Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Stanford Daily: Study Provides Food For Thought
The Stanford Daily: Study Provides Food For Thought
FEATURES/3 SPORTS/6
An Independent Publication
TUESDAY www.stanforddaily.com Volume 239
May 17, 2011 Issue 64
American graffiti
GOOGLE
A problem universities, libraries
and public schools face, he argued, is
a “public failure.” Without the gov-
Continued from front page ernment providing all the necessary
resources for these institutions,
Google can force change when it
complete,” he said. “What was miss- takes over the work that the public
ing from this story was the fact that, sector isn’t necessarily doing.
for instance, Sergey Brin and Larry “Really what we see here is
Page worked on a grant from the Na- Google on the Web as a largely
tional Science Foundation to devel- benevolent Caesar,” he said.
op what became PageRank.” “Google is essentially the sover-
Thus, the public helped fund the eign of the Web,” he added.“Google
project that eventually became is ruling the Web for us.”
Google, and it now contributes the “We’re not far enough into histo-
data critical to the company’s suc- ry,”said community member Hazem
cess. Nassar, who referred to Vaid-
“We do a tremendous amount of hyanathan’s comparison of Google
interaction with Google that con- to Caesar.
stantly improves Google,” Vaid- “This is all very recent, and the
hyanathan said. rate of change is very fast,” Nassar
No other search engine company said. “Google came out, and now
can truly compete, because there are they’re afraid of Facebook.I’d like to
none that are as well equipped. And hear more of what he has to say
no other company boasts “the about open source, especially mak-
sunken infrastructure” that Google ing libraries more accessible.”
has, he observed.
“The question is, ‘How are we Contact Tyler Brown at tbbrown
making Google smarter?’” he @stanford.edu.
added. “And we’re making Google
smarter with every click.”
But computer clicks don’t make
up the entire picture. Correction
“There is no such thing as a neu-
tral algorithm,”Vaidhyanathan said. In Monday’s article “Yearly re-
“Human beings do make deci- fund rate sees little change,” The
sions at Google,” he said. “Human Daily incorrectly reported that the
beings make decisions what the algo- officers of special-fees groups cur-
rithm cares about. It’s not just the rently have the right to a list of the
computers.” SUID numbers of individuals who
Indeed, Google shows different refunded their group. In fact, this
search results depending on location policy was overturned.
and “learns”the preferences of users It was also incorrectly reported
who have Google accounts. that,under a proposed bill to reform
“What this does is, of course, nar- the refund process, students could
row our field of vision,because we’re file a case with Judicial Affairs if
outsourcing our decision making to VSOs released their names to the
Google exponentially,which is much public. In fact, the bill only states
better for shopping but much worse that students can file a case with the
for learning,” he said. “appropriate judicial body.”
Constructive improvements
FEATURES
Guatemala’s Wise‘Doctor Pablo’
Pediatrics professor Paul Wise has spent the past 40 summers volunteering,training
and researching in the Guatemalan highlands
By ZAHRA TAJI Guatemalan town up to Western medical ished children, with two to three children for
standards. Last summer, local health promot- every one bed. Initially, Wise was angry with
ers honored him with a ceremony. the parents for letting their children become
I
n San Juan El Mirador, a traditional Wise first visited Guatemala the summer so sick. But when Sunday came and the local
town in the highlands of Guatemala after his freshman year at Cornell University. parents were allowed to visit their children,
2,500 miles from Stanford, pediatrics He had been interested in marine biology — Wise saw that the problem was neither neglect
professor Paul Wise is working to trans- specifically sharks — but was thinking about nor lack of love. It had to do with the overar-
form the local medical scene. pursuing something that would have more of ching medical care system.
“Doctor Pablo,” as the locals affectionately an immediate impact on the world. He headed That was 1970.
call him, has been traveling to Guatemala for to Guatemala to get a glimpse of the “real Wise, who is now a pediatrics professor at
40 years now, ever since he was a teenager. He world.” the Stanford School of Medicine and senior
has met with doctors,policymakers and clinics He got his wish. The hospital ward Wise fellow at the Freeman Spogli Institute for In-
from the area in an attempt to bring the tiny was assigned to was full of severely malnour- ternational Studies (FSI), has since returned
to Guatemala each summer to provide med-
ical care, train local health promoters, conduct
research and talk to various organizations and
agencies.
OPINIONS
I H AVE T WO H EADS The Stanford Daily
Established 1892 AN INDEPENDENT NEWSPAPER Incorporated 1973
Zach Zimmerman
President and Editor in Chief
Managing Editors
Kate Abbott
Deputy Editor
Kristian Bailey
Columns Editor
Tonight’s Desk Editors
An Le Nguyen
News Editor
Mary Liz McCurdy An Le Nguyen Jacob Jaffe
I
Stephanie Weber
’m going to begin this column Chief Operating Officer Managing Editor of News Head Copy Editor Sports Editor
with a confession. Since coming
Claire Slattery Nate Adams Stephanie Sara Chong
to Stanford, I think that only a Managing Editor of Sports
Anastasia Yee
Vice President of Advertising Features Editor
handful of days have gone by in Head Graphics Editor
which I haven’t talked to some Rachel Theodore L. Glasser Kathleen Chaykowski
Alex Atallah
Zack Hoberg
Managing Editor of Features
member of my family. Okay, so from
my standpoint that wasn’t a confes-
Kolb Michael Londgren
Lauren Wilson
Web Editor
Photo Editor
WISE
“A theme that has run through
my life and continues to be the core
of my academic work is the relation-
Continued from page 3 ship between technical innovation
and questions of social justice,”
Wise said.
“You have to get out and go to Gesturing to the Clark Center as
these places,” Wise said. “You can’t a meeting place of technology, de-
do justice work in Guatemala sitting sign and innovation, he emphasized
in Palo Alto.” the importance of respecting tech-
Jake Rosenberg, a student purs- nological change while at the same
ing a joint MD/PhD at the Stanford time recognizing that technological
School of Medicine, accompanied innovation raises profound ques-
Wise on one of his trips last summer. tions of justice.
Rosenberg said that Wise’s work al- “You can be an intensive care
ways emphasized caring for each pa- doctor, or a neonatologist, or a sur-
tient with individualized attention. geon, and that is extremely relevant
“Wise very much encouraged to the kinds of justice questions that
that you treat a patient in take place in rural Guatemala, the
Guatemala with the same standards Eastern Congo or in Burma,” Wise
you would treat your mother [or as] said.“These are not disconnected.”
you would treat a patient at Stan- Wise’s work in Guatemala is not
ford Hospital,” Rosenberg said. only about providing physical care
Wise earned his bachelor’s de- for the patients, but also the less tan-
gree in Latin American studies and gible, yet much-needed, follow-up
his medical degree from Cornell care. He described that part of a
University, as well as a master’s of health promoter’s role is not just to
public health from the Harvard translate the language, but also to
School of Public Health. After translate the culture. He added that
spending the first 23 years of his ac- sometimes, the patients who need
ademic life at Harvard Medical care have no obvious disease or
School, Harvard School of Public symptoms — their problems are
Health and Boston University nothing like those that you could
School of Medicine, Wise came to understand as a physician working
Stanford in 2004. solely in Palo Alto.
“I was here maybe three weeks For this reason,Wise is not only a
and I was asked to do an informal physician during his visits to
brown bag lunch seminar [to talk Guatemala, but also a research fig-
about my research],” Wise said, re- ure who trains local people to work
calling his first month at Stanford. on and deal with their uniquely
“It was over the summer, and I did- local situations.
n’t expect many people to attend.” “I strongly believe that we have a
But to Wise’s surprise, there role to play and can make a differ-
were two Nobel Prize winners ence, even freshmen undergraduate
among the attendees. students,” Wise said. “I’ve been to a
“This would have never hap- lot of very ‘complicated’ environ-
pened at Harvard,” he continued. ments, war-torn areas, and what I
“It struck me that this is such an in- don’t want students to ever feel is
timate university . . . The intimacy immobilized . . . particularly those
and the ability to craft intensely getting into technical career paths
across disciplinary kinds of work is [like] medicine or biodesign.”
very special here.” “[They] have to recognize that
In fact, Wise’s interest lies in in- the work they do is directly relevant
terdisciplinary discourse, and he to questions of justice,” he added.
works “right smack in the middle of
the interaction” between technolo- Contact Zahra Taji at ztaji@stan-
gy and social justice. ford.edu.
STUDY
“We are now exploring the mol-
ecules that are involved in signaling
between the gut and the brain and
Continued from front page the role of nerves such as the vagus
that may be mediating these
changes,” Pasricha said. “There are
These behaviors manifested them- lots of questions to be asked, and we
selves in decreased consumption of hope that this research will open up
sugar water, less active swimming in some new perspectives on depres-
warm water and a tendency to stay sion and anxiety and the relation-
in the dark areas during the maze ship to gastrointestinal disorders.
test. There has been a lot of speculation
The treated rats also exhibited linking autism to gastrointestinal
higher than normal levels of the disease.”
stress hormones corticosterone and Research regarding the link be-
corticotrophin as well as an in- tween the nervous and gastroin-
creased resting level of corti- testinal systems has opened up new
cotrophin-releasing factor (CRF), a realms of possibilities for novel
hormone linked with depression in treatments and approaches. Electri-
humans and other animals. cal modulation of the vagus nerve, a
According to Pasricha, the treat- method patented by Cyberonics,
ment interferes with the develop- has been approved by the Food and
ment of the central nervous system. Drug Administration to treat stimu-
The signaling from the gut to the lation for several years.
brain permanently changes its func- Pasricha alluded to other scien-
tion to induce anxiety and depres- tists who have proposed theories on
sion in the animals. this linkage.
Moreover, blocking the rats’ “Others have espoused theories
sense of perception with the addi- around this connection. Pierre Pal-
tion of a drug did not cause any sig- lardy, the French alternative thera-
nificant change in their behavior. pist, is certain that the roots of de-
This indicates that the treated rats pression lie in the stomach,” Pas-
were not responding to any current richa said.“In his 2007 book ‘Gut In-
pain. However, inhibiting the re- stinct:What Your Stomach Is Trying
lease of CRF dramatically reduced to Tell You,’ he outlines his belief in
depression- and anxiety-like behav- the power of the stomach to cause
ior, even in the rats that had initially or cure a wide range of physical and
experienced gastric irritation. mental ailments. Whether our re-
Having found the causal link in search validates this or not is open
the vagus nerve between the gut to question, but [it] certainly gives
and the nervous system, Pasricha is food for thought.”
now investigating the specific mech-
anisms that govern this phenome- Contact Jenny Thai at jthai1@stan-
non. ford.edu.
6 ! Tuesday, May 17, 2011 The Stanford Daily
SPORTS
TOURNEY ROMPS Wyndam
Makowsky
Between the lines
addition
fending national champion Stan- The result against Illinois Chica- freshman Nicole Gibbs, paired up
ford women’s tennis team, which University of Illinois-Chicago on go on Saturday was typical of the with junior Veronica Li. In singles,
recorded two shutouts to make it to Saturday before defeating No. 27 Cardinal’s performance all season, senior Jennifer Yen replaced Tan at
the second weekend of the tourna- Pepperdine on Sunday. but the players that achieved it the sixth spot. Gibbs and Li proved
ment. The Cardinal overwhelmed This year marks the 30th consec- were not. Stanford played without a dominating duo, recording an 8-0
I
win at the second spot. Stanford t was posed nearly as a light-
won the doubles point when senior hearted,throw-in question.Dur-
Hilary Barte and sophomore Mal- ing a conference call earlier this
lory Burdette recorded an 8-1 win month to discuss the Pac-12’s
at the top spot. new media deal,a reporter asked
“[Burdette] played probably the Director of Athletics Bob Bowlsby
best doubles I’ve ever seen her play whether the (vast) influx of new money
with me,” Barte said. would lead Stanford to consider
Head coach Lele Forood talked adding a 36th varsity sports team. His
about what in Burdette’s play has response suggested greater openness
made her better recently. to the idea than one might expect —
“She’s hitting touch shots and despite struggles with finances over the
tough volleys,” Forood said. “She’s past few years, he wasn’t entirely
hitting better overheads, and her against the idea.If anything,it sounded
game is coming together. She’s like something he’d at least like to ex-
doing more things well on the dou- plore.
bles court. She’s becoming an even “We’d have to think about it to
more versatile doubles player.” think about what we might add. No
No. 18 Nicole Gibbs lost just one plans for expansion, but it’s not out of
game on the way to a 6-0, 6-1 victo- the question.We’re more than meeting
ry over Ilinca Cristescu. Second off our gender equity requirements. We’d
the court was senior Carolyn be open-minded about it,”he said.
McVeigh, defeating Jana Knoppe The third sentence about “gender
6-2, 6-1. The clincher came at the equity”is code for “Stanford is meeting
top spot thanks to Barte. Ranked its Title IX obligations.” So if Bowlsby
third in the nation, Barte received a and co.get serious about adding anoth-
fight from her opponent, Mariya er team, allow me to propose a candi-
Kovaleva. Barte won just one game date:men’s lacrosse.
in the first set, but responded by It is not the most obvious choice.
winning 12 games in a row for a 1-6, The sport is largely concentrated on
6-0, 6-0 victory. the East Coast,and there is no Division
“I don’t know what was happen- I lacrosse team west of Colorado. Ele-
ing [in singles],” Barte said. “I was vating the sport to varsity status would
kind of low energy, and my concen- be a risk,but it’s one that should be con-
tration was all over the place.After sidered.
I lost the first set, she kind of settled While Stanford has a club team —
down, and I just got into my grove. and a very good one,at that — lacrosse
It was my first match in a while. It is one of the few sports the Athletic De-
was nice to play three sets though, partment sponsors that has a women’s
as weird as that sounds. It was nice squad but lacks a male counterpart.
to have a mental performance like This works in the men’s favor; for ex-
that.” ample,the playing field is already taken
Sunday’s fight against Pepper- care of — despite slightly different
dine proved to be a tougher con- field dimensions for the men’s and
test, but Stanford had Tan back in women’s game, Cagan Stadium is an
the lineup to help out. Tan, pairing entirely appropriate venue for the
up with McVeigh, won her doubles men’s team to use. Beyond that,
match 8-5 on court three. For the though, the success of the women’s
second day in a row, Barte and Bur- team — which just wrapped up its best
dette played well at the top spot to year to date — gives a rubric for the
win 8-5 and clinch the doubles men to follow. For example, with few
point. exceptions, the squad is made up al-
Li won Stanford’s next point most entirely of players from Mary-
when she walked off the court at land, New Jersey, Virginia and other
the fifth spot with a 6-1, 6-1 victory eastern states. The recruiting focus is
over Megan Moore. Barte earned appropriately national, and one future
her team-leading fourth point of consequence of the new media deal
the weekend with a 6-2, 6-1 victory that Bowlsby was most excited by was
against Arianna Colffer to put the the chance to continue to spread the
Cardinal one point away from the Stanford brand across the country.
second weekend. The win came With lacrosse, it’d be a symbiotic rela-
when Gibbs, recording her second tionship.
singles victory on the weekend, de- And indeed,the talent pools are in-
feated Ale Granillo 6-2, 6-3. creasing at dramatic rates.The number
“The thing with Nicole is that of high schoolers playing the sport has
she’s become kind of automatic this doubled in the past 10 years,according
year,” Forood said. “She just went to the National Federation of State
out and did what she does, which is High School Associations.While this is
dominate her opponents. She really still an East Coast phenomenon,it is no
SIMON WARBY/The Stanford Daily gets after it,gets on top of her oppo- longer exclusive to that region — par-
Freshman Nicole Gibbs volleys during one of her two singles wins on the weekend. Gibbs helped lead the No. ticipation has risen dramatically on the
1 Stanford women’s tennis team to shutout wins over Illinois-Chicago and Pepperdine in the NCAA Tournament. Please see WTENNIS, page 8 West Coast, too. Appropriately, more
universities are adding lacrosse pro-
grams.
But not on the Pacific Coast. At
SPORTS BRIEFS FAN FORUM least not yet. While the women can
compete in the Mountain Pacific
SAM SVOBODA ‘11 Sports Federation with other Pac-10
Women’s golf heads to Texas schools like Cal and Oregon, the men
S
NCAA Championships this week. costly expenditure.
After finishing fifth at the Pac-10 o here I am again,writing a sports column for The That said, the status quo may not
Championships, the Cardinal shot Daily, roughly three and a half years after my last last long. Stanford would not be the
908 at the Central Regional in sports column ran.When I was first asked to write only western school exploring the op-
South Bend, Ind., 18 strokes behind this Fan Forum, I’ll admit I was hesitant. But I fig- tion of adding men’s lacrosse, as USC
champion UCLA. This was one ured I couldn’t let my final quarter at Stanford be told LaxMagazine.com that it is con-
stroke ahead of Wake Forest for the only quarter that I didn’t contribute anything to The sidering adding the sport, too. A few
seventh place and five ahead of Daily’s sports section, right? more universities would be needed for
Duke for the final NCAA spot. The sports editor (incidentally, my first “protege” at a West Coast-based conference,but the
Sophomore Sally Watson led the The Daily, from our days covering the 2008 women’s soc- roots and developing interests are
Cardinal at eight-over for the tour- cer team) suggested writing about my experience with the there. As lacrosse continues to estab-
nament, followed by senior Rebec- hurling team here, which I helped found during my fresh- lish a foothold in youth leagues across
ca Durham, freshman Marissa Mar, man year four years ago. While this would certainly be a the West, it is only a matter of time be-
sophomore Kristina Wong and jun- new topic to most readers, I recently wrote a piece on the fore varsity teams at the collegiate level
ior Lila Barton. hurling team for Stanford’s new “Champions”website.I’m begin to pop up,too.
Texas A&M is hosting the na- sure a lot of Daily readers have not read that piece, but I Therein lies perhaps the most com-
tional championship at its Tradi- thought I could do something more worthwhile than sim- pelling argument for Stanford, which
tions Club. The favorites are No. 1 ply rewriting something I already wrote.And I didn’t want sees itself as a trendsetter in a number
USC, No. 2 UCLA and No. 3 Alaba- this final column to be all about me. (Funny, given that of fields. Lacrosse’s growth is difficult
ma, who won the West, Central and we’re already two paragraphs in and it is entirely about me to ignore,so why not jump ahead of the
East Regionals, respectively. No. 4 so far. Just bear with me.) pack? The University’s clout as both
Purdue is the defending champion My next thought was to write about the time I dominat- the top athletic and academic school in
after beating USC by one stroke ed Beatles Rock Band with Toby Gerhart, since I seem to Division I is tremendous,and by creat-
last year. tell everyone that story anyway — and who doesn’t love ing a hub for lacrosse on the West
The first round at the par-72 reading about Toby? But as life altering as that story would Coast, Bowlsby and other administra-
course will begin Wednesday at 6 Stanford Daily File Photo have been to readers, I decided against it. I also decided tors would be making a statement that
a.m., and the remaining three Sophomore Kristina Wong and the Stanford against writing about how my Chicago Bulls’ NBA Playoff says, “We think this sport is for real,
rounds will begin at 6 a.m. on Thurs- series against Miami is good vs. evil, because 1) it would be come join us as we further cement its
day, Friday and Saturday. women’s golf team placed seventh in the Central
place in collegiate athletics.” Recruits
Regional in South Bend, Ind. This earned the Car-
— Jacob Jaffe dinal a spot in this week’s NCAA Championships. Please see FAN FORUM, page 7 Please see MAKOWSKY, page 8
The Stanford Daily Tuesday, May 17, 2011 ! 7
CLASSIFIEDS
FOR RENT G E T NOTICED B Y
FOR RENT MenloPark 3BR/2.5bth. THOUSANDS.
4500$ 310-987-1957;shaunc1@stan-
ford.edu (650) 721-5803
SERVICES www.stanforddaily.
Got a deadline? Paper, thesis, applica- com/classifieds
tion? Contact Elizabeth Chapman,
PhD:Personal trainer for words. 650-
380-2466, deathlessprose@mac.com.
WANTED
$$ SPERM DONORS WANTED $$
Earn up to $1,200/month. Give the gift
of family through California Cryobank’s
donor program. Apply online:
SPERMBANK.com
FAN FORUM
through my time here. But I also
know I could have heeded my own
advice much more thoroughly.
Continued from page 6 There are still teams here that I
haven’t seen compete even once,
and while I’ve definitely been busy
rather tough to relate to Stanford through my four years here, I cer-
and 2) it’s obvious.I even considered tainly could have spent a little more
writing a football column simply to time supporting our teams.
try to get Ted Miller to link to my ar- So,after much rambling,I want to
ticle on the ESPN Pac-12 Blog, but use my farewell (slash comeback?)
those wouldn’t exactly be the no- column to give the same advice in
blest of journalistic intentions. my senior spring as I did in my fresh-
Finally, a topic came to me on man fall: take the opportunity to
Sunday night, through a combina- check out all the incredible teams
tion of factors. I read back through and student athletes we have here.
last week’s Fan Forum, in which Go support your athlete friends, but
Miles Bennett-Smith encouraged also go watch Cardinal teams you
people to take notice of the under- might not know anyone on. Follow
appreciated men’s volleyball team. the “big” sports like football, but
And earlier in the day, the Stanford also give the lesser-known sports a
women’s water polo team won the chance. Heck, go watch the club
national championship, reminding sports teams as well — honestly, we
me of my freshman year at The can use all the fans we can get.
Daily (that was the first team I was a This all might seem obvious, but I
beat writer for). guess I’m living proof that it’s not all
Given that I was writing a col- that easy to follow up on.In the end,I
umn, I also thought back to my guess my advice on Stanford sports is
freshman year column-writing,and I the same advice I would give as a sen-
realized that my first ever column ior about Stanford as a whole:take all
here was similar to Miles’, just on a the opportunities you can to enjoy
broader scale — it was encouraging and appreciate it, because it goes in-
people to take advantage of their credibly quickly. Now if you’ll excuse
opportunity to watch so many me, I’m going to go back to pretend-
world-class teams on the Farm. As ing I’m not graduating in 26 days.
my younger self put it, “You won’t
have the chance to see so many great Sam Svoboda is not only a lesser
teams for so little cost ever again.” Rock Band player than his editor,but
I look back on this article with his hypothetical friendship with Toby
mixed emotions. On one hand, I’m Gerhart isn’t nearly as well devel-
grateful that I got to see so many oped. Boast about your real athlete
great teams, athletes and games buddies at ssvoboda@stanford.edu.
8 ! Tuesday, May 17, 2011 The Stanford Daily
WTENNIS
Continued from page 6