Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Be Harrell 1991
Be Harrell 1991
Gemma C. Harper, Aikaterini Makatouni, (2002),"Consumer perception of organic food production and farm animal welfare",
British Food Journal, Vol. 104 Iss 3/4/5 pp. 287-299 http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/00070700210425723
Raffaele Zanoli, Simona Naspetti, (2002),"Consumer motivations in the purchase of organic food: A means-end approach",
British Food Journal, Vol. 104 Iss 8 pp. 643-653 http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/00070700210425930
Access to this document was granted through an Emerald subscription provided by 540409 []
For Authors
If you would like to write for this, or any other Emerald publication, then please use our Emerald for Authors service
information about how to choose which publication to write for and submission guidelines are available for all. Please visit
www.emeraldinsight.com/authors for more information.
About Emerald www.emeraldinsight.com
Emerald is a global publisher linking research and practice to the benefit of society. The company manages a portfolio of
more than 290 journals and over 2,350 books and book series volumes, as well as providing an extensive range of online
products and additional customer resources and services.
Emerald is both COUNTER 4 and TRANSFER compliant. The organization is a partner of the Committee on Publication
Ethics (COPE) and also works with Portico and the LOCKSS initiative for digital archive preservation.
T
he conflict between scientific evidence and definition of food quality which closely affects food
consumer perceptions concerning food acceptability as shown in Figure 1 (see Woodward[l]).
acceptability provides an interesting
paradox.
Definition of Organic Farming Methods
Basically organic farming refers to a particular farming
system which uses organic manures, a limited range of
plant-derived chemicals, no growth regulators, feed
additives, biocides or chemical sprays.
Attitudes
Organic farming is a production system which avoids or
largely excludes the use of synthetically compounded
fertilisers, pesticides, growth regulators and livestock feed
Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 19:48 22 January 2015 (PT)
1990, John Gummer, the Minister for Agriculture, There are several different bodies worldwide setting
advanced plans for a pilot organic extensification scheme, organic standards, and each body has its own organic
which would provide government support for farmers symbol. These bodies include: The Soil Association,
turning to organic methods of agricultural production[7]. Organic Fanners and Growers Ltd, UK Register of Organic
Also, in May 1989, the Parliamentary Secretary at MAFF, Food Standards (UKROFS), and the International
Richard Ryder MP, welcomed the first national standards Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements (IFOAM).
for organic food production. These were drawn up by the
United Kingdom Register of Organic Food Standards
(UKROFS)[7,8]. However, if organic production is to Food Acceptability
succeed and meet market demand, more government The relationship between food quality and organic farming
money is needed for research and development[9]. is exceptionally difficult to analyse and evaluate. The
problem is as Maga[10] states: some food consumers are
calling for agricultural products to revert to organic
Organic Standards methods and for food processors to abstain from adding
A farmer wishing to produce organic foods for sale in the chemicals to our food supply because they feel these
UK must follow strict organic standards. There are five chemicals are polluting the environment, constituting a
important reasons for these which relate mainly to real threat to our health. They firmly believe that
authenticity: organically grown food tastes better, is better nutritionally
and is safer for health than conventionally grown processed
(1) The consumer needs some sort of assurance that and marketed food. Because of these beliefs, they are
what he is buying is organic. willing to pay a premium for organically grown foodstuffs.
(2) The retailers marketing the produce require a
recognised method of production, so that they can Maga attempts to make a rational evaluation of such claims
confidently label the food as organic. in his extensive and scholarly work. He summarises the
pros and cons of organic farming systems as follows:
(3) The producer needs guidance on what he must and
must not do, if his produce is to qualify as organic. Advantages
(4) The producer requires protection against others
falsely labelling their produce as organic. • Problem of residual pesticides minimised.
(5) It is useful to have a description which the trading • Improved soil structure.
standards officers can use to determine what may • Uses wastes and residues.
qualify as being organically produced. • Minimises groundwater pollution through nitrates.
CONSUMER ATTITUDES TO ORGANIC FOODS 27
most organic fertilisers are not high, needing large vegetables, approximating 60 mg a day with only some
applications to be effective. The use of organic manures 10-20 mg added directly through water. Concentrations
needs skilled farming knowledge to be effective with of nitrates can vary considerably in vegetables and beer.
certain constraints, but generally will tend to improve soil The heavy beer drinking vegetarians may be most at risk!
structure, reduce groundwater pollution, and lead to a
more sustainable farming system. This disparity between "experts" view of risk and
consumer concern stems from the different criteria that
The control of plant disease requires special mention since both groups use to formulate an overall risk factor. Experts
the use of chemical sprays and consequent levels of residue use numerical estimates obtained from previous incidence
in foodstuffs give rise to consumer concern. The organic or extrapolated from animal experiments. Consumers use
farmer has to seek ways of controlling plant pests and a more complex function based partly on fatality estimates
disease without using insecticides or fungicides. These but highly sensitive to other characteristics such as the
methods involve: "catastrophic potential" or whether costs and benefits
are equally shared or the familiarity of the hazard[15]. It
• Choosing plant varieties with genetic capacity to is easy to see these contrasting criteria at work in the
resist disease. context of the "organic" debate.
• Crop rotation.
• General field sanitation.
• Non-synthetic insecticides (e.g. pyrethins, roterone, Sensory Aspects
nicotine). Apart from the possible threats to health posed by aspects
• Biological controls. of conventional farming, does organic farming produce
better tasting foodstuffs, e.g. improve organolyptic
Even such a cursory mention illustrates the great deal of qualities? Organic foods are often claimed to be better
ecological science needed by the organic farmer necessary tasting and fresher. The problem with testing such claims
to be effective in meeting current food needs. is that they can derive from varietal differences or
differences in maturity or ripeness, although Maga et
al.[16] stated that the naturally occurring variation in many
Water fruits is so large that any differences due to production
The relationships between water, crop and crop quality methods (conventional or organic) are swamped.
have received considerable attention in the scientific
literature, but these are framed mostly in terms of specific Schutz and Lorenz[17] found labelling vegetables as organic
attributes or characteristics[11-12]. Nilsson[13] and significantly increases acceptance ratings. They state
Prashar[14] emphasise the varying influence of irrigation "although generalising to all vegetables and consumers
on clearly defined biological attributes or productivity of would not be warranted, the data from this study show
the crop which significantly effects food quality quite apart that the consumer would not be receiving a product of
from organic methods. Prashar[14] also asserts the higher acceptability when purchasing an organically grown
common belief that natural rainfall produces superior fruits product". The exceptions to this were broccoli and carrots.
than those "artificially" watered.
Appledorf et al.[18] attempted to determine whether there
Of more recent concern has been the effect of nitrates was a subjective preference for healthy food based on
on human health especially directly through tap water. sensory qualities. Out of 25 health foods, five equivalent
These convert into nitrites in the human body which can traditional foods were found to be significantly superior
28 BRITISH FOOD JOURNAL 93,2
in overall acceptance (cereals, cashews, apple sauce, apple observation that: "knowledge of the emotional value of
juice and dried apples). Colour and odour were important foods is much older than the nutritional value of food,
sensory attributes. hence many people will pay the increased price because
food has an emotional rather than an intellectual value".
Hansen[19] explained that any comparison of biodynam-
ically and conventionally grown crops is extremely difficult
because of the large number of parameters which have Consumer Attitudes
to be controlled. His results showed a variable connection Consumer attitudes to organic foods described in the
between the chemical or taste composition of vegetables literature consulted provide an interesting contrast to the
grown in the two different methods of cultivation. clear results emerging from scientific studies. In addition,
some variations in the ranking and intensity of attitudes
Alvensleben and Meier[20] dealt with some psychological between countries seem apparent.
factors causing distortion in consumer perception of
product quality; these contrasted with empirical In the UK, Stopes and Woodward[22] found that a minority
observations. They found that the appearance of fruit and of the population have only an approximate idea of what
vegetables was an important factor in consumer perception
Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 19:48 22 January 2015 (PT)
Ekelurd[26] argues that consumer preferences in Sweden subject to price and availability. Thus, the market for
are usually connected with the complex question of food organic food is now characterised as supply-driven, where
quality. In Sweden, as in the UK, the increasing demand a farmer's reluctance to change farming systems is
for organic produce is strongly linked with freedom from perceived to be the main obstacle[28]. The problem is that
chemical residues and personal health rather than perceptions, beliefs and attitudes of farmers do not always
environment issues. Food quality is associated with crop correlate with their behaviour. Figure 4 gives estimates
production without chemicals. of the future size of the market in the UK.
According to valuable surveys, consumer attitudes in The findings of an assessment: "the willingness to pay
Germany show some variation from the British pattern, a premium" [29] are shown in Figure 5. Clearly, interest
with a greater emphasis on environmental linkages; in consumption increases sharply when the price premium
broader political and ecological factors bear strongly on is below 20 per cent, whereas in practice price differentials
the demand for organic food (35 per cent) in contrast to are often 40-100 per cent. This result supports the
quality or related factors (16 per cent). contention that relatively high prices are a serious obstacle
for consumers.
Alvensleben and Altinann[27] summarise the basic
conditions behind the rising demand for organic produce:
• The socio-cultural background: changing values in
the society ("post-materialism", scepticism against
economic growth and modern technology,
environmental movement, etc.).
• General discontent with the present food supply
(concern about residuals, etc.).
• Positive image of organic food (health, taste, etc.)
• Health consciousness of the consumers.
• Discontent with the mass distribution system
("alienation").
• Positive income elasticity, negative price elasticity
of demand.
B. Beharrell is based at the Department of Marketing and Business Management, Silsoe College, Cranfield Institute
of Technology. J.H. Macfie is Head of Department of Consumer Sciences, Institute of Food Research, Reading, UK.
This article has been cited by:
1. Klaus-Peter Wiedmann, Nadine Hennigs, Stefan Henrik Behrens, Christiane Klarmann. 2014. Tasting green: an experimental
design for investigating consumer perception of organic wine. British Food Journal 116:2, 197-211. [Abstract] [Full Text]
[PDF]
2. J.E. Hermansen, K. Horsted, A.G. KongstedMEAT, ANIMAL, POULTRY AND FISH PRODUCTION AND
MANAGEMENT | Meat Production in Organic Farming 199-203. [CrossRef]
3. T. VUKASOVIČ. 2013. Attitude towards organic meat: an empirical investigation on West Balkans Countries (WBC)
consumers. World's Poultry Science Journal 69:03, 527-540. [CrossRef]
4. Justin Paul, Jyoti Rana. 2012. Consumer behavior and purchase intention for organic food. Journal of Consumer Marketing
29:6, 412-422. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]
5. Rebecca Schröck. 2012. The Organic Milk Market in Germany Is Maturing: A Demand System Analysis of Organic and
Conventional Fresh Milk Segmented by Consumer Groups. Agribusiness 28:3, 274-292. [CrossRef]
6. Jos Bartels, Isabelle van den Berg. 2011. Fresh fruit and vegetables and the added value of antioxidants. British Food Journal
113:11, 1339-1352. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]
7. Joris Aertsens, Koen Mondelaers, Wim Verbeke, Jeroen Buysse, Guido Van Huylenbroeck. 2011. The influence of subjective
and objective knowledge on attitude, motivations and consumption of organic food. British Food Journal 113:11, 1353-1378.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]
8. Zuzanna Pieniak, Joris Aertsens, Wim Verbeke. 2010. Subjective and objective knowledge as determinants of organic
Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 19:48 22 January 2015 (PT)
31. Marjon van der Pol, Mandy Ryan. 1996. Using conjoint analysis to establish consumer preferences for fruit and vegetables.
British Food Journal 98:8, 5-12. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]
32. Mitchell R. Ness, Hubert Gerhardy. 1994. Consumer Preferences for Quality and Freshness Attributes of Eggs. British Food
Journal 96:3, 26-34. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]
33. Dov Basker. 1992. Comparison of taste quality between organically and conventionally grown fruits and vegetables. American
Journal of Alternative Agriculture 7:03, 129. [CrossRef]
34. Brian Beharrell, Alasdair Crockett. 1992. New Age Food! New Age Consumers! With or without Technology Fix Please.
British Food Journal 94:7, 5-13. [Abstract] [PDF]
35. Brian Beharrell. 1991. Introduction: An Environmentally Friendly Policy for Retailing. British Food Journal 93:3, 3-7.
[Abstract] [PDF]