Anxious group
by a person with SCI, such as depression, are less group (n305) (n132)
likely to be effective. Autonomic items 0.799** 0.643**
only
Non-autonomic 0.565** 0.824**
Study limitations items only
Downloaded from anp.sagepub.com at Bobst Library, New York University on April 26, 2015
314 SPINAL CORD INJURY AND MENTAL HEALTH
Downloaded from anp.sagepub.com at Bobst Library, New York University on April 26, 2015