Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Effect of Frozen Temperature On Autoxidation and Aggregation of Bluefin Tuna Myoglobin in Solution
Effect of Frozen Temperature On Autoxidation and Aggregation of Bluefin Tuna Myoglobin in Solution
net/publication/230136412
CITATIONS READS
21 375
3 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research from the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science, Japan. View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Chau-Jen Chow on 19 March 2019.
ABSTRACT
The effect offrozen storage temperatures in the range of -3C to -80C on the
autoxidation and aggregation of blueJin tuna oxy- and deoxy-rnyoglobin (Mb)in
solution was examined. Mb solution was kept frozen at various temperatures
afrer prefreezing by dry ice-acetone and examined for arctoxidation rate constant
and aggregation ratio. The temperature-dependency of these two parameters
showed the highest values at -1OC with both oxy or deoxy form. The autoxida-
tion rate constant of deoxyMb was higher than that of oxyMb between -6Cand
-2OC, while the reverse trend was observed at lower temperatures. These results
suggest that the structure of M b was perturbed through freezing resulting in
promotion of the autoxidation and aggregation of Mb simultaneously. These
results could explain the observation that deoxyMb in the inner portion of tuna
flesh discolorsfaster than oxyMb in the surface portion in the temperature range
of -3cand -2oc.
INTRODUCTION
Frozen storage is one of the most convenient methods for the long-term
storage of fish. Tuna is customarily stored frozen on board and after landing.
Bit0 (1965a) reported that the discoloration of tuna flesh proceeded during
frozen storage at about -2OC for 6 months, while the tuna flesh hardly
discolored when it was stored frozen in the temperature range of -35C to -78C.
Discoloration of frozen tuna flesh was considered to be independent of freezing
rate, but dependent on the storage temperature (Bito 1968). In this regard,
Hashimoto and Watabe (1983) reported that the storage temperature of -4OC
was capable of preventing the discoloration provided that the tuna samples were
very fresh.
With respect to variance in the rates of discoloration, Bit0 (1965a, b) found
that the inner portion of tuna flesh block discolored at a faster rate than the
surface portion when the sample was stored at temperatures of -3C to -2OC.
Chow (1991a) also found that, with temperatures of -2OC to -3OC after storing
for 3 to 6 months, the inner portion of tuna flesh cubes discolored at a faster
rate than the surface portion. This phenomenon was related to the partial
pressure of oxygen in the muscle of tuna flesh (Bito and Honma 1967; Matsuura
ef al. 1962).
Myoglobin (Mb) is the principal pigment in tuna flesh. Due to anaerobic
conditions, the fresh flesh contains purple red deoxymyoglobin (deoxyMb) in the
inner portion. Mb then combines with an oxygen molecule to form vivid red
oxymyoglobin (oxyMb). The oxyMb and deoxyMb change into brown metMb
during prolonged storage and processing, which results in the undesirable color
of meat products (Levieux and Levieux 1996; Morita et al. 1996). It is known
that low pH value can accelerate the autoxidation of Mb (Sano and Hashimoto
1958; Brown and Mebine 1969; Shikama and Sugawara 1978), and also affects
the structure of Mb (Pan-Sun and Solberg 1972). Chow (1991b) reported that
lower stability of Mb is associated with its higher autoxidation rate. In this
respect, high correlation coefficients between the rate constant and the free
energy at different pH values were observed for several fish species (Chow
1991b). Brown and Dolev (1963) found that the autoxidation rate of yellowfin
tuna and beef Mb increased along with lowering the temperature in the range of
-5C to -15C. Satterlee and Zachariah (1972) also reported that, the autoxidation
of chicken, pig and beef Mb increased with a decrease of temperature when the
temperature was between -12C and -19C. However, few data are available on
the autoxidation of Mb solution including tuna Mb in the lower temperature
range of -4OC to -6OC that is typically selected to store tuna commercially in
Taiwan and Japan.
Previously, we observed that, after quick freezing at -8OC for 2 h and then
thawing at 20C, tuna Mb in solution showed a higher autoxidation rate than
MYOGLOBIN AUTOXIDATION BY FREEZING 125
unfrozen Mb (Chow e? al. 1985, 1987, 1989). MetMb formation with quick
freezing at -8OC was minimum at pH values between 5.9 to 6.5 (Chow m al.
1985, 1987). Moreover, we also found that metMb formation exceeded 80%
regardless of pH values when Mb solution was frozen slowly at -2OC for 20 h.
These results indicated that the freezing temperatures affected the autoxidation
of Mb in solution significantly during the frozen storage. Besides, the rate of
Mb autoxidation in solution was obviously faster than in tuna flesh.
The present study investigated the effect of frozen temperature on the
autoxidation and aggregation of oxy and deoxy Mb in solution.
MATERIALS A N D METHODS
The values given for the results of metMb % are the means of triplicate
analyses with standard deviations.
The autoxidation of Mb proceeded as a first-order reaction. The autoxida-
tion rate constant was calculated following the method of Matsuura ef al. (1962)
by:
ratio increased with the storage time. A moderate variation in both parameters
was observed in the temperature range of -3Cand -80C within the 24 h storage.
However, the metMb% increased as a first-order reaction irrespective of the
frozen storage temperature between -6Cand -4OC, and was similar to the results
obtained at temperatures above OC. The rates of autoxidation were in the order
of -lOC > -2OC > -4OC > -6C> -3Cand -8OC. Chow er al. (1988)found
that the autoxidation rate constant of Mb solution decreased by reducing the
storage temperatures in the order of OC > -3C > -6C.However, f r o m Mb
solution showed higher values of metMb% than those obtained at temperature
of OC in the manner of OC < -3C< -6C.Bit0 and Honma (1967)also reported
that the temperature range causing the maximum discoloration in tuna flesh
2o
0 i
0 a 16
24
r B
0 0 16 24
Storage time (h)
was about -3C to -4C in the surface and about -6C to -7C in the inner part. The
results obtained in this study showed that the highest value of discoloration rate
in Mb solution was recognized at -lOC. This might be due to the presence of
0.2 M NaCl in the assay mixture.
Except at -8OC, the aggregation ratio of Mb solutions stored at temperatures
of -3C, -1OC, -2OC and -4OC increased consistently until 7 h, after which it
remained constant. The aggregation of Mb stored at -6C increased gradually
during the storage. The intensity was in the order of -6C, -1OC, and -2OC >
-4OC > -3C > -8OC. Chow ef al. (1985,1987) found that freezing and thawing
accelerated the aggregation of tuna Mb even if the Mb was quickly frozen
at -8OC for 2 h or slowly frozen at -2OC for 20 h. They suggested that freezing
and thawing promoted the conformational perturbation of Mb, especially in the
nonhelical region (Chow et al. 1989). Chen and Chow (2001) also reported that
milkfish Mb underwent some structural changes in a pH-dependent manner,
resulting in a higher susceptibility for both unfolding and autoxidation.
It is generally accepted that ice crystal formation in foods becomes
maximum at temperatures between -1 and -5C (Love and Elerian 1964). In the
present experiment, the freezing point of Mb solution might have been lowered
due to the presence of 0.2 M NaC1, so that the aggregation of Mb was promoted
in the temperature range of -6C to -2OC. The presence of salt at such a
concentration shifted the maximum ice crystal formation zone below -lOC.
Although the samples were quickly frozen in dry ice-acetone before storage, the
once-formed fine ice crystals might have grown up rapidly after the frozen
samples were transferred to the storage at the higher temperatures, resulting in
the acceleration of both Mb autoxidation and aggregation. The autoxidation and
aggregation of Mb in solution occurred quickly between -6C and -4OC within
one day of storage. It showed much faster rate of oxidation and denaturation
than Mb in the flesh. It might be related to the absence of any cryoprotectants
in Mb solution. Cryoprotectants, such as other water soluble proteins,
saccharides, and lipids in the flesh, might have prevented Mb denaturation
during frozen storage.
Secondly, the effect of storage temperature on deoxyMb was examined.
When deoxyMb solution was stored at the respective temperatures of -3C
to -8OC, similar changes of metMbZ and aggregation ratio were observed (Fig.
2). It demonstrated that both deoxy- and oxy-Mb behaved similarly at the
instants of freezing and during the subsequent frozen storage irrespective of the
presence of oxygen. The ferrous iron atom in deoxyMb can directly change into
the ferric form in metMb without going through the oxygenated ferrous form in
oxyMb. Such a result might explain that the inner portion of tuna flesh block
darkened during frozen storage at temperatures between -6C to -2OC, in spite
of anaerobic conditions in the flesh. The autoxidation rates were in the order of
-lOC > -2OC > -4OC > -6C > -3C > -8OC. The tendency in deoxyMb form
MYOGLOBIN AUTOXIDATION BY FREEZING 129
was quite similar to oxyMb forms. On the other hand, the pattern of aggrega-
tion of deoxyMb were also similar to those of oxyMb except at -4OC, where the
ratio increased gradually during the storage. However, an explanation for this
observation remains to be elucidated.
3
0 0 a 16 24
0 8 16 24
Storage time (h)
FIG. 2. CHANGES IN MetMb% (A) AND AGGREGATION RATIO (B) OF BLUEFIN TUNA
Deoxyhfb IN 50 mM Na-PHOSPHATEBUFFER @H 6.0) CONTAINING 0.2 M NaCl DURING
THE STORAGES AT TEMPERATURES OF -3C (o),-6C (A), -lOC (a), -2OC (m), 4 C ( A )
and -8oc( 0 )
Refer to the legend in Fig. 1 for the experimental conditions in detail.
TABLE 1.
MetMb FORMATION RATIO OF BLUEFIN TUNA OxyMb AND DeoxyMb IN
50 mh4 Na- PHOSPHATE BUFFER (pH 6.0) CONTAINING 0.2 M NaCl
DURING THE STORAGE AT -3 AND -8OC*
(%I
Temperature Storage time (day)
(C) 0 1 2 3 5
OxyMb -3 36.5*4.9 71.551.0 91.6*4.6 - 93.8*4.0
-80 36.5*4.9 78.0jz5.5 91.8+0.6 - 94.2*0.2
DeoxyMb -3 23.8*3.8 61.5*9.0 68.3*5.0 77.5*4.4 90.8*3.2
-80 23.8k3.8 38.9*5.9 36.5zk4.7 - 57.8*5.8
~
*A11 the samples were fiozen in dry ice-acetone, and kept at -80C for 2 h, and then
stored at indicated temperatures.
-80 60 40 -20 0
Storage temperature (C)
60 r
CONCLUSIONS
The autoxidation rate of both oxy- and deoxy-Mb in solution associated with
freezing and thawing was in good accordance with the aggregation ratio of Mb,
regardless of the frozen storage temperatures. Both the autoxidation rate and
aggregation ratio showed the highest values at -lOC. The autoxidation rate
constants of deoxyMb were higher than those of oxyMb in the temperature range
of -6C and -2OC, while the reverse trend was observed at temperatures between
-4OC and -8OC.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
REFERENCES
BITO, M. 1965a. Studies on the retention of meat color of frozen tuna-11. Effect
of storage temperature on preventing discoloration of tuna meat during
frozen storage. Nippon Suisan Gakkaishi 31, 534-539.
BITO, M. 1965b. Studies on the retention of meat color of frozen tuna-111. The
discoloration of tuna meat during the storage around at temperature of
freezing point. Nippon Suisan Gakkaishi 31, 540-545.
BITO, M. 1968. Studies on the retention of meat color of frozen tuna-V. Effect
of freezing rate. Nippon Suisan Gakkaishi 34, 608-612.
MYOGLOBIN AUTOXDATION BY FREEZING 133