Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment For Establishment of Ministry of Construction and Housing Iraq Housing Information and Training Center
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment For Establishment of Ministry of Construction and Housing Iraq Housing Information and Training Center
ACRONYMS
ESCWA Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia
IHITC Iraq Housing Information and Training Center
JICA Japanese International Cooperation Agency
MMPW Ministry of Municipalities and Public Works
MoCH Ministry of Construction and Housing
MMPW Ministry of Municipalities and Public Works
MoB Mayoralty of Baghdad
MoJ Ministry of Justice
MoPDC Ministry of Planning and Development Cooperation
MWR Ministry of Water Resources
MoE Ministry of Electricity
SoE State-Owned Enterprises
USAID United States Agency for International Development
2
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
FORWARD
Given that Iraq suffers from a huge shortage in the housing sector, the government is
attempting to build 1,27 million housing units by 2010 through the public and private sectors
since both possess broad construction skills but need to develop and speed up their
activities to achieve that goal. Hence, special importance should be attached to topics such
as reformulating the housing sector policy, institutional change, capacity-building and other.
The modernization process underway in the housing sector is closely linked to developing
decentralization and privatization policy and participation of public bodies concerned. The
successfulness and effectiveness of this modernization process is directly connected with
training and capacity- building, based on which the Iraqi government signed agreements
with international donors in order to enhance its capacity and that of its institutions to deal
with the private sector in order to improve the standard of housing and consequently raising
living standard of the Iraqi people.
Hence, UN-HABITAT undertook the responsibility of laying the ground for enhancing the
capacity of the Iraqi housing sector focusing on institutional development and training in
various fields such as funding of housing, planning, housing development planning,
improvement and maintenance of housing areas, infrastructure planning, participation of
bodies concerned in the housing sector, in addition to the methods and techniques of
geographical information systems in terms of housing and services development.
Over the years, the government was the provider of almost all goods and services and the
creator of suitable job opportunities for citizens. MoCH and its institutions and companies are
employing over 24000 persons in this country. A survey of the housing sector in Iraq
conducted in 2006 showed that 90% of home owners built their homes by using their own
savings or by borrowing money from friends and relatives/employers. These homes were
mostly built by small contractors who showed flexibility in dealing with the local communities
to build new housing units or renovating and expanding old ones.
Thus raising performance level of this category of contractors represents the main challenge
facing the housing sector, which requires making a change in the attitude and management
of the government and its institutions to encourage and develop the private sector.
Challenges
MoCH has asked UN-HABITAT to assist in establishing a center for knowledge and training
to undertake enhancing the technical and administrative capacity of the housing sector in
Iraq. The Iraqi Training and Knowledge Centre for Housing shall be the stimulating tool to
enhance the capacity of MoCH, its institutions & companies, other ministries, the private
sector, universities and NGOs concerned to work together to achieve the goal of building
1,27 million housing units by 2010.
It is expected that the housing sector will emerge as an investment activity in order to be
organized and oriented and not just a sector concerned with executing government projects.
This shall require a change in MoCH role in order to cooperate with the financial services
sector, construction and housing sector and national, regional and international private
investors.
Knowledge management is based on dealing with knowledge as being an important and
basic element in creating a supporting and consolidating environment to exchange expertise
between the parties committed and interested in achieving the objectives of their institution
or sector. Therefore, knowledge should be organized and available in order to be utilized by
the parties responsible upon decision-making.
The current study prepared by UN-HABITAT consultants IdRC includes a workplan
proposed for the Iraqi Center for Housing, where UN-HABITAT consultants (via its
engineering work team in Baghdad) collected information through field visits conducted to
3
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
MoCH and its institutions and companies, and also to some ministries as well as government
and private institutions concerned inside Iraq.
UN-HABITAT consultants in Amman also met some Iraqi officials from the ministries
concerned and met also with some private companies and representatives of some Iraqi
government institutions and universities. Moreover, a comparative study of similar
knowledge centers in other countries was conducted in order to obtain the best possible
means that ensure the successfulness of the proposed workplan.
The draft of this study has been prepared to be presented to MoCH as a basis for the
anticipated workshop in Amman where results and key proposals shall be discussed. The
final report shall be prepared after the workshop.
UN-HABITAT under the strengthening of the Housing Sector Project phase two will assist
MoCH in its initial steps towards establishing a functional centre. Due to limited resources of
the project, further support steps will be needed and pledges for support is required.
4
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
TABLE OF CONTENTS
5
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
ANNEXES
6
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
1.0 INTRODUCTION
Abundant natural and human resources enabled Iraq to attain the status of a middle income
country in the 1970s. The country developed good infrastructure, and the education and
health care systems were widely regarded as the best in the Middle East. Since then,
successive wars, international sanctions and a repressive, state-dominated economic
system have stifled economic growth and development and debilitated basic infrastructure
and social services.
Despite the country's rich resource endowment, Iraq's human development indicators are
now among the lowest in the region. The Iraqi population faces serious challenges re-
working fundamental aspects of its governance, political decision making and economic
development.
Developments in the housing sector reconstruction are closely related to policy reform for
decentralization, privatization and public/stakeholders participation. The success and
effectiveness of such reform is directly tied to training and capacity building. This involves
upgrading the skills of officials and civil servants working in local, public administration,
introducing practices of partnership and participation with the private and non governmental
sector, and providing appropriate mechanisms of exchange with neighboring countries and
the international community.
UN-Habitat’s “Strengthening the Capacity of the Housing Sector in Iraq” addressed this
issue and focused on institutional development and training in various related areas
including housing finance, housing development planning and management, housing areas
improvement and maintenance, planning for infrastructure and housing, CBOs and
stakeholders participation in housing, and GIS tools and techniques for housing and
services.
In response to a request by the Ministry of Construction and Housing (MoCH), and based on
a rapid needs assessment conducted at the start of the abovementioned project, a total of
26 training workshops were held inside and outside Iraq. The training provided a good
introduction to a variety of subjects as outlined in Section 4.1 below. There remains,
however, a significant need to improve the capacities of the Ministry’s staff and that of other
relevant stakeholders for this purpose.
The main objective for this assignment is to develop the tools that would assist the Iraqi
Ministry of Housing and Construction in the establishment of a center of excellence offering
training and knowledge management in the housing and urban development sector. The
provided assistance will be in a form that would enable the Iraqi government to establish a
center that is sustainable, be a focal point in the reform of housing policy in Iraq, provide
technical assistance to decision makers, and possibly be replicated in other ministries or
regions in a decentralized fashion.
The study at hand aims to address various issues regarding the establishment of the Iraq
Housing Information and Training Center (IHITC) which would take a lead role in
promoting and supporting sectoral reform. The study develops a participatory, multi-
stakeholder structure, management and planning for the proposed center.
This study also addresses the training and capacity building that have been conducted to
date by Habitat and other donors and identifies the needs to catalyze and maximize the
impacts and effects of such training in a sustainable manner.
The specific tasks were to:
1. Conduct literature review of relevant documents
2. Conduct an assessment of Iraqi Ministry and Construction and Housing to develop a
clear understanding of the Ministry’s structure, its mission, capacity and capability, and
needs both from a physical and technical context.
7
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
8
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
communicated on a daily basis to direct all the data collection efforts including the design of
a survey tool and structured interview forms.
The main tasks and activities undertaken by the IdRC technical team to meet the objectives
of the assessment at hand are described below.
1. Desk review – of previous UN Habitat training programs, other related training and
capacity building programs, reports on the Iraq Housing Sector, international housing and
building centers
2. Training and Institutional Assessment conducted simultaneously. In-depth
interviews of senior officials in MoCH, state-owned companies and commissions, as well as
other governmental and non-governmental agencies whose work impacts housing provision.
These interviews also addressed training needs, both through an analysis of previous UN
Habitat training and of current and future tasks and responsibilities of officials.
Interviews in Baghdad were supplemented by a series of meetings in Amman with
government and private sector officials, as well as participation the Housing Market Survey
Conference.
This final report is based on comments from UN Habitat, and from the
recommendations of the MoCH Committee established to “Study Establishment of
Information & Training Center for Iraq Ministry of Construction and Housing. As noted
by the Committee, there is still a need for a final workshop to define the specific
organizational set-up, roles and responsibilities of the Center within the Information
Technology Directorate.
1.2 Report Outline
The format of the report is as follows:
• Section 1 – Introduction
• Section 2 – The Current Situation – an overview of the Iraqi housing sector,
government policies and strategies, and donor input in the sector
• Section 3 – International Best Practices – outlining international best
practices in training, knowledge management, and a review of international models of
housing and construction knowledge and training centers
• Section 4 – Institutional and Training Needs Assessment, a detailed review of
the previous Habitat training, main institutions involved in housing, their roles and
responsibilities, their capacity building needs, and a review of training needs for the housing
and construction sector
• Section 5 – Business Plan for the Knowledge and Training Center, including
vision, mission, functions, target groups, legal and regulatory framework, communications
and marketing plan, capacity building plan, budget and financing, and short and long-term
action plans
9
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
10
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
The UN Habitat/IFC funded Housing Market Survey determined in late 2006 that there is a
need for 1.27 million new housing units. The goal is to build these by 2010 – approximately
900 housing units built daily from now until the end of 2010.
The Ministry of Construction and Housing has overall responsibility for the housing sector in
Iraq, but is also dependent on other ministries for planning, financing, and development of
infrastructure. Despite 24,000 employees in MoCH and its subsidiaries, 80-90 % of housing
since 1982 has been produced by produced by private sector, small scale contractors. The
main challenge is to scale up, so small contractors can be developers. This needs legislative
and regulatory support from MoCH.
The government has historically been the provider of almost all goods and services, and the
Ministry of Construction and Housing and its state-owned enterprises and commissions
employ 24,000 people nationwide. Management of MoCH activities, like all in Iraq, has a
highly centralized bureaucracy and government control. The Housing Market Survey showed
that 90% of households have built their houses independently using their own savings or
borrowing money from friends, relatives and/or employers.
Housing finance is also in a state of crisis. The Real Estate Bank, originally established to
provided funding for individual houses, is completely ineffective. The National Housing Fund,
established recently to improve the situation, has not fared much better. Banks do not want
to lend to individuals for housing, due the uncertain economic, political and security situation.
There are no large-scale private developers outside of Kurdistan. Small scale builders
construct most of the homes, and are adequately flexible to work on new housing,
extensions, renovations. The major challenge facing the sector is helping these contractors
reach the necessary scale of operations to meet housing demand. This also requires a
change in government attitude and management in order to encourage private sector
development.
Overall, a measured by UN-Habitat Key indicator 6, only 50% of households in Iraq are
connected to basic services such as electricity and water.
Other key bottlenecks as identified by the housing survey include:
• Lack of adequate institutional, human, financial and material resources
• Competition from other sectors for same resources
• Increased housing deficit and substandard living conditions
• Decreased housing affordability
• Construction of poor and substandard housing
• Infrastructure provision unable to guide urban development
• Institutions unable to guide private sector development
• Poor understanding or respect for building regulations…
The Housing Market survey recommended the following key policy guidelines:
• Finance – micro-finance, mortgage and construction financing
• Building materials and public sector professionals – increasing availability and reduce
costs of building materials, develop building skills
• Planning and land management – identify suitable land, prioritize upgrading of
partially serviced land
• Legal, institutional, policy framework for private sector housing – develop complete
framework, and gear institutional framework to support
11
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
12
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
The overall goal is to meet the Millennium Development Goal of providing housing to 90% of
Iraqis.
Specific activities proposed in the International Compact to reach these goals include:
• Establishing sector and inter-ministerial working groups – policy guidelines for
planners
• Building research and information management capacity within the Iraqi line
Ministries in support of policymaking function
• Streamlining and improve donor coordination and implementation
• Introducing Iraqi co-funding and cost sharing
Specific targets in the Joint Monitoring Mechanism include:
• Establishing the public procurement Law (2007), implement 2008 – involve private
sector in this – regulations and national competitive bidding process
• 2009 – using e-procurement for most public sector transactions
• Conducting training programs for public procurement for public servants and the
private sector
• 2007 - training to educate policymakers, administrative and law enforcement
personnel and public about rights of civil society
• Supporting civil service reform
• Privatization of state-owned enterprises, changing government’s role to a policy,
planning and regulatory role
• Formulate and adopt National Housing and Land Management Policy and address
norms and standards, construction standards (2007)
• MOCH to operationalize Housing Market Information System at national and sub-
national level (2007)
• Restructure the Iraq Housing is expected to emerge as an investment activity to be
Housing Fund and regulated, encouraged and guided, not just government
disburse loans to at least expenditure and implementation. This requires a change in the
10,000 poor and low role of MoCH to coordinate and cooperate with the financial
income households (2007) service sector, the building and construction sector and individual
private investors—national, regional and international.
These are ambitious and
daunting goals, especially
given the current security circumstances in Iraq.
Housing is a basic human right. UN Habitat’s agenda worldwide is to ensure this basic
human right is fulfilled for all. There are 15 UN agencies working in Iraq helping Iraq to meet
Millennium Development Goals, many of which relate to housing. UN Habitat has taken the
leading role within the UN system in the housing sector and has conducted a range of
activities at policy and project level to improve access to housing for Iraqis UN Habitat has
helped to organize the National Committee for Habitat in Iraq, which links the various
governmental agencies within Iraq working in the housing sector..
2.2 UN Habitat and other Donor Housing Assistance
The Habitat activity, Strengthening the Capacity of the Housing Sector in Iraq, focused
on providing wide-ranging training activities (reviewed in Section 4.1 below), produced a
working paper on housing finance strategy and supported the above-mentioned Housing
Market Survey. In 2006, the project supported the following activities:
13
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
14
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
and one for a proposal pending to provide support to the Building Research Center in
MoCH.
USAID is funding the National Capacity Development Project which will focus on core public
administration functions: fiscal management, personnel management and administration,
leadership/communications, strategic planning, information technology, and technical skills.
A key source of management knowledge will come in the form of public-private alliances,
which will leverage human, financial, and technological resources and will be based on
USAID’s Global Development Alliance (GDA)1 model. USAID also funds major infrastructure
projects.
UNDP is providing training to the MMPW to support decentralization and municipal capacity
building.
In 2005 the Japanese International Cooperation Agency (JICA) commissioned an
assessment of 12 vital sectors of the Iraqi economy to determine the gaps and needs for
capacity building and develop a comprehensive capacity building program. The JICA
Survey on Capacity Development for Iraq Re-Construction was carried out in Iraq and
Jordan to assess the status and requirements for the sector.
The Construction sector was included in this study because it supports a vital component in
the life of the Iraqi population which is housing. The survey reported that a major role of the
government will need to address the housing shortage through both, continuing a policy of
helping to secure housing through the implementation of large scale housing projects and
through the establishment of an adequate environment that would promote the propagation
of the housing development projects on private sector and cost effective basis.
The study also reported that the Iraqi MoCH major support to cope with and administer the
development required to meet current and anticipated demand, particularly given their
limited experience in administering this particular sector under the rules and forces of free
economy and in attracting foreign investment. A number of gaps were reported in the
current capabilities of the institution. Many expressed needs seemed properly focused on
core construction related issues such as tendering, project management and building
technology and standards. Strong and numerous needs were also expressed in operational
issues with heavy emphasis on information technology, a trend characteristic of all
government institutions after many years of isolation resulting in massive degradation of
operational capabilities and ability to utilize and implement modern technology and
management practices. The main areas of key interest to support the development of the
Iraqi Construction sector and its intuitions were identified and ranked in accordance to
urgency and specificity. Those included the following:
• Contracting and Procurement
• Operations
• Urban Planning
• Regulating
• Policy and Planning
• Technical Skills and Technology
• Human resources
• Organizational
• Coordination with External Parties
1
http://www.usaid.gov/our_work/global_partnerships/gda/businessmodel.htm.
15
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
2.3 Completed Training under UN Habitat Strengthening the Capacity of the Housing
Sector in Iraq
The UN-HABITAT training program consisted of a series of workshops, and study tours,
most of which took place outside of Iraq. Eight GIS courses were given in Baghdad. The
courses covered a variety of topics covering urban planning, community mobilization, private
sector participation and specific technical subjects such as private sector participation in
water and sanitation management (see Annex 3 for full listing).
According to the training materials and evaluations, training focused on active participation
of trainees, including field visits and hands-on group work. Most evaluations from trainees
during the training, and those met during the needs assessment, were positive about the
content of the training. However, when most of them returned to Baghdad, they found it
hard to follow up on their work due to lack of resources such as access to internet,
references, colleagues who understood what they had learned, and the general security
situation which makes it hard to plan and start anything new.
According to interviewees with some of the trainees, the exposure to international best
practices was useful for all participants in training courses, most of whom took active part in
the training.
The review of training evaluations and interviews with trainees provided some insights into
how future training could be improved. Recommendations are:
• More examples from Iraq should be used in the training. The trainers must be familiar
with the Iraqi situation and be able to help trainees assess how they can use the
tools they have learned in their jobs, given the difficult situation.
• There should be follow up to the training to support trainees in their daily work.
Given the limited exposure most Iraqis have had to Internet, research, connection
with trends and ideas outside of Iraq, it is very important that they have follow-up to
their training through on-going contact with trainers.
• On the GIS training, more emphasis should be given on how to use GIS, how to use
the information obtained from GIS to assist with decision making – not just the
mechanics of GIS. The training itself was considered good by trainees, some of who
are now using new methods of data processing. However, due to limited skills or
equipment, it is not always easy for them to use what they have learned.
• Trainee selection must be done carefully in order to ensure that the right people are
chosen who will really benefit from it and whose organization will therefore benefit.
• Certain core concepts such as private sector participation, strategic planning,
community participation, should be included in all training courses.
• Innovative training methods should be included in a new program, including more on-
the-job training, online contact between trainees on their jobs and trainers in Iraq or
overseas, peer learning (pairing trainees with a mentor from a similar institution).
• English training for more professional personnel will make international training more
accessible. At this time, only those who have good English can go to most
international training courses, which means the most appropriate trainees are not
always selected.
• Training should be participatory and directly relevant to the work situation of trainees.
• Study tours and training courses should include a daily, end of day evaluation and
review of what was learned, and tasks for the next day.
• Training providers outside of Iraq should be required to produce case studies from
the Arab world Iraq.
16
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
17
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
A simple example is when a landowner decides to build a house and needs to choose a
contractor. He can find a list of building contractors -- that is explicit knowledge. It is hard
data, information. He talks to his friends and colleagues to learn from their personal
experience who is a good contractor and who is not. He built a new kitchen a few years ago,
and had experience with one contractor, so feels he knows what to look for in a contractor.
This is implicit knowledge. He is combining the facts (explicit knowledge) – with his own
experience and that of his friends (implicit knowledge) and makes a final decision.
We make numerous decisions in our
personal and professional lives. Knowledge Management is a conscious strategy
Everyone in the housing and of getting the right knowledge to the right people
construction sector, from the day at the right tie and helping share and put
laborer to the Minister, makes information into action in ways that strive to
improve organizational and sector performance.
decisions based on his explicit and
It includes:
implicit knowledge. In the absence of Creating Knowledge
any explicit knowledge, any hard data, Capturing Knowledge
we make our decisions based on our Storing knowledge
discussions with colleagues, our Sharing knowledge
instincts and our experience.
The purpose of a Knowledge Center is to create knowledge, to provide more data and
information in a form which can be used to help people make decisions. The Knowledge
Center does not create all of the knowledge, but it knows where to find it. Once the
knowledge is created, it captures it by documenting it in a usable form (such as reports,
databases). Then it stores the information. Most importantly, a Knowledge Center shares
information. There are numerous examples of massive data collection exercises where data
18
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
was collected and stored, sometimes even analyzed, but never used to support decision
making.
Knowledge Management supports training by providing access to information and
resources on a particular topic. It also encourages personal connection through
“communities of practice” where people with similar professional interests connect through
Internet, direct meetings and other means. This helps to share the implicit knowledge, so
that people do not need to rely on data, or waste time sifting through reams of information
when they may find an individual who has had a similar experience.
Knowledge must be used. Even the World Bank, which developed an award-winning
Knowledge Management network, found in an internal evaluation that they needed to embed
knowledge sharing into its core business processes to ensure that it was being used to
support their results-oriented framework – not just for the sake of sharing knowledge.
The MoCH, its related entities and other stakeholders in the housing and construction sector
have many challenges ahead. Their future role will be changing from a service provider to
one of policy, planning and regulation of the sector. They need to update the practical skills
and tools they have to implement familiar activities such as housing construction and road
building. They need to learn about and implement new concepts such as private sector
participation, public-private partnership, community participation and broad-based strategic
planning.
Most of all, they need exposure, they need stimulation, they need access to information
which can help them make decisions. They need a center for this information; they need a
center for learning, a center for sharing ideas.
Knowledge Management is about seeing knowledge as a valuable asset and creating a
climate that taps into and supports the exchange of knowledge among those committed to
achieving the goals of the organization and/or sector.
Knowledge is not just a bunch of facts, a series of reports, files full of data. Knowledge is a
combination of hard data, information from other sources, and our own personal experience
that we use to – make decisions.
An effective Knowledge Center will:
• Tap all existing of knowledge (data, reports, individual expertise) before starting to
create additional knowledge
• Promote a culture of information sharing and learning – a culture where everyone
recognizes that knowledge sharing makes them stronger and more competent in
their work
A successful Knowledge Center has:
• Clear, realistic goals and objectives (do not aim to do too much too early)
• Strong support from senior management
• A solid legal and regulatory framework to support it even if there are senior
management changes
• A high level and senior position in the hierarchy or full independence (i.e., reporting
directly to a government deputy or minister, or fully independent from government)
• Resources – a commitment from its “mother organization” for regular resource
allocation
• Strong links with all levels and departments in an organization
• Where appropriate, strong links with stakeholders outside of an organization
19
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
• A dynamic Director and staff who understands the need for outreach and networking.
The Director does not need to be an expert in the topic, s/he has to be a
communicator, open to ideas, open to learning, open to communicating with all levels
of the organization and its clients
• Easy access to information for users of the Center
Knowledge and Training Centers are often
KM Success Stories
combined in order to take advantage of the
integration of knowledge management to Ford Motor Company claims US$750 million cumulative
support training. Also, a Knowledge Center savings over five years by transferring best practice
can be the catalyst for learning by knowledge across its large base of assembly plants. There
were many lessons that were learned by Ford that are now
encouraging staff of an organization to part of the KM Body of Knowledge.
come to it (physically or via Intranet links) to
obtain information to help them make better British Petroleum claims US$80 million savings per year
decisions in their work. A Knowledge and on oilfield development costs attributable to learning
Training Center includes a documentation before, during, and after major projects. These techniques
are now well documented, proven, and readily emulated by
center with easy document retrieval. A knowledgeable KM practitioners.
Knowledge Center is the catalyst for
learning, not always the exact location of
learning.
In this report, the Knowledge and Training Center for MoCH is referred to as the Iraq
Housing Information and Training Center.
In this section, a number of Knowledge Centers relevant to the housing sector were
reviewed in order to:
1. Illustrate the potential roles and activities of such a Center
2. Identify best practices in knowledge management for the housing and construction
sector
3. Identify potential partners for the Iraq Housing Information and Training Center
It should be mentioned that that review was not restricted to centers per se, it also included
governmental entities in the housing sector that follow certain practices that cold be
implemented in the center under study.
3.2 International Models of Knowledge and Training Centers
The main purpose of this task was to conduct an extensive review of housing sector centers
of excellence, research and training. The purpose of the review was to help the MoCH
IHITC formulate its mission statement and objectives. The scope of the review covered
centers in developing countries and in developed countries. The review of centers in
developing countries was conducted in a manner that identifies replicability and applicable
lessons that are pertinent to the case at hand (i.e., the Iraqi Housing Sector). The following
information on such centers was gathered through desk research and correspondence:
• Mission statements for various centers (e.g., Research, Education, Outreach)
• Targeted beneficiaries
• Technical services offered
• Staffing and Organization
• Resources
• International cooperation, and
• Financing
20
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
Descriptions of the mapped entities that were found relevant to the case at hand are
presented in this section, while descriptions of additional centers that were mapped are
presented in the Annex. The centers presented in the Annex are somewhat of a different
nature, however, parts of their scopes of services could be applied to the proposed center in
Iraq in the medium to the long term horizon
The main centers/entities that were mapped are as follows:
Developing Countries
21
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
A presidential decree was issued in 2005 for the reformulation of the Housing and Building
Research Center as The Housing and Building National Research Center with the following
main goals
• Coordination between the research efforts in the field of building industry
• Deploying of knowledge in the field of housing and building
• Satisfying more effective and economical buildings
• Developing the methods of construction
• Assisting in the development of the engineering field
• Applying construction codes and regulations
Activities
The HBRC performs eight main areas of research through different departments as
summarized in Table 3-1. The center also includes training center, Information center, and
Information technology and network department as presented in the following section.
22
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
Organization
The center is overseen by the Minister of Housing, Utilities and Urban Development. It is
managed by a board chaired by the Chairman of the Center and the following
memberships:
• Three administrative members from the center
• Eight technical members of the center (mainly the heads of the various research
departments).
• Members from outside organizations including
o Arab Contractors Company
o Central construction agency
o Universities
o Ministry of Housing Utilities and Urban Development
o Academy of the Scientific Research and Technology
o Ministry of Planning
o Ministry of Administration Development
o Ministry of Local Development
o Ministry of Religious Affairs (Al-Awkaf )
Research is conducted through 11 scientific institutes that employ 131 research staff,
including 81 assistant staff with backgrounds in civil engineering, architecture, urban
planning, geology, chemistry, electrical engineering, and building physics. There is a total of
649 employees in the center.
HBRC has 8 different laboratories equipped with up-to-date technologies which serve
building industry. The available labs are: strength of materials and quality control; raw
materials and processing; building physics; acoustics; reinforced concrete; field
measurements for structures and steel bridges; soil mechanics and foundations; and
sanitary and environmental engineering.
It is also host to a library aimed at providing sources of information, both national and
international, and makes them available to all users whether from HBRC or not. The library
uses the CDS/ISIS international system to build its database which includes the entire library
collection
23
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
More importantly, the Center has an Information Technology Network and an Information
Center to support the building sector, its organizations, companies and manufactures. This
is done through provision of updated data and analysis, with a scientific basis for decision
making. The information center is intended to link the HBRC with other local and
international information networks. Besides its database function, the computer facilities of
the information center are used for advanced analysis by HBRC staff, and to process HBRC
publications
In 1999, The Urban Training & Studies Institute was formed as a quasi-private organization
affiliated to the Housing and Building Research Center – HBRC via an Egyptian –
Netherlands Development Co-operation Program. The mission of UTI is to strengthen
institutional and human resources capacities that can nurture the improvement of the living
and environmental conditions of cities in Egypt and the Middle East. UTI has become
training and capacity building institution specialized in post-graduate and tailor-made
training, policy research and technical advisory services. It focuses on urban management &
planning, housing & real estate development policies, informal settlement upgrading and
urban renewal, urban environmental planning and management, infrastructure management
and urban finance, as well as the utilization of GIS systems in urban development. It is this
component of the HBNRC that is most relevant to the proposed center in Iraq. It is believed
that the model of this training entity can be replicated in Iraq at a smaller scale in the initial
stages that can be expanded in the future.
International Cooperation
HBNRC has partnerships and cooperation programs with a number of international
organizations including
• Institute for Housing and Urban Development Studies (IHS), Netherlands
• Environmental Impact Assessment Center (EIA), University of Manchester, UK
• School of Architecture, Planning and Landscape, University of New Castle, UK
• University of London and University of Oxford and sponsored by DFID , UK
• Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA) in the field of training and joint
research.
• Building Scientific and Technology Center, Paris (France)
Financing
The center is very largely financed through the annual governmental fund and substantial
resources are also drawn from, the construction industry for work done at the organization.
Another source of finance is the joint research work done with foreign agencies such as
UNESCO, and domestic research agencies such as the Egyptian Academy for Scientific
Research and Technology.
3.2.2 Human Settlement Management Institute (HMSI)-India
Mission
HSMI is an institute that was established by Indian Housing and Urban Development
Corporation HUDCO in 1985. It was established with initial support from the Institute of
Housing and Urban Development Studies (IHS), Rotterdam, the Netherlands.
It focuses on the development of conceptual and practical knowledge in the fields of
Housing, Housing Finance; Urban Infrastructure, Planning and Management, Urban
Finance, Transport and other urban issues pertaining to utility, social and commercial
infrastructure. It main activities can be summarized as follows:
• Training and education in these fields, especially for professionals from State Housing
Boards, Water Supply and Sewerage Boards, Urban Development authorities, Municipal
24
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
Area Description
HSMI conducts national and international level Policy Seminars for the senior level professionals and
administrators. These seminars are related with the challenges confronting the urban governance.
Seminars are also conducted for validation of research studies conducted by the Institute and on the
Training Strategies.
HSMI Training Programmes are divided into three categories:
• External: for all the professionals related to the field of human settlement and infrastructure- urban
Training and rural. These programmes train these professionals in various areas and fields of human
settlement, bringing into use the latest practices and applications.
• In-house: HUDCO's own employees. These programmes are under two broad categories I) Induction
Programmes: For the young professionals at the time of their recruitment II) Orientation Programmes:
For the Executives and the the Non-Executives.
Sponsored research including action-oriented research on subjects related to housing, urban development
Research
as well as others.
25
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
Considering the Institute’s set up (i.e., its formation by the Housing Corporation), and the
nature of its activities (mainly training and consultancy), it is believed that this institute is of
great relevance to the center under study, and should be a model to build on for the
development of the proposed center as will be seen in following sections of this report.
Organization
The HSMI is a small organization comprised of a management department, faculty in
different specializations, an administration division, a finance division, an administrative
division, and a secretarial division. The management team comprises of a Chairman and an
Executive Director for training. There are 20 faculty members (teaching and non-teaching),
four administrative officers, three finance officers, and three secretarial officers. Its small
sized set-up is an optimal model to follow for the initial stages of the Iraqi center.
The main facilities at the HSMI include equipped classrooms (three), a Computer Facility
for its training and research activities, and Library and Documentation Center.
International Cooperation
As mentioned before, HSMI was established as a result of an international cooperation
program. It maintains a number of cooperation programs with various entities including:
• United Nations Center for Human Settlement
• World Health Organization
• Institute of Housing and Urban Development Studies
• Common Wealth Government Forum, London
Financing
The center is very largely financed through the annual governmental fund and substantial
resources are also drawn from, the construction industry for work done at the organization.
Another source of finance is the joint research work done with foreign agencies such as
UNESCO, and domestic research agencies such as the Egyptian Academy for Scientific
Research and Technology.
3.2.3 Center for Housing Planning and Building (CHPB) –Sri Lanka
Mission
The Center for Housing Planning and Building (CHPB) is a Training and Research Center of
the Sri Lankan Ministry of Urban Development, Housing and Construction. It was established
in 1979 with a grant from the Government of the Netherlands. The main objective of the
center is to provide mid-career training to professionals, administrators and other personnel
involved in the housing and building development programmes in Sri Lanka.
The mission of the CHPB is delivering up to date training, research, information services in
support of National, Provincial and Local level public and private sector agencies and
individuals, who are involved in the planning and management of activities in the broad
areas of human settlements, urban infrastructure, urban development
Activities
As mentioned above, the main activity of the center is to provide mid-career training to
professionals and administrators. The importance of the mid-career training conducted by
the CHPB was recognized by the government and this led to the establishment of the CHPB
as a formal training and research institution approved by the Cabinet of Ministers on a
permanent basis as a special division of the Ministry, with an annual treasury grant for
salaries and recurrent expenditure. Over the years CHPB has expanded its activities to cater
to the training needs generated by a wide range of new programmes. Presently these
26
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
activities serve some of the needs of other Ministries, the private sector and the
requirements of individuals as well.
CHPB has earned itself a name in its areas of activities by conducting many programmes for
local professionals as well as those from the region, with the sponsorship of foreign funding
agencies. These agencies included Asian Productivity Organization (APO), United Nations
Development Programme (UNDP), UNCHS, the Institute for Housing and Urban
Development Studies (IHS), Rotterdam, the Netherlands, UNICEF and DANIDA.
In addition, CHPB has linkages with and participates in various other activities of the
ministry, construction industry, housing and related agencies, and also some activities in the
region, some of which are listed below:
• Participation as a member in the HABITAT steering committee activities
• Organization of the exhibition of Best Practices in Human Settlements as a
preparatory activity of HABITAT II conference
• Participation in Workshops organized by the ministry for formulation of Housing and
Urban Development policies
• Member of the Steering committee for the preparation of Bio-diversity action Plan of
the Ministry of environment and Women’s Affairs
• Member of the Network of Training and Research Institutes in Human settlements in
Asia and the Pacific (TRISHNET); participated in its workshops Human Settlements
Database in Asia and the Pacific; contributing to its Newsletter.
• Activities of the National Construction Contractors Association of Sri Lanka
Plans are underway to start new services and activities to offer advisory services to build
affordable houses, with less costly construction material, less costly techniques, affordable
features and less costly processes. Advice will be available in the form of plans, estimates,
brochures and leaflets.
Organization
This center also has a simple organizational structure as shown in Figure 3-1. The center
only employs 12 people. It draws upon a pool of 60 visiting faculty members to conduct the
training activities. Those experts are mainly from:
• Universities
• Public sector
• Private sector
• Banking sector, and
• Freelance consultants.
those trainers offer structured training programs in Civil Engineering Construction, Project
Management, General Management, Landscape Design, Urban Design, Disaster
management, and Skill Enhancement.
This set up is considered optimal for the Iraqi center under consideration, especially that it
could rely on expertise in Iraqi universities as the trainers in the initial stages, provided some
training of trainers activities are provided in the early stages.
The main facilities at the CHPB include four equipped classrooms, a library, a dorm, a
cafeteria, and a print shop.
27
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
Director
Clerk
Typist
Stenographer
IT specialists
International Cooperation
As with HSMI, this center was also established as a result of an international cooperation. It
maintains a number of cooperation programs with various entities including
• ADPC - Asian Disaster Preparedness Center in Bangkok, Thailand.
• ICIMOD- International Center for Integrated Mountain Network in Katmandu, Nepal.
• HUDCO India-Housing and Urban Development Corporation
• Institute of Housing and Urban Development Studies
Financing
CHPB functions as a division of the Ministry, partly financed from a government grant and
partly by the course fees levied.
28
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
29
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
benefit from their experience in their early stages. In addition to technical benefit, the
partnering efforts will help the center gain international exposure.
30
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
Table 3-3 Summary of Mapping Exercise and Relevance to Proposed Center in Iraq
Extent of Relevance with Regard to Overall
Entity Ownership Mission and Needed Comments
Structure Services Relevance
and Affiliation Objectives Resources
Good model both in terms of its affiliation with a governmental housing
Human entity, missions and objectives and in terms of it size. Center focuses
Settlement on training (external and internal), but also conducts research and
Management High High High High High High consulting, major source of income for sustaining operations. The
Institute (HMSI)- center has its own faculty, not a goal of the Iraq MoCH IHITC. Overall,
India the Iraqi center could use this center as a target for the medium range
of 5 to 7 years,
Housing and
Building
This center is relevant for long-term planning, not in the short-term, as
National
High High Medium Medium Low High it is too advanced. It I also affiliated with a Ministry and has a similar
Research
target group as the proposed MoCH center.
Center of Egypt
(HBNRC)
Best model that for immediate term. It is small sized and similar in
Center for nature. More importantly it relies on external faculties that are brought
Housing in on as needed basis. The Iraqi center can follow this model of
Planning and High High High High High High utilizing external trainers until it can afford to hire full-time trainers.
Building (CHPB) The center serves a governmental housing entity similar to the MoCH
–Sri Lanka and employs a limits number of staff. Its library and information
management strategies are ideal for the MoCH center.
31
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
Systems, and building related Quality Control; all of which are areas believed to be served
by the proposed center. Therefore, departments/units that are representative of such
responsibilities were selected and included in the field assessment.
The following sections present the main findings of those surveys/interviews presented as
per department/directorate. The information presented summarized the main information
that was extracted in the field interviews. Each section presents a brief description of the
department/unit and outlines the identified capacity needs in addition to physical needs. It is
assumed that the majority of the capacity needs could be supplemented as part of the
proposed center’s activities.
4.2 Ministry in General
The core functions as mandated to the Ministry of Construction and Housing can be
summarized as follows:
1. Developing plans for the building, housing, roads and bridges and executing the civil
airports within the general plans for the country
2. Conducting special studies related to the construction sector and the technical and
economical feasibility studies for projects, and ensuring knowledge and technology transfer
3. Preparing and/or reviewing designs, documents and work instructions for its own
projects or projects awarded to Iraqi, Arab and international consultants
4. Conducting Quality Control and participating in setting the standards for the
construction sector
5. Executing projects through bidding or direct invitations of Iraqi, Arab and
international contractors
6. Supervision and follow up on the execution of the awarded projects
7. Execute projects related to other parties inside and outside Iraq through own
execution and design staff
8. Maintenance of public roads including highways and bridges located outside
Baghdad and other municipalities. Operating and furnishing bridges and performing land
acquisition for these projects.
Figure 4-1 below shows the organization of the Ministry head quarters. As can be seen in
the Figure, there are four main departments; Commercial and Financial Affairs,
Administration and Legal, Technical Affairs, and Planning and Project Follow up. Under
each main department, there is a number of sections that are responsible for the various
issues assigned to the departments. Through those main departments and the
sections/units underneath, the Ministry of Housing and Construction has three major
operational areas; housing, roads and bridges and public buildings.
In addition, there are three main commissions; the Housing Commission, the Building
Commission, and the Roads and Bridges Commission with several companies within the
ministry performing the different construction activities required by these commissions. The
State Commission for Housing is responsible for the planning and construction of publicly
funded housing to meet the needs of the population as determined by the government.
Similarly, the State Commission for Roads and Bridges conducts planning, engineering,
construction and maintenance on all primary, secondary, and tertiary roads and bridges
outside of municipality boundaries. Lastly, the State Commission for Public Building serves
as the primary engineering and construction agent for planning and construction for all public
facilities required to carry out the duties and functions of all of the other Ministries and
agencies within the government.
The specific responsibilities of the Fund are to finance housing projects, lend capital to
individuals to build their dwellings, support and finance authorized banks, and improve
cooperative sectors. The Fund also gives loans to individuals to purchase homes (as
opposed to building homes) provided they meet certain conditions and requirements.
Discussions with representatives from the Fund revealed that the Fund aims to become a
pioneer in housing finance, and assume a role of an intermediate in finance between banks
and beneficiaries exclusively for housing purposes. It also envisions itself establishing
stronger relationships and partnerships with the private sector for the erection and
construction of housing projects. In addition to the capacity building needs, the Fund
representatives identified shortages in office space and resources such as information
systems and references (mainly textbooks, up to date technical reports, periodicals, etc.).
The need in terms of information systems and reference materials is a shortage that could
be filled by the proposed center. The Fund currently utilizes computer systems for Loaning
Systems, Auditing Systems, and Levy Systems. However, most of the used software needs
significant upgrading.
The main areas of training that were identified as needed for the staff of the Fund includes
Housing Projects Financing, Project Appraisals, Credit Mechanisms, Loan servicing,
Customer services, Public Private Partnerships, and Computer applications in finance
According to the Housing Market Survey, the Housing Fund “has missed the opportunity for
providing innovative lending instrument and instead resorted to providing project finance for
units unaffordable to households for whom they were intended”. The Fund cannot operate
outside the parameters of the original Real Estate Bank, and has issued very few loans sine
its establishment. Its mandate was modified to make it into a channel for funding other
banks that are expected to on-lend to households. This also was not successful.
4.2.2 State Commission for Housing
This is one of the important commissions within the MoCH that has a wide range of
responsibilities. The main areas within the organization include financial affairs,
projects/engineering/design, legal matters, information technology, and personnel
management. This diverse range of specialties is needed for the nature of responsibilities
undertaken by the commission. The commission also oversees housing projects in all 15
governorates in Iraq (KRG governorates are not included in its scope)
The Commission employs nearly 540 employees comprised of engineers, legal specialists,
planners, financial specialists, and IT specialists. The Commission realizes the importance
of the continuous capacity building of its staff, however, it does not maintain an organized
training program for its staff.
Interviewed individuals at the Commission indicated the need for training outside Iraq or by
trainers exposed to up to date and international practices in the various areas of training.
Also, the Commission indicated that in many cases, the nomination of trainees is based on
receipt of invitations by the various training providers and not according to a plan set by or
TNAs conducted by the Commission. Another interesting finding is the extent of training
conducted by other entities of the MoCH. This is indicative for the need of an organizing
body related to training for the various organizations within the MoCH similar to what is
proposed through the Center.
Representatives of the Commission indicated the lack of reference materials and texts that
would help improve the quality of the work. This holds true for the various areas within the
organization including engineering, finance, and legal.
Several areas of training needs were identified including Project planning and management,
Statistical forecasting and modeling related to housing planning, Cost and quality control,
related to hosing projects, Contracting and Public-Private-Partnerships, Human Resources
development, Machinery related training, Legal aspects of construction, and GIS and
training that were identified as needed for the staff of the Directorate include Installation,
operating and maintenance of VSAT, Analysis and design of data bases, Programming of
databases (MS Access), Design of websites
The GIS Unit is still in the preparatory stages and is assigned with preparing the staff of the
MoCH working on GIS and its applications, and the activation of GIS and its utilities to be
used on the ground. Being a new unit, it still needs significant training of its staff. One of
the main goals of this unit is to formalize their training activities through the Training Unit at
the IT Directorate. It envisions itself becoming a GIS training center that is responsible for
building the GIS capacity of all staff in the MoCH and its subsidiaries.
Despite limited financial resources, the Unit has managed to build the capacity of its staff to
become trainers in the field. This has mainly been done through training inside and outside
Iraq with the assistance of donor entities. The representatives of the Unit recognize the
methodology established by UN-HABITAT as having a great impact in the achievements
they have made so far. They view the completion of training methodology by UN-
HABITAT/second stage as vital to their sustainability.
The main challenges that this Unit faces are delays in the provision of the latest versions of
programs, and a lack of comprehension of essentiality of GIS by MoCH staff, especially
decision makers. Security conditions, of course, remain a challenge without saying.
The training Unit is another small
unit within the IT Directorate. This
unit is concerned with training on
IT related matters only. As seen in
Figure 4-2, it has access to a very
well equipped training laboratory
and is currently working on
expanding it. An extension to the
existing facilities, funded by
USAID, will enable them to serve
50 persons with all the needed
training tools including furniture,
computers, internet, and network.
As mentioned above, this Unit
mainly focuses on IT related
training for MoCH staff. The Unit Figure 4-2 Training Lab
realizes the importance of
partnering arrangements with
training providers from the private sector and is constantly exploring cooperation channels.
materials and technical reports.
Except for the training provided by HABITAT and the World Bank, the other training subjects
are relatively basic. There are additional needs for training in advanced network systems
and advanced programming.
4.2.5 National Center for Construction Laboratories
This center of over 1200 employees serves all the MoCH subdivisions, the Central Institute
for Testing and Quality Control, all projects implemented by ministries, the private sector, in
addition to foreign companies working in construction field. It is mainly responsible for all
activities related to testing of different construction materials (i.e., performing all tests
(physical and chemical) for constructional materials, quality control for concrete and
establishing of fields labs), soil investigations, rehabilitation of constructional parts subject to
attacks, performing of applicable research, and raising of staff capabilities by training
courses. In addition to the field laboratories established in project sites, the Center has 14
laboratories throughout the nation.
Given the nature of its services, the Center’s management sees a significant potential in
strengthening their relationship with the private sector. Considering the ongoing re-
construction activities, serving the private sector contractors can help with the Center’s
financial sustainability and can tremendously improve its financial performance. According
to the Center’s management, improved financial performance could also help the creation of
the badly needed employee incentive plan to improve their financial compensation. In other
words, the Center has an excellent potential if it were to operate on a commercial basis to
provide the various types of services within its jurisdiction.
However, due to years of neglect, and the recent conflicts, the Center is only operating at
50-60% of its capacity due to the lack of equipment needed for modern testing techniques
and methods.
The Center has a training directorate within its Research and Technical Affairs Department.
In addition to training of the Centers staff, this facility also trains staff from other
organizations mainly in the areas of laboratory testing. The Center has some physical
infrastructure for training. This mainly includes lectures halls and computer training halls.
There is a significant need for equipment in those facilities, and there is an ongoing
rehabilitation activity for some additional training halls.
Another major deficiency exists in terms of reference materials. The Center currently has a
small “library” facility with nearly 2500 documents. The library, however, only has one
computer and there is no documentation system of the contents. It is believed that the
library should serve as a vital resource for not only the Center staff, but to academic
institutions and the various organizations involved in the construction industry. There is a
need for international periodical journals and up to date references and standards.
4.2.6 State Owned Companies
As was seen in the MoCH’s organization structure, there is a total of nine state owned
companies. Most of those companies were established according to the Companies Law of
1987, and there have been some mergers of some of the companies since the last conflict.
The current companies in the MoCH organization structure are:
in Iraq are exceptional opportunities for the state companies to improve their revenues and
financial performance. However, the SOEs face fierce competition from the private sector.
They compete with the private sector, even for government contacts, and reportedly can
compete on price, but not on quality of work. They need to adopt modern management
practices in order to compete, and also need to improve their skills competing on a
commercial basis for projects. The MoCH relationship with the private sector can take
different forms: as a competitor for projects, as a partner, and an employer of private sector
firms for specific tasks. (MoCH entities often sub-contract work to smaller private
companies.)
IT applications in the construction sector are also weak in the various companies. A general
training needs and capacity for the various companies include the following:
• Construction management techniques (scheduling, resource leveling, fleet
management)
• IT applications (construction management software, GIS, and CAD)
• Financial management
• Management skills (including proposal management)
• Legal aspects
The National Development Strategy calls for privatizing most state-owned enterprises
(SOEs) by 2008, but latest reports indicate that this will be delayed. Details on the SOEs
covered in this assessment are included in the Annex.
4.2.7 Management Information Systems at MoCH
MIS in any organization broadly refers to a computer-based system that provides managers
with the tools for organizing, evaluating and efficiently running their departments. An MIS
can include software that helps in decision making, data resources such as databases, the
hardware resources of a system, decision support systems, people management and project
management applications, and any computerized processes that enable the department to
run efficiently. As was seen in section 4.2.4, the MoCH has an IT Department within its
organization that would be responsible for MIS. Although the Ministry itself and some of the
subsidiaries are relatively well equipped with computers and networking, there remains a
number of deficiencies that hinder the establishment of a comprehensive MIS for the entire
ministry. The following are the main observations that were made during the field visits to
the various entities as it relates to IT systems:
• Software and hardware: the main available software are mainly basic Microsoft
Office applications. Other specialized engineering software are also found in some entities,
however, those are mostly pirated copies. Several used software are downloaded free from
the internet. Several software in various departments, including the GIS Unit are in
desperate need of updating.
• Local domain and e-mailing system: there is no common e-mailing system the
employees using their Yahoo personal e-mail.
• Information flow system and information/Knowledge/data sharing- There is no
well defined information flow scheme, especially between the MoCH headquarters and the
subsidiaries. There is a need for improving the WAN infrastructure. The departments share
only basic managerial documents and orders and some decision making such as
communication letters and annual reports.
• GIS system -GIS system is not integrated within MIS system. Generally, there is no
well defined MIS or GIS system within the MOCH. The existing system needs serious
development in terms of computer networking system as well as online information and data
sourcing such as standards and specifications. Server database system is a must to assist
the MOCH to perform data acquisition, pre-processing, data management, storage and
retrieval, manipulation and analysis.
• Finally, there are no standard operating procedures SOPs describe the
documentation management system that include: data collection, data flow, data validation
and accuracy, data entry, data storage and data processing.
4.3 Overview for Other Entities
In addition to the MoCH, other key actors in the housing and construction sector include:
• Ministry of Municipalities and Public Works (MMPW) and the individual
municipalities within that Ministry
• Mayoralty of Baghdad (Amanat Baghdad)
• Ministry of Justice (MOJ), where the Land Registration Department is located
• Ministry of Planning and Development Cooperation (MOPDC) which oversees all
planning and development activities and is mainly responsible for coordination with
the donor community for funding of re-construction projects
• Ministry of Water Resources (MWR)which supports infrastructure development
(often implemented by MoCH)
• Ministry of Electricity (MOE) which supports infrastructure development
Urban planning was previously centralized and all done in Baghdad. There are new
regulations requiring greater decentralization, but there is still no regulatory and institutional
framework for land use planning and management under the new government. There are no
clear lines of authority, division of labor, or systems and procedures. Nearly 85% of the land
is still owned by the State.
Mayoralty of Baghdad (Amanat Baghdad)- The Baghdad Governorate is comprised of 6
districts located outside Baghdad City and its suburbs boundaries. The Governorate is
administered under the jurisdiction of the Baghdad Governor. The City of Baghdad and its
suburbs have an area of approximately 950 km2 that are administered by Mayoralty of
Baghdad. The City of Baghdad itself is divided into nine municipalities. Each municipality is
responsible for the municipal services under its jurisdiction such as water, sanitation and
solid waste collection. The planning and reconstruction of projects related to each
municipality is the responsibility of the Mayoralty of Baghdad. This includes project planning,
funding, agreements with donors, design and execution. The City of Baghdad is home to
more than 5 million inhabitants. Over the past 15 years, construction of new housing in Iraq
has been significantly below the demand, the average construction in the 1990s being below
500,000 m2 of built area compared with more than 1.5 million in 1989 and 2001. A backlog
of at least 1.4 million housing units has been estimated for Iraq. At the same time,
infrastructural maintenance, upgrading, and expansion have been largely neglected. As a
result, construction activities for housing, coupled with the maintenance, upgrading and
expansion of existing infrastructure in the city of Baghdad, is significantly needed over the
coming years.
The city of Baghdad and its inhabitants have long suffered from the lack of modern urban
planning prevalent in advanced countries. There has been some urban planning, but limited
in scope, and with no participation of citizens. The master plans produced in the lsat 20-30
years were general zoning plans with little consideration of the socioeconomic aspects of
citizens. Like all government ministries, the Mayoralty of Baghdad has suffered from the
lack of international exposure to international best practices in the last 25 years. Retaining
staff has been a problem, especially since the recent war and civil strife. Since March 2003,
some residents of Baghdad have formed grass-roots organizations to articulate their needs.
Ministry of Justice - The General Directorate of Real Estate is located in the Land
Administration Department. The process of buying and selling land can be done in one
month and is relatively efficient. Most people have titles to their land, even though the
system is fully paper-based, which makes it difficult to compile statistics on land use and
therefore to develop land use plans.
Ministry of Municipalities and Public Works -The Ministry of Municipalities and Public
works prepares urban development plans which should be implemented by municipalities.
They also design wastewater treatment plants and other infrastructural works.
All ministries have planning and follow up departments, but a recent study indicated that
they spend about one month on planning and 11 months on follow up.
The private sector in Iraq is considered by all interviewees (both public and private) to be
very competent for building small scale projects. Private sector representatives indicated that
they are also fully capable of constructing large projects, but that current banking laws, laws
regulating sale of apartments on an individual basis and land purchase laws make this kind
of investment very risky and usually not profitable. The Iraqi Contractors Federation has
30,000 members, some of them very active, some are contractors in name only.
All universities in Iraq also have engineering consulting offices, which sell their services.
Some private investors have the funds to invest in housing schemes, but individuals do not
have access to funds to purchase these homes.
With the opening up of Iraq to international investment, many contractors are at a
disadvantage in communicating with foreign businessmen. The new investment rules allow
for 100% foreign ownership and 100% repatriation of earnings, so despite the security risks,
Iraq is an appealing investment opportunity for some companies. Private companies need
assistance in preparing themselves for communicating with and negotiating with international
companies. Many contractors sign contracts in English without even understanding the
specifications – then run into later disputes. They are now getting them translated into
Arabic.
English language is also a major hurdle in the public sector to communication with donors,
researching and networking via the Internet, and attending international training courses.
There are four main universities in Baghdad, the University of Baghdad University of
Technology, Almustansaria University and Al Nahrawan. The University of Baghdad is
considered the best, but all universities are rapidly leaving anyone who has the opportunity
to leave the country. Universities outside of Baghdad are not as strong and sometimes
partner with Baghdad based universities for training courses.
4.4 Conclusions
This task focused on understanding the roles and responsibilities of the MoCH in general
and some of its departments/subsidiaries, and the general areas where training and capacity
building is needed. The data collection addressed capacity building needs that would
enable the various entities better achieve their objectives and overcome obstacles reported
by the interviewed entities.
As determined by the Housing Market Survey, and concluded in the subsequent conference,
the most urgent need in the housing sector is to reinforce the existing strengths of the
housing sector by encouraging private sector to accelerate the speed of housing
development, increase the involvement of civil society, and other moves towards
decentralization and privatization.
In the short term, the Ministry and its entities need to develop their capabilities to both
support private sector development and work with other non-government entities. The SOEs
need to improve their capabilities to compete with the private sector. The priorities for the
MoCH are to achieve the three objectives in the International Compact, which are noted
below:
• MOCH to operationalize Housing Market Information System at national and sub-
national level
• Restructure the Iraq Housing Fund and disburse loans to at least 10,000 poor and
low income households
• Formulate and adopt National Housing and Land Management Policy and address
norms and standards, construction standards
Beyond assisting in achieving these specific objectives, there is a need for an overall change
in the attitude, systems, and management of the MoCH and its entities to take on a more
policy and regulatory oriented goal. For the SOE’s, there is an urgent need to be able to
better compete with and collaborate with the private sector. Most entities have their own
training centers, some have documentation centers, some have IT center.
Training for all professional level staff is needed in the following topics in order to (1) develop
a culture of learning where staff will themselves find and use the knowledge they need to
make decisions and, (2) orient staff towards the changing role of MoCH and government in
general
• Private sector participation
• Strategic planning
• Community participation, stakeholder consultation
• Knowledge Management – how to access and use knowledge for decision making
The capacity to design and implement training programs is limited, and there are few regular
training budgets, with training mostly funded on an ad hoc basis by donors. There is a lack
of experienced trainers, training plans are either non-existent or very general, and selection
of trainees is not based on specific need, language ability, and job description (or future job
description). Training and manpower directors recognize these drawbacks and want to have
tools to improve their ability to design, implement and evaluate training programs
Employees recognize that they need to know more about private sector participation, but
have no awareness of the need for participatory planning.
Information management and documentation needs are great. Information flow between
departments, between MoCH entities is limited and ad hoc. There is a small MoCH
documentation center, but with no cataloguing system. There is limited knowledge of
software beyond word processing and Internet.
English language is a major constraint in increasing knowledge through the use of Internet,
communication with outside agencies and individuals, and also in working with international
companies and contractors.
Management capabilities need to be improved. Many senior professional staff has left and
there is an urgent need to build the capacity of staff to take on senior positions. The MoCH
coordinates well with other Ministries, but there is little sharing of data on an organized basis
within various MoCH entities and other government agencies. There is limited technical
capacity to establish databases, and even less to design information systems for specific
decision and policy making needs
Housing finance is almost non-existent. There is a need for efficient management of loan
process, lack of expertise of the Fund to manage loans and innovative approaches to
lending for low income households.
There is a need to convey to the private sector and the general public the role of the MoCH
and its plans so that they feel their needs are being taken into account and also are realistic
in their expectations of what the government can deliver. SOE’s need to improve their ability
to compete with private sector on a commercial basis, and partner with the private sector
(national and international). Proposal writing, tendering and procurement are areas where
improved skills are needed.
There is a need to develop clear, transparent policies and programs – and communicate
those programs to the public and other sector stakeholders. Existing construction guidelines
and standards are either non-existent or unclear. The MoCH needs to improve its
communication with stakeholders, establishing a consultative process – especially with
organizations working at community level.
Depending on the types of services provided by the various departments, the reported
capacity building needs differed. For example, the hard core engineering related
departments focused on core construction related issues, while other departments
addressed information technology and human resources.
The MoCH, like all government ministries, needs to translate national development
strategies into sector policies and strategies so that MoCH can assume an active role in
coordinating with relevant ministries to develop and implement new housing policies
consistent with provision of affordable housing in a market economy. It needs to support
improved access to housing resource for land, and materials and finance and institutional
support.
MoCH and its entities have strong skills in building and construction management; however,
they are less skilled in policy, planning and management. Also, many senior staff has left,
and there is urgent need for developing skills of mid-level staff to move up into their
positions, with focus on policy, strategic planning and change management.
The greatest training needs as expressed by staff are for skills in management and planning,
supported by IT/computer and English language skills. There is less demand for technical
skills, although they have been identified by previous studies. MoCH needs to start a
program of English language training; the IHITC can help in designing on-site training which
will be specifically targeted towards the needs of professional staff. This will help to increase
the effectiveness of the IHITC in helping staff educate themselves through Internet and
contact with international agencies.
There is an urgent need to build housing – MoCH is under great pressure. The MoCH will
not be able to, nor should they, build all the housing in Iraq. The Iraq Housing Information
and Training Center can help by supporting MoCH public relations staff to present the plans
and accomplishments of MoCH to the public and to private sector partners. Even with private
sector involvement it will take time. The MoCH needs to communicate to citizens, and to the
private sector, their plans and how they expect to implement them, and be realistic, so as
not to raise expectations.
The four major areas identified by the MoCH for the capacity building program support the
achievement of the goals above:
• Organizational Management and Planning
• Land and Housing Delivery
• Building and Construction Sector
• Housing Market Information and GIS
While some of the areas, such as land management, go beyond the role of the MoCH, the
MoCH, with the support of the Iraq Housing Information and Training Center, can take a
leading role in promoting improvements in other Ministries which will improve the ability for
MoCH to facilitate housing provision.
The Business Plan for the Iraq Housing Information and Training Center, outlined in Section
5, includes an outline of the capacity building needs and detailed capacity building program
which will help the MoCH and its counterparts achieve these goals. MoCH efforts in
establishing a Knowledge Management and Training Center should focus on its core tasks
and strengths, and should tap into other sources of training as appropriate. For example,
training in public administration and management is being supported by USAID for the
National Consulting Center and the MoCH should focus on housing and construction related
training and should tap directly other training sources outside of MoCH for public
administration/management training.
MoCH has a major task – providing results on the ground—getting housing built, while at the
same time stepping back and playing a more regulatory and guiding role. MoCH has good
working relationships and mechanisms of coordination with other Ministries. The need is to
extend that to working with the players noted above – Iraqi, Arab and international investors
and donors in financial services, building and construction.
The MoCH plans to continue reorganization to achieve its goals of housing sector reform,
working with governmental and non-governmental entities. The IHITC can help be the
catalyst towards achieving those goals, as a center of information, knowledge and learning
on housing related topics.
IHITC Vision
Vision of Iraqi Training and Knowledge Centre for Housing is to be the pioneering
institution in the field of improving standard of living of all Iraqis via managing a
developed government housing sector with increased private sector participation.
Duty of the Iraqi Training and Knowledge Center for Housing is to provide
knowledge and the means and tools necessary for MoCH and other public and
private institutions to be able to make sound strategic decisions to support and
implement the huge task of restructuring the housing and construction sector and
speed up the building of dwellings.
5.1.2 Mission
Iraqi Training and Knowledge Centre for Housing shall be a stimulator and motivator to
enhance the capacity of state-owned institutions to cooperate and compete with the private
sector in the field of housing in a free liberal market. The Center shall work to execute
knowledge management tasks (creating, collecting, storing and disseminating information)
via operations pertaining to information gathering, expertise analysis, scientific research and
consultancy services provision in the field of housing sector to help fulfill the objectives of the
proposed workplan.
The work-plan of the centre focus on preparing necessary capacities and availing necessary
knowledge for the housing sector stakeholders to meet the following challenges as outlined
in the Housing Market Study (2006) and agreed by Iraqi stakeholders in December 2006
workshop on: "Iraq Housing Sector Analysis and Policy Directions"
5.1.3 Goals and Objectives
The proposed goals and objectives are generally designed to build on the strengths and
abilities already found in the public and private sectors. Most importantly, given the current
economic, security and human resources constraints, the goals defined need to be realistic
and pragmatic. Change in any institution is slow, despite the urgent need, and the IHITC
needs to start with relatively modest goals and objectives in order to ensure initial success
and establish its reputation.
The goals and objectives below are divided into short and long-term. They support both the
short-and long-term goals as proposed in the Housing Market Survey (2006):
• Short-term objectives: facilitate the high-quality fast building action through small
contractors.
• Long and medium term objectives: make changes in policy and legislations to speed
up progress in the Iraqi housing sector.
Goal 1: Serve as a main resource of information for the housing and construction in Iraq
Goal 4: Provide advisory services for the housing and construction sector
Objective 4-1: Exchange knowledge on the best way possible to set up knowledge
centers with other centers inside and outside the housing sector in Iraq.
Objective 4-2: (long-term) Establish a advisory services unit to provide services on a
commercial basis.
Goal 5: Establish a national and international network to support, advocate for, and
document housing sector development
Objective 5-1: Conduct a series of seminars on key topics with open invitation to
housing sector stakeholders.
Objective 5-2: Establish contacts and official links with two similar international
centers.
Objective 5-3: Promote and publicize the Center’s functions inside and outside
MOHC.
Specific approaches and activities to support the IHITC objectives are outlined in sections
that follow. Activities are also designed to support the MoCH and other stakeholders in
reaching the 2007/2008 objectives outlined in the International Compact, which are:
• Operationalize Housing Market Information System at national and sub-
national level (directly through Urban Observatory)
• Restructure the Iraq Housing Fund and disburse loans to at least 10,000
poor and low income households (indirectly through capacity building on housing finance)
• Formulate and adopt National Housing and Land Management Policy
and address norms and standards, construction standards (indirectly through
documentation of existing guidelines, assistance with guidelines development and capacity
building)
It is important to note that the IHITC will play a supporting role to institutions responsible for
achieving the goals outlined in the International Compact; it will not have direct responsibility
for achieving them.
The Center will not provide all education, not have all the information at hand; but Center
staff will know where it can be found. It will be the meeting place for people from different
departments within MoCH, for others from outside the Ministry. It will collect and conduct
studies and research relevant to the needs and reforms of the housing sector. It will give
people the ability to find knowledge, skills, new ideas, through their own research. The IHITC
will provide tailor-made and specialized training to professionals, technical cadre and policy
makers working in central and local government agencies, NGO’s, private sector and
educational institutions. It will foster openness and transparency in planning and
implementation.
IHITC focuses its work on institution building and human resources development that will
foster urban environmental improvement and better quality of life in cities of Iraq. IHITC will
become a training and capacity building center specialized in post-graduate and tailor-made
training, policy research and technical advisory services in the fields of urban management
and planning, housing and real estate development policies, informal settlement upgrading
and urban renewal, urban land planning and management, infrastructure management and
urban/housing finance.
the business operations of the company, and to see that it achieves its business
objectives. In exercising its duties, the board may, as it deems appropriate, delegate
some of its authorities to the general manager.
Profits and Losses
The Law contains rules describing the manner by which the state-owned company’s
profits will be distributed among the concerned parties. The Law also specifies the
relevant actions that need to be taken in the event that the company’s losses for any
given fiscal year exceed certain percentages of the company’s capital.
Investment and Borrowing
The Law also contains rules specifying the investment, lending, and borrowing
options that are available to a state-owned company. Pursuant to the Law, a state-
owned company is allowed to employ its excess liquidity, if any, by investing in public
shareholding companies, or by participating in joint venture arrangements with such
public shareholding companies in projects falling within the state-owned company’s
business objective.
As to lending and borrowing, the Law allows state-owned companies to lend and
borrow from national financial institutions or other state-owned companies for the
purposes of financing its operations.
Based on the above characteristics of an SOE, the consulting team recommends that the
MoCH consider the formation of the proposed center as an SOE under its jurisdiction. The
MoCH could also investigate whether other ministries or SOE’s would be interested in
ownership of the proposed center. Shall the MoCH adopt this proposal; it would have to
develop an “Internal Regulation” that mainly addresses the main characteristics of the
proposed enterprise (i.e., objective, mission statement, management, jurisdiction, etc.). It is
believed hat the proposal developed under this study could be used as a basis to formulate
this document. A typical “Internal Regulation” under the Iraqi Companies Law would cover
the following:
1. SOE’s juridical personality with financial and administrative autonomy, paid-up capital
including movable and immovable assets.
2. Main objective of the SOE. This would also address supplementary powers which the
SOE entitled to exercise in furtherance of its main objective. Among other things,
those include:
− To own, in its name, movable and immovable assets, equipment, and
machinery, and to sell, lease, rent and dispose of the same in accordance with
the requirement of the law.
− To open and operate bank accounts with national and foreign banks in
whatsoever currency pursuant to the applicable laws and regulations. And in
furtherance of its objectives, to issue checks, payment orders, promissory notes
and bonds, and to obtain secured or unsecured banking facilities of any form.
− To enter into joint ventures, borrow and lend funds, and invest its excess
liquidity in the manner, and in compliance with the restrictions, as stipulated in the
Law.
− To conduct tenders and auctions, and to enter into in all forms of agreements
necessary for the operation of company in accordance with the laws and
regulation in effect.
− To commission local or foreign experts and consultants for the purpose of
improving and enhancing the business operation of the company.
3. Management scheme, for example by a board of directors and a general manager.
The Center should have a limited number of technical employees in the first stages provided
that it recruits its technical personnel on part-time basis from local universities, the private
sector, non-government institutions and the international market through partnership
relations coordinated by UN-HABITAT and other donors.
1- Information management
2- Capacity-building
3- Applied case-study research
4- Consultancy services
5- Coordination between the first four functions
The IHITC will be as the information center for training, to help individuals or institutions from
the public and private sector to identify training courses, evaluate their worth for their needs,
and make the links with the training providers.
The broader information, networking and outreach function of the Center will also serve to
develop capacity of housing sector stakeholders as they do their work through knowledge
sharing, networking, outreach and communication activities. At the moment, many
workshops and conferences are taking place outside of Iraq; the IHITC can be the focus for
more of these activities within Iraq.
Capacity building consists of a range of activities beyond classic “training courses.” In
addition to workshops and training courses, it can include:
• On-the-job training, including work experience and training funded by international
contractors working in Iraq
• Ongoing informal seminars on key topics
• Conferences
• Study tours, including those funded by international companies working in Iraq
• Visits to IHITC, where one obtains customer assistance in finding and using learning
resources
• Secondment to local or international institutions
• Seminar series as noted in Section ___ to provide input into specific policies and
guidelines
Capacity building in a sector so large requires more than targeting individuals. It requires
targeting the culture of the organization and helping to instill a “culture of learning” within the
organization. MoCH employees need to know there is a place to go when they need to make
a decision. In the long term, they should be able to “go” there without leaving their desk –
i.e., access it through the Internet. They might not find the answer to their question at the
Center, but they should be able to find the name of a person or organization that can help
them with their question. Alternatively, they can post a question on a discussion site related
to their “community of practice” and then obtain an answer from a variety of people to help
them make their decision. These capacity building aspects are covered in the other functions
of the IHITC.
The Internet provides a great body of knowledge, most of it in English. Initial training in
English combined with a fully networked Ministry will help the Ministry to make an
exponential jump in its capacity to support housing sector development. Purchasing and
distributing a number of language dictionaries is also a proven method to improve
knowledge gathering and is a simple measure which could help in Iraq.
The IHITC, in coordination with the Manpower Directorate, will keep or have access to
records on training needs, training conducted, and all individual trainees from MoCH and its
entities. It will establish links with all training centers. The Training Director for IHITC and
additional designated Training Center Directors from MoCH and its entities will be selected
to do a study tour to a similar Training Center. They will also attend the Training of Trainers
course.
5.3.2.2 Relation with Capacity-Building Services Providers
The Iraqi Training and Knowledge Center for Housing shall establish relations and
contacts with training services providers inside and outside Iraq and shall adopt an
accredited trainer evaluation system to ensure the use of effective training methods
and techniques. Trainers shall be trained outside Iraq, who shall (after acquiring the
The IHITC will also provide relevant information to trainers outside Iraq to make sure their
training is in Iraq context. The IHITC will establish a comprehensive database of training
opportunities including local, international, online, public and private sector providers.
Facilities within or accessed through the IHITC will make online courses available.
A variety of training models and partnerships will be used, and the IHITC will rely heavily on
outside faculty from universities and training centers, who will also be included in the training
of trainers’ courses. The IHITC will build partnerships with both public and private training
organizations. University students will be encouraged to work as interns in the IHITC in order
to develop early skills in housing and sector policy and planning.
5.3.2.3 Training Methodology
Analysis of previous training course evaluations indicated that there was a need more
participatory training directed to the specific situation and needs of participants. The training
methodology used for all training will be to engage the trainees in working on specific tasks,
plans and activities. Training methodologies will focus on an interactive approach to training
– exercise and discussions, development of action plans, both individual and organizational.
The training methodology used for all training areas shall focus on making trainees
participate in certain tasks, plans and activities. This methodology shall concentrate on
interactive-oriented training methods (exercises and discussions) and design workplans on
personal and institution levels.
The training unit of the Iraqi Center for Housing shall keep a list of training services providers
who provide their services via the internet and shall attempt to incorporate them in a long-
term training plan since this practice would help increase knowledge of best international
practices without bearing the high travel costs.
5.3.2.4 Trainee Selection
Trainee selection criteria should be transparent and stringent and the Center shall
cooperate with the HR and Training Section to formulate specific programs for
trainee selection and training follow-up. It should, use standardized screening format,
with information such as:
• Relevance of training to the trainees position and responsibilities or position in the
near future
• Personal receptiveness of the trainee to learning and change, and ability to be a
change agent within their own division/department/sector
• Previous training courses conducted
• Evaluation of trainee by previous trainers
• English language ability, where needed
5.3.2.5 Training Topics
The evaluation of institutional and training needs, including reviewing earlier training
workshops, shall be used as a basis for determining capacity-building subjects within the
four main areas considered of priority at the centre initial stage by UN-HABITAT and its
counterpart as being:
M1: Construction Management for small NT- 10: Construction Management for Small
Real Estate developers Three weeks course The potential implementing partner can provide Scale Real Estate developers
TOT3: Building
M2: Innovations in Construction 7 participants from private construction additional training topics that will help fulfill the NT-11: PSP in building and Construction
Material and
companies, MoCH construction companies, objectives and respond to the housing policy NT-12: Innovations in Construction
Construction M3:
University of Salah El-Din, University of Baghdad objectives as outlined above. Technologies and building materials
PSP in building and construction production
TOT4: Housing M1: GIS for urban studies Three weeks course The potential implementing partner can provide NT-13: GIS for Urban Studies and Local Urban
Sector related GIS M2: GIS in land and Infrastructure 7 participants from the Urban Observatory, GIS additional training topics that will help fulfill the Observatories
and Information department at COSIT, GIS department MoCH, objectives and respond to the housing policy NT-14: GIS for Real Estate Development and
M3: GIS for real estate management and
Institutional and Training Needs Assessment for Establishing
Ministry of Construction and Housing Knowledge and Training Center Draft Final Report
Mid-level MoCH officials 1. Workshop- changes in policy thinking, enabling 1. Draft strategies for selected governorates
Enhance government based on PSP and community led housing
from Housing approach, decentralization, budgeting and housing
understanding for programmes
NT-4: Housing Policies and Commission, MoMPW programming, conducive laws and regulations, participatory
enabling housing policies
Strategies Urban Planning and needs assessment and action planning. Workshop to be 2. Recommendations on decentralization
and decentralization of
Housing Directorates in conducted by Baghdad University staff and private strategies and budgetary allocations
housing decision-making
Governorates companies experts trained in the TOT. 3. suggestions for legal and regulatory reforms.
1. Participant groups produce action plans for
1. Workshop - stakeholder communication and developing one community-based housing
Improve government
Mid-level MoCH officials, consultation, community based planning, discussion of scheme
NT-5: Community based support and local
government, NGO and challenges and opportunities, international best practices,
Housing Development capability for community 2. Recommendations on challenges and
private sector field visits to community projects (within Iraq) – workshop
based housing opportunities to community-based housing
conducted, if possible, by an NGO in contract with IHC
delivery
1. Workshop – Facilitated activity with participants
Housing Fund, MoCH, developing solutions to housing finance. Use of IHC 1. Recommendations on housing finance
private sector, NGOS, information center to identify international best practices. solutions
Develop solutions to MOF, MoPDC, MMPW, Requires prior up to date short summary document on
NT-6: Housing Finance 2. Improved communication between
housing finance issues Amanat Baghdad, current status of housing finance. (To be developed by TOT stakeholders in housing finance
banking sector, Prime team which attended international training)
Ministry
(Consider making this bi-monthly seminar series)
Improve National
Housing Fund, Real 1. Workshop – select key, active staff as change agents
NT-7: Mortgage, Credit National Housing Fund,
Estate Bank and and develop with them solutions to improve access to low- 1. Recommendations on low-income housing
Management and Local Loans Real estate bank and
Commercial Banks income housing and to expedite processing of loans, use finance
Administration commercial banks staff
capabilities in Housing examples of successful projects in Iraq
Finance
MoCH, MoMPW staff 1. Workshop – Introduce participants to different success
Introduce new tools and
involved with land, and failures in urban land management, registration,
NT-8: Land Planning and techniques for land 1. An action plan for transformation/creation of
Ministry of Justice, regularization, land acquisition laws, planning and allocation
Management allocation, administration land management units in governorates.
Ministry of Finance and processes. In addition to innovative examples of land
and development
Governorates management institutions and approaches.
Create understanding
among officials private MoCH companies and 1. workshop – discuss the process of maintenance and the
NT-9: Asset Management and sector and Communities research centre, private creation of asset management companies. Assess 1. A plan for promotion of asset management
Maintenance on building maintenance sector companies and contracting process, and study cases from different companies in Iraq.
and management of NGOs, MoPDC, MoI. countries.
housing stock
1. Workshop – at Iraq Contractors Federation – case 1. Case study of UN Habitat experience in north
study of UN Habitat work with contractors in North – 2. Recommendations on short and long-term
NT-10: Construction recommendations on how to replicate in Baghdad.
Develop skills of Small contractors building tools to accelerate pace of construction by
Management for small Focus on small-scale project management. Include
housing contractors housing in Baghdad small scale contractors in Baghdad
contractors discussion of collaboration/cooperation in order to
scale up and accelerate house construction. 3. Recommendations for future
workshops/seminars/training
Initially, sharing of knowledge should be provided for free in order to establish the credibility
of the Center. It will be the best form of advertising to provide useful, targeted information to
clients.
In conjunction with the analysis of research activities, the IHITC in Year 2 will conduct a GAP
analysis of advisory services, identifying national and international sources of advisory
services on all relevant topics. This review will identify:
• Service gaps which could be filled by IHITC
• Service gaps which are now being filled by international companies and for
which IHITC could assist Iraq organizations to fill
• All services currently available as a guide to any organization doing business
in Iraq
5.3.5 Marketing and Communication
This study proposes a wide communication network. The Center’s director and employees
shall formulate a detailed workplan for communication and marketing and shall personally
abide by it. The main task in the first two years shall be wining the support, commitment and
respect of MoCH employees. Once they are convinced that the Iraqi Center for Housing has
became a credible and effective institution, they shall use it more and promote it amongst
their friends in other ministries and in the private sector.
A certain logo may be used to develop publicity, interest and commitment of a given
institution or sector such as the housing sector, or for a certain service provided by a certain
body. Thus the director and subordinates shall work to design a logo to be a distinguished
symbol of the Iraqi Training and Knowledge Center for Housing.
Suggested activities in the first 2 years include;
• Establish a welcoming, stimulating and professional looking physical environment
with basic information available (the key documents, several simple databases) before
inviting visitors
• Conduct a “soft opening” of the Center as soon as facilities are in lace by inviting the
Board of Directors and selected key officials from within MoCH and counterpart agencies to
a tour of the Center
• Ensure media coverage of the “soft opening
• Follow this with a series of tours (one per week) for senior officials from the various
MoCH entities, followed by similar tours for senior officials in other entities (public and
private sector). The goal should be to have one such tour every week.
• Identify “communities of practice” on subjects of interest to the housing and
construction sector. These are discussion groups, and e-mail networks of people with similar
professional interests. Publicize information on these groups throughout the Ministry
• Establish a simple monthly e-mail update to be sent to all MoCH staff, and to all
interested parties. Use simple database programs (MS Access, for example), for
establishing a comprehensive mailing list of people interested in housing development in
Iraq
• Conduct a monthly seminar series on key policy issues, which will be used to
improve networking, and to gain input from key stakeholders on policies. Guest speakers
should be invited, and the Training Director should facilitate the discussion. These seminars
can in the future be used to present draft guidelines, policies, etc. Suggested topics are:
o Constraints to private sector housing development – open discussion
o Housing finance – opportunities and constraints
3
This is not an engineering floor plan; it is mainly intended to demonstrate the needed area functions
As can be seen in the Figure, the main components of the IHITC include
1. Customer service/reception area
2. Offices
3. Documentation center, which will include at least one computer terminal with access
to databases and on-line documents
4. Meeting area which can also serve as seminar room for small seminars holding up to
15 people
5. Two training rooms, each holding up to 20-25 participants
6. Print and copy area, which can also house the IHITC’s server
7. GIS Lab (covered in more detail later)
Other auxiliary areas such as storage, lavatories, etc. will also be needed.
The IHITC will also make use of other MoCH facilities, such as the Ministry meeting hall, the
computer training center which has full set of computers already installed for training, and
the Manpower Directorate Training center.
Training activities will not always necessarily be conducted in the Center – the Center staff
and its affiliates will often move out to locations in other MoCH entities and beyond to
conduct training, which also supports the outreach function. In the long-term, additional
rooms and facilities will be needed to support research and advisory activities.
The training rooms will be equipped with high standard of furniture plus pull-down screens,
datashow, video and television system, slide projectors and overhead projectors. The IHITC
will be also equipped with an internal network which should be connected to a Ministry-wide
computer network. Internet service will be available for all visitors to the Center.
The proposed Knowledge Management System should be an integral part of network based
facility management system. The idea is to have a central place to store the needed
information for easy and quick reference at any time in the future. A Knowledge
Management System can take information in a variety of forms from different sources. A
good Knowledge Management Center actively seeks out information for incorporation into
the system.
The center should be the destination for free and helpful information including white papers,
case studies, free web seminars and e-newsletter. This information should be organized
and controlled through a special type of software that can:
Improve learning and foster innovation by streamlining information access and
retrieval, putting content in context
Organize information for easy retrieval and use, in order to enhance the ability of
housing sector specialist to improve self-learning, decision making and project
implementation
Categorize and assess available documentation and enable organizations to identify
knowledge gaps.
The Knowledge Management System will consist of:
Small library with hard copies of reports, books, maps, newsletters, magazines
Information retrieval stations with electronic documentation, including Internet
access, access to GIS data
Access to data available through MoCH Intranet, and selected information
accessible via IHITC website
departments/subsidiaries of the MoCH to promote the use of GIS and to improve the flow of
information between the various departments and divisions. The proposed center could be
an effective vehicle in introducing such change. It could also be a very effective tool in
assisting the GIS Unit to make MoCH officials and departments realize the importance of
GIS and its application in their various departments, and would be the focal point for the
provision of training and capacity building for other MoCH staff on GIS. Considering the
relevance of the MoCH’s work to other governmental entities (e.g., MMPW, MoB, and
others), the center can also provide the GIS related training and capacity building to staff in
those organizations. In addition to the technical benefit to the MoCH, such training
provision will help the center generate income to help it sustain its operations. Target
trainees will also include engineers and technicians from the private sector as well.
This section of the report outlines the following three areas:
• Importance of and potential uses and applications of GIS at the MoCH in general.
• The GIS related role, mission and objectives of the proposed center
• A detailed plan of GIS training lab requirements and information system network
requirements to meet the above objectives;
5.5.1 Importance Of and Potential Uses and Applications of GIS at the MoCH
In the short to medium term, it is not expected that the MoCH will be able to utilize GIS in the
housing sector to the same extent as in developing countries. The main technical
responsibilities of GIS related activities will most probably remain with the GIS Unit at the
MoCH, however, the proposed center will act as a support vehicle to the Unit in spreading
such applications throughout the MoCH (and probably other relevant ministries).
The power of GIS stems first from its visual capability. A GIS map displays relationships in
the physical world that would be invisible when viewed on a spreadsheet or in a text report.
The type or amount of information available about a particular location that can be displayed
and analyzed in a GIS map is almost unlimited. For instance, a basic map of any
geographic area that is being considered for a housing project shows only the name,
location, and boundary of the area. A GIS map can show the census data of the area, the
exact locations of utilities serving the area, if any, auxiliary services available in the area,
and many other relevant information. This view on the area can help decision makers on the
candidacy of a location for a housing project, its advantages and disadvantages, additional
needs, etc. However, GIS can only do this if such data is available and is entered into the
interactive database.
In other words, Geographical information systems (GIS) can be useful in helping to inform
decisions on resource allocation to meet housing needs. Working from census and other
survey data, enhanced with detailed information means that GIS can provide a desktop tool
at a moderate cost. GIS can help investigate the relationship between the housing and
generalized measures of need not just at one geographical point such as a local authority
district but at a wider range of areas. Thus, it can be used to identify the scale of, for
instance, surpluses of housing over a region. This clearly will be important to the MoCH
where there is doubt about investing in a new housing project. In MoCH housing projects,
the potential uses of GIS range from the allocation of capital resources and guiding
investment decisions to matching prospective tenants with appropriate properties.
GIS is one of the technologies to better control and manage the existing development
including housing and urban development. If properly utilized, the MoCH and other
governmental entities like the MoB can use it as a tool need to identify areas and groups of
people who require access to housing in the various areas of Iraq.
With Iraqi cities growing at a faster rate, the local authorities are limited in resources to
properly manage and control the development, particularly physical development. Control
over development is critical for better urban design not only for existing areas but also for the
future, which can be accomplished through the proper utilization of GIS. Another application
for GIS that the MoCH can benefit from is housing market analysis and surveys.
In the area of housing and community development, GIS can be used in a number of areas
including, site selection, targeting and resource allocation, identifying housing needs, target
populations, and analyzing housing and community development data/projects to determine
where investments are being made.
5.5.2 Mission and Objectives of the GIS Lab
With the wide and diverse GIS applications in the housing sector, the MoCH needs to
develop its capacity in the use and utilization of GIS. The GIS side of the proposed center
will be in the form of a GIS training lab that is sufficiently equipped and staffed to provide
such training as per coordination and direction of the GIS Unit at the MoCH. The main task
of GIS Lab within the proposed Center is to be a source for spatial analysis pertaining to the
housing and construction sector in Iraq. It seeks to provide training and support research
works of geographical nature. Its support activities include obtaining data, conducting spatial
analysis, drawing up applications, evaluating, educating and training.
Other short term objectives of the GIS lab include the following:
• Provide technical support to the GIS Unit at the MoCH (training needs assessments,
identification of equipment needs, data acquisition, spatial analysis, application development
and evaluation, etc.)
• Provide training to other governmental and private sector trainees in GIS as a
revenue generating activity of the proposed centers
• Acting as a facility that could be used by universities and academic institutions in Iraq
for GIS related research
• Act as a liaison for the MoCH GIS Unit to keep up with updates in the technology,
communicate with software providers, and other housing related GIS service providers
• Support the information function of the IHITC (for example, by coordinating closely
with the Urban Observatory Unit)
5.5.3 Staffing
In the initial stages of operation, there will be a full-time lab director/technician. It should be
emphasized that competent GIS experts are hard to come by in the region. Therefore, it
may be that the candidates for the technician position will have to undergo extensive training
before he/she can assume the envisioned role. Also, during the initial stages of the lab’s
operation, it is envisioned that freelance or external trainers will be needed. Those will be
recruited in accordance with the training requirements.
The minimum ideal qualifications of the technician are as follows:
This person will serve as the GIS Lab Director/technician who will mainly work with
MoCH staff (especially at the GIS Unit) to increase GIS use and support in the
MoCH. The director will also teach introductory and in-depth workshops in GIS and
GPS. Other responsibilities include assisting the GIS Unit in with curriculum
assessment and development. He/she will work with MoCH staff members to
support the continued development of the GIS Program at the ministry. He will also
supervise GIS Lab technicians and the freelance trainers in the initial stages. The
director will also make recommendations on new software, hardware and datasets
necessary to support the GIS program at MoCH.
The lab director will report to the center director and will also be able to provide
reference services, research consultation, online searching, collection development,
and bibliographic instruction, developing/delivering traditional and digital library
services that facilitate education and research, specifically in the area of geographic
information systems. Another important role for the director is to participate in grant
proposal writing since the center will be operating on a commercial basis.
With GIS being a fairly new application at MoCH, the lab director shall have the
ability to understand the change process and how it will impact daily activities at the
MoCH; and the ability to change strategies/behaviors in response to changing
priorities and conditions.
The director must have a degree in engineering or a related field with three or more
years of progressively responsible experience in an academic or training laboratory
environment. Must have at least 2-3 years experience in GIS, hands-on experience
using ESRI software products, and experience teaching GIS to a governmental
organization community. Some supervisory experience is needed along with the
ability to gather data and write clear, concise reports. Demonstrated administrative,
organizational, and problem-solving skills. Experience in grant writing and project
development; outstanding written and oral communications skills. Significant
experience with the Internet and web-based technology. The ability to interact
effectively with lab colleagues and all members of the MoCH. English capabilities is
a must.
5.6 Archiving and Library
Over the last ten years or so, many documents have been developed and made available
and distributed in electronic form. There has been a migration from hard copy documents to
CDs, or "read only" electronic books viewable via the Internet using web browsers via
hypertext links or uniform resource locators (URLs), This offers instant access. Documents
are now able to stand the test of time and can be reprinted if necessary when needed.
The documentation and archiving area in the IHITC should aim at providing sources of
information, both national and international and in languages of Arabic and English as a
start, and makes them available to all users whether from the Ministry or not.
The library should present a large selection of books, dissertations, periodicals, conferences,
groups of journals, encyclopedias, dictionaries, and scientific research in both forms of hard
and soft copies. Google now has put almost all existing books on the Internet. Visitors to the
Center will be guided in using this search engine in order to view books online and print
selected pages without having to purchase them.
The library should have a program for its development including periodical maintenance of
books and their covering, internal and external loans, making periodical lists of the recent
collections, answering the enquiries of users, photocopying…etc. In addition, the staff
members of the library are well trained through attending professional conferences and
workshops in order to be able to submit better service and increase the performance of the
library.
The library should make use of international accepted electronic information systems such
as CDS/ISIS database software to build its database. This should enable the user to
technically deal with the records according to the international rules and regulations.
The CDS/ISIS is an advanced non-numerical information storage and retrieval software
developed by UNESCO since 1985 to satisfy the need expressed by many institutions,
especially in developing countries, to be able to streamline their information processing
activities by using modern (and relatively inexpensive) technologies.
The major features of the CDS/ISIS software are:
the handling of variable length records, fields and sub fields, thus saving disk space
and making it possible to store greater amounts of information;
the handling of repeatable fields;
a data base definition component allowing the user to define the data to be
processed for a particular application;
a data entry component for entering and modifying data through user-created data
base specific worksheets;
an information retrieval component using a powerful search language providing for
field-level and proximity search operators, in addition to the traditional and/or/not operators,
as well as free-text searching;
a powerful sort and report generation facility allowing the user to easily create any
desired printed products, such as catalogues, indexes, directories, etc.;
a data interchange function based on the ISO 2709 international standard used by
leading data base producers;
an integrated application programming language (CDS/ISIS Pascal and the
ISIS_DLL), allowing the user to tailor the software to specific needs;
functions allowing the user to build relational data bases, though CDS/ISIS is not
based over a relational model;
Powerful hypertext functions allow the design of a more complex user interfaces.
An initial list of books of reference materials to be included is included in the Appendix.
Based on current rates in Baghdad, the IHITC could charge up to ____ for a 5-day non-
residential course. It could pay trainers up to _____ day in order to access highly qualified
staff.
All training for MoCH will be managed through the IHITC and be managed as IHITC/MoCH
training. It is proposed that the additional training will be funded, through the IHITC, by UN
Habitat. The IHITC should also seek other funding opportunities and once the capabilities
are established.
For 2009-2011, a core budget to fund activities is noted, for which some funding should be
provided by the MoCH. This budget will need refinement and adjustment in 2008, when the
detailed plan for the next phase is developed. Table 5.2 summarizes the budget total.