Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Modernization of Irrigation Systems: A Case of Research, Oriented To Improve Management
Modernization of Irrigation Systems: A Case of Research, Oriented To Improve Management
Modernization of Irrigation Systems: A Case of Research, Oriented To Improve Management
net/publication/226876488
CITATIONS READS
2 224
1 author:
L. S. Pereira
University of Lisbon
452 PUBLICATIONS 45,001 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
PHDROUGHT - Predictability assessment and hybridization of seasonal drought forecasts in Western Europe View project
All content following this page was uploaded by L. S. Pereira on 16 March 2017.
Key words: irrigation systems, modernization, irrigation research, design, irrigation management,
modelling
Abstract. In recent years, the traditional concept of an irrigation project has been changing. From
just a physical structure for the storage, conveyance and distribution of water, it is now being re-
garded as a more complex system, including farmers' participation. This implies an improved man-
agement in all phases, from reservoir operation to farm management, and therefore the change
from simple "operation and maintenance" to "operation, maintenance and management".
To face this new challenge, existing projects must be modernized. The Sorraia Irrigation Project
is one of those projects. In this paper major problems are identified and it is showed how research
(namely through modelling) can be oriented towards an improved management, regarding the con-
veyance and distribution systems as well as the on-farm systems.
Finally it becomes evident that beyond the technical problems to be solved, the involvement and
participation of farmers must be improved at all levelsof management. Hence, there is also a need
for implementing programs on education, training and extension.
Introduction
Modernization concept
The Sorraia Valley Project is a 15000 ha irrigation project in a long and narrow
alluvial valley near Lisbon. Water is made available by two large dams and con-
veyed in an open channel system. By using a large number of constant up-
stream level gates the supply of distributaries is regulated by Neyrpic regulators
(modules) manually operated by watermen according to O&M rules. The dis-
tribution system is mainly constituted by buried pipes. The farm turnouts, of
modular or semi-modular type, are operated by watermen. Main characteris-
tics are included in Table 1 and are reported by Rijo & Pereira (1987).
The system is represented in Fig. 1. It makes evident that it corresponds to
a past concept of irrigation systems, designed for the rotation system and partly
for continuous flow (for rice fields), and to respond to the needs of traditional
surface irrigation, where the irrigator uses a given flow rate (the " m a i n d ' e a u " )
for applying water inside the field.
There are several reasons for modernization:
- the system is much too rigid, despite the change of delivery from a rotation
system to a restricted demand system;
- as it operates with a constant water level, losses are difficult to be controlled;
- during periods of low water use - the night and the week-ends - losses are
very high;
67
C o m m a n d area 15354 ha
Storage volumes:
Maranh~o 180.9 × 106 m3
Montargil 142.7 × 106 m3
Open channel conveyance system 112.9 km
Open channel distribution system 98.5 km
Low pressure pipe distributors 171.6 km
Constant upstream level gates 303
Constant downstream level gates 85
Modules 567
Main open drains and collectors 134.5 km
Dikes 27.4 km
P u m p i n g plants:
for irrigation 7
for drainage 4
Outlets to users 2026
Farmers 2000
O&M personnel 90
- the rigidity of the system makes operation under drought conditions less ef-
fective;
- t h e relative rigidity of deliveries makes the implementation of irrigation
scheduling programs difficult;
- the constraints of the "main d'eau" limit the use of modern irrigation meth-
ods;
- t h e system is very labour consuming.
Many solutions have been proposed for the successful modernization of the
operation and management of canal systems (Jean 1981; Dedrick &
Zimbelman 1981; Jean et al. 1984; Piquereau et al. 1984; Verdier 1986). But
very few deal with the effect of existing gates (DeLeon 1986), in particular gates
which are designed to maintain a constant upstream level. Studies have been
made which yielded a solution (Rijo 1986; Rijo & Pereira 1987) which makes
use of the main equipment of the system but introduce discharge sensors at
main control points and remote controlled devices. The related research is
oriented towards the modelling and simulation of open canal systems, in-
cluding the effect of existing structures, and to search the consequent needs of
remote sensors and remote devices.
The foreseen solution is shown in Fig. 2. It schematizes the conversion of a
traditional upstream regulated system into an intelligent upstream regulated
system. This conversion allows the control of water losses by responding to real
time water demands. The remodelling of the buried pipes distribution system
is also needed to permit higher and variable flow rates at farm outlets. These
68
STRUCTURES CONTROL
Storage
Regulating O&MORGANIZkTION
I Reservoir I valve
Releases
Conveyance
I Constant ~1__
channels
upstream Design
levelgate ~constraint
Waterlevel 1
Supply I
Offtake Neyrpic I
regulators distributors -~(------Waterman
Discharge II
Oistribution1
I Pipeline pipe ~ Design
distributaries dimension constraint
Hydr.head 1~
Delivery I
I Farm Nodularor ~___
semi-modular Waterman
outlets outels
J
I~ Rotationor restricted
Traditi!nal "main~'eau" demandsystems
sur#aceirrigation andcontinuoL~sflow
Diagramoftheconveyanceanddistributionsystemwithtraditionalupstreamcontrol(Sor-
Fig. 1.
raiaValleyProject).
69
STRUCTURES CONTROL
Storage
Reservoir I Regulating
valve I
Releases I
Discharge--~
Conveyance + sensor I
Temlor.stora~eopen I IConst.upstream
t
channels Discharge---I~ ' levelgates I
+
sensors I ~I gates
Remotecontrol.I
I Level+dicharge
I
I
Supply I I Neyrpic
I distributors I
I O#~take I
+
regulators I
I ~i gates control. !
Remote
Oiseharge+time 1
Distribution
Pipeline I Remodelled
distributeries distributariesI
Hidraulichead 1
I Farm +
outlets
.............H Flowmeters'1
Discharge+time
[volume) I
On-farm demand
Improvedon-~arm
irrigation OPERATION& ~ ......
MANAGEMENT
ORGANIZATIONFOROM&M MODEL FARMERS
Fig. 2. Diagram of modernized conveyance and distribution system with intelligent upstream con-
trol.
70
On-farm irrigation
The importance given to the capability of the conveyance and distribution sys-
tem to respond to on-farm demand is explained in Fig. 4:
- yields and incomes depend highly on optimizing water availability for crops,
together with other agricultural practices;
- this availability can be estimated through climatic, soil and plant indicators
ery conditions by establishing the on-farm demand: flow rate, delivery dura-
tion, irrigation volumes and irrigation intervals;
- therefore the optimization of yields requires on-farm water demand to be op-
timized and delivery to be compatible.
71
Statistical statistloal/historical
climatic data agricultural data
Actual
climatic data _L, Climatic demand
Actual
I Crop coefficients ~ crop systems
,,,,,,
~,, , ,,,,
i Hydraulic ,,,,,,
_ ,
Travel time ~ ~ 1 ?gg
A ~ rregaied
e~ ,d,e,)and,,l
I Initial operation
conditions
J
Field sensors
information REALOPERATION l
Fig. 3. Simplified diagram of operation and management model.
Many research results about on-farm irrigation are available today through
reference books (Jensen 1981), proceedings of technical and scientific meet-
ings, technical and scientific journals and field manuals (WHW 1986). The
question is that effective transfer of technology requires experimentation and
reserach. Hence, research is done to establish appropriate irrigation scheduling
programs (Pereira et al. 1986h) and to improve irrigation methods such as level
basin irrigation (Sousa 1984), furrow irrigation (Tabuada 1986), and paddy
72
f i
02
r- =='1
÷
Z
127
H
I ~ I ~-~ I--
I + I
I r-4 I
H
I ~ I ~
=
÷
~S
0
OJ ~-I
~o
L']
,
73
In the above analsysis of the reality of an irrigation project it has been pointed
out that the project should be considered as a system and as a complex that in-
corporates different sub-systems.
Figure 5 shows the essential elements and responses of crops and on-farm
systems and conveyance and distribution systems, according to the analysis
made above. It identifies two other systems that bridge the gap between the
farm and the physical infra-structures; the irrigation scheduling/irrigation
management system, and the on-farm demand system.
Both systems can be supported by decision models or information models.
This can be of great importance for achieving the goals related to the enlarge-
ment of the scope of OM&M of the overall project and to make the participa-
tion of farmers in project management more effective.
In fact, the same information (including training on how to use it) allows far-
mers and the OM&M staff to make appropriate decisions about how, when,
and how much to irrigate, thus reducing the uncertainty of demand responses.
It is a difficult approach as existing programs make evident (JMLORD 1981;
Snyder et al. 1985). However, it is a process of evolution of the behaviour of
farmers and of OM&M organizations regarding the technological changes in
irrigated agriculture.
Conclusions
The research example described above shows that the design of projects, taking
in consideration its management, requires new approaches for combining on-
farm with conveyance and distribution management.
Such an approach is less complicated when the design concerns the moder-
nization or rehabilitation of an existing project because of the history of the
project, skills of farmers and of the related OM&M agency.
Nevertheless, the needs of management are so diverse, and can be of so great
importance, that studies have to be conducted to search technological solutions
for physical and agricultural structures that respond to such needs. In the case
of modernization the involvement of researchers, namely from universities,
can be of interest for creating the theoretical background for further applica-
tions, and for the development of extension and training programs.
74
~r
b- t~
t~
rD
H
,H
o~ .E
0
r~
r~
r~
I i
L9 F-- -
I Z
~-t
Z
kU
I .-1
~
~__
kU
I
I Z Z J~
I 6O
J ~
Z Z
O (:3
H H
b- b-
( ( I I I I
I--i H
H H
~ ~ o
4o
~z °
o
° l'
{
ffl
ltt r~
o
~0
~-~ °~
÷1 ~ ~ II
o m
75
Due attention must be given to the general concept of solutions, the interac-
tion of systems and the managerial capabilities of developed models. Co-
herence between on-farm and distribution systems is of great importance. In
order to strengthen the bridge between such systems information and decision
capabilities must be developed regarding irrigation management programs and
on-farm demand.
Education and training of staff, being able to design systems taking into ac-
count the project management issues and capabilities of farmers and agencies'
staff is needed to meet project goals.
Acknowledgements
References
Baumli, G.R. (Ed). 1982. Principles of Project Formulation for Irrigation and Drainage Projects.
ASCE, New York.
Bromley, D.W. 1982. Improving Irrigated Agriculture - Institutional Reform and the Small
Farmer. World Bank Staff Working Paper No. 531, Washington D.C.
Brower, L.A. & Buchheim, J.F. 1984. An irrigation district computerized water management
system. In: Transactions 12th Congress on Irrigation and Drainage. (Fort Collins 1984). Vol.
I(A) (pp. 986-1006) ICID, New Delhi.
Burton, M. 1986. Training programs for irrigation staff. ODI/IIMI Irrigation Management Net-
work 86/le, ODI, London.
CEMAGREF. 1981. Etude par simulation des besoins potentiels d'irrigation de la R6gion Lor-
raine. CEMAGREF, Division Irrigation, Aix-en-Provence.
Coward, E.W. & Uphoff, N. 1986. Operation and maintenance in Asian irrigation: reappraising
government and farmer responsibilities and rights. Irrigation and Drainage Systems 1 pp. 31-44.
Dedrick, A.R. & Zimbelman, D.D. 1981. Automatic control of irrigation water delivery to and
on-farm in open channels. In" Proceedings Symposium on Principles of Designing Control
Systems for Water Resources and Irrigation Using Modern Techniques. (Grenoble 1981) (pp.
113-128) ICID, New Delhi.
DeLeon, B. 1986. Prise en compte de vannes de r6gulation dans un module de simulation d'un
canal de transport et de distribution d'eau. In: XIV European Regional Conference of ICID,
Vol. II: Improvement of Water Management. (La Manga, Murcia 1986) (pp. 17-33) Comite
Espafiol de la ICID, Madrid.
76
Groenfeld, D.J. 1986. Shared government-farmer management of irrigation resources: the poten-
tial for farmer participation. In: Proceedings Darves-Bornoz Special Session Water for Food
and Peace (Lahore, Pakistan 1986) (pp. 347-369) Nat. Com. of Pakistan ICID, Lahore.
Jean, M. 1981. Principe de conception des syst~mes de commande pour les resources hydrauliques
et l'irrigation grace ~t des techniques modernes. In: Proceedings Symposium Principles of De-
signing Control Systems for Water Resources and Irrigation Using Modern Techniques (Gre-
noble, France 1981) (pp. 25-64) ICID, New Delhi.
Jean, M. & Mancel, Galand, Carmantrand. 1984. Les effets d'un programme de lutte contre les
pertes d'eau sur les modalit6s d'exploitation d'un r6seau d'irrigation. In: Transactions 12th
Congress on Irrigation and Drainage (Fort Collins, USA 1984). Vol. IA (pp. 557-575) ICID,
New Delhi.
Jensen, M.E. (Ed). 1980. Design and Operation of Farm Irrigation Systems. ASAE Monograph
No. 3, St. Joseph, MI.
JMLORD. 1981. Distribution systems improvement to facilitate water delivery. California Dept.
Water Resources and JMLORD, Inc., Fresno, CA.
Lockheed. M.E., Jamison, M.T. & Lau, L.J. 1980. Farmer Education and Farm Efficiency: a
Survey. World Bank Rep. Ser. No. 166, Washington D.C.
Menenti, M., Chambouleyron, J., Stefanini, L., Morabito, J. & Fornero, L. 1984. Agricultural
water use in large irrigation schemes. In: Crop Water Requirements (Conf6rence Internationale,
Paris 1984) (pp. 597-609) INRA. Paris.
Perraton, H. 1983. Mass media, basic education and agricultural extension. In: Basic Education
and Agricultural Extension. Costs, Effects and Alternatives. World Bank Staff Working Papers
No. 564, Washington D.C.
Pereira, L.S. 1984. On institutional problems of irrigation water management in relation to water
resources planning. In: Transactions 12th Congress on Irrigation and Drainage (Fort Collins,
USA 1984), Vol. IA (pp. 513-528) ICID, New Delhi.
Pereira, L.S. 1985. Role of government and of farmers' participation in irrigation projects: an ex-
ploratory approach regarding the development of Portuguese Agriculture. In: Special Technical
Session on State Participation in the Execution of Irrigation Works and Subsequent Follow-up
(Vifia del Mar, Chile 1985) Vol. II (pp. 7.1-7.15) Com. Chileno ICID, Santiago do Chile.
Pereira, L.A., Alves, I.M. & Pereira, L.S. 1986a. On paddy rice irrigation management: some
research results aiming improvement. In: XIV European Regional Conference of ICID, Vol. II.
Improvement of Water Management (La Manga, Murcia 1986) (pp. 267-279) Com. Espafiol de
la ICID, Madrid.
Pereira, L.S., Pereira, L.A., Ferreira, M.I., Fernando, R.M., Sousa, P.L. & Alves, I.M. 1986b.
Estudo Te6rico-Experimental das Necessidades Hidricas das Culturas. Final Report Project
JNICT 518.83.43. Instituto Superior de Agronomia, Lisboa.
Pereira, L.S. & McCready, W. 1987. Rehabilitation and modernisation of irrigation projects.
Identification of concepts, main questions and priorities. ICID Bulletin 36(2) (in press).
Piquereau, A., Tardieu, H., Verdier, J. & Villocel, A. 1984. R6duction des pertes d'eau par l'auto-
matisation de la gestion d'un barrage r6alimentant une rivi~re en vue de l'irrigation. In: Transac-
tions 12th Congress on Irrigation and Drainage (Fort Collins, USA 1984), Vol. IA (pp. 577-587)
ICID, New Delhi.
Rady, M.A. & Abdu-Zeid, M.A. 1985. Irrigation Development in Rural Societies of Egypt. In:
Water Resources for Rural Areas and their Communities (Proc. Vth World Congress on Water
Resources, Brussels, 1985) Vol. II (pp. 779-788) IWRA, Cristal Drop Publ., Ghent.
Rijo, M. 1986. Aplicag~o de um modelo matem~itico ao canal de rega de Salvaterra (Application
of a mathematical model to the irrigation canal of Salvaterra). M;Sc. Thesis, Universidade T6c-
nica de Lisboa.
Rijo, M. & Pereira, L.S. 1987. Measuring conveyance efficiencies to improve water management.
Irrigation and Drainage Systems 1(3) (in press).
77
Rijsberman, R.F. & Grigg, N.S. 1985. Identifying priorities in irrigation systems: problems and
solutions. In: Tenth Technical Conference on Irrigation, Drainage and Flood Control (Reno,
Nevada 1985) U.S. Committee of ICID.
Rydzewski, J.R. (Ed). 1977. Irrigation Development Planning. Southampton University.
Sagardoy, J.A. 1982. Organization, operation and maintenance of irrigation schemes. Irrigation
Drainage Paper No. 40, FAO, Rome.
Small, L.E. 1985. Research priorities for irrigation management in Asia. In: IIMI Research Paper
No. 1 (pp. 1-10) IIMI, Digana, Sri Lanka.
Smout, I. 1986. Training programmes for irrigation farmers. ODI/IIMI Irrigation Management
Network 86/1e, ODI, London.
Snyder, R., Henderson, D.W., Pruitt, W.O. & Doug, A. 1985. California Irrigation Mangement
Information System. Final Report. Land, Air and Water Resources Paper 10013-B, University
of California, Davis.
Sousa, P.L. 1984. Rega pot canteiros de nivel (level basin irrigation). Recursos Hidricos, 5(2),
73-102.
Swarner, L.R., Buchheim, J.F. & Goar, J.F. 1981. Scheduling farm irrigation demands through
project distribution systems. In: Transactions l lth Congress on Irrigation and Drainage
(Grenoble, France 1981) Vol. I (pp. 477-490) ICID, New Delhi.
Tabuada, M.A. 1986. Modelag~to bidimensional da infiltrac~o na rega pot gravidade (Bidimen-
sional modelling of infiltration in surface irrigation) M.Sc. Thesis, Universidade T6cnica de
Lisboa.
Teixeira, J.L. & Pereira, L.S. 1985. Modelling irrigation water consumptions and needs. Applica-
tion to river Ave basin. In: Systems Analysis Applied to Water and Related Land Resources
(IFAC Conference, Lisbon 1985) (pp. IV, 41-46) APDIO, Lisboa.
Verdier, J. 1986. Informatisation de la comande du transport et de la distribution d'eau d'irri-
gation. In: XIV European Regional Conference of ICID, Vol. II. Improvement of Water Mana-
gement (La Manga, Murcia 1986) (pp. 323-339) Com. Espafiol de la ICID, Madrid.
Vlachos, E.C., Radosevich, G.E., Skogerboe, G.V. 1978. Operational and organisational charac-
teristics for effective irrigation systems. In: Transactions 10tl~ Congress on Irrigation and
Drainage (Athens, Greece, 1978) Vol. VI (pp. 33-54) ICID, New Delhi.
WMW. 1986. On-Farm Water Management Field Manual. Water Management Wing, Min. Food,
Agriculture and Cooperatives, Islamabad, Pakistan.