Professional Documents
Culture Documents
T&D March 2011
T&D March 2011
From one
engineer to
another, let’s talk
peer-to-peer.
The quickest route is usually the most direct route. A fact
holds especially true when it comes to restoring service fol-
lowing a power disruption. Which is why direct, point-to-point,
distributed intelligence is paramount to creating a rapid self-
healing Smart Grid.
Enter S&C’s IntelliTEAM SG™ Automatic Restoration System,
ƬǯƤ Ǧ Ǥǯ
Ƥ
equipment, allowing decisions to be made where they are
needed most.
Ƥ
system after a fault and quickly restores service to segments
ǯ ơ Ǥ
control and central monitoring are fully supported, neither
Ǥ ǡ Ǧ
loading data. Using the excess capacity from any available
alternate source, be it conventional, wind, solar or battery
storage, IntelliTEAM SG restores service in seconds, making
it the fastest restoration solution on the market. And, if an
overload develops after the transfer, the system will auto-
matically transfer or shed load based on priorities that
Ƥ Ǥ
ƪ ǡ
SG can work with systems of all sizes. There are, literally, no
limitations on the number of sources or switching devices.
It is also easy to deploy and maintain. It does not require
custom programming and can be easily expanded using
ǡƬǯ Ƥ Ǥ
Ƥ
needs today yet powerful enough to shape your Smart Grid
ǡ
Ƥ Ǧ ǡ Ǧ
solution that will change forever the amount of time your
customers will lose to unexpected power interruptions.
To learn more about IntelliTEAM SG and our other unmatched
Smart Grid solutions, visit www.sandc.com/rapidrestore.
requirements into innovative products and solutions – always working closely with our customers and always
one step ahead of the competition. Our strategy of innovation, combined with a total focus on our customers
and their benefits, has made Siemens the market leader. www.siemens.com/energy/siprotec2011
Vol. 63 No. 3
MARCH2011
32
C O V E R
S T O R Y
SAVE TIME
The largest and most experienced technical staff in the industry brings
you TowerPak®, a unique solution to your transmission project needs.
All of your tower materials are coordinated for a perfect fit, bundled
and shipped as one—ready when your line crews are ready. Let us
help you organize your next project. From anchors to tower guy dead-
ends, suspension clamps, armor rods, coupling hardware, insulators,
compression & bolted dead-ends, splices, dampers, & much more,
Hubbell Power Systems delivers.
AF-0111
Never Compromise
TM
w w w. h u b b e l l p o w e r s y s t e m s . c o m
CONTENTS
Departments
8 GlobalVIEWPOINT
The Stepford Utility. We need to celebrate diversity rather than encourage
conformity if we are to realize true value in team.
By Rick Bush, Editorial Director
10 BUSINESSDevelopments
10
● NYISO Passes Reliability Audit, Meets All Reliability Standards
and Requirements
● PGE and BPA to Discuss Mutual Interests in Transmission Projects
14 SMARTGrid
● NEMA Announces SGIC Product Strategy
● Cooper Power Systems and Cisco Announce Smart Grid Collaboration
18 TECHNOLOGYUpdates
● A123 Systems to Supply 20 MW of Advanced Energy Storage Solutions
to AES Gener for Spinning Reserve Project in Chile
● East Kentucky Power Cooperative Awards SCADA/EMS System Contract
24 22 QuarterlyREPORT
The Geospatial Workforce Shortage. The geospatial industry is facing a
labor shortage, and electric utilities must be proactive in their recruiting
efforts. By Dave DiSera, GITA
24 CHARACTERSwithCharacter
An Accidental Engineer. Engineer Christer Eriksson receives a special
commendation in honor of his 50-year career with ABB.
By Stefanie Kure, Contributing Editor
70 70 PRODUCTS&Services
● Intelligent Self-Healing Software
● Software for Collaboration with Oracle Database
80 StraightTALK
Put the Smart in Customer. Utilities implementing smart grid
must change their relationship with consumers.
By Ellen Krohne, Yellow Energy Consulting
75
application is solving
ClassifiedADVERTISING a problem that has
bedeviled engineers all
79 ADVERTISINGIndex over the planet.
www.tdworld.com
PRECISE-ER.
Editorial Director Rick Bush rbush@tdworld.com
Technology Editor Vito Longo vlongo@tdworld.com
Senior Managing Editor Emily Saarela esaarela@tdworld.com
International Editor Gerry George gerry.george.tdw@talk21.com
Automation Editor Matt Tani mattelutcons@joplin.com
Contributing Editor Amy Fischbach afischbach@tdworld.com
Contributing Editor Stefanie Kure skure@tdworld.com
Technical Writer Gene Wolf GW_Engr@msn.com
Art Director Susan Lakin slakin@tdworld.com
• Precision timing using IEEE 1588 v2 Chief Executive Officer Sharon Rowlands Sharon.Rowlands@penton.com
Chief Information Officer Jasmine Alexander Jasmine.Alexander@penton.com
• Industry first: dual hot-swap power supplies Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President
• “Next-Gen” 10 slot, 36 port configurability Senior Vice President & General Counsel
Nicola Allais Nicola.Allais@penton.com
21
including Factiva, LexisNexis and Proquest. For microform availability, contact National
YOU
STRIAL NETW
IN
The
or instructional use may be obtained from the Copyright Clearance Center (CCC) at 978-
750-8400. Obtain further information at copyright.com.
strongest
PRIVACY POLICY: Your privacy is a priority to us. For a detailed policy statement about
privacy and information dissemination practices related to Penton Media Inc. products,
please visit our website at www.Penton.com.
link. CORPORATE OFFICE: Penton Media Inc., 249 West 17th St., New York, NY 10011 U.S.,
www.penton.com.
O
ur utility executives tend to have this disconcert- happens? You can be sure the other superintendents will take
ing habit of stamping out employees in their image. him down. Why? His ideas represent a threat to the status quo.
That’s not to say our executives see themselves as After all, what are the odds of him being right and all the
all-knowing gods, rather that they are quite enamoured with Stepford Superintendents being wrong?
the mirror.
Some of our utilities even have internal colleges to hone There Is a Better Way
the masses into products that can be dispensed as “full-time First, let’s assume there is true value in diversity. Let’s
equivalents” (FTEs). Nothing could be more demoralizing assume that having significantly differing opinions, skill sets
than to realize you are a commodity designed to fill a slot in a and experiences within the same job classification is a good
production line. thing. Then assume that constructively handling the conflict
that inevitably erupts makes a company stronger and better
The Palletized Man able to handle change. Yes, the clashing of ideas and person-
So why is the concept of palletized FTEs so common? alities creates friction, but maybe we could generate sufficient
Because it seemingly makes a manager’s job easier. Have a hole heat to light the fire of change.
in an organization? Go to the depth flow chart and pick the Right now, I see a lot of utility executives pulling back be-
next FTE in the queue. He or she has been through the proper cause of the downturn in the economy. Executives are can-
stamping and forging operations, so there is no risk to you. celling travel, pulling their staff out of industry groups and
You can always blame the system if it doesn’t work out. But hunkering down into holy huddles. This is a bad move for our
woe to you who go with that unconventional someone. If he or utilities and it is even worse for employees.
she doesn’t pan out, it’s all on your head. I’ve never been a big fan of benchmarking, because we di-
lute ourselves to be the best of the mediocre. We can do better.
The Stepford Staff The risk in incremental tweaking is actually greater than the
As an industry, we find it easier to deal with people who risk of bold steps.
look and think and speak just like us. We talk a good game, but I like to say that innovation overcomes resistance. Why?
we only give lip service to diversity. Because resistance is not that bright. It often has a heart but
We live in the land of the Stepford Staff. seldom displays a brain.
I just had breakfast with a utility buddy who is vice presi-
dent of operations in a mid-sized utility. I was sharing with her What It Takes to Be a Smart Utility
how my former utility had job descriptions for each job class, Another utility buddy made a simple yet profound state-
so the ideal person would fit the job perfectly. ment, “If we only knew what we already know, we would be the
Seems logical doesn’t it? Logical, yes, but in hindsight, this smartest utility in the country.”
may not be the best approach. Why is he so right on? Because our utilities are made up
Think about this scenario. You just gathered superinten- of incredibly talented individuals with perspectives, thoughts
dents together from all the divisions in your utility so they can and passions that are too seldom put into play. We settle for
share perspectives and best practices. After a few days, what is what is comfortable instead of demanding what is achievable.
the typical result? Because you went to the same promotional So rather than downsizing our staffs to the point of exhaus-
pool and picked similar persons with similar backgrounds and tion, then executing those who stick their heads up, why don’t
similar training and put them in similar jobs, why would you we celebrate diversity?
expect them to the share different perspectives? Let’s bring to the front our passionate people who will bring
Instead of coming out of the “sharing experience” full a breath of fresh air to invigorate our companies and bring
of renewed vigor, you find you have funded a two-day gripe additional value to our customers and our stockholders.
session that ends with all present feeling more depressed and
demoralized than when they arrived.
8F×SFCVJMEJOHBXPSMEPGEJGGFSFODF5PHFUIFS
$POTVMUJOHÞ&OHJOFFSJOHÞ$POTUSVDUJPOÞ0QFSBUJPO I X X XCWDPN
BusinessDevelopments
PATH Seeks
to Withdraw
Applications for
NYISO Passes Reliability Audit, Meets All Transmission Project
Reliability Standards and Requirements American Electric Power (AEP) and
The New York Independent System Operator (NYISO) announces the successful FirstEnergy Corp. have announced their
results of a comprehensive reliability audit conducted by the Northeast Power Coor- affiliates will file to withdraw their appli-
dinating Council Inc. (NPCC). The audit found the NYISO to be compliant with all cations for state regulatory approval of
38 reliability standards and the 156 requirements of the North American Electric the Potomac-Appalachian Transmission
Reliability Corp. (NERC) applicable to the NYISO. The audit was conducted from Highline (PATH) project following an
Dec. 6 to Dec. 9, 2010. announcement by regional grid opera-
“The NYISO prides itself on commitment to excellence in operations and main- tor PJM Interconnection that the project
taining the reliability of New York’s bulk electric transmission system,” said NYISO has been suspended.
President and CEO Stephen G. Whitley. “This comprehensive audit is not something PATH is a joint venture between the
an organization like the NYISO can just prepare to pass like a test; compliance must former Allegheny Energy and AEP to
be engrained in our culture. Our team works very hard every day to exceed these build a 765-kV, 275-mile (443-km) trans-
standards, and the results of this audit underscore that commitment.” mission project from Putnam County,
In conducting the audit, the team reviewed data, information and evidence sub- West Virginia, to Frederick County,
mitted in the form of policies, procedures, e-mails, logs, studies and data sheets, Maryland. Allegheny Energy merged
which were validated, substantiated and cross-checked for accuracy as appropriate. with FirstEnergy, effective Feb. 25, 2011.
In addition to auditing compliance with standards and requirements, the audit team PJM Interconnection is suspending
also reviewed the NYISO’s compliance culture. further development of the PATH proj-
“During all contact, the NYISO staff was professional in their approach to compli- ect while PJM conducts a more rigorous
ance and understood the importance of the compliance and its role in maintaining analysis of the potential need for PATH
reliability and security,” the audit report concluded. “For those that participated in as part of its continuing Regional Trans-
the audit, it was clear that all were committed to both compliance and the improved mission Expansion Plan. PJM directed
reliability and security that a strong compliance program leads to.” the construction of PATH in 2007 to
For more information, visit www.nyiso.com. resolve violations of national and local
standards for reliable operation of the
PGE and BPA Agree to Discuss Mutual region’s transmission system. Since then,
annual studies reaffirmed the need for
Interests in Transmission Projects PATH as the recommended solution for
Portland General Electric (PGE) has entered into a Memorandum of Under- resolving these issues. However, PJM’s
standing (MOU) with the Bonneville Power Administration (BPA) that allows the latest analyses indicate that the project-
two utilities to coordinate planning of new electrical substations and transmission ed need for the project has moved well
facilities and to consider joint development. into the future.
PGE has proposed Cascade Crossing, a double-circuit transmission project run- PJM has indicated that it will under-
ning from the city of Boardman to the Salem area, to help meet Oregon’s growing take an evaluation of its planning meth-
energy needs, enhance reliability of the electrical grid and allow for development of ods through a stakeholder process.
more renewable power projects to help meet the state’s Renewable Energy Standard. This process will evaluate the criteria
The project would connect new and existing energy-generating resources east of the used to determine the need for transmis-
Cascades to the Willamette Valley. sion projects under its Regional Trans-
BPA is building the McNary–John Day transmission project, which will be com- mission Expansion Plan, and determine
pleted in January 2012. BPA is conducting environmental analysis on three proposed whether the need for PATH should be
500-kV transmission lines. In addition, BPA is developing several large electrical re-evaluated in light of any approved re-
substations to integrate wind generation into the Northwest grid. visions to its planning process. Once this
The MOU allows PGE and BPA to share confidential information as they work process is complete, PJM will reassess
together on a range of issues, including system interconnections, substation loca- the need for transmission expansion in
tions and utilization of existing transmission corridors. the region. Until then, PATH companies
PGE previously executed MOUs for discussions surrounding Cascade Crossing will immediately suspend most activities
with PacifiCorp, Idaho Power and the Confederated Tribes of Warm Springs. In on the project except for those that may
order to build the project, PGE must obtain approvals from both the state and fed- be necessary to return the project to
eral governments. PGE is in the second year of what is expected to be a three-year active status at the conclusion of PJM’s
permitting process, which includes a variety of opportunities for public input. planning process review.
For more information, visit www.portlandgeneral.com or www.bpa.gov. Visit www.pathtransmission.com.
Dependable Communications
for Critical Infrastructure
Flexible
SONET multiplexer and Ethernet switch
Powerful
Precise time distribution
Secure
Internode SONET encryption
Managed
SEL network management software or third-party
software, both using SNMPv3
www.selinc.com | +1.509.332.1890
SMARTGrid SMARTGrid
Sydney, Australia will be host to tree experts as they converge July 23–July 27 for the annual conference and trade show
of the International Society of Arboriculture (ISA). The conference is being hosted by Arboriculture Australia, the local
chapter of ISA.
ISA has announced the speaker lineup and session overview for the conference, which features a look at the best in new
research, trends and best practices for the arboricultural profession and can earn ISA certified professionals up to 20 ISA
certification continuing education units.
The three-day educational programming includes two full days of utility program with Tuesday and Wednesday tracks for
utility arboriculture education. The ISA and its professional affiliate the Utility Arborist Association annually work together
to provide educational opportunities for arborists working in utility services arboriculture. The track for 2011 includes
presentations on utilities and wildfire and integrated vegetation management as well as a discussion panel on global
challenges in utility arboriculture. The discussion panel consists of global experts:
◆ John Ho, China Light and Power, Hong Kong ◆ Trevor Gardiner, New Zealand
◆ Pedro Mendes Castro, CEMIG, Belo Horizonte, Brazil ◆ Brendan Murphy, Australia
◆ Nelsen Money, San Francisco, California, U.S.
Other featured presenters include: Neil Thiessen, Dr. Ken James, Mark Amos, Michael Neal, Jim Neeser, Matt Palmer
and William Conn, Paul Fearon, David Wood, Carla Perkins and Rich Hendler.
For more information and a schedule of activities for the ISA annual conference, visit www.isa-arbor.com/events/
conference.
Alcatel–Lucent Plays
Role in PECO’s Meter
Technology Upgrade
Alcatel–Lucent has been selected to
help build an advanced IP-based opti-
cal communications network as part of
PECO’s initiative to upgrade metering
YOUR FIRST CHOICE FOR ELECTRIC POWER DISTRIBUTION SOLUTIONS
technology for customers.
FOR THE UTILITY, CONSTRUCTION AND OEM MARKETS In its role, Alcatel–Lucent is providing
and implementing end-to-end IP connec-
tivity via an optical core as well as wireless
(WiMAX) and microwave edge connec-
tions. The new network will help PECO
give customers the information they need
to use and save energy effectively.
The Alcatel–Lucent solution includes:
• A single converged IP/MPLS net-
With unmatched knowledge and experience in electric power distribution coupled work allowing PECO to offer new IP ser-
with Trinetics® components and Maysteel® precision fabrication, we can help you vices with enhanced quality of service
maintain efficiency, improve capacity and effectively utilize your power distribution and end-to-end common operations and
system – all while keeping an eye on your budget.
service management. The IP/MPLS solu-
TRINETICS® SMARTBANK™ CAPACITOR BANKS tion also has the capability to deliver seam-
Hiqh-reliability power factor correction solutions to maximize the capacity of less services across fiber and microwave
your distribution system. Custom-configured Medium Voltage pole or pad mount technologies.
capacitor banks as well as Low Voltage fixed or timer controlled banks. • A Gigabit Ethernet switch specifi-
cally built for IP network deployments in
TRINETICS® CAPACITOR SWITCHES AND CAPACITORS
Proven reliability and performance to enhance your utility operation. unusually demanding operational envi-
• CSD Oil Switch • UltraSync™ Zero-Close Synchronous Switch ronments.
• VS Vacuum Oil-Insulated Switch • 1 or 2 Bushing MV Capacitors • Microwave packet radio and long-
• UltraVac™ Solid Dielectric Switch haul microwave solutions, managed by
the Service Aware Manager, for a single
TRINETICS® RCOC STREET LIGHTING CONTROL RELAYS service-aware solution that enables PECO
Heavy-duty construction and time proven electromagnetic design for long-term
safe and reliable performance. Submersible designs for flood prone applications. to optimize service delivery in any condi-
tion, as air bandwidth is fully exploited
MAYSTEEL® POWER DISTRIBUTION ENCLOSURES for maximum utilization of the radio
Cost effective, long lasting solutions for safe underground connections in mild band and service reliability.
steel, mild steel with zinc rich primer, aluminum and stainless steel. • A complete portfolio of professional
• Fused and Non-fused Sectionalizers • Multi-Connection Secondary Enclosures and network integration services includ-
• Primary Metering • Multi-Purpose Apparatus Enclosures
ing comprehensive IP traffic engineering
and design, circuit provisioning, mainte-
SPECIALISTS IN POWER DISTRIBUTION. Call 877-219-9728 | trinetics.maysteel.com nance services and project management.
Visit www.alcatel-lucent.com.
T
he fast-growing, technically advanced geospatial indus- and standards of performance.
try is confronting a severe workforce development chal- Recruiting. Provide a clear picture of the geospatial job
lenge. As such, electric utilities, the government, the to prospective applicants to make the applicant screening
private sector, academic community and professional associa- process more efficient.
tions must prepare workers to take advantage of new geospa- Employee selection. Design interview questions, assessments,
tial job opportunities. skill tests and other methods to identify the best candidates for
As a general rule, electric utilities hire geospatial profes- geospatial positions.
sionals to acquire, manage, analyze, integrate, map, distribute Employee development. Identify career paths that include jobs
and use geographic, temporal and spatially based information with related competencies and provide that information to
and knowledge. These workers — who are in high demand employees so they understand their options for growth within
but short supply — are also involved with research and educa- the organization.
tion, technology development and applications to address the Training. Develop geospatial training programs (classroom,
planning, decision-making and operational needs of utilities online and on-the-job) that are targeted to the skills needed
nationwide. for each position, making the most efficient and effective use
of training expenditures.
Hiring the Best Candidate for the Job Performance-based coaching. Provide a clear basis for setting
To effectively recruit, train and retain qualified geospatial expectations and performance goals, establishing standards
professionals, electric utilities must first pinpoint what skills of performance and providing tools for managers to deal
they are looking for in job candidates. It’s challenging for effectively with job performance issues.
utilities to recruit without a clear definition of requirements,
and there is no “brand” to entice young geospatial workers Confronting Challenges
into the profession. Recruiting new geospatial professionals with the right tech-
Electric utilities, however, can ramp up their recruiting nical and managerial skills is not the only challenge faced by
efforts by investing in what’s called a geospatial competency utilities. The majority of companies also aren’t taking a system-
model. By establishing clear expectations and standards for atic approach to geospatial workforce planning. As a result,
geospatial jobs within their companies, utilities can develop these utilities are not satisfying the future need for workforce
realistic job descriptions that drive job postings. In addition, sustainability.
they can use competencies to create a standard branding Defined geospatial competency models can help to ensure
message for future recruiting efforts. success during the employment lifecycle. In addition, they can
While geospatial competency models may at first seem an improve the efficiency of workforce planning by defining key
abstract concept, they are not only practical and useful, but knowledge areas for training and development, workforce
critical to an electric utility’s success. Imagine hiring a new succession and continuity, knowledge retention and manage-
person in a key position, but only having a vague and general ment, and career planning. Utilities can use competencies in
idea of the knowledge, skills, and abilities required for that these practice areas to understand the workforce’s challenges
position. What impact would that have on the chance for and opportunities. In turn, the companies can leverage the
success for the new hire? And yet that is exactly what utilities strengths and fill the gaps in the geospatial industry.
are doing every day.
Dave DiSera (ddisera@ema-inc.com) serves as the chairman
Putting the Plan into Action of the research committee for the Geospatial Information and
Developing a competency model is often a rigorous and Technology Association and served as a board member
time-consuming process for electric utilities. By relying on from 1997-2003. He is a vice president and CTO with EMA Inc.
their available framework as well as standardized templates,
however, the process doesn’t need to be cumbersome. Once Editor’s note: Visit www.doleta.gov for more information on the
a utility establishes a geospatial competency model, it sets the Geospatial Technology Competency Model and the report on
foundation for the following critical processes. “Defining and Communicating Geospatial Industry Workforce
Job design. Establish geospatial job duties, qualifications Demand.”
600
MVA
500 22 23
24
20 21
18 19
16 17
14 15
400 12 13
11
10
9
8
7
300 5
6
4
200 1
2
3
Hours
CHARACTERSwithCharacter
An Accidental Engineer
By Stefanie Kure, Contributing Editor
C
hrister Eriksson recently celebrated his 50th anniver- an old friend,” he remembered. “We chatted, and he asked
sary. Not his golden wedding anniversary, as many what my business was. I told him I was on my way to the hu-
people would assume, but five decades as a dedicated man resources department to get my next assignment, and
employee of Zurich, Switzerland-based ABB, a global power my friend asked me to wait. He said he had another assign-
and automation technology company that operates in 100 ment that he would like me to consider. Before I knew it, I had
countries and employs approximately 124,000 people. After signed a new contract with ASEA and moved to Los Angeles,
half a century of working with high-voltage direct-current California, to help in the rebuild of the Sylmar converter sta-
(HVDC) transmission systems for the same company, it is dif- tion, which had been totally destroyed in an earthquake. That
ficult to imagine that, except for a bit of luck, the 67-year-old is how I came to live in the United States.”
may not have become an engineer at all. In 1980, Eriksson, who was by now married with a fam-
“I grew up on the family dairy farm in Sweden, but I knew ily, moved to Corvallis, Oregon, to work on upgrades to the
that was not what I wanted to do with my life,” he recalled. Pacific Intertie HVDC system. Since the completion of that
“My father had done some research and decided I should project in 1988 — around which time ASEA merged with
leave home to apply for work in a large factory, so that is what Brown Boveri to become ABB — Eriksson has worked in nu-
I did.” merous after-sales and business development leadership roles
In 1960, at the age of 17, Eriksson traveled 200 miles to related to HVDC technology for the company’s grid systems
Ludvika, Sweden, and enrolled in an apprentice program at business. He currently is a director of business development
ABB’s legacy company ASEA to learn about machine tools. But within the company’s Power Systems division, overseeing a
because he was a high school graduate, the human resources dozen projects with utilities on the West Coast and Canada.
office asked if he would be interested in a position other than October 3, 2010, marked the engineer’s 50-year anniver-
the one for which he had applied. sary with the company. To celebrate this rare achievement,
“I said sure, not knowing what I was getting into,” Eriksson Eriksson recently received two prestigious awards. The first,
laughed. “In those days, the company had just begun com- the Royal Patriotic Society of Sweden’s Long and Faithful Ser-
mercial exploitation of HVDC for transmission purposes, so I vice gold medal, came from his home country. The Swedish
was assigned to the department building rectifiers for industry Ambassador presented the medal to Eriksson last Nov. 15 in
and railroads for the next two years.” a surprise celebration at the Swedish Embassy in Washington,
Because military service is compulsory in Sweden, Eriks- D.C. The second honor, a lifetime achievement award, came
son left ASEA to serve 18 months in the army. He returned from ABB at the company’s annual sales meeting in Houston.
to the company after being discharged and was offered the “I was totally overwhelmed by the recognition and celebra-
opportunity to enter an industrial engineering program with tion of both these events,” he said. “I am not used to this type
an emphasis on electrical. of fanfare. I work because, after all these years, I still find my
“For the next two years, I received minimum wage payment job challenging and extremely gratifying.”
to attend school six days a week,” he said. As proof of this statement, Eriksson says has no plans to re-
Upon graduating, ASEA assigned Eriksson to a project in tire any time soon unless he can find something to do that will
which he helped tie power between Sweden and Denmark. give him the same level of satisfaction as his career at ABB.
The company next asked the young engineer if would take a When asked if he would choose a different career if he
three-year assignment in Japan. knew 50 years ago what he knows now, Eriksson does not hesi-
“That was sort of scary,” he said. “I was only in my mid-20s, tate to respond.
and three years seemed like a lifetime. In the end, I signed on “Absolutely not,” he said. “The technological progress I
and went to Japan. I had the time of my life.” have seen in the power industry since 1960 is mind-boggling,
The assignment stretched into five years, but as always, and we continue to advance. I have witnessed the movement
Eriksson ultimately returned to ASEA and Sweden. Once from vacuum tubes to transistors to microprocessors to com-
again, fate intervened. puter-based systems. It is fantastic, and I cannot imagine what
“Walking into the company on my first day back, I ran into our industry will be like in the next 50 years.”
www.omicronusa.com | www.omicron.at
overheadFacilities
When Overbuild
Meets Underbuild
Surge arresters provide a simple solution
to a complex overvoltage problem.
By Daniel J. Ward, Dominion Virginia Power
I
t was one of those so-called “overvoltage events.” Some- the three measures are quite expensive, utilities often resort
how overhead wires from the top and bottom circuits to one of them in areas where repeat overvoltage incidents
made contact. The cause was a tree contractor removing occur.
a diseased tree at a private residence. One particularly What can the customer do? Surprisingly, the answer is the
troublesome limb that had been cut had fallen into the line, customer can do very little. Some customers are often lured
bridging the top phase with one from the lower circuit. The to purchase the more expensive home surge protectors on
result was predictable. The isolators on several surge arresters the market because of their warranty, which is normally in
were blown on the lower distribution circuit and some trans- the region of tens of thousands of dollars. Unfortunately, the
formers failed, too. fine print on most of these devices contains a note that the
Several thousands of dollars in damage occurred to warranty does not cover damage associated with sustained
Dominion Virginia Power equipment. Also, TVs, heat pumps overvoltages.
and other appliances of many customers served from the lower
circuit were damaged. Appliance repair and replacement The Fundamentals
costs of US$1,000 to $2,000 or more per customer were typi- Once a conductive path is established between the two
cal. Some customers who were home at the time were fright- t
ened by the overvoltage event. Others were upset when they
realized it could happen again. How can this complex over-
voltage problem be solved cost effectively?
Overbuilt Circuits
As the incident illustrated, with two overhead circuits of
different voltages on the same poles, contact between the
two circuits can and does occur. When this happens, damage
and failures occur to both utility equipment and customer
equipment. Dominion experiences 13 sustained overvolt- t
age events annually on its distribution system. With more
than 600 miles (966 km) of overbuilt construction, mostly
34.5 kV over 13.2 kV, the annual incidence rate works out to
be 0.022/mile (0.014/km).
Traditional approaches to minimize or eliminate the risk
of these overvoltages have met with limited success largely
due to their high costs or operational difficulties. Some of the
traditional solutions include:
M Relocating or undergrounding one of the circuits
m | March 2011
www.tdworld.com 27
overheadFacilities
Prospective
sustained voltage event involving an overbuilt distribution circuit and
overvoltage to provide protection to both utility equipment on the lower
levels
circuit and customer end-use equipment served by the lower
2.0 circuit.
This problem has been a challenge at Dominion for over a
1.8 Temporary decade. One early idea was to install a normally open recloser
overvoltage
cycle on the underbuilt circuit. The load side of the recloser would
be connected to ground. In principle, it would operate like a
Normal expected
operating range fast-acting grounding switch. Install some voltage sensing and
Duty cycle of arresters make sure it is not a temporary overvoltage. The last require-
Maximum ment effectively killed the idea. One would not have the luxu-
continous ry to wait very long before equipment was damaged. Besides, it
1.0 overvoltage
capability was just too expensive.
Not to be dismayed, the idea of shunting out the lower
Most arresters are applied to operate satisfactorily in a range covering circuit had some appeal, just not with a recloser. To limit the
the nominal line-to-neutral voltage up to the temporary overvoltage overvoltage on the lower circuit, why not use an arrester? After
limits.
all, an arrester operates like a switch, and it does so automati-
cally based on voltage. It would have to be an arrester that did
Overhead line not have an isolator and one capable of absorbing quite a bit
of energy.
A station class arrester was a natural fit. To be safer, a high-
Contact
energy design was selected. For this application, the station
class arrester would function as a sacrificial arrester (that is, it
Exposure
would short out for a sustained overvoltage and prevent dam-
age to the utility equipment on the lower circuit). Once it oper-
19.9 kV
ated, it would have to be replaced.
It was not clear whether this approach would provide suf-
7.6 kV
ficient protection for customer end-use equipment and ap-
pliances, particularly electronics. If they were not protected,
it would be a show-stopper. The Information Technology In-
dustry Council (ITIC) developed a voltage tolerance envelope
applicable to 120-V IT equipment. The overvoltage portion of
the ITIC curve indicates, for example, that electronic devices
A surge arrester used for overvoltage protection functions like a fast
switch during a sustained overvoltage event. In the one-line diagram, are likely to survive if the voltage is limited to 2 per unit for
when contact is made between the two circuits, the overvoltage causes 1 msec or less. From the arrester current-resistance character-
the arrester to conduct and rapidly short out. The low-impedance shunt
istics and the available fault current, it seemed reasonable to
protects the lower circuit from the overvoltage.
expect that a station class arrester could limit the voltage to
circuits, the higher-voltage circuit dominates. Reclosing usual- around 2 per unit. The time duration was unclear.
ly occurs with both circuits, so the lower-voltage circuit winds Surge arresters are normally applied such that their tem-
up getting energized with the higher-voltage one. Transform- porary overvoltage (TOV) capability is not exceeded. In this
ers on the lower circuit do what they are supposed to do — case, the plan was to apply a 10-kV arrester knowing full well
transform. that contact with 19.92 kV would put it well beyond its TOV ca-
For the two Dominion circuits, the resulting voltage was pability. It was expected that the increased duty would quickly
2.6 times normal, which would be 300 V at a 120-V outlet. (much less than 1 msec) short out the arrester’s metal-oxide-
From this level of overvoltage, it is fairly easy to imagine how varistor blocks. Would the arrester stay intact and remain
customer appliances get damaged or destroyed. shorted for a fault current level of around 6000 A in addition
The higher voltage impressed on the lower-voltage circuit to two-shot reclosing? More importantly, would it protect?
usually causes some utility equipment on the lower circuit to Then there was the issue about energy ratings, which for sta-
fail, too. Distribution surge arresters quickly short out and tion class arresters are based on impulse tests.
blow their isolators. Several distribution transformers also Extrapolating these values to something more meaningful
succumb to the high voltage. Each shot of reclosing results in that relates to a sustained fundamental frequency overvoltage
additional damage to the lower circuit. also was a gray area, and this uncertainty resulted in selecting
The overvoltage problem associated with overbuilt circuits an energy rating higher than the standard station class arrest-
is not unique to Dominion. It is an industrywide problem. ers used by the Dominion substation group.
Get control
in your hand
ZZZFKHUULHVLW
Europe/ Middle East/Africa +39 0331 956081 . Asia Pacific +65 6278 3280 . USA +1 407 3328678 www.isatest.com
overheadFacilities
The Sequel
A second field trial was installed a couple of months after
the first one. It involved the installation of two sets of station
class arresters on a 2-mile stretch of a 34.5-kV circuit under-
built with 13.2-kV. During a storm in May 2010, almost two-
and-a-half years later, the two circuits made contact. The
fault location was not evident, but it was suspected a tree limb
caused the event. Other than replacing the two station class
arresters, no other equipment was damaged and there were
no customer claims.
In hindsight, it was fortunate the overvoltage events oc-
curred on the selected circuits in a reasonable period of time.
It could have taken much longer to occur based on the average
incidence rate and circuit lengths involved.
The Aftermath
The overvoltage protector is a simple concept based on
Wildlife guards were added because of the low arrester height and polymer-housed high-energy station class arresters. In effect,
large conductive base. In addition, to identify a failed arrester and the overvoltage protector is an electrical weak link that can be
aid in restoration, faulted circuit indicators were installed on the line
leads. Photo by Stephen E. Lackey. easily applied to overbuilt construction to prevent damage to
both customer and utility equipment from sustained overvolt-
Field Trials age events.
To help answer these nagging questions about the concept, The field trials proved to be quite successful, leading to
tests at a high-power lab seemed like a logical next step, but the the deployment of many more station class arresters for this
labs were fully booked for close to a year. As a backup plan, a purpose on the Dominion distribution system. Dominion has
field trial was arranged in August 2007. It was an area where found the overvoltage protector to be the most cost-effective
a 34.5-kV circuit ran over a 13.2-kV circuit for about 2 miles solution for preventing damages due to sustained overvoltages
(3.2 km). This circuit was selected because it had experienced from overbuilt circuits.
three sustained overvoltage events in the previous four years.
Both circuits were protected by circuit breakers with two-shot Acknowledgment
reclosing. The available 34.5-kV fault current at the substation The overvoltage protector project involved some teamwork
was 9,400 A for a single line-to-ground fault. at Dominion. Without the operational input and suggestions
One set of station class arresters were installed on a 10-ft from Dan Sullivan and Steve Barnard, the author’s concept
(3-m) crossarm below the 13.2-kV circuit near the source end would have just remained a nice idea but probably would not
of the 34.5-kV circuit. Another set was installed 1 mile (1.6 km) have been implemented. Their help was invaluable.
away. Because the 10-kV arresters were fairly short, wildlife
protection was added. Daniel J. Ward (dan.ward@dom.com) is a principal engineer
Finally, to aid in the restoration effort, faulted circuit in- with Dominion Virginia Power and a graduate of Stevens Insti-
dicators were installed on the arrester line leads to provide a tute of Technology with a BE degree and Union College with
positive sign when an arrester had shorted out. a MSEE degree. Prior to joining Dominion, he spent 21 years
Eight months later, a vehicle struck a pole, causing one of at General Electric. An IEEE Fellow, Ward received the IEEE/
the top-phase wires to fall on one phase of the lower circuit. PES Award for Excellence in Power Distribution Engineering
The fault location was approximately 0.1 mile (0.16 km) away and revised the distribution chapter for the 2006 edition of the
from one set of station class arresters and 0.9 mile (1.4 km) Standard Handbook for Electrical Engineers.
away from the other set. As expected, the station class arrester
on the affected phase shorted out at both arrester locations. Companies mentioned:
The recorded fault current from the digital relays at the substa- Dominion Virginia Power www.dom.com
tion was between 5,000 A and 6,600 A for five of the six fault Information Technology Industry Council www.itic.org
events.
T
he 21st century started off with dire predictions of realize that educating and engaging customers is the long-
an electric infrastructure collapse, but 10 years later, term solution to their acceptance of smart grid evolution.
the grid is still working. Instead of disintegration, a A lack of understanding on the residential customer’s part
dynamic and robust smarter grid is taking shape. It has led to what is being called a “smart meter backlash”:
has not been a slam dunk. There is a natural hesitation when ● Residential customers had their electromechanical
deploying new technology. It has taken some time and edu- meters replaced with smart (digital) meters with no warning
cation to separate rumors from facts, myth from reality and or preparation from the utility.
vapor from substance. ● Monthly residential electric bills jumped — doubled or
Thanks to a massive educational effort from manufactur- tripled in some cases — after the installation of smart meters.
ers and professional organizations, the industry has come to ● Legal actions to stop smart meter deployments have been
grips with a smarter grid. In 2010, Siemens began a six-city initiated in several cities in Northern California.
cross-country smart grid tour, taking its technology directly ● Residential customers in Texas petitioned the public
to utilities. utility commission to stop the deployment of smart meters.
In April 2010, ABB set up a smart grid distribution circuit As a result of the backlash, testing was performed. Utili-
at the IEEE Power & Energy Society Transmission and Dis- ties found that less than 1% of smart meters had any sort of
tribution Exposition held in New Orleans, Louisiana, U.S. mechanical problems and, accuracy-wise, the percentage was
AREVA also had a remarkable virtual display of high-voltage less. The technology was not the problem.
DC and flexible AC transmission system smart grid equip- As the famous line from the 1967 film Cool Hand Luke says,
ment. Engineers and technicians were able to have hands-on “What we’ve got here is [a] failure to communicate.” Utilities
time with the latest smart grid equipment have started adding community outreach to their smart me-
ter deployments. To paraphrase the Department of Energy’s
Education and Acceptance “Smart Grid: An Introduction” report, the education of all the
Unfortunately, utilities have not worked as hard at educat- interested members of the public is critical to the success of
ing their customers. The industry may understand the tech- the smart grid implementation.
nology, but the end user does not. This is changing as utilities Driving home the point, a Harris poll found that two-thirds
4,000
3,524
Annual consumption (kWh)
2,000
1,462
1,500
1,079 950 940
1,000
503
500 318 313
120 90
0
pu op
at e
ye es
he s
A/ om
e
pu p
g
TV lor
at er
as e
C al
r
he pac
ac
m to
r
to
in
te
er
dr oth
w loth
te
he at
er
m kt
r
A/ ntr
Co
Ro
ht
C
rn
s
r
co Lap
ra
W
co es
S
Lig
Ce
Fu
Cl
ge
C
D
fri
Re
Appliance
Average U.S. household annual electrical use for common appliances. Courtesy of the U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Information Administration.
!
®
,011')'16
1&+1#/+1',+)
,+$#/#+!#+"5-,0'1',+,+/+0*'00',++"
'01/' 21',+
,+01/2!1',+-#/1',++"'3#'+#'+1#++!#,$
1&#,/)"80,4#/#)'3#/6601#*0
*%#0!,2/1#06,$/,3'"#+!#
/4'!(
(6)'+#
/'++#/,07(,
'01&#-/#*'#/#3#+1$,/#)#!1/'!21')'16'+"201/6-/,
$#00',+)0!,+1/!1'+%!,+01/2!1',++"!,+02)1'+%!,*-+'#04&,
/#'+1#/#01#"'+1&#&+"0,++"(+,4)#"%# 0#"0,)21',+0$,/
#+%'+##/'+%!,+01/2!1',+,-#/1',++"*'+1#++!#,$1,/)"80
-,4#/"#)'3#/60601#*0
! "
'+!)2"#0 ,1&++",,/+"21",,/5-,0'1',+
/#+"1#!&+'!)-/,%/*1&1'0"#0'%+#"1,-/#-/#
-,4#/"#)'3#/6-/,$#00',+)0$,/1&#!&+%#01&1)'#&#"
&/,2%&'+"'3'"2)--#/-/#0#+11',+0+"%/,2--+#)
0#00',+01#!&+'!)-/,%/*4'))#5*'+#
+#4*#1&,"0$,/,-#/1'+%+"*'+1'+'+%-,4#/"#)'3#/6
0601#*01-#()#3#)0
&#,21",,/#5&' '1+""#*,+01/1',+/#0#10
-/1$/,*,1&#/#3#+10'+1&#'+"201/6&#,21",,/
-,/1',+,$1&##3#+1$#12/#0!,+01/2!1',+1#!&+,),%'#00$#16"#*,+01/1',+0
,-#/1',+0!1'3'1'#0/'%&10,$46*+%#*#+11#!&+'.2#0)'3#)'+#"#*,+
01/1',+0+"#.2'-*#+1+"$#.2'-*#+1"'0-)6/#21",,/
-/1'!'-+104')),$$#/$'/01&+"3'#4,$2+'.2#4,/(-/,!#"2/#0+"
*1#/')1#01'+%#%'01#/+,41
444#0*,!,+$#/#+!#!,*
&,"#0)+"'0-!(#"4'1& *')#0,$!,01)'+#+"-#/!#+1,$1&#
!,2+1/680&'01,/'!)+"*/(0#4-,/1'01�')'+%!-'1),$1,/)"&,*#
1,1&#$*#"')"#"%#*+0',+0/,3'"#+!#80!#)# /1#"/#012/+10
4/"4'++'+%1/#+"3' /+1/100!#+#'0#+&+!#" 6+#) ,/1#
/'3#/4)(),!(0)+"80+12/) #216 #!(,+06,21,2+4'+"&#/6,2
!&,,0#,21&
,2+1680-/'01'+# #!ڐ*%+'$'!#+1!,01)
'(#46$,,101#-01&/,2%&&'01,/6'+)!(01,+#))#6,/0&,--'+%'+
/4'!(6,2))#5-#/'#+!#21&#+1'!&,"#0)+",/*,/#'+$,/*1',+%,
1,
4443'0'1/&,"#'0)+"!,*
!"
)/53".%3/'54*,*4902/'&33*/.",3'2/-4)&7/2,%7*%&&,&$42*$54*,*49
*.%53429"2&&80&$4&%4/$/.6&2(&*.2/6*%&.$&)/%&3,".%
'/24)&/7&2.&2(9 /$*&49;3
4).4&2."4*/.",/.'&2&.$&
/.!2".3-*33*/.*342*#54*/./.3425$4*/.0&2"4*/.".%*6&*.&
"*.4&.".$&
!)&$/.'&2&.$&02/(2"-30".3'/52%"93'&"452*.(47/%"93/'/54
%//2<&,%%&-/.342"4*/.3&8)*#*43".%"47/%"94&$).*$",02/(2"-
$/-#*.&%7*4)".*.%//2&8)*#*4"2&"
34)&)/3454*,*49/'
"4*/.",2*%7*,,)/,%",,/54%//2
"$4*6*4*&3"4",/$"4*/.*./24)*.(34/7.)/%&3,".%44&.%&&3
7*,,&80&2*&.$&,*6&,*.&%&-/.342"4*/.3$/.3425$4*/.4&$).*15&3
3"'&49%&-/.342"4*/.3/0&2"4*/.3"$4*6*4*&32*()4/'7"9-"."(&
-&.44&$).*15&3".%&15*0-&.4")&"69&15*0-&.4%*30,"9"2&"".%
"6"2*&49/'/54%//2%*30,"93
/''&232&",7/2,%3/,54*/.34/
0/7&2%&,*6&2902/#,&-3"0&23".%
0".&,3&33*/.3"2&#&*.(/2(".*:&%#9
*.%53429&80&243)*(),*()4*.("%6".$&
-&.43*.4)*33&(-&.4/'4)&&,&$42*$
0/7&2*.%53429
/4&,&3&26"4*/.344&.%&&3$".
-"+&4)&*2)/4&,2&3&26"4*/.3/.,*.&
#96*3*4*.(4)&7*4&/2'524)&2
%&4"*,3"44&.%&&3"2&*.6*4&%4/$",,5,,3&9&.4&2."4*/.",
2/50.$"4
/2'"8
The Network is Essential to Making
The Smart Grid a Reality.
TIA ����: INSIDE Benefit from the Seize New Learn From Smart
THE NETWORK Convergence Opportunities Grid Leaders
is your opportunity to of Three Key UNDERSTAND THE DATA DON BOWMAN,
reach the architects of the Communities AND COMMUNICATIONS Manager of
next generation smart grid MOBILE � FIXED LINE
REQUIREMENTS of Engineering,
communications network. independent utility firms, Wake EMC
NETWORK OPERATORS� utility cooperatives and
including rural telcos, public power organizations ED DAVALOS,
Investor owned utilities, cooperatives, rural cellular Director, Product
public power & energy carriers and ISPs—with HEAR FROM LEADING Management
firms, utility cooperatives, the track record to WIRELESS AND Utility/
provide reliable, robust, BROADBAND NETWORK Smart Grid, AT&T
meter manufacturers, secure and ubiquitous OPERATORS about the
infrastructure owners, communications. design, deployment COLMAN KEANE,
wireless network operators and maintenance Director, Fiber
COMMUNICATIONS Technology, EPB
and any firm involved of advanced Utility
NETWORK EQUIPMENT Communications Networks Electric Power
in the intersection of SUPPLIERS �
telecom and energy INTEGRATORS�with FORGE PARTNERSHIPS BRIAN HUEY,
will be in attendance. leading edge access, core with local utilities and Strategy and
and grid technologies. energy distribution firms Business
Development,
GRID OPERATORS�looking EXPLORE THE NEW M2M Smart Grid, Oil
for technology solutions BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES and Gas, Sprint
and local partnerships for infrastructure owners,
to build private or OEMs, consultants PAUL MAULDIN,
public AMI networks. and contractors Senior Editor,
Smart Grid,
UNDERSTAND THE Transmission
POLICY AND REGULATORY & Distribution
FRAMEWORK driving
grid communications
and data management
Register Today at
www.tiaonline.org/ MAY �����, ����
DALL A S, TEX A S
registration. www.tia2011.org
smartGrid
100.5
ing of the smart grid. More than 79% of the respondents in
100.0 the United States and 72% in Australia were not at all familiar
with the term. Also, more than two-thirds of those claiming
Percent registration
99.5 knowledge of the term did not know if their homes were con-
99.0 nected to a smart grid.
>Get
from your transmission insulator system
A COMPLETE RANGE of
Equipment and Services
from the Structure to
the Conductor
RELIABILITY
28 Million Years of Installed Service Life
Field Tested for More than 25 Years
3.8 Million Units Installed at HV & EHV Levels
I N N O V AT I O N
First to Offer Redundant Sealing System
Longest Silicone Insulator Experience in U.S.
Patented Stacked Shed Design
SUPPORT
Complete Insulator & Hardware Assemblies
Highest Level of Technical Support
Custom Packaging & Tower Packs
ENGINEERING
Cost & Lead-time Saving Alternatives
Engineered Solutions for Assured Fit & Function
E-Field & Mechanical Load Modeling APEX FAMILY OF SOLUTIONS:
Transmission Suspension
>
Transmission Line Posts
Braced Post Assemblies
DOWNLOAD FREE WHITE PAPERS AT APEXINSULATORS.COM including Transmission Assemblies
“The Effect of High Temperature Conductors on Composite Suspension Insulator Performance” EHV Assemblies
Solid state
Itron 4 information, and they want innovative
Landis+Gyr
technology that is intuitive, too.”
Sensus 3
IBM announced it will invest rough-
2 ly US$1 billion in energy and environ-
1 ment solutions. IBM’s consumer re-
5 0 search has shown that roughly 31% of
residential and small commercial cus-
4 tomers fall into the passive ratepayer
Electomechanical
tive displays explaining exactly what the smart grid is and why No Turning Back
it is the future. The Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) recently
Gary Rackliffe, ABB’s vice president of smart grid, said, published a white paper titled “Accuracy of Digital Electric
“ABB introduced customer-side smart grid technology in Meters.” EPRI has found the transition from the electrome-
RTDS Technologies Inc. | 100-150 Innovation Drive | Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada R3T 2E1
Tel: 204.989.9700 Fax: 204.452.4303 | Email: rtds@rtds.com | Web: http://www.rtds.com
Refrigeration
11%
EIA commercial electricity consumption, 2008. EIA electricity end-user breakdown, 2009.
Query Available AER (via web service) Report Available AER (via web service)
AER area A
Query available DR Check status Report available DR
AER area B Check status of all sites Check status of all sites Report status of
listed as available for DR listed as available for DR available sites
Tagged control sites
client A and/or B
Non-responsive Query available Query available Report available
DR Responding sites Responding sites
Web service send status send status
Sophisticated energy management systems like this Active Energy Response (AER) program allow an organization to monitor its energy con-
sumption in real time across a large number of locations and control their loads. Courtesy of Verisae.
tially. Verisae aggregates all of the client’s facilities by web- As of mid-2010, Google had partnerships with 10 utilities
based technology to track energy consumption and control — seven in the United States, one in Canada, one in Germany
their loads in real time.” and one in India — to help customers conserve power. Enel
has roughly 32 million smart meters installed in Italian house-
Disruptive Technology or Killer Apps holds and is talking with Google about a PowerMeter app for
The C&I sector did not wait for utilities to develop ener- Enel customers.
gy management programs, and there is a good chance the Microsoft also sees opportunity in this marketplace. Its
residential sector will not, either. Google’s energy tool Power- Hohm website makes it easy for anyone in the United States
Meter is poised to either be independent of utilities or partner to figure out how energy efficient their homes are. Presently,
with them. It is a competitive environment. Once customers the Hohm website gives an approximate evaluation of the cus-
realize the data is theirs, competition will drive the issue as it tomer’s house, but Microsoft’s goal is to have devices feed data
has in so many other industries. After all, PowerMeter is a free to the Hohm app for real-time analysis.
opt-in service that gathers information from residential smart Cisco has developed an interesting approach to customer
meters — Itron is a partner with Google — and other in-home energy efficiency with its Network Building Mediator. The sys-
energy management hardware. The consumer can see real- tem aggregates data from sensors in heating, lighting, ventila-
time electricity usage data over the Internet. tion and air conditioning systems. It is designed with any-to-
In 2010, Siemens took on the challenge of smart grid education. The smart grid tour was the smart grid meets IMAX with a state-of-the-art video
projection scheme on a geodesic-dome combining interactive demos and displays. Photos by Gene Wolf.
any connectivity offering end-to-end energy management for director of corporate marketing for Trilliant. “This approach
efficiency and conservation. It is an extendable platform using extends from inside the home, out on the feeder and on to
third-party applications and cloud services. the substation. It provides intelligent communications and
Another customer-friendly scheme for the residential advanced metering, and supports demand-response measures.
sector energy management is offered by Tendril. It is a digital- The customer can save on energy costs, and the utility can be
clock-inspired, wall-mounted home energy display called the proactive in responding to events on the system.”
Vision, with a touch screen that shows real-time electricity Cellular carriers also are interested in the smart grid mar-
consumption. ketplace. Many see this as a tremendous growth market, and
Adrian Tuck, CEO of Tendril, compares Vision to the TiVo they are tailoring their services for utilities. AT&T and its part-
for its simplicity and ease of use. The Vision connects to wire- ner SmartSynch are working with Texas–New Mexico Power
less thermostats and other ZigBee-enabled devices. It commu- Co. (TNMP), known for its innovative approach to problem
nicates with the smart meter through ZigBee, too. This gives solving.
the consumer an almost intuitive way to participate in utility In 2009, TNMP installed roughly 10,000 smart meters from
demand-response programs. GE and Elster equipped with SmartSynch SSI modules to com-
municate with AT&T’s cellular service. The smart meter cel-
Utilities Have Apps, Too lular system gives TNMP the ability to read meters every 15
On the utility side, sensors are being installed through- minutes, connect and disconnect remotely, and receive real-
out the distribution grid, collecting real-time two-way data time notification of outages.
between the utility and the customer. Companies such as BPL “Using a cellular solution just makes sense,” said Allan
Global, Capgemini, Oracle, Silver Spring Networks, Smart- Burke, director of REP relations for TNMP. “AT&T has the
Synch and Trilliant are providing utilities enterprise-wide infrastructure in place, and TNMP doesn’t need to spend its
systems that allow them to manage, transfer and store data. money developing something that is already available. The
Utilities using the technology can control transmission and cost is very attractive [about $0.50/meter per month].”
distribution power flows, reduce peak power demand and “The yearlong pilot project proved so successful — a
communicate across multiple stakeholder platforms. 99.96% average daily read rate — that TNMP plans to deploy
“The customer and the distribution system are being the system to its entire customer base once PUC approval is
integrated. It is an end-to-end approach,” said Brian Jenkins, received,” Burke added.
Energi Fyn is in the final stages of a smart meter multi- ible and responsive to the needs of customers, while provid-
energy deployment that includes not only electricity, but ing utilities with operational efficiency and the ability to op-
heat and water, too. The enhanced customer services scheme timize assets. Where demand response once meant shedding
consists of fiber-optic communications and Landis+Gyr’s Ad- load, today it includes the ability to shift loads and even shape
vanced Metering Management system and meters. Energi loads.
Fyn reports high customer satisfaction with the system, which Electricity is no longer a passive purchase, either. Custom-
played a key role in deciding to expand the scheme to entire ers are involved as active participants in the electric market-
customer base. place, where choice means real-time pricing, peak-time re-
bates and critical peak pricing.
Where to Go From Here Independent third-party entrants (energy service compa-
The grid is getting smarter whether utilities like it or not. nies) are offering customer-centric services to the residential
It is evolving into an electrical grid that is interactive, flex- sector. Legacy utilities must become more customer focused,
flexible and efficient, or they risk their
customer base switching to more in-
From the Ground Up
novative entities offering value-added
kept to a minimum.
Made in the USA
© 2011 BURNDY LLC
The same logic is true for your operations. Transmission costs are more accurately
determined with empirical line rating information. Vegetation management is more
efficient with real-world ROW data. And safety is better assured when clearances are
based on “as built” evidence.
Let us show you how we can create a customized solution that brings together
engineering, vegetation and asset management, transmission systems, customer
support and distribution management under a single integrated platform.
Find out why URMC is a trusted advisor to utilities. Call Utility Risk Management
Corporation on call 866-931-8762 or drop us a line at info@utilityrisk.com
1 Identify: Thermal Line Rating get the facts
URMC’s proprietary and patented technology uses full waveform
airborne LiDAR, GPS, inertial navigation, GIS, PLS-CADD and other
innovative engineering technologies to map all objects within the right
of way. Identifying encroachments that impact safety and reliability is
crucial – items like street lights and distribution underbuild, are just
as important as tree locations. Knowing the precise location of points
of interest provides you with a complete inventory of your assets.
Negative Growth Only URMC can analyze the survey point clearance data finding
0 – 1ft all potential points of interest while analyzing the growth and
1ft – 2ft
2ft – 3ft
encroachment of every crown on or near the ROW…with limb-specific,
3ft – 4ft centimeter-level accuracy…in three dimensions…for every tree…and
4ft use this information to predict future work.
You can use the same datasets to budget for capital improvements,
maintenance and other internal requirements, helping you meet NERC
standards for a fully compliant Transmission Program. Using URMCs
powerful; engineering analytics allows you to minimize expenses and
maximize the value of your capital assets
Knowledge is Power ™
Find out why URMC is a trusted advisor.
Contact URMC at 866-931-8762 or info@utilityrisk.com
www.utilityrisk.com
MOBILEGrid
Electric Vehicles
Charge Ahead
Under the mobile smart grid concept,
electric vehicles will give and get.
By Else Veldman, André Postma and Han Slootweg, Enexis B.V.; Madeleine Gibescu,
Delft University of Technology; and Wil L. Kling, Eindhoven University of Technology
R
oad transportation equipped with conventional of renewable energy resources (for example, wind power
combustion engines is responsible for a significant and solar energy), but the intermittent output characteristics
share of carbon-dioxide emissions and polluting limit the optimal use of these resources and complicate their
cities with fine dust. On the contrary, electric vehi- integration into the power system. The flexible load of elec-
cles are environmentally cleaner and more efficient than con- tric vehicles can use the electricity produced when available,
ventional cars, even when all the energy losses from the power thereby supporting a high penetration of intermittent renew-
plant to the electric vehicle are taken into consideration. able energy generators. Furthermore, electric vehicles need to
The depletion of fossil fuel reserves is stimulating the use be regularly recharged, offering storage capacity that creates
350 200
300
Load Load
Current (amperes)
150
Current (amperes)
100 50
50
0
0 0 5 10 15 20
0 5 10 15 20
Time (hours) Time (hours)
The average load profile and capacity of a medium-voltage trans- The average load profile and capacity of a medium-voltage distribu-
mission cable in Limburg. tion cable (fed by a medium-voltage transmission cable) in Limburg.
the opportunity to transfer more energy through the distribu- ing distribution network to determine how this can be used to
tion network by using the surplus load-transfer potential of support charging electric vehicles through the introduction of
the existing network. the mobile smart grid, which also will have to include second-
When managed intelligently, it is possible for the network ary systems to control the flexible loads.
to both supply the additional energy demand for electric
vehicles and cope with intermittent energy production from Topology and Operation of Medium-Voltage Networks
renewable energy resources. To achieve this optimal approach, The design of medium-voltage (MV) networks in the Neth-
the distribution network must have sufficient capacity for the erlands comprises a (regional) distribution network supplied
additional load and be equipped with the secondary systems by high-voltage (HV) to MV substations. Typical primary
for communication and control. voltages of HV/MV transformers are 220 kV, 150 kV, 110 kV or
Enexis, a distribution network operator in the Netherlands, 50 kV; secondary voltages include 25 kV, 20 kV and 10 kV.
has analyzed the available capacity on a section of the exist- The design of the MV network is normally based on the
www.vaisala.com
sales@vaisala.com
Load (%)
150 Situation 3
MV transmission networks and MV distribution feeders,
designed to operate as open rings. 100
MV transmission networks normally satisfy the n-1 cri-
teria, which establishes system firm capacity whereby no 50
load is lost when one of the cables in a parallel circuit
0
is isolated because of a system fault or for maintenance 0 50 100 150 200
work. Number of cables
CG Power Solutions covers the full range. Of the more than 100 EHV
substation and T-line projects we’ve completed, many have involved
voltages as high as 765kv. And that’s something not many—if any—
other engineering/EPC firms can say. Whatever the voltage may be,
CG Power Solution’s unmatched technical competence enables us to
bring your project on-line following your unique
specifications, on time (or sooner) and on budget.
For a look at the step-by-step process we apply to
EHV challenges, visit cgpowersolutions.com/ehvtd or
call 800.426.0333. Formerly MSE Power Systems
MOBILEGrid
vehicles). It is assumed the additional load is as equally spread supplied with only a limited need for further investment in
over the network as the load in the first situation. grid capacity. This is in contrast with the design of the exist-
The results presented that in the first situation, the peak ing grid, which traditionally is based on peak load forecasts.
load current on a few cables and transformers exceeded the Flexible loads offer the opportunity to use the extra capacity
nominal, continuously allowable current. Because of the rela- that is already available in the existing grid but is currently
tively long thermal time constants in the cables and transform- not used.
ers, this is currently not a problem.
In the third situation, the peak load current in 14 of the The Mobile Smart Grid Concept
228 cables and in 88 of the 187 transformers exceeded the To be able to use the surplus capacity, or hidden poten-
nominal, continuously allowable current. Therefore, to use tial, of existing grids for electric vehicles and intermittent re-
the surplus grid capacity, some of the MV cables and MV/LV newable energy sources, a control strategy is needed. Enexis
transformers would need to be upgraded. is introducing the mobile smart grid concept. This concept
The network load analyses confirm that the existing MV includes data collection from the flexible loads, on the basis of
networks have surplus capacity that could be made available which a loading schedule can be determined, taking into ac-
to supply flexible loads. Electric cars are flexible, not time- count customer preferences, local grid capacity, and the actual
critical, loads that can be disconnected from the network or and forecast availability of electrical energy generators.
adjusted to a lower power when required. However, to opti- An adequate communication structure, such as the Inter-
mally use this capacity, these loads should be coupled to the net, must support the flow of information needed for intel-
grid and operated in an intelligent way. ligent charging of electric cars (that is, adjusting the loads
to the fluctuating in-feed at the distribution network (decen-
Charging Electric Vehicles tralized generation) without a car owner experiencing any
If flexible loads, such as electric vehicles, could be con- inconvenience).
trolled in such a way the load is optimized throughout the day, The loading schedules of the electric vehicles can be ad-
the capacity of the existing networks can be used more effi- justed when extra electrical energy is available or when service
ciently and more energy can be transported. Electric cars can interruptions occur. It should also be possible to slow down
be charged during off-peak load periods when the demand is the charging speed of the electric vehicles in case of emergen-
low, and in this way, the increased electricity demand can be cies on the MV transmission network to prevent interruptions.
Acknowledgement
The colleagues of the regional asset manage-
ment department of Enexis are acknowledged
for their cooperation and availability of the data
provided.
They’re not concerned about the dependability of their power supply. That’s your
responsibility.
With the power of DOW INSIDE you can count on reliability and long
cable life based on exceptional materials, dedicated R&D, deep industry knowledge,
and close working relationships with cable manufacturers and utilities alike. And,
with the DOW ENDURANCE™ family of products from Dow Wire & Cable for MV,
HV and EHV cables, you can now specify cables that exceed industry performance
standards and are built to last for decades of service.
That’s the confidence you need when it’s your job to keep the power on.
www.dowinside.com
®™Trademark of The Dow Chemical Company Dow Wire & Cable is a global business unit of The Dow Chemical Company and its subsidiaries.
DISTRIBUTIONPlanning
T
he U.S. electric grid has several challenges to over-
come for continuous delivery of uninterrupted
power. Critical needs include the upgrade or replace-
ment of aging electrical infrastructure, increased NaS battery
intelligence and communication between components on the location
Zone 4
electric grid, and increased reliability of power for electric cus-
tomers. In addition, the increasing desire for renewable en- Zone 3
ergy places challenges on grid operators as these sources of
energy are intermittent. Accurate prediction of their availabil- Zone 2
ity is difficult, and curtailment of their output may be needed Zone 1
to keep grid frequency stable.
Energy storage has been identified as a means to address Remotely controlled switch
Remotely controlled recloser
some of these issues. However, determining an economical-
ly viable and technically sound solution has proven elusive. Islanding zones at AEP’s Churubusco, Indiana, NaS deployment.
American Electric Power (AEP) has researched several energy
storage technologies to determine which technologies can reduced the oil temperature of the associated substation trans-
help overcome certain electric grid challenges. former. This energy storage system was successful in deferring
the need to build a new substation.
The First Large-Scale NaS Battery Load leveling provides one of the largest cost benefits for
In 2006, AEP deployed the first utility-grid scale sodium- energy storage systems on the distribution portion of the elec-
sulfur (NaS)-based energy storage system in the United States, tric grid because it allows capital deferral of upgrading or re-
near Charleston, West Virginia. A 1-MW, 7.2-MWh NaS bat- placing substation electrical equipment. However, this benefit
tery was deployed. In its first three years of operation, the may not be enough to completely cover the cost of deploying
battery provided approximately 1 MW of load leveling during an energy storage system.
hot summer days, improved the feeder load factor by 5% and To fully rationalize the cost of deploying energy storage
systems, benefits have to be realized
from several applications of the tech-
nology. In addition to load leveling
for capital deferral, these benefits
include providing backup power, en-
ergy arbitrage, system frequency reg-
ulation, the reduction of system losses
and the integration of renewable
sources of energy. Most of these ben-
efits compete for the same energy and
power out of the battery, so analyses
have to be performed to prioritize the
benefits, and some energy allocation
may be necessary for the applications
chosen to be deployed.
RITZGLAS® Hotstick
3033B
DISTRIBUTIONPlanning
Load Leveling
The CES units will be aggregated by a control hub at the
substation to provide load-leveling benefit to the associated
station transformer. The successful demonstration of this ben-
John Mandeville, senior engineering technologist for AEP, tests a
efit will show that these systems can be used for capital defer- prototype of the community energy storage battery system.
ral of equipment upgrade or replacement. A couple of differ-
ent schemes will be used for load leveling: ligent method for load leveling involves using time of day as a
● Schedule-based load leveling. Using this method, utilities trigger for load leveling. At a specific time of day, a determina-
can simply perform load research analysis to determine a tion is made on the necessity to perform load leveling. If the
start time and choose a discharge schedule to perform load load is at or above a set level, load leveling will be performed
leveling. on that day. This benefits the battery because a discharge will
● Time-triggered load leveling. A more complex yet more intel- not occur on a low-peak day, thus extending the life of the
battery by requiring fewer battery cycles and reserving more viding inductive and capacitive power. The ability to provide
energy to provide backup power to customers. Load studies capacitive support has great benefits to the electric grid. Most
will need to be performed to determine both the time to ana- utility loads and power lines are inductive in nature, and sig-
lyze the need for load leveling and the actual time to start load nificant levels of these inductive loads can cause voltage-drop
leveling, which may differ. concerns. Today, most utilities use capacitor banks to counter-
balance these inductive loads. CES units will be able to pro-
Power Factor Correction vide the capacitive support to counter these inductive loads
The last benefit that will be demonstrated during the CES and enable the distribution system to run more efficiently.
project is the ability to provide capacitive support to the elec-
tric grid. The CES units will use four-quadrant inverters ca- Next Steps
pable of discharging and charging real power and also pro- AEP Ohio’s CES project is expected to be deployed and
monitored through December 2013.
Metrics are being developed to ascer-
tain the benefits the CES units provide
to the distribution system and will be
KNOWLEDGE IS POWER. reported to the DOE as part of the
Get LumaSMART.
project.
E S TA B L I S H E D 1959
800-433-1816 W W W. F W T I N C . C O M
TRANSMISSIONLines
B
razil is already South America’s largest consumer Having abundant river resources, Brazil currently relies
of electric power, but over the next 10 years, the on hydroelectric power to satisfy approximately 85% of its
nation’s demand for electricity is projected to in- electricity consumption. However, much of those resources
crease by 50%, according to Energy Minister Edison are situated a considerable distance from where the power
Lobão. Accommodating that demand will require the addi- is needed most, in the rapidly growing southeastern portion
tion of some 51,000 MW in generating capacity. Although it of the country, which includes the heavily populated states of
is possible current global financial problems might alter this São Paulo, Minas Gerais and Rio de Janeiro.
projection downward to some extent, meeting any target even To meet the challenge of keeping pace with Brazil’s grow-
close to that figure poses an enormous challenge for Brazil’s ing demand for electricity, it will be necessary not only to add
utility industry. a great deal of generating capacity, but also to make distri-
bution and transmission as efficient as possible.
Hundreds of new power lines and substations
nationwide are planned for the coming years,
many of which are already under construction,
and existing lines will be improved to remove or
minimize bottlenecks.
Power problems
can cost you time Go to www.HiddenPowerProblems.com
and see what your electrical system may be hiding.
and money.
A computer locks up. Lights flicker.
A motor overheats. Just random
events? They could be signs of power
problems—which can cause costly
downtime, data loss, excess power
consumption, and equipment repair
and replacement. Problems no one
can afford.
Learn how to recognize the
symptoms of power related problems
and discover our easy-to-use Fluke
power quality tools, information
resources, and training. With them,
you can quickly and confidently diag- Fluke. Keeping your world
nose causes, implement solutions, and up and running.®
prevent problems in the future.
©2009, 2011 Fluke Corporation. Ad 3463163A
transmissionLines
POLES
1143 Vanderbilt Road • Birmingham, AL 35234
205.323.2400 • mcwanepoles.com
For more information, e-mail sales@mcwanepoles.com
E N G I N E E R E D S T R E N G T H
phone: 269.945.9541
fax: 269.945.4623
email: hastings@hfgp.com
www.hfgphighvoltage.com
transmissionLines
Genesis of aCCr
3M’s aluminum conductor composite reinforced (ACCR)
had a serendipitous genesis in the 1990s, when the com-
pany’s engineers were experimenting with metal-based
ceramic-reinforced composites for aeronautical applica-
tions. Working with a composite that demonstrated a
strong ability to resist the effects of heat, it occurred to the
engineers that such a quality could be useful to the electric
utility industry by reducing heat-induced sag on overhead
transmission lines.
The innovative product that emerged from that idea
was a conductor composed of a ceramic fiber-reinforced
aluminum core wrapped in aluminum-zirconium wires.
Basic feasibility testing began in the late 1990s. Less heat-
induced sag was only one of its potential benefits. The
Linemen have released the new ACCR conductor from the stringing high conductivity of aluminum combined with the metal’s
blocks and are in the process of installing the support and attaching it
to the insulator string. relatively light weight suggested the experimental product
could carry more power than conventional steel conduc-
A Conductor Alternative tors while using the same infrastructure. For line upgrades,
New construction of any kind in the river flood plain would that would mean no tower construction, no additional
have been unwelcome, but exacerbating the problem is the easements and fewer environmental issues.
fact that not only the towers would have to be replaced, but In 2000, 3M proposed a large-scale testing program
also new foundations would have been required. The permit- to the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) and several U.S.
ting process for such a disruptive procedure might have taken utilities. The following year, intrigued by the new conduc-
over a year or more; in fact, it was entirely possible a permit tor’s promise, the DOE began a field test at its Oak Ridge
might never have been granted. National Laboratories, while similar test projects were
ISA CTEEP sought a reliable solution that would have me- inaugurated by Xcel Energy, Hawaiian Electric and Western
chanical properties similar to the existing Oriole ACSR con- Area Power Administration (WAPA) to gather experience in
ductor yet also the electrical current capacity similar to that of a wide range of climate conditions and weather extremes.
the Grosbeak conductor. After searching on the local and in- In 2004, WAPA installed additional test sites in the Arizona
ternational markets and evaluating a limited set of options for desert, Salt River Project began a test installation just out-
the river crossing, the solution of choice was the 3M aluminum side of Phoenix and the Bonneville Power Administration
conductor composite-reinforced (ACCR) conductor. undertook field testing in Washington State.
One of the best benefits of this alternative is that the need- Meanwhile, in August of that same year, Xcel Energy
ed capacity could be achieved without having to replace or decided that four years of successful field testing had
enlarge the towers. The solution, which more than doubles established the new conductor’s dependability and com-
line capacity, is a 300-kcmil ACCR. This new conductor is not mitted to ACCR’s first commercial application — a key
only much lighter than the original conductor, the diameter is 10-mile (16-km) line designed to accommodate peak
smaller at 0.677 inches (17.2 mm). This means the same con- power demand for the Twin Cities area. That line was
ductor that increased line capacity by more than 100% also energized in May 2005, and one month later, WAPA chose
reduced the wind loading on the existing structures by about ACCR to upgrade a 20-mile (32-km) circuit line along the
9%. It allowed the issue of river construction to be avoided Colorado River supplying power to communities in
entirely. Arizona, California and Nevada.
Today, ACCR is in use by more than two dozen U.S.
The Installation utilities and in six other nations, including those with the
For the purpose of the upgrade, the 138-kV line required world’s three fastest-growing economies: Brazil, China and
an increase in capacity from 335 A to 860 A. The ACCR line India.
chosen can be operated up to 1,043 A for continuous opera-
tion at 210°C (410°F) and 1,113 A for emergency operation at
240°C (464°F). The ACCR conductor weighs 36% less than the ing for both ISA CTEEP and contractor employees.
Oriole ACSR that had been in place. Maximum sag and maxi- The process and equipment were similar to that used for
mum horizontal tension would remain essentially the same. installing an ACSR conductor. In fact, the existing ACSR con-
ISA CTEEP’s technical team worked with 3M’s Brazil and ductor was used to pull the ACCR through the existing towers.
U.S. teams to plan and prepare all the logistics for the installa- Following manufacturer’s recommendations for ACCR installa-
tion in February 2009. The installation itself required only six tion techniques, the stringing employed a 59-inch (1,499-mm)
days. The 3M technical team provided pre-construction train- tensioner and 27-inch (686-mm)-diameter stringing blocks on
ACCR conductor on the reel goes through the tensioner and up onto Companies mentioned:
the line during the stringing operation. 3M www.3m.com
suspension towers. Splice and dead-ended connectors were ap- Bonneville Power Administration www.bpa.gov
plied using a 100-ton (91-metric-ton) press. This installation Companhia de Transmissão de Energia Elétrica Paulista
process enabled the tension to remain constant throughout, www.cteep.com.br
avoiding any conductor contact with lower phases. Energy Minister Edison Lobão www.brasil.gov.br
By using this lightweight, high-performance conductor Hawaiian Electric Co. www.heco.com
for the Rio Paraná crossing, ISA CTEEP was able to avoid a Oak Ridge National Laboratories www.ornl.gov
Salt River Project www.srpnet.com
potentially interminable delay, save costs, work with innova-
U.S. Department of Energy www.energy.gov
tive technology on its transmission line and complete a vital
Western Area Power Administration www.wapa.gov
project to help meet the power needs of a growing region. As Xcel Energy www.excelenergy.com
ISA CTEEP and Brazil’s entire utility industry move forward
Customer Engagement
Leads to Lower Costs
United Illuminating’s online system
helps customers understand energy use
and make informed usage decisions.
By Joseph D. Thomas, The United Illuminating Co.
T
he United Illuminating Co. (UI) has faced a variety their electric bills, accommodate time-of-day rates and reduce
of challenges over the last decade. A 1998 restructur- call-center volume. The company deployed the Bill Analysis,
ing law required the New Haven, Connecticut, U.S.- Load and Rates Analysis, and Energy Analysis modules of
based electric utility to sell its electricity generating Aclara’s ENERGYprism software to accomplish its goals.
plants. Starting in 2006, electricity prices
in the ISO–New England wholesale market
began to rise sharply as the price of natural
gas increased. Within two years, primarily
driven by the increase in wholesale power
costs, many of UI’s 324,000 customers had
seen their electric bills nearly double — at
precisely the time when the U.S. economy
was shedding jobs and falling into reces-
sion. At the same time, customers faced
several complex new choices as new rate
structures were introduced and competi-
tors entered the generation services mar-
ket for the first time.
These new laws and regulations brought
rapid change for customers but did little to
address the rising cost and sticker shock.
Electric rates in Connecticut were then,
and remain now, among the highest in the
nation. As of January 2011, UI residential
customers, on average, paid 23.56 cents
per kilowatt-hour, compared with 12.64
cents in 2000.
Barred by law from building new gen-
eration to increase supply, and constrained
by its inability to reduce market prices, UI
instead chose a strategy of helping custom-
ers control their electric bills at the source
— their homes and businesses. UI saw that
by providing customers with more infor-
mation, it could help them make smarter
choices and manage their energy use and
costs. That’s why the utility implemented
Information provided through UI’s web-based dashboard includes graphical representa-
specialized software from Aclara to help tion of on-peak and off-peak energy use as well as a breakdown of electricity costs by func-
customers understand energy use, lower tion or appliance.
Helping Customers
Lower Costs
UI’s customers have little con-
trol over the many external factors
contributing to rising energy costs
and the increase in electric rates.
However, armed with the proper
information, customers can still
find ways to lower their bills by re-
ducing usage, improving efficien-
cy, switching to alternate genera-
tion suppliers and changing usage
behaviors. This approach also can
benefit the regional power grid
by reducing demand during peak
load times.
The software helps customers
reduce consumption in a variety
of ways. Simply being aware of
their electricity costs and usage
can encourage customers to make
smart choices that save money.
Customers also can use the soft-
ware to create energy profiles by
UI customers can perform on-request meter reads to verify correct meter operation and to further entering information about the
analyze usage up to four times per month. specific appliances they own and
learning how each one fits into that customer’s overall energy Pool $107
consumption picture. For example, a customer might use the
Other $93
system to learn how much money could be saved each month
by replacing a 15-year-old refrigerator with a new, energy-effi- Lighting $54
cient unit. Beyond all of the dashboard information, interac- Hot water $39
tive energy-audits and pointers are just a click away. Food storage $31
Cooling $23
Accommodating Time-of-Day Rates
Cooking $21
For more than 40 years, UI has offered time-of-day rates
Heating $3
for residential and commercial customers. Its metering in-
frastructure, which was deployed 10 years ago, enabled the
company to capture and present daily, hourly and 15-minute This detail of the dashboard provides customers who have complet-
interval data to customers where applicable on a daily rather ed an energy audit a breakdown of how they are using energy. The
than monthly basis. This provides customers with an appro- graph makes customers aware of how much they spend for specific
appliances and other energy uses, and helps them to identify areas
priate price signal that enables them to enjoy a slightly lower where they might cut costs.
base rate but pay slightly more during on peak. The idea is to
encourage customers to use appliances or business processes an easy-to-understand graph showing on- and off-peak usage.
that require a lot of electricity — such as dishwashers, clothes In addition, there is a rate calculator to illustrate the impact of
dryers, pool pumps, air conditioners and manufacturing transitioning to time-based rates and how their bills might be
equipment — during off-peak hours, reducing strain on the affected simply by changing behaviors and use patterns. Cus-
electric grid. In 2009, state regulators required any residential tomers also can request an on-demand meter reading to get
customer who uses more than 2,000 kWh in a month to be real-time access to their meter and data usage.
switched to a time-of-day rate.
The portal solution provides helpful tools for customers Reducing Customer Care Center Volume
who are now on, or who recently were switched to, time-based Not surprisingly, the changes in UI’s regulatory environ-
rates. For instance, the My Account dashboard gives customers ment and energy markets led to confusion among customers.
Nordic’s
Cabinet
Collection
Connection Ƚ Tough &
Durable
Ƚ Nordic’s 35kV 600 Amp Fiberglass
cabinets connect each wind lasts for
tower’s power to the substation years!
for a “daisy chain” solution. Ƚ Double
Ƚ Install up to three, 2, 3 or 4 pt. Locking for
35kV 600Amp deadbreak Security
junctions with U-straps.
Ƚ 18” or 36” high extensions
are available for extra
depth for large
cable radius bends.
Weatherization Questions
Please answer these questions about your home. Then click Next to get ways to save for Weatherization. This resulted in additional call volume
How much ceiling or attic insulation?
and extended call times in UI’s Customer
Excellent (12 inches or more)
Care Center. In addition, operating costs
Very Good (9 to12 inches)
increased for the company and often-
Good (6 to 9 inches)
times customers were frustrated due to
Fair (3 to 6 inches)
delays during high-volume periods.
Poor (under 3 inches)
Customers who register with My Ac-
None
count can find answers to many questions
instantly, without picking up the phone
UI’s energy audit asks customers a series of questions about what type of appliances they have and calling the Customer Care Center.
and what measures they have taken to make their homes more efficient. For example, custom- The applications explain details such as
ers are asked how much insulation they have in their homes. Results of the energy audit are
used to help analyze energy use.
non-energy-related charges, how billing
cycles and weather affect total charges,
and more.
UI also implemented an Aclara appli-
cation that gives Customer Care Center
representatives the same kind of infor-
mation customers see online. This makes
representatives call advisors who show
customers how to use the information
we provide to make informed decisions
about how to save on energy costs, rather
than strictly call takers.
Measuring Success
Use of UI’s Web portal has increased
dramatically. Transactions grew from
243,000 in 2007, to 607,000 in 2008, to
962,000 in 2009. That number surged to
nearly 1.3 million transactions in 2010.
Some 60,000 people — about 20% of
UI’s customers — visit the My Account
site on a monthly basis.
Planned enhancements to the website
include additional reporting capabilities
on energy usage. UI also will begin of-
fering customers the chance to sign up
for billing alerts that will tell them when
they’ve passed a certain dollar or usage
threshold. Plus, the company expects to
enhance Aclara’s carbon calculator on
the site to provide consumers with ways
to mitigate the effects of carbon taxes
that are expected in the future. Finally,
within two years, UI expects to integrate
the billing analytics into the bill print
process. This will enable customers still
receiving paper bills to understand why
their energy usage and cost has either
decreased or increased.
There are a variety of additional plans
UI has on the board that include “smart”
technology. By the fourth quarter of
2010, 32,800 new advanced meters were
installed at customer locations. These
meters provide two-way communication
www. TDWorld.com
• Marketing Opportunities
• Production Specifications
• Salesperson Information
• 2011 Media Kit
• 2011 Rates
• Editorial Calendar
• JobZone
Dashiell Corporation
12301 Kurland Drive, Suite 400
Houston, Texas 77034
713-558-6600
Dean Strickland -
VP, Sales
Dashiell Corporation- Dashiell is a unique Engineering,
help wanted
Construction, and Testing company that specializes in
“turnkey” medium and high voltage electrical systems. OverheaD TransmissiOn esTimaTOr
Our capabilities include engineering, design, purch- Hawkeye, LLC is an electrical contractor
asing, project management, construction, testing, and that performs transmission and distribution
start-up. Since 1970, we have successfully completed work for utilities in the New England area.
over 300 high voltage projects (69 kV – 500 kV) for
We are looking for experienced professionals
Industrials, Petrochemicals, Independent Power Producers,
to join our team. Hawkeye has immediate
and Utilities.
opportunities for Overhead Transmission
Estimators at our Portsmouth, NH and
Hauppauge, NY offices.
Responsibilities include:
• Performing all aspects of cost estimate
help wanted and bid preparation
• Attending pre-bid meetings and site
visits
easTern anD WesTern regiOnal • Preparation and maintenance of detailed
managers neeDeD project schedules
• Analyzing job cost and budget reports
Sherman and Reilly, the leader in power • Preparation of look-ahead documents
line stringing and installation equipment and accurate project forecasting
and tools is growing. For over 85 years, • Presenting estimate and reporting to
we’ve provided the Power Industry senior management
the most durable, safe and effective Candidate should have the following
equipment available and we have the experience and abilities:
track record to prove it. We are looking for • A minimum of 3 years experience
bright, energetic and principled people to estimating Overhead Transmission
help take our field sales organization to • A knowledge of distribution estimating
the next level. If you have a proven track • Proficiency in Microsoft Excel, Microsoft
record, 10+ years in the Power Industry, Project and/or Primavera
have demonstrated capability to develop • Must possess excellent written and
productive relationships with reps, utilities verbal skills
and contractors, and frankly like heavy • Must possess excellent interpersonal and
equipment and what it does, we want to organizational skills
hear from you. Your location isn’t critical, Hawkeye, LLC offers a competitive salary,
but we need presence in the Northwest, paid vacations and holidays, excellent
the Northeast and the Southeast. Please health insurance, life insurance, and 401k.
send a letter of introduction and a resume Please send resumes to:
to opportunities@sherman-reilly.com HR@Hawkeyellc.com
recruiting
Aevenia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 64 www.aevenia.com
Alcan Cable . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 www.cable.alcan.com
Midwestern, Mid-Atlantic,
Alcatel-Lucent . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17 www.alcatel-lucent.com
New England, Eastern Canada:
American Hotline LLC . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 53 www.americanhotline.com
Stephen M. Lach
*Arbormetrics Solutions Inc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 64E www.arbormetricssolutions.com 13723 Carolina Lane
Asplundh Tree Expert Co. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . BC www.asplundh.com Orland Park, IL 60462
BBC Fasteners . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 54 Phone: 708-460-5925 Fax: 913-514-9017
Black & Veatch . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 www.bv.com E-mail: steve.lach@penton.com
Burndy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40 www.burndy.com
Burns & McDonnell . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .IBC www.burnsmcd.com Southeastern, Mid-Atlantic,
Cantega Technologies Inc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 74 www.cantega.com New England:
CG Power Solutions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 47 www.cgpowersolutions.com Douglas J. Fix
Doble . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 www.doble.com 590 Hickory Flat Road
Alpharetta, GA 30004
Dow Wire & Cable . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 51 www.dowinside.com
Phone: 770-740-2078 Fax: 770-740-1889
Fah Teeng Industrial . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 67 www.fahteeng.com.tw
E-mail: dfix@bellsouth.net
Fecon . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 www.fecon.com
Fluke Corporation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31 www.fluke.com Southwest:
Fluke Corporation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 59 www.fluke.com Gary Lindenberger
FWT Inc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 57 www.fwtinc.com 7007 Winding Walk Drive, Suite 100
GarrettCom . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 www.garrettcom.com Houston, TX 77095
GE Digital Energy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21 www.gedigitalenergy.com Phone: 281-855-0470 Fax: 281-855-4219
General Physics Corp . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 49 www.gpworldwide.com E-mail: gl@lindenassoc.com
Gita . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 69 www.gita.org
West/Western Canada:
Hastings. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 61 www.hfgphighvoltage.com
Ron Sweeney
*Hubbell Power Systems Inc.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 64k www.hubbellpowersystems.com
303 Johnston Drive
Hubbell Power Systems Inc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 www.hubbellpowersystems.com San Rafael, CA 94903
Hughes Brothers Inc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 68 www.hughesbros.com Phone: 415-499-9095 Fax: 415-499-9096
*Huskie Tools Inc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1a www.huskietools.com E-mail: wnjsr@comcast.net
Hyundai Heavy Industries Co. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 41 www.hyundai-elec.com
IEEE/ ESMO . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32a/b www.esmoconference2011.com Craig Zehntner
IEEE/Smart Grid . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 www.mc.manuscriptcentral.com 15981 Yarnell Street, Suite 230
ISA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 www.isatest.com Los Angeles, CA 91342
Krenz & Co. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .38-39 www.krenzvent.com Phone: 818-403-6379 Fax: 818-403-6436
LumaSense Technologies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 56 www.lunasenseinc.com E-mail: wnjla@aol.com
MacLean Power Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35 www.apex@macleanpower.com
Western/Eastern Europe:
Maysteel . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20 www.trinetics.maysteel.com
Richard Woolley
McWane Poles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 60 www.mcwanepoles.com P.O. Box 250
Merrick & Co. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 71 www.merrick.com Banbury, OXON, OX16 5YJ UK
NLMCC/NECA-IBEW . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 www.thequalityconnection.org Phone: 44-1295-278-407
Nordic Fiberglass Inc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 67 www.nordicfiberglass.com Fax: 44-1295-278-408
Omicron Electronics Corp. USA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25 www.omicronusa.com E-mail: richardwoolley@btclick.com
*Osmose Utilities Services. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 64o www.osmoseutilities.com
Phenix Technologies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 www.phenixtech.com Japan:
Power Engineers Inc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 www.powereng.com Yoshinori Ikeda
PowerSense A/S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 72 www.sensethepower.com Akutagawa Bldg., 7-7,
Nihonbashi Kabutocho,
Quanta Services . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 www.quantaservices.com
Chuo-ku, Tokyo 103-0026, Japan
*Rainbow Technology Corp. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 70a www.rainbowtech.net Phone: 81-3-3661-6138
*Rainbow Technology Corp. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 70b www.rainbowtech.net Fax: 81-3-3661-6139
RTDS Technologies Inc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36 www.rtds.com E-mail: pbi2010@gol.com
S&C Electric Co. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IFC www.sandc.com
Safe Engineering Services. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 71 www.sestech.com Korea:
Schweitzer Engineering Labs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 www.selinc.com Y.B. Jeon
Sensorlink . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 www.sensorlink.com Storm Associates Inc.
*Sherman & Reilly Inc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 64b www.sherman-reilly.com 4F. Deok Woo Building
*Siemens AG . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1B www.siemens.com 292-7, Sung-san dong, Ma-po ku,
Seoul, Korea
StressCrete Group . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 73 www.stresscretegroup.com
Phone: 82-2-755-3774
TDW Vegetation Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 63 www.tdworld.com
Fax: 82-2-755-3776
TIA 2011. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33 www.tia2011.org E-mail:stormybj@kornet.net
Time Mfg. Co./Versalift . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34 www.versalift.com
URMC . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .42-43 www.utilityrisk.com Classified Sales:
*Utilicon Solutions Ltd. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 64m www.utiliconltd.com Susan Schaefer
*Utilicon Solutions Ltd./AETCO . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 64i www.99aetco.com 870 Wyndom Terrace
Vaisala OY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 45 www.vaisala.com Secane, PA 19018
Phone: 484-478-0154
Fax: 913-514-6417
*Denotes ads appearing in only certain geographic areas.
E-mail: susan.schaefer@penton.com
Transmission & Distribution World (ISSN 1087-0849) is published once monthly by Penton Media Inc., 9800 Metcalf Ave., Overland Park, Kansas
66212-2216 U.S. Periodicals postage paid at Shawnee Mission, Kansas, and additional mailing offices. Canadian Post Publications Mail Agreement No.
40612608. Canada return address: Pitney Bowes-International, P.O. Box 25542, London, ON N6C 6B2.
POSTMASTER: Send address changes to Transmission & Distribution World, P.O. Box 2100, Skokie, Illinois 60076-7800 U.S.
I
have a case of demand-side déjà vu. For those of us who ally listen to customers to find out what their energy interests
have been in the utility industry for many years, the current and concerns might be.
focus on energy efficiency and demand reduction is remi- Recent criticisms on smart meter billing from customers
niscent of the early 1980s. Time-of-use rates and energy-use in Texas and California show that we need to do more work
advisors were common in many utility companies as energy in connecting with customers in our energy dealings. And
prices soared. A major problem with the acceptance of these despite many state regulatory commissions requiring energy-
rates was that residential customers only had data after they efficiency programs of utilities for 30 years, few consumers
received the bill. Too late to matter. take advantage of these programs, even though utilities pro-
Fast-forward to 2011. Thankfully, the tools that will aid con- mote them as required. Before consumers’ behaviors change,
sumers to manage usage have appeared on the scene. There is they will have to understand “What’s in it for me?”
a lot of data available with smart meters and smart grid imple- Two straightforward customer gains would be to save mon-
mentations, but how does our industry turn that data into an ey on their electric bill and to help the environment because a
essential element for success — demand response? person is motivated to “do the right thing.” Only after under-
The challenge is to turn that data into knowledge for con- standing their benefit will they want to know how and when to
sumers and have that equate to demand and usage reductions. make changes in their consumption habits.
According to the Edison Foundation, it is estimated there will To move communication forward with customers, it comes
be 60 million smart meters installed in the United States by down to having a well-designed smart grid customer experi-
2019. Smart grid funding from U.S. Department of Energy ence strategy that requires three key elements:
grants is pouring millions more into the development and Education. We need to move customers from “I’m not ready”
implementation of the myriad of devices and systems that will to “Yes, I will.” Then answer their “What’s in it for me?” ques-
build out the utility electric systems with sophisticated tech- tions on demand-response and energy-efficiency programs.
nologies. Most industry experts agree that, done properly, Enrollment. Customers need to understand the reasons,
these systems should save utilities money in operations while whether societal or economic, to change behaviors. They need
leading to improved reliability. to know the what, when and how details before they change.
Our customers would gain significant value from our in- Partnership. Ongoing support is required to successfully
vestments in smart grid if they participate by reducing energy manage energy use tailored to individual customer needs.
use and embrace load shifting. I’ve read dozens of articles that Proactive and two-way communications of pricing and new
encourage utilities to change their relationship with their rate- programs is critical.
payers. But what should we do to engage consumers in this Today, the bulk of consumers are in the education phase.
future? I propose utilities implementing smart grid must Providing them the education to move to enrollment, rather
change their relationship with consumers. than blanketing all customers with enrollment data, which is
No longer ratepayers, customers will chose to partner with costly and ineffective, will allow more customers to move into
the utility when it suits their needs. This new paradigm will the “Yes, I will” segment in a cost-effective manner and on to a
not come easy to most utilities. In fact, I see a few leading- partnership with the utility.
edge exceptions, including Com Ed with its customer-centric The process of moving consumers through these phases is
program and San Diego Gas & Electric with its customer com- the essence of an overall long-term consumer smart grid com-
munications programs. munications program and it will take time. Let’s not déjà vu
As change management experts will stress, before behav- now that we are 30 years smarter and have the tools through
ior changes can occur, understanding must occur. Many con- smart grid implementations to develop partnerships with cus-
sumers simply don’t understand the terms we use in the world tomers. Let’s not repeat the 1980s and end up with few custom-
of electricity, they don’t understand complex rates and they ers effectively using smart grid programs.
certainly don’t understand all the utility acronyms.
We have plenty of evidence that our industry has not in- Ellen Krohne (ek@yellowenergyconsulting.com) is managing
vested sufficient time or resources to educate the “ratepayers.” principal at Yellow Energy Consulting. She previously served as
And we will find even fewer in our industry that set out to actu- a customer service executive at a Midwest utility.
July 27 Workforce and Engineering Join Burns & McDonnell, GE and their clients on April 20 for an online
Design Optimization (GIS) discussion exploring how smart metering and advanced metering
infrastructure are changing the game for utilities throughout America.
Aug. 24 Smart Grid Telecom
Sept. 21 Software Giants and the GAME CHANGERS: innovation brought to life
Home Area Network
www.burnsmcd.com/td
Trends in Renewables
I
s it possible to have too much fun? I doubt it. Not too ferent than power supplied by, say, a battery. SNL can mimic
long ago, I was web surfing, trying to track down some the output of a PV panel and simulate any parameters need-
information on photovoltaics (PV). The search engine ed for the test circuit. This has placed SNL at the forefront
came up with something shiny, which of course caught my of solar technology testing. Today, SNL is in great demand
attention, and PV was forgotten. It was a piece from one by manufacturers of hardware being used in solar farms.
of those self-help gurus. You guessed it: Gene has no adult
supervision when web surfing. EPRI and DOE Provide More Inspiration
Well, Mr. Guru was waxing on about “You can’t have fun The Electrical Power Research Institute and the Depart-
at your work.” He went further to say that it is especially true ment of Energy sponsor a joint renewable energy confer-
if you want to be successful. Personally, I rank that sort of ence every two years. It moves around the globe, and as luck
thinking at the top of my balderdash list. would have it, it took place in my hometown of Albuquer-
que, New Mexico, in 2010.
It Has Been a Blast My friends Nadav Enbar and Don Kintner from EPRI
To be honest, putting this supplement together has been invited me to attend the conference, a nonstop five-day
more than fun, it’s been downright stimulating. Actually, affair with workshops, tours and presentations focused on
overstimulated would better to describe my condition as I wind, solar and energy storage. They even went into govern-
discovered solar and wind facilities that are becoming hu- ment regulations, but I skipped that session as there was too
mongous in size. And they are becoming extremely com- much technology to track. The event was international as
plex as well. How about an offshore wind farm that stretches well, with speakers from 15 countries on six continents.
more than 350 miles and will generate 6 GW of electricity? Technology-specific discussions were very pointed. Con-
Yet 6 GW is exactly what is planned for off the Atlantic Coast sider that wind farms are designed to have roughly 15 MW
of the United States. to 20 MW on each feeder in the collector system. This has
And what about a solar farm the size of the country of worked well when wind farm ratings were 100 MW to 200
Wales but located in the Sahara Desert that will power all of MW in total output. But what issues will designers face on a
Europe? I’ll have to see to believe. 1,000-MW wind farm? How do they limit currents and short
circuits to manageable levels while maintaining control over
Overstimulated by SNL the collector station?
I called my friend Dr. Abraham Ellis at the Sandia Na- The same concerns are popping up in the large PV-
tional Laboratories (SNL) solar research facilities to dis- powered solar farms. Many utility-scale solar facilities were
cuss this trend toward bigness and complexity. Abe and created taking designs from commercial PV installations of
I go back to college where we were New Mexico State around 50 kW. Now developers are expanding these com-
Aggies. Abe made some calls, I signed some forms, and mercial designs to accommodate 50-MW PV solar farms.
soon I was walking SNL’s grounds, checking out the field The bigger PV solar farms seem to be working adequately,
tests and talking with research scientists (actually listening but one hears disturbing instances of growing pains related
very intently). This pushed me into stimulus overload, but to electronic power conversion and control. And all of this
what fun! before we scale up into PV facilities with ratings of 500 MW
Did you know that PV solar panels feed direct current or more.
directly into a centralized inverter? That much I knew. But Wind and solar technologies are still developing, and we
I hadn’t considered that the impedance of each of the cir- have a front-row seat. Would I bet against us figuring out
cuits directly impacts the amount of electricity generated. how to build mega utility-scale renewable facilities? No way.
Because no two PV panels are identical (even from the same But let’s place renewables where they make sense. Let’s
manufacturer and factory), the impedance mismatch must make sure we can provide robust controls and connections
be addressed. I also learned that solar panel impedances to the grid. And let’s be sure we have the capacity to handle
drift with age. Now, consider a solar farm with hundreds the coming generation by adding the right mix of energy-
of thousands of panels spread over thousands of acres. If storage and customer load-control solutions. If we fail to
someone could improve the impedance control at or near properly plan, design, construct and connect our utility-
the panels, they could increase the output of the solar farm. scale green generating facilities, today’s overstimulation will
Well, SNL is working with manufacturers to improve this turn into tomorrow’s nightmares. And I wouldn’t like that
technology and test the results. one little bit.
SNL has a test facility that simulates PV-generated power
— and it can do it 24/7 — so it is independent of when the
actual sun is shining. Without going into a lot of detail, cur-
rent and voltage waveforms produced by PVs are totally dif- Gene Wolf, Technical Writer
Green Energy on
I
n today’s fast-paced world where technology is ad- Fairly representative of today’s technology is the V80-2.0
vancing at fantastic speeds, the trend is bigger, bet- MW wind turbine from Danish manufacturer Vestas Wind
ter, faster and more complex, whether talking about Systems. The V80 is one of the workhorses of the industry.
smart grid technology or renewables. No sooner It stands over 410 ft (125 m), depending on the tower select-
than the latest generation of technology is installed, ed. Its nacelle, the generating equipment housing, weighs
it is out of date. The latest widget is not only bigger — or in about 74 tons (67 metric tons), the blade assembly is roughly
some cases smaller — it is full of new features that suddenly 40 tons (36 metric tons), and the tower is another 173 tons
one cannot live without. (157 metric tons), depending on the configuration, bringing
Remember when wind turbines were 50 ft (15 m) tall the total weight close to 290 tons (263 metric tons).
with rotor blades 130 ft (40 m) in diameter, generating The American Wind Energy Association (AWEA) re-
50 kW? That wasn’t so long ago. Today, the typical wind ports that the typical transport of a turbine this size takes
turbine rating runs between 1 MW and 3 MW, with 5 MW about eight semi loads: one nacelle, one hub, three blades
becoming more commonplace and 10 MW under test. and three tower sections. For a 150-MW project, the trans-
a Gigawatt Scale
As facility size increases, the cost to produce
electricity from renewables is dropping dramatically.
By Gene Wolf, Technical Writer
portation requirements can be as much as 689 truckloads, Since January 2010, five of these huge turbines have been
140 rail cars and eight ships to the United States. operational. Video of two of these turbines, erected in Em-
den, Germany, can be seen in operation on YouTube.
Megawatts, Mega Turbines
In 2009, Belgian developer WindVision began construc- Is There a Limit?
tion of the Estinnes wind farm in Belgium. This wind farm The paint is hardly dry on the E-126 and there is a new
will have installed in it 11 of the world’s largest wind tur- challenger for world’s largest wind turbine on the scene. In
bines — the Enercon E-126 7-MW wind turbines. early 2010, the Norwegian company Sway AS announced it
The E-126 was originally nameplated for 6 MW but was partnering with the Norwegian state utility Enova and
improvements have allowed Enercon to increase the rat- Clipper Marine of the U.K. to bring to life an offshore wind
ing to 7 MW. The E-126’s hub height is approximately turbine rated at 10 MW. This wind turbine will have a rotor
440 ft (134 m), and the rotor diameter is about 415 ft diameter of 475 ft (145 m) and a hub height of 525 ft (160 m).
(127 m). It will be located in Oeygarden, Norway, and is scheduled
12 m
5m
6m
has dropped by more than Blade
80% since the early 1980s. At Nacelle
that time, electricity cost be- Tower
tween $0.30/kWh and $0.40/
kWh. Today, it is costing be-
tween $0.03/kWh and $0.05/ Mass of nacelle
+hub mTop~310t to 439t mTop~500t
kWh, similar to fossil fuels. +blades
extrapolated for 10 MW mTop~750t to 850t mTop~800t to 900t mTop<500t
AWEA accredits this reduc-
tion to larger wind farms and
The evolution of turbine technology with AMSC’s SeaTitan comparison. Courtesy of AMSC.
improved technology.
Cost is only part of the equation. As AWEA experts stat- the turbine while improving reliability, the manufacturer be-
ed, there also is the advancement of technology. From the comes really popular. Since technology is progressing at an
pure physics of the situation, the total amount of energy the exponential rate, it is reasonable to expect improvements are
turbine can remove from the wind is directly proportional to close at hand. Direct-drive wind turbines hold the promise
the sweep of the turbine’s blades (total area). In other words, of answering these problems.
the longer the blades, the greater the power generated by the The Global Wind Energy Council reports that direct-
turbine. drive systems have been around for several years. Enercon
To increase the length of the blades, the hub needs to be has been a pioneer in direct-drive technology for years. The
higher, and it gets heavier because of the increased genera- direct-drive technology simplifies the nacelle by doing away
tor rating. As the tower gets taller, the wind speeds increase. with the gearbox, which reduces weight. As a result, they are
Mathematically, the energy generated from the wind is pro- lighter, cheaper and more reliable (the gearbox causes most
portional to the cube of the wind speed the turbine encoun- of the maintenance problems). Much of the weight reduc-
ters. If the wind speed can be doubled, more than eight times tion comes from the elimination of the gears and the use of
the energy can be extracted. That is the incentive for turbine permanent magnets instead of electromagnets that require
manufacturers to push the technology envelope to allow for starter brushes, coils and power from the grid every time
longer blades and higher hub heights. they are started.
Recently, Siemens and GE Energy announced designs
Increase the Rating, Not the Size using direct-drive technology. Siemens has developed the
If a manufacturer can increase the rating of the turbine SWT-3.0-101 DD 3-MW turbine. The company recently an-
without increasing the size, the manufacturer becomes nounced that Minnesota Power has decided to modify its
popular. If it can increase the rating and reduce the size of original Bison 1 Wind Power Plant turbine order to include
15 of the Siemens SWT-3.0-101
direct-drive machines. According
120 m
(394 ft) to Siemens, the SWT-3.0-101 DD
100 m
3-MW nacelle weighs 12 tons (11
(328 ft) metric tons), about 25% less than
85 m
(279 ft) its 2.3-MW turbine’s nacelle.
66 m GE Energy also has developed
(216 ft) a direct-drive wind turbine for
50 m
(164 ft)
offshore installations. The com-
pany plans to supply its 4.0-110
4-MW direct-drive wind turbine
18 m
(60 ft) for the first freshwater offshore
wind farm in the United States.
GE is partnering with the non-
0.10 MW 0.75 MW 1.50 MW 2.50 MW 3.50 MW 5.00 MW profit Lake Erie Energy Develop-
Current state of the art ment Corp. for a 20-MW wind
project in Ohio’s Lake Erie shore-
Wind turbine size increases with age. Courtesy of the Department of Energy. line.
Contact energy@hdrinc.com
www.hdrinc.com
www.tdworld.com
PV offers a direct
55
conversion of sunlight to
Photovoltaic electricity but varies as
44 CSP the sun’s energy varies
Wind
and is gone when the sun
Megawatts (thousands)
Geothermal
33 Biomass is down. The first utility-
scale solar PV power
plant went on-line in 1982
22
in Hesperia, California.
ARCO Solar developed a
11 1-MW solar farm consist-
ing of 108 PV dual-axis
0
tracker panels.
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Since then, PV proj-
ects have grown to utility-
Renewable electricity generating capacity (excluding hydropower) in the United States has scale proportions. First
grown at a compounded annual average rate of 14%. Courtesy of the Department of Energy.
Solar will develop the
One thing is for sure, Roscoe will not hold the title long. Desert Sunlight solar project. It will be a 550-MW PV so-
There are many new wind projects on the drawing boards. lar project covering about 4,500 acres (1,821 hectares). The
The proposed Caithness Shepherds Flats in Oregon will project will consist of a 250-MW solar farm near Desert
generate 845 MW from 338 turbines at an estimated cost of Center, California, and the 300-MW Stateline solar project
$1.3 billion. located in northeastern San Bernardino, California. Pacific
Gas & Electric Co. has signed a contract for 300 MW of the
Solar Options output. Southern California Edison will buy the remaining
Solar has followed the same technology trend as wind. 250 MW.
It started off slowly but has been gaining market share as CSP technology uses the sun’s energy to heat a fluid to a
the technology becomes more efficient and the cost per watt very high temperature. The fluid is then circulated through
drops. Basically, there are two types of solar technologies: pipes to transfer the heat to water to produce steam. At that
concentrating solar power (CSP), also referred to as thermal point, electricity can be generated. For utility-scale solar
solar, and photovoltaic (PV). generation, the most common CSP technologies are the
The Sandia National Labs 200-ft solar power tower is surrounded by 220 sun-tracking heliostats. Photo by Gene Wolf.
The DESERTEC Foundation estimates that over 90% of the world’s population could be supplied with clean power from the
world’s deserts using technologies that are available today. The Sahara project is the first step in proving that concept.
Courtesy of the DESERTEC Foundation.
parabolic trough and power tower designs, but there also approval from Secretary of the Interior Ken Salazar for their
are solar dish designs and Fresnel reflectors. Thermal so- $6 billion Blythe solar project. The Blythe project will have
lar offers the ability to provide electricity after the sun goes a capacity of 1000 MW and cover 7,025 acres (2,843 hect-
down, which is very attractive to utilities using renewables ares). Southern California Edison will purchase all of the
for generation. output from the project and will build a 230-kV transmission
The largest active solar energy facility in the world is the line to connect the Blythe project to its system.
Solar Energy Generating Systems plant located at Kramer
Junction, California. It started life as the world’s first large- What’s Next?
scale CSP facility, with 30 MW of capacity in 1986. The New York Times reports that there are nine solar plants
Today, it is made up of nine solar plants. Solar Energy in permitting currently. If approved, they will cover 41,229
Generating Systems has an installed capacity of 354 MW us- acres (16,685 hectares) of Bureau of Land Management land
ing 936,384 parabolic mirrors, reaching operating tempera- and have the capacity to generate 4580 MW of electricity. As
tures of over 750°F (399°C). It covers more than 1,600 acres if those statistics are not mind-boggling enough, there is the
(647 hectares). $550 billion DESERTEC solar power project to consider. It
How long the Kramer Junction facility will remain the will be located in the Sahara Desert and is purported to be
largest solar farm is anyone’s guess. The Los Angeles Times the size of Wales. Wind-wise, the story is the same — big
reports that BrightSource Energy Inc. started construction facilities.
on the Ivanpah solar project on Oct. 28, 2010, in the Ivanpah Google plans to invest in the Atlantic Wind Connection
Valley in Southern California. The CSP facility will have a project, a $5 billion 6-GW, 350-mile (563-km)-long offshore
capacity of 392 MW using three 459-ft (140-m) solar towers. wind farm planned to be located along the U.S. Atlantic Sea-
The U.S. Department of Energy has guaranteed a loan worth board. The energy harvest is getting serious, but how can
nearly $1.4 billion for the project. the industry intellectualize a wind farm 350 miles long or
According to Bloomberg, the joint developers (Solar a solar farm the size of a country? Has the industry’s reach
Millennium, LLC and Chevron Energy Solutions) received exceeded its grasp? Only time will tell.
The Big Sky Country of Montana is home to the 135-MW, 8,300-acre Judith Gap wind farm. Photo by Gene Wolf.
Integrating Renewables
The variabilities of wind and solar provide
a challenge for grid companies.
By Gene Wolf, Technical Writer
but one 1-GW project reduces those numbers significantly.
N
ot all that long ago renewable energy was
thought of as an alternative technology. Additionally, many government regulators worldwide
That is no longer the case. Renewables have have set ambitious goals for their utilities of 20% renewable
gone mainstream in every sense of the word. power generation by 2020, with some having upped the ante
Globally, nearly 80 GW of renewable power to 30% or more.
capacity was added in 2009 (the last year for which figures
were available). Wind generation accounted for about 38 GW The Key Word is Big
of that total. According to a recent report by GTM Research, Yesterday’s wind farms were considered big if they pro-
utility photovoltaic (PV) contracts exceeded 5 GW in 2010. duced 20 MW, and solar farms were huge at 5 kW. Today a
GTM also reported that the utility PV market for 2010 was wind farm has to be above 600 MW to get much attention,
about $1 billion in the United States and is expected to reach and solar farms above 50 MW are becoming commonplace.
$8 billion by 2015. Tomorrow’s wind farms will have capacities of several giga-
A couple of things are happening to make this gigawatt watts.
phenomenon become a reality. Firstly, technology has im- A proposed solar farm in the Sahara Desert will cover
proved all aspects of renewable energy — from generation thousands of square miles. It is projected to be able to gen-
efficiency (larger turbines) to increased capacity factors erate enough power to supply the needs of the European
(improved forecasting). Union (EU).
Secondly, mega projects improve the economies of scale The North American Electric Reliability Corp. (NERC)
by reducing the installed costs. Developers have long real- published a special report in 2009 titled “Accommodat-
ized larger projects reduce costs and speed up the timeline. ing High Levels of Variable Generation.” According to the
This makes sense, as 10 100-MW projects require 10 sets report, more than 145 GW of variable generation is pro-
of system studies, 10 collections of permits, 10 clusters of jected to be added to the North American grid in the next
public meetings and 10 series of other assorted paperwork, 10 years.
cost-effectiveness
sustainability
reliability
From the most innovative and efficient Extra High Voltage systems to
environmentally friendly cable technologies for Power Distribution, to
state-of-the-art cables for the renewable energies sector, our mission
is to offer ultimate know-how, technologies and services to all those
committed to provide the world with the energy of tomorrow.
LAYING IDEAS
www.tdworld.com
Megawatts (thousands)
Prediction
provides voltage control, active 159.213
power flow control and dynamic 150
energy storage. 120.903
Power electronics are being 93.930
100
used to address the problems as- 74.122
sociated with renewables in the 59.024
areas of voltage sag, frequency 47.693
50 39.295
31.181
excursions and reactive power 24.322
control (VAR consumption).
0
Beacon Power is offering 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
kinetic energy storage technol-
ogy. It is building a 20-MW Total capacity of wind generation worldwide. Courtesy of the World Wind Energy Association.
flywheel energy storage system
as part of a DOE-funded project
on the New York Independent 50
Prediction
40 38.312
Smart Energy 25 flywheel. The
Megawatts (thousands)
35
Beacon flywheel is state of the
art. It stores energy in the form 30
26.972
of inertia by a spinning disk 25
on a metal shaft levitated with 20
19.808
magnetics, using an electro- 15.111
15
magnetic bearing in a vacuum 11.331
chamber. 10 8.114 8.386
6.282 6.859
5
Wire in the Air 0
Experts have gone on record 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
saying storage is not needed
once the renewable generation Total capacity of wind generation installed each year globally.
facilities cover the landscape Courtesy of the World Wind Energy Association.
and sufficient transmission fa-
cilities connect them to the grid. Their argument is the wind It seems like an unrealistically optimistic approach con-
is blowing and the sun is shining somewhere at any given sidering the state of most transmission systems today, but
time. with a judicious application of advanced technology, there
“Many of the low-hanging fruit in wind has been taken could be some merits to it.
advantage of,” said Jack Hand, president of POWER Engi- Consider high-voltage direct-current (HVDC) trans-
neers. “In 2006 to 2008, we had a substantial growth in the mission technology. The Electric Power Research Institute
wind farm business. In 2009, it pretty much died. In 2010 hosted its annual HVDC conference in late 2010. EPRI
and 2011, we’re seeing some increased interest but it’s still brought together some of the world’s foremost HVDC ex-
very limited for several reasons. Many of the builders are perts to discuss the latest developments in the technology
developers and funding is difficult, and many are waiting on and how it is being applied.
backbone transmission lines to get approved or permitted, ABB, Alstom Grid and Siemens reported about grow-
funded and built. ing interest in combining HVDC transmission technology
“I see wind as fairly stable but not very strong in the next with renewable energy projects. Offshore projects have been
few years,” Hand continued. “But after some of the mega using HVDC for collector systems with marine cables for
western transmission projects start getting built, then maybe quite some time.
in 2012 we should see another big boom in wind.” Onshore, interests have been growing, as developers re-
Generation needs will be met if transmission resources alize HVDC offers solutions to some of the problems with
are available to move the electricity around. They argue that which they are dealing. HVDC is more efficient for moving
the renewables will back themselves up. large blocks of power at great distances. It also offers better
Valmont Newmark—Your
one source for steel,
concrete, hybrid, turbine
tower, transmission,
distribution, and
substation power
delivery
structures.
HVDC Transmission
Technology
Wayne Galli, vice presi-
dent, transmission and tech-
nical services for Clean Line
Energy Partners, made a
presentation on four HVDC
transmission projects pro- Wind turbines become part of the landscape in rural areas. Photo by Gene Wolf.
posed by his company. Galli
reported the projects will move wind-generated electricity transmission line to the southeastern United States.
from the Great Plains to the load centers on the East Coast If projects such as this are successful, then the utili-
and West Coast. ties on the other end are going to be the recipients of large
The Plains & Eastern Clean Line is the largest of the proj- amounts of variable power. They are going to require some
ects. It will be constructed in two phases. Each phase will be very sophisticated generator and load modeling combined
rated 3.5 GW with an 800-mile (1,288-km) ±500/600 bipole with statistical and probabilistic forecasting tools to be able
...SmartGrid is a reality
sensethepower.com
Contact your local NECA line chapter or IBEW local union for more information.
to handle the fluctuations inherent with variable generation Combining Smart Grid and Renewables
resources. The Pacific Northwest Smart Grid Demonstration Proj-
Of course, installing different types of variable genera- ect addresses many of these issues with smart grid enhance-
tion over a large geographical area provides a more diverse ments. The demonstration project is intended to cover five
mix of that generation, but the application of advanced smart states — Idaho, Montana, Oregon, Washington and Wyo-
grid technologies accommodates the intermittency of these ming — with about 60,000 metered customers and more
resources. than 112 MW of load. It will combine advanced analytical
Technologies such as demand-response programs and tools, software and smart grid devices from 3TIER Inc.,
synchrophasor monitoring make the grid more flexible, AREVA USA, IBM, Netezza Corp., QualityLogic Inc. and
transmission reinforcements make it more robust, and en- Drummond Group Inc.
hanced forecasting makes it more reliable. One very interesting feature of this project is the use of
wind and solar forecasting tools
provided by 3TIER, which will
monitor individual wind and solar
farms and the region as a whole
with hour-, day- and week-ahead
Opportunities forecasts. The forecasting tools
will predict how the weather af-
fects the power generation of the
renewable facilities to optimally
integrate the energy into the grid
and dispatch other assets when
production decreases.
Real-time management of
Solutions the output from a wind farm can
provide a utility with supply-side
control, including increasing or
decreasing output from other sys-
tem generation as needed or de-
creasing wind generation output
by curtailing the wind generator.
belgium@cgglobal.com
At the end of 2010, Canada’s 80-MW Sarnia solar farm was the largest photovoltaic installation in the world. It has
1.3 million photovoltaic panels covering about 240 acres. Courtesy of Black & Veatch.
Utilities Embrace
Distributed Solar
Photovoltaics and thermal solar are powering solar
projects — from deserts to rooftops — that are
rivaling fossil-fuel generation.
By Gene Wolf, Technical Writer
I
f one trait characterizes the relationship between the Not long ago, solar evoked images of using Rube Gold-
solar portion of the renewable energy market and the berg devices to heat water in someone’s garage. That has
electric industry, it is change. The change is in tech- changed, too. Now utilities are coming to grips with sophis-
nologies, in rules and regulations, in philosophies ticated solar technologies and their applications on the grid.
and in the roles developers, utilities and regulators Two basic solar technologies are used to make electricity,
play in the process. photovoltaics (PV) and solar thermal. Interestingly, PV has
Utilities have recognized the potential in developing and taken the lead in the global cumulative megawatt capacity.
owning solar facilities. Developers have seen the benefits of It has proven quick and easy for distributive generation ap-
partnering with utilities rather than just considering them plications. Solar thermal (troughs, towers and Stirling en-
customers. Governing authorities acknowledge the pay- gines) — more commonly called concentrating solar power
back in working with both utilities and developers to make (CSP) — has also gained ground with recent approvals for
renewable energy goals achievable. large solar-power farms.
Petra Solar has pioneered new technology that efficiently generates power through solar modules on utility and
streetlight poles or other assets. Petra Solar’s SunWave™ photovoltaic (PV) systems not only feed distributed clean
energy into the electric grid, they are comprehensive utility grade solutions that offer smart grid communication,
connectivity and control, increase grid efficiency, and lower the cost of utility grids.
t Outage detection
t Volt-VAR optimization
t Reactive power compensation
t Voltage support
Call +732.379.5566
Visit us online: www.petrasolar.com
E-mail us: utilities@petrasolar.com Sizeable 40 MW deployment well underway in New Jersey
www.advanced-energy.com/renewables
sales.support@aei.com | 877.312.3832
Advanced Energy, Solaron, and PV Powered are U.S. registered trademarks or service marks of Advanced Energy Industries, Inc.
www.tdworld.com
RPS
Acelerated or stregthened RPS
Voluntary state or utility standaards or goals
Strengthened voluntary standard
Pilot or study
Courtesy of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission.
property that is part of a qualified facility (fuel cell, solar or lar to those in Europe, has been hampered by the Federal
small wind) to be claimed for cash. This grant has been very Power Act, the Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act and
successful in stimulating this segment of the renewable mar- the fact that jurisdiction over electric power is divided be-
ketplace; however, it was only authorized through 2010. tween the FERC and the states, but times are changing, and
Late in December 2010, the lame-duck Congress extend- the United States is seeing the results with all the recent
ed the grant, but it was only extended through 2011, so it will FIT announcements.
have to be dealt with again in 2011. Does this remind anyone
of the yearly tax credit extensions that so negatively impact- Developers, Owners and Operators
ed the wind industry in the early 2000s? There were several Another key factor in the solar trend is the changing roles
times Congress dropped the ball and let the tax credit lapse. utilities are playing.
“The utilities know their systems better than anyone
Feed-in Tariffs Are a Huge Incentive else,” said John Olander, associate vice president, Burns &
Feed-in tariffs (FITs) are designed to encourage devel- McDonnell. “They understand the process (studies, permit-
opers, businesses and homeowners to deploy renewable ting, regulations) and the impacts to the system. Developers
energy. The U.S. National Renewable Energy Laboratory are more risk tolerant, and they often act quicker.
(NREL) estimated that more than 40 countries, mostly in “Building the facility in a year or less is normal for a
Europe, have used FITs to promote renewable energy de- developer, and speed is the biggest challenge,” Olander
velopment. FITs also are known as electricity feed laws, ad- added. “The most successful fast-track projects will require
vanced renewable tariffs, renewable tariffs and renewable a combination of the utility’s understanding and the devel-
energy payments. oper’s risk-taking ability to produce quick action on partial
Whatever they are called, they have made many countries information.”
in the European Union powerhouses for solar. Germany, not What has encouraged utilities to take the lead in renew-
exactly the first place that comes to mind for sun-drenched able projects? Subtle changes to the tax codes now allow
landscapes, leads the world in solar capacity. According to utilities to get tax credits for solar investments. Changes
NREL’s study, FITs are responsible for 75% of the solar de- made by state regulators allow utilities back into the gen-
ployment (PV) and 45% of wind power around the world. eration business as long as it is solar. Massachusetts’ Green
The introduction of FITs in the United States, simi- Communities Act is a good example. It allows Massachu-
As our choices for structural materials expand, our knowledge must expand with
it. Transmission and distribution utility engineers are increasingly looking at the total
owning costs of their towers and poles as they respond to reductions in their O&M
budgets.
Manufactured structures provide more consistent strengths, whether it is tensile
or cantilever, but they come with issues of their own. One utility is designing a line
with three structural materials that is dependent on whether the structure is a
straight, angle or deadend. Roadway crossings and guyed structures to prevent
cascading failures also require adherence to different specifications. And utilities are
now going to monopoles, where they historically would have gone with a tower. Of
course, foundations and conductor arms are also a big part of structure design, so
this topic will be addressed as well in a special supplement.
Index of Advertisers
Advertiser/ Website Page
TM
Advanced Energy ........................................................................... 27
www.tdworld.com www.advanced-energy.com/renewables
CG Power Solutions ........................................................................ 32
David Miller, Publisher David.Miller@penton.com cgpowersolutions.com
Rick Bush, Editorial Director rbush@tdworld.com
CG Power Systems ......................................................................... 22
Vito Longo, Technology Editor vlongo@tdworld.com
www.belgium@cgglobal.com
Emily Saarela, Senior Managing Editor esaarela@tdworld.com
Gerry George, International Editor gerry.george.tdw@talk21.com HDR Inc............................................................................................ 9
Gene Wolf, Technical Writer GW_Engr@msn.com www.hdrinc.com
Cathy Swirbul, Contributing Writer cathy@chscommunications.com Henkels & McCoy ............................................................................. 6
Susan Lakin, Art Director slakin@tdworld.com www.henkels.com
Julie Gilpin, Ad Production Manager Julie.Gilpin@penton.com NLMCC/NECA-IBEW ........................................................................ 21
Joan Roof, Audience Marketing Manager Joan.Roof@penton.com www.thequalityconnection.org
Steve Lach, Midwestern, Mid-Atlantic,New England, Eastern Canada Petra Solar ..................................................................................... 25
Steve.Lach@penton.com www.petrasolar.com
Doug Fix, Southeastern, Mid-Atlantic, New England dfix@bellsouth.net
PowerSense A/S............................................................................. 20
Gary Lindenberger, Southwest gl@lindenassoc.com
www.sensethepower.com
Ron Sweeney, West/Western Canada wnjsr@comcast.net
Craig Zehntner, West/Western Canada wnjla@aol.com Prysmian Cables & Systems ........................................................... 17
www.prysmian.com
Richard Woolley, Western/Eastern Europe richardwoolley@btclick.com
Yoshinori Ikeda, Japan pbi2010@gol.com Quanta Services............................................................................... 2
Y.B. Jeon, Korea stormybj@kornet.net www.quantaservices.com
Siemens Energy Inc. ....................................................................... 23
Copyright 2011 Penton Media Inc. All rights reserved.
www.usa.siemens.com
Thomas & Betts Corp./Meyer Steel Structure................................... 13
www.tnb.com
Valmont/Newmark.......................................................................... 19
www.valmont-newmark.com
In fact, nearly 25% of all wind power generated in the US runs through T&D systems built
by CG Power Solutions (formerly MSE Power Systems). The reasons? We take on the most
complex renewable energy EPC projects, and always deliver on
time, on budget. And we work with our clients’ own specs or
custom specs we develop together, not a cookie-cutter design.
That’s why—and how—we’ve earned the trust of renewable
energy providers in every corner of the country. And we can
put our energy to work for you…right now.
Visit cgpowersolutions.com/grid today to see how we’re
putting wind power on the map. Or call 877.426.0333. Formerly MSE Power Systems