Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DTJ 15 27 1 9
DTJ 15 27 1 9
38358
Abstract
Three buildings are cited in this paper,
which have become the materialized
expressions of certain architectural theories;
the Scröder House by Gerrit Rietveld, The
Jubilee Church by Richard Meier and the
Architecture as the Built
Superlofts project by Marc Koehler
Architects. The chosen exemplars belong to
different instances in recent history -the
former to the early twentieth, the second to
Form of Theory*
Ebru Özeke Tökmeci
the late twentieth and the last one to the
twenty-first centuries- and they seem to Mimar Sinan Güzel Sanatlar Üniversitesi Mimarlık Fakültesi, Mimarlık Bölümü,
reflect the state of mind and intention of
their architects as well as the general spirit Kabul tarihi/Final Acceptance: 01.03.2019
of the architectural milieus of their times.
Understanding the buildings themselves and
the theories behind them would provide an
insight about how the theoretical discourse
in the field of architecture has evolved in
decades and how architects have responded
to this evolution in regard to their
contributions to architectural theory.
Öz
Mimari yapılar, çoğu durumda, kendilerini
tasarlayan mimarın kuramsal duruşuyla
birlikte yapıldıkları dönemlerin genel
mimarlık ruhunu yansıtan örneklerdir. Bu
makalede, belirli mimarlık kuramlarının
somutlaştırılmış ifadesi haline gelmiş üç
yapı ele alınmaktadır; Gerrit Rietveld’in
tasarladığı Schröder Evi (1924), Richard
Meier tasarımı Jübile Kilisesi (1996-2003)
Introduction different characteristics. It might portray
ve Marc Koehler Mimarlık’ın geliştirdiği It would be fundamental to first try to an approach to the art of building and this
Superlofts Projesi (2015). Sözkonusu yapılar,
ilki erken yirminci yüzyıl, ikincisi geç understand the scope of the term architec- approach, emerging at a definite period of
yirminci yüzyıl ve sonuncusu da yirmibirinci tural theory. In fact, it is not likely to make time, might belong to a certain society as
yüzyıldan olmak üzere, yakın tarih
içerisindeki üç farklı anı temsil etmek üzere,
an all-inclusive designation for this, since well as to a certain individual.
söylemsel olarak sırasıyla Modernizm, the contents of the field have changed Much a collection of these thoughts,
Postmodernizm ve Sürdürülebilir Mimarlığın
kuramsal alanda etkin olduğu dönemlerden
through cultures, societies and different Virgilio Onofrei states that the theory of
seçilmiştir. Bu yapıları ve arka planlarında time periods in history. architecture considers the whole sphere
barındırdıkları teorik yaklaşımları anlamak,
mimarlık kuramının yakın onyıllar Harry Francis Mallgrave defines architec- of architecture as a study matter and has
içerisindeki dönüşümüne ve mimarların bu tural theory as simply the history of our applications in fields belonging both to
dönüşüme nasıl uyum sağladıklarına ışık
tutacaktır. ideas regarding our constructed physical the practice and to the knowledge, such
Keywords: Arhitectural theory, Theory- surroundings (2007, XXI). as architectural experience, architectural
Pratice Relation in Architecture, Modernism,
Kate Nesbitt states that, within the disci- design, research, history and also criti-
Postmodernism, Sustainable Architecture
pline of architecture, theory is a discourse cism. Each of these application fields goes
Anahtar Kelimeler: Mimarlık Kuramı,
Mimarlıkta kuram-uygulama ilişkisi, that describes the practice and production through its own dynamic process, and, in
Modernizm, Postmodernizm, Sürdürülebilir
of architecture and identifies challenges its turn, the theory of architecture, having
Mimarlık
to it (1996, 16). According to Hanno-Wal- multiple interconnections with them, is a
ter Kruft, architectural theory comprises complex subject, in a continuous evolution
any written system of architecture that is (2005, 125).
based on aesthetic or functional categories I should note here that a particular attempt
(1994, 15). Mallgrave also states that, theory has also been made to define the desired
possesses no tangible form; it exists in relationship between architectural theory
large and heavy tomes as well as in short and architectural practice, the main ques-
and spirited manifestoes (2007, XXI). Thus, tion being ‘how is the world of buildings
a set of architectural theory might come combined with the world of ideas?’ This
in the form of a handbook or a guide of seems quite challenging because on the
practical building instructions as well as one hand theory can be seen as a set of
a reflection on the aesthetical, social or reflections complementing, justifying and
practical approaches to architecture within intellectualizing what has already been
a certain era. It might comment on one built, while on the other hand, it lays down
* Bu makale, 28 Eylül 2018’de ARCHTHEO’18 single building or be a compilation of programs and requirements for architec-
Sempozyumu’nda çağrılı konuşma olarak
sunulan bildiri metninden uyarlanmıştır. commentaries on buildings with similar or ture to fulfill; it deals with architecture’s
Sayı 27, Mayıs 2019 1
Ebru Özeke Tökmeci
Figure: 4
Kruft defines the Schröder House as the A Mondrian painting raised in three
most striking practical expression of these dimensions
ideas (1994, 380). According to Frampton
(1997,145), the house was in many respects
a realization of Theo van Doesburg’s man-
ifestation of 16 Points of a Plastic Archi-
tecture as it was elementary, economic and
functional; un-monumental and dynamic;
anti-cubic in its form and anti-decorative
in its color as already prescribed. Its main
living level on the top floor, with its open
transformable plan exemplified the theory
of a dynamic architecture liberated from
the burden of load-bearing walls and the
restrictions imposed by pierced openings.
The house was also anti-cubic in the sense
that it did not try to freeze the different
functional space cells in one closed cube
but rather threw the functional space cells
centrifugally from the core of the cube.
Architects of the early modern era were
much influenced by the new forms of project for this church, however, could not
abstract painting and sculpture then being be completed until 2003, due to financial
produced by the avant-garde and De Stijl problems (Figure 5).
architects were particularly interested in
Richard Meier is one of the prominent
the work of Mondrian. Taking his linear
figures of contemporary architecture
compositions as models, the building forms
whose career dates back to the 1960’s. His
were treated as abstract compositions of
early works were among the work of five
lines and planes to define a new concept
New York Architects along with Michael
of architecture as a pure art form (Abel 1988,
Graves (1934-2015), John Hejduk (1929-
172). In this sense, the Schröder house can
2000), Charles Gwathmey (1938-2009) and
also be considered as a Mondrian painting
Peter Eisenman (B.1932), also referred to
raised in three dimensions, conforming to
as the Whites. Brought together in a 1972
an artistic method of theory which regards
the building forms themselves as visual book, namely Five Architects, the works
compositions (Figure 4). of these architects reemployed the rational
forms of the Modern Movement with an
The Jubilee Church obviously Corbusian orientation (Rowe
The Church of 2000 or the Jubilee Church 1975, 7). According to Frampton (1997, 311),
by Richard Meier (b. 1934) was designed this was an attempt made in the second
in 1996 for an international competition half of the 1960’s, to develop a theoreti-
established by the Vatican’s initiation of cal and artistic production as rigorous as
the 50 Churches for Rome 2000 project. that achieved by the pre-war European
Six contemporary architects were invited avant-garde. Since then and all through
to the competition to submit their pro- his career, Meier has kept to a form of
posals. The intention was to show and aestheticised functionalism which he sees
highlight the basic role that architecture as belonging to a great historical tradi-
would play in holy and religious spaces tion while he rejects the use of ornament
and also to demonstrate that the connection (Kruft 1994, 444). As such, he has secured
with contemporary architecture is the key himself a reputation as one of the most
to improve the quality of life in suburban civic-minded architects of his generation
areas. The construction of Meier’s winning (Frampton 1997, 311).
Figure: 5
The Jubilee Church, Richard Meier, Rome
1996-2003.
The principles that guide Meier’s work are According to Meier, architecture is
rooted in timeless, classical design issues expressing a quality of light. It should
such as Site, Order, and the use of Natural also allow one to appreciate nature that’s
Light that are not unique to period, style, around. White is all colors. It’s every-
or context (url 1). His work is characterized where. Everywhere one looks. Whiteness,
by the rational use of geometry, the clarity in a sense, reflects nature, it refracts light,
of their spaces, the superb handling of light it makes one more aware of the colors
and the use of white as a symbol of purity. of nature because of the whiteness of the
buildings (Bianchini 2018) (Figure 6).
The Jubilee Church consists of two ele-
Meier would state that the central ideas
ments; the church itself and the parish center
for creating a sacred space have to do with
with offices, an auditorium and a multipur-
truth and authenticity, a search for clarity,
pose hall. The two buildings are separated
peace, transparency, a yearning for tran-
by a wall plane and they are joined by the
quility, a place to evoke otherworldliness
concave wall of glass on the facade of the in a way that is uplifting. And to express
building. Thus, the overall structure is con- spirituality, the architect has to think of
ceived as a composition of basic geometri- the original material of architecture which
cal forms -the sphere and the cube referring is space and light (Riding 2003). According-
to their purity- and the contrast between ly, the Jubilee Church building uses as
them. The main space of the church is the much natural light as it comes in through
connection point of these two forms. the glazed glass roof between the shells
Figure: 6 (Figures 7, 8).
Whiteness reflects nature, it refracts light,
it makes one more aware of the colors of While the major expressive issue and the
nature. essence of architecture through the Modern
Movement was its function which was
seen as rational and scientific, Postmod-
ernism placed a higher value on form than
on function asserting that the form itself
is the essence or content of architecture
(Nesbitt 1996, 45). This postmodern attitude
was also much concerned with issues of
Sayı 27, Mayıs 2019 5
Ebru Özeke Tökmeci
meaning in architecture bringing forth the While the idea that a building should be Figure: 7
The central ideas for creating a sacred space
argument that ‘every building component, produced in accordance with first the nature have to do with truth and authenticity.
from structural to ornamental, accommo- and later the built environment seems as Figure: 8
dates a meaning due to particular local and old as the appearance in history of the The Jubilee Church building uses as much
natural light as it comes in through the
cultural codes.’ Such discussion has often human-made settlements, the consciousness glazed glass roof between the shells.
tried to formulate a possible correspon- regarding environmental problems and
dence between architecture and language artistic practice gained acceleration after
to transfer the concept of metaphor into the the second half of the 1960s. Through the
field of architecture. following decades, respect for the environ-
As a building conforming to postmodern ment encouraged the use of technologies
architectural language, the Jubilee Church that are compatible with it and the end of
also accommodates in itself a symbolic the 20th century witnessed the emergence of
meaning through the metaphors that it em- Sustainable Architecture. The term sustain-
ploys. The three enormous circular shells able comes from the concept of sustain-
represent the Holy Trinity. They give a able development, which is understood as
feeling of lightness to the building while satisfying the present necessities without
they also symbolize the movement of the creating future developmental problems
mounting waves or sails as the building and without compromising the demands of
future generations (Chust 2014, 230). The in-
takes on the idea of a ship sailing into the
fluence of sustainability in architecture has
seas of the third millennium (Dannels).
inspired many architects as well as produc-
The Superlofts ing a vast amount of scholarly theory.
In the twenty first century one can see Superlofts in this sense, is a new co-hous-
that the scope of architectural theory has ing concept developed by Marc Koehler (b.
become even wider with the introduction 1977) Architects [MKA], an international
of new concepts into the discourse. In the design agency founded in 2005 by Marc
pluralistic culture of today’s world, one Koehler who represents a younger genera-
can find a large number of theoretical tion of architects. In search of a socially re-
models to choose from. Among the many, sponsible way of making buildings, MKA
a tendency towards ecological resilience has taken sustainability in architecture as a
seems to have dominated the field of archi- key concept in all its production trying to
tecture since the late 20th century. create valuable connections between build-
6 Sayı 27, Mayıs 2019
Architecture as the Built Form of Theory
Figure: 9
The Superlofts Block Y, Marc Koehler
Architects, Utrecht, 2014-2017 (url 2).
Figure: 10
The Superlofts Houthavens, Amsterdam, 2016
(url 3).
ings and their environment, the culture of the permanent support structure from
its users and the latest technical possibili- the temporary infills, utilising a flexible
ties (Figure 9). and open framework that easily adapts to
Superlofts (url 4) is a customisable co-living changing cycles of use and maintenance.
and development model based on modular This facilitates a circular way of building
and Open Building systems. Superlofts and, importantly, contributes to resilient
offers its members the freedom to cus- cities that can accommodate the changing
tomise or design their homes from scratch urban programmes and lifestyles of the
incorporating any hybrid function, and people who inhabit them. Each project in-
co-create shared spaces to build a glob- tegrates the latest sustainable technologies
al co-living community. Superlofts are that support efficient and healthy buildings
designed as Open Buildings that separate in the long term (Figure 10).
Sayı 27, Mayıs 2019 7
Ebru Özeke Tökmeci
Koehler (Winston 2017) states that consum- ifestoes in order to declare an opinion
ers are becoming co-creators of the stuff into a strategy for practice and it was not
they buy and believes that the same can be surprising to see many Modern Movement
applied to the housing sector where there architects defining their formula in the
is a huge demand for more quality. More sense of a prescribed program, thus pro-
quality, for him, means more personaliza- ducing prescriptive theories of architecture.
tion of the domestic sphere and for that one The Schröder house, in this sense, was a
needs to create buildings that can adapt to concrete example of architecture as the
those personal requirements. built form of prescriptive theory.
The system is proven to be highly adapt- In the mid 1960’s, challenges to Modern
able to different sites and has already been Movement ideology and to a debased and
applied in the Netherlands and abroad. trivialized Modern Architecture acceler-
Conclusion ated and proliferated to become known
as the post-modern critique. The impacts
The evolution of architectural forms is
of postmodernism in architecture became
the result of the change in the ideals that
clearer by the growth of architectural
produced them as well as the motives
theory publications as well as the prolifera-
which dictate the character of the work
tion of theoretical paradigms or ideological
of the architect. Architecture as an end
frameworks (Nesbitt 1996, 22-28). Through
product concerns mainly what a building
such transformation of the cultural,
looks like, how it is constructed and how
therefore architectural scene, architects’
efficiently it fulfills its purpose. However,
interpretation of their practice also took
the architects who create the buildings are
another direction. According to Diane Ghi-
obliged to be equally concerned with more
rardo, while Modernism vested too much
speculative questions (Collins 1998, 16).
power in the architect to alter and redeem
While considering different factors through society; the Postmodern architect accept-
the design process such as location, social ed a modest role by reducing his mission
form, technology and so on, the values the to fulfilling the present day requirements
architect attaches to these factors and to (1986, 3). Rather than producing prescriptive
the relation between them are determined frameworks, architects have become more
according to a theoretical model of archi- engaged in the expression of their design
tecture (Abel 1988, 163). Thus, an architect philosophies through the description and
arrives at the finished product by first justification of their own work. Accord-
thinking of forms intuitively, then trying ingly, the architecture of Richard Meier,
to justify them rationally by what we may exemplified here with his Jubilee Church
call one’s individual theory of architecture building, is significant of strong theoretical
(Collins 1998, 16). consistency legislated by the architect’s
Nesbitt states that (1996, 17), architectural preferred vocabulary, conforming to an
theory can be characterized by several at- affirmative model of architectural theory.
titudes towards the presentation of its sub- Starting in the course of the postmodern
ject matter: for the most part it is prescrip- critique, the expansion within the field of
tive, proscriptive, affirmative or critical. architectural theory has gained acceleration
Prescriptive theory offers new or revived through the following decades, giving way
solutions for specific problems: it functions to the pluralist structure of current scenery
by establishing new norms for practice. with its diverse possibilities of orientation.
It thus promotes positive standards and Freed from mostly formal frameworks, the
sometimes even a design method. role of the architect has become that of a
Within the Modern Architectural debate, mediator in the process of reconciliation
architects were seen as active agents in between the built environment and social,
the construction of the community and its cultural and ecological requirements.
structures. They would produce man- Theoretical production in architecture
8 Sayı 27, Mayıs 2019
Architecture as the Built Form of Theory