Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Joseph Conrad Typhoon
Joseph Conrad Typhoon
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
https://about.jstor.org/terms
is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to The Conradian
than to give the same images fresh, renewed impetus and make them
stand for the very symbol of poetic expression.
For Conrad the implications of the hurricane, often interpreted as
an agent of evil, extend in time and space well beyond the moral plane.
They demonstrate close connections between the thematics and the nar
rative, as well as the global aesthetic preoccupations at stake. Interest
ingly, more than an apocalyptic event with sharp moral significance, the
hurricane is a privileged trope through which Conrad stages artistic
preoccupations that can be labelled Modernist, even postmodernist. The
status of language as vehicle of power and ideology is disturbed;
similarly, narrative omniscience is called into question.
The typhoon is a supreme force, a sort of absolute. It is stylistically
rendered by hyperbole, dramatic irony, and metaphor. Among these
principal tropes, which structure and sustain "Typhoon's" hyperbolic
narrative, metaphor occupies the central role. Prevalent to the point of
becoming the very essence of the text, it partakes of an ontological, ideo
logical, and artistic quest that not only permeates the short story but is
also widely diffused in Conrad's ceuvre.
Umberto Eco establishes close links between metaphor and
metonymy, stating that "each metaphor can be traced back to a subjacent
chain of metonymic connections which constitute the framework of the
code upon which is based the constitution of any semantic field, whether
partial or (in theory) global" (1981: 68). In traditional usage, as Jeremy
Hawthorn points out, metonymy is a figure of speech in which the name
of one object is given to another associated by contiguity to it. Metaphor,
in contrast, relies on similarity rather than contiguity (1994: 210).
Defined as a relation based on contiguity, that is of literally touching or
adjoining, metonymy is analogous to the Freudian concept of displace
ment in that it relies to some extent on relations of contiguity. Metaphor,
on the other hand, corresponds to the Freudian concept of identifica
tion, which involves distribution and mutual reflection. David Lodge
argues that in a Freudian interpretation of dreams, "condensation" and
"displacement" refer to metonymic aspects of the dream-work, and
"identification" and "symbolism" to the metaphoric (1976: 483).
The above theoretical discussion is especially relevant to examining
"Typhoon", for it helps to trace the aesthetic intentions at work in the
novella, and reveals the author's positioning within the general literary
canon. In that regard, Conrad's reliance more on metaphor than
Like MacWhirr, who can barely grasp the meaning of the voices reaching
his ears, the narrator often finds himself unable to make us see and hear,
which testifies at least in part, to the failure of his narrative enterprise.
The implied information deficit, due mainly to the failure of the gaze to
perceive more than faint glimpses, the occasional fluctuation of the
narrative voice, and the feeling that the act of reading is occasionally
suspended, are many indications of a fragmented narrative perspective
dwelling on partial truths. It is tempting to call "Typhoon" impres
sionistic, because of the dense visual emphasis, rich scenic presentation,
and the endorsement of moment-by-moment impact of events upon the
The spell of the storm had fallen upon Jukes. He was penetrated by
it, absorbed by it; he was rooted in it with a rigour of dumb attention.
Captain MacWhirr persisted in his cries, but the wind got between
them like a solid wedge. (53)
fixation is radically unsettled. For MacWhirr fails not only to trace the
centre of the hurricane following the instruction of old Captain Wilson
but also fails to grasp the meaning of the same author's storm strategy:
"But the truth is that you don't know if the fellow is right, anyhow.
How can you tell what a gale is made of till you get it? He isn't
aboard here, is he? Very well. Here he says that the centre of them
things bears eight points off the wind; but we haven't got any wind,
for all the barometer falling. Where's his centre now?" (33)
The wind has thrown its weight on the ship, trying to pin her down
amongst the seas. They made a clean breach over her, as over a deep
swimming log; and the gathered weight of crashes menaced
monstrously from afar. The breakers flung out of the night with a
ghosdy light on their crests - the light of sea-foam that in a
ferocious, boiling-up pale flash showed upon the slender body of the
ship the toppling rush, the downfall, and the seething mad scurry of
each wave. Never for a moment could she shake herself clear of the
water: Jukes, rigid, perceived in her motion the ominous sign of
haphazard floundering. She was no longer struggling intelligendy. It
was the beginning of the end; and the note of busy concern in
Captain MacWhirr's voice sickened him like an exhibition of blind
and pernicious folly. (53)
The storm's violence and swiftness match the sharpness and dynamic
nature of the verbs here, where most of the verbal constructions seem
activated to become action itself rather than mere descriptive tools. By
so overhauling the dynamism of the verb, Conrad obviously aims to
reinvigorate the word and enliven its poetic expression, the ultimate goal
being to free language and art from ontological and ideological absolutes.
Given this challenging project, it is no wonder that language in "Typhoon"
is used less to describe as to go beyond description and reach out to that
realm of imagination that Conrad takes to be "the supreme master of art
as of life" (A Personal Record, 25). For he seems less concerned with
rendering the world as it is ? in any case a hopeless task given the failure
of referentiality - than creating an evocative atmosphere that appeals to
the reader's interest and demands his collaboration. As he states in the
"Author's Note":
This attempt to capture the reader's attention and goad him into active
collaboration partakes of a much larger aesthetic preoccupation with
representation, and one of the central issues in "Typhoon." The battling
of the Nan-Shan against the fury of the ocean is a "fit metaphor for the
struggle of the artist, in search of a new language, of a new definition"
(Pagetti, 1988: 62). MacWhirr's wrestling with the typhoon symbolizes
the struggle between "worn out" words and "eloquent" facts that "can
speak for themselves with overwhelming precision" (9). The dynamism
of facts is overhauled; their expressiveness is in turn enhanced to the
extent that facts take on the aspect of a "clear and definite language"
(15). Ian Watt points out that "'Typhoon' stands out in the Conrad
canon partly because its values are so completely dedicated to the
triumph of fact" (1988: 54). The tension between language and fact in
the novella enacts Conrad's acute awareness of the difficulty of repre
sentation. He seems to have a strong sense of what Modernists came to
recognize as the unrepresentable, which accounts for the insistence in his
fiction on the narrators' constant confrontation with the realm of the
unnameable and unsayable. The narrator who presents the fierce and
devastating storm is, to some degree, in the same position as Marlow
who tries to relate Kurtz's deeds and penetrate his dark self. Both experi
ences challenge human nature and morals as well as language. They bring
into the open man's limits and the limits of the linguistic medium that
are paradoxically expressed through the pervasive hyperbole. The
narrator's comment is a telling example:
They were all on the bridge when the real force of the hurricane
struck the ship ... They held hard. An outburst of unchained fury, a
vicious rush of the wind absolutely steadied the ship; she rocked
only, quick and light like a child's cradle, for a terrific moment of
suspense, while the whole atmosphere, as it seemed, streamed furi
ously past her, roaring away from the tenebrous earth. (46)
gradually before the advent of the "real thing," which cleared, among
other things, MacWhirr's "rulers, his pencils, the inkstand ? all the things
that had their safe appointed places" (85). The storm washes away the
instruments of measuring and writing, the symbols of established
meaning. It simultaneously dismandes the captain's control over his
smooth, steady life and unsettles the order of language and the dominant
canons on which this order rests. Revealingly, Conrad intimates through
the raging storm an attack on the polished and policed surface of life and
language, in an effort to bring to light the irrational and hidden depths
that realistic representation has refined away. However, more than
launching an outright condemnation of realism, he seems most intent on
widening its horizons, in much the same way as the hurricane seems to
have "enlarged [MacWhirr's] conception of what heavy weather could be
like" (84). Contrary to what some critics have said, Ian Watt notes that
"MacWhirr also learns something from the typhoon, if only that he is
mortal and may go down with the ship" (1988: 55).
A universalist writer, Conrad resists easy classification, for he is at
once realist, romantic, Modernist, and postmodernist. He is constandy
borrowing from various sources, always processing and mixing them so
as to extend their possibilities, making his art thus plural and potentially
hybrid. His outlook defies easy categorization and the bulk of his art
argues for an aesthetics that transcends arbitrary classifications within a
particular literary genre or cognitive mode. Wanting to impose a single
thought or meaning on Conrad's texts is just as misleading as to attempt
to tie him to a definite literary label: "I have no charm, no flow of wit or
of facetiousness or mere patter to fill in chinks with. ... I have no literary
tradition even which will help to spin phrases. ... I am not a 'Sedulous
Ape'" (CIA 21). In line with this fundamental credo, he elaborates a
fiction concerned with much larger meanings, intent on rendering the
precariousness of existence, the flux of life, and man's inconsistent
motives. His narrative structure based on disrupted chronology, devia
tion from horizontal sequencing, constant shifts and ruptures indicates
the pulse of poetic creation and the mind's genius that is fluctuating and
periodic.
"Typhoon"'s narrative structure eloquently illustrates Conrad's en
dorsement of plurality and variation on both a thematic and structural
plane. To hint at one more instructive analogy, Jukes performs a task
similar to that of the Privileged Man in Lord Jim who is charged with
continuing Jim's story after Marlow's voice has ceased. His letter, which
relates the devastating consequences of the typhoon brings an "important
variation in a narrative that at times appears somewhat monotonously
authorial" (Lothe, 1989: 115), and serves to moderate the narrative
voice's propensity to omniscience. Indeed, in much the same way as the
storm comes to challenge the monotony of sailing on a calm, serene sea,
Jukes's letter brings a narrative variation that challenges the prominence
and monotony of the authorial voice, giving the text an uneven and
polyphonic undertone. As well as encouraging narrative variation and
polyphony, Conrad fosters multiple reading, for Jukes, who is ultimately
in charge of relating the event to the reader from the position of a
privileged eyewitness, is a fallible narrator. In fact, he not only lacks the
authorial omniscient power to generalize but also the capacity to under
stand "outside the routine of duty ... more than half what you tell him"
(17)
Conrad's choice of an unreliable narrator to operate the link
between the narrative and meta-narrative unsetdes the omniscient voice
and destabilizes the reader. The latter, who has initially been taken up by
a seemingly confident and reassuring narrator, is ultimately abandoned to
an unreliable source of enunciation. He is placed in the uncomfortable
position of being unable to dismiss Jukes's narration with a pinch of salt,
but having instead to interrogate the text and make sense of it unaided.
This typically Conradian device consists in combining an omniscient nar
rative voice with an unreliable source of enunciation, revealing two im
portant things: one, partial and fragmented nature of knowledge, and
second the provisionality and multiplicity of all reading and meaning.
Acknowledgement
An earlier version of this paper was presented at the Joseph Conrad Society
(UK) conference "Joseph Conrad and the Sea/ Joseph Conrad and London,"
4-6 July 2002.
Works cited
Eco, Umberto. The Role of the Reader Explorations in the Semiotics of Texts. London:
Hutchinson, 1981.
Hawthorn, Jeremy. A Concise Glossary of Contemporary Literary Theory. London:
Arnold, 1994.
Jakobson, Roman, and Morris Halle. Fundamentals of Language. The Hague:
Mouton, 1971.
Kozak, Wojciech. "Spatial Axiology of the Sea, the Land and Ships in Conrad's
Sea Fiction" in Joseph Conrad: East European, Polish and Worldwide, edited by
Wieslaw Krajka. 185-99. Boulder: East European Monographs / Columbia
University Press, 1999.
Lodge, David. "The Language of Modernist Fiction: Metaphor and Metonymy."
In Modernism: A Guide to European Literature 1890-1930, edited by Malcolm
Bradbury and James McFarlane. 481-96. London: Penguin, 1976.
Lothe, Jakob. Conrad's Narrative Method. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1989.
Pagetti, Carlo. "Captain MacWhirr between Form and Storm." In The Ugo
Mursia Memorial Lectures, edited by Mario Curreli. 57-68. Milano: Mursia
International, 1988.
Smith, George. "Conrad, James, and the Postcolonial Unconscious." In Conrad
at the Millenium: Modernism, Postmodernism, Postcolonialism, edited by Gail
Fincham and Attie De Lange, 309-20. Boulder: East European Mono
graphs / Columbia University Press, 2001.
Watt, Ian. "Comedy and Humour in 'Typhoon."' In The Ugo Mursia Memorial
Lectures, edited by Mario Curreli. 39-56. Milano: Mursia International, 1988.