MAF651 – SEMINAR IN MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING

RUBRIC FOR GROUP REPORT (10%)

MEMBERS’ NAME STDN’S NUMBER GROUP

1 FARAH NURSYAZANA BINTI AHMAD ZAHARI 2019728065
2 NUN ISNORFIQAH BINTI ISMAIL 2019583797
3 NURUL SHARMIN HAFIZA BINTI FAIZUDDIN 2019345933 G5
4
5

CRITERIA/ MARKS EXCELLENT GOOD SATISFACTORY POOR

MARKS
FORMAT Report is properly Report is properly Report is properly Report is not properlly
presented and formatted and formatted, missing formatted binding, no
formatted, with title completed however, two or more of the title page, no table of
page, table of contents, missing one of the format criteria. contents, no
page numbers, format criteria or paginating, no
introduction, main content. appendix
contents, conclusion
and appendix
10 10-9 8-7 6-5 5>
INTRODUCTION Provide clear overview Provide moderate Provide overview but Provide vague
of the topic using own overview of the topic, no definition of key introduction,
sentence (original),clear define some key concept, relevant irrelevant and not
definition of key concepts and terminology. Omit the using own sentences,
concept, relevant terminology and the objective of the no definition of key
terminologies and the objective of the report. concept, terminology
objective of the report. report. & the objective.
15 15-14 13-10 9-7 7>
MAIN CONTENT Provide proper Provide logic Improper or less clear Provide poorly
 Basic concept structure, readable, structure, readable; structure, with no structured contents,
 Application comprehensive yet less comprehensive continuity among less comprehensive,
relevant discussion of (omit few relevant paragraphs irrelevant discussion.
steps/processes/
the content. Smooth issues of the topic). Topics are not
pre-requisites flow of thought, good arranged accordingly.
 Benefits & topics arrangement and Not original
limitations original work.
40 40-36 35-27 26-20 20>
APPLICATION TO Provide discussion by Provide sufficient Provide example of No example of
INDUSTRY giving good example of discussion of companies’ companies’
companies’ experiences companies’ experience that apply experience on SCM
that apply the SCM experiences that SCM technique but provided
technique apply the SCM lack of discussion
technique
10 10-8 7-6 6-5 5>
CONCLUSION Provide critical Provide general Provide conclusion by No conclusion given
conclusion of the topic conclusion of the repeating the same
by giving own topic by giving sentences from the
comment general comment content with no
comment given
15 15-14 13-10 9-7 7>
REFERENCES Use sufficient Use reference Use insufficient Reference given from
references which are insufficient references reference which the textbook only
relevant to the topics, which comes from comes from unreliable
reliable (from journals) reliable and sources and without
with proper referencing unreliable sources proper referencing
style with proper style
referencing style
10 10-8 7-6 6-5 5>
TOTAL 100

Report:
 Maximum 10 pages (excluding title page and appendices)
 Attach the references used under Appendix
 Last date of submission: