Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Project Presentation Slide 1
Project Presentation Slide 1
Project Presentation Slide 1
TRIBHUVAN UNIVERSITY
INSTITUTE OF ENGINEERING
NATIONAL COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING
Talchikhel, Lalitpur
Submitted By :-
AASHIK KUMAR SAH (NCE074BCE003)
AASHISH KUMAR JHA (NCE074BCE004)
ABHAY YADAV (NCE074BCE005)
BALIRAM SAH (NCE074BCE016)
BIKESH KUMAR KESHRI (NCE074BCE019)
NEHA YADAV (NCE074BCE044)
Submitted to:-
Department of Civil Engineering
September,2021
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Submitted by:-
AASHIK KUMAR SAH (NCE074BCE003)
AASHISH KUMAR JHA (NCE074BCE004)
ABHAY YADAV (NCE074BCE005)
BALIRAM SAH (NCE074BCE016)
BIKESH KUMAR KESHRI (NCE074BCE019)
NEHA YADAV (NCE074BCE044)
Submitted to:-
Department of Civil engineering
Institute of Engineering
NATIONAL COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING
Talchikhel, Lalitpur
Nepal
September, 2021
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Submitted by:-
AASHIK KUMAR SAH (NCE074BCE003)
AASHISH KUMAR JHA (NCE074BCE004)
ABHAY YADAV (NCE074BCE005)
BALIRAM SAH (NCE074BCE016)
BIKESH KUMAR KESHRI (NCE074BCE019)
NEHA YADAV (NCE074BCE044)
Project Supervisor
Er. Amrit Man Tuladhar
Associate Professor
Head of Department (Civil)
National College of Engineering
Submitted to:-
Department of Civil engineering
Institute of Engineering
NATIONAL COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING
Talchikhel, Lalitpur
Nepal
September, 2021
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Institute of Engineering
NATIONAL COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING
CERTIFICATE OF APPROVAL
…………………………..
……………………………..
……………………………..
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
We are highly indebted to the help and advice of our dedicated teachers during the
preparation of the project report “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multistoried Commercial
Building.”
At the outset we will like to forward our sincere thanks and gratitude to our Supervisor
Associate Professor Er. Amrit Man Tuladhar , Head of Department of Civil Engineering,
National College of Engineering for providing immense guidance, care, expertise and
support for our project. We benefited alot in a great deal from his logical thoughts,
experience, and incisive comments. He helped us to develop and cultivate our feelings and
institution for structural behavior of the building and their proper design.
We also acknowledge our gratitude towards each other for such a united coordination
amongst the group members during the project as well some of the other friend who helped
us throughout the project.
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
PREFACE
This report has been prepared as part of project work to fulfill the requirement of course
syllabus prescribed to Civil Engineering final year course. Among several projects which were
offered to us, we have chosen the project entitled “Structural Analysis and Design of
Commercial Complex for Earthquake Resistance” under the guidance of our dedicated
supervisor and Department of Civil Engineering.
Comparing various models of building structures, we found public building as the most
challenging project. Thus, we have been given preference to the construction of the frame
structured six-stories commercial building with basement parking ,wall,lift, staircase, dome
roof. Building frame is the three-dimensional structure as space which consist of rigidly
interconnected beams, slab and columns. It produces greater number of the redundancy thus
reduces the moments and facilitates the even distribution of the load.
This project enabled us to acquire knowledge on proper analysis and design of building for
earthquake safety including the capability of solving and tackling the field problem to
somewhat. It has taught us to work in team which will surely help us in the future to come.
The results of calculation are presented in tabular form and sample calculations are provided
in details to reduce the bulkiness of the report. Sufficient figure and sketches have been
introduced to illustrate the theories. Reference to the appropriate clauses of standard codes
of practices has been made wherever necessary. It is clear that for understanding the process
physically and realizing the structure behaviour, manual steps by step procedure is necessary.
However due to the time constraint and to be familiar to the modern technology, the
structural analysis and design part is performed using computer software “SAP 2000 V-14”.
The burden of repeated calculations in analysis has been reduced due to use of computer
software. Report is focused on the design of slab, beam , column (square), staircase (open
well/dog-legged), concrete dome roof and foundation (raft / mat foundation).
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Symbol Description
Ф Diameter of bar
τc shear stress
γm Partial Safety Factor
Ab Area of Each Bar
Ag Gross Area of Concrete
Ah Horizontal Seismic Coefficient
Asc Area of Steel in Compression
Ast Area of Steel
Asv Area of Stirrups
B Width
D Effective Depth
d′ Effective Cover
D Overall Depth
e Structure Eccentricity
E Young’s Modulus of Rigidity
Es Modulus of Elasticity of Steel
fck Characteristics Strength of Concrete
fy Characteristics Strength of Steel
fs Steel Stress of Service Load
h Height of building
i Importance Factor (For Base Shear Calculation)
I Moment of Inertia
Ip Polar Moment of Stiffness
k Lateral Stiffness
L Length of Member
Ld Development Length
M Bending Moment
Pc Percentage of Compression Reinforcement
Pt Percentage of Tension Reinforcement
Q Design Lateral Force
R Response Reduction Factor
Sa/g Average Response Acceleration Coefficient
Sv Spacing of Each Bar
T Torsional Moment due to Lateral Force
Ta Fundamental Natural Period of Vibrations
V′ Additional Shear
VB Design Seismic Base Shear
W Seismic Weight of Floor
Xu Actual Depth of Neutral Axis
Xul Ultimate Depth of Neutral Axis
Z Zone Factor
D.L Dead Load
E.Q Earthquake Load
IS Indian Standard
L.L Live Load
RCC Reinforced Cement Concrete
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
LIST OF SYMBOLS
Ag Gross area of the section …
fsc Design stress in compressive steel at the level of centroid of compression steel ...
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background
Earthquake has become one of the natural challenging factors for the efficient construction
works. It is one of the dominant constraints while designing the frame building in the
earthquake prone zone like Nepal. Earthquake is a natural phenomenon as old as the history of
the earth itself and is considered to be most unpredictable one among all other natural disasters.
Now a days, designers and engineers are giving more emphasis towards the earthquake
resistance while analyzing and designing any structure to minimize the seismic impact.
One being a good designer has to deal with various structures subjected to various loads like
concentrated loads, uniformly distributed loads, uniformly varying loads, internal or
earthquake load and dynamic forces which are considered during the design phase. The
structure transfers its load to the supports and ultimately to the ground which are discussed
while analyzing the structures.
The initial drawing of architecture is referred. After that the loads are estimated based on
functionality and purpose of building. Then structural analysis and design evolves. Structural
Analysis deals with the prediction of performance of a given structure under stipulated loads
and other external effects. In our context, the analysis of earthquake is based on seismic
coefficient design method as described in IS 1893: 2016.
Design and analysis of multi-storey building is done scientifically before construction which
is great and helps to avoid loss of live and failure in case of structural failure. The Indian
Standard Code of practice should be thoroughly adopted for proper analysis, design and
detailing with respect to safety, economy, stability and strength.
COMMERCIAL BUILDING
A commercial building is a building that is used for commercial purpose. A commercial
building is one that is dedicated to commercial activities. The technical classification of a
commercial building for zoning purposes is that it has more than half of its floor space used for
commercial activities
Commercial buildings are owned by various individuals and group entities who construct them
or build them for profit. Developers build commercial properties with the intent to resell for
profit or to lease for income. Other investors enter after construction for similar investment
purposes. Some commercial buildings are developed by organizations for company operations.
There are many commercial buildings in Nepal but many of them are constructed without
considering earthquake impacts, which are in danger conditions. These commercial buildings
should be designed using building codes for safety from earthquake shocks.
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
So, it is vital that buildings and other similar structures that need be constructed in Nepal are
well analyzed and studied for seismic resistance along with the load calculations.
- As the average income of Nepali people is on the lower side, focus should be given to
making the constructions of buildings and structures economic or cost effective as well
as earthquake resistant.
- As major cities of Nepal are riddled with unplanned and unmanaged building spaces, it
has become vital to construct new buildings taking into consideration the orientations
and planning according to the surrounding as well.
With the changing living style, increasing population and with more pronounced scarcity of
the land, the demand for multi-storey buildings with larger spans and sizes is soaring day by
day. The studies related with earthquake demand the structures to be stronger and safer. The
earthquake, being inevitable natural catastrophe, safe design should hold the paramount
important as loss of lives and properties are unpleasant because of worst scenario it can create.
Nepal is disaster prone country. The various causes for the disaster are landslides epidemic and
fires which causes considerable losses of life and property in Nepal every year. But out of this
entire earthquake is most devastating through it is not so frequent. Nepal is a seismic prone
country and the risk it faces from earthquake is very high. After Barpak, Gorkha earthquake
which occurred on 12th. Baishakh 2072, the design of earthquake resistance of building became
very important. Cities of Nepal is getting congested since the construction of buildings are
being carried out rapidly due to population growth. So, there is a problem of scarcity of land.
The only measure that can be taken is construction of multi-storied buildings and besides
earthquake factor must be taken into account. Earthquake is considered to be greatest and
unpredictable among all natural calamities.
In the history of Nepal numerous earthquakes which damaged many lives and infrastructures.
Briefly speaking earthquake of "8 Rector Scale" were in 19th century in 1810, 1833, 1866 and
1934 AD in Nepal. The random and unmonitored construction without proper design and
guidance is one of the factor for the earthquake disaster. Earthquake can take many lives,
destruction of massive structures and create worst scenario as ever. While designing a structure
great emphasis must be given for seismic analysis so that an earthquake of large intensity
cannot destroy the buildings easily or the structure after earthquake must serve for the purpose.
There are various types of structure that are subjected to various loads like static load and
dynamic loads (earthquake load). During the design process, the structures are subjected to
internal forces like axial forces, shear forces, bending and torsional moment etc. We have to
analyze these internal forces in the members of the structures and design various sizes of
member of structures to resist these forces during the earthquake.
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Our project work “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multistoried Commercial Building "
deals with multistory frame structural building located in Kathmandu, which also lies in the
earthquake prone zone. So the effect of earthquake load must to be taken into consideration as
such the structures are analyzed for earthquake load as well as lateral load along with vertical
load. The structural analysis is carried out with help of computer program SAP 2000, Microsoft
Excel and AutoCAD draws detail drawings etc.
1.3 Objectives:
The objective of the project is to acquire knowledge and skill of analytical methods and design;
approaches, exposures and application of various available codes of practice. The project work
will assist in gaining knowledge about detail analysis and design of framed structure and
develops confidence on student. So the basic objectives comprises of followings:
Finding of structural arrangement of the plan.
Modeling of the building for structural analysis.
Detailed structural analysis of the building .
Design of various structural components.
Detailing of structural members.
Proper using of code provisions for reinforced concrete design.
Acquire knowledge on earthquake engineering.
Estimating main items of building construction.
1.4 LIMITATION
Architectural drawings are not done by us
This project will be limited to the structural analysis and design only.
Design and layout of the building service like electrical, pipeline, sanitary and sewage
system will be out of the scope of the project.
The soil parameters and conditions will be imaginary. The bearing capacity of the soil
is assumed.
The environmental, social and economic condition will not be taken into account.
The design and analysis will be limited to our knowledge of Bachelor level.
Physical and chemical properties of building materials were assumed.
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Basic concepts of the earthquake engineering, implemented in the major building codes,
assume that a building should survive a rare, very severe earthquake by sustaining significant
damage but without globally collapsing. On the other hand, it should remain operational for
more frequent, but less severe seismic events.
Buildings are fixed to the ground as shown in Fig 1.4(a). As the base of a building moves the
superstructure including its contents tends to shake and vibrate from the position of rest, in a
very irregular manner due to the inertia of the masses. When the base of the building suddenly
moves to the right, the building moves to the left relative the base, Fig 1.4 (b), as if it was being
pushed to the left by an unseen force which we call .Inertia Force.. Actually, there is no push
at all but, because of its mass, the building resists any motion. The process is much more
complex because the ground moves simultaneously in three mutually perpendicular directions
during an earthquake as shown in Fig 1.4 (b), (c), and (d).
The resultant lateral force or seismic load is represented by the force F as shown in Fig 1.4 (e).
The force F is distinctly different from the dead, live, snow, wind, and impact loads. The
horizontal ground motion action is similar to the effect of a horizontal force acting on the
building, hence the term “Seismic Load”. As the base of the building moves in an extremely
complicated manner, inertia forces are created throughout the mass of the building and its
contents. It is these reversible forces that cause the building to move and sustain damage or
collapse. Additional vertical load effect is caused on beams and columns due to vertical
vibrations. Being reversible, at certain instants of time the effective load is increased, at others
it is decreased. The earthquake loads are dynamic and impossible to predict precisely in
advance, since every earthquake exhibits different characteristics.
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Level of performance of the building in an earthquake depends upon its overall configuration.
Generally it is common that an architect fixes the configuration i.e. shape size and geometry of
a building and structural engineer adds the structural design. Contribution of building
configuration in seismic performance of the building is rarely considered. It is frequent mistake
that the earthquake load consideration in structural design guarantees earthquake resistance of
building regardless of the configuration
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Part 1: Dead Loads- Unit Weight of Building Materials and Stored Materials:
This part deals with the dead load to be assumed in the design of the building. These loads are
given in the form of unit weight of materials. The unit weight of the materials that are likely to
be stored in the building are also given in the code for the purpose of the load calculation due
to stored materials.
This code covers the unit weight or mass of the materials and parts and components in the
building that apply to the determination of the dead load in the design of building.
Part 2: Imposed Loads
Imposed load is the load assumed to be produced by the intended use or occupancy of a building
including the weight of moveable partitions, distributed, concentrated loads, loads due to
impact and vibrations and dust loads (Excluding wind, seismic, snow, load due to temperature
change, creep, shrinkage, differential settlements etc.) This part of the code deals with imposed
load of the building produced by the intended occupancy or use. Minimum imposed load that
should be taken into consideration for the purpose of structural safety of the buildings are given
in the code but it do not cover the incidental to construction and special cases of vibration, such
as moving machinery, heavy acceleration from cranes hoist etc.
Part 3: Wind Loads
This part deals with the wind load to be considered when designing the building, structure and
component thereof. This code gives the wind force and their effect (Static and Dynamic) that
should be taken into account when designing buildings, structures and components thereof. In
the code wind load estimation is done by taking into account the random variation of the wind
speed with time.
2.2.1 IS 1893 (Part 1) 2002 : Criteria for Earthquake Resistant Design of Structures
(General Provision and Building):
This code deals with the assessment of seismic loads on various structures and earthquake
resistant design of buildings. Its basic provisions are applicable to buildings; elevated
structures; industrial and stack like structures; bridges; concrete masonry and earth dams;
embankment and retaining structures and other structures. Temporary supporting structures
like scaffoldings etc. need not be considered for the seismic loads. It is concerned with the
methods of determining seismic loads and the effects of various irregularities in a building can
have upon its seismic response. This standard does not deals with the construction features
relating to earthquake resistant design in building and other structures.
2.2.2. IS 456: 2000 (Reaffirmed 2005) : Plain and Reinforced Concrete – Code of Practice:
This Indian Standard code of practice deals with the general structural use of plain and
reinforced concrete based on Limit State Design Method. According to the code, plain concrete
structures referred to those structures where reinforcement if provided is ignored for
determination of the strength of the structure. This code does not cover special requirements
for the structures like bridges, chimneys, hydraulic structures, earthquake resistance buildings
etc. but allows the use of separate code for those structures in conjunction with this code.
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
2.2.3. IS 4326: 1993 (Reaffirmed 2003) : Earthquake Resistant Design and Construction
of Buildings – Code of Practice:
This standard deals with the selection of materials, special features of design and construction
for earthquake resistant buildings including masonry construction using rectangular masonry
units, timber construction and buildings with prefabricated flooring or roofing elements.
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
3.0 METHOLOGY
3.1 Selection of building and data collection
The building plan is first selected then the data for the analysis and designing of the building
is collected if required.
Architectural drawings of the building is studied. Rooms within this commercial building are
allocated to various purposes.
Estimation of various structural elements such as beam and slab and column are designed and
checks are done with the help of deflection criteria and moment criteria.
There are three types of loads for which are considered in this analysis.
1. Dead load
2. Live load
3. Lateral load
Dead load consists of the self-weight of the column, beam, slab and wall. Dimensions of
column, beam, and slab are taken from preliminary design.
Live load are determined by using code for design loads (IS 875:2000 part 2) for various types
and purposes of rooms.
Lateral load acting in the building is earthquake/seismic load and wind load. Earthquake load
is determined by calculating lumped mass at floor level and horizontal base shear (IS 1893). It
was done by Seismic Coefficient Method. Wind load (IS 875 Part 3) is obtained by design wind
speed and design wind pressure. Earthquake load being the pre-dominant one between the two
lateral loads, hence its effect was only considered. For the analysis of earthquake load,
following methods is generally carried out:
In this project we will use seismic coefficient method (linear static method).
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
The uniformly distributed dead and live load acting on the slab are transferred to the beams
holding the slab. The slab load is distributed on the floor beams as shown in figure below. The
smaller beam holds the triangular load and the longer beams hold the trapezoidal load as shown
in figure. The beam element also resists the self-weight and the wall load including all the
finish loads on wall such as external and internal plaster.
i) Load Cases
Load cases are independent loading for which the structure is explicitly analyzed. Earthquake
forces occur in random fashion in all directions. For building whose lateral load resisting
elements are oriented in two principal directions. It is usually sufficient to analyze in these two
principal directions (X and Y direction) separately one at a time. Thus the load cases adopted
are as follows.
1. Dead load(DL)
2. Live load(LL)
3. Earthquake load in X direction (EQX)
4. Earthquake load in Y direction (EQY)
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
a) 1.5(DL±LL)
b) 1.5(DL+LL±EQX)
c) 1.5(DL+LL±EQY)
d) 1.2(DL+LL±EQX)
e) 1.2(DL+LL±EQY)
f) 0.9(DL±EQX)
g) 0.9(DL±EQY)
For the purpose of Seismic analysis of our building we use the structural analysis program SAP
2000 ver 20. It has a special option for modeling horizontal rigid floor diaphragm system. A
floor diaphragm is modeled as a rigid horizontal plane parallel to global X-Y plane, so that all
points on any floor diaphragm cannot displace relative to each other in X-Y plane. Initially, the
characteristics of the materials are defined such as concrete – M20 and reinforcement – Fe415.
Then, the load cases as well as their combinations with load factors were introduced. Next,
structures were analyzed for different load combinations and the final output was determined
in the form of SF, BM and AF etc.
Design is done on the basis of limit state of design for collapse and serviceability. The sample
calculations of various structural elements are done with numerous checks and with the help
of MS-excel, the formulation is done for each and every structural member in the building.
We adopt limit state design method for design.
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
3.6 Methodology
The following stages are involved in the analysis and design of “Earthquake Resistance
Design of Multi-storied Commercial Building at Kathmandu”.
Desk Study
Proposal Submission
Finalization of Architectural Drawing
Comparison of Result
Detailing
Finalizing and writing the report
Final presentation
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Methods of analysis:
SAP 2000 V20 is adopted as the basic tool for the analysis of the structure and this
program is based on finite element method.
Basement wall, raft / mat foundation, and staircase will yet to be analyzed and design.
IS 1893-2002 (part 1) is followed for the seismic analysis of the building.
The fundamental time period of the structure is calculated as specified in code.
Design Philosophy
There are three philosophies for design for reinforced concrete :
1. Working stress method
2. Ultimate load method
3. Limit state method
Limit state method consider the safety at ultimate load and serviceability.
Limit state method is the latest approach in structural design.
The design and constructed structures should satisfy the safety and serviceability
requirements.
Two major categories are:
a. Limit state of strength:(associated with failure of structure)
It is associated with failure under the action of probable and unfavorable
condition of design load.
a. Limit state of serviceability:
It is associated with functioning of structure or its component under the action
of most unfavorable condition of service load
Architectural Drawings
We have prepared / modified following architecture drawings with required
dimensions and name plate so far, for the project work.
Basement
Ground floor (GF)
1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th Floor
Terrace plans
Four elevations
One cross section
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, and 5th Floor Plan & Top Floor Plan
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Section at “X-X”
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Preliminary Design
Preliminary design of SLAB, BEAM and COLOUMN Completed :
For analysis of the building, it requires the rough idea on the member sizes used in the
building as beam, column and slab. According to which the contributed dead load of the
member to the structure could be estimated.
The size of the members is dependent on the limit state of serviceability on deflection and
cracking. For this, the IS code 456-2000 is referred to make sure.
Design of Slab
Steps:
1.Calculation of total load. [IS 1987 875 part 1&2]
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Calculation:
Reference Step Calculation Result
1. PRELIMINARY DESIGN OF SLAB
[On all the slabs, we have (ly/lx)>2; i.e., One way was converted
into two-way slabs by introducing secondary beam so as to
making it two-way slab. Here, our critical slab was also found
to be one way so we introduced secondary beam making it two
ways.]
Clz.23.2.1.a
𝑠𝑝𝑎𝑛,𝑙
Effective depth of slab, d=𝛼𝛽𝛾𝛿𝜆
clz.24.1 l=5m (Where, l is the smallest span.)
= 114.58 ≈ 115𝑚𝑚
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
SLAB DESIGN
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Now,
Mx= αx¯Wlx2
=0.03452*13*5.52
=18.148 kNm
We have,
BM=0.138fckbd2
𝐵𝑀
Effectife depth(d)=√0.138∗𝐹𝑐𝑘∗𝑏
18.148
=√0.138∗20∗1000
=81.088< 100mm
Hence ,
Overall depth=135 mm (ok)
Hence,
the depth
of slab =
135mm.
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
l
Assume, = 13
𝑑
6400
d= 26∗1∗1.4∗1.25∗0.8= 175.82 mm
Adopt, d= 180 mm
LOAD CALCULATION
Dead load of slab (influence area)
=20.08*25*0.135
= 67.77 KN
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
LIVE LOAD:
The project building is commercial building which
falls in a category of mercantile building.
{IS 875( part2 ) page 6}
Wall Load :
Let thickness be 230 mm
Assume deduction 30% for the opening
Wall Load =0.23*3*6.4*19 KN/m
=83.904 KN.
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
d = 1.5b = 446.07mm
D = (446.07+10+25)
=481.07 mm.
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Hence,
Size of
beam =
525mm*
325mm.
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Live Load :
Project building is commercial building which comes under the
category of mercantile building. (Ref IS 875 part 2 – page 6) ,
Live load = 4.0 KN/m²
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Where,
Pu = Axial load
Fck = characteristics strength of concrete
Ac = Area of concrete
Fy = characteristics strength of compression reinforcement
Asc = Area of longitudinal reinforcement for column
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Finally,
Adopt column size = 550 mm x 550 mm.
Hence,
the
column
size is =
550mm *
550mm.
Storey Drift
Storey Displacement: Displacement of structure with respect to base of structure.
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Ta = 0.075*(h)0.75 =0.8132 sec for RC frame building as per clz. 7.6 in the
considered direction of vibration
𝑆𝑎
= 1.672 [from c.l.z 6.4.5 of IS 1893:2002 (part I)]
𝑔
H=24m
⸫Ah =0.07223
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page
NCE074BCE : Final Year Project on “Earthquake Resistance Design of Multi Storied Commercial Building” at Kathmandu.
Conclusion
Since the project site is located at earthquake prone zone, we have given more
emphasis on earthquake load rather than others.
The seismic coefficient method is used to analysis the building due to more
practicable and easier.
Finally, we hope that efforts and coordination for the project work will prove much
useful in our future career.
Prepared By : Aashik Kumar Sah, Aashish Kumar Jha, Abhay Yadav, Baliram Sah, Bikesh Kumar Keshri, Neha Yadav
page