Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1130-Article Text-5202-2-10-20190428
1130-Article Text-5202-2-10-20190428
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.24018/ejers.2019.4.4.1130 74
EJERS, European Journal of Engineering Research and Science
Vol. 4, No. 4, April 2019
performance of the compressor, to investigate the effects of method for analyzing the compressor under consideration.
clogging on the performance of the compressor and to do a There are three types of compression processes which are
thermodynamic analysis of the said compressor to assess or possible in the reciprocating air compressor. They are
evaluate its performance. polytropic, isothermal and adiabatic compression processes.
In a bid to improving the efficiency of two-stage
reciprocating air compressor due to high temperature, an
experimental investigation was performed involving the use
of different intercoolants such as air, water, cooling source,
radiator coolant and ethylene glycol. Consequently, it was
concluded that the isothermal work required to compress the
air and the power required to drive the reciprocating
compressor reduced with respect to the intercooling [13].
Reference [14] carried out a thermodynamic analysis of a
reciprocating air compressor. During the thermodynamic
analysis, they found out that the clearance volume is one of
the parameters on which the performance and efficiency of
the compressor depend.
Fig. 1. Graph showing different compression processes.
Reference [15] presented a paper on improving the
performance and development of two stage reciprocating air The area under Fig. 1 shows the workdone in
compressor with particular focus on the case study of a compressing the air to P2 from P1 and the line with the least
reciprocating air compressor of a locomotive with the slope (isothermal compression) produces minimum or
associate problems, diagnosis and solutions highlighted. It lowest work. As seen from the graph, isothermal
involved a simulation model which they did. The simulation compression produces minimum work and it is the condition
model can predict volumetric efficiency, free air delivered, under which minimum work can be achieved in a
indicated power, shaft power, cylinder air pressure, cylinder compressor.
air temperature, resultant torque and the mass of air drawn
in or discharged out per cycle, by varying any operating 2) Polytropic Compression
parameter like speed, discharge pressure, etc. and physical This process lies between the isothermal and adiabatic
parameters like clearance volume, crank radius, connecting processes. In Fig. 1, 1-2p is a polytropic process and the
rod length and cylinder diameter. Also, compressed air was relationship between pressure (P) and volume (V) is given
produced without the use of electricity. That was done with as;
the use of speed breaker setup in roadways. Instead of using PVn = C (1)
electric drive, mechanical drive was used to generate the Also, workdone during a polytropic process is given as;
compressed air. This method of using speed breakers for the n1
generating of electricity is of great value especially because 2n P2 2 n (2)
W
P1V1
1
of the over reliance on electricity for the production of n 1 1
P
compressed air which has been the norm for many years
now [16]. where
P
II. MATERIALS AND METHODS r p = 2 (3)
P1
A. Materials
The manufacturer’s manual, operational data and field P1 = Inlet Pressure (N/m2), P2 = Discharge Pressure (N/m2),
reports for the air compressor under investigation were used V1 = Inlet Volume (m3), n = Index of Compression and
for this study. From these data, values were computed and r p = Pressure Ratio
used for the assessment of the performance of the
compressor. Also, relevant operating parameters such as the
inlet and outlet temperatures and pressures of the 3) Isothermal Compression
compressor were obtained for its thermodynamic analysis. Isothermal compression takes place at constant
temperature [14]. Workdone during an isothermal
B. Methods compression is evaluated as:
Wi = P1V1 ln rp (4)
The analysis and assessment of the compressor were done
to achieve the aim and objectives of this research with the where P1 = Inlet pressure (N/m2), P2 = Discharge
use of relevant fundamental equations that govern a two-
stage reciprocating air compressor, relevant models and pressure(N/m2) and rp = Pressure Ratio
thermodynamic analysis.
4) Adiabatic Compression
1) Analytical Model This type of air compression takes place in the absence of
A thermodynamic analysis was chosen as a suitable heat transfer [8]. The workdone during adiabatic
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.24018/ejers.2019.4.4.1130 75
EJERS, European Journal of Engineering Research and Science
Vol. 4, No. 4, April 2019
ηv = 1+C-C r
p
1
n
(6)
Where P1 = Inlet Pressure (N/m2) and P2 = Discharge
Pressure (N/m2)
where C = Clearance ratio
10) Intercooler Pressure
For minimum work condition with perfect intercooling to
6) Isothermal Efficiency ( i ) be obtained, the intercooler pressure is evaluated as:
Isothermal efficiency is given as the ratio of the
isothermal work to the actual work. Px = P1 P2 (10)
Wi
i (7) 11) Intercooler Temperature
W
For complete or perfect intercooling in a two-stage
reciprocating air compressor, the intercooler temperature
7) Multistage Compressor (also known as the intermediate temperature) is given as;
Multistage compression involves more than one stage of
compression and it is done when high pressures are required n 1
Px n
(11)
[17]. It has the two-stage (low and high pressure stages)
Tx T1
P
compression as its typical example where compression of
the air is done in two stages with an intercooler incorporated 1
between the two stages [18]. The essence is basically to Where Tx = Intercooler Temperature, K
reduce the discharge temperature and increase the discharge Px = Intercooler Pressure, N/m2
pressure to the required pressure {19]. Achieving lower P1 = Inlet Pressure, N/m2
work, better capacity and efficiency while maintaining T1 = Inlet Temperature, K
isothermal condition is very difficult since increasing
pressure ratio, rp, causes a decrease in volumetric efficiency 12) Heat rejected in the intercooler
and an increase in delivery temperature, T 2 [20]. This The rate of heat rejected in the intercooler in kg/s is given
therefore requires a multistage compressor (a two-stage type as
in this case) to solve the problem as shown in Fig. 2.
Qx = Cp (Tx-T1) (12)
Where m = Mass flow rate, kg/s
Tx = Intercooler Temperature, K
T1 = Inlet Temperature, K
Cp = Specific heat at constant pressure, KJ/kgk
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.24018/ejers.2019.4.4.1130 76
EJERS, European Journal of Engineering Research and Science
Vol. 4, No. 4, April 2019
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.24018/ejers.2019.4.4.1130 77
EJERS, European Journal of Engineering Research and Science
Vol. 4, No. 4, April 2019
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.24018/ejers.2019.4.4.1130 78
EJERS, European Journal of Engineering Research and Science
Vol. 4, No. 4, April 2019
Tables II and III represent clogging and normal periods the changes in the operating conditions of the
respectively, show the various daily average operating thermodynamic parameters of the compressor. The clarity of
values over a 30-day period when the compressor under the effects of these parameters on the performance
investigation was operating under the influence of clogging assessment of the compressor is therefore simplified via
and when it was operating almost normally. In Table II, the graphical representations as shown in Figures 3-12.
values are for a period when the compressor experienced the
problem of clogging which negatively affected the
performance of the compressor and thereby caused an
increase in discharge temperature and decrease in discharge
pressure, mass and volume flow rates respectively as the
days went by. As observed in Table III, the mean values of
the control parameters (discharge temperature, discharge
pressure, mass and volume flow rates) over another 30-day
period referred to as “normal” did not change or fluctuate
significantly; they only varied around their daily mean
values thereby making the average values per day over the
afore-mentioned period almost constant.
C. Off-design Behaviour of the Compressor
Fig. 3. Effect of Ambient Temperature on Discharge Pressure.
The Tables I and II clearly illustrate the trend in terms of
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.24018/ejers.2019.4.4.1130 79
EJERS, European Journal of Engineering Research and Science
Vol. 4, No. 4, April 2019
From Fig. 3, it is observed that the discharge pressure is a The trend in Fig. 6 shows that the change in isothermal
function of the operating ambient temperature of the intake work of the compressor affected the isothermal efficiency
air such that as the operating ambient temperature of the such that an increase in the isothermal work brought about
intake air increases the discharge pressure also increased an increase in isothermal efficiency. The reverse is the case
correspondingly. Also, a decrease in the operating ambient when the isothermal work decreased as the isothermal
temperature also led to a drop or decrease in the discharge efficiency also decreased.
pressure.
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.24018/ejers.2019.4.4.1130 80
EJERS, European Journal of Engineering Research and Science
Vol. 4, No. 4, April 2019
Fig. 9. Effect of Clogging on Volume flow rate over a period of time. Fig. 12. Effect of Temperature during clogging on discharge pressure over
a period of time
Fig. 9 shows that the volumetric flow rate of the air kept
decreasing as the number of days increased thereby Fig. 12 shows that the effect of clogging (during the
negatively affecting the flow capacity of the air compressor clogging period) caused a gradual temperature increase that
and lowering its performance. The case was different and resulted in a gradual decrease in the discharge pressure over
better when the compressor operated under normal time as the days went by.
condition.
IV. CONCLUSION
The performance of the two-stage reciprocating air
compressor located and operating at an Oil and Gas
Terminal in Rivers State, Nigeria was assessed and analysed
via the application of some relevant thermodynamic
equations. From the analysis of the performance of the
compressor, it was evident that the performance of the
reciprocating air compressor depended significantly on the
effects of clogging on the compressor.
From the thermodynamic analysis done, it was evident
that the compressor experienced 26% loss in the volumetric
efficiency of the compressor, 8% reduction or decrease in
the isothermal efficiency, 11.1% loss in the volume of air
Fig. 10. Effect of Clogging on Mass flow rate over a period of time discharged every second and 21% loss or reduction in the
mass flow rate when compared with the design
Fig. 10 also illustrates the fact that as the days went by,
specifications. These low efficiencies could be as a result of
the mass flow rate reduced continuously. This gradual
clogging which may have taken place to cause the reduction
decrease in the mass flow rate continued until after the 26th
in the performance of the compressor to such a level.
day when a sharp decrease began.
Table II and Figures 7 to 12 show that clogging had
negative effects on the performance of the compressor
which caused increase in discharge temperature, decrease in
discharge pressure, mass and volume flow rates. Therefore,
it may be justifiable to say that minimising clogging in the
compressor would likely cause improved performance that
may meet the required design performance. This work
therefore shows an effective thermodynamic performance
evaluation of the compressor at an Oil and Gas Terminal in
Rivers State, Nigeria; hence, the objectives of this research
work have been achieved. This study also contributes to the
understanding that thermodynamic analysis is a veritable
tool that can be used in analysing and accessing the effects
Fig. 11. Effect of Temperature during clogging on Volume flow and Mass of clogging in two-stage reciprocating air compressors.
flow rates In order to solve or minimize the menacing problem of
Fig. 11 shows that during the clogging period, every clogging for an improved performance of the air
increase in temperature caused decrease in the mass and compressor, the double-filter installation method should be
volume flow rates. The negative effect of clogging on the applied to limit the degree and amount of unwanted
performance of the compressor was such that, as the elements gaining entrance into the compressor. Periodic and
temperature increased daily, the volume flow rate and the timely change of the desiccants inside the compressor’s air
mass flow rate of the discharged air decreased. dryer is also recommended to minimise clogging and to
prevent moist air from being discharged; thereby ensuring
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.24018/ejers.2019.4.4.1130 81
EJERS, European Journal of Engineering Research and Science
Vol. 4, No. 4, April 2019
that discharged air are always dry. Periodic cleaning of the [6] Khan, A.R.A. (2014). Applied Thermodynamics: Reciprocating
Compressor, 1-30. httpsedoc.sitemodule-6-reciprocating-compressor-
cylinders of the reciprocating air compressor helps to pdf-free.html
minimize clogging caused by accumulation of deposits and [7] Lin, P., & Avelar, V. (2017). The Different Types of Cooling
unwanted build-ups due to corrosive effects on the internal Compressors. A Journal of Different Technologies for Cooling Data
Centres, 254, 1-12.
surface of the cylinders. Further research could be carried
[8] Muduli, S. (2015). Reciprocating Compressors, 1-15.
out to detect the presence of clogging and the exact quantity https://www.scribd.com/document/266498454/Reciprocating-
of clog in reciprocating compressors without opening the Compressors-pdf
compressor during maintenance. [9] Bloc, H. P., & Hoefner, J. J. (1993). Reciprocating Compressors &
Operation Maintenance. Houston TX: Gulf Professional Publishing.
[10] Balu, S. (2010). Parts of an Air Compressor, 1-5. httpswww.brighthub
engineering.comhvac64883-parts-ofan-air-compressor
ACKNOWLEDGMENT [11] Willingham, R.A. (2009). Testing and Modelling of Compressors for
Low Lift Cooling Applications, 1-138.
The authors would like to profoundly appreciate the [12] Mishra, P. (2018). Air Compressor and its Types, 1-7.
department of Mechanical Engineering, Rivers State httpwww.mechanicalbooster.com201803what-is-air-compressor-and-
its-types.html
University, Port Harcourt, Nigeria for the technical supports [13] Balu, S. (2010). Effects of a Multi-stage Air Compressor, 1-4.
given during the process of this research work. httpswww.brighthubengineering.comhvac63725-effets-of-a-multi-
stage-air-compressor
[14] Pipalia, V.F., Shukla, D.D., & Mehta, N.C. (2015). Investigation on
Reciprocating Air Compressor-A Review. International Journal of
REFERENCES Recent Scientific Research, 6(12), 7735-7739.
[1] Raj, N.D., Shujathullah, M., Dinesh, M., & Reddy; P.V. (2016). [15] Wadbudhe, R.C., Lodhe, A., & Shelke, A. (2017). A Research Paper
Thermodynamic Analysis of Gas Compressor. International. Journal on Improving Performance and Development of Two Stage
of Mechanical and Production Engineering, 4, (10), 110-113. Reciprocating Air Compressor. International Journal of Research in
[2] Sathyaraj, A., (2015). Analysis and Performance Enhancement of Science & Engineering, 3(2), 285-288.
Intercooler in Two Stage Reciprocating Air Compressor Using CFD. [16] Kumar, V. D., Gokulnath, A., Kumar P.N., & Kumar S.V. (2017).
International Journal on Applications in Mechanical and Production Working Of Air Compressor with Aid of Speed Braker. International
Engineering, 1(2), 1-5. Journal of Advanced Research, Ideas and Innovations in Technology
[3] Wadbudhe, R.C., Diware, A., & Kale, P. (2017). A Research Paper on 3(2), 477- 481.
Improving Performance and Development of Two Stage [17] Rogers, G., & Mayhew Y. (1992). Engineering Thermodynamics:
Reciprocating Air Compressor. International Journal of Research in Work & Heat Transfer (2nd ed.). India: Dorling Kindersley (India)
Science & Engineering, 3(2), 272-279. Pvt. Ltd.
[4] Sasmal, J.K., Suhane, A., & Agnihotri, G. (2013). Condition [18] Çengel, Y. A., & Boles, M. A. (2006). Thermodynamics: An
Monitoring and Maintenance Program of Two Stage Reciprocating Engineering Approach (5th ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill.
Air Compressor. Internal Journal of Science and Research (IJSR), [19] Dunn, D. J. (2007). Engineering Thermodynamics: Reciprocating Air
4(6), 2596-2602. Compressors, 1-23.
[5] Bagade, A.S., & Kadam, G.A. (2017). Design and Analysis of [20] Eastop, T. D., & McConkey, A. (1993). Applied Thermodynamics for
Reciprocating Double Acting Two Stage Air Compressor Crankshaft. Engineering Technologists. India: Dorling Kindersley (India) Pvt. Ltd
International Journal of Research Publications in Engineering and
Technology (IJRPET), 3(9), 80-83. .
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.24018/ejers.2019.4.4.1130 82