Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 9

From Clinical Handbook of Psychological Disorders, Fourth Edition, Edited by David H.

Barlow
Copyright 2008 by The Guilford Press. All rights reserved.

Interpersonal Psychotherapy for Depression 315

failed—not the patient. The therapist gives the treatment goals and techniques specific to
patient hope by emphasizing that depression is working with the grief problem area are dem-
treatable and many other effective treatments onstrated.
exist, and by encouraging her to explore alter-
native treatments.
Background Information
The therapist explores the patient’s feelings
about the treatment and termination. The ther- Sara, a 35-year-old, married, childless woman,
apist acknowledges not only his or her own was referred for treatment of depression fol-
sadness to be ending their relationship but also lowing the death of her baby girl in utero at 27
happiness about the patient’s improvement and weeks’ gestation. Her doctor explained that a
confidence that the patient will be able to bacterial infection was the most likely cause of
maintain the progress she made in treatment. the stillbirth. Sara’s chief complaint was: “I feel
Should symptoms recur, the patient has gained like I should be over it.”
tools to manage symptoms of depression on At 27 weeks, after not feeling the baby move
her own. Furthermore, the patient can return for at least several hours, Sara called her doc-
to IPT for “booster” sessions as needed. tor, who told her to come to the hospital. The
Using the IPT medical model, the therapist doctor was unable to find a heartbeat and told
provides psychoeducation about relapse and her that he needed to deliver the fetus. Sara re-
recurrence of major depression and prepares called feeling shocked, numb, and unable to cry
the patient about potential for relapse. Patients at first. She was given medication to induce la-
who have experienced one or more episodes of bor and an epidural, and delivered the baby
major depression are unfortunately vulnerable vaginally. Despite efforts to revive her, the baby
to future episodes. The therapist explains this was pronounced dead shortly after delivery.
and advises that given the link between stress- Sara said that she wanted to hold the baby and
ful life events and mood, the patient can antici- was given the baby to hold. She held the baby,
pate that she may have difficulty with future, who was swaddled in a white-and-pink blan-
stressful life events. Fortunately, the patient can ket. She recalled that she and her husband cried
use the coping skills she gained in treatment to uncontrollably while they took turns holding
ward off a worsening of symptoms. If the pa- the baby and for a long time after giving the
tient has improved in IPT but has either signifi- baby back to the doctor. She remembers that
cant residual symptoms or a history of multiple the baby was “very cute” and looked like her
episodes, therapist and patient may contract husband. She was given pictures of the baby
for continuation or maintenance IPT, which and footprints to take home. Sara and her hus-
has also demonstrated efficacy in forestalling band decided not to have a funeral or memorial
relapse. service for the baby.
Sara reported that since the stillbirth 2
months earlier, she had been feeling sad and ir-
CASE STUDY ritable most of day, nearly every day, and un-
able to enjoy things she used to enjoy, such as
The following case demonstrates how a clini- reading fiction, cooking, going to the movies,
cian (K. L. B.) implemented IPT for major de- and exercise. She worked as a nurse on an inpa-
pression in a 12-week acute treatment and il- tient medical floor in a New York City hospi-
lustrates how one works with the problem area tal, and prior to the stillbirth had very much
of grief. In IPT, grief (complicated bereave- enjoyed her work. She now felt unable to enjoy
ment) is considered as a focal problem area her work because of her mood, and she feared
when the onset of depression is related to the having to talk about her loss with coworkers
death of a significant other and the patient who knew she had been pregnant. She was cry-
is experiencing an abnormal grief reaction ing frequently, socially withdrawn, had low en-
(Weissman et al., 2000). Although cases that ergy and difficulty concentrating, experienced
focus on the grief problem area usually address decreased appetite, and felt very bad about her-
complicated bereavement related to the death self. She denied ever having thoughts of suicide
of a person who has actually lived, the follow- or feeling that life was not worth living.
ing case involves complicated bereavement re- Sara reported that she tried not to think
lated to a stillbirth. Indeed, the IPT problem ar- about the baby’s death, but she was frequently
eas can apply to a wide range of cases. IPT bothered by thoughts about the baby, often

Copyright © 2008 The Guilford Press. All rights reserved under International Copyright Convention. Guilford Publications
No part of this text may be reproduced, transmitted, downloaded, or stored in or introduced into 370 Seventh Ave., Ste 1200
any information storage or retrieval system, in any form or by any means, whether electronic or New York, NY 10001
mechanical, now known or hereinafter invented, without the written permission of The Guilford Press. 212-431-9800
800-365-7006
www.guilford.com
From Clinical Handbook of Psychological Disorders, Fourth Edition, Edited by David H. Barlow
Copyright 2008 by The Guilford Press. All rights reserved.

316 CLINICAL HANDBOOK OF PSYCHOLOGICAL DISORDERS

wondering what her life would have been like linked to the onset of her symptoms. Further-
had she survived. Sara had returned to work 3 more, IPT could address the interpersonal
weeks after the stillbirth, hoping that it would problems she was experiencing related to the
serve as a distraction and help her “get over” onset of her symptoms. Sara was also a poten-
her loss. She reported feeling very angry at and tial candidate for CBT, pharmacotherapy, or
avoiding other pregnant women, including (evidence-based antidepressant) psychotherapy
close friends and women with newborns, in ad- combined with medication. She was uninter-
dition to other reminders of her pregnancy. She ested in doing written homework and resistant
felt angry at having had to go through preg- to taking medication, because she was hoping
nancy, labor, and delivery without gaining the to conceive again in the near future.
pleasure of having a child.
Sara was plagued by inappropriate guilt. She
felt guilty because she feared that she had done IPT Treatment with Sara
something to cause her loss, despite the doctor Acute Phase (Sessions 1–3)
telling her that there was nothing she could
have done to prevent it. He explained that Treatment with Sara followed the IPT format
when bacterial infections cause fetal death, for acute treatment. In the first three sessions,
they often cause no symptoms in the mother the therapist obtained a thorough psychiatric
and go undiagnosed, until they cause serious history and set the treatment framework. In the
complications. Nevertheless, Sara felt that she first session, she obtained a chief complaint
should have known about the infection, and and a history of Sara’s present illness. Using
she felt guilty about having waited until age 35 DSM-IV criteria, the therapist determined that
to try to conceive. She described feeling like a Sara met criteria for major depression, recur-
failure for having had a stillbirth. Sara felt rent. She administered the HDRS to assess the
guilty that she had disappointed and upset her severity of Sara’s symptoms.
husband by losing the baby, and she did not The therapist offered Sara empathy for her
want to burden him with her feelings about the pregnancy loss, saying: “I am so sorry. You’ve
loss. suffered a terrible loss. No wonder you have
Sara had never sought treatment prior to her been feeling so badly and having such a diffi-
current evaluation. She described one prior epi- cult time.” The therapist gave Sara her diagno-
sode of major depression in her late 20s lasting sis of major depression, reviewed her specific
4–6 weeks, precipitated by a breakup with a symptoms, and gave her the “sick role.”
boyfriend of several years, but reported feeling
much worse since losing the baby. She reported “The symptoms you’ve described having in
that her mother had been treated for depres- the past couple of months—depressed mood,
sion with antidepressant medication with good not being able to enjoy things and your loss
results. of interest in things, feeling very badly about
Sara was an attractive woman of average yourself and guilty, your difficulty eating and
height and weight who looked her stated age. sleeping, and difficulty concentrating—are
She was casually but neatly dressed in jeans all symptoms of major depression. Major de-
and a large sweater. Sara’s movements were pression is an illness that is treatable. It is not
slightly slowed; her speech was fluent. Her your fault that you have been feeling this
mood was depressed and her affect, congruent way.”
and tearful. She denied current or past suicidal
ideation and any history of substance abuse or The therapist explained that Sara’s HDRS
psychotic symptoms. She denied current or score of 24 indicated moderately severe de-
past medical conditions, including thyroid dys- pression and that she would readminister the
function. She reported no known prior preg- HDRS at regular intervals to monitor Sara’s
nancies, pregnancy losses, or fertility issues progress. Given the severity of Sara’s symp-
prior to the stillbirth. In fact, she had conceived toms, her willingness to participate in psycho-
after just a couple of months of trying to get therapy, and her reluctance to take medication
pregnant. in anticipation of trying to conceive again, the
Sara was good candidate for IPT: She met therapist did not think medication was needed.
criteria for major depression and had experi- The therapist described IPT and the treat-
enced a recent life event that could be easily ment rationale:

Copyright © 2008 The Guilford Press. All rights reserved under International Copyright Convention. Guilford Publications
No part of this text may be reproduced, transmitted, downloaded, or stored in or introduced into 370 Seventh Ave., Ste 1200
any information storage or retrieval system, in any form or by any means, whether electronic or New York, NY 10001
mechanical, now known or hereinafter invented, without the written permission of The Guilford Press. 212-431-9800
800-365-7006
www.guilford.com
From Clinical Handbook of Psychological Disorders, Fourth Edition, Edited by David H. Barlow
Copyright 2008 by The Guilford Press. All rights reserved.

Interpersonal Psychotherapy for Depression 317

THERAPIST: I am trained in a psychotherapy started the inventory by asking about Sara’s


called interpersonal psychotherapy, which I family.
think could be helpful to you. Interpersonal
psychotherapy—often referred to as IPT—is “Where did you grow up? . . . Who was in
a time-limited treatment that focuses on how your family? . . . How would you describe
recent life events and stresses—such as losing your relationship with your mother? . . .
a baby—affect mood, and how mood symp- With your brother?”
toms make it difficult to current life events
and stresses, particularly problems in rela- Sara grew up in Canada with her father and
tionships. Although we will take the first few mother, both in their early 60s, and her youn-
sessions to review your history, our sessions ger brother, age 33, all of whom still lived near
will focus on the here and now, on your cur- Toronto where she had been raised. She re-
rent difficulties and relationships, not on the ported that her father had worked a lot while
past. Does this make sense to you? she was growing up, and although she was
SARA: Yes. fond of him, she did not feel so close to him.
Sara felt closer to her mother and spoke with
THERAPIST: Often, people respond to treatment her weekly but was easily irritated by her. It
with IPT in 12 weekly sessions. I propose bothered Sara that her mother was not as-
that we meet once a week for a 50-minute sertive and was intermittently depressed. She
session for the next 12 weeks. If it’s helpful, spoke weekly with her brother, who lived in
at the end of the 12 sessions, we can discuss Canada with his wife and 2-year-old son. She
whether it might be useful to have additional described her relationship with her brother
sessions to work on issues and maintain your as fairly close. She reported speaking to her
progress. How does that sound to you? brother less often since the stillbirth, because
SARA: It sounds good. I hope I can feel better in she felt jealous that he had a child. When they
12 weeks. did speak, Sara avoided asking about her
nephew.
THERAPIST: You can feel better in 12 weeks. IPT
After exploring Sara’s relationships with
has been shown in numerous research stud-
family members, the therapist asked about
ies to be effective in treating symptoms like
other important people in her life and asked
the ones you have described.
her about the relationship with her husband.
At age 33, Sara met her husband, Steve, who
After the first session Sara felt somewhat was 1 year her junior. She described Steve as
more hopeful but stated that she did not like warm and charming, and reported that he took
the idea that she had a diagnosis of major de- great care of her. She felt she did not “deserve
pression. Although she could understand that him,” because he was “such a good guy.” She
there was relationship between her stillbirth described her previous boyfriends as less emo-
and her mood, Sara still felt that she should be tionally available and “not very nice.” Both
feeling better after 2 months and did not want Sara and Steve were originally from Canada
to think of herself as depressed, like her but met in New York City, when they were in-
mother, and in need of help. Sara stated that troduced by mutual friends. Sara had moved to
she was always the “strong one” and was used New York in her early 20s, whereas her hus-
to functioning at a very high level. The thera- band had moved there 2 years prior to their
pist was not surprised by Sara’s initial skepti- meeting.
cism, because it can take time for patients to Since the stillbirth, Sara felt distant from
accept the medical model. Furthermore, pa- Steve and argued with him about “little
tients with depression often feel uncomfortable things.” She reported feeling guilty that she had
about seeking help, because they fear burden- let him down by losing the baby and feared
ing others. Nevertheless, therapist and patient that he blamed her for the baby’s death. She did
agreed to work together for 12 weeks, then de- not want to burden him further by sharing her
cide whether further sessions were needed. own distress about the loss. She also felt that
In obtaining Sara’s psychiatric history, the Steve would not be able to understand her fears
therapist conducted an interpersonal inventory, about trying to conceive again.
carefully reviewing Sara’s past and current so- Sara reported having a few close girlfriends
cial functioning and close relationships. She who lived in the tristate area and, until the

Copyright © 2008 The Guilford Press. All rights reserved under International Copyright Convention. Guilford Publications
No part of this text may be reproduced, transmitted, downloaded, or stored in or introduced into 370 Seventh Ave., Ste 1200
any information storage or retrieval system, in any form or by any means, whether electronic or New York, NY 10001
mechanical, now known or hereinafter invented, without the written permission of The Guilford Press. 212-431-9800
800-365-7006
www.guilford.com
From Clinical Handbook of Psychological Disorders, Fourth Edition, Edited by David H. Barlow
Copyright 2008 by The Guilford Press. All rights reserved.

318 CLINICAL HANDBOOK OF PSYCHOLOGICAL DISORDERS

pregnancy loss, spoke to them about once per shown to help in recovery from depression.
week. She had several friends at work, with I appreciate your dilemma. Your depres-
whom she chatted almost daily until the loss. sion makes you feel uncomfortable seeking
She described herself as “independent,” “out- support, yet support from others has been
going,” and “not one to lean on other people” shown to reduce depression and protect peo-
prior to becoming depressed. She was the one ple from becoming depressed. Does this
to whom her friends turned when they had make sense to you?
problems. Sara said that before the depression, SARA: Yes, but I also don’t want to hear what
her friends would describe her as hardworking they have to say. It just makes me more up-
and energetic. Sara reported that she rarely ar- set. They don’t understand what I have been
gued with friends because she felt “uncomfort- through.
able” with conflict. She avoided confronting
friends and coworkers when she disagreed or THERAPIST: What kinds of things have people
felt angry with them. said to you?
The therapist asked Sara if there was anyone
to whom she had turned for comfort after her Sara replied that it bothered her when peo-
loss, because it is important to have someone in ple said things like “You’ll get pregnant
whom to confide after such a terrible loss or again” or “I know someone who also lost a
any stressful experience. Sara replied that she baby.” These statements made her feel angry.
had been avoiding her friends and family since She felt that others could not understand
the loss. She had felt uncomfortable talking to what she had experienced. One close friend
friends, family, and coworkers about her preg- had recently given birth to her first child, and
nancy when she was pregnant, because she did Sara had avoided calling and seeing her. She
not like being the center of attention and felt felt that it was unfair that her friend had a
guilty that she did not enjoy the first trimester baby when she did not. A coworker had been
of her pregnancy. She felt even more uncom- pregnant at the same time but had a rela-
fortable discussing her pregnancy loss. Her tively easy pregnancy. Sara felt that her co-
parents and in-laws came to see Sara and her worker was not sympathetic to her physical
husband after the loss, but she felt unable to discomfort during pregnancy.
talk with them about what had happened and By the end of the first phase of treatment,
how she was feeling. All of her coworkers the therapist had connected Sara’s major de-
knew that she had been pregnant, and Sara felt pressive episode to her interpersonal situation
obligated to say something to them about what in a formulation centered on an IPT focal
had happened. The therapist noted that it problem area. Sara’s chief complaint reflected
sounded like Sara could trust no one with her that she was still grieving the loss of her baby
feelings about the stillbirth. Sara did not want and unable to resume her normal level of
to reach out to family or friends, or let them functioning. Her situation was a clear exam-
know how bad she felt; she explained: “I don’t ple of the grief problem area: Sara was suffer-
want to bother people with my problems. I ing from complicated bereavement. While it
don’t want to be weak.” is normal to grieve for months after losing a
The therapist reframed Sara’s difficulty in loved one, the severity of Sara’s depressive
reaching out to others, using the medical model symptoms—especially the excessive guilt, low
to explain how depression affects social func- self-esteem, and social isolation—and her
tioning: avoidance of thoughts, feelings, and remind-
ers of the baby and the baby’s death, reflected
THERAPIST: You are not weak—you are de- an abnormal grief reaction. She had not
pressed—and that’s not your fault. People sought emotional support after the stillbirth
with depression tend to minimize their own and had not really mourned the loss of her
needs and avoid seeking help from their baby. In fact, people often develop compli-
friends, as you have been, because they fear cated bereavement when they lack or have
being a burden. However, it is not only ap- not used their social network to help them
propriate to seek support from others but it mourn the loss of their loved one.
also can be really helpful to get support from The therapist presented this formulation to
others. In fact, support from others has been Sara:

Copyright © 2008 The Guilford Press. All rights reserved under International Copyright Convention. Guilford Publications
No part of this text may be reproduced, transmitted, downloaded, or stored in or introduced into 370 Seventh Ave., Ste 1200
any information storage or retrieval system, in any form or by any means, whether electronic or New York, NY 10001
mechanical, now known or hereinafter invented, without the written permission of The Guilford Press. 212-431-9800
800-365-7006
www.guilford.com
From Clinical Handbook of Psychological Disorders, Fourth Edition, Edited by David H. Barlow
Copyright 2008 by The Guilford Press. All rights reserved.

Interpersonal Psychotherapy for Depression 319

THERAPIST: From what you are telling me, it’s prior, during, and after the baby’s death—often
clear that the loss of your baby triggered a source of patient guilt—and explored Sara’s
your current depression. You have suffered a feelings associated with these events. In helping
terrible loss and you are having trouble a patient mourn the loss of a loved one, the IPT
grieving. No wonder you are having such a therapist asks the patient to describe her feel-
hard time. This is not your fault. Further- ings about the death and about the person who
more, your loss and your depression have af- died. The therapist explores what the patient
fected your relationships with people in your and the deceased did together, what the patient
life, like your husband, your friends and co- liked and did not like about the person, and
workers, and you’re having difficulty ex- what the patient wished they had done together
pressing your feelings to them. I suggest that but did not have a chance to do. The therapist
we focus our sessions on handling your grief asks the patient to describe how the deceased
over this terrible event. Grief is one of the died and how she learned about the death, and
problem areas that IPT has been shown to explores the patient’s related feelings. Given
treat. I suggest we work on helping you to that the Sara’s baby died in utero, the therapist
mourn the loss and to improve your relation- modified this inquiry somewhat by encourag-
ships that have been affected by your loss. ing Sara to talk about her experience of being
How does this sound to you? pregnant, about the baby, and what she imag-
SARA: It sounds good. ined the baby would be like. The therapist
asked Sara what she liked about carrying the
baby, what she did not like, and what she had
With Sara’s explicit agreement about the
hoped to do with the baby.
treatment focus, the therapist began the middle
Sara tearfully described having had mixed
phase of treatment.
feelings about her pregnancy. She reported that
she and Steve started trying to conceive 6
Middle Phase (Sessions 4–9) months after getting married and, to her sur-
prise, she got pregnant after 2 months. When
During the middle phase, therapist and patient she discovered she was pregnant, Sara felt re-
worked on resolving Sara’s interpersonal prob- ally happy, but scared about becoming a par-
lem area. In IPT, the strategy for working with ent. She questioned whether she was “ready.”
grief is to help the patient to tolerate and man- Sara reported that she made a great effort to
age the affect of loss, and to gather social sup- practice good prenatal care: She ate healthy,
port to help the patient through mourning. In pregnancy-safe foods, took prenatal vitamins,
addition, the therapist helps the patient to use and started prenatal yoga classes. Practicing
existing social supports, to reestablish interests good prenatal care made her feel good, “as if I
and relationships, and to form new relation- was already a mom taking care of my baby.”
ships and explore new activities to compensate Sara quickly began to experience terrible fa-
for the loss (Weissman et al., 2000). tigue and unrelenting nausea, which lasted for
The therapist continued providing psychoed- the first 12 weeks of the pregnancy. She de-
ucation about complicated bereavement and scribed feeling as if she had been “taken over”
how depression affects social functioning, and by the pregnancy. She complained that she
repeatedly linked Sara’s depression to the iden- loved to cook but did not want to cook, be-
tified problem area. She began each session cause she felt so sick. Despite the nausea, she
with the opening question: “How have things ensured that she was getting the nutrients she
been since we last met?” This question elicited needed for the baby. The fatigue and the nausea
affect and a history of Sara’s mood and events were so debilitating that Sara could no longer
between sessions, and kept her focused on her meet the physical demands of her job as a
current mood and life events. nurse. As a result, she was unable to hide her
To facilitate the mourning process, the thera- pregnancy from her coworkers; she told her su-
pist encouraged Sara to think about the loss. In pervisor, who was happy to accommodate Sara
fact, this process had begun during the initial by giving her more administrative responsibili-
phase, while the therapist took a history of the ties in lieu of patient care, until she felt better.
events related to the onset of Sara’s depression. Sara resented having to give up clinical work
The therapist asked Sara to describe the events with patients, which was the part of her job

Copyright © 2008 The Guilford Press. All rights reserved under International Copyright Convention. Guilford Publications
No part of this text may be reproduced, transmitted, downloaded, or stored in or introduced into 370 Seventh Ave., Ste 1200
any information storage or retrieval system, in any form or by any means, whether electronic or New York, NY 10001
mechanical, now known or hereinafter invented, without the written permission of The Guilford Press. 212-431-9800
800-365-7006
www.guilford.com
From Clinical Handbook of Psychological Disorders, Fourth Edition, Edited by David H. Barlow
Copyright 2008 by The Guilford Press. All rights reserved.

320 CLINICAL HANDBOOK OF PSYCHOLOGICAL DISORDERS

she enjoyed. She felt self-conscious about her At the time of her initial evaluation, Sara re-
symptoms and very guilty that her coworkers ported that she still had to lose 5 pounds to
had to absorb her patient load, despite their be- return to her prepregnancy weight. Sara missed
ing very supportive. It bothered her that others being pregnant and described feeling “empty”
idealized pregnancy when she found it so un- and “alone” without the baby inside her. She
pleasant. At the same time, she felt guilty and was eager and ready to be a parent, yet felt
selfish that she had complained about the preg- scared about conceiving again, because she
nancy: Sara felt that she should have just been feared losing another baby.
grateful she was pregnant. A couple of weeks after the stillbirth, Sara’s
The therapist empathized with Sara’s dis- doctor determined that an undetected bacterial
comfort during her first trimester and validated infection caused the stillbirth. The doctor ex-
her need to complain: plained that there was nothing Sara or her hus-
band could have done to prevent the loss, and
THERAPIST: The first trimester of pregnancy can that this kind of loss was very rare. Despite her
be really difficult and disruptive. Give your- doctor’s explanation, Sara blamed herself for
self a break! It can be hard to appreciate be- her baby’s death and feared that her husband
ing pregnant when you are feeling so terri- blamed her too, although he repeatedly denied
ble. It sounds like you did appreciate being this. The therapist explored Sara’s guilt further:
pregnant—you made a great effort to take
care of yourself. You watched your diet care- THERAPIST: What could you have done to pre-
fully and rearranged your work situation. vent your baby’s death?
SARA: I don’t know . . . I guess that is true. SARA: (tearfully) I don’t know. . . . I should
have been able to do something.
When the exhaustion and nausea subsided in
The therapist offered Sara empathy and sup-
her second trimester, Sara began to feel more
port, and related her guilt to depression:
optimistic and excited about having a child.
Seeing sonograms made the baby seem “more
real” and helped Sara feel connected to the THERAPIST: It would be great if there was some-
baby. At Week 16, Sara learned that the baby thing you could have done to prevent this
was a girl. She felt excited and immediately be- tragedy, but there is generally nothing par-
gan considering names and envisioning what ents can do to prevent a pregnancy loss. It
the baby would look like. Sara imagined that sounds like you did everything you could—
she would look like a combination of herself you took very good care of yourself. You are
and her husband, with blue eyes and blond, struggling with inappropriate and excessive
curly hair. She thought the baby would be a guilt—a symptom of depression. You are
kind person, like her husband. She imagined blaming yourself for something you didn’t
walking to the park with the baby in a stroller, do. Perhaps when you find yourself feeling
and playing with her. At Week 20, Sara began guilty, you can try to label this as a symptom
to feel the baby move, which she very much en- of depression.
joyed. When the baby moved, Sara would stop SARA: Yes. I guess I can try.
whatever she was doing to watch and feel her
abdomen. She described feeling the movements Talking about the pregnancy, the baby, and
as “some of the happiest moments in my life.” the baby’s death, and exploring related feelings
Neither she nor her husband had thought of a enabled Sara to develop a more balanced and
name for the baby, but referred to her as realistic perception of her relationship with the
“Sweetie” in utero. baby and her role in the baby’s death. She real-
For weeks after the stillbirth, Sara struggled ized that she had not taken her pregnancy for
with physical reminders of the baby. After de- granted. In fact, she had done everything she
livering the baby, she had leaky breasts for a could to manage a difficult first trimester and
few days and vaginal bleeding for several take care of her baby. In addition, her experi-
weeks. She reported that she still looked preg- ence with the pregnancy and the baby made
nant for weeks after delivering the baby, as her Sara realize that, despite her initial anxiety, she
uterus slowly returned to its prepregnancy size. was ready and excited to become a parent. By

Copyright © 2008 The Guilford Press. All rights reserved under International Copyright Convention. Guilford Publications
No part of this text may be reproduced, transmitted, downloaded, or stored in or introduced into 370 Seventh Ave., Ste 1200
any information storage or retrieval system, in any form or by any means, whether electronic or New York, NY 10001
mechanical, now known or hereinafter invented, without the written permission of The Guilford Press. 212-431-9800
800-365-7006
www.guilford.com
From Clinical Handbook of Psychological Disorders, Fourth Edition, Edited by David H. Barlow
Copyright 2008 by The Guilford Press. All rights reserved.

Interpersonal Psychotherapy for Depression 321

the end of the first month of treatment, Sara’s In addition to encouraging catharsis, the
mood was somewhat improved and her HDRS therapist encouraged Sara to work on her inter-
score had fallen to 18. She was less self-critical personal interactions, to reconnect with the
and more hopeful. people in her life, and to consider opportunities
An important part of treating grief is facili- to form new relationships and start new activi-
tating the expression of affect related to the ties to compensate for the loss. The therapist
loss of the loved one. The therapist explored explained that people with depression tend to
Sara’s feelings as she spoke about the baby and isolate themselves and stop engaging in previ-
her loss, giving her time to articulate what she ously pleasurable activities, both of which can
was feeling and to cry. Although IPT therapists perpetuate depression. Sara reported not want-
generally take an active stance, when facilitat- ing to talk to people, because she feared that
ing the expression of painful feelings, it is im- she would have to talk about the loss, or that
portant to allow for silences. By listening si- things people said would make her feel worse.
lently, the therapist showed that she could In fact, as Sara and the therapist discussed, she
tolerate Sara’s painful feelings, and that cathar- could guide the conversation in a way that
sis was an important part of mourning her loss. made her feel comfortable. They explored and
Sara was able to express feelings that she not role-played options for maintaining control of
only had been avoiding but also feelings of such conversations. Furthermore, Sara could
which she had previously been unaware. tell people what would be helpful to her. The
Sara had avoided looking at the pictures and therapist explained:
footprints of the baby from the hospital, which
had been stored in a box under her bed. She “People with depression often have difficulty
and the therapist explored what it would be asserting their needs. If you communicate
like for her to look at these items. Sara feared it your needs to others—like your husband,
would be scary, and that she would feel really friends, coworkers, and your family—you
bad. The therapist gently encouraged Sara to might improve those relationships and your
take a risk and look, because it might make her mood. The people in your life may not know
feel better to experience the feelings she had what you need. If you tell them, you might
been avoiding: not only get support from them, but you
might enjoy their company again and feel
“Your feelings are not going to hurt you. You better.”
might actually feel better if you allow your-
self to let out some of the feelings you have Using communication analysis, the therapist
been trying to keep inside. I know I am ask- asked Sara to recount arguments and unpleas-
ing you to take a risk, but you might be ant interactions with others—what she was
pleasantly surprised.” feeling during the interaction, what she said or
did, and what the other person said or did.
Between sessions, Sara looked at the pictures They explored what Sara wished other people
and the footprints. The therapist asked what it would say or do, and what options she had for
was like for her. asking them to do these things, and role-played
Sara asking for what she wanted. Sara reported
SARA: I cried a lot. She was so cute. It wasn’t as that she hated running into people who knew
hard as I thought it would be. It felt like a re- she had been pregnant but did not know about
lease. I was surprised that I felt a little better the stillbirth. In fact, she avoided going places,
afterwards. because she feared having to answer questions
THERAPIST: I am so glad you took a risk and about the stillbirth. Sara and the therapist ex-
looked. It sounds like it made you feel better. plored these interactions and how Sara could
handle them more effectively:
In fact, every few weeks before the end of treat-
ment, Sara looked at the pictures and the foot- THERAPIST: What kinds of things have people
prints. She explained that the pictures were sort asked, or what are you afraid they will ask?
of comforting, because they made her feel a SARA: People have asked “How’s your baby?”
connection to her baby. or “Weren’t you pregnant?”

Copyright © 2008 The Guilford Press. All rights reserved under International Copyright Convention. Guilford Publications
No part of this text may be reproduced, transmitted, downloaded, or stored in or introduced into 370 Seventh Ave., Ste 1200
any information storage or retrieval system, in any form or by any means, whether electronic or New York, NY 10001
mechanical, now known or hereinafter invented, without the written permission of The Guilford Press. 212-431-9800
800-365-7006
www.guilford.com
From Clinical Handbook of Psychological Disorders, Fourth Edition, Edited by David H. Barlow
Copyright 2008 by The Guilford Press. All rights reserved.

322 CLINICAL HANDBOOK OF PSYCHOLOGICAL DISORDERS

THERAPIST: How does that make you feel? had fallen to 13, consistent with mild depres-
SARA: Awful! sion.
Since the stillbirth, Sara had been bickering
THERAPIST: How do you handle it? with her husband Steve “over stupid things”
SARA: I don’t know. . . . Sometimes I say “It and felt “distant from him.” The therapist
didn’t work out” or “My baby died.” asked her to describe a recent incident. Sara
THERAPIST: That sounds good. How does it feel said that Steve came home from work and told
for you to say that? her that his friend’s wife had just had a baby.
She felt it was insensitive for him to tell her
SARA: It feels OK, but then they want to know about other people’s positive pregnancy experi-
what happened and say stupid things like ences. It bothered her that Steve did not seem
“At least you know you can get pregnant” or as uncomfortable as she was with this informa-
“You can have another one.” tion, and that he no longer seemed as upset as
THERAPIST: What would you like them to say she about the loss. The interaction made her
or do? feel “alone.” She had responded to him by say-
SARA: I would like them to just say “I’m sorry,” ing, “That’s nice,” then leaving the room and
and not ask any questions. I don’t want to ruminating for the rest of the evening about his
talk about what happened. insensitivity.
Sara reported that they often had similar in-
THERAPIST: How could you convey that?
teractions. The therapist once again related
SARA: I guess I could say, “I’m sorry, but I’d Sara’s difficulty asserting herself with her hus-
rather not talk about it.” band to depression, and noted that keeping her
THERAPIST: How does that sound? How did it feelings inside might actually be making Sara
feel to say that? feel worse. They explored interpersonal op-
tions for handling this situation in a way that
SARA: It felt OK. Don’t you think that is rude to
might make Sara feel better. The therapist also
say that?
helped Sara to explore what her husband’s in-
THERAPIST: No. You said it politely and it is ap- tentions might have been in the situation she
propriate for you to assert your needs. It is described. She wondered whether he was trying
an uncomfortable situation for both you and to make her feel better, because his friend’s wife
the person who asked the question. If you had experienced several miscarriages. They
are polite and direct with people, they are role-played Sara telling her husband how she
likely to understand. But why not try it and felt. Subsequently, when Sara was able to ex-
see? press her feelings to him, she learned that Steve
was, in fact, telling her these stories to give her
Sara reported that she had avoided returning hope. Furthermore, her husband revealed that
calls from old friends. She explained that she he was still upset about the loss of their baby
did not feel comfortable seeing her friends who but did not want to upset her by sharing his
had babies, because it would remind her of the feelings. Sara was relieved that she and Steve
baby she had lost. Sara also did not want to were “on the same page” and felt good that she
have to talk about the loss. She did not want to was able to feel close to him again. They subse-
tell them how she felt, because she feared hurt- quently were able to share more of their mixed
ing their feelings. Sara and the therapist role- feelings about the pregnancy experience.
played Sara telling her friends about her dis-
comfort and explaining that she did not want
Termination Phase (Sessions 10–12)
to offend them. Role play helped Sara feel pre-
pared and less anxious about going to work, During the final sessions the therapist and Sara
walking around her neighborhood, and talking reviewed the progress Sara had made. She re-
to old friends. As a result, she gradually start- ported that her mood was much improved. Her
ing going out more and began returning phone HDRS was now a 5, consistent with euthymia
calls. She returned to the yoga studio, where and remission. Sara’s affect was brighter, and
she had taken prenatal yoga, and started taking she was less preoccupied with the loss of her
regular yoga classes, which helped her mood baby: “I still get upset when I think about my
and provided an opportunity to be among baby, but I don’t get as upset. It doesn’t ruin my
other people. By midtreatment Sara’s HDRS entire day. I am actually able to enjoy things

Copyright © 2008 The Guilford Press. All rights reserved under International Copyright Convention. Guilford Publications
No part of this text may be reproduced, transmitted, downloaded, or stored in or introduced into 370 Seventh Ave., Ste 1200
any information storage or retrieval system, in any form or by any means, whether electronic or New York, NY 10001
mechanical, now known or hereinafter invented, without the written permission of The Guilford Press. 212-431-9800
800-365-7006
www.guilford.com
From Clinical Handbook of Psychological Disorders, Fourth Edition, Edited by David H. Barlow
Copyright 2008 by The Guilford Press. All rights reserved.

Interpersonal Psychotherapy for Depression 323

again.” Furthermore, Sara no longer blamed ciated the opportunity to talk about her feel-
herself for her baby’s death. She felt good about ings about her pregnancy, her baby, and her
her ability to communicate her feelings more baby’s death, and that she felt the therapist un-
effectively with her husband, friends, and oth- derstood and supported her. She recognized
ers, and to enjoy socializing and other activities that her feelings, while powerful, made sense in
again. context and had subsided with discussion. Sara
The therapist congratulated Sara on her hard confessed that she appreciated the therapist’s
work and achievements, and told her how “pushing” her to reconnect with others. She
happy she was that Sara felt so much better. had not thought she could handle being with
They discussed the potential for relapse and others but was pleasantly surprised.
how Sara could maintain her progress. Given Although each patient is unique, Sara’s ther-
Sara’s history of depression, the therapist ex- apy resembled other IPT treatments for major
plained that Sara was, unfortunately, vulnera- depression and is a good example of working
ble to future episodes; however, Sara could an- with the problem area of grief. The exploration
ticipate that she would be vulnerable in the and normalization of affect, communication
setting of stressful life events—role disputes, analysis, exploration of options, use of role
role transitions, deaths—and use the coping play, encouragement to take social risks, and
skills she had learned during their work to- other techniques employed in Sara’s treatment
gether. Sara anticipated starting treatments for are characteristic of working with interper-
her clotting disorder, trying to conceive again, sonal difficulties related to any of the four IPT
and, she hoped, getting pregnant for a second problem areas.
time—all role transitions. The therapist and
Sara explored ways Sara could take care of her-
self during this potentially stressful time. They COMMON PROBLEMS
discussed Sara’s reaching out to others for sup- THAT ARISE DURING TREATMENT
port, communicating with her husband about
how she was feeling, and forgiving herself if she The problems that typically arise during IPT
found herself having a hard time. treatment for major depression are (1) those in-
In the final session, Sara told the therapist herent to working with depressed patients and
that she had reread her diary entries from the (2) those related to the therapeutic frame. Al-
days before beginning treatment, and she could though these problems are not unique to IPT,
not believe how far she had come, that her how the therapist views and treats these issues
pregnancy loss had forced her to seek treat- distinguishes IPT from other psychotherapies.
ment for depression that she now realized had In keeping with important IPT themes, the
been a lifelong problem; in retrospect, she had therapist attributes problems to depression,
suffered numerous episodes of mild to moder- and to the patient’s difficulties handling inter-
ate depression. Sara admitted that she was ini- personal interactions and communicating ef-
tially very resistant to the medical model. De- fectively outside of the treatment. The therapist
fining depression as a medical illness ultimately continues to maintain an optimistic, sup-
relieved Sara of her shame and guilt about her portive, and nonjudgmental stance and avoids
difficulty in functioning. Furthermore, being transference interpretations.
able to see depression as a set of discrete symp- For example, patients with major depression
toms made it seem more manageable. Sara re- superimposed on dysthymic disorder (“double
ported that she was getting along better with depression”) and their therapists are often dis-
her mother; now that she understood depres- couraged by the chronicity of their depression.
sion, she felt more sympathy for her mother’s In these cases, the therapist should remain
struggle with depression. She was grateful for hopeful and optimistic. Some depressed pa-
the opportunity to learn coping skills that she tients feel that their depression is incurable de-
felt confident about maintaining. In addition, spite reassurances from the therapist. In these
Sara said that she would not hesitate to seek cases, the IPT therapist employs the medical
treatment in the future should she find herself model, labeling the hopelessness as a symptom
becoming depressed again. of depression, and emphasizes that patients
The therapist’s frequent encouragement, the need not feel hopeless since depression is treat-
time limit, and the brief duration of IPT helped able. Depressed patients often view seeking
keep Sara motivated. Sara said that she appre- treatment as a personal failure. The IPT thera-

Copyright © 2008 The Guilford Press. All rights reserved under International Copyright Convention. Guilford Publications
No part of this text may be reproduced, transmitted, downloaded, or stored in or introduced into 370 Seventh Ave., Ste 1200
any information storage or retrieval system, in any form or by any means, whether electronic or New York, NY 10001
mechanical, now known or hereinafter invented, without the written permission of The Guilford Press. 212-431-9800
800-365-7006
www.guilford.com

You might also like