Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Factors Associated With Anaemia Among Pregnant Women in Indonesia: A Systematic Review
Factors Associated With Anaemia Among Pregnant Women in Indonesia: A Systematic Review
Factors Associated With Anaemia Among Pregnant Women in Indonesia: A Systematic Review
Restuning Widiasih, Ardhini Dwi Utari, Tri Nur Jayanti, Anis Ardiyanti,
Rinda Intan Sari, Geuis Anggi Siska
ABSTRACT
Pregnant women are vulnerable with anaemia. Quantitative studies related anaemia in pregnancy have
been done in Indonesia including assessing factors associated with anaemia in pregnancy. However,
none of studies provide a comprehensive view of factors that associated with anaemia in pregnancy.
The aim of this review was to identify factors associated with maternal anaemia in Indonesia. The
systematic scoping review method was used in this review. The databases were Indonesian electronic
databases including; Google scholar, Kandaga, and Sinta. The keywords were bilinguals: Indonesia and
English. The inclusion criteria of studies were focused on factors related to anaemia in pregnancy,
research design included correlation and quasi-experimental, published from 2013 to 2018, full text, and
Indonesian’s studies. A total of 1986 papers were retrieved, but only 14 articles met the inclusion criteria
and were included in the analysis. Factors associated with maternal anaemia in Indonesia including
health professionals’roles, iron tablets consumption, antenatal care, education, nutrition, health
knowledge, and awareness. Multi-factors are associated with maternal anaemia in Indonesia. There is a
need for comprehensive approaches from health professionals and health services in dealing with
anaemia in pregnancy.
ABSTRAK
Anemia adalah salah satu masalah kesehatan pada perempuan hamil. Berbagai riset kuantitatif tentang
anemia banyak dilakukan di Indonesia, tetapi penelitian yang mengkaji faktor-faktor penyebab anemia
pada kehamilan secara komprehensif masih terbatas. Tujuan dari studi literatur ini untuk
mengidentifikasi faktor-faktor yang berhubungan dengan anemia kehamilan secara komprehensif di
Indonesia. Studi literatur ini menggunakan pendekatan metode Scoping review. Sumber data
menggunakan Google scholar, Kandaga, dan Sinta. Pencarian artikel menggunakan kata kunci 2
bahasa, Indonesia dan Inggris. Kriteria inklusi dari artikel yang dianalisis: riset dengan topik faktor yang
berhubungan dengan anemia kehamilan, design risetnya hubungan dan quasi-experiment,
dipublikasikan pada tahun 2013-2018, artikel full text, dan riset berasal dari Indonesia. Hasil pencarian
artikel mendapatkan 1986 artikel, akan tetapi hanya teridentifikasi 14 artikel yang memenuhi kriteria
inklusi. Hasil analisa menunjukan faktor yang berhubungan dengan anemia pada ibu hamil di Indonesia
adalah peran aktif petugas kesehatan, kepatuhan mengkonsumsi tablet Fe, kontrol kehamilan,
pendidikan formal, status nutrisi, pendidikan kesehatan, dan kesadaran ibu hamil. Faktor yang
berhubungan dengan penyebab anemia pada ibu hamil multi-faktor. Hasil studi literatur ini
menginformasikan kebutuhan akan pendekatan yang komprehensif dari layanan dan petugas
kesehatan dalam mengatasi anemia ibu hamil di Indonesia.
2
Widiasih, Utari, Jayanti, Ardiyanti, Sari, Siska DOI : 10.20884/1.jks.2019.14.1.806 Jurnal
Keperawatan Soedirman 14 (1) 2019 : 1 – 14
4
Widiasih, Utari, Jayanti, Ardiyanti, Sari, Siska DOI : 10.20884/1.jks.2019.14.1.806
Jurnal Keperawatan Soedirman 14 (1) 2019 : 1 – 14
Table 1. The summary of articles on the use of smart phone applications as KIE media for adolescent reproductive health in 2013-2018 (n=20)
2 Purwaningty Factors associated 2017 Central Quantitative Cross 74 Simple Anaemic pregnant There was a significant
as M. L. & with Anaemia in Java sectional people random women correlation between nutrition
Prameswari, pregnancy sampling status (p value 0,000) and
G. N anaemia.
3 Erwin, R. R.,Correlation among 2018 West Quantitative Cross 52 Total Third trimester of Lack of knowledge and
Machmud, R., knowledge, Sumatera sectional people sampling pregnancy awareness were an influence to
& Utama, attitude, and Iron the compliance of iron tablet
B. I. tablet consumption consumption and increased
in PHC Seberang, anaemia in pregnancy (79%)
Padang.
4 Rejeki, S. & Women’s 2014 Central Quantitative Cross 30 Total Third trimester of Pregnant women who
Huda, A. characteristic in Java sectional people sampling pregnancy who consumed iron tablets were not
consuming Iron visited health anaemic even though there
tablets and services for were different number of tablets
Anaemia in pregnancy check, 20 tablets (n=3), 60 tablets
pregnancy in and consumed (n=13), and 90 tablets (n=3)
Kaliwungu PHC, iron tablet given
Kendal district.
5 Susanti, A., Food culture taboo, 2013 Central Quantitative Cross 45 Quota Third trimester of The majority of pregnant women
Rusnoto., & economic status, Java sectional people sampling pregnancy third who anaemic were attended
Asiyah, N. and knowledge of trimester of Senior High School.
third trimester pf pregnancy, Respondents who have a good
5
Widiasih, Utari, Jayanti, Ardiyanti, Sari, Siska DOI : 10.20884/1.jks.2019.14.1.806
Jurnal Keperawatan Soedirman 14 (1) 2019 : 1 – 14
6
Widiasih, Utari, Jayanti, Ardiyanti, Sari, Siska DOI : 10.20884/1.jks.2019.14.1.806
Jurnal Keperawatan Soedirman 14 (1) 2019 : 1 – 14
of pregnancy at check)
Puskesmas Air
Dingin Kota
Padang
7
Widiasih, Utari, Jayanti, Ardiyanti, Sari, Siska DOI : 10.20884/1.jks.2019.14.1.806
Jurnal Keperawatan Soedirman 14 (1) 2019 : 1 – 14
& Sulastri, S. Poster and Texting experiment sampling women influence on iron consumption
K. Reminder to and level of Hb
pregnant women’s
compliment of Iron
consumption and
the level of HB in
the PHC of
Sukoharjo
Respon Sampling Inclusion
No. Authors Title Year Province Design Method Findings
dent Technique Criteria
13 Vernissa, V., The effectiveness 2017 West Java Quantitative Quasi 79 Consecutiv All women who Providing leaflet and counselling
Andrajati, R., of providing leaflet experiment people e sampling visited the PHC, had influenced to increasing Iron
& Supardi, S. and counselling of diagnosed as tablets consumption. The
anaemia in anaemic , and anaemic pregnant women who
pregnancy to the had Iron tablet had a good compliment of iron
compliment of therapy consumption increased their Hb
Iron consumption
level 3.34 times higher than
and the level of
anaemic pregnant women who
Hb at
the PHCs in Bogor did not compliment
districts
14 Adawiyani, The influence of 2013 East Java Quantitative RCT 100 Random The second and Providing booklet increased
R. providing Anaemia people: sampling third trimester of women’s knowledge, Hb levels,
Booklet to pregnant 50 pregnancy (14-32 and Iron compliment in the
women’s intervent weeks with ANC intervention group than control
knowledge of Iron ion check) group.
compliment and the group
HB level
and 50
control
group
8
Widiasih, Utari, Jayanti, Ardiyanti, Sari, Siska DOI : 10.20884/1.jks.2019.14.1.806
Jurnal Keperawatan Soedirman 14 (1) 2019 : 1 – 14
9
Widiasih, Utari, Jayanti, Ardiyanti, Sari, Siska DOI : 10.20884/1.jks.2019.14.1.806 Jurnal
Keperawatan Soedirman 14 (1) 2019 : 1 – 14
Majority of studies only assess a anaemia (Agustini et al., 2014; Alvionita &
single factor and did not provide a Sulastri, 2017; Andawiyani, 2013; Vernissa
comprehensive view of factors that et al., 2017). These factors supported by
associated with anaemia in pregnancy. M’Cormack and Drolet’s research (2012).
Analysis found that 4 out of 14 studies They suggested that pregnant women’s
were identified that health professionals awareness about the cause, prevention,
and health interventions were the most and treatment of anaemia should be
influencing factors related to anaemia in developed by health workers. Another
pregnancy. Health interventions including study found health worker’s differences er
health education, leaflet distribution, and on performing or collaborating on
booklets were found to increase obedience hemoglobin check and educating about
on consuming iron tablet, so that anaemia danger sign of anaemia (Rani et al., 2008).
can be avoided (Agustini et al., 2014; In addition, Lesilolo, Engka and Wungouw
Alvionita & Sulastri, 2017; Andawiyani, (2016) explained that health worker plays a
2013; Vernissa et al., 2017). Other role in providing counselling related to the
influencing factors were the compliance to needs of iron on pregnant women during
consume iron tablet supplement (n=3) ANC visits. However, in fact the availability
(Ariyani & Sarbini, 2016; Rejeki & Huda, of health workers in public health centre
2014; Rizki et al., 2014) , ANC (n=2) (PHC) is limited, and the health education
(Antono, 2017; Lesilolo et al., about anaemia to patients was not optimal
2016), nutrient status (n=2) (Purwaningtyas yet.(Adawiyani, 2013)
& Prameswari, 2017; Setyawati & Syauqy, The majority studies identified the
2014), formal education levels (n=2) huge impact of health workers on health
(Mariza, 2016; Susanti et al., 2013), and behavior. However few studies recognised
health knowledge and awareness (n=1) lack roles of health workers. Health worker
(Erwin et al., 2018). should be supported, so they can perform
Those articles informed that multi their roles. The support may be included
factors associated with maternal anaemia providing health education facilities and
in Indonesia including health infrastructures giving an incentive for
professionals’ roles, pregnant women’s health workers for their roles as health
behaviour in consuming iron supplement, educator, and adding the number of health
nutrient status of pregnant women, formal worker if possible. The ratio of health
education levels, and women’s knowledge workers with the number of patient in
and awareness of anaemia in pregnancy Indonesia is not ideal yet particularly in
and importance of Iiron supplement to rural areas (Kementerian Kesehatan
prevent it. Republik Indonesia, 2017).
10
Widiasih, Utari, Jayanti, Ardiyanti, Sari, Siska DOI : 10.20884/1.jks.2019.14.1.806 Jurnal
Keperawatan Soedirman 14 (1) 2019 : 1 – 14
is similar with other countries India and ANC coverage was the low quality of ANC.
Nigeria (Mithra et al., 2014; Ugwu et al., A study in Australia found that the ANC
2014). These two studies found pregnant services influenced pregnant women’s
women were disobedient in consuming iron health including anaemia (Bar-Zeev et al.,
tablet because of the following reasons 2014). Furthermore, Ikeanyi and Ibrahim
including forgetfulness, gastrointestinal (2015) study’s suggested that a high
side effect (nausea, vomiting, gastritis, and quality of ANC is a significant action to
constipation), on traveling, non-affordability prevent anaemia. It is necessary to
of iron supplements, belief that they have increase the quality of health services and
an adequate diet and do not need any iron develop a strategy to increase ANC visit.
supplements. Other reasons were Health professionals can establish various
inadequate counseling from health methods to increase the ANC visits
professionals, problems related to including involving pregnant women’s peer
distribution of iron tablets, difficult access group, reminding ANC visit via electronic
and poor utilization of prenatal health care media, and empowering health cadres.
services, beliefs against consuming
medications during pregnancy, and in most Level of formal Education
countries, fears that taking too much iron Level of education is another risk
may cause too much blood or a big baby factor associated with anaemia in
which, making delivery more difficult. pregnancy. Mariza (2016) found level of
Increasing pregnant women’s compliance formal education had a significant influence
for consuming iron table needs a to anaemia in pregnancy. In that study, 16
comprehensive approach. Involving family out of 30 pregnant women were anaemic,
members who live together with pregnant with the majority of them (n=11) only
women would be effective to remind about attended primary education (9 years
iron tables consumption. In addition, education) and 5 of them attended
proactive approaches and interventions secondary and high education. This finding
from health professionals would be a in line with an Ethiopian study found that
potential in increasing pregnant women’s level of education was a significant
compliance. The approaches and independent predictor for anaemia in
interventions include doing house visit, pregnancy (Gebre & Mulugeta, 2015).
developing a digital or electronic reminder However, several studies in Indonesia also
tool, and educating family members about found that pregnant women’s who anaemic
anaemia and the prevention actions. were attended senior high school
(Purwaningtyas & Prameswari, 2017;
Antenatal Care (ANC) Susanti et al., 2013). A Nepali study also
The third factor that influenced found that there was no significant
anaemia in pregnancy was antenatal care relationship between educational level of
(Antono, 2017; Lesilolo et al., 2016). the women with incidence of anaemia in
Antenatal care service has a purpose for pregnancy (p > 0,05) (Prakash et al.,
early identification of any possible 2015). Those studies revealed that
abnormalities or complications during anaemia in pregnancy were problems for
pregnancy including anaemia. The both, low level of formal education, and
government stipulates that pregnant high level of formal education. Purwoastuti
women have to visit health services for & Walyani (2013) suggested that the
antenatal care minimally 4 times during higher someone’s level of formal
pregnancy. However, the number of ANC education, the easier for them to access
visit in Indonesia decreased from 87,48% and use information. Information literacy
in 2015 to 85,35% in 2016 (Kementerian would have an impact on decision making
Kesehatan Republik Indonesia, 2017). The process (Purwoastuti & Walyani, 2013).
Indonesian Ministry of Health (MoH) Nurses should encourage pregnant women
indicated that one cause of decreasing the to be active finding information from
11
Widiasih, Utari, Jayanti, Ardiyanti, Sari, Siska DOI : 10.20884/1.jks.2019.14.1.806 Jurnal
Keperawatan Soedirman 14 (1) 2019 : 1 – 14
various sources such as from health providing nutritious foods are important to
professionals, peers, internet, and other improve pregnant women’ nutrition status.
media. Nurses’ should be actively
collaborating with the government and Health Knowledge and Awareness
other parties to provide health counselling Three studies in this literature
through various information media. review found that health knowledge and
awareness had influenced of
Nutrition Status the occurrence anaemia in
Several studies found pregnancy (Agustini et al., 2014; Erwin et
that pregnant women’s nutrition status was al., 2018; Vernissa et al., 2017).
a factor that assosiated with anaemia in Distributing a leaflet, developing a group
pregnancy. Setyawati and discussion, and monitoring iron
Syauqy consumption using a card monitoring, and
(2014)’s study found that there were counselling had increased health
different intake of Vitamin B12 and protein awareness and prevented anaemia in
between anaemic and non-anaemic pregnancy (Agustini, Lestari and Agoes,
pregnant women. The respondents were 2014; Vernissa, Andrajati and Supardi,
the third trimester of pregnant women, and 2017). In addition, health awareness is
the majority of them had deficiency of also influenced by education background.
vitamin B12 or anaemia megaloblastic. Women with low education background are
That finding in line with Purwaningtyas and at risk of anaemia in pregnancy due to low
Prameswari (2017), which found a awareness and knowledge of the
significant relationship between nutrition importance of consuming iron tablet (Erwin
status and anaemia in pregnancy (p value et al., 2018). Those Indonesian studies in
0,000). Susanti et al. (2013) also found line with an India study that found pregnant
women who unaware of their health
similar finding that pregnant women with a
especially hemoglobin level had more
good nutrition status and no history of lack
possibility of having anaemia in pregnancy
of chronic energy had not severe of
compared to women with good awareness
anaemia during their pregnancy. The
(p value: 0,027) (Gowri et al., 2017). Lack
Indonesian studies are in agreement with
of awareness also was found in a study
several studies from overseas. A study in
from Nigeria. This study found that the
Turkey found factors associated with
majority of women perceived that anaemia
anaemia in pregnancy were including lack was a normal phenomenon and they have
of iron 10%, vitamin B12 34,5% and lack of just awared after pregnancy complications
folic acid 71,7% having four or more living occurred (Onyeneho & Subramanian,
children, being at the third trimester, 2016). According to Indonesian studies,
having a low family income, and soil eating active health education using many types
tradition (Karaoglu et al., 2010). of media was influenced pregnant women’s
Furthermore, an Ethiopian study found that awareness of anaemia. Nurses as an
pregnant women who consumed good agent of change could use various media
nutrition for example milk, animal protein, and method to improve health and prevent
fruits, vegetables and plenty of vitamin A anaemia among pregnant women.
would decrease their risk of having
anaemia in pregnancy (Zerfu et al., 2016). Study limitations
Nutritious food is important for pregnant This literature review provides
women in preventing anaemia in comprehensive information
pregnancy. Fulfilling pregnant women related to various factors that have
nutrition should involve family especially associated with anaemia among
husbands. In Indonesia the majority of pregnant women. However, it only
bread winner are husbands. Improving looks at Indonesian studies. These findings
family support and involvement in may not applicable to pregnant women
12
Widiasih, Utari, Jayanti, Ardiyanti, Sari, Siska DOI : 10.20884/1.jks.2019.14.1.806 Jurnal
Keperawatan Soedirman 14 (1) 2019 : 1 – 14
Gowri, D., Sakthi, D., & Palanivel, C. Lampung Tahun 2015. Jurnal
(2017). Influence of Awareness and Kesehatan Holistik, 10(1), 5-8.
Attitude about Anemia and Iron
Supplements on Anemic Status of Mithra, P., Unnikrishnan, B., Rekha, T.,
Pregnant Women Attending a Nithin, K., Mohan, K., Kulkarni,
Tertiary Care Centre in South India J V., . . . Agarwal, D. (2014).
Contracept Stud, 2. doi: Compliance with iron-folic acid (IFA)
10.21767/2471-9749.100026 therapy among pregnant women in
an urban area of south India. Afr
Ikeanyi, E. M., & Ibrahim, A. I. (2015). Health Sci,
Does antenatal care attendance 14(1), 255-260. doi:
prevent anemia in pregnancy at 10.4314/ahs.v14i1.39
term? Niger J Clin Pract, 18(3), 323-
327. doi: 10.4103/1119-3077.151730 Onyeneho, N., & Subramanian, S. (2016).
Anemia in pregnancy:
Karaoglu, L., Pehlivan, E., Egri, M., Factors influencing knowledge and
Deprem, C., Gunes, G., Genc, M. F., attitudes among mothers in
& Temel, I. (2010). The prevalence of southeastern Nigeria. Zeitschrift für
nutritional anemia in pregnancy in an Gesundheitswissenschaften, 24(4),
east Anatolian province, Turkey. 335-349. doi: 10.1007/s10389-016-
BMC Public Health, 10, 329. doi: 0730-y
10.1186/1471-2458-10-329
Prakash, S., Yadav, K., Bhardwaj, B., &
Kementerian Kesehatan Republik Chaudhary, S. (2015). Incidence of
Indonesia. (2017). Profil Data Anemia and its Socio-demographic
Kesehatan Tahun 2016 Jakarta: determinants among pregnant
Kementerian Kesehatan Republik women attending for antenatal care:
Indonesia. A cross sectional study. International
Journal of Medical and Health
Lesilolo, T. N., Engka, J. N., & Wungouw, Research, 1(3), 12-17.
H. I. (2016). Hubungan pemberian
tablet besi dan antenatal Care Purwaningtyas, M. L., & Prameswari, G. N.
terhadap kadar hemoglobin pada ibu (2017). Faktor kejadian anemia pada
hamil di Kabupaten Bolaang ibu hamil Journal of Public Health
Mongondouw Utara. Jurnal e- Research and Development, 1(3),
Biomedik, 4(1). 43-54.
Lestari, S., Fujiati, I. I., Keumalasari, D., Purwoastuti, & Walyani. (2013). Asuhan
Daulay, M., Martina, S. J., & kebidanan masa nifas dan menyusui.
Syarifah, S. (2018). The prevalence Yogyakarta: Pustaka Baru Pres.
of anemia in pregnant women and its
associated risk factors in North Rani, M., Bonu, S., & Harvey, S. (2008).
Sumatera, Indonesia. IOP Differentials in the quality of
Conference Series: Earth and antenatal care in India. Int J Qual
Environmental Science, 125(1), Health Care, 20(1), 62-71. doi:
012195. 10.1093/intqhc/mzm052
Mariza, L. (2016). Hubungan Pendidikan Rejeki, S., & Huda, A. (2014). Karakteristik
dan Sosial Ekonomi Ibu, Konsumsi Tablet Fe Dengan
dengan Kejadian Anemia Pada Kehamilan Di
Kejadian Anemia pada Ibu Hamil di Wilayah Kerja Puskesmas Kaliwungu
BPS T Yohan Way Halim Bandar Kabupaten Kendal. Prosiding
Seminar Nasional &
14
Widiasih, Utari, Jayanti, Ardiyanti, Sari, Siska DOI : 10.20884/1.jks.2019.14.1.806 Jurnal
Keperawatan Soedirman 14 (1) 2019 : 1 – 14