Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Accounting 1
Accounting 1
Accounting 1
By
S.M.Gunawardana
MF/2009/2356
February 2014
of University of Ruhuna
i
Dedication
This Dissertation is dedication to my family members for their kindness, devotion and
endless support which gave me much more courage.
ii
Table of content
Acknowledgement ...................................................................................................................... i
Dedication .................................................................................................................................. ii
Table of content ........................................................................................................................ iii
List of Tables .............................................................................................................................. v
List of Figures ............................................................................................................................ vi
List of Acronyms....................................................................................................................... vii
Declaration .............................................................................................................................. viii
Certification .............................................................................................................................. ix
Abstract ...................................................................................................................................... x
1 CHAPTER 01 ....................................................................................................................... 1
INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................................... 1
1.1 Background of The Study ........................................................................................... 1
1.2 Banking Sector Structure in Sri Lanka ........................................................................ 1
1.3 Interest Rate Spread .................................................................................................. 2
1.4 Research Problem ...................................................................................................... 3
1.5 Research Question and Objectives ............................................................................ 4
1.6 Methodology.............................................................................................................. 4
1.7 Significance of The Study ........................................................................................... 5
1.8 Limitations of the study ............................................................................................. 6
1.9 Summary and Chapter Organization.......................................................................... 6
CHAPTER 02 ............................................................................................................................... 7
LITERATURE REVIEW .................................................................................................................. 7
2.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................... 7
2.2 What is Interest Rate Spread ..................................................................................... 7
2.3 Determinants of Macroeconomics ............................................................................ 8
2.4 Summary .................................................................................................................. 13
CHAPTER 03 ..................................................................................................................... 14
METHODOLOGY ....................................................................................................................... 14
2.5 Introduction ............................................................................................................. 14
2.6 3.2 Conceptual Framework .................................................................................. 14
2.7 Rationalization of the variables ............................................................................... 15
2.7.1 Dependent Variable ......................................................................................... 15
iii
2.8 Development of Hypotheses ................................................................................... 18
2.9 Methodology............................................................................................................ 18
2.10 Data Analysis ............................................................................................................ 18
2.11 Summary .................................................................................................................. 19
CHAPTER 04 ..................................................................................................................... 20
DATA PRESENTATION AND ANALYSIS ...................................................................................... 20
3.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................. 20
3.2 Data Presentation .................................................................................................... 20
3.3 Data Analysis ............................................................................................................ 21
3.3.1 Descriptive Statistics ........................................................................................ 21
3.3.2 Variance Inflation Factor (VIF) ......................................................................... 23
3.3.3 Regression Analysis .......................................................................................... 24
3.4 Summary .................................................................................................................. 27
CHAPTER FIVE .................................................................................................................. 28
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS................................................................................ 28
4.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................. 28
4.2 Conclusion ................................................................................................................ 28
4.3 Recommendations ................................................................................................... 30
4.4 Suggestion for Future Researches ........................................................................... 31
REFERENCES ..................................................................................................................... 32
Annexure .......................................................................................................................... 34
iv
List of Tables
v
List of Figures
vi
List of Acronyms
BR Bank Rate
US United State
vii
Declaration
I hereby declare that this dissertation is my own work and effort and that, to the best
of my knowledge and belief, it contains no material previously published or written
by another person nor material which has been accepted for the award of any other
degree or diploma of the university or other institute of higher learning, except where
due acknowledgment has been made in the text.
viii
Certification
____________________________
Supervisor
Ms.T.A.N.R. Jayarathne
University of Ruhuna
____________________________
Head
Dr.Manjula K. Wanniarachchige
University of Ruhuna
ix
Abstract
x
1 CHAPTER 01
INTRODUCTION
According to Central bank of Sri Lanka the banking sector accounted for 56.4% of
financial system assets at end of 2012 and comprises Licensed Commercial Banks
1
(LCBs) and Licensed Specialized Banks (LSBs). The distinction between LCBs and
LSBs lies in the scope of activities they can undertake. LSBs are licensed to conduct
specialized banking business and are not authorized to accept demand deposits and
deal in foreign currency. At end of 2012, there were 33 licensed banks including 24
LCBs and 9 LSBs.
2
GDP), Exchange rate (Annual percentage change of US dollar exchange rate), and
Treasury Bill rate (interest rate of 3 months treasury bills).
A study carried out in Jamaica (Tennant and Folawewo, 2008) has concluded
that narrower spreads can have definite economic benefits. The study tested
determinants of banking sector interest rate spreads in 33 low and middle income
countries.
High IRS higher the cost of credit and discourage savings. Higher cost of
credit restricts the access of potential borrowers to credit market.High IRS is
represents higher cost to borrowers and investors.According to prior researches IRS is
tend to widen in developing countries. Also it acts an obstacle to the expansion of
financial intermediation necessary for growth and development of an economy.
3
1.5 Research Question and Objectives
The Researcher develop main research question. Therefore the Question behind this
study is as follows.
What is the impact of macroeconomic determinants for Interest Rate Spread in
Sri Lanka commercial banking sector?
General Objective
Specific Objectives
1.6 Methodology
This study was conducted using annual data from the Sri Lanka LCB Financial
Statistics for the years 1983 – 2012 according to central bank of Sri Lanka (CBSL).
Thus study, identifying the macroeconomic determinant affecting IRS in Sri Lanka
commercial banking sector, was an analytical in nature. Analytical research primarily
concern with testing hypothesis, specifying and interpreting relationship by analyzing
information already available. The main objective of this study was that identify
4
determinant affecting IRS in Sri Lanka using already available data obtain from
various data source. Therefore this study was an analytical study in nature.
Macroeconomic Variable
Bank Rate
Exchange Rate
Interest Rate Spread
Treasury Bill Rate
Inflation Rate
Sri Lanka is a developing country and its banking sector as a financial intermediary
plays major role in financial sector in Sri Lanka. Interest Rate Spread is the main
determinant of the efficiency and sound financial banking and financial system.
Moreover, it is of the essence that regulatorsstudy potential business combination in
the banking industry for these can repeal existing competitive conditions and increase
bank interest spread.
Sri Lankan commercial banking interest spreads have sustained around 4.1%
and is exact to widen on the back of deposit rates falling ahead of lending rates. Due
to the dominance of unquoted state sector banks the net interest margin has squeezed
to around 4.1% due to the faster reduction in lending rates over the deposit rates.
However the scenario in the private quoted commercials banks is quite contrary with
the interest spreads widening to around 6% due to a faster reduction in deposit rates
ahead of the lending rates. This study results are more important to financial policy
5
makers. Becausemain effect on economic development of their policy decisions.Also
Government can control barriers for correct policy decisions. More ever Central Bank
of Sri Lanka can supply security for the entire banking sector as like as controller of
the all the banks.
Using secondary data obtained from different sources such as annual reports and web
based databases carries out this study. Therefore in behaviorally, there were some
disadvantages of secondary data when it was compared with primary data such as less
reliability, less accuracy, bias etc. Measurements of some variables change time to
time. (E.g. Inflation Rate – Base year of Colombo consumer price index is change).
This study covered only data year between 1983 and 2012. Data before 1983 time
period and data after the 2012, had not been used for this study. When applying some
mathematical model for analysis the result the validity of result created by these
techniques were depend on range of date and time period. Large number of data and
time period enrich the strangeness of result.
The first chapter involved giving introduction on the topic, significance of the
carrying out such research and the brief introduction on banking sector in Sri
Lanka.Next chapter is going to explain the theoretical and empirical base of the study
The study has divided into four chapters. Chapter one includes the problem
statement with a brief description of the problem situation, Conditions or the
background of the problem situation, relevance of the study and objectives of the
study. Chapter two basically covers the literature review and the related body of
knowledge in the said area of study. It is an in depth study of existing literature on this
topic. Ideas of previous Researches are examined under this chapter. Observed
variables that are investigating and graphical representation of the relationship of
these variables are presented under the third chapter.
6
CHAPTER 02
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Introduction
This chapter concluded the theories related with IRS and the literature review will
examine the determinants of Interest Rate Spread.
According to Alfred Marshall, the interest rate is the price paid for the use of capital.
This rate of interest is determined by the equilibrium formed by the interaction of the
aggregate demand for capital and its future supply. As said by Taussig, the interest
rate is determined at the level where the marginal productivity of capital equals the
marginal installment of saving (www.cliffsnote.com).
7
increase in interest rates stimulates savings; especially bank deposits and there by
provides more invest able funds thus leading to economic growth.
Numbers of studies have been carried out in search of determinants of Interest Rate
Spread. Regardless of the widespread implementation of costly financial sector
reform programs in the developing world, banking sector in many developing
countries is still characterized by persistently high interest rate spreads. (Tennant and
Folawewo, 2008)
Poke and Graeme (2007) conducted a study on The Term Spread and GDP
Growth in Australia to determine the degree to which the Australian term spread can
forecast real GDP growth. The results suggest that the term spread has been useful for
forecasting cumulative real GDP growth.
Obamuyi (2009) investigated the relationship between real interest rates and
economic growth in Nigeria from 1970 to 2006. The results show that there exist a
unique long-run relationship between interest rates and economic growth. The
researcher concluded that the relationship between investment and growth in Nigeria
8
may not allow for optimal benefits from interest rate reforms in the country. The
important condition for promoting economic growth, therefore, is for the government
to formulate and implement financial policies that enhance investment friendly rate of
interest and take into consideration those other factors which negatively affect
investment in the country.
According to Ndung and Ngugi (2000) narrow interest rate spread is important
to maintain a stable macroeconomic environment and thus reduce credit risks and also
need to minimize implicit taxes like reserve and cash ratios, complemented by fiscal
discipline to reduce the demand for financing budget deficit with low cost funds.
Perera et.al (2012) emphasis that state owned banks should also draw
regulatory attention for extract higher interest margins, possibly, as compensation for
their high operational inefficiency levels. Moreover, it is of the essence that regulators
study potential business combination in the banking industry for these can repeal
existing competitive conditions and increase bank interest spread.
A study carried on Bangladesh (Mujeri and Younus, 2009) analysis shows that
IRS is significantly influenced by operating costs and classified loans for state owned
commercial banks and specialized banks while inflation, operating costs, market share
of deposits, statutory reserve requirements, and taxes are important for the private
commercial banks.
9
Grenade (2007) carried out a trend analysis of commercial banks’ interest rate
spreads in the Eastern Caribbean Currency Union (ECCU) over the period 1993 with
employing panel data techniques to measure the relevance of micro and macro factors
in determining commercial banks’ interest rate spreads over the period. The results
indicate that the observed spreads can be attributed to the high level of market
concentration, high operating costs and non-performing loans and the central bank’s
regulated savings deposit rate.
According to Mujeri and Younus (2009) interest rate spread (IRS) affects
many macroeconomic variables. The study carried out in Bangladesh identifies
several determinants for higher the IRS in the banking sector in Bangladesh. The
analysis shows that statutory reserves requirements, the high National Savings
Directorate certificate interest rates, inflation, operating costs, market share of
deposits contribute to higher interest rate spreads in the banking sector in Bangladesh.
The analysis in terms of bank groups shows that operating costs and classified loans
significantly influences interest rate spreads.
Randall (1998) has examined Interest rate spread in the Eastern Caribbean and
the finding of the study suggested the scale diseconomies in commercial bank,
Reserve requirement, provision for loan losses and share of loan going to the public
sector have significant effect on the interest rate spread. Randall inclusion the
additional variables showed that macro policy variables, such as public sector
domestic borrowing, discount rates and Treasury bill rates, are commonly perceived
to impact on commercial bank spreads.
Folawewo and Tennant (2008) carried out a study attempt to analyze the
determinants of spreads between banks’ deposit and lending rates in SSA countries
from market and macroeconomic view points, using a dynamic panel data estimation
11
technique. Using annual data covering 33 countries, the results obtained from the
paper suggest that different market and macroeconomic policy variables play
significant role in explaining variations in IRS in the region. The paper show that the
extent of government crowding out in the banking sector, public sector deficits,
discount rate, inflationary level, level money supply, reserve requirement, level of
economic development, and population size are important determinants of interest
rate spreads in SSA (Sub-Saharan African) countries. This result has an important
implication in terms of policy design in the region.
Ndung and Ngugi (2000) emphasis that the minimal levels of reserve
requirement ratios will ensure the lending rates are kept down in a study carried out in
Kenya.This study analyzed factors behind the widening interest rate spread following
interest rate liberalization in Kenya. The survey of indicators shows that market
fundamentals and institutional factors influence interest rate spread. Disequilibrium in
the loans market is a major factor in driving the widening of interest rate spread.
There are also feedback effects from the other fundamentals to the loans market. The
factors that drive the interest rate spread are availability of deposits, alternative
investment channels for banks and the ease of portfolio adjustment at the end of the
period. Study also concluded that some institutional factors like micro market
structures and policy actions explain substantial variations in interest rate spread.
Performance in the loans market reflects a macroeconomic environment in which
stability serves to reduce the risk premium and ensure positive returns for investment,
thus reducing the credit risk.
Afzal and Mizra (2010) investigate the determinants of Interest Rate Spreads
in Pakistan’s commercial banking sector and they find out strong evidence that bank
size explains interest rate spreads. Similarly, operational efficiency, asset quality,
liquidity, risk absorption capacity and GDP growth are found to be important
determinants of banking spreads.
12
a relatively weaker influence than expected. In addition, the rise in the central bank
bill rate has a considerable effect in the rise of the lending rates, as expected.
Thornton (n.d) investigated on the Discount Rate and Market Interest Rates
and finds out that the market interest rates are influenced by numerous factors that
affect the supply of and demand for credit. One of these factors is the discount rate.
The impact of the discount rate on market rates varies with the Federal Reserve’s
operating procedures.
2.4 Summary
This chapter included the theories related with IRS and the literature review will
examine the determinants of Interest Rate Spread. There are many theories related
with interest rate spread and no of research emphasis the importance of undertaking
the study on determining interest rate spread in Sri Lanka.
13
3 CHAPTER 03
METHODOLOGY
2.5 Introduction
Macroeconomic Variables
Bank Rate
Inflation Rate
Banking Sector
Development
14
2.7 Rationalization of the variables
This paper examines the determinants of banking sector interest rate spreads in Sri
Lanka. The study has used the determinants from previous studies to guide the choice
of independent variables.
.
Interest rate spread is the interest rate charged by banks on loans to prime customers
minus the interest rate paid by commercial or similar banks for demand, time, or
savings deposits. The study has examined the spreads for the commercial banking
sector as a whole. This allows for the use of actual interest rate data in the calculation
of spreads, and gives a better understanding of the broad state of efficiency of
financial intermediation in the country.
Therefore the banking sector interest rate spreads (IRS) are calculated as:
IRS = Average Commercial Bank Lending Rate – Average Commercial Bank Deposit
Rate
The set of independent variables includes variables that might possibly explain the
dynamics of banking spreads in Sri Lanka. These are explained in detail below.
Inflation Rate
15
consumer of acquiring a basket of goods and services that may be fixed or changed at
specified intervals, such as yearly.
Treasury bill is short-term security instrument. Meaning of short term is usually less
than one year, typically three months. It was issued by government as a primary
instrument for regulating money supply and rising funds via open market operations.
Issued through the country's central bank, T-bills commonly pay no explicit interest
but are sold at a discount, their yield being the difference between the purchase price
and the par-value. This yield is closely watched by financial markets and affects the
bank interest rates. Although their yield is lower than on other securities with similar
maturities, T-bills are very popular with institutional investors because, being backed
by the government's full faith and credit, they come closest to a risk free investment.
Bank Rate
The Bank rate is the rate charged by central banks when commercial banks borrow
from them. The rate at which the Central Bank grants advances to Commercial Banks
for their temporary liquidity purposes is Bank Rate.
16
Much of the recent economic literature suggests that the discount rate is no
longer an important monetary policy tool for many countries. However, a study
(Tennant and Folawewo, 2010) results suggest that whether or not the government as
a means of controlling the money supply is using the bank rate, it is undoubtedly an
important factor in determining the size of the banking sector interest rate spreads.
The Banking sector in Sri Lanka accounted for 56% of financial system assets at end-
2012 and comprises Licensed Commercial Banks and Licensed Specialized Banks
(Central Bank of Sri Lanka 2012).The members of the banking system and the
functions they typically perform include, commercial banks that take deposits and
make loans, investment banks which specialize in capital market issues and trading,
and national central banks that issue currency and set monetary policy.
Exchange rate
The price of one country's currency expressed in another country's currency. In other
words, the rate at which one currency can be exchanged for anotheran advantage to a
floating exchange rate is the fact that it tends to be more economically efficient.
However, floating exchange rates tend to be more volatile, depending on the
particular currency. Study uses the annual percentage change in US dollar exchange
rate.
The result of the study on IRS conducted by Chortareas et.al (2006) for the
macroeconomic variables, coefficient of the exchange rate is statistically significant in
four cases only and their degree is generally low. The effect the exchange rate on
interest rate spread is positive for Paraguay and Peru but negative for Chile and
Venezuela.
17
2.8 Development of Hypotheses
This study observes the effects of the macroeconomic determinant affecting Interest
Rate Spread (IRS) in Sri Lanka.With the purpose of achieve the objectives of the
study, several hypotheses can be established.
2.9 Methodology
Secondary Data obtain from various data sources have analyzed using Regression
Model. Main data sources are annual report of Central Bank of Sri Lanka and World
Bank web site. Annual data is used in the study over the time period of 1983 to 2012.
With the objective of identifying the macroeconomic determinant affecting IRS in Sri
Lanka commercial banking sector, ordinary least square regression analysis model is
used. Following model is used to discover the macroeconomic determinant affecting
IRS in Sri Lankan commercial banking sector.
Y = β0 + β1 X1 + β2 X2 +………+ βnXn
18
Where,
BR - Bank Rate (This is the rate at which the Central Bank grants advances to
Commercial Banks for their temporary liquidity purposes)
U - Residual Error
2.11 Summary
This chapter explains the developed conceptual framework and methodology of the
study, in order to identify the macroeconomic determinant on IRS. Types of data
used is secondary data obtain from Central Bank of Sri Lanka 1983-2012 data sources
is used in the study. Regression model is employed to data analysis.
19
3 CHAPTER 04
3.1 Introduction
This chapter is devoted to present the data collected from various data source. Also
this chapter is intended to elaborate the statistical tests and interpretations of the
results of the analysis with the objective of become aware about the data and also this
chapter facilitates to check the stated hypotheses of this study to draw the final
conclusion regarding the research problem by providing necessary information. Using
tables, graphs and statistical measurements does these data presentation and analysis.
25.00
20.00
15.00
Depot Rate
10.00 Lending Rate
5.00
0.00
1983
1987
1991
1981
1985
1989
1993
1995
1997
1999
2001
2003
2005
2007
2009
2011
20
Interest Rate Spread is the difference between commercial bank lending rate and
deposit rate. Figure 4.1 shows the 1981-2012 annual average lending rate and deposit
rate of commercial banking sector in Sri Lanka. It indicates that IRS in Sri Lanka is
highly fluctuating in recent past.
As Figure 4.1 shows interest rate spread of Sri Lanka’s commercial banks
have been declining since the mid-1990s. However, since 2002, bank interest spread
has begun to increase again. This change is somewhat confused. According to CBSL
recent information’s researcher identified two reasons for those changes. First, even
though the Central Bank of Sri Lanka has reduced the official interest rate
continuously from 2001-2003.Therefore commercial banks have not given the full
benefits of reduced rates to consumers. Second, one was rapid credit growth due to
low interest rate and the market dominance of two largest state owned commercial
banks have not helped in reducing interest spread. This situation banks to earn more
interest income.
Currently IRS situation is it is decline step by step. The major reason for this
decline is the competition among commercial banks. A study carried out Effectsof
financial sector reforms in Sri Lanka (edirisooriya,2007) included the two largest
banks’ assets level has a declining trend since 2000 due to increase pressure from
other domestic private banks and foreign banks.
Prior to estimation process of the equation, all the variable concerned have been tested
for stationary process using Regression model.
21
Table 4.1: Descriptive Statistics
Source: SPSS output from Central Bank of Sri Lanka Annual Reports, 1983-2012
The Average (Mean) value of the IRS is 2.99% and its standard deviation is 4.37%.It
means the value of IRS can be deviate from mean to positive and negative sides by
4.37%.The maximum value of IRS 8.38% and minimum value is -6.64%.When
considering the average value of IRS selected commercial bank sector that are
favorable position by IRS.
SCALE is presenting percentage of commercial bank assets in gross domestic
product. In here it’s about 36.45% average values and standard deviation is 12.49%
value. Minimum value is 15.98% and maximum is 53.89%.Hence this is indicator
how much percentage include in GDP as a commercial bank assets. It helps to get a
clear idea about bank and financial sector development.
According to table average Inflation rate of commercial bank sector
10.29%and standard deviation is 5.01%.The maximum value of INF is 22.56% and
minimum is 0.58%.This representing what the impact of INF for IRS selected period.
Because Inflation rate is a term used in economics which refers to the rise in prices of
goods or services over a given time period.
When considering the BR of the commercial bank sector its take 15.33%with
standard deviation value 2.86%.The maximum is 15.00% and minimum is 10.00%.
Bank rate an important factor in determining the size of the banking sector interest
rate spreads. Cause of it is using control the money supply.
22
EXR is the annual percentage change in US dollar exchange rate. In here it’s
about 6.33% and standard deviation is 4.86%.The higher value of EXR is 16.07%and
minimum value is -2.21%.
Table 4.2 shows the VIF and Tolerance of each variable. In here the tolerance value is
measures the influence of one independent variable to all other variables.
Source: SPSS output from Central Bank of Sri Lanka Annual Reports, 1983-2012
According to this study every macroeconomic variable VIF value are greater than 1
and lower than to 10.In here researcher could identify there is no multicorllinearity
problem.
23
3.3.3 Regression Analysis
Source: SPSS output from Central Bank of Sri Lanka Annual Reports, 1983-2012
The F, Statistic in the table shows that the set of independent variables were
generally contributes to the variance in the dependent variables. And there was
statistically significant effect between IRS and the set of
variables(BR,EXR,SCALE,INF,TBR).Because of the P value (.000) is greater than
0.05 and its shows the overall model was statistically significant to predict the
24
outcome. Therefore the F, statistically significant at a level of <0.05, it is assumed that
there is a linear relationship among the variables.
When considering the results of the equation, one can see that TBR has higher
value of probability and they are not significant even 10% significant level. It can be
concluded that TBR has an insignificant impact on determining IRS.
When analyzing the results one can see that the probability value of BR is less
than 0.001 depicting that the null hypothesis of no significant influence is rejected and
it has a significant impact on the determination of IRS in the case of Sri Lanka. As per
the regression output, one percent change in the BR will exact 1.1086 percent positive
change in IRS.
The rate at which the Central Bank grants advances to Commercial Banks for
their temporary liquidity purposes is Bank Rate. Thus, bank rate is cost of funds
commercial banks’ point of view. Therefore they will increase lending rate of
commercial banks thus, Interest Rate spread.
Much of the recent economic literature suggests that the discount rate is no
longer an important monetary policy tool for many countries. However, a study
(Tennant and Folawewo, 2010) results suggest that whether or not the government as
a means of controlling the money supply is using the bank rate, it is undoubtedly an
important factor in determining the size of the banking sector interest rate spreads..
As per the result of the equation, it is clear that probability value of EXR is
less than 0.05, depicting that the null hypothesis of no significant influence is rejected
and it has a significant impact on the determining IRS. As per the regression output,
one percent change in the EXR will exact 0.230 percent negative change in IRS.
25
Efficiency and Interest Rate Margins in Latin American Banking carried out
byChortarea et.al (n.d) the exchange rate effect on net interest margin is negative for
Chile and Venezuela.
Increase in Exchange rate discourage import and encourage export. It makes
friendly environment to domestic producers, especially small and medium scale
business. Investment is goes up and it accelerates economic growth and then reduces
IRS.
In accordance with the result, probability value of INF is 0.099 and null
hypothesis of no significant impact on IRS can be rejected in 10% significant level. It
can be concluded that one percent change in INF exact 0.219 percent negative change
in IRS.
As per the regression output, SCALE is concern the probability value 0.054
and can be rejected null hypothesis of no significant impact at 10% significant level,
and the coefficient of SCALE is 0.114. It can be concluded that SCALE has a positive
significant impact on determining IRS.
Banking sector development measures the overall size of the banking sector
and is correlated with growth in GDP. Lower developing of the banking system may
reflect a lower level of efficiency in intermediation activity, leading to higher spreads.
26
Higher bank assets to GDP could indicate a more developed banking sector with more
diversity of services and more profit-oriented banks which could lead to higher
average interest income. It could be associated with more competition or greater
efficiency which could lead to lower spreads.
3.4 Summary
This chapter has discussed the results of the analysis done by using obtained data on
dependent and independent variables with established model and methodology in
chapter four. This chapter identified the determinant of Interest Rate Spread and kind
of relationship between IRS and each determinant identified.
27
4 CHAPTER FIVE
4.1 Introduction
This chapter presents the conclusion of the study based on analyzed data and an
overall summary of the study. In addition to that, this chapter consisted with
recommendations of the study with suggestions for future researches on determinant
of Interest Rate Spread.
4.2 Conclusion
This study investigated on the variables affecting Interest Rate spread in Sri Lanka.
The main objective of the study is to identify the macroeconomic determinants of IRS
in Sri Lankan commercial banking sector. In achieving this objective, there are some
specific objectives have been formed. Those are, to identify current trends in Sri
Lankan IRS, to measure the relationship between IRS and each determinant
identified, to be aware of economic impact of IRS and to suggest recommendation to
improve efficiency of financial system in Sri Lanka.
28
According with the regression results Treasury bill rate has insignificant
relationship with Interest Rate Spread in Sri Lanka even 10% significant level.
Therefore the model was redeveloped excluding that variables. As further, researcher
could identify that the inflation rate changes have not direct affected of Interest Rate
Spread in Sri Lanka. A study carried out by Hemachandra (2009), on the topic of
Interest Rate as a Policy Instrument, have explained that Inflation increased along
with other factors such as depreciation of foreign exchange rates as proxy by dollar
rate in the equation. The dollar rate in the equation tested is highly significant in
explaining inflation of the country
According to result of the regression analysis the effect of those four variables
on Interest Rate Spread can be calculated as follows.
Expected type
Variable (H1)of the Significant/ Type of the
Relationship Insignificant Relationship
Inflation rate Positive Significant Negative
Banking Sector development Negative Significant Negative
Bank Rate Positive Significant Positive
Exchange Rate Positive Significant Negative
Treasury Bill Rate positive Insignificant Positive
Result of the study concluded that all variable in the model have explained
more than 58% of the changes in IRS and each determinant have the significant effect
on Interest Rate Spread in Sri Lanka. Also it can be concluded that there are more
significant variables should be included the model and they make negative effect on
IRS. Relevant to the study could identify selected determinants were correlate each
other. Because gets in that variable one by one those doesn’t apparent expected
results exclusive of BR.
29
Relevant to the study researcher expected to identify money market current
trends. According to the study, The CBSL, since November 2004, has been
implementing a tight monetary policy. Because as one of the measures to control
rising inflation. The interest rate corridor was revised upward starting from November
2004 following which market interest rates also increased.
The researcher analysis average deposit rate included the commercial bank
sector average deposit rate, fixed deposit rate and saving deposit rates. As further
lending rate was included average prime and normal lending rates. According to this
IRS economic players can get an idea about economic direction. Hemachandra
(2009), conducted a study on The Interest Rate as a Policy Instrument have to
determine the estimations weighted average deposit rates, fixed deposits rates and the
savings deposits rates are responsible in determining total deposits of the banks.
Therefore, rather than policy rates, interest rates are important determinants of
financial savings commercial bank deposits in the country. The coefficients for
weighted average deposit rates, fixed deposit rates and savings deposit rates are
significant in explaining the behavior of total deposits of the country.
4.3 Recommendations
Interest Rate Spread is relatively higher than the regional countries. It acts as
an obstacle to development in Sri Lanka. Identifying the determinants of Interest Rate
Spread is important to maintain Interest Rate Spread moderate level.
According to the result of the study Bank rate is the most affected determinant
of Interest Rate Spread in Sri Lanka. To maintain less interest rate spread policy
makers should be responsive when deciding monetary policy rates. Inflation rate and
exchange rate are cause to determine Interest Rate Spread in Sri Lanka. Therefore
30
macroeconomic stability should be sustained through well-established fiscal policy
and international trade policy. Macroeconomic stability is essential for successful
financial liberalization process, thus policy actions should be taken to ensure
sustainable growth of the economy. Stability of key prices, including the exchange
rate, commodity prices and interest rates, is crucial. This will stimulate high
investment returns and reduce the credit risk, consequently reducing the risk premium
tagged on loan interest rate.
The study would give some suggestions to future researches. This study carried out
using macro level data. One could carry out a study on Interest Rate spread using
micro level data.
Investigate the effect of Interest Rate spread on GDP growth is another important
topic.
A study can be carried out on determinants of Interest Rate spread using Central Bank
of Sri Lanka data. Another researcher could carry out using panel data within South
Asian region and cross sectional analysis is important to make comparison among
countries.
31
5 REFERENCES
Afzal, A., & Mirza, N. (2010). The Determinants of Interest Rate Spread in Pakistan's
Commercial Banking Sector. CREB Working Paper No. 01-10, Centre for Research
in Economics and Business and Lahore School of Economics.
Central Bank of Sri Lanka - Interest Rates. (2012). Retrieved from www.cbsl.gov.lk:
http://www.cbsl.gov.lk/htm/english/_cei/ir/
Georgievska, L., Kabashi, R., Trajkovska, N. M., Mitreska, A., & Vaskov, M. (2011).
Determinants of lending interest rates and interest rate spreads. Bank of
Greece.
32
Hemachandra, W. M. (n.d.). Interest Rate as a Policy Instrument – Recent Experience
of Sri Lanka. Central Bank of Sri Lanka.
Heon Kim, D., & Hamilton , J. (1999). A re-examination of the predictability of the
yield spread for real economic activity.
Mujeri, M., & Younus, S. (2009). An Analysis of Interest Rate Spread in the Banking
Sector in Bangladesh. The Bangladesh Development Studies Vol. XXXII.
Ndung’u i, N., & Ngugi, R. (2000). Banking Sector Interest Rate Spread in Kenya.
Macroeconomic and Economic Modelling Division, Kenya Institute for Public
Policy Research and Analysis.
Tennant, D., & Folawewo, A. (2008). Determinants of Interest Rate Spreads in Sub-
Saharan African Countries: A Dynamic Panel Analysis. the 13th Annual
African Econometrics Society Conference,. Republic of South Africa.
Wells, G., & Poke , J. (2007). The Term Spread and GDP Growth in Australia. School
of Economics and Finance.
33
6 Annexure
Data Table
34
40
60
0
20
10
20
-10
10
20
30
0
10
20
30
0
1983 1983 1983
1986 1983
1987 1987
1989 1987
Annexure B
1991 1991
1992 1991
1995 1995 1995 1995
1999 1998 1999 1999
BR
INF
2003 2001
EXR
2003 2003
SCALE
2007 2004 2007 2007
2007
2011 2011 2011
2010
BR
INF
Categorical Graph of the Variables
SCALE
EXR
35
TBR
30
20
10
TBR
0
1983
1987
1991
1995
1999
2003
2007
2011
Annexure C
IRS=1.858+0.031(SCALE)
36
Result of the Regression Model for Banking Rate
IRS=-11.632+0.954(BR)
IRS=4.537-0.150(INF)
37
Result of the Regression Model for Exchange Rate
IRS=4.361-0.216(EXR)
IRS=2.787+0.015(TBR)
38
Annexure D
39
Annexure E
1.0
0.8
Expected Cum Prob
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
40
Annexure F
Histogram
6
Frequency
Mean =5.31E-16
0 Std. Dev. =0.91
N =30
-2 0 2
41