Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Effect of Moisture On Significant Mechanical Characteristics of Masonry
The Effect of Moisture On Significant Mechanical Characteristics of Masonry
percentual representation, %
B Kutná Hora (beggining of 20. cent.)
35
masonry units A Kutná Hora (beggining of 20. cent.)
16 Humpolec (beggining of 20. cent.)
3 Humpolec (beggining of 20. cent.) 25
1 Humpolec (beggining of 20. cent.)
The research of the effect of moisture on the values of 11 Fořt (17. cent.) 20
5 Fořt (17. cent.)
40
the compressive strength fb of masonry units has ma-
15
nifested a significant influence of moisture on the com- 10
pressive strength and modulus of elasticity of porous 5
building materials. 0.001 0.01 0.1
0
1 10
diameter of pores, μm
Fig. 1 displays experimentally determined rela-
tionships of the compressive strength fb, the modulus Fig. 2. Size and distribution of pores –
of elasticity E for bricks obtained from core boreholes bricks specified by mercury porosimetry
sampled from historical masonry in the pore saturati-
on state. Fig. 2 shows diagrams expressing the number, terval from 0% to 100% of saturation is a variable de-
distribution and size of pores for individual types of pending, apart from the saturation degree, also on the
bricks determined by means of mercury porosimetry. size and frequency of occurrence of individual pores.
Based on the analysis of the results of experi- The results of research indicate that the effect of mois-
mental research, with regards to the limited number ture on the investigated characteristics of bricks (fb,
of samples, we may state that the effect of moisture E) is more prominent in bricks with a porous system
content expressed by the saturation degree of the po- with a significant proportion of pores sized d∈ (0.01–
rous system on the compressive strength fb and the 1) mm as compared to bricks with a porous system
modulus of elasticity E of bricks ranging in the in- containing a significant proportion of pores sized d∈
(1.0–10) mm.
Fig. 3 displays experimentally obtained charts of fb
a) bricks – stregth x aborptivity x w and E x w relationships for sandstone and arenace-
140 ous marl. Fig. 4 displays the pore distribution in sands-
120
tone and arenaceous marl. In the case of sandstone, the
respective relationships clearly show that sandstones
100
with a greater proportion of pores sized d∈(10–100)
strength, %
0
0 20 40 60 80 100 sandstone, arenaceous marl –
saturation level, % a)
strenght x absortivity
120
sandstone, arenaceous marl – arenaceos marl – T
b) modulus of elasticity x absortivity arenaceos marl – N
120 100 sandstone
strength, %
100 80
modulus of elasticity, %
60
80
60 40
40 20
arenaceos marl – T
20 arenaceos marl – N 0
0 20 40 60 80 100
sandstone saturation level, %
0
0 20 40 60 80 100 sandstone, arenaceous marl –
saturation level, %
b) modulus of elasticity x absortivity
120
40
arenaceos marl – T
sandstone porosimetry
a) 60 20 arenaceos marl – N
7 Fořt (17. cent.)
6 Fořt (17. cent.)
sandstone
15 Fořt (17. cent.) 0
2 Fořt (17. cent.) 50 0 20 40 60 80 100
percentual representation, %
a)
ween the parts of the unit’s cross section with different
values of the modulus of elasticity E (rigidity E*U) and
Fořt (17. cent.)
60
thus with a tendency towards a different primary de-
Fořt (17. cent.)
40
its separation. The exceeding of the shear strength of
Boseň (17. cent.)
moisture along the cross section of extruded masonry as well as the results of experimental research of the
pillars (w∈(0%; 20%)), contrary to the constant mois- effect of moisture on the strength R and the modu-
ture content pattern (w = const.), the equilibrium state lus of elasticity E of P15 and P30 bricks (Witzany et
is disturbed and the normal compressive stresses are al. 2003; Čejka 2002), in the moisture content interval
redistributed along the cross section of the masonry whm ∈ (3.5%; 15%) (Fig. 10).
pillar (Fig. 8). The comparison of vertical and horizontal de-
formations of extruded masonry pillars with different
Dry Drying up Getting wet moisture contents of masonry (whm ∈ (1.36%; 15.81%))
clearly shows a progressive growth in the deformations
Course of moisture
~ 20% ~ 20%
~ 20%
(strain) of masonry pillars with high moisture contents
< 3% < 3% by weight (Figs. 11, 12). Fig. 13 manifests the effect of
< 3%
increased masonry moisture contents on a drop in the
masonry rigidity (growth in deformations, additional
Dry Drying up Getting wet pushing) by up to 80 to 90% with a simultaneous drop
in the masonry strength by up to 40% (Fig. 9) at a ma-
Stress – bricks
102.2% 102.6%
101.3%
102.2%
101.1% 101.1% sonry moisture content of 15.81% by weight as com-
100%
pared to the masonry moisture content of 3.56% by
98.8% 98.8%
98.6% 98.6%
weight (Witzany et al. 2009).
Stress – ar. marl
125.6%
120.6% 700 631 kN 626.8 kN
101% 100%
600
100% 481.2 kN
93.1% 93.1% 500 76%
93%
Load, kN
380.2 kN
400 60%
Stress – sandst.
100
of masonry 95
Experimental research of the effect of moisture on the
85
load-bearing capacity and rigidity of masonry pillars
has manifested a prominent drop in the load-bearing 75
capacity of extruded masonry pillars with their gro-
65
wing moisture content up to a value of 60% at a mois-
ture content of 15.81% by weight, as compared to their 55
100% load-bearing capacity at a 3.5% moisture content
by weight (Fig. 9). 0 5 10 12 15 25
w. moisture, %
A relative drop in the experimentally determined
load-bearing capacity of masonry in compression in Fig. 10. Comparison of load-bearing capacity of masonry in
relation to the masonry moisture content is in a good compression determined experimentally (Witzany et al. 2003),
using regulations for reconstruction design currently in force
accord with the relative drop determined using the re-
and using experimentally determined relationships R x w for
gulations for reconstruction design currently in force P15 bricks (Čejka 2002)
84 J.Witzany et al. The Effect of Moisture on Significant Mechanical Characteristics of Masonry
column 8 (15.0%)
3E-03 2.90E-03 column 8 (16.6%)
1.2
1
1.96E-03
2E-03 1.81E-03 1.82E-03 0.8
1.24E-03 1.24E-03 0.6
9.34E-04
1E-03 0.4
4.92E-04 4.67E-04 5.57E-04
3.66E-04
0.2
0
1.36% 3.56% 14.26% 15.81% 0
w. moisture of masonry columns, % 100 200 300 400 500 600 700
Load, kN
Fig. 11. Comparison of experimentally determined vertical
deformations of extruded masonry pillars for selected levels of Fig. 13. Comparison of rigidity of masonry pillars for various
loading with compressive force and masonry moisture content moisture content values in relation to loading
–1E–03
rial and physical models, may lead to erroneous conclu-
sions, but it may also be the cause of a faulty reconstruc-
–1.5E–03
tion concept and a subsequent appearance of structural
–2E–03 failures and defects. Insufficiently cogent boundary
105.45 kN
210.90 kN conditions and input parameters describing the physi-
324.75 kN –2.28E–03
–2.5E–03 cal and mechanical characteristics of masonry and its
individual components cannot be overrated by the ap-
Fig. 12. Comparison of experimentally determined horizontal
plication of “the most sophisticated” numerical model.
deformations of extruded masonry pillars for selected levels of
loading with compressive force and masonry moisture content
Acknowledgements
Kotlík, P.; Šrámek, J.; Kaše, J. 2000. Opuka [Arenaceous marl], in Weishauptová, Z. 2008. Texturní analýza stavebních materiálů
STOP. Praha. ISBN 80-902668-5-1 (in Czech). podle vysokotlaké rtuťové porozimetrie [Texture Analysis
Kutílek, M. 1984. Vlhkost pórovitých materiálů [Moisture Con- of Materials Using High Pressure Mercury Porosimetry], in
tent of Porous Materials]. SNTL. Praha (in Czech). Protocol, AV ČR, Ústav struktury a mechaniky hornin, May–
October, Praha, 2008 (in Czech).
Nwaubani, S.; Mulheron, M.; Tilly, G.; Schwamborn, B. 2000.
Pore-structure and water transport properties of surface- Witzany, J.; Čejka, T.; Zigler, R. 2003. Experimentální výzkum
treated building stones, Materials and Structures 4: 198–206. vlivu vlhkosti na fyzikální a mechanické vlastnosti porézních
doi:10.1007/BF02479415 stavebních materiálů a nosných zděných konstrukcí [Experi-
mental Research of the Effect of Moisture on Physical and
Pavlík, Z.; Michálek, P.; Pavlíková, M.; Černý, R., et al. 2007. Mechanical Characteristics of Porous Building Materials
Mšenský pískovec z pohledu transportu a akumulace vlhko- and Masonry Bearing Capacity], Stavební obzor 12(8): 97–
sti a solí – část 1 [Mšeno Sandstone with a view to Moisture 104. ISSN 1210-4027 (in Czech).
and Salt Transport and Accumulation – Part 1], Stavební ob-
zor 17(2): 33–39. ISSN 1210-4027 (in Czech). Witzany, J.; Čejka, T. 2008. Výzkum fyzikálně mechanických
vlastností porézních zdících prvků [Research of Physical and
Půbal, Z.; Myška, M. 2008. Účinky vlhkosti na konstrukce staveb Mechanical Charactersitic of Porous Masonry Materials],
z porézních materiálů [The Effects of Moisture on Building Stavební obzor 17(10): 289–292. ISSN 1210-4027 (in Czech).
Constructions from Porous Materials], Tepelná ochrana bu-
dov 11(1) (in Czech). Witzany, J.; Čejka, T.; Zigler, R. 2008. Stanovení zbytkové únos-
nosti existujících zděných konstrukcí [Determination of
Šatava, Vl. 1973. Relation between pore structure and mechani- Residual Load-Bearing Capacity of Existing Masonry Struc-
cal properties of materials, in Pore structure and properties tures], Stavební obzor 17(9): 257–265. ISSN 1210-4027 (in
of materials, Prague, September 18 to 21, 1973, D-5–D-25. Czech).
Šrámek, J. 1992. Relationship between meneralogy, physical- Witzany, J.; Čejka, T.; Zigler, R. 2009. The effect of moisture on
mechanical properties and durability of Creataceous calcitic significant mechanical characteristics of masonry, in Inter-
spongilites, in Proc. 7th International Congres on Deteriora- national Conference on Computional Design in Engineering,
tion and Corservation of Stine, Lisboa, Portugal, 57–66. CODE 2009.
Jiří WITZANY. Professor, Dr Sc., Dr.h.c., Eng., Rector Emeritus, Department of Building Structures, Faculty of Civil En-
gineering, Czech Technical University in Prague, Czech republic. Chief researcher of 2 research plan and 10 grant, author
and co-author of 10 monographs, 58 defended research reports, 180 scientific and technical articles and papers on domestic
and international conferences, 18 university textbooks, 8 experimental buildings and constructions, 5 utility models. His
extensive research activity, mainly in recent years, has been concentrated on the problems of designing building structures,
has carried out extensive theoretic and experimental research of prefabricated structures, reconstruction and rehabilitation
designs of concrete and masonry buildings, degradation processes, durability and reliability of buildings. He has designed the
reconstruction concept of Charles Bridge.
Tomáš ČEJKA. Ph.D., Eng. Assistant lecturer at the Department of Bulding Constructions, Faculty of Civil Engineering,
Czech Technical University in Prague, Czech republic. Co-researcher of 2 research plan and 8 grant, author and co-author of
10 monographs, 3 utility models, 32 scientific and technical articles and over 40 papers on domestic and international confer-
ences, 18 defended research reports His research interests include structural analysis, mainly of masonry and precast conrete
structures, reconstructions and renovations of buildings etc.
Radek ZIGLER. Ph.D., Eng. Assistant lecturer at the Department of Bulding Constructions, Faculty of Civil Engineering,
Czech Technical University in Prague, Czech republic. Co-researcher of 2 research plan and 8 grant, author and co-author of
10 monographs, 3 utility models, 32 scientific and technical articles and over 40 papers on domestic and international confer-
ences, 18 defended research reports His research interests include structural analysis, mainly of masonry and precast conrete
structures, reconstructions and renovations of buildings etc.