Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 5

1

Computer simulation of an industrial Ethane-


Cracking furnace operation
J. Kerezsi, Tisza Chemical Group Plc, T. Gal, University of Miskolc

takes place in a pyrolysis furnace that, from kinetic aspect, can


Abstract-- A computer simulation strategy is presented that is be considered as a plug-flow reactor; a kinetic reactor has
focused on the application of modeling programs for the been chosen from ChemCad list for modeling of the furnace in
simulation of multistage chemical technology processes with a question [3]. The construction of models for the processes in
large number of equipment units, including reactors, is suggested chemical reactors with the application of modeling programs
for chemical transformation processes in reactors. The submitted for the purpose of their inclusion in models of complete
strategy allows for the modeling of homogeneous and industrial flow sheets imposes certain requirements on the
heterogeneous processes in reactors of any complexity on the
basis of experimental data processing. The simulation of reactor
procedure of their development. If we would like to modify
processes has been performed with the use of the CHEMCAD some parameters of technology, than we can do it in a
program for the ethane thermal cracking. The main products of simulation program. The tendency in the world about the
Steam Cracking Olefin production technology are the ethylene simulation of steam crackers use different simulations
and propylene [1],[2]. In Eastern Europe mainly virgin naphtha, program, but most of them deal with just a furnace geometry
gas oil and hydrocarbon gases C3-C4, liquefied petroleum gases- or the main reactions [4].
are used as feedstocks. Depending on the type of the feed
different type of furnaces geometry can be built into the unit
serve as plug-flow reactors for thermal cracking of larger
III. ETHANE CRACKING SIMULATION
hydrocarbon molecules. There is a special furnace in the unit that
cracks the recycled ethane.

Index Terms — Chemcad, computer simulation, ethane Theoretical considerations


pyrolysis, olefin production, optimization, thermal cracking. The traditional mathematical modeling technique for reactor
processes is based on the application of detailed kinetic
I. NOMENCLATURE models. Many processes kinetic data may be absent or their
Mp- paraffin kinetics may be studied insufficiently. Moreover, numerical
MO-olefin non-convergence may be observed both for a single reactor
R1-R4 – radical molecule process and for an entire flow sheet while simulating
H - hydrogen. multistage chemical technology processes with recirculation.
k : reaction rate constant The one of raw materials of olefin plants is the recycled
ethane. The technology of pyrolysis is based on the
T: temperature [K]
hydrocarbons thermal cracking at a temperature of 830- 840°C
R: gas constant [kJ/kmol K]
in presence of steam. The high temperature indicates the high-
E: activation energy [kJ/Kmol]
energy collision and the hydrocarbon molecules crack in
A0: frequency factor radicals. The steam cracking means the cracking of
t : coil outlet temperature [°C] hydrocarbons in presence of steam. The temperature inside the
τ: residential time [sec] radiant tubes of furnace is between 830-860°C. Thermal
ω: acentric factor cracking of ethane in the furnace means a series of complex
V: volume [m3] consecutive and parallel reactions, but the yield of ethylene is
P: pressure [Pa] more than 40%. The cracking mechanism is mainly based on
radical mechanisms though molecular reactions can also be
II. INTRODUCTION identified in the system. These mechanisms have three main
At present, chemical engineers are showing great interest in steps. The first one is chain-initiation step that include
the development of computer models for reactor processes and endothermic reactions that need heat to start decomposition.
their application for the simulation and optimization of The second group consists of chain-propagation reactions and
industrial process flow sheets when designing or operating the last group of reactions is the group of chain-termination
them. The modern approach to the creation of resource-saving reactions that generate new molecules like olefins, paraffins
technologies assumes the application of software to simulate and hydrogen. Reactions in the third group are exothermic that
complete multistage industrial flow sheets, in particular, means it is necessary to use cooling. The ethane enters the
reactor processes, because the thermal cracking of ethane furnace in 100 mol%, and the furnace effluent contains 38-
40mol% ethane that is not considered effective. I used the
Chemcad simulator for the simulation of ethane cracking in

978-1-4673-5556-8/13/$31.00 ©2013 IEEE


2

the radiant zone of the furnace. The simulation is a very It is necessary to supply/remove heat to/from the process. This
important tool to optimize the ethane re-pyrolysis cycle. is the way of solving the direct problem of computer modeling
for reactor processes.
For nearly 25 years [13], Chemstations and its chemical
process simulation software CHEMCAD have been evolving
Kinetic Model
with the highly dynamic chemical engineering industry.
The first step of ethane thermal cracking simulation is The steps to make the ethane cracking simulations in Chemcad
creating the reaction scheme. [10] are as follows:
M p − CH 2 − H  → M p − CH 2 • + H • (1) 1.) Build the flow sheet, kinetic reactor
2.) Define the special molecules (radicals)
3.) Chose the right mathematical model

.
MpCH2 + R1• → R1H + R3• (2)
R3→Mo + R4• (3)
4.) Install each parameters of reactor
5.) Run the simulations
6.) Collect the results
First step to define the reactions
R4• + Mp→R3• + H2 (4) I know the composition of raw material and that of products
Decomposition of generated radicals is modeled on the basis because I have laboratory data of measurements. First I have
of steady-state, so all radicals are transformed in each to determine the type of model. I chose the mechanistic model,
integration step. The most important beta-scission reactions though this model is very complex, and it calculates the results
are modeled using temperature dependent selectivity. Beta- through numerical iterations, and needs more running time. I
scission is divided to scission of C-H and C-C bonds. C-H have to assign kinetic parameters for each reaction. I have to
scission recognizes primary, secondary and tertiary carbon take care about the complexity.
atoms and C-C bonds scissions are divided according to the
TABLE I
count of substituents (substituents of the bond). REACTION FOR CHEAMCAD (DETAIL)
A mechanistic kinetic model was developed on the basis of a
detailed reaction network containing 81 [5], [6] individual
reactions including both radical and molecular ones. Kinetic
parameters were assigned to each reaction from published and
arranged literature [7] data. Validation of the model was
performed by comparing its results with those obtained
experimentally from cracked gas analysis of an industrially
operated furnace, fitting the kinetic parameters to
experimentally measured yield data.
The theory of kinetic parameters is based on the Arrhenius
equation. [ 7]
E (5)
ln k = − + ln A 0
RT
The radical reactions cannot be shown with “normal” kinetic
equations. Experts launched the Severity factor instead that is
a simple method for complex pyrolysis reaction-system, which
was introduced by Linden and Peck [12]
S = t ⋅ τ 0,06 (6)

Modeling:
To build-up the furnace model, a simulation program is also These parameters can be found in the literature [9], but it is
needed. According to this, the strategy of the calculation of written in the software by manually.
reactor processes with the application of modeling programs The next step is to find the right mathematical program, which
in the construction of computer models for complete flow- I can use for my simulation. The hydrocarbons are in vapor
sheets of industrial chemical processes consists of the phase in the radiant zone so I use the Soave Redlich-Kwong
following: enthalpy model [14]. The model is based on ideal gas law, but
(1) stoichiometric data are specified for each reaction; it considers the realistic gases as well. The base equations are
(2) key component conversions, which can be determined the followings (7-11):
from experimental data, are specified for each reaction;
and the reactor process is calculated with the
determination of the flow rate, composition, temperature (7)
and other characteristics of an outlet stream, as well as the
required flow rate.[8]
3

(8)

(9)

(10)

(11)

The model is applicable for the vapour phase simulation.


Technology:
The ethane and the steam enter the convection zone
together, and the mixture is heated up by flue gases, which
come from the radiant zone. Outlet temperature of the
convection zone is 550-650°C, where the cracking of some
hydrocarbons already begins. The purpose of the water feed is
to keep the pressure in the tube, and suppress the coke
Fig.1 Flow sheet of Ethane cracking furnace in Chemcad software.
formation. The stream enters the radiation section, where the
conditions are controlled, such as the temperature, pressure,
and residence time. The temperature at the exit of radiation The raw materials, steam and ethane enter a theoretical mixer
zone achieves 850-860°C. In this zone the hydrocarbons crack (2), so it is possible to vary the CH/Steam ratio within the
and some other kinds of different (shorter) molecules are specified limits. The heat exchanger (3) symbolizes the
formed. The hydrocarbon fractions are very diverse from C1 convection section. The radiation zone is simulated by the
fraction to C10 fraction in case of ethane cracking. The main kinetic reactor (1). The controller has the role to keep the
product of the ethane cracking furnace is the ethylene. The integration time. The component separator (5) is a theoretical
furnace produces approximately 24 vol% ethane. The first separation, in order to measure the hydrocarbons and the water
period of the reactions is endothermic, so it needs high energy separately. I can set up the geometry of the furnace, the
impute. In industrial practice a mixture of methane fraction radiation zone that has four independent tube sections (the
and natural gas is used for heating. At the end of the radiant height of tubes is 10m and the inside diameters of the tubs are
zone the reactions became exothermic, so the reaction mixture 0,108m and the full length is 70m). The ethane feed is 10.5t/h,
needs cooling. The cooling method is the quench cooling and the steam feed is 4t/h in each tube. The raw material
system that includes a heat-exchanger cooling the cracked contains 99,96w% ethane.
gases by high-pressure boiler-feed-water (BFW), producing
high-pressure steam by using the heat of cracked gases. The The figure2 shows how I can control the kinetics
gases are further cooled by a direct spray of pyrolysis heavy
oil reaching a temperature of 300°C. Following this, the
cracked gases are driven to the gas separation units. The
technology parameters have to be set in such a way to obtain
the maximum monomer (ethylene, and propylene) production
and the minimum yield of methane and heavy hydrocarbons.
The constraints of the process (ex. Capacities) as well as the
financial aspects have also to be considered. For example it is
not profitable to increase the amount of dilution steam,
because it needs lot of energy, and increases the operational
cost.

Chemcad simulation:
Figure 1 shows the furnace scheme in Chemcad software.

Fig.2. Ethane and ethylene mole fraction in reactor


4

The ethane and ethylene are the two key components. As V. REFERENCES
the figure 2 shows, the fed ethane is not completely consumed;
the theoretical conversion is about 60%. Periodicals:
The main purpose of the ethane cracking simulation is to [1] T. N. Gartman, F. S. Sovetin, and D. K. Novikova, „Experience in the
build up the model, which model can be suitable for modeling Application of the CHEMCAD Program to the Modeling of Reactor
the ethane cracking furnace operation in Tisza Chemical Processes”, ISSN 0040-5795, Theoretical Foundations of Chemical
Engineering, 2009, Vol. 43, No. 6, pp. 944–954. © Pleiades Publishing,
Group Plc. In my simulations I could produce the similar data Ltd., 2009.
like the furnace, for example same operational data, and same [2] A. M. Alieva, A. Z. Tairova, A. M. Guseinovaa,N. R. Ismailovb, and T.
stream properties. This is the base of the further optimization. N. Shakhtakhtinskiia, „Optimum Zoned Fuel Gas Supply to the Coil of
an Ethane Pyrolysis Furnace”, ISSN 0040?5795, Theoretical
Results of my simulations and laboratory data are compared in Foundations of Chemical Engineering, 2010, Vol. 44, No. 6, pp. 913–
table 2. 919. © Pleiades Publishing, Ltd., 2010
[3] Gartman, T.N.” Computer Simulation of Power– and Resource–Saving
TABLE 2 Chemical Productions, Programmnye” Produkty Sistemy, 2002, no. 4, p.
29
pygas properties by Chemcad, and laboratory data [4] Eunjung Joo, Kihong Lee b, Moonyong Lee b, Sunwon Park,
„CRACKER a PC based simulator for industrial cracking furnaces”
Computers and Chemical Engineering 24 (2000) 1523-1528
[5] K.M. Sundaram, G.F. Froment, „Modeling of thermal cracking kinetics.
3. Radical mechanisms for the pyrolysis of simple paraffins, olefins, and
their mixtures”, Ind. Eng. Chem. Fundam.17 (1978) 174/182
[6] Zdenek Belohlava, Petr Zamostnya, Tomas Herink, „The kinetic model
of thermal cracking for olefins production” Chemical Engineering and
Processing 42 (2003) 461/473
[7] M. Dente, S. Pierucci, F. Ranzi, „New improvements in modelingkinetic
schemes for hydrocarbon pyrolysis reactors”, Chem. Eng.Sci. 47 (1992)
2629/2634
[8] Pechuro, N.S., Kapkin, V.D., and Pesin, O.Yu., „Khimiya i tekhnologiya
sinteticheskogo zhidkogo topliva i gaza” Chemistry and Technology of
According to the table it can be concluded that the results are Synthetic Liquid Fuel and Gas, Moscow: Khimiya, 1986
[9] Z. Belohlav, L. Fiedler, „The primary product distribution in naphtha
similar. The hydrogen, ethane, ethylene, propylene Chemcad, thermal cracking” Chem. Biochem. Eng. Q. 10 (1996) 113/117.
laboratory data are in good harmony with each other. The
furnace outlet stream is driven to the separation section and Books:
[10] Illés Vendel: „Szénhidrogéngázok pirolizise laboratóriumi
the ethane is recycled back to the furnace after separation. csőreaktorban” 1967 1-22
[11] Zdonik,S.B.,Green,E.J.,Hallee,L.P.:Oil and Gas J.26,96 1967
[12] Linden,H.R.,Peck,R.E.:Ind Eng.Chem.46,2470 1955.
IV. CONCLUSION
Standards:
The main products of the olefin plant are the ethylene and [13] http://www.chemstations.net
propylene, which are produced by thermal cracking of [14] Chemcad „help menu”
different hydrocarbons. In this period of my research I was
dealing with ethane thermal cracking. The results show that
the ethane recycles in the whole production system. In the gas VI. BIOGRAPHIES
separation unit the ethane – ethylene mixture is separated in
the distillation column. The ethylene goes to the polymer
plants, and the ethane goes back to the furnace again.
However, there are more furnaces in operation in the olefin
plant and each furnace produce ethane, so the ethane-recycle
shall be established by the operation of ethane-cracking
furnace. The most important task of the optimization is to find
the optimum parameters of the ethane cycle, between the
ethane – ethylene distillation column and ethane cracking
furnace. The ethane cracking furnace is not able to take in all
the ethane produced in the furnaces because the inlet feed has János Kerezsi was born in Budapest in Hungary, on July 8, 1980. He
a maximum capacity, and the distillation tower has a graduated from the Budapest University of Technology and Economics,
Faculty of Chemical Engineering.
maximum capacity also, so I would like to find those optimum He works for Tisza Chemical Group Plc. as process and commissioning
parameters, by means of which the ethane quantity engineer. Parallel, he is a PhD student at Miskolc University, Antal Kerpely
continuously recycling in the olefin plant system can be Doctoral School of Materials Science & Technology.
reduced.
5

Tivadar Gál, PhD was born in Pácin (Hungary) on


19th of March, 1953. He graduated from University of Petroleum and Gases,
Ploiesti (Romania) in 1977. He obtained PhD degree at University of
Pannonia (Veszprém, Hungary) in 2007. He was working for TVK Plc. from
1977 to 2011, till his retirement. At present he works for University of
Miskolc as an associate professor.

You might also like