Lampiran A

RUBRIC FOR PRESENTATION

Criteria Very Poor Poor Fair Good Very Good

Total
Scale (1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Content (40%) Includes most
Includes essential Covers topic
No essential Lack of essential essential
information with thoroughly, includes
includes adequate information and information and information, details __x8 =
some supporting details that support
coverage of knowledge in details details are somewhat
the issues presented details the topic
sketchy
Engage audience,
Presentation (20%) Clear and fluid delivery, uses Well prepared,
Not clear, not Lack of clarity and understandable, different approach speaks clearly,
includes English __x4 =
understandable understandable uses limited other than simply delivers with ease,
proficiency, eloquence
and clarity delivery techniques reading screen, invites questions
invites questions
Visually attractive,
Text is sometimes text is easy to read, Visually appealing,
Slides/Video (20%) Text is very difficult Text is difficult to hard to read, colors enhance clean simple layout,
to read, layout is read, layout is less sometimes graphics readability, graphics text is easy to read,
refers to the attractiveness __x4 =
cluttered and appealing and or special effects and special effects graphics enhance
of visual presentation
used confusing confusing distract from do not distract from understanding
understanding understanding ideas
ideas
Attitude (10%) Inconsistent with Excellent eye
Good eye contact, Presenter has a
eye contact and contact, no
Poor eye contact, no distracting clear presence in
includes dress, posture , volume. Obvious distracting
volume too low or gestures, usually the room that __x2 =
eye contact, time used distracting gestures,
and mannerism during
loud, over time has appropriate commands
mannerism(s); Over appropriate volume;
presentation volume; on-time attention; on-time
time on-time
Answers are Answers are Shows knowledge
Answers ramble, Answers are
inconsistent in uniformly good, and at a professional
off-target; may have uniformly good,
Q & A (10%) quality, either in show knowledge level for the topic. __x2 =
poor eye contact both in substance
substance or beyond Answers questions
when answering and delivery
delivery presentation with authority
Grand Total %
 Lampiran B

RUBRIK FOR CONTENT ASSESSMENT (I.E WRITTEN ASSIGNMENT/REPORT)

DIMENSIONS TRAITS 1 2 3

Introduction Not clearly Presents the Clearly

stated topic but presents
about the does not the topic in
topic engage the informative
reader manner

Conclusion Lacks an Summarize Summarize

identifiable and repeat and offer
conclusion what has excellent
been said overview of
the topic

Logical Flow No logical Sensible flow Logical and

flow, but consistent
ORGANISATION confusing, inconsistent flow
choppy

Layout Poor Improper and Sections,

labeling of inconsistent sub-topics,
sections, labeling tables and
sub-topics, figures are
tables and clearly
figures labeled

Sentencing Poor Acceptable Excellent

sentence sentencing connection
connection, but not clear with clear
long enough sentences
sentences

Problem No Too broad or Clear and

statement identificatio too narrow focused
n of and loosely statement
statement presented

Evidence of Missing or Relevant Well

support irrelevant support of supported
supporting ideas with
ideas relevant
IDEAS details
(CONTENT)
Provision of No example Adequate Relevant
examples given examples examples
with no which
connection to connect to
the ideas the ideas

Presentation Repetitive Satisfactory Excellent

of argument or lack of argument and original
clear point argument

No Available but Comprehen

reference inadequate, sive
REFERENCE
no proper compilation
referencing of reference