Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dissertation Report - Snehal-Unlocked
Dissertation Report - Snehal-Unlocked
A DISSERTATION
Submitted in partial fulfillment of the
requirements for the award of the degree
of
MASTER OF ARCHITECTURE
By
SNEHAL S. TELTUMBADE
I hereby declare that the work, which is being presented in the dissertation,
entitled “ Riverfront Development for Rejuvenation of Nag-River, Nagpur” in
partial fulfilment of the requirement for the award of the degree of Master of
Architecture, submitted to the Department of Architecture and Planning of
the Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee, Roorkee is an authentic record of
my own work carried out during the period from July 2013 to June 2014, under
the supervision and guidance of Prof. Rita Ahuja, Department of Architecture
and Planning, Indian Institute of Technology, Roorkee, India.
The matter embodied in this dissertation has not been submitted by me for the
award of any other degree of this or any other institute.
Date:
This is to certify that the above statement made by the candidate Ms. Snehal
S. Teltumbade is correct to the best of my knowledge and belief.
Thesis supervisor:
Prof. Rita Ahuja
Department of Architecture and Planning
Indian Institute of Technology, Roorkee
Roorkee, Uttrakhand, India-247667
Date:
Place: Roorkee
CERTIFICATE
Date:
Place: Roorkee
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT:
Snehal s. Teltumbade
Water bodies are the precious commodity for the survival of the human. All the
necessities of life which humans needs are dependent on availability of water
and therefore water bodies became the important location for human
settlements. Riverfront cities have historically emerged through conditions
developed by mutuality between land and water. But in today’s scenario the
relationship between water and land has become less apparent.
The same case is with Nagpur; due to urbanisation the city has lost its natural
water bodies. Nag-river has been taken as a case study which has lots of
potentiality to develop in terms of recreational riverfront. Nag-river is the oldest
river of the city due to which it has the heritage value.
This thesis aims to discuss the potentiality of river to create the vibrant public
open space for recreation in the Nagpur city by developing its riverfront and to
explore the reintegration of a city with its riverfront through the buildings of
public space and access. Riverfront design and redevelopment is currently a civic
interest which consists of both challenges as well as opportunities.
The goal of this study is to create good quality of recreational spaces along the
riverfront of the Nag-river and connect them with the various destinations.
This report will take a macro level study on the entire riverfront area.
Riverfront Development for Rejuvenation of Nag River, Nagpur
LIST OF CONTENTS
Certificate
Candidate’s Declaration
Acknowledgement
Abstract
List of Contents
List of Tables
List of Figures
List of Proposals
1.3 Aim 02
1.4 Objective 02
1.6 Methodology 03
2.1.1 Location 06
2.1.3 Climate 07
2.6 Inferences 19
3.1 Introduction 20
3.2.1 Definitions 20
3.5 Inferences 41
4.5 Inferences 62
5.1 Introduction 63
5.5.1 Zone – 3 68
5.5.2 Zone – 2 70
5.10 Inferences 80
6.4 Proposal 89
6.5.1 Section – 1 91
6.5.2 Section – 2 96
CONCLUSION ……………………………………………………………………...117
BIBLIOGRAPHY …………………………………………………………………........
LIST OF TABLES
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 33 Buildings 30
Figure 36 Transport 31
Figure 37 Landmarks 31
Figure 41 Waterfront 39
Figure 72 Zoning of the site according to the site condition in various areas 67
Figure 85 Max. potential areas for riverfront development along Nag River 78
LIST OF PROPOSALS
1.0 INTRODUCTION
The presence day world is facing a number of problems which are of our own
creation and negligence. The environmental damages are caused by people,
mushroom like growth of industries creating lots of problem leads to the
depletion of the natural resources. Natural resources play vital role in making
our life easy and happy. The rivers are drying up because of depleting water
resources. The ground water levels along the river course are dropping at an
alarming state. Rivers that are flowing along the length and breadth of our
country makes the land fertile. Most of the modern rivers in India are severely
polluted due to the irresponsible attitude and mismanagement by the people.
Relationship of the people with the rivers, and with other kinds of water sources
is rapidly deteriorating owing to the fact that there is no direct dependence for
water supply on the local water sources.
Nag River and its tributaries, pora and pili river flow through the heart of Nagpur
city. The district being named on the basis of the nag river is itself a huge
testament to its remarkable significance in regional history. At the same time, the
entire nag-river serves as a biodiversity corridor meeting the larger kanhan river
further towards the east. The Nag River eco-system is under maximum stress. As
the river flows through the city, they are termed as nallahs and looked upon by
the citizen as no more than drainage channels. The one possible way to correct
this and save both, the city and the river is to turn the face of the city towards the
river.
Though the river is in a general state of neglect, it is a significant element flowing
through the heart of the city. It also offers the largest potential for open public
space within a city. The mix of land uses along the length of the river provides
many opportunities to introduce a variety of activities at various nodes. Areas
which are still being developed also have the potential for river front
development to be included right at the planning stage. These would bring the
river bank into the public domain and increase human interaction.
1.3 Aim:
1.4 Objectives:
1.6 Methodology:
In order to achieve the objectives stated the study will include the following
sequential stages.
Recreational
Literature study
waterfront case studies
Data collection
Recommendation
Source: author
2001 Nagpur was the nation's 13th Figure 2 Location Map of Nagpur District
largest urban conglomeration and Source: Wikipedia (Nagpur district)
the foremost city in eastern vidarbha region of Maharashtra. In addition Nagpur
is the winter capital of state and the headquarters of Nagpur District and Nagpur
Division administrations. On a global scale, Nagpur is estimated to be the 114th
largest city and 143rd largest urban area in the world in 2006 in terms of
population.
Nagpur is famous as a trade centre for high-quality oranges grown in the region
and hence the city is also known as Santra Nagari (Orange City). It is one of the
important cities for the IT sector in the state. Nagpur is also called the “tiger
capital of India” because it connects many tiger reserves in India to the world.
It is Located on the banks of the River Nag, the city derives its name from the
river itself. The city is has got many awards like best city to live, best
transportation, green city and best health facility as per ABP news. It is also said
to be the cleanest city in India and the second greenest after Chandigarh. The city
is a major milestone for India, because it is such a major industrial, commercial
and transportation center.
2.1.1 Location:
Nagpur is located at the exact centre of
the Indian peninsula. The city has a Zero
Mile stone locating the geographical center
of India, which was used by the British to
measure all distances within the Indian-
subcontinent.
It is the second capital of Maharashtra is Figure 3 Nagpur District Map
situated on latitude 21 degree 9’N and Source: Wikipedia (Nagpur district)
longitude 79 6’E.
Nagpur City has three parallel rivers; Nag,Pili and Pora flowing through the heart
of the city. Out of these two are dammed on upstream side to cater the need of
city forming three major reservoirs. The river banks, also serve as Biodiversity
Corridors for the fauna and avifauna of the region. There are almost a dozen
small man made historical lakes, which use to be a source of water for the city.
Nagpur has got nine major water bodies, at least six ponds, two rivers, and
several streams within the municipal boundary of the city. During earlier times of
the establishment and development of the city of Nagpur, water bodies were
designed as significant elements of the city; serving as water storage tanks as
well as for recreation. Some of these also had religious significance and are even
today associated with temples alongside their banks. Today also they play a
major role of ground water recharge to ensure the un-interrupted water supply
through bore wells. In addition they also help in equating the temperatures
especially during the hot summer months.
Most of the water bodies are filled up due to siltation and dumping of waste. The
major contributors of river pollution are solid waste including non biodegradable
material like untreated sewage, plastic, fly ash from nearby industries, untreated
industrial discharges, waste from brick kilns etc. The occupational and domestic
activities in various households regularly result in the production of solid,
gaseous and liquid wastes which of various types and quantities, find their way
straight into the rivers. This problem has arrived due to Lack of management for
disposal of solid waste. Their natural feeding channels are look like diverted and
vanished in the urbanisation. Due to urbanisation rivers and lakes of Nagpur city
are facing many problems.
2.5 Nag-River:
Nag river is the tributary of the kanhan
river which will meet the main river in
Waingangā, sub-basin of Godavari
outside the city. The main Nag-River
along with other rivers is serving the
city from past three centuries.
Nag-river origin is from Ambazari Lake, Figure 18 nag-river Nagpur (source: author)
which has been constructed at the upstream reaches of the river and was the
prime source of water to Nagpur city till a few years ago. Nag River, gave identity
and name to Nagpur is now struggling for its own existence. In today’s condition
untreated sewage and industrial waste are directly discharged in the river. This
process leads river water to the dark gray and unpleasant drainage smell.
In 2001 most of water bodies of city are being listed as heritage site. Nag-river is
one of them which is considered to be a heritage site of the city. The nag-river
which had great value in the past is now not more than a city drain. The river
flowing through the heart of the city mainly reduced to sewage carrying corridor.
According to the centre for science and environment, the biggest challenge that
society faces is how to live with water it has, and how to live with it cleanly.
Indians have not even fully recognised that this is a challenge before them.
The nag and pili rivers run from their origin upto a distance of about 16km each,
through the city of Nagpur. These rivers take their origin in the hills to the west
of Nagpur city, in the village called lava. These two rivers then flow more or less
parallel to each other from west to east and meet each other just outside the
eastern boundary of the city. Beyond the meeting point nag river flows 40km
more until it meets the kanhan river at village sawangi.
The MPCB (Maharashtra pollution control board) has divided the river courses of
nag river into two grades A-II and A-IV. The river have been put in the category
A-II from the origin point, near Lava village upto the reservoir and thereafter,
they have been put it into category A-IV as they flow through the city.
As the river flow through the city, it termed as Nallas and looked upon by the
citizens as no more than drainage channels. The government authorities has put
no laws or restriction on discharging the domestic sewage into the river channels
which spoiling the river and the authorities themselves use these channels as
carriers of the city’s sewage. The present situation is that the water which seems
to be flowing the stream of nag river is not water of nag at all, but the water
passing through the toilets into the channels of nag river. Most of the modern
rivers in India are severely polluted due to the irresponsible attitude and
mismanagement by the people/stakeholders. Urban river health assessment
studies says, many cities of India may be termed as an excellent example of the
mismanagement of the water bodies. Nag River flows for most of its course
through the urbanised part of the Nagpur city, a city with approx. Population of
25 million under muncipal boundries.
2.6 Inferences:
Nagpur city at present has some ecological components left within it and around.
But with the development of city till date, it has come to the notice that no due
consideration has been given to these natural area. Rapid urban development in
the cities, leads to environmental degradation. Not only the water resources but
the entire natural landscapes of the cities with the precious ecosystems are
facing the brunt of this rapid urbanization. Conservation and restoration of all
our water resources requires an integrated development approach. In this case
up-gradation, restoration, rejuvenation as well as beautification of the riverfront works
need to be undertaken urgently by the local authorities.
3.1 Introduction
Purpose of the literature study is to develop a researcher’s knowledge base
regarding the context of research such as Basic understanding of concepts,
knowledge of theories, methods and literatures of current trends, latest
developments, rules and norms etc.
3.2.1 Definitions:
The word meaning of waterfront gets through as “the part of a town or city
adjoining a river, lake, harbour, etc.” (Source: Oxford American Dictionary of
Current English in English)
Moretti (2008), the word “waterfront” means “the urban area in direct contact
with water”
Yasinet al. (2010) indicated that waterfront is defined generally as the area of
interaction between urban development and the water.
Hou (2009), described the waterfront area as the conflux area of water and land.
In the literature instead of the term waterfront it has reffered by many different
words such as riverside, river edge, water edge, city port, harbourfront, and
riverfront etc.
Breen and Rigby (1994),Sairinen and Kumpulainen (2006) and Morena (2012)
imply the same thing with waterfront and urban waterfront. According to these,
waterfront identifies the water’s edge in cities and towns or urban area of all
sizes. The water body may be “a river, lake, ocean, bay, creek or canal” or
artificial.
As per history record, waterfronts are the most ideal living space for human
being to be able to provide food, transportation, settling, defence and learning
etc. therefore from the history of civilization to until today many cities are
established along the water edge. Riverfront cities have historically evolved
through conditions generated by mutuality between water and landscape. Urban
waterfronts have historically been the hub of transportation, trade and
commerce in the city.
The early settlements, waterfront and the city were directly connected. For the
trading purpose and transportation water was playing an important role. The
movement of production and people were provided by water route. These
settlements were rooted around a port with safe harbour. At this time, the
waterfront has a very few trails converging at a jetty. After, a street pattern was
slowly installed. New street pattern accelerated the builders for the development
along the street. Though the city was growing and developing, the settlements
still were connected to the waterfront road.
2 Growth of waterfronts
The first period of ports has converted due to increase of economic activities
along the shore. In this period, the settlement became a city and maritime trade
exited urban development. The waterfronts became more important state and
commerce. The road along shoreline turned into a busy street adding many
facilities like services, supplies, and office space for commercial activities.
Many industries were constructed along the waterfront and because of these
industries water edge has blocked from the street. Due to rapid urbanisation,
railroad was introduced for the new mode of transportation to fulfil the need of
time. To install the new railroad network they required the space from
waterfront. As a result, central city has got separated from the waterfronts and
the existing waterfront became more congested. Meanwhile, the waterfront
3 Deterioration of Waterfronts
All loading-offloading activities were carried out in port areas Until World War II.
With the development of containerization technology the amount of load and
speed of the loading-offloading increased. After World War II, development in
maritime industry has increased and demanded for new areas. Thus, port
activities transferred to outside the city. Many of manufactures began to leave
the city because of water and air pollution. As a result, old ports lost the role of
transportation and waterfront fell into disuse. People preferred highways to
railroad which again contributed to increase the gap between waterfront and
people. Railroads on the waterfront were neglected. Because of decline of
manufacturing plants and disinvestment from investor again railroads suffered
and waterfront virtually became a deserted, inaccessible and unsafe area further
separated the urban core from the water.
4 Redevelopment of waterfronts
Waterfront areas of neglected old ports having several problems. First problem
was pollution caused by the industrial activities along the port. Second problem
was discarded infrastructure of the industrial areas which was surrounded by
abandoned port structures. After shifting of warehouses outside the city,
highways and railroad broke off the link between waterfront and city. The
Interaction between waterfront and city has decreased. In post-independence
period, people became more concerned about environment and natural
resources.
Now people wanted to recover the aesthetic beauty of the waterfront which had
been neglected some year before. As a result, private developers and city
1 Commercial waterfront:
2 Residential waterfront:
3 Cultural waterfront:
4 Historic waterfront:
5 Recreational waterfront:
Urban design is concerned with the physical characteristics of the city and the
implications of design and planning decisions for the public realm of the city. The
urban design is an integrating tool, which serve as how various public and
private development proposals will affect the city physically. The area of focus in
urban design deals with public realm of the city which included the public
buildings, streets, sidewalks, parks and plazas that provide the outdoor public
spaces for a multiple activities and recreation.
Open spaces are reffered as a brething spaces in the city. in the early settelments
some cities were laid out with dedicated greenbelts. However, early surveyors
often made little provision for parks and squares within the town and city.
5. Landmarks
• Secure the quality of water and the environment: Clean water and
environment are the primary requirements of a waterfront.
• Waterfronts are part of the existing urban fabric: waterfront should not be
detached from the city. Isolated waterfront leads to the decay of the
waterfront area. In the history many cities has been a witness to such
instances, where the city has turned its back on the waterfront and then
water bodies has turned into a sewer lines.
• The historic identity gives character: to create identity of the place, context
and sense of place are always important. In the history of waterfronts it
enables the locals to identity and make a bond with water and also
increases the tourism potential of the waterfront.
• Mixed-use is a priority: mixed use development is a effective tool to
achieve a successfull waterfront. It certifies the different use of waterfront
by a variety of developers. Waterfront can be integrated much more
effectively by adopting a mixed use policy.
• Public access is a prerequisite: waterfront should be accessible for public
in both ways visual and physical. in india Physical access has always been
high due to the presence of ghats. Visual access means the waterfront that
has a visually appealing quality, it doesn’t mean just a visible waterfront.
• Public partipation is an element of sustainability: Public participation
ensures direct benefits to the society and thus should be encouraged.
• Revitalization is an on-going process: in the urban fabric, waterfront is a
permanent fixture. According to the time the needs and role of a
settlement changes. Respectively, the role of the waterfront also may
change, and so might the expectations of the people from the waterfront.
Thus, to suit the present and future needs waterfront has to be regularly
reinvented.
In the last few years there have been various attempts to evaluate the
performance of waterfront recreation spaces from the user's point of view. It is
essential to understand the purpose of public places and their use by people.
Successful public space always creates strong connections between the user’s
personal lives and places. It is related to their social and physical background.
For every individual place there are many factors which have to be taken into
consideration such as topography, history, culture, climate etc.
Based on the urban design principles eight criteria have been found for the
successfulness of waterfront recreation spaces: location, function, attraction,
integration, sense of place, accessibility, visual and environmental quality.
1 Location
As per expert views, location of the riverfront site is very important. It should be
at such place which is properly connected to major urban activities center. If the
location is near to the CBD or city core it would be a great location for
successfulness of riverfront.
Location of the study area which is close to the center urban activities of Nagpur,
have possibility to embellish as an active riverfront in terms of location.
2 Function
Roger Trancik stated, “The quality judgment of how well a space designed comes
from its functional meaning and from how well its physical shape accommodates
social needs”.
For successfulness of any place it is very important how that place functions at
different time on different levels. A place which don’t meet the need of users or
that serve no important functions for users is not a successful place.
Function of the riverfront is boost the economy, create the image, increase the
living standard, serve as the vibrant open space for recreation which can be
achieved through proper management of the project, and good riverfront design.
Proper architectural design, Mixed-use development, water related activities,
recreational activities will help to attract the tourist and people from nearby
areas at the riverfront which will fulfil the function of riverfront.
3 Accessibility
Benjamin Fried stated, “I want to see wide avenues, broad access, with view
corridors so you feel a visceral connection to the waterfront from downtown”.
Public accessibility is main feature of urban design. Every public space should be
accessible from all areas. Public entrance is a basic requirement for any public
place.
Ethen Kent wrote on PPS website, “The edges of a public space also play an
important role in making it accessible; a row of shops along a street, for instance, is
more interesting and generally safer to walk along than a blank wall or an empty
lot. Accessible spaces are conveniently reached by foot and, ideally, public transit,
and have a high parking turnover”.
Physical access deals with the linkage, location and entrance design. Besides, the
entry to the public place should be easily accessible and visible in order to
facilitate the user. Riverfront also be well connected to the rest of the city and
should have the large pedestrian network, multi-vehicular access. Road side
shops, boutiques, restaurants help in enhancing pedestrian flow. Secondly,
visible access is also an important factor to direct the movement of user. The
place should be easily get into and get through. Third type of access is symbolic
access, which cleary conveys the message that the place is for any particular use.
4 Attraction
According to PPS Ethen Kent said, "Even well designed and maintained
waterfronts that provide excellent public access may not necessarily fulfil their
potential as gathering places. If there are no special places that draw people, then
the intrinsic vibrancy of waterfront gets squandered."
5 Sense of Place
Gorden Cullen stated in his book 'The Concise Townscape, 1961, "Concerning
place...it is an instinctive and continuous habit of the body to related itself to the
environment, this sense of position cannot be ignored; it becomes a factor in the
design of the environment”.
Each place has its story to tell. Some stories are historical for whole community
and some are personal. Image enhancement is main aim of any public space. A
space which looks like comfortable and inviting expected to be successful public
space. Sense of comfort is depending on people perception in terms of safety,
accessibility, cleanliness, visibility of that place. A lack of these elements is the
reason for ruined of good places.
6 Integration
Integration of waterfront with the surround area of that place gives the vibrant
waterfront. Any development along riverfront or at any public space should be
integrated with the city. Riverfront development becomes dead if it is at isolated
area of city.
Ethen Kent wrote about the integration, “This is the most important quality for a
place to achieve Wand the most difficult. When a place becomes a favourite spot for
people to meet friends, greet their neighbors, and feel comfortable interacting with
strangers, then you are well on your way to having a great place”.
7 Visual Appropriateness
8 Environmental Quality
spaces within public buildings, public spaces within private buildings are the
public spaces. For a great spaces destination it is important to understand what
sets a space away from others spaces..
Streets
• Refreshment, Relaxation,
recreation, social interaction
Waterfronts
Figure 41 waterfront
Types of streets
• Boulevards
• Principal streets
• Secondary streets
• Lanes and alleys
• Physical comfort
- Microclimate
- Shelter
– Seating
• Walkability
• Safety
– Surveillance
– Presence of other people
– lighting
• Segregating pedestrian and vehicular movement
• Spatial definition
– Subdivision of ROA (right-of-way)
– Continuity along the street
• Active edges
• Car parking
• Engaging all the senses
– Memorable contrast with other places
– Serial vision and the aesthetics of movement
3.5 Inferences:
Introduction:
Sabarmati is one of the most iconic river in India. The river situated in
Ahmadabad, Gujarat and refereed as a lifeline of the city. Due to rise of
urbanization river fell into neglect. This gave rise to pollution into the river, slum
encroachment on the river banks.
Issues:
• Pollution of river
• Affected Sunday market on river bank
• Lack of open spaces
• Slum encroachment
• Flooding
• Dumping garbage into river
• Strom water drain and nalaseject untreated sewage into the river
• Haphazard development along riverfront
• Inaccessible riverfront
Objectives:
Sabarmati riverfront has 10.5km stretch with 185 hec. of reclaimed land. This
project includes new sewage treatment facility to clean up the river, water
management system to reduce flooding in flood prone areas, Retaining walls to
protect low-lying flood area.
Figure 46 landuse
of Sabarmati
riverfront
Figure
47Activities on
promenade
Source: riverfront
development
report, india
urban
conference,
mysore, nov
2011
Source: riverfront development report, india urban conference, mysore, no.v 2011
Introduction:
Godavari is a major river of south-central India
originates in the trimak in Nashik district in
Maharashtra and flows through the Deccan plateau
into the Bay of Bengal. Godavari is a second longest
river of India after ganga which forms one of the
largest river basin in central India.
Gadavaririver divedes the city into part north and south. North riverfront
crowded with gurudwaras and ghat. South riverfront is newer and sparser
development. Therefore south riverfront is comparatively undeveloped which
offers designer a great opportunity to design riverfront at south side of nanded.
This project is initiative of NandedWaghala Municipal Corporation for stretch
5km.
Issues:
Objectives:
• Environmental quality:
• Religious quality:
Creation of various activity spaces for religious use as the bank is consist of
gurudwaras and temples through: various religious amenities like ghat design,
bathing platform, washing platform, open promenades for functions and
gathering, large open spaces to handle pilgrims as tourist crowd, creation of
proper cremation spaces to avoid these activities on river banks.
• Sustainable quality:
• Ghats
• Walking paths and promenades
• Parks, garden, plazas, street planting, green areas and eco system
• oat
• Streetscaping (Street furniture, art sculpture, lighting)
• Reorganizing cremation activity
• Revenue generation systems
• Social infrastructure buildings
Source: www.frontline.in
Introduction:
Sarawak is 600km apart from peninsular
Malaysia by South China Sea. It is a largest state
of Malaysia and also known as the land of rivers
in Malaysia.
Issues:
Objectives:
Kuching riverfront project includes the long 1km promenade design, historic
preservation of existing important buildings, development of traditional market
spaces, beautification of the river, replacement of warehouse& has facilities for
refreshment, entertainment, relaxation, arts appreciation & cultural enjoyment.
The river park is also known as “The People’sPlace”.
• Long promenade
• Historic buildings and Colonial
structures
• Shopping complex, and Hotels
• Amphitheater
• beautiful landscaped, park, piazza,
gardens
• musical fountain
• food stalls, restaurants
• Environment friendly- solar energy
• Water activities, boating
• Chinese pavilion, pagoda
• Handicraft market
Introduction:
Thames river and its surrounding are form the
important part of the London. The river Thames is
important for natural and cultural asset of London city
that reflects the city’s history, its evolution, and its
contemporary significance through different projects Figure 3london map
and policies. Over the past several decades London has
rediscovered its waterfront. The milennium
celebrations and the pedestrian bridges, Tate Modern
rennovation, The Eye, City Hall and countless other
attractions have brought residents and visitors to the
Thames for excercise, museums or just to stroll. The
Issues:
Westminster’s TPA covers the river itself and the buildings and open spaces that
line the riverbank. It also covers some areas further from the river, including
areas that are linked to it visually, functionally or historically.
Policies to make better use of the Thames:
Aim is to maximize the potential of the river Thames and to facilitate its role as
the focus for the regeneration of Thames gateway, subject to sustainability,
environmental enhancement and nature conservation consideration.
Objectives:
Source: flckr.com
4.5 Inferences:
After the study of all above case
studies I can conclude that water
bodies, riverfront can be used for
various purposes such as social
purpose, vibrant recreational
activities, common public activities,
waterfront park, pedestrian
promenade, market facilities,
activities for revenue generation,
boating, institutional purpose,
business, cultural development, social interaction etc. while designing riverfront
area we need to consider existing site condition, surrounding, climate,
architectural features, users need, site appearance, public accessibility to the
place, activities for different age group, urban design principles, safety of the
place, maintenance, tourism etc.
5.1 Introduction
Recreation is an essential part of human life and finds many different forms
which are shaped naturally by individual interests but also by the surrounding
social construction. Recreational activities can be communal or solitary, active or
passive, outdoors or indoors, healthy or harmful, and useful for society or
detrimental. A list of typical activities could be almost endless including most
human activities, a few examples being reading, playing or listening to music,
watching movies or TV, gardening, hunting, hobbies, sports, studies, and travel.
Table 6 Flow in nag-river (source: impact of urbanisation on river environment- nagriver Nagpur)
Site is selected on the basis of preliminary study of the site, issues and problems
of city and inferences from literature and case studies. Nag-river is flowing
through the three different zones of the city. Study of each zone has been done in
terms of potentiality of each zone. Delineation of study area has been done by
analysing all physical features of site and on the basis of potential of riverfront
development which involves land use pattern along study area, movement
network, available open spaces, built-unbuilt urban fabric, study of surrounding
area etc. On the basis of above parameters, zone 1 found more feasible area for
this study.
Figure 72 Zoning of the site according to the site conditions in various areas. (source: author)
I have divided the whole stretch into three zones as the whole stretch was too
long to develop due to other activities present in it. These all three zones have
different stretch conditions and different uses of lands. Finally after comparing
all these zones we concluded our scope of work and site for this dissertation.
5.5.1 Zone – 3
Zone - 3 of the River stretch has various problems due to which this site was not
suitable for my Thesis project. These difficulties present in this zones area:
• Less open spaces and more residential zone is being provided due to which
no land is allocated for recreational activities.
Due to all these problems this zone is being neglected for the purpose of
riverfront development. This zone also has a very zig-zag flow of river terrain
which is also not suitable for riverfront development.
5.5.2 Zone –2
Zone - 2 of the River stretch has various problems due to which this site was not
suitable for my Thesis project. These difficulties present in this zones area:
• Less open spaces and more residential zone are being provided due to
which no land is allocated for recreational activities.
Due to all these problems this zone also gets neglected for the purpose of
riverfront development.
Zone-1 is the area where we get around 55% of the open land under which 30%
of the land comes under recreational zone. This recreational zone is located on
the banks of the Nag River which gives us the favorable conditions for the
riverfront development. Also the location is nearby state transport bus stand
which gives a suitable location for giving a recreational zone in this particular
zone. Beside all these, there are some more features are also available which are
as follows:
• No industries
• Main access road with straight along the linear river stretch
(source: author)
The site is connected by North Ambazari road which is going parallel to the site
and serving the site. The secondary roads connected by North Ambazari connect
to other parts of the city and made study area accessible from all sides. The width
of the roads varies from 3.0m, 6.5m to 12.5m.
built-unbuilt fabric
built up (47%)
Figure 85 Maximum potential areas for riverfront development along nag-river (source: author)
Weakness
• Air pollution, water pollution, and waste disposal are unaddressed issues.
• Presence of slums (especially in the nearby stretch of the River).
Opportunities
Threats
5.10 Inferences
• Planned sewerage system should be installed to overcome direct sewage
disposal into the river.
• By-laws should be strictly applied as there is a lot of encroachment is
happening along the river bank.
• Slums should be relocated far away from the river bank.
• People should not allow to dump waste in the river.
• There are no recreational areas designed in the city which can attract
people, so this riverfront development is a good initiative to be design.
• Development should orient towards the river.
• Parking areas and automobile access into development should be located
along non-river frontage access roads, with wide pedestrian areas and
landscaping.
Snehal S. Teltumbade, M.Arch., (2012-14) Page 80
Riverfront Development for Rejuvenation of Nag River, Nagpur
Planning and design process began with a complete analysis of the site and its
historical background; community needs, and market demands. There should be
some points to be remembered while designing a riverfront development and
those are as follows:
Design strategy: 1
Design strategy: 2
• Use activity to connect destinations through green space like parks, green
corridor, pedestrian ways etc.
Design strategy: 3
Design strategy: 4
Design strategy: 5
Design strategy: 6
Location
• Promote the waterfront activities at strategic locations. (Identify key
location with major water views and create activity nodes & destinations
where possible)
Function
• Provide diversified opportunities for different functions (economic
development, public enjoyment and civic identity).
• Promote the waterfront front vitality both day and night.
• Design the riverline to optimize the visual and functional value.
• Activities must be grouped so they will function in relation to each other.
Attraction
• Maximize the amenity value of sites with good natural settings.
• Promote mixed use development with public oriented activity.
• Create focal points and activities nodes.
• Promote retailing and leisure activities to the water edge.
Integration
• Avoid mismatched development in terms of water view, form and scale.
• Promote land use continuity by improving linkage system.
• Promote harmony in the visual relationships and transition between the
new and existing development.
• Promote integration of waterfront recreation areas with adjoining land
uses in terms of pedestrian, access and landscape design frameworks.
Sense of Place
• Protect the waterfronts historic value.
• Significant historical structures and landmarks should always preserve or
conserve.
• New developments or major improvement works should complement with
the old urban fabric and the street identity and special characteristic
should preserve or retain.
Access
• Enhance physical access at various levels.
• Promote visual accessibility.
• Multi functional pedestrian access is recommend with diverse variety of
experiences.
• Visual Quality maximizes the amenity value of the waterfront.
• Promote visual interest of waterfront outlook in terms of land use, built
form and landscape treatments.
• Avoid objectionable views.
• Pedestrian oriented promenade with lookout points or view corridor
should promote to be capitalized the beauty of waterfront.
• Physical layout and build form should allow maximum waterfront views.
• Special location of vertical elements such as buildings or sculptures always
has great visual impact and may act as points of reference or landmarks.
• Horizontal elements such as special designed paving pattern may create
visual interest.
• A particular paving material throughout a series of spaces would provide
continuity and sometimes used to define the direction and hierarchy of
spaces.
• The unplanned growth of the shrubs and plants should be removed for
designed landscape.
6.4 Proposal:
Based on all the information that was made available to me, from the various
local contacts, the initial site analysis, literature study, case studies and the
incredible amount of community input, I tried to develop a program for the
thesis. After long hours of analyzing the data and various studies conducted in
this report a design began to take form. The program included not only a set of
goals, objective and design concepts, but also a vision for the project.
The thesis incorporated all of the natural beauty the site had and looked to
emphasize all of the potential it held for the future of the area and region,
although, majority area of the site will be allocated for open space. The plan
includes open spaces connected by pedestrian and bicycle trails which are easily
accessible to the public. Paths will be designed to connect with existing trail
systems.
6.5.1 Section 1:
6.5.2 Section 2:
6.5.3 Section 3:
6.5.4 Section 4:
CONCLUSION:
Nagpur city at present has some ecological components left within it and around.
But with the development of city till date, it has come to notice that no due
consideration has been given to these natural areas. Though the river is in
neglect state and riverfront is abandoned right now,has the potential to create
large open space for recreation.
Nag-river is the only large open space present in the heart of the city. Infact, nag-
river divides the city in north and south Nagpur. Therefore it is felt that this area
can be treated as a precious conservation belt to stitch the city together at one
place. The future visualizes the growth of the city, thus the front of the river have
been developed as a major recreational resource and open space for the
metropolis of the future, with emphasising on retaining the character of the city
by curbing the growth of industry and trade and integrating the river by
preserving the natural asset as well as the manmade structures.
At present Nagpur Municipal Corporation is working on proposal to clean this
river and Nagpur people wants nag-river back in the city. Through this thesis I
have tried to solve the problem of losing nag river and heritage site of
Nagpur.This proposal would help to create vibrant open and recreational space
in a city, upgrade the economic condition, maintain an ecological balance as well
as attempt to improve disparities between settlements.
Overall, this project has highly beneficial economic impact, especially in
attracting new commercial, residential, mixed-use development along the river.
This thesis has shown a glimpse of what the nag-river can become with proper
design and planning.
Snehal S. Teltumbade
Proposed Riverfront Development for Rejuvenation of Nag-River, Nagpur
M.Arch. II (12510016)
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Books:
Reports/Publications:
Websites:
• http://www.nagpurpeople.com/
• http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nagpur
• http://ecosistemaurbano.com/portfolio/optimization-of-public-space/
• http://www.nagpuronline.in/city-guide/physical-features-of-nagpur
• http://www.pps.org/reference/turnwaterfrontaround/
• http://www.urbandesign.org/elements.html
• https://www.planning.org/greatplaces/spaces/characteristics.htm