Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Views and Preferences in The Development of Instructional Materials For It Courses: The Case of Bsit Students
Views and Preferences in The Development of Instructional Materials For It Courses: The Case of Bsit Students
net/publication/326504468
CITATIONS READS
2 10,091
7 authors, including:
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Exploring the Feasibility of Offering MSIT & MIT Graduate Programs at Leyte Normal University, Tacloban City, Philippines View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Lowell Quisumbing on 20 July 2018.
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Article History: Instructional material is apreeminent factor toward academic performance. It is remarkable for the
Received 03rd June, 2017 teacher to develop instructional material to guide the student in their academic performance. With the
Received in revised form presence of this instructional material, thelearning process can be fun because of the healthy exchange
14th July, 2017 of information from the student and teacher. The research method that was used in this study is
Accepted 26th August, 2017 amixed method, thirty-four (34) students were identified based on the random sampling from thefirst
Published online 29th September, 2017 year to fourth year IT Students. Based on the result there is a need for the IT faculty to develop
instructional materials specifically on the IT_101 (Information Technology with Software
Keywords: Application) since this subject is offered in the first year, thefirst semester of the school year. It is
recommended that there is an evaluation of the instructional materials that is being developed to know
IMs,
Development, the effectiveness of these instructional materials in the learning process and improvement of academic
IT Courses, performance of the students.
Quantitative,
Social Science.
materials perform such functions as anaddition to the series of Each phase in ADDIE model is related to the different
experience available to learners, anadd-on to the teacher’s stages.Analysis Phase in order to bear out the analysis phase,
voice explanations thereby making learning experience better- we have to analyze four things, like we have to analyze the
off and providing the teacher with interest into an extensive learners (where they are at, their skills and needs, and so forth),
variety of learning activities (Bawa, 2016). The importance of prepare an instructional analysis (to provide the necessary steps
instructional materials in the development of learners’ and present opportunities to discover and employ new
intellectual abilities and attainment of teaching/learning information in an instruction), create instructional goals (aimed
objectives cannot be over-emphasized. The students taught at limiting the end desired result), and analysis’s learning
with instructional materials have excellent achievement scores objectives (how to measure the accomplishment of ends).That
compared with those taught without any material (Olayinka, implies you have to be open about your goals and where you
2016). want your learners to be.Design Phasethis phase is really close
to giving the command. In the design phase, the instructional
Statement of the Problem designer evolves and focuses on designing assessment for
With limited IT books found in the library, it was noted that (his/her) topic, select a form of the course, and making their
there is a need for developed instructional materials for IT own instructional strategy.Development Phase in this third
classes to supplement learning/teaching process in the delivery stage, the instructional designers integrate the engineering with
of IT lessons. This will specifically answer the following the educational setting and operation.Implementation Phase
questions: this phase is about transforming our plan into action. In order
to go through this phase, we have to hold three major steps,
What IT subjects the respondents find difficulty in which are training the instructors, preparing the learners, and
accessing references in relation to the IT lessons? organizing the learning environment. With these three steps,
What is the level of priority that this Instructional we can display our form in very dynamic and reliable ways to
material(s) be implemented in the classroom? reach the implementation phase. Evaluation Phase the final
What is the perception of the respondents on how they process in ADDIE model is Evaluation phase. It is very
access references? important to assess each step in theparliamentary procedure to
What materials and technology are being utilized by the make sure that we attain our goals using the instructional plan
teacher to deliver the lesson? and materials to meet the learner needs. There are two types of
What can research output be derived based on the evaluation formative evaluation and summative evaluation.
responses of the BSIT students? First, formative evaluation is a continuing process that we get
along as we are turning on our instructional materials in each
Conceptual Framework/ Theoretical Framework stage of the ADDIE model. There are three basic processes of
formative evaluation, which are one to one, small evaluation
According to Nada(2015),this model helps in the evolution of group, and test in the arena. When we measure, we want to
instructional materials where teachers follow the ADDIE choose learners that have similar features to our real learners
phases which are Analysis, Design, Development, and assess the materials.The development of the IT Course
Implementation and Evaluation. instructional material will follow the ADDIE model.
Wherein it will undergo the five (5) phases of analysis, design, Students:the result of the study will help them improve their
development, implementation and evaluation phase. academic performance in the BIST course and be able to
participate in classroom discussion.
Significance of the Study
Future Researcher:the result will serve as thebasis for further
The result of the study will be significant for the following:
studies on development and evaluation of instructional
Leyte Normal University Administration: this will be the materials.
basis for the administrator to give incentives to the faculty who Review of Related Literature
can produce instructional materials.
Instructional materials are defined, according to Olumorin,
Faculty:the outcomes of the study this work will enable Yusuf, Ajidagba, and Jekayinfa, (2010) instructional materials
educators to take efficient and improved methods of teaching in its simplest term are those materials that facilitate the
and learning the subject be more interesting, more attractive teachers to teach with ease and the learners to learn without
and more pleasurable. stress. Instructional materials appeal to the sensations of
seeing, touching, sensing, touch and hearing.
Table 2. Top ten most important IT course that needs to have instructional materials
International Journal of Recent Advances in Multidisciplinary Research 2761
They include projected, non-projected, printed and others, such and Ndaloh, (2013) the teachers need to use various and
as objects/relia, 3-dimensional objects that are produced appropriate teaching methods and instructional materials, in
through locally sourced materials, plan direction, instruction order to develop positive attitudes of learners towards the
package among others. Hence, Bawa, N (2016) define subject.Meanwhile, according to Oladejo, Olosunde, Ojebisi,
Instructional materials refer to anything a teacher uses in and Isola, (2011) Instructional materials supplement, clarify,
teaching and learning situation from small stones, pieces of vitalize, emphasize instruction and enhance learning in the
papers, small sticks, asample of aleaf, chalkboard, maps, process of transmitting knowledge, ideas, skills, and attitude.
charts, radio, television, computers.Meanwhile, According to
Olayinka, (2016),the importance of instructional materials in This calls for teacher resourcefulness and improvisation on the
the development of learners’ intellectual abilities and parts of the Physics teachers. The ability of the teacher to make
attainment of teaching/learning objectives cannot be over- use of “local” materials in place of “standard” ready-made
emphasized. The students taught with instructional materials materials makes lesson more effective and improved students’
have excellent achievement scores compared with those taught achievement.Hence, Ogbondah, L. (2008),it is a fact that
without any material. It was also noted in the study that there is classroom learning depends on effective communication,
no significant interaction effect of treatment and gender on skillful application of the several techniques and materials for
students’ achievement in Social Studies.While, according to learning. When adequate instructional materials are added to
Aina, (2013) instructional materials are very important because suitable methods, efficiency in learning is assured. The
what students hear can easily be forgotten but what they see maximum impact can be made on learning when an efficient
cannot be easily forgotten and last longer in their memory. On instructor uses thesuitable method and appropriate teaching
the other hand,in his study Okobia (2011), pointed out that materials. According to Nsa, Ikot, and Udo, (2013), the results
educational attainment depends a lot on the quality of teaching. indicated that students taught practical agriculture using
The lack of instructional materials and resources for the instructional charts, pictures and filmstrips performed
implementation of Social Studies curriculum in the junior significantly better than students taught without instructional
secondary schools in the Edo State of Nigeria. Most instructors materials. In the process of teaching/learning, instructional
do not use instructional materials to instruct. The deficiency of materials that were used facilitated students understanding by
necessary instructional materials and resources reduces the supplementing, clarifying, revitalizing and emphasizing the
students to mere passive participants in the scholarship process. teacher’s verbal efforts that inadequate use or lack of use of
Therefore, there is anerosion of enthusiasm in the instructional materials in the teaching/learning situation
instruction/learning process by both instructors and pupils. (lecture method) negates the objective of teaching.Hence,
According to Abdu-Raheem and Oluwagbohunmi (2015), according to Muñoz (2010), the strengthening of the cognitive
improvisation of locally made and unsophisticated instructional prerequisites mentioned above proved that instructional
materials by instructors, including pre-service teachers will go materials positively influenced the children's cognitive skills
a long way to standardizing teaching/learning, promote development since the first graders were able to identify,
students’ performance and improve thequality of education compare, classify, differentiate, analyze pictures, decode and
generally. use divergent thinking during the implementation.
syllabus. This is to ensure that the content design and learning learning to program is correspondingly complex. There are
objectives in the design phase were met. The implementation many features of the skills that contribute to the complexity of
phase was to make sure that the learners were able to apply the programming, these issues center on the nature of the
instructional materials in their subjects. Lastly, feedback from programming skill, while others have more to do with the ways
the studentswas taken to further improve the developed in which the participants teach and learn (Jenkins, 2002).
instructional materials.
Third, Computer Repair and Maintenance (IT_103), IT
Respondents and the Research Locale of the Study students should develop a skill on troubleshooting
acomputerproblem. (e.x problem in motherboard, beeping
This study will be conducted at Leyte Normal University, sound in the computer, computer monitor not working) these
Tacloban City.The Leyte Normal University offer programs are just a few of the computer problem that the IT student
related to education, hotel management, and computer related should know how to troubleshoot acomputer problem. Web
studies. BSIT program is one of the programs that LNU offers Development (IT_306), these are higher programming skills
which the study aimed to identify the need for instructional that will allow students to create software application and
materials of the BSIT students. Web-based application. Since the students were already
The respondents of the study were determined from thefirst- exposed to the basic programming concepts in the IT_202 and
year to fourth-year BSIT students through random sampling. IT_205, it won’t be difficult for the IT students to understand
The BSIT program has a total population of 391 students. other programming languages. Software Engineering (IT_309)
Sixteen percent (16%)are fourth year students,Thirty-Eight and Network Management (IT_406) got that same number of
percent (38%) from the third year, Twenty Five percent (25%) respond from the IT students. These subjects dealwith software
are second-year students, and the remaining Twenty One development (e.g. System Development Life Cycle) and
percent (21%) are first-year students.Thirty-four (34) IT advance study on computer network simultaneously. IT
students or Nine percent (9%) of the population who was students’ needs to develop the skills on planning, designing,
identified to answer the survey questionnaire from the implementation and testing of software and network.
population. Networking basic (IT_104) is the foundation subject for
Networking Management, topology, different transmission
Research Instruments devices or media, and types of computer network basic
knowledge in networking. Database Management System
The main instruments that will be used in this study will be the (IT_302), this is the foundation subject for Database
questionnaire and interview. Management System 2 (IT_308) once the student learns the
basic concept in DBMS the students won’t find it difficult
Survey Questionnaire: The questionnaire was formulated to since the required skills in DBMS has already been established
determine what instructional material(s) that needs to be in (IT_302).
developed for the IT students in order for them to improve their
academic performance. The student should master how to design, backup and
recoverydatabase, concerns on data integrity and security and
Interview Schedule: The researchers will conduct other related issues are being taken into considerations also. In
unstructured interviews. This will be done simultaneously with Information Technology and Software Application (IT_101),
the administration of thequestionnaire. When there will be this subject deals with basic computer concepts and the use of
doubts about the responses of the respondents, the researchers Application Software (Word, Excel, Powerpoint and Internet).
will verify and clarify answers through the interview. Items The students already have this knowledge when they graduated
left unanswered by the respondents will be answered during the in high school since there is already computer subject that is
interview. being discussedat the secondary level. The last is Program
Logic Formulation where the basic of programming is being
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION taught. It involves the skills in understanding the problem and
developing anappropriate solution to a problem. This serves
This part of the research presents the data analysis using tables also as the preparatory subject for programming 1 and
and graphs and supported by qualitative responses of the Programming 2 so that it won’t be difficult for them to
respondents.Table 1 shows the list of IT subjects that needs to understand the subject since it also has programming language
have an Instructional Material based on the respond of the IT incorporated in the Program Logic Formulation subject. The
Students. There are twenty-nine IT subject that was identified least from the IT subjects that need to have an instructional
by the IT faculty to know what IT subject(s) that needs to have material is Free Elective II (IT_311) this talks about E-
an instructional material that will help the IT student(s) commerce, making business online. This is all theoretical in
improve their knowledge in computer.Based on the illustration theapplication of the subject.In the development of
the researcher identify the top ten(10) IT courses that need to Instructional Materials, the IT Faculty should consider first the
have and instructional material,it was observed that the number IT_101 in making Instructional Materials since this is the first
one(1)and two highest IT subject that must have an computer subject that is being offered to the First year student
instructional material is on IT_202 Programming II and IT_105 enrolled in the first semester of the school year. Second priority
Programming I. What is being taught here is the basic is T_402, IT_405, to develop research manual or handbook that
programming concepts wherein thestudents must learn and will guide the fourth year student who will take up thesis
understand solving problems and interpret into programming writing or Capstone Project I and II, Third IT_202 and IT_205
language, must be able to write, debug, and test a software. Programming II and Object Oriented Programming, there are
Programming is certainly a complicated skill to master, and already advanced programming the students find it difficult to
International Journal of Recent Advances in Multidisciplinary Research 2763
Rank Course Code Highly Priority Moderately Priority Priority Less Priority Not Priority
1 IT_101 28 7 4 1
2 IT_402 23 1 0
IT_405
3 IT_406 23 5 1
4 IT_102 22 4 2
5 IT_202 22 5 0
6 IT_105 21 5 1
7 IT_306 21 1 1
8 IT_302 20 2 1
9 IT_308 20 2 2
10 IT_104 19 5 2 1
11 IT_303 19 0 2
12 IT_309 19 4 0
13 IT_103 18 7 1
14 IT_208 18 5 1
15 IT_307 18 2 1
16 IT_201 17 5 1
17 IT_206 17 3 3
18 IT_304 17 1 4
19 IT_205 16 4 1
20 IT_207 16 5 2
21 IT_305 16 2 4
22 IT_310 15 4 3
23 IT_311 15 4 3
24 IT_408 15 4 3
25 IT_301 14 4 1
26 IT_203 13 5 4
27 IT_204 13 3 3
28 IT_409 0 4 3
understand the topic if there is no Instructional material Presentations of reports and others will be more
available for this subject. The least among the priority to efficient. Reports and presentations will be delivered in
develop instructional material is on IT Elective IV (IT_409) a better way.
dot Net Programming, IT students has already acquired Technologies like computers are important to us, it is
knowledge in Programming 1 and II, this is just an additional easy to use and we can get information through it.
knowledge in making programming using dot NET. In the Maximize the capabilities of a student in learning.
questionnaire, the researcher included questions on what are
Students will no longer be ignorant of this technologies.
the perceptions of the IT students on how they access
references. Based on the responses of the IT students, the
Theme three: Improvement of learning materials to enhance
researcher was able to identify the theme based on their
academic performance. It was found out the there are other
answers:
technologies or learning materials that the teachers can utilize
in the classroom to enhance the learning environment for the
Theme one: Availability of learning resources and technology
students.
In thepursuitof academic excellence, IT students aim to have
an extensive access to the different learning resources and
We borrow projectors in our instructors, the advantage
technology that would help them acquire new knowledge in IT
of getting this device is you can easily report in class or
subjects. We can’t deny the fact that learning resources such as
it is usable in reporting, the disadvantage for this is
textbooks, workbook, manuals, computer and other learning
when you broke it you have to pay it.
resources may be limited due to the lack of fund, students are
given limited time to access these learning materials. Edmodo can be used in subjects where instructors assign
it and can be used anytime and anywhere.
Only if they are available. It was convenient in getting information from the
Only allowed to use the computers when it's our class internet than the other sources.
time. Technologies like computers are important to us, it is
The disadvantage is that it is only limited. easy to use and we can get information through it.
Only if teachers allowed us to use.
Theme four: Importance of having Instructional Materials
Theme two: Importance of learning materials and technology
in the learning process. Based on the different literature, it was Based on the different literature, it is undeniable the
found that in the learning process, student will be able to importance of the instructional materials in the learning
improve their academic performance only if there’s an process. The importance of instructional materials in the
adequate learning material available for the students; development of learners’ intellectual abilities and attainment of
Helps us in enhancing our knowledge and aid us in our teaching/learning objectives cannot be over-emphasized
study. (Olayinka, 2016). It will enhance the cognitive skills of the
student (Muñoz,2010).
International Journal of Recent Advances in Multidisciplinary Research 2764
Peyton, J. K., Moore, S. C. K., &Young, S. 2010. Evidence- Sims, R. R., & Sims, S. J. 1995. The Importance of Learning
Based, Student-Centered Instructional Practices. CAELA Styles: Understanding the Implications for Learning, Course
Network Brief. Center for Adult English Language Design, and Education: Understanding the Implications for
Acquisition. Learning, Course Design, and Education. ABC-CLIO.
Ruto, Z. J., & Ndaloh, A. M. 2013. Overcoming the challenges Timperley, H., Wilson, A., Barrar, H., & Fung, I. 2008.
of using instructional methods and materials encountered by Teacher professional learning and development.
teachers of history and government in Wareng district,
Kenya. Journal of Emerging Trends in Educational
Research and Policy Studies, 4(2), 265.
*******