2007 EditionChapter 1
anrropucrion
‘CONSTITUTIONAL LAW is ho study of the maintenance
tho proper balaneo fotwean muthorty as epee by
the thre inherent powers ofthe Sate aad Ubety as a
steed hy the Ll of Rights I eror to pene tha his
tubjectsuggeeta the unjustified nssendancy of euthorty
‘ver Ibert as tha might result n tyranny or the ‘una
Fant primacy of liberty over nutorty se thie would
‘esul ln anarey. The tro role of Conetitatonal Lari to
‘stan ulin between ator a tym Ut
Fighte are exercined within the fatnomor ofthe lw ane
the Ines are enacted with due deferace to sight Ie ix
bast thatthe itident nppreciat thi st. the thread,
Bare he enters the fuenating word of Canetiitona
Law
‘The fundamental gawers of the Stale are th pice
power the power of eminent domsin, and the pomer of
{tation Among tho safeguards inthe Blof Rights are
the right to duo process and equal prozetin, the prob
tion aginst antearonslo searches a ataes, reders
af cxpremion, te impeirment elas, andthe guarantors
against injustice to the accused. Thee povrs and rights
‘euntershes hit ao not nearly hal each ter,
They have commen objective. eoisence ‘Theil
nts goa i Use sane: a welder socket bse on ao
Invilaiity of rghta whic, lthough they may not be
ctl ebltray, may aevertloa bo regula forthe
onion god,"his wos wil ea int wth euch ofthe Uwe inber
‘nt powers This fing es the regan of asta
‘onde eve qua non for the proper enjoyment of Ul
tefp il the common wel a the eritaran. Thon will
‘coal tothe examination of the diferent proviion ka
Aiello the Constitution, more commonly known as
the Bil of Righss, Once satorty i established, i is nec
asery to define ad inti reach lot rogulation become
fncreachnent ad the pestine purity of rights debe
Dy naked power
efi evrything ela, however, sort belgraud
study on the hase principles govering conttations in
fener thelr actare, cameos, amendniot or rev
Son, and Interpretation eal be presente. The adoption
tf the present Constitution of the Philippines 1987,
together with the recent pertinent decisions of the Su
‘remo Court shall aaa be reviewed.
Chapter
"THE NATURE OF THE CONSTITUTION
Definition
ACONSIVTUTION, nesting to Coley, i “that by of
ules and maim in seprdance with hich the powers of
soverignty ere habitually exerdsed™ This definition a
fompreiensive enowh to cove the writen and the
‘sen Contac,
With particular rfarenee tp Uae Contttion of the
Philippines, the more appropriate dseipion x that given
by Jui Malem, who speaks of ar “te writen In
‘strument enacted by diet aston ofthe pope by which
the fundamental pers of the goverment are sla
lished, nite and dene, and hy wih hive powers are
Aistibuted among the soveeal departments for their safe
‘and useful ocr far the bene of the body pte
Purpoocs.
Tho purpoeo of the Cansei is to preseibe the
permanent framework of «system of government, 0
Sgn to tho soveral deparimenta their respective powers
and dates, a Yo efi certain fit Fal princes on
‘which government i founded”1k shouldbe sresed that when i comes to cotain
Desi individ ight euch 9 egioas eedom, ii not
the Conltation that cuts o confers them. The correct
view te that the Consist meray rengaies nd pro
toa thene rights and dos nsbring them into existence.
“The Constitution i not "the aig of pivato rights it
Js nok the foun of Iw nor the Sapient stato of ge
fernments fait the caw bat Use consequence of ee
foal and policalfeedom.”
Supremacy of the Constitution
“The Conatittion i the base and pararhount law to
which al ee Inv moet conform and to which all pe
loos ined the highest fila of wo Land, must deer.
No act shall be valid, however noble Ss intetions, i it
nics with the Canetitton. ‘Tse Constitution mast
‘ror remain supreme, All mst bow to she mandate of his
Iw: Expediency snustnot be allowed co sap is strength
nov greet for power dabace i rectude. Right or wrang,
‘he Constion mist be upheld along as thas mk ben
‘hanged by Ue sovereign people let aregurd rel in
{ho usurpation of the maety oF lw by the pretenders ta
legitimate power!
‘Clastteation
‘Constitutions az clase into writen oF unten,
volved or enatad, and rigid o Roi
‘A writen conaitaton Is one whose pratt ae on
badd in on documento et of documenta. An waren
fenstitation, on the oer hand, coisa of roles whlch
fneve not bee iniagrated into a lage cnerte fem but
are sattrol in varoas sours uch a atte of fun
‘damental charactor, judilal decisions, commentaries of
pobleints, conloms sid trudtons and certain commen
Taw pent.
‘A converonal conetittion isan anata conti
tn, farmaly “trek of at dete tno an place fl
leing conscious or doliberate ort tlken by ens
cnt boy or rule. A cumulative costttion, by contrat
tho result of paca evolution, “not inaugurated at any
ssi time tnt changing by acetian rather than by ang
‘Sterne method”
Agi constitution is ne tht can be amended ly
ty formal snd usually dieule provet whereas ale
seasttlio i one tat can be changed by ordinary leg
‘The Constitution of tbo Philippines ie writen, con
‘ventional and eg
assentlal Qualition ofthe Written Constitution
A gad wrtton constintion must be bro, bre and
etnite
must be broad nt only esnure it provides for the
organiation ofthe entire government and coves all per
sons and things within th trary of he Stat but more
Sobor appt ey the paso reel the
Present and to antipale the fare, Th eonaiation
Must be comprehensive enough to provide for eway com
‘ingency Tt ha been aid that the onatiteton ia nly
‘he imprisonment ofthe past but the uning of te fi
ture to whieh st may be add tha a al the Tal
mont ofthe presnt6 CoNSARUTIONAL LAW
1 mua be bi and confine alto base pings
to be inplemented wit logilntiv details moe adjustable
to diage end enero amend Others, th ensitution
woul be a prix aad voluminous oxieation inaccessible
(othe understanding or even only the interest of tho peo-
fle ad unable to adapt resily to changing conditions
Fras of th ifialy ofits atsendent
Te must he cloar det let ambiguity ints prvi
sions rut in canton and divisiveness among th peo
pl, and pevhaps even py ennft. Tho exception is
Faved oni in those eases where the ros are deliberstaly
‘worded ia a vague manner, Ik the do procs las,
Tk then more malleable to jd nterpretatin Inthe
Fight of ne onions and elreumstancos,
Rasential Parts of the Welton Constitution
[A good writin constitution contain thre eesentat
ubstantive parte. Thowe are knven as to constitation of
Lert, the cnatcton of gocernmend, andthe const
tion of soersenty
"Tho firs const of a saree of presergcons sting
forch the fandamental evil and pola! rights ofthe ct
ens and imposing Hinata on the pera of govern
tment as_¢ moans of secusig the eqjyment. of thos
Fighta? These wo fund prisalplly in Arie IT of our
(Cenaitton, and no i Ati IV, V, and XI
"The second ents of «ser of provisions outing
the orzanization of te goverament, enumerating it pov
fr lying down certain olor flav to ts administra
on, und deinng Uso ectorate® Those ate fad in Art
flee Vito XL oft Constitution.
‘The thint conta ofthe provisions pointing out the
role of procedure in sesrdanee with: whieh firm
hangs in the fundamental law may be brought about”
‘Shoe are ound in Artie XVI oar Conatiaion
Permanence ofthe Constitution,
One advantage af the weten, conventional and ig
conattion fs fix jermantey, ofa capac lo rset
faprisious cr whimaial change deat not ly legit
reeds but any by pasting facie, teraporary passions ot
scensanalinfatustions ofthe people with es or persone
Ate. “A Conattation must be ian and immovable ike &
‘mountain amidst tho asf forme orn rela the oa,
Andi the raging ofthe waves" Sach a constitution
‘ot likely to be esily tampered with to sul politi expo
len, prea mins or Hod ition for
‘Bot the very vitue of permanence may’ at the same
tim be n dsadvantage whore the writen cotton is
tuntle to aut tothe noe! for change Jus new
‘conditions and ereumsancs, The difialy ef ofthe
‘ampndiag proces may be respnsile fr te delay in
Tooting the needed change ad th cao irreparable i
Jury the publi intetet
In auch situation, the vetan enim wil bo-
come an Ingeiiment rather than a par to progee, 8
{reed to Ube nation soaking to Uberate ite fom the
Hutches of beceto ul no longer conformable to thle