Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Parr 2004
Parr 2004
383
# 2004 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
Abstract
This study provides an introduction to a microwave digestion technique for the extraction of fossil diatoms from
sediments. The microwave technique is compared with the standard diatom extraction technique of Battarbee
(Diatom analysis. In: Berglund B.E. (ed.), Handbook of Holocene Palaeoecology and Palaeohydrology. John
Wiley and Sons) that uses a combination of dilute hydrochloric acid and hydrogen peroxide and the advantages
and disadvantages of their use are discussed. The results suggest that the microwave technique is fast,
inexpensive and most importantly produces replicable fossil diatom assemblage data. Small samples sizes are
used (0.3 g) for the microwave method thus lower quantities of chemicals are required (6 ml), which significantly
decreases the cost of sample processing. Our results show that the microwave digestion technique is a viable
alternative that will produce similar results within a shorter period of time.
and mentioned in Dixit et al. (1999). Generally, Table 1. Sediment samples used for the comparative analysis
microwave sample preparation systems are used and their depth in cm.
to digest samples for isotope analysis of soils by Lake Hiawatha Tuckean Swamp
Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrome-
try (ICP/MS) and, element analysis by Atomic Sample Depth (cm) Sample Depth (cm)
Absorption Spectrometry (AAS) (Parr and lh1 0–1 ts1 0–1
Farrugia 2003). However, its potential use in lh2 6–7 ts2 10–12.5
microfossil extraction is gradually being realised lh3 13–14 ts3 20–22.5
and suitable protocols are being developed. For lh4 19–20 ts4 27.5–30
lh5 28–30 ts5 40–42.5
example, microwave digestion has been assessed lh6 38–40 ts6 50–52.5
for the retrieval of fossil pollen from geological
samples (Jones 1994) and has been successfully
used for the extraction of phytoliths from herbar-
ium specimens and sediments (Parr et al. 2001; Parr Lake Hiawatha is a fresh water dune contact
2002; Krull et al. 2003; Parr and Carter 2003; Parr water body located within Yuraygir National
and Farrugia 2003). Park (Timms 1982). It is a humic lake with low
Two types of microwave digestion systems are salinity, a dominance of Na+ and Cl ions and
available – focused and pressurised. Pressurised has a high pH (>7.0) (Timms 1982). Lake
microwave digestion differs in operation somewhat Hiawatha has an area of 316 ha, is 16.8 m asl and
to focused microwave digestion. This system com- has a maximum depth of 11 m (Timms 1969).
prises six to twelve pressurised vessels that require a Tuckean Swamp is a backwater of approxi-
relatively uniform sample weight, processing time mately 5000 ha of coastal floodplain on the lower
and temperature setting. However, chemical Richmond River near Broadwater in northern
combinations may be varied for each sample. The New South Wales. Prior to European influence,
basic advantages and disadvantages of pressurised Tuckean Swamp was linked tidally to the
microwave digestion in comparison to focused Richmond River by the Tuckean Broadwater and
microwave digestion have been outlined in detail was fed by freshwater runoff from the upper catch-
by Jones and Ellin (1998). One major criticism of ment. However, the Baggotville Barrage (com-
the pressurised microwave digestion systems has pleted in 1971) prevents tidal waters moving
been that they are limited to a very small sample upstream into the swamp to protect Tuckean
size of around 0.25 g (Jones 1994) and this is parti- Swamp’s grazing and agricultural areas from salt-
cularly critical if it affects the interpretation of water intrusion. The soils of Tuckean Swamp
microfossil assemblages. Therefore, to assess the include potential and actual acid sulphate soils
ability of the microwave technique for producing developed during the last Holocene.
diatom assemblage data it was compared with the The aim of this study was thus to determine if the
method of Battarbee (1986) using sediment samples microwave digestion method could produce com-
from two coastal swamps as a case study. parable diatom assemblage data to that of a
conventional method commonly used by diatom
Description of sites researchers.
(Battarbee 1986) and the microwave digestion system. For diatom extraction, the microwave
technique. sample preparation system was programmed to
The sediment of the Lake Hiawatha core was the following settings:
predominantly sand based with four distinct soil a. 8 min ramp up to a maximum of 120 C.
horizons. The surface horizon (0–14 cm) was com- b. 8 min digestion at 120 C.
posed of a highly organic silt material. The second c. 15 min cooling time.
horizon (14–30 cm) was composed of sandy silt The chemical component of the microwave
with a high organic component. Horizon three digestion protocol is one adapted from a standard
(30–40 cm) was predominantly sand material, Aqua Regia sample preparation technique used
with a high iron content. Horizon four (40–70 cm) in the Environmental Analysis Laboratory at
was a heavy orange clay with frequent grey/green Southern Cross University. Around 0.30-g por-
mottles. tions of sediment sample was weighed into Teflon
The sediment of the Tuckean Swamp sediment digestion tubes followed by 3 ml of concentrated
core had three distinct soil horizons and was nitric acid and 3 ml of concentrated hydrochloric
predominantly silt/clay based. Soil horizon one acid. The Teflon tubes were placed into microwave
(0–5 cm) was a silty loam with a high organic bombs and processed for 31 min. After viewing
component. Horizon two (5–20 cm) was a silty the sample and determining the size fraction of
clay and horizon three (20–55 cm) was a heavy, the diatom frustules, samples were washed through
organic clay. 300 and 5 m filters simultaneously collecting the
diatom fraction. The sample was then suspended in
Conventional digestion technique high-grade ethanol and stored in a vial, ready for
mounting. Mounting of the cleaned diatoms was
Following the conventional (c) digestion procedure conducted using 700 m of sample, allowed to dry
of Battarbee (1986) approximately 0.3 g of sedi- on a coverslip and mounted using the mounting
ment material was weighed into a beaker and 10% medium Depex.
hydrochloric acid was added. The beaker was
placed on a hot plate, simmering, for approxi-
mately three 3 hours (until effervescence ceased) Microscopy and counting assemblages
in order to remove the carbonates from the sample.
The samples were then thoroughly rinsed with dis- Diatom slides were examined under a microscope
tilled water three times to remove solutes. At all at 1000 magnification. Diatoms were identified
stages, the material was left to settle for at least 6 h using Krammer and Lange-Bertelot (1991a, b,
before the supernatant was decanted. The samples 1997a, b). Around 300 diatom frustules were
were then resuspended in 10% hydrogen peroxide counted for each slide along random transects.
in order to remove the organic material, simmer- The relative abundance of each species was
ing, for approximately 3 hours. Following cleaning calculated. Diatom species with <2% relative
the material was allowed to settle. The supernatant abundance were discarded from the analysis.
was then removed, and the sample washed three
times (as above). The sample was then resuspended
in high-grade ethanol and stored in a vial, ready for Statistical analysis
mounting. Mounting of the cleaned diatoms was
conducted using 700 m of sample. The sample was Statistical analysis was carried out using multidi-
allowed to dry on a coverslip and mounted using mensional scaling (MDS; Young and Householder
the mounting medium Depex. 1938; Coxon and Davies 1982; Borg and Groenen
1997) with SPSS software. Dissimilarities between
Microwave digestion pairs of diatom assemblages were calculated as 2
measures over their diatom frequency profiles
A Perkin–Elmer, Multiwave Microwave Sample for each species. These were plotted into a two-
Preparation System was used in this study. The dimensional space to display the dissimilarities
microwave is controlled by an in-built computer between variables as Euclidean distances.
386
Figure 1. Summary plots for MDS analysis of Lake Hiawatha showing 0.93 of total variance and differences between the lh3 and lh6
samples of each method.
Figure 2. Summary plots for MDS analysis of Tuckean Swamp showing 0.99 of total variance and the close relationship of diatom
assemblages from both methods.
The results show that processing by the micro- Finally, the digested component of the residue is
wave digestion technique is faster than the con- suitable for analysis by ICP/MS or AAS for the
ventional method for extracting diatoms from interpretation of environmental and sedimentary
sediments. There are fewer steps in the microwave changes over time (Parr and Farrugia 2003). The
digestion protocol, thus limiting the opportunity main disadvantage of the microwave digestion pro-
for accidents and contamination of samples during tocol is that the initial outlay for the system is
processing. Samples do not need monitoring dur- expensive. Although, many universities and com-
ing digestion, freeing up time for the operator to mercial laboratories involved in the chemical anal-
pursue other tasks. Importantly, smaller quantities ysis sediments already have these systems as
of chemicals are required for diatom extraction standard preparation equipment by ICP/MS and
making it a significantly cheaper process to use. AAS.
389
Parr J.F. 2002. A comparison of heavy liquid floatation and lakes: a diatom-based model for water quality reconstruc-
microwave digestion techniques for the extraction of fossil tions. J. Paleolim. 25: 25–42.
phytoliths from sediments. Rev. Paleobot. Palynol. 120(3–4): Reavie E.D., Smol J.P., Carignan R. and Lorrain S. 1998.
315–336. Diatom palaeolimnology of two fluvial lakes in the St
Parr J.F. and Carter M. 2003. Phytolith and starch analysis of Lawrence River: a reconstruction of environmental changes
sediment samples from two archaeological sites on Dauar during the last century. J. Phycol. 34: 446–456.
Island, Torres Strait. Veg. Hist. Archaeobot. 12(2): 131–141. Renberg I. 1990. A procedure for preparing large sets of diatom
Parr J.F., Dolic V., Lancaster G. and Boyd W.E. 2001. A micro- slides from sediment cores. J. Paleolim. 4: 87–90.
wave digestion method for the extraction of phytoliths from Timms B.V. 1969. A preliminary limnological survey of the
herbarium specimens. Rev. Paleobot. Palynol. 116: 203–212. Wooli Lakes, New South Wales. Proc. Linnean Soc. of New
Parr J.F. and Farrugia K. 2003. Waste reduction and value South Wales 94: 105–112.
adding during fossil phytolith extraction and palaeo- Timms B.V. 1982. Coastal dune waterbodies of North-eastern
environmental analysis of volcanic sediments from West New South Wales. Aust. J. Mar. Freshw. Res. 33: 203–222.
New Britain, Papua New Guinea, using microwave digestion Wilson S., Cumming B.F. and Smol J.P. 1996. Assessing the
and ICPMS. In: Wallace L. and Hart D. (eds), vol. 15, reliability of salinity inference models from diatom assem-
Conference: The State of the Art in Phytolith and Starch blages: an examination of a 219-lake data set from western
Research, in the Australian-Pacific-Asian regions, Pandanus North America. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 53: 1580–1594.
Press, Canberra, terra australis, pp. 19–30. Young G.W. and Householder A.S. 1938. Discussion of a
Reavie E.D. and Smol J.P. 2001. Diatom-environmental set of points in terms of their distances. Psychometrica 1:
relationships in 64 alkaline southeastern Ontario (Canada) 19–22.