Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dean Castro Transcribe Final
Dean Castro Transcribe Final
BY
DEAN ARTURO M. DE CASTRO
UNIVERSITY OF MANILA GRADUATE SCHOOL OF LAW
B.2 A person under 15 years old unless, he has acted with discernment.
B.3 Performance of lawful act with due care causes an injury by mere ACCIDENT
without fault or intention of doing it.
B.6 Failure to perform an act required by law, when prevented by some lawful or
INSUPERABLE CAUSE.
C. MITIGATING CIRCUMSTANCES
6. PASSION OR OBFUSCATION
a.) Unlawful age of the victim
b.) No appreciable lapse of time between the unlawful act and the vindication
c.) The unlawful act was committed by the victim.
Passional obfuscation must arise from lawful sentiments
8. PHYSICAL DEFECTS- deaf and dumb, blind or suffering from physical defect
that restricts his means of action, defense or communication with the
fellowmen.
C.3 Qualifying- change the nature of the crime from homicide to murder, treachery,
evident premeditation
C.4 Inherent- necessarily present in the crime not used in the definition
E.G.
• abuse of public officer in bribery
• Fraud in estafa
• Deceit in simple seduction, ignominy in rape
• Breaking of a wall or unlawful entry in robbery with force upon things
*Where the accused wound cogon grass aroused his penis in committing rape, the
aggravating circumstance was considered ignominy and not cruelty in People vs Torrefiel
et. Al (CA 45088) because at the time rape was a crime against chastity and not against
person. Now that rape is a crime against person, cruelty may be appreciated as
aggravating circumstance.
a. Must have abused his public position or it must have facilitated the commission
of the crime
Transcribed By: Rosanie P. Remotin, JD
WESTERN MINDANAO STATE UNIVERSITY
ZAMBOANGA CITY
BESTBAREVER 2020_21_22
b. Not aggravating if inherent in the commission of the crime as in malversation of
public funds.
a.) Disregard of rank, age or sex- essentially applicable in crimes against person
and honor, not on crimes against property applicable in complex crime of
robbery with homicide because of homicide.
b.) Rank – deliberate intent to offend the rank, age or sex of the victim.
• Age may be old age or tender age
4. DWELLING
a.) The crime is committed in whole or in part in the dwelling or an integral part
thereof
b.) Used exclusively for dwelling purpose or living quarters, aggravating in rape,
shot inside the house, taken from the house and shot outside
NIGHTIME
BAND – more than 3 armed malefactors take part in the commission of the crime.
10. RECIDIVISM – increases the penalty by degrees. At the time of his trial for
one crime, he has been convicted by final judgement of another crime
embraced in the same title of the RPC.
11. HABITUAL DELIQUENCY- the offender has been previously punished for an
offense to which the law attaches an equal or greater penalty or for 2 or more
crimes to which it attaches a lighter penalty.
12. PRICE, REWARD OR PROMISE – it is sufficient that the offer made be the
principal inducement and accepted by the principal by direct participation and
the primary consideration for the commission of the crime.
DISGUISE- to make identification more difficult, such as use of mask, false hair or
beard, use of false name in libel.
MAY BE APPRECIATED:
18. IGNOMINY- adds disgraces and obligatory to the material injury cause by the
crime (People vs Acaya, GR No. 72998, July 22, 1933)
19. UNLAWFUL ENTRY - entrance by an opening or way not intended for the
purpose
Mitigating only in homicide and murder when the accused is ignorant and lived away
from civilized communities.
Theft, estafa or malicious mischief where the victim is the spouse, ascendants,
descendants, widow, brother or sister, or relatives by affinity in the same degree of
the accused. (Art. 332 RPC).
- In the imposition of sentence for crimes under the RPC, the court shall
sentence the accused to an Indeterminate Penalty. The maximum term of
which shall be that which, in view of the attending circumstance, could be
properly imposed under the rule of the Revised Penal Code, and the minimum
term of which shall be within the range of the penalty next lower to that provided
by the code for the offense without first considering any modifying
circumstances attendant to the commission of the crimes.
- The determination of the minimum penalty is left by law to the sound discretion
of the court and can be anywhere within the range of the penalty next lower in
degree without any reference to the periods into which it might be subdivided.
1. Death
2. Reclusion Perpetua- 20 years 1 day to 40 years
3. Reclusion Temporal- 12 years 1 day to 20 years
4. Prision Mayor – 6 years 1 day to 12 years
5. Prision Correctional
6. Arresto Mayor
7. Arresto Menor
8. Destierro
- In case of privileged mitigating circumstance of old age being over 70 years old,
or minority being below age 18 at the time of the commission of the crime, the
maximum of the Indeterminate Sentence is taken from the penalty next lower in
degree within the period applicable taking into consideration the presence of
mitigating aggravating circumstances.
- The Indeterminate Sentence law applies to SPECIAL PENAL LAWS where the
impossible penalty has minimum and maximum penalties for imprisonment.
- In complex crime, the maximum is the next lower penalty for the grave offence
in the period applicable on the mitigating and aggravating circumstances.
a. Death
b. Reclusion Perpetua
c. Reclusion Temporal
d. Prision Mayor
e. Prison Correctional
f. Arresto Mayor
g. Arresto Menor
h. Destierro
i. Perpetual Absolute Disqualification
j. Temporary Absolute Disqualificaion
k. Suspension from public office, the right to vote and be voted for, the right to
follow profession or calling
l. Public censure
3. Threefold Rule – the maximum shall not exceed more than threefold of the
most severe penalties, in no case exceeding 40 years. There must be 4 or
more sentence to be served.
4. For the purpose of the above rule – the duration of perpetual penalties shall
be computed at 30 years.
Transcribed By: Rosanie P. Remotin, JD
WESTERN MINDANAO STATE UNIVERSITY
ZAMBOANGA CITY
BESTBAREVER 2020_21_22
5. The threefold rule applies only to principal penalties and in all cases or on
different dates (People vs Geralde, 50 Phl 823)
A: His criminal liability and pecuniary liability arising from the crime are totally
extinguished by his death. Claims based on civil obligation other than crime
that may be independently prosecuted, such as obligation based on law,
contract, quasi-contract or quasi-delict must be pursued in an action against
the estate of the accused.
Q: What is the effect on the criminal and pecuniary liability if A dies after
judgement of conviction had become final?
A2: 1. By entering into marital union, the wife has granted the right of
consortium or sexual access to the husband, which she cannot refuse
without a valid excuse or reason.
2. If the wife is forced to have sexual intercourse against the will, the
crime may be grave coercion or malicious mischief if she is irritated by the
sexual act, but not rape because consent for sexual consortium was given
through matrimony.
READ:
b.) Estafa thru false pretenses or fraudulent acts- In estafa, the goods were
delivered. Juridical possession is transferred, which in robbery the goods
are taken with violence and intimidation and without the consent in theft.
a.) Race, ethnic origin, marital status, age, color and religious,
philosophical, or political affiliations.
b.) Individuals’ health, education, genetic or sexual life of a person, court
records or sentence of any court therein
c.) Social security members, health records, licenses or its denials
suspension or revocations and tax returns.
EXCEPTION:
1. To value the dignity of every human person and guarantee full respect to
human rights.
2. To recognize the role of woman in nation building and ensure the
fundamental equality before the law of man and women.
PUBLIC SPACE
- Streets and alleys, peaks, buildings, walls, bars, restaurants,
transportation terminals, public markets, evacuation centers,
government offices, public utilities and recreational spaces,
cinemas, theaters, spa.