Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Psoas and Quadratus Lumborum Muscle Asymmetry
Psoas and Quadratus Lumborum Muscle Asymmetry
Br J Sports Med: first published as 10.1136/bjsm.2008.048751 on 18 September 2008. Downloaded from http://bjsm.bmj.com/ on October 8, 2019 at National Cheng Kung University
Psoas and quadratus lumborum muscle asymmetry
among elite Australian Football League players
J Hides,1,2 T Fan,1,2 W Stanton,2 P Stanton,3 K McMahon,4 S Wilson5
1
Division of Physiotherapy, ABSTRACT limb muscles has been investigated.1 5 14
School of Health and Objective In this study, asymmetry relative to the Researchers have identified the roles of specific
Rehabilitation Sciences,
preferred kicking leg was determined if it exists for the muscles relative to the kicking and stance leg, and a
University of Queensland,
Brisbane, Queensland, Australia psoas and quadratus lumborum muscles among elite link between muscle injuries and leg preference has
2
Mater/UQ Back Stability Clinic, Australian Football League (AFL) players. been determined. However, muscles of the hip and
Mater Health Services, South Design AFL players were assessed at three time points lumbopelvic region have received less attention.
Brisbane, Queensland, Australia
3 from 2005 to 2007 (start of preseason, end of season and Two trunk muscles implicated in the task of
Brisbane Lions AFC, Brisbane,
Queensland, Australia end of preseason training). MRI was used to determine kicking are the psoas and the quadratus lumborum.
4
Centre for Magnetic the cross-sectional areas (CSAs) of the psoas and The quadratus lumborum muscle has been
Resonance, University of quadratus lumborum muscles at the L4–L5 vertebral level investigated in soccer players.15 The cross-sectional
Queensland, Brisbane, (psoas) and the L3–L4 vertebral level (quadratus area (CSA) of the quadratus lumborum muscle was
Queensland, Australia
5
School of IT and Electrical
lumborum). found to be slightly larger in soccer players than in
Engineering, University of Setting MRI was performed in a hospital setting. other athletes including weight-lifters, distance
Queensland, Brisbane, Participants 54 professional AFL players were eligible to runners and shooters. Whether or not the muscle
Queensland, Australia participate in this study. The number of subjects at each was asymmetrical in size was not reported.
Correspondence to of the three time points was 36 for time 1 (T1 Nov 2005), However, Raty et al15 did find a positive correlation
Dr Julie Hides, Division of 31 for time 2 (T2 Aug 2006) and 43 for time 3 (T3 Feb between trunk and side flexion strength and CSA
Physiotherapy, School of Health Mar 2007). of the quadratus lumborum muscle. Another group
Br J Sports Med: first published as 10.1136/bjsm.2008.048751 on 18 September 2008. Downloaded from http://bjsm.bmj.com/ on October 8, 2019 at National Cheng Kung University
to run 100 m.21 Results showed that for sprinters of both sexes,
the higher development of the psoas muscle relative to the
quadriceps femoris, rather than absolute muscle size, was a
factor in achieving better performance in a sprint. It would seem
from these studies that it is important to examine muscle size
and symmetry in different sports, as athletes may show
prominent development in muscle groups used in their
competitive activities and/or training regimes.22 23
The aims of this study were to explore whether asymmetry of
the psoas and quadratus lumborum muscles exists in AFL
players relative to the preferred kicking leg, and whether or not
this is related to number of injuries.
Br J Sports Med: first published as 10.1136/bjsm.2008.048751 on 18 September 2008. Downloaded from http://bjsm.bmj.com/ on October 8, 2019 at National Cheng Kung University
Table 1 Number (%) of current lumbopelvic or lower limb injuries at p,0.001) (table 2). There was no significant effect for ‘‘number
time of assessment of injuries’’ at any of the three time points (p.0.05).
T1 (November 2005) T2 (August 2006) (%) T3 (February/March 2007) There was also significant difference between sides for CSA of
the quadratus lumborum muscle at all three time points. The
0 16.7 12.9 25.6 quadratus lumborum muscle was significantly smaller on the
1 44.4 35.5 53.6
side of the preferred kicking leg at T1 (November 2005)
2 30.6 25.8 18.5
(F = 40.7, p,0.001), T2 (August 2006) (F = 25.9, p,0.001) and
3 8.3 25.8 2.3
T3 (February/March 2007) (F = 34.8, p,0.001) (table 2). There
0, no lumbopelvic or lower limb injuries at time of assessment; 1, one lumbopelvic or was no effect for ‘‘number of injuries’’ at any time point
lower limb injury at time of assessment; 2, two lumbopelvic or lower limb injuries at
time of assessment; 3, three or more lumbopelvic or lower limb injuries at time of (p.0.05).
assessment.
DISCUSSION
type I sums of squares model was used to analyse CSA for the The results of this study suggest that psoas and quadratus
psoas muscle and the quadratus lumborum muscle. The lumborum muscle asymmetry occurred in the elite AFL players
repeated measures factor in the analyses was ‘‘asymmetry’’, studied at all of the three time points measured. Despite the
coded as ‘‘ipsilateral’’ or ‘‘contralateral’’ to preferred kicking leg. previous lack of evidence relating to asymmetry of muscles
Number of injuries in the past season or since the last MRI around the pelvis and hips in kicking sports, several coaching
assessment (coded as 0, 1, 2 or more) was included as a between- and training sources state that kicking practices using both legs
subjects factor. The factors of ‘‘age’’, ‘‘height’’ and ‘‘weight’’ during training should be encouraged in players of professional
were included as covariates. A type I model was used as our sports such as AFL31 32 and soccer.12 33 34 The rationale for
previous analysis has shown that higher-order interactions training both legs equally is to minimise potential asymmetrical
involving weight and muscle size can be problematic for a type forces acting on joints, reduce muscle imbalances and decrease
III model. the workload of the dominant leg which may eventually lead to
As the number of squad members varied greatly across overuse injuries.10 However, even if players use both legs equally
at training, they may change strategy and kick predominantly
Table 2 Marginal means and SEs (adjusted for age, height and weight) for the CSAs of the psoas at the level
of the L4–L5 disc and quadratus lumborum muscles at the level of the L3–L4 disc
T1 (November 2005) T2 (August 2006) T3 (February/March 2007)
Ipsilateral Contralateral Ipsilateral Contralateral Ipsilateral Contralateral
Psoas (cm2) 25.05 (0.50) 23.23 (0.46) 24.43 (0.83) 23.31 (0.67) 24.48 (0.45) 23.05 (0.45)
Quadratus lumborum (cm2) 8.79 (0.29) 9.90 (0.31) 8.84 (0.41) 9.54 (0.45) 8.17 (0.22) 9.31 (0.26)
Ipsilateral, same side as the preferred kicking leg; contralateral, opposite side to the preferred kicking leg.
Br J Sports Med: first published as 10.1136/bjsm.2008.048751 on 18 September 2008. Downloaded from http://bjsm.bmj.com/ on October 8, 2019 at National Cheng Kung University
(2.7) cm2 and contralateral = 8.6 (2.6) cm217 and ipsilateral to
bowling arm = 9.1 (2.19) cm2 and contralateral = 8.61 What this study adds
(2.09) cm216, remembering that the quadratus lumborum muscle
is larger on the dominant side in cricket as opposed to the stance c Asymmetry of the psoas and quadratus lumborum muscles
leg in AFL. Muscle CSAs of the quadratus lumborum muscle exists in AFL players.
documented in the current study are larger and more c The CSA of the psoas muscle was shown to be significantly
asymmetrical than those reported for male non-athletes larger on the side of the preferred kicking leg, while the CSA of
(left = 5.38 (1.9) cm2, right = 5.2 (1.2) cm2)27 and active male the quadratus lumborum muscle was larger contralateral to the
non-cricketers (dominant hand = 7.8 (1.8) cm2, non-domi- preferred kicking leg.
nant = 7.9 (1.9) cm2).17 c Asymmetry in psoas and quadratus lumborum muscle size
Hypertrophy of the psoas muscle in AFL players is most was not related to number of injuries.
likely related to its role as a primary hip flexor,37 38 as was seen
in gymnasts, ballet dancers, figure skaters20 and cricketers.17
The results from the current study regarding CSA of the psoas One of the limitations of this investigation was the lack of
muscle at the L4–L5 vertebral level can be compared with consistency in attendance level at each time point. However,
others that have used a similar protocol. The present results this was unavoidable because of the recruitment and retire-
(February/March 2007, dominant psoas CSA = 24.48 ments within the team. Another limitation was the relatively
(0.45 cm2); non-dominant = 23.05 (0.45) cm2) are comparable small sample size, but the numbers are comparable to other
with results for cricketers (dominant = 24 (3.7) cm2, non- studies conducted in this area. Notably, participants in this
dominant = 24.9 (4.1) cm2),17 remembering that the psoas study who reported current low-back pain presented with pain
muscle is larger on the non-dominant side in cricket as of a central or bilateral nature in all but two cases. Future
opposed to the kicking leg in AFL. Psoas muscle CSAs from the studies could examine for a relationship between unilateral low-
current study are larger and less variable than those reported back pain and psoas asymmetry. Another possible direction for
for male non-athletes (18.9 (3.8) cm2),27 active male non- further research is to investigate whether particular AFL
cricketers (dominant hand = 22.1 (3.6) cm2, non-domi- positions are related to muscle asymmetry.
Br J Sports Med: first published as 10.1136/bjsm.2008.048751 on 18 September 2008. Downloaded from http://bjsm.bmj.com/ on October 8, 2019 at National Cheng Kung University
16. Hides JA, Stanton W, Freke M, et al. MRI study of the size, symmetry and function 27. Marras WS, Jorgensen MJ, Granata KP, et al. Female and male trunk geometry:
of the trunk muscles among elite cricketers with and without low back pain. size and prediction of the spine loading trunk muscles derived from MRI. Clin Biomech
Br J Sports Med 2008;42:509–13. Published Online First: 7 Dec 2007. doi:10.1136/ (Bristol, Avon) 2001;16:38–46.
bjsm.2007.044024 28. Mulder ER, Stegeman DF, Gerrits KHL, et al. Strength, size and activation of knee
17. Ranson C, Burnett A, O’Sullivan P, et al. The lumbar paraspinal muscle morphometry extensors followed during 8 weeks of horizontal bed rest and the influence of a
of fast bowlers in cricket. Clin J Sport Med 2008;18:31–7. countermeasure. Eur J Appl Physiol 2006;97:706–15.
18. Engstrom C, Walker D, Kippers V, et al. Quadratus lumborum asymmetry and L4 29. Hides JA, Richardson CA, Jull GA. Magnetic resonance imaging and ultrasonography of the
pars injury in fast bowlers: a prospective MRI study. Med Sci Sports Exerc lumbar multifidus muscle. Comparison of two different modalities. Spine 1995;20:54–8.
2007;39:910–7. 30. Barker K, Shamley D, Jackson D. Changes in the cross-sectional area of multifidus
19. Burnett AF, Barrett CJ, Marshall RN, et al. Three-dimensional measurement of and psoas in patients with unilateral back pain. Spine 2004;29:E515–9.
lumbar spine kinematics for fast bowlers in cricket. Clin Biomech (Bristol, Avon) 31. Parkin D, Smith R, Schokman P. Skill development. In: Parkin D, Smith R, Schokman
1998;13:574–83. P, eds. Premiership football: how to train, play and coach Australian football. 2nd edn.
20. Peltonen JE, Taimela S, Erkintalo M, et al. Back extensor and psoas muscle cross- Melbourne, Australia: Hargreen, 1987:19.
sectional area, prior physical training and trunk muscle strength—a longitudinal study 32. Parkin D, Smith R, Schokman P. Questions—facts, fads and fallacies. In: Parkin D,
in adolescent girls. Eur J Appl Physiol 1998;77:66–71. Smith R, Schokman P, eds. Premiership Football: How to train, play and coach
21. Hoshikawa Y, Muramatsu M, Iida T, et al. Influence of the psoas major and thigh Australian football. 2nd edn. Melbourne, Australia: Hargreen, 1987:204.
muscularity on 100 m times in junior sprinters. Med Sci Sports Exerc 33. McLean B, Tumilty D. Left-right asymmetry in two types of soccer kick. Br J Sports
2006;38:2138–43. Med 1993;27:260–2.
22. Kanehisa HK, Funato K, Kuno S, et al. Growth trend of the quadriceps femoris 34. Starosta W. Symmetry and asymmetry in shooting demonstrated by elite soccer
muscle in junior Olympic weight lifters: an 18-month follow-up survey. Eur J Appl players. In: Reilly T, Lees A, Davids K, Murphy W, eds. Science and football. London,
Physiol 2003;89:238–42. UK: E & FN Spon, 1988:346–55.
23. Kanehisa H, Nemoto IT, Fukanaga T. Strength capabilities of knee extensor muscles 35. McGill S, Juker K, Kropf P. Quantitative intramuscular myoelectric activity of quadratus
in junior speed skaters. J Sports Med Phys Fitness 2001;41:46–53. lumborum during a wide variety of tasks. Clin Biomech (Bristol, Avon) 1996;11:170–2.
24. Brand RA, Pedersen DR, Fiederich JA. The sensitivity of muscle force predictions to 36. Danneels L, Vanderstraeten G, Cambier D, et al. Effects of three different training
changes in physiologic cross-sectional area. J Biomech 1986;19:589–96. modalities on the cross sectional area of the lumbar multifidus muscle in patients
25. Close RI. Dynamic properties of mammalian skeletal muscles. Physiol Rev with chronic low back pain. Br J Sports Med 2001;35:186–91.
1972;52:129–97. 37. Bogduk N, Pearcy M, Hadfield G. Anatomy and biomechanics of psoas major. Clin
26. Narici M. Human skeletal muscle architecture studied in vivo by non-invasive Biomech (Bristol, Avon) 1992;7:109–19.
imaging techniques: functional significance and applications. J Electromyogr Kinesiol 38. Penning L. Psoas muscle and lumbar spine stability: a concept uniting existing
1999;9:97–103. controversies. Critical review and hypothesis. Eur Spine J 2000;9:577–85.