Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Construction Site Safety: Accident Reporting and Investigation
Construction Site Safety: Accident Reporting and Investigation
You generally have to report deaths, serious Persons covered by the regulations include:
injuries and dangerous occurrences immediately, • employees
and less serious injuries within 10 days.
• self-employed
If you are in an office, shop, warehouse, etc. you
have to notify incidents to your Local Authority • other persons injured on controlled
Environmental Health Department. All other types premises
of premises require reports to be sent to the local
Note
office of the Health and Safety Executive.
Trainees are no longer specifically mentioned
within these regulations, but other regulations
Legislation require that non-employed trainees must be
The Social Security Act 1975 treated as employees for all health and safety
purposes.
The Reporting of Injuries, Diseases and
Dangerous Occurrences Regulations 1995 Reporting deaths, major injuries
References and dangerous occurrences
The procedure for reporting deaths, major injuries
HSE publications
and dangerous occurrences will usually be set out
L73 A Guide to the Reporting of Injuries, Diseases in detail in company safety policies and associated
and Dangerous Occurrences Regulations 1995 documentation. A summary of the main
requirements of the regulations are set out below.
4/1/2
CONTENTS FIRST PAGE
• Specific incidents involving dangerous The minimum particulars that must be kept are:
substances being conveyed by road
• date and time of the accident or dangerous
• Escape of any substance in a quantity occurrence
sufficient to cause death, injury or damage • injured person:
to health
full name and occupation
• Malfunction of any breathing apparatus
whilst in use or when being tested before nature of injury
use • in the event of an accident to a non
• Contact with or arcing of any overhead employee:
power line full name status (e.g. passenger, customer,
visitor or bystander)
Note
There are a total of 72 scheduled dangerous nature of injury
occurrences relating to workplaces in general,
• place where accident or dangerous
mines, quarries and transport systems.
occurrence happened
There are a further 11 in respect of offshore • a brief description of the circumstances in
workplaces. which the accident or dangerous
Other reportable injuries and deaths occurrence happened
The following must be reported to the enforcing • the date on which the event was reported
authority within 10 days on an approved form. (It is to the enforcing authority
expected that Form 2508 will continue to be • the method by which the event was
approved.) reported
• Any accident at work where, because of an Accident Book
injury, a person is incapacitated for work of
their usual kind for more than three Employers are required to keep an accident book
consecutive days, not counting the day of readily available, into which details must be
the accident, but counting rest days, entered of every accident causing personal injury
weekends, etc. to any employee. The entry may be made by the
employee or by anyone acting on their behalf. The
• The death of an employee if it occurs within employer is also required to investigate the
one year of the date of the reportable circumstances of every accident.
injury, even though the injury has been
Completion of the accident book does not meet
previously reported
the employer's obligation to report specific
Keeping records accidents and dangerous occurrences to the HSE
by telephone or on an approved form.
Records must be kept of all reportable deaths,
injuries and dangerous occurrences. No precise The old Accident Book BI 510 may still be used
method is prescribed, but a photocopy of the until it is full, but thereafter, providing all the
approved form is acceptable as are electronic relevant details are correctly entered and the
databanks and computer storage. If an ‘in house’ proper records are maintained, any book may be
accident form provides for the recording of the used.
same details as on the approved form, it is
Reporting diseases
acceptable.
A disease must be reported where it has been
diagnosed in a person doing a specified type of
work. The regulations list diseases against the
type of work which makes them ‘reportable’.
4/1/3
CONTENTS FIRST PAGE
The report must be made when the disease has Pneumoconiosis Work with silica, sand,
been diagnosed by a registered medical grinding wheels, boiler
practitioner, who will notify the employer of it in descaling
writing.
Occupational Work with epoxy resin,
Diseases are reported to the appropriate enforcing dermatitis oil, cement, solvents,
authority on an approved form. (It is expected that hardwoods, plaster,
Form 2508 will be approved by the HSE.) concrete, bleach,
acids, alkalis, wood
Reports must be kept in the same manner as for
preservatives and
accidents and the minimum particulars that must
anything else which
be kept are:
causes dermatitis
• date of diagnosis of the disease Carpel tunnel Work with hand-held
• name of the person affected syndrome vibrating tools
• occupation of the person affected Reference
The Reporting of Diseases and Dangerous
• name or nature of the disease Occurrences Regulations 1995
• the date on which the disease was reported
to the enforcing authority Calculating accident frequency
rates
• the method by which the disease was
reported From the accident records it is possible to
calculate the frequency and incidence rates for
Some of the diseases and work activities listed in accidents at a particular place of work, and for the
the regulations are: types of injury, severity or duration.
Disease Work activity Frequency rate
Chemical and metal Any work activity The frequency rate formula uses 100,000 hours to
poisoning represent a person’s average working life of 50
Chrome ulceration, Work with chrome years at 40 hours per week, and the total number
acne, skin cancer, compounds, mineral of hours worked in a period. The period may be a
Folliculitis oil, tar, pitch, week, a month, a quarter or a year.
radiation
Frequency rate = Accidents x 100,000
Occupational asthma Work with epoxy Total person hours worked
resin, soldering flux, in a period
silica, sand, wood dust
For example, a large firm with some 260
Mesothelioma, lung Work with asbestos
employees had five accidents in a period of three
cancer, asbestosis
months when a total of 125,000 person hours
Leptospirosis Where there are rats, were worked.
field mice, voles or
other small mammals Frequency rate = 5 x 100,000 = 4
125,000
Hepatitis Exposure to blood or
human waste products Monthly and quarterly moving averages, regularly
Nasal or sinus cancer Working in a dusty used over a fixed period, quickly show up
building underlying trends and indicate whether the firm's
accident rate is rising or falling.
Hand, arm vibration Hand-held rotary or
syndrome or percussive tools, By using the formula with different types of
chain saws and hand- accidents, such as no time lost, time lost, time lost
held circular saws over three days, or for different causes, such as a
fall, manual handling, using plant or equipment,
etc. it is possible to determine a wide range of
4/1/4
CONTENTS FIRST PAGE
rates. This is useful in assessing performance and Rates are best displayed as bar charts, histograms
highlighting areas where accidents and losses are and graphs; these make trends visually clear.
occurring.
The frequency and incidence rate formulae given
The accident frequency rate of one company may above are also used in HSE publications.
be compared with that of another. An important
The proper and effective reporting of accidents,
point is to ensure that numbers of employees, or
along with the thorough investigation, can have
person-hours, are not padded out with persons
major benefits for a company. Some of the things
such as clerical staff or other people who are not
to consider are:
at risk due to construction activity.
It is difficult to obtain national accident frequency • reduce costs by implementing change and
rates for the construction industry, but figures preventing accidents.
taken from HSE reports can be used as a • identify training needs which will also
comparison. The best comparisons are, this month improve performance
with last month, this year with last year, since it will
be immediately obvious whether the rate, and the • show HSE inspectors that the company
safety performance, is better or worse. has a pro-active approach to safety
It is important to remember that most published • ensure that you will be able to meet the
statistics deal with reportable accidents only. requirements of the Construction (Design
Incidence rate and Management) Regulations
The incidence rate is easy to use and is based on • satisfy clients and main contractors that
the number of accidents, taken over a fixed period, your workforce is properly trained and
per 1,000 employees: totally safety orientated
Incidence rate = Accidents x 1,000 • benefit from a possible reduction of
Number of employees insurance premiums following years of
For example, if there were six accidents and the hard work to reduce accidents
firm employed an average of 120 employees, the
formula would be: Accident investigation
Incidence rate = 6 x 1,000 = 50 Accident procedure
120
Many firms have established procedures to be
Direct comparisons between the incidence rate
followed in the event of an accident. The
and the frequency rate must never be made, since
procedure outlined below is given as general
they are based on different formulae.
guidance.
Mean duration
The following steps should be taken to deal with
The mean duration, or average length of time lost the accident, and initiate an early investigation into
per accident, can also be calculated. causes:
Mean duration = Number of person-hours lost • attend to the injured person, call for
Number of lost time accidents
assistance if necessary and arrange for
Analysis and presentation of data first aid, doctor, ambulance, hospital
Computers are ideally suited to producing the • isolate machine, tools or equipment
various frequency and accident rates, moving
averages, etc. There are many commercially • do not disturb or move anything unless to
available computer programmes to manage release an injured person
accident statistics or a simple computer • inform manager or safety officer, safety
programme can be easily devised, using the
representative and other appropriate
labour resources and person-hours which are
persons such as fire officers, engineers or
already known for production purposes.
insurers
4/1/5
CONTENTS FIRST PAGE
• ensure any remaining hazard is guarded responsible for investigating accidents must take
against extreme care not to disturb the scene, workplace
• take notice of anything significant and or machinery.
make general observations at the scene of Recording evidence
the accident
Statements from witnesses should contain such
Conducting an investigation details as their age and occupation, etc. The time,
date and place of interview should be indicated at
It is not usually possible to investigate every minor
the end of the statement.
accident, but those involving major or serious
injuries to persons and major damage to plant or Witnesses’ statements should always be written in
equipment should be thoroughly investigated so their own words, even if these include slang or
that immediate action can be taken to prevent a expletives.
recurrence. The following headings may be useful
The statement should be read to the witness, and
as a guide to the steps to be taken:
signed by them and by the person who took the
• investigate promptly statement.
• record evidence Identifying the types of evidence
• identify types of evidence, i.e. factual, Evidence will usually include:
corroborative, etc.
• statement of witnesses and others given
• interview the injured person if possible
orally, or in writing. ‘Others’ may include
• question the person in charge and other experts who have been called in to
supervisors examine a machine or the state of a
scaffold
• obtain details of injured person’s job and
what they usually or normally do • documentation of all kinds
• interview witnesses • material exhibits of all kinds
• inspect plant for signs of misuse or defects Factual evidence comprises the facts related by
• establish the full sequence of events persons directly involved, and by witnesses who
are able to say what they felt, saw, heard, etc., or
• ascertain nature and extent of injury or give an expert opinion. This type of evidence is
damage primary, direct and positive and should be written
• complete accident report and accident book in simple language keeping to the facts and
avoiding inferences, opinions and beliefs. The
• notify appropriate authorities facts should be recorded clearly, accurately and in
Investigate promptly sequence.
The sooner an investigation is started the better, The best witnesses are those persons directly
provided it is safe to do so. involved who are able to:
Engineers and supervisors will be anxious to find • listen carefully to the questions
ways and means of repairing the damage to plant, • answer directly, fairly, impartially and
machinery or buildings, but first priority should be truthfully
to establish the cause of the accident.
• state clearly when they do not know the
Safety specialists and safety representatives will answer
be concerning themselves solely with the safety
implications and preventing a recurrence. • remain calm when they are being asked
questions
It is important that the investigation is properly
Material evidence includes, for example, items of
supervised and organised. Where HSE Inspectors
plant, equipment, machines, scaffolds, ladders,
may wish to investigate, any other persons
4/1/6
CONTENTS FIRST PAGE
hand tools, where the use of or the state or Questioning should not take the form of an
condition of the item has a bearing on the interrogation. Someone well known to the injured
accident. person is probably the best person to do this.
Corroborative evidence tends to support the Safety officials are more likely to receive the co-
truthfulness and accuracy of the evidence which operation of an injured person if they are able to
has already been given. The confirming evidence demonstrate a genuine interest in their welfare and
may take the form of site records, plant or recovery. This may involve visiting the injured
maintenance records, warning notices, written person, with the doctor's approval, in hospital or at
procedures, reports made by safety officers or home.
safety representatives.
Questioning the person in charge
Opinions are not generally acceptable as
evidence in a court of law, but people in the vicinity Establish from the injured person, manager,
of an accident should be asked to give an opinion. supervisor or the person in charge, what the
In this way a full picture can be built up of the normal job and tasks of the injured person were.
circumstances of the accident. Experts or Did they include the activity which led up to the
specialists who are familiar with the type of accident? Other questions which might be asked
accident, or technical and other factors include:
surrounding the accident, may be called upon to • what task or type of job was being
express their expert opinions. performed?
When there is a lack of real or factual evidence, • was it planned or part of a planned activity?
other forms of evidence such as circumstantial • at what stage of the work did the accident
and corroborative evidence tend to become more occur?
valuable.
• was the person involved trained, and if so,
Photographs taken immediately after an accident when?
record the state of the scene and often highlight
conditions which existed at the time. Machines, • was the person authorised to carry out that
equipment, tools and obstructions, and factors type of work or use machinery in that
such as floor conditions, space, dimensions, etc. location?
may show up very well on photographs. • was the person authorised to be where the
If possible, it is best to engage professional accident occurred?
photographers and to obtain the largest possible • what instructions had been given?
prints. Time, date and place or subject
• how many other persons were or should
photographed should be written on the back of the
have been involved in the activity?
pictures.
• was the activity or task covered by any
Interviewing the injured person statutory regulations or code of practice?
This should be an early priority. Even the briefest • were safe and correct procedures being
description of the accident should suffice initially. observed?
The physical and mental state of the injured • did unsafe acts cause the accident? If so,
person will need to be considered, and tact and were they those of the injured person,
patience required during the interview. The injured workmates, or others?
person should be in a fit state to answer
questions. • did any unsafe condition contribute to the
accident?
The injured person should be encouraged to talk
about how the accident happened and it is • what safety equipment or personal
important they have confidence and trust in the protection was available and in use?
listener. It is important to stress that the purpose of • were other contractors’ employees or plant
the investigation is to find the cause so that and machinery involved or at fault?
preventive action can be taken. Blame should not
be apportioned.
4/1/7
CONTENTS FIRST PAGE
• had the injured person been involved in reveal signs of misuse or defects which may or
previous accidents? may not have contributed to the accident. The
scene should also be carefully examined to see if
Interviewing witnesses trip hazards, slippery floors, or some other defect
Skill is required when interviewing. Witnesses contributed to, or caused, the accident.
should be interviewed one at a time. If they wish to Assistance from specialists and persons directly
say anything before notes are taken, they should involved or familiar with the type of plant,
be allowed to do so. equipment, or machinery in question can provide
valuable information.
Interviewers should seek answers to the following
basic questions: Establish a sequence of events
• what did the witness actually see or hear? Evidence gained from interviews and from
• what was the witness doing at the time? inspection of the scene, plant, equipment or
machinery, should give an indication of the
• what was the proximity of the witness to the sequence of events leading up to the accident.
accident or occurrence?
Ascertain the extent of injury or damage
• what actions did the witness take?
It is not always possible to ascertain the full extent
• what actions did others take before and of injuries and damage resulting from an accident.
after the accident?
There may be complications or delayed effects
• what was the condition of the workplace at from injuries. The total time off work will obviously
the time? not be known at the time of investigation.
• what hazards or unsafe conditions existed; Whilst it may be easy to identify the extent of the
what unsafe acts were performed? damage caused to plant, machinery, equipment,
• what was the probable cause(s) of the buildings and materials, it is far from easy to
accident or occurrence? measure the overall effects of the accident in
terms of lost time, lost production and, of course,
Skilled interviewers allow witnesses to tell things in
the suffering of the injured person or persons.
their own way, intervening only to clear up specific
points or answers where necessary. Questions Completion of the accident book and an
should be impartial, and should be recorded accident report form
together with the answers.
Accident report details will vary, depending on who
It is expected that certain details will differ in produces the report and whom the report is for. To
witnesses’ accounts, but there should be help eliminate or reduce this variation, guidance in
agreement about basic facts if the true cause of making reports and the use of a standard form is
an accident or occurrence is to be determined. recommended.
The important witnesses are those persons Reports should be concise, unbiased and should
involved. Their evidence will be more valuable summarise the essential information obtained
than evidence from witnesses who saw or heard during the investigation.
only from a distance, although, they too, should be
Sample accident and damage report forms are
interviewed. Corroborative evidence and
included as Appendices A and B.
information is often required, particularly when
witnesses are few or are not reliable.
As much evidence and information as possible
should be collected, since the action taken to
prevent a recurrence will be based on what is
learned.
Inspection of plant for misuse or defects
Inspection of plant, equipment, tools and
machinery immediately after an accident may
4/1/8
CONTENTS FIRST PAGE
..................................................................................................................................................................
6. Normal occupation....................................................................................................................................
12. To whom was the accident reported? ............................Date ............... Time ........................................
16. Has the accident been recorded in the official company register? ..........................................................
19. Was the injured person authorised to be at the place of the accident for the purpose of his/her
work?
..................................................................................................................................................................
4/1/9
CONTENTS FIRST PAGE
..................................................................................................................................................................
b) State what the injured person was doing at the time ...........................................................................
c) If falls of persons from heights or into excavations or holes are involved, state distance of fall in .....
metres
..................................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................
23. Names and addresses of witnesses to the accident. Obtain witnesses wherever possible.
Attach signed statement from each witness.
a) ..............................................................................................................................................................
b) ..............................................................................................................................................................
c) ..............................................................................................................................................................
4/1/10
CONTENTS FIRST PAGE
4/1/11