Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Physico-Chemical Properties of Palm Oil Fuel Ash As Composite Sorbent in Kaolin Landfill Liner System
Physico-Chemical Properties of Palm Oil Fuel Ash As Composite Sorbent in Kaolin Landfill Liner System
Physico-Chemical Properties of Palm Oil Fuel Ash As Composite Sorbent in Kaolin Landfill Liner System
Table 2 Particle size distribution, specific surface area and average density of POFA subjected to 2 stage grinding
Figure 1c Morphological structure for raw ash passing +38 test sieve
39
Figure 1d Morphological structure for ground ash
2.4. Chemical and elemental compositions concentrations of any trace toxic heavy metals. Table 3
Chemical compounds and elements present in the presents chemical compounds detected from the
ground POFA were analyzed using Energy Dispersive analysis.
X-ray Fluorescence (EDXRF-Minipal 4 X-ray
spectrometer, model PW4030) analyzer, operated at 2.5. Mineralogical analysis
standardless. Interested chemical compound was The mineral compositions of the ground POFA were
centered on quantity of SiO2, responsible for releasing detected via Brucker D8 Advanced X-Ray
Si3+ ions during isomorphous reaction with Al3+ ions; diffractometer (XRD). Major mineral contents picked
CaO, responsible for releasing Ca2+ ions, during cation by the instrument were then identified using ICDD
exchange reaction and crowdingout effect, and for the 2006 mineral identification approach, as shown in
initiation of pozzolanic reaction. Particular interest was Figure 2.
centered on the presence and background
40
2.6. Mass loss on ignition 3.1.2. Effect of beneficiation processes on particle size
To ascertain the quantity of unburnt carbon present in distribution and surface area
the POFA, mass loss on ignition (LOI) test was Table 2 presents the particle size distribution and
performed in accordance with test procedure specified corresponding SSA obtained from the powdered POFA.
in the BS 1377: Part 3 (BSI, 1990). The test was carried The table also shows the average particle density of the
out on triplicate test coupons for both the as received ash. It can be seen that from the first stage mechanical
and ground POFA samples, via ELE-electric muffle activation, the mean particle diameter when 60 % from
furnace SCALTEC. Calibrated SPB32 120g analytical the tested particles were captured was 40 ; the
bench-top balance was used for weighing all test corresponding SSA value was 4288.94 cm2/g. Second
coupons. The furnace was maintained at temperature of stage pulverization substantially reduced the mean
440 25 0C for 4 h. Specimens were later transferred to particle diameter to 27 . Corresponding SSA for the
a desiccator for cooling to constant weight not exceed second stage grinding significantly increased to 5405.40
0.1% of the previous measured mass. For each cm2/g. The value indicates about 32% reduction in the
specimen, LOI value was determined by calculating mean diameter, with a corresponding increase in SSA
mass after ignition as % of initial mass. Average values by 26%. Also, the values represent a remarkable
were recorded and results presented in Table 3. improvement in exposure of negative charged reactive
surface of the ground POFA (Gambhir, 2004). Also it
2.7. pH value is anticipated that an effective filler effect and
In earthen sanitary landfill liner, the pH controls most pozzolanic reaction will be achieved from the
chemical and biological processes (Chun et al., 2008). beneficiated particle sizes recorded (Chai et al., 2011).
The test was performed on the ground POFA-aqueous
solution in accordance with the test procedure specified 3.1.3. Effect of beneficiation processes on surface
in the BS 1377: Part 3 (BSI, 1990). In the electronic morphology
method, HACH Sension 1 bench-top pH meter and Microstructure of sieved POFA retained on 75 and
CORNING-PC-420D stirrer was operated at an ambient 38 test sieves, and receiving pan is presented in
temperature of 26 0.1 0C. Triplicate aliquot of the Figs. 1a, b and c respectively. On the order hand,
ground ash specimens were prepared and mixed with Fig.1d shows the scanned morphological structure of
distilled water at a liquid-to-solid ratio of 2.5. the ash after mechanical activation. Generally, the first
three SEM analyses reveal distinct grain size reduction,
That is, 30 0.1 g of the POFA in 75 mL of distilled as finess progresses. Finally, SEM analysis for the
water, using 100 mL beaker. Each of the POFA- homogenized POFA followed by the 2-stage
distilled water aqueous solutions was then stirred for mechanical grinding is as shown in Fig.1d. From the
few minutes via Thermolyne Cimarec Stirring Hotplate, figure, it can be visualized that there is strong
with its temperature knob turned off to prevent possibility that the overwhelming dark background
specimen heating. The suspension was later covered appearance are the carbon content present in the ash as
with aluminum foil and allowed 8 h. contact time before impurities and other foreign materials. However, SEM
measuring the pH. The pH values obtained for all tested structure of raw and ground POFA resembles the
coupons were then averaged and final result is presented presented in Weerachart et al. (2009).
in Table 3.
3.2. Potential use of POFA as co-sorbent in kaolin
3. DISCUSSION landfill liner system
3.1. Physico-chemical properties of POFA 3.2.1. Effect of ground POFA on isomorphous reaction
3.1.1. Beneficiation of POFA in kaolin liner
As can be seen in Table 1, physical characteristics of the As illustrated in Table 3, the main chemical
as-received and ground POFA shows that visual composition of the ground POFA was SiO2 (52.35%).
appearance of the raw ash was characterized by dark Possibility abound that in the presence of moisture and
spongy and porous structure. Main constituents of the suitable pH environment, the dissociation of the SiO2
raw ash include hard but light weight honeycombed from the ash to release Si4+ ions may take place (Chun
impurities, and irregular shape and cellular textures. et al., 2008; Prashant, 2005). In addition, under same
The descriptions were in agreement with the results of condition, the Al2O3 (6.27%), may as well dissociates to
Abdul et al. (2011) and Weerachart et al. (2009). yield Al3+ ions. In particular, the dissociated Al3+ ions
from the ground POFA may undergo some isomorphous
However, POFA beneficiation through sieving and the substitution by replacing the Si4+ present in the silica
two-stage pulverization processes revealed that the ash tetrahedral sheets without altering the silica structure.
was having grayish appearance, after sieving through The substitution reactions may then results in a deficit
the 150 test sieve. In addition, the matrix of the of positive charge, and a corresponding development of
ground POFA possess very fine and powdery airborne a negative charge on the kaolinite mineral
textured. The gray colour indicates significant amount (O’Flarhearty, 1976). The reaction is anticipated to
of carbon contents have been removed through the complement the weak isomorphism in the kailinitic clay
sieving exercise. when used as co-sorbent in the design of earthen
sanitary landfill liner.
41
POFA
5000
Lin (Counts)
4000
Lin (Counts)
3000
2000
1000
6 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
2-Theta - Scale
2 Theta
POFA - File: POFA.raw - Type: 2Th/Th locked - Start: 6.000 ° - End: 85.000 ° - Step: 0.018 Scale
° - Step time: 15.4 s - Temp.: 25 °C (Room) - Time Started: 10 s - 2-Theta: 6.000 ° - Theta: 3.000 ° - Chi: 0.00 ° - Phi: 0.00 ° -
Operations: Strip kAlpha2 0.500 | Import
00-046-1045 (*) - Quartz, syn - SiO2 - Y: 93.05 % - d x by: 1. - WL: 1.5406 - Hexagonal - a 4.91344 - b 4.91344 - c 5.40524 - alpha 90.000 - beta 90.000 - gamma 120.000 - Primitive - P3221 (154) - 3 - 113.010 - I/Ic P
Quatz (SiO2, Y: 93.05
00-027-0759 (N) - Magnesium
%); Magnesium Oxide (MgO , Y: 17.26 %); Potassium Magnesium Silicate
Oxide - MgO4 - Y: 17.26 % - d x by: 1. - WL: 1.5406 - Rhombo.H.axes - a 411.44000 - b 11.44000 - c 12.58000 - alpha 90.000 - beta 90.000 - gamma 120.000 - Primitive - R (0) - 36 - 142
(K00-019-0973
2 MgSi (I) O
-
3 8 , Y
Potassium 33.75
Magnesium %);
Silicate Phosphorus
- K2MgSi3O8 - Y: 33.75 % - Oxide (P1.5406
d x by: 1. - WL: 2O5-,Hexagonal
Y: 38.92 %)- b and
- a 5.20800 Magnesium
5.20800 - c 8.68300 Aluminum
- alpha 90.000 - beta Iron- 203.959
90.000 - gamma 120.000 Oxide - I/Ic PD
00-023-1301 (C) - Phosphorus Oxide - P2O5 - Y: 38.92 % - d x by: 1. - WL: 1.5406 - Orthorhombic - a 16.30000 - b 8.14000 - c 5.26000 - alpha 90.000 - beta 90.000 - gamma 90.000 - Face-centered - Fdd2 (43) - 8 -
(MgAl2Fe1.8O4, Y: 26.69 %)
01-071-1233 (I) - Magnesium Aluminum Iron Oxide - MgAl.2Fe1.8O4 - Y: 26.69 % - d x by: 1. - WL: 1.5406 - Cubic - a 8.35900 - b 8.35900 - c 8.35900 - alpha 90.000 - beta 90.000 - gamma 90.000 - Face-centered -
3.2.2. Effect of ground POFA on cationic exchange POFA complementing the weak kaolin as co-sorbent in
reactions in kaolin liner the design of earthen sanitary landfill liner may result.
From Table 3, it is also noteworthy that the calcium
oxide; CaO ( %) inherited by the POFA may as 3.2.3. Effect of ground POFA on crowding of calcium
well dissociates under conducive hydrated environment ions in kaolin liner co-sorbent in kaolin landfill liner
to release Ca2+ ions. The Ca2+ ion is known to possess In addition, it may be anticipated that the released Ca2+
strong ionic potential (O’Flarhearty, 1976). Although ions from the ground POFA into the leachate
having weak ionic potential, the potassium oxide, K 2O environment may be in excess of cationic exchange
( %) may as well dissociates and release its K + capacity of the co-sorbent system. Hence, in this
ions. Both of the metal ions may readily undergo scenario, it is also anticipated that the kaolin-POFA
ionic exchange with ions of toxic heavy metallic such liner saturated with Ca2+ ions may experience particle
as Cu2+, Zn2+, Cd2+, and Pb2+ present in landfill flocculation due to Ca2+ ions crowding effect
leachate. Hence, strong anticipation in the processed (O’Flarhearty, 1976). Anticipated long term effect of
crowding of Ca2+ ions may result to the reduction in
42
hydraulic conductivity of the kaolin-POFA matrix as REFERENCES
sanitary landfill liner system. Abdul, A.A.S.M., Hussin, M.W. 2011. Effect of Palm
Oil Fuel Ash in Controlling Heat of Hydration of
3.2.4. POFA as a complementary pozzolanic material Concrete. Proc. Eng’g. 14: 2650-2657.
in kaolin landfill liner system Abdullah. A.Z, Salamatinia, B, Mootabadi, H, Bhatia,
The summation of SiO2 , Al2O3 and Fe2O3 plays S. 2009. Current status and policies on biodiesel
important role in the expected efficacy of mineral or industry in Malaysia as the world’s leading
natural admixtures. As can be seen in Table 3, the producer of palm oil. Engy. Polcy. 37: 5440–5448.
chemical analysis reveals that in accordance with the ASTM Designation C618-01. 2001. Standard
ASTM C618-01 (2001) specification, the summation of specification for coal fly ash and raw or calcined
SiO2 , Al2O3 and Fe2O3 present in the ground POFA natural pozzolan for use as a mineral admixture in
satisfies requirements to be classified as Class C Portland cement concrete. Annual Book of ASTM
supplementary cementitious material (SCM). It is Standards, American Society for Testing and
anticipated that in a hydrated environment, the CaO in Materials.
the Kaoin-POFA mixture may react with the SCM. In BSI (British Standard Institution) BS 1377: 3: 1990.
long term, expected overall effect of the reaction is that Chemical and electro-chemical tests. BSI, Milton
the composite landfill liner system may chemically Keyness.
change into a natural cement structure of calcium BSI (British Standard Institution) BS 1377: 4: 1990.
silicates/aluminates under suitable pH environment Compaction-related test. BSI, Milton Keyness.
(Chun et al., 2008; Prashant, 2005). In addition, from Chai, J, Jatuphon,T, Sawang, S, Kraiwood, K. 2011.
Figure 2, the present of magnesium oxide (MgO4, Filler effect and pozzolanic reaction of ground
) ), potassium magnesium silicate palm oil fuel ash. Const. and Bldg. Matls. 25:
(K2MgSi3O8, ), and magnesium aluminum 4287-4293.
oxide (MgAl2Fe1.8O4, ) ) in the POFA also Chai, J, Kraiwood, K, Weerachart, T, Tirasit, S. 2007.
implies its suitability as cementing agent in the kaolin- Evaluation of the sulphate resistance of concrete
POFA composite system (Chun et al., 2008). It is containing palm oil fuel ash. Const. and Bldg.
anticipated that the overall effect of the minerals may Matls. 21:1399-1405.
substantial increase the attenuation efficiency of the Chindaprasirt, P, Homwuttiwong, S, Jaturapitakkul, C.
kaolin-POFA matrix, through the occlusion of injurious 2007. Strength and water permeability of concrete
heavy metal ions present in landfill leachate. containing palm oil fuel ash and rice husk- bark
Significant quantity of quartz (SiO2, ) mineral ash. Const. and Bldg. Matls. 21: 1492-1499.
detected was in agreement with results of Foo & Chun, Y., Yin, W, Shabuddin, W. A, Ying, P. L. 2008.
Hameed (2008). Oil palm ash as partial replacement of cement for
solidification/stabilization of nickel hydroxide
4. CONCLUSIONS sludge. J. Haz. Matls. 150:413-418.
Based on the physico-chemical test carried out on the Chun, Y.Y, Sharifah, A.S.A.K, Ying, P.L, Sharifah,
POFA as discussed above, the following conclusions N.S, Zurinawati, Z. 2008. An investigation into
are drawn: physicochemical characteristics of ash produced
1) An effective filler effect and pozzolanic reaction from combustion of oil palm biomass waste in a
may be achieved from the beneficiated POFA and boiler. Fuel Prosc. Tech. 89,693-696. Const. and
kaolin mixture. Bldg. Matls. 21:1492-1499.
2) Admixing kaolin with POFA may complement Cynthia, A.C. and Raymond, N.Y. 2002. Aspects of
the weak isomorphism in kailinitic clay when used kaolinite characterization and retention of Pb and
as co-sorbent in the design of earthen sanitary Cd. App. Clay Sc. 22: 39-45.
landfill liner. Daniel, D.E. 1987. Earthen liners for waste disposal.
3) Long term effect of crowding of Ca2+ ions may ASCE Spec. Publ. 43, Geotechnical Practice for
result to the reduction in hydraulic conductivity of Waste Disposal, 21.
the kaolin-POFA matrix as sanitary landfill liner Faisal, A, Wan Daud, W.M.A, Husin, W.N.W, Sahu,
system. J.N. 2011. Utilization possibilities of palm shell as
4) The overall effect of the various mineral a source of biomass energy in Malaysia by
constituents of the POFA may substantial increase producing bio-oil in pyrolysis process. Biom. And
the attenuation efficiency of the kaolin-POFA Bioengy. 35:1863-1872.
matrix, through the occlusion of injurious heavy Foo, K.Y., and Hameed, B.H. 2009. Value-added
metal ions present in landfill leachate. utilization of oil palm ash: A superior recycling of
the industrial agricultural waste. J. Hazds. Matls.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 172:523-531.
The present study was financially supported by the Gambhir, M.L. 2004. Concrete Technology 3rd ed.
Research University Grant (RUG) program: Tier 1 cost Tata McGraw-Hill Publ. Comp., Ltd. p 116.
centre code: Q.J130000.7122.01J25, Universiti Mei, F. C, Kah, P. L, Hui, J. C, Ili Izyan, S.B. R. 2009.
Teknologi Malaysia. Removal of boron from ceramic industry
wastewater by adsorption-flocculation mechanism
43
using palm oil mill boiler (POMBA) bottom ash coal, oil palm biomass and their blends during
and Polymer. Wat. Resch. 43: 3326-3334. pyrolysis via thermogravimetric analysis (TGA).
Mohammad, I, Mohamed, E.I, Bala, M. 2011. Biores. Tech. 101: 4584–4592.
Influence of elevated temperature on physical and Sulaiman, F,Abdullah, N, Gerhause,H, Shariff, A.
compressive strength properties of concrete 2011. An outlook of Malaysian energy, oil palm
containing palm oil fuel ash. Const. and Bldg. industry and its utilization of wastes as useful
Matls. 25:2358-2364. resources. Biom. and Bioengy. 35:3775-3786.
Mohd Warid, H, Khairunisa, A. 2009. Properties of Weerachart, T, Chai, J, Prinya, C. 2009. Use of palm
Palm Oil Fuel Ash Cement Based Aerated oil fuel ash as a supplementary cementitious
Concrete Panel Subjected to Different curing material for producing high-srength concrete.
Regmes. Msian. J. Civ. Eng’g. 21(1);17-31. Const. and Bldg. Matls. 23:2641-2646.
Nor Fatiha, Z, Keat, T. L, Azlina, H. K, Subhash, B, Weerachart, T, Chai, J. 2010. Strength, drying
Abdul Rahman, M. 2005. Study of adsorbent shrinkage, and water permeability of concrete
prepared from oil palm ash (OPA) for flue gas incorporating ground palm oil fuel ash. Cem.&
desulfurization. Septn. and Purftn. Tech. 45: 50– Conc. Compts. 32: 767-774.
60. Weerachart, T, Tirasit, S, Chai, J. 2007. Use of waste
O’Flaherty, C.A. 1976. Highway Engineering, 2nd ed., ash from palm oil industry in concrete. Waste Mgt.
Vol. 2, Edward Arnold Publ.: 251-260. 27: 81-88.
Prashant, S, Dalwant, S, Micheal, A. 2005. Competive Wunchock,K, Theerawat, S, Chai J, Prinya C. 2011b.
adsorption behavior of heavy metals on kaolinite. Effect of palm oil fuel ash fineness on the
J. Colld. and Interf. Sc. 290: 28-38. microstructure of blended cement paste. Const.
Rejini, R., Richard, J.B., Lois A.C.T., Geoff, C.A. and Bldg. Matls. 25: 4095-4104.
2009. Characterization and use of biomass fly ash Wunchock,K, Theerawat,S., Chai J. 2011a. Effect of
in cement-based materials. J. Hazds. Matls. Palm Oil Fuel Ash Fineness on Packing Effect and
172:1049-1060. Pozzolanic Reaction of Blended Cement Paste.
Shuit, S.H, Tan, K.T,Lee, K.T, Kamaruddin, A.H. Proc. Eng’g. 14:361-369.
2009. Oil palm biomass as a sustainable energy Yoon Lin, C, Tomoko, Sohei, S. 2011. System
source: A Malaysian case study. Engy. 34: 1225– analysis for effective use of palm oil waste as
1235. energy resources. Biom. and Bioengy. 35:2925-
Siti Shawalliah, I, Norazah, A, Khudzir, I, Azil, B. A, 2935.
Zulkifli, A, Mohd, J. A. 2010. Investigation on
thermochemical behaviour of low rank Malaysian
44