Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Irreducible Fracture-Dislocations of The Femoral Head Without Posterior Wall Acetabular Fractures
Irreducible Fracture-Dislocations of The Femoral Head Without Posterior Wall Acetabular Fractures
Irreducible Fracture-Dislocations of The Femoral Head Without Posterior Wall Acetabular Fractures
reduction and fixation, and fixation details. Radiographic To liberate the proximal femur, the taut posterior–
evaluations included review of the screening, postoperative superior capsular–labral obstructing lesion was incised sharply
anteroposterior (AP) and oblique pelvic films, most recent AP with a scalpel from cranially to caudally under direct
and oblique pelvic films, and both preoperative and post- visualization. Residual local debris was excised. Assuring
operative pelvic computed tomography (CT) scans. A similar anesthetic skeletal relaxation, the manipulative hip reduction
radiographic and clinical review of the remaining 65 reducible was then possible using proximal femoral flexion, adduction,
fracture–dislocations was performed. internal rotation, and anterior translation. No additional
After surgical intervention, all patients were placed on instrumentation, surgical table attachments, or special devices
deep venous thrombosis prophylaxis and received intravenous were necessary for reduction of the femoral head. This
antibiotics. Standard protocol postoperative pelvic CT scans maneuver also allowed for reduction of the femoral head in the
were obtained. There were no active hip motion restrictions patient with iatrogenic femoral neck fracture. The surgical
applied, but gait training using 8 weeks of injured hip protected wound was then packed with a saline-moistened sponge.
weight bearing was monitored by a licensed physical therapist The femoral head fracture components and debris previ-
beginning after surgery. Oral indomethacin was administered ously removed from the acetabulum were cleansed of clot,
without incident for 6 weeks after operation to prevent ectopic cancellous debris, and chondral flap fragments on the surgical
bone formation. Follow-up clinical and radiographic evalua- nurse’s sterile table. The femoral head fracture fragment was
tions were performed for a minimum of 6 months in all patients. then prepared with glide holes using an appropriate sized
miniature fragment drill. The 2 glide holes were positioned
Surgical Technique and Technique caudally on the head fragment to avoid the weight-bearing area
of Reduction and were oriented perpendicular to the fracture plane. A
After being medically cleared for surgical intervention, corresponding countersink of appropriate size was used to the
the patients were taken to the operating room, administered remove surrounding cartilage to the level of subchondral bone.
general anesthesia including muscle relaxation, and positioned The proximal femur, which had been dislocated at injury
supine on an operating room table (OSI, Union City, CA). A and then surgically reduced into the acetabulum after soft
folded blanket placed posterior to the lumbosacral region tissue release as described above, was then surgically
elevated the pelvic area from the table. The hairs of the dislocated anteriorly from the joint manually using a figure-
perineum and anticipated surgical site were shaved, then the of-four maneuver and slight traction. Although caudal anterior
perineal area was cleansed thoroughly with isopropyl alcohol femoral head fractures could be reduced accurately without
and isolated using barrier drapes from the planned surgical anterior surgical dislocation, none of our patients had such
field. The entire injured lower extremity, hip region, and a fracture pattern. All our patients had fractures involving their
ipsilateral flank were next prepared sequentially with iodine superior femoral heads and required direct visualization to
and then with isopropyl alcohol solutions. Skin preparation accurately reduce the fracture. The predrilled femoral head
and draping were complicated especially for the inguinal and chondro-cancellous articular fracture fragments were reduced
posterior thigh regions due to the fixed flexion position of the and secured to the proximal femur fragment initially using
injured hip. A Smith-Petersen exposure was used after intrave- thin-diameter wire remote from the cartilage whenever
nous antibiotic administration and patient-specific identifica- possible and then definitively with 2 miniature cortical lag
tion, and treatment plan details were confirmed. The incision screws after drilling and accurate depth assessments. The wires
extended from the anterior superior iliac spine distally approx- were removed, and the hip was then atraumatically manually
imately 12 cm between the retracted tensor fascia lata and the re-reduced into the acetabulum. The injured hip was examined
sartorius muscles. The common rectus femoris muscle tendon through a full passive range of motion to assure stability and
was incised, tagged, and then retracted distally. The iliopsoas congruency. Fluoroscopic orthogonal views and also real-time
muscle was elevated and retracted medially from the anterior fluoroscopy through a 180-degrees passive motion arc
hip joint capsule, which was completely intact for all patients. confirmed the hip congruency, reduction accuracy, and implant
Next, an obliquely oriented T-shaped capsulotomy was safety before wound closure. The wound was irrigated. The
made with the upper limb paralleling and sparing the anterior anterior surgical capsulotomy and rectus femoris tenotomy
acetabular labrum while the perpendicular capsulotomy limb were repaired directly, and the fascial and dermal layers and
paralleled the femoral neck, an essential step to dislocate the skin closed primarily.
hip. The hip joint hematoma, the femoral head fracture
fragments within the acetabulum, and the residual osteochon- RESULTS
dral debris were removed. In all 7 patients, the dislocated There were 5 men and 2 women, with an average age of
proximal femoral component had exited the acetabulum 42.1 years (range 21–82 years). Five patients were involved in
through a posterior–superior labral–bone interval, and the torn motor vehicle collisions, 1 was injured in a snowboarding
yet extremely taut posterior–superior labral and capsular accident, and 1 was crushed in an industrial accident (Table 1).
tissues severely limited any movements of the dislocated Evaluation of the hip injury included a physical examination,
proximal femur. The proximal femur’s sagittal head fracture AP pelvic radiograph, and standard protocol pelvic CT after
plane extended from the superior femoral head to its caudal exit thorough resuscitation and evaluation.
adjacent to the head–neck junction. The cancellous bone of this All patients had uniquely similar and distinct physical
proximal femoral fracture surface was forcefully impacted examination findings of the involved limb. The involved
against the supra-acetabular lateral iliac cortical bone. extremity was locked in slight flexion at the hip, and the limb
TABLE 1. Clinical Data Regarding Patients With Irreducible Fracture–Dislocations of the Femoral Head Without Posterior
Wall Fracture
Patient Age Time to Attempted Attempted Time to Operative Intraoperative Dislocation Length of
ID Sex (yr) Mechanism Side Reduction (h) Reductions Reduction (h) Time (min) Follow-up (mo) Complications
5 M 39 Crush R 5 2 6 17 20 —
4 M 21 Snowboard L 2 1 4 14 9 Femoral neck fracture
2 F 29 HSMVC L 6 2 12 12 41 —
3 M 82 HSMVC L 5 1 8 11 10 —
7 F 29 HSMVC R 12 2 32 14 6 AVN
6 M 56 HSMVC R 8 4 14 11 6 AVN
1 M 39 HSMVC L 4 2 6 12 9 —
AVN, avascular necrosis; F, female; HSMVC, high-speed motor vehicle collision; L, left; M, male; R, right.
was in neutral rotation with obvious leg length discrepancy Patients were taken to the operating room in a mean time
(Figs. 1A, B). of 12 hours from their presentation (range 4–32 hours) for
As part of their evaluations, all patients had an AP plain open reduction and internal fixation of the femoral head
pelvic radiograph performed at presentation. The radiograph fracture–dislocation. Two patients had associated primary
showed consistently unique findings—the sagittal plane femoral organ system injuries that prevented urgent surgery until
head fracture fragment remained in the acetabulum, the 14–32 hours after presentation. The remaining patients were
proximal femoral fracture component was dislocated poster- treated within 8 hours.
osuperiorly relative to the acetabulum, and the dislocated Because no acetabular fractures occurred in conjunction
proximal femoral component was tightly approximated to the with the femoral head fracture–dislocation, a Smith-Petersen
supra-acetabular lateral iliac cortical bone (Fig. 2). surgical exposure was used. In all cases, the displaced proximal
All patients received a standardized pelvic CT scan, with femur had herniated through a posterior–superior labral–bone
coronal and sagittal reconstructions, confirming and detailing traumatic interval. The displaced and taut labral band tethered
the findings seen on radiographs (Figs. 3A, B). the displaced proximal femoral component and blocked
The first closed reduction attempt was made within reduction. The tight labral tissue was then incised to allow
6 hours on average (range 2–12 hours). Also on average, the proximal femoral reduction into the acetabulum. After
2 (range 1–4) closed reduction attempts failed before pro- incision of the tethering labral band, hip flexion, adduction,
ceeding to operative management (Table 1). In an instance, the internal rotation, and manual traction were required to reduce
initial routine attempted closed reduction maneuver resulted in the hip. After preparation of the femoral head fragments, the hip
an iatrogenic femoral neck fracture (Figs. 4A, B). was surgically dislocated anteriorly averaging 13 minutes (range
FIGURE 1. A, Lateral view of a patient with a left irreducible femoral head fracture–dislocation. The entire limb is prepped into the
field. The limb is typically slightly flexed at the knee and the hip (solid arrows) in neutral rotation. B, Anterior view of a patient with
a left irreducible femoral head fracture–dislocation. The ipsilateral torso and entire limb are prepped into the field. The limb is in
neutral rotation and has a leg length discrepancy, with the involved side being shorter (solid arrow). There is no adduction or
internal rotation component noted on the physical examination, as would be expected in the typical posterior hip dislocation.
acetabular region, which were findings not present in the closed manipulative reduction attempts at closed reduction
65 patients who had a reducible fracture. In all our patients, can result in iatrogenic injury. In our series, 1 (14%) patient
there was a sagittal plane femoral head fracture fragment within sustained an iatrogenic femoral neck fracture as a result of
the acetabulum, but none of the patients had acetabular fracture. a routine reduction maneuver. That patient had all the clinical
The plain pelvic radiographs and CT scan should be inspected and radiographic markers for irreducibility. Prompt recogni-
for concomitant femoral neck fracture or other injuries. The tion of the irreducible injury most likely could have prevented
pelvic CT scan details the locations of the fragments, rules out this from occurring. At this patient’s last follow-up clinic visit,
acetabular fracture, and identifies joint debris. she displayed no signs or symptoms of osteonecrosis and had
It is relevant that none of these patients had a posterior healed her fractures uneventfully.
wall acetabular fracture. Perhaps, this finding alone is Open reduction and internal fixation was performed
responsible for the proximal femoral irreducibility. Because within 8 hours for 5 patients and for more than 14 hours for
the posterior wall remains intact, the proximal femoral 2 other patients. These 2 delayed treatment patients had
component exits the joint through the traumatic labral interval. associated medical conditions that prevented more urgent
This torn labral interval then captures the displaced com- surgical intervention. Symptomatic aseptic necrosis occurred
ponent at the narrower femoral neck region (Fig. 7, inset). The in both of these patients within 6 months after injury.
planar cancellous femoral head surface is then crushed The anterior Smith-Petersen surgical exposure has been
tightly against the lateral cortical bone of the supra-acetabular shown to be effective in treatment of femoral head fracture–
area as a result (Fig. 7). Perhaps this is the reason that no dislocations.16–18 Anterior capsular blood flow has been shown
patients with posterior wall acetabular fracture–dislocations to have minimal contribution to the femoral head.22 Despite
or posterior hip dislocations without fracture were noted posterior injury, due to the dislocation, and an anterior
with this clinical scenario. Irreducibility may occur in exposure, we did not attribute the aseptic necrosis in our series
patients with concomitant posterior wall fracture–dislocation as a result of the surgical exposure.18
due to obstructing fragments of bone within the acetabulum, This clinical series describes the unique and reliable
but perhaps not due to a taut constrictive traumatic labral clinical and radiographic hallmarks of irreducible femoral
interval. head fracture–dislocations without associated acetabular
Unfortunately, these unique clinical and radiographic fracture. These injuries are an atypical variant of the more
markers were not noted early in this series so an average of common reducible femoral head fracture–dislocations that
2 closed reduction attempts were made before operative have been previously reported in numerous series.2,5,6,10,16–19
reduction. Even using complete muscle relaxation, each Early recognition of the irreducible injury pattern by clinical
patient’s injured hip position was notably rigid on examination and radiographic hallmarks is essential to provide appropriate
and could not be dissociated from its ‘‘locked’’ position. and timely treatment while avoiding related complications.
Although prompt reduction is thought to decrease risk of Emergency room physicians and orthopaedic surgeons should
femoral head avascular necrosis and improve outcomes, be more alert when treating an injured patient who presents
multiple manipulative closed reduction attempts actually have with hip pain after a high-energy traumatic event, especially if
poorer results.2,5–7,10,17 Furthermore, multiple or forceful the physical examination reveals fixed hip flexion with neutral
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors thank Julie Agel for her help in data
collection and manuscript preparation.
REFERENCES
1. Mostafa MM. Femoral head fractures. Int Orthop. 2001;25:51–54.
2. Brumback RJ, Kenzora JE, Levitt LE, et al. Fractures of the femoral head.
Hip. 1987:181–206.
3. Butler JE. Pipkin type-II fractures of the femoral head. J Bone Joint Surg
Am. 1981;63:1292–1296.
4. DeLee JC, Evans JA, Thomas J. Anterior dislocation of the hip and
associated femoral-head fractures. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1980;62:
960–964.
5. Epstein HC. Posterior fracture-dislocations of the hip; long-term
follow-up. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1974;56:1103–1127.
6. Epstein HC, Wiss DA, Cozen L. Posterior fracture dislocation of the hip
with fractures of the femoral head. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1985;201:9–17.
7. Thompson VP, Epstein HC. Traumatic dislocation of the hip; a survey of
two hundred and four cases covering a period of twenty-one years. J Bone
Joint Surg Am. 1951;33-A:746–778; passim.
8. Yang RS, Tsuang YH, Hang YS, et al. Traumatic dislocation of the hip.
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1991;265:218–227.
9. Lang-Stevenson A, Getty CJ. The Pipkin fracture-dislocation of the hip.
Injury. 1987;18:264–269.
10. McKee MD, Garay ME, Schemitsch EH, et al. Irreducible fracture-
FIGURE 7. Fractured femoral head–neck–shaft component dislocation of the hip: a severe injury with a poor prognosis. J Orthop
dislocated posterosuperiorly through constricting capsulola- Trauma. 1998;12:223–229.
bral defect. The cancellous surface of the femoral head is 11. Bosse MJ, Poka A, Reinert CM, et al. Heterotopic ossification as
crushed against the lateral cortical bone of the supra- a complication of acetabular fracture. Prophylaxis with low-dose
irradiation. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1988;70:1231–1237.
acetabular area. 12. Chakraborti S, Miller IM. Dislocation of the hip associated with fracture
of the femoral head. Injury. 1975;7:134–142.
13. Hougaard K, Thomsen PB. Traumatic posterior dislocation of the hip–
rotation and obvious limb length discrepancy. Routine pelvic prognostic factors influencing the incidence of avascular necrosis of the
imaging confirms femoral head fracture, the posterior– femoral head. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg. 1986;106:32–35.
superior displacement, and close approximation of the 14. Sahin V, Karakas ES, Aksu S, et al. Traumatic dislocation and fracture-
dislocation of the hip: a long-term follow-up study. J Trauma. 2003;54:
proximal femoral component relative to the acetabulum and 520–529.
the lack of an acetabular fracture. Closed reduction should not 15. Yue JJ, Wilber JH, Lipuma JP, et al. Posterior hip dislocations: a cadaveric
be attempted in such patients to avoid iatrogenic fracture or angiographic study. J Orthop Trauma. 1996;10:447–454.
other problems including pain, unnecessary sedation, failed 16. Marchetti ME, Steinberg GG, Coumas JM. Intermediate-term experience of
reduction attempts, increased time to definitive reduction and Pipkin fracture-dislocations of the hip. J Orthop Trauma. 1996;10:455–461.
17. Stannard JP, Harris HW, Volgas DA, et al. Functional outcome of patients
management, and patient/surgeon/family member stress. with femoral head fractures associated with hip dislocations. Clin Orthop
Urgent operative reduction using a Smith-Petersen exposure Relat Res. 2000;377:44–56.
is accomplished by releasing the constrictive traumatic labral 18. Swiontkowski MF, Thorpe M, Seiler JG, et al. Operative management of
interval.23 In none of these patients was the irreducibility due displaced femoral head fractures: case-matched comparison of anterior
versus posterior approaches for Pipkin I and Pipkin II fractures. J Orthop
to other soft tissues such as the piriformis muscle tendon or Trauma. 1992;6:437–442.
obturator internus muscle tendon. It is possible to visualize and 19. Canale ST, Manugian AH. Irreducible traumatic dislocations of the hip.
release these potentially constrictive structures using the J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1979;61:7–14.
Smith-Petersen exposure if necessary, but it is not possible to 20. Matta JM. Fractures of the acetabulum: accuracy of reduction and clinical
subsequently repair them after their release. Prophylaxis for results in patients managed operatively within three weeks after the injury.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1996;78:1632–1645.
heterotopic ossification with indomethacin should be consid- 21. Kaempffe FA, Bone LB, Border JR. Open reduction and internal fixation
ered by the surgeon postoperatively. of acetabular fractures: heterotopic ossification and other complications of
Although this is a small clinical series with limited treatment. J Orthop Trauma. 1991;5:439–445.
follow-up data, we have identified and described consistent 22. Trueta J, Harrison MH. The normal vascular anatomy of the femoral head
in adult man. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1953;35-B:442–461.
and distinct clinical and radiographic markers of irreducible 23. Kim YT, Ninomiya S, Tachibana Y, et al. Acetabular labrum entrapment
femoral head fracture–dislocations without associated poste- following traumatic posterior dislocation of the hip. J Orthop Sci. 2003;8:
rior wall acetabular fractures. Our intraoperative findings and 232–235.