Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Biogreases For Environment Friendly Lubrication: March 2019
Biogreases For Environment Friendly Lubrication: March 2019
Biogreases For Environment Friendly Lubrication: March 2019
net/publication/331904328
CITATION READS
1 2,246
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Umesh Chandra Sharma on 20 March 2019.
ABSTRACT
Biogrease is an environmentally acceptable green lubricant formulated from
plant origin base oils, thickeners and performance additives for the
lubrication of industrial, automotive and other mechanisms. Biogreases
are attractive particularly to those applications in which the grease is lost
to the environment and cannot be collected for reclamation such as
agriculture and forest machinery, rail road and marine applications where
grease is lost to soil and water. The present article on bio-grease first gives
a basic definition of lubricant and grease followed by functions and history
of use of grease in human civilization. A survey of world grease market and
future estimates is given based on national lubricating grease institute
(NLGI) and Frost & Sullivan grease production survey and reports. A
discussion on three basic grease components with their sources, advantages
and disadvantages is given in tabular form. Need for biogreases and their
application areas are discussed. The bio-based content required in grease
for its labelling as a bio product is discussed. The article then presents the
chemical and structural differences between mineral and vegetable oils and
fats, limitations of vegetable oils in using them as base oil for lubricating
greases and different chemical methods to modify these oils for their potential
use as bio-lubricant and bio-grease. The laboratory method for production
of bio-grease from transesterified esters of vegetable oils using conventional
lithium or aluminium metal soaps is included. Finally, the important test
methods like consistency, dropping point, biodegradability, oxidation
stability, water washout resistance, operating temperature, etc. needed to
analyze the performance of a biogrease are discussed.
1
Department of Chemical Engineering, UIET, CSJM University, Kanpur-208024 (India)
2
Department of Chemical Engineering, Thapar University, Patiala-147004 (India)
*Corresponding author : E-mail : uc_sharma@hotmail.com
2 Environmental Sci. & Engg. Vol. 1: Sustainable Development
INTRODUCTION
HISTORY OF GREASE
The earliest record for use of lubricants and greases to reduce friction
by human civilization dates back to 2400 B.C. in a painted wall relief of an
Egyptian Pharaoh’s tomb where a worker standing on the front of the sledge
is seen pouring the water on sand for moving a large statue (Fig. 1.)[10].
Hittite chariots from another tomb dated to around 1400 B.C. are found
Biogreases for Environment Friendly Lubrication 3
The vegetable oils, animal fats and other bio-based materials kept wheels
and gears moving along smoothly for over 4,000 years[5] until the second
half of the 19th century when they were replaced by mineral oil and to a
lesser extent by synthetic oil based lubricant and greases[12]. Since 1859,
only the mineral oil based greases were manufactured[13]. Vegetable oil
based greases have been reported in literature as early as the 1940’s;
however, their practical applications appeared only in the 1960’s. The main
reasons for their limited applications appear to be their high prices, limited
performance and lack of support from government and environment
agencies[12]. Current century is witnessing the resurgence of greases made
from vegetable oils after a gap of around 150 years principally due to
uncertainties in crude oil prices, depleting oil reserves, excess production
of vegetable oils in many parts of the world, growing environmental
consciousness, drive for products based on renewable sources and stringent
legislative compliances[5].
The mineral oil based greases lead the market in terms of the volume
consumed, provide better stability in extreme temperatures applications
and are less expensive in comparison to synthetic and semi-synthetic oil
based greases but less durable compared to them. The synthetic and semi-
synthetic oil based greases are expensive but employed in more severe or
even quite exotic applications[2].
The mineral and synthetic oil based greases continue to dominate the
market today and this situation is likely to continue as long as the crude
oil is available at affordable prices. The recent success of nuclear talks
between Washington and Tehran in July 2015 may culminate in availability
of Iranian crude to global consumers. The current crude oil prices at US$40
a barrel are already the lowest since March 2009. These factors might
adversely affect the growth of biodegradable oils based lubricants and
greases segment in market.
total worldwide grease volumes were mineral oil based greases, followed
by synthetic and semi-synthetic oil based greases at about 3% each.
Biogreases made their entry in NLGI survey for the first time with about
1% market share [12]. The NLGI 2012 Grease Production Survey indicates
that only 0.42% of the total reported production worldwide is based on
biodegradable base oils[14]. Frost and Sullivan reports that the mineral oil
based greases accounted for 40.4% of the global industrial grease market
revenue in 2012, while the synthetic and semi-synthetic oil based greases
amounted to 55.6% of the total revenue mainly due to higher prices, with
remaining 3.9% revenue contributed by environment friendly greases. In
2013, the total industrial grease market generated US$1,169.3 million and
it is expected to grow at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 6.6%
between 2012 and 2019 (Fig. 3.)[2].
Fig. 3: Global industrial greases sales breakdown in 2012 and projections for 2019
(Data source: Frost and Sullivan, 2014)
GREASE STRUCTURE
Greases contain three basic components: base oil, thickener and additives.
Base oil can be a mineral oil, synthetic oil, or vegetable oil. Thickeners can
be inorganic (silica and bentonite clay) or organic (polyurea) materials or
metal soaps. The metal soap can be a reaction product of a metal-based
material (oxide, hydroxide, carbonate, or bicarbonate) and carboxylic acid
or its ester, or it can be added separately. Commonly used soap-type greases
are based on calcium, lithium, aluminium and sodium. The additives for
lubricating oils and greases are similar[15]. The various grease components
with their sources, advantages and disadvantages are given in Table 1.
Table 1: Grease components with their source, advantages and disadvantages[5, 15]
Base oil Petroleum Petroleum fra- Thermal and oxidati- Depleting feedstock
(75-90%) ctions having an ve stability/Low cost / / Toxicity and envir-
average volati- High lubricity onmental issues /
lity lower than Supply and price
that of gas oils fluctuations
Vegetable oil Soybean/Sun- Good lubrication / Thermal and oxida-
flower/ Canola / Biodegradable tive instability / Hi-
Castor/Corn/ gh price
Cottonseed/ Pa-
lm oil/ Karanja/
Jatropha
Synthetic oil Diesters and po- Thermal, oxidative, Diesters may deg-
lyol esters/Poly- hydraulic and hydrol- rade elastomeric
glycols/Polyalp- ytic stability/Wide vis- seals / Polyol esters
haolefins (PAO) cosity range/Wide ope- are expensive / Poly-
rating temperature glycols may degrade
range/High lubricity/ seals and surface
Low volatility/Long coatings/High visco-
service life sity PAO oils have
varying degrees of
biodegradability
Fatty acids Simple metal Anti-corrosion proper- Limited tempe-
from vegeta- soaps (lithium ties / Water resistant / rature and perfor-
ble, animal or or aluminium) Easy availability mance range / Can
fish oils re- stiffen after exten-
acted with ded use
metal hydro-
xide
Simultaneous Complex metal High and low tempe- Can be water-sen-
reaction of an soaps (lithium, rature applications / sitive / May harden
alkali with a aluminium, or Wash and corrosion on overheating
fatty acid and calcium sulph- resistance / Ability to
an inor-ganic onate) carry high loads with-
or short-chain out requiring extreme
organic acid pressure additives
Table 1: Contd...
Compone- Sources Examples Advantages Disadvantages
nt (wt.%)
double bonds. The saturated oils with greater hydrogen content are
preferred over unsaturated oils for intended application as base lube oil
because of better performance at low temperatures and stability towards
oxidation[5].
oil based lubricants and greases. Vegetable oils can be chemically modified
by transesterification, epoxidation, enzyme catalyzed esterification and
estolide formation for their use as bio-lubricants and bio-greases[16].
Consistency
the higher is the penetration number. Table 2 below lists the NLGI
consistency numbers in order of increasing consistency[1, 8].
Dropping Point
Biodegradability
Oxidation Stability
Pumpability
Operating Temperature
from needed areas. The mineral oil in grease can flash, burn or evaporate
at temperatures greater than 177ºC. At low enough temperature, the grease
becomes so viscous that it can be classified as hard grease. The pumpability
suffers and machinery operation may become impossible due to torque
limitations and power requirements. The pour point of base fluid has been
accepted as the low-temperature limit of grease[8].
CONCLUSIONS
The first oil crisis in 1973 followed by second oil crisis in 1979 shocked the
world oil consumers with supply and price fluctuations in petroleum
products. These two crises in quick succession alarmed the world powers
and caused them to look for alternatives of crude oil. Beginning from the
same decade, researchers started publishing their works on the negative
environmental impacts of mineral oil based lubricants and greases. The
1992 United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change
(UNFCCC), later extended in 1997 Kyoto Protocol, helped raising the
awareness among the common people to protect the environment from
anthropogenic interference. The depleting crude oil reserves, fluctuations
in oil prices and negative environmental impacts of petroleum products
are causes of major concern for everyone involved. Today a wide range of
biogreases are available commercially with lower cost environment friendly
manufacturing processes. The biogreases can be used in all applications
conventionally requiring mineral oil based greases, but are particularly
advantageous to agriculture, forest machinery, rail road and marine
applications where the grease is finally lost to soil or water. Apart from
cost and environmental benefits, biolubricants and biogreases can help in
improving the economic health of rural communities.
REFERENCES