Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 4

 COMPARISON  DISTEMPER  MELAMINE  POLYURETHRANE  FREANCH POLISH

1. DEFINITION  Distempers are the paints  transparent/natural wood  transparent/natural wood  French polishing is a
consisting of powdered finishes. finishes. wood finishing technique
chalk, pigments, and glue  Melamine is a synthetic that results in a very high
mixed in water. These are resin made by mixing gloss surface, with a deep
also known as water paints. melamine and colour.
 Powder form of – dry formaldehyde
distemper ,Paste form of
distemper – oil bound
distemper.
2. BASE  Whiting or chalk , colouring  Melamine polish consists  Synthetic hydrocarbon  Shellac is a resin secreted
pigments of this resin, which spreads polymers which form a by the female lac bug on
as a thin film over the film over the wood surface trees in the forests of
furniture surface that is coated, thus India and Thailand. It is
laminating it. processed and sold as dry
flakes and dissolved in
alcohol to make liquid
shellac
3. VEHICLE/CARIER/BINDER  Water as carrier and , glue or  formaldehyde  PU Polish can be both  methylated
casein as a binder water-based and solvent- spirit./alcohol
based.

4. FINISHES  Provide better smooth  after its application that  Polyurethane provides  French polishing is a
surface.They give reflective offers more of glossy superior gloss and colour wood finishing technique
coating. appearance then matt retention, exhibiting a that results in a very high
 Limited availability of finish on coated wood very high gloss wet look gloss surface
shades. Colours will fade panel or surface. finish. ... It is available in
over time.  wide range of finishes, Shades white, blue, red,
from matte to satin to green, and almost all
glossy. furniture & industrial
colours.
5. APPLICATION  Needs primer and putty  Sanding is a must to  Apply a very  It is a classic technique of
before painting. smoothen the rough thin coat of polyurethane wood finishing. It is a
 After that apply the first surfaces. with a fine brush, foam mixture of shellac and
layer of professional  Apply one coat of sealer to pad, or cloth. Work with alcohol. A rubbing pad
distemper. Apply 2-3 more increase the adhesion of the grain, and avoid lubricated with oil is used
coatings after equal time melamine. It takes about applying too for the application of this
intervals. 12 hours to dry. much polyurethane to finish on the wooden
 The paint can be directly  Spray the first coat of avoid raising the grain. surface.
applied to the wall without melamine. Resanding with The initial coat should be
removing the coating. smooth water paper after dry within a couple of
drying. hours, and then apply a
 Spray the final coat of second coat.
melamine.
6. MODE OF APPLICATION  Paint can be applied with a  It gets applied by spraying.  Apply a very thin coat of  French polishing is a
brush, a roller, or a spray polyurethane with a fine method of applying finish
gun. brush, foam pad, or cloth. to wood by hand with a
cotton pad.
 applying it with a special
pad lubricated with oil.
7. PROCESSING  after application to a  Melamine is a closed pore,  after application to a  after application to a
substrate in a thin layer, and makes it non- substrate in a thin layer, substrate in a thin layer,
converts to a solid film. breathable. It protects the converts to a solid film. converts to a solid film.
wood from hot and cold
objects placed on it and
also from minor damage.
8. USES  It is most commonly used to  not allowing the moisture  purpose of protection.  results in a highly glossy,
protect, color, or provide of the wood to escape,  These coatings help glass-smooth surface
texture to objects. preventing it from damage protect substrates from with a rich depth that
 Used on interior side of from the elements and various types of defects beautifully highlights the
plastered wall and ceiling. protecting it from wear such as corrosion, grain of the wood.
and tear from use. weathering, abrasion and
enhance the aesthetics of other deteriorating
the wood . processes.
9. INTERIOR APPLICATION  Applied on plastered  Melamine is more suited  The PU Polish prevents the  It is recommended for all
surfaces or surfaces which to interior applications and furniture from moisture, interior works.
have been previously white that too is exclusive for scratches, dust, water,
washed. wooden items. therefore suitable for
 Not suitable for surfaces  outdoor application. PU
which remains wet for most Polish can be very hard
of the time as bathrooms , and strong, providing
kitchens. exceptional wear
resistance, and long-
lasting protection to the
surface.
PU Polish would be a
better choice than
Melamine Polish for the
exterior.
10. OUTDOOR APPLICATION  They are not suitable for  The melamine polish  Polyurethane finish for  It is not weather proof,
exposed situations. deteriorates when wood is not  they can’t be used on
exposed to sunlight, recommended for external surface
mostly turning yellow and outdoor use as it may turn
loosening. Over time, it yellowish and crack on
may also chip off at the exposure to UV rays.
edges of the furniture.
11. UV PROTECTION  Less UV resistance  Less UV resistance  Less UV resistance  Less UV resistance
 lasts for much longer than
standard French polish.
12. DURABILITY  Distempers last for 4 – 5  lasts for much longer than Very durable, but susceptible  French-polished shellac is
years and they have an only standard French polish. to cracking and UV damage. durable and doesn’t
mild odour. require much in the way
of polishing once dry. It’s
flexible, so resists
cracking, scratches, and
wear
13. DRYING TIME  Leave it to dry for minimum  Melamine polish dries off  Water-based dries quickly,  Allow
of 12 to 16 hours. within 20 mins. oil-based dries slowly. the polish to dry for 15
 Therefore the polish  It takes oil-based minutes or so before
mixture needs to be used polyurethane 24 hours repeating the process.
within 8 hours of time. and water-based Additional layers of
polyurethane 6 hours to thinned polish can be
dry enough applied using straight
strokes along the grain.
Leave at least 10 to15
minutes between layers.
14. COST  Cost-effective  Melamine polish is a  Varies greatly, but 10-20%  cost-effective way can be
popular and budget- more expensive than to get wooden furniture
friendly polish for wooden varnish for comparable French polished as it can
furniture in India. brands. be cheaper than buying
new furniture.
15. TOXICITY  Water-based distemper is  Melamine is an organic  Once the polyurethane  nontoxic
environmentally friendly, compound that is toxic in finish has dried and cured,
but oil-based distemper can nature. It is often it is generally considered
let off some fumes which combined with to be safe, but during the
could be harmful. formaldehyde to produce drying and curing process,
melamine resin, which is the finish releases
safe and not toxic. potentially harmful
chemicals into the air via
evaporation.
16. WASHABILITY  The walls that are coated  Melamine polish has only  Washability of emulsion  only limited resistance
with Distemper are not fully limited resistance against paint is good hence the against water.
washable because erosion of water. surface painted with this  Cleaning is best only with
distemper occurs when paint can be easily cleaned a soft cloth without any
washed with water. The with water. remedies
distemper will peel off when
it is wet.

You might also like