Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Leonora Carrington, Evolution of A Feminist Consciousness
Leonora Carrington, Evolution of A Feminist Consciousness
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Woman's Art Inc. is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Woman's Art Journal.
http://www.jstor.org
Leonora Evolution of
Carrington: a
Feminist Consciousness
WHITNEYCHADWICK
Surrealism offered many women their first glimpse ists' associations with nature. At St. Martin d'Ardeche,
of a world in which creative activity and liberation a village near Lyons, they renovated a group of old
from family-imposed social expectations might coexist. buildings, and Ernst covered the walls with cement
It did not, however, supply women artists with a model casts of birds and mythical animals. Carrington's
for mature, autonomous, creative activity. Leonora Car- paintings of this period reveal a growing vocabulary
rington's (b. 1917) background and life typify in many of magical animals, at the center of which lies the
ways those of other women associated with the move- image of the white horse.
ment during the 1930s and 1940s; but her commitment Although previously dated between 1937 and 1940,
to linking psychic freedom with a specifically feminist two paintings, Self-Portrait (Fig. 1) and Portrait of
political consciousness gives her a unique place in Sur- Max Ernst (cover illustration), should be regarded as
realist history. From the beginning her revolution was companion pieces. Both were probably executed in late
a private one, having nothing to do with Marx, Freud, 1938 or early 1939. They offer evidence of Carrington's
or Surrealist theorizing. It was a direct frontal assault early interest in the alchemical transformation of mat-
not on the family as an institution, but on one par- ter and spirit and her response to the Surrealist cult
ticular family, hers, leading lives of Catholic piety and of desire as a source of creative inspiration. She had
capitalist gain in a remote corner of Lancashire, En- read her first books on alchemy in 1936 while a stu-
gland. Her father was a wealthy textile manufacturer, dent at Amed6e Ozenfant's academy in London.
her mother the daughter of an Irish country doctor. Ernst's interest in the occult tradition extolled by An-
The outlines of her life are well known: a rebellious dr6 Breton in the second Surrealist manifesto of 1929
childhood, the precipitous meeting with Max Ernst at encouraged her in this direction. In Self-Portrait, the
a party in London in 1937 and the couple's life together artist depicts herself perching on the edge of a Vic-
before World War II, Ernst's arrest as an enemy alien, torian chair in an otherwise empty room. The clear
Carrington's flight to Spain and subsequent mental colors, crisp edges, and enamel-like surface of almost
collapse, the year of exile in New York preceeding her imperceptible brushwork contribute a feeling of com-
final move to Mexico in 1942. pelling intensity. The images, though exactly defined,
One of the founders of the Women's Liberation Move- convey a sense of symbolic and elusive narrative.
ment in Mexico in the early 1970s, Carrington's in- Animals surround the figure: a white rocking horse
sistence on woman's right to secret powers not shared floats against the wall, another horse gallops into a
by man and the development of a visionary imagery landscape outside the open window, and a small
in her work have been documented by feminist scholar hyena, possessed of an almost human expression and
Gloria Orenstein.1 But the origins of her feminist vi- three pendulous breasts, warily approaches the chair.
sion lie in the paintings and writings produced be- Behind the hyena a patch of ectoplasm2 indicates the
tween 1938 and 1947 and in the events that plunged animal's recent materialization. The artist's eyes burn
Carrington into a period of personal crisis and redi- with intensity; her thick chestnut hair springs from
rection. A detailed examination of these works reveals her head like a horse's mane. The line between human
both the sources of her feminism and her transition and animal, the animate and the inanimate, is blurred,
from personal awareness to political consciousness. and the shadows cast by the chair, the seated figure,
Carrington's first paintings from the period of her and the hyena's body merge into a single form.
life with Ernst contain themes and images drawn from The images of the horse and the hyena have pow-
childhood and are often presented as whimsical satires erful personal associations for Carrington and reap-
on upper-class English society. Filled with animals pear in a number of later paintings and stories. The
and birds, they spin a web of mystery and fantasy hyena makes its first appearance as an agent of trans-
in an illusionistic space derived from Giorgio de Chi- formation in Carrington's work in her early short story
rico and from the early Ernst. Fairy tales and bible "The Debutante," first published in Breton's Anthol-
stories filled Carrington's childhood; their influence ogy of Black Humor (Paris: Le Sagittaire, 1941). In
lends her early paintings an air of gentle narrative. the Self-Portrait she places herself between the lactat-
Carrington's life with Ernst strengthened both art- ing hyena, a nocturnal animal belonging to the fecund
38 Woman's Art Journal
Fig. 3. Leonora Carrington, The House Opposite (c. 1947), egg tempera on panel, 13" x 3218". Edward James Foundation, Sussex.
reality by using the language of alchemical lore. Car- possessed blond woman walking two dogs asks Mar-
rington had never shared Surrealism's interest in garet of the unfashionable clothes, untidy hair, and
Freud and the Freudian language of the dream and rhythmic pounding inside her head. "Yes," replies the
the unconscious; her earliest paintings rely on a mag- latter, "if the present cuts its throat." As the story
ical realism based on autobiographical detail, legend, draws to a close, the blond woman mocks Margaret
and personal symbolism. The use of alchemical im- with evidence of her lovemaking. Margaret is over-
agery enabled her to establish more profound connec- whelmed by a powerful sense of loss.
tions between individual perception and cosmic unity. Carrington's first meeting with Ernst in New York
Released finally from the mental hospital into the occurredby chance at the Pierre Matisse Gallery. The
care of a former nanny sent from England by her experience caused both of them deep unhappiness. "I
family, she fled to the Mexican consulate in Lisbon don't recall ever again seeing such a strange mixture
where Renato LeDuc, a Mexican diplomat whom she of desolation and euphoria in my father's face as when
had met in Paris through Picasso, arranged refuge. he returned from his first meeting with Leonora in
(She later married LeDuc as part of the arrangement New York," Ernst's son, Jimmy, later recorded. "One
that made possible her passage to New York.) Car- moment he was the man I remembered from Paris-
rington met Ernst again, by accident, in a Lisbon alive, glowing, witty and at peace-and then I saw
market. He was now in the company of Peggy Gug- in his face the dreadful nightmare that so often comes
genheim. Carrington had heard nothing about Ernst with waking. Each day that he saw her, and it was
since leaving France and had feared that he had not often, ended the same way."1 The elder Ernst recorded
survived his internment. In fact he was released dur- Carrington's presence in many of his major paintings
ing the winter of 1940 and had returned to St. Martin of those years, including Napoleon in the Wilderness
to discover that Carrington had given up the house (1941;Museum of ModernArt, New York) and Europe
and left the country. It was Guggenheim who came After the Rain II (1940/42; Wadsworth Atheneum);
to his aid and arranged his passage to New York in she reunited the horse and Ernst's self-proclaimedalter
1941 and who later recalled two months of dreadful ego, the Bird Superior Loplop, in a story called "The
complications in Lisbon as she, Ernst, and Carrington Bird Superior Max Ernst," which she wrote for a spe-
attempted to regain control over their lives.9 As de- cial number of View (April 1942) dedicated to Ernst.
scribed by Guggenheim, Carrington was melancholy The setting is the alchemical laboratory where the
and unhappy, weakened by her recent illness, and dev- Bird Superior and the horse merge into a single crea-
astated by the loss of Ernst; but Guggenheim was tive being in the presence of the alchemical fire that
determinednot to give up her new love. The dissolution warms a large cauldron. The story ends with the phys-
of the peace at St. Martin d'Ardeche, the loss of the ical transformation of the Bird Superior into a bird
loved one, and the reverberations of these events left which unties the horse from the fire and leaps onto
an indelible mark on Carrington's work between 1940 its back: "they escape through the war winds which
and 1944. leap out of the pot like smoke, like hair, like wind."12
Unlike Breton, who transmuted the reality of The presence of the horse and the alchemical language
thwarted love into visionary union, Carrington al- of transmutation provide stunning metaphors for the
lowed its pain to inform her work in a barely disguised symbolic union of the lovers (now parted forever), the
manner. She arrived in New York in the late summer liberation of the imagination, and the release of the
of 1941. Her story "Waiting" was published later that spirit.
year in the Surrealist magazine View.10In "Waiting" Both View short stories contain true-life details and
there is a confrontation between two women whose address the loss of love. The loss is accepted and
attachment, one present, one past, is to the same man. mourned in "Waiting," then resolved metaphorically
"Do you fondly believe that the past dies?" a self- through fantasy and alchemical transmutation in
40 Woman's ArtJournal
"The Bird Superior Max Ernst." Filled with references Their friendship extended to the sharing of dreams,
to a young woman's quest for autonomy, they present stories, and magic potions. What would later become
symbolic barriers to self-knowledge and indicate Car- some of Varo's most persistent images-fantastic and
rington's desire to locate new sources of poetic magical machines, particularly boats powered by the
expression. wind and sun, quasi-scientific and alchemical equip-
It was in Mexico during the 1940s that Carrington ment, elaborate architectural constructions, landscapes
evolved a new pictorial language, one autonomous and based on the technique of decalcomania-can be found
grounded in female sensibility and knowledge. In 1942 in Carrington's transitional works of the mid-1940s,
she joined Benjamin Peret, Remedios Varo, and other in paintings like Les Distractions of Dagobert (1945)
Surrealist exiles in the land that Breton had called and Tuesday (1946).18Varo's stories of the period often
the "Surrealist place par excellence.""3She and Renato include aristocratic English characters; at least one
LeDuc moved into an apartment in Mexico City just dream jotted into her notebooks contains a reference
a few blocks from that of Varo and Peret. The LeDuc- to "Leonora," and her paintings of the 1950s some-
Carrington "marriage of convenience" was short-lived, times appropriate motifs from Carrington.19In Mimesis
and in 1946 she married exiled Hungarian photog- (1960; Private Collection), for example, Varo uses hu-
rapher Emerico 'Chiqui' Weisz, with whom she had man figures to mimic the forms of furniture, and the
two sons. work as a whole reworks the strange encounters and
Carrington and Varo soon became the center of a formal parodies of Carrington's 1938 Self-Portrait.
group of Europeans. The existence of this active group Although Carrington and Varo would continue to
of exiled painters and writers in Mexico during the share a vision of painting as a recording of life's many
1940s set the stage for the creative activity that flour- voyages-physical, metaphysical, and spiritual-their
ished there during the next decade. More significant interests after 1946, as reflected in their paintings,
for the history of feminist consciousness were the ar- gradually diverged. In late 1947 Varo traveled to Vene-
tistic results of the close emotional and spiritual re- zuela to visit her brother. She remained for two years,
lationship that developed between Carrington and during which time Peret, from whom she had grown
Varo, which propelled their work into a maturity dis- estranged, returned to Paris. Her involvement with
tinguished by powerful and unique sensibilities newly the followers of Gurdjieff influenced her to pursue
independent of earlier influences by other Surrealist themes of enlightenment and spiritual development
painters. The two, who were friends in France, now in which spirit and matter were unified and expressed
became co-travelers on a long and intense journey that through mathematical and scientific metaphor. It was
led them to explore the deepest resources of their crea- in 1946 that Carrington remarried in anticipation of
tive lives. the birth of her first child, and her work after that
For some months after her separation from LeDuc, date seeks its own resolution of the spiritual and the
Carrington had lived with Varo and Peret; she has domestic in a language rooted in that of woman's psy-
since identified her friendship with Varo as, "my most chic awareness.
important friendship," remarking that, "Remedios's In the opening lines of "Down Below," Carrington
presence in Mexico changed my life."14Although the had indicated her growing interest in probing the
history of Surrealism is marked by close personal sources of the female creative spirit:
friendships between women-Leonor Fini and Meret Later, with full lucidity, I would go "Down Below," as
Oppenheim, Dora Maar and Jacqueline Lamba Breton, the third person of the Trinity. I felt that, through the
Carrington and Fini-Carrington and Varo were the agency of the Sun, I was an androgyne, the Moon, the
first to sever their work from male creative models Holy Ghost, a gypsy, an acrobat, Leonora Carrington
and collaborate in developing a new pictorial language and a woman. I was also destined to be, later, Elizabeth
that spoke directly to their needs as women.'5 of England. I was she who revealed religions and bore
During their first years in Mexico neither produced on her shoulders the freedom and the sins of the earth
many paintings. Carrington seems to have found writ- changed into Knowledge,the equal between them.20
ing a more exploratory medium for her new imagery, Orenstein, following a feminist model that has revised
and her serious production of paintings did not begin traditional definitions of madness and sanity as they
again until 1945; Varo's works were first exhibited in relate to women's experience, argued that Carrington's
1954, and their dates of execution remain problematic.16 "breakdown" might more accurately be viewed as a
During the 1940s Varo worked at a variety of jobs, "breakthrough" to new levels of psychic awareness.21
none of which paid particularly well, and all of which The paintings and writings produced during the mid
inhibited her own painting. There is no indication that 1940s, including "Down Below," reveal the search for
either woman looked forward to a professional career a language adequate to the task of communicating
or public acceptance of her art. "I painted for myself," this specifically female vision.
Carrington later said. "I never believed anyone would Among Carrington's early paintings from the Mex-
exhibit or buy my work."17But paint and write they ico period, including The Old Maids (1947; Private Col-
did. Carrington wrote plays and short stories, executed lection), Night Nursery Everything (1947; Private
dozens of watercolors, many of them covered with the Collection, Dallas), and Neighborly Advice (1947; Ed-
mirror writing that had led to her earlier expulsion ward James Foundation, Sussex),2 are many which
from school, and began experimenting with egg tem- use the image of the house and the domestic activities
pera on gesso panels; Varo filled notebooks with ac- that take place within its walls as metaphors for wom-
counts of dreams, short stories, invented games, and an's consciousness and as a way of rooting psychic
magic formulas. Together they wrote at least one play. awareness in the real world. Crookhey Hall (1947; Pri-
Woman's Art Journal 41
beasts who accompany the chariot indicates that the 2. The "ectoplasm" was in reality, according to Carrington, a
image has sources in the Tarot pack, the seventh card rubbedout area of the painting, but she agrees that it could be
of which is the Chariot card, indicating the triumph ectoplasm;conversationwith Carrington,February1986.
3. ComparePortraitof Max Ernst (coverillustration);unfortunately
of the higher principles of human nature and bearing this detail is generally not visible in reproductionsof the two
a chariot accompanied by black and white sphinxes. works.
Behind the chariot to the left in Amor que move il sole 4. See Jean Markdale,Womenof the Celts, A. Mygind,trans. (Lon-
is a double being, both sun and moon, identified by don: Hauch and Henry, 1975), for a more complete discussion
of this image.
the crescent shape on the top of one head and the 5. "The House of Fear" (Paris: Parisot, 1938), with preface and
solar rays that radiate from the other. In one hand illustrations by Max Ernst.
the figure holds a fish from the sea in the same cradle- 6. The term derives originally from an Ernst painting of that title
shaped net that appears in Night Nursery Everything. (1926;Private Collection,Basle) which contains the image of a
leaping anthropomorphicfemale horse.
The triumphal procession in Amor que move il sole 7. Ernst, prefaceto "TheHouse of Fear."
rolls along as if part of a medieval pageant celebrating 8. Reprintedby Editions de la RevueFontaine, Paris, 1945.
the birth of the cosmos, an impression enhanced by 9. Peggy Guggenheim, Confessions of an Art Addict (London:
the use of delicate blues and golds in the palette. In Deutsch, 1960),87.
10. View (November1941),24.
the Celtic legends to which Carringtonso often turned, 11. Jimmy Ernst, A Not-So-Still Life (New York: Random House,
the horned god is also an image of fecundity, an al- 1984),168.
lusion difficult to ignore in this context as the painting 12. View (April 1942),13.
is signed and dated July 12, 1946, two days before the 13. Andre Breton, "FridaKahlo de Rivera"(1938),reprintedin Sur-
birth of Carrington's first son. It was an event which realism and Painting, S.W. Taylor, trans. (New York: Harper
& Row, 1972),141-44.
she had anticipated with great excitement and one 14. Interviewwith Carrington,New York,April 1984.
announced here in this triumphant female procession 15. See WhitneyChadwick,WomenArtists and the SurrealistMove-
bearing new life and attended by the sun and the ment (Boston: New York Graphic, 1985), 80 and passim. The
moon. womenthemselveshave characterizedthese relationshipsas pas-
The years between 1946 and the mid 1960s were sionate friendships rather than sexual liaisons. For a further
discussion of this aspect of female friendship see CarrollSmith-
years spent juggling the often conflicting demands of Rosenberg,DisorderlyConduct(New York:Knopf, 1985),11-78.
motherhood and art. Carrington's continuing search 16. This chronologyis clarifiedby Janet Kaplan in Remedios Varo:
for enlightenment, spiritual development, and for a Her Life and Work(forthcoming);see also Janet Kaplan, "Reme-
dios Varo: Voyages and Visions," WAJ (F '80/W '81), 13-18. I
uniquely female visionary language propelledher into am grateful to Peter Engel for allowing me to consult unpub-
a variety of occult and esoteric studies; at the same lished material on RemediosVaro which will appear in the cat-
time she devoted energy and care to her sons, her alogue for the exhibition of her work at the New YorkAcademy
friends, and even the impoverished local Indians of Sciences (April22-June 20, 1986).
whose handicrafts she sold.25These multiple demands 17. Interviewwith Carrington,New York,April 1984.
18. Locationsunknown;Tuesdaywas exhibitedat the PierreMatisse
led, finally, to a conscious articulation of her concerns Gallery in 1948 at Carrington'sfirst one-personexhibition and
through the women's movement of the early 1970s. is illustratedin Chadwick,WomenArtists, plate 190.
Although she firmly believes that true psychic evolu- 19. I am grateful to Janet Kaplan and Walter Gruen who made it
tion is unique to woman's vision, she has rejected the possiblefor me to consult the unpublishednotebooksof Remedios
idea that psychic liberation can be achieved without Varo.
20. "DownBelow," VVV (February1944),81.
political emancipation. "I am 70 years old," she re- 21. Orenstein,"Carrington'sVisionary Art,"68.
cently remarked, "and I am trying to figure out how 22. Night Nursery Everything is reproducedin Chadwick, Women
to live the remainder of my life. The things that in- Artists, plate 179. It is not known whether all the paintings
terest me most now are issues surrounding aging, ill- identified as being in the Edward James Foundation are still
there, as many have appearedat London auction houses since
ness, and death."26To these concerns she has also James's recent death.
added a strong belief in the need for greater cooper- 23. Introductionto "LeonoraCarrington"(Pierre Matisse Gallery,
ation and sharing of knowledge between politically New York,1948).
active women in Mexico and North America. It was 24. Interviewwith Gerszo,New York,June 1984.
a desire to begin to forge these connections that 25. Telephone interview with Dr. Solomon Grimberg, November
1985.
brought her to New York in February 1986 to accept 26. Conversationwith Carrington,New York,February1986.
an Honor Award at the Women's Caucus for Art con-
vention, where those who met her were touched by her
warmth and charm, as well as her independence and
political commitment. * WHITNEY CHADWICK, Professor of Art at San Francisco
State University, is author of Women Artists and the Sur-
1. Gloria Orenstein, "LeonoraCarrington'sVisionary Art for the realist Movement (1985). She is writing a book on Leonora
New Age," Chrysalis, III (1978),65-77. Carrington.