Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Is Resilience Only Skin Deep Rural African Americans' Socioeconomic Status-Related Risk and Competence
Is Resilience Only Skin Deep Rural African Americans' Socioeconomic Status-Related Risk and Competence
REFERENCES
Linked references are available on JSTOR for this article:
https://www.jstor.org/stable/23484576?seq=1&cid=pdf-
reference#references_tab_contents
You may need to log in to JSTOR to access the linked references.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
https://about.jstor.org/terms
Sage Publications, Inc. and Association for Psychological Science are collaborating with JSTOR
to digitize, preserve and extend access to Psychological Science
Psychological Science
24(7) 1285-1293
Is Resilience Only Skin Deep? Rural ©) The
The Author(s)
Author(s)2013
2013
Reprints and permissions:
African Americans' Socioeconomic sagepub. com/journalsPermissions. nav
DOI: 10.1177/0956797612471954
Abstract
Many African American youth may develop high levels of allostatic load, a measure of physiological wear and tear on
the body, by developing psychosocial competence under conditions of high risk related to socioeconomic status (SES).
The current study was designed to test this hypothesis, which is based on John Henryism theory. In a representative
sample of 489 African American youth living in the rural South, cumulative SES-related risks and teacher-reported
competence were assessed at ages 11 to 13; depressive symptoms, externalizing behavior, and allostatic load were
assessed at age 19. The data revealed that rural African American preadolescents who evinced high psychosocial
competence under conditions of high cumulative SES-related risk displayed low levels of adjustment problems along
with high allostatic load at age 19. These results suggest that, for many rural African Americans, resilience may indeed
be only "skin deep."
Keywords
adolescent development, environmental effects, health, neuroendocrinology, socioeconomic status
In the Black Belt that stretches across rural South Carolina, South evince high levels of planful self-regulation,
Georgia, Alabama, Mississippi, and Louisiana, poverty academic achievement, and psychological adjustment
rates are nearly 20% (Proctor & Dalaker, 2003). The despite a lifetime of exposure to such challenges (Brody,
socioeconomic risk factors that characterize this region Kogan, & Grange, 2012). These children have been called
have considerable consequences for the development resilient because their competence develops in the face
of rural African American children, adolescents, and of contextual adversity, enabling them to "beat the odds"
young adults. These risk factors include chronic, endemic with which their environments present them,
poverty and limitations in occupational and educational The resilience literature is characterized by a wide
opportunities, frequent housing adjustments in response spread assumption that if children and youth who face
to economic pressures, changes in employment status, major adversities are doing well as indexed by external
interpersonal and institutional racism, difficulty in access
ing pediatric and adolescent medical care, and marginal- " ^ ^
ization by health-care professionals (Dressier, Oths, of Georgia, Center for Family Research,
& Gravlee, 2005). Nevertheless, a remarkable number of 1095 College Station Rd„ Athens, GA 30602-4527
African American children and adolescents in the rural E-mail: gbrody@uga.edu
behaviors—for examp
evince high levels of
negotiated those adve
however, is that thes
internal, physiologica
Americans. Thus, the
levels of self-regulat
the presence of the m
socioeconomic status
nal behaviors appear
ring outwardly und
bodies that renders t
logical health outcom
African American yo
have to go beyond o
manifestations of ph
of the study reported
esis that African Am
ers rate them as self-
and socially competen
SES-related risk will,
depressive symptom
(b) manifest high lev
ological stress. In the
structs from allosta
theory to explain
The myriad stressor
of low SES encounte
systems. As the con
body achieves stabilit
multiple, interconnec
repeatedly perturbe
potential implications
exacted. Some researc
allostatic load (AL). O
posite reflecting vari
stress response, incl
lary system, the hyp
metabolism, fat depo
immune functionin
Rowe, & Singer, 200
between exposure to
ment of AL been est
youth (Brody, Yu, et
that AL is conjectur
chronic diseases and
Boyce, & McEwen, 20
up with SES-related r
forecast higher AL l
pants who exhibit
This hypothesis wa
(James, 1994). JH is a
ized by a determinati
Method Measures
20 symptoms on the
the time), 1 {some or
moderate amount of
Responses to these it
Externalizing sympto
Self-Report (Achenba
sive, Intrusive, and R
index externalizing s
these subscales was .
past-month cigarette,
excessive drinking on
Monitoring the Futu
man, & Schulenberg,
were summed to form
cedure that is consist
2001; Newcomb & Be
nalizing symptoms an
lated (p < .001); they
to form the externalizing-problems score. problems score, which could range from 0 to 100
(a = .72).
AL in young adulthood. The protocol for measuring
AL when the youth were 19 years of age was based on
Results
procedures that Evans (2003) developed for field studies
involving children and adolescents. Resting blood près- Preliminary analyses
sure was monitored with a Critikon (Tampa, FL) Dina
map Pro 100 while the youth sat reading quietly. Three Table 1 presents descriptive statistics for the sample,
readings were taken every 2 min, and the average of the along with bivariate correlations. The bivariate correla
last two readings was used as the resting index. This pro- dons support our hypothesis and the inclusion of gender
cedure yields highly reliable indices of chronic resting and health problems as controls in the data analyses,
blood pressure (Kamarck et al., 1992). Teachers reported that male youth evinced lower levels
Overnight urinary catecholamines and Cortisol were of self-control/competence than did female youth across
assayed. Beginning on the evening of data collection, all preadolescence. At age 19, young men reported lower
urine that the young adult voided from 8:00 p.m. to 8:00 levels of depressive symptoms and higher levels of exter
a.m. was stored on ice in a container with metabisulfite as nalizing behavior than did young women. SES-related
a preservative. Urine was delivered to the Emory University risk assessed across preadolescence was associated posi
Hospital medical laboratory in Atlanta, Georgia, for assay- tively with AL at age 19, and higher teacher ratings of
ing. Total unbound Cortisol was assayed with a radioim- preadolescent self-control/competence forecast lower
munoassay (Contreras, Hane, & Tyrrell, 1986). Epinephrine levels of self-reported depressive symptoms and exter
and norepinephrine were assayed with high-pressure nalizing behavior at age 19
liquid chromatography with electrochemical detection
(Riggin & Kissinger, 1977). Creatinine was assayed to con
trol for differences in body size and incomplete urine void
Hypothesis testing
ing (Tietz, 1976). Technicians blind to the participants' To test our hypothesis, we constructed regression
SES-related risk status assayed the samples. tions in which depressive symptoms, externalizin
AL was calculated by summing the number of physi- lems, and AL in young adulthood were predicted f
ological indicators on which each young adult scored in successive blocks of variables: gender and heal
the top quartile of risk; possible scores ranged from 0 to lems as controls, SES-related risk and self-control/
6. The AL indicators were overnight Cortisol, epinephrine, tence, and a product term representing the lat
and norepinephrine; resting diastolic and systolic blood variables.
pressure; and body mass index (weight in kilograms The results of the analyses for depressive sy
divided by the square of height in meters). and externalizing problems are presented in Ta
Both analyses revealed that teacher-rated preadolescent
Health problems in young adulthood. The youth self-control/competence robustly predicted self-re
reported their health problems at age 19 using the Gen- outcomes in young adulthood. These main
eral Health Perceptions subscale from the RAND 36-Item were qualified by the SES-Related Risk x Self-Con
Correlations
(ages 11-13)
3. Self-control/competence 0.087 (4.049) -.289*** -.229*** —
(ages 11-13)
4. Allostatic load (age 19) 1.495 (1.255) .069 .147** -.044 —
5. -0.001 (1.589)
Externalizing .112* .023 -.251*** .000 —
(age 19)
6. Depressive symptoms 13.065 (8.920) -.093* .069 _ 213*** -.040 449*** —
(age 19)
7. Health problems (age 19) 24.908 (17.478) -.222*** .151** -.181*** .040 .261*** .389***
Competence interaction—depressive symptoms: AHl, competence was not associated with depressi
483) = 4.271, p < .04, A/?2 = .007; externalizing problems: toms (simple slope = -0.194, SE = 0.136, n.s.) or
AKl, 483) = 4.762,/» < .03, A#2 = .009. izing problems (simple slope = -0.034, SE = 0
To interpret these results, we plotted estimated levels n.s.) during early adulthood. These associations
of depressive symptoms and externalizing problems at progressively stronger as the level of SES-related
low (1 SD below the mean) and high (1 SD above the which youth were exposed increased and ul
mean) levels of preadolescent SES-related risk and self- reached significance (at 1 SD above the mean SES
control/competence (Aiken & West, 199D- Figures la risk, simple slope = -0.580, SE = 0.138, p <
and lb show that the interactions were consistent with for depression and simple slope = -0.109, S
the hypothesis. When youth lived with low levels of SES- p < .001, for externalizing problems). Self-rep
related risk, teacher-rated preadolescent self-control/ depressive symptoms and externalizing prob
Table 2. SES-Related Risk and Self-Control/Competence in Preadolescence as Predictors of Depressive Symptoms, Ext
Problems, and Allostatic Load at Age 19 (N = 489)
Outcome
Gender (male = 1, -1.169 0.804 -0.065 0.381 0.147 0.120* 0.209 0.122 0.083
female = 0)
Health problems 0.175 0.022 0.343*** .151 0.024 0.004 0.260*** .099 0.003 0.003 0.046 .008
SES-related risk -0.190 0.284 -0.028 .151 -0.076 0.052 -0.064 .099 0.143 0.043 0.153** .028
Self-control/ -0.387 0.100 -0.176*** .176 -0.072 0.018 -0.183*** .127 0.007 0.015 0.023 .028
competence
SES-Related Risk -0.144 0.070 -0.085* .183 -0.028 0.013 -0.093* .135 0.029 0.011 0.122** .043
x Self-Control/
Competence
CO
E
CD 0.5
-Q
O
Q_
O)
c 0.0
"m
CO
c
£-0.5
, , -1.0
Low High Low High
Preadolescent Self-Control/Competence Preadolescent Self-Control/Competence
Fig. 1. Young adults' (a) depressive symptoms and (b) externalizing problems as a function of their socioeconomic status (SES)-related risk
and self-control/competence in preadolescence (low = 1 SD below the mean; high = 1 SD above the mean). The lines represent the results of
regression analyses at low and high levels of SES-related risk, and the numbers in parentheses refer to the simple slopes (***p < .001).
highest among young adults who, during preadoles emerged among young adults who, during preadoles
cence, had received low ratings on self-control/compe cence, had received high teacher ratings on self-control/
tence from their teachers and had also experienced high competence and had also experienced high levels of SES
levels of SES-related risk. Self-reports of these two out related risk. The success-oriented, highly active coping
comes were lowest among young adults who, as preado style these youth employed in the presence of high risk
lescents, had experienced high levels of SES-related risk was associated with cumulative wear and tear on their
but had received high ratings on self-control/competence bodies that was detected during young adulthood.
from their teachers. Thus, young adults who, during pre A comparison of Figures la, lb, and 2 reveals a
adolescence, had manifested age-appropriate indicators distinct pattern of psychological adjustment and physio
of hard work and success while experiencing high levels logical outcomes for this sample of young adults. Highly
of SES-related risk reported the lowest levels of internal
izing and externalizing behaviors. JH theory suggests that
—«— Low SES-Related Risk (-0.032)
a single-minded focus on success protected these youth
from psychological adjustment problems. - . - High SES-Related Risk (0.046*)
In this study, we found that rural African American pre- A premise of this study was that when low-SES, rural
adolescents who evinced high levels of self-control/com- African Americans make active efforts to beat the odds, a
petence under conditions of high SES-related risk toll may be exacted on their bodily systems. For example,
displayed low levels of adjustment problems but high low-SES adults who use active coping to deal with stress
levels of physiological risk (high AL) during young adult- ors that are largely uncontrollable have higher blood
hood, at age 19- These findings are consistent with a pressure, greater total peripheral resistance, and greater
counterintuitive pattern of mental- and physical-health risk of hypertension than do low-SES adults who are
outcomes that JH theory suggests. According to this the- rated low on active coping (James et al., 1992; Wright,
ory, many rural African Americans should resemble the Treiber, Davis, & Strong, 1996). The present results are
legendary folk hero John Henry: While growing up in a consistent with these findings and suggest the need for
high-risk context, they are expected to be highly goal further research that elucidates the mediating mecha
oriented and hardworking, to focus persistently on sue- nisms responsible for the physiological costs associated
cess, and to avoid unconventional behavior, but eventu- with active coping (Chen & Miller, 2012; Cohen, Evans,
ally to manifest indicators of physiological stress. Our Stokols, & Krantz, 1986). Clearly, refined analyses of the
findings are consistent with propositions that poor health coping mechanisms that underlie the results presented
and health disparities during adulthood are tied to earlier here are needed.
experiences; they also reinforce the importance of obtain- Strengths of the present study include its prospective,
ing data on both overt behavioral adjustment and covert longitudinal design and analysis of a large sample,
physiological distress (Shonkoff et al., 2009). The measures of the constructs minimized common
This study also has heuristic value for furthering the method variance. SES-related risk across preadolescence
understanding of a remarkably similar, counterintuitive was indexed from mothers' reports; preadolescent self
set of findings in the health-disparities literature. This lit- control and competence were assessed from teachers'
erature indicates that African American adults experience reports; indicators of AL at age 19 were measured with a
greater physical morbidity and mortality than do adults standard protocol that included overnight urine voids,
of other ethnicities. For example, African American blood pressure readings, and body mass index; and psy
adults are twice as likely as are European Americans chological adjustment was evaluated through young
to die from heart disease, cancer, and diabetes (Lantz adults' self-reports. Limitations of the study also should
et al., 2001; Mensah, Mokdad, Ford, Greenlund, & Croft, be noted. It is not known whether the results would
2005). Conversely, in epidemiological surveys, African generalize to low-SES European American or Latino fam
Americans consistently report lifetime rates of mental dis- dies living in either urban or rural communities. The JH
orders that are no higher than the rates reported by construct was not assessed directly because no valid
European Americans, even with exposure to SES-related measure of it is available for children and adolescents,
risk controlled (Breslau, Kendler, Su, Aguilar-Gaxiola, & Instead, age-appropriate indicators that exemplify this
Kessler, 2005; Kendler, Kuhn, Vittum, Prescott, & Riley, construct, self-control and competence, were assessed,
2005; Riolo, Nguyen, Greden, & King, 2005). In the près- and our hypothesis was tested using those indicators,
ent study, we found a parallel discrepancy between par- Nevertheless, the results suggest that rural African
ticipants' psychological adjustment and health, as indexed American youth who live in low-SES circumstances and
by AL. This suggests that resilience is multidimensional; manifest psychological resilience may be at risk for
hidden indicators of compromised physiological health, developing high AL.
such as high AL, may accompany observable competence
and positive adjustment. In such cases, resilience may Author Contributions
indeed be only "skin deep." T. Yu, E. Chen, G. E. Miller, S. M. Kogan, and S. R. H. Beach
We applied JH theory to derive a hypothesis about provided critical revisions. T. Yu performed the data ana
rural African American youth. An obvious question is under G. H. Brody's supervision. All authors approved the
whether the same pattern would be found for a broader version of the manuscript for submission.