Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Architecture of Renaissance Period: History of Architecture - III Dept. of Architecture, SSIU
Architecture of Renaissance Period: History of Architecture - III Dept. of Architecture, SSIU
2 Aversion to Gothic
12 Jan 2016 2
1 Introduction to Renaissance Architecture
It also saw the invention or application of such potentially powerful innovations as paper, printing, the compass, and gunpowder.
To the scholars and thinkers of the day, however, it was primarily a time of the revival of Classical learning and wisdom after a long period of cultural decline
and stagnation.
The style was carried to France, Germany, England, Russia and other parts
of Europe at different dates and with varying degrees of impact.
The main features in the style were the Classic orders, which were often
used decoratively.
Buildings designed for more modern wants were clothed in the classic
garb of ancient Rome.
Because of their good taste, architects consulted them, and often were their pupils, as
Ghiberti, Donatello, and Brunelleschi.
The schools of painting also had their influence on architecture, and aided the tendency
which caused structures to be looked upon as works of art, instead of being only based
on form and structural necessities.
Architects followed the Byzantine Dome, but lifted it boldly from its substructure and
placing it on a ‚drum,‛ with windows, making it a dominating feature.
Likewise, first to introduce the wall of massive rusticated masonry with arched openings, in
which the wall was frankly treated as motif.
The architects, although attracted by the mere external appearance of ancient Roman art,
followed the traditions of the Middle Ages, which did not separate the structure from the
decoration.
Although the new architecture began with the colossal dome of the cathedral of Florence, and culminated in the stupendous church of St. Peter at Rome, it
was pre-eminently an architecture of palaces and villas, of façades and of decorative display.
Constructive difficulties were reduced to their lowest terms, and the constructive framework was concealed, not emphasized, by the decorative apparel of the
design.
Among the masterpieces of the early Renaissance are many buildings of small dimensions, such as gates, chapels, tombs and fountains.
In these the individual fancy had full sway, and produced surprising results by the beauty of enriched mouldings, of carved friezes with infant genii, wreaths of
fruit, griffins, masks and scrolls; by pilasters covered with arabesques as delicate in modelling as if wrought in silver; by inlays of marble, panels of glazed
terra-cotta, marvellously carved doors, fine stucco-work in relief, capitals and cornices of wonderful richness and variety.
Planar classicism also tends to divide a wall into neat sections, with
such elements as columns, pilasters, and stringcourses.
Villa Rotunda,
Vicenza, 1592
The need to integrate the design of the plan with the façade was introduced
as an issue in the work of Filippo Brunelleschi, but he was never able to
carry this aspect of his work into fruition.
The first building to demonstrate this was St. Andrea in Mantua by Alberti.
The development of the plan in secular architecture was to take place in the
16th century and culminated with the work of Palladio.
One of the first true Renaissance facades was the Palazzo Piccolomini at
Pienza (1459–62), attributed to the Florentine architect Rossellino.
Façades were flat and unbroken, depending mainly for effect upon the
Palazzo Piccolomini, Pienza,
distribution and adornment of the openings, and the design of doorways, Italy; by Bernardo Rossellino
courtyards and cornices.
Regular repetition of openings on each floor, and the centrally placed door
marked by a feature such as a balcony.
An early and much copied prototype was the façade for the Palazzo Rucellai
(1446 and 1451).
Internally vaults and flat ceilings of wood and plaster were about equally common, the
barrel vault and dome occurring far more frequently than the groined vault.
Many of the ceilings of this period are of remarkable richness and beauty.
Domes used rarely in the Middle Ages, but after the success of the dome in Brunelleschi’s
design increased its use.
The dome became an indispensable element in church architecture and later even for secular
architecture.
The combination of dome, drum, and barrel vaults developed as characteristic structural
forms of churches.
Round domes were less successful due to structural difficulties compared to those with
pointed profiles.
Italian renaissance domes were first developed in Florence and were soon spread all over
various Italian cities.
La cupola di San Pietro,
Rome, 1506
Re-defining Building Crafts Jay Thakkar 12 Jan 2016 15
vaulting
Beginning of the fifteenth century the Gothic principles of
ribbed vaulting were abandoned, giving place to the revival of
the Classic method of solid semicircular vaulting.
Sant'Andrea,
Mantua,
Re-defining Building Crafts Alberti, begun 1462 Jay Thakkar 12 Jan 2016 16
walls and openings
External walls are highly-finished ashlar masonry, laid in straight
courses.
Palazzo Medici-Riccardo
Re-defining Building Crafts Florence, 1444 Jay Thakkar 12 Jan 2016 17
rustications
A popular decorative treatment of the Renaissance palazzo
was rustication, in which a masonry wall is textured rather
than smooth.
One of the first buildings to use pilasters as an integrated system was in the
Old Sacristy (1421–1440) by Brunelleschi.
The presence, particularly in Rome, of architectural remains showing the ordered Classical style provided an inspiration to artists at a time when philosophy
was also turning towards the Classical.
Right
West facade of
Reims Cathedral ,
Reims, France, ca.
1225–1290.
Re-defining Building Crafts Jay Thakkar 12 Jan 2016 22
comparative study – plan
Renaissance Gothic
Symmetry and proportion of part to part carefully studied. Picturesqueness and beauty of individual features more particularly sought
after.
Grandeur gained by simplicity.
Grandeur gained by multiplicity.
Fewness and largeness of parts to make the building appear less in size than
it really is. In consequence of the large number of parts, the building appears larger than
it really is.
Towers are sparingly used, and when they occur are symmetrically placed.
Towers are a general feature, and are often crowned with a spire.
The dome is a predominant feature
The tower and spire are predominant features.
Interiors of churches were planned on Roman principles, with domes and
pendentives. Interiors are more irregular, and are covered with stone vaulting, or open-
timbered roofs.
The parts are few, the nave being divided into three or four compartments,
by which a general effect of grandeur is produced. The parts are many, a nave of the same length as a Renaissance church
probably divided into twice as many compartments.
Large materials, with idea of fewness of parts. Small materials to carry out idea of multiplicity.
Stucco or plaster were often used as a facing material where stone was Masonry was worked according to the nature of the material to a new and
unobtainable. significant extent.
The use of the material according to its nature was lost, the design being It is not too much to say that, as in a mosaic, each piece in a wall has its value
paramount. in this style.
Corners often rusticated, blocks of unsmoothed stone, or carefully indented Corners often of ashlar masonry or smooth-faced stone, the rest of the walling
with patterns. being of rough.
Simplicity of treatment and breadth of mass are prominent characteristics of Boldness and richness of sky-line and intricacy of mass are prominent
the style. characteristics.
Open-timbered roofs occur, but the tendency was gradually to plaster them Open-timbered roofs are a beautiful feature of the style.
or paint in fresco.
Used decoratively in facades, as in the pilasters, and structurally as for Where used, they were entirely structural, or expressive of the load borne.
porticos.
Stained glass was little used, all the best efforts at color being obtained by Stained glass was extensively used, being the chief glory of internal decoration,
means of opaque decoration, as fresco or mosaic, which was lavishly applied and partly the raison d'etre of the immense traceried windows, which acted as
to interiors. a frame for its reception.
Great efficiency in the crafts is noticeable in the work of early Renaissance Carving was often grotesque and rudely executed, but in the best examples,
architects who were often painters and sculptors. possesses a decorative character in harmony with the architecture.
Space was organised by proportional logic, its form and rhythm subject to
geometry, rather than being created by intuition as in Medieval buildings.
The façades, which were sometimes highly ornate; the doorways, with columns, pediments, sculpture and carving, receiving especial attention.
High external domes did not come into general use until the next period.
The Riccardi Palace in Florence (1430) marks the first step of the
Renaissance in this direction.
The style became more decorated and ornamental, statuary, domes and cupolas
becoming very evident.
During this Cinquecento, buildings retained much of the freedom and refinement of
Quattrocento.
Orders freely used as subordinate features in the decoration of doors and windows.
Tempietto (littleJay
temple)
Re-defining Building Crafts Thakkar 12 Jan 2016 34
The lantern-crowned dome was developed.
Cornices and mouldings proportioned and profiled with utmost care, with relief
enrichments in stucco used effectively.
Balustrade was elaborated into a feature at once useful and highly ornate.
Greatest artists exercised their talents in painting of vaults and ceilings, as in the
Sistine Chapel.
The architectural period coincides with the age of Leonardo, Michelangelo and
Raphael.
Witnessed extraordinary palaces, villas, and churches, most famous being St.
Peter’s, Rome.
Usually of great size, and built around ample courts with arcades of classic model in two
or three stories.
Sumptuous reception-rooms and halls, magnificent ceilings and frescoes by the great
painters of the day.
Antique statues and reliefs adorned the courts, vestibules, and niches of these princely
dwellings.
The great pentagonal Palace of Caprarola, near Rome, by Vignola, perhaps the most
successful identity.
Outside Rome, took on various local and provincial phases of style, especially at Venice,
and Vicenza.
Disposed in extensive grounds laid out with terraces, cascades, and shaded
alleys.
Prolific in memorial and chapels added to existing churches, like the Chigi
Chapel by Raphael.
Churches generally with dome as the central feature with a cruciform plan, and
simple & uninteresting exteriors.
Treated both internally and externally with Roman Corinthian pilasters and
arches.
Among the best churches is the Gesù at Rome, by Vignola (1568), with a
highly ornate interior of excellent proportions and a less interesting exterior.
The term Mannerism derives from the Italian word maniera, meaning ‚style‛
or ‚way of working.‛
Buildings showed visual trickery and unexpected elements that challenged the
renaissance norms.
They created works that led to the Baroque style in which the same architectural
vocabulary was used for very different rhetoric.
Michelangelo credited with inventing the giant order, a large pilaster that
stretches from the bottom to the top of a façade-used in his design, Campidoglio
in Rome.
In façades, the features at first glance appear evenly spaced, they are actually quite
irregularly spaced.
Also the strange way the building seems to be halfway between one and two
stories, so the observer can not be quite sure if there is a second story or not. It
is as if the second story has been compressed down.
There are fake windows all over, mirroring the dummy doors.
The keystone is slightly raised out of place, pushing the joint above open.
His pupil Giacomo della Porta continued this work in Rome, particularly in the
façade of the Jesuit church Il Gesu, which leads directly to the most important
church façade of the early Baroque, Santa Susanna by Carlo Maderno.
Dynamic spaces favored to heighten the feeling of motion and sensuality through
curvaceousness.
Dizzying array of rich surface treatments, twisting elements, and gilded statuary.
Interior is often no more than a shell for painting and sculpture (especially in the late
Baroque).
Re-defining Building Crafts Santi Apostoli, Rome. Jay Thakkar 12 Jan 2016 49
4 Schools of Italian Renaissance
THE Renaissance of Italy varies considerably in the chief centres of the great
revival, namely, Florence, Rome, and Venice, and this was due to various
social and political causes, which will be enumerated shortly.
The Medici dynasty, so intimately connected with the rise of Florentine art, was
founded by John of Medici (died 1429), who took the popular side against the
nobles, gradually usurping supreme authority over the State.
His son Cosimo (died 1464) employed his wealth liberally in the advancement of art.
He founded the Medici Library and Platonic Academy, and was the patron of
Brunelleschi, Donatello, Michelozzo, Lippi, Masaccio, and others.
Under Pietro and Lorenzo Medici, who succeeded Cosimo, Florence "the Athens of
the Renaissance" became the centre of the revival in art and literature.
The style eschewed the complex proportional systems and irregular profiles of Gothic structures, and placed emphasis on symmetry , proportion, geometry,
and regularity of parts.
15th century architecture in Florence featured the use of classical elements such as orderly arrangements of columns , pilasters , lintels , semicircular arches
, and hemispherical domes.
While the enormous brick dome that covers the central space of the Florence Cathedral used Gothic technology, it was the first dome erected since
classical Rome and became a ubiquitous feature in Renaissance churches.
The buildings of the early Renaissance in Florence expressed a new sense of light, clarity, and spaciousness that reflected the enlightenment and clarity of
mind glorified by the philosophy of Humanism .
Pazzi Chapel,
Florence, 1420
S. Maria Novella,
Florence, 1470 Palazzo Ruccellai,
Florence, 1430
Palazzo Medici,
Florence, 1445
S. Andrea,
Mantua, 1512
Palazzo Strozi
Florence, 1489
Santo Spirito,
Re-defining Building Crafts Jay Thakkar 12 Jan 2016 55Florence, 1428
Introduction – roman school
Roman Renaissance architects derived their main designs and inspirations from Roman and Greek classical models.
Donato Bramante (1444–1514) was a key figure in Roman architecture during the High Renaissance .
The Palazzo Farnese, one of the most important High Renaissance palaces in Rome , is a primary example of Renaissance Roman architecture.
Tempietto,
Rome, 1510
Palladian architecture , in masterpieces such as Villa Emo, Villa Barbaro, Villa Capra, and Villa Foscari, evoked the imagined grandeur of antique classical
Roman villas.
Palladio created an architectural movement called Palladianism, which had a strong following in the next three centuries, inspiring a new generation of
architects till modern times.
Architects placed emphasis on symmetry, proportion, geometry and the regularity of parts as demonstrated in classical antiquity and in particular
ancient Roman architecture.
Always preferred forms that were clearly defined and structural members that expressed their purpose.
Architecture became not only a question of practice, but also a matter for theoretical discussion. Printing played a large role in the dissemination of
ideas.
The 15th century became the era of the treatise, exemplified by Alberti's De re aedificatoria (Ten Books on Architecture) (1485), the printed translations
of the writings of Vitruvius, Vignola's The Rule of the Five Orders of Architecture, and Sebastiano Serlio's Seven Books of Architecture.
During the Renaissance, architects trained as humanists helped raise the status of their profession from skilled laborer to artist.
They hoped to create structures that would appeal to both emotion and reason. Three key figures in Renaissance architecture were Brunelleschi, Alberti,
and Palladio.
He is perhaps most famous for his discovery of perspective and for engineering the dome of the
Florence Cathedral
His accomplishments also include sculpture, mathematics, engineering and even ship design.
Few men have left a legacy as monumental as Brunelleschi. Only now is he receiving
deserved recognition as the greatest architect of the Renaisssance.
He is generally credited with bringing about the Renaissance view of architecture, underlying feature
of his work was "order‛.
As Brunelleschi began to build the dome, most people in Florence had doubts and said
it was impossible.
There was no conceivable way to build a dome that size that would be self-supporting.
an inner shell made of a lightweight material, and an outer shell of heavier wind-
resistant materials.
Gothic construction is based on the pointed arch, using stone shafts, or ribs, to
support the vault, or ceiling.
Reinforcing elements were vertical marble ribs and horizontal sandstone rings
connected with iron rods, with the whole supported by oak staves.
The inner and outer shells were also tied together internally by a system of arches.
When completed, this self-buttressed unit required no external support to keep it
standing.
This type of support structure is common in modern engineering, his idea and
understanding about the forces needed to sustain the dome was revolutionary.
Other than a few modifications to remove rotted wood, the supports still hold up the
entire dome.
Deeply interested in classical literature, and his works exhibit more decorative
treatment than Brunelleschi.
For Alberti the measure of the man must generate the measure of the buildings.
Defines beauty as "the harmony and concord of all the parts achieved in such
a manner that nothing could be added or taken away or altered except for
the worse."
Beauty is something proper and innate and diffused throughout the whole,
whilst ornament is something added and fastened on, rather than proper and
innate.
Basílica de Sant'Andrea
Re-defining Building Crafts Mantua, 1472Jay Thakkar 12 Jan 2016 78
facades
The facades -S. Francesco (1450), S. Maria Novella (1456), S.
Sebastiano, first and second scheme (1460 and 1470), and S.
Andrea (1470)-illustrate a development which is the
consequence of the changes in Alberti's approach to antiquity.
The cornice of the entablature that separates the two levels halves the
major square, so that the lower portion of the building becomes a
rectangle that is twice as wide as it is high.
Areas outlined by the columns on the lower level are squares with sides
that are about one-third the width of the main unit.
He was a major celebrity of the 15th century, only he wasn't an actor or athlete.
He was an architect.
Bramante was the only to be considered as talented as the ancients, the highest
praise as you could get.
Introduced High Renaissance style to Milan & Rome, where his plan for St.
Peter's Basilica formed the basis of the design executed by Michelangelo.
At Rome, he had greater access to Roman ruins and could really embrace their
designs. This is where his signature style took off.
Designed the cloisters for Santa Maria del Pace, based design on the
Colosseum.
Around 1500, he designed the cloisters for Santa Maria del Pace,
based design on the Colosseum.
The quest for the perfect Christian church obsessed Renaissance architects.
How could Christian and humanist ideals be reconciled architecturally?
The aim achieve not only through use of antique columns, but in the whole
building conception.
He cited the globe, trees, animals and many other natural forms, and
recommended nine basic geometrical figures, all determined by the circle.
His architectural fame lies chiefly in three buildings: the interiors of the
Laurentian Library and its lobby at the monastery of San Lorenzo in
Florence, Ceiling of the Sistine Chapel and St Peter's Basilica in Rome.
St Peter's was "the greatest creation of the Renaissance", and a great number
of architects contributed their skills to it.
But at its completion, there was more of Michelangelo’s design than of any
other architect, before or after him.
Believed his flexible design principles could be applied to any type and scale of
building.
Used classical principles to design villas and palaces, creating houses with temple
fronts.
First architect to use classical porticos – used largely for religious buildings - into
domestic building.
His most famous is Villa Capra, also known as the Rotunda, was modelled after the
Roman Pantheon.
Known for popularizing the Palladian arch or Palladian windows. it allowed more
light to stream in.
Believed that beauty would arise from the relationships of the parts to each other and
to the whole.
For Andrea Palladio a more analytical search for beauty through mathematical
proportion was most important.
Palladio supplies general rules of proportion for the height of rooms to their width
and length, three dimensions constituting the shape of a room.
It came straight out of Vitruvius, and has been thought with good reason to be a
residue of the Greek architectural theory of proportion.
With the exception of the third case, all these ratios are commensurable and as
simple as possible.
His designs would have a central hall - with suites of rooms arranged
around them.
Firstly, the overall plan is a central block flanked with identical wings,
ensuring symmetry; the central block is faced with a temple front.
Secondly, the interior plan is also symmetrical, with a great hall at the
centre. And thirdly, the building has a tall major story and a short attic
story.
Palladio would often model his villa elevations on Roman temple facades.
The proportions of each room within the villa were calculated on simple mathematical ratios like 3:4 and 4:5, and the different rooms within the house were
interrelated by these ratios.
It is a powerful yet simple scheme, one that would be copied many times.
The whole is contained within an imaginary circle, which touches each corner
of the building and centres of the porticos.
In order for each room to have some sun, the design was rotated 45 degrees
from each cardinal point of the compass.