Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mosquito-Malaria Theory (Or Sometimes Mosquito Theory) Was A
Mosquito-Malaria Theory (Or Sometimes Mosquito Theory) Was A
Contents
1Early concepts
2Scientific grounds
o 2.1Disproof of miasma theory of malaria
o 2.2Discovery of mosquito as disease vector
3King's theory
4Manson's theory
5Proof
6References
7Further reading
8External links
Early concepts[edit]
Malaria was prevalent in the Roman Empire, and the Roman scholars associated the
disease with the marshy or swampy lands where the disease was particularly rampant. [13]
[14]
It was from those Romans the name "malaria" originated. They called it malaria
(literally meaning "bad air") as they believed that the disease was a kind of miasma that
was spread in the air, as originally conceived by Ancient Greeks. Since then, it was a
medical consensus for centuries that malaria was spread due to miasma, the bad air.
However, in Medieval West Africa, specifically at Djenné, the people were able to relate
mosquitos with malaria.[15]
The first record of argument against the miasmatic nature of malaria was from an Irish
surgeon John Crawford who wrote an article "Mosquital Origin of Malarial Disease"
in Baltimore Observer in 1807,[16] but it provoked no consequences. It was instead
ridiculed as impossible and his work had since been lost. [17] An American physician
Charles Earl Johnson provided a systematic and elaborate arguments against
miasmatic origin of malaria in 1851 before the Medical Society of North Carolina.
[18]
Some of his important points were:[19]
Scientific grounds[edit]
Disproof of miasma theory of malaria[edit]
The notion that malaria was due to miasma was negated by the discovery of malarial
parasite. A German physician Johann Heinrich Meckel was the first to observed in 1847
the protozoan parasites which he recognised only as black pigment granules from the
blood and spleen of a patient who died of malaria. But he did not understand the
parasitic nature and significance of those granules in connection with malaria. In 1849 a
German pathologist Rudolf Virchow realised that it could be those granules that were
responsible for the disease. In 1879 an Italian biologist Ettore Afanasiev further argued
that the granules were definitely the causative agents. [20][21][22]
A major discovery was made by a French Army physician Charles Louis Alphonse
Laveran working in Algeria, North Africa. At the hospital in Bône (now Annaba), he
noticed spherical bodies from a patient's blood film, free or adherent to red blood cells.
[23]
On 6 November 1880 he observed from one patient's blood the actual living parasite,
describing it as "a pigmented spherical body, filiform elements which move with great
vivacity, displacing the neighboring red blood cells." He also observed the process
of maturation of the parasite (which is now called exflagellation of microgametocytes).
He meticulously examined 200 patients, and noted the cellular bodies in all 148 cases
of malaria but never in those without malaria. He also found that after treatment
with quinine, the parasites disappeared from blood.[24][25] These findings clearly indicated
that the parasite was the cause of malaria, and establishing the germ theory (nature) of
malaria.[26] He named the parasite Oscillaria malariae (later renamed Plasmodium
malariae) and reported his discovery to the French Academy of Medicine in Paris on 23
November and 28 December.[27] For his discovery he was awarded the Nobel Prize for
Physiology or Medicine in 1907.[2][28][29][30]
Discovery of mosquito as disease vector[edit]
In the early 1880s Laveran's germ theory of malaria was generally accepted by the
science community. However pivotal problems still remained, such as what transmit the
malarial parasites and how. The scientific clue emerged when a British medical officer
Patrick Manson discovered for the first time that parasites were transmitted by
mosquitoes. In 1877 while working in Amoy, a coastal town in China, he found that the
mosquito Culex fatigans (now Culex quinquefasciatus) was the vector of the
filarial roundworm that he called Filaria sanguinis hominis (but now Wuchereria
bancrofti). His findings were published in the China Customs Medical Report in 1878,
[31]
and relayed by Spencer Cobbold to the Linnean Society in London.[32] This was the
first direct evidence that mosquitoes could transmit microscopic parasites in humans,
further suggesting that the same could be true in case of malaria. [5][33]
King's theory[edit]
Based on the report of Manson's discovery, an American physician Albert Freeman
Africanus King developed a proposition that malaria is transmitted by mosquitoes. [1] He
revealed his idea in 1881 to his colleagues C.V. Riley and L.O. Howard, who did not
share the same opinion. Unfettered he developed the theory with proper justifications
and presented it before the Philosophical Society of Washington on 10 February 1882,
under the title "The Prevention of Malarial Disease Illustrating inter alia the Conservative
Function of Ague". He went so far as to suggest the complete covering of Washington,
DC along the Washington Monument with giant net to protect the city from malaria. [6] His
idea was ridiculed as inconceivable as scientist still believed malarial parasite was
spread through inhalation or ingestion from air (still not far from the miasma theory). [4] He
did not give up, and instead formed a more elaborate argument which he published as a
15-page article in the September 1883 issue of The Popular Science Monthly,[34]
[35]
making an introduction as:[36]
I now propose to present a series of facts... with regard to the so-called “malarial
poison,” and to show how they may be explicable by the supposition that the mosquito
is the real source of the disease, rather than the inhalation or cutaneous of a marsh-
vapor.
King carefully selected his view in 19 points. [37][38] To paraphrase his lengthy arguments:
occurrence of malaria always coincided with conditions that are also ideal for
mosquitos, such as in the time of day, geographical area, temperature, and climate. But
the flaw in his proposition was that he believed malaria was transmitted by mosquito
through its eggs.[4]
Manson's theory[edit]
In 1889 Patrick Manson returned to England and worked at the Seamen's Hospital
Society and also as lecturer on tropical diseases in St George's Hospital at London in
1882. His attention was soon drawn towards malaria and began to realise the
implications of his own discovery of filarial transmission on malaria. [5] He strongly
supported Laveran's germ theory of malaria, which was not yet completely embraced by
the entire medical community of the time. He proposed that:
Proof[edit]
The page in Ross' notebook where he recorded the "pigmented bodies" in mosquitoes that he later identified as
malaria parasites
In 1894 Patrick Manson devised an ingenious procedure for detecting malarial parasites
at different developmental stages from blood samples.[43] This would later prove to be the
tool for experimental proof of his theory. Manson demonstrated to and taught Ronald
Ross the technique from which Ross became convinced of Laveran's germ theory.
Trained and mentored by Manson, Ross returned to India in March 1895 to start his
investigation. But to the dismay of Ross it was not an easy task. His first detection of
malarial parasite from patients came only after two months of hard work. [44] The
disappointed Ross had to be encouraged by Manson calling the study as the "Holy
Grail" of malaria research, and that Ross was the "Sir Galahad".[4]
After one and half years he made no significant progress. On 20 August 1897 he made
a momentous discovery that some mosquitoes had malarial parasites in them. He had
fed the blood of a malarial patient (Husein Khan) to different groups of mosquitoes four
days before, and found that only one type (which he called "brown type" or more
commonly "dappled-winged mosquitoes", not knowing the species, which in fact
was Anopheles) acquired the malarial parasites in its stomach. [45][46] This was the first
evidence for Manson's theory that mosquito did carry the malarial parasite, and Ross
would later famously call 20 August as "Malaria Day" (now adopted as World Mosquito
Day).[47][48][49][50]
The second experimental evidence came in the mid-1898 when Ross demonstrated the
transmission of bird malaria Proteosoma relictum (now Plasmodium relictum) between
larks and mosquitoes, which he called "grey mosquitos" (which were Culex fatigans, but
now renamed Culex quinquefasciatus).[51][52][53] He showed that the mosquitoes ingested
the parasites from infected birds and could infect healthy birds. He further discovered
that the parasites developed in the stomach wall and were later stored in salivary
glands of the mosquito.[54][55] This was a conclusive evidence that malarial parasites were
indeed transmitted by mosquitoes.[11] In his report Ross concluded that:
These observations prove the mosquito theory of malaria as expounded by Dr Patrick
Manson.
On 9 July 1898 Ross wrote Manson:
Q.E.D. and [I] congratulate you on the mosquito theory indeed.
Ross' scientific evidences were soon fortified by Italian biologists including Giovanni
Battista Grassi, Amico Bignami, and Giuseppe Bastianelli, who discovered that human
malarial parasite was transmitted by the actual biting (disproving one of Manson's
hypotheses) of female mosquito. In 1899 they reported the infection of Plasmodium
falciparum with the mosquito Anopheles claviger[12] However the practical importance of
validating the theory, i.e. control of mosquito vector should be an effective management
strategy for malaria, was not realised by the medical community and the public. Hence
in 1900 Patrick Manson clinically demonstrated that the bite of infected anopheline
mosquitoes invariably resulted in malaria.[39] He acquired carefully reared infected
mosquitoes from Bignami and Bastianelli in Rome. His volunteer at the London School
of Tropical Medicine, P. Thurburn Manson gave a detailed account of his malarial fevers
and treatment after bitten by the mosquitoes. As he summarised, Manson's clinical trial
showed that the practical solution to malaria infection was in:
References[edit]
1. ^ Jump up to:a b Hempelmann, E; Krafts, K (2013). "Bad air, amulets and
mosquitoes: 2,000 years of changing perspectives on malaria". Malaria
Journal. 12 (1): 232. doi:10.1186/1475-2875-12-
232. PMC 3723432. PMID 23835014.
2. ^ Jump up to:a b Nye, ER (2002). "Alphonse Laveran (1845-1922):
discoverer of the malarial parasite and Nobel laureate, 1907". Journal of
Medical Biography. 10 (2): 81–
7. doi:10.1177/096777200201000205. PMID 11956550. S2CID 392786
14.
3. ^ Garrec, MF (2003). "Alphonse Laveran, a life dedicated to the
discovery of malaria". Soins (677): 31. PMID 12929603.
4. ^ Jump up to:a b c d e Lalchhandama, K (2014). "The making of modern
malariology: from miasma to mosquito-malaria theory" (PDF). Science
Vision. 14 (1): 3–17. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2014-04-27.
5. ^ Jump up to:a b c Eldridge, BF (1992). "Patrick Manson and the discovery
age of vector biology". Journal of the American Mosquito Control
Association. 8 (3): 215–20. PMID 1402856.
6. ^ Jump up to:a b Cook, G C (2000). "Perceptions of malaria transmission
before Ross' discovery in 1897". Postgraduate Medical
Journal. 76 (901): 738–
740. doi:10.1136/pmj.76.901.738. PMC 1741788. PMID 11060174.
7. ^ "The mosquito-malaria theory". The Yale Journal of Biology and
Medicine. 75 (2): 102. 2002. PMC 2588730. PMID 12230307.
8. ^ Jump up to:a b c Manson, P (2002) [1900]. "Experimental proof of the
mosquito-malaria theory. 1900". The Yale Journal of Biology and
Medicine. 75 (2): 107–12. PMC 2588736. PMID 12230309.
9. ^ Nye, ER (1991). "Ronald Ross: discoverer of the role of the mosquito in
the transmission of malaria". The New Zealand Medical
Journal. 104 (919): 386–7. PMID 1681486.
10. ^ "Ronald Ross - Facts". Nobel Media AB. Retrieved 31 January 2014.
11. ^ Jump up to:a b Bynum, W. F. (2002). "Portraits of science. Mosquitoes
bite more than once". Science. 295 (5552): 47–
48. doi:10.1126/science.1068205. PMID 11778027.
12. ^ Jump up to:a b Cox, Francis EG (2010). "History of the discovery of the
malaria parasites and their vectors". Parasites & Vectors. 3 (1):
5. doi:10.1186/1756-3305-3-5. PMC 2825508. PMID 20205846.
13. ^ Hassl, Andreas R. (2008). "Die Malaria im Römischen Kaiserreich: eine
bemerkenswerte Textstelle in den Digesten". Wiener Klinische
Wochenschrift. 120 (S4): 11–14. doi:10.1007/s00508-008-1033-
2. PMID 19066765. S2CID 27800762.
14. ^ Sallares, R; Bouwman, A; Anderung, C (2004). "The spread of malaria
to Southern Europe in antiquity: new approaches to old
problems". Medical History. 48 (3): 311–
28. doi:10.1017/s0025727300007651. PMC 547919. PMID 16021928.
15. ^ McKissack, Patricia; McKissack, Fredrick (1995). The Royal Kingdoms
of Ghana, Mali, and Songhay Life in Medieval Africa. Macmillan.
p. 104. ISBN 978-0-8050-4259-7.
16. ^ McCollom, John H. (1901). "The Rôle of Insects in the Propagation of
Disease". The American Journal of Nursing. 2 (3): 181–
193. doi:10.2307/3402517. ISSN 0002-936X.
17. ^ Neghina, Raul; Neghina, Adriana Maria; Marincu, Iosif; Iacobiciu, Ioan
(2010). "Malaria, a journey in time: in search of the lost myths and
forgotten stories". The American Journal of the Medical
Sciences. 340 (6): 492–
498. doi:10.1097/MAJ.0b013e3181e7fe6c. ISSN 1538-2990. PMID 206
01857.
18. ^ Malburne, Meredith. "An Address before the Medical Society of North
Carolina, at Its Second Annual Meeting, in Raleigh, May 1851, by
Charles E. Johnson, M.D.: Summary". Documenting the American South.
the University Library, The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.
Retrieved 22 April 2014.
19. ^ Johnson, Charles E. "An Address before the Medical Society of North
Carolina, at Its Second Annual Meeting, in Raleigh, May
1851". Documenting the American South. the University Library, The
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. Retrieved 22 April 2014.
20. ^ Cox, Francis EG (2010). "History of the discovery of the malaria
parasites and their vectors". Parasites & Vectors. 3 (1):
5. doi:10.1186/1756-3305-3-5. PMC 2825508. PMID 20205846.
21. ^ Manson-Bahr, P (1948). "Milestones in malaria". Medical
Times. 76 (11): 463. PMID 18100626.
22. ^ Manson-Bahr, P (1961). "The malaria story". Proceedings of the Royal
Society of Medicine. 54 (2): 91–
100. doi:10.1177/003591576105400202. PMC 1870294. PMID 1376629
5.
23. ^ Bruce-Chwatt LJ (1981). "Alphonse Laveran's discovery 100 years ago
and today's global fight against malaria". Journal of the Royal Society of
Medicine. 74 (7): 531–
536. doi:10.1177/014107688107400715. PMC 1439072. PMID 7021827
.
24. ^ Laveran, CL (1982). "Classics in infectious diseases: A newly
discovered parasite in the blood of patients suffering from malaria.
Parasitic etiology of attacks of malaria: Charles Louis Alphonse Laveran
(1845-1922)". Reviews of Infectious Diseases. 4 (4): 908–
11. doi:10.1093/4.4.908. PMID 6750753.
25. ^ Haas, L F (1999). "Charles Louis Alphonse Laveran (1845-
1922)". Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry. 67 (4):
520. doi:10.1136/jnnp.67.4.520. PMC 1736558. PMID 10486402.
26. ^ Sherman, Irwin (2008). Reflections on a Century of Malaria
Biochemistry. Advances in Parasitology. Vol. 67. London: Academic
Press. pp. 3–4. doi:10.1016/S0065-308X(08)00401-6. ISBN 978-0-
0809-2183-9. PMID 18940418.
27. ^ Sequeira, JH (1930). "Alphonse Laveran and his work". British Medical
Journal. 1 (3624): 1145–
7. doi:10.1136/bmj.1.3624.1145. PMC 2313558. PMID 20775532.
28. ^ "The Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine 1907". nobelprize.org.
Nobel Media AB. Retrieved 23 April 2014.
29. ^ "Alphonse Laveran - Biographical". Nobelprize.org. Nobel Media AB.
2013. Retrieved 23 April 2014.
30. ^ Sundberg, C (2007). "Alphonse Laveran: the Nobel Prize for Medicine
1907". Parassitologia. 49 (4): 257–60. PMID 18689237.
31. ^ Chernin, E (1983). "Sir Patrick Manson's studies on the transmission
and biology of filariasis". Reviews of Infectious Diseases. 5 (1): 148–
66. doi:10.1093/clinids/5.1.148. PMID 6131527.
32. ^ Cobbold, T. Spencer (1878). "The Life-history of Filaria bancrofti, as
explained by the Discoveries of Wucherer, Lewis, Bancroft, Manson,
Sonsino, myself, and others". Journal of the Linnean Society of London,
Zoology. 14 (76): 356–370. doi:10.1111/j.1096-3642.1878.tb01540.x.
33. ^ Manson, Patrick (August 1878). "On the Development of Filaria
sanguinis hominis, and on the Mosquito considered as a
Nurse*". Journal of the Linnean Society of London, Zoology. 14 (75):
304–311. doi:10.1111/j.1096-3642.1878.tb01837.x.
34. ^ Daniels, WB (1950). "Albert Freeman Africanus King (1841-1914); his
theory as to the transmission of malaria by mosquitoes". The Medical
Annals of the District of Columbia. 19 (9): 499–505,
passim. PMID 15438311.
35. ^ Howard, L. O. (1915). "Dr. A. F. A. King on Mosquitoes and
Malaria". Science. 41 (1052): 312–
315. Bibcode:1915Sci....41..312H. doi:10.1126/science.41.1052.312. P
MID 17789057.
36. ^ King, A.F.A. (1883). "Insects and disease—mosquitoes and
malaria". Popular Science Monthly. 23: 644–658.
37. ^ McCollom (1901). "The Rôle of Insects in the Propagation of
Disease". The American Journal of Nursing. 2 (3): 181–
193. doi:10.2307/3402517. JSTOR 3402517.
38. ^ Anonymous (1941). "Albert King". Nature. 147 (3716):
85. Bibcode:1941Natur.147T..85.. doi:10.1038/147085d0.
39. ^ Jump up to:a b Manson-Bahr, P (1938). "The Jubilee of Sir Patrick
Manson (1878-1938): A Tribute to his Work on the Malaria
Problem". Postgraduate Medical Journal. 14 (157): 345–
57. doi:10.1136/pgmj.14.157.345. PMC 2477395. PMID 21313134.
40. ^ Cook, GC (1994). "Manson's demonstration of the malaria parasite 100
years ago: the major stimulus for Ross' discovery?". The Journal of
Infection. 28 (3): 333–4. doi:10.1016/s0163-4453(94)92243-
8. PMID 7916371.
41. ^ Chernin, Eli (1988). "Sir Ronald Ross vs. Sir Patrick Manson: A Matter
of Libel". Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences. 43 (3):
262–274. doi:10.1093/jhmas/43.3.262. PMID 3063748.
42. ^ Manson, P (1894). "On the Nature and Significance of Cresenteric and
Flagellated bodies in Malarial Blood". BMJ. 2 (1771): 1306–
8. doi:10.1136/bmj.2.1771.1306. PMC 2405325. PMID 20755205.
43. ^ Manson, P (1894). "On the Nature and Significance of the Crescentic
and Flagellated Bodies in Malarial Blood". British Medical
Journal. 2 (1771): 1306–
8. doi:10.1136/bmj.2.1771.1306. PMC 2405325. PMID 20755205.
44. ^ Ross, R (1896). "Observations on Malaria Parasites made in
Secunderabad, Deccan". British Medical Journal. 1 (1831): 260–
1. doi:10.1136/bmj.1.1831.260. PMC 2406240. PMID 20755993.
45. ^ Ross, R (1897). "On some Peculiar Pigmented Cells Found in Two
Mosquitos Fed on Malarial Blood". British Medical Journal. 2 (1929):
1786–8. doi:10.1136/bmj.2.1929.1786. PMC 2408186. PMID 20757493.
46. ^ Ross, R; Smyth, J (1997). "On some peculiar pigmented cells found in
two mosquitoes fed on malarial blood. 1897". Indian Journal of
Malariology. 34 (2): 47–55. PMID 9293695.
47. ^ Sinden, Robert E (2007). "Malaria, mosquitoes and the legacy of
Ronald Ross". Bulletin of the World Health Organization. 95 (11): 821–
900. doi:10.2471/blt.04.020735 (inactive 31 October
2021). hdl:10665/269872. PMC 2636258. PMID 18038083.
48. ^ Gibson, Mary E. "Ronald Ross and the treatment of malaria".
Wellcome Collection. Archived from the original on 24 April 2014.
Retrieved 24 April 2014.
49. ^ "World Mosquito Day". Malaria No More UK. Archived from the
original on 2 February 2014. Retrieved 24 April 2014.
50. ^ Cook, GC (Jul–Aug 1997). "Ronald Ross (1857-1932): 100 years since
the demonstration of mosquito transmission of Plasmodium spp--on 20
August 1897". Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine
and Hygiene. 91 (4): 487–8. doi:10.1016/s0035-9203(97)90295-
9. PMID 9373663.
51. ^ Bynum, WF (1999). "Ronald Ross and the malaria-mosquito
cycle". Parassitologia. 41 (1–3): 49–52. PMID 10697833.
52. ^ Katz, FF (1997). "On the centenary of Sir Ronald Ross's discovery of
the role of the mosquito in the life cycle of the malaria parasite". Journal
of Medical Biography. 5 (4): 200–
4. doi:10.1177/096777209700500403. PMID 11619711. S2CID 322339
83.
53. ^ Rajakumar, K; Weisse, M (1999). "Centennial year of Ronald Ross'
epic discovery of malaria transmission: an essay and tribute". Southern
Medical Journal. 92 (6): 567–71. doi:10.1097/00007611-199906000-
00004. PMID 10372849.
54. ^ Ross, R (1898). "Pigmented cells in mosquitos". British Medical
Journal. 1 (1939): 550–
1. doi:10.1136/bmj.1.1939.550. PMC 2410758. PMID 20757668.
55. ^ Ross, Ronald (1898). "Report on the cultivation of Proteosoma, Labbé,
in grey mosquitos". Indian Medical Gazette. 33 (11): 401–
408. OCLC 63606142. PMC 5141207. PMID 29001935.
Further reading[edit]
Packard, Randall M. (2010). The Making of a Tropical
Disease: A Short History of Malaria. Maryland, US: The
Johns Hopkins University Press. ISBN 978-1-42-140175-1.
Cook, G.C. (2007). Tropical Medicine: an Illustrated History
of The Pioneers. Oxford, UK: Elsevier. ISBN 978-0-08-
055939-1.
Sherman, Irwin (2008). Reflections on a Century of Malaria
Biochemistry. London: Academic Press. ISBN 978-0-0809-
2183-9.
Nye, Edwin R.; Gibson, Mary E. (1997). Ronald Ross :
Malariologist and Polymath : a Biography. New York: St.
Martin's Press, Inc. ISBN 0-312-16296-0.
Ross, Ronald (1923). Memoirs, with a Full Account of the
Great Malaria Problem and Its Solution. London: John
Murray.
Haynes, Douglas M. (2001). Imperial Medicine: Patrick
Manson and the Conquest of Tropical Disease. Philadelphia:
University of Pennsylvania Press. ISBN 978-0-81-223598-2.
Lehrer, Steven (2006). Explorers of the Body : Dramatic
Breakthroughs in Medicine from Ancient Times to Modern
Science (2nd ed.). New York: iUniverse. p. 248. ISBN 978-
0-595-40731-6.
External links[edit]
Malaria: Past and Present
The History of Malaria, an Ancient Disease
History of Malaria: Scientific Discoveries
The History of Malaria on Stamps
History at UCLA
Categories:
Malaria
History of medicine
Scientific theories
Parasitology
Insect vectors of human pathogens
Navigation menu
Not logged in
Talk
Contributions
Create account
Log in
Article
Talk
Read
Edit
View history
Search
Search Go
Main page
Contents
Current events
Random article
About Wikipedia
Contact us
Donate
Contribute
Help
Learn to edit
Community portal
Recent changes
Upload file
Tools
What links here
Related changes
Special pages
Permanent link
Page information
Cite this page
Wikidata item
Print/export
Download as PDF
Printable version
Languages
العربية
Español
Edit links
This page was last edited on 3 February 2022, at 20:45 (UTC).
Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License; additional terms may apply. By using this site,
you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Wikipedia® is a registered trademark of the Wikimedia Foundation, Inc., a
non-profit organization.
Privacy policy
About Wikipedia
Disclaimers
Contact Wikipedia
Mobile view
Developers
Statistics
Cookie statement