(2)
United States Patent
Cermenati et al.
009771551B2
US 9,771,551 B2
Sep. 26, 2017
USt
(10) Patent No.:
(4s) Date of Patent:
oa
oy
@
3)
wo
ep
@y
ws)
G0)
May 29, 2013
oy
(32)
8)
66)
LIQUID CLEANING COMPOSITION WITH
ABRASIVES,
Applicant: The Procter & Gamble Company,
incinnai, OH (US)
Inventors: Laura Cermenati, Brissels (BE):
Marina Jozefa Hermie, Hever (BE):
James Robert Tinlin, Brussels (BE)
‘The Procter & Gamble Company,
incinnati, OH (US)
Assignee
Notice: Subject to any disclaimer, the term ofthis
patent is extended or adjusted under 35
USC. 1544) by $43 days
Appl. No.: 14/282,248
Filed: May 20, 2014
Prior Publication Data
US 201410352723 Al Dee. 4, 2014
Foreign Application Priority Data
er) 13109681
Int. C1,
cmp 1700
CUD 166
cmp 13
cup 1735
CUD 186
cD 14
cmp 314
cup 320
Us. CL
cre
(2006.01)
(2006.01)
(2005.01),
(2006.01)
(2008.01)
(2006.01),
(2006.01)
(200601)
CHD 17/0004 2013.01): CHD 66
(2013.01), CIID 13 (2013.01), CHD 11835
(2013.01): C11D 1/86 2013.01): CIID 194
(2013.01); CTD 3/14 (2013.01), CIID 32075
(2013.01)
Field of Classification Search
CPC... CIID 17/0013; CHD ¥14: CLID 39715
See application file for compete search history.
References Cited
USS. PATENT DOCUMENTS.
suey
Suva
08s
rot9s0
Hioss
Diss
S194
Lives
Libs
1988
Daimler
Plate ea
Lyn
Mannbeimer
Miton
Fundarburk et
Conor ta
Len at
Chapa
emake
2.082.278
2oss0K0
Yassoot
Beery
daswore
2502279
Ysi2.04a
ta
4240919
ASesei7
4708235 11987 Hartman otal
Sites & "71998 Guot eal
Shev052 A $1999 Aidson ei ab
Sooner) A 51999 Osaounis oa
(6360,121 BL 42002 Catalfame eal
{8590965 B2 32004 Neda ea.
Sagpioek 8292010 Chena
20020137647 AL 9.2002 Hackental tal
Souaunesis9 AL Oyssio a
dor o1so7ss At Gonzales a
SoIoLso9st Gonzales eta
ale Delecisyder .... CHD3/3726,
‘een
AL, 32012 Peree-Prat Vinuest ta
Al* 123012 Gonzales ons CLID 170013
1810493
317736 AL 122012 Gonzales ea.
ao120321567 Al 122012 Gonzales a
so1DUR2ISEE AL 122012 Gonzales ea
gu12022719 AL 122012 Pewee Viawes ta
20130067669 AL "32013 Gonvales ea
aornog7est7 AL 32013. Poer-Pat Vinwes ta.
so1d0nsa72t AL 122014 Gonzales ea,
20140382720 AL 122014 Gonzales eta
am1aunsisa4 AL 122014 Gonzales a
FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS
we 1 987 156 AL
iP 2 338.966 AL
Wo wo 2011087748 AP
WO WO 2011135508 Al
WO WORT Al
(OTHER PUBLICATIONS
Nominal Ofice Action for US. Appl No, 14281, 99, data Ape
13, 2015,
Final Office Acton for US. Appl. No, 14281,997, dated Oct. 9,
2015, 10 pages.
TPCT Seaath Report dated Sep. 11, 2004; PCTUS2O 14039656; 6
Pages
US" Appl No, 14282,196, led May 20,2014, Cenmenai et
* cited by examiner
Primary Examiner — Gregory Webb
(74) Attorney, Agent, or Firm — Lauren Christine
Gonzalez; John T. Dipre
on ABSTRACT
A liquid cleaning andlor cleansing composition comprising
abrasive cleaning particles; one or more surfactants selected
from the group consisting of anionic, nonionic, cationic,
tures thereof and first acidic eompo=
‘nent wherein said acide component consists of one or more
chelating aids: wherein at least one nonionic surfataat is
‘comprised in ssid composition snd the total level of non-
jonie surfactant is less than 2% by weight of the (otal
‘composition andlor a least one anion surfactant is com
prised in said composition and the total level of anionic
Surfactant is less than 2% by weight ofthe total composition
13 Claims, No DrawingsUS 9,771,551 B2
1
LIQUID CLEANING COMPOSITION WITH
"ABRASIVES.
‘TECHNICAL FIELD
“The present invention relates to liquid compositions for
‘leaning andior cleansing a variety of surfaces, including
hard surfaces in and around the house, dish surfaces, etc
More spocfially, the present invention relates to liquid
Scouring composition comprising suitable particles for
‘leaning andior cleansing. In a highly preterred embodi
ment, the compositions of the present invention relate t0
hard surface cleaning compositions,
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
Scouring compositions such as particulate com
for lguid (nel. gel, paste-type) compositions co
ining
abrasive components are well known in the art Such com
Positions are used for cleaning anor cleansing a variety of
surfaces: especially those surfaces that tend to become
foiled with dificult to remove stains and soils
Amongst the curently known scouring compositions, the
most popular ones are based on abrasive particles with
shapes varying from spherical to iregular. The most com
‘mon abeasive particles are either inorganie like carbonate
salt clay, silica silicate, shale ash, perlite and quartz sand or
‘organic’ polymeric beads Tike’ polypropylene, PVC,
melamine, urea, polyacrylate, polyurethane and derivatives,
and come in the fonm of liquid composition having creamy
‘consistency withthe abrasive particles suspended therein.
‘Known abrasive compositions provide improved cleing
versus il parle compositions and developments have
boon made on improving surface safety without significantly
alfeting the cleaning performance
However, there sil remains a need for leveraging syn:
‘egies between abrasive particles and the formulation i
‘onder to maximize the cleaning performance
I's thus an objective ofthe present invention to provide
a Jiguid cleaning andr cleansing composition suitable 10
‘leanicleanse a variety of surfaces, wherein the composition
provides good cleaninglleansing performance at mi
‘num cos.
thas heen found thatthe above objective ean be mt by
the composition secording to the present invention.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
In a frst aspect, the present invention relates to liquid
‘leaning andor cleansing composition comprising abrasive
‘leaning particles; one of more surfactants seleted from the
troup consisting of anion, nonionic, cationic, amphoteric
land mixtures thers; anda first acidie component wherein
said avidie component consists of one or more chelating
ids; whorein a least one nonionic surfactant is comprised
in said composition and the total level of nonionic surfoctant
js less than 2% by weight ofthe total composition andor at
Jeast one anionic surfactant i comprise in said composi
and the foal level of anionic surfactant i Hess than 2% by
‘weight ofthe total composition,
“The present invention further encompasses a process of
‘leaning andlor cleansing a surface with aliquid, cleaning
andor cleansing composition comprising abrasive cleaning
particles, wherein suid surfce is contacted with said com-
Position, preferably wherein said composition is applied
‘onto said surface
o
2
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE
INVENTION
The Liquid Clesning/Cleansing Composition
‘The compositions according tothe present invention are
designed as clesners/cleansers fora varity of inanimate and
animate surfaces. In an embodiment, the compositions
herein are suitable for cleaning/cleansing surfaces selected
from the group consisting of inanimate surfaces, animate
surfaces
Ins prefered embodiment, the compositions herein are
suitable for cleaning/cleansing. inanimate surfaces seleeted
{rom the group consisting of houschold hard surfaces: dish
surfaces; surfaces like leather or syntbetic leather, and
flomotive vehicles surfaces,
In & highly prefered embodiment, the compositions
herein are suitable wo clean housshokd hard surfaces.
By “household bard surface", iis meant herein any kind
of surface typically found in and around houses Tike kiteh-
ens, bathrooms, eg. floors, walls, tiles, windows, eup-
boards, sinks, showers, shower plastifed curtains, wash
basins, WCs, fixtures and fitings and the like made of
ferent materials ike ceramic, vinyl, no-wax vinyl, Hino-
Jeum, melamine, glass, Inox, Formica, any plastis,
plastitied wood, metal or any painted or varnished or sealed
surface and the like. Household hard surfaces also inelude
household appliances including, but not Tmited wo relig-
cerators, froovers, washing machines, automatic dryers,
‘ovens, microwave ovens, dishwashers and so on, Sueh hard
strlaces may be found both in private households as well as
in commercial, institutional and industrial envieonmeats,
[By “abrasive foam particles” as used herein, itis meant
abrasive cleaning or scouring particles derived from frag-
‘menting 2 foam structure to provide nonspberical and
highly shaped profil
‘By “biodegradable” itis meant hersin chemical dissolt-
‘ion, disintegration or digestion of biodegradable abrasive
particles in a compost media at a rate of above 50%
According. 10 ASTM6400 tost_ method, ASTM6400 test
method refers to compostabilty of dhe material, but herein
compositability is refemed to as biodegradability. The
mate biodegradability of biodegradable abrasive particles
‘under controlled composting conditions is determined inthis
test method,
‘By “dish surfices” it is meant herein any kind of surfaces
found in dish cleaning, such as dishes, cutlery, cutting
‘boards, pans, and the lke. Such dish surfaces may’ be found
both in private households as well as in commercial, inst
tutional and industrial environments.
[By “acidic component” it is meant herein the listed
‘components in a solution pH of from 9 t0 14 (ineluding
‘when partially or totally neutralised),
By “chelating acid” it is meant herein organic andor
inorganic, preferably organic, acids in thee salt form having.
paturally oecuring chelating properties
In an another preferred embodiment, the compositions
herein are suitable for clening/cleansing animate surfaces
selected from the group consisting of human skin; anil
skin; human hair; animal hair; and txth
‘The compositions according (othe present invention are
liquid compositions as opposed to a solid or a gas. Liquid
‘compositions include compositions having a wate-ike vi
cosity as well as thicken! compositions, such as gels and
pastes.
‘Ina preferred embodiment herein, the liquid compositions
Doerein are aqueous compositions. Therefore, they may com-US 9,771,551 B2
3
prise from 65% to 99.5% by weight ofthe total composi
‘of water, preferably from 75% to 98% and more preferably
rom 80% 10 95%
In another preferred embodiment hercin, the liquid com=
positions herein are mostly non-agueous compositions
although they may comprise from (Me to 10% by weight of
the total composition of wate, preferably from 0% to 5%,
more preferably from 0% to 1% and most preferably 0% by
‘weight of the total composition of water
In. preferred embodiment, the pH ofthe composition is
from greater than 0 0 less than 14, preferably from 210 12,
more preferably from 2 to 12 but n0t including between 6
and 8, even more preferably from 2 to 6 or from 8 to 12
most preferably from 2104 or from 8 10 12, measured at 20°
(C. Most preferred are alkaline compositions having pil of
from 8 to 12, measured at 20°C.
In an embodiment herein, the compositions herein are
‘kaline compositions, and thus havea pH, sis measured at
20°C, of 8 to 12, more preferably 8.5 1 11.5
preferably 910 11,
In other preferred embodiment compositions have pH of
fiom 2 to 6, preferably 2 to 5 more preferably 2 to 4 and
altematively have pH! preferably below pHi 9,
Accordingly, the compositions herein may comprise site >
‘able bases and acid to adjust the pH
‘A suitable base to be used herein is an organic andor
‘noryanic base, Suitable bases for use herein ae the caustic
alkalis, such as sodium hydroxide, potassium hydroxide
and/or Tithium hydroxide, andior the alkali metal oxides,
‘ch, as sodium andlor potassium oxide or mixtures ther,
AA prefered base isa eastic alla, more preferably sodium
hiytioxide and/or potassium hydroxide,
‘Other suitable bases include ammonia, ammonium car.
bonate, all available carbonate silts such as K,CO,
Na,CO,, Ca,CO,, My,COs, ete. alkanolamines (@s eg.
rmonocthanolamine), urea and urea derivatives, polyamine,
ee
“Typical levels of such bases, when present, are of fom
0.01% to 5.0% by weight ofthe total composition, prefer
ably from 0.05% to 3.0% and more preferably from 01% t0
06,
The compositions herein comprise a first acidic compo
nent wherein said first aeidie component consists of one or
more chelating acids, preferably selected from the group
‘consisting of citric aeid, one or more salts of citric acid,
trae, one or more salts of citrate, phosphoric avid, one oF
‘more salts of phosphoric acid, tartaric aed, one or more salts
‘of tare acid, oxalic acid, one or more salts of oxalic avi,
maleic acid, one or more salts of maleic acid, glycolic acid,
‘oncor more salts of glycolic acid, succinic acid, one or more
salts of succinic ack, plutarie aeid, one oF more salts of
lutric aid, adipic avid, one or more salts of adipic acid,
and mixtures thereof, more proferably solected from the
zroup consisting of citric acid, one oF more salts of citic
id, citrate, one or more salts of citrate, phosphoric acid,
salts of phosphoric acid, and mixtures thereof. The level of
said frst acidic component is preferably from greater than
(0% to less than 0.5%, preferably from 0.1% to 0.48%, more
preferably from 0.2% to 0.47%, even more preferably Irom
10.3% to 0.46%, by weight of the composition. It has sur-
prisingly been found that small levels of such fist acidic
‘component provide improved cleaning ofa partite contain
jing composition, Once the level of such component is
increased t0 0.5% by weight or higher, the cleaning is no
Jonger improved and thus material is added with no further
beneiis on cleaning.
4
The compositions herein may comprise 4 second acidic
‘compontent wherein said second acidie component consists
‘fone or more non-chelating acids, preferably selected from
the group consisting of formie acid, one or more salts of
formic acid, lactic acid, one oF more salts of lactic acid,
hydrochloric acid, one or more salts of hydrochloric acil
stlphuric acid, one or more salts of sulphuric acids, and
rnixturesthereo The combination of first and second acidic
components provides added stability as wel as added ben-
clits towards limescale removal foi hard surfaces,
‘A ypical level of suel further aeids, when present, is of
rom 0.01% to 3.0% by weight of the total composition,
preferably from 0.08% to 3.0% and mote preferably from
0.059% 10 1.5%,
‘Ina preferred embodiment according to te present inven-
tion the compositions herein are thickened compositions.
Preferably, the liquid compositions herein have a viscosity
‘of up t 7500 eps at 20 +", more preferably rom S000 eps
{0 50 cps, yet more preferably from 2000 eps to 50 eps and
‘ost preferably from 1500 cps to 300 eps a 20 5 ad 20°
C. when measured with a Rheometer, model AR 1000
(Supplied by TA Instruments) with a 4 em conic spindle in
Stainless steel, 2° angle (linear increment from 0.1 to 100
soc"! in max, 8 minutes),
‘In another embodiment, the compositions herein have a
waterlike viscosity, By “waterlike viscosity” it is meant
Ipreina viscosity thats close to that of water. Preferably the
Tiquid compositions herein have a viscosity of up to 50 eps
at 60 rpm, more preferably from 0 eps to 30 eps, yet more
preferably from 0 eps to 20 eps and most preerabiy from 0
ps to 10 eps at 60 pin and 20° C. when measured with @
iooktield digital viscometer model DV Tl, with spindle 2.
"The compositions herein comprise one of more surf
fants selected from the group consisting of anionic, non-
jonic, cationic, amphoteric and mixtures thereof: and
‘wherein a least one nonionic surfactant is comprised inthe
‘composition and the foal level of nonianie surfaetant is ess
than 2%, preferably feom 0.1% t0 1.952%, moee preferably
from 0.2% 10 18%, most preferably from 0.5% to 1.75%, by
‘weight ofthe foal composition andor atleast one anionic
strlactant is comprised inthe composition and the total level
‘of anionie surfactant is less than 2%, preferably from 0.1%
to 195%, more preferably from 0.2% ta 1.8%, most pref
erably from 0.5% to 1.75% by weight ofthe total compo-
sition, It has been surprisingly found that such levels of
surfactant synergistically work withthe abrasive panicles to
provide better cleaning. but once the level exceeds the above
‘anges, no substantial improvement is observed versus the
cost associated with adding such excess material
‘Non-imiting examples of suitable non-ionic surfactants
include alcobol alkoxylate, alky] polysaccharides, amine
Dxides, block copolymers of ethylene oxide and propylene
oxide, fluoro surfactants and silicon based surfactants.
"A prefered class of non-ionic surfctants suitable forthe
present invention is alkyl ethoxylates. The alkyl ethoxylates
Of the present invention are either linear or branched, and
‘contain from 8 carbon atoms 016 carbon atoms in the
hydrophobic tal, and from 3 ethylene oxide units to 25
ethylene oxide ‘units in the hydrophilic head group.
Examples of alkyl ethoxylates include Neodol 91-62,
‘Neodol 91-80 supplied by the Shell Corporation (P.O. Box
2463, 1 Shell Plaza, Houston, Tex.) and Alfonie 810-605
supplied by Condea Corporation, (900 Threadneedle PO.
Box 19029, Houston, Tex.). More profered alkyl ethoxy
Jates comprise fom 9 to 12 carbon atoms in the hydrophobic
tail, and from 4 to 9 oxide units inthe hydrophilic head
soup. A preferred alkyl ethoxylate is Cy... EO,, availableUS 9,771,551 B2
from the Shell Chem
Neodol 91-51. A most prefered alkyl elhoxylate is C...,
EO,, available from the Shell Chemical Company under the
tradename Neodol 91-82, Other prefered nonionie strfac-
tants are Co Fy, available from Kolbe under te tradename
‘Greenbentine DE80, of Cy FO, available from Sasol under
the tradename Maripal 1038. Non-ione ethoxylates can also
be derived from branched aleahols. For example, alcohols
‘ean be made from branched olefin feedstocks such as
propylene or butylene. In a preferred embodiment, the
branched aleliol is either & 2-propyl-1-heptyl aleobol or
2butyl-L-oetyl alcohol. A desirable branched alcobol
‘ethoxylate is 2propyl-L-heptyl FO7/AO7, manufactured
‘and sold by BASF Corporation under the tradename Luten-
sol XP 79IXL 79.
‘Another class of non-ionic surfactant suitable for the
present invention is alky polysaccharides. Such surfactants
are disclosed in ULS. Pat. Nos. 4,565,647, 5,776,872, 5.83,
(062, and 5,906,973. Among alkyl polysaccharides, alkyl
polyelycosides comprising five andlor sx carhon sugarrings
are prefered, those comprising six carbon sugar rings are
‘more preferred, and those wherein the sx earbon sugar ring
js derived from glucose, i, alkyl polyglucosides ("APG")
‘are most prefered. The alkyl substituent in the APG chin
length is jveferably a saturated or unsaturated alky! moiety
‘containing from 8 fo 16 carbon atoms, with an average chai
Jength of 10 carbon atoms. CC, alkyl polyglucosides are
‘commercially available from several suppliers (eg, Simi
sol surfactants frm Seppie Corporation, 75 Quai d'Orsay,
75321 Pars, Cedex 7, Franee, and Glucopon 2208, Glueo-
pon 225%, Glucopon 4258, Plantaren 2000 NB and Plane
fen 2000 N UPR, from Cogais Comporation, Postfach 13,
(01 64, D 40551, Dusseldorf, Germany),
Another class of non-ionic surfactant suitable for the
present invention is amine oxide, Amine oxides. particularly
those comprising ffom 10 carbon atoms to 16 earbon atoms
inthe hydrophobic til, are beneficial because oftheir strong
Cleaning profile and ceflectivenoss even at levels below
(0.10%. Additionally Cp, amine oxides, expecially C.-C
‘amine oxides ae excelent solubilizers of perfume, Alter:
native non-ionic detergent surfactants for use herein are
alkoxylated alcohols generally comprising from 8 to 16
‘carbon atoms in the hydrophobic alkyl chain of the aleohol
‘Typical alkoxylation groups are propoxy groups or ethoxy
groups in combination with propoxy groups, yielding alk
‘ethoxy propoxylates. Such componnds are commercially
fvailable under the tradename Astarox® available fom
Rosia (40 Rue de la Haie-Cog, F-93306, Aubervllers
‘Céxkex, France) and under the tradename Nonidet® available
from Shell Chemica
The condensation products of ethylene oxide with 3
hydrophobic base formed by the condensation of propylene
‘oxide with propylene glycol are also suitable for use herein,
‘The hydrophobic portion of these compounds will prefer
ably have moleeulae weight of from 1500 to 1800 and will,
‘exhibit water insofubiity. The addition of polyoxyethylene
moieties to this hydrophobic portion tends to increase the
‘water solubility ofthe molecule as a whole, and the liquid
‘character ofthe prdict i retained vp tothe point where the
polyoxyethylene content is about 50% of the total weight of
the condensation product, which corresponds to eondens:-
tion with up 49 40 moles of ethylene oxide. Fxamples of
‘compounds ofthis type include certain ofthe commercially
_vailable Plaronie® surfactants, marketed by BASF. Chemi-
cally, such surfactants have the structure (EO),(PO),(EO).
fr (PO)FO),(PO), wherein x,y, and zane from 110 100,
preferably 3 1 50, Pluronic surfactants knowa to be good
0
o
6
wetting surfactants are more preferred. A description ofthe
Pluronic® surfactants, and properties thereof, including
wetting properties, can_be found in the brochure entitled
“BASE Performance Chemicals Plutonic & Tetronick
Surfactants", available from BASF,
Other suitable though not preferred non-ionic surfctans
include the polyethylene oxide condensates of alkylphenols,
eg, the condensation produets of alkyl phenols having an
alkyl group containing from 6 10 12 carbon atoms in ether
4 straight chain or branched chain configuration, with elle
Yylene oxide, the said ethylene oxide being present in
mounts equa 1 $10 28 moles of ethylene oxide per mole
of alkyl phenol The alky! substituent in such compounds
can be drive from oligomerized propylene, isobutylene,
or from other sources of iso-oetane n-etane, iso-nonane oF
wonane. Other non-ionic surfactants that can be sed
include those derived from natural souees such as sugars
and include Cj-C Nealkylslucose amide surfacauts
Suitable anionie surfactants for use herein are selected
from the group consisting of alk! sulphonate, alkyl aryl
sulphonates,alky! sulphates, alkyl alkoxylated sulphates,
eC alk alkoxylated linear or branched diphenyl oxide
dbsulphonates, or mixtures thereot.
Suitable alkyl sulphonates for use herein include water-
soluble salts or acids ofthe formula RSO;M wherein Risa
CoC linear or branched, saturated oF unsaturated alkyl
aroup, preferably a Cy alkyl group and more preferably
ACC alk] group, and Mis ora cation, ex, am alkali
‘etal cation (e, sodium, potassium, lithium), ce ammo-
‘ium of substituted ammonium (eg. methyl, dimeths,
and trimethyl ammonium cations and quaternary smo
cations, such as teramethyl-ammoniuim and dimethyl pip-
eridinium cations “and quaternary ammonium cations
erived from alkylamines sch as ethylamine,diethylamine,
‘eethplamine, and mixtures thereo, aod the ike).
Suitable alky aryl sulphonates Tor use herein include
water-soluble salts or aeids ofthe formula RSO,M wherein
Ris an aryl, preferably a benzyl, substituted By a C-Can
linear oF branched! saturated oF unsaturated alkyl group.
preferably a Cy-Cyy allyl group and more preferably a
Co-Cye alkyl group, and M is Hora cation, ean alk
‘metal cation (e., sodinm, potassium, lithium, calm,
‘magnesium and te like) of ammonium or substituted
‘ammonium (¢, methyl, dimethyl, and trimethy] ammno-
‘ium cations and quaternary ammonium cations, suel as
‘etrametiyl-ammonium and dimethslpiperiinium cations
and quatemiary ammonium cations derived from alkylam-
ines such as ethylamine, diethylamine, triethylamine, and
rintures thereof, and the Tike).
An example of C4-Cq alkyl sulphonate i Hostapar®
SAS available from Hoechst, An example of eommerially
available alkyl ary) sulphonate is Lauryl aryl sulphonate
from Su.Ma. Particularly prefered alkyl aryl sulphonates
aralkyl benzene sulphonstes commercially available under
trade name Nansa available from Albright&Wilson
Suitable alkyl sulphate surfctants for use herein are
acconing to te formula R,SO,M wherein Ry represents a
hydrocarbon group selected from the group consisting of
slrauht o branched alkyl radicals containing fom 6 t0 20
carbon atoms and alkyl phenyl radicals containing from 6%
18 carbon atoms in the alkyl group, Mis H or a cation, eg.
an alkali metal cation (6a, sodium, potasium, lithium,
Calcium, magnesiim and th ike) of amimenium or subst
tuted ammonium (eg, methyl, dimethyl, and trimethyl
ammonium cations and quaternary ammoniim cations, sch
as tetramethyammonivm and dimethyl piperiiniur ci
fons and quaternary ammonium eations derived fom alky-US 9,771,551 B2
7
Jamines such as ethylamine, dielhylamine, triethylamine,
and mixtures thereof, and the like) Particularly prelerred
branched allyl sulphates 10 be used herein are those con-
ining from 10 to [4 total carbon atoms like Islchem 123
ASB. Tsalchom 123 ASP commercially available from
Enichem isa C3, surfactant which is 94% branched. This
material can be deseribed a8 CHy—(CH,)y--CH
(CH.OS0,Na)(CH,), CH, where nem-8-9. Also pre-
ferred alkyl sulphates are the alkyl sulphates where the alkyl
chain comprises a total of 12 carbon atoms, Le, sodium
2-butyl octyl sulphate. Such alky! sulphate is commercially
‘available from Condea under the rade name IsofolR 128,
Particularly suitable finer alkyl sulphonates inelude Cya-C<
paraffin sulphonate Tike Hostapurk SAS commercially
available from Hoochst
Switable alkyl alkoxylated sulphate surfactants for use
herein are according tothe formula RO{A),SO,M wherein
Ris an unsubstituted CC, alkyl or hydroxyalkyl group
having 2Cy-C alkyl eomponent, preferably 8C-'alky
‘or hydroxyalkyl, more preferably C,-Cyq alkyl or hydroxy
alkyl, is an ethoxy or propoxy unit ms greater than 7270,
Typically hetwoen 0.5 and 6, more preferably between 0S
and 3, and Mis H or a cation which can be, for example, 2
metal cation (eg. sodium, potassium, lithium, calcium,
‘magnesium, te), ammonium or substtuted-ammonium cat-
jon, Alkyl ethoxylated sulfates as wel as alkyl propoxylated
sulfates are contemplated herein. Specific examples of sub-
‘tuted ammonium cations inelude methyl, dimethyl, im-
‘thy-ammoniam and gustemary ammoniim eations, such
‘a fetramethyl-ammonium, dinethy!piperidinium and eat-
fons derived from alkanolamines sich as ethylamine, dieth-
‘ylamine, triethylamine, mixtures thereof, and the Tike
Exemplary surfactants are C,,-C, alkyl polyethoxylate
(1.0) sulfate (C,-€ 4BC1.0)8M), C.-C, alk polyethony-
Inte 2.25) slate (C.-C, ,E2.25)8M0) C.-C alkyl poly-
cethoxylate (3.0) sulfate (C.-C, E.0)8M), C.-C 4 alkyl
polyethoxylate (4.0) sulfate (Cy2-C,4P, (4.0)SM), wherein
M is conveniently selected from sodium and potassium.
Suitable Cj-Cay alkyl alkoxylated linear or hranched