Professional Documents
Culture Documents
schaeffer1990-MATERIALS PROCESSING WITH EXCIMER LASERS
schaeffer1990-MATERIALS PROCESSING WITH EXCIMER LASERS
schaeffer1990-MATERIALS PROCESSING WITH EXCIMER LASERS
To cite this article: R.D. Schaeffer , M.J. Scaggs & T.P. McGarry (1990) MATERIALS PROCESSING WITH EXCIMER LASERS,
Materials and Manufacturing Processes, 5:4, 617-640, DOI: 10.1080/10426919008953281
Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all the information (the “Content”) contained
in the publications on our platform. However, Taylor & Francis, our agents, and our licensors make no
representations or warranties whatsoever as to the accuracy, completeness, or suitability for any purpose of the
Content. Any opinions and views expressed in this publication are the opinions and views of the authors, and
are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis. The accuracy of the Content should not be relied upon and
should be independently verified with primary sources of information. Taylor and Francis shall not be liable for
any losses, actions, claims, proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages, and other liabilities whatsoever
or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with, in relation to or arising out of the use of the
Content.
This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic
reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing, systematic supply, or distribution in any
form to anyone is expressly forbidden. Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at http://
www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-conditions
MATERIALS & MANUFACTURING PROCESSES, 5(4), 617-640 (1990)
ABSmACT
INTRODUCTION
Excimer lasers are the most versatile and powerful ultraviolet light sources
currently available. The unique properties of deep UV radiation and the interaction
with various materials are currently being investigated and utilized in the industrial
sector to provide a non-contact tool which can cost effectively perform
micromachining and marking applications. A very important aspect of the current
excitement for excimer laser use is improvements made by excimer manufacturers
towards providing more reliability, lower operating costs, and more predictable
behavior - essentially working towards the goal of "turn-key" operation. Also, the
unique properties of excimer lasers and their UV interaction with materials differs
significantly from more common material processing lasers like the CO 2 (10.6 !Jm)
and Nd:YAG (1.06 !Jm) and these differences make the excimer laser the tool of
choice for many applications, especially those requiring a high degree of precision
or those sensitive to harmful side effects such as charring or melting.
617
Excimer lasers are a class of electronically excited molecular gas lasers which
permit high intensity, short duration pulses of UV light. The term excimer is derived
from EXCited homo nuclear dIMER (diamotic molecule), for example, molecular
xenon (Xe, *). However, the most widely used excimers involve excited heteronuclear
dimer such as ArF*, for example. These lasers are technically referred to as
"exciplexes". Depending on the gas mixture in the laser head, excimers can be
operated at many different wavelengths, the four most common being 193 nm (argon
fluoride - ArF), 248 nm (krypton fluoride - KrF), 308 nm (xenon chloride - XeCI),
Downloaded by [USC University of Southern California] at 13:14 13 March 2015
and 351 nm (xenon fluoride - XeF). In addition to the gases which form the actual
lasing partners, a buffer gas, usually neon (Ne) or helium (He) is used to provide a
third body collision partner. Laser radiation is generated when the tightly bound
exciplex makes a transition back to the repulsive ground state, giving off energy as
UV photons (1-3).
An excimer laser head (Fig. 1) contains three parts: the active lasing medium, an
optical resonator and a power supply. The atoms or molecules of the active gas lasing
medium absorb the energy delivered by the power supply, and then emit a portion
of the absorbed energy as laser light. The optical resonator consists of two mirrors
placed at either end of the pressure vessel. One mirror reflects 100 percent of the
beam. The other, typically an uncoated Mgf', window, transmits 90 percent to allow
partial feedback and permit beam extraction. Also included in the laser head are high
voltage storage capacitors, a thyratron switching circuit, and other computerized
electronic circuitry.
STORAGE
CAPACitOR
fllGH
VOLTAGE
LASU
THYRATRON OUIPur
SWITCH
2 3 /1 5--5 7 [rnrn] 0
The beam profile is rectangular (Fig. 2) and its flat top without peaks or holes
is well suited to processing large areas using projection imaging techniques. The
mask used to image the beam onto the work piece is a metal stencil of 0.1 to 0.2 mm
thickness. It can contain a hole or slot, an array of holes or a combination of slots,
or any complex pattern designed for a particular application. The parallel processing
of mask imaging may allow higher throughput than the serial approach used with a
spot beam from a CO 2 and YAG laser.
Many materials (Table 1) exhibit high absorption coefficients in the UV. Because
most of the energy is absorbed in a surface layer typically less than 1 Jlm thick,
ablated material is removed layer-by-layeron a pulse-to-pulse basis. Since the entire
process occurs during the 10 to 50 nsec duration of a typical laser pulse, there is
insufficient time for a considerable amount of heat to diffuse into the surrounding
material. This accounts for the virtual absence of a heat-affected zone, and is one
important reason why excimers are often substituted for either CO 2 or YAG lasers
in marking, drilling, cutting and surface treatment applications. Other advantages
include better quality and yields, especially for materials with low absorption at 10.6
and 1.06 Jlm (noble metals), and/or materials sensitive to high thermal stress (glass
and ceramics). Also, due to the short wavelength of excimers, an order of magnitude
better resolution than can be achieved with infrared lasers is possible, allowing higher
machining and marking precision.
620 SCHAEFFER ET AL.
TABLE 1
Generalized summary of key parameters
for typical materials and processing types.
In the pioneering days of excimer laser development, gas lifetimes were measured
in thousands of shots and high voltage components, most notably the thyratron
switch, were operated close to their maximum specifications. These were two of the
most pressing areas to improve upon before the excimer could take its place in the
industrial work place.
The first major breakthrough in improved reliability came in 1984 with the
development of magnetic switching circuitry (MSC"). The MSC reduces current
risetime and prevents reverse currents in the high voltage circuit, while also acting
to reduce the current across the most sensitive component, the thyratron. Since the
introduction of MSC, failures of the thyratron switch and high voltage capacitors
have virtually been eliminated. Standard operating ranges without failure are in
excess of 109 pulses, equating to more than 2,000 operating hours at a repetition rate
of 200 Hz with a 70% duty cycle (4,5).
allowing long term operation of the laser under reproducible and identifiable
operating conditions. Also, in the present state-of-the-art lasers, a fiber optic local
area network is used to increase reliability and security of data transmission.
Another broader area of concern has been increasing the reliability of "low tech"
components, affecting everything from circulation fan assemblies, halogen
compatibility of materials, and better shielding to reduce electro-magnetic
interference (EMI) levels. At present, the limiting high voltage component seems to
be the pair of discharge electrodes which are subject to slow electrode burn-off that
generates dust impurities. It is difficult to predict the lifetime of an electrode, as its
Downloaded by [USC University of Southern California] at 13:14 13 March 2015
shape changes because of burn-off affecting output parameters such as energy, beam
homogeneity, pulse-to-pulse stability and jitter. A major goal of excimer laser
manufacturers today is the improvement of electrode design and lifetime, although
recently a record breaking 1010 pulses was achieved on a test laser without replacing
the thyratron, electrodes, capacitors or power supply.
Microlithography
Pattern generators produce the reticles (microcircuit masks on a large scale) that
are used for production of highly integrated semiconductor circuits. First, a layer of
chrome then a thin layer of optical photoresist, is deposited on glass or fused quartz.
Usually the integrated circuit (IC) pattern is exposed on the photoresist with a light
source, in this case the excimer laser. The unexposed photoresist, the bare chrome,
and the remaining photoresist are removed in sequence, leaving the IC pattern in
chrome on glass.
A pattern generator equipped with a mercury arc lamp can take as long as 50
hours to generate a pattern. In contrast, electron beam and excimer systems can print
patterns in about two hours. The biggest drawback of the e-beam system is cost,
which can range from $3 to $5 million, while capital investment for an excimer based
622 SCHAEFFER ET AL.
Downloaded by [USC University of Southern California] at 13:14 13 March 2015
Contact printing (mask-to-wafer alignment and exposure) is used for small scale
production of high resolution devices. The excimer laser plays a role in modern
contact printing because 193 nm light does not require filtering, has relatively high
intensity, exhibits the shortest usable wavelength in the vacuum-UV, and is capable
of generating 0.2 ~m lines on polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) resists (Fig. 4). Also,
a synthetic quartz mask can be used at 193 nm (9,10).
etching requires higher fluences to ablate the material. The desired pattern may be
imaged through a mask or the beam can be focussed to a small spot and scanned
across the surface to carve a thin line in the work piece. Direct writing can also be
used to repair faulty devices (Fig. 5).
One example is direct writing of tungsten on both silicon and polymer substrates.
The objective is to exploit the packaging advantage made possible by using the highly
focussed laser beam to create extremely thin metal lines used for chip-to-chip
connections. Excimer laser driven dissociation of tungsten hexafluoride gas can be
used to produce 1 ~mmetal lines on a variety of substrates where the "drawing"
speed can be as fast a several centimeters per second. The process can also be
adapted to deposit other conductors such as zinc, aluminum, molybdenum, platinum,
copper and gold. The advantages of laser writing are maskless operation and the use
of targets with surface irregularities.
In addition to high resolution prints with the high aspect ratios, the excimer laser
can be used in multi-level resist schemes. Optimum results were achieved at all
wavelengths with a minimum gap between the mask features and the wafer surface,
however, 193 nm is preferred over 248 nm due to less diffraction and much higher
sensitivity of PMMA. A typical application is small scale production of high
frequency devices on gallium arsenide and lithium niobate substrates.
Optical wafer steppers are used on high volume semiconductor production lines.
The leading manufacturers are employing line-narrowed excimer lasers at 248 nm to
increase feature resolution to 0.3 ~m over 1 ~m depth of focus in their deep UV
evaluator.
Micromachining
Absorption by metals, especially silver, gold and copper, is much higher in the
ultraviolet spectral region than in the infrared (Table 2). The excimer beam is except
for small reflection losses, almost completely absorbed by surface layers. In most
cases a molten pool of about 1 ~m depth appears during the pulse. Typically,
material removal by vaporization or expulsion of molten metal is at a rate between
0.1 and 2 ~m per pulse, and peak powers up to 100 GW/cm2 must be used.
To make small holes (10 to a few 100 ~m) a circular aperture is illuminated with
the light from an excimer laser, and the reduced image is directed on to the work
piece. The energy density is then increased to the required value. This technique was
used to perforate the 100 ~m thin stainless steel (shown in Fig. 6) with holes 50 and
150 ~m diameter. Holes with straight, clean walls can also be made in titanium,
nickel, and tungsten. Fig. 7 shows the average material removal rate per laser pulse
as a function of hole size. This data is based on a wavelength of 248 nm and a
constant energy density of 40 J/cm2• Metal up to 1 mm thick can be perforated by
placing the work piece at the focal point of a spherical lens and using an unstable
resonator. Using 200 mJ energy at 248 nm it takes approximately 500 laser pulses to
make holes about 100 ~m in size. Circular holes of larger diameters are made by
626 SCHAEFFER ET AL.
moving the part in the direction of the beam axis. The opening, which has a very
smooth wall, is enlarged by a milling action from the inside.
TABLE 2
Fraction of Energy Absorbed on Metal Surfaces
at Normal Incidence (%).
Aluminum 2 10 18
Iron 4 35 60
Copper 1 8 70
Molybdenum 4 42 60
Nickel 5 25 58
Silver 1 3 77
Figure 6. 50 !Jm and 150 Jim diameter holes in 100 !Jm thick stainless steel.
MATERIALS PROCESSING WITH EXCIMER LASERS 627
potses
noo
2000
Downloaded by [USC University of Southern California] at 13:14 13 March 2015
1800
1600
'~OO .007S"
stainless sleel
1100
1000
aoo
600
,
ioo 100 soc .00 \00 600
diameter I JJm
Required energy densities are material interaction dependent, but more than 10
J/cm 2 are frequently needed for most metal processing. For example, one application
required an energy density of 12 J/cm2 to machine slots in gold, while another called
for more than 20 J/cm2 to drill small holes in molybdenum refractory metal. Fig. 8
shows a feature machined in gold.
Kapton, which has a high temperature stability and is difficult to process with
other lasers without causing charring, roll-off due to melting and cracking, can be
precision micromachined and/or drilled with consistent quality by using an excimer
626 SCHAEFFER ET AL.
UV light. This material exhibits an ablation rate of about 1 11m per pulse if
irradiated at 248 nm at an energy intensity of about 1 J/cm2 (Fig. 9) (11).
Downloaded by [USC University of Southern California] at 13:14 13 March 2015
Heat-free and clean removal of polymer insulation from wires (Figs. 10, 11) with
diameters of approximately 50 11m is another excellent application. The non-contact
wire-stripping process takes about a second, is applicable to wires with different
diameters and insulations, and makes it possible to remove the insulation at very well
defined positions and lengths anywhere along the wire. Depending on the thickness
of the jacket material, an energy density of 200 m.l/cm? at 248 nm can strip wire in
0.2 to 1 second.
1.6
x Xe CI (308 nm )
1.4 o Kr F ( 248 nm )
• Ar F (193 nm )
1,2
Downloaded by [USC University of Southern California] at 13:14 13 March 2015
E 1.0
z
Q 0.8
I-
«
ii5 0,6
«
0.4
0.2
.' .
a
0.01 0.1 1 10
--ENERGY DENSITY (J/cm') - - .
Excimer lasers are also used quite successfully in the machining of various
ceramics. In many cases, ablative processing of oxide such as ceramics using the
excimer laser is the only acceptable solution to avoid thermal cracks and formation
of microcracks in material walls. Table 3 givesdata on excimer related processing for
various materials. In general, the ablation rate is the same for both fired and green
substrates because firing does not alter the grainy structure and absorptivity in the
UV. In this process, the excimer laser beam removes a microscopic layer by
vaporizing the material at temperatures above lO,OOO°C. The end result is a conical
shaped hole with an inner wall that is smooth and shows no sign of molten material.
The cone angle depends on energy density - higher values result in a hole which
approaches the ideal cylindrical shape. An ablation depth per pulse of 0.47 ~m is
achieved in ceramic using a 248 nm excimer laser operated at an energy f1uence of
34 J/cm2• This is typical for processing at aspect ratios below one. Increasing the-
depth of the hole causes the ablation depth per pulse to fall off sharply but the
variation in beam size and in turn the variation in f1uence over the total drilling
depth is estimated to be less than 5 percent by burn in patterns at different working
distances. Normally, multiple holes are drilled in parallel at high repetition rates and
630 SCHAEFFER ET AL.
Downloaded by [USC University of Southern California] at 13:14 13 March 2015
it may require multiple pulses to etch down to the desired depth. Areas ranging from
0.07 to 0.017 em' can be simultaneously processed at fluences of 7 to 30 J/cm 2l
respectively, with a typical excimer laser operating at 500 mJ per pulse. Changing
from ceramic drilling to cutting increases the ablation rate nearly twofold. A possible
explanation for this is that in drilling the vaporized material is restricted to
recondensation in a relatively small channel. When cutting it expands into the kerf.
Fig. 13 shows a machined ceramic surface (12).
MATERIALS PROCESSING WITH EXCIMER LASERS 631
TABLE 3
Summary of excimer laser etch rates for ceramics
20 0.15
30 0.17
45 0.19
308 10 0.15
25 0.17
100 0.23
Marking
TABLE 4
Excimer Laser Marking Applications
For polymers, color pigment is more important than properties of the material.
Often a photochemical change occurs when a wavelength of 308 nm is used at about
0.5 to 1 J/cm2• Varying the wavelength to 248 nm can change the absorption depth
and the contrast of the mark. For permanence, a depth of about 50 IJm provides the
best wear resistance. For small marks, single shot mask applications are usually
suitable, but legend fields of 10 em' can be marked with a single pulse in a few tenths
of a second by using a scanning procedure. Fig. 15 shows excimer marked polymer
materials.
MATERIALS PROCESSING WITH EXCIMER LASERS 635
Downloaded by [USC University of Southern California] at 13:14 13 March 2015
Electronic surface mount devices and thin ceramic materials are now being
marked with an excimer rather than a CO 2 laser because of high resolution and
freedom from local heating and microcracks. The excimer wavelength of 308 nm is
used for nearly all ceramics because it provides a legible mark with a single pulse
(Fig. 16). By using a long focal length lens, the depth of focus can be as much as
several millimeters, eliminates time consuming refocussing for parts of only small
thickness variance.
High quality and high visibility marks can be produced on glass surfaces with an
excimer wavelength of 193 nm. About 2 J/cm2 is concentrated at the target area per
laser shot, and each pulse removes approximately 0.1 f.lm of material. Higher contrast
shape edges can be obtained by placing a metal grid behind the mask, a technique
that is especially useful for smooth, transparent surfaces (Fig. 17).
636 SCHAEFFER ET AL.
Downloaded by [USC University of Southern California] at 13:14 13 March 2015
Two of the most promising areas of film deposition are in thin film diamond
growth and high Tc superconductors. Both of these techniques involve using an
appropriately chosen excimer wavelength, usually 248 nm or 193 nm, and evaporating
a target material onto a substrate. The substrate and target are normally contained
within an evacuated vessel, and the substrate is generally heated.
Applications in diamond film growth that are under development are fabricating
hard coatings for tools and mechanical parts, lithography masks, electronic devices
taking advantage of diamond's outstanding electrical properties, and acoustic devices
such as coated speaker diaphragms. Usually 193 nm radiation is used in the excimer
assisted growth technique, with the substrate being held between 700°C-l,OOO°C.
Substrates include silicon, sapphire, diamond, ceramics and metals, and typical
deposition rates of 5-10 jJm!hour can be achieved. As in other diamond growth
techniques, a hydrogen atmosphere is usually used, which maximizes growth of
diamond structure as opposed to other carbon structures (13,14).
MATERIALS PROCESSING WITH EXCIMER LASERS 637
Downloaded by [USC University of Southern California] at 13:14 13 March 2015
SUMMARY
When used in a fashion to take advantage of their strengths, excimer lasers are
an extremely valuable tool for use in many materials processing applications. They
excel at removing small amounts of material with finesse and precision, marking
small parts at high rates of speed, photochemical applications which make use of
high efficiency and high power UV laser light, surface alteration and thin film
638 SCHAEFFER ET AL.
Downloaded by [USC University of Southern California] at 13:14 13 March 2015
REFERENCES
1. Ewing, J., "Excimer Lasers", Laser Handbook, Vol. 3, M.L. Stitch, Ed. North
Holland Publishing Company, p.B5, (1979).
6. Jain, K., and R.T. Karth, "Excimer laser projection lithography", Applied Optics,
Vol.23, p.648, (1984).
7. Pol, V., and G. Escher, "Excimer laser based lithography", SPIE Conference on
Microlithography, (1986).
9. Cullman, E., Karl Suss KG-GmbH & Co., "Excimer Laser Printing with 193 nm
Wavelength", Highlights No.4, Lambda Physik (1987).
10. Ehrlich, D., and M. Rothschild, "A Review of Excimer Laser Projection
Lithography", Journal of Vacuum Science & Technology B, Vo1.6, p.l, (1988).
11. Srinivasan, R., K. Casey, and B. Braren, "Subnanosecond probing of the ablation
of polyimide (Kapton''") by ultraviolet laser pulses", Chemtronics, VolA, p.153,
(1989).
12. Sowada, U., S. Ishizaka, H-J. Kahlert, and D. Basting, "Excimer laser processing
of aluminum oxide ceramics", Chcmtronics, VolA, p.162, (1989).
15. Dijkkamp, D., T. Venkatesan, X.D. Wu, SA Shaheen, N. Jisrowi, Y.H. Min-Lee,
W.L. McLean, and M. Croft, Applied Physics Letters Vol.51, p.619, (1987).
16. Inam, A, X.D. Wu, T. Venkatesan, S.B. Ogale, c.c. Chang, and D. Dijkkamp,
Applied Physics Letters, Vol.51, p.lIl2, (1987).
17. Mannhart, J., M. Scheuermann, c.c. Tsuei, M.M. Oprysko, C.C. Chi, c.r.
Umbach, R.H. Koch, and C. Miller, Applied Physics Letters, Vol.52, p.1271,
(1988).
Downloaded by [USC University of Southern California] at 13:14 13 March 2015