Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TX Frampton Modern Architecture 5e Pagine 1 4,152 222,241 258,285 301,331 378 Compressed
TX Frampton Modern Architecture 5e Pagine 1 4,152 222,241 258,285 301,331 378 Compressed
9 Introduction Chapter 4
71 Structural Rationalism and
the Influence of Viollet-le-Duc:
PART I Gaudí, Horta, Guimard and
Cultural Developments and Berlage 1880–1910
Predisposing Techniques
1750–1939 Chapter 5
81 Charles Rennie Mackintosh
Chapter 1 and the G
lasgow School
14 Cultural Transformations: 1896–1916
Neo-Classical Architecture
First published in 1980 in the United Kingdom
1750–1900 Chapter 6
by Thames & Hudson Ltd, 181A High Holborn,
London WC1V 7QX 85 The Sacred Spring: Wagner,
Chapter 2 Olbrich and Hoffmann
www.thamesandhudson.com 23 TerritorialTransformations: 1886–1912
First published in 1980 in the United States Urban Developments 1800–
of America by Thames & Hudson Inc., 1909 Chapter 7
500 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York 10110
92 Antonio Sant’Elia and
www.thamesandhudsonusa.com Chapter 3 Futurist Architecture 1909–14
33 Technical Transformations:
This new edition 2020
Structural Engineering Chapter 8
Modern Architecture © 1980, 1985, 1992, 2007 1775–1939 98 Adolf Loos and the Crisis
and 2020 Thames & Hudson Ltd, London
of Culture 1896–1931
Text by Kenneth Frampton
PART II Chapter 9
Copyediting by Sarah Yates
A Critical History 1836–1967 104 Henryvan de Velde and
Art direction and series design: Kummer & Herrman the Abstraction of Empathy
Layout: Kummer & Herrman Chapter 1 1895–1914
All Rights Reserved. No part of this publication 48 News from Nowhere:
may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or England 1836–1924 Chapter 10
by any means, electronic or mechanical, including 108 TonyGarnier and the
photocopy, recording or any other information
storage and retrieval system, without prior permission Chapter 2 Industrial City 1899–1918
in writing from the publisher. 58 Adler and Sullivan:
the A
uditorium and the Chapter 11
British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data
A catalogue record for this book is available from the High Rise 1886–95 113 Auguste Perret: the Evolution
British Library of Classical Rationalism
Library of Congress Control Number 2020933628
Chapter 3 1899–1925
64 Frank Lloyd Wright and the
ISBN 978-0-500-20444-3
Myth of the Prairie 1890–1916
Printed and bound in China through Asia Pacific
Offset Ltd
5
Chapter 12 Chapter 23 Chapter 3 Afterword
117 TheDeutsche Werkbund 213 Frank Lloyd Wright and the 304 The Vicissitudes of Ideology: 617 Architecture in the
1898–1927 Disappearing City 1929–63 CIAM and Team X, Critique Age of Globalization
and Counter-critique 1928–68
Chapter 13 Chapter 24 643 Bibliography
124 TheGlass Chain: European 220 AlvarAalto and the Chapter 4
Architectural Expressionism Nordic Tradition: National 315 Place,
Production and 688 Endnotes
1910–25 Romanticism and the Doricist Scenography: International
Theory and Practice Since 1962 695 Acknowledgments
Sensibility 1895–1957
Chapter 14
132 The Bauhaus: the Evolution Chapter 25 Chapter 5 696 Illustration Credits
of an Idea 1919–32 232 Giuseppe Terragni and 351 Critical
Regionalism:
the Architecture of Italian Modern Architecture 704 Index
Chapter 15 Rationalism 1926–43 and Cultural Identity
140 TheNew Objectivity:
Germany, Holland and Chapter 26
Switzerland 1923–33 240 Architectureand the State: PART IV
Ideology and Representation World Architecture and the
Chapter 16 1914–43 Modern Movement
152 ModernArchitecture in
Czechoslovakia 1918–38 Chapter 27 Chapter 1
255 Le Corbusier and the 369 The Americas
Chapter 17 Monumentalization of the Introduction • United States •
156 DeStijl: the Evolution and Vernacular 1930–60 Canada • Mexico • Brazil • Colombia •
Dissolution of Neo-Plasticism Venezuela • Argentina • Uruguay •
Chapter 28 Peru • Chile
1917–31
263 Mies van der Rohe and
Chapter 18 the Monumentalization Chapter 2
163 Le
Corbusier and the Esprit of Technique 1933–67 435 Africa and the Middle East
Nouveau 1907–31 Introduction • South Africa •
Chapter 29 West Africa • North Africa • East
Chapter 19 271 The Eclipse of the New Deal: Africa • Turkey • Lebanon • Israel/
176 From Art Deco to the Popular Buckminster Fuller, Philip Palestine • Iraq • Saudi Arabia •
Iran • Gulf States
Front: French Architecture Johnson and Louis Kahn
between Two World Wars 1934–64
1925–45 Chapter 3
469 Asia and the Pacific
Chapter 20 PART III Introduction • India • Pakistan •
185 Miesvan der Rohe and the Critical Transformations Bangladesh • Sri Lanka • China •
Significance of Fact 1921–33 1925–90 Japan • South Korea • Australia •
New Zealand
Chapter 21 Chapter 1
192 The New Collectivity: 282 The International Style: Theme Chapter 4
Art and Architecture in the and Variations 1925–65 525 Europe
Soviet Union 1918–32 Introduction • United Kingdom •
Chapter 2 Ireland • France • Belgium •
Chapter 22 297 New Brutalism and the Spain • Portugal • Italy • Greece •
204 LeCorbusier and the Architecture of the Welfare Former Yugoslavia • Austria •
Germany • Denmark • Sweden •
Ville Radieuse 1928–46 State: England 1949–59 Norway • Finland
6 7
cultural dependency: the one being truly
Neo-Classical in a cross-cultural sense, the
other being derived from Le Corbusier’s
Chapter 2
Unité d’Habitation at Marseilles. Where
Tange was ultimately to lose any sense New Brutalism and the
Architecture of the Welfare
of human scale or place in the enormous
residential megastructures that he began
to propose in the late 1950s, specifically his
Boston Bay project of 1959 and his Tokyo
Bay proposal of 1961, Mayekawa was to
make a bold attempt to accommodate a
State: England 1949–59
part-Western, part-Japanese lifestyle within
the multistorey layers of a giant anti-seismic
structure. That the Harumi apartment block, In January 1950 I shared offices with my impetus from two important Parliamentary
like the synthetic lifestyle it was intended esteemed colleagues Bengt Edman and Acts: the Education Act of 1944, raising the
to house, could be, at best, only a qualified Lennart Holm. These architects were at the school leaving age to fifteen, and the New
success seems to have been acknowledged time designing a house at Uppsala. Judging Towns Act of 1946. This legislation was
by Mayekawa himself when in 1965, in an from their drawings I called them in a mildly the effective instrument of an extensive
essay entitled Thoughts on Civilization sarcastic way ‘Neo-Brutalists’. (The Swedish government building programme, resulting
in Architecture, he came to the sobering word for ‘New Brutalists’!) The following in the construction of some 2,500 schools
conclusion that: 269 Mayekawa, Harumi Apartments, Tokyo, 1957. summer, at jollification with some English within a decade and in the designation of
friends, among whom were Michael Ventris, ten new towns, to be built on the model of
Modern architecture is and must be squarely are the products of human brains, the modern Oliver Cox and Graeme Shankland, the term Letchworth Garden City, with populations
based on the solid achievements of modern architecture and the modern cities which was mentioned again in a jocular fashion. ranging from 20,000 to 69,000.
science, technology, and engineering. Why are built by them tend to become inhuman. When I visited the same friends in London A great deal of this work – outside such
then does it so often tend to become something That which has beclouded the rudimentary last year, they told me that they had brought precocious authorities as the Hertfordshire
inhuman? I believe that one of the main principles of modern architecture, that which the word back with them to England, and that County Council which, under the leadership
reasons is that it is not always created merely is distorting its sense of mission is today’s it had spread like wildfire, and that it had, of C.H. Aslin, was to pioneer the wholesale
to satisfy human requirements, but rather ethical system regulating human action, and somewhat astoundingly, been adopted by a prefabrication of schools – came to be
for some other reason, such as the profit the system of value judgments concealed certain faction of younger English architects. carried out either in the ‘reduced’ Neo-
motive. Or an attempt is made to cramp the behind this ethical system. These ethical and Georgian manner of the average municipal
architecture into the framework of some budget value criteria are the forces which are moving Hans Asplund, architect, or in the so-called Contemporary
formulated by the mechanical operations of a modern civilization but are also obliterating Letter to Eric de Maré, Architectural Review, Style, which was largely modelled on the
powerful bureaucratic system of the modern human dignity and making a mockery of the August 19561 official architecture of Sweden’s long-
state, this budget having nothing to do with Declaration of Human Rights. The conclusion of established Welfare State. The syntax of this
human considerations. Another possibility the tragedy is by no means simple. We must go After the Second World War, Britain style – which was presumably considered to
is that inhuman elements may be contained back to the beginnings of Western civilization possessed neither the material resources be sufficiently ‘popular’ for the realization
within science, technology, and engineering and discover whether the power to bring about nor the necessary cultural assurance to of English social reform – comprised an
themselves. When man attempts to understand such an ethical revolution can really be found justify any form of monumental expression. architecture of shallow-pitched roofs, brick
a certain phenomenon, science analyses it, in the inventory of Western civilization itself. If anything the post-war tendency lay in the walls, vertically boarded spandrels and
breaking it down into the simplest possible If not, then we must seek it, together with opposite direction, since in architecture, squarish wood-framed picture windows, the
elements. Thus, in structural engineering Toynbee, in the Orient, or perhaps in Japan.9 as in other matters, Britain was in the final last either left bare or painted white. This
when one attempts to understand a certain stages of relinquishing its imperial identity. so-called ‘people’s detailing’ became, with
phenomenon, the methods adopted are those With this paradoxical proposition, that While Indian independence initiated the local additions, the received vocabulary
of simplification and abstraction. The question traditional Japanese culture may yet in its disintegration of the Empire in 1945, the of the left-wing architects of the London
arises of whether the use of such methods essence survive as the one force capable of class conflict that had so bitterly divided the County Council (LCC), and it acquired a
may not cause a departure from human redeeming the technocratic excesses of the country during the Depression came to be wider acceptance through the influence of
realities … Modern architecture must recall its West, the era of the International Style was partially alleviated by the welfare provisions the more active editors of The Architectural
rudiments, its initial principles as a human brought to its definitive close, not only in of the Attlee Labour Government. Post- Review, J.M. Richards and Nikolaus Pevsner,
architecture. Whereas science and engineering Japan but through out the rest of the world. war social reconstruction gained its first who, from having first argued for a stringent
and all had a coarse grainy texture which envisaged, and moreover welcomed, as the late 19th century, antedating by a year the
was clearly regarded by the collaborators life substance of a new industrial vernacular. publication of the equally brutal avant in his 1948 Roq et Rob project, proved
as one of their main virtues’. There was Richard Hamilton’s ironic collage for this project for Le Corbusier’s Maisons Jaoul, seminal to the formation of the Brutalist
something decidedly existential about an exhibition, entitled Just what is it that makes Paris, and anticipating the various projects sensibility, and the Smithsons followed their
exhibition that insisted on viewing the today’s homes so different, so appealing, for village infill housing designed by James enthusiasm for Mies with a subtle reworking
world as a landscape laid waste by war, not only inaugurated Pop culture but also Stirling, William Howell and the Smithsons of Le Corbusier’s béton brut manner: as
decay and disease – beneath whose ashen crystallized the domestic image of the themselves, and exhibited at the CIAM Aix- they put it in 1959, ‘Mies is great but Corb
layers one could still find traces of life, Brutalist sensibility. The Smithsons’ ‘House en-Provence Congress of 1953. communicates.’ Similarly, the shock first
albeit microscopic, pulsating within the of the Future’, exhibited at the Daily Mail The mid-1950s clearly saw an extension experienced by Stirling on visiting the
ruins. Henderson, writing of his work in Ideal Home Exhibition in 1956, was evidently of the Brutalist base beyond the hermetic Maisons Jaoul in 1955 was soon outweighed
this period, stated: ‘I feel happiest among intended as the ideal home for Hamilton’s preoccupations of the Smithsons, by the enthusiasm with which he followed
discarded things, vituperative fragments, muscle-bound ‘punch-bag’ natural man and Henderson and Paolozzi. By 1955 both its example. The close correspondence
cast casually from life, with the fizz of his curvaceous companion. Howell and Stirling were part of a Brutalist between the syntax of the Maisons Jaoul and
vitality still about them. There is an irony in Split between a sympathy for old- formation, although Stirling later denied the style of Stirling’s Ham Common housing
this and it forms at least a partial symbol for fashioned working-class solidarity and the that he ever thought of himself as such. of 1955 [272] can hardly be disputed, although
an artist’s activity.’ promise of consumerism, the Smithsons While his Sheffield University entry of load-bearing cross walls were used in the two
That this was the underlying motivation were ensnared in the intrinsic ambivalence 1953 was indeed Tectonesque his house cases to entirely different architectural ends.
of Brutalism in the 1950s was not lost on of an assumed populism. Throughout the project of the same year returned Stirling The ultimate integration of the British
the visitors to ‘This Is Tomorrow’, a show second half of the 1950s they moved away to the utilitarian brick aesthetic of the Brutalist aesthetic – the fusion of its
staged in 1956 by the ICA Independent from their initial sympathy for the lifestyle 19th century, though this work remained contradictory ‘formalist’ and ‘populist’
Group at the Whitechapel Art Gallery, of the proletariat towards more middle-class removed, in its Neo-Plastic composition aspects into a glass and brick ‘vernacular’
under the leadership of Lawrence Alloway. ideals that depended for their appeal on of interlocking squares, from the brutal drawn from the industrial structures of
For this exhibition, the Smithsons, once both conspicuous consumption and mass anti-art aura of the Smithsons’ Soho house. the 19th century – came with the works of
again in collaboration with Henderson ownership of the automobile. At the same Meanwhile, within the LCC, architects such Stirling and his partner James Gowan in
and Paolozzi, designed a symbolic time, they remained far from sanguine as Colquhoun, Carter, Howell and John 1959, their dormitory project for Selwyn
temenos – a metaphorical shed in an about the evident potential for such Killick had begun to realize a number of College, Cambridge, and their Engineering
equally metaphorical backyard, an ironic new-found ‘mobility’ to destroy both the Corbusian housing schemes culminating Building for Leicester University. Some
reinterpretation of Laugier’s primitive hut structure and the density of the traditional in that parody of the ‘radiant city’, the Alton acknowledgment must be made here of
of 1753 in terms of the backyard reality city. In their London Roads Study of 1956 East Estate built at Roehampton in 1958. the work of the late Edward Reynolds,
of Bethnal Green, London, about which they attempted to resolve this dilemma by Despite the fact that Mies’s IIT campus whose structurally expressive (not to say
Banham remarked: projecting the elevated freeway as the new had been the initial influence in shaping the expressionist) designs, which he made while
urban fix. Meanwhile at a domestic scale they Smithsons’ first building, the subsequent still a student, exerted a decisive influence
One could not help feeling that this particular continued to regard the chromium consumer development of the Brutalist style found on the development of Brutalism, most
garden shed, with its rusted bicycle wheels, a product in the crumbling tenement or the much of its vocabulary in the late work notably in the Howell and Killick entry for
battered trumpet and other homely junk, had plastic interior as the ultimate liberating icon of Le Corbusier. His revitalization of the Churchill College, Cambridge, of 1958, and
been excavated after an atomic holocaust, and of their conciliatory style. Mediterranean vernacular, manifest then in Stirling’s Leicester project.
300 Part III: Chapter 2 New Brutalism and the Architecture of the Welfare State 301
comprising flatted laboratories, lecture Florey Residential Building, designed by
halls and offices. Leicester absorbed the Stirling for Queen’s College, Oxford, in 1966.
fundamental contradictions of the initial The major works of this series – Selwyn,
Brutalist position by recombining the Leicester, the History Faculty and the Florey
canonical forms of the Modern Movement Building – follow one another as a catalogue
with elements drawn from the industrial of types for the modern university. This
and commercial vernacular of Stirling’s typological orientation, with its tendency
native Liverpool (see, for instance, the to dismember and recombine discrete
pioneering work of Peter Ellis). All that now architectural elements, partly in response
remained of the Purist paradigm of the to empirical demands and partly out of a
late 1920s was the marine detailing – the determination to ‘deconstruct’ the received
deck rails, companion ladders and cowls forms of the Modern Movement, shaped
that had been polemically illustrated in these late ‘monuments’ of Brutalism to a
Vers une architecture. For the rest, Leicester far greater degree than any concern for the
was an eclectic tour de force that recalled, attributes of place.
in its remarkable juxtaposition of diverse For all that programmatic demands have
elements, not only the work of Telford been invariably met, Stirling’s significance
and Brunel but also the work of William to date has lain in the compelling quality
Butterfield as manifest in his All Saints’ of his style: in the brilliant architectonic
273 Stirling
and Gowan, project for Selwyn College, Church, Margaret Street, London, of 1849. of his form rather than in the consistent
Cambridge, 1959. What other strategy, one may argue, than refinement of those ‘place’ attributes which
the Gothic Revival could have succeeded do of necessity determine the quality of life.
The Stirling and Gowan Selwyn College in combining Purist formal elements with Despite his reverence for Aalto, Stirling’s
proposal [273] not only introduced the the Romantic imagery of Wright’s Johnson achievement has been largely removed from
crystalline plasticity of their initial style Wax complex of 1936–39, while at the same the receptive ambience and self-effacing
but also presented for the first time the time integrating such Brutal structural sensibility of, say, Aalto’s Säynätsalo City
‘front’ versus ‘back’ theme that was to be components as the exposed diagrid floors Hall. It is as though the formal mastery of
typical of their characteristic organization, drawn from Kahn’s Richards Laboratories his syntactical imagination came to disown
a theme derived from the solid-versus- of 1958? the critical ‘place-creating’ potential that
glazed expression of the Ville Radieuse slab. While Leicester imposed, as it were, a 45° he himself had once posited in his village
Once again it was Reynolds’s warehouse grid over an otherwise orthogonal geometry, infill housing of the mid-1950s. As Manfredo
project of 1958 [274] that seems to have Stirling’s History Faculty Building [276] at Tafuri has written of Stirling’s later work:
been the key influence on the form of the Cambridge of 1964 rendered the diagonal
Leicester Engineering Building [275], a as the major organizing axis of the plan. Suspending the public destined to use
work in which Stirling and Gowan finally At the same time, the History Building his buildings in a limbo of a space that
arrived at their unique expression. What stretched the brick and glass syntax of ambiguously oscillates between the emptiness
had previously been the slab element in Selwyn and Leicester until the crystalline of form and a ‘discourse on function’ – that
Le Corbusier’s Pavilion Suisse was here form of the glass began to overwhelm the is architecture as an autonomous machine,
transformed (via the Reynolds warehouse controlling armature of the brick. Despite as it is spelled out in the History Building at
scheme) into the horizontal form of this, it still displayed the coupled elevator Cambridge and made explicit in the project
a crystalline-roofed laboratory block, stair tower, not only as an articulation for Siemens AG – Stirling carries out the most
while Le Corbusier’s free-standing access of access reminiscent of Kahn’s ‘servant’ cruel of acts by abandoning the sacred precinct
tower reappeared as a vertical cluster, element (see the Richards Laboratories) but 275 Stirling and Gowan, Engineering Building, Leicester in which the semantic universe of the modern
University, 1959. tradition has been enclosed. Neither attracted
276 Stirling, History Faculty Building, Cambridge
University, 1964. nor repulsed by the independent articulation
of Stirling’s formal machines, the observer
274 Reynolds, project for a delivery warehouse, Bristol, 1958.
also as a typological device that denoted is forced into a swinging course, itself just as
the Stirling house style. This device was to oscillating as the perverse play of the architect
be repeated in the last and least successful with the elements of his own language.4
of the brick and glass series, namely the
and Counter-critique 1928–68 town planning, must include the just division
between the owners and the community of the
unearned increment resulting from works of
congresses, set against a background of scenic
splendour, not the reality of industrial Europe,
and it was the first Congrès to be dominated
joint interest.2 by Le Corbusier and the French, rather than
the tough German realists. The Mediterranean
1. The idea of modern architecture includes the La Sarraz Declaration, Between the La Sarraz declaration cruise was clearly a welcome relief from
link between the phenomenon of architecture Congrès Internationaux d’Architecture of 1928 and the last CIAM conference the worsening situation of Europe and in
and that of the general economic system. Moderne, 19281 held in Dubrovnik in 1956, CIAM passed this brief respite from reality the delegates
2. The idea of ‘economic efficiency’ does through three stages of development. produced the most Olympian, rhetorical, and
not imply production furnishing maximum The 1928 CIAM declaration, signed by The first, lasting from 1928 to 1933 and ultimately destructive document to come out
commercial profit, but production demanding a twenty-four architects, representing France comprising the CIAM congresses held in of CIAM: the Athens Charter. The hundred
minimum working effort. (6), Switzerland (6), Germany (3), Holland (3), Frankfurt in 1929 and Brussels in 1930, was and eleven propositions that comprise the
3. The need for maximum economic efficiency is Italy (2), Spain (2), Austria (1) and Belgium in many respects the most doctrinaire. Charter consist in part of statements about the
the inevitable result of the impoverished state of (1), emphasized building rather than Dominated by the German-speaking Neue conditions of towns, and in part of proposals
the general economy. architecture as ‘the elementary activity Sachlichkeit architects, who were mostly for the rectification of those conditions,
4. The most efficient method of production of man intimately linked with evolution of socialist persuasion, these congresses grouped under five main headings: Dwellings,
is that which arises from rationalization and the development of human life’. CIAM addressed themselves first, at Frankfurt, Recreation, Work, Transportation, and
and standardization. Rationalization and openly asserted that architecture was under the title ‘Die Wohnung für das Historic Buildings.
standardization act directly on working unavoidably contingent on the broader Existenzminimum’, to the problems of The tone remains dogmatic, but is also
methods both in modern architecture issues of politics and economics and that, minimum living standards, and then, generalized and less specifically related to
(conception) and in the building industry far from being removed from the realities at Brussels (CIAM III), under the title immediate practical problems than were
(realization). of the industrialized world, it would have ‘Rationelle Bebauungsweisen’, to the issues the Frankfurt and Brussels reports. The
5. Rationalization and standardization react in to depend for its general level of quality not of optimum height and block spacing for generalization had its virtues, where it brought
a threefold manner: on craftsmen but on the universal adoption the most efficient use of both land and with it a greater breadth of vision and insisted
(a) they demand of architecture conceptions of rationalized production methods. Where material. CIAM II, initiated by the Frankfurt that cities could be considered only in relation
leading to simplification of working methods on four years later Hitchcock and Johnson city architect, Ernst May, also established a to their surrounding regions, but this persuasive
the site and in the factory; were to argue for the pre-eminence of working party, known as CIRPAC (Comité generality which gives the Athens Charter
(b) they mean for building firms a reduction style as determined by technique, CIAM International pour la Résolution du its air of universal applicability conceals a
in the skilled labour force; they lead to the emphasized the need for planned economy Problème de l’Architecture Contemporaine), very narrow conception of both architecture
employment of less specialized labour working and industrialization, denouncing as it did whose primary task was to prepare themes and town planning and committed CIAM
under the direction of highly skilled technicians; so efficiency as a means for maximizing for future congresses. unequivocally to: (a) rigid functional zoning of
(c) they expect from the consumer (that is to profit. Instead it advocated the introduction The second stage of CIAM, lasting city plans, with green belts between the areas
say, the customer who orders the house in of normative dimensions and efficient from 1933 to 1947, was dominated by the reserved to the different functions, and (b) a
which he will live) a revision of his demands production methods as a preliminary step personality of Le Corbusier, who consciously single type of urban housing, expressed in the
in the direction of a readjustment to the new towards a rationalization of the building shifted the emphasis to town planning. words of the Charter as ‘high, widely-spaced
conditions of social life. Such a revision will industry. Thus, that which aesthetes would CIAM IV in 1933 was without doubt the most apartment blocks wherever the necessity of
be manifested in the reduction of certain regard as a formal preference for regularity comprehensive congress from an urbanistic housing high density of population exists’. At
individual needs henceforth devoid of real was for CIAM the initial prerequisite for standpoint, by virtue of its comparative a distance of thirty years we recognize this as
justification; the benefits of this reduction will increasing housing production and for analysis of thirty-four European towns. merely the expression of an aesthetic preference,
foster the maximum satisfaction of the needs superseding the methods of a craft era. The Out of it came the articles of the Athens but at the time it had the power of a Mosaic
of the greatest number, which are at present La Sarraz document took an equally radical Charter, which for inexplicable reasons were commandment and effectively paralyzed
restricted. attitude to town planning, when it declared: not published until a decade later. Reyner research into other forms of housing.
intent underlying the whole enterprise. project solutions that were either truly saw no reason to concern themselves with Manhattan (river to river, 64th–22nd streets), 1962.
In the case of the English Archigram indeterminate or capable of being realized the social and ecological consequences of
group, who began to project Neo-Futurist and appropriated by society. It is this more their various megastructural proposals, preoccupation with the childless unit
images just before the first issue of than anything else that distinguishes them of which Peter Cook’s ‘Plug-In City’ of may have been an implicit critique of the
their magazine Archigram in 1961, it is from that other prominent Fuller disciple on 1964 was a typical example. Similarly, in bourgeois family, the ultimate stance
obvious that their attitude was closely the British scene, Cedric Price, whose Fun their obsession with suspended space-age of Archigram was hardly critical, as the
tied to the technocratic ideology of the Palace of 1961 and Potteries Thinkbelt of 1964 capsules, Dennis Crompton, Michael following passage from Peter Cook’s
American designer Buckminster Fuller were nothing if not realizable and, in theory Webb, Warren Chalk and David Greene Architecture: Action and Plan of 1967
at least, both indeterminate and capable, felt under no obligation to explain why one makes evident:
respectively, of meeting an evident demand might choose to live in such expensive and
for popular entertainment and a readily sophisticated hardware and yet at the same it will often be part of the architect’s brief
accessible system of higher education. time in brutally cramped conditions. Like to investigate the ‘possibilities’ of a site …
Aside from a certain subversive eroticism Banham acting out the narcissistic gestures in other words to use the ingenuity of the
(the biologically functionalist parody of Vishnu in his solipsistic, inflatable architectural concept to exploit the maximum
evident say in Michael Webb’s ‘Sin Centre’ bubble, equipped with high fidelity and profit from a piece of land. In the past this
of 1962 [285]) Archigram was more interested presumably other conveniences (in homage would have been considered an immoral use of
in the seductive appeal of space-age imagery probably to the philistine ethos of Fuller’s the talents of an artist. It is now simply part of
and, after Fuller, in the Armageddon ironic lyric ‘Roam Home to a Dome’: see the sophistication of the whole environmental
overtones of survival technology than in the p. 273), they all proposed space standards and building process in which finance can be
processes of production or the relevance of that were well below the Existenzminimum made into a creative element of the design.2
such sophisticated technique to the tasks of established by those pre-war functionalists
the moment. For all their surface irony, Ron they supposedly despised. The work of Archigram was surprisingly
Herron’s ‘Walking Cities’ of 1964 [286] were If anything was destined to reduce close to that of the Japanese Metabolists,
architecture ‘to the level of the activities who, reacting to the pressures of Japanese
285 Webb, ‘Sin Centre’ project, 1962.
286 Herron, ‘Walking City’ project, 1964.
of certain species of insects and overcrowding, started in the late 1950s to
mammals’ – to quote Berthold Lubetkin’s propose constantly growing and adapting
1956 attack on the reductivism of Soviet ‘plug-in’ megastructures where the living
Constructivist architects (his target was cells, as in the work of Noriaki Kurokawa,
Ginzburg’s OSA group) – it was surely these would be reduced to prefabricated pods
residential cells projected by Archigram. clipped on to vast helicoidal skyscrapers.
Modelled on Fuller’s Dymaxion House Alternatively, as in the projects of Kiyonori
of 1927 or on his Dymaxion Bathroom Kikutake [288], they would be attached like
of a decade later (see p. 273), these units limpets to the inner and outer surfaces of
aspired to being ‘autonomous packages’, in large cylinders floating in or on the sea.
the sense that they were designed chiefly Kikutake’s floating cities are surely among
for individuals or couples. Although this the most poetic visions of the Metabolist
interpretable.19
users. Hertzberger’s antipathy to the
305 L.
Krier, project for Echternach, Luxembourg, 1970. The continuous pitched roof This precept has been the point of mechanistic provision of flexibility, as
(centre to bottom right) contains shops, apartments and a school. departure from which Hertzberger has found in the sophisticated infrastructural
evolved the rest of his work, culminating in propositions of both Habraken and
influence on the thought and practice of associative perspective. … Man after all has the erection in 1974 of the Centraal Beheer Friedman, seems to have been vindicated
Hertzberger has been Aldo van Eyck, who been accommodating himself physically in insurance offices in Apeldoorn [306], built here by the apparent spontaneity and
is responsible for the most consistently this world for thousands of years. His natural to his designs in the form of a ‘city within ease with which the working spaces have
sustained and significant critique of genius has neither increased nor decreased a city’. This reinforced-concrete frame and been taken over and modified. And while
modern architecture as an inseparable part during that time. It is obvious that the concrete-block structure is ordered about one can only be circumspect about the
of the Enlightenment. In 1962 Van Eyck full scope of this enormous environmental an irregular cluster of working platforms rhetorical comparison that Hertzberger
delivered one of his sharpest attacks on experience cannot be combined unless we set within a regular orthogonal tartan grid draws between the appropriation of space
Europocentrism and on the bankruptcy of telescope the past. … Architects nowadays are comprising floors, columns, light slots in the Centraal Beheer and the Saussurian
imperialist culture: pathologically addicted to change, regarding and service ducts. Top-lit gallery spaces linguistic distinction between langue and
it as something one either hinders, runs after, of varying height separate these 7.5-metre parole, there is little doubt that his approach
Western civilization habitually identifies itself or at best keeps up with. This, I suggest, is why (24-foot) square platforms from one another has done something to overcome the
with civilization as such on the pontifical they tend to sever the past from the future, and allow natural light to filter down to chronic inaccessibility of the architectural
assumption that what is not like it, is a with the result that the present is rendered the lowest public levels. The suspended discourse in a Taylorized age.
deviation, less advanced, ‘primitive’, or, at emotionally inaccessible, without temporal platforms provide a network of activity The architects of the Tendenza would
best, exotically interesting at a safe distance.17 dimension. I dislike a sentimental antiquarian spaces that may be appropriated as either surely agree with Hertzberger’s argument
attitude toward the past as much as I dislike individual or group working stations, that the functionalist organization of
Five years later, in his magazine a sentimental technocratic one toward through the rearrangement of modular residential units into strictly subdivided
Forum, Van Eyck anticipated many of the the future. Both are founded on a static, elements comprising desks, seats, light areas for living, dining, cooking, washing
arguments since advanced by the Kriers, clockwork, notion of time (what antiquarians fittings, cabinets, couches and expresso and sleeping is in itself a tyranny, and that
including a certain scepticism with regard and technocrats have in common), so let’s machines, etc. According to Hertzberger we should attempt to return to the pre-
to the notion of progress: start with the past for a change and discover this bunker-like labyrinth – reminiscent industrial norm of interconnected rooms,
the unchanging condition of man.18 in its introspection of Wright’s Larkin offering an altogether looser fit between
It seems to me that past, present and future Building of 1904 – has been deliberately volume and activity (see Hertzberger’s
must be active in the mind’s interior as a The unifying concept with which Dutch left unfinished so as to encourage ‘Diagoon’ experimental houses built in
continuum. If they are not the artifacts we Structuralism hoped to overcome the the ‘spontaneous’ appropriation and Delft in 1971). On the other hand they
make will be without temporal depth or reductive aspect of Functionalism was decoration of the space by its immediate would no doubt reject outright his ‘casbah’
354 Part III: Chapter 5 Critical Regionalism: Modern Architecture and Cultural Identity 355
concerns are evident in his opposition to
the invasion of privacy in the modern world
and in his criticism of the subtle erosion
of nature which has accompanied post-
war civilization:
Luis Barragán, whose finest houses (many aqueduct crossed over the town, reaching the has always remained committed to that City, 1957.
of which have been erected in Mexico patios, where there were great stone fountains abstract form which has characterized the
City, in the suburb of Pedregal) assume a to receive the water. The patios housed the art of our era. Barragán’s penchant for large, in the work of Amancio Williams, above all
topographic form. As much a landscape stables, with cows and chickens, all together almost inscrutable abstract planes set into in Williams’s bridge house in Mar del Plata
designer as an architect, Barragán has Outside, in the street, there were iron rings the landscape is perhaps at its most intense of 1943–45 and more recently perhaps in
always sought a sensual and earthbound to tie the horses. The channeled logs, covered in his gardens for the residential districts Clorindo Testa’s Bank of London and South
architecture; an architecture compounded with moss, dripped water all over town, of of Las Arboleadas (1958–61) and Los Clubes America, Buenos Aires (1959); in Venezuela,
of enclosures, stelae, fountains and course. It gave this village the ambience of a (1961–64) and in his freeway monument, in the Ciudad Universitaria built to the
watercourses; an architecture laid into fairy tale. No, there are no photographs. I have Satellite City Towers, designed with Mathias designs of Carlos Raúl Villanueva between
volcanic rock and lush vegetation; an only its memory.3 Goeritz in 1957 [331]. 1945 and 1960; on the West Coast of the
architecture that refers indirectly to the Regionalism has, of course, manifested United States, first in Los Angeles from the
Mexican estancia. Of Barragán’s feeling This remembrance was surely influenced itself in other parts of the Americas: in late 1920s in the work of Neutra, Schindler,
for mythic and rooted beginnings it is by Barragán’s lifelong involvement with Brazil in the 1940s in the early work of Oscar Weber and Gill, and then in the Bay Area
sufficient to cite his memories of the Islamic architecture. Similar feelings and Niemeyer and Affonso Reidy; in Argentina school founded by William Wurster and in
356 Part III: Chapter 5 Critical Regionalism: Modern Architecture and Cultural Identity 357
of building – at one time. Only so can the The worship of the sun and the measurement
expression be sufficiently general, sufficiently of time from its light reach back to the earliest
varied, sufficiently forceful to capture people’s recorded history of man. It is interesting to
imaginations and provide a friendly climate note in the case of Fort Lauderdale that if one
long enough for a new school of design were to follow a 26° latitudinal line around
to develop. … the globe, one would find Fort Lauderdale in
San Francisco was made for Maybeck the company of Ancient Thebes – the throne of
Pasadena was made for Greene and Greene. the Egyptian sun god, Ra. Further to the East,
Neither could have accomplished what he one would find Jaipur. India, where heretofore,
did in any other place or time. Each used the largest equinoctial sundial in the world
the materials of the place; but it is not the was built 110 years prior to the founding of
materials that distinguish the work. … A Fort Lauderdale.
332 Wolf, model for the Fort Lauderdale Riverfront Plaza, region may develop ideas. A region may Mindful of these magnificent historical
1982. accept ideas. Imaginations and intelligence precedents, we sought a symbol that would
are necessary for both. In California in the speak of the past, present and future of Fort
the Southern California work of Harwell late Twenties and Thirties modern European Lauderdale. … To capture the sun in symbol
Hamilton Harris. No-one has perhaps ideas met a still developing regionalism. In a great sundial is incised on the Plaza site
expressed the idea of a Critical Regionalism New England, on the other hand, European and the gnomon of the sundial bisects the site
more forcefully than Harris, in ‘Regionalism Modernism met a rigid and restrictive on its north-south axis. The gnomon of the
and Nationalism’, an address which he first regionalism that at first resisted and double blade rises from the south at 26° 5’
gave to the North West Regional Council then surrendered. New England accepted parallel to Fort Lauderdale’s latitude. …
of the AIA in Eugene, Oregon, in 1954. This European Modernism whole because its own Each of the significant dates in Fort
was the occasion when he first advanced his regionalism had been reduced to a collection Lauderdale’s history is recorded in the great
felicitous distinction between restricted and of restrictions.5 blade of the sundial. With careful calculation
liberated regionalism: the sun angles are perfectly aligned with
Despite an apparent freedom of penetrations through the two blades to
Opposed to the Regionalism of Restriction is expression, such a level of liberative cast brilliant circles of light, landing on the
another type of regionalism; the Regionalism regionalism is difficult to achieve in otherwise shadowy side of the sundial.
of Liberation. This is the manifestation of North America today. Within the current These shafts of light illuminate an
a region that is especially in tune with the proliferation of highly individualistic appropriate historical marker serving as
emerging thought of the time. We call such a forms of expression (work which is often annual historical reminders.6
manifestation ‘regional’ only because it has patronizing and self-indulgent rather
not yet emerged elsewhere. It is the genius of than critical) only a few firms today In Europe the work of the architect Gino
this region to be more than ordinarily aware display any profound commitment to the Valle may be considered regional inasmuch
and more than ordinarily free. Its virtue unsentimental cultivation of a rooted as his career has always been centred on the
is that its manifestation has significance American culture. An atypical example of city of Udine. Aside from his concern for the
for the world outside itself. To express this current ‘regional’ work in North America city, Valle made one of the earliest post-war
regionalism architecturally it is necessary is the sensitively sited houses designed reinterpretations of the rural vernacular
that there be building – preferably a lot by Andrew Batey and Mark Mack for the of Lombardy in his Casa Quaglia, built at
Napa Valley area in California; another Sutrio in 1954–56 [334].
333 Williams, bridge house, Mar del Plata, 1943–45. is the work of the architect Harry Wolf, It is surely understandable that in
whose activity has been largely restricted Europe, where the vestigial city-state was
to North Carolina. Wolf’s metaphorical still very much alive, such a regionalist
approach to place-making was polemically impulse would emerge spontaneously after
demonstrated in his 1982 competition the Second World War when a number of
entry for the Fort Lauderdale Riverfront significant architects were able to contribute
Plaza [332]. As his description indicates, the to the culture of their native cities.
intention was to inscribe Fort Lauderdale’s Among those of the post-war generation
334 Valle,
Casa Quaglia, Sutrio, 1954–56.
history into the site through the incidence who remained committed to a regional 335 Scarpa,Querini Stampalia Gallery, Venice, 1961–63.
of light. inflection one may count Ernst Gisel in 336 Schnebli, Castioli House, Campione d’Italia, 1960.
358 Part III: Chapter 5 Critical Regionalism: Modern Architecture and Cultural Identity 359
Zürich, Jørn Utzon in Copenhagen, Vittorio Cantonal Library at Lugano (1936–40) as an while simultaneously retaining, through in the landscape, concealing the rapacious
Gregotti in Milan, Sverre Fehn in Oslo, Aris exemplary Rationalist work. Scarpa, an unusual capacity for the craft suburban development that has taken
Konstantinidis in Athens, and last but by no Ticinese practice in the mid-1950s, with enrichment of his form. One of the most place in the Ticino since 1960. Instead of
means least Carlo Scarpa in Venice [335]. the exception of Galfetti, was orientated exotic examples of this occurs in his being terraced into the site, they ‘build the
Switzerland, with its intricate towards the work of Frank Lloyd Wright application of intonaco lucido (polished site’, after the thesis advanced by Vittorio
linguistic boundaries and its tradition of rather than the prewar Italian Rationalists. plaster) to the fireplace surrounds of a Gregotti in ll territorio dell’architettura
cosmopolitanism, has always displayed Of this period Tita Carloni wrote: ‘We converted farmhouse at Ligrignano in 1979. (1966). They declare themselves as primary
strong regionalist tendencies. The cantonal naively set ourselves the objective of an Two other traits in Botta’s work may forms, set against the topography and the
principle of admission and exclusion has “organic” Ticino, in which the values of be seen as critical: on the one hand, his sky. Their capacity to harmonize with the
always favoured extremely dense forms of modern culture were to be interwoven in a constant preoccupation with what he terms partially agricultural nature of the region
expression, with the canton favouring local natural way with local tradition.’ Of Ticinese ‘building the site’, and on the other, his stems directly from their analogical form
culture and the Federation facilitating the Neo-Rationalism in the early 1970s we find conviction that the loss of the historical city and finish; that is to say, from the fair-
penetration and assimilation of foreign him writing: can only be compensated for by ‘cities in faced concrete block of their structure and
ideas. Dolf Schnebli’s Corbusian vaulted miniature’. Thus Botta’s school at Morbio from the silo or barnlike shells in which
villa at Campione d’Italia on the Italo-Swiss The old Wrightian schemata were superseded, Inferiore is interpreted as a micro-urban they are housed, these last alluding to the
frontier (1960) [336] may be seen as initiating the chapter of ‘big commissions’ for the State, realm – as a cultural compensation for traditional agricultural structures from
the resistance of Ticinese architecture with good reformist intentions, was closed. It the evident loss of civic life in Chiasso, the which they are derived.
to the influence of commercialized all had to be begun all over again, from the nearest large city. Primary references to Despite this feeling for a domestic
modernism. This resistance found an echo ground upwards, housing, schools, minor the culture of the Ticino landscape are also sensibility which is at once modern and
immediately in other parts of Switzerland, didactic restorations, competition entries as evoked by Botta at a typological level, such traditional, the most critical aspect of
in Aurelio Galfetti’s equally Corbusian an opportunity to investigate and critically as the house at Riva San Vitale [337], which Botta’s achievement resides in his public
Rotalinti House in Bellinzona (1961) and assess the contents and forms of architecture. refers obliquely to the traditional towerlike projects; in particular in the two large-
in Atelier 5’s assumption of the Corbusian In the meantime cultural confrontation country summer houses or rocoli which scale proposals which he designed in
béton brut manner, as this appeared in in Italy, political commitment, and the were once plentiful in the region. collaboration with Luigi Snozzi. Both of
Siedlung Halen, built outside Berne in 1960. exacting confrontation with our own native Aside from these references, these are ‘viaduct’ buildings and as such
Today’s Ticinese Regionalism has its intellectuals, especially Virgilio Gilardoni, Botta’s houses serve as markers in the owe something to Kahn’s Venice Congress
ultimate origins in the pre-war protagonists meant that history books started to appear landscape – as indicators of limits or Hall project of 1968 and to Rossi’s first
of the Italian Rationalist movement in on our desks, and above all faced us with the boundaries. The house in Ligornetto, for sketches for Gallaratese. The 1971 Botta/
Switzerland, above all the work of the challenge of critically reappraising the whole example, establishes the frontier where Snozzi project for the Centro Direzionale,
Italian Alberto Sartoris and the Ticinese evolution of modernism, most especially that the village ends and the agrarian system Perugia, is projected as a ‘city within a
Rino Tami. Sartoris’s main realizations of the 1920s and 1930s.7 begins: its main aperture (a large ‘cut-out’ city’, and the wider implications of this
were in the Valais, most notably a church opening) turns away from the fields and design clearly stem from its potential
at Lourtier (1932) and two small concrete- As Carloni suggests, the strength of towards the village. Botta’s houses are applicability to many megalopolitan
framed houses, built in association provincial culture resides in its capacity often treated as bunker/belvederes, where situations throughout the world. Had it
with viticulture and under construction to condense the artistic and critical the fenestration opens onto choice views been realized, this centre, conceived as
between 1934 and 1939, of which the most potential of the region while assimilating a ‘viaduct-megastructure’, could have
renowned is the Morand-Pasteur residence and reinterpreting outside influences. 337 Botta, house at Riva San Vitale, 1972–73.
established its presence in the urban region
at Saillon (1935). Of the compatibility The work of Carloni’s prime pupil, Mario without compromising the historic city or
between Rationalism and rural architecture Botta, is typical in this respect, with its fusing with the chaos of the surrounding
Sartoris wrote: ‘Rural architecture, with its concentration on issues which relate suburban development. A comparable
essentially regional features, is perfectly directly to the specific place while adapting clarity and appropriateness obtained in
at home with today’s rationalism. In fact it methods and approaches drawn from their Zürich Station proposal of 1978, where
embodies in practice all those functional outside. Formally educated under Scarpa, a multilevel bridge concourse would not
criteria on which modern building methods Botta was fortunate enough to work, only have accommodated shops, offices,
are essentially based.’ Where Sartoris however briefly, for both Kahn and Le restaurants and parking but would also
was primarily a polemicist keeping the Corbusier during the short period when have constituted a new head building
Rationalist precepts alive throughout the they projected civic works for Venice. while some of the original functions were
Second World War and its aftermath, Tami Evidently influenced by these men, Botta retained in the existing terminus [338].
was mainly a builder, and the Ticinese went on to appropriate the Italian Neo- It is no accident that Tadao Ando, who
architects of the 1960s were able to take his Rationalist methodology as his own, is one of the most regionally conscious
360 Part III: Chapter 5 Critical Regionalism: Modern Architecture and Cultural Identity 361
rays of sunlight … [where] walls become revelatory quality of his forms under light.
abstract, are negated, and approach the Thus he wrote of his Koshino House of 1981
ultimate limit of space. Their actuality is [339, 340]:
lost, and only the space they enclose gives a
sense of really existing.’ Light changes expressions with time. I believe
While the cardinal importance of light that the architectural materials do not end
is stressed in theoretical writings of both with wood and concrete that have tangible
Kahn and Le Corbusier, Ando sees the forms but go beyond to include light and wind
paradox of spatial limpidity emerging which appeal to our senses. … Detail exists
out of light as being peculiarly pertinent as the most important element in expressing
to the Japanese character and with this identity. … Thus to me, the detail is an element
he makes explicit the broader meaning which achieves the physical composition of
which he attributes to the concept of a self- architecture, but at the same time, it is a
enclosed modernity: generator of an image of architecture.
338 Botta and Snozzi,
project for the alteration Spaces of this kind are overlooked in the In their article on the Critical
of Zürich Station, 1978: utilitarian affairs of everyday and rarely Regionalism of the Greek architects
the original station
building (bottom) and make themselves known. Still they are Dimitris and Susana Antonakakis, entitled
bridge across the tracks. capable of stimulating recollection of their ‘The Grid and the Pathway’ (Architecture in
own innermost forms and of stimulating new Greece, 1981), Alex Tzonis and Liane Lefaivre
architects in Japan, should be based at former intimacy with both nature and discoveries. This is the aim of what I call demonstrate the ambiguous role played by
Osaka rather than Tokyo and that his culture. Thus he writes: closed modern architecture of this kind is the Schinkelschüler in the building of Athens
theoretical writings should formulate likely to alter with the region in which it sends and the founding of the Greek state:
more clearly than any other architect of his After World War II, when Japan launched out roots and to grow in various distinctive
generation a set of precepts which come on a course of rapid economic growth, the individual ways. Still, though closed, I feel In Greece historicist regionalism in its
close to the idea of Critical Regionalism. people’s value criteria changed. The old, convinced that as a methodology it is open in neoclassical version had already met with
This is most evident in the tension that he fundamentally feudal family system collapsed. the direction of universality.10 opposition before the arrival of the Welfare
perceives as obtaining between universal Such social alterations as concentration
modernization and the idiosyncrasy of of information and places of work in cities What Ando has in mind is the
rooted culture. Thus we find him writing led to overpopulation of urban centers and development of an architecture where the
in an essay entitled ‘From Self-Enclosed underpopulation of agricultural and fishing tactility of the work transcends the initial
Modern Architecture toward Universality’: villages and towns (as was probably true perception of its geometric order. Precision
in other parts of the world as well). Overly and density of detail are both crucial to the
Born and bred in Japan, I do my architectural dense urban and suburban populations made
339, 340 Ando, Koshino House, Osaka, 1981: view and
work here. And I suppose it would be possible it impossible to preserve a feature that was ground plan.
to say that the method I have selected is formerly most characteristic of Japanese
to apply the vocabulary and techniques residential architecture: intimate connection
developed by an open, universalist Modernism with nature and openness to the natural
in an enclosed realm of individual life styles world. What I refer to as an enclosed Modern
and regional differentiation. But it seems Architecture is a restoration of the unity
difficult to me to attempt to express the between house and nature that Japanese
sensibilities, customs, aesthetic awareness, houses have lost in the process
distinctive culture, and social traditions of modernization.9
of a given race by means of the open,
internationalist vocabulary of Modernism.8 In his small courtyard houses, often set
within dense urban fabric, Ando employs
By ‘enclosed modern architecture’ concrete in such a way as to stress the taut
Ando intends the literal creation of walled homogeneity of its surface rather than its
enclaves by virtue of which man is able to weight, since for him it is the most suitable
recover and sustain some vestige of his material ‘for realizing surfaces created by
362 Part III: Chapter 5 Critical Regionalism: Modern Architecture and Cultural Identity 363
as infill. A much less equivocal regionalist (1) Critical Regionalism has to be
spirit permeates the park and promenade understood as a marginal practice, one
that Dimitris Pikionis designed for the which, while it is critical of modernization,
Philopapp0u Hill in 1957, on a site adjacent to nonetheless still refuses to abandon the
the Acropolis in Athens [341]. In this archaic emancipatory and progressive aspects of the
landscape, as Tzonis and Lefaivre point out, modern architectural legacy. At the same
time, Critical Regionalism’s fragmentary
Pikionis proceeds to make a work of and marginal nature serves to distance it
architecture free from technological both from normative optimization and from
exhibitionism and compositional conceit (so the naïve utopianism of the early Modern
341 Pikionis, park paving on the Philopappou Hill, Athens, typical of the mainstream of architecture Movement. In contrast to the line that runs
1957. of the 1950s), a stark naked object almost from Haussmann to Le Corbusier, it favours
dematerialized, an ordering of ‘places made the small rather than the big plan.
State and of modern architecture. It is due for the occasion’, unfolding around the hill (2) In this regard Critical Regionalism
to a very peculiar crisis which explodes for solitary contemplation, for intimate manifests itself as a consciously bounded
around the end of the nineteenth century. discussion, for a small gathering, for a vast architecture, one which rather than
Historicist regionalism here had grown not assembly. … To weave this extraordinary emphasizing the building as a free-standing
only out of a war of liberation; it had emerged braid of niches and passages and situations, object places the stress on the territory
out of interests to develop an urban élite set Pikionis identifies appropriate components to be established by the structure erected
apart from the peasant world and its rural from the lived-in spaces of folk architecture, on the site. This ‘place-form’ means that
‘backwardness’ and to create a dominance but in this project the link with the regional the architect must recognize the physical
of town over country: hence the special is not made out of tender emotion. In a boundary of his work as a kind of temporal
appeal of historicist regionalism, based on completely different attitude, these envelopes limit – the point at which the present act of
the book rather than experience, with its of concrete events are studied with a cold building stops.
monumentality recalling another distant empirical method, as if documented by an (3) Critical Regionalism favours the
and forlorn élite. Historical regionalism had archaeologist. Neither is their selection and realization of architecture as a tectonic
united people but it had also divided them.11 their positioning carried out to stir easy fact rather than the reduction of the built
superficial emotion. They are platforms to environment to a series of ill-assorted
The various reactions which followed be used in an everyday sense but to supply scenographic episodes.
the proliferation of the 19th-century Greek that which, in the context of contemporary (4) It may be claimed that Critical
Nationalist Neo-Classical style varied from architecture, everyday life does not. The Regionalism is regional to the degree that
the vernacular historicism of the 1920s to investigation of the local is the condition for it invariably stresses certain site-specific
the committed modernism of the 1930s reaching the concrete and the real, and for factors, ranging from the topography,
as this became manifest in the work of rehumanizing architecture.12 considered as a three-dimensional matrix
such architects as Stamo Papadaki and into which the structure is fitted, to the
J.G. Despotopoulos. As Tzonis points Tzonis sees the work of the Antonakakis varying play of local light across the
out, a consciously regionalist modernism partnership as combining the topographic structure. Light is invariably understood
emerged in Greece with the earliest works path of Pikionis with the universal grid of as the primary agent by which the volume
of Aris Konstantinidis (his Eleusis house of Konstantinidis. This dialectical opposition and the tectonic value of the work are
1938 and his Kifissia garden exhibition of seems to reflect once again that split revealed. An articulate response to climatic
1940), and this line was developed further between culture and civilization remarked conditions is a necessary corollary to this.
by Konstantinidis in the 1950s, in various on by Ricoeur. Perhaps no work expresses 342, 343 Antonakakis, apartment building in Benaki Hence Critical Regionalism is opposed to
low-cost housing schemes and in the hotels this duality more directly than their Benaki Street, Athens, 1975. Transverse section and view. the tendency of ‘universal civilization’ to
he designed for the Xenia national tourist Street apartments built in Athens in 1975 optimize the use of air conditioning, etc.
organization between 1956 and 1966. In all [342, 343], a layered structure wherein a Regionalism is not so much a style as it is a It tends to treat all openings as delicate
of Konstantinidis’s public work a tension labyrinthine route drawn from the Greek critical category orientated towards certain transitional zones with a capacity to
appears between the universal rationality island vernacular is woven into the regular common features, which may not always be respond to the specific conditions imposed
of the trabeated reinforced-concrete frame grid of the supporting concrete frame. present in the examples cited here. These by the site, the climate and the light.
and the autochthonous tactility of the As with the largely overlapping categories features, or rather attitudes, may perhaps be (5) Critical Regionalism emphasizes the
native stone and blockwork which is used used in the previous chapter, Critical best summarized as follows. tactile as much as the visual. It is aware
364 Part III: Chapter 5 Critical Regionalism: Modern Architecture and Cultural Identity 365
that the environment can be experienced in (7) Critical Regionalism tends to flourish
terms other than sight alone. It is sensitive to in those cultural interstices which in
such complementary perceptions as varying one way or another are able to escape the
levels of illumination, ambient sensations optimizing thrust of universal civilization.
of heat, cold, humidity and air movement, Its appearance suggests that the received
varying aromas and sounds given off by notion of the dominant cultural centre
different materials in different volumes, surrounded by dependent, dominated
and even the varying sensations induced satellites is ultimately an inadequate model
by floor finishes, which cause the body to by which to assess the present state of
experience involuntary changes in posture, modern architecture.
gait, etc. It is opposed to the tendency in an
age dominated by media to the replacement
of experience by information.
(6) While opposed to the sentimental
simulation of local vernacular, Critical
Regionalism will, on occasion, insert
reinterpreted vernacular elements as
disjunctive episodes within the whole. It will
moreover occasionally derive such elements
from foreign sources. In other words it
will endeavour to cultivate a contemporary
place-orientated culture without becoming
unduly hermetic, either at the level of formal
reference or at the level of technology. In
this regard, it tends towards the paradoxical
creation of a regionally based ‘world
culture’, almost as though this were a
precondition for achieving a relevant form of
contemporary practice.
368 369
international competition of 1922 for the of 1944. The proto-Art Deco aspects of different time and in different initial Salvador Allende in Chile (1970–73), when
new headquarters of the Chicago Tribune Cormier’s work meant that the Modern works, ranging from Gregori Warchavchik’s an attempt was made to build housing en
newspaper. Saarinen’s design, in effect, Movement per se did not fully emerge in own house in São Paulo of 1927 to Carlos masse through the adoption of Russian
established the set-back, attenuated high- Canada until well after the Second World Raúl Villanueva’s Gran Colombia School prefabricated methods.
rise format of what would become the War, most decisively with Arthur Erickson’s built in the outskirts of Caracas in 1939,
typical Art Deco skyscraper. Simon Fraser University campus laid out a discernibly modern work following his
Absent in previous editions is the extent on high ground just outside Vancouver in return to Venezuela after studying at the
to which both Mies van de Rohe at the IIT 1962. However, a more general adoption of Ecole des Beaux-Arts in Paris. For each
and Walter Gropius in Harvard greatly modern architecture in Canada came with of the eight Latin American countries
influenced the education of architects in Expo ’67, built in Montreal on an island included in this edition I have not been able
the States, particularly during the first two in the St Lawrence River. This happens to to do more than to trace the evolution of
decades (1945–65) of the Pax Americana, be the last time that the US participated a singular manner of building in relation
the period of relative peace worldwide seriously in a world exhibition, which it did to the modernization of society in general
overseen by the United States. The scope via the US Pavilion, a large geodesic sphere and the ideological line adopted by those
of this influence is indicated by the designed by R. Buckminster Fuller. This in power at a particular moment in time;
technologically advanced but expressively technological tour de force was matched by for example, when Getúlio Vargas rose to
discreet corporate practice of Skidmore, Moshe Safdie’s equally radical multistorey power in Brazil, becoming president in
Owings and Merrill (SOM) and by the works housing scheme, known as Habitat ’67, 1930, he immediately commissioned Lúcio
of Gropius’s post-war GSD protégés such as which at great cost to the Canadian Costa to go to Portugal, with the naive aim
John Johansen, Edward Larrabee Barnes, government attempted to demonstrate the of evolving an authentic national style for
Ulrich Franzen and Paul Rudolph, who in potential for delivering some of the benefits Brazil to be ostensibly derived from the
various ways produced their own versions of suburban living in an otherwise dense, rooted Portuguese vernacular.
of the New Monumentality. As far as the medium-rise residential structure. It is remarkable that in Latin America,
US is concerned, Rudolph is surely the Both before and after the Second where the political scene has often been
most egregious omission from previous World War, South America would be seen in a state of turmoil, it has been possible
editions of this history, above all for his from Europe and even from the United for successive governments to introduce
singular masterwork, the Art & Architecture States as a kind of proving ground for the significant socio-economic reforms
Building for Yale University in New Haven, Modern Movement. This much became irrespective of whether they happen to be
Connecticut, of 1963. particularly evident with the New York implemented from the Left or the Right.
Although modern architecture in Museum of Modern Art’s exhibition ‘Brazil A typical leftist government in this regard
the United States has been prominently Builds’ of 1943 and, twelve years later, ‘Latin was the presidency of Lázaro Cárdenas
featured in previous editions of this work, American Architecture since 1945’, curated in Mexico. He redistributed land to
there were few references to its northern by Henry-Russell Hitchcock. Brazil has previously landless tenants and, further,
neighbour, Canada. At the turn of the always occupied a privileged position in the in 1938, expropriated the international oil
century, as Richard Ingersoll has pointed received histories of the Modern Movement companies that had invested in the Mexican
out, Canadian architects were just as since the 1950s, as was borne out by the first oilfields. This action was even supported
classically trained as their American edition of this history, in which the works by President Franklin D. Roosevelt during
counterparts, although their formation in of Lúcio Costa and Oscar Niemeyer were the height of the American New Deal, the
this regard was as much British as it was highlighted, notably the Brazilian Pavilion programmes, public work projects and
French, as is evident from John Lyle’s Union at the New York World’s Fair of 1939 and the reforms designed to stimulate economic
Station in Toronto, completed in 1930, with Ministry of Education and Health Building recovery after the Great Depression. It was
its monumental enfilade of Doric columns. in Rio de Janeiro of virtually the same date. in just such a climate that the Mexican
At that time, the most sophisticated In this regard, Brazil has served as the state constructed rural school buildings
classically trained architect in Canada was template for my analysis of the Modern throughout the country. Something similar
unquestionably the Quebecois architect Movement in other Latin American would happen during the presidency of
Ernest Cormier, whose magnificent countries including Argentina, Chile, Fernando Belaúnde Terry in Peru, over
Supreme Court of Canada building in Colombia, Mexico, Peru, Uruguay and the years 1963–68, when his government
Ottawa, with its monumental mansard Venezuela. As might be expected, the backed the international experimental
roofs, was completed five years after his breakthrough of the Modern Movement in housing settlement known as PREVI,
crypto-modernist University of Montreal each of these countries occurred at a slightly and again during the brief presidency of
Apart from Frank Lloyd Wright, who Nazi seizure of power in Germany in 1933,
became influential worldwide following immigrated either to the USSR or to the US,
the publication of the Wasmuth volumes depending on their ideological affinities.
of his work in 1910, the socially progressive The first was Ludwig Mies van der Rohe,
ideology of the Modern Movement first who was invited to the US in 1937 to head
appeared in the US via European émigrés. up the department of architecture in the
The first to arrive were the Viennese Armour Institute, Chicago, its name being
architects Rudolf Schindler and Richard soon changed to the Illinois Institute of
Neutra, both of whom went to the States Technology, or IIT. Mies’s arrival in Chicago
with the express purpose of working for was followed by that of László Moholy-Nagy,
Wright, Schindler in 1914 and Neutra in who would found the New Bauhaus in the
1924. The other figure of consequence was same city in 1938.
the Finnish architect Eliel Saarinen, who It is difficult to overstate the extent of
migrated to the States after gaining second Mies’s influence on American post-war
place in the international competition architecture, particularly on the post-1945
of 1922 for the design of the multi-storey corporate practice of Skidmore, Owings
Chicago Tribune building with an abstract and Merrill (SOM). Even an architect as 345 Howe & Lescaze, PSFS Bank Building, Philadelphia, 1936.
346 Gropius, Gropius House, Lincoln, Massachusetts, 1938. Ground-floor plan.
mullioned design that anticipated the Art individualistic and eclectic as Eero Saarinen,
347 Breuer, with Emil Roth and Alfred Roth, Doldertal Apartments, Zürich, 1936.
Deco skyscraper manner of the 1920s. Soon despite being a protégé of his father,
after his arrival Saarinen met the newspaper Eliel, was equally affected by Mies van der tactile material palette, invariably combining the Doldertal, Zürich [347]. Breuer’s move
tycoon George Booth, who commissioned Rohe’s work, as is evident from the GM timber cladding with dry stone (fieldstone) towards a more tactile use of traditional
him to design and direct the Cranbrook Headquarters built to his design in Detroit walls. This hybrid manner was recognized materials would be consolidated in three
Academy of Art in Michigan, which between 1949 and 1955. The one exceptional by Henry-Russell Hitchcock in his essay houses that he and Gropius designed for
was conceived as a utopian educational talent in the Chicago office of SOM who ‘Marcel Breuer and the American Tradition’, Lincoln, Massachusetts, in 1938 [346], one
community, primarily dedicated to the had the independence to depart from Mies, which accompanied a 1938 exhibition of each for their own occupation and one for
teaching of applied art. Similarly, in 1922 despite his professional formation at the the same name, staged at the newly created the historian James Ford, whose book The
the young Swiss architect William Lescaze IIT, was Myron Goldsmith, whose Kitts Peak Graduate School of Design (GSD), Harvard Modern House in America (1944) was an early
also arrived in the US, where he eventually Observatory, Arizona (1962), was a striking University. Breuer had first ventured into documentation of the Modern Movement in
formed a partnership with the Philadelphia work of engineering comparable in its stone walling in his Gane Pavilion designed the United States.
architect George Howe; together they originality to Fazlur Khan’s Hajj Terminal, with the British architect F.R.S. Yorke for the At Gropius’s invitation, Sigfried Giedion
designed the remarkable fifteen-storey Jeddah, Saudi Arabia, of 1981, also designed Royal Agricultural Show at Bristol, England, gave the Charles Eliot Norton Lectures at
Philadelphia Savings Fund Society (PSFS) by the Chicago office of SOM. in 1936, one year before his migration to Harvard in 1939, which would become the
bank building of 1936 [345], which for Upon their arrival in the States, Walter the States. However, his very first attempt substance of his influential book Space,
the next thirty years remained the only Gropius and his Bauhaus colleague Marcel at a softer functional mode was manifest in Time and Architecture, published in 1941.
high-rise structure in Philadelphia. These Breuer jointly created a form of vernacular his Doldertal Apartments of the same year, Gropius and Breuer’s Chamberlain Cottage
European pioneers were followed by a wave modernism, which, while adhering to a white, designed in association with Alfred Roth and [348, 349], built at Wayland, Massachusetts,
of leading German architects who, after the flat-roofed format, would incorporate a more Emil Roth and built for Sigfried Giedion in in the same year, was clad with redwood
throughout Holl’s work, there is a notable dormitories, completed for the University
shift in the scale and density of detailing as of Virginia in Charlottesville in 1992. In this
he passed, for example, from the so-called instance, seven dormitory blocks, clad in
‘Void Space/Hinged Space’ housing that he brick and of three to four storeys, step down
built in Osaka, Japan, in 1991, to the large to culminate at the bottom of a slope in a
urban works that he has completed in brick-clad dining hall with canted skylights.
China, above all the so-called Linked Hybrid Three years later, they followed this stepped
Building, Beijing, or the Vanke Center, assembly with an even more organic
Shenzhen, both dating from 2009. composition for the Scripps Neuroscience
The practice of Tod Williams and Billie Institute [356, 357] in La Jolla, San Diego,
Tsien is equally committed to a culture California, constructed of fair-faced concrete
of materials, wherein the tactility of their and partially clad with fossilized limestone.
architecture enhances an inherently The regionally inflected modernism
topographic approach to the evolution of that emerged on the West Coast in the first
form. This is evident in their New College quarter of the 20th century was continued
The mid-1960s saw the beginning of a new [363]. Fuller’s sphere, penetrated by a
architectural tradition in Canada, which monorail, evoked the space-age condition
363 Safdie,Habitat ‘67, Montreal, 1967. Section.
took different forms across the country, of weightlessness through the suspension 364 Hanganu, Musée d’Archéologie et d’Histoire Pointe-
depending on the regional climate and the of astronautical objects within its à-Callière, Montreal, 1992.
scope of the work. At this time, a modern seemingly limitless volume. In this regard
manner with few precedents began to it unequivocally represented the techno-
emerge in the three major cities: Montreal scientific superiority of the United States, first move towards a regionally inflected
in the east, Toronto – slightly further while Safdie’s Habitat, subsidized by the Canadian architecture appeared in Toronto
west – and Vancouver in the far west. Canadian government, was an audacious in the work of Ron Thom, whose part-
Modern environmental culture first demonstration of the stacking of duplex Brutalist, part-late Gothic Revival enclave
manifested itself in Montreal in the work of apartments so as to provide roof terraces for of Massey College was constructed in the
the Quebecois Art Deco architect–engineer each unit, thereby affording the essential built-up area of the city in 1963. This was
Ernest Cormier, primarily through his benefits of suburban living in a high-density followed in 1965 by the equally Brutalist, angle to street level before an existing Beaux
Université de Montreal, constructed housing complex. organically planned Scarborough College Arts museum. These gardens and water
between 1928 and 1955. After the Second Just over a decade later, one of the [366] built of concrete on a bucolic site features were designed by the landscape
World War modern architecture appeared more significant architects to emerge in outside the city centre to the designs of the architect Cornelia Oberlander, with whom
in Montreal in two downtown mega- Montreal was the Romanian émigré Dan Australian architect John Andrews. Erickson would regularly collaborate
developments: the Place Ville Marie (1958), Hanganu, who first made his mark with an On the west coast, the first figure of throughout his career.
an office and shopping complex by I.M. Pei, elegant set of two-storey, brick-faced terrace stature to emerge during the post-war period Equally within the Canadian inventive
and the merchandise mart and rooftop houses built in the Rue de Gaspé on Nuns’ was Arthur Erickson, whose Simon Fraser tradition was a uniquely seminal work
hotel, known as the Place Bonaventure, Island, close to the centre of the city in 1980. University (1962–72) [365], conceived as a by the then émigré American architect
built to the designs of Ray Affleck in Hanganu later added two other exceptional landscaped megastructure, was integrated Barton Myers, who, with Jack Diamond
‘corduroy’ bush-hammered concrete in mid-rise works to the downtown area: the into the rising site of a small mountain and Richard Wilkin, designed a dormitory
1964. Montreal finally came to the fore with UQAM (Université du Québec à Montréal) near Vancouver. Erickson followed this for the University of Alberta at Edmonton.
Expo ’67, a state-sponsored world exhibition Design School (1996) and the Pointe-à- achievement with two other megastructural This was the so called HUB (Housing Union
staged in 1967 on an island in the middle of Callière museum of archaeology and history works: his bridge-like design for the Building) of 1973 [367], a 292-metre (958-foot)
the St Lawrence River. This exhibition was [364], completed in the old city in 1992. University of Lethbridge in Alberta (1972), long, climate-controlled, top-lit galleria with
dominated by two monumental works, the Toronto’s entry into modernity began and his Robson Square complex, completed the students’ rooms stacked in five floors
first being Buckminster Fuller’s US Pavilion, in 1958 with the international competition as an axial spine running through the centre on either side of a self-contained volume,
which took the unique form of an enormous for Toronto City Hall, won by the Finnish of Vancouver in 1986. This last, occupying which was equipped with a full range
geodesic sphere. As it happens, this was the architect Viljo Revell and realized over the three city blocks, consisted of a continuous of social amenities at ground level. This
last national pavilion to be fully supported next decade. The asymmetrical composition structure comprising a courthouse, typologically inventive work was echoed
by the US government in a world exhibition. of this work consisted of two curved high- municipal offices and a stepped rooftop in the ‘high-tech’, light steel-framed Wolf
The other prominent work, which was also rise slabs of varying heights embracing a landscape culminating in an ornamental House built to the designs of Myers in the
predicated on tetrahedral geometry, was shallow-domed, circular council chamber, pool and multiple waterfalls. These cascades inner suburbs of Toronto in 1977; it was the
Moshe Safdie’s multistorey experimental the whole being elevated on a podium well accompanied a sequence of stramps second in a sequence of three steel houses
housing complex, known as Habitat ’67 above the existing street level. However, the (stepped ramps), which descended at an that he designed and built, with the first and
last being for his own occupation. Myers’s shadow and lightens toward the edges as an The most significant public work to be
final domestic exercise in steel was built in intermediary zone. completed by this practice to date is their
Toro Canyon, Montecito, in 1999; this house Grande Bibliothèque du Québec in Montreal
and studio was designed for his southern Such a ‘zone’ proved to be equally of 2005 [370], said to be the largest public
Californian retirement and constructed a essential in the peripheral organization of library in the French-speaking world.
full decade after his return to the US and the their Strawberry Vale School [369], built in Built in the Latin Quarter of Montreal, it
establishment of his office in Los Angeles in Victoria, British Columbia, in 1996, where comprises, in addition to the library, an
1984. This singular monumental work seems paired classrooms open onto a common auditorium, an exhibition space, shops, a
to refer to the Asian tradition of an open-air terrace sandwiched between them and set restaurant/café, and a series of small stalls
pleasure pavilion. before a local micro-landscape of moss- for booksellers, located along a pedestrian
The consistently distinguished Canadian covered rocks. lane behind the main body of the building.
practitioners of the next generation are More than any of the other ‘pagoda’ Directly accessible from the city subway
John and Patricia Patkau, who began their structures designed by Patkau Architects system, this long building is served by
significant career in Vancouver with their during the last decade of the 20th century an elevator shaft and a cable-suspended
Seabird Island School, built at Agassiz in the Gleneagles Community Centre in West staircase, both of which rise from the
1991 for an Indian band living in the Fraser Vancouver [368] depends on the interaction entrance to serve the library above. Faced
Valley. The hump-backed, shingle-covered, of a whole range of constructional with locally fabricated extruded glass
laminated timber roof of this school was components besides the laminated timber channel planking, this building has, in
conceived in some measure as a topographic trusses supporting the roof, thereby many respects, been treated as a structure
metaphor, consciously harmonizing with engendering a symbiotic combination of within a structure, as the open library stacks
the profile of an adjacent mountain range. are housed in a louvred timber case that in
367 Myers, Diamond and Wilken, Housing Union
Its deep eaves sweep low over a south-facing Building, Alberta, Canada, 1973. Sectional perspective. 368 PatkauArchitects, Gleneagles Community Centre, its turn is contained within a weatherproof
porch and are held in position by a canted West Vancouver, 2003. glass enclosure.
369 PatkauArchitects, Strawberry Vale School, Victoria,
pergola, which consciously alludes to the fish- British Columbia, 1996. Playing areas facing on to moss- Two works by Patkau Architects
drying racks of the indigenous coastal villages covered rocks. dating from 2016 testify to their continual
of the Pacific Northwest. Of this and similar inventiveness. The first of these is the
structures Patricia Patkau has remarked: environmental elements that is inherently Audain Art Museum, projected as a bridge-
sustainable. Of this they have written: like, pitched-roof gallery spanning over
Many of our buildings have covered porches the flood plan of Fitzsimmons Creek in
for various purposes: to modify the sun, shed The structural system consists of cast-in-place Whistler, British Columbia. The second is a
the rain, or to provide a sense of shelter. Most concrete floor slabs, insulated double-wythe, visitors’ centre close to the 200-year-old Fort
of our roofs come down low at their edges; tilt-up concrete end walls, and a heavy timber York National Historic Site, located adjacent
some, however, go up to capture light at the roof. This structure is an important component to an elevated expressway feeding the centre
top. Most cover an interior volume that is in of the interior climate-control system of the of Toronto. Parallel to the monumental
Despite the leading role played in Mexico Cecil O’Gorman, which promptly led to his
by the Ecole des Beaux-Arts well into the being commissioned for the design of two
1930s, as is evident from Adamo Boari’s adjoining studios on an adjacent site for
monumental Palace of the Fine Arts of 1934 the artists Frida Kahlo and Diego Rivera
and Carlos Obregón Santacilia’s Monument [376, 377]. All three buildings were exercises
to the Revolution of 1938, the Modern in Le Corbusier’s Purist manner as this
Movement in Mexico came into being via had appeared in the Paris studio which Le
José Villagrán García’s Institute of Hygiene Corbusier designed for the painter Amédée
built in Mexico City in 1925. The exposed in Ozenfant in 1922. What O’Gorman added
situ concrete character of this symmetrical to the Purist syntax was an exceptionally
two-storey building, with its regularly dynamic use of colour, the cubistic forms of
spaced square windows and oversailing flat the studios being differentiated from one
cornices – reminiscent of Tony Garnier’s another by a particularly vibrant contrast.
work in Lyons at the beginning of the Convinced by the polemic advanced by
20th century – could hardly have been Le Corbusier in his Vers une architecture
more removed from the Mexican Pavilion (1923), O’Gorman felt that the priority for
erected for the Ibero-American Exhibition a post-revolutionary society was the mass
staged in Seville in 1929. This pavilion, production of housing and schools to serve 374 O’Gorman, National Autonomous University of Mexico Library, Mexico City, 1951.
375 O’Gorman, secondary school project, 1932.
designed by Manuel Amabilis, incorporated the needs of the working class. Throughout
376 O’Gorman, house-studio of Frida Kahlo, Mexico City, 1929. Elevation.
sculptural forms and decorative elements the first half of the 1930s, on Rivera’s 377 O’Gorman, house-studio of Diego Rivera, Mexico City, 1929. Elevation.
of Aztec origin, a provocative assertion recommendation, O’Gorman found himself
of pre-Hispanic culture that did not find designing and building schools [375], house that he built for himself close to El Cetto were among the most significant
favour with the exhibition authorities, which were elegant functionalist essays in Pedregal in Mexico City in 1948. The form of designers to come to Mexico in the late
who relegated the pavilion to a remote reinforced concrete frame construction. this work was as retrogressive as the equally 1930s as political refugees. Where Meyer’s
corner. However, the indigenous roots of By the early 1940s, however, O’Gorman cryptic studio that Diego Rivera built for political reputation found immediate favour
Mexican culture would gather momentum had become totally disillusioned with the himself in Anahuacalli in 1957. Indifferent with the left-wing government of Lázaro
with the Mexican Muralist movement, Modern Movement, not only because it had to the latter-day populism of O’Gorman Cárdenas, leading on his arrival in 1938 to
which flourished through to the middle been appropriated by real estate developers and Rivera, Villagrán García continued his appointment as director of the State
of the century, as is evident from the Pre- but also because its austere abstract to pursue his rationalist agenda in the Institute of Urbanism and Planning, the
Columbian iconography of the mosaic character rendered it inimical to the more design of health facilities, beginning with relatively apolitical Cetto would eventually
designed by Juan O’Gorman in 1951 for the picturesque values of the Mexican working a tuberculosis hospital that he built in the find work with Luis Barragán, collaborating
bookstack of the National Autonomous class. This impasse led him to abandon manner of Garnier in 1929 and continuing on the design of the apartment buildings
University of Mexico (UNAM) [374]. architecture altogether in favour of mural with a cardiological hospital in 1937 and a that would characterize the beginning
Graduating from UNAM in 1925, after painting, and with this shift he became children’s hospital in 1942, all of which were of Barragán’s career in Mexico City.
studying with Villagrán García, O’Gorman increasingly preoccupied with folkloric built in Mexico City. This association led to their subsequent
began his independent career in 1929 by symbolism, overwhelmingly evident in The Swiss-German architect Hannes collaboration on the design of the El
designing a small studio for his father, the self-consciously primitive, troglodyte Meyer and the German architect Max Pedregal neighbourhood on a site that had
the mid-1960s with the much larger 11,000- corresponds to the orthogonal form of the Programmatically inventive and character. Fortunately, the megastructure
unit Nonoalco-Tlatelolco development in building. meticulously detailed, one of the the most as a whole is parallelled by an allée of trees
Mexico City built in anticipation of the 1968 The traces of a highly sophisticated arresting works of the first decade of the and a beautiful landscape that permeates
Olympic Games. minimalism may be found in Mexican 21st century is the Vasconcelos Library the site throughout, so as to temper the
The other architect to have a major architecture throughout the second half [384] in Mexico City completed in 2008 to technological severity of the work.
impact on the development of Mexican of the 20th century in works as varied the designs of Alberto Kalach, assisted
architecture at this time was Pedro as the Quintana House (1956) [383], the by Gustavo Lipkau, Juan Palomar and
Ramírez Vázquez, who in 1964 realized two Jaysour Building (1964) and the Escuela Tonatiuh Martínez. This technological tour 384 Kalach, Vasconcelos Library, Mexico City, 2008.
major museums within the prestigious Bancaria y Comercial (1989), all three works de force, rendering the national library as
Chapultepec Park in Mexico City – the being designed by the brilliant yet still a mechanistic labyrinth, is comparable as
National Anthropological Museum and the insufficiently recognized Augusto Álvarez. a high-tech manifestation to the Centre
Museum of Modern Art. Vázquez had been Within this Mexican minimalist tradition Pompidou, Paris, of 1972, which was also
one of the designers of a lightweight steel can also be counted the much later San treated as if a cultural institution were
frame system expressly conceived as an anti- Pablo Oztotepec Market in Milpa Alta built merely a giant machine. In this instance,
seismic armature with which to facilitate the to the designs of Mauricio Rocha in 2003. however, the sublime scale recalls the
construction of rural schools throughout monumentality of the 18th-century French
382 TEN Arquitectos, National Laboratory of Genomics,
the country, of which some 35,000 units were Guanajuato, 2009.
architect Étienne-Louis Boullée, an effect
built during the 1960s with local materials which is paradoxically due to the extensive
and labour. Despite this excursion into light- use of glass roof lights, equally translucent
weight steel-framed construction, the next floors and a continuously louvred glass
decade saw the emergence of a decidedly envelope. This is complemented by an array
Brutalist monumentality, as seen in the two of suspended steel bookcases and stairways
major institutional buildings that Teodoro that hang down in a somewhat ominous
González de León and Abraham Zabludovsky way, so much so as to visually interrupt
built in Chapultepec Park, the Colegio de the spatial thrust of the main axis. Despite
México of 1976 and Museo Rufino Tamayo the bold cantilevered concrete canopy over
of 1981. A reinforced concrete architecture the entrances, there is little here of the
of greater refinement was achieved with civic deportment that accompanied such
the National Laboratory of Genomics [382] institutions in the past. Instead this 300-
built in Guanajuato in 2009 to the designs metre long (984-foot) long galleria, covered
of TEN Arquitectos, wherein the pattern by a stepped canopy of dematerialized
of the timber formwork for the concrete bookcases, has a disturbingly Babelic
In the late 1920s the Russian émigré yet hybrid national style, appropriate to the
architect Gregori Warchavchik played a modern epoch. Carlos Ramos, director of
fundamental role in the development of the the School of Architecture of Porto, became
Paulista School of architecture, initially by profoundly involved in orchestrating
designing a symmetrical, cubic villa for his this state-sponsored research into the
own occupation in 1929 [385]. While stripped Portuguese vernacular.
of ornament, this house was surrounded As previously noted, Brazil first
by one of the earliest cacti gardens in presented its baroque version of modern
Brazil, designed by Warchavchik’s wife, architecture to the world with the Brazilian
the autodidact landscape architect Mina Pavilion, built for the New York World’s Fair 386 Costa, Ministry of Education and Health, Rio de Janeiro, 1938.
Klabin. Both Oscar Niemeyer and Lúcio of 1939 to the designs of Costa and Niemeyer
Costa worked with Warchavchik during the (fig. 263). The pavilion was complemented (azulejos) [386]. This was the first synthesis younger colleague Paulo Mendes da Rocha
late 1920s, Niemeyer as his assistant and by an equally organic aquatic garden of the lyrical manner that Niemeyer would and subsequently on the leading architect
Costa as his business partner prior to his designed by Roberto Burle Marx, who develop further with the various buildings of the next generation, Angelo Bucci. One
appointment at the age of twenty-eight to had previously been responsible for the he realized around in Pampulha, a suburb of the most direct translations of Reidy’s
head up the Escola de Belas Artes (School of roof garden of the Ministry of Education of Belo Horizonte, between 1942 and 1944, reinforced-concrete portal system was the
Fine Arts) in Rio de Janeiro. and Health in Rio de Janeiro of 1938. This including the casino that he built on a reinforced-concrete blade walls carrying
An intriguing aspect of Lúcio Costa’s building had been designed by a team of promontory in the centre of an artificial the roof of Mendes da Rocha’s Paulistano
career is that he was as much involved with young architects under the leadership of lake (fig. 262). However, the one work Stadium, realized in São Paulo in 1958
historic preservation as with modernism Costa and enriched with murals by the that would be decisive in transferring [387]. Artigas also took from Reidy the idea
and to this end he became involved in painter Candido Portinari made of blue the plastically dynamic manner of Rio to of bringing the rigid-frame, reinforced-
research into the Portuguese vernacular, and white traditional Portuguese tiles São Paulo was Affonso Eduardo Reidy’s concrete portals down to the ground on
first in 1948, when the Brazilian government Museum of Modern Art [388], built in Rio de point supports, as found in his singular
sent him to Portugal to study the evolution 385 Warchavchik, Casa Mariana, São Paulo, 1929. Janeiro in 1953 in the midst of Burle Marx’s architectural school, FAU-USP (Faculdade de
of agrarian typologies in the ‘home Flamingo Park. Predicated on a reiteration Arquitetura e Urbanismo da Universidade
country’. His initial research in this area of a single reinforced-concrete portal de São Paulo) [389], completed in São
informed his contribution to the 1950 Luso- frame, repeated throughout the length Paulo in 1967. This consisted of a large
Brazilian Congress in Washington, DC, of the museum, the main floor was held reinforced-concrete box elevated two floors
when he argued that masterpieces of the above the ground on canted point supports, above ground level on fourteen tapering
Minas Gerais region in south-eastern Brazil while the two exhibition levels above were concrete columns. The unique feature of
should be seen as the colonial version of the cable-suspended from the portal frames. this building was its monumental top-lit
original Portuguese Baroque. His second The tectonically expressive character of assembly hall, which Artigas conceived as
visit to Portugal in 1953 not only confirmed this building had a profound influence on the political heart of the school.
his initial findings but also prompted the the Paulista School of architecture, first on Both Artigas and Mendes da Rocha
Salazar regime to conduct a survey of its João Batista Vilanova Artigas, whose bold shared a socio-political commitment, which
own into the Portuguese vernacular with structural approach would also have an accounts for their dismissal from the faculty
the similar aim of deriving an authentic, impact on successive architects, then on his of the architecture school by the US-backed
design of a series of public buildings, mostly a courtyard which was at its corners stepped
cultural institutions, university faculties in section so that one could pass through
and museums. Around this time he received the neighbourhood diagonally from one
the most prestigious commission of his courtyard to the next. This relatively open
career, the Presidential State Guest House, circulation testified to Salmona’s lifelong
otherwise known as the Casa de Huespedes opposition to gated communities.
(1980–82) [405], built on a peninsula Among the talented Colombian architects
projecting out into the Bay of Cartagena, of the 1980s, equally committed to the
next to one of the fortifications of this importance of the public realm, one needs
colonial city. Conceived as an austere, to acknowledge the work of Oscar Mesa, an
self-contained, cloistered retreat for the architect who was particularly influenced by
president and his honoured guests, it was the work of Louis Kahn, as his Metropolitan
constructed out of a mixture of bricks and Theatre in Medellín of 1986 [406] makes
local coral stone. The most poetic aspect abundantly clear. Equally notable is the
of this work is the way in which it conveys 1,500-unit La Mota housing complex built
the atmosphere of a Pre-Columbian ruin in Medellín in 1987 [407] to the designs of
embedded in a tropical landscape, which Laureano Forero Ochoa, a rational Brutalist
Salmona designed with his wife, the three- to four-storey scheme, the units of
landscape architect María Elvira Madriñán. which were ingeniously organized.
After completing the state guest house, Despite continual political strife in the
Salmona was engaged with a social project country at large, progressive policies were
in the Candelaria district of Bogotá. This pursued in Bogotá by one government
exercise in urban renewal was based on after another, beginning with Jaime Castro
nine perimeter blocks, of which only four Castro, who as mayor reorganized the
were built. Each block was grouped around administrative and financial structure
Carlos Raúl Villanueva was the most was integrated by a serpentine covered
internationally renowned modernist walkway linking the different faculties.
architect practising in Venezuela during Villanueva subsequently designed all the
the second half of the 20th century. Of principal faculty buildings, including the
Venezuelan origin but born in London in Aula Magna – a large auditorium– enlivened
1900 to a diplomatic family and educated in by a giant polychromatic mobile specially
Paris at the Ecole de Beaux-Arts, Villanueva created as a decorative acoustical device by
returned to Caracas in 1929, where, after the celebrated American artist Alexander
an apprenticeship in the Ministry of Public Calder [411]. The cantilevered reinforced- 410 Villanueva, Gran Colombia School, Caracas, 1939.
Works, he would start his independent concrete canopy meandering through the
practice in 1935 with the commission to campus [412] was interspersed with exotic
design the Museo de Bellas Artes for Los gardens, which were enriched by free- Venezuelan Pavilion that he designed was Tomás José Sanabria, who designed
Caobos, Caracas. He followed this work standing sculptures and wall reliefs created for Expo ’67 in Montreal. It consisted of the Hotel Humboldt (1956), located at
in 1939 with the design of the somewhat by distinguished artists of the international three interconnected, double-height cubes the top of the Ávila mountain range that
Art Deco Gran Colombia School [410], modernist avant garde, such as Henri fabricated out of welded-steel sheet, each separates Caracas from the sea and linked
built in Santa Teresa. In 1942 he won the Laurens, Fernand Léger, Jean Arp, Victor one painted in a different colour – yellow, by cable car to the downtown of the city.
competition for an inexpensive, medium- Vasarely and Antoine Pevsner. blue or red – of the Venezuelan national The exceptionally sensitive Jesús Tenreiro-
rise housing scheme in the newly emergent Villanueva’s lifelong commitment flag. Each cube was designed to exhibit an Degwitz was the first Venezuelan architect
central district of Caracas, known as El to abstract art was also evident in the aspect of contemporary Venezuelan culture. to make a name for himself outside the
Silencio. This rambling neighbourhood unit While the first displayed a four-screen capital with his headquarters for the CVG
409 Domínguez, Centro Simón Bolívar, Caracas,
was a hybrid work, the front being rendered 1949–57. Elevation. documentary dedicated to the history of the electrical company [413], built in the boom
in a muted Spanish colonial manner, while country, the second contained a ‘rainforest’ town of Guayana in 1968. This exceptional
the rear comprised an array of stacked sculpture designed by the Venezuelan work took the form of a dematerialized
terraces in reinforced concrete. In 1957 he artist Jesús Rafael Soto. This was a maze pyramid made up of thin brick panels
was commissioned to design two large of plastic cables hanging from the ceiling held in place by an equally delicate steel
high-rise, low-cost housing schemes on through which visitors had to weave their frame. These panels served as brises-
the outskirts of the city. These were made way in order to arrive at the third and final soleil shielding the stacked office floors
up of free-standing slab blocks of different cube, which contained a bar musicale where within from the sun. With characteristic
heights set on undulating ground, the most musicians played Venezuelan folk music. melancholy Degwitz remarked:
significant of which was the 23 de Enero Another important architect at work
estate, commemorating the date of the 1958 in Caracas during the 1950s was Cipriano The site is the highest point in Ciudad
coup d’etat, designed in association with Domínguez, who designed the monumental Guayana, and it was barren, with nothing built
José Manuel Mijares. twin towers of the Centro Simón Bolívar around it. There was no city plan establishing
Villanueva’s ultimate masterwork was [409], situated at the head of the urban limitations on height or bulk. The CVG
the University City of Caracas, built on axis devised in 1939 by the French planner architects requested something like a landmark,
the fringes of the city, the master plan of Maurice Rotival. An equally prominent and the pyramid came forth as a natural form
which was first outlined in 1944. This plan architect who left his mark on the city for human beings living in a difficult tropical
411 Calder, acoustical artwork in the Aula Magna, University City of Caracas, 1944.
412 Villanueva, University City of Caracas, 1944. Plan of covered walkways.
climate … The stepped pyramid allows for the The ultimate manifestation of Degwitz’s
interaction of inner and outer space through architectural maturity was the city hall of
a façade of continuous balconies with shaded Barquisimeto [414], of 1967. Perhaps the
gardens, a beautiful sight that is visible from most remarkable aspect of this work is the
almost all the working areas inside. It was to geometrical rationality of the in-situ concrete
be the first building in the future centre of Alta walls by which the building is organized in
Vista, the heart of the new city, so it had the a manner reminiscent of the rhythmic order
character of a foundation stone for an imagined to be found in the work of Louis Kahn.
beautiful metropolis – one that ultimately never A tectonic and spatial probity of an
came to be.1 entirely different kind would appear much
417, 418 Bonet, Berlingieri House, Maldonado, Uruguay, 1947. View (top left) and detail of vault to wall connection
(bottom left).
419, 420 Testa, Bank of London and South America, Buenos Aires, 1966. Section (top right) and sketch of section
(bottom right).
structural ceiling of the hall. Although Testa three other architects. The covered walkway
continued to practise both as an architect leading into this Corbusian building
and an artist throughout his life, he would was made out of cantilevered reinforced-
never equal the tectonic tour de force of the concrete parasols like those structures for
Bank of London and South America, except shelter projected by Amancio Williams in
for the National Library in Buenos Aires, an audacious proposal for a hospital in
designed in association with Francisco Corrientes dating from 1953. Similar concrete
Bullrich and Alicia Cazzaniga in 1962 but not parasols appeared as a repetitive canopy
completed until 1992. element in an aborted megastructural
Testa had first come to the fore in 1955 project for the University of Tucumán
with his winning entry for the civic centre designed by a team of architects under the
for Santa Rosa de la Pampa, designed with leadership of Horacio Caminos.
in brick having a similar form to the in 1968 out of the same brick and reinforced-
reinforced-concrete shell structures built concrete technique that he had already
in Mexico by the Spanish émigré engineer applied to his larger structures. One of the
Félix Candela. The latter had, in turn, been most significant works of his late career is
strongly influenced by the distinguished the parish centre of San Juan de Ávila built
Spanish engineer Eduardo Torroja, whose in Alcalá de Henares, Spain, in 1998, where
masterwork was the Madrid hippodrome of the double-curved walls forming the sides
1941. These two exemplary figures prompted of the ecclesiastical volume undulate more
Dieste to design wide-span, doubly curved dynamically than before in relation to the
brick warehouses and factories, and above vaults of the roof.
all the dynamic monumental form of the It is indicative of the stature of Dieste
Church of Christ the Worker [431, 432], built that he published a book on his work in 1987
at Atlántida in 1960. Rendering both the divided into three sections: a photographic
continuous sidewalls and roof in undulating and graphic record of his built work; a
reinforced brickwork, Dieste created a detailed presentation of the calculations
non-hierarchical space in this church, involved in the design of the brick vaults;
bringing the priest closer to the people. This and a political manifesto testifying to the
anticipated the changes in the liturgical form economic, ecological and human advantages
of the Roman Catholic Church that followed in an underdeveloped country such as
the Second Vatican Council of 1963, which Uruguay of building in brick, rather than with
effectively orientated the priest towards the the more advanced and expensive modes of
congregation rather than the altar. building in steel and reinforced concrete.
What is truly remarkable about Dieste’s
work is the way in which his most civic
433 Dieste,
two typical shell structures: (a) Don Bosco
structures came to be realized quite early in School Gymnasium, Montevideo, 1983–84; (b) Bus
his career, not only the church at Atlántida, Terminal, Salto, 1973–74.
but also the church of San Pedro at Durazno
(1974). However, his reputation as a master
builder depends in the final analysis on the
numerous industrial structures [433] that
he designed as a series of reinforced brick,
curved and doubly curved vaulted forms,
beginning with a market hall in Porto
Alegre, Brazil, of 1972 and continuing with
a bus depot at Salto in 1974, warehouses in
Montevideo and Juanicó built between 1976
and 1994, and maintenance sheds for the
Brazilian railways at Rio de Janeiro in 1979.
Dieste built a remarkable house for himself
Like many other Latin American countries, Institute of Peru. Belaúnde eventually
Peru had no modern architectural culture started on a political career in 1944 by
before 1910, when an émigré Polish joining the National Democratic Front.
architect, Ricardo de Jaxa Malachowski, In 1956 he founded the Acción Popular
who had been trained at the Ecole des (Popular Action) Party, which, among other
Beaux-Arts in Paris, was invited to establish things, aimed at recapturing the Inca
a department of architecture in the traditions of community and cooperation
National University of Engineering. The while occupying the middle ground
modernization of Peruvian society was between the traditional right-wing oligarchy
a relatively slow process, for only after and the radical left. When Belaúnde was
the end of the Second World War was a first elected to the Peruvian Congress in
centre-left government voted into power 1945 he introduced legislation expanding Luis Sert to lecture in the school during Aldo van Eyck (The Netherlands), Atelier 5
under the presidency of José Bustamante the role of the state in the production the 1950s. (Switzerland), Charles Correa (India),
y Rivero. The liberal policies of the of social housing. This eventually led to In 1960 the British architect Peter Land Toivo Korhonen (Finland), Herbert Ohl
Bustamante presidency came to an abrupt the creation of the Corporación Nacional came to Lima to work for two years as (Germany), and Fumihiko Maki, Kisho
end in 1948 with a right-wing military coup de Vivienda (CNV), the first completed the field director of an inter-American,
435 de Ozoño and de Castro, PREVI Housing, Lima,
led by General Manuel Odría, although project of which was 1,200 apartments multidisciplinary graduate programme in 1969–74.
subsequently it was a left-wing military built as the Unidad Vecinal Número 3 urban and regional planning sponsored
government under the leadership of Juan (UV3). These units were designed by a team by the Peruvian government and the
Velasco Alvarado (president from 1968 to of young architects comprising Alfredo Organization of American States (OAS).
1975) that finally brought about land reform Dammert, Carlos Morales, Manuel Valega, The immediate success of this programme
in Peru. Luis Dorich, Eugenio Montagne and Juan encouraged Belaúnde to establish a
In 1936 Fernando Belaúnde Terry Benites. The work was eventually integrated department of urban planning under
returned to Peru, his family having been into Belaúnde’s plan for Lima. The CNV Land’s direction within the school. In 1966
exiled since 1924 on political grounds. continued to function through various Belaúnde took a further proactive step by
After attending high school in France, periods of military rule, realizing several inviting Land to organize an international
Belaúnde moved in 1930 with his family unidades vecinales, although its name was low-rise, high-density housing exhibition,
to the United States, where he began to frequently changed. Apart from his salient known as PREVI. Land conceived this
study architecture, first at the University of engagement with the provision of low-cost exhibition along the lines of the Deutscher
Miami and then at the University of Texas housing, Belaúnde was also involved in the Werkbund Weissenhofsiedlung housing
at Austin. Back in Peru in 1937, he founded upgrading of the department of architecture exhibition staged in Stuttgart of 1927.
the magazine El Arquitecto Peruano, which in the National University of Engineering, Carried out under the auspices of the United
focused on the specific housing and which he conceived along the lines of the Nations, PREVI involved contributions
urban problems facing the country. This Bauhaus. This led him to hire a progressive from architects worldwide, including James
publication coincided with the foundation teaching staff, which included Peruvian Stirling (UK), Germán Samper (Colombia),
of two key institutions: the Peruvian teachers as well as émigré European talent. Candilis, Josic & Woods (France), Oskar
Architectural Association and the Urban Belaúnde invited Walter Gropius and José Hansen (Poland), Inguez/Vasquez (Spain),
436 Garland, Correa, Griñan and Agurto, Palomino Housing, Lima, 1964.
437 Mazuré, Nash and Miguel Cruchaga Belaúnde, social housing, Callao, 1974.
Peru 425
Chile
448 Cruz, with the Valparaíso School, Palace of Dawn and Dusk, Ritoque, Quintero, 1982.
that Klotz built on spectacular sites over for Madrid following the military coup.
the next decade, one of the most elegantly Fernández Larrañaga remained in Spain
expressive is his Reutter House of 1998 [454], until 1980, when he returned to enter the
on a site descending to the sea at Cantagua. Santiago office of Mario Pérez de Arce, for
As in the work of the Brazilian practice whom he worked for the next nine years.
MMBB this house is approached from above At the beginning of the 1990s he began
456 delSol, Hotel Remota, Puerto Natales, 2008.
via a light-weight steel passerelle. Apart to give courses at his alma mater in both 457 Fernández, Radic, Puga and Mardones, Library at Lo
from the dynamic spatial organization, architecture and landscape design. He Contador, Santiago, 1997.
458 Ovalle, Adolfo Ibáñez University Graduate Centre,
the plastic qualities of this house derives also competed successfully in a series of Santiago, 2007.
from a dramatic interplay between the competitions for the design of a number of
different forms of revetment, ranging from important buildings and parks within the
horizontal timber cladding to ribbed metal city. As a result he opened his own office in of this architect may be judged from the
sheets, timber louvres, steel windows and 1997, when he collaborated with Cecilia Puga constant dialectic in his work between
thin steel balustrading. Klotz eventually and Smiljan Radic on the design of a semi- tectonic and topographic form.
complemented his domestic work with a subterranean addition to the university An eccentrically subtle brand of Post-
number of Neo-Rationalist public buildings, library in the Lo Contador campus of the Modernism emerged in Chile with the
including the Altamira School, Santiago Pontifical Catholic University [457]. In Chilean Pavilion designed for the Seville
(2000), and the Economics Faculty and the addition to occasional domestic work and Expo of 1992 by José Cruz Ovalle and
Library of the Diego Portales University, landscape design, Fernández Larrañaga Germán del Sol. The organic form of this
dating from 2006 and 2012 respectively. received a series of university commissions, building, lined in wood and covered with
A distinguished Chilean architect beginning with an elegant chapel designed copper, was designed to house the totally
and landscape architect of a slightly in 1997 for the San Joaquín campus of the improbable exhibit of an 85-ton artificial
earlier generation is Teodoro Fernández Catholic University, Santiago [455]. He Antarctic iceberg, which the critic Jorge
Larrañaga, who, after graduating from the followed this at the millennium with a new Francisco Liernur would associate with the
department of architecture of the Catholic communications faculty and a library for countrywide campaign of 1988 that voted
University in Santiago in 1972, left Chile the same campus. The exceptional range Pinochet out of the presidency, if not exactly
25quartet
quartet
quartet
25
25
The vast span of this geographical domain and realized by Le Corbusier, along with his
can perhaps only be fully appreciated if one patronage of a rising generation of Indian
recognizes that it takes up three volumes architects who are prominently featured
within the ten-volume survey entitled here, namely Achyut Kanvinde, Charles
World Architecture 1900–2000: A Critical Correa, Balkrishna Doshi and Raj Rewal.
Mosaic, which was published by the China These talented professionals were followed
Architecture and Building Press at the by the equally gifted representatives of the
millennium. The territory covered in this post-Nehru generation, such as Bijoy Jain,
account begins with the development of Sanjay Mohe and Rahul Mehrotra.
modern architecture in South Asia after The more varied developments in the
the declaration of Indian independence in other nations that make up the South Asia
1947, together with the partitioning of the subcontinent –Pakistan, Bangladesh and
former colony into India, with its largely Sri Lanka – are in part due to the absence
Hindu population, and the predominantly of a comparable modernizing vision of the
Muslim societies of East Pakistan and West same power and conviction as that of Nehru.
Pakistan, later to become Bangladesh. Nevertheless, in the case of Bangladesh,
Modern architecture in India was largely we have to nevertheless acknowledge the
championed by the charismatic first prime equally exceptional leadership of the master
minister of the country, Jawaharlal Nehru, architect Muzharul Islam, who was not
who, having received an elite British only a sensitive architect in his own right,
education, returned to India in 1912 to but also the primary inspiration for the
become the leader of the left wing of the successive generation of Bengali architects,
Indian National Congress. Thereafter, Nehru such as Kashef Chowdhury, Marina
remained committed to the development of Tabassum and Rafiq Azam. Similarly, the
India as a secular, multi-faith, independent leading Sinhalese architects who emerged
nation state. The implementation of this in the 1950s, Minnette de Silva and Geoffrey
vision caused him to become a patron Bawa, would make seminal contributions
of modern architecture, which he saw as to the architectural culture and identity
being capable of both embodying and of Ceylon prior to its declaration of
representing the Indian modern project. At independence in 1972 and its transformation
the same time he was interested in a modern into the independent state of Sri Lanka.
manner of building that was not only The development of a similarly inflected
appropriate to the monsoon climate, but modern architectural culture came into
was also enriched by the cultural legacies being much later in China, partly because
of the Hindu and Mughal traditions. This of its relatively undeveloped state prior
led to his unequivocal support for the new to the Second World War and then the
Punjabi capital of Chandigarh, designed subsequent civil war, culminating in the
469
triumph of the Communist Revolution Malaysia and Philippines, in a relatively Korea has had a time-honoured role of
in 1949. Despite the pioneering efforts of peaceful manner, while others only after tragic acting as a conduit for the introduction of
the architect and scholar Liang Sicheng and brutal struggles. Vietnam, Laos and Chinese civilization into Japan, but was also
in the late 1930s and 1940s to survey and Cambodia were the unfortunate victims of the first Asian country to be annexed by
document traditional Chinese architecture, the cold war. These countries were to witness Japan as early as 1910. Half a century later
and his subsequent attempts to dissuade half a century of great turmoil and ideological Korea became the site of a bitter conflict
Mao Zedong from following the Socialist divisions. They have been engulfed by an lasting from 1950 to 1953 between the
Realism of the Soviet line in architecture, extremely bloody form of warfare Communist government of North Korea,
it proved impossible to overcome the and destruction.1 under Soviet influence, and the American-
cultural hard line of the party. Given the aligned South Korea. This war culminated
reductive nature of capitalist development, This traumatic experience, along with the in an uneasy peace, with the stalemate of
it is ironic that the cultivation of a modern fact that large parts of South East Asia have a demilitarized zone separating North and
architecture in China ultimately stems from since time immemorial been water-based South Korea along the 38th parallel north.
Deng Xiaoping’s opening up of the country societies, has made it extremely difficult for This continental trajectory concludes
to trade with the West in 1983. Immediately South East Asia to evolve and sustain a truly with two independent nations that
after this Western corporate practices arrived compelling culture of modern architecture. throughout the first half of the 19th century
in China en masse to design and build one Within this context Japan stands out represented the most remote extent of the
spectacular building after another, while as a civilization that was able to transform British Empire, namely Australia and New
the central committee of the Chinese itself in the space of half a century from a Zealand. The first significant architectural
government pursued a policy of rapid large- feudal society into a modernized, quasi- intervention in the largely barren expanse
scale urbanization, ultimately leading to an industrialized nation state, capable, as it of the former was the foundation of the
environmentally unsustainable, maximizing happened, of overwhelming the Russian Australian capital of Canberra in 1912,
pattern of urban development virtually imperial fleet in a single encounter during designed by the American architects Marion
bereft of any redeeming features. This the Russo-Japanese War of 1905, thereby Mahony and Walter Burley Griffin. While
policy has since been drastically changed paving the way for its emergence as an East these same architects came up with a proto-
as much more attention is now being paid Asian colonizing power. After occupying modern architecture for Australia as early
to the resuscitation of rural China, with Manchuria in northeast Asia in 1931, Japan as 1917, a general culture of modernism did
the restoration and economic expansion of launched the idea of its so-called Greater not begin to evolve there until the 1950s,
traditional settlements and villages. One East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere, a concept when it emerged out of the domestic work of
of the consequences of this has been the created and promulgated for Asian territories such architects as Peter Muller, Ken Woolley,
emergence of a new generation of Chinese that it occupied, which would further amplify Robin Boyd and Harry Seidler. A similar
architects who have come to the fore by its imperial ambitions and bring it into bitter delayed effect also occurred in New Zealand;
designing and building exceptionally conflict not only with China but also more a rigorous modern architecture appeared
sensitive and appropriate works in remote problematically, after Pearl Harbor, with the for the first time in 1940 with the work of the
parts of the country. United States. In 1945 Japanese expansionism émigré Austrian architect Ernst Plischke.
A generalizable modern architectural ended with the country being the involuntary
culture has yet to emerge in South East testing ground for the first use of the atomic
Asia. For most of the countries making up bomb. The post-war reconstruction of
the labyrinthic complexity of this region, Japan enabled it to play a leading role in the
including even the authoritarian welfare development of modern architecture, which
state of Singapore, the cultivation of a accounts for its inclusion in Part III of this
sophisticated culture of architecture has history. However, this section features the
proven elusive. Part of the reason for this work of two Japanese architects who belong
has been the war-torn nature of the region, to quite different generations: Fumihiko
as the Singaporean master architect William Maki and the much younger Kengo Kuma.
Lim has written: The first is celebrated in this overview for the
vitality and refinement of his practice while
In the decades after World War II, the states the second is acknowledged for the particular
of South Asia became independent after the way in which he integrates traditional
departure of colonial powers – some like Japanese crafts into his architecture.
After the departure of the British in 1947, large space of the mosque, attended by four
India had the fortune of being inspired by equally abstract minarets.
Nehru’s modernizing, democratic vision, in Until the establishment of a department
which modern architecture was destined of architecture in West Pakistan University
to play a seminal role. Pakistan, however, of Engineering and Technology, Lahore,
had its latent modernizing drive tempered in 1965, Pakistan’s architects were mostly
by a military government that until the trained outside the country, either in the
early 21st century kept itself in power from United Kingdom or United States. Among
one generation to the next. A decade after these foreign-trained architects were Habib
partition, in 1958, the military leader of Fida Ali and Yasmeen Lari. One of the finest
the time, Ayub Khan, decided to shift the works of Fida Ali’s initial career was the
capital from Karachi to Rawalpindi, where Burmah-Shell oil company headquarters
the state would create adjacent to it the in Karachi, won in competition in 1973
totally new city of Islamabad on a gridiron and subsequently carefully developed and
plan prepared by the international planning detailed, although not finally completed
consultancy Doxiadis Associates, based in until 1978 [532]. Removed from the dramatic
Athens. A number of other foreign architects character of Fida Ali’s early work, Yasmeen
were involved in the design of Islamabad, Lari’s architecture was equally finely detailed
most notably the American architect as is evident from the houses that she built
Edward Durell Stone, whose pyramidal in the 1970s, including the Commodore Haq
presidential complex in the centre of the house and her own house, both in Karachi.
plan is the most successful monumental Perhaps her most sensitive work to date has
work of his career. Stone’s presidential been the Anguri Bagh housing in Lahore,
residence dominates the principal axis of which, save for its underlying concrete
the main square with the Assembly and superstructure, is faced entirely in brick in
Foreign Office set at either end of the cross- much the same spirit as Ray Rewal’s Asian
axis. In the development of this work Stone Games Village housing, New Delhi (1980–82).
persuaded Ayub Khan to avoid any literal Four other architects played key roles
evocation of Mughal architecture, and a in the initial development of Pakistan’s
similar, somewhat secular interpretation modern architecture: the locally trained
seems to have led to the selection of the Nayyar Ali Dada, who began his career by designing and realizing the monumental Corbusian complex for Karachi University;
Turkish architect Vedat Dalokay for his Shakir Ali Auditorium in the National and finally the American practice of Payette
entry to the 1970 international competition College of Art in Lahore; the American Associates, which designed the 700-bed Aga
for the design of the Shah Faisal national William Perry, who designed the precisely Khan University Hospital in Karachi, under
532 Dalokay, Shah Faisal Mosque, Islamabad,
mosque in Islamabad [532]. This highly 1970–86.
detailed Business Administration Institute construction from the mid-1970s to 1985.
refined, largely abstract work features four 533 Fida Ali, Pakistan Burmah-Shell in Karachi; the ubiquitous French architect This treatment centre and medical school
inclined concrete roof plates covering the Headquarters, Karachi, 1973–78. Michel Écochard, who designed a Neo- has since been greatly expanded.
The leading architect of the post- some 250 kilometres north of Dhaka. The
independence generation in Bangladesh mosque, built amid rice paddies, consists
was Muzharul Islam, who, after the 1971 of a single-storey concrete structure with
war of liberation, played a major role in a double square plan divided between an
devising a modern architecture that would open-air forecourt and a domed prayer
be appropriate to the heavy monsoon hall. In contrast, the Friendship Centre is
climate of Bengal [534]. Throughout his a single-storey, grass-covered, load-bearing
life Islam served intermittently as an brick matrix, constructed as a labyrinth of
architectural adviser to the government, and rooms interspersed with courts and rain-
this eventually led to the appointment of harvesting tanks. Everywhere in the Bengal
Louis Kahn as the architect of the national Delta, water is both a precious resource
assembly building, the Sher-e-Bangla Nagar and a threat. Thus, in addition to the flood
[535], finally completed in Dhaka in 1963. protection – an earthen berm surrounding
Through his Chetana research group, Islam the orthogonal complex – it was necessary
combined architectural discourse with the to implement an elaborate network of water
cultural aspirations of the 19th-century mains, service runs and septic tanks in order
Bengal Renaissance, as personified by the to ensure that floodwater would not mix
writer, musician and artist Rabindranath with sewage during the monsoon season.
Tagore, to which Islam added a left-wing Tabassum’s Bait Ur Rouf Mosque [538,
critical sensibility appropriate to his epoch. 539], completed in 2013 at Faidabad Uttara, in
Among the current generation of the northern extension of Dhaka, is equally
Bengali architects to inherit this legacy Kahnian both in its intrinsic geometry and
was the partnership of Kashef Mahboob the load-bearing brickwork out of which it
Chowdhury and Marina Tabassum, who is largely built. The form of this diminutive
began their joint career by winning the 1997 mosque – 75 feet (22.8 metres) long on
national competition for the Independence each side of its square plan and 25 feet
Monument and the Liberation War
Museum, a work which, after many delays,
534 Islam, architect’s residence, Dhaka, 1969.
was finally completed to their designs in Section.
the Suhrawardy Udyan in Dhaka in 2013.
Following the dissolution of this husband-
and-wife partnership at the millennium,
Chowdhury designed and built two
outstanding works: the Chandgaon Mosque
in Chittagong (2005) and a training facility 535 Kahn, National Assembly Building, Sher-e-Bangla Nagar, Dhaka, 1963.
known as the Friendship Centre [536, 536 Chowdhury, Friendship Centre, Gaibandha, 2011.
537], built on a flood plain at Gaibandha 537 Chowdhury, Friendship Centre, Gaibandha, 2011. Section.
0 1m 5m
GROUND FLOOR PLAN
3m 15m
540 Azam, project for the Bangladesh Chancery complex, Islamabad, 2015. Rendering.
In Sri Lanka, formerly known as Ceylon, deceptively presenting the hotel as a quasi-
the most talented exponent of what is now ruin about to be consumed by the exuberant
known as vernacular modernism was the tropical jungle of its hilltop site.
native-born, British-educated Geoffrey A more recent regionally sensitive work
Bawa, who first came to public notice with in Sri Lanka is the British High Commission
his wood-framed, pitched-roof Bentota [542] built in Colombo to the designs of the
Beach Hotel of 1969. In the evolution of his Edinburgh-based architect Richard Murphy.
idiosyncratic regional manner Bawa would This work is not only passively responsive to
be influenced by two seminal figures: the climate, but also sensitively contextual
first, the Sri Lankan architect Minnette de by virtue of its use of native kalugal stone,
Silva, who had studied at the Architectural local terracotta tiles and coconut timber
Association School in London and who in panels. Equally local in character is its
1948 became the first Asian female member orthogonal organization around water
of the RIBA; and, second, by the émigré courts and fountain pools, which contribute
Danish architect Ulrik Plesner, who would to the building’s natural ventilation and
work closely with Bawa during the first cooling. This process is augmented by
half of the 1960s. As much esteemed for his glass skylights set over the central access
landscape design as for his architecture, corridors, which act as thermal chimneys,
Bawa would begin work in 1948 on his venting hot air out of the offices they serve.
country estate of Lunuganga, his landscape Among a rising generation of young
masterwork, which occupied much of the Sri Lankan architects working within the
rest of his life. distinctly local modern tradition initiated
Bawa’s luxurious tropical manner was by Geoffrey Bawa are such figures as
elevated to monumental status with his Sri Hirante Welandawe, Channa Daswatte,
Lankan Parliament complex [541], built on Amila de Mel, Palinda Kannangara and
a small island in the middle of an artificial above all, perhaps, the practice of Team
lake at Sri Jayawardenepura, Kotte, in 1982. Architrave. Team Architrave’s elegant, steel-
He followed this government commission framed, six-storey office building, designed
with a plan for a new university at Matara, and realized in 2017 in the midst of
under continuous development from 1980 to Colombo’s chaotic downtown, is a welcome
1988. The green wall of vegetation covering realistic ‘green’ oasis.
the exposed frame of the Kandalama Hotel
at Dambulla is one of his most significant
later works. Completed towards the end of
his life, it not only embodies the sense of
tropical luxus for which he was renowned 541 Bawa, Parliament Complex, Colombo, 1982.
but is also a kind of ecological tour de force 542 Murphy, British High Commission, Colombo, 2008.
1. Classroom 9. Gym
2017. 4. Laboratory
5. Library
12. Bamboo Garden
13. Car Parking
SECTION
552 6.OPEN
Corridor
Architecture,
14. Garden Garden School, Beijing,
7. Student Cafeteria
2017.
15. Farm
8. Faculty Cafeteria 16. Pond
While Maki’s concept was as much indebted Maki’s highly refined tectonic approach
to Team X as to Japanese Metabolism, his moved him in two different but
distinctive approach towards the aggregation complementary directions: first, towards
of urban form came from his formative taut orthogonal volumes, clad with thin
experience in the Graduate School of Design metal skins that dematerialize at their
(GSD) at Harvard University. Between 1954 extremities into paper-thin louvres and
and 1968 he was influenced by José Luis Sert, perforated translucent screens, as in his
as is evident from the slowly aggregated civic Tepia Pavilion, Tokyo, of 1990; and, second,
form of Maki’s Hillside Terrace apartments, towards light-weight engineering forms that
Tokyo, on which he worked for over two display an affinity for the European Gothic
decades with the same developer, from 1969 tradition. An architect with an equally
to 1992. Predicated on Tange’s National dematerializing approach at a monumental
Olympic Stadium of 1964, Maki’s smaller scale is Yoshio Taniguchi, most particularly
Fujisawa Municipal Gymnasium, Tokyo in his Tokyo Kasai Rinkai Park Visitors’
[564], of 1986 was, in effect, a confirmation of Centre [565] and his exceptionally
the same heroic engineering tradition, only monumental Toyota Municipal Museum of
executed this time as a light-weight steel Art, both of 1995.
structure with stainless-steel cladding in The most prominent Japanese architect
order to achieve an economic shell form. As of virtually the same generation has
Serge Lalat informs us: unquestionably been Tadao Ando, whose
excursion into landscaped pieces in the
The great vault of the roof has an unsupported 1980s was evidently among some of the
span of 80 meters (262 feet). It is made up of finest civic works built anywhere in the
a network of steel H-girders which support decade, above all his Chapel-on-the-Water at
565 Taniguchi, Tokyo Kasai Rinkai Park Visitors’ Centre, Tokyo, 1995.
566 Maki, Republic Polytechnic Campus, Singapore, 2007.
558 Europe
670 Consuegra, telecommunications tower, Cádiz, 1993.
Elevation.
671 Paredes Pedrosa, Ceuta Public Library, 2007–14.
672 Consuegra, Social Housing Ramón y Cajal, Seville,
1983–87.
Any appraisal of the evolution of modern the Department of Electrical and Computer
architecture in Portugal has to acknowledge Engineering built for the University of
the didactic and creative contribution Coimbra in 1991. The most sculptural aspect
of Fernando Távora, who, together with of Byrne’s career to date has been the
Carlos Ramos, was the prime mover of maritime control tower that he designed for
the reformation of the Porto School of the port of Lisbon in 2001 [678].
architecture throughout the 1950s. Távora’s Carrilho da Graça’s career began with 678 Byrne, Torre APL, Lisbon, 2001.
lifelong preoccupation was to combine the a hilltop swimming pool, designed with
functionality of the Modern Movement Carlos Miguel Dias for Campo Maior in and then with an archaeological museum city. Hyper-aware that the traditional school
with the equally reasonable, but less 1990 [679]. Thereafter he assumed a more completed in Lisbon the same year [680]. is now rapidly evolving under the impact
abstract, rationality of vernacular culture, minimalist approach than that of Byrne, The latter is typical of the architect’s of digital technology, the municipality
an ambition that he perhaps came closest first with a theatre and concert hall that penchant for superimposing circulation elected to build four new schools, designed
to realizing in the pousada (hotel) [677] that he designed in Poitiers, France, in 2008 on top of an archaeological site so as to by the émigré architect Claudio Sat [683,
he added in 1984 to the 18th-century Santa focus the visitor’s attention on the stone 684], instead of upgrading or replacing
677 Távora, Santa Marinha da Costa Convent hotel
Marinha da Costa Convent in Guimarães. addition, Guimarães, 1975–84. foundations that remain. The seemingly
679 Carrilho da Graça, Municipal Swimming Pool,
Although the Porto School has largely thick walls of this design are built up out Campo Maior, 1990.
shaped the perception of Portuguese of corten-steel plates and are covered with
architecture over the past forty years, a translucent glass roofs.
number of other architects across the An atypical work equally removed from
country also accomplished significant works both Porto and Lisbon is the Paula Rego
in the same period, above all the practices of Museum built in Cascais between 2005 and
the Lisbon-based architects Gonçalo Byrne 2009 to the designs of Eduardo Souto de
and João Luís Carrilho da Graça. Starting Moura [681, 682]. This building, housing
within a decade of each other, they both the work of Rego, establishes its unique
established the lines of their respective architectural presence through two shell
practices early in their careers, with the first concrete volumes superimposed in each
largely focused on the design of university instance over square plans, respectively
campuses and the second orientated housing a library and a café. The in situ
towards museological commissions. Byrne’s concrete of these forms is dyed red in
career began with a continuous six- to eight- contrast to the lawn and trees onto which
storey housing complex built in the relatively the building opens.
low-rise Chelas district of Lisbon from 1972 One of the little-acknowledged
to 1974. However, Byrne came into his own Portuguese achievements in the 21st century
as a civic architect with the faculty buildings are the new schools designed and realized
that he designed for the universities of for the municipality of Óbidos between 1989
Oeiras and Coimbra over the years 1988–96; and 2010, beginning with a school built
one of his finest works from this period is adjacent to a stadium in the centre of the
690 De Carlo, Nuovi Collegi Universitari (University of Urbino), 1956. Plan and section.
It was Otto Wagner who first coined the Rietveld, a free-standing house by Richard
term ‘Modern Movement’ in his book Neutra and a pair of semi-detached houses
Moderne Architektur of 1899. Yet towards by Adolf Loos, which were the last works of
the end of his life he seems to have sensed his life. A key figure in Vienna in the late
the pending denouement of modernity 1920s and early 1930s was Peter Behrens, 718 Ehn,Karl Marx-Hof, Vienna, 1930.
719 Welzenbacher, Heyrovsky House, Thumersbach,
on the eve of the first industrialized war who, after being appointed professor in the
1932.
of 1914–18, as is suggested by the more Vienna Academy of Fine Arts, practised as 720 Welzenbacher, Heyrovsky House, Thumersbach,
measured title, Die Baukunst unserer Zeit, an industrial architect designing factories 1932.
of the fourth edition of his book of 1914. He and warehouses in a manner somewhat
could hardly have foreseen, however, the reminiscent of Erich Mendelsohn.
economic devastation that befell Austria A much younger Austrian figure of After graduating from Clemens sculpture rather than architecture, although
along with the dismantling of the Austro- comparable stature at the time was the Holzmeister’s masterclass in the Vienna its internal spaces were of a liveable size and
Hungarian Empire in 1918, the year of his Tyrolean architect Lois Welzenbacher, Academy of Fine Arts in 1955, Gustav generous proportions. Coop Himmelb(l)au’s
death. As a result, Vienna suffered both whose Heyrovsky House [719, 720] at Peichl became an influential figure on steel construction Blazing Wing, installed in
housing and food shortages, which led to Thumersbach, near Zell am See, of 1932 was the Austrian scene in 1964 by founding the Graz in 1980, was equally artistic. However,
the election of a socialist government under an organic masterwork equal to the finest magazine Bau along with Hans Hollein, the overall Neo-Constructivist line of the
Mayor Jakob Reumann. Under Neumann contemporaneous houses designed by Walter Pichler and Oswald Oberhuber. Graz School, as represented by the work
‘Red Vienna’, as the city was then known, Hans Scharoun. Four years later he won a competition for of Volker Giencke, Helmut Richter and
entered into an extensive programme of Austrian architecture did not easily the design of a group of provincial radio Klaus Kada, would distinguish itself from
building workers’ housing in the form of a recover from the country’s annexation stations [721], which were built between the de-constructivist approach of Coop
loose ‘ring’ of mid-rise perimeter blocks on by the Third Reich in 1938 and from the 1969 and 1984 as five concentrically planned Himmelb(l)au as we first encounter this in
the city fringes. The most monumental of Second World War until the early 1950s, stations in Eisenstadt, Salzburg, Innsbruck, 1986 in the penthouse lawyer’s office that
these developments was the Karl Marx-Hof when Roland Rainer came to the fore Linz and Dornbirn, with Peichl giving each they designed for the top of a classical block
(1926–30), built to the designs of Karl Ehn with his Sports Hall, Vienna, of 1952 one a precisely detailed, machine-like, in Vienna as a cataclysmic concatenation
[718], who had been a pupil of Wagner. and his prefabricated, timber-framed metallic identity. of steel and glass [725]. Nothing could be
Soon after its completion the Karl Marx-Hof Fertighaus Siedlung of 1953. Thereafter Anton Schweighofer was equally more removed from this than Kada’s glass
was besieged by artillery in a show of force Rainer’s practice was largely devoted to committed as Peichl to the invention of new museum at Bärnbach of 1988 or Giencke’s
by the government to repress a workers’ the development of low-rise, high-density building types, hence the stepped format of conservatory for the botanical garden of
rebellion. Despite this violent hiatus the housing as a new universally valid form his Neo-Constructivist orphanage proposed Graz of 1992, where the necessary hothouse
emphasis on social housing reappeared of land settlement appropriate to an for Vienna in 1969 [722]. In retrospect this heating was integrated with the tubular
in the Wiener Werkbundsiedlung of automotive age, as he demonstrated most may be read as a transitional work between metal framing supporting the glass.
1930–32, which, under the direction of the persuasively in his Puchenau housing estate Rainer’s ecological rationalism and the Giencke’s collage-like, multi-material
architect Josef Frank, was modelled on the [723], under continuous development on the emerging anarchic artist–architects of approach to building was distinguishable
Deutscher Werkbund housing exhibition banks of the river Danube between 1963 and the Graz School of architecture of whom from Richter’s maximizing use of glass, as
staged in Stuttgart in 1927. This Viennese 1995. The cultural ecological advantages of the most extreme was Günther Domenig. this is found in the long, entirely glazed
model settlement featured amongst other this approach were fully documented in his The Steinhaus of 1986, designed for his façade of his Brunnerstrasse housing in
works a row of five terrace houses by Gerrit book Livable Environments of 1972. Domenig’s occupation, veered towards Vienna of 1990 or in the large secondary
Note for the fifth edition H.F. Mallgrave, Modern Architectural Theory:
The bibliography for the fifth edition has been A Historical Survey, 1673–1968 (2009)
updated not only to cover the titles upon which M. Tafuri, Architecture and Utopia: Design and
our research was based but also to include related Capitalist Development (1976)
works for the purposes of further reading — Theories and History of Architecture (1980)
and research. — The Sphere and the Labyrinth: Avant-Gardes
and Architecture from Piranesi to the 1970s
Abbreviations (1987)
— and F. Dal Co, Modern Architecture (1979)
AA Architectural Association, London
AAJ Architectural Association Journal
AAQ Architectural Association Quarterly Part I: Cultural Developments and
AB Art Bulletin Predisposing Techniques 1750–1939
AD Architectural Design
AIAJ American Institute of Architects Journal Chapter 1
AMC Architecture, mouvement et continuité Cultural Transformations: Neo-Classical
AR Architectural Review Architecture 1750–1900
A+U Architecture and Urbanism R. Banham, Theory and Design in the First Machine
JAE Journal of Architectural Education Age (1960), esp. chs 1–3
JSAH Journal of the Society of Architectural L. Benevolo, History of Modern Architecture,
Historians I (1971), esp. preface and ch. 1
JW&CI Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld R. Bentmann and M. Muller, ‘The Villa as
Institutes Domination’, 9H, no. 5, 1983, 104–14, and
RIBAJ RIBA Journal no. 7, 1985, 83–104
B. Bergdoll, European Architecture, 1750–1890 (2000)
General D. Brownlee, Friedrich Weinbrenner, Architect
of Karlsruhe (1986)
L. Benevolo, Origins of Modern Town Planning T. Buddensieg, ‘“To build as one will … ”
(1967) Schinkel’s Notions on the Freedom of
— History of Modern Architecture (1971) Building’, Daidalos, 7, 1983, 93–102
F.D.K. Ching, M. Jarzombek and V. Prakash A. Choisy, Histoire de l’architecture (1899)
A Global History of Architecture (2017) L. Dehio, Friedrich Wilhelm IV von Preussen:
F. Dal Co and M. Tafuri, Architettura Ein Baukünstler der Romantik (1961)
contemporanea (1976) P. de la Ruffinière du Prey, John Soane
K. Frampton and A. Simone, A Genealogy of (1982)
Modern Architecture: Comparative Critical B. de Montgolfier, ed., Alexandre-Théodore
Analysis of Built Form (2016) Brongniart (1986)
S. Giedion, Space, Time and Architecture (1941) M. Dennis, Court and Garden: From French Hôtel
— Mechanization Takes Command (1948) to the City of Modern Architecture (1986)
H.-R. Hitchcock, Architecture: Nineteenth and A. Dickens, ‘The Architect and the Workhouse’,
Twentieth Centuries (1958) AR, December 1976, 345–52
643
A. Drexler, ed., The Architecture of the Ecole des — and D. Watkin, Neoclassical and Nineteenth A. Vidler, ‘The Idea of Type: The Transformation M.H. Contal, ‘Vittel 1854–1936. Création d’une
Beaux-Arts (1977) [with essays by R. Chafee, Century Architecture, 2 vols (1987) of the Academic Ideal 1750–1830’, ville thermale’, Vittel 1854–1936 (1982)
N. Levine and D. van Zanten] W. Oechslin, ‘Monotonie von Blondel bis Durand’, Oppositions, 8, Spring 1977 [the same issue W.L. Creese, The Legacy of Raymond Unwin (1967)
P. Duboy, Lequeu: Architectural Enigma (1986) Werk-Archithese, January 1977, 29–33 contains Quatremère de Quincy’s extremely W. Cronon, Nature’s Metropolis: Chicago and the
[definitive study with foreword by Robin A. Oncken, Friedrich Gilly 1772–1800 (repr. 1981) important article on type that appeared in Great West (1991)
Middleton] A. Pérez-Gómez, Architecture and the Crisis of the Encyclopédie Méthodique, III, pt 2, 1825] G. Darley, Villages of Vision (1976)
R.A. Etlin, The Architecture of Death (1984) Science (1983) — The Writing of the Walls: Architectural Theory M. de Solà-Morales, ‘Towards a Definition:
R. Evans, ‘Bentham’s Panopticon: An Incident in J.M. Pérouse de Montclos, Etienne-Louis Boullée in the Late Enlightenment (1987) Analysis of Urban Growth in the Nineteenth
the Social History of Architecture’, AAQ, III, 1728–1799 (1969) — Claude Nicolas Ledoux (1990) Century’, Lotus, 19, June 1978, 28–36
no. 2, April–July 1971, 21–37 N. Pevsner, Academies of Art, Past and Present S. Villari, J.N.L. Durand (1760–1834) Art and J. Fabos, G.T. Milde and V.M. Weinmayr, Frederick
— ‘Regulation and Production’, Lotus, 12, (1940) [unique study of the evolution of Science of Architecture (1990) Law Olmsted, Sr. (1968)
September 1976, 6–14 architectural and design education] D. Watkin, Thomas Hope and the Neo-classical R.M. Fogelson, The Fragmented Metropolis: Los
B. Fortier, ‘Logiques de l’équipement’, AMC, 45, — Studies in Art, Architecture and Design, I (1968) Idea (1968) Angeles 1850–1930 (1967)
May 1978, 80–85 A. Picon, French Architects and Engineers in the Age — C.R. Cockerell (1984) A. Fried and P. Sanders, Socialist Thought (1964)
K.W. Forster, ‘Monument/Memory and the of Enlightenment (1992) — and T. Mellinghoff, German Architecture and [useful for trans. of French utopian socialist
Mortality of Architecture’, Oppositions, J. Posener, ‘Schinkel’s Eclecticism and the the Classical Ideal (1987) texts, Fourier, Saint-Simon, etc.]
Fall 1982, 2–19 Architectural’, AD, November–December 1983 J.F. Geist and K. Kurvens, Das Berliner Miethaus
M. Gallet, Charles de Wailly 1730–1798 (1979) (special issue on Berlin), 33–39 Chapter 2 1740–1862 (1982)
F. Gilly, Friedrich Gilly: Essays on Architecture, H.G. Pundt, Schinkel’s Berlin (1972) Territorial Transformations: Urban Developments A. Grumbach, ‘The Promenades of Paris’,
1796–1799 (1994) G. Riemann, ed., Karl Friedrich Schinkel: Reisen 1800–1909 Oppositions, 8, Spring 1977
E. Gilmore-Holt, From the Classicists to the nach Italien (1979) H. Ballon, The Paris of Henri IV (1991) L. Hilberseimer, R. Anderson and P.V. Aureli,
Impressionists (1966) — Karl Friedrich Schinkel: Reise nach England, H.P. Bartschi, Industrialisierung Metropolisarchitecture and Selected Essays
J. Guadet, Eléments et théorie de l’architecture Schottland und Paris (1986) Eisenbahnschlacten und Städtebau (ETH/GTA (2012)
(1902) A. Rietdorf, Gilly: Wiedergeburt der Architektur 25, Stuttgart, 1983) A.J. Jeffery, ‘A Future for New Lanark’, AR, January
A. Hernandez, ‘J.N.L. Durand’s Architectural (1943) L. Benevolo, The Origins of Modern Town Planning 1975, 19–28
Theory’, Perspecta, 12, 1969 R. Rosenblum, Transformations in Late Eighteenth (1967) S. Kern, The Culture of Time and Space, 1880–1918
W. Herrmann, Laugier and Eighteenth-Century Century Art (1967) — History of Modern Architecture, I (1971), chs 2–5 (1983)
French Theory (1962) A. Rowan, ‘Japelli and Cicogarno’, AR, March — The History of the City (1980) [encyclopaedic J.H. Kunstler, The Rise and Decline of America’s
Q. Hughes, ‘Neo-Classical Ideas and Practice: 1968, 225–28 [on 19th-century Neo-Classical treatment of the history of Western Man-made Landscape (1993)
St George’s Hall, Liverpool’, AAQ, V, no. 2, architecture in Padua, etc.] urbanism] D. Leatherbarrow, ‘Friedrichstadt – A Symbol of
1973, 37–44 J. Rykwert, The First Moderns (1983) F. Borsi and E. Godoli, Vienna 1900 (1986) Toleration’, AD, November–December 1983,
E. Kaufmann, Three Revolutionary Architects, P. Saddy, ‘Henri Labrouste: architecte- — Paris 1900 (1989) 23–31
Boullée, Ledoux and Lequeu (1953) constructeur’, Les Monuments Historiques de C. Boyer, Dreaming of the Rational City: the Myth A. López de Aberasturi, lldefonso Cerdá: la théorie
— Architecture in the Age of Reason (1968) la France, no. 6, 1975, 10–17 of American City Planning (1983) générale de l’urbanisation (1979)
M. Lammert, David Gilly: Ein Baumeister der G. Semper, H.F. Mallgrave and W. Hermann, A. Brauman, Le Familistère de Guise ou les F. Loyer, Paris XIXe. siècle (1981)
deutschen Klassizismus (1981) The Four Elements of Architecture and Other équivalents de la richesse (1976) [Eng. text] — Architecture of the Industrial Age (1982)
K. Lankheit, Der Tempel der Vernunft (1968) Writings (1989) S. Buder, Pullman: An Experiment in Industrial Order H. Meyer and R. Wade, Chicago: Growth of a
N. Leib and F. Hufnagl, Leo von Klenze, Gemälde J. Starobinski, The Invention of Liberty (1964) and Community Planning 1880–1930 (1967) Metropolis (1969)
und Zeichnungen (1979) — The Emblems of Reason (1990) D. Burnham and E.H. Bennett, Plan of Chicago B. Miller, ‘Ildefonso Cerdá’, AAQ, IX, no. 7, 1977,
D.M. Lowe, History of Bourgeois Perception (1982) D. Stroud, The Architecture of Sir John Soane (1961) (1909) 12–22
T.J. McCormick, Charles Louis Clérisseau and the — George Dance, Architect 1741–1825 (1971) Z. Celik, Remaking of Istanbul: Portrait of an N. Pevsner, ‘Early Working Class Housing’, repr.
Genesis of Neoclassicism (1990) W. Szambien, J.N.L. Durand (1984) Ottoman City in the 19th Century (1986) in Studies in Art, Architecture and Design,
H.F. Mallgrave, Gottfried Semper: Architect of the M. Tafuri, Architecture and Utopia: Design and I. Cerdá, ‘A Parliamentary Speech’, AAO, IX, no. 7, II (1968)
19th Century (1996) Capitalist Development (1976) 1977, 23–26 G. Pirrone, Palermo, una capitale (1989)
G. Mezzanotte, ‘Edilizia e politica. Appunti J. Taylor, ‘Charles Fowler: Master of Markets’, AR, F. Choay, L’Urbanisme, utopies et réalités (1965) F. Rella, ll Dispositivo Foucault (1977) [with essays
sull’edilizia dell’ultimo neoclassicismo’, March 1964, 176–82 — The Modern City: Planning in the 19th Century, by M. Cacciari, M. Tafuri and G. Teyssot]
Casabella, 338, July 1968, 42–53 D. Ternois, et al., Soufflot et l’architecture des trans. M. Hugo and G.R. Collins (1969) J.P. Reynolds, ‘Thomas Coglan Horsfall and the
R. Middleton, ‘The Abbé de Cordemoy: The lumières (CNRS/ Paris 1980) [proceedings of a [essential introductory text] Town Planning Movement in England’, Town
Graeco-Gothic Ideal’, JW&CI, 1962, 1963 conference on Soufflot held at the University G. Ciucci, F. Dal Co, M. Manieri-Elia and Planning Review, XXIII, April 1952, 52–60
— ‘Architects as Engineers: The Iron of Lyons in June 1980] M. Tafuri, The American City from the Civil W. Schivelbush, The Railway Journey: The
Reinforcement of Entablatures in 18th- G. Teyssot, Città e utopia nell’illuminismo inglese: War to the New Deal (1980) Industrialization of Time and Space in the 19th
century France’, AA Files, no. 9, Summer 1985, George Dance il giovane (1974) C.C. and G.R. Collins, Camillo Sitte and the Birth Century (1977)
54–64 — ‘John Soane and the Birth of Style’, of Modern City Planning (1965) A. Service, London 1900 (1979)
— ed., The Beaux-Arts and Nineteenth Century Oppositions, 14, 1978, 61–83 G. Collins, ‘Linear Planning throughout the C. Sitte, City Planning According to Artistic
French Architecture (1984) A. Valdenaire, Friedrich Weinbrenner (1919) World’, JSAH, XVIII, October 1959, 74–93 Principles (1965) [trans. of Sitte’s text of 1889]
688 689
3 H.M. Wingler, ‘Johannes Itten and Lyonel Chapter 18 6 A. Kopp, ‘Editorial Favoring Deurbanization 5 C. Cattaneo, ‘The Como Group: Neoplatonism
Feininger: On the Problem of State Care for 1 Le Corbusier, ‘The Lesson of Rome’, in Towards (1930)’, in Town and Revolution; Soviet Architecture and Rational Architecture’, Lotus International,
Intellectuals in the Professions’, in The Bauhaus: a New Architecture, trans. F. Etchells (1946), and City Planning, 1917–1935, trans. T.E. Burton no. 16, September 1977, 90.
Weimar, Dessau, Berlin, Chicago, trans. W. Jabs and 141. (1970), 248.
B. Gilbert (1979), 35. 2 ‘Une Villa de Le Corbusier, 1916’, in L’Esprit 7 N.A. Miliutin, ‘Sotsgorod. The Principles of Chapter 26
4 R. Banham, ‘The Bauhaus’, in Theory and Design Nouveau, nos 4–6, 1968, 692. Planning’, in Sotsgorod. The Problem of Building 1 R. Byron, ‘New Delhi’, The Architectural Review,
in the First Machine Age, 2nd edn (1967), 281. 3 Le Corbusier, ‘Argument’, in Towards a New Socialist Cities, trans. A. Sprague (1974), 66. January 1931.
5 R. Banham, ‘Germany: the Encyclopaedics’, Architecture, trans. F. Etchells (1946), 12. 2 B. Lubetkin, ‘Soviet Architecture, Notes on
in Theory and Design in the First Machine Age, 4 Le Corbusier, Oeuvre complète (1910–1929), Chapter 22 Development from 1932–1955’, Architectural
2nd edn (1967), 313. vol. 1 (1956), 86 [6th edn]. 1 Le Corbusier, ‘Argument’, in Towards a New Association Journal, September–October 1956, 89.
6 C. Schnaidt, ‘My Dismissal from the Bauhaus’, 5 C. Rowe, ‘The Mathematics of the Ideal Villa’, in Architecture, trans. F. Etchells (1946), 14. 3 B. Miller, ‘The Debate over the New
in Hannes Meyer: Buildings, Projects and Writings The Mathematics of the Ideal Villa and Other Essays 2 R. Fishman, Urban Utopias in the Twentieth Architecture’, in Architecture and Politics in
(1965), 105. (1976), 3. Century. Ebenezer Howard, Frank Lloyd Wright and Germany 1918–1945 (1968), 139.
6 Ibid., 12. Le Corbusier (1977), 14. 4 F.F. Lisle, Jr, ‘Chicago’s “Century of Progress”
Chapter 15 7 Le Corbusier, Precisions (1988), 139. Exposition: The Moderne as Democratic, Popular
1 G.F. Hartlaub, ‘Letter to Alfred H. Barr’, The Art 8 C. Schnaidt, ‘Building, 1928’, in Hannes Meyer: Chapter 23 Culture’, Journal of the Society of Architectural
Bulletin, XXII, no. 3, September 1940, 164. Buildings, Projects and Writings (1965), 95. 1 Die Heimstätte, no. 10, 1931. Historians, vol. 31, no. 3, October 1972, 230.
2 Ibid., 163. 9 Le Corbusier, ‘In Defense of Architecture’, 2 F.L. Wright, ‘Style in Industry’, in Modern 5 S. Giedion, Architecture You and Me (1958), 48.
3 S. Lissitzky-Küppers, ‘Proun Room, Great Berlin trans. N. Bray, A. Lessard, A. Levitt and G. Baird, Architecture: Being the Kahn Lectures for 1930
Art Exhibition 1923’, in El Lissitzky. Life, Letters, Oppositions, no. 4, October 1974, 93. (1987), 38. Chapter 27
Texts (1968), 365. 10 Le Corbusier, Precisions (1988), 219. 3 F.L. Wright, An Autobiography (1945), 472. 1 Le Corbusier and P. Jeanneret, ‘Villa de Mme.
4 C. Schnaidt, ‘Project for the Peter’s School, 4 M. Schapiro, ‘Architect’s Utopia’, Partisan H. de Mandrot’, in Oeuvre complète (1929–34),
Basle, 1926’, in Hannes Meyer: Buildings, Projects Chapter 19 Review, vol. 4, no. 4, March 1938, 43. vol. 2 (1935), 59.
and Writings (1965), 17. 1 Le Corbusier, L’Art décoratif d’aujourd’hui 2 Le Corbusier and P. Jeanneret, ‘Petites Maisons:
5 C. Schnaidt, ‘Project for the Palace of the (1925). Chapter 24 1935. Maison aux Mathes (Océan)’, in Oeuvre
League of Nations, Geneva, 1926–27’, in Hannes 2 L. Benevolo, Storia dell’architettura moderna 1 A. Aalto, ‘Architecture in Karelia’, in Sketches, complète (1934–38), vol. 3 (1939), 135.
Meyer: Buildings, Projects and Writings (1965), (1960), 327–31. trans. S. Wrede (1978), 82. 3 Le Corbusier and P. Jeanneret, ‘Petites Maisons:
25. 2 A. Aalto, ‘Finnish Pavilion at the Paris World’s 1935. Une maison de week-end en banlieue de
6 M. Stam, ‘Kollektive Gestaltung’, ABC (1924), 1. Chapter 20 Fair 1937’, in Alvar Aalto, ed. K. Fleig (1963), Paris’, Oeuvre complète (1934–38), vol. 3 (1939),
7 C. Schnaidt, ‘The New World, 1926’, in Hannes 1 P. Carter, ‘Biographical Notes’, in Mies van der 81. 125.
Myer: Buildings, Projects and Writings (1965), 91. Rohe at Work, 3rd edn (1999), 174. 3 A. Aalto, ‘Furniture and Lamps’, in Alvar Aalto, 4 C. Rowe, ‘Neo-“Classicism” and Modern
8 Le Corbusier, ‘The Spectacle of Modern Life’, in 2 P. Johnson, ‘1922: Two Glass Skyscrapers’, in ed. K. Fleig (1975), 199. Architecture II’, in The Mathematics of the Ideal
The Radiant City (1967), 177. Mies van der Rohe, 3rd edn (1978), 187. 4 ‘The Rationalist Utopia: The Humanizing Villa and Other Essays (1976), 94.
9 S. Giedion, ‘The Modern Theatre: Interplay 3 P. Johnson, ‘1927: The Design of Apartment of Architecture’, in Alvar Aalto in his Own
between Actors and Spectators’, in Walter Gropius, Houses’, in Mies van der Rohe, 3rd edn (1978), Words, ed. and annotated by G. Schildt (1997), Chapter 28
Work and Teamwork (1954), 64. 194. 103. 1 P. Johnson, ‘Architecture in the Third Reich’,
10 W. Gropius, ‘Sociological Premises for 4 P. Johnson, ‘1930: The New Era’, in Mies van der 5 ‘The Rationalist Utopia: The Trout and the Horn and Hound, 1933.
the Minimum Dwelling of Urban Industrial Rohe, 3rd edn (1978), 195. Stream’, in Alvar Aalto in his Own Words, ed. and 2 P. Johnson, ‘1950: Address to Illinois Institute
Populations’, in Scope of Total Architecture (1978), annotated by G. Schildt (1997), 108. of Technology’, in Mies van der Rohe, 3rd edn
101. Chapter 21 6 L. Benevolo, ‘Progress in European Architecture (1978), 203.
1 B. Lubetkin, ‘Soviet Architecture: Notes on between 1930 and 1940’, in History of Modern 3 P. Carter, ‘Mies van der Rohe: An Appreciation
Chapter 16 Development from 1917 to 1932’, Architectural Architecture. The Modern Movement, vol. 2 (1971), on the Occasion, This Month, of His
1 J. Anděl, Introduction to the Art of the Avant-Garde Association Journal, May 1956, 262. 616. 75th Birthday’, Architectural Design, 31, no. 3,
in Czechoslovakia 1918–1938 (1993). 2 J. Billington, The Icon and the Axe: an Interpretive March 1961, 108.
History of Russian Culture (1967), 489. Chapter 25 4 C. Rowe, ‘Neo-“Classicism” and Modern
Chapter 17 3 R. Fullop, The Mind and Face of Bolshevism 1 R. Banham, ‘Sant’ Elia and Futurist Architecture II’, in The Mathematics of the Ideal
1 De Stijl, Catalogue 81 (Amsterdam, Stedelijk (1988), 102. Architecture’, in Theory and Design in the First Villa and Other Essays (1976), 149.
Museum, 1951), 10. 4 A. Kopp, ‘1925–1932: New Social Condensers. Machine Age, 2nd edn (1967), 129.
2 J. Baljeu, ‘Towards Plastic Architecture’, in The Stroikom Units’, in Town and Revolution; Soviet 2 Il Gruppo 7, ‘Architecture’, trans. E.R. Shapiro, Chapter 29
Theo van Doesburg (1974), 144. Architecture and City Planning, 1917–1935, trans. Oppositions, no. 6, Fall 1976, 90. 1 E. Fratelli, ‘Louis Kahn’, Zodiac America, no. 8,
3 J. Baljeu, ‘Towards Collective Construction’, T.E. Burton (1970), 141. 3 Ibid. April–June 1892, 17.
in Theo van Doesburg (1974), 147. 5 A. Kopp, ‘1925–1932: New Social Condensers. 4 L. Benevolo, ‘Political Compromise and 2 ‘The Problem of a New Monumentality.
4 J. Baljeu, ‘-□+=R4’, in Theo van Doesburg (1974), The Workers’ Club’, in Town and Revolution; Soviet the Struggle with the Authoritarian Régimes’, Monumentality, by Louis I. Kahn’, in New
149. Architecture and City Planning, 1917–1935, trans. in History of Modern Architecture. The Modern Architecture and City Planning, ed. P. Zucker (1944),
T.E. Burton (1970), 123. Movement, vol. 2 (1971), 574. 578.
Credits
158 Architectural Publishers Artemis 277 Alison and Peter Smithson
160 Photo Timo Christ/Alamy Stock Photo 278 Dept of Planning and Design, City of
172, 173, 174, 175, 176, 177, 178 Architectural Sheffield
Publishers Artemis 279 © Architectural Design
181 © The Frank Lloyd Wright Foundation 280, 281 Alison and Peter Smithson
182 Courtesy Roger Cranshawe 282 Courtesy G. Candilis
183 © The Frank Lloyd Wright Foundation 285 © Architectural Design
185 Photo Hedrich Blessing 286 Archigram
186, 187 © The Frank Lloyd Wright Foundation 287 Buckminster Fuller Archives
191 Swedish Institute, Stockholm 289 Tomio Ohashi
192 Arkkitehti, Helsinki 290 Retoria, Tokyo
194 Gustav Velin, Turku 291 Courtesy Richard Rogers. Photo Martin
1 Chronicle/Alamy Stock Photo 77 Kunstgewerbemuseum, Zürich 197 Museum of Finnish Architecture, Helsinki Charles
2 Photo A. F. Kersting 78 Bildarchiv Foto Marburg 198 Museum of Finnish Architecture, Helsinki. 293 Milton Keynes Development Corporation
3 Bibliothèque Nationale, Paris 84 Roger Sherwood, Modern Housing Prototypes, Photo Welin 294 HfG-Ulm Archives
6 Plate 43 of ‘Altes Museum’ from Karl Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass. and 199 Museum of Finnish Architecture, Helsinki. 297 Courtesy Jahn & Murphy
Friedrich Schinkel, Sammlung Architektonischer London, 1978 Photo E. Mäkinen 298 Photo Tim Street-Porter/OTTO
Entwürfe, Ernst & Korn (Gropius’sche Buch- und 87 Kaiser Wilhelm Museum, Krefeld 200 Heikki Havas, Helsinki 301 E. Stoecklein
Kunsthandlung), 1858 89 Firmenarchiv AEG-Telefunken 208 Country Life 302 Olivier Chaslin
7 Bibliothèque Sainte-Geneviève, by Henri 90 Reproduced by permission of The Architects 210 Photo Fine Art Images/Heritage Images/ Architectenburo Herman
306, 307, 308, 309
Labrouste. Paris, France, 1843 Collaborative Inc. Getty Images Hertzberger
9 Bibliothèque Nationale, Paris 100, 105, 106, 108 Bauhaus-Archiv 213 Bernard Rudofsky 310 John Donat
11 Photo Mas 111 Courtesy Royal Netherlands Embassy 214 Bundesarchiv Koblenz 311 Hedrich Blessing
15 Museum of the City of New York 113 KLM Aerocarto 217 Photo Roger-Viollet 312 Malcolm Lewis
21 Courtesy Fiat 114 Burkhard-Verlag Ernst Heyer, Essen 218 Photo Cervin Robinson 313 Courtesy Foster + Partners, London. Photo
25 Photo A. F. Kersting 117 Bauhaus-Archiv 219 Courtesy Rockefeller Center, Inc. Richard Davies
27, 29 Royal Institute of British Architects, 120 Stadt-und Universitätsbibliothek, Frankfurt 221, 222, 223, 226, 227, 228, 229, 230, 231, 232 314 Courtesy Foster + Partners, London
London 121 Design by Karel Teige. Art Institute of Architectural Publishers Artemis 315 Retoria, Tokyo, Photo W. Fujii
30 Country Life Chicago. Wentworth Greene Field Memorial 233, 234 Museum of Modern Art, New York, 316 Courtesy Michael Graves. Proto Acme
34 Chicago Architectural Photographing Fund (2011.854) The Mies van der Rohe Archives Photo
Company 122 H. Herdeg, Fotostiftung Schweiz, Museum of 236 Architectural Publishers Artemis 318 Studio Hollein
35 Historic American Buildings Survey, photo Architecture and Civil Engineering, Prague 239 Photo Hedrich Blessing 320 Courtesy Rem Koolhaas
Jack E. Boucher, 1965 125, 126 National Museum of Technology, Prague 241 United States Information Office 321 Courtesy Peter Eisenman
36, 38 © The Frank Lloyd Wright Foundation 127 Stedelijk Museum, Amsterdam 242 Tennessee Valley Authority 322 Photo Jean Marie Monthiers, courtesy
39 Henry Fuermann 131 Stedelijk van Abbemuseum, Eindhoven 243 Buckminster Fuller Archives Bernard Tschumi Architects
40, 41 © The Frank Lloyd Wright Foundation 132, 133, 134 Architectural Publishers Artemis 244, 245 Courtesy Philip Johnson 330 IBA, Berlin
43 Chicago Historical Society 137 Roger Sherwood, Modern Housing Prototypes, 246 By permission of the Trustees of the 339, 340 Courtesy Tadao Ando
46 FISA Industrias Gráficas Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass. and University of Pennsylvania (all rights reserved) 342, 343 Courtesy Atelier
47 Kunstgewerbemuseum, Zürich London, 1978 247 Photo Cervin Robinson 344 Photo Alinari/Topfoto
56 © Hamlyn Group, photo Keith Gibson 138, 139 Architectural Publishers Artemis 248, 250, 251 By permission of the Trustees 345 Howe & Lescaze
57 Glasgow School of Art 141 Colin Rowe, The Mathematics of the Ideal of the University of Pennsylvania (all rights 346 Walter Gropius © DACS 2020
58 Heins L. Handsur, Vienna Villa, MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass. 1977 reserved) 347 Marcel Breuer, Alfred Roth, Emil Roth
59 Photo ullstein bild/ullstein bild via Getty 142, 143, 144, 145 Architectural Publishers Artemis 252 Photo Tim Street-Porter 348 Photo ullstein bild via Getty Images
Images 147 © Centre Georges Pompidou, Bibliothèque 253 Architectural Publishers Artemis 349 Walter Gropius © DACS 2020
60 Hessisches Landesmuseum, Darmstadt Kandinsky, fonds Mallet Stevens 254 Redrawn by Stefanos Polyzoides 350 © Ezra Stoller/Esto
64 Bildarchiv der Österreichisch Nationalbank, 148 Courtesy CNAM/Cité de l’architecture et du 255 Courtesy Mrs Dione Neutra 351 Marcel Breuer, Bernard Zehrfuss, Pier Luigi
Vienna patrimoine/Archives d’architecture du Xxe siècle, 256 Architectural Publishers Artemis Nervi
65 Courtesy Atelier © André Lurçat 260, 262 The Architectural Review 352 © Ezra Stoller/Esto
67 Museo Civico, Como 153, 154 © Centre Georges Pompidou, 264 © Architectural Design 353 Walter Gropius © DACS 2020
70, 71, 72, 74 Albertina, Vienna Bibliothèque Kandinsky, fonds Prouvé 265 Antonin Raymond, An Autobiography, 354 Julius Shulman photography archive,
75 Museum Bellerive, Zürich 156 © Auguste Perret, UFSE, SAIF, 2005. Courtesy Charles E. Tuttle Co., Inc., Tokyo, 1973 1936-1997. © J. Paul Getty Trust. Getty Research
76 Archives Henry van de Velde, Bibliothèque CNAM/Cité de l’architecture et du patrimoine/ 267, 269 Retoria, Tokyo Institute, Los Angeles (2004.R.10)
Royal, Brussels Archives d’architecture du Xxe siècle 271 Alison and Peter Smithson 355 Photo © Paul Warchol
696 697
356 courtesy Tod Williams Billie Tsien Architects 389 Photo Raul Garcez Pereira, Archive of 434, 435 Peter Land, The Experimental Housing 473 Photo Juha Ilonen
& Partners Biblioteca da Faculdade de Arquitectura e Project (PREVI), Lima: Design and Technology in a 474 Photo Helena Sandman
357 Photo © Michael Moran/OTTO Urbanismo da Universidad de São Paulo New Neighborhood = El Proyecto Experimental De 475 Shadrach Woods architectural records and
358 Photo © Andy Ryan 390 Photo © Leonardo Finotti Vivienda (PREVI), Lima: diseño y tecnología En Un papers, 1923-2008, Avery Architectural & Fine Arts
359 Courtesy Aman Resorts aman.com 391, 392, 393, 394 Paulo Mendes da Rocha Nuevo Barrio. Universidad De Los Andes, 2015 Library, Columbia University
360 Courtesy Harry C. Wolf 395 Photo © Nelson Kon 436 El arquitecto peruano (January-February 476 Courtesy gta Archives/ETH Zurich, André
361, 362 Photo courtesy Stanley Saitowitz/Natoma 396 Angelo Bucci/spbr arquitetos 1967) Studer Archives. Photo Marc Lacroix © DACS 2020
Architects Inc. 397 Photo © Nelson Kon 437 Mazuré, Nash and Miguel Cruchaga 477, 478 © Fernando Guerra/FG+SG
363 Courtesy Safdie Architects 398 Photo © Leonardo Finotti Belaúnde 479 © Gerald Zugmann/Vienna, www.zugmann.
364 Photo DeAgostini/Getty Images 399 Photo © Nelson Kon 438, 439 Courtesy Barclay & Crousse, Estudio at
365 Photo John Fulker, courtesy of the Erickson 400 Courtesy Sarah Hospital, Macapá, Brazil Lima 480 © Aga Khan Trust for Culture
Estate Collection 401 Curitiba BRT 440 © Cristobal Palma/Estudio Palma 481 Courtesy Pedro Guedes
366 University of Toronto Scarborough Library, 402 Photo © Germán Téllez 441, 442, 443 Photo Renzo Rebagliati. Courtesy 482 Ernst May
Archives & Special Collections: UTSC Archives 403 Courtesy Fundación Rogelio Salmona, Borasino Arquitectos 483 Photo Filipe Branquinho. Courtesy José
Legacy Collection, Series F. Photographs - Box 1 Bogotá 444 Roberto Dávila Carson Forjaz Architectos
(File 5) 404 Photo Gabriel Ossa. Courtesy Fundación 445, 446 Archivo Histórico José Vial Armstrong. 484 Photo Christian Richters
367 Architects: A.J. Diamond and Barton Myers, Rogelio Salmona, Bogotá Escuela de Arquitectura y Diseño. Pontificia 485, 486 Middle East Technical University
Architects and Planners. In association with 405 Courtesy Ricardo L. Castro Universidad Católica de Valparaíso Archives
R.L. Wilkin, Architect. Partner in Charge: Barton 406 Metropolitan Theatre, Medellín, Colombia 447 Fondo Mario Pérez de Arce. Archivo de 487 Courtesy H.U. Khan
Myers 407 Laureano Forero Ochoa Originales. FADEU. Pontificia Universidad 488 © Cemal Emden and EAA-Emre Arolat
368, 369 Photo © James Dow/Patkau Architects 408 Photo Iwan Baan Católica de Chile Architecture
370 Photo © Bernard Fougères/Patkau Architects 409 Cipriano Dominguez 448 Archivo Histórico José Vial Armstrong. 489 Courtesy Hashim Sarkis Studios. Photo Jean
371 Courtesy Shim-Sutcliffe Architects 410 Fundación Villanueva, photo Paolo Gasparini Escuela de Arquitectura y Diseño. Pontificia Yasmine
372 Photo Ed Burtynsky, courtesy Shim-Sutcliffe 411 Photo José Félix Vivas. © 2020 Calder Universidad Católica de Valparaíso 490 Photo Richard Saad
Architects Foundation, New York/DACS, London 449, 450 Christian De Groote 491 Photo Joe Kesrouani. Courtesy L.E.FT
373 Photo James Steeves 412 Fundación Villanueva, photo Paolo Gasparini 451 Photo © Leonardo Finotti Architects
374 Photo Frédéric Soltan/Corbis via Getty 413, 414 Courtesy The Estate of Jesús Tenreiro- 452 Enrique Browne 492 © Zaha Hadid Architects
Images Degwitz 453 José Medina 493 Courtesy Mendelsohn Archives,
375 Colección O’Gorman. Coordinación 415 Drawing taken from the book “Todo llega 454 Photo Alberto Piovano, courtesy Mathias Kunstbibliothek, Berlin
Servicios de Información Universidad Autónoma al Mar” published by the Polythecnic University Klotz Studio 494 Courtesy Yacov Rechter
Metropolitana, Unidad Azcapotzalco México of Valencia in 2019. Reproduced courtesy Oscar 455 Photo © Leonardo Finotti 495 Photo © Zeev Herz
DF. Photo Maricela González Cruz Manjarrez, Tenreiro 456 Photo Felipe Cammus. Courtesy Geman de 496 Courtesy Zvi Hecker
Archivo Fotográfico “Manuel Toussaint” del 416 Walter James Alcock Sol 497 Sketch by Zvi Hecker
Instituto de Investigaciones Estéticas, UNAM. 417, 418 Antoni Bonet i Castellana 457 Arq: Architectural Research Quarterly, 498 Al Mansfeld
© Estate of Juan O’Gorman/ARS, NY and DACS, 419, 420 © SEPRA and Clorindo Testa, O’Neil Ford Chile Issue 36. Cambridge University Press, 499 Photo © Yael Pincus
London 2020 Monograph 4: Banco de Londres y América del p. 51. Courtesy Archivo de Originales. FADEU. 500 Courtesy Harvard University, Graduate
376, 377 © Estate of Juan O’Gorman/ARS, NY and Sud, 2011 Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile School of Design, Cambridge, Mass.
DACS, London 2020 421 Photo Alejandro Goldemberg, courtesy 458 © Roland Halbe 501 Iraq Consult (Baghdad) and Rifat Chadirji
378 Photo E. Timberman, from Max L. Cetto, MSGSSS Arquitectos 459 © Cristobal Palma/Estudio Palma 502 Shubeilat Badran Assciates (sba), Amman,
Moderne Architektur in Mexiko (Verlag Gerd Hatje, 422, 423 Courtesy MSGSSS Arquitectos 460 Courtesy Smiljan Radic Studio Jordan
Stuttgart, 1961). By permission of Bettina Cetto 424 Courtesy Archivo Williams Director Claudio 461 South African Architectural Record, February 503 Photo © Jay Langlois/Owen Corning
379 © Felipe Cliamo, LEGORRETA® Williams 1937 504 Aga Khan Visual Archive (AKVA), Aga Khan
380 Photo © Fundación Armando Salas Portugal 425 Fundación Joaquín Torres-García, 462, 463 Adèle and Antonio de Souza Santos, Documentation Center, MIT Libraries/courtesy
381 Fundación ICA, A.C. Montevideo Architects Arriyadh Development Authority
382 Courtesy TEN Arquitectos 426 Julius Shulman Photography Archive, 464, 465 Photo Dave Southwood 505 Utzon Archives/Aalborg University & Utzon
383 Archivo de Arquitectos Mexicanos, Facultad Research Library at the Getty Research Institute, 466 Photo Simeon Duchoud. Courtesy Kéré Center
de Arquitectura, Universidad Nacional Autónoma Los Angeles Architecture 506 Kamran Diba
de México 427 Instituto de Historia de la Arquitectura, 467 Photo Onerva Utriainen. Courtesy Heikkinen 507 Photo Kamran Adle. The Aga Khan Trust for
384 Photo Yoshi Koitani Facultad de Arquitectura, Universidad de la + Komonen Culture
385 Geraldo Ferraz, Warchavchik e a introdução República, Montevideo 468 Courtesy Heikkinen + Komonen 508 Courtesy AbCT Inc.
da nova arquitetura no Brasil: 1925 a 1940, Museu 428 Mario Payssé Reyes 469, 470 Photo Onerva Utriainen. Courtesy 509 © Aga Khan Trust for Culture/Photo Al-Hariri
de Arte de Sao Paulo, 1965, p. 22 429 Photo © Leonardo Finotti Heikkinen + Komonen Mokhless
386 Photo © Nelson Kon 430 Luis García Pardo 471 Courtesy Heikkinen + Komonen 510, 511 Utzon Archives/Aalborg University &
387 Paulo Mendes da Rocha 431 Photo © Leonardo Finotti 472 Courtesy Hollmén Reuter Sandman Utzon Center
388 Affonso Eduardo Reidy 432, 433 Eladio Dieste Architects 512 Kamel El Kafrawi, Paris
704 705
72; 45; Park Güell 73, Bayer, Herbert 136, 138 Bellalta, Jaime 427 Murdered Jews of Europe Bizri, Amin 454 Bordeaux, Botanical Museum
208; Paseo de la Bonanova BBPR (Banfi, Belgiojoso, Bellinzona, Rotalinti House 623; 792; Monument to Björn, Malene 467; 509 543–4; 641
flats 354; La Rinascente Peressutti and Rogers) 331, 360 Karl Liebknecht and Björkhagen, St Mark’s 604, Borgafjäll, ski hotel 604;
568; Sagrada Familia 237, 525, 566, 567; 344 Benevolo, Leonardo 9–10 Rosa Luxemburg 187; 631 760
Church 73; 44; Sagrada Bear Run, Falling Water 215, Benites, Juan 420 Neue Nationalgalerie BKF 411 Borie, Henri Jules 171
Familia School 72; Sants 216, 217, 566; 185 Benš, Adolf 154, 155; 124–5 341; Neue Wache 19; Blair, John 524 Bosselt, Rudolf 86
Station square 556; Saria Beardsley, Aubrey 81 Benscheidt, Karl 122 Neukölln hospital 332; Blake, William 54, 81 Boston, Bay plan 296;
housing 557; School of Beaudouin, Eugène 183, 285, Bentham, Jeremy 337 Olympic Stadium 250; Blankenberge, casino 548 University 374
Civil Engineering 555; 338, 540; 153–5 Bentota, Bentota Beach Hotel Perls Haus 186; Bloch, André 447 Botkhil, cemetery 484
World Exhibition (1929) Beaudouin, Laurent 542; 486 Philharmonie 131, 588; Blondel, Jacques-François 16, Botta, Mario 360–61; 337–8
187, 190, 234, 266, 335; 635 Bentsen, Ivar 595 729; Prounenraum 17, 20 Boullée, Etienne-Louis 17,
159–60; see also Igualada Beck, Haig 516 Berenguer, Francesc 72, 73 141; Quartier McNair, Bloomfield Hills, Cranbrook 18, 21, 315, 325, 330,
Cemetery; Sant Just Beel, Stéphane 551–2; 658–9 Berg, Max 44; 20 Zehlendorf 635; 803; Academy of Art 372 393; 3
Desvern Beeston, Boots Pharmaceutical Berlage, Hendrik Petrus 71, Reichsbank competition Boari, Adamo 388 Boulogne-sur-Seine, Maison
Barclay, Sandra 425; 438–40 Plant 285–6, 529; 258 78–80, 128, 145, 146, 157, 187, 191, 263, 266, 267; Bo Bardi, Lina 399, 622; 398 Cook 153, 172
Bardi, Pietro Maria 233, 566 Behne, Adolf 125, 126 185, 187, 243, 336, 549, 568; 233; Schauspielhaus 19; Boberg, Gustaf Ferdinand Boulton, Matthew 36
Barlow, William Henry 38 Behnisch, Günther 525, 590; 51–4 Schillerstrasse block 221 Bourg-la-Reine, Villa
Bärnbach, museum 585 734 Berlin, AEG Turbine Factory 332; Secession Exhibition Boccioni, Umberto 93–4, 96, Hennebique 43
Barnes, Edward Larrabee 370, Behrens, Peter 84, 86, 88, 91, 120, 122, 185; 88–9; Altes (1923) 131; Silk Industry 97 Bourdelle, Antoine 115;
374, 376 107, 113, 118, 119–20, 122, Museum 19–20, 269, Exhibition (1927) 187; Bochum, University 310 85
Barquisimeto, City Hall 408; 123, 124, 128, 132, 147, 165, 568; 6, 240; Bauakademie Sommerfeld House 136; Bock, Richard 67, 68, 69; 37 Bourgeois, Victor 147, 189,
414; Hotel Jirahara 410 185, 199, 241, 286, 457, 521, 185; Baumschulenweg South Friedrichstadt plan Bodiansky, Vladimir 183, 338, 546–7; 647–8
Barragán, Luis 356, 389–90, 584; 87–9 Crematorium 810; 356; 330; Spreebogen 444; 153–4; 475 Bournville 30, 53
425, 430; 331 Beijing 618; Beijing Berlin Building Exhibition competition (1993) 639; Bodrum, Vicem Bodrum Bowman brothers 254
Barranquilla 402 International Airport (1931) 190, 191, 267; Total Theatre project Residences 453; 488 Boyd, Robin 471
Barrionuevo, Francisco 557 489; Chinese Television Berliner-Tageblatt 149–50, 243; 118; Bofill, Ricardo 347, 354 Braem, Renaat 549–50
Barshch, M. 198, 202 Headquarters (CCTV) building 127; Berlin Vinetaplatz housing Bogardus, James 38 Brandt, Marianne 138
Barth, Othmar 586; 726 618; Commune-by-the- Wall 639–41; Brandenburg 332, 591; 303; Wertheim Bogdanov (Alexander Brasília 209, 277, 290–92,
Barthes, Roland 348 Wall (Bamboo House, Gate 19; Britz housing store 93 Malinovsky) 193–4, 195 295; 264; Uruguayan
Bartlesville, Price Tower 215 Split House) 489; 543–4; 147; Capitol Cinema Berman, Solon S. 13 Bogotá 400, 402, 618, 622; Embassy 415; 428
Bartning, Otto 125 Courtyard Hybrid 496; 128; Chancellery 248; Bermúdez, Guillermo 402 Alto de los Pinos Breamlea, Tucker House
Bascans, Ramiro 417 Fragrant Hill Hotel 488; Checkpoint Charlie Bernau, Trades Union School apartments 403; 518–19; 593
Basel, Petersschule 142, 143; Garden School 493; apartment block 350; 150, 456 Fundación Cristiana Breines, Simon 273
109; signal tower 632 551–2; Linked Hybrid department stores 130; Free Berne, Siedlung Halen 360, de la Vivienda 402; 402; Brescia, Revolutionary Tower
Bassett-Lowke, W.J. 83, 84, Building 379, 636; 805; University 312, 598; 283–4; 530, 634 housing 402; National 233
286 National Grand Theatre Friedrichstrasse housing Besa, Jaime 428; 447 University 402; Residencias Breslau (Wrocław), Exhibition
Batey, Andrew 358 of China 489, 618; 349; Friedrichstrasse office Bescós, Ramón 555 El Parque 403; 403–4 (1913) 44; Home and
Bat Yam, Town Hall 457–8; National Stadium 618; building competition Bexhill-on-Sea, De La Warr Bohigas, Oriol 354, 556–7 Work Exhibition (1928)
495–6 Ten Great Buildings 488 131, 186; 157; German Pavilion 525, 527; 605 Boileau, L.-C. 76 131; Jahrhunderthalle
Baudrillard, Jean 617 Beirut 454; Beirut Exhibition Chancellery 641; 808; Bexley Heath, Red House Boileau, Louis-Hippolyte 241, 44; 20; Petersdorff Store
Baudot, Anatole de 43–4, 46, Centre 454; 491; Collège Grosse Schauspielhaus 49–50; 25–6 243 130; 95; Poelzig’s office
76, 78 Protestant Français 127, 128; 92; Hansaviertel Bezard, Norbert 209 Bolchover, Joshua 490 building 127
Bauhaus 107, 122, 125, 132–9, 454; Issam Fares Institute Interbau (1955) 229–30; Bieler, Walter 633 Bologna 331 Breuer, Marcel 137, 138, 150,
159, 191, 195, 294, 322; 97, 454–5; 492; Ministry 201; Hauptstadt project Bijvoet, Bernard 145, 181, Bonaduz, bridge 633 151, 195, 271, 285, 292, 369,
100–106 of National Defence 310, 311; 280–81; Haus 182; 112 Bonatz, Paul 241, 243, 250, 372–4, 472, 513, 549, 581;
Baumann, Povl 595 454 des Rundfunks 596; Bilbao, Guggenheim Museum 452 105, 347, 351
Baumgarten, Alexander Bélanger, François-Joseph Hotel Berlin 332; housing 618, 624 Bonell, Esteban 557; Brinkman, J.A. 145, 285, 286,
Gottlieb 14 34 (Gropius) 150; International Bill, Max 292, 322, 337, 426, 667–8 308; 110–11
Baumschlager and Eberle 635, Belaúnde Terry, Fernando Building Exhibition (1987) 566, 568; 294 Bonet, Antoni 411, 417; Brisbane, Queensland Gallery
636; 803–4 420–21, 634 356, 591; Kaiser Wilhelm Bindesbøll, Gottlieb 223, 224 417–18 of Modern Art 517
Bawa, Geoffrey 469, 486, 520; Belgrade, apartment blocks, Memorial Church 588; Bing, Samuel 106 Bonfanti, Enzo 331 Bristol, Clifton Suspension
541 New Belgrade 581; 712; 731; Kochstrasse housing Binney, R.K. 521 Bonsiepe, Gui 322 Bridge 35; Gane Pavilion
Baxter, Woodleigh School Government Building, New 348; Lindenstrasse housing Birkenhead Park 26 Booth, George 372 373; warehouse project
519–20 Belgrade 581; 711 336; Mehringplatz proposal Birkerts, Gunnar 338 Borås, Hestra Estate 611 302; 274
Bayardo, Nelson 415–16 Belgrand, Eugène 28 311; Memorial to the Birkenshaw 36 Borasino, Oscar 425 Britannia Tubular Bridge 36; 16
White