Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Article 12 Under The Indian Constitution
Article 12 Under The Indian Constitution
• Article 12 does not clear about the definition of Jurisdiction. However, the
school of thought is that since the judiciary has the power to make and
enforce laws, it should be considered to be a State. However, whereas a false
judgment may cause a violation of the fundamental rights of a citizen,
obstructive decisions of the Courts are subjected to the tests of Article 14 of
the Constitution.
Thus, the simple regulatory power of the government over any statutory or
non-statutory body is not enough for it to be deemed as a State. The
concerned administrative body has to be financially, functionally and
administratively and pervasively controlled by the government.
Essential Part of the Indian Constitution
Being a pivotal part of the Constitution of India, it has chastity along with
some black marks.
Some members of the Assembly were concerned that the wording of the
Article was too vague and some moved amendments. They particularly had
trouble with the term ‘other authorities’ which would in effect bring in almost
every government agency or officer under the sphere of ‘State’. One member
had a complaint regarding while it was fine for fundamental rights to be
binding on institutions like district boards and municipalities, to refer to these
institutions as the ‘State’ was inappropriate.
In the end, it got clarified that ‘authorities’ would refer persons that had ‘the
power to form laws or the power to have discretion vested in it’. Also, in
response to members who were against of the use of the term ‘State’, it was
argued that it would be burdened to list out the various institutions upon
whom fundamental rights were binding; so the term ‘State’ – with its
comprehensiveness and economy of words – was useful to adopt throughout
the fundamental rights section and therefore the Constitution.
The Assembly adopted the Article with just one amendment: ‘or under the
government of India’ was added to the end of the Article 12 to account for
those territories which were not part of India but nonetheless under the
control of the Indian government.