Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Assessment of Road Accidents in Nigeria
Assessment of Road Accidents in Nigeria
Assessment of Road Accidents in Nigeria
ABSTRACT
Lagos-Ibadan Expressway is infamous for increasing rate of accidents on our roads with
high accident rate, leading to loss of innocent a view to making necessary recommendations
lives. The contributions of human, road, aimed at reducing the accident rate to the
vehicle and environmental factors to these barest minimum.
road accidents were examined. A
comprehensive questionnaire was distributed In 1966, the Federal Government of Nigeria
to one hundred (100) respondents (drivers, commissioned a firm of consultants to
passengers, health workers, federal road undertake a feasibility study to determine the
safety officers, passengers and students of most economical solution to the problems of
tertiary institutions, to obtain their views on road transport between Lagos (the then
accidents. nation’s capital) and Ibadan, the largest city
in Nigeria. The study recommended that a
road link was viable and should be
Official reports on road accidents were constructed on a new alignment.
obtained from LUTH, UCH and FRSC and Consequently, Messrs Scott Wilson Kilpatrick
subjected to statistical analyses. It was and Partners were commissioned for the final
established that the human factors engineering design of the new road. The total
(nonchalant attitude of drivers, distractions length of the proposed road was 110km:
from passengers and carelessness of Ikeja to Shagamu – 44km; Shagamu to
pedestrians) among others, contribute most Alapako – 39km and Alapako to Ibadan –
to accident followed by road factor, then 27km. Later, due to inadequacy of funds the
vehicle factor while the environmental factor scope of the design and construction were
contributes least. Analysis also shows that at reduced by the government (Ibraheem,
least one (1) person is killed; at least 3 1980).
people are injured out of at least 6 people
involved in a single accident on the Lagos- The problem of accident on our highways is
Ibadan Expressway. pathetic and hazardous to life and properties.
Though road accidents cannot be totally
Keywords: Accident, human factor, road eliminated, they may be reduced to the
factor, vehicle factor and environmental barest minimum by taking cognizance of the
factor. causes of the accidents; what to do to reduce
accident rate and examining existing
INTRODUCTION accident patterns and probable accident
The accident rate on Nigerian roads is quite causes with reference to people, highways,
alarming and has become a thing of worry. vehicles and environment. It has been
Unfortunately, lives and properties are observed that failed portions of the Lagos-
irredeemably lost to road accidents and the Ibadan expressway are not repaired and
pace at which this occurs is on the such portions become ditches over time.
increase. It is of great concern to any Construction and repair of roads are not
highway engineer, who is interested in given to competent hands that abandon such
highway safety engineering, to investigate the works without completing them or waste a lot
contributions of various factors (human, of time on them. Furniture such as kilometer
road, vehicle and environment) to the posts, traffic signs, traffic signals and traffic
1
NSE TECHNICAL TRANSACTIONS VOL 47, No. 2 APRIL – JUNE 2013
A. O. Adeboje, A. O. Olutaiwo and A. S. Adedimila
markings are lacking on the Lagos – Ibadan occurred every 10 minutes in Lagos between
Expressway. 1990 and 2004 (Balogun, 2006).
Hitherto, vehicle inspection is done in – situ Price (2006) gave the World Health
on the road and not in the testing yard of the Organization’s report of 2002 which indicated
Vehicle Inspection Office (VIO) where that though there were over 1.1 million road
vehicles could be checked thoroughly and deaths, over 1 million of the deaths recorded
certificate of road worthiness issued. The were from low-income countries. Surprisingly
presence of the federal road safety officers the low income countries contribute only
on the road does not seem to caution or about 40% of all motor vehicles in the world.
change drivers’ disobedient attitude. Table 1 shows deaths resulting from road
Policemen barricade the road, hamper traffic injuries in different regions of the
smooth movement of vehicles and neglect globe.
their duties of securing lives and properties
on the route.
The road users causing accidents may be
drivers, pedestrians and/or passengers
The aim this paper is to investigate the (Kanna and Justo, 2001). Human
causes of road accidents on Lagos- behavioural attitudes causing accidents on
Ibadan expressway between year 2000 and the highways may constitute 80 – 85% of the
year 2007. The specific objectives of the accidents on the highways (Balogun, 2006).
study are as follows: When the driver sights an object on his way,
he applies brake. The higher the speed of the
To determine and analyze accident driver, the less the ease of stopping after
rate along the Lagos – Ibadan perceiving obstacle; and the lower the speed
expressway. of the driver, the more the ease of stopping
at perception of the obstacle. The perception
To examine the influence of human, - reaction time ( ) is the time that elapsed
vehicle, road and environmental before the action of applying the brake is
factors on accidents on the Lagos – taken.
Ibadan expressway.
2
NSE TECHNICAL TRANSACTIONS VOL 47, No. 2 APRIL – JUNE 2013
A. O. Adeboje, A. O. Olutaiwo and A. S. Adedimila
3
NSE TECHNICAL TRANSACTIONS VOL 47, No. 2 APRIL – JUNE 2013
A. O. Adeboje, A. O. Olutaiwo and A. S. Adedimila
report is 13.95%. We cannot rely fully on the are limited to their location and the casualties
accident records obtained from the teaching brought to them.
hospitals as given above because their details
4
NSE TECHNICAL TRANSACTIONS VOL 47, No. 2 APRIL – JUNE 2013
A. O. Adeboje, A. O. Olutaiwo and A. S. Adedimila
5
NSE TECHNICAL TRANSACTIONS VOL 47, No. 2 APRIL – JUNE 2013
A. O. Adeboje, A. O. Olutaiwo and A. S. Adedimila
Year Total No. Total Total No. Year Total No. Total Total No. of
of Live No. of of of No. of Live
Patients Deaths Casualties Casualties Death Casualties
2001 33 27 60 2000 70 5 65
2002 32 23 55 2001 50 10 40
2003 213 25 238 2002 40 7 33
2004 217 16 233 2003 30 5 25
2005 209 15 224 2004 60 6 54
2006 212 48 260 2005 70 10 60
2007 289 44 333 2006 50 12 38
Total 1,205 198 1,403 2007 60 5 55
Souce: Lagos University Teaching Hospital Total 430 60 370
Health Records (2008) Souce: University College Hospital Accident
and Emergency Records (2008)
6
NSE TECHNICAL TRANSACTIONS VOL 47, No. 2 APRIL – JUNE 2013
A. O. Adeboje, A. O. Olutaiwo and A. S. Adedimila
7
NSE TECHNICAL TRANSACTIONS VOL 47, No. 2 APRIL – JUNE 2013
A. O. Adeboje, A. O. Olutaiwo and A. S. Adedimila
Month Month
Figure 2: Histogram showing Mean Number of people involved
Figure 1: Histogram showing Mean of Accidents
Month
Mean of people injured
Figure3: Histogram showing Mean Number of people injured Figure 4: Histogram showing Mean Number of people killed
8
NSE TECHNICAL TRANSACTIONS VOL 47, N0 2, APRIL – JUNE 2013
A comprehensive record of accident along the of all and sundry for the safety of road users and
Lagos-Ibadan expressway between year 2004 stability of our nation’s economy.
and 2007 was obtained from the Oyo State
command of the Federal Road Safety Human factor such as drivers’ high-headedness,
Commission and presented in Table 8. The disobedience to traffic laws and regulations,
number of accidents in Figure 1 does not drunkenness, over-speeding, lack of discipline,
commensurately produce the number of and distractions caused by passengers contribute
people involved in Figure 2. Figure 2 shows majorly to accident occurrence and fatalities.
that accidents during the early and later part of Speed limit of 100km per hour (as designed)
the year are fatal accidents that affect many should be enforced on Lagos-Ibadan Expressway.
people even when few number of accidents Alcohol test (breath analysis) should be conducted
occurred; hence, we can say that minor on drivers (most especially commercial drivers
accidents due to carelessness and rush occur before they use the road) and strict penalty should
in the middle of the year be handed to violators. There should also be a
periodic orientation for drivers and passengers and
Figure 2 shows that there is a relatively high there should be imposition of “Traffic Safety
number of people involved in accidents at the Week”. The subject road is in a very bad condition,
early and later part of the year (January, the shoulders are chopped-up (turned to ditches),
February, April, November and December). shoulders are not pulled-up (resurfaced) following
This could be due to people rushing to meet asphalt overlay of pavement surface and
appointments, setting plans for year - ending or necessary road furniture such as road signs,
setting unrealistic goals for a new year which signals, markings and kilometer posts are not
could lead drivers to throw caution to the wind. installed on the road. A regular repair of road
Figure 2 agrees with Figure 3 greatly, as the pavements and adjoining structures should be
number of people involved in accidents at the done as at when due. Repair of shoulders should
early and later part of the year produce be carried out in tandem with the carriageway
commensurate number of people injured in repair, rather than being alienated. Kilometer
road accidents. As a result of this, it is posts, traffic signs, signals, markings and
suggested that the Federal Road Safety channelization should be installed where
commission should give more enlightenment necessary as these are lacking on the Lagos-
campaigns during these periods of the year Ibadan Expressway.
(January, February, April, November and
December) in order to ameliorate the spate of On-the-road vehicle inspection method is
accidents and casualties on the Lagos-Ibadan employed in Nigeria and people are unduly given
expressway in particular and the Nigerian driver’s license. Most vehicles plying the road are
roads in general. Figure 4 shows that the not road worthy and the applicable traffic law
highest number of people killed in accidents enforcement agencies do not enforce laws in a
are recorded in the months of January, way that enhances safety. Vehicles should be
February, April and November. Figure 1 to 4 checked at VIO’s yard periodically and road
and Table 9 were derived from data from Table worthiness certificate issued to motorists. Violators
8 while Tables 4 and 5 are derived from Table of this rule should have their vehicles impounded.
3. Also, our law enforcement agents should be
incorruptible and check vehicle conditions
From Table 9, a total number of 137 accidents properly.
occurred between year 2004 and year 2007
out of which 905 people were involved, 476 Though sudden rain and unclear weather (at night
people were injured and 176 people were or very early in the morning) may also contribute to
killed. On the average, at least 6 people were accident occurrence, environmental factor
involved, at least 3 people were injured while contributes least to accident rate along the route.
at least 1 person was killed in every accident Motorists should wear retro-reflective
that occurred on the Lagos-Ibadan recommended glasses at night and in the
expressway. afternoon (when the sun ray is high) so as to
reduce the effect of light reflection or sun-rays on
CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS the drivers visibility. It was established
Road accident, whether major or minor, does not mathematically that for a single accident that
only inflict damages on the road users or cause occurred on the Lagos-Ibadan Expressway at least
eternal sorrow to their relatives alone, but it also 6 people were involved; at least 3 people were
pose danger to the economy of the nation. In lieu injured while at least a person was killed. The best
of this, road accident issues should be the concern
9
NSE TECHNICAL TRANSACTIONS VOL 47, N0 2, APRIL – JUNE 2013
way to reduce the number of people involved in Garber N. J. and Hoel, L. A. (1999): Traffic and
accident is to educate road users on the danger Highway Engineering, Second Edition, PWS
and prevention of accidents by avoiding over- Publishing, London.
speeding. This will reduce accidents along the
Lagos-Ibadan Expressway and impact positively Ibraheem, A (1980): Lagos – Ibadan
on the population of the country as well as reduce Expressway – Problems and Solutions,
mortality and morbidity rates due to accidents. Presented to the Nigerian Society of Engineers
at the 1980 Annual Lecture.
The Federal Road Safety Commission does not
have adequate data in their custody. This may be Kanna, S. K. and Justo, C. E. G. (2001):
due to insufficiency of funds, unavailability of Highway Engineering, Eight Edition, Mem
materials and resources. Accident records must be Chan & Bros Publisher, India.
kept for references and projection of future
accidents in order to plan adequately and prevent Lakhani, R., Karns, K., Kohlhaas, L., Ortiz, P.,
accidents in the future. It is also recommended Sampath, A., Schroeder, F. and Viswanathan,
that the federal and state governments should S. (2004): A study into causes of Traffic-
provide funds for research and upgrading of related Accidents at the Intersection of 33rd
accident information data base management so as and State Streets by IPRO 334, group A,
to be able to access necessary information for United States.
planning, development and accident prevention.
The services of professional Highway and Traffic LUTH (2008): Rate of Road traffic Accidents
Engineers should be employed in the design, (RTA’s) 2001-2007 by the Lagos University
maintenance, construction and reconstruction of Teaching Hospital Health Records, Lagos.
highways as well as propaganda on highway
Price, S. J. (2006): Which Intervention
safety and accident prevention.
Strategies to Reduce Morbidity and Mortality
REFERENCES from Road Traffic Accidents would be Most
Effective in Low-Income Countries, A
Balogun, S. A. (2006): Road Safety Practice Published B.Sc. Thesis of Intercalated Degree
in Nigeria, BOAAS Resources Nigeria in International Health Accessed online from
www.sally%20RTA%20Lit%20
Limited, Abuja.
review%20project%20Final on 28/7/2008.
FRSC (2007): Rate of Accidents along Lagos - UCH (2008): Rate of Road Traffic Accidents
Ibadan Expressway by FRSC, Oyo State along Lagos Ibadan Expressway 2000-2007,
Command, RS 11.32. University College Hospital Accident and
Emergency Records, Ibadan.
FRSC (2007): Road Traffic Accidents Statistics
along Ojota - Mowe Axis by FRSC, Lagos
State Command, RS 2.1.
10