COMPARISON OF RESPONSES

Storey No.1

Beams:
A B C D
Edge Beams Full Model (Without Full Model (With Percent Difference (%)
Construction Stage Model
earthquake forces) earthquake forces) B vs A C vs B
Bay Width/Length 4m 5m 6m 4m 5m 6m 4m 5m 6m 4m 5m 6m 4m 5m 6m
Bending Positive 28.23 46.35 88.45 23.93 42.99 97.38 28.23 54.16 88.45 -15.23 -7.25 10.1 17.97 25.98 -9.17
(Mz) Negative 43.44 74.98 137.25 34.57 66.84 145.88 51.49 125.01 149.21 -20.42 -10.86 6.29 48.94 87.03 2.28
Shear Fy 59.35 82.7 124.15 42.57 64.98 118.08 60.35 97.21 124.15 -28.27 -21.43 -4.89 41.77 49.6 5.14
Torsion Mx 0.61 1.1 2.12 1.32 2.73 4.93 0.6 1.1 2.12 116.39 148.18 132.55 -54.55 -59.71 -57

Interior Beams

Bending Positive 39.13 66.87 134.46 43.69 78.54 179.36 39.13 66.87 134.45 11.65 17.45 33.39 -10.44 -14.86 -25.04
(Mz) Negative 58.45 104.28 202.02 62.98 121.45 267.77 60.92 146.57 202.02 7.75 16.47 32.55 -3.27 20.68 -24.55
Shear Fy 75.92 110.02 175.46 76.29 116.12 213.48 75.92 114.28 175.46 0.49 5.54 21.67 -0.48 -1.58 -17.81
Torsion Mx 0.02 0.03 0.09 0.2 0.36 0.77 0.06 0.36 0.26 900 1100 755.56 -70 0 -66.23
NOTE: NEGATIVE sign indicates % DECREASE in response and POSITIVE sign indicates % INCREASE in response.
Columns:

A B C D
Corner Columns Full Model (Without Full Model (With Percent Difference (%)
earthquake forces) Construction Stage Model earthquake forces) B vs A C vs B
Bay Width/Length 4m 5m 6m 4m 5m 6m 4m 5m 6m 4m 5m 6m 4m 5m 6m
Axial Fx 744.8 1040 1050 93.01 141.01 226.88 744.8 1040 1500 -87.51 -86.44 -78.39 700.77 637.54 561.14
Bending Mz 19.93 34.08 61.47 22.41 45.36 94.24 25.55 73.27 64.13 12.44 33.1 53.31 14.01 61.53 -31.95
Moment My 13.08 27.4 42.76 10.73 30.5 50.94 21.27 60.74 56.8 -17.97 11.31 19.13 98.23 99.15 11.5
Shear Fy 11.36 19.06 33.03 9.68 19.23 37.95 16.35 41.78 42.08 -14.79 0.89 14.9 68.9 117.26 10.88
Forces Fz 7.7 15.77 24.35 5.29 14.4 24.3 13.78 39.84 35.62 -31.3 -8.69 -0.21 160.49 176.67 46.58

Edge Columns

Axial Fx 1180 1670 2520 170.48 257.69 441.97 1180 1670 2520 -85.55 -84.57 -82.46 592.16 548.07 470.17
Bending Mz 25.77 45.61 88.09 40.23 80.72 170.31 27.05 79.12 88.09 56.11 76.98 93.34 -32.76 -1.98 -48.28
Moments My 16.4 35.81 59.16 18.53 52.56 89.11 23.3 65.82 69.93 12.99 46.77 50.63 25.74 25.23 -21.52
Shear Fy 13.49 23.29 43.16 16.95 33.35 66.82 17.79 46.7 51.23 25.65 43.19 54.82 4.96 40.03 -23.33
Forces Fz 9.07 19.18 31.39 8.93 24.27 41.58 14.61 43.3 41.82 -1.54 26.54 32.46 63.61 78.41 0.58

Interior Columns

Axial Fx 1730 2560 4000 307.63 470.17 830.86 1730 2560 4000 -82.22 -81.63 -79.23 462.36 444.48 381.43
Bending Mz 3.09 2.97 7.43 3.82 8.51 20.53 20.5 80.8 48.34 23.62 186.53 176.31 436.65 849.47 135.46
Moment My 0.183 0.48 1.86 3.21 8.81 17.18 16.02 67.35 27.3 1654.1 1735.42 823.66 399.07 664.47 58.91
Shear Fy 1.7 1.56 3.83 2.04 4.74 11.66 12.14 45.16 24.95 20 203.85 204.44 495.1 852.74 113.98
Forces Fz 0.95 0.17 0.65 1.5 4.15 8.19 10.59 43.5 24.8 57.89 2341.18 1160 606 948.19 202.81
NOTE: NEGATIVE sign indicates % DECREASE in response and POSITIVE sign indicates % INCREASE in response.
 Bending Moment (+Mz)

Bay Full Model (Without Earthquake Forces) Construction Stage Model Full Model (With Earthquake Forces) Bay
4m 28.23 23.93 28.23 4m
5m 46.35 42.99 54.16 5m
6m 88.45 97.38 88.45 6m

120

100
Bending Moment (+Mz)

80
Full Model (Without
60 Earthquake Forces)
Construction Stage Model
40
Full Model (With
Earthquake Forces)
20

0
4m 5m 6m
Bay Width/Length

Shear Force (Fy)

Bay Full Model (Without Earthquake Forces) Construction Stage Model Full Model (With Earthquake Forces) Bay
4m 59.35 42.57 60.35 4m
5m 82.7 64.98 97.21 5m
6m 124.15 118.08 124.15 6m

140

120

100

Shear Force (Fy)

80 Full Model (Without
Earthquake Forces)
60
Construction Stage Model
40 Full Model (With
Earthquake Forces)
20

0
4m 5m 6m
Bay Width/Length
 Bending Moment (-Mz)

Full Model (Without Earthquake Forces) Construction Stage Model Full Model (With Earthquake Forces)
43.44 34.57 51.49
74.98 66.84 125.01
137.25 145.88 149.21

160
140
120
Bending Moment (-Mz)

100
Full Model (Without
80 Earthquake Forces)
60 Construction Stage Model
Full Model (With
40 Earthquake Forces)
20
0
4m 5m 6m
Bay Width/Length

Torsional Moment (Mx)

Full Model (Without Earthquake Forces) Construction Stage Model Full Model (With Earthquake Forces)
0.61 1.32 0.6
 1.1 2.73 1.1
2.12 4.93 2.12

5
Torsional Moment (Mx)

4
Full Model (Without
3 Earthquake Forces)
Construction Stage Model
2
Full Model (With
Earthquake Forces)
1

0
4m 5m 6m
Bay Width/Length
 Bending Moment (+Mz)

Bay Full Model (Without Earthquake Forces) Construction Stage Model Full Model (With Earthquake Forces) Bay
4m 39.13 43.69 39.13 4m
5m 66.87 78.54 66.87 5m
6m 134.46 179.36 134.45 6m

200
180
160
Bending Moment (+Mz)

140
120
Full Model (Without
100 Earthquake Forces)
80 Construction Stage Model
60 Full Model (With
40 Earthquake Forces)
20
0
4m 5m 6m
Bay Width/Length

Shear Force (Fy)

Bay Full Model (Without Earthquake Forces) Construction Stage Model Full Model (With Earthquake Forces) Bay
4m 75.92 76.29 75.92 4m
5m 110.02 116.12 114.28 5m
6m 175.46 213.48 175.46 6m

250

200

Shear Force (Fy)

150
Full Model (Without
Earthquake Forces)
100 Construction Stage Model
Full Model (With
50 Earthquake Forces)

0
4m 5m 6m
Bay Width/Length
 Bending Moment (-Mz)

Full Model (Without Earthquake Forces) Construction Stage Model Full Model (With Earthquake Forces)
58.45 62.98 60.92
104.28 121.45 146.57
202.02 267.77 202.02

300

250
Bending Moment (-Mz)

200
Full Model (Without
150 Earthquake Forces)
Construction Stage Model
100
Full Model (With
Earthquake Forces)
50

0
4m 5m 6m
Bay Width/Length

Torsional Moment (Mx)

Full Model (Without Earthquake Forces) Construction Stage Model Full Model (With Earthquake Forces)
 0.02 0.2 0.06
0.03 0.36 0.36
0.09 0.77 0.26

0.9
0.8
0.7
Torsional Moment (Mx)

0.6
0.5 Full Model (Without
0.4 Earthquake Forces)
Construction Stage Model
0.3
Full Model (With
0.2 Earthquake Forces)
0.1
0
4m 5m 6m
Bay Width/Length
 Axial Force (Fx)

Bay Full Model (Without Earthquake Forces) Construction Stage Model Full Model (With Earthquake Forces) Bay
4m 744.8 93.01 744.8 4m
5m 1040 141.01 1040 5m
6m 1050 226.88 1500 6m

1600
1400
1200
Axial Force (Fx)

1000
Full Model (Without
800 Earthquake Forces)
600 Construction Stage Model
Full Model (With
400 Earthquake Forces)
200
0
4m 5m 6m
Bay Width/Length

Bending Moment (Mz)

Bay Full Model (Without Earthquake Forces) Construction Stage Model Full Model (With Earthquake Forces) Bay
4m 19.93 22.41 25.55 4m
5m 34.08 45.36 73.27 5m
6m 61.47 94.24 64.13 6m

100
90
80

Bending Moment (Mz)

70
60
Full Model (Without
50 Earthquake Forces)
40 Construction Stage Model
30 Full Model (With
20 Earthquake Forces)
10
0
4m 5m 6m
Bay Width/Length

Shear Force (Fz)

Bay Full Model (Without Earthquake Forces) Construction Stage Model Full Model (With Earthquake Forces)
4m 7.7 5.29 13.78
5m 15.77 14.4 39.84
6m 24.35 24.3 35.62

45
40
35
30
Shear Force (Fz)

25 Full Model (Without

20 Earthquake Forces)
Construction Stage Model
15
Full Model (With
10 Earthquake Forces)
5
 40
35
30

Shear Force (Fz)

25 Full Model (Without
20 Earthquake Forces)
Construction Stage Model
15
Full Model (With
10 Earthquake Forces)
5
0
4m 5m 6m
Bay Width/Length
 Bending Moment (My)

Full Model (Without Earthquake Forces) Construction Stage Model Full Model (With Earthquake Forces)
13.08 10.73 21.27
27.4 30.5 60.74
42.76 50.94 56.8

70

60
Bending Moment (My)

50

40 Full Model (Without

Earthquake Forces)
30
Construction Stage Model
20 Full Model (With
Earthquake Forces)
10

0
4m 5m 6m
Bay Width/Length

Shear Force (Fy)

Full Model (Without Earthquake Forces) Construction Stage Model Full Model (With Earthquake Forces)
11.36 9.68 16.35
19.06 19.23 41.78
 33.03 37.95 42.08

45
40
35
30
Shear Force (Fy)

25 Full Model (Without

20 Earthquake Forces)
Construction Stage Model
15
Full Model (With
10 Earthquake Forces)
5
0
4m 5m 6m
Bay Width/Length
 Axial Force (Fx)

Bay Full Model (Without Earthquake Forces) Construction Stage Model Full Model (With Earthquake Forces) Bay
4m 1180 170.48 1180 4m
5m 1670 257.69 1670 5m
6m 2520 441.97 2520 6m

3000

2500

2000
Axial Force (Fx)

Full Model (Without

1500 Earthquake Forces)
Construction Stage Model
1000
Full Model (With
Earthquake Forces)
500

0
4m 5m 6m
Bay Width/Length

Bending Moment (Mz)

Bay Full Model (Without Earthquake Forces) Construction Stage Model Full Model (With Earthquake Forces) Bay
4m 25.77 40.23 27.05 4m
5m 45.61 80.72 79.12 5m
6m 88.09 170.31 88.09 6m

180
160
140

Bending Moment (Mz)

120
100 Full Model (Without
80 Earthquake Forces)
Construction Stage Model
60
Full Model (With
40 Earthquake Forces)
20
0
4m 5m 6m
Bay Width/Length

Shear Force (Fz)

Bay Full Model (Without Earthquake Forces) Construction Stage Model Full Model (With Earthquake Forces)
4m 9.07 8.93 14.61
5m 19.18 24.27 43.3
6m 31.39 41.58 41.82

50
45
40
35
Shear Force (Fz)

30
Full Model (Without
25 Earthquake Forces)
20 Construction Stage Model
15 Full Model (With
10 Earthquake Forces)
 45
40
35

Shear Force (Fz)

30
Full Model (Without
25 Earthquake Forces)
20 Construction Stage Model
15 Full Model (With
10 Earthquake Forces)
5
0
4m 5m 6m
Bay Width/Length
 Bending Moment (My)

Full Model (Without Earthquake Forces) Construction Stage Model Full Model (With Earthquake Forces)
16.4 18.53 23.3
35.81 52.56 65.82
59.16 89.11 69.93

100
90
80
Bending Moment (My)

70
60
Full Model (Without
50 Earthquake Forces)
40 Construction Stage Model
30 Full Model (With
20 Earthquake Forces)
10
0
4m 5m 6m
Bay Width/Length

Shear Force (Fy)

Full Model (Without Earthquake Forces) Construction Stage Model Full Model (With Earthquake Forces)
13.49 16.95 17.79
 23.29 33.35 46.7
43.16 66.82 51.23

80
70
60
Shear Force (Fy)

50
Full Model (Without
40 Earthquake Forces)
30 Construction Stage Model
Full Model (With
20 Earthquake Forces)
10
0
4m 5m 6m
Bay Width/Length
 Axial Force (Fx)

Bay Full Model (Without Earthquake Forces) Construction Stage Model Full Model (With Earthquake Forces) Bay
4m 1730 307.63 1730 4m
5m 2560 470.17 2560 5m
6m 4000 830.86 4000 6m

4500
4000
3500
3000
Axial Force (Fx)

2500 Full Model (Without

2000 Earthquake Forces)
Construction Stage Model
1500
Full Model (With
1000 Earthquake Forces)
500
0
4m 5m 6m
Bay Width/Length

Bending Moment (Mz)

Bay Full Model (Without Earthquake Forces) Construction Stage Model Full Model (With Earthquake Forces) Bay
4m 3.09 3.82 20.5 4m
5m 2.97 8.51 80.8 5m
6m 7.43 20.53 48.34 6m

90
80
70

Bending Moment (Mz)

60
50 Full Model (Without
40 Earthquake Forces)
Construction Stage Model
30
Full Model (With
20 Earthquake Forces)
10
0
4m 5m 6m
Bay Width/Length

Shear Force (Fz)

Bay Full Model (Without Earthquake Forces) Construction Stage Model Full Model (With Earthquake Forces)
4m 0.95 1.5 10.59
5m 0.17 4.15 43.5
6m 0.65 8.19 24.8

50
45
40
35
Shear Force (Fz)

30
Full Model (Without
25 Earthquake Forces)
20 Construction Stage Model
15 Full Model (With
10 Earthquake Forces)
 45
40
35

Shear Force (Fz)

30
Full Model (Without
25 Earthquake Forces)
20 Construction Stage Model
15 Full Model (With
10 Earthquake Forces)
5
0
4m 5m 6m
Bay Width/Length
 Bending Moment (My)

Full Model (Without Earthquake Forces) Construction Stage Model Full Model (With Earthquake Forces)
0.183 3.21 16.02
0.48 8.81 67.35
1.86 17.18 27.3

80
70
60
Bending Moment (My)

50
Full Model (Without
40 Earthquake Forces)
30 Construction Stage Model
Full Model (With
20 Earthquake Forces)
10
0
4m 5m 6m
Bay Width/Length

Shear Force (Fy)

Full Model (Without Earthquake Forces) Construction Stage Model Full Model (With Earthquake Forces)
1.7 2.04 12.14
1.56 4.74 45.16
 3.83 11.66 24.95

50
45
40
35
Shear Force (Fy)

30
Full Model (Without
25 Earthquake Forces)
20 Construction Stage Model
15 Full Model (With
10 Earthquake Forces)
5
0
4m 5m 6m
Bay Width/Length