Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Structural Health-Monitoring System For Roof Structure of The Dalian Gymnasium
Structural Health-Monitoring System For Roof Structure of The Dalian Gymnasium
gymnasium journals.sagepub.com/home/ase
Abstract
The roof of Dalian gymnasium was designed in the form of suspen-dome structure. A structural health–monitoring system has been
developed for the roof structure to guarantee the safety condition during construction process as well as in future service. In this arti-
cle, a monitoring scheme was proposed in detail according to the mechanical characteristics of the roof structure. Fiber Bragg grating
sensors, inclinometers, and accelerometers were applied to measure necessary structural information. In order to interrogate differ-
ent types of sensors, a novel data acquisition device of the structural health–monitoring system was also introduced and has achieved
multitudinous physical variable synchronization acquisition. By analyzing the data obtained during the construction and normal opera-
tion of the gymnasium, the structural health condition was evaluated and the structural damage could subsequently be located.
Keywords
data acquisition device, fiber Bragg grating sensors, finite element method, structural health–monitoring system, suspen-dome
structure
lB = 2nL ð1Þ
Monitoring scheme and sensor disposition
More than 200 sensors were installed on the roof struc- The environmental change induces the wavelength
ture of the gymnasium to monitor various parameters change of reflected light. Hence, the strain can be pre-
including FBG sensors, inclinometers and acceler- sented by
ometers (Figure 2).
e = KDlB ð2Þ
Stress measurement of chord members. Based on the FBG where e is the strain, K is the sensitivity coefficient of
sensing technology, fiber optic sensors were designed sensors, and DlB is the wavelength change.
and developed to monitor various physical quantities The cross-section of the truss work was in the shape
such as strain and temperature with the advantages of of an inverted triangle. The strain variation of chord
light weight, high accuracy, and high resistance to elec- members was monitored by FBG sensors (Figure 3).
tromagnetic interference. Due to concerns of a cross sensitivity between strain
Light propagates through the gratings with negligible and temperature, an FBG temperature sensor was
signal variation. Only those wavelengths that satisfy the mounted by the side of each FBG strain sensor for
Bragg condition are affected and strongly back-reflected. temperature compensation. The Young’s modulus of
The center wavelength of the reflected light lB is decided the members is 210 GPa, on the basis of which the
by the grating period L and the effective index n stress of the members can be then determined.
1582 Advances in Structural Engineering 22(7)
where a is the inclination, Iout is the output current, Io Figure 4. Cable system of the roof structure.
is the output current of the initial status, and K is the
sensitivity of the sensor.
The relation between cable force DF and wavelength
of the sensor can be obtained according to equation (1)
Vibration measurement. The modal parameters were
and FBG sensor working principle (Li and Ren, 2008;
acquired by the accelerometers installed on the roof
Yi et al., 2011)
structure of the gymnasium to assist analyzing the
structural dynamic characteristics which could predict
DF = GDlB ð4Þ
the dynamic response.
where G is the sensibility coefficient of the cable force,
and DlB is the center wavelength change of FBG
Monitoring method of the cable system and measure point
sensor.
disposition. Due to the large span of the roof structure,
After the FBG sensor has been installed on the
cable system consisting of circumferential cables, radial
anchor, the cable was tensioned in the manufacturing
cables, and struts were built beneath the truss to reduce
factory. The sensibility coefficient of the cable force
the internal force and deflection of the central area
was 5.34 kN/nm calibrated through the tension test.
(Figure 4). The cable system was important to the
The sensitivity coefficient was also closely related
whole structure. In order to enhance the stiffness of
with the install location of FBG sensors because the
the cable system, proper pre-stress was applied so that
inappropriate location of the sensor would lead to
the structure would have the ability to undertake exter-
measurement error. The von Mises stress nephogram
nal load and support the truss structure. From the
of anchor is given in Figure 7 simulated by FE analysis
above, monitoring the pre-tension process of the cable
software ANSYS. In order to get large sensitivity coef-
system was necessary for safety construction.
ficient, sensors were installed on the pivot area where
The whole pre-tension process was divided into four
local stress concentration exists.
stages as follows. Stage 1 applied 10% of the designed
value on all of the radial cable which just straightened
the radial cable from relaxing status. As a result, there Data acquisition device of the SHM
was no strain changes monitored during this stage. system
Stages 2, 3, and 4 applied 50%, 70%, and 105% of the
designed value on the radial cable, respectively. An FE In the field of SHM, various kinds of new sensors such
model was built to simulate the last three stages of the as FBG sensors and electronic sensors have been devel-
pre-tension process. Figure 5 shows the cable force dis- oped to satisfy the requirement of sensing a quantity of
tribution in each stage. Based on the finite element physical parameters (Park et al., 2006). A special
method (FEM) results, the monitoring scheme for designed data acquisition device was in great demand
cable system is presented in Figure 6. to acquire signals from polytypic sensors to implement
In order to monitor the cable force, FBG sensors the function of data processing and structural safety
were installed on the anchor instead of the cable con- evaluation. In order to take the ability of SHM for
sidering the fact that the cable consisted of steel strand large-span structures, it was required that the data
and an outside steel tube. There existed a linear rela- acquisition device should be specified with the follow-
tionship between the strain of the anchor and that of ing goals according to the architectural characteristics:
the cable within the elastic range. Using epoxy, the
FBG sensor was glued on the anchor to monitor the 1. Due to the complexity of the large-span struc-
change of cable force. tures, parameters such as stress, acceleration,
Li et al. 1583
Figure 8. The picture of the sensing channels of the data acquisition device.
1 pm 62 me TCP/IP 80 nm 15 48
Figure 10. The picture of the demodulation module for electronic sensors.
filtered such as ambient noise. The strain and inclina- is shown in Figure 10. The integrated circuit
tion mainly depict the quasi-static process, and resam- board supported the demodulation for bridge
pling algorithm was adopted to decrease the sampling circuit, IEPE signal, voltage signal, and current
rate to 20 Hz for strain and inclination measurements. signal. The adjacent channel isolation could
Within each module, there was a real-time clock creat- reach up to 50 dB, and this module had the
ing a time-stamp. When data from multiple acquisition hardware-level filtering and noise reduction.
sources were to be combined, a universal timer with 3. In this device, the built-in modules acquiring
built-in 40 MHz clock installed in the field program- signals of FBG sensors and electronic sensors,
mable gate array (FPGA) accurately synchronized all respectively, were controlled by FPGA. Unlike
the individual clocks in the measurement modules. processors, FPGAs were truly parallel in
Time synchronization was 25 ns. Afterwards, the nature, so different processing operations did
obtained data were transferred to a buffer waiting for not have to compete for the same resources.
instructions from a real-time controller. The transmis- Each independent processing task, such as data
sion control protocol/Internet protocol enables the acquisition of acceleration and strain, was
data acquisition device to communicate with the calcu- assigned to a dedicated section of the chip,
lation terminal. At last, the monitoring results were and can function autonomously without any
processed to evaluate the structural safety condition. influence from other logic blocks. As a result,
In Table 1, specific parameter of the data acquisi- the performance of one part of the application
tion device is given. The characteristics of this device was not affected when more processing was
are summarized in detail as follows: added.
4. The real-time controller was embedded in this
1. In this project, a swept laser source with higher device with industrial-scale stability, in which
power and lower noise instead of the broad- equipped with an industrial processor in charge
band source enabled the data acquisition device of multi-rate management for data acquisition
to lengthen the sensing distance up to 20 km, and data transmission from FPGA to computing
interrogating the FBG signal. Meanwhile, the terminal through Transmission Control (TCP)/
measurable wavelength range was 80 nm from Internet Protocol (IP) protocol for further data
1510 to 1590 nm. Every channel of the 15 FBG processing and structural safety assessment.
channels can measure up to 100 sensors con-
nected in series in one single fiber. The swept In further data processing on the calculation termi-
laser source possessed the advantage of better nal, the criterion for structural safety assessment was
repeatability and accuracy without the need for compiled in the program. For strain measurement of
periodic recalibration. critical members, the safety evaluation was done by
2. As for the electronic sensors (current signal, comparison of the monitoring results with the steel
voltage signal, etc.), the demodulation module material strength to ensure the loading capacity. With
1586 Advances in Structural Engineering 22(7)
Figure 11. Percentages of cable force monitored at each stage contribute to the designed value, as it can be seen from
that contribute to the designed value. which that all the cable forces fail to reach 50% of the
designed value at stage 2. Considering the friction loss
regard to cable force measurement, the system com- and interaction in the cable system, it was normal and
pared the measured loads with the designed value. acceptable, and that was the reason for applying 105%
of the designed value at stage 4. However, when the pre-
tension construction was completed, sensor installed on
Analysis of the monitoring results
cable 20 showed the cable force was about 100 kN less
Analysis of the monitoring results of cable system than the designed value. Thorough inspections have
during the pre-tension construction process been carried out for the cable. This situation could be
probably caused by manual operation error due to the
Proper pre-stress for the cable system could enlarge
fact that the tension equipment was manually operated.
the stiffness of the cable system such that the structure
Hence compensation was made for cable 20 to reach the
possesses enough carrying capacity. Radial cable was
designed value. The error between monitored cable force
tensioned after the pre-tension construction of circum-
and target value at each stage was less than 10%.
ferential cable finished. Considering the fact that there
was a limited number of tension equipment, each stage
was carried out ring by ring to ensure the uniformity Monitoring results of struts. Stress changes of struts at
of the tension distribution. The tension construction each stage during the pre-tension construction process
lasted for 9 days in the process of which the SHM sys- are illustrated in Figure 12. The absolute maximum
tem was used to monitor the cable force. Parts of the stress change was 29.748 MPa less than the yield
monitoring results are listed as follows. strength 310 MPa.
Each end of the strut was equipped with one FBG
Monitoring results of radial cable. Figure 11 shows the strain sensor. The wavelength time-history of Z1-1
percentages of cable force monitored at each stage that strut in the second stage of pre-tension process is given
Figure 13. Stress time-history of Z1-1 strut in second stage of cable tensioning.
Li et al. 1587
Conclusion
Figure 16. Strain variation from October to January. The measurement system has been successfully operat-
ing for nearly 2 years, during which the system has
was nearly no strain changes for the first 25 days. been updated once. The obtained data was used to
Afterwards, the local temperature began to decline gra- evaluate the safe condition of the roof structure.
dually leading to the contraction of the steel structure. Conclusions are as follows:
This explained the increase in compressive strain in this
period. From day 53, the gymnasium suffered from a 1. The data acquisition device of the SHM sys-
strong wind lasting for 5 days, as a result of which the tem applied on roof structure of the Dalian
strain of most members suddenly decreased. During gymnasium could measure signals from vari-
this period, the maximum stress change was ous types of sensors such as optical fiber sen-
14.54 MPa, indicating that the structure was still under sors and electronic sensors synchronously in
safe condition. real time.
2. Data have been stored for the stress time-
history of key members. During the pre-tension
Monitoring results of load application on roof construction process, the cable system was ana-
structure. During the operation period, an extra truss lyzed. The difference between monitored cable
structure was added (Figure 17). Roof structure force and designed value at each stage was less
designed primarily for distributed loads must be than 10%.
checked locally for point loads. So load applications 3. During the operation period, the truss work
were carried out on the roof structure divided into was monitored for load application and long-
three stages: 20, 35, and 40 tons of weight. These loads term monitoring results were also analyzed.
were applied separately on the truss structure hoisted The results indicated that the structure was
on the roof structure. The three-dimensional (3D) under safe condition.
Sumitoro S, Matsui Y, Kono M, et al. (2001) Long span Zhang QL, Lv J, Li H, et al. (2013) Numerical analysis and
bridge health monitoring system in Japan. Health Moni- monitoring research for construction progress of Shang-
toring and Management of Civil Infrastructure Systems hai Tower. Building Technique 42(15): 9–12.
4337: 517–524. Zheng J, Qu WL and Zhang QL (2007) Structural health
Wu Z and Fujino Y (2005) Structural health monitoring and monitoring for the steel bracket of Shenzhen Civil Center.
intelligent infrastructure. Smart Materials and Structures Building Structure 37(3): 57–60.
14(3): 448–464. Zhou GD, Yi TH and Chen B (2016) Innovative design of a
Xia Y, Zhang P, Ni YQ, et al. (2014) Deformation monitor- health monitoring system and its implementation in a
ing of a super-tall structure using real-time strain data. complicated long-span arch bridge. Journal of Aerospace
Engineering Structures 67: 29–38. Engineering 30(2): B4016006.
Yi TH, Li HN and Gu M (2011) Multiple optimization stra- Zhou X (2010) Structural design and health monitoring of
tegies based sensor placement method for structural Jinan Olympic Sports Center. Engineering Mechanics
health monitoring. Journal of Building Structures 32(12): 27(2): 105–113.
217–223.