Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 26

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/343064269

Noise Control in Residential Buildings

Article · July 2020

CITATION READS
1 9,948

2 authors:

Aayush Adhikari Bishal Thapa


Tribhuvan University Tribhuvan University
2 PUBLICATIONS   1 CITATION    2 PUBLICATIONS   1 CITATION   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Seepage Analysis of an Earthen Dam View project

Landslide Susceptibility Mapping of Phewa Watershed using AHP View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Bishal Thapa on 20 July 2020.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


Running head: NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 1

Noise Control in Residential Buildings

Aayush Adhikari

Bishal Thapa

Department of Civil and Geomatics Engineering

Institute of Engineering (IOE), Pokhara


NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 2

Abstract

Acoustics play a vital role in design and construction as they can significantly define the

ambiance of any residential building. While sound as a whole may not necessarily be unsettling,

the excessive unpleasant sound turns to noise and can vitiate the ambiance of a building. It is

therefore of paramount importance that the acoustic factors of a building be considered and

methods to mitigate the noise be implemented where necessary. In this article, we shall discuss

the various methods which may be brought about regarding the noise control in residential

buildings while also considering their efficacy.

Keywords: Noise Control, Acoustics, Site planning, Construction, Barriers.


NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 3

Noise Control in Residential Buildings

Sound is created when the surrounding air molecules are vibrated by external energy.

While sound altogether is unavoidable in any residential building, excessive and unpleasant

sound i.e. noise is undesirable. Whether the noise produced is coming from the traffic nearby,

airports, factories, events, or functions, excessive noise is undesirable to any resident. When

exposed to such undesirable noise for a prolonged period, the noise can cause irritation, fatigue,

degradation in listening power, and some cases even permanent damage to the ear. It has been

observed that the sounds above 90 decibels can cause chronic hearing damage. In modern times,

with the recognition of sound pollution, the realization that noise is a health hazard has also

taken place. As such, it has become pressing that the acoustics of a residential building and the

effects it may have on the residents be taken into consideration.


NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 4

Architectural Design for Noise Control

The architectural design of any building can play a vital role in noise control. It deals

with proper placement of the relevant rooms and elements like doors and windows, in order to

reduce the unwanted and excessive noise and hence provide a more ambient environment. This is

much more economical compared to other methods.

The following ideas during design may be put to practice for an acoustically whole

building:

● During design, the placement of rooms should be done in a manner such that the

rooms which are more likely to be affected by the noise (bedrooms, living room,

and dining room) be placed at maximum distance from the source of the noise.

The lesser affected rooms (kitchen, playroom, bathroom) be placed nearer to the

source, and as such, they can provide an effective shield between the source and

the noise.

Figure 1 Example of acoustically sound placement of rooms


NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 5

● Walls which act as the major insulation between the noise and the room itself

should be designed in such a manner that they have the least possible number of

openings towards the source of the noise. The wall cavities like doors and

windows bring down the effectiveness of the wall in keeping the noise away.

● The presence of natural barriers in the design of a one-story house can effectively

block the noise coming from the sources. However, they will be less effective in

the case of high rise buildings.

Figure 2 Use of natural barriers


NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 6

● During the design part, it is imperative that the placement of balconies also be

given much consideration. The improper placement of balconies as shown in the

figure can lead to the noise being drawn into the building instead of keeping it

away in case of tall buildings. Therefore, the balconies should be placed away

from the source of noise which will help to reduce the noise levels.

Figure 3 Role of balconies in noise control


● Finally, having a courtyard or open space in and around the house can also be put to

practice. The courtyard will provide distance from the source of noises and as such the

building will be less disposed to high levels of noise. However, it is not practicable where

there is not adequate space for the construction.

Pros. The advantages of using architectural design for noise control are:

● It is one of the most economically feasible methods.

● It is easy to put to practice as the only requirement is that of an acoustical

consultant.

● It is practiced during the design of a building so there is no hassle of extra

construction or expenditure.
NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 7

Cons. The disadvantages of using architectural design for noise control are:

● It has limited effectiveness against multiple sources of noise.

● It may be difficult to implement in the present context of rapid urbanization.

Sound absorption

The sound-absorbing ability of any building element needs to be measured using a certain

unit or a parameter. The American Society of Testing and Measurement put forward a class

rating that proves helpful in our quest to study the sound absorption ability of any building

element. According to it, the sound absorption of any element can be measured in terms of the

Sound Transmission Class (STC). It is a unit that directly corresponds to the number of decibels

of sound which is reduced when sound passes through a building element. For example, if a

sound of 70 decibels passes through a wall and the internal sound is of 50 decibels, then it can be

concluded that the wall has a Sound Transmission Class value of 20.(Federal Highway

Administration, 1972) This can prove to be particularly effective for acoustical planners.
NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 8

Construction techniques in acoustical planning

The use of proper construction techniques in a building can play a huge role in noise

reduction. During the construction period, it is necessary to carefully plan the various building

elements like the wall, doors, windows, etc. keeping in mind their function as noise reducers.

The improper construction techniques may not only fail to stop the excessive noise but also lead

to the building being noisier. As any kind of sound that enters into the building must pass

through one or the other building element, we can use the proper construction technique and

hence help to reduce the noise levels.

Construction Techniques for Various Building Elements

For ample noise reduction and acoustic wellness of a building, the building elements

should be constructed with proper planning and techniques. Some of which we will discuss

below:

Walls. Walls are perhaps the most essential component in noise reduction for any

building. They are responsible for blocking most of the sources of noise and keeping

it away. If there are any frailties in the wall, the structure itself may also be

jeopardized. Walls are the most effective in keeping noise away and here we shall

discuss some methods which can be used to further improve their abilities:

● Increasing the thickness of a wall increases mass of the wall which in turn

increases its sound insulation and this helps to further reduce the noise.

● Airspace can be provided in between two layers of the wall. The air in between

the layers helps to insulate the noise. It is economical.


NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 9

● In walls where studs are used, it is advisable to increase the spacing between them

to provide more insulation to the noise.

● Increasing the airspace between the walls (where used) and providing a blanket of

sound-absorbing material such as wool can also be done where necessary.

● Finally, the wall should be made free of cracks and the edges should be sealed to

make the most of its insulating capacity.

Figure 4 Noise mitigation techniques for wall


NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 10

Windows. Windows are the most vulnerable element in noise control. They not only

bring about cavities in the wall but also have very little sound insulation themselves.

Thus the proper construction techniques and plans must be practiced to ensure that

the windows do not degrade the insulation of the wall and also to make the most of

the insulation ability of windows.

● Placement of windows must be given proper thought. They should be avoided where

possible and should be kept away from possible sources of noise.

● The size of the windows is another aspect to be considered. The larger size allows for

more noise to pass through and so the window must be made of optimum size.

● The windows must be made sealable so that they can be opened when necessary but

closed when required.

● Also, the glass used in the window can be altered. The use of double-glazed glass or

even thicker glass can significantly improve the sound insulation of a window.

Doors. Although doors are inevitably the major pathway of letting noise in, they are

much more complicated to handle for noise control. We can however take the following steps to

ensure some effort for noise control is made:

● Solid soundproof doors, although expensive, are perhaps the best choice for noise

control regarding doors.

● Gasket stops can be used on doors to ensure the doors are properly sealed and noise is

not let in.

● Also, the placement of doors is a vital aspect. Doors should be placed far from the

source of noise where possible.


NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 11

Ceilings and Floors. On buildings where the noise sources may come from overhead or

beneath the building, necessary steps may have to be taken.

● The use of thick concrete slabs in ceilings or floors can be done to reduce the noise.

● Also, false ceilings and false floors can be put to practice.

Masking. Noise masking is basically just the covering up the noise coming from the

source by the use of music, electronics devices, and such.


NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 12

Acoustical Site Planning

Acoustical site planning refers to placing proposed development on a site such that

maximum advantage is taken of acoustical isolation for both interior and exterior open spaces. It

includes:

● Placing as much distance as possible between the noise source like traffic and

noise-sensitive area;

● Placing noise compatible activities like commercial facilities, parking spaces

between a noise source and noise-sensitive areas;

● Using buildings as barriers;

● Using noise-sensitive buildings to face away from the noise.

Following are the methods of acoustical site planning:

Distance

By increasing distance between a residential building and a potential source of unwanted

noise, noise can be effectively reduced. Doubling the distance from a noise source can reduce

its intensity by as much as 6 dB. (Federal Highway Administration, 1972)

Figure 5 Effect of distance on sound intensity


NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 13

In the case of skyscrapers and other tall buildings, it is by perhaps the most practical technique

that can be put to practice as any other method of noise mitigation seems very problematic to

be put to practice.

Noise Compatible Land Uses as Buffers:

Placing noise compatible activities between residential zones and noise source, adjacent

communities are protected from noise sources like highway and airports. This increases the

distance between the noise source and noise-sensitive establishments. Furthermore, facilities

constructed between them may act as a noise barrier.

Figure 6 Garage is kept between the highway and residential zone


NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 14

Pros. Advantages of using noise compatible land use as a buffer are:

● Along with reducing the impact of noise, noise compatible land uses can further

enhance communities by providing space for essential infrastructures and services

like parking spaces and supermarkets.

● Planned and predetermined ways of land usage allow for greater development

flexibility of neighboring communities.

Cons. Demerits of using noise compatible land use as a buffer are:

● Enough land may not be available.

Cost: Cost of using noise compatible land use as the buffer is low, as only expenses are fees of

the acoustical consultant and the site planner.

Buildings as Noise Shields

The concept of using building while are less sensitive to noise as the shields for

mitigating the noise that may reach the noise sensitive building is a feasible one. One study

shows that a two-story building can reduce noise levels on the side of the building away from the

noise source by about 13dBA.(Hans et al., 1963)

Pros. Benefits of using buildings as noise shields are:

● Using buildings eliminates the need for other sound barriers.

● Urban areas lacking space for other measures can adopt this measure to deal with

the noise of a bustling urban area.

Cons. Disadvantages of using buildings as noise shields are:

● If the buildings used as a shield are noise sensitive, they have to be

soundproofed.

● Gaps between buildings will reduce the effectiveness of the noise shield.
NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 15

Construction. Pre-existing buildings or new buildings can be used to insulate the inner area from

noise.

Cost. In preplanned places, the incurred cost is that of an acoustic planner only. However, in places

where buildings as noise shields are used at later stages of development, the cost of repurposing a

preexisting building and cost of soundproofing a building used for noise-sensitive activities should

also be considered.

Planned unit development and residential cluster development

Planned unit developments (PUDs) and cluster developments are forms of land design

that usually focus on the integration of the natural features of a site with the new development to

be constructed on the site.

Cluster (or Clustering) is a site-planning technique that concentrates buildings and

structures in specific areas on a lot, site, or parcel to allow the remaining land to be used for

recreation, open space, or preservation of features or structures with environmental, historical,

cultural, or other significance.

Maintaining adequate distance by keeping open spaces between noise source and

residence, PUD, and cluster development can be used as a proactive measure to deal with noise.

Pros. advantages of using planned unit development and residential cluster development

as noise shields are:

● The appearance of communities can be maintained properly.

● Planned and predetermined ways of land usage allow for greater development

flexibility of neighboring communities.


NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 16

Cons. Disadvantages of using planned unit development and residential cluster

development as noise shields are:

● Due to the positioning of open spaces closer to the noise source, noise-sensitive

recreational activities may be hindered.

Construction. Construction of planned unit development and residential cluster

development is dependent on long term planning. It requires foresight from planners, central

government, local bodies, and citizens.

Cost. It depends on local factors like the size of the area, planned zones, land

acquisition, manpower available.


NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 17

Figure 7 Planned unit development and residential cluster development


NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 18

Barriers

Barriers are the obstructions placed between the source of a sound and the receiver(Federal

Highway Administration, 1972). To be effective, barrier height must cover the line of sight

between them. The most commonly used barriers are earth berms and solid walls. Absorptive

sound barriers are better than reflective ones as these reduce the chances of formation of the echo

chamber.

To achieve a 5-decibel reduction of noise, a barrier must be built at the line of sight (and

hearing) of the average individual. The primary determinant of its effectiveness is its height: every

additional meter above the line of sight reduces the sound by an additional 1.5 decibels.

Earth Berms

Earth berm is a sloped structure built adjacent to highways within its right of way. Its

height ranges from 5’ to 50’ depending upon the impedance required.

Figure 8 Earth berm cross-section

Earth berms reflect and absorb sound waves. Since earth berms are inclined, and not

exactly vertical, the sound gets deflected upwards with many reduced chances of echo chambers

being created
NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 19

Pros. Advantages of using earth berm as noise barrier are:

● A berm can provide noise attenuation of up to 15 dBA if it is several feet higher than

the “line of sight” between the noise source and the receiver. (Federal Highway

Administration, 1972)

● Compared to walls of the same height, earth berms provide 1 to 3 dBA better noise

attenuation.

Cons. Disadvantages of using earth berm as noise barrier are:

● Building earth berms later is significantly costlier than building the wall at the same

time. The cost of constructing earth berms can rise significantly with a slight increase

in its height.

Construction. Earth berm must cover the line of sight between source and recipient of

noise to work effectively. Further increase in height depends upon the required insulation. The

ground area covered depends upon the height and slope of the berm.

Cost. The cost involved in the construction of an earth berm are:

● Construction cost: Land acquisition cost is dictated by the area upon which

construction goes on. Seeding and plantation costs are also included as construction

costs.

● Maintenance cost: Drainage, erosion prevention, mowing, etc are maintenance costs

to be considered.
NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 20

Wall

Thin, vertical structures made of rigid particles like steel and concrete can be used to

prevent direct transmission of sound to neighborhoods. Generally, walls work by reflecting sound

waves. Walls of absorptive nature can also be constructed with grooves on walls, and walls with

vegetation.

Pros. Advantages of using walls as noise barrier are:

● A wall can provide noise attenuation of up to 15 dBA if it is several feet higher than

the “line of sight” between the noise source and the receiver.(California Division of

Highways, 1972)

● As vertical walls are of small thickness, they can be installed easily at places with

limited space thus allowing walls to be built as post-construction noise mitigation

measures.

Cons. Disadvantages of using walls as noise barrier are:

● Though effective for residents living within its vicinity, walls are less effective at larger

distances.

● Due to the reflective nature of walls, residents previously undisturbed by highway noises

complain of disturbance after the construction of walls.

Figure 9 Sound waves reflected by walls


NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 21

● Commuters as well as residents complain of damage to scenery due to construction of

walls: "It turns backyards into prison walls", "With walls roads feel like a tunnel with no

roof."

Construction. Walls can be constructed of any solid structure high enough with adequate

mass and density. Generally used materials are wood, precast concrete, and woods; among these,

precast concrete has been observed to lack durability. With these materials, walls can be made of

virtually unlimited designs as a requirement.

Cost. Cost is largely dependent upon the type, manpower, maintenance, weather

condition, and other local factors. It is worth noticing that the cost of installing precast concrete

walls on one side of the highway in California has reached up to 2 million USD.

Plantations

Planting vegetation adjacent to the street can also reduce noise to some degree. Plants

absorb and scatter sound waves. Plants also provide psychological relief, providing appealing

aesthetics and hiding sources of noise from.

Pros. Advantages of using plantations as barrier are:

● They provide pleasant aesthetics and are psychologically relaxing.

Cons. Disadvantages of using plantations as noise barrier are:

● The performance of plants as a barrier is quite unsatisfactory compared to other

alternatives.

● Deciduous plants will be effective during some periods only.


NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 22

Construction. Building a proper plantation barrier needs enough land, adequate plants,

as well as time for plants to grow to desirable height are required monetary and time cost.

Cost. Costs are much more dictated by factors like plants used, maintenance required,

etc.

Combination of various barrier designs

Often, the most economical, acoustically acceptable, and aesthetically pleasing barrier is some

combination of the barrier types previously discussed.

In addition to cost advantages, an earth berm with a barrier wall on top of it possesses several

other advantages over both a wall and a berm alone:

● It is more visually pleasing than a wall of equivalent height.

● The berm portion of this combination is less dangerous for a motorist leaving the

roadway.

● The non-vertical construction of the berm does not reflect noise to the opposite side

of the highway the way a wall does.

● The combination requires less land than would be required for a berm of equivalent

height and slope.

● Another combination to be considered is that of plantings in combination with a

barrier. Not only do plantings and ground cover provide some additional noise

attenuation, but they also increase visual appeal.


NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 23

Conclusion

We have discussed some of the methods pertinent to the reduction of noise in residential

buildings. While the applicability and adeptness of the aforementioned methods may differ

concerning the location, space of the building, and the nature of the noise, it is established that

the use of the said methods can be of huge help for noise reduction. As discussed already the

proper acoustical design and construction is applicable in case of the buildings which are yet to

be built; these methods being generally economical are applicable even in case of regular

building construction. Planned unit development and residential cluster development are the

most feasible and cost-efficient when implemented as proactive measures to protect

communities from noise. Barriers can be used as both proactive and reactive measures; the wall

is often the most effective when noise sources like highways are constructed near to a preexisting

community, whereas other barriers like earth berms and plantations are better suited to preserve

the appearance of communities along with protecting them from noise.


NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 24

References

Bolt, Beranek, and Newman, Inc. (1971). Highway Noise; a Design Guide for Highway

Engineers. Highway Research Board, National Research Council.

https://books.google.com.np/books?id=y3AnAQAAMAAJ&pg=RA5-PA102&lpg=RA5-

PA102&dq=residential+cluster+development+and+noise+control&source=bl&ots=RGM

db7GD0c&sig=ACfU3U0Sd-dqXmS6MJG-

420AJZOnrzw2iA&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwiV48COu8fqAhWHwzgGHXpxDGY

Q6AEwC3oECA0QAQ#v=onepage&q=residential%20cluster%20development%20and

%20noise%20control&f=false

Busch, T. B., Hodgson, M. H., & Wakefield, C. W. (2003). Scale-model study of the

effectiveness of highway noise barriers. Www.Researchgate.Net, 5–8.

https://doi.org/10.1121/1.1605412

California Division of Highways, Highway Noise Control, Value Engineering Study, (October

1972), P.33

Federal Highway Association (FHWA) & Louisiana Department of Transportation and

Development (LaDOTD). (2000). I-49 Connector, Lafayette: Environmental Impact

Statement. Federal Aid Project.

Federal Highway Administration. (1972). The Audible Landscape: A Manual for Highway Noise

and Land Use. https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/environment/noise/noise_barriers/inventory/

Federal Highway Administration. (1972). The Audible Landscape: A Manual for Highway Noise

and Land Use. Pages 35-58 [Image Files] Retrieved From:

https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/environment/noise/noise_barriers/inventory/
NOISE CONTROL IN RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 25

Hans, Bernard, & Relchow. (1963). Town Planning and Noise Abatement. Architect’s Journal,

137(7), 357–360.

Landau, M. D. L. (2017). On Highway Noise Barriers, the Science Is Mixed. Are There

Alternatives? Undark.Org. https://undark.org/2017/12/27/highway-noise-barrier-science/#

The United States. Federal Highway Administration. (1982). LR-1071, Section 50 (I-70)

Reconstruction, Washington/Fayette/Westmoreland Counties: Environmental Impact

Statement. Northwestern University.

Wagner, K. W. (2016). Building the Wall: Highway Sound Barriers and the Evolution of Noise.

99percentinvisible.Org. https://99percentinvisible.org/article/building-wall-highway-

sound-barriers-evolution-noise/

View publication stats

You might also like