Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Book Der Fru
Book Der Fru
HELMINTHOLOGY
DAVID I. GROVE
MD. FRACP, FRCPA, DTM&H
C.A.B INTERNATIONAL
C.A.B. International
Wallingford
Oxon OX10 8DE
UK
ISBN 0-86198-689-7
Preface vii
Acknowledgements viii
I am very grateful to the University of Western Australia for twelve months' sabbatical
leave during which time much of the basic research for this book was undertaken in the
United Kingdom. Special tribute must be paid to two key sources. The first is th e
magnificent Tropical Medicine and Parasitology: Classic Investigations edited by BH
Kean, KE Mott and AJ Russell (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, 1978) in whic h
translations of many of the most important original articles are brought together. The
second is the Tropical Diseases Bulletin in which the helminthological literature has
been abstracted since the early part o f this century. Thanks are due to Dr CR Morris for
providing a photograph of his grandfather, WH Ransom, to Dr John Walker fo r
obtaining a photograph of H Dew from the University of Sydney, and to Prof J
Bailenger for assistance in collecting biographical details of L Normand and C Bavay.
The photographic plates were expertly put together by Mr J Hadaway and Mr C
Hentschke. Publication of these plates has been made possible by a generous grant from
the Pathology Advisory Fund Committee of the Queen Elizabeth Hospital, Woodville,
South Australia. This book has been produced on a personal computer using Wor d
Perfect 5.1 (Word Perfect Corporation, Utah) and Glyphix (SWFTE International ,
Delaware). Finally, and most importantly, I must express my gratitude to my wife ,
Marilyn, and my children, Duncan, Graham, Br onwen and Lachlan, for the patience and
forbearance they have shown during the many hours that this book has taken to prepare.
Chapter 1
(1) Nematoda The worms are elongated and cylindroidal in shape with a basically
bilateral symmetrical arrangement. The integument consists of a non-nucleated cuticle
secreted by the underlying hypodermis. They have a pseudocoele (a body cavity which
is not lined with mesothelium), a complete gastrointestinal tract, and those that are
parasitic in humans are unisexual.
(2) Platyhelminthes These helminths are bilaterally symmetrical and are compressed
dorsoventrally to give a leaf-like or tape-like shape. The integument generally consists of
a syncitial cytoplasmic covering continuous with nucleated portions of the cytoplasm
situated in the parenchyma beneath the muscle layer. They lack a body cavity, with the
region between the internal organs being filled with spongy, mesenchymatous cells.
Flatworms of human importance fall into two classes:
a.Trematoda The worms are unsegmented and the adult forms are usually endowed with
suckers and an incomplete gut (one aperture only). They may be either unisexual or
1
2 A History of Human Helminthology
hermaphroditic.
b. Cestoda The adult worms are usually segmented with the body being divided
transversely into separate, sexually complete units called proglottids. The scolex (head)
is provided with suckers + hooks. They have no gut and are hermaphroditic.
(3) Acanthocephala The adult worms have a proboscis armed with hooks which is
retractile into a sheath. The elongated, more or less cylindroidal worms have an
integument that is perforated by canals, a large pseudocoele, no gastrointestinal tract and
are unisexual. Transmission occurs through an arthropod intermediate host.
(4) Nematomorpha These elongated, cylindroidal worms have a true body cavity, the
mouth and anus is frequently absent, and the pharynx is degenerate. They have no
excretory system and the sexes are separate. The adult forms are free-living in the soil
while the juvenile stages are parasitic in arthropods.
(5) Annelida These are bilaterally symmetrical, segmented creatures with a well-defined
gut, body cavity and excretory, vascular and nervous systems. Earthworms
(oligochaetes) and leeches (hirudines) are hermaphroditic, with the latter possessing
suckers.
and Several Species of Worms Macerating and Direfully Cruciating every part
of the Bodies of Mankind etc. which appears to be the first English textbook on
this subject. In his book, Ramsay dealt with worms and their origin, thei r
distribution within the human body, the effects of age and other factors o n
susceptibility to infection, the clinical features, the prognosis, treatment an d
methods of prevention of worm infections 35. Although used by some parasit -
ologists such Dujardin (Histoire naturelle des helminthes ou vers intestinaux ,
184517) and Diesing (Systema Helminthum, 1849-1851 16), the term was not us-
ually adopted in general pathological and medical texts until Requin (1852) in
his "Élémens de pathologie médicale " argued that the term "la maladi e
vermineuse" (wormy illness) was complex, clumsy and embarrassing, an d
championed the use of the word "helminthiasis", derived from a combination of
µ (HELMINTHIAN) meaning "to suffer from worms", and
(ASIS), to denote "the condition of" suffering from a worm infection 38. There
were, however, some opponents. Davaine (1877), for example, wrote that h e
did not believe that medical language gained in clarity or conciseness by th e
introduction of the expression 15. Nevertheless, the terms "helminth" an d
"helminthiasis" found favour with many subsequent authors and are no w
well-entrenched in the medical literature.
The Greek and Roman physicians of the M editerranean basin before and around
the time of Christ recognized two, sometimes three, worms as parasitizing the
human frame. All these worms were large and inhabited the gastrointestina l
tract, hence they were appreciated relatively easily. Thus, Celsus (c.30 BC-38
AD)12 and Pliny (23-79 AD) 11 spoke of tapeworms and roundworms, whereas
Hippocrates (c.460-374 BC) 22, Aristotle (384-c.322 BC) 4 and Galen (129-c.200
AD)19 were familiar with tapeworms ( Taenia species), round worms ( Ascaris
lumbricoides) and threadworms (Enterobius vermicularis ). Ascaris
lumbricoides was called in Greek µ (HELMINS
STRONGYLE), meaning "round worm", Enterobius vermicularis was termed
(ASKARIS, ASCARIS - there have been two transliterations, th e
former said to be closer to the original etymologically and the latte r
phonetically), and the tapeworm was known as µ (HELMINS
PLATEIA) meaning "flatworm" or, more rarely, a s (TAINIA, TAENIA)
meaning "band" or "ribbon worm".
The Romans and those who wrote in Latin translated the word µ
(HELMINS) by "lumbricus". They used this expression to encompass all th e
intestinal worms, and also earthworms which they believed were closel y
related. Thus, the word "lumbricus" was a group term analogous to a generi c
description and was modified by an adjective to indicate the type in the fol -
lowing manner: "lumbricus teres" ("teres" = "round, cylindrical") for Ascaris
4 A History of Human Helminthology
Table 1.1. Classification of worms infecting humans according to Linnaeus, 1758 33.
(Worms found rarely or not then recognized as being pathogenic for humans have been
omitted in Tables 1-14)
___________________________________________________________________
(frogs etc.), Pisces (fish), Insecta (arthropods and crustaceans) and Verme s
(other invertebrates). He then subdivided these classes into various orders, the
Class Vermes being partitioned into five orders (Table 1.1). There wer e
justifiable criticisms of his class ification. For example, George Louis Leclerc de
Buffon, a wealthy French count and keeper of the Jardin du Roi, wrote wit h
some acerbity that no-one could imagine that a mollusc was a worm or tha t
crayfish were insects. With the publication of the tenth edition of his work i n
1758 33 , Linnaeus introduced a major change in the manner of describin g
animals. He had derived his concepts of genus and species from Greek logic ,
and in the earlier editions of his Systema Naturae had used several lines o f
descriptive text to define and differentiate various species. In this edition ,
however, he limited the species designation to a single word in order to reduce
the expenses of publication. Thus, by a combination of force of circumstances
and Greek logic, binary nomenc lature was born. By 1758, he acknowledged six
species of worms, which were placed in two different orders, as being capable
of infecting humans (Table 1.1). The differentiation between Taenia solium and
Taenia lata (now known as Diphyllobothrium) was clearly established .
Fasciola hepatica, which he had at one time regarded as a leech, now found its
rightful place among the helminths, and Gordius medinensis (= Dracunculus
medinensis) was becoming accepted increasingly by various authorities as being
of a verminous nature.
In 1782, the German pastor, Johann Goeze (Göze) published a major work
on the natural history of worms inhabiting the bodies of animals entitle d
Versuch einer Naturgeschichte der Eingeweidewürmer thierischer Körper 21.
This book was written primarily for submission to the Royal Academy o f
Science in Copenhagen which had set in 1780 a prize essay on the subject o f
the origin of parasitic worms. Goeze argued for the spontaneous origin o f
helminths and received second prize. His work, however, is a major contribu-
tion to the helminthological literature, particularly from a systematic point o f
6 A History of Human Helminthology
view. Goeze did not follow the binary system of nomenclature and often used a
number of adjectives to describe each parasite. He divided worms into te n
genera: Ascaris, Trichocephalos, Gordius, Cucullanus, Strongylus, Pseudo-
echinorhynchus, Planaria, Fasciola, Taenia and Chaos. He recognized nine
species of worms as infecting the human body reasonably commonly (Tabl e
1.2). The additions to the worms described by Linnaeus were due to th e
differentiation of Taenia saginata from T. solium by Goeze, his appreciatio n
that hydatid cysts (Echinococcus granulosus ) were wormy in nature when he
found the characteristic taeniid heads within each cyst, and the discovery in
the interim by others of Trichuris, which Goeze renamed Trichocephalos
when he found that what had been identified previously as the tail was in fact
the head.
Between 1788 and 1793, JF Gmelin issued a revised version of Linnaeus' s
work which was published as the thirteenth edition of Systema Naturae 20.
Gmelin retained the basic format used by Linnaeus. The total number o f
parasitic species listed by Gmelin remained the same (Table 1.3), but th e
number of species which are recognized today fell by one. Gmelin failed t o
maintain Goeze's distinction between Taenia solium and Taenia saginata and
this separation fell into oblivion for another 60 years. On the other hand, h e
recognized correctly the helminthic nature of Cysticercus cellulosae , which he
called Taenia cellulosae. He was completely unaware, however, that this org-
anism was merely a stage in the life cycle of Taenia solium, and accorded it
separate specific status.
In 1798, G Cuvier in his Tableau élémentaire de l'histoire naturelle de s
animaux, produced a classification which divided worms into two groups - the
"cavitaires" and the "parenchymateux". Worms in the first group had a distinct-
ive digestive cavity with an anus. The second group lacked complete digestive
tubes: if there was a gut at all, it was incomplete with the anus being absent 14.
In 1800, the German naturalist, Johann Zeder, published what was purport-
Nomenclature and Classification 7
Table 1.4. Classification of worms infecting humans according to Zeder, 1800 43 and
180044
____________________________________________________________________
Rundwürmer Rundwürmer
Fusaria lumbricoides Fusaria lumbricoides Ascaris lumbricoides
Fusaria dispar Mastigodes hominis Trichuris trichiura
Fusaria vermicularis Enterobius vermicularis
Filaria medinensis Dracunculus medinensis
Hakenwürmer Hakenwürmer
Saugwürmer Saugwürmer
Distoma hepaticum Distoma hepaticum Distoma hepaticum
Bandwürmer Bandwürmer
Halysis solium Taenia solium
Halysis lata Diphyllobothrium latum
Blasenwürmer Blasenwürmer
Polycephalus hominis Polycephalus echinococcus Echinococcus granulosus
Cysticercus finna Taenia solium
(also C. pyriformis,
C. albopunctatus)
___________________________________________________________________
Soon afterwards, in 1849 and 1851, the German CM Diesing issued his two
volume Systema Helminthum totalling 1,267 pages16. Human helminths fell into
three orders, the Nematoidea, Myzelmintha and Cephalocotylea. The orde r
Myzelmintha included two suborders, the Cercariaea and Trematoda. Th e
Cercariaea contained many species of the genera Cercaria of Müller and Redia
of de Filippi which were later shown to be larval stages of adult worms placed
in the suborder Trematoda. In this book, another species of human importance,
Anchylostomum duodenale , was now listed (Table 1.8).
The labours of Goeze, Zeder, Rudolphi, Dujardin, Diesing and others ha d
expanded helminthology greatly, developing it into a specialized study of th e
metazoan parasites of the internal organs and structures of Man and animals. In
the process, however, the relationship between these worms and non-parasitic
animals was largely lost, for the parasitic helminths were generally considered
to be a separate and peculiar class of animals. There were opponents of thi s
view, such as CE von Baer and FS Leuckart, but this error was not correcte d
finally until the middle of the nineteenth century when Carl Vogt united th e
various groups of parasitic helminths with those of the free-living animals with
which they were closely relate d42. Thus, Vogt classified the parasitic nematodes
together with the free-living nematodes in the Nemathelminthes, and cas t
parasitic cestodes and trematodes with free-living flatworms such a s
turbellarians in the Platyhelminthes.
While this was satisfying for the zoologist, it was not particularly relevant to
the medical practitioner who was less interested in systematics and preferred to
consider the helminths as a biological group. With the appearance in 1855 of
Friedrich Küchenmeister's book Die in und an dem Körper des lebende n
Menschen vorkommenden Parasiten 28, medical helminthology leaves th e
12 A History of Human Helminthology
the world (Table 1.10). In addition, the parasites now known as Hymenolepis
diminuta and Dipylidium caninum were listed as infecting humans. Two new
nematodes and another trematode made their appearance in Davaine's text i n
187715 (Table 1.11). Strongyloides stercoralis was discovered in the pre-ceding
year, but it was not at first realized that the parasitic female worm and th e
first-stage larva were different stages in the life cycle of the same parasite, and
they were each given separate specific s tatus. Microfilariae had been discovered
a number of years earlier by Demarquay then had been identified in the blood
by Lewis in 1872, hence their designation as Filaria hominis sanguinis .
Although the adult worm had be en discovered in 1876 by Bancroft, news of the
find came too late to be incorporated into Davaine's book and his descriptio n
was based upon the microfilaria l stage. Fasciolopsis buski had been discovered
more than forty years before by Busk, but the finding of further cases in th e
1870's renewed interest in a previously obscure parasite.
By the appearance of Blanchard's two volume work in 1885-1890 8, the ident-
ity of Anguillula intestinalis and A. stercoralis had been determined an d
Nomenclature and Classification 15
Blanchard called the parasite Rhabdonema intestinale (Table 1.12). Two new
flukes of some importance had been discovered - Clonorchis sinensis by
McConnell and Paragonimus westermani in humans by Ringer and Manson .
Baelz had incorrectly divided the former parasite into two species and Blan -
chard perpetuated the error. Mention was also made of the parasite now called
Heterophyes heterophyes .
By 1906, when the English version of Braun's textbook was published 9,
several new nematodes had been described (Table 1.13). Manson had reported
in 1893 a portion of Leuckart's description of Onchocerca volvulus from
specimens sent to him from West Africa by a missionary, and Stiles had diff -
erentiated Necator americanus from Ancylostoma duodenale . In addition, two
new filarial parasites, Filaria ozzardi and Filaria perstans had been
discovered. Similarly, major fin ds had been made with the trematodes. Katsur-
16 A History of Human Helminthology
It is clear from the foregoing discussion that many different names were often
used to describe the same worm. This led to chaos and confusion and inhib-
ited the flow of ideas and the generation of new discoveries, for unles s
everyone possessed a common language, there was considerable uncertainty
Nomenclature and Classification 17
Table 1.15. Classification of worms according to Beaver, Jung and Cupp, 1984 6.
____________________________________________________________________
as to what other writers were saying. This problem applied not just to medical
helminthology, but was even more germane to zoologists who had to deal with
more than a million animal species.
In an attempt to produce uniformity and order, the Frenchman, Raphae l
Blanchard, presented a Code to the First International Zoological Congress in
Paris in 1889. This code was adopted by that and the subsequent Congress in
1892 but failed to receive universal support. The Third Congress in 189 5
appointed an international commission to develop a code which would be ac-
18 A History of Human Helminthology
ceptable to all zoologists. Progress reports were delivered at the Fourth (1898)
and Fifth (1901) Congresses. At the Sixth Congress in 1904, the International
Code of Zoological Nomenclature was p resented and the commission was made
permanent.
The code consisted of 36 articles supplemented with various recommend -
ations including a code of ethics and conditions for the suspension of the rules
in certain cases. The naming of animals was based upon the binary system o f
nomenclature. Article 26 provided the foundation stone upon which the whole
edifice was erected for this statement confirmed that the starting point for such
an arrangement began with the publication in 1758 of the tenth edition o f
Linnaeus's Systema Naturae. The 36 basic articles which were adopted ar e
reproduced in Table 1.16.
In addition to these articles, a code of ethics was laid down in which it wa s
suggested that when an author published a name of a new genus or specie s
which was preoccupied, the person discovering the error should inform th e
author and give him ample opportunity to propose a new name. Furthermore,
a procedure was devised whereby the rules could be suspended in certai n
cases. The circumstance in which this could arise would be when the com -
mission judged that a strict application of the rules would result in greate r
confusion than uniformity. In such cases, notice of at least one year had to b e
given in two or more of the following publications: Bulletin de la Société
Zoologique de France, Monitore Zoologica, Nature, Science, or Zoologischer
Anzeiger in order to allow debate. If the vote of the commission was no t
unanimous, then the matter would be referred to the next Internationa l
Congress which would appoint a special boar d of three members to make a final
decision.
The accumulation of knowledge over the years has in many instances necess-
itated the splitting of a species or the subdivision of a genus. An example of the
former is the differentiation of the Taenia solium and Taenia saginata. In like
manner, the genus Distoma of Retzius 1790 has been subdivided into man y
genera including Clonorchis, Fasciolopsis, Paragonimus and Schistosoma. On
some occasions, a name has been applied which had already been used fo r
another member of the animal kingdom. Thus, Trichina spiralis of Owen 1835
was changed to Trichinella spiralis by Railliet in 1895 when it was realized that
the generic name had already b een used for an insect. This is an example where
a name is a homonym, i.e. where the same name has been applied to two o r
more different animals. This contra sts with synonyms which are different names
used for the same animal.
All these eventualities were covered in the rules, but the article which gave
rise to the greatest dissent and concern, particularly in the medical sphere, was
Article 25 which described the law of priority. This law required that the valid
name of a genus or species was the name under which it was first described ,
provided the principles of binary nomenclature were followed and the nam e
was accompanied by an indication, definition or description of the organism .
Nomenclature and Classification 19
the consistent general application of the binary nomenclature in zoology. The date 1758, therefore,
is accepted as the starting point of zoological nomenclature and of the law of priority.
"Article 27 - The law of priority obtains and consequently the oldest available name is retained:
"(a) When any part of an animal is named before the animal itself;
"(b) When the larva is named before the adult;
"(c) When the two sexes of an animal have been considered as distinct species or even as
belonging to distinct genera;
"(d) When an animal represents a regular succession of dissimilar generations which have been
considered as belonging to different species or even to different genera.
"Article 28 - A genus formed by the union of two or more genera or subgenera takes the oldest
valid generic or subgeneric name of its components. If the names are of the same date, that selected
by the first reviser shall stand.
"The same rule obtained when two or more species or subspecies are united to form a single
species or subspecies.
"Article 29 - If a genus is divided into two or more restricted genera, its valid name must be
retained for one of the restricted genera.
"If a type was originally established for said genus, the generic name is retained for the restricted
genus containing said type.
"Article 30 - The designation of type species of genera shall be governed by the following rules
(a to g), applied in the following order of precedence:
"I. Cases in which the generic type is accepted solely upon the basis of the original publication:
"(a) When in the original publication of a genus, one of the species is definitely designated as a
type, this species shall be accepted as type, regardless of any other considerations. (Type by original
designation.)
"(b) If in the original publication of a genus, typicus or typus is used as a new specific name for
one of the species, such use shall be construed as 'type by original designation.'
"(c) A genus proposed with a single original species takes that species as its type. (Monotypical
genera.)
"(d) If a genus, without originally designated (see a) or indicated (see b) type, contains among
its original species one possessing the generic name as its specific or subspecific name, either as
valid name or synonym, that species or subspecies becomes ipso facto type of the genus. (Type by
absolute tautonymy.)
"II. Cases in which the generic type is accepted not solely upon basis of original publication:
"(e) The following species are excluded in determining the types of genera.
"Species which were not included under the generic name at the time of its original publication.
"Species which were species inquirendae from the standpoint of the author of the generic name
at the time of its publication.
"Species which the author of the genus doubtfully referred to it.
"(f) In case a generic name without originally designated type is proposed as substitute for another
generic name, with or without type, the type of either, when established, becomes ipso facto the type
of the other.
"(g) If an author, in publishing a genus with more than one valid species, fails to designate (see
a) or to indicate (see b, d) its type, any subsequent author may select the type, and such designation
is not subject to change.
(Type by subsequent designation.)
"The meaning of the expression 'select the type' is to be rigidly construed. Mention of a species
as an illustration or example of a genus does not constitute a selection of a type.
"Article 31 - The division of a species into two or more restricted species is subject to the same
rules as the division of a genus. But a specific name which undoubtedly rests upon an error of
identification cannot be retained for the misdetermined species even if the species in question are
afterward placed in different genera. Example: Taenia pectinata Goeze, 1782 = Cittotaenia
pectinata (Goeze), but the species erroneously determined by Zeder, 1800, as Taenia ' pectinata
Goeze' = Andrya rhopalocephala (Riehm); the latter species does not take the name Andrya
pectinata (Zeder).
22 A History of Human Helminthology
"Article 32 - A generic or a specific name, once published, cannot be rejected even by its author,
because of inappropriateness. Example: Names like Polyodon, Apus, albus, etc., when once
published, are not to be rejected because of a claim that they indicatecharacters contradictory to
those possessed by the animals in question.
"Article 33 - A name is not to be rejected because of tautonymy, that is, because the specific or
the specific and subspecific names are identical with he generic name. Examples:Trutta trutta,
Apus apus.
"Article 34 - A generic name is to be rejected as a homonym when it has previously been used
for some other genus of animals. Example: Trichina Owen, 1835, nematode, is rejected as
homonym of Trichina Meigen, 1830, insect.
"Article 35 - A specific name is to rejected as a homonym when it has previously been used for
some other species of the same genus. Example: Taenia ovilla Rivolta, 1878 (n. sp.) is rejected as
homonym of T. ovilla Gmelin, 1790.
"When in consequence of the union of two genera, two different animals having the same specific
or subspecific name are brought into one genus, the more recent specific or subspecific name is to
be rejected as a homonym.
"Specific names of the same origin and meaning shall be considered homonyms if they are
distinguished from each other only by the following differences:
"(a) The use of ae, oe and e, as coeruleus, cereleus; ei, i and y as chiropus, cheiropus; c and
k as microdon, mikrodon.
"(b) The aspiration or non-aspiration of a consonant, asoxyryncus, oxyrhynchus.
"(c) The presence or absence of a c before t, as autumnalis, auctumnalis.
"(d) By a single or double consonant, litoralis, littoralis.
"(e) By the ending ensis and iensis to a geographical name, as timorensis, timoriensis.
"Article 36 - Rejected homonymscan never be again used. Rejected synonyms can again be used
in case of the restoration of erroneously suppressed groups. Example: Taenia Giardi Moniez, 1879,
was suppressed as a synonym of Taenia ovilla Rivolta, 1878; later it was discovered that Taenia
ovilla was preoccupied (Taenia ovilla Gmelin, 1790). Taenia ovilla, 1878, is suppressed as a
homonym and can never again be used, it was still-born and cannot be brough to life, even when the
species is placed in another genus (Thysanosoma). Taenia Giardi, 1879, which was suppressed as
a synonym, becomes valid upon the suppression of the homonymTaenia ovilla Rivolta.
____________________________________________________________________
This applied whether or not a particular name was in common or popular use.
Thus, Bilharzia haematobia, a name which had been used for decades to des-
ignate the worm discovered by Bilharz, had to be altered to Schistosoma
haematobium because the latter name was given to the parasite several months
before Cobbold published his designation. Such occurrences led the British
Medical Journal in an editorial in 1926 to complain tha t
"archaeoparasitologists" or:
assiduous individuals have spent their days and nights ransacking musty archives and
long-forgotten tombs. From these they have extracted a galaxy of paradoxically new
yet old names which they have tacked on to the familiar names of our youth. 1
Nevertheless, such changes were essential if the rules were to produce th e
uniformity and stability for which they were designed. A major difficulty ,
however, lay in knowing who real ly said what about which worm. Not only was
much of the literature inaccessible or unavailable, but there was ofte n
Nomenclature and Classification 23
fear, however, that Professor Leiper's pl ea will bring him neither tranquillity nor
peace"2. It ought to be added in parenthesis, moreover, that Leiper himself was
no saint in these matters, for he sought to use the rules to his own advantag e
when he attempted (unsuccessfully) to rename Dracunculus medinensis as
Fuellebornius medinensis 30.
Nevertheless, comments such as these did have one solid effect. In order to
leave no room for uncertainty as to the features of an organism being newl y
named, the International Zoological Congress which met in Budapest in 1927
added a new section (c) to the law of priority, article 25:
(c) But no generic name nor specific name, published after December 31, 1930, shall
have any status of availability (hence also of validity) under the Rules, unless and until
it is published either
1. with a summary of characters (seu diagnosis; seu definition; seu condensed
description) which differentiate or distinguish the genus from other genera or
species.
2. or with a definite bibliographic reference to such summary of characters (seu
diagnosis; seu definition; seu condensed description). And further
3. In the case of a generic name, with the definite unambiguous designation of the type
species (seu genotype; seu autogenotype; seu orthotype). (Cited in 18).
One major change in medical te rminology occurred subsequently, not under the
auspices of the International Commission on Zoological Nomenclature, but as
an opinion of the committee on terminology of the American Society o f
Parasitologists when it reported in December 1940 that:
It was of the opinion of the Committee that under the International Rules of
Zoological Nomenclature Trichuris rather than Trichocephalus is the valid generic
name.37
The committee also indicated that it felt that Dioctophyma renale was the
correct name for the giant kidney worm which infects humans very rarely.
In July 1958, the XV International Congress of Zoology adopted a new ,
complete official transcript of the International Code of Zoological Nomen -
clature. This was published in London in 1961 with alternate pages set i n
French and English and has set the seal on the nomenclature of animals 27.
PARASITISM
Another word in need of definition is the term "parasite". This word was derived
from the Greek word (PARASITOS) which means literally "on e
who eats at the table of another" and was formed by a combination of
(PARA) = "besides" and (SITOS) = "food". Küchenmeister in 185 5
defined parasites in the following manner:
Parasites are independent organised beings, descended from peculiar animal or
vegetable parents, which require, in order that they may be enabled to complete their
development, growth, or reproduction, to take up their abode either constantly or
temporarily in or upon a second animal or vegetable organism of a different kind, from
which they also derive their nourishment. Human parasites are those which select the
Nomenclature and Classification 25
The word "infest" has sometimes been used instead of "infect" to denote th e
presence of worms in a host. "Infect" and "infection" are derived from the Latin
word "infectus", the past participle of "inficere" meaning "to dip in", "put into",
"taint" or "stain". Its use long antedated the knowledge of pathogeni c
microorganisms and implied tainting with morbid matter, or contamination with
noxious effluvia, vapours and miasmata. Thus, there was a connotation o f
trouble caused by invisible, internal agents. "Infest" and "infestation" on th e
other hand, are derived from the Latin word "infestus", the past participle o f
"infestare", meaning "to make hostile, unsafe, disturbed or troublesome", an d
referred to obvious external agents such as pirates, thieves, rats and fleas which
molested or harassed the victim. These ideas were embodied in Dr. Samue l
Johnson's Dictionary of 1785 whic h defined infect as to "act upon by contagion;
to taint; to poison; to pollute" while to infest was "to harass; to disturb; t o
plague". The same concepts are enjoined in the modern Oxford Englis h
Dictionary which gives the meaning of infect as "to affect (a person, animal or
part of a body) with disease" while to infest is "to trouble (a country or place)
with hostile attacks....said of persons (e.g . robbers, pirate), animals (e.g. wolves,
vermin, insects), diseases or other evils".
Nevertheless, as pathological processes due to organisms capable o f
independent multiplication within the host such as bacteria, protozoa, fungi
and viruses became increasingly recognized, there was an attempt to limit the
term infection to such organisms, while infestation was proposed for thos e
organisms which do not (or usually do not) multiply within the host such a s
helminths and insects. Further, the argument was expressed that intestina l
worms are not truly within the body, though this idea has never been used t o
assert that non-invasive gastrointestinal bacterial infections should be calle d
infestations.
In view of this confusion, the American Society of Parasitology in 193 3
appointed a committee to investigate the matter. They concluded:
We believe that 'infest' and 'infestation' ought to revert to their original use in
connection with external, and in most cases, visible agents. There would be retained
the long established use of these terms in connection with most insects in speaking of
such conditions as dogs "infested" with fleas, "infestations" of mosquitoes and the like.
On the other hand, we believe the terms 'infect' and 'infection' are properly applicable
wherever the parasite invades and establishes itself within the body of the host,
including in this sense, the gastro-intestinal tract. This would apply then, not only to
bacteria and protozoa, but also to helminths....We fail to see any reason for continuing
the use of the term 'infestation' as applied to internal parasites and believe that the
present confusion will disappear only as its use be discontinued. 36
This view was supported in 1960 by an editorial in the British Medical Journal
which remarked that "Consistency and common sense would therefore seem to
favour the use of the word infection for intestinal helminths." 3 This concept has
largely held sway and most technical works now refer to helminth infection s
Nomenclature and Classification 27
REFERENCES
The finding of worms within the bodies of humans and animals inevitably led
to questions concerning how those so afflicted became infected. For much o f
recorded history, the most comfortable and gen erally accepted explanation given
was that the parasites had arisen by a process of spontaneous generation. This
was a theory not easily denied, and a critical battle raged for over a century and
a half from the late seventeenth century until near the middle of the nineteenth
century before the protagonists of this theory were finally silenced. There were
two key factors which determined the outcome of this conflict of opinion. The
first was the invention of the microscope which allowed discovery of th e
presence of ova and spermatozoa and demonstration of the cellular basis o f
animals, including helminths. As will be shown, this was not enough t o
persuade many students of the subject, and the argument was only settled when
the second factor, experiment, was introdu ced into helminthology. Nevertheless,
even after it was agreed that wor ms multiplied by sexual and asexual processes,
many years often elapsed before the precise details of the mode of transmission
of a particular parasite were defined.
How and when these various discoveries were m ade are recounted for specific
worms in the various chapters that follow. In particular, the events leading to the
demonstration of the phenomenon of alternation of generations in trematodes are
reviewed in chapter 4 while the controversy that led to the recognition of th e
relationship between cystic w orms and tapeworms is covered in chapter 12. the
present chapter attempts to provide the historical sequence in which thes e
disparate threads unfolded and the interpretations which they engendered in the
minds of helminthologists.
Belief in the spontaneous generation of certain plants and animals goes back to
ancient times and probably began when man started to speculate on the origins
of life. This process of "spontaneous generation", sometimes known a s
"equivocal generation" or, more latterly, "abiogenesis" provided the simples t
and most obvious explanation for many puzzling observations. How else could
the sudden appearance of mus hrooms after a heavy rain or the plague of locusts
or rodents in certain seasons be explained? As has been described in th e
29
30 A History of Human Helminthology
These beliefs persisted into the Middle Ages and the Renaissance. Th e
Arabians of the Dark and Middle Ages provided the prime link between th e
literature of the past and the Renaissance in Europe. Avicenna (Ibn Sina )
(980-1037) was convinced that intestinal worms arose from the intestina l
contents in combination with moisture and various other factors:
There are four kinds of worms....They are different because of different origin and
surrounding. Some are formed from moisture not divided or broken up by attraction
of the liver, or excess of fermentation. Others are formed from moisture divided or
broken up by the attraction of the liver and fermentation....Thirdly, some are formed
by an intermediate condition.8
Moreover, Avicenna even believed that with a proper mixing of the element s
and under the influence of the stars, all animal s and even man could be produced
by spontaneous generation. Another Arab, Al-Qaz wini (died 1283), propounded
a novel explanation for the existence of these worms. He suggested that divine
wisdom determined that parasites should take their origin from putrefyin g
substances so that they could absorb them as food and hence purify the air and
prevent epidemic diseases 3.
These concepts were accepted by a number of European writers of the Middle
Ages such as Albertus Magnus (Albert von Baellstaedt, c.1193-1280) 9,
Villanovanus (Arnauld de Villeneuve, c.1300) 198, Edward Wotton
(1492-1555) 207 and Cardanus of Pavia (1501-1576)33 . Thus, Villanovanus
considered that there were four kinds of worms: long, round worms bred from
"salt Fleghm"; short, round worms in "sharp Fleghm"; long, broad worms i n
"sweet Fleghm"; and short, broad worms in "natural Fleghm or Mucus" 198.
Cardanus believed that slow putrefaction produced lower animals such a s
worms while rapid putrefaction resulted in higher animals such as birds 33. This
belief in the influence of temperature was taken up by other writers such a s
Gabucinus (1547) who wrote that the lower temperature of the intestine led to
the formation of tapeworms 63, while Mercurialis (1623) claimed that different
temperatures influenced the formation of small and large intestinal worms 130.
Paracelsus (1493-1541) had similar fantastic ideas:
many things will be changed in putrefaction so that they give birth to a noble fruit,
because putrefaction is a reversal and death of all things and a destruction of the
original character of all natural things. From this comes rebirth and a new birth with
thousandfold improvement.160
Thus, Paracelsus considered that worms were produced from "sperma" an d
putrefaction, a bird could be recreated from its own ashes in horse manure ,
while a pigmy could be similarly produced fro m putrefied human sperm if it was
kept under the correct conditions. Likewise, Ambroise Paré, one of the fathers
of modern surgery, believed that intestinal worms were created by spontaneous
generation in decomposing humours:
The worms are formed by a thick, sticky and crude material which decomposes in the
stomach and then descends into the intestines....On account of its stickiness which
makes it adherent to the intestines, it cannot be discharged from the abdomen. Being
retained, it undergoes still further putrefaction wherefrom worms are produced and
32 A History of Human Helminthology
Bordeu) and "Lebenskraft" (F riedrich Casimir Medicus). The way in which this
invisible and imperceptible vital principle was supposed to act was described
differently by the various schools of philosophy. In general, however, it wa s
believed that the vital force either created living creatures directly out of its own
metaphysical properties or it generated them by its action upon primordia l
matter.
Not everyone was happy with such ideas, however. Thus, Sir Thoma s
Browne (1645) questioned "whether mice may be bred by putrefaction?" 27
Browne, however, only refuted error with error, or at least with opinions that
seemed more reasonable than did the original ones. It was around this period
that the doctrine of "preformation" was evolved. The central thesis of pre-
formation was that the act of procreation merely permitted the appearance
in an organized and formed state of a being that was already pre-existent .
The theory first appeared in the scientific literature in Swammerdam's book
on insects in 1669189, then the theme was taken up by others. Marcell o
Malpighi, for example, believed that he could discern the form of an embryo
in an unincubated egg126,127. This led to the supposition that a complete being
lay in an egg and only a suitable stimulus was required to cause it to unfold.
This view extended to the concept of "emboitement" or "syngenesis" i n
which it was held that the being in the egg held, in its own ovaries, egg s
which in turn held secondary ova and so on. Thus, Eve was considered to
contain within her gonads the forms of all the men and women that wer e
ever to be. Thus, de Malebranche in 1673, in propounding his "principle of
plenitude" wrote:
all the bodies of men and beasts, which shall be born or produced till the end of the
world, were possibly created from the beginning of it. 125
This concept of preformation was then applied to the origin of worms, but this
led to all sorts of philosophical and theological difficulties, particularly in th e
first half of the eighteenth century, as will be described later.
It was at this stage that two events of epochal importance occurred: (1) Redi
began to experiment on the origin of invertebrate animals and (2) th e
microscope was invented then its use in microbiology popularized b y
Leeuwenhoek. Both of these fac tors were ultimately to have immense effects on
the acceptance of the theory of spontaneous generation.
Francisco Redi, court physician to the Duke of Tuscany, published in 1668 his
monumental work, Esperienze intorno alla generazione degl'insett i
(Experiments on the generation of insects )169. Redi could not accept the view
that "worms" were produced in dead animals or plants but postulated that they
were generated by insemination in putrefying matter, the latter merely serving
34 A History of Human Helminthology
as a suitable nest in which animals could deposit their eggs and in which th e
resultant offspring could find nourishment. In contrast to his predecessors ,
however, Redi undertook a large number of experiments in order to test thi s
view. First, he killed three snakes and placed them in an open box to decay .
Soon afterwards, he found that they were covered with maggots (which he called
worms). Once all the meat had been consumed, however, the maggot s
disappeared. In order to determine what had become of them, he repeated the
experiment but, on this occasion, he covered ev ery exit from the box. He noticed
that some of the worms became quiet, appeared to shrink and assumed a shape
similar to an egg. Furthermore, he recognized that there was a variety of shapes
amongst these pupae, so he separated them into different glass container s
covered with paper. After a week or so, the shells of the eggs (pupae) broke and
flies came forth, the same kind of fly appearing from the same type of pupa .
Thereupon, he repeated the experiments on many occasions with various kind
of dead animals, and in every case the result was the same with one or othe r
kind of fly developing, sometimes all k inds. Moreover, he also observed that the
meats became covered with true eggs fr om which the maggots hatched. This led
him to the conclusion:
Having considered these things, I began to believe that all worms found in meat were
derived directly from the droppings of flies, and not from the putrefactions of meat. 169
This seemed especially likely as flies of the same kind as those that were bred
had hovered over the meat before it grew maggotty. Nevertheless, compare d
with other observers, Redi made a crucial step, remarking "Belief would be vain
without the confirmation of experiment" 169. Thereupon, he put a snake, som e
fish, some eels and a slice of veal from a m ilk-fed cow, each into separate, large,
wide-mouthed flasks. Each flask was carefully sealed, then a duplicate serie s
was set up except that the mouth of each vessel was left open to the atmosphere.
He watched and found that no maggots developed in the closed flasks whereas
flies entered and left the open containers at will and maggots eventuall y
appeared. Redi repeated these experiments on many occasions. He not onl y
showed that maggots were not bred spontaneously from meat, but traced th e
development of eggs through larval and pupal sta ges to adulthood. Nevertheless,
it must be conceded that Redi was led astray in his studies of the appearance of
larvae in galls on plants. He began with the same hypothesis as he had proven
with flies on meat, but was unable to demonstrate any way in which eggs could
enter a plant. This led him back to an acceptance of spontaneous generation for
these creatures:
Hence I have changed my opinion and I think it probable that the generation of worms
in trees does not....proceed from the eggs deposited by flies. 169
Redi believed that the principle which created the flowers and fruit in the first
place was the same as that which produced the grubs:
the efficient cause resided in the peculiar potency of that kind of soil or principle which
creates the flowers and fruits of living plants, and is the same that produces the worms
of these plants.169
Origin and Migration of Worms 35
Moreover, Redi thought that worms found in the intestines and other parts o f
humans probably arose in an analogous fashion by spontaneous generatio n
through the agency of the same vital force:
In this same manner it could perhaps be true, and I feel disposed to believe it, that in
the intestines and other parts of man, are born the lumbricoids and flesh worms. 169
Thus, Redi showed clearly that some parasites arose from ova, but concede d
that other parasites may arise by a process akin to spontaneous generation.
Redi's experiments were soon followed by publication of the observations of
the Dutchman, Jan Swammerdam. In 1669, he published his Algemeene
verhandeling von bloedloose diertjens (General account of bloodless ani -
malculae) which dealt with the modes of transformation of insects and high -
lighted the different manner of development of the various types of insects. He
also showed that the pupa was not an egg but a stage in development of the life
cycle of a single individual. He demonstrated clearly, for example, that lic e
developed from eggs, that insects found in various plant galls resulted from eggs
laid by certain flies, and he noted that certain parasitic "worms" sometime s
found in caterpillars or butterflies were the offspring of other insect s
(Ichneumon flies) that were in the habit of laying their eggs beneath the skin of
the caterpillars 189. The experiments and observations of these two pioneers were
to prove turning points in the understanding of the origin of "lesser animals", as
they were commonly known at that time.
The Englishman, Edward Tyson, writing in 1683, was well aware of th e
studies of Redi and others, which he described as indicating "univoca l
generation", i.e. natural generation from the same type of organism:
The consideration of Insects, and their manner of generation, as it is a subject of
curious speculation; so of late hath been much illustrated by the laborious researches
of many inquisitive persons: whose travels therein, tho' they have much advanced the
doctrine of univocal generation; and bid very fair the exploding of that, too easily
received, and common error, of their production from, putrefaction. 194
Tyson demonstrated the sexual apparatus o f roundworms (Ascaris lumbricoides
which he called Lumbricus teres) by dissection and believed that once present
in the gut, these worms reproduced sexually:
yet once there, there is nothing more plain, than that the Lumbricus Teres propogated
by univocal Generation; there being in this Sort so perfect a Distinction of Sexes,
Male and Female.195
Tyson had greater trouble with tapeworms. He studied in detail their anatomy,
discovering their head, but he could find no evidence of two sexes. Moreover,
he could not conceive how these organs could have had their origins fro m
outside of the body for they resembled nothing in the external world:
yet one great difficulty still remains with me, how to account for several of those, that
are bred in Animal bodies not such as we may suppose to be hatched from the eggs of
the like kind, that are received with food or in other ways; but with whom we cannot
meet with a parallel, or of the same Species, out of the body, in the whole world as is
known besides.194
This problem was so insuperable for Tyson that he ended the title of his paper
36 A History of Human Helminthology
with the words "and the whole urged, as a difficulty against the doctrine o f
univocal generation" 194.
Meanwhile, the invention of the microscope had opened up a new world of
microorganisms. Furthermore, this technology was essential for the demon -
stration of ova and spermatozoa, the manner in which new life was produced,
and the ways in which animal tissues were organized. These new vistas wer e
ultimately to sound the death knell for the theory of spontaneous generation. It
is difficult to assign proper credit for the invention of this instrument. The art of
making convex and concave lenses had long been learnt, but the use of suc h
lenses in microscopes first took place around the end of the sixteenth or th e
beginning of the seventeenth century. It is not known with certainty wh o
invented the compound microscope, but Harting 72 concluded that the accolade
probably belongs to the Dutchman, Cornelius Drebbel of Almaar, or hi s
countrymen, Hans and Zacharias Janssens of Middleburg.
Little heed was paid at first to this innovation but it began to be used by a
number of scientists including the Englishmen, Robert Hooke (1653-1703) and
Nehemiah Grew (1641-1712), the Dutchman, Swammerdam, and the Italian,
Marcello Malpighi (1628-1694). Most of these workers concentrated o n
microscopical aspects of macroscopic plants and animals, however, and the real
discoverer of the invisible world of microscopical living creatures was th e
Dutch microscopist, Antony van Leeuwenhoek (1632-1723). Leeuwenhoe k
made his own microscopes and improved upon their optics. In 1673, he pub-
lished his first paper, in the Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society ,
which dealt with mould, the morphology of the eye of the bee, and the micro-
scopical appearances of lice. Over th e next fifty years, Leeuwenhoek sent letters
to the Royal Society covering an eno rmous field of observations on microscopic
biological matters101. Not only did he describe in abundance the group o f
unicellular organisms now known as protozoa, but he was the first to visualize
bacteria, a feat which was not repeated until improvements in microscope s
made it possible for others to see them. Thomas Huxley suggested many years
later that this demonstration of the abundance of microorganisms with thei r
manifest provision for multiplication made it seem to many observers that the
doctrine of spontaneous generation was not only untrue but also absurd 80.
Leeuwenhoek himself was a preformationist and a firm opponent of the theory
of spontaneous generation. Being aware of the general belief that Fasciola
infection was acquired by animals feeding on contaminated pastures, h e
examined green sods from a meadow on which some infected sheep had fed and
looked for microscopical creatures resembling flukes, but failed to find any 100.
Nevertheless, observations that many o f the innumerable small organisms found
in water and moist soil resembled helminths led naturally to the conjecture by
many helminthologists that, after their almost unavoidable introduction in th e
human system, these creatures would grow into parasitic worms. The evolution
of such ideas, both correctly and in error, will be traced in the followin g
sections.
Origin and Migration of Worms 37
As the century drew to a close, there were still many staunch believers in the
theory of spontaneous generation. But the o pponents were becoming more vocal
and were exemplified by Bidloo, who, no doubt girded by his discovery of eggs
in Fasciola, in 1698 laid it:
down as a certain truth, that these, as well as other small living creatures, are produced
from their like, by the means of eggs, seed or spawn, according to the nature implanted
in them at their first creation.16
and considered that these "seeds" were ingested in contaminated water.
spontaneous generation:
Some Philosophers, pretend that the worms and several other Insects are bred of
Corruption, only by a Fortuitous Combination of Matter without any seed. But if these
Philosophers could explain to me two things, the one how casual disorder could range
with so much order the Organical parts of Animals, and the other, from whence it
comes that we see no new Species of Insect bred, since that must happen according
to their System.5
In order to support his arguments, Andry included quotations from two of his
correspondents. On 26 February 1699, Mr Niklaas Hartsoeker of Amsterdam
had written to him:
There's nothing has life, be it Animal or Plant, but which comes from Seed, and
nothing is ever engendered by corruption....I am of the opinion that those Worms
ingender by Male and Female in the Bowels, and that some of their coming to issue
with the Excrements, and to fal l upon some Herb or other thing, are swallowed
by another, in whose Intreals the Worms contain'd in those Eggs come forth and are
fed.73
In like manner, Giorgio Baglivi in Rome wrote on 14 July of the same year:
You ask me 1. If it proceeds from an Egg?....The beginning and original of all Animals
and Vegetables is from an Egg....Since no Man says that Plants rise from Putrefaction,
they ought not in reason to deduce the Original of Insects and other baser Animals
from thence.... Worms Eggs lying hid in the Intestines are enliven'd and
brought forth.... Therefore the Flat Worm derives its Original from an Egg of its own
kind.11
Clericus (1721) accepted the views of Redi , Andry and those of like mind, but
considered that "The most difficu lt Question remains yet to be discussed, to wit,
From whence the first Seed of Worms is derived" 37.
Not everyone was convinced by these arguments, however. Vallisnerius, for
example, vigorously opposed the views of Andry and endeavoured to explain
the presence of entozoa by supposing them to be transmitted from parent t o
child via the placenta or through the breast milk 197. Vallisnerius was in fact a
proponent of "emboitement" which was mentioned earlier. A logical extension
of this theory was that Adam, the first man, harboured not only all mankind to
be, but all of his worms as well. This created appalling theological problem s
and Vallisnerius put the issues:
It is not reasonable to suppose that God would have placed the first worm in his body,
forasmuch as Man in this state of innocence was to be free of all kinds of
diseases....But if on the other hand, after the lapsed state of Adam, we allow that
worms were formed by God.... a greater difficulty will arise....for....it will follow that
God made a new creation of worms, which is contrary to Holy Writ; since God hath
taught us, that before Man was made, all other animals were created. 197
Vallisnerius attempted to solve this dilemma by assuming that before the Fall,
parasitic worms ate contentedly from Adam's superfluities and even performed
good works by gently licking any holes in the gut and healing them. But when
Adam fell:
all things were suddenly changed; so that these worms were made Ministers of Divine
justice and raised an insurrection upon him.197
Origin and Migration of Worms 39
The advocates of the theory of sponta neous generation received staunch support
as the eighteenth century entered its second half from the writings of Georges
Leclerc, Comte de Buffon (17017-1788) and John Turbeville Needha m
(1713-1781). In 1749, Buffon's monumental Histoire Naturelle began to appear
in France30. In this work, Buffon developed the idea that vitality was a n
indestructible property of all living things. He regarded living matter as being
composed of indestructible organic molecules which, in the process o f
spontaneous generation, were rearranged to constitute vitality:
excess molecules, unable to penetrate the interior mould of the animal, reunite with
several particles of brute matter in the food and form organized bodies....This is the
origin of tapeworms, ascarides, flukes and all other worms which are born in the liver,
stomach and intestines.30
Similar views were expressed by Needham in Britain. Needham undertoo k
some experiments which he interpreted as supporting these concepts. Fo r
example, he took a portion of an almond germ and placed it in water in a phial
closed with cork; subsequently, he claimed to see a swarm of minute, moving
objects of "animalcules" which he believed came from the almond. Needha m
repeated the experiment with hot mutton gravy which, despite being sealed ,
swarmed with life a few days later. Similar results were obtained in othe r
experiments and Needham concluded that the organisms derived from a
"vegetative force in every microscopic po int of matter and every visible filament
of which the whole animal or vegetable texture consists" 146.
The views of Buffon and Needham were attacked by the Italian abbott ,
Lazzarro Spallanzani (1729-1799) who undertook numerous, well-conceived
experiments which included heating infusions as well as hermetically-sealin g
them. He concluded that animalcules may be carried into the infusions by the air
and that this was the explanation of their supposed spontaneous generation 184.
Moreover, Spallanzani found that there were two distinct classes of thes e
microscopical creatures, or "infusoria". One, which he called ordini superior i
(superior order), was easily destroyed by boiling for half a minute, whereas the
other, which was exceedingly minute microscopically and which he calle d
ultime ordini, sometimes survived boiling for half an hour; these wer e
presumably bacteria. Nevertheless, Spallanzani was criticized by the proponents
40 A History of Human Helminthology
of spontaneous generation on the gr ound that he had "spoiled" the air by heating
it.
Some of the various erroneous ideas were expanded and magnified by many
students of helminthology in the latter years of the century. Thus, the grea t
classifier, Linnaeus, took the theory of heterogony and applied it to large r
free-living creatures. He found a free-living tapeworm, Schistocephalus solidus ,
and regarded it as an immature tapeworm which would develop into the adult
broad tapeworm, Diphyllobothrium latum , when swallowed. Similarly, h e
believed that he had discovered the free-living stages of Fasciola hepatica and
Enterobius vermicularis; he mistook a planarian for the former and a free-living
Rhabditis-like worm for the latter 117.
The discovery of the existence of eggs in many helminths was explained i n
different ways. Some believed that eggs hatched out in the external world gave
birth to free-living creatures and that these in turn were transformed into adult
worms after their introduction into the intestines. Such concepts fitted nicel y
with the theory of heterogony as developed by Linnaeus. Others would hav e
none of this and considered them mere by-products. Others again seized hold
of Vallisnieri's idea that entozoa were transmitted by the transplacental o r
transmammary routes or by kissin g. The major evidence for this hypothesis was
the assertion by a number of observers that they had found entozoa, not only in
the young of animals, but even in the fetus within the body of the mother. Other
investigators, however, adduced the se same observations in favour of the theory
of spontaneous generation.
Such was the interest in the origins of parasitic worms that the Royal Society
of Copenhagen in 1780 set a prize essay on this subject. The first prize was won
by Marcus Bloch, a medical practitioner from Berlin, while the second wa s
taken by the Reverend Johann Goeze in Dudlinburg, Germany. Both of thes e
men argued for the spontaneous origin of parasitic worms. Among the twelve
"facts" which Bloch used to support this position were:
- worms are sometimes located in very young animals, recently born animals, and even
in abortions
- many worms which are never found in the gut occur in the interior parts of the
animal without any passage to the exterior
- worms live in locations where other organisms are digested
- worms die rapidly on removal from the host body
- most animals have their own peculiar parasitic worms 19
Bloch believed that worms destined to live in a particular location within a
particular animal could not have arrived there by chance and that therefore they
must have been generated spontaneously. He acknowledged that many worms
produced a vast number of eggs, as did Goeze who considered that egg s
excreted in the faeces were lost for ever as far as the parasitic intestinal worm
was concerned though they may serve as food for other animals 65.
There were opponents of such views, however. Pallas wrote that:
It cannot be doubted that the eggs of Entozoa are scattered abroad and undergo various
changes without loss of vitality, and that immediately they reach the body of a suitable
Origin and Migration of Worms 41
animal, through the medium of its food and drink, they grow into worms. 158
Pallas even attempted to prove hi s views by experiment. In 1781, he introduced
the small red eggs of the dog tapeworm, now known as Dipylidium caninum,
through a small wound into the abdominal cavity of a pup. One month later, he
claimed to be able to find there small tapeworms and adduced this observation
as in favour of his views 159. Whereas, in general, his hypothesis that worm s
arose from eggs was correct, his experiment was totally in error and the worms
he found, in retrospect, had nothing whatever to do with the ova h e
administered.
The concept of heterogony, however, led to an extremely important observ-
ation in 1790 by the Dane, Peter Christian Abildgaard. Abildgaard noticed that
a cestode worm which lived in the intestine of the little fish known as a
stickleback had no reproductive organs but bore certain resemblances to tape-
worms that he had seen in mergan sers and other fish-eating birds. He wondered
whether the worms in the fish cou ld be an immature form of the bird parasite so
he decided to test this hypothesis:
I collected a great number of stickleback fishes and for three days I fed those to two
ducks. After another three days I killed the ducks and opened their intestines. In one
of the duck's intestines I found 63 pieces of the tapeworm from the fish; they were all
living and more active and faster in their movements than those taken from the belly
of the fishes. They had the same length and shape as in the before-mentioned seabirds.
In the other duck, I found only one tapeworm which was living. 1
This epochal observation was the first successful experiment designed t o
elucidate the life cycle and transmission of an internal parasite.
Voices like his, however, were largely crying in the wilderness. As thousands
of animals were examined for the presence of parasites and as the number o f
known entozoa became larger and larger, helminthology became separated from
zoology and was treated as a distinct discipline. It became mere descriptiv e
enumeration hardly concerned at all with the life-histories and development of
the animals that were so carefully registered. Helminthologists were content to
point out the inadequacy of earlier attempts to explain the presence an d
acquisition of entozoa and returned to the convenient theory of spontaneou s
generation. This trend seemed to be supported by the discovery that many cysts
were verminous in nature (described in chapter 12) but were manifestly devoid
of reproductive organs as were the microscopic organisms now known a s
cercariae that had been discovered by OF Müller in 1773 and which h e
classified as belonging to the "Infusoria" 136.
The second half of the nineteenth century opened with a flurry of speculation
and activity concerning tapeworms and cystic wo rms. Following the statements
of Dujardin and von Siebold, the Belgian, PJ van Beneden, theorized that the
head of a tapeworm is produced from the eggs of a tapeworm and conjectured
that if the egg reached the gut of a suitable animal host, then the jointed adult
tapeworm would mature. On the other hand, he postulated that if the egg found
its way into the gut of an unsuitable host, then the larva would develop but the
hind part would become inflated and the head would sink into it, thus forming
a cysticercus13. Van Beneden was correct in deducing that bladderworms were
larval tapeworms but was wrong in his belief that adult worms would develop
directly from eggs when ingested by an appropriate host. In any case, h e
provided no hard evidence to substantiate his views.
It was at this point that a major wind of change blew upon the scene .
Friedrich Küchenmeister in Germany became interested in the problem o f
cystic worms and tapeworms and began to experiment in order to solve th e
problem. Although there had been previous essays into experimentation i n
helminthology, some of which had been successful, by investigators such as
Pallas, Abildgaard Creplin and Herbst, none had been as dramatic as Küchen-
meister's were to prove, nor did they achieve such widespread recognition .
Küchenmeister began with two of the most easily accessible bladderworms,
Cysticercus pisiformis, of the rabbit and C. fasciolaris of the mouse. In 1851,
Küchenmeister fed a large number of C. pisiformis to foxes which are natural
predators of rabbits, then recovered many young tapeworms which he initially
called Taenia crasscipes (= crassiceps = Taenia pisiformis)92,93. He wrote in
Gunsburg's Zeitschrift für klinische Medicin :
Preliminary communication: I hereby give notice, in order to achieve priority for my
scientific observations and the further development of this subject, that between 18
March and 19 April 1851, I recovered 35 individual Taenia crasscipes from foxes
that had been given approximately 40 Cysticercus pisiformis of rabbits 22, 15 and
8 days and 30 hours previously.92
Küchenmeister then gave C. fasciolaris to a cat and again succeeded in rearing
Origin and Migration of Worms 47
time he found a large number of cysticerci 14. At around the same period ,
Leuckart was able to produce C. fasciolaris in the livers of mice after feeding
these animals with eggs from T. crassicollis from cats. It was not until 1867,
however, that Leuckart produced hydatid cysts in suckling pigs after feeding
them with ova of Taenia echinococcus (= Echinococcus granulosus )112.
Another observation which helped finally to spell the lie to von Siebold' s
concepts of "strayed tapeworms" flowed from t he studies in 1852 of the Prague
zoologist, von Stein. Von Stein examined the development of a small blad -
der-worm in the larva of the meal-worm, Tenebrio molitor, and demonstrated
that, as Goeze had already proven in the case of C. fasciolaris of mice (but
which had been ignored), the caudal vesicle was formed first and then th e
scolex developed within it, whereas von Siebold believed that the scolex was
formed first and that the tail then underwent hydropic degeneration 187. This,
together with an increasing m ass of experimental observations made it abund-
antly clear that development of these cestodes is divided between two kinds of
animals. In one, the definitive host, the adult tapeworm is found, while in the
other, the intermediate host, some form or other of an intermediary stag e
occurs.
Although, as indicated above, Küchenmeister was able to produce C. cell-
ulosae by feeding Taenia solium eggs to pigs, success did not attend his efforts
to generate the adult tapeworm w hen he fed cysticerci to dogs. Others, such as
von Siebold and May, claimed to be able to do so, but Küchenmeister (quite
correctly) did not believe them. He ther efore determined to examine the effects
of administering C. cellulosae to humans under the sentence of death. In 1854,
in collaboration with two medical colleag ues, he induced a convicted murderer
(unknowingly) to ingest over 70 cysticerci during the several days prior t o
execution. Forty eight hours after de ath, he found a number of small, immature
tapeworms in the intestine of the condemned man 97. In the same year that
Küchenmeister reported these observations (1855), Aloys Humbert produced
a patent infection in himself; three months after consuming 13 C. cellulosae,
he began to pass T. solium segments79. A similar experiment with like result
was undertaken by Leuckart in the following year 108. In late 1859 and early
1860, Küchenmeister had an opportunity to repeat his original experimen t
except that on this occasion he was able to infect the prisoner twice severa l
months before execution. On this occasion, he recovered eleven tapeworms,
the largest of them being five feet in length 98.
It took a little time to define the life cycle of the related human parasit e
Taenia saginata. In late 1861 and early 1862, Leuckart undertook a number
of experiments in which he fed T. saginata segments to calves and eventually
recovered the cysticercus known as C. bovis 111. Leuckart's findings were soon
confirmed by Mosler and many others. No-one has ever gone to Küchen -
meister's lengths and fed C. bovis to criminals in order to recover adult T.
saginata from the intestines at autopsy. In 1870, John Oliver in India in some
Origin and Migration of Worms 49
develop, yet when certain encysted cerc ariae were ingested, the larvae escaped
rapidly from the cyst walls and matured in the gut. Thus, Cercaria echinifera
was converted very rapidly in the intestine of warm-blooded animals int o
Distoma echinfera while C. flavum became transformed into Monostomum
flavum in finches and sparrows 196. Likewise, G Wagener in 1857 proved that
the original hypothesis of von Sieb old was correct when he witnessed in snails
the metamorphosis of the miracidium of Distoma cygnoides of the frog into a
redia204.
Investigations of the life cycles of nematodes during this period wer e
sporadic and did not follow a common theme. The most significant advances
were made with Trichinella spiralis. The larvae of this parasite had bee n
discovered in 1835 and although von Siebold had suggested that they wer e
intermediate stages awaiting tran sfer to another host, it was uncertain how this
was achieved. In 1851, however, Herbst reported a major discovery. A fe w
years earlier, he had tried without success to transmit infection to a cat b y
inserting cysts subcutaneously. In November 1850, he fed some trichinou s
flesh obtained from a dead badger to three dogs then identified trichinellae in
their muscles at variable intervals thereafter 75. This report was treated wit h
much reservation, however, and the problem was not solved for anothe r
decade. After a false start in which Leuckart concluded that Trichuris trichiura
adults developed in pigs after they were fed trichinous flesh 109, Virchow in
1859 discovered the adult T. spiralis in the intestines of a dog three and a half
days after it was fed with trichinous meat 200-202. This finding was confirmed by
Leuckart110, then shortly thereafter, Zenker identified the adult worms in th e
small bowel of a human 212. All three of these investigators demonstrated the
migration of newborn larvae, thus making the complete life cycle clear (se e
chapter 22).
Some desultory experiments were undertaken with Ascaris lumbricoides
during this period. Davaine faile d to infect a cow with A. lumbricoides but did
observe that larvae hatched from the eggs and were passed in the faeces when
ova were fed to rats45. Davaine thought it unlikely that an intermediate hos t
was required for transmission, but this view was challenged by others, partic-
ularly in view of a number of negative experiments: Mosler in 1860 failed to
infect himself by swallowing eggs 134, while Leuckart in 1867 was unable t o
infect a variety of animals with embryonated A. lumbricoides eggs or a horse
with Ascaris megacephala (= Parascaris equorum), a dog with Ascaris
marginata (= Toxocara canis), or a cat with Ascaris mystax (= Toxocara
cati) ova112. Nevertheless, Unterberger in 1868 showed that Ascaris maculosa
(= Ascaridia columbae) of the pigeon developed directly while Henry in 1873
demonstrated direct transmission of T. cati to cats.
Success was achieved, however, with such challenge infections with on e
important nematode parasitic in humans, Enterobius vermicularis. In 1865,
Leuckart and three of his students swallowed a few dozen eggs of this worm
that had been kept in a humidified incubator. Over the next several weeks, they
Origin and Migration of Worms 51
nard, but the critical experiments were those of Louis Pasteur which wer e
published in 1860 and 1861.
In 1858, however, FA Pouchet had begun to present a series of papers to the
Academy of Sciences in Paris in which he claimed to have proved th e
existence of spontaneous gene ration, which he called heterogenesis, by exper-
iments using flasks, air, hay, water and heat. In 1859, he published his book,
Hétérogonie, in the preface of which he explained how he had come to study
the phenomenon:
when by meditation it was evident to me that spontaneous generation was one of the
means employed by nature for the reproduction of living things I applied myself to
discover the methods by which this takes place.165
Pouchet believed that spontaneous generation required the presence of a vital
force coming from pre-existin g living matter; he did not believe that life could
be generated from non-living matter.
Meanwhile, Pasteur had become interested in the problems of fermentation.
In 1857 he isolated a ferment (since shown to be bacterial) that soured milk,
then he showed that yeasts or moulds on grapes were necessary for th e
fermentation of sugar into alcohol in the making of wine. These observations
convinced him that fermentation and putrefaction were vital processes; thi s
view compared starkly with that of Baron von Liebig, the premier authority on
the matter, who regarded fermentation as being "of the nature of death". Like
Spallanzani, Pasteur believed that organisms associated with fermentatio n
came from the air. The major criticism of Spallanzani's work had been that in
boiling his sealed flasks, he had also altered in some way the contained air .
Pasteur therefore set about proving the crux of his hypothesis, that is that air
carried germs. First, he showed that germs or bodies resembling them existed
in the air by filtering air through gun-cotton then examining the sedimen t
microscopically; these were similar to the organisms that had already bee n
observed in fermenting substances. The next problem was to demonstrate that
these germs were alive. This he did by showing that sterile infusion s
containing air which had been heated became infected if dust from the air was
introduced into it. He then took a series of flasks containing an infusion o f
fermentable substances but in which the neck of each flask was very narrow
and long, more or less horizontal in orientation, and drawn out into an "s "
shape. The flasks and their contents were then heated to boiling point for a
long period. Even though they were then left for months, the contents did not
ferment. When the neck was seve red, however, fermentation became apparent
within a few hours and organisms were demonstrated in it under the micro -
scope.
These experiments were brought together in Pasteur's Mémoire sur les
corpuscles organisés qui existent dans l'atmosphère. Examen de la doctrine
des générations spontanées which was published in 1861 162. The success of
these experiments was the final turning point and marked the downfall of the
doctrine of spontaneous generation, although a vociferous rear-guard actio n
Origin and Migration of Worms 53
was fought for a number of years by a few workers including Pouchet, Häckel,
and the English physician, Charlton Bastian, who a few years earlier had des-
cribed in detail the anatomy of the Guinea worm. The word "biogenesis" was
coined by TH Huxley80 in 1870 to express the hypothesis that living matte r
always arises by the agency of pre-existing living matter, while the ter m
"abiogenesis" was used for the opposite view. Perhaps the most extreme sup-
porter of abiogenesis during this period was Bastian who, in a book of greater
that one thousand pages published in 1872, promulgated the doctrine o f
"archebiosis", i.e. that animals can be gen erated spontaneously from non-living
matter12. Bastian continued the fight until his death in 1915. He is a classi c
example of the principle enunciated by Max Planck:
A new scientific truth does not become accepted by way of convincing and
enlightening the opposition. Rather, the opposition dies out and the rising generation
becomes well-acquainted with the new truth from the start. 164
It took some time for the dust to clear and for the controversy over spont -
aneous generation to be seen in perspective. In reviewing the whole question
in 1881, the learned The New Sydenham's Society's Lexicon of Medicine and
the Allied Sciences summarized the problem thus:
This subject has attracted much attention of late years. Pouchet in France, Häckel in
Germany and Bastian in this country have been its most prominent supporters....The
most ingenious apparatus and modifications of experiments have been suggested by
both sides....Unfortunately, the evidence that one side regards as irrefutable is either
entirely ignored or met with a direct denial by the other. The results of one's
experiments are the negative ones of his opponent....On the whole, it may be said
that no conclusive proof has been obtained of the occurrence of abiogenesis. 167
In the event, the proponents of spontaneous generation gradually disappeared
from view and the doctrine of spontaneous generation became abandoned by
biologists. Certainly, no experimental helminthologists still supported th e
concept. All their time and energy was devoted to elucidate the complex and
mysterious life cycles of many parasitic worms.
The first major success came with Fasciola hepatica when Thomas in
England190,191 and Leuckart in Germany113-115 independently worked out the life
cycle of this parasite between 1879 and 1882. In a series of epidemiological
studies and laboratory experiments, both authors discovered that miracidi a
hatched from Fasciola eggs invaded Lymnaea snails and there
metamorphosed into brood sacs or sporocysts in which rediae subsequentl y
developed. The latter in turn developed cercariae within them. Bot h
investigators were uncertain as to the subsequent course of events, postulating
that either the snails containing cercariae were ingested or that cercaria e
escaped from the molluscs, encysted on grass, then were ingested. The matter
was not settled until 1892 when Lutz showed that Fasciola cercariae were
54 A History of Human Helminthology
liberated from damaged or dead snails then en cysted on plant or other material.
He then demonstrated that when these cysts were fed to guinea pigs, the life
cycle was completed 123. These findings with Fasciola led to an intensive
search for a snail intermediate host for Schistosoma haematobium , but as is
related in chapter 8, nothing was found and controversy continued until well
into the next century as to whether an intermediate host was necessary.
The remaining cestode of major human importance of which the life cycle
was obscure was Diphyllobothrium latum . A partial solution to this problem
was provided during this period by Max Braun in the eastern Baltic region. He
found immature worms, the head of which resembled that of the broa d
tapeworm, in a variety of fresh-water fish (pike, perch, ruff and burbot). H e
then fed in 1881 these parasites to dogs and eventually recovered adult D.
latum 22, then repeated the experimental process in humans 22,23 . The second
intermediate host was now clear, but how the fish became infected remained
unsolved for another 35 years.
During this period, observations were made upon the life cycles of certain
cestodes of lesser significance for humans. Grassi found in 1887 tha t
Hymenolepis nana could be transmitted directly from one definitive host to the
next68. In 1889, Grassi and Rovelli showed that Dipylidium caninum
developed in fleas70. Three years later, they showed that Hymenolepis
diminuta developed in a variety of arthropod intermediate hosts 71.
Pieces were put into place partially or completely during this period for a
number of nematodes. In 187 6, Leuckart reported that when he had fed ova of
Trichuris affinis to a lamb and T. crenatus eggs to pigs, he was able to recover
subsequently adult worms 112 then Railliet in 1884 reported a simila r
phenomenon with dogs and T. depressiusuculus. This was applied to the
human parasite, T. trichiura, in 1886 when Calandruccio successfully infected
himself after swallowing eggs, the results being reported by Grassi 67. In the
same year, Calandruccio likewise i nfected a boy with Ascaris lumbricoides by
administering embryonated ova to him. This experiment was also reported by
Grassi67, who had claimed a similar result in a few years earlier 66, although that
claim must be viewed with considerable circumspection in view of th e
unusually short incubation period that he reported.
Similar attempts were made to transmit hookwor m infection. In 1878, Grassi
and his colleagues failed to infect humans b y ingestion of either hookworm ova
or larvae (presumably first-stage), nor could they infect a dog by administering
eggs orally69. In 1886, however, Leichtenstern undertook feeding experiments
and reported that he was able to infect humans by administering third-stag e
hookworm larvae orally 102, a feat which Wilms repeated in 1897 with th e
similar parasite, Strongyloides stercoralis 206. A far more important even t
occurred when the German, Looss, working in Egypt reported in 1898 tha t
infective larvae were able to penetrate the intact skin, migrate to the gut and
mature119. This was greeted with considerable scepticism, but several year s
later he was able to prove his point as will be described in the next section.
Origin and Migration of Worms 55
At the turn of the nineteenth century, great interest centred on Looss's claim of
1898 that hookworm larvae could p enetrate the intact skin. As indicated in the
preceding section, this report was greeted with considerable scepticism. I n
order to prove his point, he applied filariform larvae to the skin of a thirteen
year old boy one hour before he was due to have his leg amputated. Immed-
iately following removal of the leg, the exposed skin was excised and histo -
logical sections disclosed larvae in the dermis. Looss reported his findings in
1901 120 , but disbelief was still rampant. He therefore persuaded an hospita l
attendant to allow himself to be infected ex perimentally. After ascertaining that
the person was not infected already, a drop of culture fluid containing infective
larvae was placed on his forearm; hookworm ova were found in his faeces 71
days later, thus proving that the life cycle of this parasite could be completed
in this manner 121.
These observations with hookworm were then applied to the similar parasite,
Strongyloides stercoralis. Van Durme showed with histological studies i n
1901-2 that Strongyloides infective larvae were able to invade the skin o f
56 A History of Human Helminthology
guinea pigs50. Over ten years later, Fülleborn took the final step in experiments
with dogs and showed that larvae applied to the skin migrated through the lungs
and then were able to develop into adult worms in the intestines 62.
In 1905, Robert Leiper went to the Gold Coast (Ghana) to further in -
vestigate the life cycle of Dracunculus medinensis . First, he repeated
Fedchenko's experiments and examined the manner in which Cyclops were
infected. He then fed a monkey on bananas contaminated with copepods that
had been infected with guinea worm embryos five weeks earlier. Six months
later, he found five immature Dracunculus in the tissues at post-morte m
examination103. In 1913, Turkhud in India gave a small number of infecte d
Cyclops in water to five "volunteers". Just over one year later, one of thes e
persons developed a clinical infection, although whether this was as a result of
the experimental exposure or was acquired naturally cannot be determined with
certainty193.
By analogy with Wuchereria bancrofti, it seemed very likely that Loa loa
was also transmitted by some form of biting insect. In 1912, Leiper journeyed
to West Africa and fed many type s of arthropods on infected persons. He found
that development of microfilariae occurred in flies of the genus Chrysops 104 but
he did not publish details of the developmental changes. His results wer e
confirmed several years later by Kleine and then by Connal and his wife, th e
latter pair of investigators providing considerable detail 39,40.
Another question that burned in the minds of many helminthologists at this
time concerned the manner of transmission of schistosomiasis. As is discussed
in chapter 8, investigators fell into one of two camps - those that favoure d
direct transmission and those that believed that there must be an intermediate
host. The answer came not from a study of Egyptian schistosomiasis, but from
investigation of Schistosoma japonicum infection that had just been discovered
in Japan. In 1909, Fujinama and Nakamura showed by a series of experiments
using cows that infection was acquired via the skin rather than by the ora l
route 60,61. The events leading up to such infection were described by Miyair i
and Suzuki in 1913. They reported that they had collected snails of uncertain
identity (subsequently shown to belong to the genus Oncomelania) from a
roadside ditch, found that they were free of trematode infections, then exposed
them to S. japonicum miracidia hatched from eggs. They observed that th e
miracidia invaded the snails, developed into sporocysts then ultimatel y
produced and released cercariae. They then exposed the skins of mice t o
cercariae released from naturally-infected snails and a few weeks late r
recovered adult schistosomes from the portal veins of the infected mice 132,133.
These results were then soon confirmed by Leiper and Atkinson 107 and by
Yokogawa210.
In the light of these observations, Leiper then turned his attention t o
schistosomiasis in Egypt. After a rapid series of experiments, he was able t o
report in 1915 that he had infected Bulinus snails with miracidia derived from
terminal-spined eggs (S. haematobium), observed their development through
Origin and Migration of Worms 57
of years. In 1917, Ciurea found that certain species of fish were the secon d
intermediate host of Opisthorchis felineus 36, but again, the nature of the firs t
intermediate host remained unknown.
During this period, the missing link in the chain of transmission of the broad
tapeworm, Diphyllobothrium latum , was finally put into place. Janicki an d
Rosen in Switzerland attempted to infect fish directly with larvae hatched from
D. latum eggs. When this failed, Janicki examined the stomach contents o f
species of fish that were known to transmit the infection. He found by a process
of exclusion that all fish containing younger stages of the tapeworm ha d
copepods in their gut 82. Likewise, Rosen examined a number of potentia l
primary intermediate hosts without success until he turned his attention t o
copepods. In the body cavity of certain Cyclops, he found oncospheres typical
of D. latum 171. Both investigators came to this conclusion independently in June
1917. In order to complete the life cycle experimentally, Rosen infecte d
copepods by exposing them to tapeworm eggs then six weeks later placed trout
in the aquarium. When the fish were killed s ubsequently, he found plerocercoids
in the musculature 171.
In 1911, Nicholl and Minchin found t hat Hymenolepis nana, in addition to its
direct cycle of transmission, could also be acquired by ingestion of infecte d
fleas147.
The only helminth infection of major human importance in which the life cycle
was still uncertain at the beginning of the seco nd quarter of the twentieth century
was Onchocerca volvulus. A number of investigators had studied a number of
potential intermediate hosts without success, and in 1917 Robles in Guatemala
had suggested on epidemiological grounds that blackflies of the genus Simulium
may be involved but he offered no definitive evidence. That these flies wer e
indeed the vector was proven by Blacklock in Sierra Leone. He reported i n
1926 that Onchocerca microfilaria were present in the gut of these insects and
he traced their development into infective larvae which migrated into th e
proboscis 17,18. Like most of the other filarial nematodes, this worm has neve r
been transmitted experimentally to humans.
The remainder of the century saw several small points in the life cycles of the
important human parasites tidied up and observations made upon the lif e
histories of a number of worms of lesser signifi cance. With respect to nematodes
of lesser importance for humans, Dyce Sharp showed in 1927 that Mansonella
perstans developed in Culicoides 51,52. Buckley reported in 1933 that insects of
the same genus were the vectors of Mansonella ozzardi 28,29. Likewise,
Culicoides were found by Chardome and Peel in 1949 to be the intermediat e
hosts of Mansonella streptocerca 35. In 1960, Edeson and his colleague s
reported that they had induced a patent infection in a human with Brugia
Origin and Migration of Worms 59
pahangi although they had failed to achieve this result with B. malayi 53. The
latter infection was transmitted success fully to monkeys by Orihel and Pachecho
in 1968157. Likewise, Cross and his colleagues reported in 1979 that they had
transmitted successfully Wuchereria bancrofti to monkeys44. Four years earlier,
Orihel and Moore had transmitted Loa loa to two species of subhuma n
primates156.
The details of the first and second intermediate hosts of Gnathostoma
spinigerum were described by Prommas and Daengsvang in in 1936 168. Mack-
erras and Sandars described the molluscan inte rmediate host of Angiostrongylus
cantonensis in 1955124 while Morera and Ash in 1971 described the slug vector
of Angiostrongylus costaricensis. Infection with Capillaria philippinensis was
shown to be by ingestion of infected fish by Cross and his colleagues in 1972 43.
With respect to trematodes of lesser human significance, Asada in 192 8
discovered the snail first intermediate host of Heterophyes heterophyes 7.
Cameron in 1931 showed that certain snails were the intermediate host o f
Dicrocoelium dendriticum 32, while Krull and Mapes later found that meta -
cercariae developed in ants 91. In 1933, Tubangui and Pasco identified the snail
intermediate hosts of Echinostoma ilocanum 192. In 1934, Vogel showed tha t
snails of the genus Bithynia were the first intermediate host of Opisthorchis
felineus 203. The first and second intermediate hosts of O. viverrini were
described by Wykoff and his colleagues in 1966 208.
Concerning cestodes of less importance for huma ns, Stunkard showed in 1940
that mites were the vector of Bertiella studeri 188.
OVERVIEW
REFERENCES
42. CREPLIN FHC. "Distoma". In, Allge meine Encyclopädie der Wissenschaften und Kunste,
JS Ersch und JP Grüber (Editors), Leipzig, Sect. 1. Part 29: 309-329, 1837. Partl y
translated in 84
43. CROSS JH, BANZON T, CLARKE MD, BASACA-SERVILLA V, WATTEN RH ,
DIZON JJ. Studies on the experimental transmission of Capillaria philippinensis in
monkeys. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 66 :
819-827, 1972
44. CROSS JH, PARTONO F, HSU MK, ASH L R, OEMIJATI S. Experimental transmission
of Wuchereria bancrofti to monkeys. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene
28: 56-66, 1979
45. DAVAINE CJ. Nouvelles re cherches sur le développement de la propogation de l'ascaride
lombricoide et du trichocéphale d e l'homme. Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances
de l'Académie des Sciences, third series, 4: 261-265, 1862. Translated in 84
46. DAVAINE CJ. Traité des entozoaires et des maladies vermineuses de l'homme et de s
animaux domestiques, second edition, J B Baillière et fils, Paris, pp 1003, 1877
47. DOLOEUS J. De infantum et puerorum morbis. In, Encyclop. medicinae, Francofurti, 4:
10, 1684-1691. Cited in 46
48. DRUMMOND JL. Thoughts on equivocal generation of entozoa., Annals of Natura l
History 6: 101-108, 1841
49. DUJARDIN F. Histoire naturelle des helminthes ou vers intestinaux, Librairi e
Encyclopédique de Roret, Paris, pp 654, 1845
50. van DURME P. Quelques notes sur les embryons de "Strongyloides intestinalis" et leu r
pénétration par la peau. Thompson Yates Laboratories Report 4: 471-474, 1901-1902
51. DYCE SHARP NA. Development of microfilaria perstans in Culicoides grahami : a
preliminary note. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 21:
70, 1927
52. DYCE SHARP NA. Filaria perstans: its development in Culicoides austeni . Transactions
of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 21: 371-396, 1928
53. EDESON JF, WILSON T, WHARTON RH, LAING AB. Experimental transmission of
Brugia malayi and B. pahangi to man. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropica l
Medicine and Hygiene 54: 229-234. 1960
54. ESCHRICHT DF. Inquiries, experimental and philosophical, concerning the origin o f
intestinal worms. Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal 31: 314-356, 1841
55. FARLEY J. The spontaneous generation controversy (1700-1860): the origin of parasitic
worms. Journal of the History of Biology 5: 95-125, 1972
56. FEDCHENKO (FEDTSCHENCKO) AP. (Concerning the structure and reproduction of
the Guinea worm [Filaria medinensis L.]. Izvestiia Imperatorskago Obshchestva Liubitelei
Estestvoznaniia Antropologii i Ethnografii - Moskva, 8: columns 71-81, 1870. In Russian.
Translated in 84
57. de FILIPPI. Descrizione di nuovi entozoi trovati in alcuni molluschi d'aqua dolce .
Bibliotheca Italiana, an 22, 87: 333-340, 1837
58. FILLIOZAT J. La doctrine classique de la médecine Indienne, Imprimerie Nationale, Paris,
1949
59. FORBES D. Extracts from the half yearly reports of the diseases prevailing at Dharwar in
the 1st grenadier regiment, for the year 1836. N.I. for the year 1836. Transactions of the
Medical and Physical Society of Bombay 1: 215-225, 1838
60. FUJINAMI A, NAKAMURA H. (The mode of transmission of Katayama disease in the
Hiroshima prefecture, Japanese schistosomiasis, the development of its causative worm ,
and the disease in animals caused by it.) Hiroshima Iji Geppo 132: 324-341, 1909. I n
Japanese. Abstracted in 205
61. FUJINAMI A, NAKAMURA H. (Route of infection, development of the worm in the host
and animals in Katayama disease in Hiroshima Prefecture [Japanese blood sucking worm
disease - schistosomiasis japonica].) Kyoto Igaku Zasshi 6: 224-252, 1909. In Japanese.
Translated in 84
Origin and Migration of Worms 63
of Ibn Sina (Avicenna) with a short biography. Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene
25: 65-67, 1922
87. KNOCH J. Vorläufige Mittheilung über den Bothriocephalus latus die Entwicklung
desselben, die Wanderung und endliche Uebertragung seines Embryo's in den Menschen.
Archiv für pathologische Anatomie und Physiologie und für klinische Medicin (Virchow)
24: 453-461, 1862
88. KOBAYASHI H. (A preliminary report on the source of the human liver distome ,
Clonorchis endemicum (Bälz)(= Distoma spathulatum Leuckart.) Annotatione s
Zoologicae Japonenses 271-277, 1911. In Japanese, with English summary
89. KOBAYASHI H. A preliminary report on the source of the human liver distome ,
Clonorchis endemicum (Bälz) (Distomum spathulatum , Leuckart). Far Easter n
Association of Tropical Medicine: Transactions of the Second Biennial Congress, Hong
Kong, pp 108-112, 1912
90. KOBAYASHI H. Studies on the lung fluke in Korea. I. On the life-history an d
morphology of the lung fluke. Mittheilungen aus der medizinischen Fachschule zu Keijo
2: 97-115, 1918
91. KRULL WH, MAPES CR. Studies on the biology of Dicrocoelium dendriticu m
(Rudolphi 1819) Looss, 1899 (Trematoda: Dicrocoeliidae) including its relation to th e
intermediate host, Cionella lubrica (Muller). IX. Notes on the cyst, metacercaria, an d
infection in the ant, Formica fusca. Cornell Veterinarian 43: 389-409, 1953
92. KÜCHENMEISTER F. Vorläufige Mittheilung. Über Cysticercus pisiformis der Kanin-
chen. Zeitschrift für klinische Medicin (G unsburg) 2: 240, 1851. Translated by L Herzberg
93. KÜCHENMEISTER F. Einiges über den Übergang der Finnen in Taenien und über das
Digitalin. Zeitschrift für klinische Medicin (Gunsburg) 2: 295-299, 1851
94. KÜCHENMEISTER F. Ueber die Umwa ndlung der Finnen (Cysticerci) in Bandwuermer
(Taenien). Prager Vierteljahrsschrift für die Praktische Heilkunde 33: 106-158, 1852
95. KÜCHENMEISTER F. Über Cestoden im Allgemeinen und die des Mensche n
insbesondere etc., Zittau, 1853. Partly translated in 55
96. KÜCHENMEISTER F. Experimente über die Entstehung der Cestoden Zweiter Stuf e
zunächst des Coenurus cerebralis . Under Mitwirkung des Herrn Professor Haubner auf
Befehl und Kosten des hohen königliche sächsischen Staatsminsterii des Innern. Zeitschrift
für klinische Medicin (Gunsburg) 4: 448-451, 1853
97. KÜCHENMEISTER F. Offenes Sendschreiben an die k.k. Gesellschaft der Zertze z u
Wien. Experimenteller Nachweiss, da ssCysticercus cellulosae innerhalb des menschlichen
Darmkanales sich in Taenia solium umwandelt. Wiener medicinische Wochenschrift 5:
1-4, 1855. Translated in 84
98. KÜCHENMEISTER F. Erneuter Versuch der Umwandlung des Cysticercus cellulosae
in Taenia solium hominis . Deutsche Klinik 12: 187-189, 1860. Abstracted in Medica l
Times and Gazette ii: 414, 1860
99. KÜCHENMEISTER F, HAUBNER GC. Weitere Mittheilungen über die Entwicklung
der Band- und Blasenwürmer Nach den Versuchen von Dr. Küchenmeister und Dr .
Haubner. Magazin für die Gessamte Thierheilkunde 20: 366-368, 1854; 21: 100-118 ,
1855
100. van LEEUWENHOEK A. Part of a letter from Mr. Anthony van Leeuwenhoe k
concerning worms observ'd in sheeps' livers and pasture grounds. Philosophica l
Transactions of the Royal Society 24: 1522-1527, 1704
101. van LEEUWENHOEK A. The selec t works of Anthony van Leeuwenhoek containing his
microscopical discoveries in many of the works of nature, translated by S Hoole from the
Dutch and Latin editions, Henry Fry, London, 1798
102. LEICHTENSTERN O. Futterungsversuche mit An kylostomalarven. Ein neue Rhabditisart
in den Fäces von Ziegerlarbeitern: Berichtigung. Centralblatt für klinische Medicin 7 :
673-675, 1886
103. LEIPER RT. The etiology and prophylaxis of dracontiasis. British Medical Journal i :
129-132, 1907
Origin and Migration of Worms 65
104. LEIPER RT. Filaria loa. Cited in British Medical Journal i: 39-40, 1913
105. LEIPER RT. Report on the result s of the Bilharzia mission in Egypt, 1915. Journal of the
Royal Army Medical Corps 25: 1-55, 147-192, 253-267, 1915
106. LEIPER RT. On the relation between the terminal-spined and lateral-spined eggs o f
Bilharzia. British Medical Journal i: 411, 1916
107. LEIPER RT, ATKINSON EL. Observations on the spread of Asiatic schistosomiasis .
British Medical Journal i: 201-203, 1915
108. LEUCKART R. Die Blasenbandwürmer und ihre Entwicklung. Zugleich ein Beitrag zur
Kenntnis der Cysticercusleber, J Ricker, Giessen, pp 162, 1856
109. LEUCKART R. Expériences sur la trichina spiralis (le ver devient un trichocéphale dans
l'intestin du porc). Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances de l'Académie de s
Sciences 49: 453-457, 1859
110. LEUCKART R. Der geschlechstreife Zustand der Trichina spiralis. Eine vorläufige
Mittheilung. Zeitschrift für rationale Medicin 8: 259-262, 334-335, 1860. Translated in
Quarterly Journal of Microscopical Science 8: 168-171, 1860
111. LEUCKART R. Die menschlichen Parasiten und die von ihnen herrührenden Krankheiten.
Ein Hand- und Lehrbuch für Naturforscher und Aertze, CF Winter'sche Verlagshandlung,
Leipzig, volume 1, pp 776, 1863
112. LEUCKART R. Die menschlichen Parasiten und die von ihnen herrührenden Krankheiten.
Ein Hand- und Lehrbuch für Naturforscher und Aertze, CF Winter'sche Verlagshandlung,
Leipzig, volume 2, pp 882, 1867-1876
113. LEUCKART R. Zur Entwickelungsgeschichte des Leberegels. Zoologischer Anzeiger 4:
461-464, 1881. Translated in 84
114. LEUCKART R. Zur Entwickelungsgeschichte des Leberegels ( Distomum hepaticum ).
Archiv für Naturgeschichte 1: 80-119, 1882
115. LEUCKART R. Zur Entwickelungsgeschichte des Leberegels. Zweite Mittheilung .
Zoologischer Anzeiger 5: 524-528, 1882
116. LEUCKART R. Die Parasiten des Menschen und die von ihnen herrührende n
Krankheiten. Ein Hand- und Lehrbuch für Naturforscher und Aertze, CF Winter'sch e
Verlagshandlung, Leipzig, volume 1, pp 1009, 1879-1886. The parasites of man and the
diseases which proceed from them, translated by WE Hoyle, Young J Pentland ,
Edinburgh, pp 771, 1886
117. LINNAEUS C. Cited in 24
118. von LIPPMANN E O. Urzeugung und Lebenskraft. Zur Geschichte dieser Probleme von
den ältesten Zeiten an bis zu den Anfängen des 20. Jahrhunderts, Julius Springer, Berlin,
pp 135, 1933
119. LOOSS A. Zur Lebensgeschichte des Ankylostoma duodenale . Centralblatt für
Bakteriologie und Parasitenkunde, Abteilu ng originale 24: 441-449, 483-488, 1898. Partly
translated in 84
120. LOOSS A. Ueber das Eindrigen der Ankylostomalarven in die menschliche Haut. Cen-
tralblatt für Bakteriologie und Parasitenkunde, Abteilung originale 29: 733-739, 1901
121. LOOSS A. The anatomy and life histo ry of Agchylostoma duodenale Dub. A monograph.
Part II. The development in the free state. Translated from the German by M Bernhard.
Records of the School of Medicine, Egyptian Ministry of Education, 4: 163-613, 1911.
Pp 252-277 reprinted in the Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 15: 155-157 ,
171-174, 182-185, 199-201, 235-238, 1912. Abstracted in Journal of the Royal Arm y
Medical Corps 19: 42-55, 1912
122. LOW GC. A recent observation on Filaria nocturna in Culex: probable mode of infection
in man. British Medical Journal i: 1456-1457, 1900
123. LUTZ A. Zur Lebensgeschichte des Distoma hepaticum . Centralblatt für Bakteriologie
und Parasitenkunde, Abteilung originale 11: 783-796, 1892. Partly translated in 84
124. MACKERRAS MJ, SANDARS DF. The life-history of the rat lung-worm ,
Angiostrongylus cantonensis (Chen) (Nematoda: Metastrongylidae). Australian Journal
of Zoology 7: 1-21, 1955
66 A History of Human Helminthology
148. NITZSCH CL. Seltame Lebens- und Todesart eines kleinen bisher unbekannte n
Wasserthierchens. In, Kilian. Georgia, der Der Menschen im Leben und im Staate, p p
257-262, 281-286, 1807
149. NITZSCH CL. Beitrag zur Infusorienkunde, oder Naturbeschreibung der Zerkarien und
Bazillarien. Neue Schriften der naturforschenden Gesellschaft zu Halle 3: 1-128, 1817
150. von NORDMANN A. Mikrographische Beiträge zur Naturgeschichte der wirbellose n
Thiere, G Reimer, Berlin, two volumes, pp 268, 1832
151. OKEN LH. Cited and partly translated in 24
152. OKEN LH. Cited and partly translated in 181
153. OLIVER JH. Cited in Seventh Annual Report of the Sanitary Commissioner (1870) of the
Government of India, Calcutta, pp 82-83, 1871
154. ONJI Y, NISHIO K. (General observations on new intestinal flukes.) Igaku Chuo Zasshi
14: 875-883, 1915. In Japanese
155. ORIBASIUS. Cited in 2
156. ORIHEL TC, MOORE P JJ. Loa loa: experimental infection in two species of African
primates. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 24: 606-609, 1975
157. ORIHEL TC, PACHECHO G. Brugia malayi in the Philippine macaque. Journal o f
Parasitology 54: 1234-1235, 1968
158. PALLAS PS. Bemerkungen über die Bandwürmer in Menschen und Thieren. Neu e
nordische Beyträge Physikalische und Geographische Erd- und Vokerbeschriften 1 :
39-112, 1781. Partly translated in 116
159. PALLAS PS. Einige Erinnerungen die Bandwürmer bettrefend: in Beziehung auf da s
zwölfte und vierzehnte stück des Naturforschers. Neue nordische Beytrage Physikalische
und Geographische Erd- und Vokerbeschriften 1: 113-131, 1781
160. PARACELSUS. De natura rerum, liber primus de generationibus rerum naturalium .
Saemtliche Werke, K Sudhoff (Editor), München, 14 volumes, 1922-1923. Partl y
translated in 77
161. PARÉ A. Les oeuvres d'Ambroise Paré etc., Paris, 1561. Partly translated in 77
162. PASTEUR L. Mémoire sur les corpuscles organisés qui existent dans l'atmosphère .
Examen de la doctrine des générations spontanées, Société Chimique, Paris, 1861
163. PERRONCITO E. On the tenacity of life of the cysticercus in the flesh of oxen and on the
rapid development of the corresponding Taenia mediocanellata in the human body. The
Veterinarian 50: 817-818, 1877
164. PLANCK M. Wissenschaftliche Selbstbiographie, Johann Barth, Leipzig, 1955. Partl y
translated in 55
165. POUCHET FA. Hétérogonie, Paris, 1859. Partly translated in 31
166. POUCHET, VERRIER. Expériences sur l es migrations des entozoaires. Comptes Rendus
Hebdomadaires des Séances de la Académie des Sciences 54: 958-963, 1862. Translated
in Quarterly Journal of Microscopical Science 2: 171-175, 1853
167. POWER H, SEDGEWICK LW (Editors). The New Sydenhams Society's lexicon o f
medicine and the allied sciences, The New Sydenham Society, London, five volumes ,
1881-1894
168. PROMMAS C, DAENGSVANG S. Preliminary report of a study on the life-cycle o f
Gnathostoma spinigerum . Journal of Parasitology 22: 180-186, 1936
169. REDI F. Esperienze intorno alla generazione degl'insetti, Carlo Dati, Firenze, pp 177 ,
1668. Experiments on the generation of insects, translated from the 1688 edition by M
Bigelow, Opencourt Publishing Co., Chicago, pp 160, 1909
170. RHIND W. A treatise on the nature and cure of intestinal worms of the human body ,
Samuel Highley, London, pp 153, 1829
171. ROSEN F. Recherches expérimentales sur le cycle évolutif du Dibothriocephalus latus .
Bulletin de la Société Neuchâteloise des Sciences Naturelles 42: 29-49, 1917. Partl y
translated in 84
172. RUDOLPHI CA. Entozoorum sive vermium intestinalium historia naturalis, Treuttel et
Würtz, Paris, two volumes, pp 1370, 1808-1810
68 A History of Human Helminthology
natural history from more exact observations is attempted; and the whole urged, as a
difficulty against the doctrine of univocal generation. Philosophical Transactions of th e
Royal Society 13: 113-144, 1683
195. TYSON E. The Lumbricus Latus (Abstract). Memoirs of the Philosphical Transactions
of the Royal Society pp 122-130. Abstract of 194
196. la VALETTE de ST. GEORGE A. Symbolae ad trematodorum evolutionis historiam ,
Berlin, pp 38, 1855
197. VALLISNERIUS (VALLISNIERI) A. Opera fisico-mediche stampate e manoscritte .
Raccolte da Antonio suo figliuolo, S Coleti, Venezia, three volumes, pp 1696, 1733 .
Partly translated in 37
198. VILLANOVANUS (de VILLENEUVE) A. De lumbricus et ascaridibus. In, Opera omnia,
Basileae, 1585. Original edition c. 1300. Cited in 37
199. VIRCHOW R. Die Cellularpathologie in ihrer Begründung auf physiologische un d
pathologische Gewebelehre, A Hirschwald, pp 440, Berlin, 1858. 1859. Cellula r
pathology as based upon physiological and pathological histology, translated from th e
second edition by F Chance, J Churchill, London, pp 511, 1860
200. VIRCHOW R. Futterungsversuch mit Trichina spiralis. Deutsche Klinik 11: 430, 1859
201. VIRCHOW R. Recherches sur le développement de la trichina spiralis (Ce ver devien t
adulte dans l'intestin du chien). Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances d e
l'Académie des Sciences 49: 660-662, 1859
202. VIRCHOW R. Helmintholgische Notizen. 3. Ueber Trichina spiralis. Archiv für
pathologische Anatomie und Physiologie und für klinische Medicin (Virchow) 18 :
330-345, 1860. Abstracted in British and Foreign Medico-Chirurgical Review 26 :
515-516, 1860
203. VOGEL H. Der Entwicklungszyklus von Opisthorchis felineus (Riv.) nebst Bemerkungen
über Systematick und Epidemiologie. Zoologica 33: 1-103, 1934
204. WAGENER H. Beiträge zur Entwickelungs-Geschichte der Eingeweidewürmer .
Naturkundige Verhandelingen van de Hollandsche Maatschapij der Weteschappen t e
Haarlem, pp 112, 1857
205. WARREN K S. Schistosomiasis: the evolution of a medical literature. M.I.T. Press ,
Cambridge, Mass., pp 1307, 1973
206. WILMS. Anchylostoma duodenale und Angullula intestinalis . Schmidt's Jahrbücher der
in-und ausländischen gesammten Medicin 256: 272, 1897
207. WOTTON E. Edoardi Wuottoni Oxoniensis, De differentiis animalium, Lutetia e
Parisiorum, 1552
208. WYKOFF DE, HARINASUTA C, JUTTIJUDATA P, WINN MM. Opisthorchis
viverrini in Thailand - the life cycle and comparison with O. felineus, Journal of
Parasitology 51: 207-214, 1965
209. YOKOGAWA S. (A new parasite involving trout as its intermediate host and its ne w
generic name.) Okayama Igakkai Zasshi No. 279, 1912. In Japanese
210. YOKOGAWA S. (Schistosoma japonicum in Formosa, especially on its intermediat e
host.). Taiwan Igakkai Zasshi 149: 178-183, 1915. In Japanese. Abstracted in 205
211. YOKOGAWA S. (Paragonimus ringeri . Study of stages from the crab and points o f
difference distinguishing it from similar cysts occurring there.) Taiwan Igakukai Zasshi
No. 175, pp 298-307, 1917. In Japanese. Abstracted in Tropical Diseases Bulletin 12 :
173-174, 1918
212. ZENKER FA. Ueber die trichinen-Krankheit des Menschen. Archiv für pathologisch e
Anatomie und Physiologie und für klinische Medicin (Virchow) 18: 561-572, 1860 .
Translated in 84
70 A History of Human Helminthology
Table 2.1. Landmarks in the understanding of the origin and transmission of worms
___________________________________________________________________
1853 von Siebold discovered Echinococcus granulosus adult worms in the intestines of
dogs after feeding hydatid cysts to them
1854 van Beneden generated Cysticercus cellulosae by feeding Taenia solium eggs to
pigs
1855 Küchenmeister reported the recovery of immature Taenia solium after feeding
Cysticercus cellulosae shortly before execution to a condemned murderer
1855 Humbert ingested Cycsticercus cellulosae and three months later began to pas s
Taenia solium proglottids in his stools
1855 la Valette de St. George showed that certain encysted cercariae but no t
non-encysted cercariae developed into adult flukes when ingested by birds o r
animals
1857 Wagener witnessed the metamorphosis of Distoma cygnoides miracidia into rediae
in snails
1857+ Pasteur showed that a bacterial ferment soured milk and that yeasts or mould s
were necessary for the making of wine from grapes
1859 Virchow discovered adult Trichinella spiralis in the gut of a dog after feeding it
with trichinous meat
1860 Zenker discovered adult Trichinella spiralis in the bowel at the post-morte m
examination of a young woman who had died of a typhoidal illness after recently
eating trichinous pork
1860 Küchenmeister repeated his experime nt on a condemned murderer. The incubation
period was several months and this time he recovered Taenia solium tapeworms
up to 1.5 m long
1861 Pasteur showed that air contained bacteria which caused putrefaction in steril e
infusions
1862 Leuckart fed Taenia saginata proglottids to calves and generated Cysticercus
bovis
1865 Leuckart and his students swallo wed Enterobius vermicularis eggs and developed
patent infections
1867 Leuckart generated hydatid cysts in pigs after feeding them with Echinococcus
granulosus ova
1870 Oliver may have produced a patent Taenia saginata infection in a human afte r
feeding Cysticercus bovis to a man
1870 Fedchenko reported that Dracunculus medinensis larvae developed with the body
of Cyclops (crustacean)
1877 Perroncito recovered an adult Taenia saginata from a human 4 months afte r
ingestion of Cysticercus bovis
1877 Manson discovered that Wuchereria bancrofti microfilariae metamorphosed i n
certain mosquitoes
1881 Thomas and Leuckart independently discovered that Lymnaea snails were the
intermediate hosts of Fasciola hepatica
1881-3 Braun showed that certain freshwater fish were the second intermediate hosts of
Diphyllobothrium latum by feeding infected fish to dogs and humans the n
recovering adult worms
1886 Calandruccio produced a patent infection with Trichuris trichiura in himself after
swallowing eggs
1886 Leichtenstern produced patent infections with hookworm in humans afte r
administering infective larvae orally
1887 Grassi showed that Hymenolepis nana could be transmitted directly from on e
definitive host to another
1889 Grassi and Rovelli reported that Dipylidium caninum larvae developed in fleas
1892 Grassi and Rovelli showed that Hymenolepis diminuta developed in a variety of
arthropod intermediate hosts
72 A History of Human Helminthology
1892 Lutz fed Fasciola cysts to guinea pigs then recovered adult flukes
1897 Wilms infected a human by administering Strongyloides stercoralis larvae orally
1898 Looss first claimed that hookworm infective larvae penetrated the intact skin
1900 Low reported thatWuchereria bancrofti infective larvae were found in th e
mouthparts of mosquitoes that had been filariated by Thomas Bancroft
1901 Looss showed by histological examination of an amputated leg that hookwor m
larvae applied before amputation penetrated the skin
1901-2 van Durme showed that Strongyloides larvae penetrated the skin
1907 Leiper recovered immature Dracunculus medinensis from a monkey 6 month s
after feeding it water containing infected Cyclops
1909 Fujinami and Nakamura demonstrated that Schistosoma japonicum infection in
cows was acquired via the skin
1911 Looss reported the development of a patent hookworm infection 71 days afte r
percutaneous infection of a human
1911 Yokogawa discovered that trout were the second intermediate hosts o f
Metagonimus yokogawai
1911 Kobayashi recovered adult Clonorchis sinensis from the biliary system of cat s
after feeding them with fish infected with certain encysted, immature flukes
1913 Leiper reported that tabanid flies ( Chrysops) were the vectors of Loa loa
1913 Miyairi and Suzuki discovered that Oncomelania snails were the intermediat e
hosts of Schistosoma japonicum , described the larval stages of the parasite, and
recovered adult worms from mice infected percutaneously with cercariae released
from these snails
1913 One out of five persons given infected Cyclops to drink by Turkhud develope d
dracunculiasis one year later
1914 Fülleborn showed that Strongyloides stercoralis larvae applied to the ski n
developed into adult worms in the gut of dogs
1914 Nakagawa showed that crabs of the genus Potamon were the second intermediate
hosts of Paragonimus westermani
1915 Onji and Nishio found that certain fishes were the second intermediate hosts o f
Heterophyes heterophyes
1915 Leiper and colleagues showed that miracidia from terminal-spined egg s
(Schistosoma haematobium) developed in Bulinus snails, described the
intermediate stages, then recovered adult worms after infecting mic e
percutaneously with cercariae obtained from these mice
1916 Leiper proved that miracidia derived from lateral-spined eggs developed i n
Biomphalaria snails and were a different species ( S. mansoni)
1917 Muto reported that Semisulcospira snails were the first intermediate hosts o f
Metagonimus
1917 Ciurea discovered that certain fishes were the second intermediate hosts o f
Opisthorchis felineus
1917 Janicki and Rosen discovered that certain crustaceans ( Cyclops) were the first
intermediate hosts of Diphyllobothrium latum
1917-19 Ando, Kobayashi, Miyairi, Nakagawa and Y okogawa all concluded independently
that Melania (= Semisulcospira) snails were the first intermediate hosts o f
Paragonimus
1918 Muto showed that Bithynia (= Parafossarulus) snails were the primar y
intermediate hosts of C. sinensis
1921 Nakagawa reported that Segmentina snails were the first intermediate hosts o f
Fasciolopsis buski
1922 Nakagawa showed that Fasciolopsis cercariae escaped from the snails an d
encysted on grass, then fed them to dogs and recovered adult worms
1922 Connal and Connal provided detailed descriptions of the development of Loa loa
Origin and Migration of Worms 73
in Chrysops
1926 Blacklock discovered that Simulium blackflies were the vectors of Onchocerca
volvulus
1927 Dyce Sharp showed that Culicoides midges were the vectors of Mansonella
perstans
1928 Asada described the snail intermediate host of Heterophyes heterophyes
1931 Cameron observed that certain snails were intermediate hosts of Dicrocoelium
dendriticum
1933 Buckley found that Culicoides was the vector of Mansonella ozzardi
1934 Vogel found that Bithynia snails were the first intermediate hosts of Opisthorchis
felineus
1936 Prommas and Daengsvang described the first and second intermediate hosts o f
Gnathostoma spinigerum
1949 Chardome and Peel showed that Culicoides was the vector of Mansonella
streptocerca
1952 Krull and Mapes showed that Dicrocoelium dendriticum larvae encysted in certain
ants
1953 Edeson and his colleagues infected a human with Brugia pahangi using Mansonia
mosquitoes
1955 Mackerras and Sandars reported that slugs were the intermediate hosts o f
Angiostrongylus cantonensis
1966 Wykoff and colleagues described the first and second intermediate hosts o f
Opisthorchis viverrini
1968 Orihel and Pachecho produced patent infections in monkeys with B. malayi
1971 Morera and Ash described the slug vector of Angiostrongylus costaricensis
1972 Cross and his colleagues found that Capillaria philippinensis infection was
acquired by ingesting infected fish
1975 Orihel and Moore transmitted Loa loa to subhuman primates
1979 Cross and his colleagues successfully infected monkeys with Wuchereria
bancrofti
___________________________________________________________________
74 A History of Human Helminthology
Chapter 3
TRADITIONAL REMEDIES
Men have undoubtedly tried to rid themselves of worms infecting their bodies
for almost as long as they have recognized them. As discussed elsewhere in this
book, only a very small number of parasitic helminths were known during most
of recorded history. These were certain visible worms that enjoyed a wide
geographical distribution and were extruded from time to time from the
gastrointestinal tract, i.e. tapeworm proglottids or segments (Taenia and
Diphyllobothrium species), the common roundworm (Ascaris lumbricoides)
and the pinworm or threadworm (Enterobius vermicularis). In addition, Guinea
worm (Dracunculus medinensis) was found in certain restricted localities but
its verminous nature was a matter of some controversy.
Most attention, therefore, was paid to the common intestinal worms. Plants
were the major therapeutic sources. Herbal products that were believed to have
specific vermicidal or vermifugal properties were often combined with
purgatives (to flush the worms out) and various sweeteners or diluents. In the
Egyptian Papyrus Ebers (c.1500 BC), for example, castor oil and senna were
recommended as purgatives and anthelmintics were often administered together
with honey, sweet beer or dates126. While it is true that certain preparations did
have some therapeutic efficacy, the coincident, spontaneous passage of
senescent worms often led to anthelmintic properties being ascribed erroneously
to many concoctions.
The development of herbal products depended upon the local botanical flora
with the result that different remedies tended to develop in different parts of the
world. Nevertheless, in some instances, the same or related plants were used
over wide geographical areas. Thus, the pomegranate (Punica granatum) was
utilized in countries ranging from Egypt to China. For convenience, however,
major traditional remedies are reviewed in relation to different regions of the
globe.
Many different anthelmintics were used in the countries abutting the Med-
iterranean Sea in the centuries before the birth of Christ. The Egyptian
75
76 A History of Human Helminthology
Papyrus Ebers (c.1500 BC) mentions various purgatives such as castor oil,
colocynth and senna as well as specific vermifuges such as pomegranate 126.
Clay tablets found in the library of Asur-bani-pal (c.650 BC) in Assyria refer to
mint, coriander seeds, onion, colocynth, myrrh, turpentine, pomegranate and
cassia as anthelmintics79. These agents, as well as extracts of Artemisia, acacia
gum, anise seed, fennel, garlic, mulberry, olive oil, pepper, scammony seed,
spearmint and male fern root found their way into the materia medica of
ancient Greece and Rome. Extraordinarily complicated combinations of drugs
and directions for their administration were evolved. Thus, Celsus (c.25 AD)
wrote:
For the flat worms, there should be given as draughts, a decoction of lupins, or of
mulberry bark, to which may be added, after pounding, either hyssop or a vinegar
cupful of pepper, or a little scammony. Alternatively, on one day let him eat a quantity
of garlic and vomit, then on the next day take a handful of fine pomegranate roots,
crush them and boil them in a litre and a half of water down to one-third, to this add
a little soda, and drink it on an empty stomach. At three hours interval, let him take two
further draughts; but with the addition of half a pint of sea water or strong brine; then
on going to stool, sit over a basin of hot water. Again, for the roundworms...., both the
same remedies may be given and some milder ones, such as pounded-up seeds of
nettles or of cabbage or of cummin in water, or mint in the same of a decoction of
worm-wood or hyssop in hydromel or cress-seeds pounded up in vinegar. It is also of
service either to eat lupin or garlic, or administer into the lower bowel a clyster of olive
oil.28
Many of these drugs maintained their popularity over the next two thousand
years.
Pomegranate
The roots or bark of the pomegranate (Punica granatum) have been used as an
anthelmintic for millenia. Perhaps the earliest record is in the Egyptian Papyrus
Ebers:
to kill roundworm: root of pomegranate 5 ro (1 ro = 15 ml), water 10 ro, remains
during the night in the dew, is strained and taken in one day.126
Pomegranate continued to be popular with the physicians of ancient Greece and
Rome for the treatment of both roundworm and tapeworm infections and was
still being recommended around 1,000 AD by the Arabian, Avicenna6.
Nevertheless, pomegranate bark was little valued in northern Europe until the
beginning of the nineteenth century when the Englishman, Buchanan, introduced
it from the the East Indies. The alkaloid, pelleterine, was isolated as the active
principle26 and pomegranate decoctions remained a standard remedy until well
into the twentieth century.
from the powdered rhizomes of Dryoptera filix mas. These plants are spread
widely throughout the northern hemisphere. The efficacy of this extract in the
treatment of tapeworm infections was recorded long ago by the Greek,
Theophrastus of Eresus (370-c.285 BC) who wrote:
Of male fern, no part but the root is useful and it has a sweet astringent taste. It expels
the flat worm. It has no seed nor juice; and they say it is ripe for cutting in the
autumn.165
Likewise, the Roman, Pliny (23-79 AD), recommended powdered root of male
fern as an anthelmintic24. Filix mas has maintained its popularity in one form or
another for centuries. One classic example of its use was as the major
constituent of Madame Nouffer's "Tapeworm Cure" in the late eighteenth
century. The French king, Louis XVI, was somewhat peeved to find this in 1776
after he had handed over 18,000 francs for the formula. Madame Nouffer's
technique was described by Davaine46. Three drachms of the pulverized root in
four ounces of infusion were administered followed by a bolus of calomel,
scammony and gamboge after two hours. When vomiting occurred, the remedy
was repeated and strong coffee was given to prevent sickness. If the worm was
not fully expelled in four hours, an ounce of magnesium sulphate in warm water
was then drunk.
The general practice was to collect rhizomes of the plant in autumn, free them
from roots and dead parts, then soak them in ether for 48 hours. This was then
filtered out, leaving a dry, oily residue, oil of aspidium. Male fern was added to
the British Pharmacopoeia in 1863. Beginning with the work of Boehm in
1897 14 , a number of phloroglucinol compounds have been isolated as active
principles. The major anthelmintic constituent is filicic acid (= filicin)26. Male
fern remained popular in the treatment of tapeworm infections until more
effective and less toxic drugs became available in the middle of the twentieth
century.
Semen-contra-vermes (Santonin)
Chrysanthemum
Tin
Metallic tin has been used to treat tapeworm infections for centuries. Their use
was praised by Paracelsus (1493-1541) 127 and tin filings were commonly
prescribed until the first half of the nineteenth century. This was somewhat
dangerous, however, as tin preparations often contained traces of lead or arsenic
that led to poisoning. "Cestodin", a combination of metallic tin, tin oxide and tin
chloride was used until recent years.
AFRICA
Kousso (kosso)
Tapeworm infections have been particularly common for many years among
people living in Ethiopia as a result of the habit of eating raw beef. Con-
sequently, there was also considerable interest in that country in developing
taenicides. The most popular of these was kousso which was derived from the
blood-red flowers and seeds of the tree Hagenia abyssinica (= Banksia abyss-
inica = Brayera anthelmintica). One of the earliest records of its use is the
indication by a sixteenth century monk that Bitole, the fourth Golla chief,
adopted the habit of taking it during his term of office from 1546-1554 124.
The drug attracted the attention of Spanish and Portuguese Jesuit missionaries
in the early seventeenth century. They observed that it was prepared by steeping
a handful of seeds of flowers in two quarts of beer all night then the bitter potion
was drunk in the morning. Little interest in this preparation was shown in
Europe, however, until the Frenchman, Dr Brayer, publicized its effectiveness
in the 1820's125. In 1845, his compatriot, Rochet d'Héricourt brought enough
drug for 40,000 doses to Paris. Its effectiveness was confirmed by several
French medical authorities and it became popular not only in France but also in
Anthelmintics 79
Britain. A major problem initially was its expense but, with increasing
availability, its price fell. Kousso was finally given a place in the British
Pharmacopoeia in 1863. The active principles were identified as phloroglucinol
derivatives, kosin and kosotoxin, related to filicic acid of male fern26. Its
popularity waned in Europe in the latter part of the nineteenth century but it is
still widely used in Ethiopia today.
ASIA
Betel nuts are seeds of the palm, Areca catechu, which is widespread in
southern and eastern Asia. According to Liu102, the chewing of betel nut has
been practised for at least 1400 years and has built up a reputation as a
taeniafuge. It may also be administered in the form of a decoction obtained from
the dried, powdered nut. Such a technique is described by Sun Szu-Miao in the
T'ang dynasty (c.650 AD):
Grind 14 pieces of Ping-lang (Areca catechu) into powder and sift. Then boil the shells
of Ping-lang in 2.5 sheng of water until half a sheng of the liquid is left. After filtration,
put the powder into the liquid. Drink the solution from time to time and lie in bed and
keep warm. The worms will come out.159
The active principle is the alkaloid, arecoline26.
Kamala
Kamala is a resin derived from the glands and hairs covering the fruits of
Mallotus philippinensis (= Rotteria tinctoria) which is widespread in Asia and
has been used as a folk remedy for centuries. It became popular in Europe for
the treatment of tapeworm in the nineteenth century and was entered into the
British Pharmacopoeia in 1863, decoctions being prepared in alcohol. Like male
fern and kousso, the active constituents are ploroglucodins such as rottlerine
which paralyse the cestodes26. Its popularity waned with the appearance of more
efficient agents in the twentieth century.
THE AMERICAS
Pumpkin seeds
Oil of chenopodium
The most widely used indigenous plant anthelmintic from the Americas is oil of
chenopodium derived from Chenopodium ambrosioides, popularly known as
American wormseed, Mexican teak, Jerusalem oak and "epazote" or "paico"89.
This aromatic herb is found as an annual weed in locations varying from
Argentina in the south to Canada in the north. Archaeological and ethnological
studies suggest that it has been used for many centuries. Wild plants have been
found growing in association with long-abandoned Pueblo ruins while the
pre-Columbian Maya of Yucatan in Mexico called it "lucum xiu" meaning
"worm-plant"139. The plant was illustrated in a sixteenth century codex
concerned with the Aztecs49. In the early eighteenth century, Peter Kalm
(1715-1779), a Swedish botanist and traveller, reported that it was used by both
the indigenous inhabitants as well as European settlers in the American colonies
for the treatment of Ascaris 83. In 1723, plants were taken to Europe, cultivated
widely, and were soon in common use. The leaves, seeds and flowering tops
have all been used to produce decoctions. The extracted oil of chenopodium,
usually prepared by boiling, became the common form of the drug throughout
the nineteenth century and during the first half of the twentieth century. The
active principle, ascaridol, a volatile terpene, was isolated and eventually
synthesized 27.
Although Baumler (1881) and Breton (1905) in the United States of America
had tried oil of chenopodium without success in ancylostomiasis, Bruning
began to use it successfully in 190917 then this was confirmed by Schüffner152.
In view of its easy availability and cheapness, oil of chenopodium was employed
with considerable success by the Rockefeller Foundation in hookworm
campaigns in the Dutch East Indies (Indonesia), Malaya (Malaysia) and Fiji in
the 1920's and then in Brazil in the 1930's. Toxic reactions including
gastrointestinal upsets, headache, deafness, tachycardia and rarely death were
recognized with increasing frequency, however, and this together with the
development of other safe, effective anthelmintics led to its official aban-
donment. Moreover, a recent study of traditional village use of Chenopodium
extracts has cast doubts on its efficacy89. Nevertheless, it continues to be used
by millions of urban and rural people in the third world for the treatment of
intestinal worm infections.
Leche de higueron
The inhabitants of equatorial South America and Central America have long
used the sap of the figs, Ficus glabrata and F. laurifolia, as an anthelmintic.
The milky fluid (latex) has been called leche de higueron or lait d'higueron.
Wucherer remarked in 1866 that it was effective in the treatment of hookworm
infection180 then in 1912 Berrio reported that it was useful for trichuriasis 12. The
active principle, ficin, is a protease related to papain27.
82 A History of Human Helminthology
Mechanical irritants
Stannum purum et granulatum (tin)
Purgatives
Salina, Glaubers, ammonia etc. (Glaubers' salts etc)
Olea expressa
Olea ricina (castor oil from Ricinus species)
Oleum nucum
Scammoneum (scammony from Convolvulus scammonia)
Helleborum (hellebore from Helleborus species)
True anthelmintics
Stizolobium (from cowhage, Macuna pruriens)
Aqua frigida (ice water)
Oleum Chaberti (Chabert's oil)
Oleum animali Dippelis
Oleum terebinthicae (turpentine from Pistacia terebinthus)
Petroleum
Oleum cajeputi (from Melaleuca)
Camphora (from Camphora officinarum = Laurus camphora)
Artemisiae judaicae sive cinae semen (semen-contra-vermes)
Tanaceti vulgaris semina
Helminthocorton
Goeffroeae surinamensis cortex (bark of Geoffroea surinamensis)
Polypodii (Aspidii) filicis maris radix (root of male fern)
Spigelias
____________________________________________________________________
NINETEENTH CENTURY
One major advance in the chemotherapy of helminth infections was made during
the first quarter of the twentieth century. This was the discovery that antimony
compounds when administered intravenously were effective in the treatment of
schistosomiasis. In addition, a number of other compounds with some
anthelmintic efficacy were described.
Antimonials
Betanaphthol
Bismuth
Bismuth carbonate was used by Loeper in 1921 for the treatment of enterobiasis
but did not enjoy wide favour104.
Carbon tetrachloride
The pace of discovery quickened considerably during the second quarter of the
twentieth century. These drugs influenced many helminth infections and ranged
from the introduction of tetrachlorethylene in the treatment of hookworm
infection to the use of lucanthone for the therapy of schistosomiasis and
diethylcarbamazine for filariasis.
Arsenicals
Chloroquine
Diethylcarbamazine
In 1947, Hewitt and his colleagues showed that the piperazine derivative,
diethylcarbamazine, was active against Litomosoides carinii in cotton rats and
against Dirofilaria immitis in dogs76. This anthelmintic was the result of a
research programme initiated because of the large number of American veterans
who had acquired filariasis during World War II. Later in the same year,
Santiago-Stevenson described the use of diethylcarbamazine in humans with
bancroftian filariasis and noted that it produced a dramatic fall in the numbers
of circulating microfilariae144. Subsequent observations, however, revealed that
these effects were not sustained. Within a year or two, a number of investigators
reported that diethylcarbamazine produced some clinical improvement in
patients with loiasis154,156. The majority of these patients did not have
microfilaraemia, however, and it took some little time for it to become clear that
the reduction in microfilaraemia was transient. Likewise, the effects of
diethylcarbamazine in onchocerciasis were soon examined. In 1948, Mazzotti
and Hewitt found some reduction in the numbers of microfilariae in the skin
after diethylcarbamazine treatment but observed living adult worms in extirp-
ated nodules113. Mazzotti then noted that microfilarial numbers in the skin built
up again to pre-treatment levels over the next few months112. In contrast to all
of these conditions, Danaraj in 1958 observed that the ill-defined filarial
infection, tropical pulmonary eosinophilia, responded dramatically and perm-
anently to diethylcarbamazine treatment45.
Although diethylcarbamazine has been used primarily in filarial infections,
it has also been used for the treatment of gastrointestinal nematode infections.
Hewitt and colleagues in 1948 observed that it was effective in canine ascar-
iasis77 then in the following year Oliver-Gonzalez and others showed that it was
reasonably effective in humans infected with Ascaris lumbricoides 120. While
diethylcarbamazine was thought to be moderately valuable in ancylostomiasis 44,
it was noted to be ineffective in enterobiasis 105.
stercoralis infective larvae in vitro 91. In 1928, de Langen reported that oral
administration of gentian violet in conjunction with intravenous injection of
tartar emetic was effective in strongyloidiasis 97 but in the following year he
acknowledged that his patients had relapsed98. Faust, on the basis of exper-
iments in monkeys, believed that adult worms were killed in situ 56 then in 1932
claimed that 95% of patients were cured by oral gentian violet57. Palmer123 gave
gentian violet by slow intravenous injection in this condition then Schreiber 151
extolled its value when given by duodenal intubation. Nevertheless, the
preponderance of opinion was that the drug was of little value in the treatment
of strongyloidiasis.
Wright and Bray in 1938 used gentian violet for the treatment of entero-
biasis179 but much more effective drugs are now available.
Hexylresorcinol
Lucanthone (miracil D, nilodin) was the first schistosomicidal drug which was
metal-free and orally active. Its efficacy in experimental schistosomiasis was
first shown by Kikuth and colleagues during World War II2 then this was
reported several years later88. Experimental and clinical studies indicated that
it was most active against Schistosoma haematobium, less active against S.
mansoni and had little effect on S. japonicum. It was shown eventually by Rosi
and co-workers that the active form was an hydroxymethyl derivative now
known as hycanthone138. This drug was then used clinically as hycanthone
methanesulphonate (etrenol)35. Concern was expressed about possible muta-
genic effects, however, and it was eventually replaced by more effective and less
toxic agents.
Phenothiazine
Piperazine (diethylenediamine)
In 1942, Giroud noted that a patient infected with Enterobius was cured when
treated with piperazine. This observation was taken up by Mehrez who in 1947
confirmed its effectiveness 115. Two years later, Fayard described its efficacy in
ascariasis58. This drug was so superior to all previously available agents for the
treatment of ascariasis and enterobiasis that Bueding and Swartzwelder in
195718 considered its discovery to be one of the most important turning points
in development of the chemotherapy of helminthiasis. Piperazine was prepared
in a number of forms including the hydrate, citrate, adipate and phosphate
compounds. Piperazines were shown rapidly to be ineffective in the other major
intestinal nematode infections but they are still widely used in many countries
as inexpensive, popular anthelmintics.
Suramin (antrypol)
Tetrachlorethylene
Bephenium
In 1958, Copp and his colleagues reported the discovery of quaternary ammon-
ium compounds effective against intestinal nematodes; of these, bephenium was
the most interesting37. In the same year, the drug was reported to be an effective
agent against Ancylostoma caninum and Toxocara canis in dogs and T. cati in
felines21 then was shown to be superior to tetrachlorethylene in the treatment of
human ancylostomiasis 66,184. Moreover, the drug was noted to be effective also
against Ascaris lumbricoides 66 and to be variably effective in
trichostrongyliasis 68 and heterophyiasis117 but ineffective in enterobiasis and
strongyloidiasis.
Bithiniol
Dichlorophene
Dithiazanine
Hetol (chloxyl)
Hexachlorophene
Metrifonate
Niclosamide
Niridazole
82
and least active against S. japonicum 145. Niridazole held pride of place in the
treatment of urinary schistosomiasis for a short period but has now been largely
displaced by less toxic drugs, especially praziquantel.
Oxamniquine
In 1973, Foster and colleagues reported that oxamniquine was active against
Schistosoma mansoni in rodents and monkeys although it was inactive against
S. haematobium and S. japonicum 60. In the same year, Katz and his colleagues
tested the efficacy of the drug when given by oral and intramuscular routes to
humans with schistosomiasis in Brazil and observed that the latter route was
preferable85. Subsequent studies indicated that oxamniquine was more active
against South American than African strains of S. mansoni 162.
Oxantel
Paromomycin
Pyrantel
Stilbazium
Thiabendazole was introduced in 1961 when Brown and his colleagues showed
that this agent had broadspectrum activity against intestinal nematodes in pigs
and horses15. Later that year, Gordon indicated that it was highly effective
against nematode infections of the gastrointestinal tract of sheep67. The drug was
then tried in human infections and was found to be variably effective in
ascariasis81, enterobiasis54 , ancylostomiasis81,173 and strongyloidiasis 61,173
but
inactive in trichuriasis.
Mebendazole was introduced in 1971 by Brugmans and colleagues who
showed that it was effective in enterobiasis16. It was soon noted to be also active
in ascariasis 64,129, trichuriasis64,129 , ancylostomiasis8,64 , trichostrongyliasis3 and
capillariasis 155 but to be of doubtful efficacy in strongyloidiasis. In addition,
mebendazole was shown to be of some value in intestinal taeniasis87,119. Sub-
sequently, experimental studies in animals suggested that it may be of value in
echinococcosis 75 then it was used with partial success in humans with hydatid
infections by Bekhti and colleagues in 197710.
The activity of albendazole against certain trematode, cestode and nematode
infections in animals was described by Théodoridès and colleagues in 1976164.
It was shown to be effective in a number of human gastrointestinal nematode
infections including enterobiasis, ascariasis, trichuriasis and ancylostomiasis by
Pene and co-workers in 1981130 but to be of variable effectiveness in
strongyloidiasis 38. More recently, it has been suggested that albendazole may be
better than mebendazole in the treatment of infections with Echinococcus
granulosus and E. multilocularis 128.
Cambendazole was used in strongyloidiasis with good effect by Martirani and
Rodrigues in 1976111 but the drug has since been withdrawn from the market.
Flubendazole, a fluorine analogue of mebendazole, was reported to have
similar activity to that compound by Schenone and colleagues 149.
92 A History of Human Helminthology
Viprynium (Pyrvinium)
Viprynium pamoate is a cyanine dye. In 1953, both Hales and Welch69 and
Weston and others178 showed that it had anthelmintic activities in animals. It was
then shown in the same year to be of some value in human hookworm infection
by Perez-Santiago and colleagues131 but its main role came to be in the treatment
of enterobiasis.
The last quarter of the twentieth century is only halfway through but already
two valuable new drugs, ivermectin and praziquantel, have appeared.
Ivermectin
Praziquantel
CONCLUSION
It is only fifty years since the sulphonamides first appeared then penicillin
ushered in the dawn of antibiotic therapy of bacterial infections. In that short
time, a variety of antibiotics have been developed for the treatment of the vast
majority of bacterial infections. In contrast, cures for worms have been sought
Anthelmintics 93
for millenia. Although remarkable advances have been made in recent times,
many helminthiases, particularly nematode and cestode infections of the tissues,
remain refractory to therapy. They offer a continuing challenge for
parasitologists, pharmacologists and physicians.
REFERENCES
pyrantel pamoate. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 18: 50-52, 1969
20. BUNNAG D, RADOMYOS P, HARINASUTA T. Field trial on the treatment of fasciol-
opsiasis with praziquantel. Southeast Asian Journal of Tropical Medicine and Public Health
14: 216-219, 1983
21. BURROWS RB. The anthelmintic effect of bephenium on Ancylostoma caninum. Journal
of Parasitology 44: 607-610, 1958
22. BURROWS RB, HUNT GR, LILLIS WG. A new series of pyridines with anthelmintic
activity. Journal of Parasitology 47: Supplement, 35-46, 1961
23. BYLUND BG, BANG B, WIKGREEN K. Tests with a new compound (praziquantel)
against Diphyllobothrium latum. Journal of Helminthology 51: 115-119, 1977
24. CAIUS PLINIUS SECUNDUS. Historia naturalis, translated by J Bostock and H T Riley,
Bohn's Classical Library, six volumes, London, 1855-1857
25. CAMPBELL WC, BLAIR LS. Efficacy of avermectins against Dirofilaria immitis in dogs.
Journal of Helminthology 52: 308-310, 1978
26. de CARNERI I, VITA G. Drugs used in cestode diseases. In, International encyclopedia
of pharmacology and therapeutics, section 64, Chemotherapy of helminthiasis, R Cavier
and F Hawking (Editors), Pergamon Press, Oxford, volume 1, pp 145-213, 1973
27. CAVIER R. Chemotherapy of intestinal nematode diseases. In, International encyclopedia
of pharmacology and therapeutics, section 64, Chemotherapy of helminthiasis, R Cavier
and F Hawking (Editors), Pergamon Press, Oxford, volume 1, pp 215-436, 1973
28. CELSUS AC. De medicina, translated by WG Spencer, Loeb Classical Library, Hein-
emann, London, three volumes, 1948-1953
29. CERF J, LEBRUN A, DIERICH XJ. A new approach to helminthiasis control: the use of
an organophosphorus compound. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 11:
514-517, 1962
30. CHANG CHUNG-CHING. (Synopsis of the golden chest.) In, Chung-Ching's complete
work. About 217 AD. In Chinese, partly translated in 78
31. CHRISTOPHERSON JB. The successful use of antimony in bilharziasis administered as
intravenous injections of antimony tartaratum (tartar emetic). Lancet ii: 325-327, 1918
32. CHUNG HL, CH'EN C, HOU TC. Preliminary observations on efficacy of chloroquine in
treatment of paragonimiasis. Chinese Medical Journal 72: 1-14, 1954
33. CHUNG HL, K'O HY, TS'AO WC, HSU CP. Hexachloroparaxylol as a new specific
remedy for curing paragonimiasis in cats and man. Chinese Medical Journal 85: 756-759,
1965
34. CHUNG HL, TS'AO WC, HSU HC, KUO CH, K'O HY, MO PS, CHANG HY, CHUO
HT, CHOU WH. Hexachlorophene (G.11) as a new specific drug against Clonorchis
sinensis. Chinese Medical Journal 82: 691-701, 1963
35. CLARKE V de V, BLAIR DM, WEBER MC. Field trials of hycanthone (etrenol
Winthrop) in the treatment of urinary and intestinal bilharziasis. Central African Journal of
Medicine 15: 1-6, 1969
36. CLERICUS (LE CLERC) D. Historia naturalis et medica latorum lumbricorum intra hom-
inem et alia animalia, nascentia, Fratres de Tournes, Genevae, pp 449, 1715. A natural and
medicinal history of worms bred in the bodies of men and other animals etc., translated by
J Browne, printed for J Wilcox at the Green Dragon, Little Britain, pp 436, 1721
37. COPP FC, STANDEN OD, SCARNELL J, RAWES DA, BURROWS RB. A new series
of anthelmintics. Nature 181: 183, 1958
38. COULAUD JP, DELUOL AM, CENAC J, ROSSIGNOL JF. L'albendazole dans le
traitement de la strongyloidose. À propos de 66 observations. Bulletin de la Société de
Pathologie Exotique 75: 530-533, 1982
39. COULAUD JP, LARIVIÈRE M, AZIZ MA, GERVAIS MC, GAXOTTE P, DELUOL
A M, CENAC J. Ivermectin in onchocerciasis. Lancet i: 526-527, 1984
40. CRAIGE AH, KLECKER AL. Taenicical action of di-phentane-70. North American
Veterinarian 27: 26-30, 1946
41. CULBERTSON JT. Experimental chemotherapy of filariasis. Transactions of the Royal
Anthelmintics 95
and treatment with hexylresorcinol. China Medical Journal 51: 937-944, 1937
109. MANSON-BAHR P. Phenothiazine as an anthelmintic. Lancet ii: 808-809, 1940
110. MAPLESTONE PA, MUKERJI AK. Hexylresorcinol as an anthelmintic. Indian Medical
Gazette 67: 610-612, 1932
111. MARTIRANI PA, RODRIGUES LD. Ensaio clinico com o cambendazole, uma nova
droga na terapeutica anti-helmintica (nota previa). Revista do Instituto de Medicine
Tropical de São Paulo 18: 71-75, 1976
112. MAZZOTTI L. Estudio ucerca del tratamiento de la oncocercosis. Medicina, Mexico 29:
1-5, 1949
113. MAZZOTTI L, HEWITT R. Tratamiento de la oncocercosis por el cloruro de 1-dietil-
carbamil-4-metilpiperazine (Hetrazan). Medicina, Mexico 28: 39-42, 1948
114. MAZZOTTI L, MENDEZ D. El difentano-70 en el tratamiento de la teniases. Revista del
Instituto de Salubridad y Enfermedades Tropicales (Mexico) 16: 9-14, 1956
115. MEHREZ R. Les nouveaux traitements de l'oxyurose. Thèse Méd. (Paris) No. 546, 1947
116. NAGAHANA M, YOSHIDA Y, MATSUNO K, KONDO K. Treatment of Taenia
saginata and Diphyllobothrium latum infections with bithiniol. American Journal of
Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 15: 351-354, 1966
117. NAGATY HF, KHALIL HW. Bephenium hydroxynaphthoate against Heterophyes het-
erophyes infections. Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 64: 263, 1961
118. NEGHME RA. The effect of acridine (mepacrine) on tapeworms. Revista Chilena de Hist.
Nat. 43: 97-99, 1939
119. de OLIVEIRA GOMES ME. The treatment of taeniasis with mebandazole. Folha Médica
66: 87-95, 1973
120. OLIVER-GONZALEZ J, SANTIAGO-STEVENSON D, HEWITT R. Treatment of six
cases of ascariasis in man with 1-diethylcarbamyl 4-methylpiperazine hydrochloride.
Southern Medical Journal 42: 65, 1949
121. OTTO GF, MAREN TH. Filaricidal activity of substituted phenyl arsenoxides. Science
106: 105-107, 1947
122. OTTO GF, MAREN TH. Studies on chemotherapy of filariasis. American Journal of
Hygiene 50: 92-141, 1949
123. PALMER ED. A note on the treatment of strongyloidiasis with intravenous gentian violet.
American Journal of Tropical Medicine 30: 91-92, 1950
124. PANKHURST R. The traditional taenicides of Europe. Journal of the History of Medicine
24: 323-334, 1969
125. PANKHURST R. Europe's discovery of the Ethiopian taenicide - kosso. Medical History
23: 297-313, 1979
126. PAPYROS EBERS. Das hermetische Buch über die Arzneimittel der alten Aegypter in
hieratischer Schrift. Herausgegeben, mit Inhalsangabe und Einleitung versehen von Georg
Ebers. Mit hieroglyphische-latineischen Glossar von Ludwig Stern, two volumes, Leipzig,
1875. The Papyrus Ebers, translated from the German version by CP Bryan, Geoffrey
Bles, London, pp 167, 1930
127. PARACELSUS. De natura rerum liber primus de generationibus rerum naturalium;
Saemtliche Werke, K Sudhoff (Editor), München und Berlin, 14 volumes, 1922-1923
128. PAWLOWSKI Z. Chemotherapy of human echinococcosis. Proceedings of XII
Congresco Internacional de Hidatologia, pp 346-347, 1985
129. PEÑA CHAVARRIA A, SWARTZWELDER JC, VILLAREJOS VM, ZELEDÓN R.
Mebendazole, an effective broad-spectrum anthelmintic. American Journal of Tropical
Medicine and Hygiene 22: 592-593, 1973
130. PENE P, VICENTELLI JM, SOULA G, BOURDERIOUX CH, ROSSIGNOL JF. Le
zentel (albendazole) dans le traitement des nématodoses intestinales. Étude multicentrique
en Afrique de l'Ouest. À propos de 390 observations. Médecine d'Afrique Noire 28:
483-485, 1981
131. PEREZ-SANTIAGO E, OLIVER-GONZALEZ J, THILLET CJ. The effect of cyanine
dye on infections with hookworm and trichuris in man. American Journal of Tropical
Anthelmintics 99
153. SEATON DR. A short way with Taenia saginata. Lancet i: 808-809, 1956
154. SHOOKHOFF HB, DWORK KG. Treatment of Loa loa infections with hetrazan.
American Journal of Tropical Medicine 29: 589-593, 1949
155. SINGSON CN, BANZON TC, CROSS JH. Mebendazole in the treatment of intestinal
capillariasis. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 24: 932-934, 1975
156. STEFANOPOULO CJ, SCHNEIDER J. Essais de traitement de la filariose à F. loa par
la 1-diethylcarbamyl 4-methylpipérazine. Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances
de l'Académie de Biologie 142: 930-931, 1948
157. STEMMERMAN GN, NAKASONE N. Strongyloides stercoralis infestation:
malabsorption defect with reaction to dithiazanine iodide. Journal of the American Medical
Association 174: 1250-1253, 1960
158. STRAUB M. Tetrachloorkoulstofvergiftigi ng in twaalf gevallen. Geneeskundig Tijdschrift
vor Nederlandsch-Indië 65: 624-645, 1925
159. SUN SZU-MIAO (One thousand golden prescriptions.) About 650 AD. In Chinese, partly
translated in 78
160. SWARTZWELDER JC, FRYE WW, MUHLEISEN JP, MILLER JH, LAMPERT R,
PEÑA CHAVARRIA AA, ABADIE SH, ANTHONY SO, SAPPANFIELD RW.
Dithiazanine, an effective broad spectrum anthelmintic. Journal of the American Medical
Association 165: 2063-2067, 1957
161. SWARTZWELDER JC, MILLER JH, LAMPERT R, PEÑA CHAVARRIA A, ABADIE
SH, FRYE WW, MUHLEISEN P, LIZANO C. Anthelmintic activity of stilbazium iodide
(monopar) against intestinal nematodes in man. Journal of Parasitology 48: 29-30, 1962
162. SYMPOSIUM DE OXAMNIQUINE. Rio de Janeiro, Brasil, Junho, 1973. Revista do
Instituto de Medicina Tropical de São Paulo 15, supplement, pp 1-175, 1973
163. TALAAT SM, AMIN N, EL MASRY B. The treatment of bilharziasis and other intestinal
parasites with dipterex. A preliminary report of 100 cases. Journal of the Egyptian
Medical Association 46: 827-832, 1963
164. THEODORIDES VJ, GYURIK RJ, KINGSBURY WD, PARISH RC. Anthelmintic
activity of albendazole against liver flukes, lung and gastrointestinal roundworms.
Experientia 32: 702, 1976
165. THEOPHRASTUS. Enquiry into plants, translated by A F Horst, Loeb Classical Library,
Heinemann, London, two volumes, 1948-1949
166. THETFORD ND, OTTO GF, BROWN HW, MAREN TH. The use of phenyl arsenoxide
in the treatment of Wuchereria bancrofti infection. American Journal of Tropical Medicine
28: 577-583, 1948
167. THIENPONT D, BRUGMANS J, ABADI K, TANAMAL S. Tetramisole in the treat-
ment of nematode infestations in man. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and
Hygiene 18: 520-525, 1969
168. THIENPONT D, VAN PARIJS OF, RAEYMAKERS AH, DEMOEN PH,
ALLEVWIJN FT, MARSBOOM RP, NIEMEGEERS CJ, SCHELLEKENS KH,
JANSSEN PA. Tetramisole (R.8299), a new potent broad spectrum anthelmintic. Nature
209: 1084-1086, 1966
169. THOMAS H, GÖNNERT R, POHLKE R, SEUBERT J. A new compound against adult
tapeworms. Proceedings of the Seventh International Conference of the World Association
for the Advancement of Veterinary Parasitology, Thessaloniki, Abstract No. 51, 1975
170. THOORIS GC. Le traitement expérimental de la filariose à Wuchereria bancrofti en
Océanie française par la suramine (naphuride de sodium). Bulletin de la Société de Path-
ologie Exotique 49: 311-317, 1956
171. TYSON E. Lumbricus latus, or a discourse read before the Royal Society, of the joynted
worm etc. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society 13: 113-144, 1683
172. ULIVELLI A. Terapia antibiotica della teniasi (primi favorelli resulti del trattamento con
paromomicina). Revista di Clinica Pediatrica 72: 371-383, 1963
173. VILELA M de P, RODRIGUES LD, CAPELL JI, BRANDAO JA, MARTIRANI I,
ZACATO M. O emprego di tiabendazole no tratamento de estrongiloidiase de outras
Anthelmintics 101
SYNOPSIS
IN ANIMALS
The name of the person who first found liver flukes and knowledge of when the
observation was made have been lost in the sands of time. The flukes wer e
probably found independently by numerous people in diverse places over many
years. The first recorded reference to these worms was made by a Frenchman,
Jean de Brie, in 1379. de Brie, who was known as "Le bon berger", meaning
"The good shepherd", had been commissioned by Charles V of France to write
a treatise on the proper management of sheep and the production of wool .
Although he did not describe the morphology of the parasite, was uncertain of
its precise nature, and appears to have been somewhat confused as to whether
the worms were the cause of, or the consequence of sheep rot, there is littl e
103
104 A History of Human Helminthology
flounder), colour, the transparent skin and discussed its motion. He was rather
confused about parts of the internal anatomy, however, giving the wor m
non-existent eyes, liver, heart and circulatory system. Nevertheless, he di d
discern correctly a bowel, discovered eggs, and recognized that the creature s
were hermaphroditic. Concerning the ova, he recounted that he had found:
an innumerable quantity of oval particles, hundreds of which, taken together, are not
equal to the size of a grain of sand. They are of a pale red colour, and I take them to
be the spawn or eggs.8
and with respect to the sexuality of the flukes, he noted:
Notwithstanding my most diligent examination of these creatures, I could never
discover any difference of the sexes; and its seem to me most probable that they are of
that species called Hermaphrodites, or everyone equally prolifick. 8
Even though Fasciola had been known for many years, there was an imperfect
perception of its structure and confusion as to its zoological position. Thus ,
Gabucinus, Redi, Malpighi and Borel seem to have equated the fluke wit h
cucurbitini (Taenia), while Bonamicus, Fromann and Wepfer regarded it as a
kind of leech. In fact, Linnaeus appears at various times to have considered it as
a leech, a planarian, and a cestod e. More than 100 years were to pass before the
details of the fluke's anatomy were worked out correctly by a number o f
investigators including Mehlis (1831) 56, Emile Blanchard, Rudolf Leuckart ,
Sommer and Macé.
IN HUMANS
Although this fluke had been found many times in animals, infection wa s
rarely recognized in humans. Passing references to human infection wer e
made in the seventeenth century. According to Clericus, Pierre Borel noted
that he had seen flukes, which he called insects, in all sorts of animal s
including humans and pigs, writing, "mihi asseruit in omnibus animalibu s
insecta haec reperiri et se in hominibus, porcis etc., eos vidisse" 11. Similarly,
Marcus Malpighi claimed that cucurbitine worms occurred frequently in th e
livers of humans and animals, especially in cattle and wrote: "In hepat e
frequentes occurent vermus cucurbitini in homine et brutis, praesertim i n
bove"53. Again, Bidloo recalled having seen, in human livers, worms similar to
those commonly encountered in the livers of sheep and cattle 8, while Wepfer
claimed to have often found the bile ducts of humans filled with "hirudinibus"
(leeches).
The first person to clearly describe finding these flukes in a human, however,
was Pallas who in 1760 recounted observing worms in the hepatic ducts of a
female patient during an autopsy in Berlin 66. He was followed a century later by
Bucholz in Weimar who found a large number of flukes in the gallbladder of a
convict who had died from a "putrid fever" 17. Although Bucholz's case wa s
accepted by Davaine 24, Küchenmeister46 noted that Bremser had later examined
some of the worms which had been preserved and thought that they were really
106 A History of Human Helminthology
NOMENCLATURE
Linnaeus at first regarded the fluke as a slug, but eventually created the genus
Fasciola in his group Intestina of his Class Vermes and named the parasit e
Fasciola hepatica in 175851. The generic name is derived from the Latin word
"fasciola" meaning "fillet" or "small b andage". Goeze believed that the organism
was a planarian and at one time called it Planaria latiuscula. In 1786, Retzius
needlessly changed the name of the genus to Distoma, meaning two openings
(as opposed to the Monostoma - worms with a single opening - and Polyostoma
- worms with multiple openings) 70,71, then Abildgaard designated the fluk e
Distoma hepatica 1. This nomenclature was followed by Zeder (1800) ,
Rudolphi (1808-1810) and Dujardin (1845), while Diesing (1849-1851) called
it Distomum hepaticum, with the result that the disease was known for man y
years as distomiasis. With the establishment of the law of priority i n
nomenclature in the early part o f this century, however, the Linnean designation
regained pride of place through Opinion 84 of the International Commission on
Zoological Nomenclature 41.
Early students of Fasciola suggested all manner of means by which the worms
were produced and propagated, ranging from generation by putrified o r
decaying substances to the eff ects of excessive wetness or heat. Bidloo in 1698,
however, no doubt girded by his discovery of eggs in the flukes, asserted tha t
these suggestions were but "ideal tales" and "senseless imaginations". He laid:
it down as a certain truth, that these, as well as other small living creatures, are
produced from their like, by the means of eggs, seed or spawn, according to the nature
implanted in them at their first creation.8
Bidloo thought it most probable that the worms bred in moist earth then were
swallowed together with their eggs in water by herbivorous animals such a s
sheep, stags, calves and wild boars. He did not believe, however, that the adult
worms forced their way from the gut into the gall bladder and biliary system .
Rather, he reasoned that the eggs might be carried into the biliary passages ,
become fixed there, then nourish themselves on the bile and develop.
Bidloo's correspondence with Antony van Leeuwenhoek encouraged th e
Dutch microscopist to investigate the manner of transmission of this infection.
Being conversant with the general view that infection was acquired by animals
feeding on contaminated pastures, he examined green sods from the meadows
Fascioliasis 107
which came from the enclosed winding animals....Some of the enclosed animals
succeeded, finally, at various places, in breaking through. All those that slipped out by
themselves had the appearance of the previously described cercariae. 10
These yellow royal worms were given the generic name Redia by de Filippi in
1837 in honour of Francesco Redi 30; de Filippi later accepted the view that the
redia was a larval stage and recommended that the name be no longer used to
designate a genus31. It caused much astonishment that cercariae were no t
derived from parents resembling themselves, but came from these peculiar ,
animated, worm-shaped sacs. Oken, in whose journal Bojanus published hi s
discovery, remarked that "observations of this kind make one dizzy" 64 and
added that "one might lay a wager that these cercariae are the embryos o f
distomes"63. This observation of Bojanus was confirmed by CE von Baer i n
1827.
The story was taken a stage further in 1831 when Karl Mehlis, a medica l
practitioner in Clausthal in (now West) Germany, not only discovered th e
operculum (lid) of each fluke ovum, but also saw an infusorian-like ciliate d
embryo slip out of many eggs of the flukes, Monostomum flavum and Distomum
hians 56. Several years later (1837) Friedrich Creplin (1788-1863), a medical
practitioner and zoologist in Greifswald, (now East) Germany, showed that the
eggs of Fasciola hepatica likewise hatched a ciliated larva 23. Again it caused
some surprise that the embryo, later to be called a miracidium, meanin g
"youthful person" by Braun 12 should be so different in appearance from th e
parent worm. The discovery of these motile worms led von Nordmann to point
out that the ability of the flukes' progeny to swim about in water suggested that
hosts were unlikely to become infected by passively ingesting eggs, but rather
that the swimming embryos might seek out their hosts themselves 62.
Nevertheless, it was not until Simonds showed in 1852 that not a single fluke
was found nor were any traces of liver rot present in sheep fed fluke eggs, that
the old hypothesis that infection was acquired by ingestion of eggs was finally
laid to rest 78.
Meanwhile, Carl von Siebold had linked the embr yos released from fluke eggs
with rediae and cercariae. While District Medical Officer in Heilsberg (no w
known as Lidzbark) in East Prussia (present-day Poland), he had occasion t o
examine large numbers of the fluke Monostomum mutabile which lived in the
orbital cavities of geese. He noted the hatching of ciliated larvae from the eggs
and watched them swimming around in the water. After a while, they died and
disintegrated, each one releasing from its interior a motile, cylindrical body with
two short lateral processes and furnished with a pharynx and simple gut. These
he recognized as being identical with certain cercaria-sacs that he had seen in
snails. Although he was not able to actually witness the process, he theorize d
that the adult trematode worms produce e ggs from which the larvae hatch, swim
around to find an appropriate snail, penetrate the tissues of the new host, then
die releasing cercaria-sacs (rediae) 75. This hypothesis was eventually prove n
correct when G Wagener observed the metamorphosis of the miracidium o f
Fascioliasis 109
Distoma cygnoides of the frog into a redia in 1857 88. The fate of the cercariae
thus produced remained uncertain although von Siebold reported in 1837 that
some cercariae such as C. echinata encysted in snails.
Despite the observations and hypotheses mentioned above, most authorities
held that Cercaria, Redia and Distoma were unrelated organisms, eac h
deserving and occupying separate generic sta tus in the schemes of classification.
To others, however, all these seemingly irregular phenomena constituted a
complete chaos which appeared to break down all the known laws of anima l
existence and propogation. It was at t his point that the Danish scholar, Johannes
Steenstrup, entered the scene. He succeeded in evolving a certain plan out o f
this confusion by the discovery of a hidden, underlying law of nature throug h
which all the phenomena that had seemed devoid of plan could be brought t o
order. He synthesized many reports in the literature with his own observations,
then in 1842 he published a book in which he promulgated his doctrine of the
"Alternation of Generations" 81. This term had already been used in 1819 by the
German poet and navigator, A von Chamisso, who had shown that in the Salpae,
a form of marine animal, free individuals and individuals bound together i n
chains alternated with one another in each successive generation. In his work,
Steenstrup gave an account of the evolution of coelenterates (Medusae an d
claviform polyps), of pelagic tunicates (Salpae), and of trematodes, and found
a phenomenon common to all of them that he summarized in the followin g
terms:
An animal bears young which are, and remain, dissimilar to their parent, but bring
forth a new generation, whose members either themselves, or in their descendants,
return to the original form of the parent animal. 81
Thus, just as the polyp originating from the eggs of a medusa represented a n
alternate generation, so did the royal yellow worm (cercaria or redia) derive d
from the ciliated embryo of a fluke. The consequences of this statement wer e
that cercariae were the progeny of trematodes, that these worms passed part of
their existence in a state of freedom, and that whole divisions of families must
be abolished because they included only undeveloped forms. Steenstru p
observed that in some of the Trematoda the latter generations remained within
the earlier forms until they attained their full development whereas other s
forsook them earlier to become free-swimming then underwent a complet e
metamorphosis. He conjectured fur ther that cercariae might penetrate into other
animals, lose their tails and become adult flukes. Steenstrup knew that C.
echinata encysted in snails so he extracted parasites from the cysts after various
periods and showed that they contained typical fluke-like forms. His view s
required both correction and completion, particularly in his supposition tha t
final maturation occurred in the body of the snail, but they provided a n
indispensable principle upon which the details of the life cycles, not only o f
trematodes but also of cestodes, could be fleshed.
Although some investigators such as von Siebold (1844) 76 and van Beneden
(1852) 7 seized upon this idea of alternation of generations, other authoritie s
110 A History of Human Helminthology
assertion of the previous year, each cer caria was endowed with a long tail. What
was more, these cercariae and rediae appeared to be identical with those he had
seen in the snail collected from the farm at Wytham two years before. H e
concluded that:
There can be no doubt that the cercariae I found really belong to the liver fluke. The
rediae in which they occurred were closely similar to those I have found throughout
this examination of the snails I have infected with embryos, and in the same snail with
these rediae were sporocysts, still recognisable by the eye-spots and papilla as
belonging to F. hepatica. Moreover, all the specimens of L. truncatulus which I have
infected have proved to contain larval trematodes, clearly belonging to one and the
same zoological species, and as a preliminary precaution a number of snails of the
same gathering as those submitted to infection were examined, and all were completely
free from larval trematodes.84
Furthermore, Thomas observed that rediae sometim es did not produce cercariae,
but generated rediae instead. Indeed, he found as many as four generations o f
larval F. hepatica within the same snail, and calculated that a single fluke might
give rise to over 1,000 cercariae. He ended his paper by indicating that it was
still necessary to elucidate the manner in which sheep were infected wit h
cercariae. He noted that this could occur either by consumption of mollusc s
containing cercariae, as Leuckart favoured, or as he believed more likely ,
cercariae might swim about, encyst on grass and then be ingested. Thomas' s
second report84 and Leuckart's final paper50 both came out in October 1882 .
Thomas then wrote two further papers 85,86 reviewing his findings and comparing
them with those of Leuckart.
Despite Thomas's confident anticipation that he would soon be able to pro-
vide the answer to the last-posed question, another ten years were to elaps e
before the Brazilian, Adolfo Lutz, proved that infection was acquired by in -
gestion of cysts containing metacercariae. In t he interim, Leuckart had also tried
to infect rabbits but was unable to find any worms. The reasons for his apparent
lack of success were not apparent until Ssinitzin discerned the pathway o f
migration in the body of young worms in 1914. Lutz was working in Hawai i
where he was the Director of the Leper Hospital in Honolulu. Although h e
published his findings as referring to F. hepatica, it has since been suggested
that the species he studied was in fact F. gigantica 2. Be that as it may, the
findings are equally applicab le. Lutz observed in 1892 that snails infected with
Fasciola only liberated cercariae when they were damaged or dead. Thes e
cercariae encysted rapidly as soon as they found support, whether a plant o r
some other material, and remained viable for up to two months. He infected a
kid, a piglet and three guinea pigs with numerous cysts of different ages. The
kid died within 20 hours of feeding, probably because it was weaned too early,
and worms could not be found in the piglet bec ause its stomach was too full. He
had more luck with his guinea pigs. The f irst animal was infected on 23, 24 and
27 December 1891 with about 60 cysts. It was found dead one month later and
autopsy revealed numerous small cavities filled with blood clot in the live r
parenchyma: 29 flukes ranging in size from 5-9 mm were recovered from this
114 A History of Human Helminthology
organ. In the second guinea pig, which had been fed with about 20 cysts, 1 8
flukes were recovered 32 days later, one of them being in the liver and the rest
being located in the peritoneal cavity. Similar findings were obtained with the
third guinea pig 52. Finally, Shirai eventually proved that not only were cercariae
non-infective, but the cysts were not either until a period of at least twelv e
hours had elapsed after encystment 74.
Thus, the mode of transmission of the parasite from excretion of eggs in the
faeces to ingestion of metacercariae had been determined. What remained to be
demonstrated was the route of migration and the processes of maturation o f
worms in the definitive host.
Bidloo further realized that the numbers of worms varied enormously: in one
liver he recovered 870 worms plus ma ny fragments, whereas in other livers he
found but ten or twelve flukes. He postulated a number of mechanisms b y
which they might cause ill-effects, including distension, destruction an d
inflammation of the biliary passages following obstruction of the biliar y
circulation by worms and their products, inf lammation and necrosis of the liver
by worm toxins, and competition by the worms with the organs for nutrien t
juices.
Once the location of worms in the biliary tree was identified correctly, the
logical assumption seemed to be that they reached that site via the opening of
the bile duct into the duodenum. For over 200 years this remained accepte d
dogma. In 1880, Thomas made an observation which could have put him on
the right path, but he failed to interpret it properly. In September of that year,
he was sent a liver which contained over 2 00 small, immature flukes. He noted
that:
no flukes of any kind could be found in the larger ducts. By far the largest number
were in the smaller branches of the bile ducts or in centres of destroyed hepatic
tissue. They occurred especially near the surface of the liver. The young fluke on
entering the liver by the duct appears to push its way onwards into smaller ducts
where some remain whilst others penetrate the walls of the ducts and crawl forwards
to the surface, causing the destruction of the parenchyma as they proceed. Arrived
at the surface of the liver, they may pass along beneath the peritoneum, or....pierce
the peritoneum and set up perihepatitis.83
Furthermore, Thomas had seen flukes in the peritoneal cavity of a rabbit and
had been told of worms in the mesentery and uterus of a sheep that had died
of the rot. Thus, Thomas made the correct observations, but his interpretation
was exactly opposite to the actual route of migration. Leuckart made similar
observations and also arrived at the same misconception. Lutz (1892) made
the same mistake. In one of his experimental guinea pigs, the vast majority of
young flukes were in the peritoneal cavity, but he concluded erroneously that:
the invading flukes soon go to the periphery of the liver and when the normal bile
passages become too narrow, they burrow further....through the soft parenchyma.
Having reached the surface, they perforate the capsule and thus can reach the
peritoneal cavity where they live perhaps for some time, but probably do not reach
full development.52
It fell to Dimitry Ssinitzin (also known as Sisintsin) in Moscow in 1914 to
demonstrate what is generally accepted as being the true pathway of migration.
He put the reasoning behind his experiment in a very entertaining fashion a
few years later:
I am now a cercaria which has just emerged from its cyst and has found itself in the
intestinal tract....On me are poured smart, biting fluids from the digestive glands and
I wish nothing more than to escape this horrib1e place....What am I to do? If I were
smaller, I should penetrate into a blood vessel but I am too big for that. Dr. Leuckart
advises me to look for the opening of the gall duct in the duodenum, but while I am
listening to him I am transported far behind this opening and how can I, in such a
spacious hollow filled with moving food, find that commended spot? I do not accept
116 A History of Human Helminthology
this advice; I hasten to conceal myself in any place; I work my way into the bottom,
between the folds of the epithelium and penetrate through the intestinal wall. 79
Ssinitzin infected rabbits with metacercariae and found that the young worms
had escaped from the cyst walls within two to three hours of reaching th e
intestine. He then observed that they penetrated the intestinal wall and passed
into the peritoneal cavity where they remained for up to two weeks. They then
attached themselves to the surface of the liver by the mouth suction cap, pen-
etrated into the liver parenchyma with the aid of hard, pointed spines, the n
passed further into the biliary passages every day. He noticed that they fed on
erythrocytes during their travels and emphasized the large haemorrhages they
left in their tracks behind them. Final ly, they reached the larger branches of the
biliary system and mature worms bega n to pass eggs two months or more after
infection80.
Ssinitzin's findings were confirmed in guinea pigs by Shirai in 1927 74 and
then in rabbits by Krull and Jackson in 1943. Suzuki in 1931 provide d
confirmation in another manner. He freed young worms from their cysts b y
artificial digestion then inject ed them directly into the abdominal cavity, portal
vein and bile duct of goats, rabbits and guinea pigs. He claimed success for the
portal but not the biliary routes. Nevertheless, he did not believe that th e
former pathway was really relevant in natural infections, considering instead
that some of the young worms penetrated the intestinal wall to enter th e
abdominal cavity 82.
The duration of infection is uncertain, but three patients have been reported
with longlasting infections, suggesting that in humans, worms may live for at
least nine years 3.
IN ANIMALS
IN HUMANS
For many years, a diagnosis of fascioliasis was difficult to prove. The rar e
patient passed flukes in the faece s or brought them up in the vomitus. The first
person who considered the diagnosis in and proved it in a living patien t
appears to have been Dr. San Pedro Marti n de la Calle in the late 1880's (cited
in4 ). His patient remained undiagnosed for four months until it suddenl y
occurred to Martin de la Calle that many sheep had been dying for the past few
months from a disease called locally "con vulia", and that these sheep had many
signs somewhat reminiscent of those present in his patient. He examined the
carcasses of some of these sheep and found flukes in the biliary system. The
clue being thus obtained, he set abo ut looking for flukes in the patient's faeces;
nothing was found at first, but eventually an adult fluke was passed after the
patient had been treated with castor oil.
Surprisingly, no attempt was apparently made to examine the faeces micro-
scopically for ova, despite the fact that it was well-known to veterinarians that
eggs were common in the faeces of infected shee p. Indeed, the first person who
diagnosed a patient in this way seems to have been Ward in 1911 89. Martin and
his collaborators found eggs in the bile in 1944 54; it is likely that this will
become more common now that upper gastrointestinal endoscopy is bein g
practised widely.
A clue to the infection may be provided by finding an eosinophilia; this was
also first recorded by Ward 89. The possibility of diagnosing fascioliasis sero-
logically by a complement fixation test was first demonstrated in sheep b y
Weinberg in 1909 90, then this assay was improved and used in a human patient
by Servantie in 1921 73. Skin tests, both by scratch testing and by intradermal
injection, were used by Morenas with the former technique being mor e
accurate57.
It is only in recent times that effective therapy for fascioliasis has becom e
available. Many years ago, Chabert claimed to effect the passage of flukes with
his empyreumatic oil 19. Küchenmeister (1855) despaired of treatment, bu t
recommended that calomel and mineral waters or oil of turpentine with sulph-
uric ether be tried 46. Subsequent putative remedies included extract of mal e
fern, antimony compounds, carbon tetrachloride and thymol, but evidence for
Fascioliasis 119
continued to hatch over weeks or months, thus prolonging the period of trans-
mission. Thirdly, he indicated that outbreaks of fascioliasis in sheep wer e
associated with similar epidemics in rabbits and that these animals greatl y
facilitated the dispersion of ova. Fourthly, he confirmed that Weinland' s
observation of cercarial cyst formation on grass 92 was applicable to F. hepat-
ica, and thus helped to explain the mod e of acquisition of infection 83,84. Finally,
his and Leuckart's discovery that certain speci es of snails were the intermediate
host made the epidemiology of fascioliasis comprehensible. The potentia l
magnitude of transmission was emphasized by their calculations that eac h
fluke produced at least 40,000 eggs, and that a single miracidium might gen-
erate over 1,000 cercariae. Militating against this, however, was the fact that
environmental conditions generally prevented the majority of miracidia an d
cercariae from finding their intended hosts. It was now clear that epidemic s
were common in wet years because moisture both enhanced the development
of F. hepatica eggs and favoured the multiplication of molluscan intermediate
hosts. Sheep were likely to be infected by eati ng grass contaminated with cysts,
perhaps by ingesting infected snails, and possibly by drinking adulterate d
water. During this century, studies have defined the species of Lymnaea and
related genera that are intermediate hosts of this parasite in different regions
of the world.
Despite the ravages of rot in sheep, it was recognized that fascioliasis was
rare in humans 4. Indeed, by 1915, it was said that only 28 cases had been re-
corded in the literature up to that time, although it must be said that man y
hundreds of such infections have since been reported. There was considerable
discussion for many years as to whether it was safe for humans to eat the flesh
of sheep with this infection. With the demonstration of Simonds (1850) that
feeding F. hepatica eggs did not result in infection, and with the delineation
of the life cycle by Thomas and Leuckart (1 881-1882), it became apparent that
the dangers of such a practice were not at all that great. Nevertheless, thi s
possibility was in the back of t heir minds when Humble and Lush in 1881 dis-
cussed how their patient had become infected. After discounting this as a
possibility, for the patient had not been in the habit of eating sheep's livers ,
they remarked that "we can throw no light on the question, how the patien t
contracted the disease" 40 but did mention that "he frequently ate th e
watercress" 40.
It subsequently became accepted that infection could be acquired by eating
plants contaminated with cysts, particularly watercress ( Nasturtium
officinale), or by drinking polluted water. The role of the former wa s
emphasized when a small outbreak of fascioliasis occurred in six patients in
Hampshire, England in 1958-1959; all of them were in the habit of eatin g
watercress frequently29. It was shown even more dramatically in a larg e
outbreak in Monmouthshire, England in 1968-1969 in which 44 patients were
infected, all of whom admitted to have eaten watercress from the same be d
Fascioliasis 121
which also was located near some infected cattle and sheep 39.
The possibility of preventing fascioliasis in sheep has been known for mor e
than 600 years. de Brie in 1379 concluded his dissertion on rot in sheep b y
reminding his readers that "the s hepherd should take care not to lead his sheep
near marshy places where la dauve grows all summer long" 15. Fitzherbert
(1523) emphasized this, recommending that the sheep "may nat well be lette
out of the fold tyll the sonne have domynacion to drie them away" 32.
Thomas amplified preventive measures by recommending that infecte d
sheep be destroyed, infected livers disposed of, and manure from infecte d
sheep be collected and eggs hindered from developing by the addition of coal
tar or by being spread over, dry, well-drained ground. Further, he emphasized
the value of draining the land and destroying snails with a dressing of lime or
with salt83. To these measures were added during this century, adequat e
chemotherapy of infected animals and t he introduction of newer molluscicides.
Understanding the epidemiology and the frequent incrimination of water -
cress as the vehicle by which human infections were acquired, led to repeated
calls for education of the public concerning the dangers of eating wild water-
cress, and recommendations that watercress be grown commercially unde r
controlled conditions.
F. GIGANTICA
The adult fluke was discovered in the liver of a giraffe and named Fasciola
gigantica by Spencer Cobbold in 1855 21. The life cycle of this parasite and the
pathology and clinical features it induces parallel those of F. hepatica, but
different species of snails are the intermediate hosts.
In 1895, de Gouvêa in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil published an account of a
French naval officer who had recently been in Senegal and who had presented
with fever and haemoptysis, then had coughed up a fluke 2.5 cm long 38. There
have been differences of opinions as to the identity of this parasite. According
to Brumpt16, Railliet considered that it was the liver fluke, F. hepatica var
augusta while Raphael Blanchard identified it as F. gigantica. In 1927,
Pigoulewsky described F. gigantica infection in a child in Tashkent, USSR.
The diagnosis was based only upon the appearances of eggs found in th e
faeces67. The first clearcut case of fascioliasis gigantica was reported b y
Codvelle and his colleagues in 1928 22.
122 A History of Human Helminthology
REFERENCES
pflanzischen Parasiten des Menschen, two volumes, BG Teubner, Leipzig, pp 486, 1855.
On animal and vegetable parasites of the human body. A manualof their natural history,
diagnosis and treatment. Volume 1. Animal parasites belonging to the group entozoa, trans-
lated by E Lankester, The Sydenham Society, London, pp 452, 1857
47. van LEEUWENHOEK A. Part of a letter from Mr. Antony van Leeuwenhoek concerning
worms observ'd in sheeps livers and pasture grounds. Philosophical Transactions of the
Royal Society 24: 1522-1527, 1704
48. LEUCKART R. Zur Entwickelungsgeschichte des Leberegels. Zoologischer Anzeiger 4:
641646, 1881. Translated in 43
49. LEUCKART R. Zur Entwickelungsgeschichte des Leberegels (Distomum hepaticum).
Archiv für Naturgeschichte 1: 80-119, 1882
50. LEUCKART R. Zur Entwickelungsgeschichte des Leberegels. Zweite Mittheilung. Zool-
ogischer Anzeiger 5: 524-528, 1882
51. LINNAEUS C. Systema naturae, per regna tria naturae, secundum, classes, ordines, genera,
species, cum characteribus differentiis, synonymis, locis, tenth edition, L Salvii, Holmiae,
two volumes, pp 823, 1758
52. LUTZ A. Zur Lebensgeschichte desDistoma hepaticum. Centralblatt für Bakteriologie und
Parasitenkunde, Abteilung originale 11: 783-796, 1892. Partly translated in 43
53. MALPIGHI M. Opera posthuma. Quibus praefixa est vita, a seipso scripta, A et J Churchill,
Londini, pp 187, 1698
54. MARTIN R, LE ROY, SUREAU B, BABOUOT P, BOURCART N. Un nouveau cas de
distomatose hépatique: diagnostic précoce par le tubage duodénal. Bulletin de la Société de
Pathologie Exotique 37: 359-363, 1944
55. MARTIN de la CALLE SP. Abstracted in, Distomiasis in man, Lancet ii: 1340-1341, 1890
56. MEHLIS CF. Novae observationes de entozois, auctore Dr Fr Chr H Creplin. . . Angezeigt
und mit Bemerkungen begleiter von Dr E Mehlis. Isis (Oken's), Oder Encyclopädische
Zeitung, Jena, pp 68-99, 166-199, 1831
57. MORENAS L. Les réactions d'allergie cutanée dans la distomatose humaine àFasciola
hepatica: cuti et intra-dermo-réaction. Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances et
Mémoires de la Société de Biologie 137: 563-565, 1943
58. MÜLLER OF. Vermium terrestrium et fluviatilium, seu animalium infusorium,
helminthocorum et testaceorum, non marinorum, succincta historia. Vol. 1, Infusoria,
Havniae et Lipsiae, pp 135, 1773
59. NIK-AKHTAR B, TABIBI V. Metronidazole in fascioliasis. Report of four cases. Journal
of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 80: 179-180, 1977
60. NITZSCH CL. Seltsame Lebens- und Todesart eines kleinen bisher unbekanntnen Wasser-
thierchens. In, Kilian. Georgia, oder Der Menschen im Leben und im Staate, pp 257-252,
281-286, 1807
61. NITZSCH CL. Beitrag zur Infusorienkunde, oder Naturbeschreibung der Zerkarien und
Bazillarien. Neue Schriften der naturforschenden Gesellschaft zu Halle 3: 1-128, 1817
62. von NORDMANN A. Mikrographische Beiträge zur Naturgeschichte der wirbellosen
Thiere, G Reimer, Berlin, two volumes, pp 268, 1832
63. OKEN L. Cited in 13
64. OKEN L. Cited in 77
65. PAGENSTECHER HA. Trematodenlarven und Trematoden, Helminthologischer Beitrag,
Heidelburg, pp 56, 1857
66. PALLAS PS. Dissertatio medica inauguralis de infestis viventibus intraviventia, Lugduni
Batavorum, 1760
67. PIGOULEWSKY SW. (Un cas de Fasciola gigantica Cob chez un enfant Usbék en Vieux
Tashkent. Pensée Médecine d'Usbekistane.) In Russian, pp 59-61, French summary, p 131,
1927. Republished in German in Archiv für Schiffs- und Tropen-Hygiene 32: 511-512,
1928
68. REDI F. Esperienze intorno alla generazione degl'insetti, Carlo Dati, Firenze, pp 177, 1668.
Experiments on the generation of insects translated from the 1688 edition by M Bigelow,
Opencourt Publishing Co., Chicago, pp 160, 1909
69. REDI F. Osservazioni intorno agli animal viventi che si trovano negli animali viventi, Piero
Fascioliasis 125
1379 First recorded reference to worms in sheep by de Brie, who also linked
infection with feeding animals in certain types of pastures at particular times
of the year
1523 Fitzherbert gave an accurate clinical description of fascioliasis in infected
sheep
1670 Faber observed that worms were located in the biliary tree
1690 Bidloo discovered eggs and recognized that the worms were hermaphroditic
1758 Linnaeus named the worm Fasciola hepatica
1760 Pallas gave the first detailed account of human infection (earlier allusions had
been made by Borel, Malpighi and Bidloo)
1882 Leuckart and Thomas described independently the development of miracidia
through to cercariae in the snail, Lymnaea truncatula
1892 Lutz demonstrated that adult worms developed after ingestion of encysted
metacercariae
1911 Ward diagnosed human fascioliasis by finding eggs in faeces
1914 Ssinitzin demonstrated the pathway of migration of flukes in the definitive
host
1985 Schiappacasse and colleagues reported that praziquantel was effective in
human fascioliasis
___________________________________________________________________
Chapter 5
SYNOPSIS
While performing in 1843 an auto psy on a Lascar (i.e. a sailor from the eastern
part of India) who had died in the naval hospital Dreadnought in Greenwich,
England, the English surgeon, George Busk, found 14 flukes in the duodenum.
This finding was not reported until 1852 when, based upon informatio n
supplied by Busk, it was described briefly by George Budd in his book ,
Diseases of the Liver. It was noted that these flukes, which were not present in
the gall bladder or bile ducts:
were much thicker and larger than those of the sheep, being from an inch and a half
to near three inches in length. They resembled the Distoma hepaticum in shape, but
were like the Distoma lanceolatum in structure; the double alimentary canal, as in the
latter variety, being not branched, and the entire space between it towards the latter
part of the body being occupied by the uterine tube. 8
This discovery was cited again in 1857 by ER Lankester in appendix B to his
translation of Küchenmeister's textbook, On animal and vegetable parasites
127
128 A History of Human Helminthology
of the human body. After speculating about the possible life cycle of th e
parasite, he went on to say that:
In the absence of any other distinguishing name for this species, I have called it, after
the name of its discoverer, Distoma Buskii.19
Busk, however, objected to this designation. M oreover, Cobbold considered the
name invalid on the ground that Lankester had not provided a sufficien t
description of the parasite. Cobbold therefore asked Busk to suggest a ne w
name, and the latter thereupon proposed the appellation, Distoma crassum
(derived from the Latin "crassus" meaning "thi ck" or "gross"). This was adopted
by Cobbold when he redescribed the worm in his Synopsis of the Distomidae
communicated to the Linnean Society in London in June 1859 and published
in its journal in the following year10. This was to cause confusion subsequently,
with some authors calling the worm D. crassum Busk and others referring to
it as D. crassum Cobbold. Cobbold himself used the former term in his original
description. To complicate matters more, the name Distoma crassum had
already been used in 1836 by von Siebold for a fluke found in a house martin.
This nomenclature was rejected by C obbold for the same reason that he had set
aside D. buskii, i.e. the naming was not accompanied by an adequat e
description. Cobbold's redescription w as based on one of Busk's original flukes
which had been kept in the museum of the Royal College of Surgeons i n
London. He subsequently sent the worm to Leuckart who concurred wit h
Cobbold's view and described it as D. crassum in his textbook in 1863 23.
Weinland and also Davaine14, however, were misled by the inaccurate original
description of the uterine coils and transferred the worm to the genu s
Dicrocoelium.
The parasite was not recognized again until the northern spring of 1874. A
missionary and his wife who had been resident in China for about four year s
consulted Dr George Johnstone in London concerning persistent diarrhoea .
They were referred to Cobbold who treated them with aloes and asafoetid a
without any improvement. Eventually, however, twelve worms were expelled
spontaneously. When Cobbold showed them to Busk, "he at once recognised
them as referrable to the species he had long ago discovered" 11.
Meanwhile, Dr JG Kerr, the founder of the Hospital for the Insane i n
Canton, China, had sent another worm to Professor Gross in the Unite d
States of America, remarking that it had been vomited by a 15 year ol d
Chinese boy. He added that at one time, a four year old English girl ha d
passed nine of these worms. The parasite passed into the hands of Josep h
Leidy who exhibited it at the Academy of Natural Science in Philadelphia i n
October 1873. Leidy described its external morphology but said nothing of its
internal organization and misdi agnosed it as Fasciola hepatica 20. He corrected
the error 18 years later, merely to commit another when he equated it with F.
magna 21.
In 1887, J Poirier began the fashion of giving new specific names to variant
specimens of F. buski when he described the worm passed by a 35 year ol d
Fasciolopsiasis 129
When he named the parasite F. buski in 1857, Lankester speculated about the
life cycle of this worm. He surmised that the usual host was probably som e
species of lower animal living in the tropics and that humans were likely t o
acquire the infection in a fashion similar to the way in which they becam e
infected with F. hepatica 19. The means by which the latter worm was trans-
mitted was not known at that time, although speculation that snails wer e
involved was rife. When this was confirmed by Thomas and Leuckart in 1882
(see chapter 4), it gave credence to the idea that fasciolopsiasis was trans -
mitted likewise. Lankester's suppositions were substantiated further when i t
was discovered that pigs in certain endemic areas were infected not infre -
quently with F. buski. The only other observation of significance that wa s
made during the nineteenth century was the discovery of the operculum of the
F. buski egg. Although Cobbold had desc ribed the appearance and dimensions
of these ova in 1875 11, he apparently failed to see the operculum. This wa s
eventually discovered by an anonymous commentator who examined a spec-
imen submitted to the British Medical Journal by JH Walker in Sandakar ,
North Borneo in 1891 1.
This, therefore, was the background when Koa n Nakagawa in Formosa (Tai-
wan) in 1915 turned his attention from the study of the life cycle of Para-
gonimus westermani to investigate that of F. buski. Human infections with the
parasite were almost unknown on that island, but fasciolopsiasis was ver y
common in pigs, so he obtained his specimens from that source. He pursued
his experiments over five years, finally publishing his results in 1921 28 and
again with more details in the following year 29. He noted that when eggs were
deposited in water during the warmer months, they developed over the nex t
two to three weeks, then hatched miracidia which swam about freely in th e
water. He incubated these miracidia with a number of species of snail s
collected from local ponds and brooks but obtained either negative o r
confusing results. Realizing that he had to have snails that were free of an y
naturally-acquired infection (there being at least 17 different forms of cercariae
present on Taiwan), he tried to raise s nails artificially from eggs in aquaria. He
finally succeeded in cultivating what he considered to be two species of snail,
Plan-orbis coenosus and Segmentina largillierta (now both known as
Segmentina hemisphaerula ). These snails proved susceptible to infection, for
when he placed them with F. buski miracidia in an aquarium in April 1920,
the snails:
were soon found covered by swarming miracidia which tried to bore into the head,
foot, tentacles, mantle etc. They left their ciliated coats as they penetrated into the
snail.28
In the tissues of the snails, he observed that the miracidia transformed int o
sporocysts, grew and migrated, especially into the mantle and walls of the ali-
Fasciolopsiasis 131
It is perhaps remarkable that wh en Cobbold in 1875 found that his patient had
fasciolopsiasis, this diagnosis was made only because adult flukes wer e
passed in the stools. Apparently he was not in the habit of examining micro-
scopically the faeces of patients whom he suspected of having an helmint h
infection, even though such a technique had been described nearly 20 year s
earlier. Even had he done so, however, he would not have arrived at the cor-
rect diagnosis, as the eggs of F. buski were not described at that time. Never-
theless, observation of their presence would have alerted him to the existence
of some intestinal worm in the gastrointestinal tract.
The first person to find F. buski eggs in the faeces was JH Walker in British
North Borneo in 1891. In a 22 year old Chinese male with beriberi:
microscopic examination of the faeces showed that they contained....very numerous
eggs of a kind I could not find described in any books at my disposal. 37
He then went on to describe the eggs and provided a figure illustrating one .
Walker attempted to ascertain the the adult worm producing these eggs b y
treating the patient with a combination of anthelmintics and purgatives; th e
patient pronounced himself cured but failed to bring the parasites to th e
hospital. He had more luck with a second patient in whose faeces he foun d
similar eggs; anthelmintic therapy resulted in the recovery of an adult fluk e
which he identified as Distoma crassum.
Microscopical examination of the faeces then became standard practice ,
particularly in the heavily endemic area around Shaohsing in China, wit h
Barlow remarking that:
in diagnosing fasciolopsiasis there are only two pathognomonic signs; the finding of
ova in stool and the vomiting of live flukes. Only in cases of massive infestation does
the latter occur, while it is almost impossible to overlook ova in the stool when but
one fluke is harboured because of a large number of ova discharged by one adult. 5
although he also claimed that "fluke-harboring individuals are easil y
recognized on the streets after one has seen many cases clinically" 5.
Stoll and his colleagues took this diagnostic procedure one step further and
136 A History of Human Helminthology
showed that quantification of the number of eggs in the stools was a valuable
index of the number of adult worms with which a person was infected. They
further demonstrated that each fluke produce d between 15,000 and 48,000 ova
per day36.
spongy leaf on a fibrous, cellular petiole and the root-stalk is spindle-shaped and
cellular. The air cells keep the plant supported on the water, and the rootlets get their
food largely from the water, although there is a root which is sent down to the
bottom, even though the depth may be 12 or 15 feet. These plants are usually alive
with little snails, feeding on the tender skin on the stems, petioles, leaves and nuts.
It is not unusual to find more than 20 on a single nut. This obliterates distance for the
emerging cercariae and brings encystment where it is more efficacious and
dangerous.5
Water caltrop and water chestnut were grown in shallow ponds and infection
was enhanced by fertilizing with human night soil. Surveys of these plant s
showed that there was an average of 17 cysts for every caltrop nut.
Barlow then went on to examine the durability of cysts and found that they
were not very resistant to drying, being unable to withstand one day in the hot
sun. For this reason, vegetables which were grown on dry soil were not inf -
ected, even though they were located near ponds containing many infecte d
snails.
Subsequent experience in other endemic regions indicated that F. buski
cercariae were not fastidious but could live on almost any kind of water plant
growing in stagnant water near infected snails. Thus, cysts were described on
the roots and leaves of lotus, water bamboo, Salvinia natans and Lemna
polyrhiza 18. The most common way in which humans acquired infection was
by peeling off the outer covering of each nut with teeth, before swallowing the
raw food.
Likewise, the important snail intermediate hosts in various regions wer e
characterized. These snails were somewhat difficult to identify and there was
considerable confusion initially. Segmentina hemisphaerula (identical with
Nakagawa's S. largillierta and his Planorbis coenosus and synonymous with
Barlow's S. nitidellus) and Hippeutis cantori (= Planorbis schmakeri of Bar-
low) were found to be the major molluscan hosts in eastern Asia, whil e
S. trochoideus was identified as the most important vector in northeaster n
India.
The interaction between the pig and human cycles also caused some con -
sternation at first. Nakagawa noted that porcine fasciolopsiasis was common
in Taiwan, whereas human infe ction was prevalent around Shaohsing. Barlow
showed that pigs could be infected with cerca riae derived from human sources,
although the parasite appeared to be somewhat smaller 5.
Once he had discovered the life cycle of F. buski, Nakagawa was quick to
list various measures designed to reduce the transmission of infection. H e
indicated that the eating of raw water pl ants and the drinking of unboiled water
should be prohibited, while the consumption of uncooked freshwater fish and
138 A History of Human Helminthology
REFERENCES
1. ANONYMOUS. A rare parasite. British Medical Journal ii: 1224-1225, 1891
2. BARLOW CH. Experimental ingestion of the ova of Fasciolopsis buski : also the
ingestion of adult Fasciolopsis buski for the purpose of artificial infestation. Journal of
Parasitology 8: 40-44, 1921
3. BARLOW CH. Life cycle of Fasciolopsis buski : discovery of the means of infestation
of human beings. China Medical Journal 36: 546, 1922
4. BARLOW CH. Life cycle of Fasciolopsis buski (human) in China. China Medica l
Journal 37: 453-472, 1923
5. BARLOW CH. The life cycle of the human intestinal fluke Fasciolopsis busk i
(Lankester). American Journal of Hygiene Monograph Series, No 4, pp 99, 1925
6. BARLOW CH. The treatment of fasciolopsiasis. China Medical Journal 41: 253-265 ,
1927
7. BROWN NW. The Fasciolopsinae of China. A study of two species from Chekian g
Province. Johns Hopkins Hospital Bulletin 28: 322-329, 1917
8. BUDD G. Diseases of the liver, John Churchill, London, second edition, pp 486, 1852
9. BUNNAG D, RADOMYOS P, HARINASUTA T. Field trial on the treatment o f
fasciolopsiasis with praziquantel. Southeast Asian Journal of Tropical Medicine an d
Public Health 14: 216-219, 1983
10. COBBOLD TS. Synopsis of the Distomidae. Journal of the Linnean Society, London,
Zoological Division 5: 1-56, 1860
11. COBBOLD TS. On the suppos ed rarity, nomenclature, structure, affinities and source of
the large human fluke (Distoma crassum Busk). Journal of the Linnean Society 12 :
285-296, 1875
12. COBBOLD TS. Parasites: a treatise on the entozoa of man and animals including some
accounts of the ectozoa, J&A Churchill, London, pp 508, 1879
13. COLE AF. Five cases of Fasciolopsis infection, with remarks. Transactions of the Royal
Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 14: 93-96, 1921
Fasciolopsiasis 139
buski with additional data on the distribution of this parasite in China. Journal o f
Parasitology 13: 166-172, 1927
37. WALKER JH. Two cases of beri-beri asso ciated with Distomum crassum , Anchylostoma
duodenale and other parasites. British Medical Journal ii: 1205, 1891
38. WARD HB. Fasciolopsis buskii, F. rathouisi and related species in China. China Medical
Journal 24: 1-10, 1909
SYNOPSIS
141
142 A History of Human Helminthology
examination these were clearly seen to protrude from the bile ducts, which,
on being dissected, were found more or less obstructed by and containing
them in large numbers, some lying fr ee, others coiled up and either solitary
or in groups of twos or threes within the biliary ducts; all were dead....No
distomata were found in the gall-bladder, nor were any ova discovered on
microscopical examination of the bile and lining membrane of this sac .
Numerous ova and shreds of epithelium were found in the biliary canals. 45
McConnell concluded that the flukes in the bile ducts caused degeneration of
the liver, and that the "cholaemic condition" induced by obstruction of th e
biliary channels was the immediate cause of death. He then went on to des-
cribe the external and internal morphology of the flukes, which were nearl y
one inch in length, then compared them with the two flukes well-known i n
Europe, Distoma hepaticum (Fasciola hepatica) and Distoma lanceolatum
(Dicrocoelium dendriticum), as well as discussing them in relation to Fasc-
iolopsis buski found in China by Kerr and wrongly identified by Leidy a s
F. hepatica (see chapter 5). This led McConnell to the conviction that th e
flukes that he had found in the liver "not only differ from the ordinary live r
fluke (Dist. hepaticum) but constitute an entirely new species" 45. His paper
was published in The Lancet on 21 August 1875 then four weeks late r
Spencer Cobbold wrote to the editor of that journal remarking that:
without doubt the species is new to science, and ought to have som e
distinctive name by which it may be recognised amongst th e
trematodes. I propose to call it Distoma sinense.11
This name was presumably intended to indicate its discovery in the body of a
Chinese person. In the following year, however, Leuckart, in his textbook ,
labelled the parasite Distoma spathulatum 43.
The parasites were encountered again in 1877 by William McGregor i n
Port Louis, Mauritius. Eight Chinese persons were suffering from a paralytic
illness, and he found the flukes in the three patients who died. Naturall y
enough, but quite wrongly, he ascribed the pa ralysis to these worms 47. In 1878,
McConnell again found the parasites in a Chinese cook from Hong Kong 46. In
the same year, Ishizaka discovered the infection in a farmer in Okayam a
Prefecture in Japan31, then Erwin Baelz recovered the worms during th e
autopsy of a patient in Tokyo University Hospital in 1883. Baelz recognized
two forms of the fluke: he regarded the smaller form as being pathogenic and
named it Distoma hepatis endemicum sive perniciosum and the larger type as
being nonpathogenic, calling it Distoma hepatis endemicum sive innocuum 3.
Ijima, however, believed them to be identical and shortened the name of the
parasite to Distoma endemicum 30.
In 1895, Raphael Blanchard erecte d the genus Opisthorchis and placed D.
sinense in it6. In 1907, however, Arthur Looss created the genus Clonorchis
for this oriental liver fluke with branched instead of lobed testes, the nam e
being derived from the Greek words (CHLON) and (ORCHIS)
meaning "branch" and "testis", respectively 44. He recognized two species ,
Clonorchiasis 143
Clonorchis sinensis, a larger form that he believed was found more commonly
in China, and C. endemicus, a smaller worm which was thought to be found
mainly in Japan and Indochina. In addition, Looss believed that the shapes of
the eggs differed between the two forms of the worm. Kobayashi (1912) ,
however, considering that the size of the adult worm depended upon the nature
and size of the host and upon the in tensity of infection, and believing that there
were no significant differences in the shape of the eggs, concluded that there
was only one species, C. sinensis 36,38.
Heanley's approach was adopte d with success several years later, however, by
the Japanese zoologist Harujiro Kobayas hi, while working in Korea. He exam-
ined a variety of molluscs, fishes and aquatic arthropods while looking fo r
trematode larvae. He found a number of fo rms of cercariae and encysted young
flukes, but noted that one particular kind of immature, encysted fluke wa s
common in certain freshwater fish that came from the same regions wher e
human clonorchiasis was freque nt. Since cats were known to be often infected
naturally, he used these animals for experimental studies. They were firs t
shown to be uninfected by repeated examination of the faeces then given the
flesh of fish containing these cysts. Kobayashi then fed them exclusively on a
diet of boiled rice and disinfected milk. Nine kittens and two cats were fed on
the fishes Pseudorasbora parva and Leucogobia guntheri. They either died
or were killed at varying intervals; all were found to be infected wit h
C. sinensis (Kobayashi called the worm C. endemicus) in the bile duct, hepatic
ducts, gall bladder, pancreas and duodenum. These findings were first reported
by Kobayashi in the form of a short note in Japanese in 1911 35, then appeared
in English the following year 37.
In 1913, Houghton, a western physician, also claimed to have determined
the life cycle of C. sinensis 25. While making some observations in 1910 o n
parasites present in foodstuffs commonly eaten in Shanghai, China, where he
was working, Houghton noticed the practically constant presence of a larval
trematode free in the intestine of a species of fish of the genus Notropis. In
view of the possibility that these larvae might parasitize humans or some other
mammalian host, he fed them to kittens. In the first experiment, two suckling
kittens were fed, one with raw fish, boi led rice and tinned milk, while the other
Clonorchiasis 145
received rice and milk only. On killing the animals two months later, he found
that the animal fed with fish was infected with C. sinensis whereas the control
cat was not. The experiment was repeated and similar results were returned,
with hundreds of Clonorchis being recovered. On the third attempt, bot h
kittens died of an intercurrent illness after o ne month. Houghton concluded that
although his data were scanty, it seemed likely that clonorchiasis was acquired
by ingestion of undercooked, sma ll cyprinidine fish. Nevertheless, his findings
must be viewed with some scepticism, since the larvae he saw were lying free
in the intestines, not encysted in the flesh, nor did subsequent investigator s
give any credence to his work. Indeed, Leiper and Atkinson in 1914 made a
similar finding in fish near Shanghai and concluded that it had nothing to do
with the life cycle of Clonorchis 42. Despite Houghton's claim that th e
intestinal larvae were the only trema todes found either in the gut or in the flesh
of the fish, it is possible that C. sinensis cysts were present conincidentally in
the skin, thus causing him to misinterpret the relationship between th e
intestinal larvae and the adult worms that he reared.
Meanwhile, Kobayashi continued his studies using cats, dogs, rabbits ,
guinea pigs and rats, describing his findings in Japanese in 1912 36 and in
English in a German journal published on 15 January 1915 38. He observed that
cysts were abundant both in the subcutaneous tissues and in the muscles o f
fish, particularly in the more superficial parts. In these papers, he showed that
another ten species of freshwater fi shes also acted as intermediate hosts. Later,
Kobayashi and other workers found further species of freshwater fishes tha t
were vectors of C. sinensis, so that by 1965, approximately 80 such species
had been identified 40, although only a dozen or so were important sources of
human infections 78.
Thus, although Kobayashi had demonstrated conclusively tha t
experimental animals, and therefore almost certainly humans, acquire d
infection with C. sinensis by ingestion of infected fish, the mode of infection
of the fish remained unknown. Kobayashi thought it highly likely that a
mollusc was involved and suspected Melania species as prime candidates.
with C. sinensis was confirmed experimentally b y Hsu and Li in 1940 27. Mean-
while, Galliard (1938) found that Bithynia chaperi and Melania tuberculata
were the major intermediate hosts of the infection in Vietnam 18.
Attempts continued meantime to persuade miracidia to hatch from eg g
shells. A variety of mechanical stimuli such as placement of ova in runnin g
water34 were deemed to be ineffective. It was eventually shown by Hsu and Li
in 1940 that miracidia hatch only in the alimentary canal of susceptibl e
snails28. These authors showed that when eggs were ingested by Bithynia
fushsiana, miracidia hatched within one hour then penetrated the gut wall to
become sporocysts within four hours of infection. The sporocysts the n
migrated into the lymph spaces surrounding the intestine and rectum. There,
they produced rediae which in turn migrated primarily into the liver, but also
into other regions such as the foot and mantle, and produced cercariae within
them.
Discovery of the snail intermediate host permitted observation of the fate
of these cercariae. After escaping from the snail and having a brief free -
swimming existence, the cercaria e became attached to the fish, discarded their
tails, penetrated under the scales and encysted in the subcutaneous tissues or
in the muscles. Three or four weeks were required for complete development
into metacercariae at temperatures occurring during summer.
(the earliest time at which he looked). The only places in which worms were
ever seen were the biliary system, duodenum and stomach. Furthermore, when
the bile ducts were ligated, worms were found in the duodenum, but not in the
biliary tree, liver or abdominal cavity. Finally, when young flukes were placed
directly into the peritoneal cavity of rabbits, the worms failed to migrate to the
liver and bile ducts during the three and a half weeks of observation. Thus ,
Mukoyama concluded that young fluke s were unable to penetrate the intestinal
mucosa but migrated directly along the bile duct. Similar conclusions wer e
reached several years later by Faust and Khaw who observed that whe n
animals swallowed cysts, young flukes attached themselves to the duodena l
mucosa, massed in the region of the opening of the common duct, then by 48
hours after infection had all migrated into the biliary tree 15. Since that time,
however, some investigators have cast some doubt upon this route o f
migration. Nevertheless, the weight of evidence favours the direct lumina l
route.
Once flukes have reached the biliary system, they may live there for many
years. Although Muto found that most worms in infected dogs died during the
space of two to three years 53, there are reports of Chinese emigrants continuing
to pass eggs after long periods of residence in non-endemic areas, wherea s
concomitant infections with other worms such as Ascaris, Trichuris and
hookworm disappeared spontaneously. Thus, one person who had live d
continuously in Costa Rica for 25 years retained his infection with C. sin-
ensis49. Similarly, C. sinensis ova were found in the bile of a Vietnamese who
had lived in New Caledonia for 24 years7 and another Chinese patient still had
clonorchiasis after living in Panama for over 40 years 9. Nevertheless, these
reports must be viewed with some circumspection, since it is possible tha t
infection could have been acquired for example, by ingestion of undercooked
fish which had been imported from China.
While the route of migration was of great interest to parasitologists, th e
consequences of infection were of mor e concern to pathologists and clinicians.
When he first found the flukes, McConnell believed that they had played a
major part in causing the deat h of his patient 45, and McGregor thought that the
flukes produced a paralysis of reflex origin 47. McConnell had doubts abou t
this, however, when he reported his second case in 1878 46, and this was
echoed a number of years later by Heanley in Hong Kong when he wrote that:
The literature of tropical medicine abounds with instances of commo n
parasites being mistaken for causes of disease until further investigatio n
has shown the parasite to be as common in the healthy population as in the
sick.20
Heanley, in fact, reported the first major series of patients with clonorchiasis.
He examined 300 unselected livers at autopsy during an 18 month period and
found that 109 of them were infected, the number of flukes present rangin g
between one and 350, with the average burden in adult persons being of the
order of 40-50 worms. He was not impressed by the damage produced b y
these worms, remarking that:
Clonorchiasis 149
After doing more than 3,000 post mortems in Cantonese, I am still unable
to say whether C. sinensis ever produces disease in them, although I a m
inclined to think that it in very old people the enlargement of the bile ducts
may help in the production of gall-stones. 20
and adding as an addendum to the title of his paper on clonorchiasis, the words
"its small pathological importance" 20.
Nevertheless, it gradually became clear that serious damage could b e
caused by C. sinensis, particularly in heavy infections. Perhaps the mos t
massive infection on record is that described by Sambuc and Beaujean i n
which 21,000 flukes weighing approximately 300 g were recovered from the
liver and biliary system65. In 1920, Mebius gave a detailed pathological study
of clonorchiasis seen in Chinese in Indonesia 48. The worms were shown t o
induce an epithelial proliferation and crypt formation in the extrahepatic bile
ducts, luminal enlargement and thickening of the walls of the intrahepati c
ducts, periportal lymphocytic infiltration and fibrosis, and atrophy of live r
parenchymal cells. These features were interpreted as indicating hyperplastic
cholangitis with chronic fibrosing hepatitis. Similar changes were also noted
by Hoeppli (1933) in a series of 66 patients 21. In all of these individuals, the
infection was discovered incidentally at autopsy, most patients having die d
accidentally, and the conclusion was drawn that bodily damage may b e
considerable even though symptoms were abs ent or slight. More recent studies
such as those of Hou 23 have defined the incidence of gall-stones, biliar y
obstruction, cholangitis and cirrhosis in clonorchiasis, but the absence o f
controls has not allowed adequate evaluation of the role of Clonorchis in the
genesis of these conditions.
Although flukes generally live in the bile ducts, worms have occasionally
been found in the pancreatic ducts, the first such patient being described b y
Sambuc in 191364. Attempts have been made from time to time to associat e
clonorchiasis with cancer. Watson-Wemyss in 1919 reported the coexistence
of carcinoma of the liver and clonorchiasis in a Chinese soldier 72, but this
association was almost certainly coincidental since both conditions are ver y
common in eastern Asia. There may, however, be more substance in the sug-
gestion of a causal relationship between clonorchiasis and carcinoma of th e
bile ducts 17.
Although the first patient reported with clonorchiasis had features clearl y
referrable to the hepato-biliary system, having both fever and jaundice 45, these
signs could also have arisen as a result of complications of the Clonorchis
infection or from a co-existent illness. When he described his second cas e
three years later, McConnell remarked that:
I am inclined to believe that there do not exist any special symptoms o f
liver infection by these flukes - nothing by which the disease can b e
150 A History of Human Helminthology
by duodenal intubation 5.
Immunodiagnosis has not been of great value. Kuwabara and Muto in 1921
found that the complement fixation reaction was positive in a patient wit h
longstanding clonorchiasis but negative in a patient with recent infection 41. In
the following year, Ryuji extended these observations in both humans and exp-
erimental animals and concluded that the established methods of faeca l
examination for ova were both more reliable and easier 62.
Radiological investigations such as oral cholecystography and intravenous
cholangiography, although not providing an aetiological diagnosis, may give
a picture of structural damage consequent upon the infection 57. Functional
damage may be indicated by liver function tests, particularly in patients with
heavy infections or bacterial complications, but these tests are usually normal
in persons with light infections. Choi and his colleagues, for example, found
no significant differences between asymptomatic infected persons an d
uninfected control subjects 10.
Initial attempts to treat clonorchiasis were based upon the principle of firstly
stimulating liver secretions (hopefully) by the administration of such agents as
calomel, urotropin and sodium salicylate in order to expel the parasites from
the bile duct mechanically, then secondly, obtaining their removal from th e
intestines by prescription of purgatives and enemata 61. Needless to say, these
measures were not particularly effective. Direct surgical intervention wit h
flushing out of flukes by drainage of the gall bladder was also tried o n
occasion54,71. Similarly, Bercowitz proposed prolonged duodenal intubatio n
and suction in order to remove a dult worms, but the side-effects of such a pro-
cedure were somewhat severe 5.
A number of specific anthelmintics have been advocated. Some efficac y
has been claimed for tartar emetic 8, arsphenamine66 , gentian violet 14,56
,
68 58 29 4 32,59
neostibnal , gold , fouadin , chloroquine , hexachloroparaxylol , and
hetol76,77 but the effectiveness of these drugs left a lot to be desired and their
toxicity was a serious problem. The recent introduction of praziquantel (see
chapter 3) has provided a safer and more effective drug. Although Wang and
his colleagues compared praziquantel, amoscanate and hexachloroparaxylol
in 98 patients in China and concluded that hexachloroparaxylol was the drug
of choice70, subsequent workers have found that praziquantel to be the most
effective. Thus, Rim and his colleagues treated 35 patients with three doses of
praziquantel on a single day and cured 30 of them; the remaining five patients
were cured by a second course of treatment and there were few side-effect s
apart from headache and dizziness 60. Similar results have been reported b y
other investigators 2,22.
152 A History of Human Helminthology
REFERENCES
1. ABBOTT RT. Handbook of medically important mollusks of the Orient and Wester n
Pacific. Bulletin of the Museum of Comparat ive Zoology, Harvard College 100: 245-328,
1948
2. AMBROISE-THOMAS P, GOUVILLIER A, WEGNER DG. Le praziquantel dans le
traitement des distomatoses hépatiques extrême-orientales à Clonorchis sinensis ou
Opisthorchis viverrini. Bulletin de la Société de Pathologie Exotique 74: 426-433, 1981
154 A History of Human Helminthology
3. BAELZ E. Über einige neue Parasiten des Menschen. Berliner klinische Wochenschrift
20: 234-238, 1883
4. BASNUEVO JG. Cloroquina y clonorchiasis. Revista Kuba de Medicina Tropical y
Parasitologia 5: 105-110, 1949
5. BERCOWITZ Z. Clinical studies of human infestations with the liver fluke ( Clonorchis
sinensis). American Journal of Tropical Medicine 11: 43-60, 1931
6. BLANCHARD R. Animaux parasites (Notice préliminaire). Bulletin de la Sociét é
Zoologique de France 20: 217, 1895
7. BORDES FP, CAVALLO A, VAILLANTA, MARTIN M. Distomatose hépatiqu e
évoluant plus de vingt ans après l'infestation. Médecine Tropicale 23: 139-142, 1963
8. BRUG SL. Un cas grave de clonorchiase traité par l'émétique. Bulletins de la Société de
Pathologie Exotique et de ses Filiales 14: 161-162, 1921
9. CALERO MC. Clonorchiasis in Chinese residents of Panama. Journal of Parasitolog y
53: 1150, 1967
10. CHOI DW, KIM JW, PARKS SB. Laboratory findings in symptomless clonorchiasis.
Korean Journal of Parasitology 8: 8-12, 1970
11. COBBOLD TS. The new human fluke. Lancet ii: 423, 1875
12. FAUST EC. Notes on larval flukes from China. II. Studies on some larval flukes from
the central and south coast p rovinces of China. American Journal of Hygiene 4: 241-301,
1924
13. FAUST EC. Some recent aspects of the epidemiology of Clonorchis infection in China.
China Medical Journal 39: 287-296, 1925
14. FAUST EC, KE-FANG Y, KHAW O K, YUNG-AN C. Experimental therapy i n
Clonorchis infections. Proceedings of the Society for Experimental Biology and Medicine
23: 607-608, 1926
15. FAUST EC, KHAW OK. Excystment phenomena in Clonorchis sinensis . Proceedings
of the Society for Experimental Biology and Medicine 23: 245-248, 1925
16. FAUST EC, KHAW OK. Studies on Clonorchis sinensis (Cobbold) with a consideration
of the molluscan hosts of Clonorchis sinensis (Cobbold) in Japan, China and southeastern
Asia and other species of molluscs closely related to them. American Journal of Hygiene
Monograph Series, Number 3, pp 284, 1927
17. FLAVELL DJ. Liver fluke infection as an aetiological factor in bile duct carcinoma of
man. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 75: 814-824,
1981
18. GALLIARD H. Recherches sur l'étiologie de la distomatose hépatique au Tonkin .
Annales de l'École Supérieure de Médecine et de Pharmacie Indochine 2: 96-103, 1938
19. GUNN H. Clonorchis sinensis in Orientals arriving in the United States. Journal of the
American Medical Association 67: 1835-1836, 1916
20. HEANLEY CN. The age incidence of 109 cases of Opisthorchis sinensis infection in
Cantonese: its small pathologica l significance. Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene
2: 38-39, 1908
21. HOEPPLI R. Histological changes in the liver of thirty-six Chinese infected wit h
Clonorchis sinensis . Chinese Medical Journal 47: 1125-1141, 1933
22. HORSTMANN RD, FELDHEIM W, FELDMEIER H, DIETRICH M. High efficacy
of praziquantel in the treatment of 22 patients with Clonorchis/Opisthorchis infections.
Tropenmedizin und Parasitologie 32: 157-160, 1981
23. HOU PC. The pathology of Clonorchis sinensis infection of the liver. Journal o f
Pathology and Bacteriology 70: 53-64, 1955
24. HOUDEMEYER E. Au sujet d'une coutume favorisant l'infestation des Indochinois par
Clonorchis sinensis (Cobbold, 1875). Bulletins de la Société de Pathologie Exotique et
de ses Filiales 27: 21-23, 1934
25. HOUGHTON HS. Notes on the life cycle of Clonorchis. China Medical Journal 27 :
168-171, 1913
26. HSU HF, CHOW CY. Studies on certain problems of Clonorchis sinensis . II.
Clonorchiasis 155
Investigation in the chief endemic centre of China, the Canton area. Chinese Medica l
Journal 51: 341-356, 1937
27. HSU HF, LI SY. Studies on ce rtain problems of Clonorchis sinensis . VIII. Experimental
proof of Bithynia longicornis as the first intermediate host of C. sinensis. Chinese
Medical Journal, Supplement 3: 241-243. 1940
28. HSU HF, LI SY. Studies on certain problems of Clonorchis sinensis . IX. The migration
route of its larval stages in the snail, Bithynia fuschsiana . Chinese Medical Journal ,
Supplement 3: 244-254, 1940
29. HUECK O, WEN HH. Zur Fuadinbehandlung bei Opisthorchis sinensis . Archiv für
Schiffs- und Tropen-Hygiene 42: 25-27, 1938
30. IJIMA I. Notes on Distoma endemicum , Baelz. Journal of the College of Science ,
Imperial University, Tokyo 1: 47-59, 1886
31. ISHIZAKA K. Igaku Zasshi (40): 20-26, 1878. In Japanese
32. JOHN L, WANG CN, TSENG FJ, FAN KC, TU CC, CHANG TF, SUN KJ, CHI N
CM, TU SF. Hexachloroparaxylol in the treatment of clonorchiasis sinensis. Chines e
Medical Journal 84: 8-16, 1963
33. KEAN BH, MOTT JE, RUSSELL AJ. Tropical medicine and parasitology. Classi c
investigations, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, two volumes, pp 677, 1978
34. KHAW OK. The hatching pheno mena of Clonorchis ova. Proceedings of the Society for
Experimental Biology and Medicine 22: 564-566, 1925
35. KOBAYASHI HARUJIRO. (A preliminary report on the source of the human live r
distome, Clonorchis endemicus [Bälz][=Distoma spathulatum Leuckart]). Annotationes
Zoologicae Japonenses 271-277, 1911. In Japanese, with English summary
36. KOBAYASHI HARUJIRO. Saikingo Zasshi No. 202, pp 1-66, 1912. In Japanese
37. KOBAYASHI HARUJIRO. A preliminary report on the source of the human live r
distome, Clonorchis endemicum (Bälz)(Distomum spathulatum , Leuckart). Far Eastern
Association of Tropical Medicine: Transactions of the Second Biennial Congress, Hong
Kong, pp 108-112, 1912
38. KOBAYASHI HARUJIRO. On the life history and morphology of Clonorchis sinensis .
Centralblatt für Bakteriologie, Parasitenkunde und Infektionskrankheiten, Abteilun g
originale 75: 299-317, 1915
39. KOENIGSTEIN RP. Observations on the epidemiology of infections with Clonorchis
sinensis. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 42 :
503-506, 1949
40. KOMIYA Y. Clonorchis and clonorchiasis. Advances in Parasitology 4: 53-106, 1966
41. KUWABARA S, MUTO M. (Is immunization possible in liver distomiasis?) Chu o
Igakkai Kw. Zasshi Nagoya pp 34-45, 1921. In Japanese. Abstracted in Japanese Journal
of Medical Science 1: 145, 1922
42. LEIPER RT. Report on an exp edition to China to study the trematode infections of Man.
Unpublished report to the Colonial Office, pp 4, 1915. Abstracted in Tropical Diseases
Bulletin 6: 295-296, 1915
43. LEUCKART R. Die menschlichen Parasiten und die von ihnen herrührende n
Krankheiten. Ein Hand- und Lehrbuch für Naturforscher und Aertze, C F Winter'sch e
Verlagshandlung, Leipzig, volume 2, pp 882, 1867-1876
44. LOOSS A. On some parasites in the museum of the School of Tropical Medicine ,
Liverpool. Annals of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology 1: 123-152, 1907
45. McCONNELL JF. Remarks on the anatomy and pathological relations of a new species
of liver-fluke. Lancet ii: 271-274, 1875
46. McCONNELL JF. "Distoma sinense" (McConnell). Lancet i: 406, 1878
47. McGREGOR W. A new form of paralytic disease associated with the presence of a new
species of liver parasite. Glasgow Medical Journal 9: 3-15, 1877
48. MEBIUS J. Clonorchiosis hepatis, cirrhosis parasitaria en typische groei van het galgang-
epitheel. Geneeskundig Tijdschrift voor Nederlandsch-Indië 60: 224-294, 1920
49. MOORE D. Note on the longevity of Clonorchis sinensis . Public Health Reports 39 :
156 A History of Human Helminthology
18021803, 1924
50. MUKOYAMA T. (Experimental study on the transmigration route of the liver distome
in the body of the final host). Aichi Igakkai Zasshi 29, No. 2, 1922. In Japanese .
Abstracted in Japan Medical World 2: 243, 1922
51. MUTO M. Ueber den ersten Zwischenwirt von Clonorchis sinensis . Verhandlungen der
japanischen pathologischen Gesellschaft, Tokyo 8: 151, 1918. Abstracted in Tropica l
Diseases Bulletin 17: 49, 1921
52. MUTO M. (On the primary intermediate host of Clonorchis sinensis ) Chuo Igakkai
Zasshi 25, No. 3: 49-52, 1918. In Japanese. Translated in 33
53. MUTO M. On the duration of life of Clonorchis sinensis infecting the animal body. Japan
Medical World 2: 224-226, 1922
54. NARDONE PM. La distomiasis sinense. Contributo allo studio delle sindromi d a
"Clonorchis sinensis" nell'esturio dello Yangtzekiang e nella zona di Shanghai (Cur a
chirugica con fistola biliare terapeutica). Annali di Medicina Navale 53: 59-78, 1948
55. OLDT F. Is clonorchiasis a health menace in China? China Medical Journal 41: 185-204,
1927
56. OLIVIER PH, KANDOU R. De behandeling van Clonorchiasis sinensis me t
Gentiaanviolet Grübler. Geneeskundig Tijdschrift voor Nederlandsch-Indië 67: 59-63 ,
1927
57. OTTO JH. Zur Frage der röntgenolo gischen Erkenbarkeit krankhafter Veränderungen am
Magen-Darmkanal bei Patienten mit Opisthorchis sinensis . Archiv für Schiffs- un d
TropenHygiene 41: 296-302, 1937
58. OTTO JH, TSCHAN TJ. Ueber de Behandlung der menschlichen Infektion mi t
Clonorchis sinensis (Kobbold) mit Goldeinspritzungen. Archiv für Schiffs- un d
Tropen-Hygiene 39: 99-106, 1935
59. PLOTNIKOV NN, SINOVICH LI. (Experimental therapy of clonorchiasis wit h
hexachloroparaxylol. Preliminary communication). Meditsinskaya Parasitologiya i
Parazitarn e Bolezni, pp 301-302, 1964. In Russian, with English summary
60. RIM HJ, LYU KS, LEE JS, JOO KH. Clinical evaluation of the therapeutic efficacy of
praziquantel (Embay 8440) against Clonorchis sinensis infection in man. Annals o f
Tropical Medicine and Parasitology 75: 27-33, 1981
61. ROUX, TARDIEU. Un cas de distomatose hépatique ( Opisthorchis sinensis ) chez une
Européene. Bulletin de la Société Médico-Chirurgicale de l'Indochine 3: 528-532, 1912
62. RYUJI S. (Diagnostic value of complement fixation in distomiasis). Okayama Igakkwai
Zasshi No. 384, 1922. In Japanese. Abstracted in Tropical Diseases Bulletin 19: 651 ,
1922
63. SAITO S. (The internal organs of Clonorchis sinensis ova and the morphology of th e
miracidium). Tokyo Igakkai Zasshi 12: 579-587, 1898. In Japanese. Partly translated in
33
64. SAMBUC E. Distomatose pancréatique. Bulletin de la Société Médico-Chirurgicale de
l'Indochine 4: 331-333, 1913
65. SAMBUC E, BAUJEAN R. Un cas de cachexie aqueuse chez l'homme (distomatos e
hépatopancréatique) avec syndrome pseudo-béribérique. Bulletin de la Sociét é
Médico-Chirurgicale de l'Indochine 4: 425-429, 1913
66. SHATTUCK GC. Results of treatment for clonorchiasis. American Journal of Tropical
Medicine 3: 475-494, 1923
67. SHIMUZU K, KAWADA T. Prevention of distomi asis hepatis as carried out in Okayama
prefecture. Journal of the Public Health Association of Japan 13: 1-4, 1937
68. SHIRAI M. Studies on the tr eatment of experimental liver distomiasis with "Neostibnal".
Scientific Reports of the Government Institute of Infectious Diseases 5: 633-645, 1926
69. STRAUSS WG. Clinical manifestations of clonor chiasis - a controlled study of 105 cases.
American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 11: 625-630, 1962
70. WANG QN, LIU JB, LIU YH, CHEN RX, QIU ZD, QU ZG. Comparison o f
praziquantel, amoscanate and hexachloroparaxylol in clonorchiasis sinensis. Chines e
Clonorchiasis 157
SYNOPSIS
159
160 A History of Human Helminthology
eruption on his face and legs. While the patient was speaking, he was seized
by a fit of coughing and expectorated small quantities of reddish sputum .
Manson (who at that time was trying to find the daytime location of periodic
microfilariae) placed some of this material on a microscope and was astounded
to find that instead of the anticipated microfilariae, it:
contained, besides ordinary blood and mucus corpuscles, large numbers of bodies
evidently the ova of some parasite. These bodies were oval in form, one end of the
oval being cut off by an operculum, granular on the surface, bloodstained, measuring
on an average 1/300" x 1/500". Firm pressure on the covering glass caused them to
rupture and their contents to escape, the shell being left empty and fractured at the
opercular end....No distinctly organised embryo could be made out in the uninjured
ovum, but when the contents were expressed, they resolved themselves into oil
masses, and granular matter having very active molecular movements. 69
Concerned that there might be a parent worm in the mouth or throat, Manson
examined the oral cavity caref ully but failed to find such a parasite. In order to
exclude accidental introduction of ova in food, he obtained a fresh specimen
of sputum two days later and confirmed the presence of eggs. He wrote in his
diary at this time that "I cannot but think that the parent of the ova and th e
haemoptysis are associated as cause and effect" 72. Several years later he
recalled that "I concluded that a parasite must reside somewhere below th e
vocal cords, probably in the lungs, and that I had stumbled on a new disease." 71
Further enquiry revealed that the patient had o nly been in Amoy for one year.
He was a native of Foochow in China but fifteen years previously he had gone
to Taiwan to live and had remained there for nearly ten years. Moreover, the
attacks of haemoptysis had begun after he had been on that island for about a
year. He had lived in a town called Tacktc ham, a place about two days' journey
from Tamsui, and this reminde d Manson of the parasite discovered by Ringer.
Accordingly, he wrote to Ringer who s ent him the solitary specimen preserved
in "spirit of wine". Manson placed a little of the sediment in the spirit under a
microscope and "found in it several ova of the same shape, colour, an d
dimensions as those I had some time before found in the Chinaman' s
sputum."69
The parent parasite was light brown in colour, of a firm, leathery texture, and
measured nearly half an inch in length. Manson realised that it was a
trematode, but being unsure of whether or not it was a new species, sent it to
Spencer Cobbold in London together with a covering letter dated 4 May 1880
saying:
I could not find in your 'Parasites' a worm to correspond, and as I have some idea that
the worm is not an unfrequent cause of haemoptysis in Chinese, I turn to you for
more information. I send the worm - evidently a fluke - and also a sample of the
Chinaman's sputum.68
Cobbold communicated news of the discovery to the meeting of the Quekett
Microscopical Club on 25 June 1880, and there announced his intention t o
name the fluke Distoma ringeri after its discoverer. The first notice of thi s
event appeared in an abstract in The Lancet of 3 July 1880 13 then Manson's
Paragonimiasis 161
specimen. At last I have got a prominent one, and trust you will be able to compare
the eggs in the sputa with those which you found in the lung of a patient affected
with distoma. It is not at all improbable that you will find them identical. I had called
them Gregarinae, because they are exactly what is described as such, but now when
I send my first notice of them to Europe, I saw some cases what seem to me to prove
that the oval bodies must be eggs of some worm, and if so, there could hardly be
question of another than distoma. I wrote this to Leuckart, and he too is of the same
opinion....
P.S. I ask your pardon for my bad English, I have not much practice in writing the
language, and feel only too well that I always make mistakes. 18
When Manson examined the specimens sent to him by Baelz, he found that the
bodies were identical in every respect with those coughed up by his ow n
patient and with those expressed from Ringer's fluke 70. It was now clear that
Baelz's Gregarina pulmonalis were none other than ova of the fluke named
D. ringeri by Cobbold.
Near the end of 1880, the Japanese investigator, Nakahama, who had been
a medical student at Tokyo Imperial University and a pupil of Baelz, went to
Okayama in Japan to study the disease. He surveyed patients who came to the
clinic of the Okayama Prefectural Hospital between November 1880 an d
October 1882, and found 52 cases of the infection. In November 1881 in the
same hospital, Drs Kiyono, Suga and Yamagata performed their first autopsy
on a patient with parasitical haemoptysis and found about 20 cysts, each con-
taining one or two worms. Nakahama tried to study the morphology of these
worms but they had shrunk so badly in alcohol that it was impossible t o
discern details of their structu re. Nevertheless, he sent several worms to Baelz
in Tokyo with the suggestion that they be named Distoma pulmonalis. In
March 1883, Nakahama and Suga carried out a second autopsy and obtained
several more worms. Nakahama published his findings in four parts between
February and September 1883 94, then Baelz prepared a report (published in
a German journal) in which he named the species D. pulmonale 17, even
though he must have known that Cobbold had called the same parasite D.
ringeri.
Before all these events occurred, however, a royal tiger had died in th e
Amsterdam Zoological Gardens in Holland in September 1877. At autopsy,
worms thought to be a species of Distoma were found in the lungs. These hel-
minths were sent by the director of the zoo, Dr CF Westerman, to the Dutch
zoologist Coenraad Kerbert for further identificaton. Kerbert described th e
worms, which were nearly one centimetre long, as being:
found, always in pairs, inside rather thick, fibrous capsules, which, because of the
somewhat blue color, were noticed immediately on the outer surface of the lungs. 49
Since flukes had already been found in the lungs of an otter by Natterer an d
described by Diesing in 1850 (D. rude) and in an Indian mongoose by Cob-
bold in 1859 (D. compactum), Kerbert thought that this trematode migh t
prove to be one of those species. Detailed examination revealed that this was
not so, and Kerbert recorded the discovery in 1878, naming the worm afte r
Paragonimiasis 163
Westerman and wrote: "I feel justified, therefore, in introducing this unknown
worm to zoologists as Distoma westermanni, n. sp"49.
Three years later, another tiger died in the Zoological Gardens in Hamburg,
Germany, and a similar parasite was found in its lungs. This material was also
forwarded to Kerbert, enabling him to undertake an intensive morphological
study50.
The specimens studied by Kerbert were re-examined later by Leuckart and
Nakahama (who had gone from Japan to study parasitology in Germany with
Leuckart), and they compared them with the Japanese flukes. Nakahama, inc-
identally, later returned to Japan and was awarded the degree of doctor o f
medicine by Tokyo Imperial University. Much was expected of him as he was
the first Japanese to receive such an extensive parasitological training, but he
soon abandoned this vocation and took up a position as chief of the medical
section of the Nippon Life Insurance Company. In 1889, Leuckart wrote that
in his and Nakahama's opinion, the European and Japanese forms of th e
worms were identical 64. This view became accepted and Stiles and Hassa l
voiced the general opinion when they stated that the human parasite "though
originally supposed to represent a new species, is now generally admitted to
be identified with Kerbert's form from the tiger. 107.
Since Kerbert's description had priority, Cobbold's name of D. ringeri and
Baelz's D. pulmonale lapsed, and the parasite became known as D. wester-
manni, although there were pleas to the contrary, such as that written by Paul
in Japan:
'Distoma pulmonale' is the best name; it raises no question as to priority of discovery,
and by its affinity with the names 'distoma haematobium' and 'distoma hepaticum' it
aids the memory and pleases an orderly mind.101
There was considerable confusion over the correct spelling of the specifi c
name, however, with the forms westermanni, westermanii and westermani all
being used by different authors, and even by the same author; eventually the
last description became generally accepted even though Kerbert had first des-
cribed it as westermanni.
A number of authors realized that the morphological features of this fluke
were so distinctive that it should not be retained in the genus Distoma. In
1899. Max Braun erected the genus Paragonimus for the mammalian lung
flukes, making P. westermani (Kerbert) the type species 21. The name
Paragonimus was derived from the Greek words (PARA) meaning "by
the side of" and µ (GONIMOS) meaning "gonad" or "genitalia". Later
in the same year, and unaware of Braun's revision, Arthur Looss gave a
detailed description, which was the most accurate and complete that wa s
available for many years, of the parasite. He established the genus Polysarcus
for the mammalian lung flukes 66, but because of its slightly later appearance,
this name was relegated to synonymy.
164 A History of Human Helminthology
Manson concluded his paper of 1880 by remarking that the questions of the
existence and identity of the intermediate host or hosts of the parasite offered
a very interesting field for further investigation 69. Almost 40 years were t o
pass, however, before the life cycle of P. westermani was finally determined.
As soon as he first saw the ova, Manson realized that their contents wer e
undeveloped. For about 18 months after his discovery of the eggs, he scrut -
inized sputa of about 150 persons in a fruitless search for more ova; he hoped
that these would enable him to observe t he development of the larva within the
egg and characterize the conditions under which it hatched. He deduced that
the infection was not endemic in Amoy, and eventually obtained some fres h
infected sputum from Taiwan which permitted him to continue hi s
experiments. He placed some phlegm in water jars in his laboratory, the n
examined them daily for the first fortnight or so, but the ova refused to hatch.
He then forgot about the specimens for six weeks or so until his wife com -
plained of an odour emanating from the laboratory. The smell was comin g
from the decomposing sputum on which fungi of all descriptions wer e
growing. When he examined this material, Manson found that miracidia had
developed and escaped from the ova by way of the opercula 70. He reasoned
that the intermediate host must be an inhabitant of fresh water, common t o
Japan and Taiwan where parasitic haemoptysis appeared to be endemic, but
rare on the Chinese mainland around Amoy. With great foresight, h e
considered the possibility of a snail being the intermediate host. He wrote to
R Hungerford, a conchologist in Hong Kong for further information .
Hungerford replied on 21 October 1881 and with remarkable prescience put
his finger on the correct species:
My dear Manson, Your discoveries about the lung fluke are decisively interesting,
and any help I can give you in this matter is very much at your service. I know of one
fresh water species which I think answers all your requirements of 16 shells of which
I am sending you from my collection in the mail. Let me know if you would like to
have a few specimens in spirit and I will write to a friend in Nagasaki to send them
down. The shell I speak of is Melania libertina (Gould)....It occurs in Japan
at....places widely apart....I have found none of this species in China, however,....On
the whole I think M. Libertina must be your friend, he is a hardy beast and will reach
you from Tamsui alive....It will be something in favour of my hobby, if it helps clear
up a doubtful point in the natural history of flukes. 38
The full significance of Manson's perspicacity is displayed when it is recalled
that it was not until 1882 that Thomas and Leuckart demonstrated that Fasc-
iola hepatica was transmitted by molluscs (see chapter 4). Unfortunately, the
lack of potentially appropriate snails and the difficulty in obtaining a con -
tinuing supply of ova prevented Manson from pursuing the matter further.
Manson's observations on the development and hatching of miracidia were
confirmed by Nakahama in 1885, but no further significant advances wer e
Paragonimiasis 165
made until the Japanese physician, Koan Nakagawa, reported his discoveries
in 1915.
The discovery by Kobayashi that freshwater fishes were the second inter -
mediate host of Clonorchis sinensis (see chapter 6) encouraged Nakagawa ,
who had been appointed head of the public hospital in Shinchiku, Taiwa n
where parasitic haemoptysis was endemic, to seek the intermediate host o f
P. westermani. He knew that an intermediate host was necessary for he ha d
shown earlier that miracidia were incapable of developing in the definitiv e
host. In October 1913, he had both fed puppies with miracidia and immersed
them in water containing miracidia but had failed to find flukes in the dog s
45-100 days later90. He therefore collected and examined all the molluscs ,
fishes, amphibians and insects that he could find. In September 1914, he cap-
tured a crab that was of type he had not seen before in a rivulet near Kalapai
village. He identified this creatu re as Potamon obtusipes, although it was later
shown to be P. rathbuni 53. In the liver of this crustacean, Nakagawa foun d
numerous encysted larvae, 0.2 mm in diameter, which were unmistakabl y
half-grown trematodes, but the specific identity of which was uncertain .
Continued searching, however, revealed the worms that he had been seeking:
as a result of further investigation I found in the gills full-grown ones with all the
morphologic structures peculiar to the distome of the human lung. 89
The second form of encysted larvae measured 0.3-0.4 mm in diameter, had a
short, thick, straight body and an oval sucker with a spine. Nakagawa at that
time believed that both the large and the small cysts belonged to P. wester-
mani, with the smaller variety being merely younger stages of the larger. Sub-
sequently, he found both kinds of metacercariae in P. dehaani, and occasion-
ally in another crab, Eriocheir japonicus.
Nakagawa was convinced on morphological grounds that the larger cysts at
least, were stages in the life cycle of P. westermani, but in order to prove the
point, he had to raise adult worms from them. He therefore fed the liver, gills
and other organs of a crab harbouring numbers of encysted larvae to two pup-
pies that had been obtained fr om an area where paragonimiasis was unknown.
One of the dogs died 60 days later; post-morte m examination showed the lungs
to have a large number of cysts. Within each cyst, two or three P. westermani
were present, although they were insufficiently mature to produce eggs. The
second dog died 90 days after eating infected crab. At autopsy, the lungs of the
dog were found to contain numerous cysts enclosing adult flukes ready t o
discharge ova. He then repeated the experiment with three more puppie s
brought from a nonendemic area; two were fed with a large quantity of th e
internal organs of infected crabs while the third was left as a control. The first
two dogs died about seven weeks later and were found to be infected wit h
166 A History of Human Helminthology
streams in the region. He found 17 different kinds of cercariae, but could not
distinguish those of the lung fluke. He therefore put various snails in wate r
containing P. westermani miracidia in order to see which kinds of molluscs the
miracidia would infect:
It resulted that they infected Melania libertina Gould and M. oblique-granosa Smith
most abundantly. From this it may be assumed that these two species of fresh water
molluscs are the first intermediate hosts of the lung distomes. 89
Nakagawa tried to keep the snails alive in an experimental pond but they all
died within a few weeks and no fully-developed cercariae could be seen. He
did find, however, that all the M. libertina living in the creeks of a highl y
endemic area contained sporocysts in the liver and a particular cercaria which
he then described. He wrote in 1916 that "it may not be unreasonable to con-
clude that these cercariae are tho se of the lung distome. However, we have not
yet any experimental proof" 89.
In 1917, Nakagawa added new data to his earlier observations and indicated
that M. tuberculata was also a likely vector. He published a detailed des -
cription of the development of larvae in the snails, but it is unclear whethe r
these snails were infected experimentally with miracidia derived from human
P. westermani ova or whether they were naturally-infected snails. It is prob-
able that he was dealing with the latter case since he justified his assertion that
the resultant cercariae were P. westermani on a number of grounds, including
the resemblance between the cercariae and the small type of cyst he ha d
described in the livers of crabs. Further, he attempted to establish the link in
the life cycle between molluscs and crabs by infecting crabs with cercaria e
derived from snails. He had considerable difficulty in obtaining crabs free of
flukes, but finally secured 50 P. obtusipes and 20 P. dehaani. He put these
together with Melania snails in a stream on 4 September 1915 but was re -
warded with only scant success. Again, it is uncertain whether the snails were
infected experimentally or naturally. It seems likely that they were the latter,
in which case the identity of the parasites is doubtful. When Nakagaw a
examined the crabs 36 days later, he found none of 20 P. obtusipes and only
one of 20 P. dehaani infected. When the remaining 30 crabs were dissected
after a further three weeks, he could find only three infected animals .
Nakagawa was uncertain why it was so difficult to infect the crustacean s
experimentally. Indeed, the few crabs found to have been infected may wel l
have acquired their infection naturally in the wild. Nevertheless, Nakagaw a
was convinced that he had demonstrated the life cycle of P. westermani, and
in 1917 published his findings in the Journal of Experimental Medicine 90.
As mentioned earlier, Yokogawa in 1917 showed that the two types of cysts
found by Nakagawa in crabs represented different species of flukes. Thi s
confuses further the validity of the observations just described. Nakagaw a
recognized he veracity of Yokogawa's assertions and admitted that the forms
taken by him to be developmental stages of P. westermani belonged to some
unknown fluke. He thereupon published a new series of illustrations of th e
168 A History of Human Helminthology
various stages in the development of the larvae which form large cysts 91,92 to
replace the earlier series which had depicted both forms of larvae. The smaller
cysts were subsequently identified as belonging to a previously undescribe d
fluke, Stephanolecithus parvus 92,93.
Inconclusive attempts to passage P. westermani through M. libertina were
also made by Kakami 40. In 1918, Kobayashi working in Korea, showed tha t
under experimental conditions, P. westermani miracidia attacked M. gott-
schsei, M. nodiperda var. quinaria and M. extensa vigorously. He concluded
cautiously that the genus Melania was probably concerned in the metamorph-
osis of Paragonimus 55. He then examined the effects of infecting M. pauci-
cincta with P. westermani miracidia reared from human sputum. Th e
miracidia penetrated the skin readily and gave rise to sporocysts localized near
the surface. Within each sporocyst, a single redia was formed. The redia e
migrated into the deeper parts of the snail's body and formed secondgeneration
rediae which in turn migrated into the liver and produced cercariae 56. Similar
experiments were performed and results obtained at almost the same time by
K Miyairi78,79.
In a new attempt to prove that snails were the intermediate host of P. west-
ermani, A Ando (also known as R Ando) took cercariae isolated from (prob-
ably) naturally-infected Melania and introduced them through the mouth, gills,
genital openings and wounds on the surface of crabs, but the cercariae failed
to develop or else the crabs died. He therefore put P. dehaani into a pool with
snails heavily infected with cercariae; the snails had been obtained from a n
area that was highly endemic f or paragonimiasis. Many crabs became infected
subsequently with P. westermani, and some of the parasites were induced to
develop into adult Paragonimus when the infected crabs were fed to youn g
dogs6 . Ando also showed that a second intermediate host was necessary fo r
maturation, for when cercariae obtained from s nails were fed to or injected into
experimental definitive hosts, they failed to develop 8.
Although Ando later contended that he had proved definitely that Melania
libertina was the intermediate host of P. westermani 14, S Yokogawa and
Wakeshima in 1934 still believed that there was no conclusive proof that Mel-
ania species were involved, for experimental infections had never been carried
through from the miracidial through the cercarial and cystic to the adult stages
using defined worms obtained from infected individuals 130. It was not until
1934 that the complete life cycle of any Paragonimus (P. kellicotti) was
carried through experimentally 3. Finally, in 1952, M Yokogawa succeeded in
infecting experimentally P. dehaani, E. japonicus and P. clarkii with P.
westermani by feeding the crabs with cercariae in the digestive glands of M.
libertina121. This technique was necessary because Yokogawa had found that
cercariae were rarely shed from the snails under natural conditions. H e
concluded, therefore, that the second intermediate hosts were infected b y
eating snails containing mature cercariae.
The snail intermediate hosts of P. westermani all belong to the family
Paragonimiasis 169
For a number of years, the route o f migration of P. westermani larvae from the
mouth to the lungs was in doubt. Otani (1887) favoured the haematogenous
route100, while Yamagiwa (1890) believed that direct migration from th e
peritoneal cavity across the diaphragm to the pleural space and lungs wa s
more likely119. Once the final part of the life cycle was discovered by Naka -
gawa, however, the pathway of migration of larvae was determined independ-
ently and with incredible speed by f ive investigators, with Ando 4, Hisao Koba-
yashi60, Nakagawa88,89 and Sadamu Yokogawa 125,126 first reporting their results
in 1915 and Yoshida 134 doing likewise in the following year. Each of thes e
persons reported similar findings, so it is impossible to assign priority to any
particular individual. The most accessible of these papers, however, are those
of Nakagawa89 and Yoshida134 . In the experiments performed by these tw o
investigators, dogs and cats were fed upon infected crab flesh then killed after
varying periods. Once the larvae had escaped from the cysts, they penetrated
right through the intestinal wall, usually that of the jejunum, and entered the
peritoneal cavity, mostly within 48 hours. They then crossed the abdomina l
cavity and perforated the diaphragm to reach the pleural spaces after several
days. The larvae then travelled beneath the visceral pleura before burrowing
into the lung parenchyma where cysts were formed and the worms matured.
As Yokogawa remarked:
metacercariae....don't instantly penetrate the parenchyma, but rather they penetrate
the visceral pleura; from that point, they form the tiny vacuoles or tunnels. Even if
they move into the parenchyma, the young larvae penetrate freely into the tissues of
the lung and form petechiae in many places there. 126
In the lungs, the larvae developed into adult worms and often persisted fo r
many years. Ando and Tsuyuki recorded the case of a patient who still ha d
eggs in his sputum 20 years after leaving an endemic area 10.
Sometimes the migrating flukes took aberrant paths such as into th e
abdominal wall where they moved about in the muscles and connective tissue
planes, or through the mediastinal connective tissues, particularly via th e
perivascular sheaths, to the neck and head. Under these circumstances ,
however, they failed to complete their development. Thus, Nakagawa wrote:
These parasites can bore through various tissues and may reach other organs than the
lungs, where they form their regular cysts, but the lungs seem to be the most
170 A History of Human Helminthology
favourable place for their development and the laying of their eggs. In other organs,
they can never reach the perfect growth.89
These views were echoed by S Yokogawa:
metacercariae....are able to live and grow in connective tissues such as the
mediastinum, the greater omentum, subcutaneous connective tissue, orbit, eyelids,
the scrotum and brain. They don't have means of discharging eggs or ovulation.
What is more a mechanical stimulation causes suppurative inflammation in the area,
thus the larvae might be destroyed by lack of nutrition. In contrast to the above fact,
those parasites which reside in the lungs easily produce ova when the nutrients are
provided; thus they stay there longer and produce those symptoms which initially
attracted my attention to them as parasites.126
Subsequent studies, however, showed that this was not always true. Fo r
example, Kimuri found large numbers of eggs in the neighbourhood of cysts
in the brain 52, and Choy and Ludlow noted ova in a mass in the anterio r
abdominal wall 28.
In order to determine whether resistance to reinfection could be induced in
paragonimiasis, Ando fed cysts repeatedly to dogs that were already infected
with adult flukes. He found that the number of flukes which matured declined
progressively. Furthermore, when puppies born of infected bitches were chal-
lenged, flukes failed to develop in the lungs. Thus, Ando concluded that a n
effective immunological response was mounted 9.
Pathological reactions in the definitive host were studied in experimenta l
animals and in humans that came to autopsy, with attention being focused on
both the worms in the lungs and those in aberrant sites. S Yokogawa 126 and
other early investigators found that migrating larvae caused little reaction .
Sometimes, petechiae were noticed in the intestinal wall where larvae ha d
presumably penetrated and a m ild inflammatory reaction in the serous cavities
was evoked occasionally. Similarly, helminths migrating through the body not
infrequently left small haemorrhages marking their tracks. Kau and Wu studied
the histopathology of the lungs of cats infected experimentally and note d
collapse, congestion, oedema and leucocytic infiltration which culminated in
the formation of a fibrous cyst wall around worms 45. Ova surrounded by
chronic granulomatous inflammation were seen in the walls of cysts, in th e
bronchial mucosa and submucosa, and in the hilar lymph nodes. Simila r
changes were described in infected human lungs 37,86,100. Cysts about 1 cm in
diameter were found more commonly in the deeper parts of the lungs, with a
matrix of small blood vessels in the capsule and with openings into th e
airways, thus allowing egress of ova and any blood surrounding the worms. In
ectopic locations, chronic inflam mation produced granulomatous tubercle-like
lesions which sometimes suppurated.
Paragonimiasis 171
subsequently concluded that the eggs that he had seen were really those o f
Schistosoma japonicum. Nevertheless, Kawamura and his colleagues late r
claimed that Paragonimus infection may be a significant cause of centra l
nervous system disease 46,47. In one village of 686 inhabitants, 11 cases of brain
complications were found among the children, so me of whom died. An autopsy
was performed on only one of these children, however; it disclose d
Paragonimus eggs in caseous cysts in the brain. The outstanding clinical feat-
ures were described as follows:
It begins with sudden severe headaches with vomiting and dizziness. In many cases,
there are epileptic attacks....These attacks are repeated several times and may last
from one to two hours or as long as ten or fifteen days. Various symptoms at the time
of the onset disappear gradually....mentality is weakened in some cases and in worst
cases they become idiotic.47
In other patients, spastic paraplegia followed infection, most commonly when
it involved the lower thoracic area with extradural deposits of worms 98, the
first such patient being reported in 1917 by Moriyasu 85.
When Manson found Paragonimus ova in the sputum of his patients, he nat-
urally turned his attention towards trying to cure them and made many attempts
of dislodge the parasites. With consi derable ingenuity, he introduced a number
Paragonimiasis 173
Rim and his colleagues showed that niclofolan was effective in cats and dogs
infected with P. westermani 102. In the following year, menichlopholan ( =
niclofolan) was shown to give a cure rate of between 73% and 90% in humans
infected with P. uterobilateralis in Nigeria97. Ripert and colleagues then exam-
ined the efficacy of a single dose of niclofolan in Cameroon and obtained a
cure rate of 100% 105. Finally, praziquantel (see chapter 3) has been shown to
be highly effective. In 1981, Rim and co-workers in Korea reported that up to
100% effectiveness could be obtained, depending upon the dose of prazi -
quantel used103. In contrast to niclofolan, however, praziquantel had negligible
side-effects. Thus, this agent seems destined to become the standard agent for
the therapy of paragonimiasis.
As the mode of transmission between first and second intermediate hosts was
clarified and as the various reservoir hosts of the adult worms were identified,
the epidemiology of paragonimiasis gradually began to be understood. Th e
first advance was the discovery of infection in Potamon obtusipes (= P.
rathbuni) and then in P. dehaani and Eriocheir japonicus by Nakagawa. This
was followed by the demonstration by various investigators that in addition to
Potamon and Eriocheir, other genera of crabs, including Potamiscus,
Parathelphusa and Siamthelphusa, were important in transmission in some
countries. Furthermore, the cr ayfish, Cambaroides and Procambarus, and the
shrimp, Palaemon, were also found to be vectors of infection. Similarly, the
realization that a snail, Melania (= Semisulcospira) libertina was the first
intermediate host of P. westermani was followed by the discovery that species
of Brotia were also susceptible to infection. It became appreciated tha t
different species of both primary and secondary intermediate hosts ha d
different habitats, some living in mountain streams, whereas others inhabited
delta regions.
Transmission of infection, however, depended upon the presence of defin-
itive hosts excreting P. westermani ova into the environment. In addition t o
humans and the tigers originally shown to be infected by Kerbert, a wide range
of vertebrates, including dogs, cats, pigs, panthers, wolves and foxes, wa s
shown to be infected in nature 58,59. Railliet in 1890 was apparently the firs t
person to report the occurrence of P. westermani in dogs, the specimen being
shown in the Japanese veterinary exhibit at the Paris exposition and bein g
named by him "Metagonimus pulmonalis , or better M. ringeri, or better still,
M. westermanni". In 1892, Janson reported that Tokishige found the lung fluke
in dogs and pigs in Japan, while the parasite was found in cats by Inouye and
Katsurada in 1893 (cited in 128).
For humans to acquire infection, however, cysts have to be ingested in a
viable state. The dietary habits and methods of preparing crustaceans var y
Paragonimiasis 175
from place to place. In China, the eating of crabs dates back at least 3,00 0
years118. The dish may be well- or slightly-cooked, or eaten uncooked ,
depending upon the preference of the consumer. Sometimes the crabs ar e
merely immersed in millet or rice wine, so that these "drunken" crabs are still
living when devoured. In some areas, the crab juice is a domestic remedy for
such ailments as whooping cough a nd measles 77, while Koreans commonly eat
fresh crabs as an antipyretic and an tidiarrhoeal remedy 57. Famine may increase
the consumption of crabs and thus precipitate an outbreak of paragonimiasis,
as happened in eastern Nigeria du ring the Nigerian Civil War of 1967-1970 96.
Finally, infection may occur even without eating crabs as was indicated by the
disease occurring in American soldiers who were presumed to have drun k
contaminated water 106.
Although paragonimiasis has been found most commonly in eastern Asia,
infection was recognized gradually amongst th e indigenous inhabitants of other
regions, including Central America 63, South America19 , Central Africa65 and
Melanesia35. Even though some of these infections may have been acquired as
a result of transmission via immigrant carriers from endemic regions, as may
have happened, for example, with the Peruvian engineer who was a patient of
Barton19, it is now realized that in some of these foci, infections are caused by
species of Paragonimus other than P. westermani (see differentiation of
species).
Even without knowing anything of the life cycle of P. westermani, Manson was
able, by the use of elementary epidemiological principles, to indicat e
accurately the means by which human infection could be prevented:
It is only necessary to boil or filter water, and never to eat uncooked vegetables or
other uncooked food.71
The validity of these views was established when the life cycle wa s
determined, with particular attention being paid to avoiding uncooked crabs
and other potentially-infected crustaceans. If these measures were adopted ,
paragonimiasis could be eliminated in human populations. To this end, health
education campaigns have been carried out in several heavily endemic areas,
but it is difficult to change the entrenched habits of a population.
Attempts to break the life cycle of Paragonimus by attacking one of the
intermediate hosts are difficult. Extermination of crabs is next to impossible,
even if desirable, owing to their hiding in deep holes and under stones in river
beds57. Similarly, control of molluscs is often not practicable, although chem-
ical agents and natural predators such as ducks and carp have been tried 7.
176 A History of Human Helminthology
DIFFERENTIATION OF SPECIES
Speciation in the genus Paragonimus has long been a subject of confusion and
controversy. As discussed earlier, Baelz classsified the human parasite no w
known as P. westermani as two separate species, but this view was no t
generally accepted. For a number of years, the lung flukes found in variou s
animal species were also equated with P. westermani. This seemed not unreas-
onable because it appeared until 1894, that all of these animals could hav e
been infected in areas in which human paragonimiasis was endemic.
In 1894, Henry Ward described a lung fluke obtained from a cat in Michi-
gan, USA. Although differences were m entioned between this worm and those
described by Kerbert in tigers and by Leuckart and others in humans, th e
parasite was nevertheless assigned tentatively to the species, P. westermani,
especially as there was a possibility that the host had been brought as a pe t
from the Orient114. Exotic infection seemed less likely, however, when Kelli-
cott later that year discovered worms in the lungs of a dog in Columbus, Ohio;
these parasites were sent to Ward and he identified them as being identica l
with those reported earlier by him from the cat 116. No doubt remained tha t
paragonimiasis was endemic in the USA when Stiles and Hassal in 1900 re-
corded the discovery made two years earlier by AJ Payne of many lung flukes
in pigs in Cincinatti, Ohio, this parasite also being given the tentativ e
designation, P. westermani 107. In 1908, however, Ward reached th e
conclusion that the lung fluke found in cats, dogs and pigs in the United States
was undoubtedly a distinct species, and to this he gave the name, P.
kellicotti 115. In 1915, Ward and Hirsch compared Kerbert's original specimens
from the tiger with animal material from the USA and human flukes fro m
eastern Asia. On the basis of the structure and distribution of the cuticula r
spines, they concluded that these flukes represented three separate specie s
which they named P. westermani, P. kellicotti and P. ringeri, respectively 117.
Kobayashi, on the other hand, believed that there was but one species, for
when he examined flukes from a variety of both natural and experimental hosts
in Korea, he found great variation in the cuticular spines 56. Ameel in 1934
reached the view that differentiation of species on the basis of cuticular spines
was very doubtful, but found that there was a clearcut difference between P.
kellicotti and P. westermani in the anatomy of the digestive tract 3. Despite the
difficulties in establishing the systematic position of new isolations, a number
of new species have been described in the last two decades. By 1975 ,
Yokogawa was able to list 31 species of Paragonimus but recognized that
some of them were not or may not be valid 122. At least nine species ar e
believed cause to disease in man, although some of them may be synonymous.
Paragonimiasis 177
P. AFRICANUS
This fluke was found in the mongoose and dog and was first described by
Voelker and Vogel in 1965 in West Africa 111. The snail and crab inter-
mediate hosts are probably Potadoma freethii and Sudanautes species,
respectively. Later in the same year, Vogel and Crewe identified P. afric-
anus eggs in sputa from 30 patients 112.
P. ECUADORIENSIS
This species was found in 1979 by Voelker and Arzube in a coati in Ecua-
dor109. The crab host is Hypoloberca aequatoralis but the first inter-
mediate host is as yet unknown. The same authors identified eggs in th e
sputum of two patients in Ecuador as P. ecuadoriensis.
P. HETEROTREMUS
This fluke was first reported in rats by Ch'en and Hsia in 1964 27. It was
described later in the same year as P. tuanshanensis by Chung and col-
leagues30. Tricula gregoriana and Potamon species were shown to be the
first and second intermediate hosts, respectively. It was first found i n
humans in the subcutaneous tissues of the chest of a 13 year old boy i n
Thailand by Miyazaki and Harinasuta in 1966 81, then in the lungs of 39
year old Laotian male 80.
P. HUEITUNGENSIS
Immature forms of this worm were first found in biopsy of migratory sub-
cutaneous nodules from two children in China and colleagues in 1977 ,
then the adult worms were recovered from rats, cats and dogs infecte d
experimentally32. The snail host is Tricula cristata and the crab hosts are
species of Siropotamon and Isalopotamon.
P. KELLICOTTI
P. MEXICANUS
This species was found in opossums in 1968 by Miyazaki and Ishii 83.
P. peruvianis, reported by Miyazaki and colleagues from Peru in 1969 82,
is now thought to be a synonym. Miyazaki and Ishii 83 also identified the
eggs in the lungs of a 35 year old Mexican, and which had been described
as P. westermani by Martinéz Báez and Jiménez Galán in 1961 76, as being
those of P. mexicanus. Details of the life cycle were described by Brenes
and collaborators in 1980 22.
P. MIYAZAKII
This fluke was first recovered from a cat which had been infected with
a crab by Kamo and colleagues in Japan in 1961 42. Bythinella species41
and P. dehaani 108 were shown to be the first and second intermediat e
hosts, respectively. Human infections have also been described 123.
P. SKRJABINI
P. UTEROBILATERALIS
This trematode was recovered from a swamp mongoose in West Africa and
described by Voelker and Vogel in 1965 111. The crab hosts are species of
Sudanonautes. Human infection with this parasite was first describe d
under this name by Onuigbo and Nwako in Nigeria in 1974 99 then by
Voelker and Nwokola in 1977 110. Praziquantel was shown to be effective
in treatment by Monson and colleagues in 1983 84.
REFERENCES
1. ABBOTT RT. Handbook of medically important mollusks of the Orient and Western Pacific.
Bulletin of the Museum of Comparative Zoology, Harvard College 100: 245-328, 1948
2. ABEND L. Ueber Haemoptysis parasitäria. Deutsches Archiv für klinische Medizin 100:
501-511, 1910
Paragonimiasis 179
3. AMEEL D. Paragonimus, its life history and distribution in North America and its taxonomy
(Trematoda: Troglotrematidae). American Journal of Hygiene 19: 279-317, 1934
4. ANDO A. (Investigation on Paragonimus westermani.) Chugai Iji Shinpo Nos. 847, 851,
856, 1915. In Japanese
5. ANDO A. Komplementablekung bei der Distomiasis pulmonum. Verhandlungen der
japanischen pathologischen Gesellschaft, Tokyo 7: 128, 1917. Also: (Complement fixation
test of paragonimiasis) Nihon Byori Gakkai 7: 633, 1917. In Japanese
6. ANDO A. (The first intermediate host of Paragonimus westermani.) Tokyo Iji Shinshi Nos.
2175-2178, pp 21, 1920. In Japanese. Abstracted in Tropical Diseases Bulletin 17: 51, 1921
7. ANDO A. (A supplementary notice on the prevention and elimination of pulmonary
distomiasis.) Nippon Biseibutsakkwai Gakka Zasshi 15: 43-56, 1921. In Japanese.
Abstracted in Japan Medical World 1: 19, 1921
8. ANDO A. (Morphologische und biologische Untersuchung ueber die Zerkaria vonPara-
gonimus westermani.) Chugai Iji Shinpo 41: 286-297, 1921. In Japanese. Abstracted in
Tropical Diseases Bulletin 21: 538, 1924
9. ANDO A. (Can immunisation be obtained by the infestation of Paragonimus westermanii?)
Iji Shinbun No. 1070, 1921. In Japanese. Abstracted in Tropical Diseases Bulletin 20:
209-210, 1923
10. ANDO A, TSUYUKI A. (On the endemic of pulmonary distomiasis in Tokigun, Gifu
prefecture.) Iji Shinbun No. 1136, pp 327-337, 1924. In Japanese
11. ANDO A YAMADA M. Chuo Igaku Zasshi No. 128, pp 1-11, 1916. In Japanese. Also
published as ANTO R, YUMATA R (X-ray diagnosis of pulmonary lesions of Paragonimus
westermani.) Taiwan Igakukai Zasshi No. 169, pp 934-935, 1916. In Japanese. Abstracted
in Tropical Diseases Bulletin 10: 109, 1917
12 ANONYMOUS. Microfilariae. Lancet ii: 25, 1880
13. ANONYMOUS. Parasitical haemoptysis. Lancet ii: 548-549, 1880
14. ANONYMOUS. In, 406th Medical General Laboratory. Annual Historical Report 1951.
Professional Section, Tokyo, pp 304, 1952. Cited in 128
15. ARCE J. La paragonimiasis en El Peru. Crónica Médica, Lima 32: 249-254, 1915
16. BAELZ EO. Ueber parasitäre hämoptoë (Gregarinosis pulmonum). Centralblatt für die
medicinischen Wissenschaften 18: 721-722, 1880. Translated in 48. Abstracted in Lancet ii:
548-549, 1880
17. BAELZ EO. Ueber einige neue Parasiten des Menschen. Berliner klinische Wochenschrift
20: 234-238, 1883
18. BAELZ EO. Cited in 73 and 74
19. BARTON. Cited in 15
20. BERCOWITZ Z. Clinical studies on human lung fluke disease (endemic haemoptysis)
caused by Paragonimus westermani infestation. American Journal of Tropical Medicine 17:
101-122, 1937
21. BRAUN MG. Über Clinostomum Leidy. Zoologischer Anzeiger 22: 489-493, 1899
22. BRENES R, ZELEDÓN R, ROJAS G. Biological cycle and taxonomic position of a Costa
Rican Paragonimus and the present status of Paragonimus from the New World. Brenesia
18: 353-366, 1980
23. CH'EN HT. (New species of lung flukes and note on Paragonimus species in China as
related to human infections.) 1958 Annual Report of the Chungshan Medical College, p 152,
1959. In Chinese
24. CH'EN HT. Taxonomic consideration of Paragonimus, including morphological notes on
P. skrjabini. Acta Zoologica Sinica 12: 27-36, 1960
25. CH'EN HT. The etiologic agent of human paragonimiasis in China. Chinese Medical Journal
81: 345-353, 1962
26. CH'EN HT. Paragonimus, Pagumogonimus and a paragonimus-like trematode in man.
Chinese Medical Journal 84: 781-791, 1965
27. CH'EN HT, HSIA TK. (A preliminary report on a new species of Paragonimus.) Zhongshan
Daxue Wuebo 2: 236-238, 1964. In Chinese, with English summary
28. CHOY PD, LUDLOW AI. Ova ofParagonimus westermani encysted in the abdominal wall.
China Medical Journal 40: 326-328, 1926
29. CHOY HL, CH'EN CH, HOU TC. Preliminary observations on efficacy of chloroquine in
180 A History of Human Helminthology
treatment of paragonimiasis. A report of 3 cases. Chinese Medical Journal 72: 1-14, 1954
30. CHUNG HL, HO LY, CHENG LT, TS'AO WC. The discovery in Yunnan Province of two
new species of lung flukes Paragonimus tuanshanensis sp. nov. and Paragonimus
menglaensis sp. nov. Part I. Studies on morphology and life history with discussion on
possible pathogenicity to man. Chinese Medical Journal 83: 641-659, 1964
31. CHUNG HL, HO LY, TS'AO WC, HSING PH, TUNG YC, MU SH. The discoveryof a
minute freshwater snail, Tricula sp. as the first intermediate host of Paragonimus
szechuanensis. Chinese Medical Journal 82: 712-717, 1963
32. CHUNG HL, HSU CP, HO LY, KAO PC, LAN S, CHIU FH. Studies on a new pathogenic
lung fluke - Paragonimus heit'ungensis sp. nov. Chinese Medical Journal 3: 379-394, 1977
33. CHUNG HL, TS'AO WC. Paragonimus westermani (Szechuan variety) and a new species
of lung fluke - Paragonimus szechuanensis. Part I. Studies on morphological and life history
of Paragonimus szechuanensis. Chinese Medical Journal 81: 354-378, 1962
34. CHUNG HL, TS'AO WC. Paragonimus westermani (Szechuan variety) and a new species
of lung fluke - Paragonimus szechuanensis. Part II. Studies on clinical aspects of
paragonimiasis szechuanensis - a new clinical entity. Chinese Medical Journal 81: 419434,
1962
35. CILENTO RW, BACKHOUSE TC. Paragonimiasis: its first recorded occurrence in the
Territory of New Guinea. Medical Journal of Australia i: 79-81, 1927
36. COBBOLD TS. Note by the President. Journal of the Quekett Microscopical Club 6: 139-
140, 1880
37. DIACONITA GH, GOLDIS G. Investigations in pathomorphology and pathogenesis of
paragonimiasis. Acta Tuberculosea Scandinavica 44: 51-75, 1964
38. HUNGERFORD R. Cited in 73
39. IKEDA M. (Report on treatment of lung fluke disease with emetine hydrochloride.) Namman
Igukkwai Zasshi 3: 120-126, 1915. In Japanese
40. KAKAMI. (Paragonimus westermanii, investigation of the lung distoma in South Ham
Kyung Province, Korea.) Chosen I Ho No. 12, pp 151-156, 1916. In Japanese. Abstracted
in Tropical Diseases Bulletin 8: 504, 1916
41. KAMO H, HATSUSHIKA R, MAEJIMA J. Studies on Paragonimus miyazakii Kamo,
Nishida, Hatsushika et Tomimura 1961. I. Snail intermediate host and intrasnail stages.
Yonago Acta Medica 11: 26-34, 1967
42. KAMO H, NISHIDA H, HATSUSHIKA R, TOMIMURA T. On the occurrence of a new
lung fluke, Paragonimus miyazakii n. sp. in Japan (Trematoda: Troglotrematidae). Yonago
Acta Medica 5: 43-52, 1961
43. KATAMINE D, MURAKAMI F, MOTOMURA K, NIKISHUBO K, AJISAKA S,
TAKATSO H. (Treatment of human paragonimiasis with bithionol). Endemic Diseases
Bulletin, Nagasaki University 3: 130-138, 1961. In Japanese, with English summary
44. KATSURADA F. Schistosoma japonicum, a new human parasite which gives rise to an
endemic disease in different parts of Japan. Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 8:
108-111, 1905
45. KAU LS, WU K. Preliminary report on histopathology of paragonimiasis in cats in China.
Chinese Medical Journal Supplement 1: 101-105. 1936
46. KAWAMURA R, ISHIBARA C, YAMAGUCHI S. (Paragonimus westermanii infection
in children, with invasion of the brain.) Tokyo Iji Shinshi No. 2064, pp 449-454, 1918. In
Japanese. Abstracted in Tropical Diseases Bulletin 16: 130, 1920
47. KAWAMURA R, YAMAGUCHI M. On the pulmonary distomiasis which caused brain
symptoms in children. Japan Medical World 1; No. 4: 1-7. 1921
48. KEAN BH, MOTT KE, RUSSELL AJ. Tropicalmedicine and parasitology. Classic investig-
ations, two volumes, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, pp 677, 1978
49. KERBERT C. Zur Trematoden-Kenntnis. Zoologischer Anzeiger 1: 271-273, 1878. Partly
translated in 48
50. KERBERT C. Beitrag zur Kenntnis der Trematoden. Archiv für mikroskopische Anatomie
und Entwicklungsmechanik 19: 529-578, 1881
51. KIKUIKO M, IMAMURA H. (Paragonimus westermanni infection, treatment by emetine
hydrochloride.) Chu Gai Iji Shimpo No. 908, 1918. In Japanese. Abstracted in Tropical
Diseases Bulletin 15: 214-215, 1920
Paragonimiasis 181
52. KIMURI O. A case of cysts in the brain caused by Paragonimus westermani. Mittheilung
aus der pathologischen Institut der kaiserlich-japanischen Universität zu Sendai, Japan 1:
375-384, 1921
53. KOBA K. Revision of the specific name of a crab as a second intermediate host ofParagon-
imus westermani in Formosa. Science Reports of the Tokyo Bunrika Daigaku 39: 201-207,
1936. Abstracted in Tropical Diseases Bulletin 34: 397, 1937
54. KOBAYASHI HARUJIRO. (A crayfish as one of the intermediate hosts ofParagonimus
westermanii) Chosen Igakukai Zasshi No. 19, pp 65-69, 1917. In Japanese. Abstracted in
Tropical Diseases Bulletin 12: 174, 1918
55. KOBAYASHI HARUJIRO. Studies on the lung fluke in Korea. I. On the life-history and
morphology of the lung fluke. Mittheilungen aus der medizinischen Fachschule zu Keijo 2:
97-115, 1918
56. KOBAYASHI HARUJIRO. Studies on the lung fluke in Korea. II. Structure of the adult
worm. Mittheilungen aus der medizinischen Fachschule zu Keijo 3: 16-36, 1919. Abstracted
in Tropical Diseases Bulletin 14: 139-140, 1919
57. KOBAYASHI HARUJIRO. On the development of Paragonimus westermanni and its pre-
vention. Japan Medical World 1: 14-17, 1921
58. KOBAYASHI HARUJIRO. On the animal parasites in Korea. Japan Medical World 5: 9-16,
1925
59. KOBAYASHI HARUJIRO. Lung-fluke disease in Chosen. Mittheilungen aus der medizin-
ischen Akadamie zu Keijo 9, Nos. 3 & 4, pp 3, 1926
60. KOBAYASHI HISAO. (The migratory course of the lung fluke in the body of the final host.)
Tokyo Iji Shinshi Nos. 1925 & 1930, 1915. In Japanese
61. KOMIYA Y, YOKOGAWA M. The recovery of Paragonimus eggs from stools of patients
by AMS III centrifuging technic. Japanese Journal of Medical Science and Biology 6:
207-211, 1953
62. KONDO K. (Antimony treatment of paragonimiasis.) Tokyo Iji Shinshi Nos. 2383-2385,
1924. In Japanese. Abstracted in Tropical Diseases Bulletin 22: 474, 1925
63. LARA A. Hemoptysis endemica de los Paises tropicales. Revista de Medicina de Yucatan 9:
1-5, 1913
64. LEUCKART R. Die parasiten des Menschen und die von ihnen herrhührenden Krankheiten.
Ein Hand- und Lehrbuch für Naturforscher und Aertze, C F Winter'sche Verlagshandlung,
Leipzig, Abtheilung 2, volume 1, pp 897, 1886-1901
65. LIBERT C. A case of paragonimiasis. West African Medical Journal 5: 51-52, 1932
66. LOOSS A. Weitere Beiträge zur Kenntnis der Trematoden-Fauna Aegyptens zugleich
Versuch einer naturlichen Gliederund des Genus Distomum Retzius. Zoologische Jahrbücher
Abteilung für Systema 12: 521-784, 1899
67. LÜ CH et al. Clinical observations of195 cases of Paragonimus in children. Chinese Journal
of Pediatrics 8: 143-146, 1957
68. MANSON P. Further observations on microfilariae, with descriptions of new species, com-
municated (with a prefatory note) by the President. Journal of the Quekett Microscopical
Club 6: 130-140, 1880
69. MANSON P. Distoma ringeri. China Imperial Maritime Customs. Medical Reports for the
half year ended 30th September 1880. 20th issue, pp 10-12, 1881. Reprinted in Medical
Times and Gazette ii: 8-9, 1881
70. MANSON P. Distoma ringeri and parasitical haemoptysis. China Imperial Maritime
Customs. Medical reports for the half yearended 30th September 1881. 22nd issue, pp 55-62,
1882. Reprinted in Medical Times and Gazette ii: 42-45, 1882
71. MANSON P. On endemic haemoptysis. Lancet i: 532-534, 1883
72. MANSON P. Cited in 73
73. MANSON-BAHR P. Patrick Manson as aparasitologist. A "critical review". In International
Review of Tropical Medicine, D R Linicombe (Editor), Academic Press, New York, pp
77-129, 1961
74. MANSON-BAHR PH, ALCOCK A. The life and work of Sir Patrick Manson, Cassell,
London, pp 273, 1927
75. MARTIN SH. Paragonimiasis and its treatment. China Medical Journal 41: 457-460, 1927
76. MARTINÉZ BAELZ M, JIMÉNEZ GALÁN A. Un cas de trematodiasis pulmonar reg-
182 A History of Human Helminthology
istrado en Mexico. Revista del Instituto de Salubridad y Enfermedades Tropicales 21: 101-
114, 1961
77. MINAMI S, SATO T. Hautgeschwülste durch Lungen distoma (Paragonimus westermani).
Arbeiten aus der medicinischen Universität zu Okayama 2: 78-88, 1930
78. MIYAIRI K. (A contribution to the knowledge and development of the lung fluke). Sai Kin
Gaku Zasshi No. 281, 1919. In Japanese
79. MIYAIRI K. Beitrag zur Kenntnis der Entwicklung für Paragonimus westermanii. Mittheil-
ungen aus der medizinischen Fakultät der kaiserlichen Universität Kyushu Fukuoka 6:
313-319, 1922. Abstracted in Tropical Diseases Bulletin 21: 539, 1924
80. MIYAZAKI I, FONTAN R. Mature Paragonimus heterotremus found from a man in Laos.
Japanese Journal of Parasitology 19: 109-113, 1970
81. MIYAZAKI I, HARINASUTA T. The first case of human paragonimiasis caused by
Paragonimus heterotremus Chen et Hsia, 1964. Annals of Tropical Medicine and Para-
sitology 60: 509-514, 1966
82. MIYAZAKI K, IBANEZ N, MIRANDA H. On a new lung fluke found in Peru. Para-
gonimus peruvianus sp. n. (Trematoda: Troglotrematidae). Japanese Journal of Parasitology
18: 123-130, 1969
83. MIYAZAKI I, ISHII Y. Studies on the Mexican lung flukes with special reference to a des-
cription of Paragonimus mexicanus (Trematoda: Troglotrematidae). Japanese Journal of
Parasitology 17: 445-453, 1968
84. MONSON MH, KOENIG JW, SACHS R. Successful treatment with praziquantel of six
patients infected with the African lung fluke, Paragonimus uterobilateralis. American
Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 32: 371-375, 1983
85. MORIYASU R. (A case of myelitis caused by parasitism of Paragonimus westermani in
the vertebral canal.) In Japanese. Cited in 128
86. MUSGRAVE WE. Paragonimiasis in the Philippine Islands. Philippine Journal of Science
B 2: 15-63, 1907
87. NAKAGAWA K. (A preliminary report on the discovery of the intermediate host of the
human lung fluke.) Tokyo Iji Shinshi No. 1910, 1915. In Japanese
88. NAKAGAWA K. (On the migratory course of the lung fluke in the body of the final host).
Tokyo Iji Shinshi No. 1923, 1915. In Japanese
89. NAKAGAWA K. The mode of infection in pulmonary distomiasis. Certain freshwater crabs
as intermediate hosts of Paragonimus westermanii. Journal of Infectious Diseases 18:
131-142, 1916
90. NAKAGAWA K. Human pulmonary distomiasis caused by Paragonimus westermanni.
Journal of Experimental Medicine 26: 297-323, 1917
91. NAKAGAWA K. (Description of the cysts and young developing worms ofParagonimus
westermanii.) Taiwan Igakukai Zasshi No. 176, pp 366-368, 1917. In Japanese. Abstracted
in Tropical Diseases Bulletin 12: 174, 1918
92. NAKAGAWA K. (A new species of lung fluke infesting the pond crabs, Potamon dehaani,
of Kalapai as an intermediate host.) Juzankai Zasshi 23: 1-2, 1918. In Japanese
93. NAKAGAWA K. Further notes on the studyof the human lung distome Paragonimus west-
ermani. Journal of Parasitology 6: 39-43, 1919
94. NAKAHAMA T. (Ueber den Bau des Distomum pulmonis.) Tokyo Iji Shinshi Nos. 254,
261, 282 and 283, 1883. In Japanese
95. NUNOGAMI M. (Skin reaction in paragonimiasis.) Kumamoto Igakkwai Zasshi 6: 513,
1930. In Japanese
96. NWOKOLO C. Outbreak of paragonimiasis in eastern Nigeria. Lancet i: 32-33, 1972
97. NWOKOLO C, VOLKMER KJ. Single dose therapy of paragonimiasis with meni-
chlopholan. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 26: 688-692, 1977
98. OH SJ. Spinal paragonimiasis. Journal of Neurological Science 6: 125-140, 1968
99. ONUIGBO WI, NWAKO FA. Discovery of adult parasites of Paragonimus uterobilat-
eralis in human tissue in Nigeria. Zeitschrift für Tropenmedizin und Parasitologie 25: 433-
436, 1974
100. OTANI S. (Cysten des Gehirns mit Eiern von Distomen sonst in der Leber, Darmwand,
Peritonäen, Lymphdrüsen.) Tokyo Igakkwai Zasshi 1: 458-460, 1887. InJapanese, with
German summary. Also, with the same title, Zeitschrift für medicinischen Gesellschaft,
Paragonimiasis 183
1877 Kerbert discovered adult worms in the lungs of a tiger and named the
parasite Distoma westermanni
1879 Ringer discovered an adult worm in the lung of a human
1880 Baelz and Manson discovered independently eggs in the sputum of
humans and recognized that haemoptysis was the main symptom with the
patients being otherwise usually well
1880 Manson observed that eggs needed to incubate for several weeks before
miracidia were released
1881 Manson postulated that a snail may be the first intermediate host and
Hungerford suggested that Melania libertina was a likely candidate
1887 Otani found parasites in the brain
1913 Nakagawa showed that miracidia were not infective to dogs
1914 Nakagawa found encysted larvae which resembled adult Paragonimus in
the gills of a crab which could be a second intermediate host
1915 Nakagawa reported that adult worms developed in dogs fed these cysts
1915 Ando, Kobayashi, Nakagawa and Yokogawa determined independently the
pathway of migration of larvae in the definitive host
1916-22 Nakagawa, Yokogawa, Kobayashi, Miyairi and Ando all concluded
independently that snails of the genus Melania (= Semisulcospira) were
probably the first intermediate host
1939 Yokogawa proposed a combination of emetine and prontosil for treatment
1961 Bithiniol was shown to be an effective treatment
1965 P. africanus infections were identified in humans by Vogel and Crewe
1974 P. uterobilateralis infections were identified in humans by Onuigbo and
Nwako
1975 Niclofolan was shown in experimental animals to be an effective treatment
1981 Rim and colleagues showed that praziquantel was a very effective drug
___________________________________________________________________
Chapter 8
SYNOPSIS
Before Theodor Bilharz went to Cairo, Egypt in 1850, he sought the advice of
his erstwhile teacher and mentor, Carl von Siebold, as to which branch o f
natural science he should particularly direct his attention. Von Siebol d
recommended that he concentrate on h uman helminths, as it seemed likely that
the "strange country" would provide a fruitfu l field for such investigations. And
so it did. Bilharz was astonished at the variety and numbers of worms ,
especially intestinal nematodes, that he encountered during the course o f
performing some 200 post-mortem examinations. In early 1851, whil e
carrying out an autopsy on a young man, he made a discovery that astounded
him. He found a worm, which not only had he never seen before, but whic h
187
188 A History of Human Helminthology
of the genus, that name being adopted earlier than either Schistosoma
Weinland 1858, Gynaecophorus Diesing 1858 or Bilharzia Cobbold 1859 183.
In the same year, Leiper also tried to beat off the term Schistosoma by again
drawing attention to the use o f the word for nearly a century by teratologists to
denote a fairly common type of monstrosity in domesticated animals 140.
Nevertheless, the International Commission on Zoological Nomenclature by
Opinion 77 in 1922 placed Schistosoma on the Official List of Generi c
Names 113. Thus, the valid names for the organism and the disease ar e
Schistosoma and schistosomiasis, respectively.
feeding dogs and rabbits with ova, I am at a loss to understand; and his apparent
suspicion that parasites 'may increase in the (human) body from the development
of eggs' in a direct manner, is to me a mere haphazard conception, and one which
virtually sets at nought the well established experiences of every original
experimenter whose name is known in connexion with the advancement of
helminthology in its ontogenic bearings. Throughout the whole of Dr Harley's
remarks on this head - and I confess to have the greatest difficulty in
comprehending the purport of many passages - the generally received opinion as
to the necessity of an intermediate host amongst the Trematoda seems to me to
have been altogether overlooked, and therefore to that extent utterly ignored. So far
as Dr Harley is concerned in this particular relation, the teachings of Leuckart,
Pagenstecher, Guido Wagner, Siebold, van Beneden and especially Filippi, are
altogether a dead letter.57
This was an unjust criticism for Harley had in fact been much more scientific
in his approach than the cocksure Cobbold. As already intimated, Harley, as
early as 1864, had suggested on general grounds than an intermediate hos t
might be necessary, and had actually looked for schistosomes in snails before
Cobbold had. But he realized, as Cobbold himself had remarked in justifying
separate generic status for Bilharzia, that schistosomes were so different from
other flukes that it did not necessarily follow that were transmitted in the same
way. It was not only reasonable, but necessary, that direct infection should be
proven or disproven by experiment.
Permeating both the "direct" and "snai l" theories was the widely held belief
that water was intimately concerned in the transmission of infection. Ther e
were, however, two views as to the way in which infection was acquired from
water. As early as 1864, Cobbold declared that it was quite clear to him that
people in Africa were infecte d when they drank unfiltered waters 56. Two years
later, Dr Rubidge of Port Elizabeth, South Africa, put forward a novel ide a
based upon perspicacious epidemiological and clinical observations when he
wrote to Harley in London in response to the latter's request for information on
endemic haematuria. Harley quoted Rubidge in his second communication on
the subject to the Royal Medical and Chirurgical Society:
Pretty extensive enquires lead me to believe that bathing in rivers has something
to do with the production of the disease. I have never met with a case in boys who
do not frequently bathe in the Zwarlkojss or Booker's River. On the other hand,
those few boys in the families of my patients who are free from the disease, bathe
in the sea only. My impression is that the parasite gains entrance into the skin while
the individual is bathing in the river and I may mention that the lad W. Jones . .
described a sort of urticarious eruption attended with great irritation, as a frequent
result of bathing in Booker's River....Females are rarely affected, if at all. I have not
myself observed a single wellmarked case in this sex. 179
Following on from this, Harley in 1870 put forward the hypothesis that ov a
may be inserted into the skin while bathing, perhaps by being injected by the
ovipositor of a minute, leech-like animal 104.
In 1882, attention was focused again on water as the vehicle of infection
when a dozen staff of the Eastern Telegraph Company at Suez were attacked
Schistosomiasis haematobia 195
with schistosomiasis after drinking water from the Sweet Water Canal while
walking or shooting nearby12. In the same year, Allen also noted that in Natal,
South Africa, the infection was most common in natives and in the mal e
children of white settlers, then put forward the following observation:
The reason is very evident; they are the largest consumers of unfiltered water. It is
not so often in girls, they staying at home more can as a rule get filtered water; boys
and natives, living much in the veldt and drinking copiously from the first stream
they come across, soon imbibe it.4
In this view, Allen was supported by Lyle, al so of Natal 150, Sonsino in Egypt 188,
and Castle in East Africa 40. While agreeing that infection was much mor e
common in males, Guillemard (1883) was not so sure that drinking infected
water was the correct explanation. He referred to Sonsino's patients in th e
Zagazig where not a single female case occurred, yet only unfiltered water was
available. He favoured the possibility that infection occurred while bathing in
contaminated water:
The mode of infection, so far from being evident, is extremely obscure; but the
supposition that river-bathing, which is but seldom indulged in by women, is in
some way connected with the acquirement of disease seems the most tenable. 101
Allen later (1888) came around to this notion, remarking that:
Nearly all the youths bathing in the Umdimdusi and Drop Spruit are infected, while
the girls, who do not bathe, remain free of the disease. 6
and suggested that an unknown larval stage might enter the body through the
skin. In 1894, Brock supported this view strongly. After stating that "it i s
among boys, who are fondest of swimming, that the symptoms earliest make
their appearance." 38 and that females were rarely affected, he remarked that:
other things being equal, the chances of infection occurring will be greater from the
large quantity of water which must come in contact with the body in bathing, than
from the comparatively small amount conveyed into the stomach by drinking; so
that granting the larvae to have the power of penetrating the body by some means,
we should expect to meet with a much larger proportion of cases among bathers
than among those who only drink the infective water. 38
In contrast, Bronte Elgood (1908) examined the relationship between the
prevalence of schistosomiasis and water contact in schoolgirls and in female
hospital patients in Cairo. She found that i nfection was common in young girls,
even in those who did not bathe in the Nile, but was rare in adult women. She
concluded that infection was unlikely to be due to bathing, was possibly a
consequence of faulty storage of water, or was a result of the consumption of
raw vegetables or fruit that had been washed in dirty canals or rivers 73. Looss
acidly replied that Dr Elgood's conclusions "appear deficient in lucidity ,
disconnected, contradictory" 145, for he considered it impossible that miracidia
could live under the conditions suggested. In fact, Leiper was later to show that
Cairo had two water supplies; in addition to piped filtered water for drinking,
there was a separate supply of unfiltered water direct from the Nile fo r
gardens, and suggested that it was via this route that the girls acquired thei r
infection137. Elgood and Cherry later disputed the significance of Leiper' s
196 A History of Human Helminthology
Despite Harley's failure to infect rabbits and dogs with S. haematobium ova,
Schistosomiasis haematobia 197
this idea was not given up and was examined repeatedly by a number o f
investigators. Mantey made some experiments in 1880 but his results wer e
negative157, In 1882, Hatch in India failed to infect puppies by feeding the m
with S. haematobium eggs in urine mixed with milk 108. In 1894, Lortet and
Vialleton failed in all attempts to produce infection directly; they passed eggs
into the stomach of guinea pig s through a tube, injected ova intravenously into
rabbits, and fed Macacus monkeys with eggs in their food 149. Lortet even kept
sheep with shaven, lightly excoriated legs plunged in water containing many
S. haematobium miracidia for three months, but found no trace of adult worms
at post-mortem examination 148. He had chosen sheep as the host as many sheep
in Sicily were infected naturally with Bilharzia crassa, a parasite closely
related to S. haematobium. Yet as Milton later justly remarked, thi s
experiment would have been more meaningful if Lortet had used B. crassa
miracidia instead 161.
Also in 1894, Looss gave various species of monkeys (since Cobbold had
shown that they were susceptible to infection) water containing miracidia to
drink repeatedly for six to eight weeks; again the results were negative 142.
Despite his failure to prove infection by this means, Looss championed th e
notion that transmission did not require an intermediary host, albeit h e
accepted eventually that infection occurred through the skin. The former tenet
was held because he failed to find an infected intermediate host, as will b e
detailed shortly. Looss explained the rea soning upon which the latter statement
was based to the Egyptian Medical Congress in 1905. His argument wa s
centred principally upon his demonstration that miracidia could not survive in
stomach juice or hydrochloric ac id; perforce, they must travel through the skin
as he had already shown was the case with hookworm larvae. He regretted ,
however, that he did not have any proof, despite repeated attempts to confirm
his thesis:
Unfortunately I still cannot furnish you with the indisputible proof by experiment.
I have already made some trials for introducing larvae into the animals, but these
experiments, fewer than the rest, and being conducted without system, did not give
decisive results.143
Other investigators also kept trying. Wolff in German East Africa (1911)
failed to infect a cat immersed for half an hour in water swarming wit h
miracidia204. Bour in Mauritius (1912) was unable to infect two cynomolgous
monkeys, either orally or percutaneously 36, while Joyeux in French Wes t
Africa was unable to infect a Cercopithecus ruber monkey by bathing it in
urine containing miracidia 117. In 1914, Conor carried out an extensive series
of experiments in Tunis, administering miracidia orally, percutaneously an d
subcutaneously to monkeys, sheep, rabbits, guinea pigs and rats, all wit h
negative results61. Finally, Fülleborn, Leiper and some of Looss's ow n
colleagues in unpublished studies 134 failed to achieve infection directly. Bu t
Looss remained obstinate, explain ing all these failures with the claim that man
was the only known host for S. haematobium 147.
198 A History of Human Helminthology
letter dated 3 August 1893, i ndicating the nature of his discovery and when he
had made it, to the secretary of the Societa To scana di Scienze Naturali in Pisa.
Perhaps he was not sure of his facts, but was afraid that Lortet and Vialleton
would beat him to the mark. In the event, he changed his mind and wrote to
The Lancet, his paper appearing on 9 Se ptember 1893. Without providing any
details of the experiments, he proclaimed:
After many experiments I succeeded with a small crustacean (amphypoda) and
obtained evidence that this same crustacean is an effective intermediary host of
bilharzia, and so discovered the secret of the life history of the African parasite. 189
Sonsino then amplified his conclusions, indicating that S. haematobium
resembled a holostome rather than a digenetic trematode and underwen t
metamorphosis but neither alternation nor asexual generation in a smal l
crustacean. He stated that the free-swimming miracidia penetrated th e
crustacean at its head, then encysted. Human infection was acquired b y
ingesting these infected crustaceans in contaminated drinking water. He then
went on to say that his further researches had revealed that larvae of several
kinds of aquatic insects were also efficient vectors. This report was received
with acclamation in an accompanying Lancet editorial15, but in the following
year further work indicated that these conclusions were completely untenable
and forced Sonsino to withdraw them entirely 190. It must be admitted though,
that this withdrawal was less public than it might have been - it was published
in the Pisa Society's proceedings but not in The Lancet! Nevertheless,
Sonsino's idea was adopted tentatively by Balfour in Khartoum, Sudan, i n
1904 when he wondered whether the minute crustaceans (probabl y
Ostracoda) obtained from a school well and which took up miracidia might
not be the long sought for intermediate host 24. Nothing came of this suggestion
either.
At around the same time as Sonsino (1894), Lortet and Vialleton reported
that they were unable to infect a number of species of molluscs (includin g
Corbicula, Lanistes, Melania, Physa, Unio and Vivipara), aquatic arthropods,
or water plants with S. haematobium 149. Lortet then continued thi s
experimental work in Lyon, France with local species of Lymnaea, but again
without luck 148.
Simultaneously, Looss in Egypt embarked upon the trail. Initially (1893),
like Cobbold and Sonsino, he predicted that molluscs would be vectors, so he
searched for natural infections amongst local molluscs:
Naturally, the most likely course and that which one expected a priori was for the
embryo after escaping from the egg-case to penetrate, in a manner similar to that
observed in other species of distoma, into some intermediate host appertaining to
the class of mollusca. In my experiments in this connexion, I repeated those of
Cobbold and Sonsino, but with the like absolutely negative results. 142
Even when he dissected snails from the most notorious foci of human infection
in the Nile delta, he failed to find any evidence of schistosomal infection. This
led him to state categorically in 1894:
It is more particularly these latter negative experiences that induce me now
200 A History of Human Helminthology
Research, first communicated these results in July 1915 198, even though
Warren looked upon these observation s as merely tentative and deprecated the
drawing of definite conclusions, particularly as the snails could have bee n
infected naturally and as there was no proof that they were the cercariae of S.
haematobium. Publication of Leiper's discoveries prompted a flurry of activity
by Cawston. He exposed a mouse and a guinea pig to washings obtained from
infected snails, but the mouse escaped and schistosomes could not be found in
the guinea pig at autopsy six months later. Nevertheless, Cawston the n
indulged in what was to become a favourite hobby of his, publishing these in-
determinate findings in three different journals 41. In the following year (1916),
he recorded finding "bilharzia forms of cercariae" in 17.4% of 533 specimens
of P. africana42. Cawston had made a quite unwarranted assumption an d
Leiper condemned this when reviewing the paper for the Tropical Diseases
Bulletin:
The use of the term 'Bilharzia forms' for cercariae with bifid tails is exceedingly
misleading. The presence of a bifid tail is no indication that a cercaria belongs to
any special systematic group. In Egypt, 9 out of 27 recorded species of cercaria
have 'bifid tails'.136
A multitude of papers flowed from Cawston's pen over the next several years,
much to the exasperation of Leiper who wrote "There is no evidence that the
various forms so loosely and repeatedly termed 'Bilharzia cercariae' in thi s
author's numerous papers are actually such" 138 and "The subject matter ha s
already been repeatedly reviewed in this Bulletin, and the present pape r
contains nothing new" 139.
In fact, one of these so-called cercaria of S. haematobium finally turned out
(when sent to Leiper for identification) to be that of S. bovis43. In 1920,
however, Annie Porter showed by infecting experimental animals that P.
africana was naturally-infected with both S. haematobium (commonly) and
S. mansoni (occasionally), and that Lymnaea natalensis rarely harboured
cercariae of S. haematobium174. Porter was later to remark that cercariae of at
least 22 different species has been found in P. africana 175. Cawston finally had
a modicum of luck when he succeeded eventually in infectin g
laboratory-reared P. africana with S. haematobium miracidia and obtained
cercariae six weeks later 44.
Several years later, Blacklock an d Thompson in Sierra Leone also infected
Physopsis with miracidia from S. haematobium ova, obtained cercariae from
these snails, infected monkeys and guinea pigs, then recovered S.
haematobium adult worms 33.
In 1921, 17 autochthonous cases of schistosomiasis were found i n
Portugal. França investigated the attraction of various species of local snails
for miracidia of S. haematobium and opined that Planorbis corneus var
metidjensis (now known as Planorbarius metidjensis ) was likely to be the
intermediate host 88; in this, he was later proven to be correct 29.
A focus of infection with S. haematobium was found in a village nea r
Schistosomiasis haematobia 205
Bombay, India in 1952 by Gadgil and Shah 92, then it was shown by Gadgil in
1963 that the local vector was the limpet, Ferrisea tenuis 91.
or bacillary dysentery, for neither of these conditions nor their causative agents
were recognized at that time. What is less clear is how many of the eggs in the
intestines that he saw were those of S. haematobium and how many were S.
mansoni, for he did not differentiate between the two, labelling them all a s
eggs of S. haematobium. It seems most likely that those patients with intestinal
schistosomiasis as well as vesical schistosomiasis were infected concurrently
with both S. haematobium and S. mansoni.
In 1854, Bilharz's colleague, Griesinger, published a classic report on his
findings in the 117 cases of schistosomi asis that he had encountered during the
course of 363 autopsies. He descri bed the various changes that could be found
in the bladder. In the mildest cases, there were simply:
foci of hyperaemia....containing many fine extravasations of blood. The mucosa
was somewhat swollen....and often....covered either with viscous mucus or with a
soft grayishyellow, hemorrhagic exudate. In these secretions, the eggs of the
Distoma were found, en masse.100
He noted that the urine in the bladder of these patients was generally light and
clear. In more advanced cases, he described "polypoid patches of the mucosa
which were....discolored....(and) often....showed a brittle crust on th e
surface"100.
Bilharz believed that these changes could be attributed to inflammation an d
extravasation of blood consequent upon invasion of the small blood vessels by
schistosomes and deposition of their eggs. He also recognized a third type of
lesion:
In some instances solitary clusters of pea-to-bean size, yellowish or ecchymotic
papillomata or vegetations one to three lines high were found on the mucosa. They
were wart-like or fusiform.100
There were countless transitional forms or intermediate stages between these
tumours and the diffuse lesions, so he concluded that the former simply rep-
resented more advanced degrees of same process.
Griesinger also noted that all these changes were often seen in the ureteric
mucosa and sometimes even in the renal pelvis. He realized that th e
consequences of the ureteric lesions were much more serious:
Deposits on the mucosa and frequent thickening of the submucosa caused stricture
of the ureter; in addition, there may be spindle-shaped or sac-like dilation of the
lumen, muscular hypertrophy, and/or urinary retention with its complications. In
cases where these changes had been present a longer time, fatty degeneration,
pyelitis, hydronephrosis and complete atrophy of the kidney parenchyma were
found.100
In the same manner as Bilharz, Griesinger connected vesical schistosomiasis
with the urinary lithiasis endemic in Egypt "In addition, large urinary stones
often formed in the kidneys, ureters and bladder with serious consequences" 100.
Griesinger understood that these disturbances in the function of the urinar y
tract sometimes led to a generalized chroni c disease, culminating in death from
debilitation, pneumonia, dysentery and anaemia. Like Bilharz, he realized that
urinary schistosomiasis was sometimes associated with intestinal disease ,
Schistosomiasis haematobia 207
having found that 50 of his 117 cases with urinary schistosomiasis had acute
or chronic dysentery. Similarly, 20 of the pe rsons had died of "bilious typhoid",
so he remarked cautiously that there was not necessarily a direct link between
schistosomiasis and dysentery or typhoid fever. He suggested that an y
relationship between schistosomiasis and both hepatic abscess and live r
atrophy was worthy of investigation. Finally, his discovery of schistosome ova
in the blood of the left side of the heart caused him to remark that "th e
transportation of the worms or at least their eggs into the general circulation
and to essential organs must be kept in mind" 100.
In 1856, Bilharz published a lengthy paper on the relationship between S.
haematobium and pathological changes in the urinary system 31. He classified
the pathological changes in the urinary system into four groups: catarrha l
inflammation of the bladder and ureters, induration and calcification of th e
mucosa, polypoid growth of the mucosa, and mucosal ulceration. All of these
changes Bilharz attributed to the presence of eggs in the mucosa. H e
postulated that male worms carrying a pregnant female in the gynaecophoric
canal migrated against the flow of blood to the small vessels of the vesica l
venous plexus and that the female worms then deposited ova in a gelatinous
substance. He suggested that the adult worms and eggs blocked blood flo w
causing rupture of the vessels and extravas ation of eggs, either into the mucosa
itself, or directly into the lumen of the urinary tract. If trapped in the tissues,
the eggs acted as foreign bodies and stimulated an inflammatory reactio n
which resulted in the lesions seen.
These descriptions of the gross morbid anatomical changes in urinar y
schistosomiasis have hardly been improved upon since. Following thes e
pioneering studies, the histopathological changes of chronic inflammation and
fibrosis around eggs were described by a number of investigators e.g .
Zancarol205. The pathogenesis of these lesions is similar to that which occurs
in S. mansoni infection and is described in the next chapter.
Urinary schistosomiasis is sometimes complicated by the development of
neoplasia. This was first suggested by Harrison in Liverpool in 1889; h e
reported that four out of five specimens of bladder schistosomiasis sent to him
from Alexandria by Mackie were complicated by the presence of squamou s
carcinoma106. He acknowledged that further investigations were needed t o
determine whether the worms were merely an irritant in persons predisposed
to cancer or whether there was a direct aetiological relationship between the
worm infection and cancer. A similar case was reported by Albarran an d
Bernard in 1897 3. In 1911 Ferguson set the association on a firmer foundation
when he described a series of 40 cases of malignant neoplasia, usuall y
carcinoma, in the bladder of patients with schistosomiasis. He wrote: "I have
no hesitation in affirming that cancer of the urinary bladder is the irritatio n
cancer of Egypt." 83 To underscore his point, Ferguson went on to contrast this
with intestinal schistosomiasis, remarking that he had not been able to trac e
any relationship between schistosomiasis and cancer of the anus, rectum o r
208 A History of Human Helminthology
sigmoid colon.
The behaviour of S. haematobium adult worms in blood vessels wa s
studied in anaesthetized monkeys by Fairley 78,80. He observed that the adul t
worms moved with a peristalsis-like action of the body and with the aid of the
ventral sucker. When the time for egg-laying was at hand, the female worms
left their male partners and retrogressed against the portal bloodstream to the
small venules. By a process of elongation , each worm then worked the anterior
truncated part of its body into a vessel of smaller diameter than its own, then
ejected an ovum, with the spine pointing backwards into the current of blood.
The adult worm then withdrew slightly and the overdistended venul e
contracted down upon the egg, and so the process was repeated. Fairle y
believed that the spine engaged the vessel wall, then rent a tear in it under the
forces of the bloodstream, and was thus extruded into the perivenous tissue.
This view was disputed later by Brumpt who could see no role for the spine 39.
With respect to the location of the adult worms, Fairley showed tha t
although they could be found in the portal and inferior mesenteric veins, the
largest numbers were present in the vesical and uterine venous plexuses. I n
this situation they may live for many years; one well-known English zoologist
and physician was infected whilst on a naturalist expedition between th e
Limpopo and Zambesi rivers in 1878, and continued to pass eggs for at least
another 28 years 51.
The pathological changes in the liver and lungs in S. haematobium
infections broadly resemble those caused by S. mansoni ; the recognition of
these effects is described in chapter 9.
It must have been clear to Bil harz and Griesinger when they first found ecchy-
moses and blood clots in the blad der of a boy with vesical schistosomiasis that
passage of blood in the urine would be a promi nent feature of schistosomal inf-
ection. This, in fact, was the sign which gave Bilharz the clue to the diagnosis
of schistosomiasis when later that year, he first found eggs in the urine of a
living patient. In his review of urinary schistosomiasis in Egypt, Griesinge r
listed haematuria, pyelitis, enlargement of the kidney, septicaemia and acute
exacerbation of various obscur e and undiagnosed bladder and kidney ailments
as the ways in which patients with the infection could present clinically 100.
Bilharz later re-emphasized these points, making particular mention of a
feeling of pressure and tenderness in the lower abdomen, increasing o n
occasion to vehement burning or colicky pain, frequency of micturition ,
passage of mucus in the urine, and haematuria, the last being usually only a
slight admixture of blood, but long-lasting and recurring frequently. Lik e
Griesinger, he also thought that infection predisposed to urolithiasis, especially
to stones in the ureter 31.
Schistosomiasis haematobia 209
ureters may be felt through the usually thin abdominal wall. On rectal examination,
the bladder will be felt firm and contracted, and bimanually the great thickening of
and around the bladder will be well appreciated. On introducing a sound, it can
often only be passed just beyond the neck of the bladder into a very much
contracted cavity.153
In addition, Maddern noted that urethral fistulae and a destructive, distorting
false elephantiasis of the scrotum and perineum might supervene 153.
With respect to prognosis, Bilharz recognized that the disease may last for
many years, thus indicating that either the worms lived for a long time, or that
reinfection was common. On the whole, he thought that the latter was more
likely. Nevertheless, he did not reject the possibility that spontaneous cur e
might occur, for he often encountered pigmented, leathery areas of bladde r
mucosa which contained innumerable calcified ova but no living adult worms
or fresh eggs31. Both Bilharz and Griesinger thought that death was ofte n
caused by intercurrent illness, and this view was supported by practitioners in
South Africa who claimed that they had never seen anyone die fro m
schistosomiasis 4,150. Cobbold was among the first to realize that the severity of
clinical manifestations bore some relation to the worm burden. He contrasted
'slight' and 'excessive' invasions thus:
In cases of the former kind not more than a dozen or so of the parasite's eggs will
be passed at each act of micturition, whereas in the latter it is not uncommon for
the patient to pass fifty, or for that matter, a hundred dozen bilharzia eggs at a time.
In severe cases the daily average of evacuated ova greatly exceeds this estimate. 59
Nevertheless, Cobbold went on to suggest that:
the severity of the symptoms and consequent dangers are, as a rule, more
dependent upon associated disorders than upon the actual number of parasites
present.59
Infections in British troops in the South African war revealed that the disease
was more prolonged than had hitherto been believed. Symptoms persisted for
between five and thirteen years, often intermittently, but it was concluded that
mortality arising from infection did not exceed 1% in the 466 soldier s
studied107.
The early investigators recognised the need for effective anthelmintics to cure
schistosomiasis. Griesinger suggested that calomel and oil of turpentine might
be effective, and that perhaps certain foods such as onions and garlic migh t
exert a beneficial effect 100. Bilharz indicated that local pains usuall y
disappeared rapidly after the use of opium, but he was less sanguine abou t
prospects for eradication of the worms, for he thought it would be difficult for
drugs to reach them in their domicile in the veins. He tried on a couple o f
occasions to poison worms in diseased specimens with calomel, but wit h
inconclusive results 31.
In 1870, Harley reported the effects of his treatment for endemi c
haematuria. He found that general therapy with potassium iodide and henbane
was of little use, but that local injections of emulsions of oil of male fern o r
potassium iodide in a strong infusion of wormwood or quassia into the bladder
Schistosomiasis haematobia 213
course (20gr), 70% were pronounced cured and they remarked that:
the successful treatment of complications dependent upon bilharziasis, such as
urinary fistulae and rectal papillomata, is enormously facilitated by the elimination
of the causative factor.133
The effectiveness of the drug was demonstrated amply by Shaw in 1921 who
studied the cystoscopic appearances in 23 patients with schistosomiasis who
were undergoing treatment. In half of these persons, there had been activ e
nodules present before therapy, and these disappeared after administration of
tartar emetic. Similarly, infiltrations and signs of subacute cystitis subsided ,
and even the fibrotic areas appeared to improve and become pink 184.
Not surprisingly, when an effective drug was promulgated, others tried to
cash in on the credit. In the week following Christopherson's paper, a lette r
was published by JE McDonagh in which he recalled that he had use d
antimony in 1911 and had eliminated ova from the urine in 23 cases; h e
claimed that he had used the drug empirically because of its effectiveness in
some other disease caused by animal parasites 151. He reiterated this claim two
years later, quoting from the 1915 edition of his book Biology and treatment
of venereal diseases :
I should like to mention that I have had great success in treating cases of
bilharziasis with intravenous injections of antimony. 152
This drew forth the riposte that although it was the earliest record of the use
of antimony in bilharziasis, it could not have been more effectivel y
pigeon-holed. Similarly, but more in the nature of an anecdote, Wiley wrote
that a case of urinary schistosomiasis had been treated in a like manner at the
Australian Dermatological Hospital in Cairo in 1916 203.
Following the introduction of tartar emetic, a number of other trivalen t
organic antimonials were developed, pentavalent antimonials being found to
be ineffective in schistosomiasis. Sodium antimonyl tartrate (SAT) wa s
claimed by some to be better tolerated than the potassium salt, but this view
was not accepted universally. The advent of st ibophen (fouadin, neoantimosan)
in 1929 was hailed as a considerable advance because it could be given b y
intramuscular injection and as it was at first thought to have higher cure rates
and less toxicity that tartar emetic 124,125. Lithium antimony thiomalat e
(anthiomaline) was introduced in 1935 and could also be given b y
intramuscular injection. Sodium antimonyl gluconate (triostam) given b y
intravenous injection had variable effectiveness 75. Sodium antimonyl
dimercaptosuccinate (TWSB, stibocaptate, astiban) was introduced b y
Friedheim and colleagues in 1954 for schistosomiasis mansoni 90, and was then
used in schistosomiasis haematobia in 1956 89. Unfortunately, these
compounds, though less toxic, were less effective than tartar emetic.
A major problem with the antimonials was the severe, sometimes fata l
toxicity associated with their use. In 1936, Khalil estimated that antimon y
killed about 2,000 persons in Egypt each year122. This appalled Diamantis who
considered such therapy monstrous, seeing that the infection would not have
killed the patients in that time, and that had they kept to certain rules, the y
216 A History of Human Helminthology
showed in field experiments that when the waterways were dried, the Bulinus
snails took up a position with the shell-opening facing down and secreted a
protective coat of slime, with the result that 50% of the snails survived 25.
Nevertheless, snail eggs were killed by these physical measures.
An alternative approach was to kil l the snails with chemical molluscicides.
In 1920, Chandler showed in labora tory experiments that snails were killed by
immersion in a 1 in 1,000,000 solution of copper sulphate 46, then Khalil in
1927 demonstrated in a field experiment that all the Bulinus in an oasis were
killed by this measure and that none were alive six months later 121. In 1932,
Humphreys reported that carbolic acid in a strength of 1 in 20,000 killed all
the snails in the irrigation system in the Gezira region of the Sudan 112, but
copper sulphate remained the mainstay of intervention. In 1941, Mozle y
indicated that malachite green (mineralized basic copper sulphate) was just as
effective and much less expensive 165. These molluscicides were in tur n
followed in 1957 by sodium pentachlorophenate 130 then in 1959 by
niclosamide (Bayer 73, Bayluscide) 96,98. Nevertheless, it was concluded i n
1962 that this approach had been unfruitful, largely because of the grea t
expense involved, the difficulty in providing adequate teams to distribute the
molluscicides, aestivation (similar to hibernation) of the snails, and toxicity of
the molluscicides for aquatic fauna 20. More recently, a mood of optimism has
returned, with Webbe writing in 1981:
There is ample evidence that area-wide mollusciciding is now successfully
controlling snails in major control programmes - for example, in Egypt and China
- and that control of transmission based on the essential focality of transmission in
many areas (St. Lucia, Ghana, Yemen and Saudi Arabia) is also being successfully
prosecuted by killing snails and surveillance.200
A third technique of control is by the mass treatment of infected persons.
This was hailed with enthusiasm following the introduction of specifi c
treatment with tartar emetic in 1918. Christopherson himself wrote:
It is in mass treatment in schools and villages where the hope to eradicating the
disease lies....My own view is that there is more hope of successfully dealing with
the schistosomiasis problem by the symptomatic treatment of individual cases
wherever they are met than by attempting to eliminate the disease by destruction
of snails which can only be a practicable proposition in limited areas. 52
In Egypt, a large number of treatment centres w ere set up in an effort to control
the infection but less than 5% of the total number of infected persons wer e
treated each year. In 1933, Rose reviewed the effectiveness of this programme
and wrote:
complete unanimity exists among all Egyptian specialists. No influence on the mere
occurrence of the disease has been obtained by the present methods. But on the
contrary, no doubt exists that....the grave cases of urinary fistulae, the pyo- and
hydronephroses, the numerous urinary calculi, all these serious complications of
Egyptian schistosomiasis have greatly diminished in number. 178
Control based upon mass chemotherapy lay in the doldrums for man y
years. Recently the outlook has changed because of two factors. Firstly, more
effective and less toxic drugs have appeared. Secondly, it has been realize d
222 A History of Human Helminthology
REFERENCES
17. ANONYMOUS. The intermediate host in Bilharzia. Journal of Tropical Medicine and
Hygiene 18: 232-234, 1915
18. ANONYMOUS. Cited in 95
19. ANONYMOUS. Combined Intelligence Objectives Subcommittee File No. 25, vol. 54, 1945.
British Intelligence Objectives Subcommittee Final Report, vol. 116, 1946
20. ANONYMOUS. A century of schistosomiasis. Lancet i: 1223-1224, 1962
21. ANONYMOUS. Chemotherapy in schistosomiasis. British Medical Journal i: 128-129, 1972
22. ANONYMOUS. Immunological control of schistosomiasis. British Medical Journal ii:
366-367, 1972
23. ANONYMOUS. Menace of Man-made lakes. British Medical Journal i: 62-63, 1973
24. BALFOUR A. Endemic haematuria (Bilharzia). Wellcome Research Laboratory Report 1:
51-52, 1904
25. BARLOW CH. The effect of the "winterrotation" of water upon snails involved in the spread
of schistosomiasis in Egypt, 1930-1931 and 1931-1932. American Journal of Hygiene 17:
724-742, 1933
26. BARLOW CH. Is there dermatitis in Egyptianschistosomiasis? American Journal of Hygiene
24: 587-599, 1936
27. BARLOW CH, MELENEY HE. A voluntary infection with Schistosoma haematobium.
American Journal of Tropical Medicine 29: 79-87, 1949
28. BAYLIS HA. The names of some molluscan hosts of the schistosomes parasitic in man.
Annals of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology 25: 369-372, 1931
29. BETTENCOURT A, BORGES I. Le Planorbis metidjensis, hôte intermédiaire du
Schistosoma haematobium au Portugal. Confirmation expérimentale. Comptes Rendus
Hebdomadaires des Séances et Mémoires de la Société de Biologie 87: 1039-1040, 1922
30. BILHARZ T. Fernere mittheilungen über Distomum haematobium. Zeitschrift für wissen-
schaftliche Zoologie 4: 454-456, 1853. Partly translated in 120
31. BILHARZ T. Distomum haematobium und sein Verhältniss zu gewissen pathologischen
Veränderungen der menschlichen Harnorgane. Wiener medizinische Wochenschrift 6: 49-65,
1856. Abstracted in 195
32. BILHARZ T, von SIEBOLD CT. Ein Beitragzur Helminthographia humana, aus brieflichen
Mittheilungen des Dr. Bilharz in Cairo, nebst Bermerkungen von Prof. C. Th. von Siebold
in Breslau. Zeitschrift für wissenschaftliche Zoologie 4: 53-76, 1852-1853 (distributed2
September 1852). Partly translated in 120
33. BLACKLOCK DB, THOMPSON MG. Human schistosomiasis due toS. haematobium in
Sierra Leone. Annals of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology 18: 211-234, 1924
34. BLAIR DM, HAWKING F, ROSS WF. The effect of Miracil D on human schistosomiasis.
Lancet ii: 911-912, 1947
35. BLANCHARD R. Traité de zoologie médicale. J-B Baillière et fils, Paris, 2 volumes, pp
1689, 1885-1890
36. BOUR FE. On numerous cases of oedema of the legs and albuminuria occurring in a
reformatory, with a contribution to the study of bilharziosis. Journal of Tropical Medicine and
Hygiene 15: 148150, 1912
37. BROCK GS. Anatomy and physiology of the Bilharzia ovum. Lancet ii: 622-625, 1893
38. BROCK GS. On the Bilharzia haematobia. Journal of Pathology and Bacteriology 2: 52-74,
1894
39. BRUMPT E. La ponte des schistosomes. Annales de Parasitologie Humaine et Comparée 8:
263297, 1930
40. CASTLE RF. Haematuria in East Central Africa. Lancet i: 931-932. 1891
41. CAWSTON FG. Schistosomiasis in Natal. Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 18:
257-258, 1915; Bilharziosis in Natal. British Medical Journal ii: 746,1915; Bilharziosis.
Lancet ii: 1427, 1915
42. CAWSTON FG. Report on the examination of 1,000 molluscs in Natal. Medical Journal of
South Africa 11: 197, 1916
43. CAWSTON FG. Schistosomes of man andbeast in Natal. South African Medical Record 18:
264, 1920
44. CAWSTON FG. Experimental infestation of freshwater snails. Transactions of the Royal
224 A History of Human Helminthology
71. DIESING KM. Revision der Myzhelminthen. Abtheilung: Trematoden. Sitzungsberichte der
kaiserlichen Akademie der Wissenschaften in Wien. Mathematisch-naturwissenschaftliche
Classe 32: 307-390. 1858
72. DOUGLAS SR, HARDY FW. Some remarks on 50 cases of Bilharzia disease with special
reference to the characters of the white corpuscles found in the blood and urine. Lancet ii:
1009-1012, 1903
73. ELGOOD BS. Bilharziasis among women and girls in Egypt. British Medical Journal ii:
1355-1357, 1908
74. ELGOOD BS, CHERRY T. Bilharziasis: its incidence and eradication. Lancet ii: 636-637,
1919
75. ERFAN M, TALAAT S. Trivalent sodium antimony gluconate in the treatment of
schistosomiasis. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 44:
123-126, 1950
76. ERIAN A. The treatment of bilharziosis by massive doses of emetine. Practitioner 103:
391-393, 1919
77. FAIRLEY NH. Observations on the clinical appearances of bilharziasis in Australian troops
and the significance of the symptoms noted. Quarterly Journal of Medicine 12: 391-403,
1919
78. FAIRLEY NH. Bilharziasis: some recent advances in our knowledge. Lancet i: 1016-1021,
1919
79. FAIRLEY NH. The discovery of a specific complement fixation test for bilharziasis and its
practical application to clinical medicine. Journal of the Royal Army Medical Corps 32:
449-460, 1919
80. FAIRLEY NH. A comparative study of experimental bilharziasis in monkeys contrasted
with the hitherto described lesions in Man. Journal of Pathology and Bacteriology 23:
289-314, 1920
81. FAIRLEY NH, WILLIAMS FE. A preliminary report on an intradermal reaction in schisto-
somiasis. Medical Journal of Australia ii: 811-818, 1927
82. FARID Z, BASSILY S, SHULERT AR, ZEIND AS, McCONNELL E, ABDEL WAHAB
MF. Urinary blood loss in Schistosoma haematobium infection in Egyptian farmers.
Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 62: 496-500, 1968
83. FERGUSON AR. Associated bilharziasis and primary malignant disease of the urinary
bladder, with observations on a series of forty cases. Journal of Pathology and Bacteriology
16: 76-94, 1911
84. FISHER AC. The treatment of schistosomiasis with acriflavine. Lancet i: 897, 1934
85. FORSYTH DM, BRADLEY DJ. Irreversible damage by Schistosoma haematobium in
schoolchildren. Lancet ii: 169-171, 1964
86. FORSYTH DM, RASHID C. Treatment of urinary schistosomiasis. Practiceand theory.
Lancet i: 130-133, 1967
87. FOUQUET. Note sur le traitement des accidents produits chez l'homme par la présence dans
l'organisme de la Bilharzia. La France Médicale i: 667-680, 693-696, 1888
88. FRANÇA C. Bilharziose em Portugal. Medicina Contemporanea 39: 273-275, 1921
89. FRIEDHEIM EA. Le traitement de la bilharziose urinaire à S. haematobium par le
dimercaptosuccinate d'antimoine (TWSb). Bulletin de la Société de Pathologie Exotique 49:
1247-1252, 1956
90. FRIEDHEIM EA, da SILVA JR, MARTINS AV. Treatment of schistosomiasis mansoni
with antimony-a,a'-dimercapto-potassium succinate (TWSb). American Journal of Tropical
Medicine and Hygiene 3: 714-727, 1954
91. GADGIL RK. Human schistosomiasis in India. Indian Journal of Medical Research 51:
244-251, 1963
92. GADGIL RK, SHAH SN. Human schistosomiasis in India. Discovery of an endemic focus
in Bombay State. Indian Journal of Medical Science 6: 760-763, 1952
93. GAUD J, JAUBERTIE R. Rôle des facteurs humains dans la répartition géographique des
bilharzioses en Afrique. Annales de Parasitologie Humaine et Comparee 26: 420-439, 1951
94. GERRITSEN J, WALKER AR, de MEILLON B, YEO RM. Longterm investigation of
blood loss and egg load in urinary schistosomiasis in adult African Bantu. Transactions of
226 A History of Human Helminthology
the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 47: 134-140, 1953
95. GIRGES R. Schistosomiasis (bilharziasis), John Bale, Sons and Danielsson, London, pp
527, 1934
96. GÖNNERT R. Results of laboratory and field trials with the molluscicide Bayer 73.
Bulletin of the World Health Organization 25: 483-501, 1961
97. GÖNNERT R, ANDREWS P. Praziquantel, a new broadspectrum antischistosomal agent.
Zeitschrift für Parasitenkunde 52: 129-150, 1977
98. GÖNNERT R, SCHRAUFSTÄTTER E. A new molluscicide: Molluscicide Bayer 73.In,
Proceedings of the Sixth International Congress of Tropical Medicine and Malaria, Lisbon,
1958. Abstracts of the papers, Lisbon, Instituto de Medicina Tropical, vol. 2, p. 197, 1959
99. GORDON RM. Emetine periodide in the treatment of S. haematobium infections amongst
West African children. Annals of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology 20: 229-237, 1926
100. GRIESINGER W. Klinische und anatomische Beobachtungen. Über die Krankheiten von
Egypten. Archiv für Physiologie Heilkunde 13: 528-575, 1854. Partly translated in 120
101. GUILLEMARD FH. Bilharzia haematobia. Lancet i: 151, 1883
102. HARLEY J. On the endemic haematuria of the Cape of Good Hope. Medico-Chirurgical
Transactions 47: 55-72, 1864. Abstracted in Lancet i: 156-157, 1864
103. HARLEY J. A second communication on the endemic haematuria of the Cape of Good
Hope. Medico-Chirurgical Transactions 52: 379-387, 1869
104. HARLEY J. Third communication on the endemic haematuria of the southeastern coast of
Africa, with remarks on the topical medication of the bladder. Medico-Chirurgical
Transactions 54: 47-62, 1871. Abstracted in British Medical Journal ii: 641-642, 1870
105. HARLEY J. Discussion of, Cases of haematuria due to Bilharzia by TS Cobbold, presented
to the Royal Medical and Chirurgical Society. British Medical Journal i: 1097, 1885;
Lancet i: 985, 1885
106. HARRISON R. Specimens of Bilharzia affecting the urinary organs. Lancet ii: 163, 1889
107. HARRISON WS. The prognosis in bilharziasis. Journal of the Royal Army Medical Corps
21: 385-388, 1913
108. HATCH WK. Endemic haematuria. British Medical Journal ii: 737, 1882
109. HOEPPLI R. Morphological changes in human schistosomiasis and certain analogies ni
ancient Egyptian sculpture. Acta Tropica, Supplement 30: 1-11, 1973
110. HUGGINS D. Ineficácia do K-7505 (Ronnel) no tratamento da esquistossomíase
mansônica. Revista de la Sociedad Brasileira de Médica Tropica 2: 221-224, 1968
111. HULSE EV. Joshua's curse and the abandonment of ancient Jericho: schistosomiasis as a
possible medical explanation. Medical History 15: 376-386, 1971
112. HUMPHREYS RM. Vesical schistosomiasis in the Gezira irrigated area of the Sudan.
Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 26: 241-252, 1932
113. INTERNATIONAL COMMISSION ON ZOOLOGICAL NOMENCLATURE. Thirty five
generic names in Protozoa, Coelenterata, Trematoda, Cestoda, Cirrepoda, Tunicata and
Pisces placed in the official list of generic names (Opinion 77), Smithsonian Miscellaneous
Collections, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D C, Publication 2657, 73: 71-73, 1922
114. JAMES C, WEBBE G, NELSON GS. The susceptibility to praziquantel of S. haematobium
in the baboon (Papio anubis) and of S. japonicum in the vervet monkey (Cercopithecus
aethiops). Zeitschrift für Parasitenkunde 52: 179-194, 1977
115. JOANNIDES NZ. Die Wirkung des Salvarsans auf dieBilharzia. Deutsche medizinische
Wochenschrift 37: 1551, 1911
116. JORDAN P. Trial of Ambilhar, a nitrothiazole derivative, in S. mansoni infections in
Tanzania. British Medical Journal i: 276-278, 1966
117. JOYEUX C. Note sur quelques cas de bilharziose observés à Kouroussa (Guinea Française).
Bulletins de la Société de Pathologie Exotique et de ses Filiales 5: 504-505, 1912
118. KATZ N, PELLEGRINO J. Ensaio laboratorial e clínico com hycanthone nôvo agente
esquistossomicida. Revista de la Sociedad Brasileira de Médica Tropica 1: 219-230, 1967
119. KATZ N, ROCHA RS, CHAVES A. Preliminary trials with praziquantel in human
infections due to Schistosoma mansoni. Bulletin of the World Health Organization 57:
781-785, 1979
120. KEAN BH, MOTT KE, RUSSELL AJ. Tropical medicine and parasitology. Classic
Schistosomiasis haematobia 227
197. WARREN KS, MAHMOUD AA. Targeted mass treatment: a new approach to the control
of schistosomiasis. Transactions of the Association of AmericanPhysicians 89: 195-204,
1976
198. WATKINS-PITCHFORD W. Note on schistosomiasis. Medical Journal of South Africa 10:
226, 1915
199. WATSON JM, ABDEL AZIM M, HALAWANI A. Investigations on the antibilharzial
actions of Miracil D (Nilodin). Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and
Hygiene 42: 37-54, 1948
200. WEBBE G. Schistosomiasis: some advances. British Medical Journal ii: 1104-1106, 1981
201. WEBBE, G, JAMES A. A comparison of the susceptibility to praziquantel of S.
haematobium, S. japonicum, S. mansoni, S. intercalatum and S. mattheei in hamsters.
Zeitschrift für Parasitenkunde 52: 169-178, 1977
202. WEINLAND DF. Human cestoides. An essay on the tapeworms of man giving a full
account of their nature, organization, and embryonic development; the pathological
symptoms they produce, and the remedies which have proved successful in modern practice.
To which is added an appendix, containing a catalogue of all species of helminthes hitherto
found in man, Metcalfe and Co., Cambridge, Massachussetts, pp 93, 1858
203. WILEY CJ. The treatment of bilharziosis by intravenous injections of tartar emetic. British
Medical Journal ii: 716-717, 1918
204. WOLFF. Ueber Bilharzia in Deutsch-Ostafrika. Archiv für Schiffs- und Tropen-Hygiene
13: 167, 1909
205. ZANCAROL G. A specimen of Bilharzia haematobia, with ova in the tissues of the bladder
and large intestine. Transactions of the Pathological Society of London 33: 410-412, 1882.
Abstracted in British Medical Journal i: 13, 1882; Lancet i: 16, 1882
Schistosomiasis haematobia 231
SYNOPSIS
233
234 A History of Human Helminthology
These structures were empty apart from a few granules massed against th e
inner edge. A few days later, however, Bilharz's colleague, Wilhel m
Griesinger found the same bodies in a piece of large bowel, but on thi s
occasion, they contained living o rganisms which crawled out and swam about,
resembling S. mansoni miracidia. This naturally led Bilharz to put th e
question: "Therefore, how should we regard these bodies. Are they a second
type of egg or a kind of pupal covering assumed by the organism after leaving
the egg?"13
As discussed in chapter 8, Bilharz came down in favour of the latte r
proposition. There were two reasons for this. Firstly, he found S. haematobium
eggs and these bodies intermingled in the tissues. Secondly, and mor e
importantly, Bilharz believed that he had seen the same structure within a n
adult female S. haematobium:
Last summer I found one of these bodies in one of the first female specimens of
Distomum haematobium that I studied. It was in the front part of the oviduct, the
posterior of which contained the usual egg. I made a drawing of that specimen at that
time.13
Since he had seen this phenomenon only once, he surmised that the specimen
in the oviduct had metamorphosed abnormally early. This erroneou s
observation was to set the scene for confus ion and controversy for the next half
century as to whether there were one or two species of schistosomes tha t
infected humans in Egypt. Bilharz, in forthright terms, left no doubt as to his
views:
That these shells belong to the developmental stages of Distomum haematobium
and not to another organism seems indubitable to me. I not only found them
intermixed with eggs of Distomum haematobium in the calcified areas within the
liver, in the submucosa, and in the mucosa of the large intestine in acute dysentery,
but also, although only once, in the oviduct of a female worm which also contained
ordinary eggs.13
Proof that the bodies which occ upied Bilharz's mind were indeed egg shells of
S. mansoni was, in retrospect, provided in 1853. In a letter to von Siebol d
dated 4 January of that year, Bilharz included a drawing of a "capsule" which
is clearly the shell of a lateral-spined S. mansoni ovum12. Griesinger accepted
Bilharz's contention completely, for in the legend accompanying an illustration
in his paper of a typical S. mansoni egg, he wrote:
saclike bodies provided with a lateral spike (eggs? pupal coverings?); in any case,
belonging to the developmental cycle of the Distoma haematobium, since such a
body was once found in the fallopian tube of the organism. 43
As mentioned in the previous chapter, Harley in 1864 was so struck by the
complete absence of lateral-spined ova in the urine of patients with endemic
haematuria in South Africa that he was induced to name the parasite in tha t
region Distoma capense 44. Sonsino then suggested that schistosomiasis was
caused by two different species of worms, each producing characteristic ova
which differed in the position of their spine, but later abandoned this thesis in
favour of the postulate that one f orm of egg developed into a male worm while
Schistosomiasis mansoni 235
Japan in 1904 (see chapter 10). Manson's view was then championed by Louis
Sambon, a lecturer at the London School of Tropical Medicine. Putting al l
these thoughts together, he proposed at a meeting of the Zoological Society of
London on 19 March 1907 that the worm producing lateral-spined eggs b e
named Schistosomum mansoni 102. He so named the parasite in recognition of
Manson's earlier suggestion that there may be two species of Africa n
schistosomes: "In appreciation of this, one of his many genial intuitions, th e
new Trematode is dedicated to him"103. Sambon justified his creation of a new
species on the grounds of difference s in the morphology of the eggs, variations
in the clinical manifestations, and dissimilar geographical distributions o f
infection:
the ova of the new species have a large, curved, lateral spine which distinguishes
them from those of the old classic species with a short, straight spine at their posterior
extremity....S. mansoni ova are eliminated solely by way of the intestine....The
patients harbouring this parasite suffer from a haemorrhagic enteritis, but they never
present haematuria....S. mansoni has a wide distribution throughout Africa....It is
found also in the West Indies....and very likely in other places within the Tropics. 103
Sambon reiterated these points later in the year in a further communication ,
remarking on this occasion that although adult schistosomes of humans an d
cattle were very similar in general appearance, with the exception of the male
S. japonicum, he had no doubt that a minute comparative anatomical study of
these worms would bring out info rmation about many structural differences 104.
To further support his argument, Sambon drew attention to the report in July
of that year by Holcomb of a large number of cases of schistosomiasis wit h
lateral-spined eggs in the Caribbean, including no less than 167 cases i n
Puerto Rico, yet endemic haematuria was completely unknown 47.
Sambon's new species met with a vitriolic blast from Looss in a 39 pag e
paper entitled "What is Schistosomum mansoni Sambon 1907?". He
introduced his paper by remarking that:
if Dr. Sambon's view were correct, all of us who have devoted attention to the
subject, would have indeed been wandering in the dark since the time of Bilharz
himself, fiftyseven years ago.73
And indeed, some of them, with Looss amongst them, were. Looss was th e
arch protagonist of two controversial theories - the direct infection hypothesis
and the single species stance - both of which he was destined to lose. Afte r
bemoaning the fact that no notice had been taken of the (vague an d
unspecified) cautionary "hints" that he had "dropped" while in London tw o
years earlier (but precisely to wh om he could not remember), Looss castigated
Sambon's credentials saying:
Among scientific workers, it is a good custom that anyone who believes he has made
a new discovery also takes the trouble to prove it; it is not customary among scientists
to assert something then call for the help of others to establish it. 73
He then launched into an attack on Sambon's propositions. Looss's arguments
were centred on the following b ases. Firstly, he insisted that the differentiation
of species could only be made on the morphology of the adult worms, not on
Schistosomiasis mansoni 237
the appearance of the eggs. The foun dation stone of Looss's faith was Bilharz's
statement that he saw both types of eggs in one worm. He then adde d
sarcastically:
This observation is now fifty seven years old and might have been known to Dr.
Sambon if he had studied of those authors who he accuses of having failed to
recognise an obvious fact.73
Looss then remarked that if his memory did not fail him, he had seen several
similar female worms during the course of the years, and regretted that h e
could not produce them. Nevertheless, to let it be absolutely clear where h e
stood, he reiterated:
The occurrence of terminal-spined and lateral-spined eggs in one and the same
individual worm is one of the fundamental facts on which my views rest; I wonder
how Dr. Sambon will explain it by his theory.73
Looss thought that the position of the spine depended upon the position of the
egg during the process of its formation in the ootype. Extrapolating from his
observations on a number of trematodes, Looss deduced that lateral-spine d
eggs were abnormal and were probably produced by unfertilized femal e
worms. He explained the presence of a miracidium in some of these eggs as
being the result of a process of parthenogenesi s. Secondly, Looss dismissed the
differing clinical and pathological pictures associated with the two forms o f
eggs on the basis of variations in the habits of the human host and th e
conditions of the country. He produced an amazing and intricate hypothesi s
based upon the supposition that mirac idia were infective directly, and that they
developed into sporocysts in the liver. He postulated that when the infecting
dose of miracidia was high, there would be plenty of male worms present to
carry the females off to the vesical venous plexus where they produce d
terminal-spined eggs and caused urinary schistosomiasis. In contrast, h e
suggested that when the infecting dose was low, solitary females sometime s
developed, that these spinsters produced lateral-spined eggs, and that thes e
lonely worms sometimes migrated as far as the large intestine. Moreover ,
Looss believed that there was not a sharp line of demarcation between these
two responses. Finally, Looss contended feebly that the differences i n
geographical distribution of the two forms of parasite and disease cited b y
Sambon were based "upon a peculiarly one-sided interpretation of th e
literature" 73. Looss concluded his lengthy paper:
there is no possible doubt....that this species....must produce the same two shapes of
eggs as does the Sch. haematobium....If, therefore, Dr. Sambon wishes to maintain
that there is an independent "Sch. mansoni"....the entire proof of its existence
remains to be given.73
In January of the following year (1909), Sambon replied to Looss' s
criticisms in a long article with the same title as that used by Looss 105. He
began by saying that he ought to have refuted Looss's "critical", "violent" and
"ill-considered" paper at once, but he had delayed in the hope that someon e
would be able to describe distinctive morphological features for adul t
S. mansoni. Since this had not yet been done, he now found it necessary t o
238 A History of Human Helminthology
reply lest his silence be interpre ted wrongly. Sambon let it be clear that he had
the utmost regard for the eminent scientist who had studied helminthology in
Egypt during the previous 25 years, but tempered this by remarking that :
"Respect for authority is one thing, slavish submission to authority i s
another"105. Sambon then proceeded to counter Looss's arguments point b y
point. He insisted that the marked differences in the morphology of the eggs
were quite sufficient to estab lish a new species, quoted precedents established
by zoologists, and asserted that Looss himself had subscribed to new species
on much flimsier grounds. Conce rning Bilharz's alleged discovery and Looss's
vague confirmation of two forms of egg within the one adult worm, Sambon
declared:
Until he can show me an actual specimen I am bound to place the worm capable of
producing the two kinds of eggs with the phoenix, the chimaera and other mythical
monsters.105
He then demolished Looss's dismissal of the different clinico-pathologica l
effects associated with the two forms of worms, demonstrating that Looss' s
views were a: "multitude of surmises and conjectures more or les s
improbable"105 and adding nastily: "But Professor Looss has a theory, an d
theories often require a careful selection of the facts" 105. Sambon then
re-emphasized the different geographical distributions of S. mansoni and
S. haematobium. He noted that large numbers of patients in certain region s
passed vast numbers of lateral-spined eggs, yet not a single terminal-spine d
ovum could be found, and questioned how this could possibly be consisten t
with Looss's idea that they were a product of unfertilized female worms - there
would have to be an entire absence of ma le schistosomes. Further, he reasoned
that explaining all these lateral spines on the basis of abnormality an d
parthenogenesis bordered on absurdity. Next, Sambon showed that he had not
distorted the literature; rather, it was likely that the several patients wit h
urinary schistosomiasis in America that Looss had referred to, had acquire d
their infection in Africa, and there was no doubt that urinary schistosomiasis
alone occurred in southern Africa. Finally, he stood his ground and declared:
I never for a moment placed myself on the same level in the latter respects (as a hel-
minthologist) with the celebrated professor of Cairo, but at the same time I would say
that I have paid some attention to the subject, and cannot abandon my independence
of judgement, or my right to give expression to my views. 105
Two years later (1911), stung by Sa mbon's objections, Looss returned to the
debate. He had concluded on the basis of further observations that it was not
necessary to invoke parthenogenesis. Instead, he postulated that unfertilized
eggs are laterally spined, and that after fertilization, there is a "transitio n
period" following which the eggs become terminally spined. He had th e
impression that once the production of normal (terminal-spined) eggs ha d
begun, the others (lateral-spined) were usually evacuated quickly, bu t
reiterated: "that the females of S. haematobium can, and do, produce two
forms of eggs is beyond question, even now" 74.
Schistosomiasis mansoni 239
Shortly before Leiper left Egypt for Europe in July 1915, a mouse which had
been infected with cercariae from Planorbis boissyi (now known as
Biomphalaria alexandrina) died. This mouse was infected with adult schisto-
somes, and although only two or three eggs were seen, they were all laterally
spined. According to Looss's later theory, they were abnormal products in the
transitional phase of young sexually matu re worms of S. haematobium, where-
as according to Sambon, they indicated that the adult worm was S. mansoni.
On Leiper's reaching London, he found that four monkeys, also infected with
cercariae from P. boissyi, also began to pass lateral-spined eggs in August, but
they died within a fortnight from an overwhelmingly intense infection .
Similarly, in rats infected with P. boissyi-derived cercariae, only laterall y
spined eggs were found. Leiper had also infected some animals very lightl y
with cercariae from Bulinus (known to Leiper as Bullinus) snails in the hope
that some of these animals would live long enough to permit the testing o f
potential anthelmintics. Unfortunately, the infection was so light that no worms
were found in any of these animals.
In October of that year, Leiper reviewed the position and realized that h e
needed to infect animals lightly with cercariae from P. boissyi so that they
would survive for several months and thus enable the female schistosomes to
pass through Looss's hypothetica l "transition period". Secondly, another group
of animals had to be infected heavily with cercariae from Bulinus in order to
establish the specific nature of this form of parasite. Accordingly, he returned
to Egypt in November 1915 and infected monkeys orally and mice, rats and
monkeys percutaneously. The smaller animals were killed weekly in order to
assess the mode of development. Worms were first recovered 17 days afte r
infection from a mouse infected with cercariae obtained from Bulinus;
although the parasites were immatur e, they showed differences in the structure
of the gut when compared with with those obtained from mice infected with
P. boissyi-derived cercariae. Egg production began during the ninth week. He
published his findings and conclusions in a preliminary report in the British
Medical Journal in March 1916:
By submitting individual mice, each on one occasion only, for a limited period to
infection with the cercariae from single infected molluscs, it has been possible to
demonstrate that those developing in the Bullinus molluscs always produce bilharzia
worms which give rise solely to terminal-spined eggs, while those which have
developed in Planorbis boissyi always become worms which produce solely
lateral-spined eggs.71
He then turned his attention to experiments with monkeys. Two monkeys taken
from London to Egypt were infected orall y on the same day, one with cercariae
from Planorbis and the other with cercariae from Bulinus. The former monkey
began to pass lateral-spined eggs after six weeks and died from dysentery on
the sixtieth day. The other monkey had no eggs in the urine or faeces and was
killed six weeks after infection; worms were found in the liver and in th e
mesenteric veins but no eggs were seen. Meanwhile, a third monkey had been
242 A History of Human Helminthology
snails then subsequently recovering S. mansoni adult worms 76. Lutz also
pointed out that the cercariae of S. mansoni had in fact been seen, but no t
recognized as such, by Pirajá da Silva as early as 1912 when the latte r
described them and named them Cercaria Blanchardi. Finally, Lutz showed
that P. olivaceus was infected naturally with S. mansoni cercariae, and
re-examined in detail the kinetics of inf ection in experimentally infected snails.
He found that miracidia penetrated the molluscs within 10-15 minutes, th e
most usual site of attack being the antenna. Sporocysts were apparent within
three to four days then secondary sporocysts were seen migrating into th e
visceral sac 20 days after infection. Mature cercariae were found about fiv e
weeks after exposure 77.
In Caracas, Venezuela, Juan Iturbe (1917) infected P. guadelupensis (now
known as Biomphalaria glabrata ) with miracidia obtained from S. mansoni
ova51. He observed the transformation of miracidia into sporocysts then th e
production of secondary sporocysts then the appearance of cercariae after six
to seven weeks. White mice, guinea pigs and newborn puppies were infected
percutaneously with these cercariae; two months later, adult S. mansoni were
recovered from the portal vein of two mice. Iturbe found, however, that th e
most constant success was obtai ned when experimental animals were fed food
contaminated with livers of P. guadelupensis containing large numbers o f
cercariae. He then found many naturally infected snails of this species in the
city. Finally, Ampullaria luteostoma and P. cultratus were infected under
laboratory conditions, but he did not regard these as being vectors in nature.
Also from South America, Cardoso in 1923 reported that Planorbis
centrimetralis was the common intermediate host of the parasite in Sergip e
State, Brazil 16.
The cycle of transmission was again invest igated by Faust and his colleagues
in the early 1930's. They infected the snail they called Heliosoma
(Planorbina) guadaloupense (= Biomphalaria glabrata ) with S. mansoni
miracidia then produced patent infec tions in a variety of experimental animals.
With respect to development of the parasite in the snails, they first identified
sporocysts on the eighth day. Cercariae began to emerge after 24-35 days ,
depending upon the season and continued to be discharged for four months ,
producing altogether about 100,000 cercariae from a single miracidium 31,32.
The taxonomy of the snail vectors of S. mansoni has been a matter of some
controversy. Planorbis boissyi described by Potiez and Michaud in 1838 was
shown to be identical with Planorbis alexandrinus described by Ehrenberg in
1831; this latter name therefore had priority. A number of other genera were
raised, however, to house intermediate hosts of S. mansoni; these included, in
addition to the genus Planorbis described by Geoffoy in 1767, Biomphalaria
raised by Preston in 1910 98, Tropicorbis enunciated by Pilsbry and Brown in
1914, Afroplanorbis of Thiele, 1931, and Australorbis erected by Pilsbry in
1934. A World Health Organiz ation study group in 1954, however, noted that
it had long been recognized that the known species of snails which serve a s
244 A History of Human Helminthology
intermediate hosts for S. mansoni are generically the same, and that they al l
have probably been derived from the same stock. They recommended that the
name Biomphalaria should be used for all the snail intermediate hosts o f
S. mansoni 99. In 1965, the International Commission on Zoological Nomen-
clature confirmed this view and ruled that the correct generic name for th e
following snail vectors of S. mansoni, Armigerus, Planorbina and Taphius,
was Biomphalaria 50. In an annotation on an abstract concerning this decision,
Wright noted that it had not been necessary to consider Australorbis and
Tropicorbis since they were both junior synonyms of Biomphalaria 123. The
correct names for the major African vectors of schistosomiasis mansoni ar e
therefore Biomphalaria alexandrina and B. pfeifferi.
Concerning the South American molluscan vectors, Martins in 193 8
considered that Planorbis centrimetralis , P. guadaloupensis, P. immunis, P.
nigricans, P. olivaceus and perhaps P. peregrinus were all synonyms given
to members of a variable species properly known as Australorbis glabratus
85
. As already noted, the proper name for Australorbis is Biomphalaria,
therefore the correct name for the major South American vector o f
schistosomiasis mansoni is Biomphalaria glabrata .
lungs up to 19 days after infection, and peak numbers of worms in the live r
were reached on the thirteenth day. Mature worms were first seen in th e
colonic venules 35-40 days after infection 32,33.
Adult worms may live in the portal venous syst em of humans for many years.
One patient has been recorded who, at least 26 years after infection, was still
passing eggs containing living miracidia 116. Epidemiological evidence ,
however, suggests that the average life span for these worms is between five
and ten years 120.
such a mass of concentrically arranged young fibrous tissue, and lying in the centre
of the newly formed mass, as if it had become impacted in the vessel, and had by its
presence produced the proliferation of tissue which resulted in cirrhosis, an ovum. 110
Although he entitled his paper "Note on a new form of liver cirrhosis due to
the presence of the ova of Bilharzia haematobia", it is clear that he was
visualizing eggs of S. mansoni, for he remarked that most of the ova wer e
laterally spined. Most of the eggs were dead with merely the shell remaining
and were surrounded by fibrou s tissue, but he occasionally observed fresh ova
which were filled with a mass of inflammatory cells. Symmers thought that all
of these changes were indicative of a cirrhosis of the liver caused b y
schistosome ova.
Cirrhosis of the liver and splenomegaly with ascites have long bee n
recognized as being frequent in Egypt. Indeed, an attempt has been made to
link the abdominal distension and gy naecomastia seen on several reliefs on the
tomb of Mehou, a notable of the VIth Dynasty, to hepatic involvement i n
schistosomiasis 46. Certainly, this form of liver disease accounted for 4% of the
admissions to the medical wards of the Kasr-el-Aini Hospital in Cairo during
the early part of this century. In 1909, Day and Ferguson reported thei r
experience with this problem and concluded that it was not due t o
schistosomiasis 23. Fifteen years later, however, Day changed his position when
ova were discovered at liver biopsy in a series of patients subjected t o
splenectomy. He regarded splenomeg aly as an early and often transient feature
of S. haematobium infection, but concluded that progressive and lastin g
splenomegaly may accompany hepatic schistosomiasis mansoni, even whe n
infection of the intestinal tract was slight. Day believed that there were tw o
types of "cirrhosis". If the numbers of eggs were small, a diffuse multilobular
cirrhosis was established, but if they were numerous, the dense periporta l
(pipestem) fibrosis of Symmers was found 22.
The paucity of eggs in the liver and the recovery of male worms alone from
the portal vein, however, led Girges in his review to conclude that:
Egyptian splenomegaly is a disabling endemic parasitic syndrome caused by male
Schistosoma mansoni infestation of the liver and portal vein....It presents an
absolutely different picture from the ordinary type of schistosomiasis mansoni. There
is very little or no alimentary disturbance or implication of the gut, the brunt of the
infection being inflicted upon the viscera.40
Subsequently, the view was promulgated that these features were very similar
to Banti's syndrome and "before falling back on this obscure diagnosis in the
future, the question of schistosomiasis....will have to be considered" 4.
Nevertheless, the genesis of these liver changes remained a matter o f
controversy for many years. Thus, in 1959, Carter and Shaldon wrote:
the importance and extent of the infiltration of the liver by ova, and the nature and
causes of the fibrosis found in the livers of patients with schistosomiasis, are still
disputed.17
Experimental studies, however, eventually placed beyond any doubt tha t
when splenomegaly and ascites were due to schistosomiasis of the liver, they
248 A History of Human Helminthology
delta40. He divided them into two types - the intestinal and hepatic. Intestinal
schistosomiasis was in turn divided into four phases following "Baoonah itch"
(indicating cercarial invasion) and a laten t period: (1) febrile or toxaemic stage
lasting three to six weeks - this was seen in 3% of his patients and was marked
by the sudden or insidious onset of fever, hepatosplenomegaly, occasiona l
urticaria, indigestion, diarrhoea and tendern ess in the right hypochondrium; (2)
dysenteric stage lasting two to three years - this was seen in nearly three fifths
of his patients and coincided with the ap pearance of eggs in the faeces and was
characterized by exacerbations of dysentery every 15-20 days associated with
fever; (3) intestinal or papillomatous stage - this was seen in one third of his
patients and was typified by thickening of the lower bowel which was ofte n
palpable through the abdominal wall, and the appearance of papillae in th e
rectum. (4) final stage or "stage of repair" was seen in only 0.2% of hi s
patients - Girges considered it the terminal stage of infection with marke d
sclerosis and contraction of the tissues and with only a few atrophie d
papillomata left. The manifestations of hepatic schistosomiasis (which Girges
considered as being synonymous with Egyptian splenomegaly) were initially
the same as those in intestinal schistosomiasis. The second stage was marked
by the appearance of an enlarged, hard, o ften tender liver and spleen. The third
stage was indicated by the appearance of ascites. Ova were typically absen t
from the stools. As already indicated, it is now probable that this conditio n
frequently had nothing whatever to do with schistosomiasis.
Similar syndromes to these were described a few years later by Pons i n
Puerto Rico96. They were reiterated again by Gelfand in Southern Rhodesi a
(Zimbabwe) who recognized three clinical varieties: (1) an acute phase o f
fever and urticaria, often associated with malaise, anorexia and cough; (2 )
chronic abdominal pain and periodic mild diarrhoea with occasional blood and
mucus in the stools; (3) a late form with cirrhosis and splenomegaly 39.
In many endemic areas, not only is polyparasitism present, but infection s
with gastrointestinal bacterial and viral pathogens are common. Thi s
frequently makes it difficult to discern which features are due to schisto -
somiasis and which are due to other pathogens. In recent years, a number of
community studies have shed some light on this problem by relating th e
clinical manifestations to the int ensity of infection. A controlled study by Cook
and his colleagues of schistosomiasis in the West Indian island of St. Luci a
showed that gastrointestinal symptoms were no more frequent in infected than
in non-infected individuals, but that hepatomegaly and splenomegaly wer e
more common in the moderately and heavily infected children, as defined by
the numbers of eggs excreted in the faeces 20. Similar observations were then
made in Kenya 109 and in Brazil 68.
These findings confirmed views on the prognosis in schistosomiasi s
mansoni. Although severe and sometimes fatal infections with S. mansoni
were well-described in the nineteenth century, it was recognized that such an
outcome was uncommon. Before elucidation of the life cycle, there was some
Schistosomiasis mansoni 251
speculation that autoinfection might occur, and that this could influence th e
prognosis. When it was realized that infection was acquired from infecte d
snails and that adult worms did not multiply in the human host, it seeme d
probable that continuing exposure was necessary for the development o f
severe disease. This concept was supported by the observation that expatriate
troops infected during World War I did not develop progressive disease when
they were removed from the endemic areas 27.
In the last several decades, some longitudinal studies of the effects o f
schistosomiasis have been carried out, although they have tended to con -
centrate on the more heavily infected individuals. Thus, Katz and his col -
leagues in Brazil followed up 112 patients fo r ten years; two patients died from
haematemesis, seven had evolved towards hepatosplenomegaly, but most of
the others showed little progres s in the severity of the disease 58. Rather similar
results were reported by Kloetzel, also in Brazil, who observed 105 patients
infected with S. mansoni for five years and found that only seven had died 63.
Thus, schistosomiasis mansoni, although it may be a cause of considerabl e
morbidity, is not a major cause of death.
intradermal test114, but immunoassays have remained much less useful tha n
parasitological diagnostic techniques.
In 1902, Manson wrote that with the exception of Mesopotamia, Cyprus and
Mauritius, schistosomiasis had hitherto been supposed to be peculiar to Africa.
He then reported the instance of an Englishman who had been infected with
schistosomes producing laterally spined eggs while residing in the Wes t
Indies. Its occurrence in a white man suggested to Manson that the infection
must be not uncommon among the indigenous inhabitants. He then dre w
attention to the parallels betwee n schistosomiasis and another African disease,
Guinea worm infection, which had been at one time prevalent in parts o f
Central and South America, and noted that the latter condition had no w
disappeared. Although he did not specifical ly say so, Manson implied that both
of these infections had been introduced from Africa, and with remarkabl e
precision and foresight wrote: "It is evident that the distribution of this an d
similar parasitic diseases depends on the presence or absence of the efficient
Schistosomiasis mansoni 255
intermediaries" 81.
This form of schistosomiasis wa s indeed found to be common in parts of the
Americas. In 1908, Pirajá da Silva wrote that the worm was probabl y
introduced into the New World from Af rica by West African slaves, beginning
in 1550. Infection was particularly common in the environs of Bahia, Brazil
from where da Silva was writing. That city was at one time one of the mai n
entry ports during the times of the slave trade. He postulated that these people
were the carriers of schistosomes from Africa, and that the schistosome eggs
found climatic conditions in America favourable for development 92. More
recently, it has been suggested that Recife in Brazil may have been the most
important entry point, particularly during the Dutch administratio n
(1630-1654), since the Dutch brought in an in ordinately high number of slaves
during this period 2.
Although laterally spined eggs were common in South America in the early
parts of this century, haematuria and terminally spined eggs were not, eve n
though the latter disease was frequent in parts of Africa and may have been at
some time in the past in the Western Hemisphere. This became explicabl e
when Leiper proved that S. mansoni and S. haematobium were different
species and required different molluscan vectors. Snails susceptible t o
S. mansoni were found in various regions of the Americas, although they were
usually different species from those seen in Africa, but snails susceptible t o
S. haematobium were absent. While indigenous American snails wer e
susceptible to S. mansoni and are most important in transmission, there may
also have been a small-scale introduction of African vectors. For example ,
Biomphalaria alexandrina pfeifferi and Bulinus tropicus were found in the
municipal gardens and in ditches about the city of São Paulo, Brazil. It wa s
suggested that these species may have been introduced in water barrel s
brought from Africa during the slave trade times, and had been left behin d
when the barrels were washed out and refilled with fresh water 9. Further
support for the slave trade theory was provided by the demonstration tha t
infection was common in those places where slaves from endemic areas o f
Africa had been imported, such as northe astern Brazil. This infection may now
be becoming zoonotic, for Martins in Brazil in 1958 found that natura l
infections were common in wild and domestic rodents 86.
While it is the view of the vast majority of investigators that S. mansoni was
introduced from Africa, a few workers believe that this worm was autochth-
onous in Brazil. Magalhães and Dia s, for example, reached this opinion on the
basis of reports of a disease with symptoms similar to that seen in schisto -
somiasis mansoni which was said to have existed along the rivers before the
arrival of the Portuguese 80.
256 A History of Human Helminthology
REFERENCES
96. PONS JA. Studies on schistosomiasis mansoni in Puerto Rico. V. Clinical aspects o f
schistosomiasis in Puerto Rico. Puerto Rico Journal of Public Health and Tropica l
Medicine 13: 171-254, 1937
97. PORTER A. The invertebrate (molluscan) hosts of Schistosoma mansoni and Fasciola
hepatica in South Africa. Medical Journal of South Africa 16: 75-76, 1920
98. PRESTON. Annals and Magazine of Natural History 6: 535, 1910
99. REPORT OF A STUDY GROU P. Bilharzia snail vector identification and classification
(Equatorial and South Africa). World Health Organization Technical Report Series, No.
90, pp 1-22, 1954
100. RITCHIE LS. An ether sediment ation technique for routine stool examinations. Bulletin
of the United States Army Medical Department 8: 326, 1948
101. RODRIGUEZ HF. Schistosomal hepa tosplenomegaly. Boletín de la Asociación Médica
de Puerto Rico 48: 393-403, 1956
102. SAMBON LW. Descriptions of some new species of animal parasites. Proceedings of
the Zoological Society of London. No. 19, pp 282-283, 1907
103. SAMBON LW. New or little known African entozoa. Journal of Tropical Medicine and
Hygiene 10: 117, 1907
104. SAMBON LW. Remarks on Schistosomum mansoni . Journal of Tropical Medicine and
Hygiene 10: 303-304, 1907
105. SAMBON LW. What is "Schistosomum mansoni" Sambon 1907? Journal of Tropical
Medicine and Hygiene 12: 1-11, 1909
106. SCOTT JA. Dilution egg counting in comparison with other methods for determining
the incidence of Schistosoma mansoni. American Journal of Hygiene 25: 546-565, 1937
107. SHAW AF, GHAREEB AA. The pathogenesis of pulmonary schistosomiasis in Egypt
with special reference to Ayerza's disease. Journal of Pathology and Bacteriology 46:
401-424, 1938
108. SHIROMA M, OKUMURA M, MEIRA JA, FERREIRA JM. Cirurgia da hipertensão
portal na esquitossomose mansônica hepatosplênica. Avaliação clínica de 150 casos de
anastomose espleno-renal. Revista do Hospital das Clínicas; Faculdade de Medicina ,
Universidade de São Paulo 22: 309-337, 1967
109. SIONGOK TK, MAHMOUD AA, OUMA JH, WARREN KS, MULLER AS ,
HANOKA AK, HOUSER HB. Morbidity in schistosomiasis mansoni in relation t o
intensity of infection: study of a community in Machakos, Kenya. American Journal of
Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 25: 273-284, 1976
110. SYMMERS WStC. Note on a new form of liver cirrhosis due to the presence of ova of
Bilharzia haematobia . Journal of Pathology and Bacteriology 9: 237-239, 1904
111. SYMMERS WStC. A note on a case of bilharzial worms in the pulmonary blood in a
case of bilharzial colitis. Lancet i: 22, 1905
112. SYMPOSIUM DE OXAMNIQUINE. Rio de Janeiro, Brasil, Junho, 1973. Revista do
Instituto de Medicina Tropical de São Paulo 15: Supplement, pp 1-175, 1973
113. TALIAFERRO WH, HOFFMAN WA, COOK DH. A precipitin test in intestina l
schistosomiasis. Journal of Preventive Medicine 2: 395-414, 1928
114. TALIAFERRO WH, TALIAFERRO LG. Skin reactions in persons infected wit h
Schistosoma mansoni. Porto Rico Journal of Public Health and Tropical Medicine 7 :
23-35, 1931
115. TOMB JW, HELMY MM. The diagnosis of in testinal schistosomiasis by sedimentation.
Transactions of the Royal Society o f Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 25: 181-185, 1931
116. WALLERSTEIN RS. Longevity of Schistosoma mansoni: observations based on a case.
American Journal of Tropical Medicine 29: 717-721, 1949
117. WARREN KS. The immunopathogenesis of schistosomiasis: a multidisciplinar y
approach. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 66 :
417-434, 1972
118. WARREN KS. Regulation of the prevalence and intensity of schistosomiasis in man:
immunology of ecology? Journal of Infectious Diseases 127: 595-609, 1973
262 A History of Human Helminthology
SYNOPSIS
Ova of the parasite now known as Schistosoma japonicum were first dis-
covered in 1888 by Tokuho Majima (pen-name, Naganori) in Japan when he
made a postmortem examination of a man who had been suffering with ascites
and peripheral oedema. Majima noted that the spleen of this patient wa s
enlarged to five times the normal weight but that the liver was shrunken an d
contracted. The liver, moreover, had granular nodules both on its surface and
in the parenchyma amongst thickened connective tissue. When histologica l
sections of the liver were prepared:
It was found most surprisingly and unexpectedly that with the thickened interlobular
tissue there were countless parasite eggs, and these were located only in the
connective tissue....these eggs were oval....in shape and varied in size from 0.065 to
0.06 mm in length and 0.05 to 0.04 mm in diameter. The shells of the eggs did not
possess small covers (opercula). There were two kinds of eggs; the first type was pale
yellow in color with contents of a granular nature streaked with brownish-black
pigment....The second type had only the egg shell with no contents and were,
therefore, colorless and transparent.72
Majima wondered where the eggs came from, and with excellent logic bu t
miserable luck, opened the bile duct and the portal vein in the hope of finding
adult worms. He was unsuccessful - if he had been, he would have anticipated
the discovery of S. japonicum by 16 years. Majima was not able to examine the
faeces of this patient but predicted that eggs might have been found there .
263
264 A History of Human Helminthology
discovered by rolling them around on a micr oscope slide that a small, knob-like
projection was always present 60.
Evidence of the antiquity of schistosomiasis ja ponica in eastern Asia has been
provided recently by finding typical eggs in human tissue. In 1971, a corps e
which had been buried 2,100 years pr eviously in Hunan Province of China was
exhumed and characteristic S. japonicum eggs were recovered from digested
liver. Four years later, eggs were found similarly in a corpse which had been
buried 100 years earlier than the previous one 75.
samples were sent to an eminent German authority who considered that the y
were neither coccidia nor trematode ova, but the eggs of a nematode o f
unrecognizable species. At Patrick Manson's suggestion, Catto began to section
systematically all the preserved tissues. He found nematode larvae in smear s
prepared from the large intestine, a minute adult nematode in an artery of the
mesorectum, and a nematode larva in a mesenteric lymph node. Stimulated by
these observations, and no doubt misled by the German opinion, Manson and
Catto presented the case to a meeting of the British Medical Association i n
Oxford in July 1904 as that of an infection with a new nematode: "The parasite
would seem to be an oviparous nematode of minute dimensions and o f
unknown species" 74.
Catto continued his dissections and eventually found male and female adult
trematode worms in the mesenteric vessels, although neither he nor exper t
pathologists could be certain whether they were arteries or veins. Within th e
bodies of the female worms Catto now saw ova corresponding to the ova l
bodies in the viscera and realized that he was dealing with concomitan t
nematode and trematode infections. Manson then sent specimens to the Inter-
national Zoological Congress at Berne, Swi tzerland, where they were examined
by Blanchard, Looss, Ward, Stiles, Grassi and others, all of whom agreed that
the parasite was a schistosome and new to science. Catto then presented a n
updated version of his findings, describing both the autopsy features and th e
adult worms, to a meeting of the Pathological Society of London on 1 5
November 190416. Blanchard subsequently named the parasite Schistosoma
cattoi in Catto's honour, then Catto published a detailed record of the parasite
under that name in the British Medical Journal of 7 January 1905 17.
Further investigations revealed the identity of this parasite with the on e
described by Katsurada so, by the law of priority, Katsurada's designation ,
Schistosoma japonicum, stands as the correct name for this helminth. Thus, the
worm was discovered independently by several workers. Faust and Melene y
have placed these events in perspective well:
As has frequently been the case in many important contributions to science, several
workers attack the same problem contemporaneously, but without knowledge of each
other's investigations. Only the circumstance of time gives one the honor which the
other quite equally deserves. Such is the case with Schistosoma japonicum
Katsurada.29
Katsurada in Yamanashi attacked the problem logically and systematically; he
began with patients with a particular clinical syndrome, found eggs in thei r
stools, confirmed their presence in the viscera of other patients, surmised that
adult worms must live in the portal veno us system, found the male worm in that
position in a naturally-infected cat, then pursued the quest relentlessly until he
found female worms in another animal. Fujinami in Hiroshima, having earlier
found the eggs in another of his patients, was beaten to the punch by a mer e
month or so, but was without doubt t he first to find the female adult worm, and
the first to find an adult schistosome in a human being. Finally, Catto i n
268 A History of Human Helminthology
When the adult forms of S. japonicum were discovered, it was clear that th e
infection must be transmitted in a fashion similar to that of S. haematobium.
But, as already discussed in chapter 8, the life cycle of that parasite too wa s
quite obscure, with protagonists of the direct infection theory and th e
intermediate host school each ardently defend ing their own particular view. The
speed with which the Japanese investigators worked out the life cycle of S.
japonicum is little short of remarkable, considering that it took only nine years
from Katsurada's discovery of the adult worms until Miyairi and Suzuk i
demonstrated transmission through snail intermediate hosts. This contrast s
starkly with the 64 years between Bilharz's discovery of S. haematobium and
Leiper's elucidation of the life cycle of that worm - and that largely followed the
precedent set by the Japanese. In defence of the European investigators ,
however, it must be remarked that two factors worked in favour of the Oriental
scientists. Firstly, Miyairi and Suzuki found snails susceptible to infection and
naturally infected with S. japonicum at almost their first attempt, whereas a
number of European investigators examined many different species with a
conspicuous lack of success. Secondly, although animals can be infecte d
experimentally with S. haematobium and S. mansoni, occidental schisto-
somiasis in nature is principally a disease of humans. Oriental schistosomiasis,
on the other hand, is a major zoonosis with humans and animals being equally
infected; this was known as early as 1847 for Fujii then wrote that even th e
cattle and horses were not immune to the affliction 32. This facilitated research
enormously for simple animal models were th erefore available for experimental
elucidation of the life cycle. Fujinami recognized this when he looked back on
the early years of schistosomiasis research in Japan:
animal experiments have been easily carried on, as the subjects of the experiment
could be infected by immersing them in water of the ditches in the endemic area. The
animal experiments have led to the solution of many interesting problems in the
pathology of the disease.34
Animal experimentation was indeed the key to success, but the key had first
to be found. It was Fujinami himself, in collaboration with Nakamura, a n
assistant professor of pathology at Kyoto Unive rsity, who made the fundamental
discovery. Because the adult schistosomes lived in the portal venous syste m
and were often found in the intestinal wall, many Japanese investigators thought
Schistosomiasis japonica 269
it likely that infection was acquired via the gastrointestinal tract, possibly by the
ingestion of worms in contaminat ed water. On the other hand, the development
of leg rashes and subsequent disease in farme rs working in rice fields suggested
that infection might occur through the skin.
Fujinami and Nakamura therefore devised an experiment to test the various
hypotheses. They decided to use cows since these animals were not onl y
susceptible to infection, but they were also large and docile enough to be made
to stand in water with only the hooves be ing soaked and without water touching
the anus and genitalia, thus avoiding the possibility of infection via the mucous
membranes of these organs. They used 17 cows up to one year of age an d
which had been obtained in Hiroshima ci ty where the infection was absent. The
experiment was begun on 7 June 1909 with the beasts being divided into a
number of groups. The first gr oup of six calves was given only boiled food and
water, and except on these occasions, th eir mouths remained covered. Each day
they were taken out of the barn and stood in water, three of them in the mud of
a rice paddy and the other three in a river which received great volumes o f
water from the rice fields. All of these animals became infected with S.
japonicum, but much larger numbers of adult worms were found in the cows
that had been allowed into the rice fields. A second group of seven calves had
their legs washed with soap and alcohol, then oiled and covered wit h
water-proof, protective leg bags. Four o f these animals ate and drank in the rice
fields, while three of them were taken to the river banks to feed. Six of these
cows remained uninfected, and a solitary worm pair was recovered from th e
seventh animal. A third group of two cows was fed and watered like the first
group. One cow was confined to the barn; no infection developed. The other
animal was placed in an irrigation canal for nearly five and a half hours on one
day only, nevertheless, it became infected with 31 worms. Finally, no special
measures were taken for a fourth group of two cows which were permitted to
roam freely; both animals became infected. Fujinami and Nakamura therefore
concluded that infection was acquired by penetration of the skin 35,36:
The great difference between the findings for group A and B is obvious - like snow
and charcoal - and we feel that the problem of the mode of entry of the infection,
which has vexed scientists for so long, has at last been incontrovertibly solved" 35
Further, they deduced that infection could be acquired easily in a short space
of time by contact with contaminated water, but that the risk of infection was
greater in the stagnant waters of the paddy fields and small irrigation canal s
than in the fast-flowing waters of the rivers.
The two researchers found schistosome s in different stages of growth in most
animals. One cow, however, had been exp osed on only one occasion, and when
it was killed 26 days later, small mal e and female worms were found in copula.
Although no eggs were detected, this observation led Fujinami and Nakamura
to write that: "the time required for the parasite to grow is comparativel y
short"36.
This conclusion was verified by experiments which they undertoo k
270 A History of Human Helminthology
importance of the morphology of the cercaria for his own studies of the lif e
cycle of S. haematobium:
In the meantime, however, Miyairi and Suzuki....had succeeded by another method
of approach in tracing the metamorphosis in a closely allied, if not identical, snail in
the South Island of Japan. My own observations therefore confirmed generally the
results of these workers, apart from establishing my chief, ulterior object, which was
to provide a simple and reliable means of attacking the complex problems of B.
haematobia.62
The life cycle of S. japonicum was then confirmed in another geographical
area by S. Yokogawa. In February 1914, adult schistosomes were found in a
pig in Taiwan, then subsequent surveys disc losed them in dogs, pigs, goats, and
cattle. Yokogawa therefore collected snails and examined them for cercaria e
resembling those described by Miyairi. Eventually he succeeded in finding an
infected snail, obtained the cercariae and rubbed them on to the skin of a rabbit.
Eighteen days later, he killed the animal and recovered young schistosomes 5
mm long from the portal venous system 122. Many years later, Hsü and Hs ü
showed with human volunteers that the Formosan strain of S. japonicum is a
non-human, zoophilic strain wh ich develops for a short period in the viscera of
humans but does not reach maturity 42.
Attention then turned to China when Faust and Meleney investigated schisto-
somiasis and its transmission on the Chinese mainland. Their first step was to
obtain some snail vectors, known at that time as Blanfordia nosophora , from
S Yoshida in Osaka, Japan. In February 1922, they showed that these snail s
were susceptible to S. japonicum miracidia from a Chinese patient whereas the
usual molluscs in the Peking area, including Viviparus, Planorbis and
Lymnaea species could not be infected. Fa ust and Meleney therefore postulated
that the same or a similar species of mollusc must be the intermediate host in
China. In August 1922, Meleney found some similar snails near Soochow in
the lower Chang Jiang (Yangtze) Valley on river banks near the water's edge
and on water grass stalks. When dissected in the hospital laboratory, 28% of
these snails (which were identified subsequently as Oncomelania (Hemibia)
hupensis by Bryant Walker of Detroit, Michigan, USA) contained schistosome
cercariae. These cercariae were then used to infect laboratory mice and S.
japonicum adult worms were eventually obtained 78. Another batch of snails
which was not naturally infected was infected under experimental conditions
with S. japonicum miracidia of Chinese origin and the metamorphoses of the
larvae were observed. Cercariae, which were produced nine weeks afte r
exposure of the snails, were used to infect experimental dogs 28. Finally, O.
hupensis was infected successfully with S. japonicum of Japanese origin 27.
In 1932, Tubangui demonstrated that a snail identified by J Bequaert o f
Harvard University as Blanfordia quadrasi (now known as Oncomelania
quadrasi) was the intermediate host of S. japonicum in the Philippines 111.
Meanwhile, in an appendix to Faust and Meleney's monograph o n
schistosomiasis japonica which appeared in 1924, Nelson Annandale of th e
276 A History of Human Helminthology
Zoological Survey of India and the Indian Museum, Calcutta, had reviewed the
status of the molluscan intermediate hosts of S. japonicum. He concluded that
there were three species which transmitted the worm, nosophora, formosana
and hupensis, all of which belonged to the genus Oncomelania Gredler 1881,
which was quite distinct from the genus Blanfordia 2.
Once Fujinami, Nakamura and others had shown that infection was acquired
by the percutaneous route, Yoneji Miyagawa turn ed his attention to both tracing
the route of migration of the worms from the skin to the portal venous system,
and determining the structures of the various developmental forms. He went to
Yamanashi province of Japan in the summer of 1911. Initially, he looked for
worms in the portal venous blood. Experimental animals, especially dogs and
rabbits, were immersed in water in areas where the disease was rampant, then
he collected blood between two and twenty four hours later. In these samples,
Miyagawa managed to find schistosomula. He then identified similar worms in
the skin and concluded that they had penetrated the skin partly directly an d
partly via the hair follicles, then entered the vascular system and possibly the
lymphatics, and were carried to the portal veins. He examined the anatomy of
these skin worms in detail and compared them with adult worms in the portal
vein and free-living miracidia, and found that they resembled adul t
schistosomes more than miracidia. This led him to conclude (before Miyair i
and Suzuki's proof) that the change in appearance must have occurred in a n
intermediate host:
On comparing the youngest described worms with the miracidia originating from
eggs, I found a considerable difference. I assume, therefore, that S. japonicum very
probably has an intermediate host.81
In a subsequent study, Miyagawa reported that he had found schistomula i n
thoracic duct lymph of infected dogs and in the draining lymph nodes. Because
of the paucity of numbers of worms in the lymph, however, he believed tha t
most worms passed directly via the bloodstream 82. Soon afterwards, Ogat a
made use of Miyairi and Suzuki's discovery t o confirm Miyagawa's findings. He
applied cercariae to the skin of experimental animals and observed thei r
passage through the integument via the bloodstream to the lungs 91.
Two schools of thought then arose as to the means by which worms reached
the portal system from the lungs. Narabayashi proposed that the parasite s
entered the pleural space then passed through the diaphragm to the liver and
portal circulation 88. He was supported in this view by Suyeyasu who studie d
serial sections of mice 104, but Miyagawa and Takemoto contended tha t
schistomula left the lungs via the systemic arterial circulation and were carried
to the gastrointestinal tract where they then found their way to the porta l
Schistosomiasis japonica 277
venules. Miyagawa and Takemoto based this view on their failure to fin d
worms penetrating the diaphragm or in the liver parenchyma, wherea s
parasites were seen in the intr ahepatic blood vessels of experimentally infected
animals84.
Shortly thereafter, Cort examined the development of these worms in detail.
He noted that soon after penetrating the skin, the tail of the cercaria was los t
and the cephalic glands dege nerated. By the twelfth day, the majority of worms
had reached the liver. There was little increase in size until the larvae reached
this organ, although the digestive system became more organized and the oral
sucker assumed its adult character. Cort was unable to distinguish between the
sexes in the earliest liver stages, but began to discern differences when the y
reached 0.3-0.4 mm in length. Growth continued after sexual maturity but at a
slower rate. As growth continued, he observed that the body of th e
female worms became rounded on cross-section while that of the male worms
flattened gradually and the sides grew up to form the gynaecophoric canal. Pari
passu with these events, the suckers grew and the digestive system becam e
horse-shoe shaped and distended with food. Differentiation of th e
reproductive organs came relatively late and they only became clearl y
distinguishable when the male and female worms attained lengths of 1.5 an d
2.0 mm, respectively 22.
A year or two later, Meleney and Faust re-examined both of these aspects .
They observed the process of invasion by cerca riae, noting that during invasion,
if not before, the tail of the organism dropped off, and determined that invasion
might be effected within several hours but could take up to two days. Within
two to three days of exposure of e xperimental animals, most schistosomula had
reached the lungs. Although a few worm s were side-tracked in heavy infections
and reached the pleural cavity where they degenerated, most larvae passe d
through the lungs into the systemic circulation. Meleney and Faust agreed with
Miyagawa's contention, for they recovered worms at this stage of the infection,
not only from mesenteric artery, but also from the renal, splenic and a variety
of peripheral arteries79. They found that those worms which reached the portal
venous system were able to grow and develop, with sexual differentiatio n
occurring as early as the seventeenth day, although sexual maturity was no t
reached until after four weeks. By this time, the worms had migrated retrograde
from the liver to the distal mesenteric venules where they laid eggs 28,29.
In 1932, Goto attempted to settle the argument over the two routes of migra-
tion. He found that washing out of the organs and tissues of dogs infected with
S. japonicum supported the systemic arterial migration theory of Miyagawa and
Takemoto while serial sections of decalcified mice indicated direct migration
as espoused by Narabayashi and Suyeyasu. Consequently, Goto concluded that
the results obtained depended upon the technique used 39.
Once within the portal system, worms may live for many years, continuing
infections being reported 32 years 76 and 47 years40 after the last possible
278 A History of Human Helminthology
exposure.
leucocytes, and particularly eosino phils, congregated around eggs in the tissues
and abscesses formed; these tended to break outwards by small openings into
the intestinal mucosa. Thrombosis of the lar ger mesenteric and portal veins was
frequently seen in later cases. In the liver, there was, in addition to th e
inflammatory lesions produced by degeneration of eggs, a general pipeste m
fibrosis. The spleen varied in size, but was sometimes hypertrophie d
enormously. Faust and Meleney were unimpressed by lung lesions, but noted
that eggs might sometimes be seen in the brain.
and noted that cows and horses were also affected, writing "Persons who g o
into the mud immediately develop red rashes; the associated pruritis (sic) i s
said to be unbearable" 52. He then went on to state that the signs of Katayam a
disease were "(an) enlarged liver and spleen, sometimes abdominal ascites ,
anaemia and bloody stools" 52.
Although the relationship betwen schistosomiasis japonica and skin rashes
was fairly striking, there were some dissenters. For example, Miyagawa (1913)
discounted the association on a number of grounds, including variations i n
geographical distribution of the two conditions, differences in the histological
appearances of the skin, and the absence of eggs in the faeces of many patients
with dermatitis 83.
In various parts of China, a syndrome of fever with urticaria had been recog-
nized from time to time. This condition was known as Yangtze Fever, Hankow
Fever, Kiukang Fever and Urticarial Fever, dep ending upon the region in which
it was observed. In 1910, Houghton at Wuhu Hospital in China associated this
syndrome with S. japonicum infection69, then this opinion was supported b y
other observers. In 1913, Edgar gave an excellent description of the syndrome
which usually afflicted children or young men who bathed in creeks or waded
in marshy ground in the Chang Jiang (Yangtse) valley; the condition wa s
particularly well-recognized in foreign seamen. According to Edgar, malaise
was followed by headache, myalgia and fever which was remittent in character
and lasted for three to six weeks. Half of the cases had transient or persistent
urticaria, and many complained of cough and transitory diarrhoea whic h
sometimes developed into dysentery. The illness usually settled down withi n
two to three weeks 26.
This description was reiterated in the following year by Laning wh o
described two further stages in the evolution of the disease 56, a classification
which was also adopted by Mann 73. The next stage of illness was associate d
with hepatosplenomegaly, dysentery, marked eosinophilia, and the passage of
S. japonicum eggs in the stools. A terminal stage which may or may no t
supervene was typified by a:
cirrhotic liver, sometimes enlarged, sometimes shrunken, ascites, oedematous
extremities, marked emaciation, anaemia, weakness, passage of blood and mucus in
the stools.56
Interest in the clinical manifestations of schistosomiasis japonica by Western
clinicians was rekindled when a number of troops became infected during the
invasion of Leyte island in the Philippines in 1944. A number of series o f
patients were reported, and these descriptions generally followed the patter n
described thirty years earlier in China 30,45,107
With respect to prognosis, it had been apparent from the early times that the
severity of illness seemed to be dependent upon the intensity of infection. Long-
term observations of expatriates infected in China before and around Worl d
War I, and of Allied troops infected in Southe ast Asia during World War II, and
who were then removed from the endemic area, indicated that the prognosi s
Schistosomiasis japonica 281
Details of the development of drugs which have been used in the therapy o f
schistosomiasis japonica have been described in chapter 8. Initially, quinine 110
and arsenicals were tried, particula rly in Japan, but these drugs did not pass the
test of time and proved of little use. In 1913, Hutcheson reported that emetine
282 A History of Human Helminthology
was useful in patients with dysentery 43. In view of the efficacy claimed for the
drug in other forms of schistosomiasis, there may have been some activit y
against S. japonicum, but it is also possible that the patients had concurren t
amoebic dysentery which responded to the drug. There was dispute over th e
effectiveness of emetine during the next few years 51,94,112, but interest in it
largely waned in favour of tartar emetic.
Following the introduction of antimonials for the treatment of schistosomiasis
in Africa, the drug was tried in Chin a and Japan against S. japonicum. In 1921,
Sanders and Priston reported that intravenous injection of antimony was effic-
acious in three patients; there was a great reduction in the numbers of ov a
excreted and those that were present in the faeces were not viable 97. On the
other hand, Libby, in a small series of cases, found that tartar emetic was not
particularly active and this led to suggestions that this drug was less effective
in schistosomiasis japonica than in other forms of human schistosomiasis 65. In
a later and more extensive study, the same author concluded that while tartar
emetic was useful in mild and moderate cases, it was of little value for patients
with severe infections where there was hepatosplenomegaly 66. Nevertheless,
Meleney and his colleagues regarded the drug as curative when a total dose of
1.5-2.0 grams of antimony was given over a period of 18-20 days 29,80.
Moreover, Nishi investigated the actions of the drug in experimentally infected
dogs and found that sodium antimony tartrate was able to kill youn g
schistosomes and affected eggs in tissues 90.
In 1951, Pesigan and his colleagues showed that lucanthone, when used in
doses recommended for other forms of schistosomiasis, was ineffective in the
treatment of S. japonicum infections93. Likewise, metrifonate and oxamniquine
were found to be inactive. At a symposium on niridazole held in Lisbon i n
1965, there were suggestions that this drug may be less effective i n
schistosomiasis japonica than in the treatment of S. mansoni and S. haem-
atobium infections. This question was investigated further by Santos and hi s
colleagues in the Philippines; they found that the cure rate in 106 patient s
treated with various regimens of niridaz ole ranged between 48% and 85% 98. Sy
then treated 237 persons and managed to follow up just over half of them one
month later; 55% were cured, the egg count wa s reduced in 18%, and there was
no response in the remaining 27% of patients 105. Praziquantel now looks to be
the drug of choice in the treatment of schistosomiasis japonica. Th e
introduction of this drug has been described in chapter 8. Suffice it to say here
that Santos and his colleagues studied the effects of different dosage regimens
in 128 Filipino patients and found that praziquantel was very effective; onl y
24% of patients treated for three days and reviewed 12 months later were still
passing ova in the faeces 99.
Schistosomiasis japonica 283
The syndrome known as Katayama disease and w hich turned out to be caused
by S. japonicum, was associated with water long before the causative agent was
identified. Thus, Fujii in 1847 related the condition to wading in the padd y
fields, and by making use of the appearance of a rash on the legs, was able to
pinpoint the time of the year at which infection was acquired to the seaso n
between spring and summer 32. The same connection between working in rice
fields and Katayama disease was recognized by Kawanishi who, in 1904 ,
provided a concise description of the locale. At that time, Katayama was a
village of 190 inhabitants and 36 houses situated at the foot of a hill 80 fee t
high. The paddy fields were several feet lower than the level of the river, thus
making it very difficult to drain the stagnant water, particularly during th e
prolonged rainy season, and it was in these fields that workers developed the
erythematous eruption on their legs 52. Furthermore, it was in these people that
Kawanishi found S. japonicum eggs, thus bringing the nature of the affliction
closer to clarification.
Fujii also recognized the focal nature of the condition, the locations an d
boundaries of which were gradually extended by a number of Japanes e
clinicians over the next sixty years. The discoveries by Catto in 1904 o f
S. japonicum in a man from Fukien province of China16,17, and in an 18 year old
male in Hunan province, China, by Logan in the following year 68 widened
knowledge of the geographical distribution considerably, as did the report by
Wooley in 1906 of schistosomiasis japonica in the Philippines 118. Many years
later (1937), Brug and Tesch discovered an endemic focus of infection i n
Sulawesi, Indonesia12. From time to time, weather conditions led to epidemics
of schistosomiasis in new areas as, for example, occurred when the summe r
floods in the Chang Jiang (Yangtse) valley in 1931 brought the infection from
the upper part of the system down to the delta 47, or when major floods occurred
in China in 1954 67.
The reason for the association with water fell into place, of course, with the
discovery that certain species of snails were the vectors of infections. Attention
then turned to investigating the behaviour and ecology of these long, narrow,
operculated snails. The amphibious snails were most numerous in wet, moist
soil near water and thick grass. The population was densest along irrigatio n
ditches and became progressively thinner on the banks of rivers and canals, in
rice beds, and in paddy fields. It was shown that they were most active at night,
but crawled only at a rate of about three metres a month. If the surface of the
earth became dry, the snails dug down into the deeper, wetter reaches, and by
closing the operculum, survived for three months or so, although infecte d
molluscs tended to die earlier. Mating was found to occur throughout the year,
but was at a maximum in the spri ng and early summer and at a minimum in the
early winter, with many snails hibernating during the depths of winter. Th e
average life span was determined at around five years or so, wit h
284 A History of Human Helminthology
Hopes for the control or, better, the eradication of schistosomiasis have been
held for many years. Over a century ago, Fujii left a memoir expressing thi s
desire:
I recently read my manuscripts and found the script of 'Katayama Memoir'. Thirty
years have passed....By knowing (what causes it), we can treat it. In this way, the
mysterious disease which has existed for many years can be eliminated easily. This
would be good for the people.32
Once Fujinami and Nakamura had shown that infection was acquired whe n
parasites penetrated the skin , they were able to suggest several means whereby
the infection could be contained:
(1) the faeces which contain the eggs must be disinfected. (2) in order to prevent the
growth of the causative agent, constructions on land and water must be renovated; (3)
in order to prevent the causative agents penetrating the body, contact with
contaminated water should be avoided.36
The first of these points was overvalued to some extent, for it took no account
of the excretion of eggs by infect ed animals, while the last proposal was clearly
impossible for the many peasants whose livelihood depended upon working in
the paddy fields. The discovery of the snail intermediate host by Miyairi an d
Suzuki, however, provided another point at which the cycle of transmissio n
could be attacked. This seemed the simplest approach, so attention in Japa n
centred upon the evaluation of various molluscicides. Of all the chemical s
tested, lime was found to be the surest and most economical agent 34,37. This
chemical was available readily in Japan and the farmers used it for fertilizing
the rice fields. Lime was therefore spread on the banks of infested canals and
drainage ditches, and in the water contained in them. Alternatively, Fujinami
and Fukutuni showed that burying the snails in wet, but not dry, soil kille d
them.
In 1928, Todokoro reported on the effectiveness of a combination o f
measures in Hiroshima prefecture in Japan. These included the destruction of
snails with lime, the installation of pit latrines, the replacement of cattle b y
horses (which are less susceptible to infection 34) for ploughing, the repression
of wild rats, and educating the local inhabitants about the dangers of immersing
skin in water. The results were highly encouraging, with the incidence of skin
rashes decreasing and the prevalence of infection in cattle and the numbers of
Schistosomiasis japonica 285
snails dropping markedly 108. Since that time, and occurring pari passu with
improving economic conditions, as well as the introduction of specifi c
measures such as the cement lining of irrigation ditches and the availability of
more effective molluscicides, the infection has almost disappeared i n
Japan120,121.
Similar excellent results have not been achieved in the Philippines o r
Indonesia where the paucity of economic resources has militated agains t
attempts to control the infection.
The situation in China is somewhat less clear. In 1924, after reviewing the
biological and technical problems in volved, Faust canvassed some of the social
and political factors that would affect control measures:
One more fact must be kept in mind in considering such an undertaking so intimately
concerning the native farming class - namely, their suspicion that only harm can result
from any stranger tresspassing on their domain. Coupled with this is the improbability
of securing any government cooperation at the present time in China. 27
Then, with truly prophetic foresight, he went on to add:
In spite of these unpleasant facts, the problem of eradicating schistosomiasis from
China is a hopeful one. One must bear in mind that China is an ancient country, that
she moves slowly and deliberately, but that she moves surely. The next fifty years will
bring much in the way of reorganization and development in China. It seems not too
much to expect that public health and preventive medicine will follow closely upon
the steps of improved agriculture and commerce, and that in this scheme of affairs,
schistosomiasis will not long be allowed to remain an uncontrolled infection in the
heart of the country.27
Schistosomiasis was regarded in China as a serious parasitic disease with a
major economic impact. By the middle of the 1950's, a nationwide contro l
scheme was evolved and put into operation. Maegraith visited the country a
year or two after the inititiation of this programme and has recorded hi s
impressions 71. The extent of infection at that time was not fully known, but it
was estimated that over 11 million people were infected in the fertile region of
the Yangtse valley. The three major components of the control scheme wer e
mass treatment of overt infections (with the two-fold aim of bringing clinical
relief and a reduction in the contamination of the environment with eggs) ,
preventing the pollution of water by infected human and animal faeces, an d
destruction of the snail intermediate hosts. Schistosomiasis centres wer e
established for the purpose of mass treatment, propaganda and administrative
control, while the actual field work was done by local farming and villag e
communities. The year 1970 was set as the target for effective control. Th e
most commonly used anthelmintic was sodium or potassium antimony tartrate,
given intravenously, initially in seven or 20 day courses, but later in a three day
regimen of treatment. Educational campaigns were set up to limit promiscuous
defaecation; arrangements were made to collect and store faeces for one week
in order to allow the ammonia that was generated to destroy the ova whic h
otherwise would survive for several months, but problems were encountered
in dealing with animal faeces. Snail control with molluscicides was instituted
286 A History of Human Helminthology
with Paris green or calcium arsenate being used most commonly at first, bu t
later sodium pentachlorophenate be came the most popular chemical; they were
sprayed on land within two metres of the water level. Physical methods were
also employed; these included burning of grass in summer and the manua l
removal and burial of snail-containing mud in winter.
In 1977, an American delegation visited China in order to assess the impact
of these various measures on the prevalence of schistosomiasis 4. The members
of the delegation noted that by 1959, 25,000 communal health units concerned
with schistosomiasis control had been set up. Between 1958 and 1962 ,
5,000,000 people were treat ed with schistosomicides. The campaign to reduce
the numbers of Oncomelania hupensis , however, was the most importan t
feature of the control efforts. The delegation considered that there had been a
reduction by two thirds in the prevalence of human schistosomiasis. Th e
success of the programme was ascribed to China's economic, social an d
political organization which permitted disciplined mass participation, a n
approach which would be very difficu lt for any other nation to emulate. Finally,
it was also concluded that in addition to the effects of the various specifi c
control measures, the reduction in schistosomiasis transmission was probably
also consequent upon a general improvement in socio-economic conditions.
Brumpt who placed four ducks in a vessel containing C. ocellata then recov-
ered subsequently eggs and adult forms of B. polonica 14. In 1940, Brackett
(who had been exposed naturally on many occasions) infected himself delib-
erately with C. stagnicola and C. ocellata then excised the lesions 29 and 50
hours later, respectively; no cercariae were seen but intense inflammation was
noted11. Subsequently, similar cases of dermatitis caused by cercariae o f
Trichobilharzia, Gigantobilharzia and Ornithobilharzia species, the definitive
hosts being birds and the vectors including species of Chilina, Physa,
Planorbis, Polypis and Stagnicola were reported from many parts of the world.
A second form of cercarial dermatitis acquired in fresh water was shown to
be due to penetration of human skin by cercariae of schistosomes whic h
develop in mammals other than man. This was first reported by Buckley i n
1938 who found that dermatitis in workers in paddy fields was a consequence
of infection with S. spindale cercariae15. Similar effects have since bee n
recognized as being caused by S. bovis 9, S. douthitti 24, S. mattheei 1 Hetero-
bilharzia americana 58 and Orientobilharzia turkestanicum 96.
Finally, cercarial dermatitis may also be acquired while bathing in salt water,
as was first reported by Penner in 1950. Seabirds serve as the definitive hosts
while marine molluscs are the vectors of the worms. Penner described a new
avian schistosome larva, Cercaria littorinalinae from the marine snail,
Littorina planaxis, found on the coast of southern California 92. Two years later,
Stunkard and Hinchcliffe described a s imilar affliction on the beaches of Rhode
Island, USA102. Parasites now known to cause this condition include Bilharzia
variglandis 102 and Gigantobilharzia huttoni 59.
S. BOVIS
S. INCOGNITUM
The distinctive eggs of this parasite were recovered from the faeces of tw o
human patients by Chandler in 1926. He proposed the name S. incognitum as
the parent worms were unknown 18. Later, the adult worms were found in pigs
and dogs in India8, then subsequently in rodents in southeast Asia. The egg s
have a short, pointed, terminal spine.
288 A History of Human Helminthology
S. INTERCALATUM
S. MARGREBOWIEI
This schistosome was discovered in ruminants by Le Roux in 1933 64. The egg
has a small, terminal spine. A human infection was reported by Lapierre and
Hien in 1973 57.
S. MATTHEEI
S. MEKONGI
The first case of human schis tosomiasis of southeast Asian origin was reported
in 1957 not from Asia but from Paris when Vic-Dupont and colleagues dis -
covered the condition in an 18 year old Eurasian with hepatosplenomegaly and
haematemesis; the early part of the patient's childhood had been spent o n
Khong island in the Mekong river between Laos and Cambodia 114. Between
1963 and 1966, Barbier, also in Paris, saw four more Indochinese students who
were infected similarly; enquiry revealed that they had all lived on Khon g
island7. Alerted by these observations, a World Health Organization team was
sent to the island and found that schistosomiasis was endemic there 44.
Subsequent surveys indicated that the infection was endemic in some regions
of Thailand. Shortly thereafter, the intermediate host was identified as a n
aquatic, not amphibious mollusc, Lithoglyphopsis aperta 41, now known as
Tricula aperta 25. In 1978, Voge and her colleagues erected a new species, S.
mekongi, for this parasite, on the grounds that the eggs were smaller, th e
prepatent period in mice was l onger, and the intermediate host was different 115.
Schistosomiasis japonica 289
S. RODHAINI
This parasite of African wild rodents was described by Brumpt in 1931 13. The
eggs have a subterminal spine. It is transmit ted by Biomphalaria snails. Human
infection was reported in Zaire in 1954 by Gillet and Wolfs 38.
REFERENCES
A. NOUVELI
A. RECONDITA
Flukes of this genus are found in the intestines of birds and mammals, no t
including man. Snails are the first intermediate host. Cercariae penetrate the
skin of a fish or tadpole then move about f reely in the tissues as mesocercariae.
In 1973, an unidentified mesocercaria was observed in the retina of a woman,
in Ontario, Canada, who had often prepared frogs' legs for eating 125. A
disseminated fatal infection with mesocercariae of A. americana occurred in
1976 in Ontario in a young man who had eaten inadequately cooked frogs '
legs51. Finally, A. marcianae mesocercariae were removed from the skin of a
man, in Louisiana, USA, who had eaten baked raccoon 17.
DICROCOELIASIS
DICROCOELIUM DENDRITICUM
This parasite was confused with the common liver fluke, Fasciola hepatica,
297
298 A History of Human Helminthology
for many years. The worm is a common parasite in the biliary passages o f
sheep, deer and other herbivorous and omnivorous animals in many parts of
the world. It was named Fasciola lanceolata by Rudolphi in 1803 115, then
Fasciola dendritica by him in 1819116. In 1899, Looss transferred the worm
to the genus Dicrocoelium erected by Dujardin in 1845 47, this name being
derived from the Greek words (DIKROOS, DICROOS) and
(KOILIA, COELIA), meaning double and cavity, respectively; the parasit e
thus became known as D. dendriticum 83.
It took many years to elucidate the complete life cycle of D. dendriticum.
The eggs are embryonated when passed in the stools, but do not hatch i n
water. When ingested by appropriate land snails, metamorphosis occurs with
two generations of sporocysts being formed and the eventual production o f
cercariae. Many species of land snails act as the first intermediate host ,
depending upon the geographical region. Cercariae of this worm had in fact
been seen and labelled Cercaria vitrina by von Linstow in 1887, but thei r
relationship with D. dendriticum was not appreciated at that time.
In 1929, two papers appeared in Germany giving accounts of attempts t o
solve the problem of the source of this infection. Both investigations wer e
based upon intensive epidemiological inves tigations in several heavily infected
parts of that country. W. Nöller found that the snail, Zebrina detrita, was
heavily parasitized with C. vitrina. Since the distribution of the snail an d
dicrocoeliasis did not quite coincide, however, he considered that either C.
vitrina may not be the cercaria of D. dendriticum, or else that Z. detrita was
not the normal host of the worm. Further searching showed that Torquilla
frumentum was host to the same cercaria, and that its distribution did correlate
with the presence of infected sheep 97. In another area, Vogel found that Z.
detrita and Helicella candidula were infected with von Linstow's cercaria, and
he thought it very likely that the latter mollusc might be the intermediate host
of D. dendriticum 139. This view was proven to be correct two years later when
Cameron infected Helicella by feeding these snails with Dicrocoelium eggs,
then raising adult flukes in sheep infected with the cercariae obtained fro m
these snails 31.
Cercariae of Dicrocoelium aggregate in slime balls and are left on the grass
as the snail moves along. In 1952 and 1953, Krull and Mapes in the US A
showed that metacercariae develop in the ant, Formica fusca, and that
infection of the mammalian host resulted from ingestion of infected ants 70,71.
This was confirmed by Vogel and Falção in Germany 142, then the ants, F.
cinerea and F. picea, were shown to be the intermediate hosts in the USSR 105.
The first description of human infection with this parasite is shrouded i n
controversy. The patients described by Bucholz in Germany and Chabert i n
France might have been infected with F. hepatica or D. dendriticum (see
chapter 4). The same might be said for the nine year old daughter of a
shepherd in Bohemia described by Dr Kirchner of Kaplitz and recounted by
Miscellaneous Trematode Infections 299
Cobbold39; in this girl, 47 mature worms were found in the gall bladder a t
autopsy. This uncertainty flows from the difficulty those observers had i n
establishing the identity of the adult fluke. The diagnosis is usually made ,
however, by finding the distinctive eggs in the faeces. Many of these cases ,
though, are spurious. Strom showed in 1927 that they result from the ingestion
of liver heavily contaminated with eggs 132; in such patients, the excretion o f
eggs in the stools is transient compared with patients with true dicrocoeliasis.
Most of the infections with this parasite have been reported from the USSR 93.
Success has been claimed for thymol and stibophen in the treatment o f
dicrocoeliasis121, but subsequent experience has shown that these drugs are not
always reliable. Praziquantel may prove to be effective.
D. HOSPES
ECHINOSTOMIASIS
E. HORTENSE
This parasite was first described by Asada in 1926 11. It was placed in the genus
Echinostoma of Rudolphi (1809) and emended by Dietz in 1910 45; the name
was derived from a combination of the Greek words (ECHINOS) and
µ (STOMA) meaning "spine" and "mouth", respectively. In 1976 ,
Arizono and his colleagues descr ibed infections in four people who ate loaches
(Misgurnus anguillicaudatus). Subsequently, loaches were collected from the
same restaurant in which two of the patients had eaten; parasites wer e
recovered from the soft tissues adjacent to the gills and a puppy was fed with
40 metacercariae and two humans ingested 10 metacercariae each. Egg s
appeared in the faeces after two weeks and the volunteers developed abdominal
pain lasting for several days about one month after infection. The dog wa s
necropsied after 33 days and five adult worms were recovered from its small
intestine9.
E. ILOCANUM
Eggs of this fluke were first found in the faeces of prisoners in Manila, Phil -
ippines by Garrison in 1907. He l ater recovered 21 adult worms, 2-6 mm long,
after administration of oleoresin of aspidium to one person. Since the prisoner
came from the Ilocano region of the Philippines, in 1908 he named i t
Fascioletta ilocanum 53. In 1911, Odhner transferred this helminth to the genus
Echinostoma 99. The parasite was found subsequently in various parts o f
southeast Asia, with first Tubangui (1 931) showing that rats, then Chen finding
that dogs, were reservoirs of infection.
In 1933, Tubangui and Pasco described the life cycle of the parasite (which
they called Euparyphium ilocanum); miracidia penetrated the snails Gyraulus
convexiusculus and Hippeutis umbilicus, metamorphosed into rediae, the n
produced daughter rediae and cercariae, the latter being liberated and encysting
on freshwater molluscs which may be eaten raw 137. G. prashadi was shown
subsequently to be the primary intermediate host in India. Worms attach to the
intestinal wall and may cause diarrhoea. Recently, Radomyos and colleagues
have shown that praziquantel is effective in the treatment of this infection 107.
E. LINDOENSE
This species was first reported as E. ilocanum by Brug and Tesch in 1937 in
the Celebes (Sulawesi), Indonesia 28, but was re-described as E. lindoense by
Sandground and Bonne in 1940 119. The parasite was named after the Lak e
Lindoe region of Central Celebes where human infection was common, with up
Miscellaneous Trematode Infections 301
The metacercariae of these parasites, which were first described by Ando and
Ozaki in 19238, encyst in the tissues of tadpoles and frogs. Majima found 66
adult E. macrorchis in the intestines of a boy in Japan in 1927 90. Since then,
occasional infections of humans by both species have been reported fro m
various parts of southeast Asia 25.
E. MALAYANUM
This parasite was first found in two Tamil coolies in Singapore and Kual a
Lumpur, and was named E. malayanum by Leiper in 1911 74. Species of
Lymnaea and Indoplanorbis were shown to be the first intermediate host by
Rao110 and then by Lie and Virik 79.
E. REVOLUTUM
This fluke was first found in the caecum of an Indian patient and designate d
Amphistomum hominis by Lewis and McConnell in 187677. Subseqently, it was
called Gastrodiscus hominis by Sonsino (1896) 128, then was redescribed i n
1913 by Leiper who renamed it Gastrodiscoides hominis 75. The generic name
is derived from the Greek words (GASTER ) and (DISKOS,
DISCOS) meaning "belly" and "disc", respectively, with the suffix
(EIDOS) indicating "like" or "similar". The worm is common in parts o f
northeastern India where more than 40% of the population may be infected 29,
but it is also found in other parts of Asia. Pigs are a common reservoir host but
various species of monkeys have also been found to be infected. The life cycle
is uncertain, but the snail, Helicorbis coenosus, has been infected
experimentally 48. Humans may be infected with large numbers of thes e
helminths, which are approximately 1 cm long and almost as much wide; 999
worms were recovered from one individual, simply by the administration o f
soap and water enemas29. Parasites generally attach to the large bowel and the
infection may cause diarrhoea. Mechanical t herapy with soap and water enemas
Miscellaneous Trematode Infections 303
H. HETEROPHYES
H. KATSURADAI
This fluke, first recognized in 1782 by Bloch who named it Distoma conoid-
eum 23, and renamed by Dietz in 1909 44, is a common parasite of birds such as
ducks, geese and fowl. The intermediate hosts are Planorbis and Lymnaea
snails. The infection is common in some parts of Thailand, where more tha n
half of the population may be infected 148.
METAGONIMIASIS
OPISTHORCHIASIS
OPISTHORCHIS FELINEUS
This fluke, about 1 cm long, was discovered in the biliary passages of a cat by
Rivolta in 1884 and named Distomum felineum by him113, the specific desig-
nation reflecting the host in which it was found. In 1895, R Blanchard erected
the genus Opisthorchis and placed this fluke in it, the worm thus being known
as O. felineus 22. The generic name was derived from a combination of th e
Greek words (OPISTHON) and (ORCHIS) meaning
"posterior" and "testis", respectively.
Several years earlier (1892) in Tomsk, in the Siberian region of the USSR,
Winogradoff first reported this infection in humans. He found the parasite i n
nine patients and named it Distomum sibiricum 143. Subsequently, Kholo-
kowsky diagnosed the infection in a peasant from near Leningrad but who had
travelled extensively in Siberia 66. Askanazy then discovered the worm in five
people living in the East Prussian district of Heydekrug. Further studie s
Miscellaneous Trematode Infections 307
revealed that a wide range of mammals including dogs, cats, foxes, pigs, rats,
rabbits and seals were infected in cent ral and eastern Europe and adjacent parts
of the USSR 49.
The life cycle of O. felineus was elucidated in fits and starts. Askanazy i n
1905 believed that he had shown that the fishes Idus melanotus (chub) and
Leuciscus rutilus (roach) were the intermediate hosts 14. Lühe then indicated
that the details of the development of the parasite were known only meagrely,
and suggested that an encysted larval worm found in Prussia in the flesh o f
L. idus and L. rutilus could be the metacercarial stage and that an earlier phase
perhaps passes in the body of a small bivalve mollusc, Dreissena polymorpha
86
. In 1917, Ciurea stated that he believed that Askanazy had been in error and
had probably been working with holostomes 38. Ciurea isolated encyste d
cercariae from the fishes Tinca tinca and Idus idus, then recovered mature
O. felineus twelve days after feeding the parasites to cats and dogs. Subsequent
studies by a number of investigators demonstrated that other freshwater fishes
of the genera, Abramis, Barbus, Blicca, Cyprinus, and Scardinius, were also
hosts of the larval stage of O. felineus.
The nature of the first intermediate host of the fluke remained obscure until
1934 when Vogel showed that development of the parasite occurred in th e
snail, Bithynia leachi 141. He found that eggs hatched after they were ingested
by the snails, then the miracidia mig rated into the tisssues, metamorphosed into
first then second generation sporocysts, then produced rediae in which th e
cercariae developed after about two months. B. leachi is the only species of
snail which has been shown to be susceptible to infection with this parasite .
Vogel observed that when cercariae enco untered the fish, they became attached
to the scales, dropped their tails, then penetrated into the tissues.
Vogel also investigated the route of migration of the worms in the definitive
host. He showed that like Clonorchis, but unlike Fasciola, metacercariae of
O. felineus excysted in the duodenum, then migrated through the ampulla o f
Vater to the distal bile passages wh ere they became attached to the mucosa and
matured, beginning the laying of e ggs about three to four weeks after ingestion.
Worms in the bile passages may induce inflammation and subsequent fibrosis
leading to biliary obstruction and secondary bacterial infection an d
cholelithiasis. Clinical studies indicated that the likelihood of significan t
damage depended upon the number of worms present. Patients with 50 or so
worms usually had no ill-effects, but people with many hundreds of worm s
sometimes had severe biliary and hepatic disease.
The diagnosis is made by finding eggs in the faeces or duodenal fluid. Hexa-
chloroparaxylol (chloxyl) was claimed to be partially effective in Russia n
patients with opisthorchiasis103. Praziquantel has been shown to be effective in
the treatment of O. viverrini infections and is presumably also active against O.
felineus.
308 A History of Human Helminthology
O. VIVERRINI
This fluke was first found in a civet cat (Felis viverrus) by Poirier in 1886 and
named Distoma viverrini by him104. It was transferred to the genus Opisth-
orchis of Blanchard 22 by Stiles and Hassal in 1896 131
. Nevertheless, it is
possible that the correct name for this parasite is O. tenuicollis, reflecting the
Distoma tenuicollis described by Rudophi in 1819 116.
Most early reports of this infection in southeast Asia referred to this parasite
as O. felineus 63,106, although Leiper (1911) made a provisional diagnosis of O.
viverrini for some flukes from two prisoners in Chiengmai gaol in Thailand that
had been sent to him by Dr. Kerr 74. Differentiation between the two species is
extremely difficult; Wykoff and colleagues in 1965 could not distinguis h
between them on the basis of the appearances o f the adult worms or of the eggs,
but found differences in the patterns of the flame cells in the cercariae 146. The
infection is now recognized as being common in Thailand, with up to half of the
population being infected in some areas 54.
The life cycle of this parasite was studied in Thailand by Wykoff and hi s
colleagues; they showed that the snail intermediate hosts were Bithynia
goniomphalus, B. funiculata and B. laevis, while the most important fis h
intermediate hosts were species of Cyclocheilichthys, Hampala and
Punteus 146.
Early clinical studies suggested a high frequency of diarrhoea, abdomina l
pain and jaundice in patients with opisthorchiasis, but these studies were not
well-controlled 54,117. Subsequently, Wykoff and co-workers compared th e
clinical and biochemical findings in 921 infec ted persons with those in a similar
number of uninfected persons in Thailand, and could find no significant dif -
ferences between the two groups 145. On the other hand, Upatham and col -
leagues have shown more recently in a study of a village with 309 inhabitants
that right upper quadrant abdominal pain was more common in those persons
with heavy infections 138. It is possible that there is an association betwee n
opisthorchiasis and carcinoma of the bile duct; for example, 5896 worms were
found an autopsy of a man who died from this neoplasm 54.
The diagnosis is usually made by findi ng eggs in the faeces. Upatham and his
collaborators have defined recently the relationship between intensity o f
infection and faecal egg excretion138. A number of drugs have been proposed
as a treatment for opisthorchiasis viverrini. Partial responsiveness t o
dehydroemetine was shown by Muangmanee and co-investigators in 1974 94.
Niclofolan was thought to be of some value in patients with light infections 6.
Bunnag and Harinasuta showed in 1980 that the infection responded well t o
praziquantel; 23 out of 26 patients were cured by a two day course of treatment
and toxicity was minimal 30.
O. NOVERCA
Miscellaneous Trematode Infections 309
This fluke, which is a common parasite of dogs and pigs in India, was firs t
found in these animals in that country by Lewis and Cunningham in 1872; i t
was named O. noverca by Braun in 1902 26. It has been recorded twice i n
humans, on both occasions by McConnell in India. McConnell, like Lewis and
Cunningham, considered it to be identical with Distoma conjunctum
discovered by TS Cobbold in the liver of an American red fox in 1858. Th e
first patient was a Muslim who died in Calcutta in 1876; post-morte m
examination revealed small flukes in dilated intrahepatic bile ducts 87.
McConnell encountered another patient i n 1878 and on this occasion noted that
the flukes were somewhat larger than those described by Cobbold 88.
O. GUAYAQUILENSIS
This worm was first obtained from an eight year old girl in Assam, India and
named Artyfechinostomum sufrartyfex by Lane in 1915 72. It was later re-
described and transferred to the genus Paryphostomum of Dietz (1909) by
Bhalerao in 193119. The generic name is derived from the Greek word s
(PARAPHYE) and µ (STOMA) meaning "fringe" and "mouth",
respectively. The details of the life cycle are uncertain, but A. mehrai, which is
probably a synonym of P. sufrartyfex, utilizes the snail, Indoplanorbis exustus
108
. It is also possible that this species is synonymous with Echinostoma
malayanum described by Leiper in 1911.
PLAGIORCHIASIS
The genus Plagiorchis was raised by Lühe in 1899 85. It is derived from the
Greek words (PLAGIA) and (ORCHIS) meaning "oblique" and
"testis", respectively. The species of Plagiorchis normally occur in the
310 A History of Human Helminthology
P. PHILIPPINENSIS
Africa and Garcia first found this fluke in 1935 during the autopsy of a man
from Ilocano, Philippines, but they left it un-named 1; it was given its curren t
name by Sandground in 1940 118. That first patient was also infected wit h
Echinostoma ilocanum and Spelotrema brevicaeca . People in this region o f
the Philippines were in the habit of eating grubs of certain species of insect s
which may be the second intermediate hosts.
P. JAVENSIS
Sandground in 1940 first found this worm in a Javanese who also had a heavy
infection with Echinostoma ilocanum 118.
P. MURIS
Tanabe described this fluke in 1922 133,134. McMullen in 1937 infected himself
experimentally89. A natural infection in a human has been reported only once;
it was found in a Japanese patient who was being treated for a heavy ,
concurrent infection with Metagonimus yokogawai 13.
This fluke was described by Fain and Vandepitte in 1957 after they had found
it in a retroauricular cyst removed from a boy in Central Africa 50. Eggs similar
to those produced by this parasite had been removed previously from near the
ear of a man by Yarwood and Elmes in 1943 147. This genus is closely related
to, or may be identical with, Achillurbania 16. The generic name is derived from
a combination of the Greek words (POIKILOS) and
(ORCHIS) meaning "many" or "various" and "testis", respectively.
Onji and Nishio described this fluke in 1915 101. It has been reported in humans
in Korea124. The generic name is derived from a combination of the Gree k
words (PYGIDION) and (OPSIS) meaning "posterior" o r
"rump" and "sight", respectively.
Miscellaneous Trematode Infections 311
This fluke was first reported a s Heterophyes brevicaeca in 1935 by Africa and
Garcia who found it in the intestine of a Filipino male 1. It was renamed
Spelotrema brevicaeca by Tubangui and Africa in 1938 136. The complete life
cycle is unknown, but encysted metacercariae have been found in the crab ,
Carcinus maenas 56. In humans, eggs have been observed in the centra l
nervous system 2 and in the heart 3.
This fluke, described by Onji and Nishio in 1915 101, has been reported in
humans in Japan, Taiwan and Hawaii 5,59.
This parasite was discovered in the intestine of a Nigerian by Watson and sent
to Conyngham in London. The flukes were pronounced a new species b y
Blanchard, then Conyngham named it Amphistomum watsoni in 190441. The
parasite was renamed Watsonius watsoni by Stiles and Goldberger in 1910 129.
312 A History of Human Helminthology
It has been recovered from a human only this once. The life cycle is unknown.
REFERENCES
1. AFRICA CM, GARCIA EY. Plagiorchis sp., a new parasite of the human intestine. Papers
on helminthology: 30th jubilee of the activities of KJ Skrjabin, Moscow, pp 9-10, 1935
2. AFRICA CM, LEON W de, GARCIA EY. Heterophyidiasis: V. Ova in the spinal cord of
man. Philippine Journal of Science 62: 393-399, 1937
3. AFRICA CM, LEON W de, GARCIA EY. Heterophyidiasis: VI. Two more cases of heart
failure associated with the presence of eggs in sclerosed valves. Journal of the Philippine
Islands Medical Association 17: 605-609, 1937.
4. ALICATA JE. Life cycle and developmental stages of Philophthalmus gralli in the
intermediate and final hosts. Journal of Parasitology 48: 47-54, 1962
5. ALICATA JE, SCHATTENBURG OL. A case of intestinal heterophyidiasis in man ni
Hawaii. Journal of the American Medical Association 110: 1100-1101, 1938
6. AMBROISE-THOMAS P, WEGNER DH, GOULLIER A, DESGEORGES PT,
BILLIAULT X. Essais de traitement des opistorchiases humaines par le niclofolan (Bay
9015). À propos de 51 cas. Bulletin de la Société de Pathologie Exotique 73; 293-301, 1980
7. ANAZAWA K. (First instance of Echinostoma revolutum found in man and its course of
infection.) Taiwan Igakkai Zasshi No. 288, pp 221-224, 1929. In Japanese
8. ANDO A, OZAKI Y. (On four new species of trematodes of the genus Echinostomata).
Dobutsu Gaku Zasshi 34: 108-119, 1923. In Japanese
9. ARIZONO N et al. (Studies on Echinostoma hortense Asada, 1926 with special reference to
its human infection.) Japanese Journal of Parasitology 25: 36-45, 1976. In Japanese, with
English summary
10. ARTIGAS PdeT, PEREZ MD. Considerações sôbre Opisthorchis pricei Foster, 1939, O.
guayaquilensis Rodriguez, Gomez et Montalvan, 1949 e O. pseudofelineus Ward, 1901.
Descrição de Amphimerus pseudofelineus minutus n. subsp. Memorias do Instituto Butantan
30: 157-166, 19601962
11. ASADA J. (On a new species of trematode belonging to the Echinostoma family). Tokyo Iji
Shinshi No. 2447, p 1633, 1926. In Japanese
12. ASADA J. (Determination of the first intermediate host of Heterophyes heterophyes
occurring parasitic in human body in Japan and an experimental investigation of its
development.) Tokyo Iji Shinshi No. 2564, pp 6-12, 1928. In Japanese. Abstracted in Japan
Medical World 8: 134, 1928
13. ASADA J, OTAGAKI H, MORITA D, TAKEUCHI T, SAKAI Y, HONISHI T,
OKAHASHI K. A case report on the human infection with Plagiorchis muris, Tanabe 1922,
in Japan. Japanese Journal of Parasitology 11: 512-516, 1962
14. ASKANAZY M. Weitere Mittheilungen über die Quellen der Infektion mit Distomum
felineum. Schriften der physikalisch-oekonomischen Gesellschaft zu Königsberg 46: 127-131,
1905-1906
15. BASCH PF. Completion of the life cycle of Eurytrema pancreaticum (Trematoda:
Dicrocoeliidae). Journal of Parasitology 51: 350-355, 1965
16. BEAVER PC, DURON RA, LITTLE MD. Trematode eggs in the peritoneal cavity of a man
in Honduras. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 26: 684-687, 1977
17. BEAVER PC, LITTLE MD, TUCKER CF, REED RJ. Mesocercaria in theskin of man in
Lousiana. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 26: 422-426, 1977
18. BENNINGTON E, PRATT I. The life history of the salmon-poisoning fluke,Nanophyetus
salmincola (Chapin). Journal of Parasitology 46: 91-100, 1960
19. BHALERAO GD. Trematode parasites of pigs in Bengal. Records of the Indian Museum 33:
475482, 1931
20. BILHARZ T, von SIEBOLD CT. Ein Beitrag zur Helminthographia humana, aus brieflichen
Mittheilungen des Dr. Bilharz in Cairo, nebst Bemerkungen von Prof. C. Th. von Siebold in
Breslau. Zeitschrift für wissenschaftliche Zoologie 4: 53-76, 1853. Partly translated in 62
Miscellaneous Trematode Infections 313
Oekologie und Geographie der Tiere, Jena, Supplement 12: heft 3, 265-512, 1910
46. DOLLFUS R. Distome d'un abcès palpébro-orbitaire chez une panthère. Possibilité d'affinités
lointaines entre ce distome et les Paragonimidae. Annales de Parasitologie Humaine et
Comparée 17: 209-235, 1939
47. DUJARDIN F. Histoire naturelle des helminthes ou vers intestinaux, Librairie Encyclopédique
de Roret, Paris, pp 654, 1845
48. DUTT SC, SRIVASTAVA HD. The intermediate host and the cercaria ofGastrodiscoides
hominis (Trematoda: Gastrodiscidae). Journal of Helminthology 40: 45-52, 1966
49. ERHARDT A, GERMER WD, HORNING B.Die Opisthorchiasis, hervorgerufen durch dem
Katzenleberegel Opisthorchis felineus (Riv.). Parasitologische Schriftreihe 15: 1-170, 1962
50. FAIN A, VANDEPITTE J. Description du nouveau distome vivant dans des kystes ou abcès
rétroauriculaires chez l'homme au Congo Belge. Annales de la Société Belge de Médecine
Tropicale 37: 251-281, 1957
51. FERNANDES BJ, COOPER JD, CULLEN JB,FREEMAN RS, RITCHIE AC, SCOTT AA,
STUART PF. Systemic infection with Alaria americana (Trematoda). Canadian Medical
Association Journal 115: 1111-1114, 1976
52. von FRÖLICH JA. Beyträge zur Naturgeschichte der Eingeweidewürmer. Der Naturforscher,
Halle 29: 5-96, 1802
53. GARRISON PE. A new intestinal trematode of man. Philippine Journal of Science 3:
385-393, 1908
54. HARINASUTA C, VAJRASTHIRA S. Opisthorchiasis in Thailand. Annals of Tropical
Medicine and Parasitology 54: 100-105, 1960
55. HIRASAWA I. (On Echinochasmus perfoliatus found parasitic in man and on the final host
of this parasite.) Tokyo Iji Shinshi No. 2577, 1928. In Japanese. Abstracted in Japan Medical
World 8: 275, 1928
56. HOCKLEY AR., Observations on the metacercaria of Spelotrema. Proceedings of the First
International Congress of Parasitology p 525, 1964
57. HSÜ H F. Euparyphium jassyense Leon and Ciurea (= E. melis, Schrank) found at the
autospy of a Chinese. Chinese Medical Journal 58: 552-555, 1940
58. JANSON C. Die Haustiere in Japan. IV. Die Krankheiten der Hausthiere in Japan. (2)
Parasitäre Krankheiten. Archiv für wissenschaftliche und praktisch Thierheilkunde 19, 1893
59. KAGEI N, OSHIMA T, ISHIZAKA K, KIHATA M. (Two cases of human infection with
Stellantchasmus falcatus Onji et Nishio 1915 [Heterophyidae] in Kochi Prefecture.) Japanese
Journal of Parasitology 13: 472-478, 1964. In Japanese, with English summary
60. KATSURADA F. (On the genus Heterophyes in Japan.). Okayama Igakkai Zasshi No. 268,
pp 373-380, 1912. In Japanese
61. KATSURADA F. (On the genus Heterophyes in Japan: suplementary note.). Okayama
Igakkai Zasshi No. 269, 1912. In Japanese
62. KEAN BH, MOTT JE, RUSSELL AJ. Tropical Medicine and Parasitology. Classic
investigations, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, 2 volumes, pp 677, 1978
63. KERR AF. Intestinal parasites in northern Siam. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical
Medicine and Hygiene 9: 82-89, 1916
64. KHALIL M. A preliminary note on the second intermediate host ofHeterophyes in Egypt.
Journal of Helminthology 1: 141-142, 1923
65. KHALIL M. The life history of the human trematode parasite Heterophyes heterophyes in
Egypt. Lancet ii: 537, 1933
66. KHOLOKOWSKY. Cited in 27
67. KLIKS M, TANTACHAMRUN Y. Heterophyid (Trematoda) parasites of cats in North
Thailand, with notes on a human case found at necropsy. Southeast Asian Journal of Tropical
Medicine and Public Health 5: 547-555, 1974
68. KOBAYASHI H. (On a new genus of the trematodes, Loxotrema ovatum). Saikingaku Zasshi
no. 204, pp 777-786, 1912. In Japanese
69. KOBAYASHI H. A distomid larva infesting the Egyptian mullet. Journal of Helminthology
1: 97-98, 1923
70. KRULL WH, MAPES CR. Studies on the biology of Dicrocoelium dendriticum (Rudolphi
1819) Looss, 1899 (Trematoda: Dicrocoeliidae) including its relation to the intermediate host,
Miscellaneous Trematode Infections 315
96. MUTO M. (Ueber der ersten Zwischenwirt des Metagonimus yokogawai). Kyoto Igaku
Zasshi 14: 115-134, 1917. In Japanese, with German summary, pp 7-8
97. NÖLLER W. Befunde bei Schnecken von Thüringer Schwafweiden in einem
Lanzettegelgebeite. Tierärtzliche Rundschau 35: 485-489, 1929
98. ODEI MA. A note on dicrocoeliasis andFasciola gigantica infection in livestock in northern
Ghana with a record of spurious and of genuine Dicrocoelium hospes infections in man.
Annals of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology 61: 215-218, 1966
99. ODHNER T. Echinostoma ilocanum (Garr) ein neuer Menschen Parasit aus Ostasien.
Zoologischer Anzeiger 38: 65-68, 1911
100. ODHNER T. Die Verwaudschaftsbeziehungen der TrematodengattungParagonimus Brn.
Zoologiska Bidrag Frân, Uppsala 3: 231-246, 1914
101. ONJI Y, NISHIO K. (General observations on new intestinal flukes.) Igaku Chuo Zasshi 14:
875-883, 1915. In Japanese
102. OZAKI Y, ASADA J. (On a new species of Katsurada's Heterophyes family of parasites
found in a human case.) Tokyo Iji Shinshi No. 2445, 1925. In Japanese. Abstracted in Japan
Medical World 6: 42, 1926. Also: A new human trematode, Heterophyes katsuradai n. sp.
Journal of Parasitology 12: 216-218, 1926
103. OZERETSKOVSKAYA NN, FIRSOVA RA, KARNAUKHOV VK et al. (Effectiveness and
tolerance of the 3-day scheme of chloxyl treatment of opisthorchiasis.) Meditsinskaya
Parazitologiya i Parazitarn e Bolezni 42: 581-585, 1973. In Russian, with English summary.
104. POIRIER MJ. Trematodes nouvelles ou peu connus. Bulletin de la Société Philomathique,
series 10, 7: 27-29, 1886
105. POPOV KK, KALINTINA ZI. (The development of Dicrocoelium dendriticum on high
altitude grounds of central Caucasus.) Zoolohichn Zhurnal Ukrayin 41: 1793-1797,
1962. In Russian
106. PROMMAS C. Report of a case of Opisthorchis felineus in Siam. Annals of Tropical
Medicine and Parasitology 21: 9-10, 1927
107. RADOMYOS P, BUNNAG D, HARINASUTA T.Echinostoma ilocanum (Garrison, 1908)
Odhner 1911, infection in man in Thailand. Southeast Asian Journal of Tropical Medicine
and Public Health 13: 265-269, 1982
108. RAGHUNATHAN VS, SRINIVASAN T. Artyfechinostoma mehrai infestation. Journal of
the Indian Medical Association 38: 485-487, 1962
109. RAILLIET A. Les parasites des animaux domestiques au Japan. Le Naturaliste No. 79, 143,
1890
110. RAO MA. A preliminary report on the adult trematode obtained from Cercaria indicae
Sewell, 1922. Indian Journal of Veterinary Science and Animal Husbandry 3: 317-320, 1922
111. von RATZ I. Húsovökben élö trematodák. In, Fleischfressern lebende Trematoden.
Kulonleyamat az Allatani Kozlemenyek 7: 15-20, 1908
112. RIM HJ. Studies on the chemotherapy of trematode infections in Korea. Korean Medical
Journal 12: 425-457, 1975
113. RIVOLTA S. Sopra una specie di Distoma nel gatto e nel cane. Giornale di Anatomia,
Fisiologia e Patologia degli Animali 16: 20-28, 1884
114. RODRIGUEZ JD, GOMEZ LF, MONTALVAN CJ. El Opisthorchis guayaquilensis (una
nueva especie de Opisthorchis encontrada en el Ecuador). Revista Ecuatoriana de Higiene
y Medicina Tropical 6: 11-24, 1949
115. RUDOLPHI CA. Neue Beobachtungen über die Eingeweidewürmer. Archiv für Zoologie
und Zootomie 3: 1-32, 1803
116. RUDOLPHI CA. Entozoorum synopsis cui accedunt mantissima duplex et indices
locupletissima, Sumtibus Augusti Rücker, Berolini, pp 811, 1819
117. SADUN EH. Studies on Opisthorchis viverrini in Thailand. American Journal of Hygiene
62: 81115, 1955
118. SANDGROUND JH. Plagiorchis javensis n. sp. A new trematode parasitic in man. Revista
de Medicina Tropical y Parasitología, Bacteriología, Habana 6: 207-211, 1940
119. SANDGROUND JH, BONNE C. Echinostoma lindoense n. sp., a new trematode parasite
of man in the Celebes, with an accountof its life history and epidemiology. American Journal
of Tropical Medicine 20: 511-535, 1940
Miscellaneous Trematode Infections 317
120. SANDWITH FM. A case of Distoma heterophyes in a living patient. Lancet ii: 888, 1899
121. SCHEID G, MENDHEIM H, AMENDA R. Die Lanzettegelinfektion (Dicrocoeliasis) beim
Menschen nebst Mitteilung eines neuen Falles. Zeitschrit für Tropenmedizin und
Parasitologie 2: 142150, 1950
122. SCHRANK FP. Zoologische Beobachtungen. Der Naturforscher, Halle 18: 66-85, 1782
123. SCRIABINE KI (=SKRJABIN), PODYAPOLSKAYA WP, SCHOULZ GS. (Human and
animal metagonimiasis in the Far East of USSR.) "Tropical Medicine and Veterinary
Science" 8: 16-25, 1930. In Russian. Abstracted in Tropical Diseases Bulletin 29: 48, 1932
124. SEO BS, HONG ST, CHAI JY. Studies on intestinal trematodes in Korea. III. Natural
human infections of Pygidiopsis summa and Heterophyes heterophyes nocens. Seoul
Medical Journal 22: 228-235, 1981
125. SHEA M, MABERLY AL, WALTERS J, FREEMAN RS, FALLIS AM. Intraretinal larval
trematode. Transactions of the Academy of Ophthalmology and Otolaryngology 770P: 784,
791, 1973
126. SKRJABIN KI. (Echinostoma paraulum - nouveau parasite de l'homme.) Meditsinskaya
Parazitologiya i Parazitarn e Bolezni 7: 129-138, 1938. In Russian, with French summary
127. SKRJABIN KI, PODJAPOLSKAJA WP. Nanophyetus schikhobalowi n. sp. Ein neuer
Trematode aus dem Darm des Menschen. Zentralblatt für Bakteriologie, Parasitologie und
Infektionskrankheiten, Abteilung originale 119: 294-297, 1931
128. SONSINO P. Contributo alla entozoologia d'Egitto. Mémoires Présentés à l'Institut d'Égypte
3: 285-336, 1896
129. STILES CW, GOLDBERGER. Study of the anatomy ofWatsonius (n.g.) watsoni of man
and of nineteen allied species of mammalian trematode worms of the superfamily Paramph-
istomoidea. U.S.A., Treasury Department, Hygienic Laboratory Bulletin No. 60, 1910
130. STILES CW, HASSALL A. Comparison of the type of Distomum longissimum von
Linstow, 1883, with type of D. longissimum corvinum Stiles and Hassal, 1894. Veterinary
Magazine 3: 151155, 1896
131. STILES CW, HASSALL A. The lung fluke (Paragonimus westermani) in swine and its
relation to parasitic haemoptysis in man. Annual Report of the Bureau of Animal Industry,
U.S. Department of Agriculture, pp 560-611, 1900
132. STROM J. (On false distomiasis in the liver of man.) "Revue de Microbiologie et
Epidemiologie" 6: 433-437, 1927. In Russian, with English summary pp 476-477.
133. TANABE H. (Contributions to the knowledge of the developmental cycle of digenetic trem-
atodes. On a new species of trematode, Lepoderma muris n. sp.) Okayama Igakkai Zasshi
No. 385, pp 47-58, 1922. In Japanese
134. TANABE H. (Studies on the trematodes that use the fresh water fishas their intermediate
hosts. II. On the Japanese Echinochasmus perfoliatus, Ratz). Okayama Igakkwai Zasshi No.
387, 1922. In Japanese. Abstracted in Japan Medical World 2: 270, 1922
135. TRAVASSOS L. Sobre um interessante trematodeo parasito dos seios maxilares de gamba
(Didelphis marsupialis). Revista Brasileira Biologia 2: 213-218, 1942
136. TUBANGUI MA, AFRICA CM. The systematic position of some trematodes reported from
the Philippines. Philippine Journal of Science 67: 117-127, 1938
137. TUBANGUI MA, PASCO A. The life history of the human intestinal fluke,Euparyphium
ilocanum (Garrison, 1908). Philippine Journal of Science 51: 581-603, 1933
138. UPATHAM ES, VIYANANT V, KURATHONG S, BROCKELMAN, WY, MENARUCHI
A, SAOWAKONTHA S, INTARAKHAO C, VAJRASTHIRA S, WARREN KS. Morbidity
in relation to intensity of infection in opisthorchiasis viverrini: study of a community in Khon
Kaen, Thailand. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 31: 1156-1163, 1982
139. VOGEL H. Beobachtungen über Cercaria vitrina und deren Beziehung zum
Lanzettegelproblem. Archiv für Schiffs- und Tropen-Hygiene 33: 474-489, 1929
140. VOGEL H. Himasthla muehlensi n. sp., ein neuer menschlicher Trematode der familie
Echinostomatidae. Zentralblatt fürBakteriologie, Parasitenkunde und Infektionskrankheiten,
Abteilung originale 127: 385-391, 1933
141. VOGEL H. Der Entwicklungszyklus von Opisthorchis felineus (Riv.) nebst Bemerkungen
über Systematik und Epidemiologie. Zoologica 33: 1-103, 1934
142. VOGEL H, FALÇÃO J. Ueber den Lebenzyklus des Lanzettegels, Dicrocoelium
318 A History of Human Helminthology
SYNOPSIS
Hydatid cysts have been known since ancient times in both animals an d
humans, but the parasitic nature of these "bladders" was long unrecognized .
Mention is made in the Talmud of cystic lesions in the viscera of sacrificia l
animals. Hippocrates (460-37 9 BC) alluded to tumours filled with water in the
lungs of cattle, sheep and pigs. Similarly, in his aphorisms on human medicine,
he wrote: "When the liver is filled with water and bursts into the epiploon, in
this case the belly is filled with water and the patient dies"(VII,55) 57. In his
commentary on the works of Hippocrates, Galen (129-c.200 AD) interpreted
this aphorism as describing an hydatid cyst which had burst into the peritoneal
319
320 A History of Human Helminthology
cavity. Galen was also familiar with echinococci and cysticerci (probabl y
Cysticercus tenuicollis, the cystic form of the tapeworm, Taenia hydatigena)
in the abdomen of butchered animals, for he wrote: "The liver is very muc h
inclined to produce hydatids in the surrounding fascia. Sometimes, the liver of
slaughtered animals is full of them" 47. Aretaeus of Cappadocia was also aware
of hydatid cysts in humans. He recorde d a case in which attempted paracentesis
of the abdomen was hindered by blockage of the trocar and cannula wit h
vesicles; this circumstance indicated puncture of an echinococcal cys t
containing daughter vesicles:
Small and numerous bladders, full of fluid, are contained in the place where ascites
is found; but they also float in a copious fluid, of which this is the proof; for if you
perforate the abdomen so as to evacuate the fluid, after a small discharge of the fluid,
a bladder within will block up the passage.8
Hydatid cysts were noted from time to time in medical works of th e
succeeding centuries but their true nature was not generally understood. They
were usually ascribed to being either (1) excrescences or growths in the viscera
produced by collections of serum and mucus, sometimes mixed with pus ,
between laminae of cellular tissue, (2) enlarged and degenerated glands or, (3)
following the discovery of lymphatic glands in the seventeenth century, a s
distended and varicous lymphatics.
It was not until near the end of the seventeenth century that an awarenes s
began to dawn that some of these cysts were animal in nature. Observation s
were made on a variety of cysts in animals and humans. First, came th e
realization that some of these "bladders" wer e really worms. Once this had been
achieved, the various species of cysti c worms, including echinococci, cysticerci
and coenuri, were differentiated. The problem was compounded by th e
common practice of using the term "hydatid" in medicine to refer to any cystic
swelling, with the consequence that echinococcal cysts in humans needed to be
separated from similar non-parasitic tumours.
The clue that some of these cysts were of animal origin was that many o f
them had one of the cardinal att ributes of living animal creatures - spontaneous
movement. The Italian, Francisco Redi, appears to have been the first person
to both observe and record this phenomenon. Working in Florence in 1684, he
found cysts (probably Cysticercus pisiformis ) in the mesentery and also lying
free in the peritoneal cavity of a hare. Within each cyst, he observed a retracted
neck. Moreover, on watching the cysts closely, he noticed that the free cyst s
moved independently. This caused him to comment "quasi animalia foren t
proprio motu arta" 98 meaning that the cysts moved about on their own as if they
were animals.
Redi wondered whether these cysts could possibly be the eggs of the worms,
Fasciola hepatica, that he had found in the biliary system of the same rabbit,
and had noted previously in the livers of sheep. He thought this was unlikely,
however, as the liquid within the cysts did not coagulate when he boiled it, in
contrast to his earlier observations on the behaviour of eggs in mammalia n
Echinococcosis 321
ovaries (in which he had found that the enclosed liquid did congeal). Redi also
discovered a similar cyst in a marten and, realizing the similarity of thes e
various cysts from different animals, grouped them together under the nam e
"Glandette o vesichette verminose" meaning "wormy glands or cyst s
(vesicles)" 98.
In the following year (1685), Philip Hartmann, a professor in the University
of Königsberg, East Prussia (now Kaliningrad, USSR), emphasized the animal
nature of these cysts and clearly related them to intestinal worms. In th e
omentum of a dissected goat, he found cysts that he called "vesicular hydatids"
(probably Cysticercus tenuicollis ), the largest being greater in size than a
chicken's egg. He noticed a small, white, globular appendage at the extremity
of each cyst. When one of these was incised and pressed gently, it was turned
inside out. He wrote that at once "the rounded tail of a protruding intestina l
worm became evident" 52. Furthermore, he thought that he had noticed som e
movement, so he placed the specimen in a container of warm water an d
reported that:
When it was submerged and clinging to the bottom, I saw not only the proboscis but
also the vesicular body begin movement in a marvellous manner; it moved with a
singular form of undulation, exhibiting contraction and expansion with rising and
falling of its parts.52
The sac itself consisted of nothing beyond a very thin membrane which wa s
very smooth on both surfaces and contained a clear liquid lymph within it. On
the following day, another goat, which had just died and was still warm, was
brought to the dissecting room. In this animal, his students, Thormann an d
Litius, found more bladder worms and verified his observations, clearl y
demonstrating movements while the cysts were still within the membran e
formed by the enclosing omentum 52. In 1688, he was again to find a motile cyst,
this time in a pig (Cysticercus cellulosae ; see chapter 13), then in 1694 h e
found Cysticercus fasciolaris in a mouse54.
These early observations were unknown to the Oxford physician, Edwar d
Tyson, when he rediscovered such movements in Cysticercus tenuicollis . In
February 1687, he told a meeting of the Royal Society that "Hydatides i n
Animalls are a sort of Living creatures" 115. He recounted his observations o n
bladders about the size of a pigeon's egg that he had found in the peritonea l
cavity of a gazelle brought from Aleppos (now Halab, Syria). He is recorded
in the Journal Book of the Royal Society as describing the bladders in th e
following terms:
They were found involved in two coats like the corion and the Amnion, the innermost
having a neck of a more Opake and solid substance that the rest of the Bladder, which
neck, (at its first being taken out of the Animall) was observed to move as if alive; the
whole bladder being filled with a Limpid water he supposed might be as the stomach
to the worm.115
Tyson was said to have come to the conclusion that "(they") are worms sui
generis or at least the Embrios of them" 115. This remarkable insight of Tyson's
that the cysts loosely termed "hydatids" were worms or at least the embryos of
322 A History of Human Helminthology
them, predated by more than 150 years the experimental demonstration tha t
bladders are the "embryonic form" or intermediate stage in the development of
tapeworms.
Further details of these observatio ns are provided in Tyson's definitive report
published in 1891 (the delay being due to difficulty in publishing th e
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society )116. He observed that when-
ever a candle was brought near the cyst , the neck, a small, white protruberance,
moved. Tyson canvassed the possibility that these cysts represented an egg or
embryo of an insect, with the bladder being the amnion and the outer coa t
representing the chorion. He thought this unlikely since he had found man y
such structures that were all in a similar state when dissecting "rotten sheep",
whereas he would have expected that som e of them should have been in a more
mature state if they had been a developing insect. He named these cyst s
Lumbricus hydropicus in the following words:
These Hydatides therefore I cannot but think are a sort of Worms or Insects sui
generis, and because they contain so much water in them, and are usually to be met
with in rotten Sheep which are usually Hydropical; I call them Lumbrici Hydropici 116
Although less definite on this occasion by including "or Insects" in his opinion
on the nature of hydatids, the consensus of his remarks in the text of th e
manuscript, together with the title which he gave it, viz.: " Lumbricus
hydropicus or an Essay to prove that Hydatides often met with in morbi d
Animal bodies, are a Species of Worms, or Imperfect Animals" 116 leaves little
doubt that he considered that hydatid cysts were most likely worms. Never -
theless, he did not think that all such cysts were necessarily verminous i n
nature, for he also wrote: "in some I have not observed this Neck and Structure
of Parts, but only a transparent bl adder fill with a Lymph, and those I take to be
of another kind" 116. Tyson then went on to give his clinical experience wit h
hydropical bodies occurring in humans, some of which were undoubtedl y
echinococci.
Similarly, Marcus Malpighi in 1697, probably unaware of the discoveries of
his contempories, recognized the vitality of cysts he found in pigs ( Cysticercus
cellulosae), and described accurately the small head within each cyst 81.
Despite the major importance of all these observations and the considerable
impetus that they could have given to the elucidation of the nature of the cysts
and the life cycles of these organisms, more than 60 years were to pass before
another significant advance was made. This newly found comprehension of the
animal nature of these cysts was largely ignored or forgotten by naturalists and
the medical profession until 1760. In that year, Morgagni 84 recalled the
researches of Redi, Hartmann and Tyson, and pointed out that th e
bladderworms described by various authors were not all of the same kind.
Just how long it took for the recognition of the animal nature of hydatid and
other verminous cysts to penetrate the general consciousness of the medica l
profession is illustrated by the proceedings of the London Medical Societ y
published in The Lancet as late as the year 1833:
Echinococcosis 323
Mr. Stephens entered the room in some haste, to exhibit to the Society three or four
hydatids which he procured in the course of the afternoon, affording the members an
opportunity to personally witness the existence of life in these 'imperfect animalcules'
as Baillie terms them, though the hydatids shown on this occasion will almost justify
the employment of the less equivocal term 'animal'.
The President immediately drew attention to the exhibition. 'This is very interesting,'
he observed, 'as it settles a point greatly in dispute. Here is a head as clearly as a head
can be. Get a little warm water and see if it will revive the movements.'
Mr. Stephens. 'Most probably it will not, for, unfortunately, they are now expiring, but
they had this afternoon as free and perfect movement as a lively leech, and though
now almost spherical, have assumed an alternately contracted and bulging form.'
The President. 'Gentlemen will please to be very careful in examining them lest they
break and the fact of life shut from our observation.' 2
Thereupon, warm water was procured and motion was demonstrated when the
cysts were placed in it. These cysts, which were not E. granulosus, had been
obtained from the mesentery of a sheep and considerable discussion the n
ensued as to the relationship between these transparent cysts and the semi -
opaque, pulpy cysts which members had encountered previously in sheep and
in humans.
At almost the same time as Redi, Hartmann and Tyson made the observations
already described, a Swiss physician and pathologist, Johann Wepfer, dis -
covered in 1688 a cyst, later to be known as Cysticercus fasciolaris, in the liver
of a mouse121. It is possible that this parasite may have been seen some 20 years
earlier by Pecquet 90, but he did not at that time appreciate fully the significance
of the observation. Not only did Wepfer r ecognize the animal nature of the cyst,
but he also realized that it resembled the tapeworm then known as "lati s
lumbricus intestinorum". This interpretation was facilitated by the fact that the
caudal vesicle of this cysticercus is relatively small and the head of the worm
is not invaginated into it (hence it has has also been called a strobilocercus) .
Although Wepfer was the first person to establish a link between any species
of tapeworm and its intermediate cystic form, he was completely unaware of the
life cycle of the parasite and merely considered C. fasciolaris as an encysted
tapeworm. Again, news of this observation was not disseminated widely and
it fell into oblivion.
In 1766, Peter Pallas made two major contributions to our knowledge o f
cystic worms. Firstly, by classifying "hydatids" into non-adherent and adherent
forms, he managed to separate cystic worms from serous cysts, respectively .
Secondly, he renewed awareness of the morphological similarities betwee n
cystic worms and the heads of tapeworms 89. He propounded a theory that al l
324 A History of Human Helminthology
was connected to a very delicate membrane. When part of this membrane was
placed in water, the granules dropped off immediately and appeared to swim
around individually. In one of the vesicles, the size of a pigeon's egg, he found
many thousands of these granules which were so small that they were hardl y
visible to the naked eye. On examining them with a magnifying glass, he saw
plainly that they were true tapeworms:
he bodies were flat and dotted black; in front four suckers and on the rounded
foreshortened proboscis the exceedingly small double-hook crown; however, on each
one, posteriorly, was a small, sloping indentation like an anus. 49
Goeze concluded, therefore, that these cysts were a kind of tapeworm whic h
were distinct from the coenuri that were found in the brain of giddy sheep .
Thus, there was now no doubt that echinococcal cysts were alive, that they were
verminous, and that they were related to tapewo rms. Goeze named them Taenia
visceralis socialis granulosus, meaning the tapeworm which was found in the
viscera and contained a multitude of granules 49. Shortly afterwards (1786) ,
Batsch renamed the parasite Hydatigera granulosa 13.
From this point, unfortunately, progress in the understanding of the nature of
cystic worms ceased for more than half a century. Indeed, a genera l
retrogression occurred. In 1800, Zeder erected a distinct classificatory group
for the cystic worms, thus separating them as a zoological entity from th e
tapeworms 122. At first, he called echinococci, Polycephalus hominis 122 , then
in 1803, he renamed them Polycephalus echinococcus 123. The problem was
then compounded by Laennec (1804) who investigated hydatid cysts i n
humans. He could not find the familiar taeniid heads seen in hydatid cysts from
sheep and oxen, so concluded that they must either belong to another genus, or
else be of a completely different nature. Being less than convinced of thei r
animal nature, he gave them the name "acephalocysts" 71. Because of Laennec's
authority, this view was generally accepted until Livois showed in 1843 tha t
acephalocysts were but ordinary hydatids in which the scolices had not ye t
developed 78.
The views of Zeder were perpetuated by Rudolphi in his major text of 1808-
1810. He placed the tapeworms in the Order Cestoideorum while the cysti c
worms were located in the Order Cysticorum 101. Meanwhile, however,
Rudolphi in 1801 had erected the genus Echinococcus 99, which was later to be
placed in this latter order. The name was derived from a combination of th e
Greek words (ECHINOS) and (KOKKOS/ COCCUS)
meaning "spine" and "berry", respectively. The Index Catalogue of Medica l
and Veterinary Zoology has cited this parasite as Echinococcus granulosu s
([Goeze 1782]) Batsch 1786) Rudolphi 1805, with Rudolphi in his 180 5
paper100 describing Taenia hydatigena granulosa in swine. Later, Rudolph i
divided the genus Echinococcus into three species, E. hominis, E. simiae and
E. veterinorum, which he believed infected humans, sub-human primates, and
sheep or cattle, respectively 101.
In the succeeding decades, there was considerable confusion and disput e
326 A History of Human Helminthology
THE BACKGROUND
in different animal hosts "since the young brood was so seldom seen near the
cestodes"103. He then changed his mind about the development of these cyst s
and arrived:
at the most decided conviction that the cystic worms are strayed tapeworms which
have remained undeveloped and become degenerated, and of which the body grew
out in foreign soil into a vesicle, without developing sexual organs. 102
Von Siebold voiced this view repe atedly and vociferously. In another paper, he
expounded this theme once more:
I finally became convinced that all cystic Entozoa are nothing else than undeveloped
or larval tapeworms, which, arrested in their wanderings, have become aberrant and
dropsically degenerated.107
This idea was partly engendered by his false belief that, in bladder worms, the
scolex end of the larva was formed first th en this developed a posterior (caudal)
projection which in turn underwent secondary hydropic degeneration. Vo n
Siebold seems to have been unaware that Goeze had already shown in the case
of C. fasciolaris of the mouse, that first the cystic caudal end was formed, then
the scolex appeared. It was not until the Prague zoologist, von Stein ,
demonstrated in 1853 a similar development of a small bladderworm in th e
larva of the mealworm (Tenebrio molitor) that this sequence of events became
generally accepted. Moreover, von Siebold either conveniently forgot, or else,
incredibly, was ignorant of the writings of earlier workers, and claimed, even
as late as 1853, that he was the first person to draw attention to the similarity
between cystic worms and tapeworms 107. This so annoyed Küchenmeister that
he went to great lengths in his textbook to demonstrate that von Siebold was
decidedly in error in this claim 69. Furthermore, von Siebold's championship of
the theory of dropsical or cystic degeneration of tapeworms was to lead to an
acrimonious difference of opin ion with Küchenmeister. Thus, according to von
Siebold, certain eggs of the tape worm of the cat, T. crassicollis (now known as
T. taeniaeformis), frequently strayed into rodents and there degenerate d
dropsically (i.e. filled with fluid) into C. fasciolaris, but when their host was
devoured by a cat and they became transplanted into their "proper soil", they
cast off the degenerated segments, returned to the normal form of T. crassicollis
and arrived at sexual maturity. Von Siebold then went further and claimed that
with the exception of C. fasciolaris of the mouse, and possibly C. crispus, all
of the many other cystercerci have deg enerated so far into a dropsical state, that
by virtue of their gross distension, they were no longer fit to return to the state
of sexual maturity and consequently they perished without descendents 105,109.
In 1850, the Belgian zoologist, PJ van Beneden theorized that the head of a
tapeworm (which he named "scolex") is produced from the egg of a tapeworm
and conjectured that if the egg reached the gut of a suitable animal host, th e
jointed mature tapeworm (which he called "strobila") would develop and grow
without interruption. On the other hand, he hypothesized that if the egg found
its way into the intestine of an unsuitable host, the head would develop but that
the hind part would become inflated and the scolex would sink into it, thu s
Echinococcosis 329
At the same time, von Siebold embarked upon a personal attack on Küchen-
meister and tried to claim credit for himself for the discovery of the phenom-
enon in two ways. Firstly, he harked back repeatedly to an earlier comment in
his article "Parasiten" dated 1844 102 (although it actually appeared in 1845) on
the similarity between cystic worms and tapeworms; this, as we have already
seen, was not an original observation. Secondly, he tried to impai r
Küchenmeister's credibility by asserting that if he had not come to the latter's
aid in determining the species of the adult tapeworms, the whole theory of the
process of metamorphosis would have been thrown into such a state of con -
fusion that it could hardly have been corrected 107. To this, Küchenmeister
responded in kind saying: "no-one has so grievously offended in the study o f
cestodes as the professor of zoology" 70.
As we have already seen, Küchenmeister attacked von Siebold's claims t o
priority in drawing attention to the relationship between cystic and tapeworms
and castigated his theory of dropsical degeneration 69. This in turn, drew the
following riposte from von Siebold: "(Küch enmeister) has been led away by his
zeal, to depart from that calmness of tone which becomes scientific contro -
versy."109. When Leuckart came later to review this contre-temps, he sided with
von Siebold: "Küchenmeister in his book underrates von Siebold's share in the
solution of the problem in a way which is, to every unprejudiced critic, utterly
unfair"76. Küchenmeister may have used strong words, but there is no doubt that
his experiments opened the door to the t ruth and his interpretation of the results
thus obtained were correct.
It must also be remarked in passing that not on ly was von Siebold wrong with
his theory that cystic worms were strayed, degenerated, dropsical worms, but
he also came eventually to the view that with the exception of echinococci, all
the cystic worms were derived from one species of tapeworm which he called
T. serrata. Thus, von Siebold claimed that w hen he fed C. pisiformis of rabbits,
C. tenuicollis of cattle, C. cellulosae of pigs and C. cerebralis of sheep to dogs,
he always found T. serrata in the gut. He concluded that the nature of the cyst
is determined by the species of host in which the T. serrata larvae find
themselves. These false observations reinforced his incorrect belief that cystic
worms were a pathological st ate rather than being a physiological necessity for
continuation of the life cycle 109. The only feasible explanation for this amazing
error on von Siebold's part is that his dogs were coincidentally infected with T.
serrata and that the dog was not a favourable host for the development of some
cysticerci such as C. cellulosae.
In passing, it should be noted that the idea that all of these cysts were derived
from T. serrata was one of the points which Pouchet and Verrier used a fe w
years later (1862) to attack the whole concept of cystic migrations o f
tapeworms. They also criticized the experiments of Küchenmeister, van Ben-
eden, von Siebold and others on other grounds, including their belief that the
experiments were "too successful". In th eir own experiments, Pouchet and Ver-
rier recovered more tapeworms than the numb er of scolices that they had given,
Echinococcosis 331
and claimed to obtain two distinct species of tapeworms after feeding a single
coenurus to a dog. This induced van Bene den to return to the fray to refute their
views, but Pouchet and Verrier remained recalcitrant saying:
we cannot believe that a microscopic embryo of a taenia enclosed in the intestines of
a sheep can make for itself a passage up into the brain of the ruminant, and then
undergo transformation into a vesicle, which engenders numerous scolices. 93
Nevertheless, this was the last gasp of the sceptics and the views of Küchen-
meister and others became generally accepted.
To prove beyond all doubt that cystic worms were necessary steps in th e
development of taenia, it was also requisite to show their development fro m
tapeworm eggs. Such an experiment was first undertaken by Küchenmeiste r
with the parasite he knew as Coenurus cerebralis (= T. multiceps). First he
procured coenuri from a sheep then administered them to a dog in order t o
obtain mature proglottids of the tapeworm. These were in turn given to a
healthy sheep on 25 July 1853. Sixteen days later, the sheep became affected
with vertigo (dizziness and loss of balance - coenurosis causes "staggers" i n
sheep). When the animal was killed three days later, 15 small coenuri wer e
Echinococcosis 333
found on the surface and in the substance of the brain. The experiment was then
repeated in collaboration with Prof. Haubner of the Veterinary School i n
Dresden, and at the expense of the government of Saxony. Similar results were
obtained with Coenurus cerebralis, Cysticercus pisiformis , Cysticercus
tenuicollis and Cysticercus cellulosae by these investigators 68. At around the
same time, Leuckart was similarly able to produce Cysticercus fasciolaris in
the livers of mice after feeding these animals with eggs from T. crassicollis
from a cat.
Although a number of investigators in the middle 1850's were able to pro-
duce a variety of cysticerci and coenuri by feeding eggs to appropriate animals,
initial attempts to replicate these results with echinococci were unsatisfactory.
Haubner came close to success when he fed a pig with eggs of T. echinococcus
and found immense numbers of small vesicles resembling cystic worms in the
various organs on dissecting the animal a f ew months later. Unfortunately, none
of them were sufficiently developed for him to be sure that they wer e
echinococcal cysts 55. Success finally crowned the efforts of Leuckart in 1867 75.
He infected four suckling pigs with ova of T. echinococcus and was able to
make careful naked eye examinations of the resulting cysts at intervals afte r
infection. In one pig four weeks after feeding, he noted that the liver wa s
studded with small, tubercular-like nodules 0.35 mm in diameter. Thes e
nodules had a thick, homogenous capsule enclosing semisolid, granula r
contents, and were most frequent in the interlobular spaces and beneath th e
peritoneal coat of the liver. By eight weeks after infection, the parasites were
1 mm in diameter, showed slight lamination of the outer layer, possessed a
well-marked inner germinal layer and contained fluid which escaped from it on
puncture. After 19 weeks, the echinococcal cysts were 10-12 mm in diameter.
Subsequently, Krabbe and Finsen successfully infected sheep wit h
echinocococcal eggs, then Dévé and Dew r outinely infected many experimental
animals.
Two major series of investigations which did much to clarify the details of the
migration of larvae and the deve lopment of cysts were undertaken in Paris then
Rouen in France by Felix Dévé 34,35, and in Melbourne, Australia by Harol d
Dew38 . It was observed that eggs hatched in the stomach then the liberate d
larvae bored through the walls of that viscus or the small intestine and entered
the radicles of the portal vein and were carried to the liver. Indeed, De w
observed larvae in the portal vein within eight hours of feeding ova to pigs 37.
Some larvae penetrated the hepatic filter and passed to the lungs. A few of the
larvae managed to escape through this second net and enter the systemi c
circulation and lodged finally in the peripheral tissues. This sequence of events
334 A History of Human Helminthology
fitted with the observed distribution of cysts in the human body. As early a s
1860, Davaine25 analysed reported cases and noted that in 373 cases, nearl y
50% of cysts were found in the liver, 10% in the lungs, and the rest wer e
scattered throughout the rest of the body. Subsequent surveys such as those of
Thomas114, Dévé34 and the "Australasian Hydatid Register "23 largely confirmed
this distribution, except that a larger proportion of cysts were found in the liver,
at the expense of non-pulmonary hydatids. T hese series also showed that a third
or more of patients had multiple cysts.
Goeze had observed a granular coat lining the interior of echinococcal cysts,
but the germinal membrane was first properly described by Goodsir 51. Many
observations were made on the mode of development of scolices and broo d
capsules from this membrane by Huxley (1852), Naunyn (1862), Rasmmussen
(1869) and Leuckart (1885), but considerable differences of opinion existe d
until the position was clarified by Dew who carried out a series of invest -
igations in the 1920's. He studied the microsc opical appearances of echinococci
in the livers of suckling pigs from as early as 12 hours after infection to as late
as 150 days37. Even at the earliest time period, an accumulation of mononuclear
cells was observed around the lar vae, together with lysis of adjacent liver cells;
this was followed by a marked infiltration of eosinophils into the follicle .
Vesiculation commenced in the second week and the follicle wall becam e
marked more clearly into layers by four weeks; the elastic laminated cuticular
membrane was developed and the nuclear material which comprised th e
germinal layers of the cyst was scattered irregularly on its inner surface. These
features were more apparent a t three months and the young cyst was beginning
to be surrounded by a fibrous adventitia derived from the host. Scolices an d
brood capsules did not appear until at least six months after infection. Th e
brood capsules began as small masses on the germinal layer which vacuolated
and formed scolices on their inner surfaces 36. Observations over many years in
both humans and experimental animals showed that the rate of growth of these
cysts was extremely variable, even within the same organ in the same subject.
They undoubtedly grew faster in soft tissues but usually took between two and
many years to grow large enough to produce symptoms.
Occasionally, daughter cysts were found within hydatid cysts, i.e. they were
replicas of the original cyst, bein g composed of an outer laminated layer and an
inner nuclear layer usually containing brood capsules and scolices. It wa s
Naunyn in 1862 who first showed that daughter cysts could arise directly from
the germinal membrane or from brood capsules 86. He also claimed that th e
daughter cysts could develop from sco lices, although this was denied by others.
That he was correct, was proven subsequently by Dévé. Dévé and Dew both
brought forward evidence that suggested that daughter cyst formation may be
stimulated by environmental influences including trauma, entry of chemical s
such as bile or urine into a cyst, and bacterial infection of cysts.
In the late eighteenth century, the great English surgeon and anatomist, John
Echinococcosis 335
Hunter, first formulated the idea that pelvic hydatid cysts were often secondary
to rupture of a visceral cyst and were not the result of multiple infections 59. This
view was criticized by Charcot and Davaine on theoretical grounds, but wa s
revived by Bright in 1861 20 and by Petain and Volkmann (1877), all of whom
warned surgeons about the risk of sowing hydatid elements by puncture of a
fertile cyst. In 1889, Lebedev an d Andreev showed that if young daughter cysts
were released into the peritoneal cavity, they continued to develop int o
fully-fledged hydatid cysts 74. In 1898, Alexinsky in Russia injected hydati d
"sand" (brood capsules and scolices) into the peritoneal cavity of seven rabbits
and eventually recovered echinococcal cysts from four of the animals 1. Dévé
then performed a series of experiments which put the matter beyond all doubt.
On 21 September 1900, he injected brood capsules and scolices from a sheep
hepatic cyst intraperitoneally into two rabbit s, remarking that echinococci never
form daughter cysts in sheep. On dissection 16 weeks later, nine or ten small
secondary echinococcal cysts were found in the peritoneal cavity of one rabbit
and in the injection track in the subcutaneous tissues and in the omentum of the
other rabbit26. Moreover, in the same series of experiments, Dévé demonstrated
that, contrary to previous opinion, hydatid cysts do not die when they ar e
punctured and the fluid drained 27. This still begged the question as to whether
it was brood capsules, scolices, or both that produced secondary cysts. In a later
study, Dévé produced hydatid cysts in many organs by intravenous o r
intra-arterial injection of living scolices alone 29,30. This experience led Dévé to
believe that daughter cysts probably arise most commonly from scolices. Dew
repeated Dévé's experiments and concluded that secondary cysts may b e
formed in all three ways, that is, from daugher cysts, brood capsules an d
individual scolices 38.
One of the most striking features of echinococcosis is the fact that infectio n
with large cysts may be completely asymptomatic. This has been known from
time immemorial. Hydatid cysts (althoug h their true nature was unknown) were
found frequently in slaughtered animals which had seemed perfectly health y
while alive. Similarly, echinococcal cysts were encountered from time to time
at post-mortem examination of humans who had not complained during life of
symptoms that could be ascribed to the parasite. At the same time, it wa s
appreciated gradually that most o f the clinical manifestations of echinococcosis
were due to pressure effects on adjacent tissues, and were thus dependent upon
the size, number and location of such cysts. The Icelandic physician, Joh n
Hjaltelin, summed this up when he wrote in 1869:
(The) symptoms are variable, according to the seat and the size of the parasite, and
consist mainly in the functio laesa of the affected organ. This rule holds good,
336 A History of Human Helminthology
whether the hydatid exists in the brain, in the spine, in the organs of the chest, or in
one of the abdominal organs.58
Since these cysts grew slowly, it was noted that the natural history of echino-
coccosis tended to have a slowly progressive, chronic nature.
Perhaps the largest cyst or accumulation of cysts ever recorded was in th e
case of a farmer from near Otago, New Zealand. When he was a child of si x
years, he fell on a large stone and may well have caused a hydatid cyst to burst
into the peritoneal cavity, for he became acutely ill for several weeks, the n
gradually recovered. After two to three years, however, his abdomen gradually
became more prominent and continued to increase in size slowly over the next
30 years. By the age of 39 years, his abdomen measured 57" (145 cm) in girth,
and he weighed 17 stones (108 kg). His health deteriorated to the point where
surgical advice was sought. Peritoneal flu id was aspirated and shreds of hydatid
cyst were found. At operation in 1927, daughter cysts varying in size fro m
cherries to coconuts were evacuated filling bucket after bucket and at least 11
gallons (50 litres) were removed. Ten weeks later, the patient, now weighing
many stones less, returned to work as a shepherd. After three or four years, two
cysts were observed growing in the abdomen, but the patient refused operation
for another 13 years until 1943 when the two cysts, about the size of feta l
heads, were excised 11.
Perhaps the longest duration of infection on record is the case of an English
boy aged 11 years who had an abdominal hydatid cyst removed in St. Barthol-
omew's Hospital, London in 1882. Two years later, he migrated to the United
States of America. He was asymptomatic until 1926 when he developed recur-
rent bouts of abdominal and lumbar back pain. In 1939, at the age of 67, and
56 years after the initial operation, a mass was felt in the right upper quadrant
of his abdomen. At operation, two masses of cysts were found in the liver and
small, isolated lesions were scattered around the peritoneal cavity 72.
The majority of patients have complications arising from echinococcal cysts
of the liver44, while pulmonary echinococcosis has proved to be the secon d
most frequent problem 12. Many patients have been recorded, however, wh o
have suffered with echinococci in sites ranging from the heart (sudden death)
to the bones (fracture).
In addition to pressure effects, certain toxic reactions to echinococci began
to be recognized. Among the more doubtful ones was the claim of Dévé tha t
echinococcosis caused infantilism and that this condition could be improve d
when the cysts were removed. Much more substantial was the appreciatio n
around the turn of this century (at the same time that an understanding o f
allergic reactions began to dawn) that anaphylactic reactions, often fatal, may
occur in echinococcosis, particularly when echinococci ruptured either spont-
aneously or as a result of trauma such as diagnostic aspiration. Finally, major
suppurative complications as a result of secondary bacterial infection wer e
recognized.
Echinococcosis 337
The diagnosis of echinococcosis has always been difficult, since not only does
the parasite itself remain hidden in the tissues, but there are no embryoni c
forms which issue forth into either the bloodstream or the excretions and which
might be searched for. Rarely, a cyst has ruptured into the lungs or into th e
biliary or intestinal tracts and the tell-tale grape-like daughter cysts have been
coughed up or passed in the faeces. Similarly, a mass thought to be an abscess
has been lanced and daughter cysts have extruded through the wound. Suc h
observations have not always been reliable, however, for other lesions hav e
sometimes been mistaken for echinoc occi, such as parts of a hydatidiform mole
discharged from the uterus per vagina.
Following the discovery by Goeze in the late eighteenth century of the path-
ognomonic scolices and hooklets, it became possible to be certain of the diag-
nosis. Nevertheless, this discovery was of only of limited value, particularl y
when diagnostic aspiration of suspected echinococcal cysts fell out of favou r
because of the risk of causing secondary echinococcosis or precipitating a n
anaphylactic reaction. Some writers in the nineteenth century placed grea t
reliance upon the sign of "hyda tid thrill"; this fremitus or vibration is produced
by loosely-packed daughter cys ts shifting within the mother cyst. Nevertheless,
it is so rare as to be of little practical value 10.
For all of these reasons, attention turned during the early years of th e
twentieth century to developing immunological tests to assist in the diagnosis
of echinococcal infection. The first serological test was reported in 1906 b y
Ghedini who described a complement fixation antibody assay using hydati d
fluid from human cysts 48. This was followed in the next year by the demon -
stration by Fleig and Lisbonne of precipitating antibodies in the sera of persons
with hydatid disease46. Weinberg then compared the two procedures, favoured
the former, and did much to standardize the assay 120. The first skin test for
echinococcosis was described in 1911 by Casoni who used carbolized, filtered
antigens from the fluid in a sheep hydatid cyst; he noted the delaye d
inflammatory reaction which developed some hours after immunization 21. Ten
years later, Magath described an immediate reaction occurring within a fe w
minutes of application of antigen 80 then this was confirmed as a more reliable
diagnostic indicator by Dew and his colleagues 40. Much effort was made over
the next few decades to improve these diagnostic tests, but they have remained
only ancillary aids, for they are negative in up to a quarter of patients wit h
proven infection, and are falsely positive in another small proportion o f
patients. Nevertheless, they have proved useful adjuncts to diagnosis in th e
right clinical setting.
An alternative approach has to been to try to define the hydatid cyst b y
radiological techniques, although until recently, these methods have had little
chance of allowing the clinician to be completely confident about the nature of
338 A History of Human Helminthology
Despite many attempts to find anthelmintic drugs active against hydatid cysts,
surgery has remained the mainstay of the therapy of echinococcosis. The first
problem which all surgeons have had to face was to decide whether attempts
at surgical intervention were more likely to do harm or good. This wa s
particularly relevant prior to the advent of modern anaesthesia and surgica l
techniques. John Hunter is quoted as saying, concerning hydatids of the liver,
during one of his lectures on the principles of surgery: "When known to be a
bag containing fluid it may be opened, but I would not be in a hurry to d o
this"60. On the other hand, over a century later, another surgeon declared that
although it is well-known that cysts occasionally die and atrophy resulting in
"spontanteous cure", this happy outcome ought never be relied upon in place
of surgery113.
Throughout most of recorded history, surgery has consisted simply of punct-
ure and drainage of a cyst. The experience of Aretaeus at the beginning of the
Christian era8 has already been alluded to, and Bonetus in 1697 recorded the
case of a patient with a liver cyst which discharged more than 200 vesicle s
(daughter cysts) when it was opened 18. Another famous case from the sam e
century is that of the Earl of Shaftesbury who was treated by his persona l
physician, John Locke (cited in 88). Shaftesbury had a palpable abdomina l
tumour for 12 years before it caused him any inconvenience. In May 1668, he
experienced severe abdominal p ain and vomiting then suddenly a soft mass the
size of an ostrich's egg appeared in his abdominal wall. On 12 June it wa s
opened by cautery and a large quantity of purulent matter containing "man y
bags and skins" was discharge d. Some of the most eminent surgeons and phys-
icians in London were consulted and it was decided to keep the abscess open
for drainage by insertion of a silver tube. This operation became commo n
knowledge and Dryden penned the folllowing lines:
The working ferment of his active mind
Echinococcosis 339
The demonstration by von Siebold that dogs were the definitive host o f
E. granulosus and the experimental generation by Leuckart of echinoccoca l
cysts after feeding eggs to sheep clarified in a dramatic fashion ou r
understanding of the mode of transmission of hydatid infection. The next steps
were to define the incidence of infection in humans, the prevalence of infection
in various intermediate hosts, and the frequency of infection in dogs, and t o
analyse the factors influencing the transmission of the parasite.
It had long been appreciated that hy datid infection was more common among
people with particular occupations such as farmers and butchers and i n
members of their families. The reasons for this were now plain. When suc h
people killed domestic animals such as sheep and cattle, it was their common
practice to feed the offal (which often contained cysts) to farm and house dogs.
These became infected and the resultant adult worms produced multitudes of
eggs which were passed in the faeces. Although infection may be acquired by
children eating dirt or by the consumption of uncooked, contaminated fruit and
vegetables or by drinking polluted water, it was realized that the most potent
source of infection was the caressing of dogs, allowing them to lick the hands
and face, or to feed from common plates and dishes.
Just as the frequencies of hydatid infections in relation to occupation wer e
analysed, so the distribution of echinococcosis in different countries wa s
investigated. It became apparent by the middle of the ninteenth century tha t
echinococcosis in Iceland had reached e pidemic proportions. The Physician-in-
chief of the country, Dr Thorensen, considered that about one in seven of the
inhabitants were so infected, and one o f his successors, John Hjaltelin, believed
from his own experience of numerous autopsies, that echinococcal cysts could
Echinococcosis 341
be found in one or another of the internal organs of nearly every fifth adul t
body58. This remarkable prevalence was attributed to the intimate relationship
between the Icelanders and their sh eep, cattle and dogs. It was estimated at that
time that in Iceland there were 20 dogs per 100 inhabitants 64. For the same
reasons, high frequencies were noted in a number of other sheep-raisin g
countries including Australia, New Zealand, Argentina, Uruguay and nations
of North Africa and the Midd le East. Thus, a writer to the Melbourne Argus in
Australia observed on 10 May 1874 that:
Hydatid disease is endemic in this colony; and though not so constantly met with as
in Iceland, we may probably claim the doubtful honour of holding the second place
in the list of countries so affected....To meet with hydatids as a cause of deranged
health is now a matter of daily expectation with every medical practitioner.
The common occurrence of hydatid infection in humans was found to be co-
existent with a very high frequency of infection in certain stock animals. Thus,
in Iceland in 1863, Krabbe found echinococcal cysts in 12.5% of sheep 64.
Similarly, in a survey in Victoria, Australia in 1929, 16.5% of 11,257 sheep,
23.9% of 4922 cattle and 0.5% of 2497 pigs were found to be infected 45.
Despite the higher frequency of infection in cattle, sheep were of mor e
importance in the maintenance of the life cycle of the parasite since the cysts in
cattle were commonly simple, unilocular and sterile. Similarly, Dévé in 1923
found that in Tunisia, nearly all of the cattle, 20-60% of sheep and 30% o f
camels examined were infected, while infec tions were insignificant in goats and
pigs31.
Occurring pari passu with a high prevalence of infection in cattle and sheep,
was a high frequency of infection in dogs. For example, in Iceland in 1863 ,
28% of dogs were infected 64, while in New Zealand in 1937, about one third of
the estimated 120,000 rural dogs harboured adult E. granulosus 9. It was thus
clear that echinococcosis was a zoonosis with the cycle being maintaine d
between dogs and farm animals, particularly sheep, with human infectio n
occurring incidentally and playing no part in the continued transmission o f
infection.
While the sheep-dog cycle thus described is the most important epidemio -
logical scenario, a number of other life cycles which may be of local importance
have been discovered. These include transmission between kangaroos an d
dingoes in Australia (with the potential for infecting aborigines) and between
deer and wolves in Canada. On the basis of these different intermediate hos t
specificities and/or on morphological characteristics, E. granulosus has been
separated into a number of subspecies including E. granulosus granulosus , E.
g. borealis, E. g. canadensis and E. g. equinus. Although these subdivisions
may be somewhat controversial, all of these data have provided an ample base
on which to evolve effective methods of prevention and control.
342 A History of Human Helminthology
however, was a fortuitous change in farming practice; male lambs were killed
at a younger age (4-5 months), thus giving cysts insufficient time to reac h
maturity43. The consequences of all these measures were that by 1927, th e
number of dogs had fallen to one for every 15 people from the one per fou r
persons obtaining in 1890, and only 1 in 1500 of the human population ha d
hydatid infection 83.
Campaigns of increasing sophistication were mounted in a number of more
developed countries such as Australia and New Zealand. Educational pro -
grammes alone often had no great effect. Since the infection had no noticeably
detrimental effects on wool and mutton, farmers had no particular incentive to
keep their sheep clean of parasites. They objected especially to the extra labour
involved in boiling offal prior to feeding their dogs. One despairing Ne w
Zealander lamented that "It has been re ported to us that our leaflets are not only
left unread, but are sometimes condemned to ignoble use" 9.
The control of echinococcosis suffered from two major disadvantages com-
pared with campaigns against that other common wormy zoonosis, trichinosis.
In the latter case, epidemics of fatal infection so alarmed the populace that the
legislature was prodded into action. This was reinforced by the sever e
economic consequences of trichinous infe ction. In contrast, echinococcosis was
an infection of low-grade endemicity and did little to penetrate the nationa l
consciousness. Perhaps more importantly, infection of the viscera had n o
deleterious effects on the flesh for food purposes and so did not interfere with
the export of frozen meat which was a staple article of the sheep and cattl e
trade of many countries 3.
Ultimately, however, legislation was enacted in some countries embodying
the control of dogs, the compulsory intermittent administration of anthelmintics
(first arecoline, the active constituent of areca nut, and later of bunamidin e
hydrochloride), prohibition of feeding raw offa l to dogs, educational campaigns,
and the monitoring of the results of these efforts. In many places, thes e
programmes have been eminently successful, but in other countries lackin g
sufficient finanacial and technical resources, echinococcosis continues it s
ravages unchecked. Perhaps immunization of animals may eventually become
a practical proposition, but no-one has yet improved on the unsuccessfu l
attempts of Dévé in 1927 to immunize rabbits challenged with echinococci 32.
E. MULTILOCULARIS
During the first half of the nineteenth century, a number of European pathol-
ogists, including Ruysch, Buhr and Luschka, described a peculiar and rar e
tumour of the liver which they called "alveolar colloid" or "colloid carcinoma".
In 1855, Rudolf Virchow recognized the characteristic hooklets of Echino-
344 A History of Human Helminthology
coccus in such a tumour and showed that the lesion was not a malignant pro-
liferation but was helminthic in nature. Believing that it was a variation of the
larval form of the common Taenia echinococcus (as E. granulosus was then
known), Virchow termed the lesion "ulcerative multilocular hydatid" 117. He
suggested that growth took place exogenously (instead of endogenously within
a cyst wall) in the lymphatic spaces, the size and shape of which determined the
nature of the growth.
Initially, helminthologists followed Virchow's line that there was only on e
adult echinococcal parasite. It was then realized, however, that this form o f
hydatid infection was restricted in dis tribution to Germany, Switzerland, Russia
and adjacent regions. In 1875, Morin 85 first propounded the view that ther e
were two distinct species, one causing the usual hydatid infection, and the other
producing the lesion described by Virchow. Considerable controversy was to
follow. Klemm in 1883 fed the Virchow- type hydatid to dogs and could discern
no significant differences between the resultant adult worms and th e
well-known T. echinococcus. Thus, he upheld Virchow's statement as to th e
unity of the two forms 63. On the other hand, Mangold in 1892 infected a suck-
ling pig with eggs of an adult echinococcal tapeworm derived previously from
a human alveolar hydatid. Autopsy four months later revealed two small alve-
olar hydatid cysts in the lungs of the pig and Mangold believed that thes e
results supported the dualist conception 82. Posselt in Austria repeated thi s
experiment in 1904 and obtained tapeworms from a dog fed with an alveolar
echinococcal cyst. These worms had minor variations in the size and number
of hooklets and the ova were arranged in a different manner. Posselt regarded
these differences as sufficient to justify the creation of a distinct species which
he named T. alveolaris 91. He also believed (erroneously) that this type o f
hydatid disease was frequent in oxen and its limited geographical distribution
was attributable to close association of humans with these animals. Further -
more, Posselt did not think that the dog was the normal definitive host, although
he did not know the exact means by which man was infected. Other authorities
took up these points to evolve the "double or dualist theory" that postulated the
existence of two species whose larvae had different pathological effects an d
whose adults may be differentiated morphologically. The major point in favour
of this theory was the peculiar geographical distribution of the parasite 92.
Nevertheless, some parasitologists, in particular Dévé, still held to th e
original single form or "unicyst theory" which held that there was one species
of parasite, E. granulosus, which under certain conditions gave rise to th e
alveolar form of hydatid cyst. The main argument in favour of this hypothesis
was that the alveolar hydatids were believed to be confined to humans. Th e
corollary to this was that since dogs do not have access to human livers, th e
variety should have become extinct if they were a separate species. In 1931 ,
Dew reported the first apparent case of alveolar hydatid infection in Australia;
the parasite showed characteristics of both an alveolar hydatid and the multi-
locular form of E. granulosus. He used this observation to support the notion
Echinococcosis 345
that the two lesions were morphological variants of the larval form of the same
adult parasite39. Dévé then obtained, from the Pathological Museum in Vienna,
portions of a tumour which Posselt in 1906 had described as an ordinar y
hydatid and an alveolar hydatid lying side by side in the heart of a human ,
separate and distinct and with no connection or intermediate morphologica l
stages. On re-examination, Dévé fo und all intermediate stages between the two
supposedly distinct forms and decided that the loculative change in the hydatid
must be ascribed to some special environ mental effect 33. A commentator in The
Lancet in 1933 felt that at last the matter had been probably settled and stated
that:
The reasonable conclusion from these facts is that there is one species o f
hydatid which occasionally grows in an abnormal fashion as the result o f
abnormal, presumably extrinsic stimuli; and that the health officer is no t
faced with the attempt to devise special preventive measures in the effort to
combat infection from unknown strobiles inhabiting an unidentified hos t
species.5
But the dualist theory was not yet laid to rest. In 1951, Rausch and Schiller
discovered alveolar hydatid in fections in the tundra vole ( Microtus oeconomus
inuitus) on St. Lawrence Island, Alaska 97. Alveolar echinococcosis was als o
found to be prevalent in the Eskimo population on the island and Rausc h
speculated that this form was probably identical with that causing alveola r
hydatid infections in Europe and in the USSR. Natural infections were the n
found in other mammals, including ground squirrels and shrews. In 1955 ,
Vogel showed by feeding experiments that the Alaskan and European hydatids
were identical118. Moreover, he found that foxes (Vulpes vulpes) in the Serbian
Alps were infected naturally with adult Echinococcus. He took the proglottids
of these worms and fed them to voles and rats, and alveolar echinococcosi s
resulted. Conversely, when a cyst from an infected field vole was fed to a dog,
adult worms were obtained which differed morphologically from E. granulosus
in a number of respects. Ironically, when Vogel re-examined some of Posselt's
material, held in the Innsbruck Pathological Institute, he found simila r
tapeworms in the small intestine of a dog that Posselt had fed with huma n
alveolar material in 1901. Vogel also determined that, unlike E. granulosus,
this parasite also developed in cats and foxes as well as in dogs. Further, h e
could find no major morpholo gical differences between Alaskan and European
collections, and concluded that they were geographical races of the one species.
Finally, Vogel pointed out 119 that on the basis of priority, the valid name for this
species was not E. alveolaris but E. multilocularis Leuckart 1863. This
designation stands today, although it is rather unfortunate as it sometimes lead
to confusion with the multilocular form of echinococcosis commonly seen i n
cattle and which has also been given the name "multilocularis" but is in fact a
form of E. granulosus.
Thus, it became generally agreed that there were two species of Echino-
346 A History of Human Helminthology
E. VOGELI
domestic dogs could also be infected and are probably the usual source o f
infection for humans96. In the paca (a rodent), the larva forms a polycysti c
hydatid with endogenous proliferation, but in humans, the parasite is invasive
and spreads by exogenous budding similar to E. multilocularis. Experience of
this infection is limited. Like ot her echinococcal infections, definitive diagnosis
is made by recovery of all or part of the parasite. Treatment is by surgica l
resection where possible, but longterm mebendazole therapy is being evaluated
currently. The prognosis is frequently poor, and prevention is difficult.
REFERENCES
1. ALEXINSKY JP. Ueber ein neues Operationsverfahren zur Entfernung von Echinococcus in
der Leber und anderen parenchymatösen Bauchorganen. Archiv für klinische Chirurgie 56:
819-826, 1898
2. ANONYMOUS. London Medical Society: Living hydatids. Lancet i: 719-720, 1833
3. ANONYMOUS. Hydatid disease and public health. British Medical Journal ii: 970, 1929
4. ANONYMOUS. Some problems of hydatid disease. British Medical Journal i: 146, 1931
5. ANONYMOUS. The alveolar hydatid. Lancet ii: 304, 1933
6. ANONYMOUS. Medical treatment for hydatiddisease? British Medical Journal ii: 563, 1979
7. ARCE J. Hydatid disease (hydatidosis). Pathology and treatment. Archives of Surgery 42:
1-17, 1941
8. ARETAEUS CAPPADOX. De causis et notis etc. In, The extant works of Aretaeus the
Cappadocian, translated by F. Adams, The Sydenham Society, London, pp 510, 1856
9. BARNETT L. Hydatid disease. Prevalence and prevention. New Zealand Medical Journal 36:
105-117, 1937
10. BARNETT L. Hydatid disease: errors in teaching and practice. British Medical Journal ii:
593-599, 1939
11. BARNETT L. Colossal hydatids associated with choloperitoneum. Medical Journal of
Australia ii: 511-514, 1944
12. BARRETT NR, THOMAS D. Pulmonary hydatid disease. British Journal of Tuberculosis
38: 39-95, 1944
13. BATSCH AJ. Naturgeschichte der Bandwurmgattung überhaupt und ihrer Arten insbesondere
nach den neueren Beobachtungen in einem systematischen Auszuge, Halle, pp 298, 1786
14. van BENEDEN PJ. Les vers cestoides ou acolytes, considérés sous le rapport de leur classif-
ication, de leur anatomie et de leur développement. Extracted from Mémoires de l'Académie
Royale de Belgique de Bruxelles, volume 25, pp 190, 1850. Abstracted in British and Foreign
Medico-Chirurgical Review 10: 322-335, 1852
15. van BENEDEN PJ. Mémoires sur les vers intestinaux. Supplement to Comptes Rendus
Hebdomadaires des Séances de l'Académie des Sciences, tome 2, Paris, pp 376, 1858 (written
1852, couronné par l'Institut, 1853)
16. BLANCHARD R. Traité de zoologie médicale, J-B Baillière et fils, Paris, two volumes,
pp 1691, 1895-1890
17. BOBILLIER. Extraction of a large hydatid growth from the abdomen; iodine injections;
recovery. Lancet ii: 583, 1851 (Abstract)
18. BONETUS T. Sepulchretum sive anatomica practica ex cadaveribus morbo denatis, L Chonet,
Genevae, four volumes, pp 1706, 1697-1700
19. BREMSER JG. Ueber lebende Würmer im lebenden Menschen. Ein Buch für ausübende
Aertze. Mit nach der Natur gezeichneten Abbildungen auf vier Tafeln. Nebst einem Anhage
über Pseudo-Helminthem, Carl Schaumburg und Comp., Wien, pp 284, 1819
20. BRIGHT R. Clinical memoirs on abdominal tumours and intumescence, London, pp 55, 1861
21. CASONI T. La diagnosa biologica dell'echinococcosi umana mediante l'intradermoreazione.
Folia Clinica Chemica e Microscopica 4: 5-16, 1911
348 A History of Human Helminthology
22. COBBOLD TS. Entozoa: an introduction to the study of helminthology with reference more
particularly to the internal parasites of man, Groombridge and Sons, London, pp 480, 1864
23. COLE G. The Australasian hydatidregistry. Health Bulletin No. 83/84, Melbourne, pp 2255-
2261, 1945. Abstracted in Tropical Diseases Bulletin 44: 602, 1947
24. D'ALESSANDRO A, RAUSCH RL, CUELLO C, ARISTIZABAL N. Echinococcus vogeli
in man, with a review on polycystic hydatid disease in Colombia and neighboring countries.
American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 28: 303-317, 1979
25. DAVAINE C. Traité des entozoaires et des maladies vermineuses de l'homme et des animaux
domestiques, J-B Baillière et fils, Paris, pp 838, 1860
26. DÉVÉ F. Des greffes échinococciques. Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances et
Mémoires de la Société de Biologie 53: 115-116, 1901
27. DÉVÉ F. Du siège sous-séreux des greffes échinococciques péritonéales. Comptes Rendus
Hebdomadaires des Séances et Mémoires de la Société de Biologie 53: 117-118, 1901
28. DÉVÉ F. De la greffe hydatique obtenue par l'inoculation de scolex. Bulletin et Mémoires de
la Société de Chirurgie de Paris 28: 905-910, 1902
29. DÉVÉ F. Echinococcose secondaire emboliquepériphérique. Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires
des Séances et Mémoires de la Société de Biologie 75: 100-102, 1913
30. DÉVÉ F. Secondary echinococcosis. Lancet ii: 835-838, 1919
31. DÉVÉ F. Enquête étiologique sur l'échinococcose en Tunisie. Archives de l'Institut Pasteur de
Tunis 12: 353-356, 1923
32. DÉVÉ F. Essai de vaccination anti-échinococcique par le sable hydatique tyndallisé. Comptes
Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances et Mémoires de la Société de Biologie 97: 1130-1131,
1927
33. DÉVÉ F. De l'existence de formes de transition entre l'échinococcosehydatique et l'échino-
coccose alvéolaire chez l'homme. Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances et Mémoires
de la Société de Biologie 113: 223-224, 1933
34. DÉVÉ F. L'échinococcose secondaire, Massen et Co., Paris, pp 228, 1946
35. DÉVÉ F. L'échinococcose primitive (Maladie hydatique), Librairie de l'Académie de
Médecine, Paris, pp 362, 1949
36. DEW HR. Observations on the mode of development of brood capsules and scolices in the
encysted stage of Taenia echinococcus. Medical Journal of Australia ii: 381-384, 1922
37. DEW HR. The histogenesis of the hydatid parasite (Taenia echinococcus) in the pig. The
development of the Taenia echinococcus from embryo to hydatid cyst. Medical Journal of
Australia i: 101-110, 1925
38. DEW HR. Hydatid disease. Its pathology, diagnosis and treatment, Australasian Medical Pub-
lishing Company, Sydney, pp 419, 1928
39. DEW HR. Echinococcus alveolaris, with report of an Australian case. Australian and New
Zealand Journal of Surgery 1: 115-141, 1931
40. DEW HR, KELLAWAY CH, WILLIAMS FE. The intradermal reaction in hydatid disease
and its clinical value. Medical Journal of Australia i: 471-478, 1925
41. DIESING CM. Systema helminthum, Wilhelmum Braumüller, Vindobonae, 2 volumes, pp
1267, 1849-1851
42. DUJARDIN F. Histoire naturelle des helminthes ou vers intestinaux, Librairie Encyclopédique
de Roret, Paris, pp 654, 1845
43. DUNGAL N. Eradication of hydatid disease in Iceland. New Zealand MedicalJournal 56:
213-222, 1957
44. FAIRLEY KD. Hydatid disease of the liver. Medical Journal of Australia i: 177-186, 1924
45. FAIRLEY NH, WRIGHT-SMITH RJ. Hydatid infestation (Echinococcus granulosus) in
sheep, oxen and pigs, with special reference to daughter cyst formation. Journal of Pathology
and Bacteriology 32: 309-335, 1929
46. FLEIG C, LISBONNE M. Recherches sur un sérodiagnostic du kyste hydatique par al
méthode des precipitins. Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances et Mémoires de al
Société de Biologie 62: 1198-1201, 1907
47. GALENUS CC. In, Medicorum graecorum opera quae extant, edited by KG Kühn (Greek text
with Latin translation), 20 volumes, Leipzig, 1821-1833
48. GHEDINI G. Ricerche sul siero di sangue di individuo affetto da cisti da echinococco e sul
Echinococcosis 349
liquido in essa contenuto. Gazzetta degli Ospedali et delle Cliniche 27: 1616-1617, 1906
49. GOEZE JAE. Versuch einer Naturgeschichte der Eingeweidewürmer thierischer Körper,
PA Pape, Blankenburg, pp 471, 1782. Partly translated in 62.
50. GOEZE JAE. Versuch einer Naturgeschichte der Eingeweiderwürmer thierischer Körper,
PA Pape, Blankenberg, pp 471, 1782. Partly translated in 69.
51. GOODSIR. Cited in 16
52. HARTMANNUS PJ. Vermes vesiculares sive hydatoides in caprearum omentis et in pulmon-
ibus arterius furfuracea. Miscellanea Curiosa Sive Ephemeridum Medico-Physicarum
Germanicarum Academiae Naturae Curiosorum. Decuriae II. Annus Quarti Anni
MDCLXXXV (1685). Observatio LXXIII, Johannis Ernesti Adelbulneri, Nuremberg, pp 152-
157, 1705. Translated in 62.
53. HARTMANNUS PJ. De anatome canis hydropici. Miscellanea Curiosa Sive Ephemeridum
Medico-Physicarum Germanicarum Academiae Naturae Curiosorum. Decuriae II, Annus II,
Anni 1694, Leipzig and Frankfurt, p 299, 1695
54. HARTMANNUS PJ. De vesicularibus vermibus in mure. Miscellanea Curiosa Sive Ephemer-
idum Medico-Physicarum Germanicarum Academiae Naturae Curiosorum. Decuriae III,
Annus II, Anni 1694. Observatio CXCIII, Leipzig and Frankfurt, pp 304-305, 1695
55. HAUBNER. Cited in 69
56. HEATH DD, CHRISTIE MJ, CHEVIS RA. The lethal effect of mebendazole on secondary
Echinococcus granulosus, cysticerci of Taenia pisiformis and tetrathyridia of Mesocestoides
corti. Parasitology 70: 273-285, 1975
57. HIPPOCRATES. Works of, translated by WH Jones and ET Whithington, Loeb Classical
Library, Heinemann, London, four volumes, 1948-1953
58. HJALTELIN J. The hydatid disease in Iceland: a few remarks on district-physician John
Finsen's contribution to our knowledge of the disease. Lancet ii: 178-180, 1869
59. HUNTER J. Medical and Surgical Transactions 1: 35, 1793. Cited in 34
60. HUNTER J. Cited in 4
61. HUTCHINSON J. The surgical treatment ofhydatid tumours in the abdomen. British Medical
Journal i: 197-201, 1864
62. KEAN BH, MOTT KE, RUSSELL AJ. Tropical medicine and parasitology. Classic investig-
ations, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, 2 volumes, pp 677, 1978
63. KLEMM H. Zur Kenntnis des alveolären Echinococcus. Münchener Dissertation, pp 1-27,
1883
64. KRABBE. Recherches helminthologiques en Danemark et en Islande, GEC Gad, Copenhagen,
pp 68, 1866
65. KÜCHENMEISTER F. Vorläufige Mittheilung(Über Cysticercus pisiformis der Kaninchen).
Zeitschrift für klinische Medicin 2: 240, 1851
66. KÜCHENMEISTER F. Einiges über den Übergang der Finnen in Taenien und über das
Digitalin. Zeitschrift für klinische Medicin 2: 295-299, 1851
67 KÜCHENMEISTER F. Ueber die Umwandlung der Finnen (Cysticerci) in Bandwuermer
(Taenien). Prager Vierteljahrsschrift für die Praktische Heilkunde 33: 106-158, 1852
68. KÜCHENMEISTER F. Experimente über die Entstehung der Cestoden Zweiter Stufe
zunachst des Coenurus cerebralis. Under Mitwirkung des Herrn Professor Haubner auf
Befehl und Kosten des hohen königliche sachsischen Staatsministerii des Innern. Zeitschrift
für klinische Medicin 4: 448-451, 1853
69. KÜCHENMEISTER F. Die in und an dem Körper des lebenden Menschen vorkommenden
Parasiten. Ein Lehr- und Handbuch der Diagnose und Behandlung der thierischen und
pflanzischen Parasiten des Menschen, Teubner, Leipzig, 2 volumes, pp 486, 1855. On animal
and vegetable parasites of the human body. A manual of their natural history, diagnosis and
treatment. Volume 1. Animal parasites belonging to the group Entozoa, translated by E
Lankester, The Sydenham Society, London, pp 452, 1857
70. KÜCHENMEISTER F. Cited in 76
71. LAENNEC RT. Mémoire sur les vers vésiculaires, principalement ceux qui se trouvent dans
le corps humain, pp 176, 1804
72. LAWSON TC. Echinococcus cysts of the liver of fifty six years' duration. Journal of the
American Medical Association 112: 1331-1333, 1939
350 A History of Human Helminthology
c.400 BC Hippocrates alluded to lesions that were undoubtedly hydatid cysts in the
abdomen of humans
1766 Pallas hypothesized that human hydatid cysts arose from tapeworms
1782 Goeze described the scolices within hydatid cysts and indicated their
similarity with the heads of tapeworms
1851 Bobillier injected iodine into an hydatid cyst
1853 von Siebold discovered the adult tapeworms in the small intestine of dogs
after feeding them with larvae from echinococcal cysts obtained from
sheep
1855 Küchenmeister argued that offal of slaughtered domestic animals should
not be fed to dogs
1855 Virchow discovered characteristic echinococcal hooklets in so-called
"colloid carcinoma", now named E. multilocularis
1863 Naunyn recovered adult tapeworms from the small intestine of a dog fed
with the contents of an hydatid cyst obtained from a human
1867 Leuckart generated hydatid cysts in pigs by feeding them with eggs
obtained from adult tapeworms
1867 Leared reported that kamala eradicated tapeworms from the intestines of
dogs
1889 Lebedev and Andreev showed that daughter cysts released into the
peritoneal cavity of rabbits developed into fully-fledged cysts
1898 Alexinsky demonstrated that cysts developed from "hydatid sand" (brood
capsules + scolices) injected intraperitoneally in rabbits
1906 Ghedini described a complement fixation test for serodiagnosis
1911 Casoni described a skin test for immunodiagnosis
1913 Dévé produced cysts by injection of scolices alone
1922-5 Dew described in detail the development of larvae in the tissues
1975 Heath and colleagues showed that mebendazole had some parasiticidal
activity in experimental echinococcosis
___________________________________________________________________
Chapter 13
SYNOPSIS
355
356 A History of Human Helminthology
BC32,85; the parasites may, in fact, have been Taenia saginata since, according
to Herodotus, the ancient Egyptians did not eat pork. Tapeworms wer e
described by the Greeks including Hippocrates (460-375 BC) 51, Aristotle
(384-c.322 BC)8 and Threophrastus (c.372-286 BC) who called them eithe r
µ (HELMINS PLATEIA) meaning "flatworm" or
(TAINIA, TAENIA) meaning "band" or "ribbon" worm. Thus, Threophrastus
remarked:
This worm (flatworm) naturally infects certain races. Speaking generally, the
following are liable to it - the Egyptians, the Arabians, the Armenians....The Thracians
have it not, nor the Phrygians. Among the Hellenes, those Thebans who frequent
wrestling schools and the Boeotians generally are liable to it: but not the Athenians. 105
Romans such as Celsus (c.20 AD) 24, Pliny the Elder (23-79 AD) 20 and Galen
(129-c.200 AD)41 recognized tapeworms and named them "lumbricus latus".
"Lumbricus" was a group term meaning "worm" and "latus" meant "broad" or
"wide". Thus, Galen wrote concerning intestinal worms:
Again, worms also occasionally take possession of the bowel, and these are discharged
at one time from the lower bowels, at another more nastily from the mouth; and we
observe them sometimes to be flattened, which are the worst, at times to be rounded.41
Similarly, these worms were apparent to peoples in many other parts of th e
world, including India and China and mention is made of them in the Asia n
ancient literature 52.
Early writers had various ideas about the nat ure of these worms. Hippocrates,
Aristotle and Galen regarded the tapeworm as an animal, but Aetius 2 (c.550
AD) and Paulus Aegineta 1 (c.640 AD) thought that a tapeworm represented a
transformed strip of intestinal lining. In the latter part of the first milleniu m
after Christ, some Arab authors such as Serapion (c.800 AD) regarded th e
individual tapeworm proglottids as distinct worms 99. These were named
cucurbitini, not only because of their resembl ance to pumpkin seeds ( Cucurbita
species), but also because pumpkin seeds were one of the earliest remedies for
tapeworm infection. Many Arab writers did not consider the whole tapeworm
as a worm at all, but believed that it was a membrane formed by the intestine
to hold these cucurbitini, whereas others, including Ibn Sina (Avicenna ,
981-1037 AD) thought that cucurbitini (pumpkin seed worms) and taeni a
(gigantic worms) were completely different creatures 10.
The name taenia "solium" was apparently first used in relation to tapeworms
in a publication by Arnaldo Villanovani (Arnault de Villeneuve, c.1300 A D)
who wrote:
quidam dicunt quod isti cucurbitini generantur in ventre cujusdam maximi lumbrici
qui aliquando emittitur longior uno vel duobus brachiis, qui solium sive cingulum
dicitur.111
According to Nicholas Andry , this expression was already in verbal use before
Villanovani's time and reflected the erroneous belief that a person could only
be host to a single tapeworm. He wrote that the worm was "called solium from
its being the only one of its species in the body" 4. This view was disputed by
Taeniasis solium and Cysticercosis 357
Leuckart, however, on the grounds that the Latin word for "single" or "alone"
is "solus" whereas "solium" means "seat" or "throne" 66. Leuckart therefore
solicited the views of Dr Krehl, professor of oriental languages at th e
University of Leipzig, who reported: "It is impossible to derive the word solium
from the classic languages" 61. Krehl then went on to say that there were n o
appropriate words in either Arabic or Hebrew, but that: "I should like to offer
as an explanation the certainly somewhat Syriac word for tapeworm, namel y
Schuschl-e (properly 'chains')"61. Krehl postulated that schuschl-e had become
transformed into solium via Arabic then French or Spanish authors of th e
Middle Ages: "Among the Arabians it would be changed into susl or sosl, and
among the romance authors it would lose the second s" 61. This explanation
seems a bit far-fetched. Simpler ones could be invoked equally well; perhaps
the worm has been called "solium" because segments of the worm issue from
the "solium" (meaning "seat" or "ru mp") while sitting on the "solium" (meaning
the "throne", i.e. toilet)!
As will be discussed in the next two chapters, Taenia solium was confused
with Taenia saginata and Diphyllobothrium latum for two thousand years or
more. Although Platter was ab le to discern differences between the strobiles of
Taenia and Diphyllobothrium (see chapter 15), the key to the definitiv e
separation of the various tapeworm species, as well as to a proper under -
standing of the nature of these parasites, was the discovery that tapeworms had
a head. It fell to the Englishman, Edward Tyson, to make this fundamenta l
discovery in 1683107, then, in the following year, the Italian, Francesco Redi ,
independently published small-scale and rather crude illustrations of the heads
of dog and cat tapeworms 90.
Many earlier anatomists had noticed a difference in the size of each end of a
tapeworm segment. Some, including Spigelius104 and Amatus Lusitanius, did
not take the setting of the worm segmen t in relation to the intestine into account
and were misled into describing the more slender end as the tail. Others ,
despite their most diligent enquiries, could not come to any certain conclusion
as to the orientation of the worm within the body. Others again, such as Tulp 106
and Fehr37, even described and illustrated heads that were not heads at all .
Tyson, near the end of the seventeenth century, eloquently summed up th e
current state of knowledge:
The head of the Nile does not seem to be more plerplex't, and obscure to the Ancients,
than that of this Worm, which has created as many controversies among Anatomists
of late, as that has with the Geographers of old. 107
Tyson was fortunate in not only having a number of patients who suffered from
tapeworm infections, but in encountering such worms in a variety of animals.
It was the finding of tapeworms in the intestines of dissected dogs that allowed
him to orientate the worm in the bowel correctly and gave him access to th e
whole worm, thus permitting him to find the head:
And it was in a Dog I opened at our private meeting, at the Anatomical Theater of the
College of Physicians, where I observed this worm alive in the Ilion; not lying streight,
358 A History of Human Helminthology
but in many places winding and doubling. Having taken notice how the Joynts were,
I traced it up, by carefully opening the intestine to the smallest Extream; where I
expected the head to be; and which did lye towards the Duodenum; whereas the
broader end was free, and did nothing adhere; whereas that small extream did do
firmly stick, and has fasten'd itself to the inward coat of the Intestine, that it was not
without some trouble, by gently raising it with my Nail, that I freed it from its
adhesion.107
Tyson put the worm in spirit of wine then took it home to examine it at leisure
with a microscope. Thereupon, he found that the head:
very plainly appeared....beset with two orders of Spikes, or Hooks, whereof the larger
did arise from the Center or Middle spreading themselves over the edges of the
circumference; the other which were issuing out about the middle from the Center
and were shorter....I could not upon my strictest Enquiry and with extraordinary
Glasses too, inform myself of any orifice here, which we may suppose to be the
mouth....This end was not perfectly flat, but a little globous and I could perceive....the
neck....For some little space here, I could not observe with the glasses any Joynts at
all, but after, very thick set, and small, and gradually increasing in length, as they
descended towards the Tail.107
Subsequently, Tyson found similar hea ds in other tapeworms and was left in no
doubt as to the correctness of his observations. He was troubled by his failure
to observe a mouth in the head of the worm, and solved this dilemm a
incorrectly by mistaking the genital aperture in each proglottid for a mouth .
Tyson was, however, on the right track in his assessment of the hooks:
Upon the whole, what seems most agreeable to me, and to be the true use of this part
we call the head is this; by means of these hooks, or Spikes it might fasten itself, and
so prevent, its too easy ejection out of the body. For it being so very long, and large
too, and its body in many places winding, and convoluted, the descent of the faeces
upon all occasions would be apt to carry it out with them; had it not this hold, which
is so fast, that rather than loosen itself, parts of the body are sooner broken off, which
we frequently see in the stool....hence it is that this Worm is of so difficult a cure. 107
Tyson also addressed two other questions. Firstly, it had been asserted by a
number of authorities, both ancient and moder n, that tapeworms were not living
creatures. This opinion seemed to Tyson to be wide of the mark, for he, as well
as as many other physicians, had "observed it to move, and therefore to be an
Animal and alive" 107. Secondly, other authors admitted a tapeworm to be alive,
but maintained that it was not a single worm but many worms linked together
and enveloped by a lining derived from the intestine. This sac was deemed not
to be animated itself but received its motion from the proglottids (cucurbitini)
enclosed within it. Thus, Gabucinus in 1547 wrote:
I think the Broad worm to be nothing else, as Hippocrates says, than the white
scourings of the Guts within which living creatures like Gourd-seed are bred....It
comes away very frequently in pieces.39
Tyson disputed this view, for while examining a tapeworm recovered from a
dissected dog, a couple of joints fell off intact, and yet there was no evidence
of any membrane attached to the remainder of the worm. Further, he wa s
unable to find such a structure in any tapeworm he examined, whether o f
Taeniasis solium and Cysticercosis 359
On the mature lower segments the marginal openings in part project so far that the
protrusion and the indented osculum can be seen with the naked eye. I inserted a
horse hair, and afterwards I pulled off the surface with fine instruments until I saw
with pleasure under the magnifying glass that the hair was in the transverse canal that
led to the ovary.43
Goeze observed eggs in the ovaries and drew rudimentary figures depictin g
them. He was particularly puzzled by the fact that he had never seen an y
tapeworm, whether of human or animal origin, which did not have eggs, and
wondered how fertilization took place. Although Goeze did not know th e
answer, he postulated a number of mechanisms, amongst which was the idea
that these worms may be hermaphroditic:
Are there, therefore, two sexes amongst them? Or is every tapeworm sufficient to
itself and does it fertilize its own eggs? How are the organs for this purpose
constituted and where are they?43
Over the next few decades, many of the details of the anatomy of tapeworms
were elucidated. The absence of a digestive sys tem was confirmed and the pres-
ence of a vascular system was defined. Goeze himself had noticed two smal l
openings on each side of every proglottid, each of which traversed the length
of the proglottid. It was then shown that these vessels were interconnected at
the head and descended throughout the length of the tapeworm, communicating
with each other from proglottid to proglottid at their lateral margins. In 1841,
Eschricht published the first detailed anatomy of a tapeworm ( D. latum) 34. In
1847, Emile Blanchard discovered the nervous system of tapeworms 16. Finally,
the anatomy of the sexual apparatus w as gradually pieced together by a number
of investigators, particularly the Germans, Mehlis, Platner and von Siebold. In
1835, von Siebold had observed that Taenia eggs contained an embryo wit h
small hooks100, then in the following year he had discovered Taenia
spermatozoa101. Leuckart provided a major analysis of the reproductive system
in 1862, then Sommer a few years later provided further details of thi s
system103.
There still remained the problem o f defining the nature of the organization or
individuality of a tapeworm. As mentioned earlier, many of the ancient Greek
and Roman investigators were of the opinion that a tapeworm originate d
through the union of separate proglottids. Some writers believed that th e
cucurbitini were held together by an enclosing membrane derived from intest-
inal mucus, others thought that they were glued together, while yet other s
believed that they held each other by mouth openings. This view that tape -
worms were formed by the union of previously free cucurbitini held sway until
the end of the 17th century when the heads of tapeworms were discovered .
Although this concept was now disposed of, a new question arose. Was a tape-
worm a simple animal with a head and jointed body, or was it a compoun d
animal? Most authors considered the tapeworm as a single animal that main-
tained its hold in the gut by means of the head and fed itself through it; th e
longitudinal canals that had been recognized as running through the entir e
Taeniasis solium and Cysticercosis 361
length of the worm were thought to arise in the suckers and were regarde d
erroneously as an intestine. Thus, a tapeworm was viewed as a single animal
with numerous proglottids which were cast off at the posterior end. A n
alternative proposition, championed by P J van Beneden (1850), suggested that
the tapeworm was a compound animal of separate individuals. This concep t
grew out of Steenstrup's theory of the "Alternation of Generations" .
Accordingly, a tapeworm was believed to be a combination of two generations:
the scolex which was single and had arisen by asexual multiplication, and the
proglottids or sexual individuals which were usually present in large numbers.
In essence, the scolex was considered to be the "nurse" to the strobila .
According to van Beneden:
the head (scolex) remains like a true nurse, asexual....By continued budding there
arises from an originally isolated nurse a whole community of individuals - a colony
in which one has to distinguish not only animals at various stages of maturity, but also
one asexual and aberrant member, the so-called 'head'. 12
This view was attractive to Moquin-Tandon who wrote that the Taenia is a
perfect animal which is composed of a scolex and a number of proglottid s
which:
constitute special organisms placed end to end and enjoying a community of life, but
each of which at the same time is provided with all the elements essential to its
individuality.78
Just as there was confusion over t he nature of tapeworms, so have there been
differences of opinion over terminology. Felix Dujardin introduced the ter m
"proglottis" to describe the isolated joint or cucurbitinus. This word wa s
derived from the Greek word (GLOTTIS) meaning "tongue". Strictly
speaking, since the plural of this word is "proglottides", "proglottis" should be
used for a single joint and "proglottides" for more than one. These classica l
niceties have been corrupted in many textbooks, however. I have followed the
practice of the major text on medical parasitology 11 in using the terms
"proglottid" and "proglottids" to describe one or more joints, respectively. The
term "segment" is also vague, but is commonly used to indicate a number o f
proglottids joined together. Similar etymological difficulties confront the user
of the word "scolex". This term was introduced by van Beneden 12 to describe
the head of a tapeworm. It is derived from the Greek word (SKOLEX,
SCOLEX) for a worm. The use of "scolices" as the plural form of this word is
firmly entrenched in the literatu re, presumably by analogy with the Latin words
"index" and "indices". According to the Oxfor d English Dictionary, and as more
recently discussed by Arme 9, such usage is erroneous and the rules of Gree k
declension dictate that it should be "scoleces". Since it is hallowed by custom,
I have continued to use "scolices" in this book. Similar difficulties apply to the
term "strobila", also introduced by van Beneden, to indicate the connecte d
series of proglottids. This word could be derived either from the Greek word
(STROBILOS) meaning "anything twisted" or a "pine-cone" o r
from (STROBILE) meaning "plug of lint twisted into the shape of
362 A History of Human Helminthology
DISCOVERY OF CYSTICERCI
The ancient Greeks were well-acquainted with measly pork although they did
not comprehend its nature. By the time of Aristophanes of Athens (c.448-386
BC), the condition was so well known that he could use it in his play, "Th e
Knights", with the slave Demosthenes suggesting that Cleon (one of the main
characters) should be treated in the same way that pigs were examined:
Let us force a stake into his mouth as do the cooks, and then, by pulling out his
tongue, we will examine boldly and at our ease his wide-opened mouth to see if he is
measled."
Similarly, Aristotle knew the chief localizations of cysts in pigs and compared
them to hailstones 8, while others remarked upon their resemblance to pearls.
Aristotle considered that infected pigs could not remain standing on their hind
legs, and that if the bristles, especially those of the back, were pulled out they
usually had drops of blood on their roots.
J Rumler in 1558 may have been the first person to describe cysticerci i n
humans when he found tumours on the surface of the dura mater in an epileptic
person96. Some authorities also cite Conrad Gesner as having described th e
parasite in 1558, but I have not been able to find a specific reference to such
a passage. Panarolus in 1652 found similar cysts in the corpus callosum of the
brain of an epileptic priest83. In 1656, the Englishman Thomas Wharton found
large numbers of cysts, which he took to be glands, in the adipose tissue and
muscles of a soldier 116. As discussed in chapter 12, none of these observers was
aware of the animal nature of these lesions, and recognition of this fac t
developed pari passu with similar observations made with other cysti c
parasitic worms.
In 1688, three years after he had described the motion of cysticerc i
(Cysticercus tenuicollis) in the omentum of a goat, Philip Hartmann also found
cysts in the heart of a pig. Within each cyst, and attached to its inner surface by
bands which he termed the "frustulum", Hartmann found a worm, although he
did not realize that he was looking at a head with its suckers and circlet o f
hooks:
Taeniasis solium and Cysticercosis 363
In the heart of a pig I noticed that there were very many cysts....when the capsules
were cut open a peculiar skin of thin membrane could be removed. This covered both
a clear liquid and a white filament coiled like a white thread - itself a small worm. 48
Marcus Malpighi, at the end of the seventeenth century, discovered independ-
ently the animal nature of these cysticerci, and was the first person to speak of
the head of a worm within each cysticercus. He investigated the structure o f
cysts found in measly pork and saw within each vesicle, a whitish body which
looked like a spiral staircase. At its extremity, he recognized a small head and
wrote: "in apice atollitur capitulum" 75 meaning that at the apex of this body, a
small head was erected. Around this period, Otto Fabricius also recognized the
animal nature of measly pork. Nevertheless, these descriptions were eithe r
vague or remained unnoticed for many years.
In 1784, and apparently ignoran t of these earlier reports, Goeze re-examined
the cysts found in pork, recognized that they were helminthic in nature, an d
described clearly their morphology. In addition, he pointed out the similarities
between the head of the worm with in the cyst and that of an adult Taenia found
in the intestinal tract of humans 44. He included these wormy cysts among hi s
"Taenia viscerales hydatigenae". Nevertheless, Goeze still believed in th e
zoological independence of these parasites from tapeworms.
In 1786, Werner rediscovered these cysticerci in humans. While dissecting
the body of a soldier who had been in good health but who had drowne d
accidentally, he found two small cysts, each of which contained a worm, under
the pectoralis major muscle. These he named "Finna" since they resemble d
measly pork which was called "fi nnen" in Germany 115. Over the next few years,
a number of pathologists including Fischer, Treutler, Brera, Stenbech, Loschge
and Laennec found similar lesions in humans, mostly in the muscles an d
choroid plexus.
When Gmelin came to publish his revision of Linnaeus's Systema Naturae
in 1790, he accepted the verminous nature of these cysts, as well as thei r
resemblances to tapeworms, and called them Taenia cellulosae 42. In 1803,
Zeder created a new genus, Cysticercus, to house these parasites 123. This name
was derived from a combination of the Greek words (KUSTIS,
CYSTIS) and (KERKOS, CERCOS) meaning "bladder" and "tail" ,
respectively. A few years later, Rudolphi adopted this generic classification and
applied the specific name "cellulosae" of Gmelin, the parasite thus becoming
known as Cysticercus cellulosae 95. This name persisted until the genus wa s
abolished when cysticerci were shown to be larval stages of Taenia, but the
term "cysticercus cellulosae" continues to be used to describe the organisms of
this type found in pigs and humans.
364 A History of Human Helminthology
from Küchenmeister's home, although the short time at his disposal gav e
Küchenmeister scant hope for success. The investigation was undertaken i n
collaboration with two medical colleagues, Dr D and Dr Z, whose names h e
was not allowed to publish 63. Since C. cellulosae was not available at the time,
one of these colleagues gave fresh C. pisiformis from a rabbit and C. tenuicollis
from a pig intermingled with noodles in a soup cooled to blood temperature to
the convict, so that he received the bladder worms without knowing it. Three
and a half days before the convict's death, ho wever, Küchenmeister's wife found
some C. cellulosae in their evening meal, which consisted of warm roast pork
obtained from a nearby restaurant. Küchenmeister rushed around to th e
restaurant, and after much pleading, obtained one pound of pork from the pig,
which had been slaughtered 60 hours previously. Next morning, the priso n
doctor gave the convict some blood sausage, from which a few of the fatt y
pieces had been removed and a dozen bladder worms inserted, for breakfast.
Over the next two and a half da ys, the condemned man ingested a further 61 C.
cellulosae in sausage or soup. Forty eight hours after execution, the intestines
were examined by Küchenmeister and his medic al collaborators in the presence
of several professors. Not only did he find young larvae with hooklets, bu t
Küchenmeister found a young tapeworm:
I was successful in finding a small Taenia which was tightly attached with its
projected proboscis to a piece of duodenal mucosa which I had softened in water for
a few minutes.63
This was examined under the microscope and:
we saw a young Taenia with a projected proboscis to which four hooklets pointing
forward were loosely attached; these, when compared with other preparations of T.
solium, T. serrata vera, and Taenia cystic. tenuicolli, proved clearly to be hooklets
of the T. solium.63
Subsequently, they found another nine specimens, one of which had the com-
plete classical crown of T. solium with 22 hooklets in two rows. Küchenmeister
was left in no doubt that all these specimens harboured hooklets of the typ e
seen in T. solium and C. cellulosae and not in the other cysticerci. Most of the
worms were 3-4 mm long, but one was 6-8 mm in length and had an append-
age. No traces of the last feedings were found in the intestines, and Küchen -
meister believed that those cy sticerci were probably already dead at the time of
administration. In reviewing his r esults, he summarized them by saying that the
experiment had established:
(1) that the C. cellulosae is the scolex of the T. solium hominis
(2) that the mode of infection with T. solium is exactly the same as with all others
originating from bladder worms and probably like that of most of the Taeniae
(3) that we, therefore, infect ourselves with T. solium since cysticercus is transmitted
by those foods which we eat raw.63
Küchenmeister recognized, however, that th e experiment needed to be repeated
with a longer time being allowed for comp lete development of adult tapeworms
to occur.
In an attempt to head off any adverse criticis m of the ethics of the experiment,
Taeniasis solium and Cysticercosis 367
A complete understanding of the life cycle of T. solium required not only that
mature tapeworms be produced in humans after ingestion of C. cellulosae in
measly pork, but that these cy sts should also be generated in pigs following the
consumption of T. solium eggs obtained from proglottids passed by infecte d
humans. This latter course was pursued contemporaneously with the former .
It will be remembered that from the time of Pallas, various experimenters had
fed eggs to animals, but they had sought adult worms in the intestines rather
than cysticerci in the tissues. The first person to demonstrate the generation of
C. cellulosae was the Belgian, P J van Beneden. In 1853, he gave T. solium
eggs to a pig, then when it was slaughtered at the abattoirs four and a hal f
months later, found a large number of C. cellulosae in the muscles. Van
Beneden controlled the investigation by keeping another pig under the sam e
conditions, except that it was not given any eggs; it had no cysticerci a t
autopsy13.
Similar results were then reported by Prof. Haubner in collaboration wit h
Küchenmeister49. In view of the economic importance of the subject, Küchen-
Taeniasis solium and Cysticercosis 369
meister and Haubner had been commissioned by the Royal Saxon Ministry of
State to investigate the metamorphosis of cystic worms. Three pigs were given
T. solium proglottids on 7, 24 and 26 J une and on 2 and 13 July 1855. The first
animal was killed on 26 July and small cysticerci with incompletely developed
heads were found. The second pig was slaughtered on 9 August and a thousand
cysticerci were disseminated in the viscera. The third hog, sacrificed on 2 3
August, was massively infected; Haubner and Küchenmeister counted 133 C.
cellulosae in 4.5 drachms of meat which was the equivalent of 80,00 0
cysticerci per stone (approximately 6.4 kg) of pork. In a similar series o f
experiments, they failed to generate C. cellulosae in dogs and sheep fed with
T. solium proglottids.
These observations were confirmed in the following year (1856) by Leuckart
who infected successfully a number of pigs and observed them for up to si x
months after infection 65. Similar experiences were then reported by Mosle r
(1865) and Gerlach (1870).
Occasionally, humans, like the pig, were found to be infected with C. cell-
ulosae although this represented a dead end for the parasite, in civilize d
communities, at least. The obvious conclusion (which, naturally, has neve r
been put to the test), was that such infections in humans were acquired b y
ingestion of T. solium eggs. The ova could either be ingested in contaminated
food or water, or could be transferred directly from the anus to the mouth via
fingers. An alternative possibility, suggested by Leuckart 66, was that reversed
peristalsis might sometimes occur with retrograde movement in the intestines
of mature proglottids which in turn then ruptured to release infective eggs.
Attention then turned to study of the proce sses by which migration and devel-
opment of larvae occurred in animal intermediate hosts. Early workers found
that when eggs were swallowed by a pig, they hatched and the released larvae,
furnished with hooks, bored their way through the intestinal mucosa an d
migrated to the tissues where they lodged and developed into cysticerci ,
producing a scolex by a process which was ter med "asexual gemmation". These
events were then described in great detail by Yoshino 119,120.
TAENIASIS SOLIUM
The sign of tapeworm infection, par excellence, has always been the passage
of proglottids through the anus. Sometimes, huge segments of worm wer e
passed, particularly when anthelmintics were taken, thus engendering consid-
erable terror in the patient. Tyson records the instance of a 20 year old patient
of his, who, upon the use of an emulsion of cold seeds, dragged a tapewor m
from himself "not without some frightful Apprehensions that the Guts and all
were coming out" 107. This parasite measured 24 feet in length and numbere d
370 A History of Human Helminthology
was dependent upon the continuing presen ce of an adult tapeworm 28. Definitive
studies in which the recurrence of infection in a treated subpopulation in a n
endemic area is assessed are still awaited.
CYSTICERCOSIS
Cysticercosis in humans was recognized much less frequently than was taen-
iasis solium. Occasionally the two conditions occurred together in the sam e
patient. Thus, von Graefe (1866) found intestinal tapeworms in five of 8 0
patients with ocular cysticercosis 46. In many cases, patients were asymptomatic,
as instanced by the incidental discoveries by Wharton and Werner of th e
organisms in previously healthy individuals. Some persons had smaller o r
larger numbers of subcutaneous nodules. One of the more dramatic examples
of a patient with disseminated cysticercosis was described thus:
He was pale and the face appeared puffy, but two outstanding features were the chain
of nodules visible on the forehead and the greatly enlarged, apparently well developed
and powerful muscles....The nodules....are found in the subcutaneous tissues of the
forehead, scalp, beneath the left eye, in the neck and in the tissues of the cheek. They
occur singly or in groups of two or three of varying size. When single, they are ovoid,
flattened ovoid, or spherical according to the amount of pressure exerted by the
surrounding tissues. In size, they range downwards from half an inch in longest
diameter. They are found in the aponeuroses of the abdomen, elbow-joints, thighs and
legs. In the muscles, they can be felt singly, in groups and in chains. One cyst is
present in the left eye. . They have never been painful. They are movable and not at
all adherent to the skin. Nearly all the muscles are enlarged, especially those of the
shoulder girdle, and on contraction the muscles present a nodular appearance. He
gives the appearance of being a powerful man....but the muscle power is in fact very
feeble. Enlargement is due to the presence of the cysticerci and to the concomitant
myositis.88
Such infections frequently left no serious musculo-skeletal sequelae, however,
as evidenced by the man with hundreds of calcified cysts in his muscles, who
after three days in hospital following an epileptic fit, attended the Scottis h
Highland Games and took second place in the long jump 35.
By the time Cobbold wrote his textbook on helminthology in 1864, it wa s
well-recognized that cerebral cysticer cosis might cause convulsions and mental
disturbances as well as various cranial nerve and long tract signs 26. In 1934,
interest in this subject was re-awakened when a large number of Britis h
soldiers returning from various outposts of Empire with "idiopathic epilepsy"
were found to be suffering from cerebral cysticercosis 71,72. An unexpected
feature of this study was that parasite s were often present for many years before
the onset of cerebral symptoms; these appeared to be associated with death of
the worms. In explanation of this, MacArthur (1935) hypothesized that th e
biological objective of cysticerci while in the tissues of the intermediate host is
to remain quiescent and he likened them to: "thieves who have entered some
premises where they stay hidden so long as concealment is helpful to thei r
purpose"73 and suggested that death of the parasite may have liberated toxins
372 A History of Human Helminthology
The diagnosis of tapeworm infection was obvious when a patient passed pro-
glottids, but identification of the species of worm was not possible from these
specimens for many years. After Küchenmeister described in 1852 the appear-
ances of the reproductive organs, parti cularly the number of lateral branches on
the gravid uterus in T. solium and T. saginata (which he called T. medio-
canellata; see chapter 14), identification of the proglottids became possible on
a routine basis. Alternatively, a specific diagnosis could also be made afte r
treatment of a patient and recovery of the tapeworm head, but this was ofte n
less feasible.
At about the same period, it was also found that a diagnosis of tapeworm inf-
ection could be made by demonstration of taeniid eggs in the faeces. The first
person to describe such eggs (which he took to be indicative of a new species
of tapeworm) in faeces was Ransom in 1856 89. He was followed soon
afterwards by Davaine who, in his textbook, emphasized the value of faeca l
examination29. Despite occasional claims to the contrary, subsequent exper -
ience indicated that this technique did not permit differentiation of T. solium
and T. saginata infections. With the introduction of the perianal swab tech -
nique for the diagnosis of enterobiasis (see chapter 17), it was found that this
method also enhanced the ability to diagnose tapeworm infections, particularly
those due to T. saginata 87.
On the other hand, the diagnosis of cysticercosis was an altogether different
proposition. The only certain method of diagnosis was by specific identification
of the parasite following surgical removal of a cyst. This was particularl y
difficult in patients with cerebral cysticercosis, although diagnosis was helped
when eosinophils were found in t he cerebrospinal fluid 113. Despite the manifest
advantages of a reliable immunodiagnostic assay for cysticercosis, repeate d
Taeniasis solium and Cysticercosis 373
Remedies effective against tapeworms have been sought and their virtue s
expounded from the earliest time s23. So many agents had been declared to have
anthelmintic properties, that in the middle of the nineteenth century, Küchen-
meister was induced to declare:
if the multitude of remedies recommended for any disease is an evidence of their want
of power against it, we must say that the therapeutics of the tapeworm is extremely
defective.62
Yet this was not entirely fair, for many of these preparations did possess some
antitapeworm activity. Anecdotal clinical experiences over centuries hav e
provided fairly convincing evidence of the efficacies of many of these drugs .
They were often given concurrently with powerful purgatives which increased
peristalsis and assisted in evacuation of the tapeworm. Küchenmeiste r
attempted to produce some order out of the chaos by a series of in vitro
experiments in which he mixed Taenia ova in egg white with various com -
pounds and determined the time that the ova took to die 62. It is only in the last
100 years that various putative anthelmintics have been submitted to carefu l
clinical trial and rigorous scientific analysis.
Perhaps the best known and most commonly used anthelmintic in the treat-
ment of tapeworm infection over the centuries has been oleoresin of Aspidium,
otherwise called filix mas or extract of male fern. This drug, which is prepared
from rhizomes of the plant now known as Dryoptera filix mas, dates from the
time of early Greek medicine. These plants are widespread in the norther n
hemisphere. The rhizomes were collected in the autumn, freed from roots and
dead parts, then dried carefully. An extract was obtained by soaking th e
powdered, dry rhizomes in ether for 48 hours, then the ethereal phase wa s
filtered and concentrated. This elixir, or its principal anthelmintic constituent,
filicic acid or filicin, maintai ned the premier place in the array of antitapeworm
anthelmintics until the middle of the present century 23. Filix mas, in fact, was
the major component of the famous but secret tapeworm remedy of Madame
Nouffer in Morat, Switzerland, which w as purchased for 18,000 francs in 1776
374 A History of Human Helminthology
mepacrine secured the most favoured place for a while, but it was the n
superseded by the introduction of the salicylamide derivative, niclosamide .
Gönnert and Schraufstätter screened a g reat number of salicylamide derivatives
and reported in 1960 that this particular compound was extremely activ e
against Hymenolepis diminuta in rats45. World-wide clinical trials followed and
showed that the drug was highly active against practically all the tapeworm s
infecting man, with cure rates ranging between 80% and 100% 27,60. Niclos-
amide caused lysis of tapeworms in the intestines, so concurrent administration
of a laxative was deemed advisable because of the theoretical risk of causing
cysticercosis in T. solium infections, although this view has been dispute d
recently91.
In 1972, an heterocyclic pyrazino-isoquinoline derivative, praziquantel, was
found to have unusually broad anthelmintic activity. Five years later, it wa s
reported that this drug had cure rates of nearly 100% in patients infected with
T. solium (adult worms), T. saginata and D. latum, and, in addition, was
effective against Hymenolepis species21,33. Furthermore, it was noted to b e
active against C. cellulosae, including cysticerci in the brain, but sinc e
administration of this drug may precipitate severe side-effects, concurrent use
of corticosteroids may be needed to suppress the inflammatory reaction 47,92.
The treatment of cysticercosis has been surgical with removal or parasite s
whenever possible, together with symptomatic treatment of complications such
as epilepsy. It is possible that praziquantel may revolutionize the management
of cysticercosis in many patie nts and obviate the need for surgical intervention.
376 A History of Human Helminthology
Comprehension of the life cycle of T. solium provided a rational basis for the
institution of effective control measures. In his paper of 1855 detailing th e
experimental infection of a human with T. solium, Küchenmeister was quick
to point out the implications for a population that was in the habit of eating raw
pork and recommended that the best method of preventing infection with adult
tapeworms would be by "public instruction and warning to be careful wit h
infected pork"63. By public instruction, Küchenmeister meant the necessity for
the thorough cooking of all por k. Further studies on his part revealed that these
cysts could remain viable for up to a week after slaughtering a pig 64. The value
of proper cooking of pork was emphasized several years later when th e
transmission of Trichinella spiralis in this medium was also demonstrated. The
temperatures necessary to kill cysticerci were investigated by Perroncito in a
series of experiments with T. saginata (see chapter 14). Further researche s
indicated that pickled, salted or smoked pork was not necessarily safe 15 but that
Taeniasis solium and Cysticercosis 377
freezing at -10 oC for a week110 or at -20oC for at least 12 hours was an effective
control measure 15. Recently, it has also been shown that infected carcasses can
be sterilized by gamma irradiation without affecting the quality of the meat 109.
Similarly, it became apparent that good sanitation, particularly with respect
to disposal of human wastes, was essential for the prevention of both porcine
and human cysticercosis, since Taenia eggs were extremely resistant t o
destruction in the environment (see chapter 14). In this respect, vegetable s
grown in gardens fertilized with human faeces were especially dangerous and
needed to be avoided. By these means, it was hoped that the incidence o f
human cysticercosis would be reduc ed and that the economic wastage resulting
from the condemnation of pork would be curtailed. A mere recitation of th e
facts was often insufficient to attain these ends, however, and intensive health
education was often required to achieve a change of habits. Thus, Viljoe n
(1937) recorded the instance of the South African farmer and his househol d
who preferred to use the rear of a hedge close to the homestead rather than a
stinking, fly-infested privy, to relieve themselves. This area could, moreover,
be cleaned immediately by pigs trained to come at a whistle. Similarly, three
farmers of high repute had the ir faith in the life cycle of T. solium shaken when
their scrupulously-styed pigs developed cysticercosis; subsequent detectio n
revealed that some black members of the staff were in the habit of easin g
themselves in the sty and that one of them had tapeworm infection 110. Finally,
the effectiveness of prompt diagnosis and treatment of T. solium infections in
the reduction of human cysticercosis was appreciated.
In developed countries, taeniasis and cysticercosis are both now kept at bay
by a combination of treatment with effective anthelmintics, personal hygiene,
efficient disposal of human wastes, rigid inspection and disposal of infecte d
meat, and storage of pork in refrigerators.
REFERENCES
10. AVICENNA (IBN SINA). "Al canon fi Al Tib", c. 1000 AD. In Arabic. Libri in re medica
omnes, qui hactenus ad nos pervenere. Id est, libri canonis quinque, De virisbus cordis, De
removendis nocumentis in regimine sanitas, De sirupo acetosa et cautica, translated by JP
Mongio Hydruntino et J Costaeo Laudens, V Valgrisius, Venetiis, pp 966, 1564. Cited in 59
11. BEAVER PC, JUNG RC, CUPP EW. Clinical parasitology, Lea & Febiger, Philadelphia, pp
825, 1984
12. van BENEDEN PJ. Les vers cestoides ou acolytes, considérés sous le rapport de leur
classification, de leur anatomie et de leur développement. Extracted from Mémoires de
l'Académie Royale de Belgique, Bruxelles, pp 190, 1850. Abstracted in British and Foreign
Medico-Chirurgical Review 10: 322-325, 1852
13. van BENEDEN PJ. Note sur des expériences relatives au développement des cysticerques.
Annales des Sciences Naturelles 1: 104, 1854
14. BERTOLUS G. Dissertation sur les métamorphoses des Cestoides. Thèse de Montpellier,
1856
15. BIAGI F, VELEZ G, GUTIERREZ ML. Destrucción de los cisticercos en la carne de cerdo
parasitada. Boletín de la Oficina Sanitaria Panamericana 58: 303-307, 1965
16. BLANCHARD E. Recherches sur l'organisation des vers. Annales des Sciences Naturelles,
séries 3, Zoologie, 6: 271-341, 1847; 7: 87-127, 1847; 10: 321-364, 1848: 11: 106-202,
1849
17. BLOCH ME. Abhandlung von der Erzeugung-wuermer und den Mitteln wider dieselben,
Sigismund Friedrich Hesse, Berlin, pp 54, 1782
18. BORRICHIUS. Cited in 107
19. BUDD. Report of cases treated by kousso. Lancet i: 773-774, 1850
20. CAIUS PLINIUS SECUNDUS. Historia naturalis, translated by J Bostock and HT Riley,
Bohn's Classical Library, London, six volumes, 1855-1857
21. CANZONIERI CJ, RODR GUEZ RR, CASTILLO HE, IBAÑEZ de BALLELA C,
LUCENA M. Ensayos terapéuticos con praziquantel en infecciones porTaenia saginata e
Hymenolepis nana. Boletín Chileno de Parasitología 32; 41-42, 1977
22. CARMAN JA. A note on the clinical aspect of the treatment of taeniasis withcarbon tetra-
chloride. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 25: 187-190,
1931
23. de CARNERI I, VITA G. Drugs used in cestode infections. In, International Encyclopedia of
Pharmacology and Therapeutics, Section 64, volume 1, Chemotherapy of Helminthiasis, R
Cavier and F Hawking (editors), Pergamon Press, Oxford, pp 145-213, 1973
24. CELSUS AC. De medicina, translated by WG Spencer, Loeb Classical Library Heinemann,
London, three volumes, 1948-1953
25. CLERICUS (Le CLERC D). Historia naturalis etmedica latorum lumbricorum intra hominem
et alia animalia, nascentium etc., Fratres de Tournes, Genevae, pp 449, 1715. A natural and
medicinal history of worms bred in the bodies of man and other animals etc., translated by J
Brown and J Wilcox at the Green-Dragon, Little Britain, pp 436, 1721
26. COBBOLD TS. Entozoa: an introduction to the study of helminthology with reference more
particularly to the internal parasites of man, Groombridge and Sons, London, pp 480, 1864
27. da CRUZ FERREIRA FA. Ensaios terapêuticos con o Bayer 2353 (Yomesan) na teniase (T.
saginata). Anais do Instituto Medicina Tropical (Lisboa) 17: 1009-1015, 1960
28. CULBERTSON JT. Immunity against animal parasites, Columbia University Press, New
York, pp 274, 1941
29. DAVAINE C. Traité des entozoaires et des maladies vermineuses de l'homme et des animaux
domestiques, J-B Baillière et fils, Paris, pp 838, 1860
30. van DOEVEREN W. Observations physico-médicales sur les vers, qui se forment dans les
intestins; ou l'on traitement particulièrement du taenia, antrement dit, le ver solitaire, Lyon,
pp 369, 1764
31. DUJARDIN F. Histoire naturelle des helminthes our vers intestinaux, Librarie
Encyclopédique de Roret, Paris, pp 654, 1845
32. EBBELL B. Altägyptische Bezeichnungen für Krankheiten und Symptome. Skrifter Utgitt av
Det Norske Videnskaps-Akademi i Oslo. II. Hist.-Filos. Klasse, No. 3, pp 65, 1938
33. ESPEJO H. Tratamiento de infecciones por Hymenolepis nana, Taenia saginata, Taenia
solium y Diphyllobothrium pacificum con praziquantel. Boletín Chileno de Parasitología 32:
Taeniasis solium and Cysticercosis 379
39-40, 1977
34. ESCHRICHT DF. Anatomische-physiologische Untersuchungen ueber die Bothryocephalen.
Nova Acta Leopoldino-Carolinae Academiae (Breslau) 19, Suppl. 2: 3-152, 1841
35. EVANS RA. Cysticercosis in an athlete. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical
Medicine and Hygiene 32: 549-550, 1939
36. FAIRLEY NH. Cited in 72
37. FEHR JM. Hiera picra vel de Absynthio ad normam et formam Academiae Naturae
Curiosorum selecta, 1664; J Tresner, Lipsiae, pp 176, 1667
38. FLISSER A, PEREZ-MONTFORT R, LARRALDE C. The immunology of human and
animal cysticercosis: a review. Bulletin of the World Health Organization 57: 839-856, 1979
39. GABUCINUS H. De lumbricis alvum occupantibus etc., commentarius, H Scotus, Venetiis,
pp 56, 1547. Partly translated in 25
40. GALBRAITH HT. Tapeworm as a cause of chorea. Lancet i: 1348, 1904
41. GALENUS CC. Works of, In, Medicorum graecorum opera quae extant, edited by KG Kühn
(Greek text with Latin translation), Leipzig, 20 volumes, 1821-1833
42. GMELIN JF. Systema naturae per regna tria naturae, secundum classes, ordines, genera,
species cum characteribus differentiis, synonymis, locis, thirteenth edition, GE Beer, Lipsiae,
8 volumes, pp 3021-3909, 1788-1793
43. GOEZE JAE. Versuch einer Naturgeschichte der Eingeweidewürmer thierischer Körper, P A
Pape, Blankenburg, pp 471, 1782. Partly translated in 58
44. GOEZE JAE. Neueste Entdeckung dass di Finnen, im Schweinefleische keine
Drüsenkrankheit sondern wahre Blasenwürmer sind, etc, Halle, pp 40, 1784
45. GÖNNERT R, SCHRAUFSTÄTTER E. Experimentelle Untersuchungen mit
N-(2'-Chlor-4-nitrophenyl)-5-chlorsalicylamid, einem neuen Bandwurmmittel. I. Mitteilung:
Chemotherapeutische Versuche Arzneimittel-Forsch 10: 881-884, 1960
46. von GRAEFE A. Nächtragliche Bemerkungen über die modificirte Linear-extraction. Archiv
für Ophthalmologie 12: 150-223, 1866
47. GROLL E. Cisticercosis humana y praziquantel: una appreciacíon panorámica de las primeras
experiencas clínicas. Boletín Chileno de Parasitología 36: 29-37, 1981
48. HARTMANNUS PJ. Anatomia glandiorum. Miscellanea Curiosa Sive Ephemeridum Medico-
Physicarum Germanicarum Academiae Imperialis Leopoldinae Naturae Curiosorum Decuriae
II. Annus Septimus, Anni MDCLXXXVIII (1688) Observatio XXIV, Literis Joannis Ernesti
Adelbulneri, Nuremberg, pp 58-59, 1716. Partly translated in 58
49. HAUBNER GC, KÜCHENMEISTER F. Weitere Mittheilungen über die Entwickelung der
Band- und Blasenwürmer Nach den Versuchen von Dr. Küchenmeister und Dr. Haubner.
Magazin für die gesellschaft Thierheilkunde 20: 366-368, 1854; 21: 100-118, 1855
50. HELLER A. In, Cyclopaedia of the practice of medicine (H von Ziemssen, editor), volume 3,
Chronic infectious diseases, translated by AH Buck, The Sydenham Society, London, pp
595-613, 1875
51. HIPPOCRATES. Works of, De morbis, Book IV, section 5, translated by WH Jones and ET
Whithington, Loeb Classical Library, four volumes, 1948-1953
52. HOEPPLI R. Parasites and parasitic infections in early medicine and science, University of
Malaya Press, Singapore, pp 526, 1959
53. HOLLENBACH. Wochenschrift der Thierheilkunde und Viehzucht 2: 301, 353, 1859
54. HUMBERT A. Cited in 14
55. JACKSON FC. The treatment of tapeworm infestation with dichlorophen. South African
Medical Journal 30: 853-854, 1956
56. JENNER W. On tapeworm and its treatment by the oil of male fern. Association Medical
Journal 4: 718-721, 1856
57. JUDSON JE. Tapeworms as a possible cause of diabetes. Lancet ii: 1256, 1903
58. KEAN BH, MOTT JE, RUSSELL AJ. Tropical medicine and parasitology. Classic
investigations, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, two volumes, pp 677, 1978
59. KHALIL M. An early contribution to medical helminthology translated from the writings of
the Arabian physician Ibn Sina (Avicenna) with a short biography. Journal of Tropical
Medicine and Hygiene 25: 65-67, 1922
60. KNORR R. Bandwürmbehandlung mit Yomesan abei 36 Patienten. Medizinische Klinik
(München) 55: 1937-1938, 1960
380 A History of Human Helminthology
BC Tapeworms in humans and cysticerci in animals were known but their true
nature was not appreciated. Multiple remedies, including extract of male
fern (filix mas), were described for intestinal taeniasis
c.1550 Kamala and kousso were introduced as antitapeworm agents
1558 Rumler probably described cysticerci in a human
1683 Tyson discovered the head of a tapeworm
1688 Hartmann discovered the verminous nature of C. cellulosae in pigs
1784 Goeze pointed out the similarities between the heads of tapeworms found
in the human intestinal tract and the invaginated heads in C. cellulosae in
pigs
1854 van Beneden reported that he had generated C. cellulosae in the muscles
of a pig fed with T. solium ova
1855 Küchenmeister fed C. cellulosae in pork to a condemned murderer and
recovered small tapeworms several days later
1855 Humbert infected himself with C. cellulosae then began passing segments
of T. solium three months later
1856 Ransom described the diagnosis of intestinal taeniasis by finding eggs on
microscopical examination of the faeces
1860 Küchenmeister fed C. cellulosae in pork to a condemned murderer 4 and
2.5 months prior to execution, then recovered a large number of adult T.
solium, one being five feet in length
1926 Roth demonstrated calcified cysticerci by radiography
1934 Fairley showed that antibodies were present in the sera of patients with
cysticercosis
1960 Niclosamide was introduced for the treatment of intestinal taeniasis
1977 Praziquantel was introduced for the treatment of intestinal taeniasis
1980 Praziquantel was shown to be effective in cysticercosis
__________________________________________________________________
Chapter 14
SYNOPSIS
Tapeworms have been known for generations (see chapter 13), but conceptions
about the three species of large tapeworms that commonly infect man, Taenia
solium, T. saginata and Diphyllobothrium latum , were hopelessly confuse d
and intermingled for many centuries. As discussed in Chapter 15, D. latum
began to be recognized as a separate entity in the seventeenth century, leaving
the other two species lumped together under the name, amongst many others,
of T. solium. Distinction between D. latum and the species of Taenia was
relatively easy, even when a head was not available for examination, because
the shape of the proglottids and the position of the genital pore were quit e
different. It was another matter with the worms we now know as T. solium and
T. saginata, however, for the distinguishing fe atures in the proglottids are much
more subtle and their classification required a knowledge of their interna l
anatomy, particularly the branches of the uterus. It required the discovery o f
tapeworm heads before definite distinction between these two species wa s
385
386 A History of Human Helminthology
achieved. Remarkably though, 170 years were to pass after Tyson's discovery
of the head of a tapeworm (see chapter 13), before general agreement on the
two species was obtained.
In 1700, Nicolas Andry de Boisregard described, under the name T. solium
or Taenia sans épine (Taenia without thorns), a cestode which was none other
than T. saginata 2. Andry not only provided illustrations of the proglottids, but
also, for the first time, gave drawings of the head of a tapeworm obtained from
a human. The scolex had no hooks and there is no doubt that this worm was T.
saginata, but he was completely unaware of the existence of two species o f
Taenia. Vallisneri in 1714 again made the same mistake, describing an d
figuring T. saginata under the name of T. solium 39. As discussed in chapter 15,
Charles Bonnet then drew a hybrid tapeworm in 1750, with the head of T.
saginata and the body of D. latum; he did, however, correct this error in 1777.
Again, in his Systema Naturae (1758), Linnaeus, under the designation T.
solium, described what was in fact a T. saginata as the typical form of the
Taenia infecting Man, although he did note that the worm had some variations
in its appearance 27. Peter Pallas was also confused by this variability. He wrote
that T. solium (which he called T. cucurbitina, and to which he ascribed a
crown of thorns) was sometimes delicate, thin and narrow, and at other times,
stout, thick and fat 31. Although he did not realize it, he was in fact describing
T. solium and T. saginata, respectively.
Johannes Goeze, recognizing both the morphological differences and th e
variations in the geographical distribution of the two forms, in 1782, separated
the human taeniid tapeworms into two categories:
I know and possess two species of intestinal tapeworm; the first is well known - long,
with thick, fattened segments which I shall call Taenia cucurbitina, grandis,
saginata. The second seems to be a variety of the first, which under all circumstances
remains the same and is found in my part of the country more frequently than the
former; I call it Taenia cucurbitina, plana, pellucida.12
Like Pallas, Goeze called these worms T. cucurbitina. His name of Taenia
cucurbitina, grandis, saginata indicated that one parasite was large and fat ,
while the Taenia cucurbitina, plana, pellucida reflected the flat and
transparent nature of the other tapeworm. Goeze possessed nine specimens of
T. saginata, seven without heads and two complete examples. He wrote that:
It is truly amazing to compare the pieces of this flattened tapeworm with others. The
most mature lower segments are not as long as in the flat, transparent variety, but are
much thicker. Some have the thickness of half a line [1mm] and are all marked with
little lines lengthwise on the surface. In a section of worm more than one ell [an
English ell is 1.13 metres and a Flemish ell is 68 cm] in length, the marginal openings
are set in each segment, one on each segment, some right, some left....In the next ell
of this specimen, the segments are much narrower and almost pushed one on top of
the other and thereby give a considerable thickness. 12
Goeze was intrigued by variations in position of the marginal openings for he
noted that "The order in the position of the marginal openings, which is hardly
ever the same, still remains very puzzling and yet it cannot be withou t
Taeniasis saginata 387
purpose"12. He did not dwell at length on the appearances of the two heads of
the Taenia cucurbitina, grandis, saginata that he possessed, merely writing:
In the first specimen the head is not flat and ribbonlike but round, ascarislike; in the
latter, however, it is flatter. I am only adding that the head end of both of these
specimens is completely different from the head end of the notched, segmented
tapeworm from the cat, as mere observation shows. In the first, however, one cannot
see, as in the cat's tapeworm, the suckers and the hooks with the naked eye, and the
segments only start after a very narrow neck.12
Goeze then went on to contrast the appearance of the flat, transparent variety,
Taenia cucurbitina, plana, pellucida (i.e. T. solium), after first proving that it
was not simply an immature form of Taenia cucurbitina, grandis, saginata.
Goeze had several specimens of Taenia cucurbitina, plana, pellucida which
were complete with head. He noted that the dendritic ramifications of the uterus
were far more defined and visible in this form of tapeworm than in Taenia
cucurbitina, grandis, saginata, then he described definitively the head of the
tapeworm now called T. solium:
The head of the worm is like a small box and not round. At the four corners of the
head there are four suckers and a superior rostellum which can be seen through the
microscope.12
In addition, the accompanying figures indicate clearly the four suckers and the
crown with two rows of hooks.
Although Goeze's description of the head of T. solium was unequivocal, he
did not stress (and perhaps was not aware of) the value of this feature i n
distinguishing T. solium from T. saginata, the latter species not having a crown
of hooks. Just before Goeze published his findings, M. Bloch, a physician in
Berlin, contributed a discourse which won the gold medal given by th e
Academy of Science at Copenhagen for its prize essay set in 1780. The title of
this essay was "Concerning the seeds of intestinal worms: whether tapeworms
etc. are inborn in animals or enter from outside". Amongst other things, Bloch
proposed in this essay a classif ication of tapeworms in which, for the first time,
the presence or absence of hooks on the head was used as a specific character.
Although he divided the genus Taenia into the "inarmatae" containing 1 6
species and the "armatae" with four species, he did not use this feature t o
differentiate between the human tapeworms, T. saginata and T. solium 7.
Several years later, Batsch expresse d similar views to Goeze. As with Pallas,
he preferred the name T. cucurbitina and distinguished two constant varieties
within this species; these were recognizable by the features mentioned b y
Goeze, as well as upon the ramifications of the uterine branches that he noted.
In addition, Batsch was also aware of regional variations in the relativ e
frequencies of the forms of tapeworms 3.
Nevertheless, these judicious observations largely passed unnoticed or were
ignored. T. saginata continued to be confounded with T. solium, or was simply
considered as a variety of the latter. Thus in Berlin, Rudolphi saw onl y
specimens of Taenia with hooks, while Bremser in Vienna, by contrast ,
encountered only Taenia without hooks. Indeed, Bremser 8 believed, along with
388 A History of Human Helminthology
FS Leuckart and Mehlis, that all young taeniae had hooks and lost them with
advancing age, just as an ageing man loses his hair. In 1830, Nicolai agai n
drew attention to the presence of hooks in on e form of tapeworm and named the
parasite T. dentata 29, but his views were still not heeded. Further examples of
regional variations in the type of tapeworm present were described. Thus ,
Wawruch noted that in the parts of Wurtemberg situated in the Danube basin,
only unarmed taeniae were present, while in the region in the Necker basin ,
only armed Taenia occurred40. Similarly in Java, Schmidtmuller examined 148
taeniae in the space of 15 years, and finding them all to be unarmed, name d
them Bothriocephalus tropicus. The situation became so confused that neither
Dujardin (1845) nor Diesing (1849-1851) in their major textbooks admitted
two distinct species of Taenia infecting humans.
In 1852, Friedrich Küchenmeister declared that there were definitely tw o
distinct species of Taenia, clearly distinguishable, not only by their genera l
appearances, but particularly by the structures of their heads and thei r
reproductive systems. He observed that the head of T. solium was armed with
hooks, whereas the other species, which was also larger and fatter, was always
bare of hooks. Again, there were 9-15 lateral uterine branches in the proglottids
of T. solium whereas the other species had 15-20 such branches. To this latter
species, Küchenmeister gave the name T. mediocanellata, the specific epithet
denoting a main transverse channel running through the region between th e
four sucking discs 19,20. When Leuckart reviewed this matter a few years later,
he gave Küchenmeister little credit:
In 1852, Küchenmeister again advanced the opinion that besides T. solium there was
another large-jointed species to be distinguished in man....if Küchenmeister had been
better acquainted with the literature of helminthology, and had consulted it more
carefully, he would have learned that his discovery was not as new as he supposed,
but was rather only a confirmation and extension of observations which would have
long since been fully settled if the observers had a more rich and complete material
to work upon.26
This comment was typical of Leuckart's penchant for unfair criticism o f
Küchenmeister. The fact is that the distinction between T. saginata and
T. solium was not generally recognized until Küchenmeister's publication, but
was accepted thereafter.
Not only was Küchenmeister's designation, T. mediocanellata, founded on
an erroneous anatomical idea, but some of the purists objected to thi s
nomenclature on the suspect ground that t he term "mediocanellata" was derived
from a combination of Greek and Latin roots. Some authors consequentl y
preferred the term T. inerme or T. inermis to describe T. saginata. This created
a dilemma since such usage flew in the face of precedent, but the problem was
solved when Leuckart in 1867 pointed out that Goeze had earlier used th e
designation "saginata" to describ e this species and that the correct name should
therefore be T. saginata 25,26. This name was then adopted generally, although
first Leuckart then Blanchard 6 considered that it would be more in keeping with
Taeniasis saginata 389
a mature segment of T. saginata about four feet long to a four week old calf,
then reinfected the animal one week later with smaller pieces of the sam e
tapeworm. The animal appeared well but then died suddenly on 8 December.
At post-mortem examination, all the muscles and some of the visceral organs
as well as the lymphatics were permeated with:
cysts which were 1.5-3 mm wide and 2-4 mm in length. They had a whitish
appearance as though filled with a chalky or caseous mass, as I had never observed
in any young cysts of the Cysticercus cellulosae in a similar way. Inside the exudative
layer, which was surrounded by a firm connective tissue membrane, they contained
a light, clear vesicle of 0.4-1.7 mm in diameter. On cutting into this cyst, this
protruded and proved on closer examination to be a young cysticercus....At this stage
of development, no suckers could be found. The inner parts of the head cone showed
little enlargement of the end, and in the region of the smaller cysticerci it was a simple
conical shape.24
Leuckart then repeated the experiment and infected another calf with 25-3 0
proglottids of T. saginata. The animal became quite sick during the third week
after infection, but then recovered completely. Seven weeks after infection, a
biopsy was taken from the sternomastoid muscles and about a dozen cysticerci
were obtained. In contrast to the scolex of C. cellulosae:
this head cone was without a bend and in spite of its small size (hardly 1 mm), also
in spite of the small size of the vesicle (3-4 mm), was already provided with
completely developed suckers. Instead of the protruding hooks, there was on the
bottom of the invagination, between the suckers, a tight circle of small rudiments. 24
Leuckart believed that the larval stage of T. saginata may lag behind that of
T. solium with respect to size, and that this might partly account for it having
escaped the attention of helminthologists up to that time. He concluded that
by these experiments he had established beyond any doubt the specifi c
nature of T. saginata and, furthermore, that he had shown that infection with
this parasite was acquired by humans from cattle and possibly othe r
ruminants22,23.
Leuckart's findings were confirmed twice in 1863 by Mosler 28, by Cobbold
and Simonds in 1864 and again in 1865 38, then by Roll (1865), Gerlach (1870),
Zurn (1872), Saint-Cyr (1873), Jolicoeur ( 1873), Masse and Pourquier (1876),
Perroncito (1877) and others. Various investigators confirmed the earl y
observations that pigs and sheep were insusceptible to this species of tape -
worm, and demonstrated that rabbits were likewise inhospitable hosts. Th e
cysticercus was designated Cysticercus ex Taenia mediocanellatae by Davaine
then as C. bovis by Cobbold 10; the latter name has stuck. One wonders why so
many investigators felt it necessary to confirm these findings. Perhaps the y
wanted a ready demonstration of the almost incredible phenomenon of th e
migration of worms and the alternation of generations, and this provided a
convenient excuse and a workable system. Perhaps they wanted to prove their
mastery over these worms. Perhaps it simply gave them a feeling of achieve-
ment and satisfaction. In any event, it was c lear that cattle were the intermediate
host of T. saginata, and that humans were likely to acquire infection with this
Taeniasis saginata 391
Although rare claims have been made for findin g C. bovis in humans11, the clin-
ical manifestations of infection with this parasite, for all practical purposes ,
devolve from the presence of intestinal worms. Consequently, the symptom s
and signs are much the same as have been described already for taeniasi s
solium. Proglottids of T. saginata are said to break off more easily than those
of T. solium and Küchenmeister has a particularly graphic description of their
passage which he notes may occur either in the faeces or separately:
The segments pass when the patient is standing quietly and falling into his trousers,
he suddenly has a moist and cool feeling about the legs, and when he seeks to free
himself from this unpleasant sensation, finds a single proglottis attached to or creeping
about the leg. Women especially are afraid lest the proglottides should fall unperceived
upon the ground when they are walking or standing. 21
Presumably they were grateful for the invention of elastic underwear! It ha s
been concluded that 8-9 proglottids are produced per worm per day34. These
tapeworms might also reach remarkable lengths. One patient treated wit h
extract of kamala passed three yards of T. saginata, and then on being treated
again almost immediately with oil of male fern, passed a further 11 yards ,
together with the head, making 14 yards of tapeworm in total 1. Despite their
ability to reach huge sizes, these worms rarely cause intestinal obstruction ,
although several cases of this complication are on record 9. It has even been
claimed that a complete T. saginata, ten feet long, has been removed from the
gall bladder of an old man with acute cholecystitis 4. Infections may also be
multiple. In 1893, Bérenger-Férand 5 reviewed 2686 cases and found that one
worm was present in 87% of persons, two were present in 7.8% and 2.3% had
three tapeworms. Cases with more t han 5 worms was exceptional although one
patient was claimed to have 27 T. saginata and another, 59 tapeworms. More
certain is the patient of Hodson who, when treated in the Khartoum Civi l
Hospital with filix mas, produced 31 specimens of T. saginata 13.
Observations over the centuries have sho wn that the prognosis is good in this
infection since there is no likelihood of people developing cysticercosis.
REFERENCES
1. ANONYMOUS. A case in which fourteen yards of Taenia mediocanellata were voided with
the head. (Under the care of Dr. Murchison). British Medical Journal ii: 86, 1867
2. ANDRY de BOISREGARD N. De la génération des vers dans le corps de l'homme. Avec trois
lettres sur les sujets des vers, les deux premières....par M. Nicolas Hartsoeker et l'autre ....par
M. Georges Baglivi, Laurent d'Houry, Paris, pp 468, 1700. An account of the breeding of
worms in human bodies etc., translated by H Rhodes and A Bell, pp 266, 1701
3. BATSCH AJ. Naturgeschichte der Bandwurmgattung überhaupt und ihrer Arten insbesondere,
Halle, pp 298, 1786
4. BENEDICT EB. Taenia saginata in the gall bladder. Journal of the American Medical
Association 87: 1917, 1926
5. BÉRENGER-FÉRAND. Du nombre et de la longueur des taenias que l'on rencontré chez
l'homme. Bulletin de l'Académie de Médecine 29: 12-15, 1893
6. BLANCHARD R. Traité de zoologie médicale, J-B Baillière et fils, Paris, two volumes, pp
1689, 1885-1890
7. BLOCH M. Abhandlung von der Erzeugang der Eingeweidewürmer und den Mitteln wider
dieselben. Eine von der königlich dänischen Societät der Wissenschaften zu Copenhagen
gekrönte Preisschrift, Sigismund Friedrich Hesse, Berlin, pp 54, 1782
8. BREMSER JG. Ueber lebende Würmer im lebenden Menschen. Ein Buch für ausübende
Aertze. Mit nach der Natur gezeichneten Abbildungen auf vier Tafeln. Nebst einem Anhange
über Pseudo-helminthen, Carl Schaumburg und Comp., Wien, pp 284, 1819
9. CHRISTOPHERSON JB, IZZEDIN M. Acute intestinal obstruction by tapeworms (T.
saginata): mechanical blocking of the ileo-caecal valves, necessitating laparotomy. British
Medical Journal i: 697-698, 1918
10. COBBOLD TS. Parasites: a treatise on the entozoa of man and animals including some
account of the ectozoa, J&A Churchill, London, pp 500, 1878
11. FONTAN C. Cysticercus bovis chez l'homme localisé à la région mammaire. Taenia inerme
de l'intestin. Parasitism adulte et larvaire chez le meme sujet. Gazette des Hôpitaux 92:
183-185, 1919
12. GOEZE JAE. Versuch einer Naturgeschichte der Eingeweidewürmer thierischer Körper, P A
Pape, Blankenburg, pp 471, 1782. Partly translated in 17
13. HODSON VS. Tapeworm hospitality. Lancet ii: 728, 1921
14. HUBER. Notizen über das Vorkommen pflanzicher und thierischer Parasiten in unserm
Bezirk. 13 Bericht die Naturhistorische Vereins in Augsburg, pp 121-129, 1860
15. ISOBE M. (On the resistance of the egg of Taenia saginata.) Taiwan Igakkai Zasshi No. 222,
pp 29-75, 1922. In Japanese, with English summary
16. JUDAS A. Nouveau documents sur la fréquence du Taenia en Algérie. Receuil de Mémoires
de Médecine, de Chirugie et de Pharmacie Militaires 13: 230, 1860
17. KEAN BH, MOTT KE, RUSSELL AJ. Tropical medicine and parasitology. Classic
investigations, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, two volumes, pp 677, 1978
18. KNOX R. Observations on the Taenia solium; and on its removal from the human intestinal
canal by spirits of turpentine. Edinburgh Medical and Surgical Journal 17: 384-393, 1821
19. KÜCHENMEISTER F. Ueber eine neue Taenia des Menschen, Taenia mediocanellata
hominis, seu Zittauensis (mihi). Deutsche Klinik 4: 101-103, 1852
20. KÜCHENMEISTER F. Ueber Cestoden im Allgemeinen und die des Menschen insbesondere
etc., Zittau, pp 148, 1853
21. KÜCHENMEISTER F. Die in und an dem Körper des lebenden Menschen vorkommenden
Parasiten. Ein Lehr- und Handbuch der Diagnose und Behandlung der thierischen und pflanz-
ischen Parasiten des Menschen, BG Teubner, Leipzig, two volumes, pp 486, 1855. On animal
and vegetable parasites of the human body. A manual of their natural history, diagnosis and
treatment. 1. Animal parasites belonging to the group Entozoa, translated by E Lankester, The
Sydenham Society, London, pp 452, 1857
22. LEUCKART R. Ueber Taenia solium und T. mediocanellata (Helminthologische
Experimentaluntersuchungen 2). Nachrichten von der königlich Gesellschaft der
Wissenschaften und der GeorgAugusts Universität, Göttingen, pp 15-21, 1862.
Taeniasis saginata 395
23. LEUCKART R. Ueber den Finnenzustand der Taenia mediocanellata. Nachrichten von der
königlich Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften und der Georg-Augusts Universität, Göttingen, pp
195-206, 1862
24. LEUCKART R. Die menschlichen Parasiten unddie von ihnen herrührenden Krankheiten. Ein
Hand- und Lehrbuch für Naturforscher und Aertze, C F Winter'sche Verlagshandlung, Leipzig,
volume 1, pp 776, 1863. Partly translated in 17
25. LEUCKART R. Bericht über die wissenschaftlichen Leistungen in der Naturgeschichte der
niederen Thiere während der Jahre 1866 und 1867. Archiv für Naturgeschichte 33J, 2:
163-304, 1867
26. LEUCKART R. Die Parasiten des Menschen und die von ihnen herrührenden Krankheiten.
Ein Hand- und Lehrbuch für Naturforscher und Aertze, CF Winter'sche Verlagshandlung,
Leipzig, volume 1, pp 1009, 1879-1886. The parasites of man and the diseases which proceed
from them. A textbook for students and practitioners, translated by WE Hoyle, YoungJ
Pentland, Edinburgh, pp 771, 1886
27. LINNAEUS C. Systema naturae per regna tria naturae, secundum classes,ordines, genera,
species, cum characteribus, differentiis, synonymis locis, tenth edition, L Salvii, Holmiae, two
volumes, pp 823, 1758
28. MOSLER KF. Helminthologische Studien und Beobachtungen, A Hirschwald, Berlin, pp 89,
1864
29. NICOLAI KF. Zur Geschichte der Bandwürmer. Neuer Zeitschrift für Natur- und Heilkund
1: 464-471, 1830
30. OLIVER JH. Cited in Seventh Annual Report of the Sanitary Commissioner (1870) of the
Government of India, Calcutta, pp 82-83, 1871
31. PALLAS PS. Bemerkungen über die Bandwürmer in Menschen und Thieren. Neue nordische
Beyträge Physikalische und Geographische Erd- und Völkerbeschriften 1: 39-112, 1781
32. PAWLOWSKI Z, SCHULTZ MG. Taeniasis and cysticercosis (Taenia saginata). Advances
in Parasitology 10: 269-343, 1972
33. PENFOLD HB. The life history of Cysticercus bovis in the tissues of the ox. Medical Journal
of Australia i: 579-583, 1937
34. PENFOLD WJ, PENFOLD HB, PHILLIPSM. Taenia saginata: its growth and propagation.
Journal of Helminthology 15; 41-48, 1937
35. PENFOLD WJ, PENFOLD HB, PHILLIPS M. Ridding pasture ofTaenia saginata ova by
grazing cattle or sheep. Journal of Helminthology 14: 135-140, 1936
36. PERRONCITO E. On the tenacity of life of the cysticercus in the flesh of oxen and on the
rapid development of the corresponding Taenia mediocanellata in the human body. The
Veterinarian 50: 817-818, 1877
37. RANSOM BH. The destruction of the vitality of Cysticercus bovis by freezing. Journal of
Parasitology 1: 5-9, 1914
38. SIMONDS JB, COBBOLD TS. On the production of the so-called "acute cestode
tuberculosis" by the administration of proglottides of Taenia mediocanellata. Proceedings of
the Royal Society 14: 214-220, 1865
39. VALLISNERI A. Opera fisico-mediche stampate e manoscritte, raccolte da Antonio suo
figliuolo, S Coleti, Venezia, three volumes, pp 469, 1733
40. WAWRUCH AI. Practische Monographie der Bandwürmkrankheit etc., C Gerold, Wien, pp
212, 1844
41. WEISSE JF. Wieder einmal über das rohe Fleisch. Journal für Kinderkrankheiten 16:
384-385, 1851
396 A History of Human Helminthology
BC Tapeworm infections in humans were known but the various species were
not distinguished. Various anthelmintics were used
1700 Andry drew an illustration of Taenia saginata although he called it
T. solium
1782 Goeze recognized two forms of Taenia but little notice was taken of this
observation
1852 Küchenmeister clearly distinguished T. saginata from T. solium on the
basis of the morphology of the head and the number of lateral branches of
the uterus
1861 Leuckart generated Cysticercus bovis in a calf fed with T. saginata
proglottids
1868-9 Oliver, in a poorly-controlled study, observed T. saginata infection in
persons who ate measly beef
1877 Perroncito infected a person with a single C. bovis and the subject began to
pass T. saginata proglottids 54 days later
1960 Niclosamide was introduced for treatment
1977 Praziquantel was introduced for treatment
___________________________________________________________________
Chapter 15
SYNOPSIS
Although tapeworms have been known since ancient times (see chapter 13), it
was not until around the beginning of the seventeenth century that it was
realized that more than one species of tapeworm infected humans. According
to Davaine 24, it is now apparent in retrospect that two Swiss observers, first
Thaddeus Dunus in Lucarno in 1592, then Gaspard Wolphius in Zurich, des-
cribed in a recognizable fashion, the worm now known as Diphyllobothrium
latum. Dunus wrote: "De lumbrico lato (mirae longitudinis): squamosus instar
serpentis, nisi rectius geniculatus dicatur, fotus sui simillimus" 26 meaning that
the broadworm of remarkable length had the scaly appearance of a snake
397
398 A History of Human Helminthology
except that the leading joints were attached and supported each other.
Nevertheless, these observers did not allude to the differences between this
worm and either of the two species of Taenia now known to infect humans. The
first person to do this, although his description is somewhat vague, was Felix
Platter (Platerus) in Basel (Switzerland) in 1602. Whereas his predecessors and
contemporaries called all tapeworms "Lumbricus latus", Platter discerned two
forms of tapeworms passed by humans. He called the first of these, Taenia
intestinorum, and this became known to later authors as Taenia prima plateri
(the first Taenia of Platter):
One is characterized by a kind of membranous skin, similar to the fabric of the small
intestine, equal to it in length but not at all empty inside as it, and about a finger's
breadth wide. This they call the Latum lumbricorum (the broad intestinal worm), but
more correctly it should be called the Taenia intestinorum (the taenia of the intestines)
since it has no likeness to the lumbricus; it is not alive, as is the lumbricus; nor is it
stirred from its place, but remains fixed for a long time until it is passed....On this
fascia there are generally transverse lines about a finger's breadth apart. They appear
along its whole length and resemble vertebrae, swelling out in the intervals between
them.63
The second form he called Taenia longissima, and this became known as
Taenia secunda plateri (the second Taenia of Platter) to later authors. It
probably refers to T. solium, but may possibly have been T. saginata:
On another occasion, very long taenia of the same type were observed. However, they
were shaped differently and appeared to be composed of many attached segments
which could be separated from one another. These segments, since gourds sometimes
bear square seeds, are called the vermis cucurbitinus. The worm is rarely passed
whole, but generally in many pieces. Previously, each of these individual pieces was
believed to have been an individual worm, called a cucurbitinus; however, they are
only pieces broken off from the fascia.63
Thus, the hallmark upon which Platter based his distinction between the two
species of worms was the shape of the proglottids. His descriptions were
incomplete and to some degree erroneous. He was unaware that tapeworms had
a head and does not appear to have realized that tapeworms were living
organisms.
In 1618, the Dutchman, Adrien van der Spiegel (Spigelius), probably without
being aware of the previous account, again reported the existence of two
distinct species of tapeworms in humans80. Nicholas Andry in 1700 also
recognized two types of tapeworms:
One has....a long Thorn full of knots running along the middle of its body upon the
upper side....The other wants this Thorn, but at every Joint upon the sides, has a sort
of small Nipple open at the Point.3
The first of these he labelled as Taenia à épine (Taenia with a spine) and the
second he called Taenia sans épine (Taenia without a spine). Perusal of his
illustrations of Taenia à épine leaves no doubt that the spine which he
described as running down the middle of the entire length of the worm is in fact
the medially-placed genital openings of the worm now called D. latum.
Diphyllobothriasis 399
Similarly, examination of his figures of Taenia sans épine clearly indicates that
the small nodules that he described at the margin of each proglottid are the
laterally-placed genital pores of T. solium or T. saginata. Thus, the key
distinguishing feature for Andry was the position of the genital apertures
(although he did not recognize them as such, considering them to be pulmonary
openings).
It is not certain who first saw the head of D. latum following the first
description of a tapeworm head by Edward Tyson in 1683. In 1750, in Geneva,
Charles Bonnet published his study of human tapeworms. In this work, he
emphasized the "stigmata umbilicialia" of the broad tapeworm and the
"stigmata lateralia" of Taenia, but he included a figure showing what
Blanchard11 later called "un être fanstastique" (a fantastic being) with the head
of a T. saginata and the body of Diphyllobothrium 12. In 1777, however,
Bonnet corrected his earlier publication and described the head of the broad
tapeworm in detail for the first time, noting its attenuated shape and the two
suctorial grooves, then went on to outline the appearance of the proglottids
("rings", as he called them)13. Shortly thereafter (1779), von Gleichen-
Rusworm likewise described the scolex of the worm31. Bremser in 1819 again
described the worm and created a new genus, renaming the worm Bothrio-
cephalus latus, to indicate that it was the broad worm with the grooved head18.
In 1841, Eschricht published the first detailed description of the anatomy of the
adult worm28. Nine years later, Diesing renamed the parasite Dibothrium
latum 25, then this was changed to Dibothriocephalus latus by Lühe in 189949.
Finally, the parasite was transferred by Lühe50 in 1910 to the genus
Diphyllobothrium erected by Cobbold in 185720. The generic name was
derived from a combination of the Greek words (DIS),
(PHYLLOS) and (BOTHROS) meaning "two", "leaf" and "groove" or
"sucker", respectively.
The origins and mode of transmission of this parasite remained obscure for
many years. Several epidemiological observations, however, pointed towards
the direction in which the solution would be found. As observers became more
confident in their ability to differentiate D. latum from other tapeworms, it
became apparent that this infection had a restricted geographical distribution.
These infections were at first unknown outside Europe and were thought to be
most common in Switzerland and adjacent areas of France, Scandinavia and the
Baltic regions. For example, in the early parts of the nineteenth century, one
quarter of the inhabitants of Geneva were said to be infected21. This indicated
to many commentators that there was something unusual about the mode of
transmission of this infection, but its nature was by no means clear.
400 A History of Human Helminthology
Since attempts to infect potential hosts with larvae derived from eggs were
unsuccessful, attention turned to the other end of the life cycle. As it was known
that other species of bothriocephali could be found in animals or birds which
either primarily or exclusively ate fish, Max Braun in Dorpat (Tartu), Estonia
(present-day Estonskaya SSR, USSR), decided to look for the intermediate host
of D. latum among the fish eaten ordinarily by the people living in his region.
He therefore examined fish brought to the market in Dorpat from Lake Peipus
and surrounding regions, and soon found young bothriocephali in pike (Esox
lucius) and burbot (Lota vulgaris). More than 90% of the fish in the market
were so infected, with variable numbers of unencapsulated worms being found
in the muscles and viscera. Such worms had been seen previously by Knoch in
St. Petersburg but he had not realized what they were. In fact, plerocercoids of
402 A History of Human Helminthology
The question still remained as to the manner in which the precursors of the
plerocercoids reached these fish. In 1883, Braun found five round holes in the
Diphyllobothriasis 403
killed six hours later and free procercoids were found in the stomach contents,
some with and some without caudal appendages. In a fish killed the next day,
Rosen found procercoids in the stomach wall. Four days after infection, he
believed that the larvae could be considered plerocercoids and they migrated
from the gut into the muscles and viscera. Rosen concluded his paper by
writing:
The life cycle of Dibothriocephalus latus is now completed: (1) by the negative result
of the direct infection of fish by ciliated larvae; (2) by the positive result of a mode of
development in cestodes unknown until now; that is, the existence of two
intermediate hosts....The development passes from the oncosphere to the plerocercoid
by an intermediate larva,....the procercoid.70
The following year, Rosen published another paper which provided further
details. In particular, the ciliated body emerging from the D. latum egg was
called a coracidium and the plerocercoid was defined by the development of
two suckers71. Unfortunately, what had begun in friendship and teamwork
between Janicki and Rosen turned sour. In this latter paper71, Rosen, because
he had carried out the last decisive experiment, tried to take the whole credit for
himself and launched a violent diatribe against Janicki. An unpleasant
controversy between the two followed, with Janicki replying to Rosen's attack39.
Von Bonsdorff has portrayed succinctly their subsequent paths: "Janicki, who
was an eminent parasitologist, became professor of zoology at Warszawa;
Rosen made no further scientific career"14.
Felix Platter was remarkably accurate in his summation of the clinical features
of this infection when he wrote in 1609:
While taeniae remain in the body, unless something else happens, few serious
symptoms occur from which it can be perceived that an individual carries this foulness
in his body before they pass unexpectedly, at which time they occasion great fright on
being found. There is a pressing desire to rake food much more often than was
customary and a certain heaviness in the stomach. If anything is in the stomach, it is
felt. The symptoms become worse when an intestinal worm dies or if a segment is
broken off from the others and putrefies.63
With the passage of time, however, all manner of ills were ascribed to this
worm. Thus, Abbotts Smith in 1863 wrote that anal itching, an itchy nose,
swollen abdomen, nausea, vertigo, palpitations during the night, fainting and
epigastric pain could all be caused by D. latum 1.
The clinical manifestations were put on a more certain basis when humans
were infected experimentally. The medical students infected by Braun17
developed malaise and abdominal pain three weeks after ingestion of plero-
cercoids. Le Bas has described in detail the clinical features in three humans
infected experimentally, and concluded that the effects were little more than
discomforting with transient diarrhoea at the onset of patent infection after two
406 A History of Human Helminthology
worm. Similar challenges one and two years later failed to produce patent
infections. In 1936, four years after the original infection, he again infected
himself with six plerocercoids and patent infection occurred; anthelmintic
therapy seven weeks later resulted in four heads and 26 metres of tapeworm.
Finally, Tarassov infected himself with seven more plerocercoids; he began to
pass eggs in his faeces 14 days later. While harbouring the worms, he had
much abdominal pain, lost 8 kg in weight, and weakness forced him into a
sanatorium. Five weeks after infection, he treated himself and expelled 38
metres of tapeworm with seven heads86. While these results could be inter-
preted as indicating transient immunity one and two years after the initial
infection, it is far more likely that those challenges were made with
non-infective plerocercoids. Certainly, there was no significant immunity
several months and several years after the first exposure to D. latum, and this
is probably the normal state of affairs.
In July 1877, Gustav Reyher in Dorpat (Tartu), Estonia (USSR), saw a 66 year
old woman who became steadily weaker and paler during the course of a year.
He diagnosed her as suffering from pernicious anaemia, a disease which had
been defined by Biermer in 1872. She also complained of intermittent
diarrhoea and on one such occasion had passed a segment of D. latum. Reyher
therefore treated her with extract of filix mas and was surprised to find that not
only was the worm expelled, but that within a few weeks, her general health
had returned to normal. Six months later, Reyher encountered a similar
situation in a 30 year old man; treatment resulted in an equally striking cure.
Rehyer then began to collect a series of such cases and by 1884 had seen 12
patients. In late 1883, he began to examine the wet blood films and found that
although the numbers of red cells were reduced markedly, they were often
larger than normal, and he also noted that the white cells were often reduced in
number. The results of this serendipitous bedside observation, which was
skilfully followed up, were finally published in June 188668
Independently of Reyher, JW Runeberg in Helsingfors (Helsinki), Finland
had been following a similar line. In 1883, he had seen a number of cases of
pernicious anaemia, all with a fatal outcome, and had been struck by the fact
that the majority of patients had D. latum in their intestines. Thereafter, the
faeces of patients who were seen in his clinic were examined systematically for
D. latum eggs and, if they were found, an anthelmintic was given. In September
1886, he reported his experiences at a Congress in Berlin; 12 of 19 patients
with pernicious anaemia were also infected with D. latum and all of these
persons were cured by expulsion of the worm73. Nevertheless, the Congress
received his communication with reserve.
It seems probable, however, that in addition to these two investigators, the
408 A History of Human Helminthology
The diagnosis of infection with D. latum was obvious if patients passed pro-
glottids and brought them along for identification. With the discovery that
helminth eggs are passed in the faeces, it became possible to diagnose infection
by microscopical examination of the stools. It is uncertain who first applied this
to diphyllobothriasis, but Davaine in his textbook of 1860 provided an
illustration of the appearances of such eggs in the faeces23. When the
association between D. latum infection and pernicious anaemia was
appreciated later that century, physicians in endemic areas realized that it was
necessary to exclude diphyllobothriasis in patients with this form of anaemia.
occurred in female Jews who were in the habit of tasting raw fish to test their
skill in flavouring it.
A number of studies were consequently undertaken to determine the primary
and secondary intermediate host of infection in this region. Procercoids were
shown to develop in D. oregonensis 29, D. silicis and D. silicoides53 , while
plerocercoids were found in Stizostedeon canadense-griseum, S. vitreum, Esox
lucius and Lota maculosa 88. Moreover, it was found that heavy infections in
fish occurred in some lakes near which there was a very sparse human
population. Since it was known that carnivores, including dogs, foxes, otters,
bears and cats can harbour adult D. latum, the high frequency of dogs in the
area suggested that these animals may be an important reservoir of infection.
On the other hand, eggs from dog faeces were much less likely to hatch active
coracidia (1.5%) c.f. ova in human faeces (80%)53. The relative contributions
of the various definitive hosts remains obscure, however, as their inputs have
not been subjected to precise mathematical analysis. In any case, investigations
in the USSR subsequently showed that eggs from dogs developed almost as
frequently as eggs from humans, albeit more slowly85.
Continued observations revealed that infection was not only endemic in fish
in Lake Superior and its surrounds, but also in lakes which drained through
Lake Winnipeg into Hudson Bay53. Eventually, endemic foci of infection were
found in Eskimos in northwest Canada and in Alaska. Similarly, the parasite
was introduced into Chile and became established in the Andean Lake District
some 800 kilometres south of Santiago, with Salmo lacustris and S. irideus
proving to be secondary intermediate hosts56.
In 1947, Stoll estimated that there were just over 10 million people infected
with D. latum, about one quarter of them in Europe and most of the rest in the
USSR with small foci in North America, South America and Japan83. Within
the Soviet Union, the broad tapeworm had been first reported by Pallas in St.
Petersburg (Leningrad) in 1781. Subsequent surveys indicated that the
prevalence of infection in Leningrad before the Second World War was
somewhere between 5 and 10% of the population. This region was at first
regarded as the centre of infection, but it became apparent that the worm was
widespread within the USSR, including Siberia62. Very high rates of infection
were found in the Baltic region, for example, around 70% of the population of
the western shore of Lake Peipus in Estonia were infected in 1926. Similarly,
in Finland,which had long been one of the best known zones of endemic
diphyllobothriasis, frequencies varying between 0 and 100% were found in
different parts of the country; parasitism was most frequent in the
Finno-Ungarian linguistic group, probably as a result of their dietary customs10.
In some areas, industrialization altered the ecology and favoured the spread
of infection. Increased intensities of infection sometimes occurred around new
reservoirs in regions where D. latum was infrequent previously, such as on the
Volga River in the USSR69. Similarly, construction of the Moscow Canal
allowed the development of permanent new foci of infection. On the other hand,
Diphyllobothriasis 413
out in the USSR ever since World War II and about 65 million people are
examined annually. The results have been gratifying in some places but
discouraging in others, particularly in the Volga river region64.
In Finland, the attitude was passive for many years, particularly because
people cherished the idea that an absence of the worm was a sign of poor
health. In 1949, however, a pamphlet was published by a hygienist named
Savonen who pointed out that the abundance of D. latum blemished the repute
of Finnish public health. In the next few years, educational campaings were
begun and registration of new cases was made compulsory in 1955. In 1963,
the State Medical Board issued instructions that educational campaigns should
be expanded. The result was that the number of cases registered dropped from
nearly 34,000 in 1959 to just under 3,000 in 197514.
D. PACIFICUM
The adult tapeworm, which is normally a parasite of fur seals, was first
described by Nybelin in 193158, then renamed D. pacificum by Margolis in
195654. All the cases of human infection with this parasite have been reported
from the western border of South America (Peru and Chile) and from Japan,
the first ones being described by Baer and colleagues in 19677. The infection
was acquired by eating undercooked saltwater fish. The clinical features were
similar to those seen in diphyllobothriasis latum and the condition was found
to respond to treatment with praziquantel 51.
D. URSI
This parasite was described in the brown bear (Ursus arctos) in Alaska by
Rausch in 1954. It has been described in a human recently55.
OTHER SPECIES
REFERENCES
1. ABBOTTS SMITH M. On human entozoa: comprising the description of the different species
of worms found in the intestines and other parts of the human body and the pathology and
treatment of the various affections produced by their presence, HK Lewis, London, pp 245,
1863
2. ABILDGAARD PC. Almindelige Betragntninger over Indvoldeorme, Bemaerkninger ved
Diphyllobothriasis 415
BC Tapeworm infections in humans were known but the species were not
distinguished. Various anthelmintics were used
1592 Dunus described tapeworms with morphological features now recognized
as those of Diphyllobothrium
1602 Platter differentiated Diphyllobothrium from Taenia on the basis of the
shape of the proglottids
1700 Andry described Diphyllobothrium as "Taenia à épine" to indicate the
central "spine" due to the medially placed genital pores of
Diphyllobothrium c.f. the lateral pores of Taenia
1747 Spöring drew attention to the relationship between broad tapeworm
infection and human habitation near water with an increased consumption
of fish
1777 Bonnet illustrated the head of the adult worm
1860 Davaine described diagnosis by finding eggs in the faeces
1881 Braun found larvae (plerocercoids) resembling Diphyllobothrium in pike,
burbot and other fish, then produced patent infection with adult worms in
dogs fed with plerocercoids
1882 Braun produced patent infections in humans who ingested plerocercoids
1877-86 Reyher found that pernicious anaemia was cured in patients who were also
infected with D. latum and in whom the worm was eradicated with
anthelmintics
1883-86 Runeberg made observations similar to those of Reyher
1901 Hamilton reported a case which had been unequivocally acquired in North
America
1917 Janicki found very young larvae of Diphyllobothrium (procercoids) in the
stomach of fish which also contained many copepods and thought that
copepods may be the primary intermediate host
1917 Rosen independently found procercoids in the body cavity of certain species
of copepods, observed the development of coracidia obtained from D. latum
eggs in these copepods, then obtained plerocercoids in fish by infecting
them with procercoids
1928 Isaacs and colleagues treated successfully tapeworm pernicious anaemia by
the administration of raw liver, even though the parasite persisted
1948 von Bonsdorff showed that tapeworms competed with the human host for
dietary vitamin B12
1963 Soininen showed that niclosamide was effective therapy
1977 Praziquantel was introduced for treatment by various investigators
__________________________________________________________________
Chapter 16
B. STUDERI
B. MUCRONATA
The adult tapeworm was first recovered from a howler monkey (Alouatta
nigra) in Paraguay by Meyner in 189578. The first human infection was
described in 1928 by Cram who studied specimens recovered from a young
Spaniard by Dr Alberto Recio in Cuba25. A number of further cases have been
reported from the Americas, some being described as B. studeri, but the
modern view is that they were probably B. mucronata 9.
421
422 A History of Human Helminthology
D. GRANDIS
D. FUKUOKAENSIS
In 1970, Kamo and Miyakai described this worm as a new species. The
parasite was recovered from a girl in Japan60.
DIPYLIDIASIS
A cyclophyllidean tapeworm of dogs and cats, 10-70 cm long, has been known
for generations. It was named Taenia osculis marginalibus oppositus by
Linnaeus in 1748, Taenia canina by him in 175873, T. cucumerina by Bloch
in 1782 19 Dipylidium cucumerinum by Leuckart in 186370 , then Dipylidium
caninum by Railliet in 189288. The generic name is derived from a combination
of the Greek words (DIS) and (PYLIS) meaning "two" and "gate",
respectively.
The life cycle of the parasite was first investigated by Melnikov who showed
in 1869 that when eggs were ingested by the dog louse, Trichodectes canis, the
hexacanth embryos were liberated in the intestines then migrated to the body
cavity where they tranformed into cysticercoids 77. Although this was later
disputed by Zimmerman122, who could not infect these lice experimentally, the
validity of this vector is generally accepted. Sonsino, in 1888, examined the
possible role of fleas in transmission but convinced himself that the mouthparts
of fleas were too small to allow ingestion of Dipylidium eggs100. In the
following year, however, Grassi and Rovelli showed that eggs hatched in the
intestines of the dog flea, Pulex serraticeps (= Ctenocephalides canis), and the
Miscellaneous Cestode Infections 423
human flea, Pulex irritans, then migrated into the body cavity where they
developed into procercoid then cysticercoid larvae43. They noted that the itch
induced by these arthropods caused the dogs to paw and gnaw at the skin, then
bite and swallow the vectors.
The first human case of dipylidiasis was seen by in 1751 by Godefridus
Dubois, a pupil of Linnaeus. Dubois wrote: "est Taenia species quae....
vulgarites in canibus et saepissime apud homines invenitur"31 meaning that this
tapeworm was commonly found in dogs but rarely in humans. A second spec-
imen recovered from a 13 year old boy in Blasius, then deposited by Mekel in
the Museum of Comparative Anatomy in Halle, was re-examined by Leuckart
who concurred with its identification as D. caninum 70. Salzmann of Esslingen
then found the parasite in a 16 month old child in 186194. Infections have since
been reported sporadically from many parts of the world, most of the affected
individuals being children. The clinical manifestations are similar to those seen
in taeniasis, and niclosamide has been found to be an effective remedy55.
HYMENOLEPIASIS
HYMENOLEPIS DIMINUTA
The clinical features are usually minimal, and the infection has been shown to
respond to treatment with niclosamide 55.
H. NANA
This tapeworm was discovered in 1851 by Theodor Bilharz during the autopsy
of a boy in Egypt who had died from meningitis. He wrote to his mentor, von
Siebold, in Germany, describing his findings:
The first incision into the intestine....disclosed immediately large numbers of a small
tapeworm. The worm was a fully developed Taenia with broad segments; it was the
width of a sewing thread and length of hardly 10 mm.13
Von Siebold duly reported this discovery in his journal, and after noting that
Bilharz had wanted to call it Taenia aegyptiaca in view of the country in which
it was discovered and suggested that "it be named Taenia nana because this
tapeworm differs by its smallness so greatly from the other two species of
man"13.
In 1858, Weinland proposed dismembering the genus Taenia and established
the genus Diplocanthus for T. nana and the genus Hymenolepis for T. murina
and related species114. The name Diplocanthus, however, had already been
used by Agassiz for a genus of fish, so this name was invalid. Meanwhile,
Bilharz had provided some of his worms to museums in Vienna and Halle.
Leuckart then used these specimens to improve the morphological description
of the parasite, and renamed it Taenia (Hymenolepis) nana in 186370.
Eventually, it was designated Hymenolepis nana in 1891 by Blanchard, who
accepted the identity of T. nana and T. murina 16. The generic name,
Hymenolepis, is derived from a combination of the Greek words µ
(HYMEN) and (LEPIS) meaning "membrane" and "shell", respectively.
Although Spooner may have found these worms in the USA in 1873101, they
were not met again with certainty until 1885 when Dr Hoelz in Belgrade recov-
ered 50 small tapeworms from a seven month old girl after treatment with
ethereal extract of male fern; he sent the worms to Leuckart who recognized
them as H. nana 72.
A similar parasite in rodents was described by Dujardin 1845 as Taenia mur-
ina 32 . Since this worm and H. nana were so similar morphologically,
speciation was based upon the susceptibility of rats and humans to the strains
of parasite derived from each species. Grassi (1887) was of the view that
T. nana was merely a variety of T. murina because when he gave mature
proglottids of T. murina to six persons, one individual developed a patent
infection42. This experiment proved little, however, since H. nana infection was
endemic in humans in that district. In 1906, Stiles separated H. nana into a
human variety, H. nana, and a murine variety, H. nana var. fraterna 103. Since
repeated attempts to infect the heterologous host species were unsuccessful,
and as the human and rodent forms appeared to have different geographical
distributions, however, Joyeux (1919) again proposed to separate them into
Miscellaneous Cestode Infections 425
two distinct species, H. nana and H. fraterna 57. The name, H. fraterna, was
chosen since the prior designation, T. murina of Dujardin, was invalid; this
nomenclature had been used by Gmelin in 1790 to describe the worm related
to Cysticercus fasciolaris of Rudolphi (1808). To confuse the nomenclature
even further, the name Taenia nana had also been used by van Beneden in
185212 for a parasite that was subsequently identified as being the adult form
of Echinococcus granulosus.
In contrast to Joyeux's contention that there were two species, however, Saeki
in 1920 showed that infection could occur across species. He obtained
Hymenolepis eggs from a nine year old girl, then infected successfully mice,
rats and one out of two monkeys93. These results were confirmed by
Uchimara111and Woodland117,118 . Uchimara111 and Kiribayashi then did the
reverse experiment and infected children with Hymenolepis eggs from murine
sources. Thus, these results, together with the morphological similarities,
indicated that H. nana and H. fraterna (or T. murina) were identical.
Studies designed to elucidate the life cycle of both the murine and human
forms of the parasite were pursued concurrently with attempts to define their
host specificity. Grassi in 1887 showed that transmission from rat to rat was
direct without the mediation of a vector42; this was confirmed several decades
later by Joyeux56, Scott (as H. longior)96 and Woodland 117
. In 1920, Saeki
examined the kinetics of infection in mice and also proved that humans could
be infected directly93. On microscopical examination of the intestines of
infected rodents, oncospheres were seen in the villi ten hours after infection,
cysticercoids were noted in the mucosa at four days, then after five days, worms
could be found in the intestinal lumen; proglottid formation began on the eighth
day and eggs were found in the faeces 16-17 days after infection. Saeki then
swallowed 1,000 eggs himself on four occasions, but all his efforts to infect
himself failed. When he tried again and infected a four year old girl, however,
he found eggs in her faeces after 19 days. When she was treated 62 days after
infection, large numbers of adult worms were found. It is possible that heavy
infections are at times the result of autoinfection, for Heynemann47 found that
previously uninfected mice infected with as few as 10-25 larvae developed up
to 1,500 adult worms.
In addition to this direct cycle, Nicholl and Minchin found the cysticercoids
of the parasite in the body cavities of the fleas, Xenopsylla cheopis and Cerato-
phyllus fasciatus 85. This was confirmed by Johnston54, then later Bacigalupo
in Argentina demonstrated that the fleas, Ctenocephalides canis and Pulex
irritans, and the mealworms, Tenebrio molitor and T. obscurus, were also
capable of transmitting the infection5. In all these vectors, however, the
cysticercoids differed morphologically somewhat from those developing
directly in the intestine of the definitive host.
H. nana is now well-recognized as being widespread and common in
children in certain parts of the world. Contrary to initial impressions, the
426 A History of Human Helminthology
infection has usually been found to be asymptomatic, even when parasites are
present in large numbers. Treatment at first was difficult. The early
anthelmintics were generally ineffective63. Mepacrine was only moderately
efficacious, but then niclosamide was shown to be partially effective11 and
praziquantel was then found to be even better95.
M. LINEATUS
M. VARIABILIS
The adult worm is normally a parasite of the intestinal tract of foxes, skunks
and similar mammals. It was first described by Mueller in 192881. The larval
Miscellaneous Cestode Infections 427
stages are found in a wide variety of carnivorous animals. Adult worms are
found rarely in humans. The first case, recorded by Chandler in 1942, was of
a 13 month old child in Texas who passed more than 25 feet of tapeworm
segments when treated with oleoresin of aspidium; these segments were
thought to represent at least four worms22. Subsequently, patients were reported
from Denmark (in a Greenlander), from East Africa (in a European) and from
the USA.
R. CELEBENSIS
R. DEMERARIENSIS
In 1881, Patrick Manson in Amoy, China, was in quest of an adult filarial worm
(Wuchereria bancrofti) in order to support his view that elephantiasis was a
consequence of an infection with this worm (see chapter 23). Post-mortem
examinations were extremely difficult to carry out as the populace was opposed
to them and a previous attempt by Manson to perform one had had unfortunate
consequences. When a 34 year old man with elephantiasis, lymph-scrotum and
dysentery died in September of that year, Manson carried out a secret autopsy
with the aid of a trusted servant in the Chinese cemetery at the dead of night by
the light of a flickering candle. Instead of finding adult filariae, he discovered
a dozen ribbon-like worms 30 cm long by 5 mm wide in the retroperitoneal
adipose tissue, similar worms in the pleural cavity, and large numbers of
parasites in the gastrointestinal tract75,76. He sent these specimens to Spencer
Cobbold in London who believed them "to be new to science" and named them
Ligula mansoni ; this name was noted by the editor of The Lancet 3 in an
addendum to Manson's report, the formal description by Cobbold following the
next year23. The worm was renamed Bothriocephalus liguloides by Leuckart
in 1884 then Bothriocephalus mansoni by Blanchard in 1886.
A number of workers, including Manson himself, believed that these worms
were an immature form of cestode, possibly related to Diphyllobothrium. In
1854, Diesing28 had raised the genus Sparganum, the name being derived from
the Greek word (SPARGANOS) meaning "ribbon", to house
worms with similar morphological features. Although this genus could not
stand with the acceptance of the theory of alternation of generations and the
recognition that these worms were immature, Verdun in 1907 suggested that
each immature form of the "Bothriocephaliden" (i.e. diphyllobothriids), whose
adult state was unknown, should be placed provisionally in this genus until the
adult form was ascertained. This had, in fact, already been done by Stiles and
Tayler-Jones106 who in 1902 called the parasite, discovered by Manson,
Sparganum mansoni.
In June 1916, Yoshida and his collaborator, Yamada, fed a Sparganum re-
moved from the abdominal wall of a female patient to a dog that was coincid-
entally infected with Diphyllobothrium cordatum. Thirteen days later, different
eggs began to appear in the faeces. When the dog was killed two months after
infection, the investigators recovered a single, large, pseudophyllidean, adult
tapeworm which they took to be a Dibothriocephalus (= Diphyllobothrium)119.
The complete natural life cycle was then elucidated by Okumura in Japan in
191986. He found adult tapeworms in naturally-infected dogs that were identical
with those raised by Yamada and Yoshida. He took ova from these worms and
infected Cyclops leuckarti, then recovered procercoids as had been shown two
Miscellaneous Cestode Infections 429
years earlier for Diphyllobothrium latum (see chapter 15). The procercoids
were then fed to experimental frogs and mice and were found to pierce the
intestinal wall, migrate into the body cavity of these hosts, and develop into
plerocercoids or spargana. Furthermore, Okumura showed that similar
parasites were to be found in 30-60% of frogs in that region of Japan, as well
as in the snake, Elaphe climacophora. When plerocercoids from these
naturally infected animals were in turn fed to dogs, similar adult tapeworms
developed in the intestines. In 1922, Yoshida showed that as well as being host
to adult worms, cats and dogs also harboured the larval stages. Further, he
found spargana in chickens and ducks and concluded that humans acquire
infection either by drinking water containing infected Cyclops or from eating
raw, contaminated chicken120.
Sparganosis was prone to afflict the eye, particularly in patients in Indochina.
In May 1927, Casaux presented, to the Indochinese MedicoChirurgical Society,
such a case and recounted that the woman had been in the habit of applying dis-
membered frogs to her eyes; he suggested that there may be direct entry of
spargana into the orbital tissues. Evanno arrived at the same conclusion; he
placed a sparganum in the conjunctival sac of a monkey and recovered it 11
days later from the upper lid. Both of these experiences are recorded by
Motais80 who also reported four similar cases in which ocular sparganosis again
followed application of split frogs to the eyes. Independently, Faust and his
colleagues35 noted that AS Campbell of Foochow, China, had extracted
spargana from the fingers of two patients who had applied split frog poultices
to themselves. The possibility of being infected in such a way was confirmed
by Kobayashi64 who infected himself percutaneously. Penetration of the larvae
caused itching and erythema, then excision of the skin revealed three
plerocercoids in tunnels in the dermis and hypodermis. Two further excisions,
the second 47 days after infection, of hard, rounded, painless, subcutaneous
nodules disclosed more plerocercoids. Mueller and Coulston84 carried this
experiment one stage further. They obtained spargana from a monkey,
inoculated themselves subcutaneously, then excised some of the parasites ten
or more weeks later, and transferred one of them to a cat where it was able to
continue its natural evolution.
By these means, it was determined that infection could be acquired in one of
three ways - by drinking infected water (procercoids), by ingestion of
contaminated flesh (plerocercoids), and by direct penetration of plerocercoids
from poultices through the skin.
In 1929, Faust pointed out that although the term Sparganum mansoni had
been used for all the unbranched spargana recovered from man, there were
several species, all of which had an identical appearance in the sparganum
stage, and which could only be identified after generation of the adult form in
experimental dogs35. Moreover, he declared that the larvae should be referred
to as the larval stage of the appropriate adult worm, thus Sparganum mansoni
indicated the sparganum stage of Diphyllobothrium mansoni. By the early
430 A History of Human Helminthology
S. houghtoni
The adult form of this pseudophyllidean tapeworm was first recovered from a
Miscellaneous Cestode Infections 431
S. erinacei
This tapeworm was first recovered from a hedgehog (Erinacea europaea) and
described as Dobium erinacei-europaei by Rudolphi in 181992, then renamed
Sparganum erinacei-europaei by Diesing in 185428, then called Diphyllo-
bothrium erinacei by Faust and colleagues in 192935. Finally, it was transferred
to the genus Spirometra by Mueller in 193783. It has been recorded as a
parasite of man in five cases, all in Japan108.
T. brauni
The adult worm was recovered from the intestines of a dog in northeast Africa
and described by Setti in 189798. It was given its current name of T. brauni by
Fain and colleagues in 195633. Some authorities have considered this species
to be synonymous with T. serialis.
T. multiceps
The adult worm is a parasite of dogs, wolves and foxes. According to Küchen-
meister and Zurn, Scultetten and Rentter in 1634-1645 were the first to refer
to the bladder-worm stage of this parasite97. Wepfer stated that "gid" or vertigo
in sheep and cattle was caused by a bladder in their brain and referred to an
epidemic which occurred in 1658115. In 1780, Leske 69 40
then Goeze
independently discovered the scolices with four suckers and a double row of
hooks in the bladders of this parasite, with the former author naming it Taenia
multiceps (multiceps meaning many-headed) and the latter calling it Taenia
vesicularis, cerebrina, multiceps (meaning the many-headed, cystic worm in
the brain). The cystic form was then renamed Coenurus cerebralis by Rudolphi
in 180891. In 1853, Küchenmeister showed that C. cerebralis, which was
common in herbivores, especially sheep, goats and cattle, was the intermediate
stage of T. multiceps 67, then this was confirmed by Haubner46. In 1910, Hall
erected the genus Multiceps and transferred the parasite to it, the worm's name
thus becoming Multiceps multiceps 45. Finally, in 1967, Versteer transferred the
worm back to the genus Taenia 113.
T. serialis
T. crassiceps
T. taeniaeformis
The adult worm is a common parasite of cats. It was first described by Batsch
in 1786 as Hydatigera taeniaeformis 8, then renamed Taenia crassicollis by
Rudolphi in 181091. It was finally designated T. taeniaeformis by Wolffhügel
in 1911116. The intermediate stage is a strobilocercus, i.e. a larval strobila with
a cyst attached at the posterior end; it was long known as C. fasciolaris and is
a common parasite of rats. Its metamorphosis into an adult Taenia was first
observed by Küchenmeister in 185266. Two infections in humans have been
recorded; in both cases, the strobilocercus was embedded in the liver. The first
case was described by Bacigalupo in 1922 as T. infantis occurring in a five
year old child in Argentina4, and the second patient was a 77 year old
Czechoslovakian man102.
T. longihamatus
REFERENCES
1. ADAMS AR. Two further cases of human infestation with Bertiella studeri (Blanchard,
1891) Stiles and Hassall, 1902, with some observations on the probable synonymy of the
specimens previously recorded from man. Annals of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology 27:
471-475, 1933
2. AKASHI S. Taiwan Igakkai Zasshi No. 167, 1916. In Japanese. Abstracted in China Medical
Journal 31: 166-167, 1917
3. ANONYMOUS. Lancet ii: 617, 1882
4. BACIGALUPO J. Sobre una nueva especie de Taenia, Taenia infantis. Semana Médica 26:
726, 1922
5. BACIGALUPO J. Évolution de l'Hymenolepis fraterna Stiles, chez Pulex irritans L.,
Xenopsylla cheopis Rothschild et Ctenocephalides canis Curtis. Annales de Parasitologie
Humaine et Comparée 9: 339-343, 1931
6. BAER JG. The taxonomic position of Taenia madagascariensis Davaine 1870, a tapeworm
parasite of man and rodents. Annals of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology 50: 152-156, 1956
7. BAILLET C. Recherches sur un cystique polycéphale du lapin et sur le ver qui résulté de sa
transformation dans l'intestin du chien. Mémoires de l'Académie des Sciences, Inscriptions et
Belles-lettres de Toulouse (6) i: 452-482, 1863
8. BATSCH AJ. Naturgeschichte der Bandwürmgattung. Überhaupt und ihrer Arten
434 A History of Human Helminthology
57. JOYEUX C. Hymenolepis nana (v. Siebold 1852) et Hymenolepis nana var. fraterna Stiles,
1906. Bulletins de la Société de Pathologie Exotique et de ses Filiales 12: 228-231, 1919
58. JOYEUX C, BAER JG. Les cestodes rares de l'homme. Bulletins de la Société de Pathologie
Exotique et de ses Filiales 22: 114-136, 1929
59. KAMO H, IWATA S, HATSUSHIKA R, MAEJIMA J. (Experimental studies of the life cycle
of Diplogonoporus grandis. II. Experimental infection of marine copepods with coracidia.)
Japanese Journal of Parasitology 22: 79-89, 1973. In Japanese, with English summary
60. KAMO H, MIYAKAI I. Diplogonoporus fukuokaensis sp. nov. (Cestoda:
Diphyllobothriidae)from a girl in Japan. Japanese Journal of Parasitology 19: 635-644, 1970
61. KEAN BH, MOTT KE, RUSSELL AJ (Editors). Tropical medicine and parasitology: classic
investigations, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, two volumes, pp 677, 1978
62. KELLER. Note sur une nouvelle méthode de traitement de la sparganose oculaire. Bulletin
de la Société Médico-Chirurgicale de l'Indochine 15: 524-536, 1937
63. KEVORKOV N P. (On some problems of the treatment of Hymenolepis nana.)
Meditsinskaya Parazitologiya i Parazitarn e Bolezni 12: 83-88, 1943. In Russian. Abstracted
in Tropical Diseases Bulletin 41: 498, 1944
64. KOBAYASHI H. (Studies on the development of Diphyllobothrium mansoni [Cobbold 1882]
Joyeux 1927 [Third report]. Experimental studies on the mode of infection by the mature
procercoid.) Taiwan Igakkai Zasshi 30: 3-8, 1931. In Japanese, with English summary
65. KOSAKA S. The first case of Mesocestoides lineatus parasitic on the human body. Japanese
Journal of Parasitology 14: 212, 1942
66. KÜCHENMEISTER F. Ueber die Umwandlung der Finnen (Cysticerci) in Bandwuermer
(Taenien). Prager Vierteljahrschrift für die praktische Heilkunde 33: 106-158, 1852
67. KÜCHENMEISTER F. Experimente über die Entstehung der Cestoden Zweiter Stufe
zunächst des Coenurus cerebralis. Under Mitwirkung des Herrn Professor Haubner auf
Befehl und Kosten des hohen königliche sächsischen Staatsminsiterii des Innern. Zeitschrift
für klinische Medicin 4: 448-451, 1853
68. KÜCHENMEISTER F, ZÜRN FA. Die Parasiten des Menschen, Ambrosius Abel, Leipzig,
two volumes, pp 582, 1878-1881
69. LESKE MG. Von dem Drehen der Schafe und dem Blasenbandwurme im Gehirn derselben
als der Ursache dieser Krankheit, Leipzig, pp 52, 1780
70. LEUCKART R. Die menschlichen Parasiten und die von ihnen herrührenden Krankheiten. Ein
Hand- und Lehrbuch für Naturforscher und Aertze, CF Winter'sche Verlagshandlung, Leipzig,
volume 1, pp 766, 1863
71. LEUCKART R. Über Taenia madagascariensis Davaine. Abhandlungen der deutschen
zoologischen Gesellschaft pp 68-71, 1891
72. LEUCKART R. Cited in 14
73. LINNAEUS C. Systema naturae per regna tria naturae, secundum classes, ordines, genera,
species cum characteribus differentiis, synonymis, locis, tenth edition, L Salvii, Holmiae, two
volumes, pp 823, 1758
74. LÜHE M. Zur Anatomie und Systematik der Bothriocephaliden. Verhandlungen der deutschen
zoologischen Gesellschaft 9: 30-55, 1899
75. MANSON P. Case of lymph scrotum associated with filariae and other parasites. Lancet ii:
616617, 1882
76. MANSON-BAHR P. Patrick Manson as a parasitologist. In, "A critical review". In,
International review of tropical medicine, DR Linicombe (Editor), Academic Press, New
York, pp 77-129, 1961
77. MELNIKOV NM. Ueber der Jugendzustände der Taenia cucumerinum. Archiv für Natur-
geschichte 35: 62-70, 1869
78. MEYNER R. Zwei neue Taenien aus Affen. Ein Beitrag zur Kenntnis der Cestoden.
Zeitschrift für Naturwissenschaft 68:1-106, 1895
79. MORISHITA K, SAWADA I. On tapeworms of the genus Multiceps hitherto unrecorded
from man. Japanese Journal of Parasitology 15: 495-501, 1966
80. MOTAIS F. Considération sur la pathogénie de la sparganose oculaire. Bulletin de la Société
Médico-Chirurgicale de l'Indochine 7: 363-368, 1929
81. MUELLER JF. The genus Mesocestoides in mammals. Zoologische Jahrbücher, Abteilung
für Systematik, Oekologie und Geographie der Tiere, Jena 55: 403-418, 1928
Miscellaneous Cestode Infections 437
82. MUELLER JF. A Diphyllobothrium from cats and dogs in the Syracuse region. Journal of
Parasitology 21: 114-121, 1935
83. MUELLER JF. A repartition of the genus Diphyllobothrium. Journal of Parasitology 49:
294-296, 1937
84. MUELLER JF, COULSTON F. Experimental human infection with the sparganum larva of
Spirometra mansonoides (Mueller, 1935). American Journal of Tropical Medicine 21:
399-425, 1941
85. NICHOLL W, MINCHIN EA. Two species of cysticercoids from the rat flea (Ceratophyllos
fasciatus). Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 1: 9-13, 1911
86. OKUMURA T. An experimental study on the life-history of Sparganum mansoni, Cobbold.
A preliminary report. Kitasato Archives of Experimental Medicine 3: 190-197, 1919
87. PARONA E. Di un caso di Taenia flavopunctata riscontrata in una bambina di Varese.
Giornale dell'Accademia di Medicina di Torino 32: 99, 1882
88. RAILLIET A. Notices parasitologiques. Première series. Bulletin de la Société Zoologique
de France 17: 110-117, 1892
89. RAILLIET A. Traité de zoologie médicale et agricole, second edition, Paris, pp 736, 1893
90. RAILLIET A, HENRY A. Sur un cénure de la gerbille à pieds velus. Bulletins de la Société
de Pathologie Exotique et de ses Filiales 8: 173-177, 1915
91. RUDOLPHI CA. Entozoorum sive vermium intestinalium historia naturalis. Treuttel et
Würtz, Paris, three volumes, pp 1370, 1808-1810
92. RUDOLPHI CA. Entozoorum synopsis cui accedunt mantissima duplex et indices
locupletissima, Sumtibus Augusti Rücker, Berolini, pp 811, 1819
93. SAEKI Y. (Experimental studies on the development of Hymenolepis nana.) Jika Zasshi No.
238, pp 203-244, 1920. In Japanese. Abstracted in Tropical Diseases Bulletin 18: 112, 1921
94. SALZMANN. Ueber das Vorkommen der taenia cucumerina in Menschen. Jahrescheft des
Vereins für Vaterland. Naturkunde in Württemberg 17: 102, 1861
95. SCHENONE H, GALDAMES M, RIVADENEIRA A, MORALES E, HOFFMAN MT,
ASALGADO N, MENESES F, MORA M V, CABRERA G. Tratamiento de las infecciones
par Hymenolepis nana en niña con una dosis oral unica de praziquantel (Embay 8440).
Boletín Chileno de Parasitología 32: 11-13, 1977
96. SCOTT HH. A contribution to the experimental study of the life histories of Hymenolepis
fraterna Stiles, 1906, and Hymenolepis longior Baylis, 1922, in the mouse. Journal of
Helminthology 1: 193-196, 1923
97. SCULTETTEN, RENNTNER. Cited in 68
98. SETTI. Nuovi elminte dell'Eritrea. Bolletino dei Musea di Zoologia e Anatomia Comparata
della Real Universita di Genova, pp 56, 1897
99. SHEA M, MABERLEY AL, WALTERS J, FREEMAN RS, FALLIS AM. Intraocular
Taenia crassiceps (Cestoda). Transactions of the American Academy of Ophthalmology and
Otorhinolaryngology 77: 778-783, 1973
100. SONSINO P. Ricerche sugli ematozoa del cane e sul ciclo vitate della di tenia cucumerina,
Pisa, pp 47, 1888. Also, Atti della Società Toscana di Scienze Naturali Residente in Pisa 10:
20-64, 1889
101. SPOONER EA. Specimens of Taenia nana. American Journal of Medical Sciences 65: 136,
1873
102. STERBA J, BARUS V. First record of Strobilocercus fasciolaris (Taeniidae-larvae) in man.
Folia Parasitologica 23: 221-226, 1976
103. STILES CW. Illustrated key to the cestode parasites of man. Bulletin 25 of the Hygiene
Laboratories, United States Public Health and Marine Hospital Service, pp 104, 1906
104. STILES CW. The occurrence of a proliferating cestode larva (Sparganum proliferum) in
man in Florida. Bulletin 40 of the Hygiene Laboratories, United States Public Health and
Marine Hospitals Service, pp 7-18, 1908
105. STILES CW, HASSALL A. Bertiella, a new name for the cestode genus Bertia Blanchard,
1891. Science 16: 434, 1902
106. STILES CW, TAYLER-JONES L. A larval cestode (Sparganum mansoni) of man which
may possibly occur in returning American troops. Bulletin 35 of the Bureau of Animal
Industry, United States Department of Agriculture, pp 43-47, 1902
438 A History of Human Helminthology
107. STUNKARD HW. The morphology and life history of the cestode, Bertiella studeri.
American Journal of Tropical Medicine 20: 305-333, 1940
108. SUZUKI N, KUMAZAWA H, HOSOGI H, NAKAGAWA O. A case of human infection
with the adult of Spirometra erinacei (Rudolphi 1819), Faust, Campbell and Kellogg, 1929.
Japanese Journal of Parasitology 31: 23-26, 1982
109. TANG CC, TANG CT. Raillietina (R.) celebensis (Janicki 1902), its development in
intermediate host, epidemiology and taxonomy. Acta Parasitologica Sinica 1: 1-13, 1964
110. TURNER M, LEIPER RT. On the occurrence of Coenurus glomerulatus in man in West
Africa. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 13: 23-24, 1919
111. UCHIMARA R. (On the development of Hymenolepis nana and Hymenolepis murina.)
Jikwa Zasshi No. 286, 1922. In Japanese. Abstracted in Japan Medical World 3: 53, 1923
112. VAILLANT L. Sur deux helminthes cestoïdes de la genette. Institut, Paris 31: 87-88, 1863
113. VERSTEER A. A taxonomic revision of the genus Taenia Linnaeus, 1758, s. str.
Onderstepoort Journal of Veterinary Research 36: 3-58, 1969
114. WEINLAND DF. Human cestoides. An essay on tapeworms of man etc., Metcalfe and Co.,
Cambridge, Massachussetts, pp 93, 1858
115. WEPFERUS JJ. Observationes anatomicae, ex cadaveribus eorum, quos sustulit apoplexia,
cum excertitatione de ejus loco affecto, JC Suteri, Scaffhusii, pp 304, 1658
116. WOLFFHÜGELK. Los zooparásitos de los animales domésticos en la República Argentina,
Buenos Aires, pp 108, 1911
117. WOODLAND WN. On the life-cycle of the Hymenolepis fraterna (H. nana var. fraterna
Stiles) of the white mouse. Parasitology 16: 69-83, 1924
118. WOODLAND WN. On the development of the human Hymenolepis nana (Siebold 1852)
in the white mouse; with remarks on "H. fraterna", "H. longior" and "H. diminuta".
Parasitology 16: 424-435, 1924
119. YOSHIDA S. The occurrence of Bothriocephalus liguloides Leuckart, with especial
reference to its development. Journal of Parasitology 3: 171-176, 1917
120. YOSHIDA S. (On the morphology of the adult form of Sparganum mansoni found in the
frog and other animals.) Tokyo Iji-Shinshi Nos. 2271 and 2272, 1922. In Japanese.
Abstracted in Tropical Diseases Bulletin 20: 223, 1923
121. ZEDER JG. Erster Nachtrag zur Naturgeschichte der Eingeweidewürmer von JAE Goeze mit
Zusätzen und Anmerkungen herausgegeben von Zeder, Siegfried Lebrecht Crusius, Leipzig,
pp 320, 1800
122. ZIMMERMAN HR. Life-history studies on cestodes of the genus Dipylidium from the dog.
Zeitschrift für Parasitenkunde 9: 717-729, 1937
Chapter 17
SYNOPSIS
The adult form of the helminth now called Enterobius vermicularis was one of
the few worms known to ancient man, for it wa s both big enough to be seen and
had that incontrovertible sign of life - independent motility. Records of it s
existence may be found in the literature of several millenia go. Some authorities
have interpreted the worm described as "Herxetef" in the Egyptian Papyrus
Ebers (c.1550 BC) as indicating this parasite 70. With respect to the Greeks ,
Hippocrates (c.460-375 BC) in his Aphorisms (III, 26) mentions the
occurrence of the worm in children 43, while Aristotle (384-c.320 BC) liste d
among the three kinds of helminths of which he was aware: those which were
large and flat, those which were cylindrical, and those which were thin 2. It is,
the last mentioned worms, the "thin ones", which he called ascaris, tha t
represent the worms now named E. vermicularis, whereas the "cylindrica l
ones" are now designated Ascaris lumbricoides. Similarly, the Roman, Galen
(129-c.200 AD) numbered the pinworm amongst the three species of human
helminths he recognized 31.
Knowledge of these worms continu ed down through the ages; the Arab, Avi-
cenna (Ibn Sina), for example, described them 4. The nature and distinctiveness
of this worm was not always understood clearly, however. Thus, St. Coulet in
1729 failed to distinguish well between E. vermicularis and cucurbitini and
gave the impression that a tapeworm consisted of a large number of E. verm-
439
440 A History of Human Helminthology
The origin of threadworms was shrouded in mystery and for most of recorded
history was generally ascribed to spontaneous generation. By the end of th e
eighteenth century a number of helmint hologists including Goeze and Rudolphi
Enterobiasis 441
had found and described eggs within the female worms. Nevertheless, ther e
was not an instantaneous acceptance of th e idea that the adult worms developed
from the eggs. Thus, Bremser (1819), who readily saw the eggs in femal e
worms, thought it inconceivable that they could be transmitted through th e
media of food, air or water and still clung to the theory of spontaneou s
generation10. Several years earlier (1812), JM Barry in Ireland rejecte d
spontaneous generation and proffered his own explanation, albeit a fallacious
one, as to how transmission might occur. He saw no difficulty with the concept
that minute germs might be imbibed in food or water then grow and develop
within the human body and described an incident which he felt supported his
belief. Twenty years earlier, a patient had come to him seeking removal of the
threadworms which he, his wife, children, servant and visitors had all bee n
afflicted with since moving to a new house four years before. Worms that were
similar in appearance except in col our were found in the water of a nearby well
and he concluded that they may have been the source of the affliction, despite
the objections of a naturalist acquaintance that the creatures were likely to be
of a different species 5.
As late as 1855, Friedrich Küchenmeister was quite astray in his under -
standing of the life cycle of these worms. He had kept ova in water for si x
months, yet after that time, could discern no trace of segmentation, let alone the
formation of a mature embryo. This led him to deduce that development must
take place within the warm milieu of an animal body. Küchenmeister the n
suggested that infection might be transmitted by the adult worms themselves;
he postulated that they crawled out of the anus at night, wandered about th e
bedding, then entered the gut of a bed-fellow (though whether he thought that
this was via the mouth or the anus he did not say), whereupon eggs wer e
released which in turn developed into adult worms:
the emigration of a single pregnant female is sufficient to explain the infection of
whole families with Oxyurides....The sleeping of a married couple, one of whom is
affected with Oxyurides, in the same bed, which is expecially the case amongst the
poor who only possess one bed, the sleeping of these parents and their children, or of
several children together, one of which is troubled with Oxyurides is sufficient to
infect whole families with these worms. For if only a single female which emigrated
at night, has wandered into the intestine of one of these bedfellows who had hitherto
been free from Oxyurides, the perpetual infection is established in consequence of the
abundant reproduction of this parasite.55
Küchenmeister was in fact most unlucky with the Enterobius eggs he chose
to study and the way in which he dealt with them. He saw in the interior of each
egg two large hyaline globules surrounded by finely granular detritus .
Presumably, he was looking at either unfertilized eggs or ova which ha d
degenerated in the water in wh ich he placed them. Several years later, in 1858,
Claparède discovered that the most advanced eggs sometimes containe d
tadpole shaped embryos whilst still within the body of the pregnant femal e
worm17. In 1860, Vix reported that he had seen such eggs in the rectal mucus
and had recovered them from the perianal skin; they were ripe and in th e
442 A History of Human Helminthology
process of hatching. This led him to surmise that young Enterobius were
capable of developing directly in the r ectum without having to have a freeliving
phase of existence 85. This view, of course, was very similar to the one already
propagated by Küchenmeister.
Spencer Cobbold writing in 1864 was little more enlightened than either of
the previously mentioned investigators. After noting that it was generall y
supposed that the egg may be reared to an adult in the one and same bearer, he
remarked (perhaps having the precedents of intermediate hosts for trematodes
and cestodes in mind): "I believe this notion to be entirely fallacious" 18.
The only way in which the question as to whether mature eggs could develop
directly when ingested by a human, or whether they first had to pass through an
intermediate hosts, could be resolved was by experiment. In October, 1865 ,
Rudolf Leuckart and three of his students each swallowed a few dozen egg s
which had been kept in a humified incubator. Nearly two weeks later, three of
the investigators found some young adult E. vermicularis 6-7 mm long in their
faeces; Leuckart himself recovered 18-20 worms over four weeks 59. A similar
experiment was repeated by Grassi in 1879. He first assured himself that h e
was free from infection with E. vermicularis, then he ingested six femal e
worms taken from an individual who had died 24 hours previously. After fifteen
days, he became troubled by pruritus ani and he found a number of femal e
worms full of eggs in his faeces; they continued to be passed in each stool for
over a month 36.
Thus, there was no question that an intermediate host was quite unnecessary
or that humans became infected by ingesting mature eggs. The role of mal e
worms in the generation of these eggs had been a matter of controversy fo r
many years, however. As men tioned earlier, Bremser at first could not find any
male threadworms in humans and speculated that reproduction might occur by
parthenogenesis. Despite the eventual discovery of the male sex, the apparent
rarity of this sex encouraged some authors such as Rudolphi and von Siebold
to believe that this hypothesis may well be true. Many years later, however ,
Zenker (1868) proved that it was easy to find many male worms at autopsy by
scraping lightly the mucosal surface of the intestinal canal after removal o f
faecal matter92. There was therefore no longer any reason to doubt that bot h
male and female worms were involved in the reproductive process.
Some uncertainty remained, however, as to whether adult worms coul d
develop directly from eggs laid within the human body. In 1922, Goebe l
claimed that he had succeeded in observing the development of ova that ha d
been deposited in the intestine into mature worms in the lowest parts of th e
small intestine and in the appendix 33. On the other hand, Wundt several years
later collected eggs from the appendix and was unable to stimulate hatching of
eggs with granular contents under any experimental conditions. Moreover, she
found that those ova which contained embryos liberated them in the gastri c
juice but that the larvae were killed by duodenal, jejunal or appendiceal fluid.
Enterobiasis 443
This led her to conclude that it was highly improbable that E. vermicularis
could develop within the gut without the eggs first passing out in the faeces ,
undergoing development in the external environment, then entering again b y
the mouth91. This conclusion was reinforced by the finding of Philpot wh o
showed that the "tadpole" larva was destroyed by digestive juices whereas a
later stage of the parasite, which had developed an oesophagus, becam e
resistant to those juices 68.
Koch in 1925 then investigated the hypothesis put forward that adult worms
might re-enter the anus and produce infection by that means. He injected adult
female worms into the rectum of a child be means of an enema, and took elab-
orate precautions to prevent infect ion by mouth. The child became infected and
Koch concluded that worms multiplied in the intestine without externa l
reinfection involving passage through the stomach. Koch did not, however ,
observe such a phenomenon happening naturally 51. A different means of
retrograde infection was proven experimentally by Schüffner an d
Swellengrebel. They showed that larvae could hatch on the perianal skin, then
migrate back through the anus and develop into adult worms, a process which
they called "retrofection" 80. How important this mode of infection is in nature
remains uncertain.
Some of the ancient writers such as Galen 31 were able to differentiate the parts
of the intestinal tract in whic h the three commonly recognized intestinal worms
were located. Enterobius was thought to be localized chiefly in the rectum near
the anus whereas Ascaris lumbricoides was assigned to the upper smal l
intestine and tapeworms were deemed to extend over a considerable length of
the small bowel. The placement of threadworms in the rectum seeme d
eminently reasonable since many practitioners were familar with their habit of
crawling out of the anus at night. This became the accepted dogma until th e
middle of the ninteenth century although there were occasional remarks tha t
worms could be found in the colon and especially in the caecum 46,89.
In the middle of the nineteenth century, however, Dr Gros of Moscow ,
having ascertained on the basis of autopsy studies in Russia, Germany, France
and Italy that these worms resided not in the rectum but in the distal parts of the
small intestine and in the caecum, publicized this finding 37. This observation
was confirmed shortly thereafter by Stricke r in Frankfurt 84, then amplified a few
years later by Zenker.
Zenker examined in detail the mode of development of worms following the
ingestion of eggs. He showed that when eggs were swallowed, the embryo s
hatched in the stomach, then passed into the upper small intestine where they
increased rapidly in size and moulted. Worms i n all stages of development were
444 A History of Human Helminthology
found in the small bowel. After copulation, the fecund female worms passe d
into the caecum where they congregated whilst most of the male helminth s
remained in the jejunum and ileum. When the female worms were fully grown
and distended with eggs, they commenced their descent into the large intestine
and finally deposited their eggs in the rectum and on the perianal skin 92.
The behaviour of these worms was studied further by Koch who reported his
observations on ten infected children i n 1925. The external migration of worms
began in the early hours of sleep and lasted about three hours. Koch observed
as many as 65 worms migrating in this fashion from one child. The laying of
eggs began almost immediately and was completed within 15-20 minute s
depending upon the amount of moisture present. Many worms wandered into
the female genitalia, but Koch never observed any returning to the bowel 51. It
had in fact been known for yea rs that female adult worms sometimes wandered
into the female genitalia, on occasion reaching the peritoneal cavity 53.The
observations of Koch were confirmed a few years later by Reardon who also
showed that each female worm deposited about 11,000 eggs 69.
When it was shown in 1916 by Stewart that Ascaris lumbricoides larvae
liberated from eggs in the stomach migrated through the tissues of the hos t
before returning to the bowel, attent ion turned to determining whether a similar
phenomenon occurred with E. vermicularis. No evidence of such larva l
migration was found in mice and other animals infected with E. vermic-
ularis 41,44,68.
The number of worms in the bowel is extremely variable. Perhaps the most
ever recorded is that reported by Bijlmer in 1946; he found at autops y
approximately 10,000 worms in the bow el of a 40 year old emaciated man who
had died in Holland 7.
Until relatively recent times, the diagnosis of enterobiasis was dependent upon
the discovery, either by the patient, a clinician, or another observer, of adul t
worms passed spontaneously. Küchenmeister has recounted one such case:
a shoemaker came to me for advice as the Oxyurides disturbed him at night. As soon
as he went to bed and got warm, the Oxyurides began to march out of his anus, with
violent itching, and wander about in the anal folds, and even, in his opinion, attempted
to free themselves by biting. Once when he did not know what to do with himself, he
446 A History of Human Helminthology
wakened his wife and begged her to see whether she could not discover what it was
that troubled him so much. By means of a light, the woman found the little white
worms, and picked them off, and since then, whenever he was again troubled, she
always did him the same service.55
The discovery of Enterobius eggs, however, provided an alternative approach
and in his review in 1877, Heller put forward the possibility of diagnosin g
infection by means of finding eggs in rectal mucus 42.
In 1929, Oleinikow showed that E. vermicularis infection could be diagnosed
easily by scraping perianal skin with a spatula and then cleaning the spatula on
the edge of a slide; further, this method was much more reliable than looking
for eggs in faeces 67. In 1937, Maurice Hall described the "NIH swab" for the
diagnosis of enterobiasis. This consisted of a glass rod wrapped in cellophane
at the point and perforating a rubber cork at the other end, the latter being used
to seal the cellophane in a test tube for transport. The cellophane was the n
flattened out on a glass slide, a couple of drops of caustic soda added, then a
cover slide placed in position and the specimen examined microscopically for
eggs39 . A few years later, Graham described a modification of this swab i n
which the cellophane was replaced by transparent Scotch cellulose tape 35; this
has become the most popular and enduring of the diagnostic techniques used
in enterobiasis, particularly after B eaver indicated that the preparation could be
cleared with toluene 6.
The finding of eggs in the faeces has been used recently to demonstrate the
prehistoric existence of infection. The oldest record is of Enterobius ova found
in coproliths, dated approximately 8,000 BC, that were discovered in Utah ,
United States of America 30.
It is generally held that Enterobius infections do not produce an eosinophilia,
although there is an isolated report of doubtful significance by Schmidt wh o
infected himself with the worm and observed his blood eosinophil level ris e
from within normal limits to 28% five weeks later 77.
It had long been recognized that although persons of all ages may be infected
with threadworms, children were infected much more frequently. Thus, D r
Elliotson in his "Lectures on Worms" in 1833 wrote:
"There can be no doubt that children are much more disposed to ascarides [= E. verm-
icularis] and to lumbrici [= A. lumbricoides] than others; and not only so, but as age
advances, the constitution frequently becomes so unfit for the continuance of these
worms that they are absolutely shaken off without any physic at all....Thousands have
ascarides when they are young and never have them afterwards. 28
The clustering of infection, particularly in families became understandabl e
when the direct transmission of infection was demonstrated by Leuckart 59, and
with the recognition that eggs could be fully embryonated soon after discharge
Enterobiasis 447
into the external environment. Not only was the carriage of eggs in bedding ,
food, air and so on feasible, but Zenker and Heller showed how easily auto -
infection could occur, particularly in persons plagued with pruritus ani, for they
found eggs and even whole adult worms under the nails and the skin fold s
around the nails93. It was then an easy matter to transfer these eggs to th e
mouth. Cobbold has recounted what he considered to be a remarkable an d
foolproof method of ensuring such reinfection:
One aristocratic person, who was infected by myriads of these entozoa, confessed to
me that in his extreme distress, and consequent rage, he had freely bitten the live
worms in halves between his teeth. He had thus exposed himself to a terrible revenge
since multitudes of the ova entering his mouth subsequently found their way into the
stomach and intestines.20
Although it had been known since the time of Zenker and Heller that egg s
were transmitted commonly by the fingers, being caught under the finger nails
and in the nail-folds, Lentz was not satisf ied that this was the whole explanation
for infections often recurred despite all appropriate precautions bein g
taken. He then carried out some experiments which showed conclusively that
the ova could become airborne following activities such as restless movements
under bedclothes and changing the bedding 58. His findings were confirme d
several years later when investigators in the United States revealed that house
dust was frequently contaminated with ova 66. Subsequently, it was determined
that most eggs survived for 48 hours when kept in cool, moist air, but that the
majority were dead after this period in dry, cool air, while all were kille d
rapidly by a dry, warm atmosphere 47. Proof that such eggs were viable wa s
provided by Schüffner and Swellengrebel in 1949 when they infected seve n
doctors and students with eggs which had lain in room dust for three days o r
longer80.
The increased ease with which enterob iasis could be diagnosed following the
introduction of the NIH swab resulted in a new appreciation of how common
the infection was. Many surveys showed that a third or more of the population
in a number of countries was infected. Futhermore, it became apparent that in
these countries, E. vermicularis had little respect for sex, age, race o r
socio-economic status23. Infection was found to be less common in tropica l
countries that in nations in temperate zones. Thus, only 1% of schoolchildren
on the island of Guam in the Pacific Ocean were infected in 1947 83 whereas all
of the schoolchildren surveyed in Amsterdam during World War II wer e
infected79.
Countless remedies have been used do wn through the ages for the management
448 A History of Human Helminthology
beating of the bedroom carpets, washing of the floors....in short, every kind of
procedure which shall operate to prevent the re-introduction of the eggs of these very
common entozoa.19
Over the new few decades, a wide array of drugs was put forward for th e
treatment of enterobiasis, presumably indicating that each of them lef t
something to be desired. These included thymol 9, butolan75, aluminium sub-
acetate76, salvarsan (arsenic) 38 , vermitacet (extract of Tanacetum vulgare)54 ,
chloramin86, cupronat (copper) 50, oxylax (Tubera jalapae plus dihydrooxy-
phthalophenon)12, tetrachlorethylene 90, hexylresorcinol and gentian violet 24. In
1940, following the recognition of its anthelmintic properties by Harwood and
colleages in 193840, Manson-Bahr reported that phenothiazine was ver y
effective in six children and three adults with enterobiasis, all of whom were
cured62. This observation was soon confirmed by a number of investigators but
unacceptable side-effect became apparent and led to abandonment of the drug.
In 1942, Giroud noted that a patient undergoing piperazine treatment fo r
another condition was cured clinically and parasitologically of enterobiasis 32.
The value of the drug was then investigated by Mehrez who wrote a thesis on
the subject in 1947 63. In 1951, Mouriquand and colleagues published, for the
first time in the more accessible literature, the observation that piperazine was
effective in the treatment of enterobiasis 65, then this was confirmed by White
and Standen who demonstrated in a controlled trial that piperazine hydrate was
more effective (83% cures) than gentian violet (70%) and a lactose placeb o
(17%)88. A number of antibiotics including tetracycline 61 and combinations of
bacitracin and succinylsulphathiazole 15, neomycin and phthalysulphathiazole 3,
and spiramycin and diphetarsone 78 were shown to be effective. Tetracycline is
now contra-indicated because of the recognition of its propensity to stai n
permanently the teeth of children. In 1956, the efficacy of a derivative o f
cyanide dye, pyrvinium (viprynium), was reported71,74. In 1965, Davis indicated
that thiabendazole was effecti ve26 while shortly thereafter, the value of pyrantel
was described13 as was the administration of mebendazole 11. Recently, Cho and
colleagues have shown that viprynium and mebendazole remove worms at all
stages or development whereas py rantel and piperazine are inactive against the
larval stages of the parasite 16.
In 1919, Koford and White rep orted the discovery of eggs of an unknown type.
They had found these ova in the faeces of 429 of 140,000 soldiers examined in
the laboratory car Metchnikoff during the course of a hookworm survey o f
troops. Since they presumed that the eggs were derived from an unknow n
species of Oxyuris (i.e. Enterobius), Koford and White gave them the name of
Oxyuris incognita 52. Several years later, however, Sandground showed tha t
450 A History of Human Helminthology
they were merely eggs of the plant nematode, Heterodera radicicola , which
had been ingested and had passed through the bowel to cause a spuriou s
infection73.
REFERENCES
1. ANONYMOUS. Intestinal worms and appendicitis. British Medical Journal ii: 1595-1596,
1906
2. ARISTOTLE. Opera omnia, graece et latine, cum indice nominum et rerum absolutissimo,
F Dübner, E Heitz and U C Bussemaker (Editors), Didot, Parisiis, five volumes, 1848-1874
3. ASKUE E, TUFTS E, DROUGHMAN V. Pthalyl-sulfathiazole (sulfathalidine) in the
treatment of enterobiasis. Journal of Pediatrics 44: 380-385, 1954
4. AVICENNA. Libri in re medica omnes, qui hactenus ad nos pervenere etc., V Valgrisius,
Venetiis, pp 966, 1564. Original Arabic version, "Al Canon fi Al Tib" c. 1,000 AD. Cited in
49
5. BARRY JM. On the origin of intestinal worms particularly the Ascaris vermicularis.
Transactions of the Association of Fellows and Licentiates of the King's and Queen's College
of Physicians in Ireland 2: 392-396, 1812
6. BEAVER PC. Methods of pinworm diagnosis. American Journal of Tropical Medicine 29:
577-587, 1949
7. BIJLMER E. Exceptional cases of oxyuriasis in the intestinal wall. Journal of Parasitology 32:
359366, 1946
8. BRADY FJ, WRIGHT WH. Studies on oxyuriasis. XVIII. The symptomatology of oxyuriasis
as based on physical examinations and case histories. American Journal of Medical Science
198: 367372, 1939
9. BRAU. De l'oxyurose en Indochine. Bulletin de la Société Médico-Chirurgicale de l'Indochine
3: 582-584, 1912
10. BREMSER JG. Ueber lebende Würmer im lebenden Menschen. Ein Buch für ausübende
Aertze. Mit nach der Natur gezeichneten Abbildungen auf vier Tafeln. Nebst einem Anhage
über PseudoHelminthen, Carl Schaumburg und Comp., Wien, pp 284, 1819. Translated from
the 1824 French version of CLF Panoucke in 48
11. BRUGMANS JP, THIENPONT DC, van WIJNGAARDEN I, VANPARIJS OF,
SCHUERMANS VL, LAUWERS HL. Mebendazole in enterobiasis. Radiochemical and pilot
clinical study in 1,278 subjects. Journal of the American Medical Association 217: 313-316,
1971
12. BUCHOLZ CH. Zur Behandlung des Oxuriasis mit Oxylax. Deutsche medizinische
Wochenschrift 51: 1914-1915, 1925
13. BUMBALO TS, FUGAZZOTTO DJ, WYCZALEK JV. Treatment of enterobiasis with
pyrantel pamoate. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 18: 50-52, 1969
14. CAVIER R. Chemotherapy of intestinal nematodes. In, International encyclopaedia of pharm-
acology and therapeutics, section 64, volume 1, Chemotherapy of helminthiasis, R Cavier and
F Hawking (Editors), Pergamon Press, Oxford, pp 215-436, 1973
15. CHAN KF, BROWN HW. The treatment of pinworm (Enterobius vermicularis) infection
with bacitracin and sulfasuxidine. Journal of Pediatrics 43; 290-293, 1953
16. CHO SY, HONG ST, KANG SY, SONG CY. Morphological observations ofEnterobius
vermicularis expelled by various anthelmintics. Korean Journal of Parasitology 19: 18-26,
1981
17. CLAPARÈDE. De la formation et de la fécondation des oeufs chez les vers nématodes,
Genève, pp 101, 1859
18. COBBOLD TS. Entozoa: an introduction to the study of helminthology with reference more
particularly to the internal parasites of man, Groombridge and Sons, London, pp 480, 1864
19. COBBOLD TS. A lecture on the treatment of threadworm. British MedicalJournal i: 167,
Enterobiasis 451
1874
20. COBBOLD TS. Parasites: a treatise on the entozoa of man and animals including some
account of the ectozoa, J&A Churchill, London, pp 500, 1879
21. CONTOLI. Cited in 45
22. COULET E St. Disputatio medica inauguralis de ascaridibus et lumbrico lato etc., Lugduni
Batavorum, pp 8, 1728. Also, Tractatus historicus de ascaridibus et lumbrico lato etc.,G
Potuliet, Lugduni Batavorum, pp 228, 1729
23. CRAM EB, REARDON L. Studies on oxyuriasis. XII. Epidemiological findings ni
Washington, D.C. American Journal of Hygiene 29: 17-24, 1939
24. D'ANTONI JS, SAWITZ W. The treatment of oxyuriasis. American Journal of Tropical
Medicine 20: 377-383, 1940
25. DATE W. Intestinal worms. Lancet i: 145-146, 184-185, 1872
26. DAVIS JH. Thiabendazole in pinworm infestations. American Journal of Diseases of Children
109: 567-570, 1965
27. EASTWOOD EH. The relationship between appendicitis, Oxyuris vermicularis and local
eosinophilia in the appendix wall. Journal of Pathology and Bacteriology 26: 69-81, 1923
28. ELLIOTSON J. Lectures on the theory and practice of medicine: worms. London Medical
Gazette 12: 689-695, 1833
29. FISCHER W. Oxyuren und Appendicitis. Deutsche Zeitschrift für Chirurgie 183: 222-245,
1924
30. FRY GF, MOORE GJ. Enterobius vermicularis: 10,000 year old human infection. Science
169: 1620, 1969
31. GALENUS CC. In, Medicorum graecorum opera quae extant, edited by K G Kühn (Greek
text with Latin translation), 20 volumes, Leipzig, 1821-1833
32. GIROUD. Cited in 14
33. GOEBEL F. Die Oxyuriasis. Ergebnisse der Inneren Medizin und Kinderheilkunde 22:
106-138, 1922
34. GORDON H. Appendiceal oxyuriasis and appendicitis based on a study of 26,051 appendixes.
Archives of Pathology 16: 177-194, 1933
35. GRAHAM CF. A device for the diagnosis of Enterobius infection. American Journal of
Tropical Medicine 21: 159-161, 1941
36. GRASSI GB. I malefazi delle mosche. Nota preliminare. Gazzetta degli Ospedali, Milano 4:
467468, 1883
37. GROS G. Études progressives d'helminthologie. Gazette des Hôpitaux, Paris 27: 538-539,
1854
38. HAJOS K. Die Behandlung der Oxyuriasis mit Salvarsan. Medizinische Klinik 18:
1619-1620, 1922
39. HALL MC. Studies on oxuriasis. I. Types of anal swabs and scrapers, with a description of
an improved type of swab. American Journal of Tropical Medicine 17: 445-453, 1937
40. HARWOOD PD, JERSTAG AC, SWANSON LE. The efficacy of phenothiazine for removal
of ascarids from swine. Journal of Parasitology 24 (Suppl.): 16-17, 1938
41. HASEGAWA T. (On some observations on the development of Oxyuris vermicularis.) Tokyo
Iji Shinshi No. 2367, pp 861-870, 1924. In Japanese. Abstracted in Japan Medical World 4:
203, 1924
42. HELLER A. Oxyuris vermicularis. In, Cyclopaedia of the practice of medicine, volume 7,
Diseases of the chylopoietic system, H von Ziemssen (editor); translated by AH Buck,
Sampson Low, London, pp 752-770, 1877
43. HIPPOCRATES. Works of, translated by WH Jones and ET Whithington, Loeb Classical
Library, Heinemann, London, four volumes, 1948-1953
44. HIRAISHI S. Some experiments on the growth of Oxyuris vermicularis. Japan Medical
World 4: 118-119, 1924
45. HOEPPLI R. Parasites and parasitic infections in early medicine and science, University of
Malaya Press, Singapore, pp 526, 1959
46. HOOPER R. Observations on human intestinal worms being an attempt at their arrangement
into classes, genera and species. Memoirs of the Medical Society of London 5: 224-285, 1799
452 A History of Human Helminthology
47. JONES MF, JACOBS L. Studies on oxyuriasis. XXIII. The survival of eggs of Enterobius
vermicularis under known conditions of temperature and humidity. American Journal of
Hygiene 33: 88-102, 1941
48. KEAN BH, MOTT KE, RUSSELL AJ. Tropical medicine and parasitology. Classic investig-
ations, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, pp 677, 1978
49. KHALIL M. An early contribution to medical helminthology translated from the writings of
the Arabian physician Ibn Sina (Avicenna) with a short biography. Journal of Tropical
Medicine and Hygiene 25: 65-67, 1922
50. KNOLLER G. Behandlung der Oxyuriasis mit Cupronat. Deutsche medizinische Wochen-
schrift 51: 1664, 1925
51. KOCH EW. Oxyurenfortpflanzung in Darm ohne Reinfektion und Magenpasse. Zentralblatt
für Bakteriologie, Parasitenkunde und Infektionskrankheiten, Abteilung originale 94:
208-236, 1925
52. KOFOID CA, WHITE AW. A new nematode infection of man. Journal of the American
Medical Association 72: 567-569, 1919
53. KOLB R. Ueber den Befund van auf dem Peritoneum des Cavum Douglasii angewachsenen
Oxyuriden. Centralblatt für Bakteriologie, Parasitenkunde und Infektionskrankheiten,
Abteilung originale 31: 268-272, 1902
54. KRIMER M. "Vermitacet" gegen Oxyuris vermicularis. Deutsche medizinische
Wochenschrift 50: 803-804, 1924
55. KÜCHENMEISTER F. Die in und an dem Körper des lebenden Menschen vorkommenden
Parasiten. Ein Lehr- und Handbuch der Diagnose und Behandlung der thierischen und pflanz-
ischen Parasiten des Menschen, BG Teubner, Leipzig, two volumes, pp 486, 1855. On animal
and vegetable parasites of the human body. A manual of their natural history, diagnosis and
treatment. Volume 1. Animal parasites belonging to the group entozoa, translated by E
Lankester, The Sydenham Society, London, pp 452, 1857
56. LEACH. In, Catalogue of the species of entozoa, or intestinal worms, contained in the
collection of the British Museum, W Baird (Editor), pp 132, 1853
57. LEIPER RT. Discussion on the validity of certain generic names at present in use in medical
helminthology. Archiv für Schiffs- und Tropen-Hygiene 30: 484-491, 1926
58. LENTZ FA. Zur Biologie des Oxyuris vermicularis. Zentralblatt für Bakteriologie,
Parasitenkunde und Infektionskrankheiten, Abteilung originale 135: 156-159, 1935
59. LEUCKART R. Die menschlichen Parasiten unddie von ihnen herrührenden Krankheiten. Ein
Hand- und Lehrbuch für Naturforscherund Aertze, CF Winter'sche Verlagshandlung, Leipzig,
volume 2, pp 882, 1867-1876
60. LINNAEUS C. Systema naturae per regna tria naturae, secundum classes,ordines, genera,
species cum characteribus differentiis, synonymis, locis, tenth edition, L Salvii, Holmiae, two
volumes, pp 823, 1758
61. LOUGHLIN EH, RAPPAPORT I, MULLIN WG, WELLS HG, SHOOKHOFF HB. The
treatment of enterobiasis with terramycine base. Antibiotics and Chemotherapy 1: 588-593,
1951
62. MANSON-BAHR P. Phenothiazine as an anthelmintic in threadworm and roundworm
infections. Lancet ii: 808-809, 1940
63. MEHREZ R. Les nouveaux traitements de l'oxyurose, Thèse, Paris, 1947
64. von MOTY. L'appendicite parasitaire. Écho Médical du Nord 6: 217-221, 1902
65. MOURIQUAND G, ROMAN E, COISNARD J. Essai de traitement de l'oxyurose par al
pipérazine. Journal de Médecine de Lyon 32: 189-195, 1951
66. NOLAND MO, REARDON L. Studies on oxyuriasis. XX. The distribution of the ova of
Enterobius vermicularis in household dust. Journal of Parasitology 25: 173-177, 1939
67. OLEINIKOW SV. (Sur le diagnostic et l'épidémiologie dans l'enterobiase.) "Russian Journal
of Tropical Medicine" 7: 393-401, 1929. In Russian with French summary. Abstracted ni
Tropical Diseases Bulletin 27: 983, 1930
68. PHILPOT F. Notes on the eggs and early development of some species of Oxyuridae. Journal
of Helminthology 2: 239-252, 1924
69. REARDON L. Studies on oxyuriasis. XVI. the number of eggs produced by the pinworm,
Enterobiasis 453
Enterobius vermicularis, and its bearing on infection. Public Health Reports 53: 978-984,
1938
70. RIAD N. La médecine au temps des Pharaons. La médecine à travers le temps et l'espace,
Librairie Maloine, Paris, pp 319, 1955
71. ROYER A. Preliminary report on a new antioxyuritic, Poquil. Canadian Medical Association
Journal 74: 297, 1956
72. RUDOLPHI CA. Neue Beobachtungen über die Eingeweidewürmer. Archiv für Zoologie und
Zootomie 3: 1-32, 1803
73. SANDGROUND JH. "Oxyuris incognita" or Heterodera radicicola. Journal of Parasitology
10: 92-94, 1923
74. SAWITZ WG, KARPINSKI FE. Treatment of oxyuriasis with pyrrovinyquinium chloride
(Poquil). American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 5: 538-543, 1956
75. SCHICKHARDT E. Butolan, ein neues Mittel gegen Oxyuriasis. Münchener medizinische
Wochenschrift 67: 722, 1920
76. SCHMIDT WT. Zur Therapie der Oxyuriasis. Münchenener medizinische Wochenschrift 69:
400-401, 1922
77. SCHMIDT WT. Neue Beiträge zur Oxyuriasis. Münchener medizinische Wochenschrift 70:
495-496, 1923
78. SCHNEIDER J, BIGUET J, MACHEZ J M. Traitement de l'oxyurose par le diphétarsone -
speramycine et par le diphétarsone. Thérapie 15: 648-654, 1960
79. SCHÜFFNER W. Die Bedeutung der Staubinfektion für die Oxyuriasis. Richtlinien der
Therapie und Prophylaxe. Münchener medizinische Wochenschrift 91: 411-414, 1944
80. SCHÜFFNER W, SWELLENGREBEL NH. Retrofection in oxyuriasis. A newly discovered
mode of infection with Enterobius vermicularis. Journal of Parasitology 35: 138-146, 1949
81. SEMON HC. Trichotillomania due to threadworms. British Medical Journal i: 641, 1922
82. STILL GF. Observations on Oxyuris vermicularis in children. British Medical Journal i:
898-900, 1899
83. STOLL NR, CHENOWETH BM, PECK JL. Low incidence ofEnterobius vermicularis in
natives of Guam, M.I. Puerto Rico Journal of Public Health and Tropical Medicine 22:
235-253, 1947
84. STRICKER W. Physiologisch-pathologische Bemerkungen über Oxyuris vermicularis.
Archiv für pathologische Anatomie und Physiologie und für klinische Medicin (Virchow) 21:
360-361, 1861
85. VIX E. Ueber Entozoen bei Gesiteskranken, ins Besondere Quber die Bedeutung, das
Vorkommen und die Behandlung von Oxyuris vermicularis. Allgemeine Zeitschrift für
Psychiatrie 17: 1-31, 149-198, 225-302, 1860
86. WEINBERGER. Eine Einfache und Zuverlassige Oxyurenbehandlung. Medizinische Klinik
20: 750, 1924
87. WELLER TH, SORENSEN CW. Enterobiasis: its incidence and symptomatology in a group
of 505 children. New England Journal of Medicine 224: 143-146, 1941
88. WHITE RH, STANDEN OD. Piperazine in the treatment of threadworms in children. Report
on a clinical trial. British Medical Journal ii: 755-757, 1953
89. WOLF. De vermibus intestinorum, Giessae, pp 27, 1763
90. WRIGHT WH, BOZICEVICH J, GORDON LS. Studies on oxyuriasis. V. Therapy with
single doses of tetrachlorethylene. Journalof the American Medical Association 109: 570-573,
1937
91. WUNDT N. Ueber Möglichkeit der intraintestinalen Entwicklung von Oxyuren unter
Umgeung der Magenpassage. Münchener medizinische Wochenschrift 71: 546-548, 1924
92. ZENKER F. Ueber die Naturgeschichte des Oxyuris vermicularis. Verhandlungen der
physicalisch-medicinischen Societät zu Erlangen, pp 20-21, 1870 (presented 20 July 1868).
Also, Tageblatt der 42. Versammlung deutscher Naturforscher und Aertze zu Dresden, p 140,
1868
93. ZENKER F, HELLER A. Cited in 42
454 A History of Human Helminthology
BC Adult worms have been known from ancient times and various anthelmintics
have been employed
1819 Bremser discovered the male adult worm
1854 Gros showed that adult worms were located primarily in the caecum
1860 Vix recovered eggs from the perianal skin
1865 Leuckart infected himself and three students with ova and recovered adult
worms from their stools two weeks later
1868 Zenker observed the stages of development of larvae in the intestines at
autopsy and found male adult worms in the colonic mucus
1924 Philpot showed that the larva within the eggshell developed further in the
external environment and became resistant to digestive juices
1937 Hall described the "NIH swab" for diagnosis
1941 Graham modified the swab by substituting Scotch tape for cellophane
1956 Viprynium was introduced for treatment
1969 Pyrantel was introduced for treatment
1971 Mebendazole was introduced for treatment
___________________________________________________________________
Chapter 18
SYNOPSIS
Despite the relatively large size of Trichuris trichiura and its not infrequent
occurrence, the ancient writers seem to have been unaware of the existence of
this parasite. The first reference to the worm is found in the works of Joannes
Actuarius, a Byzantine physician who lived during the reign of Andronicus II
(1328-1341 AD). Actuarius mentioned that some worms resembling thi n
strings were sometimes "excreted" from the intestinal wall; he appears to have
believed that they were a stage in the development of the roundworm, Ascaris
lumbricoides, which he considered was generated spontaneously 4. This report
received little recognition and the same fate was to befall the next description
of the parasite.
In 1623, the Portuguese physician and adventurer, Alexei de Abreu, wrote
Tratado de las siete enferme dades (Treatise on the seven diseases ) which has
been described as the earliest book on tropical medicine 34. In this book, de
Abreu discussed certain maladies which he had observed in Angola and Brazil
between 1594 and 1606. One of these conditions appears to be trichuriasi s
which he described in his section on yel low fever, since the worms were almost
invariably found in patients dying from that disease:
455
456 A History of Human Helminthology
In those same interior parts wrinkled corrupted and ulcerated in some patients, a little
worm or worms are bred (white like earthworms, the size of a thumb in the length,
the width of sewing thread, not very thick, they have a mild, soft body, the head hard
and black) which eroding that flesh, together with the corruption it keeps rotting, and
eroding, and soon leaves the lower part of the rectum exposed. 3
Only a limited number of copies of this book was printed (perhaps less tha n
20034), and this discovery and descrip tion did not receive the acknowledgement
it deserved.
No further allusion was made to the existence of this worm until Morgagni
in his anatomical letters (published in about 1760) recorded his discovery of
the parasite in 1740:
I dissected 11 cadavers consecutively, and in six of them....I definitely found worms.
The first three or four that I saw were white, very thin, and at most a thumb's breadth
in length. They lay hidden inside feces at the base of the appendix....In another corpse
I found several, all longer than those mentioned, but equal in length to the last two
joints of the little finger; these....were....in the part of the caecum which adjoined the
appendix....They were very pointed at one end and gradually became a little thickened,
turning from white to somewhat dark at the tail which comprised half their length;
otherwise they were totally white and as thin as a hair. 52
This observation of Morgagni was unknown to the Germans who rediscov-
ered the parasite in 1761. During the winter of 1760-1761, an epidemic o f
mucoid diarrhoea (? cholera) raged in Göttingen and killed many of th e
inhabitants as well as French troopers who were stationed there. Whil e
dissecting the body of a five year old girl, one of the medical student s
accidentally opened the caecum and several worms crawled out. One of th e
students, HA Wrisberg, believed that these were worms of a new species but
the prosector, DT Wagler, and some of the other young doctors, after th e
fashion of Actuarius, considere d them to be merely developing E. vermicularis
or A. lumbricoides. The specimens were then taken to Roederer and Buttner to
settle the argument. They pronounced the worm to be previously undescribed
and gave it the name "trichuris" because of the hairlike shape of the tail, th e
name being derived from the Greek words (THRIX) [combining for m
- (TRICH-)] and (OURA) meaning "hair" and "tail", respectively.
Many further examples were found in subsequent autopsies and Roedere r
presented the findings to a meeting of the Academy of Science at Göttingen on
10 October 1761:
The worm is round and cylindrical and at one end has a blunted point; at the other end
it elongates into a thin, threadlike tail. The greatest thickness amounts to about
one-third of a line [1 line = the 12th part of a Rhenish inch; about 2 mm] the length
of the body is seven lines and the tail 15 lines....some (were) rolled together like
spirals; others were less bent. The former are males, the latter females. In all them the
tail is bent. Body and tail are transparent, shiny and white. 61
Not only did Roederer manage to separate the two sexes, but he also saw the
small white eggs which could be expressed together with mucus through th e
genital opening. The marked differences in appearance between the two sexes,
in fact, misled some later investigators into believing that there were tw o
Trichuriasis 457
different species. Roederer, however, made one major error when he mistook
the head for the tail. The true anatomical arrangement was recognized b y
Goeze32 who in 1782 thought it necessary to change the name to Tricho-
cephalos, meaning "hair-like head", but Goeze but did not use binary nomen-
clature and gave it no specific name. Meanwhile, however, Linnaeus (1771 )
had called the worm Ascaris trichiura 48. In 1788, Schrank named it Tricho-
cephalus hominis and Hooper later named it Trichuris vulgaris 38. In 1800,
Zeder renamed the parasite Fusaria, and gave it the specific epithet, dispar,
from the same Latin word meaning "unlik e" or "unequal" 74. In 1810, Rudolphi 65
reverted to the modification by Schrank of Goeze's name for the parasite and
called it Trichocephalus dispar. This remained the popular name for more than
a century until 1941 when the American Society of Parasitologists 59 declared
that the Rules of Zoological Nomenclature concerning priority require d
reversion to the generic name Trichuris of Roederer and Buttner and th e
specific designation trichiura of Linnaeus.
The manner in which the infection was transferred from one person to another
remained a mystery for many years, despite the fact that the eggs of the parasite
were found almost as soon as the adult worms were rediscovered in 1761. In
1855, Küchenmeister put forward an entirely fallacious, albeit ingenious ,
hypothesis to explain the life cycle. T wo recent observations provided him with
stimuli for his idea. First, Leidy had discovered the larvae of Trichinella
spiralis (which Diesing called Trichina affinis) in the muscles of swine (se e
chapter 22). Second, Küchenmeister himself had recently demonstrated tha t
human tapeworm infection was acquired by ingesting Cysticercus cellulosae
in undercooked pork (see chapter 14). He sugg ested, therefore, that T. trichiura
eggs excreted in human faeces were ingested by pigs and the liberated larvae
migrated to the muscles (as T. spiralis). These larvae were in turn ingested by
humans in poorly cooked meat and developed into adult Trichuris in the
intestines45. Küchenmeister attempted to prove this hypothesis by experiments
on dogs but had no success. The untenability of this theory was shown late r
when Virchow and Leuckart discovered adult T. spiralis in the intestines of
experimental animals (see chapter 22).
Küchenmeister did, however, try to observe the fate of eggs and recorded :
"After preserving the eggs of Trichocephalus for six months in water, n o
embryos appeared, but only numerous, clear, but pretty regularly arrange d
globules"45. He was out of luck for he did not observe the ova for long enough,
or at the right season of the year. Several years later, Casimir Davaine in Paris
took up the same problem and reached the following conclusions: eggs were
expelled unembryonated, development only took place outside of the huma n
458 A History of Human Helminthology
body, this process took four to six months or more to complete, and the larvae
within each egg may live for over one year 22. Indeed, he later showed that the
larvae could remain alive for five years 23.
Davaine thought it unlikely that an intermediate host was required and that
hatching and development probably took place directly following ingestion of
mature eggs23, but this remained an open question for a number of years .
Eventually, Leuckart undertook some experiments with related species o f
Trichuris in animals. He fed embryonated eggs of Trichocephalus (= Trich-
uris) affinis to a lamb and 16 days later found several hundred youn g
trichocephali about 1 mm in length in the intestine. In a similar experiment ,
Leuckart fed T. crenatus ova to pigs and four weeks later recovered 50-8 0
worms, 10-30 mm long, which were close to sexua l maturity47. Railliet then had
a similar experience. He collected eggs of T. depressiusculus on 19 February
1884, kept them in water until 28 July 1884 and then fed them to a dog. Three
months later, on 27 October 1884, he obtained 150 mature worms 57.
Thus, these experiments proved that related species of Trichuris developed
without an intermediate host but evidence of the same phenomenon happening
with T. trichiura in humans was lacking. In 1886, Salvatore Calandruccio, an
associate of Grassi in Italy, having assured himself that he was not infected with
T. trichiura by examining microscopically his faeces repeatedly over si x
months, swallowed some embryonated T. trichiura eggs on 27 June 1886.
Twenty seven days later, on 24 July, he found whipworm eggs in his faeces for
the first time, thus proving that direct infection occurred in humans an d
showing that the incubation period was nearly four weeks. These results were
published, with minimal acknowledgement to Calandruccio, by Grassi 33 in the
following year, much to the disgust of the former who some years later wrote
a bitter letter to the Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene :
Calandruccio discovers the cycle of evolution of the Ascaris lumbricoides and of the
Trichocephalus dispar, and shows the experiments to Grassi who praises them and
says: 'I shall publish a note under your name in a German paper.' This preliminary note
duly appeared, but not under my name but his, thus expressed 'my pupil
Calandruccio', implying that I had studied under his direction, whereas I had not made
my observations in his laboratory and he was ignorant of them before my
communication.16
For whatever reason, Grassi never replied in the same forum to this attack.
three grades; patients with light infections (< 7,500 eggs/g faeces) usually had
no symptoms, those with moderate worm burdens (7,500-30,000 eggs/ g
faeces) sometimes had vague abdominal pains, usually in the right lowe r
quadrant, and urticaria, while those with heavy infection (> 30,000 eggs/ g
faeces) had dysentery, abdominal pain, tene smus and sometimes rectal prolapse
with the worms being visible easily to the naked eye on the mucosa of th e
prolapsed bowel 39.
For almost a century after the re-discovery of T. trichiura by Roederer and his
colleagues, a diagnosis of trichuriasis was made only occasionally in livin g
patients, and that was when worms were passe d spontaneously, usually with the
faeces, as recorded by Roederer: "sometimes they were passed by the patient" 61.
A most unusual way of diagnosing Trichuris infection was recounted by Wedl
in 1854. H Ulrich removed a concretion about the size of cherry stone from an
inguinal abscess which had resulted from an intestinal perforation .
Microscopical examination of this material disclosed ova of T. trichiura in the
midst of other material derived from faeces 71.
Diagnosis was put on a simple and sound basis, however, when Ransom in
1856 and then Davaine in 1857 reported that int estinal helminthiasis, especially
trichuriasis, could be diagnosed by microscopical examination of faeces fo r
ova. In the summer of 1852, while examining the faeces of cats and dogs for
ova of nematodes, it occurred to WH Ransom that intestinal helminthiasis i n
humans might be diagnosed by a similar means. In July 1854, he found eggs of
Trichuris and of an unknown tapeworm in the stools of a nine year old girl 58.
In 1853, while examining the stools of dogs with cholera, Davaine foun d
Trichuris eggs in the excrement. He had the opportunity to confirm thi s
observation in humans several years later when he found large number o f
Trichuris eggs in the faeces of an individual with meningitis; the patient died
and large numbers of adult Trichuris were found in the caecum at autopsy 21.
Davaine noted that the characteristic eggs were recognized easily by thei r
brown colour, ovoid shape, the small bulges at each end, the absence of a n
operculum, and length of 0.05 mm. This description by Davaine has bee n
hailed incorrectly as the foundation of the diagnosis of intestinal helminthiasis
by microscopical examination of the stools 5,69.
The finding of eggs in faeces has been used to demonstrate the prehistori c
existence of infection. Thus, Aspöck and colleagues found ova in faeces (dated
between 800 and 350 BC) obtained from saltmines in Austria 6.
Trichuriasis can sometimes be diagnosed and an assessment made of th e
damage produced by proctoscopic or sigmoidoscopic examinations. Perhaps
the first person to record the use of this technique was Ross who in 194 2
described the sigmoidoscopic appearances in a 2 8 year old woman with chronic
462 A History of Human Helminthology
diarrhoea:
This confirmed the diagnosis in a remarkable manner, showing a little reddening and
thickening of the mucosa of the lowest 9 in. of the bowel, most conspicuous about 7
in. from the anus where the mucous membrane was seen to be covered by a layer of
sticky mucus, underlying which were several haemorrhagic spots 1-2 mm. in
diameter; attached to some of these spots moving whipworms could be seen, and
several were removed with forceps.64
It was recognized early that Trichuris infection was more common in children
than in adults. As helminthiasis su rveys were undertaken in various parts of the
world, it became obvious that the infection was more frequent in tropical than
temperate countries. The discovery by Calandruccio that infection wa s
transmitted directly without the mediation of an intermediate host paved th e
way for investigations of the factors controlling the epidemiology of infection.
These included the demonstration that the time taken for development of eggs
was dependent upon temperature. Dinnik and Dinnik showed that larva e
developed within 11 days at 35 oC, but that 180 days were required when they
were kept at 15oC24. The other major factor determining the spread an d
intensity of infection was the usage of infected human excreta to fertiliz e
vegetable gardens, for it had been known since the times of Davaine that eggs
were able to survive for many months under moist conditions. Similar factors
determined the epidemiology of ascariasis, and it was realized that the tw o
infections tended to go hand in hand. Little attention has been paid specifically
to the prevention and control of trichuriasis, but where it has, it has depended
largely upon general environmental sanitary measures.
T. SUIS
T. VULPIS
From time to time, human infections with T. vulpis have been reported, with the
diagnosis being based upon t he increased size of T. vulpis eggs compared with
464 A History of Human Helminthology
REFERENCES
1. ABADIE SH, SAMUELS M. A fatality associated with dithiazanine iodide therapy .
Journal of the American Medical Association 192: 326-327, 1965
2. ABBOTTS SMITH W. On human entozoa: comprising the description of the differen t
species of worms found in the intestines and other parts of the human body, and th e
pathology and treatment of the various affections produced by their presence, HK Lewis,
London, pp 245, 1863
3. de ABREU A. Tratado de las siete e nfermedades, Pedro Craesbeeck, Lisboa, 1623. Partly
translated in 34
4. ACTUARIUS J. Methodi medendi libri sex, quibus omnia, quae ad medicina m
factitandam pertinent, fere complectitur, CH Malthisius interprete, Venetiis, pp 399, 1554
5. ANONYMOUS. The week. British Medical Journal ii: 65, 1863
6. ASPÖCK H, FLAMM H, PICHER O. Darmparasiten in menslichen Exkrementen au s
prähistorischen Salzbergwerken der Hallstatt-Kultur (800-350 v. Chr.). Zentralblatt fü r
Bakteriologie, Abteilung originale 223: 549-558, 1973
7. BASNUEVO JG. Tricocefaliasis y arsenicos organicos pentavalentes. Revista Kub a
Medicina Tropical y Parasitologia 4: 185-188, 1948
8. BEAVER PC, JUNG RC, CUPP EW. Clinical parasitology, ninth edition, Lea an d
Febiger, Philadelphia, pp 825, 1984
9. BECKER E. Ueber die durch Trichocephalus dispar verusachten krankheitszustande .
Deutsche medizinische Wochenschrift 28: 468-470, 1902. Abstracted in British Medical
Journal, epitome of the current medical literature p 13, 1903
10. BEER RJ. Experimental infection of man with pig whipworm. British Medical Journal i:
44, 1971
11. BELLINGHAM O'B. On the frequency of the presence of the Trichocephalus dispar in
the human intestines. Dublin Journal 12: 341-347, 1838
12. BERRIO LP. Contribution à l'étude de la trichocéphalose et de son traitement par le latex
d'higueron. Revue de Médecine et d'Hygiene Tropicale 9: 178-184, 1912
13. BLANCHARD R. Traité de zoologie médicale. J-B Baillière et fils, Paris, two volumes,
pp 1691, 1885-1890
14. BLANCHARD R. Sur un travail de M. le Dr. J. Guiart intitulé: Rôle du trichocéphal e
dans l'étiologie de la fièvre typhoïde. Archives de Parasitologie 9: 122-128, 1904
15. BURROWS RB. MOREHOUSE WG, FREED JE. Treatment of trichuriasis wit h
"enseals" of emetine hydrochloride. American Journal of Tropical Medicine 27: 327-328,
1947
16. CALANDRUCCIO S. Unicuiq ue suum, Prof. J.B. Grassi! (Every man his own Professor
Trichuriasis 465
SYNOPSIS
Ancient man must have been w ell aware of, if not terrified by, the large, motile
creatures resembling earthworms that he pass ed in the faeces from time to time,
or, more rarely, escaped through other orifices. These large roundworms were
mentioned in the Egyptian Papyrus Ebers (c.155 BC) 95, and were discussed by
a number of Greek and Roman writers including Hippocrates (c.460-375 BC)
in his Aphorisms (III,26)57, Aristotle (384-c.320 BC) 6, and Pliny (23-79 AD) 21.
The Greeks called these roundworms µ (HELMINS
STRONGYLE) meaning "worm" and "rou nd", respectively. Roman authors re-
ferred to them as "lumbricus teres", in view of their fancied resemblance to the
common earthworm, and to disti nguish them from "lumbricus latus" (the broad
worm, i.e. tapeworm), and "ascaris" of the Greeks (which, confusingly ,
indicated the worm now known as Enterobius vermicularis ). At the beginning
of the Christian era, Celsus (c.20 AD) wrote:
Again, worms also occasionally take possession of the bowel, and these are discharged
at one time from the lower bowels, or more nastily from the mouth; and we observe
them sometimes to be flattened, which are the worse, at times to be rounded. 23
Galen (129-c.200 AD)42 and Alexander Trallianus (c.525-605 AD) knew that
A. lumbricoides normally inhabited the upper part of the small intestin e
469
470 A History of Human Helminthology
It was generally held for many centuries that A. lumbricoides, like other
intestinal worms, arose by a proces s of spontaneous generation (see chapter 2).
During the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, however, a number o f
observers came around to the view that these worms were viviparous, i.e. they
brought forth smaller versions of themselves. Thus, Amatus Lusitanius told of
a girl who voided a large worm and, when her father trod on it, other worm s
escaped from its interior 3. Similarly, Felix Platter recounted the story of a boy
who died and when his abdomen was opened, his intestines were stuffed with
a great number of living worms which were in turn filled with other smalle r
worms98. Dominicus Panarolus claimed that from two persons:
flesh-coloured worms about 16 inches long were expelled. These worms bore many
little worms in them and the little worms looked like so many little sticks of wood.
These small worms were innumerable; they were slender and white, being about six
inches long, and on being born they slithered like so many tiny serpents. 94
Tyson, however, being certain of his discovery of the eggs, was convinced that
all this was nonsense: "Whatever is related of this nature, I cannot but think is
a mistake....For they are not viviparous but oviparous as I have shewn" 133. It is
possible, though, that Tyson may have thought erroneously that the whole cycle
of reproduction and growth could occur within the same host, for he went on
to say:
their containing so vast a number of eggs in the cornua uteri, as I have expressed, does
not sufficiently account for the prodigious quantity, that are sometimes observed to
be bred in animal bodies.133
Alternatively, he may simply have meant that a vast number of eggs wer e
available to contaminate the environment. In any event, the concept tha t
Ascaris was viviparous died hard. More than a century after Tyson clearl y
described the eggs, Church wrote:
Everyone who has examined this worm attentively when newly discharged from the
body must have observed an appearance like white threads, folded, as it were together
about the middle of the worm. This substance has in general been supposed to the
intestines of the worm filled with chyle....but the fact I am going to relate seems to
prove beyond doubt that this white appearance is in reality the young worms nearly
fit for exclusion from the parent.26
The "evidence" Church advanced was that when he put a roundworm passed
by a child in a cup of water and spirit, it produced three worms about one inch
long which were exactly like the parent worm. He then went on to speculat e
that infection might be acquired by worms creeping into the mouth while a
person lay asleep on the ground 26.
By the middle of the nineteenth century, however, there could no longer be
any doubt that transmission depended upon eggs being excreted in the faeces,
472 A History of Human Helminthology
and that worms developed from them. At tention turned, therefore, to discerning
the way in which this occurred. In particular, the question arose as to whether
or not an intermediate host was involved in this process. Initially, development
within the egg was examined. The first person to study this aspect was Gros in
Moscow in 1849. He put moistened eggs into an incubator at a temperature of
15-16 oC and found that they began to develop within 24 hours, but require d
four months to reach a perfect state o f larval development 53. Richter in Dresden
made similar observations and showed that eggs remained alive for up t o
eleven months. He placed unsegmented A. lumbricoides eggs in water on 15
November 1854 but did not examine them again until 15 October 1855, a t
which time he found living larvae within the egg shells although none of them
had hatched108. Similarly, Leuckart found that larvae remained motile within the
egg shells for six months and showed them to the Congress of Germa n
naturalists in 1857 74. Furthermore, Leuckart found that the period necessary for
the development of the larvae was variable and was dependent upon th e
temperature.
These processes were reinvestigated by Davaine in 1859. He found tha t
development of larvae took four to six months or even more to be completed,
and reported at that time that they remained alive for more than one year 31. Sub-
sequently, he discovered that larvae were still viable five years afte r
collection32. Davaine also ascertained that incubation of eggs in gastric juice in
vitro did not dissolve the egg shell and permit escape of the enclosed larva. He
therefore performed an experiment in which he introduced two small fabri c
containers, one containing embryonated A. lumbricoides eggs, and the other
holding unembryonated ova, into the stomach of a dog. The flasks wer e
recovered from the faeces two days later and the contents examined. In th e
latter flask, unembryonated eggs were found, while in the former container ,
only a few free larvae could be detected. Davaine interpreted these results as
indicating that:
the egg shell is not dissolved by the intestinal juices because undivided eggs were
found intact in the flasks but the eggs are sufficiently softened so that the embryos
within, activated by the heat of the intestines, could pierce it and escape. 32
In October 1861, Davaine gave 300-400 A. lumbricoides eggs to a cow but
could find no worms in the intestines four months later; he concluded that the
cow was not a susceptible host to this parasite. In October 1862, he fed large
numbers of eggs which had been kept viable for five months to a rat. Whe n
Davaine killed the animal twelve hours later, he found large numbers of intact
eggs in the stomach and the upper small bowel, but in the more distal parts of
the small intestine, he discovered liberated larvae and larvae that were in the
process of hatching through a small pore in the shell. In a subsequen t
experiment upon another rat, he found that these freed larvae were expelled in
the faeces. Davaine summarized his findings:
eggs of....A. lumbricoides develop outside the body of man, but the embryo only
hatches when it is brought into the intestine by food or drink. Two conditions are
Ascariasis 473
doubtless necessary for this hatching: the softening of the shell by intestinal juices and
the activity of the embryo under the influence of heat of about 40 oC. In whichever
animal supplies these conditions, the egg hatches if it remains in the intestine long
enough; however, the embryo does not linger if the animal is not of the kind where
the worm can (sic) acquire its final form.32
Although Davaine thought that transmission was direct, a number of authors
after him believed that an intermediate host was probably necessary. Negative
results with direct feeding experiments were obtained by Mosler in 1860 .
Mosler first swallowed A. lumbricoides eggs himself, but a patent infection, as
assessed by the subsequent administration of anthelmintics, failed to develop.
He then fed mature eggs to a number of c hildren, initially in small numbers, but
later gave several dozen ova to each child. No worms were ever evacuated after
anthelmintic therapy, but in one or two children, fever with dyspnoea occurred
a few days after administration of the eggs 85. Similarly, Leuckart in 1867 failed
to achieve patent infections in dogs, rabbits, pigs and mice fed wit h
embryonated eggs. Likewise, he failed to infect a horse directly with eggs of A.
megalocephala (= Parascaris equorum), a dog with those of A. marginata (=
Toxocara canis), and a cat with eggs of A. mystax (= Toxocara mystax = T.
cati), all of these ascarids being natural parasites of these hosts. These findings
convinced Leuckart that there must be intermediate hosts for this group o f
parasites. In support of such an hypothesis, he noted that A. acus, which was
found as an encysted larva in Leuciscus alburnus, occurred in the adult form
in the pike, and that a larval Ascaris encysted in the muscles of a mole ,
continued to develop when administered to a buzzard. Finally, Leuckar t
considered that Davaine's experiment with rats indicated that the rat was th e
intermediate host, and the free larvae excreted in the rat's faeces would mature
after subsequent ingestion by humans 75. Others took up similar ideas. Fo r
example, von Linstow (1886), believed that a garden myriapod, Iulus
guttulatus, was the vector. He suggested that these creatures ingested Ascaris
eggs in human excrement deposited in the garden, the eggs then hatched and
the larvae encysted in their organs. The myriapods then parasitized variou s
fruits and were eaten accidentally by humans 78.
On the other hand, experiments with other ascarids suggested that no inter-
mediate host was necessary. In 1868, Unterberger showed that A. maculosa (=
Heterakis maculosa = Ascaridia columbae) of the pigeon developed directly,
and Henry (1873) found that A. mystax of the cat and dog were transmitted in
a similar fashion. In 1879, Battista Grassi in Italy undertook an experiment in
an attempt to settle the matter. On 20 July 1879, he ingested about 10 0
embryonated eggs of A. lumbricoides that had been obtained the precedin g
October from the large intestine o f a cadaver and that had been cultivated since
that time. On 21 August 1879 (22 days later ), he claimed to have found Ascaris
eggs in his faeces, thus indicating that direct infection had occurred 51. This
report must be viewed with some circumspection, however, in view of th e
unusually short incubation period that he indicated. A few years later ,
474 A History of Human Helminthology
When the development of the larva within the egg had been discovered, attent-
ion turned eventually to studyi ng the anatomy of the newly-liberated larvae, the
most important studies in this regard being done by Hallez 54,55. However,
uncertainty still surrounded the nature of the events occurring betwee n
ingestion of the eggs and maturation of the worms. A number of observer s
including, Heller, Leuckart, Grassi, Laennec, Küchenmeister and Vix had seen
immature worms. For example, Heller in Erlangen in present-day Wes t
Germany, had found 18 small worms between 2.75 and 13 mm in length in the
small intestine of a madman; each head had the three characteristic lips but the
sexes were indeterminate 56. It seemed clear, therefore, that growth an d
maturation took place within the small intestine, but the details were unclear.
In order to examine an analogous system, Leuckart studied the development of
A. mystax in the cat. According to Blanchard, Leuckart found larvae 0.4 mm
Ascariasis 475
long in the stomach soon after ingestion. They stayed there until they wer e
1.5-2 mm in length, then passed into the intestine. When the worms ha d
reached 2.8 mm in size, they moulted, losing their perforating tooth an d
acquiring the three lips that were prominent in adult parasites. Blanchar d
(1890) commented that it was likely that A. lumbricoides developed in the
same manner in humans 12. On the other hand, Martin found that the larvae of
the ascarids of the calf, pig, horse and dog only hatched when eggs reached the
small intestine, as indeed Davaine had found in rats that had been given A.
lumbricoides.
No further significant advances were made until Francis Stewart, an English-
man working in Hong Kong, began to exp eriment with Ascaris in pigs in 1915.
First, he fed large numbers of embryonated A. suum eggs to a pig on 13
occasions between 20 September and 6 December 1915. When the animal was
killed on 15 December, only one small Ascaris was found. A second pig was
given large numbers of mature A. lumbricoides ova between 27 September and
2 December 1915; its faeces were examined repeatedly until 17 April 1916 ,
but no eggs were found. Stewart interpreted these findings as indicating tha t
direct infection did not occur, so he reverted to the modes of investigation used
50 years earlier by Davaine. On 6 April 1916, he fed mature A. lumbricoides
ova to four rats. Faeces passed between six and 22 hours later contained free
larvae of A. lumbricoides. Thereupon, Stewart gave A. suum ova three times
to three of the rats and twice to the fourth rat which then received a second dose
of A. lumbricoides ova. Two days after its final infection, the last rat died. At
autopsy of this animal, the lungs appeared congested and microscopica l
examination revealed numerous active larvae. A few larvae were also found in
the liver. The other three rats seemed to have pneumonia, so one of them was
killed and abundant larvae were again found in the lungs. Histologica l
examination of the lungs of these rats r evealed larvae in the alveolar spaces and
in the bronchi. The third rat was killed 12 days after the last infection, but no
larvae were found. In order to determine whether larvae in the lungs of a ra t
were capable of further development in another host, Stewart gave portions of
infected lung to a pig. He killed the animal two weeks later but failed to fin d
any ascarids. Nevertheless, he advanced some possible reasons to explain this
negative finding and concluded:
The life history of A. lumbricoides presents an alternation of hosts....When ripe eggs
reach the alimentary canal of the rat....or mouse....they hatch. The larvae liberated
enter the bodies of their host, a few only escaping in the faeces. Between four and six
days after infection they are found in the blood vessels of the lungs and liver . . On the
sixth day, they have passed from the blood vessels into the air vesicles of the lung
causing haemorrhage into them....they are (then) found....in the bronchi....On the
sixteenth day the host is free from parasites....It is obvious that the transfer of the
parasite from the bronchi of the rat and mouse to the intestine of man and of the pig
could be readily effected. The intermediate host might readily contaminate the food
of the definitive host and the dust and earth of his surroundings. 115
Stewart's paper was published in the British Medical Journal of 1 July 1916 115.
476 A History of Human Helminthology
In the issue of the following week, a laudatory letter written by Ronald Ross,
the discoverer of the life cycle of malaria, appeared:
Will you allow me space to offer my warmest congratulations to Captain F.H. Stewart
I.M.S., upon his work on the above subject [the life history of Ascaris lumbricoides],
the most important medical work which has been done for a long time past. The mode
of entry of Ascaris has perplexed everyone from the beginning of parasitology,
because no intermediate host could be found, or even suggested, while direct infection
seemed unlikely for many reasons, in spite of the alleged result of various
experiments. That rats and mice are apparently the intermediate hosts will come as a
great surprise to many, and will constitute a valuable addition to medical zoology. 109
No doubt with his own experie nce in mind of when he was ordered to abandon
his malaria research at a critical stage in favour of studies on kala azar, Ross
added:
His paper is also another proof of the common observation that important discoveries
must wait until the proper kind of worker comes along to tackle them. I hope sincerely
that, in spite of the war, every facility will be given to Captain Stewart to complete his
invaluable work.109
In fact, this was the first of a series of fragmented, confusing and contradictory
reports which were spread over the next five years. Stewart at first placed an
emphasis on his observation exactly the opposite to the correct state of affairs.
However, an editorial in the British Medical Journal discussing Stewart's first
paper made no reference to his theory that rats and mice were intermediat e
hosts in the life cycle of A. lumbricoides and, no doubt with the experiments of
Calandruccio and others in mind, suggested instead that the complete cycle of
migration through the lungs and d evelopment within the one host might occur 5.
There was, of course, precedent for this idea, for Looss had demonstrated ten
years earlier a similar sequence of events in ancylostomiasis (see chapter 20).
Nevertheless, Stewart was so upset that he wrote complaining that insufficient
weight had been given to his experiments on pigs in which he failed to induce
direct infection and he rejected as untenable the idea that Ascaris passes
through the lungs of the same host as that in which it attains full maturity 116. It
must be said in Stewart's defence, however, t hat these experiments were carried
out under extremely difficult conditions during wartime. He himself was well
aware of the deficiencies for he wrote in a footnote to one paper:
The author regrets that he is obliged to publish incomplete work and pleads in excuse
that he has been obliged to discontinue the research, not knowing when he will have
an opportunity of resuming it.121
Although Stewart made a major contribution in discovering the systemi c
migration of Ascaris larvae, subsequent events were to show that he was quite
wrong in ascribing transmission to an intermediate host. In fact, he did not give
up the idea of an intermediary role for rod ents for some time. He postulated that
larvae might escape from the rodents in their saliva, and showed that larva e
obtained from the lungs could survive for up to 24 hours on damp bread 117. He
then repeated his attempts to transfer A. lumbricoides larvae to pigs; he fed
infected rat and mouse lung to four pigs and recovered small numbers (1-15)
Ascariasis 477
of ascarids in three of them and no worms in the fourth pig. Although Stewart
wrote that these experiments could hardly be considered very satisfactory, the
fact that two control pigs had no worms, enabled him to cling to the belief:
The experiments which have been conducted so far tend to prove that the larvae from
the lungs of rodents can infect the pig, and it is probable that in nature infection in
man and the pig takes place by food contaminated by rats and mice. 117
More enduring, however, were his studies of the migration of worms in mice.
Stewart believed that A. lumbricoides larvae hatched when the eggs wer e
ingested then either bored their way into the venules of the portal system o r
ascended the bile duct. He found larvae in dilated hepatic capillaries between
two and five days after infection following which they escaped through th e
hepatic veins to the lungs where they were filtered out in the pulmonar y
capillaries. They then passed together with effused blood into the alveola r
spaces on the sixth day and the worms ascended the bronchial tree and reached
the mouth by the eighth day117,119. Stewart found later, however, that the larvae
in the mouth were swallowed subsequently and passed through the intestines
to be excreted in the faeces 118,120.
In 1917, Ransom and Foster in the United States repeated many of Stewart's
experiments. They confirmed the systemic migration of A. suum larvae in rats
and mice. They also attempted to infect pigs, and although they failed t o
achieve patent infections, suggested, on very tenuous grounds, that this ma y
have been due to the age of the animals rather than indicating that an inter -
mediate host was required 101. Nevertheless, Sadao Yoshida reported in 1918
that it was possible for infection to be acquired from larvae obtained from an
intermediate host. He swallowed A. lumbricoides larvae taken from the lungs
of a guinea pig, but at first had a negative result. He then ingested 50 large r
larvae (1.65 mm long) recovered from the trachea of a guinea pig and foun d
eggs in his faeces 75 days later 141.
Meanwhile, because of repeated suggestions that no intermediate host was
necessary and that migration and maturation occurred within the same host ,
Stewart undertook further experiments with A. suum infections in pigs. He
showed that, in this host too, larvae migrated through the lungs with the pigs
suffering from Ascaris pneumonia. However, he failed to find convincin g
evidence of adult worms in the gut three to four weeks later and considered (in
1918) that while the matter was not yet fully resolved: "the evidence of these
six experiments is opposed to the hypothesis of direct development without an
intermediate host"121. Even so, he continued to be plagued with uncertainty. In
1919, Stewart reported the results of infecting two four-day-old pigs wit h
22,000 A. suum eggs. Large numbers of ascarids were seen in the intestines of
one pig two weeks later, but none at all could be found in the other pig killed
after another five days. A third pig, two months old, was given 50,000 eggs ,
and when killed 31 days later; no worms could be found. Stewart wrote with
masterly understatement: "these experiments are very puzzling" 122.
Later in that same year (1919), Ransom and Fos ter announced that A. lumbri-
478 A History of Human Helminthology
coides larvae migrated systemically in g uinea pigs and rabbits as they do in rats
and mice. They also infected a goat twice with A. suum eggs. It died ten days
later and numerous larvae, 1-2 mm long, were found in the lungs, trachea ,
oesophagus and stomach, and thousands of young ascarids, 10 mm in length,
were seen in the small intestine. A lamb had also been fed with ova and killed
103 days later; 50 immature ascarids, 6-13 cm long, were recovered from the
bowel. These results reinforced Ra nsom and Foster in their belief that infection
was direct 102.
Stewart later (1920) came round to this view when he found young worms
in the small intestine of three pigs fed with A. suum eggs124, for he wrote in
1920: "It is extremely probable that the worm can undergo full development in
one host alone - that is, man or the pig" 123.
Final proof that this was indeed the case was provided by Shimesu Koin o
(pen name Sui) in 1922. On 28 August, he ing ested 2,000 A. lumbricoides ova.
A single larva was found in his sputum three days after infection, five on th e
next day, and 178 on the fifth day. He was unable to collect any sputum on the
succeeding two days because he was seriously ill but larvae were then found
again for the next four days. Fifty days after ingestion of eggs, he took a n
anthelmintic and recovered 667 immature A. lumbricoides. Thus, Koino proved
that A. lumbricoides larvae both migrate through the lungs and develop within
the intestine of the same human host 68.
While it was now clear that systemic migrati on occurred and that worms mat-
ured in the one host, uncertainty remained about the precise route by whic h
larvae reached the lungs after hatching in the gut. Yoshida (1918) claimed on
the basis of his experiments that Ascaris larvae bored their way through th e
intestinal wall into the peritoneal cavity, pierced the diaphragm, entered th e
pleural space, then finally penetrated into the lungs from the surface, as ha d
been shown with Paragonimus 142. This view was refuted by a number o f
investigators who showed that larvae passed via the portal vein to the liver ,
then by the hepatic veins and inferior vena cava through the right heart to the
pulmonary vasculature, or via the mesenteric lymphatics and the thoracic duct
to the venous system, and that larvae in the viscera reached those location s
through the systemic circulation 7,40,86,87,100, although one of the authors 7
considered that some larvae might also reach the liver via the peritoneal cavity.
In addition, Ohba in 1925 showed that larvae could be excreted in the urin e
during the migratory stage, with t he maximum output occurring five to six days
after infection 88.
In 1927, Fülleborn41 put all the known facts together and postulated that the
reason why A. lumbricoides larvae could not settle in the gut initially wa s
because this species may have originally re quired an intermediate host, as is the
case with certain fish ascarids, and that later, the definitive host became th e
intermediate host as well. Since Kondo 69 had shown under experimenta l
conditions that artificially-liberated Ascaris larvae smeared on the ski n
Ascariasis 479
The number of complaints that have been ascribed to Ascaris infection over the
centuries is legion. Spontaneous passage of the worms was well-known an d
Hippocrates wrote that this may be preceded by abdominal pain 57. Caelius
Aurelianus (c.450 AD) believed that these worms may cause the gnashing of
teeth by sleeping children, and that when large numbers were present, th e
abdomen became hardened 10. Paulus Aegineta of Alexandria (c.640 AD) des-
cribed in detail what he considered to be the clinical manifestations o f
ascariasis:
Those who have roundworms experience pain of the intestines and stomach, small
dry tickling cough, and in some cases hiccough, sleep with palpitations and irregular
startings; and some start from their sleep with a scream, and again fall over asleep.
The pulse is unequal and the fever has irregular exacerbations, making its attacks with
coldness of the joints, and coming on three and sometimes four times in the day or
night. Children have mastication and projection of the tongue....and grinding of the
teeth; they shut their eyes and wish to remain silent and are offended when disturbed.
Their eyes appear bloody, their cheeks red, and again change to pale. But these things
occur at intervals in a short time. Sometimes the worms crawling up to the stomach
occasion nausea, gnawing pain, and anorexia....When forced to take food, they can
scarcely swallow for nausea, or they vomit what they have taken, or their bowels are
loose with corruption of the food, or are inflated like a bladder, but the rest of the body
is wasted....But one must not expect to find all these symptoms in all cases, but certain
ones, according to prevailing circumstances.1
According to Hoeppli, the Chinese physicians of around the third century AD
considered that ascariasis altered the character of the pulse in various ways:
A pulse felt at the upper Kuan portion to be under light tension and sliding in quality
indicates that ascaris becomes active....A pulse felt....to be floating in quality indicates
that the patient has stagnant heat in his stomach and will vomit ascaris. 59
Again, Hoeppli cites the following exchange:
"What is the distinguishing feature of the pulse in a case of abdominal pain caused by
worms?" somebody asked. The physician replied: "During the ordinary abdominal
pain the pulse becomes feeble and thready. If, on the contrary, it is full and bounding,
it indicates the sure presence of ascaris in the abdomen." 59
Such views changed little over the centuries. As late as 1829, the Englis h
surgeon, William Rhind, gave a comprehensive and remarkable account of the
symptoms and signs that were then believed to attend the presence of intestinal
worms (both roundworms and tapeworms):
The most general symptoms observable in those affected with worms are the
following: - The appearance of the countenance is changed, it is generally very pale
or of a leaden colour, with a red, circumscribed spot in one or both cheeks. The eyes
lose their brilliance, the pupil is enlarged, and a blue rim is perceivable round the
under eyelid. The nose is swelled and very generally the upper lip is somewhat
Ascariasis 481
tumified, and there is continual itching and irritation of both these. Sometimes, too,
there is a bleeding from the nose. There is also headache, throbbing in the ears, a foul
tongue, more saliva than natural in the mouth and the breath is very fetid especially
early in the morning. The appetite is variable; sometimes it is quite gone and at other
times it is voracious with a continual gnawing sensation in the stomach. There is also
nausea and a desire to vomit; when this takes place, the fluid ejected is limpid like
water. There are often violent gripings, and these are principally felt around the
umbilical region. The urine is turbid and after it has deposited a sediment, it has the
appearance of milk and water. The belly too is hard, and feels like a drum. There is
a general emaciation of the body; the sleep is troubled and accompanied by grinding
of teeth. The patient is generally lazy and indolent, sometimes in good and sometimes
in irritable temper. Blindness, deafness, delirium, and even apopleptic and epileptic
fits have been known to have their origin from these worms. The last and most
decisive symptom observed is that in the matter vomited, but more generally in the
alvine secretions, entire worms or portions of them are perceived. 107
Rhind did, however, add some caveats:
It must be remarked that all the above symptoms are not always found in the same
individual; nor do any of them, except the last, exclusively indicate the presence of
worms. When these symptoms occur and cannot be attributed to any other cause, the
strong presumption is that the cause is worms....At the same time, it may be
mentioned that worms sometimes exist, and that in considerable quantities, without
causing any inconvenience or bad symptom whatsoever. 107
The observation that worms may cause no i ll-effects had even led some observ-
ers such as Avicenna, Roeder er and Abildgaard to suggest that worms may not
only be harmless, but may be very useful in the alimentary canal by consuming
excessive nutrients and stimulating bowel movements. Rhind thought that this
was fanciful and deprecated such ideas, saying:
like all other diseases and all other evils which are incident to man, they are to be
combated and warded off by the wisdom and foresight with which he is endowed for
that purpose.107
In contrast to all-encompassing views of the symptomatology of Ascaris
infection, such as espoused by Rhind, Küchenmeister was closer to the trut h
when he wrote baldly in 1855: "as a general rule, the host and his guests agree
very well together and give one another very little mutual trouble" 70. Küchen-
meister did recognize, however, that these parasites could occasionally cause
intestinal obstruction or rarely produce jaundice, pancreatitis or layryngea l
spasm, and had been known to wander through intestinal fistulae.
Even so, a wide range of clinic al manifestations of Ascaris infection was still
accepted by many practitioners, and w as explained on the basis of two different
mechanisms33. Firstly, gastrointestinal symptoms and signs were clearly local
reactions consequent upon the presence of worms in the alimentary system. It
was recognized that roundworms were u sually located in the small intestine but
occasionally they were met with in the biliary system, mouth and pharynx, or
respiratory system. Secondly, "ref lex irritation" or "sympathetic excitation" was
held to account for the diverse non-gastrointestinal symptoms commonl y
blamed upon intestinal helminthiasis. This vague concept seemed to man y
482 A History of Human Helminthology
on the right mammary line....On the twelfth day it was scarcely palpable. . The spleen
was not palpable.68
This clinical picture was re-described in 1932 by Löffler who, in addition to
recounting the clinical features noted by Koino, showed that transien t
pulmonary opacities were present in chest radiographs and that there was an
associated eosinophilia in the peripheral blood 79. Although Löffler's syndrome
was caused commonly by migrating Ascaris larvae, it was recognized tha t
migrating hookworm and Strongyloides larvae, as well as other agents, could
also cause the syndrome. Similar effects were noted ten years later by Voge l
and Minning in Germany who gave Ascaris ova to six volunteers 136, and then
by Brudastov and colleagues in Russia who undertook experimental self -
infections16.
In 1967, Gelpi and Mustafa found that outbreaks of acute respirator y
infection recurring each spring among young local employees of an oi l
company in Saudi Arabia were due to infection with A. lumbricoides; larvae
were found in the sputum then eggs were recovered from the faeces two t o
three months later 46. It was then realized that this presentation was mos t
common in areas where transmission was seasonal, for Spillman 113 showed that
pulmonary ascariasis was rare in areas where transmission was continuou s
throughout the year.
Because populations rarely have solitary A. lumbricoides infections, there
have been few studies of the clinical manif estations of pure intestinal ascariasis,
and it is probable that Küchenmeister's summation of the situation may years
ago was fairly accurate. Nevertheless, small numbers of worms in ectopi c
locations can cause significant and sometimes fatal disease. There have been
hundreds of such reports in the literature of the twentieth century alone, bu t
they represent a very small fraction of the total number of infected persons .
Ascarides have on occasion caused obstructive jaundice, liver abscess ,
pancreatitis, appendicitis and respiratory obstruction, and have migrate d
through intestinal perforations and fistulae, and out through the mouth and the
nose. Of all the various complications, however, intestinal obstruction is th e
most frequent. In a series of 202 cases who had either solitary ascariasis or light
infections with Trichuris trichiura as well, Swartzwelder in New Orleans ,
USA, found in an uncontrolled and selected study that abdominal discomfort
was the chief symptom, fever was quite often present, and that intestina l
obstruction occurred in 18 patients 125.
Although most individuals have only one or two worms, rare patients have
vast numbers. An adult patient in Peiping, China presented with a perforated
intestine; even though 1533 worms were removed from the peritoneal cavity
at operation, he died subsequently and a further 445 worms were recovered at
autopsy, bringing the total number to 1978 ascarids 60. Similarly, 1488 worms
were removed from a patient in Malaysia110, 990 were recovered from a nine
year old European girl and 899 from an eleven year old Hottentot in Sout h
Africa76, and 693 worms were obtained from a two year old child with intestinal
484 A History of Human Helminthology
A diagnosis of Ascaris infection has been made from time to time when adult
worms are expelled spontaneously, usually in the faeces. The diagnosis i s
normally made, however, by finding Ascaris eggs in the stools. Such ova i n
faeces were first illustrated clea rly by Swayne in 1849, although he had no idea
of their true nature, believing them possibly to be involved in the causation of
cholera 126. Indeed, the Rev Mr Berkeley, in discussing the nature of thes e
bodies, went so far as to remark that: "w e still remain to discover what they are,
as it should seem that no ova of entozoa are known which can be reconcile d
with them"11. In 1854, Wedl described the histological examination of a n
intestinal concretion removed from an ingu inal abscess by H Ulrich. In addition
to T. trichiura eggs which Wedl illustrated clearly, other bodies were present
which he noted: "most nearly rese mbled those of Ascaris lumbricoides"137. The
eye of faith is required, however, to recognize such an egg in the figure h e
provided. The diagnosis of ascariasis by microscopical examination of th e
faeces was first put on a sound basis in 1856 by the English physician, W H
Ransom. Ransom described the case of a 12 year old girl who presented at the
Nottingham General Hospital complaining of abdominal pain and giving a
history of having passed two round worms after the administration of a n
aperient. Examination of her stools revealed "very numerous ova of ascari s
lumbricoides, the characters of which are well known and easil y
recognisable"103. and Ransom provided clearcut illustrations of Ascaris ova. It
is perhaps most remarkable that only seven years after an argument had raged
in the columns of The Lancet and the London Medical Gazette, and the College
of Physicians had been disposed to produce a report on the nature of thes e
so-called "cholera bodies", that Ransom was able to write so facilely that the
morphological characteristics of these eggs were well-known and were easily
Ascariasis 485
Over the centuries, a large number of agents has been used for the treatment of
ascariasis. These comprised two major grou ps of compounds: purgatives which
expelled worms by increasing peristalsis and stimulating intestinal secretion,
and vermifuges, including substances of vegetable, animal or mineral origin,
which poisoned the worms themse lves. Concerning purgatives, Elliotson in his
lecture on worms in 1833 wrote that:
486 A History of Human Helminthology
As to getting rid of worms, in the first place, any brisk purgative may answer the
purpose. A good dose of calomel and jalap is an old remedy and a very excellent
one....(or) twelve grains of calomel and half a drachm of rhubarb. 36
With respect to destruction of roundworms, Elliotson advised that oil o f
turpentine was one of the best remedies available:
(it) should be given by the mouth and the dose then is from half an ounce to three
ounces. It is best not to give it fast lest it should create sickness and be lost....The
effect it generally produces is that of making the patient sick, purging him
violently....and causing extreme vertigo.36
As the century progressed, this drug was replaced gradually in popularity by
santonin, the active principle of semen-contra-vermes, so-called because of its
vermifugal properties and its fanci ed resemblance to semen. The drug was pre-
pared from the dried, unexpanded flower heads of the genus Artemisia,
especially A. cina which is common in the Midd le East. Thus, Anderson (1864)
wrote:
The introduction of 'santoninum' into the British Pharmacopoeia was no more than
was expected by those practitioners who have for several years been convinced of its
efficiency, and especially of its superiority to all known anthelmintics in the treatment
of roundworm.4
Because of its toxicity and non-uniformity in its therapeutic effectiveness ,
however, santonin fell into disuse as better drugs became available. Thes e
agents included oil of chenopodium and its active principle, ascaridole ,
prepared from Chenopodium ambrosioides var. anthelminthicum, common in
the United States of America, and thymol found in a large number of plants of
the genera Thymus (thyme), Origanum and Carum (ajowa). Thus, Vervoort in
1913 compared oil of chenopodium, thymol, Eucalyptus oil and sundry other
anthelmintics, and concluded that wormseed oil (oil of chenopodium) was a
good anthelmintic in ascariasis, rather more expensive than thymol, bu t
possessing the advantage of being able to be given in capsules 135.
Another product active agains t Ascaris was helminal, a dried extract of a red
alga, Digenea simplex 35, which had long been used as a popular vermifuge in
Japan, the active principle of which was kainic acid. The anti- Ascaris
properties of the alkylated phenol, hexylresorcinol, were first studied b y
Lamson and colleagues in 1931 71 and this drug became popular for the treat-
ment of ascariasis in the United States. Betanaphthol and carbon tetrachloride
also enjoyed transient popularity with some practitioners. Following the use of
piperazine in enterobiasis (see chapter 17), F ayard in a thesis presented in Paris
in 1949 gave an account of its efficacy in some 2,000 patients with ascariasis;
70-95% of people passed roundworms on the second and third day afte r
treatment, but stool examinations in order to assess the percentage of cures and
the reductions in egg excretion were apparently not performed 38. The efficacy
of the drug in its various forms was confirmed in many published studies ,
beginning in 1954 with those of Brown 14 and Brumpt and Ho-Thi-Sang17 .
Meanwhile, the piperazine derivative, diethylcarbamazine, was shown b y
Ascariasis 487
Many years ago, Chandler wrote that A. lumbricoides has been one of Man's
most faithful and constant companions from time immemorial, and has clung
to mankind through the stone, copper and iron ages up to the present day. He
went on to predict that modern plumbing would eventually dissolve th e
partnership25. The financial, technical, and educational difficulties in providing
effective waste disposal systems in most endemic areas, however, ar e
enormous, and the words Lane wrote fifty years ago are just as apposite today:
Sewered privies cleanly kept are sure safeguards for the user. But to devise privies of
demonstrable effectiveness and inoffensiveness, to provide them for millions of
people of poor means, and to alter the habits of these so that they religiously use and
clean them, is a task which will not be completed within the lifetime of any of us. 72
Ascariasis 489
A. SUUM
This parasite was so named by Goeze in 1782 49, but has also been referred to
frequently in the older literature as A. suilla, a designation given by Dujardin
in 1845. Confusion has reigned for many years as to the relationship between
A. lumbricoides and A. suum. Various investigators could not discern an y
morphological differences between the two form s until Sprent (1952) described
alterations in the labial denticles 114. While many workers have confirmed and
extended Sprent's observations, others have found them to be inconsistent, and
sometimes individual worms could not be differentiated reliably from on e
another. Similarly, differences of opinion have occurred over chromosoma l
numbers and biochemical and immunological characteristics. The sam e
problem has bedevilled using physiological differences in the infectivity o f
roundworms derived from humans or pigs for the opposite host as a
distinguishing feature.
In 1925, Payne and her colleagues infected five young pigs with embryonated
Ascaris eggs of human origin; all anima ls suffered respiratory disturbances, but
no adult worms were recovered from the gut 96. On the other hand, Galvi n
(1968) infected successfully pigs with A. lumbricoides ova, but the percentage
of ova which matured and the duration of infection were reduced when com-
pared with pigs infected with A. suum 43.
Koino in 1922 gave 500 A. suum ova to his brother and produced a severe
respiratory disease. He failed to find Ascaris larvae in the sputum or evidence
of intestinal infection, and contrasted t his with the results of infection of himself
with A. lumbricoides:
490 A History of Human Helminthology
The pig Ascaris can not parasitise till adult worms in human. Therefore although
morphologically they are the same, they are entirely different. If there is a strain of pig
Ascaris which can parasitise in human, it must be a deviated strain. Human body is
not a good host for pig Ascaris.68
Similarly, Payne and her colleagues gav e A. suum ova to two human volunteers
but failed to produce patent infections 96. On the other hand, Takata claimed to
infect successfully 7 of 17 human volunteers who swallowed 2-25 A. suum
eggs, but the prepatent period in many of th em was extraordinarily short (25-29
days)128. Lýsek recovered mature worms from the gastrointestinal tract afte r
administering A. suum eggs to himself 81. Finally, four students in Montreal ,
Canada, swallowed unknowingly large numbers of eggs in food which had been
contaminated maliciously. They all developed severe respiratory infections. In
two of them, immature worms were passed in the stools four months afte r
ingestion of eggs, but no worms were recovered following anthelmintic therapy
seven months after ingestion 97.
Epidemiological evidence suggests that ther e is not much cross-over between
porcine and human ascarids. For example, Caldwell and Caldwell reported in
1926 that 45% of pigs in one region were infected with Ascaris c.f. only 1% of
humans, despite apparently fa vourable conditions for infection of humans from
that source22. Similar observations have been made since in other parts of the
world.
Thus, although the contribution of A. suum to human ascariasis cannot b e
determined precisely, it would seem that A. suum is a possible, though not a
major cause of this condition.
REFERENCES
1. AEGINETA P. De re medica. The seven books of Paulus Aegineta, translated by F
Adams, The Sydenham Society, London, three volumes, 1844-1847
2. AMATO NETO V, LEVI GC, CAMPOS LL. Observaçoes sobre a atividad e
anti-helmintica do pamoato de pirantel. I. Tratamento da ascaridiase. Revista do Instituto
de Medicina Tropical de São Paulo 12: 207-210, 1970
3. AMATUS LUSITANIUS. Medici physici praestantissimi. Curationum medicinaliu m
centuria quatuor etc, B Constantinus, Venetiis, pp 645, 1557
4. ANDERSON W. On santonine: with especial reference to its use in the round an d
thread-worm. British Medical Journal i: 443-445, 1864
5. ANONYMOUS. The life history of Ascaris lumbricoides . British Medical Journal ii: 23,
1916
6. ARISTOTLE. Opera omnia, graece et latine, cum indice nominum et rerum absolutissimo,
F Dübner, E Heitz et UC Bussemaker (Editors), Didot, Parisiis, five volumes, 1848-1874
7. ASADA J. (Experimentelle Unt ersuchung ueber die Entwicklung und Infektionswege von
Ascaris lumbricoides.) Tokyo Iji Shinshi pp 161-168, 218-223, 1921. In Japanese .
Abstracted in Tropical Diseases Bulletin 21: 568-569, 1924
8. ASADA J. (On the development of ascarid larvae in the body of the host. Especially on
the desquamation of the ascarid larvae and the nourishing substances for the ascari d
larvae.) Tokyo Iji Shinshi No 2366, pp 812-815, 1924. In Japanese. Astracted in Japan
Medical World 4: 179, 1924
Ascariasis 491
obstruction due to accumulation of very large numbers of round worms. British Journal of
Surgery 11: 432-438, 1924
77. LINNAEUS C. Systema naturae sive per regna triae naturae, secundum classes, ordines,
genera , species, cum characteri bus, differentiis, synonymis, locis, tenth edition, L Salvii,
Holmiae, two volumes, pp 823, 1758
78. von LINSTOW O. Ueber den Zwischenwirth von Ascaris lumbricoides L. Zoologischer
Anzeiger 9: 525-528, 1886
79. LÖFFLER W. Zur Differential-Diagnose der Lungenfiltrierungen: uber fluchtig e
SuccedanInfiltraten (mit Eosino philie). Beiträge zur Klinik Tuberkulose und specifischen
TuberkuloseForschung 79: 368-382, 1932
80. LUTZ A. Zur Frage der Uebertragung des mensichlichen Spulworms. Weiter e
Mittheilungen. Centralblatt für Bakteriologie und Parasitenkunde, Abteilung originale 3:
425-428, 1888
81. LÝSEK H. P ispevek k otázce patogenity škrkavky prase i pro lov ka. eskoslovenska
Epidemiologie, Mikrobiologie, Imunologie 10: 134-136, 1961
82. MAUNG M. The occurrence of the second moult of Ascaris lumbricoides and Ascaris
suum. International Journal for Parasitology 8: 371-378, 1978
83. MIURA K, NISHIUCHI K. Ueber befruchte und unbefruchtete Ascarideier i m
menschlichen Kote. Centralblatt für Bakteriologie, Parasitenkunde un d
Infektionskrankheiten, Abteilung originale 32: 637-641, 1902
84. MORISHITA K. Studies on the epidemiological aspects of ascariasis in Japan and basic
knowledge concerning its control. In, Progress of medical parasitology in Japan, K
Morishita, Y Komiya and H Matsubayashi (Editors), Meguro Parasitological Museum,
Tokyo, volume 4, pp 3-153, 1972
85. MOSLER F. Ueber einen Fall von Helminthia sis. Archiv für pathologische Anatomie und
Physiologie und für klinische Medizin (Virchow) 18: 242-250, 1860
86. NETTESHEIM W. Das Wandern der Spulwurmlarven in inneren Organen. Münchener
medizinische Wochenschrift 69: 1304-1306, 1922
87. NISHIGORI M, OHBA T. (On the route of migration in the host's body taken by th e
Ascaris.) Nissin Igaku 13: 13-16, 1924. In Japanese. Abstracted in Japan Medical World
4: 263, 1924
88. OHBA T. (Investigation on the presence of Ascaris-larvae in the urine during the initial
stage of infection with Ascaris.) Taiwan Igakka Zasshi No 242, pp 465-469, 1925. I n
Japanese, with English summary
89. OLIVER-GONZALEZ J, SANTIAGO-STEVENSON D , HEWITT RI. Treatment of six
cases of ascariasis in man with 1-diethylcarbamyl 4-methylpiperazine hydrochloride .
Southern Medical Journal 42: 65-66, 1949
90. ORIHEL TC. Primates as models for parasitological research. In, Medical Primatology,
S Karger, Basel, pp 772-782, 1971
91. OTTO GF, CORT WW. Further studies on post-treatment reinfection with Ascaris in the
United States. Journal of Parasitology 20: 245-247, 1934
92. OTTO GF, CORT WW, KELLER AE. Environmental studies of families in Tennessee
infested with Ascaris, Trichuris and hookworm. American Journal of Hygiene 14 :
156-193, 1931
93. PAN C, RITCHIE LS, HUN TER GW. Reinfection and seasonal fluctuations of Ascaris
lumbricoides among a group of children in an area where night soil is used. Journal of
Parasitology 40: 603-608, 1954
94. PANAROLUS D. Iatrologismorum seu medicinalium observationum pentecosta e
quinque etc., F Moneta, Romae, pp 445, 1652. Partly translated in 133
95. PAPYROS EBERS. Das hermetische Buch über die Arzneimittel alten Aegypter i n
hieratischer Schrift. Herausgegeben, mit Inhaltsangabe und Einleitung versehen vo n
Georg Ebers, Mit hieroglyphisch-lateinischem Glossar von Ludwig Stern, Leipzig, two
volumes, 1875. The Papyrus Ebers, translated from the German version by CP Bryan,
Ascariasis 495
BC Adult worms have been known since ancient times and various
anthelmintics have been employed
c.170 AD Galen knew that adult worms normally inhabited the upper small intestine
1683 Tyson described the anatomy of the worm and clearly distinguished it from
the earthworm. He discovered the eggs
1849 Gros found that eggs took several months to embryonate
1856 Ransom showed that ascariasis could be diagnosed by finding eggs in the
faeces
1862 Davaine showed that eggs remained viable for up to five years
1862 Davaine discovered that when embryonated eggs were fed to rats, larvae
were liberated in the small intestine then were passed in the faeces
1879 Grassi swallowed embryonated eggs and claimed to find evidence of a
patent infection 22 days later
1886 Calandruccio gave 150 eggs to a boy and recovered 143 worms after
anthelmintic administration three months later
1916 Stewart found that larvae liberated from eggs in the intestines of rats
underwent systemic migration through the lungs then returned to the gut
1922 Koino infected himself with 2,000 eggs, recovered larvae from his sputum
several days after infection, then recovered 667 immature worms from his
intestines after anthelmintic administration 50 days after infection
1949 Fayard reported that piperazine was a useful treatment
1958 Bephenium was shown by Goodwin and colleagues to be useful for
treatment
1962 Bui Quoc Hong and co-workers showed that thiabendazole was an effective
treatment
1966 Tetramisole was demonstrated by Do Nascimento and colleagues to be
efficacious
1969 Thienpont and colleagues showed that levamisole was even more effective
than tetramisole
1970 Amato Neto and co-workers indicated that pyrantel was active
1973 Mebendazole was shown by a number of investigators to be useful in
ascariasis
__________________________________________________________________
Chapter 20
SYNOPSIS
In May 1838, while dissecting the body of a peasant woman who had died of
pulmonary infarction in the Maggiore Hospital in Milan, the Italian doctor,
Angelo Dubini, encountered "a little worm in the small intestine, in the midst
of much gray mucus....this worm impressed me as having really distinct generic
characteristics" 70. Dubini did not publish news of this discovery, however, until
he came across the parasite again four and a half years later. In November
1842, Dubini found another example of this peculiar worm in the jejunum of
an old lady who had suffered with dropsy (oedema). Both of these parasites,
and the specimen he found in a third patient in the following month, were all
499
500 A History of Human Helminthology
female worms. On 15 December 1842, Dubini found a dozen worms in the first
part of the jejunum of a woman who had died from a chest abscess, and this
time, male helminths were present. The parasites were so frequent, that in the
course of 100 autopsies, he encountered them in more than twenty cadavers.
Dubini described the worms as being:
somewhat curved in on themselves....about four and one half lines [= 1 cm] in length,
transparent in the anterior, and marked by wavy yellow brown or red stripes in the
posterior three quarters. A black spherical dot marks the boundary between the
transparent and colored parts. Posteriorly, the female has a blunt tail which is slightly
curved.70
Dubini recognized that the worms were nematodes, for they were cylindrical
in shape, elastic, possessed a complete intestinal tract with a mouth at one end
and an anus at the other, and were unisexual. There were a number of char-
acteristics, however, which he felt justified the erection of a new genus in which
to place this worm. He described the salient features:
Head not distinct from body; round mouth furnished with four hooks folded back
towards the center and situated above conical eminences which project from the
interior of the pharynx; esophagus enlarged at the bottom like a club and distinct from
the spherical, blackish stomach; blunt tail in the female, spread out like a fan in the
male; a single central penis in which are inserted two small vas deferens.70
Dubini named the genus Agchylostoma, being a mistransliteration of the Greek
words (AGCHYLOS i.e. ANCHYLOS because before [CH]
should be transliterated as "N" and not "G") and µ (STOMA), meaning
"curved" and "mouth", respectively. Dubini thought that was the
Greek word for "hook" and intended the name to reflect the hooked shape of the
body of the parasite and its prominent mouth. In addition, he gave it the specific
epithet, duodenale, to indicate its common location in the intestine.
Dubini considered the reasons why the worm, despite its moderate size, had
not been discovered earlier. Until a short period before his own era, it had not
been the general practice to open the bowel at autopsy, and the worm was so
small that there would have been no chance of feeling it through the intestinal
wall when squeezing the gut. When it became common to open the intestines
and examine the mucosa (particularly in patients with typhoid fever and
tuberculosis), the usual procedure was to wash out the intestinal lumen with
large volumes of water which would probably have carried away many worms.
Finally, the worms were ordinarily embedded in somewhat opaque mucus
which made it extremely difficult to visualize them.
Dubini's discovery was confirmed several years later in Egypt by the German
physician, Pruner (1846) 171, then by the latter's compatriots, Bilharz 31
and
Griesinger , also in Egypt. In 1865, Wucherer found the parasite in Brazil204,
92
then the worm was found subsequently in many countries. A number of studies
were then made of the anatomy of the worm, the most complete and extensive
being those of Looss in Cairo141.
Confusion and controversy reigned over the proper name of the worm. In
addition to Dubini's name of Agchylostoma duodenale, it was called Ancylo-
Hookworm Disease 501
In 1868, Camuset appreciated that the hookworm found in South America was
distinct from A. duodenale seen in Europe and Africa and indicated clearly the
differential characteristics. This information was buried in a thesis52, however,
and was not generally known until Leger drew attention to it in 1921125.
Likewise, Adolfo Lutz in 1888 noted some differences between the Brazilian
hookworm and the European form, but did not classify the former as a new
species143. In 1901, Dr AJ Smith in Galveston, Texas, USA, recognized that the
worms expelled by a patient from a plantation in southern Mexico were not the
same as Dubini's A. duodenale but thought that they might be identical with
Uncinaria stenocephala of dogs189. Smith sent specimens to CW Stiles in
Washingtom as did Drs CA Claytor in Washington, DC, and BK Ashford in
Puerto Rico. Stiles described a number of morphological differences between
this parasite and classical A. duodenale (which, following Railliet, he called
Uncinaria duodenalis), including replacement of the hook-like teeth in the
mouth by semilunar plates, the location of the vulva, and appearance of the
caudal bursa of male worms. In addition, he thought that the eggs of the
American worm were slightly larger. Stiles concluded that:
These parasites differ from all of the members of the genus Uncinaria which I can
find recorded, and on that account, I propose to base a new species, Uncinaria
americana, upon them.192
In 1903, Stiles suggested splitting up the genus Uncinaria (i.e. Ancylostoma)
and placed the American hookworm in the subgenus, Necator 193. He elevated
this subgenus to generic status in 1906194. The name meant "the killer" and was
derived from the Latin word "neco", meaning "to kill". In 1915, the Inter-
national Commission on Zoological Nomenclature in Opinion 66 declared that
the official name for the parasite was Necator americanus 105.
502 A History of Human Helminthology
Dubini made little mention of hookworm ova other than to say that the elliptical
eggs could be seen in the oviduct of female worms, and to provide a
rudimentary drawing of them in situ 70. Not much attention was paid to the eggs
over the next twenty years, and Wucherer in 1866 wrote "Nothing is known
about the way in which the eggs or embryos of Ancylostoma are introduced into
the human body and under what conditions they exist outside it"204.
In view of the unavailability of A. duodenale in Germany at the time, Rudolf
Leuckart, in the same year that Wucherer wrote those words, made some
observations on the related hookworm of dogs, Dochmius trigonocephalus
(now called Uncinaria stenocephala) in order to study any developments
which may occur within the egg. He found that when the eggs were placed in
damp earth or mud, the segmented embryo formed a larva which hatched after
three or four days. The larvae moulted after a further three days, then a second
moult at the end of another week coincided with a marked change in the
internal organization of the worms, and they were no longer able to feed.
Leuckart supposed that these forms, which resembled Rhabditis (a free-living
worm), must enter some intermediate host, but preliminary experiments were
Hookworm Disease 503
In any case, Looss was not convinced that everything had indeed been clarified
about the life cycle. He then claimed that in eight months he had advanced
knowledge further than Leichtenstern had done over many years, and went on
to justify this assertion by describing the percutaneous penetration of infective
larvae138 (see later).
Another blind alley also bedevilled a proper understanding of the in vitro
development of hookworms for over thirty years. In 1886, Leichtenstern first
put forward the proposition that hookworms underwent heterogony, i.e. larvae
developed outside the human body into a generation of sexual animals which
in their turn produced offspring. Such a phenomenon had been described with
Strongyloides stercoralis (see chapter 21). Leichtenstern wrote:
By observing suitable culture methods....a freeliving, sexually mature rhabditis form,
reproducing itself through unlimited generations, was successfully cultivated from the
egg and larva of ankylostoma; a form which is essentially distinct form the parasitic
ankylostoma....I foresee that my observations, being that of an 'outsider' will not at
once be accepted by zoologists, but rather be received with careful reserve and
incredulity.126
Nevertheless, Leichtenstern wrote categorically: "I am in a position entirely to
dispose of all such doubts and objections" 126. He then went on to canvass the
possibilities that these freeliving worms might be identical with either
freeliving nematodes which frequently occur in decaying matter, or may be
S. stercoralis which was sometimes found in association with hookworms in
the intestines. Later that year, however, Leichtenstern retracted these statements
when further experiments convinced him of his error127. Many years later,
Looss remarked somewhat pontifically:
Supreme personal confidence in his method of research, and neglect inspired by this
confidence of the biological probabilities pointed out by specialists on the subject,
were the reasons which made it possible that Leichtenstern was deceived. It is
fortunate in the interests of science that he was soon convinced himself that he was
in the wrong; for where personal convictions play the most prominent part it is not
always easy for impersonal reason brought forward by others, to gain a hearing.142
Ironically, the same trap was to befall Looss with his insistence that the
transmission of schistosomiasis was direct, yet, unlike Leichtenstern, Looss in
that instance remained obdurate.
Although the question of the existence or non-existence of heterogony in
A. duodenale was settled rapidly as far as the German literature was concerned
by the recantation of Leichtenstern, the same did not apply to English
investigators. In 1889-1890 and quite independently of Leichtenstern, Captain
GM Giles of the Indian Medical Service in Assam made observations during
the course of an investigation into the aetiology of kala azar and beri beri which
caused him to claim that heterogony occurred with hookworm83. Giles's views
were soon opposed by Macdonald who repeated the experiments but failed to
verify the findings; he believed that Giles had inadvertently cultured S.
stercoralis 145. This view was echoed by Kynsey112 then Sonsino suggested that
Giles may have cultured freeliving nematodes. On the other hand, Giles was
506 A History of Human Helminthology
In 1898, Arthur Looss reported that infective hookworm larvae penetrated the
intact skin. This was a momentous discovery, for it was the first time that the
percutaneous penetration of any worm was shown. The discovery itself was
serendipitous. Looss had attempted to infect himself experimentally with
Strongyloides stercoralis, and on examining his faeces, was surprised to find
numerous Ancylostoma eggs. He reflected, therefore, on how this might have
occurred. He had never had any misgivings about allowing water containing
hookworms to settle on his hands, although he had ensured that they had been
kept away from his mouth. The matter remained inexplicable to him until he
had another experience:
A drop of water with a high larva content fell on my hand one day and rolled off. I
paid no attention to this moist spot which dried itself after a few minutes. But at the
same time I felt there an intense burning....and the spot became extremely red. What
508 A History of Human Helminthology
was the meaning of this? The cause could only be the Ancylostoma larva.138
Looss then repeated the process with water alone, but had no repetition of the
reaction. Thereupon, he applied some more larvae to the skin:
The reddening of the skin and the burning sensation started exactly as before. I then
scraped off the last moisture residue from the epidermis....The Ancylostoma larvae
previously present in such abundance had disappeared except for a few very indolent
ones; in their place among the scraped-off epidermal cells were found numerous
empty worm skins! The larvae themselves could only have penetrated the skin.138
In fact, his hand was so swollen the next day that he thought it best to ask for
medical help. Two or three months later, he noted a considerable increase in
the number of hookworm eggs in his stools138.
This assertion by Looss that hookworm larvae penetrated the skin was met
with hostile criticism from a number of quarters, so much so that he determined
to say nothing more on the subject till he could prove his point. The most
telling argument against his hypothesis was that he could have acquired the
infection naturally as he lived in an endemic area. This necessitated morph-
ological confirmation by Looss of penetration of the skin by larvae. First, he
tried to infect skin removed from a cadaver and heated to 37oC; this was
unsuccessful. Next, with the cooperation of his colleague Maddern, who was
professor of surgery at Kasr-el-Aini Hospital in Cairo, he extended his
observations by infecting a 13 year old boy who was about to have his leg
amputated. One hour before operation, a drop of fluid containing many larvae
was spread out on the skin. Immediately following removal of the leg at
operation, a section of skin was excised and histological sections were
prepared. Looss found that the larvae entered the skin and that they did this via
the hair follicles:
Inside the hair follicles the larvae crowded toward the hair papilla. When particularly
numerous in the same follicle, they completely destroyed the outer root sheath.
Having reached the hair papilla they left the follicles to penetrate the adjacent tissue
of the cutis vera.139
and concluded "That actual penetration of the Ancylostoma larvae into the skin
does occur can now be looked upon as unassailable" 139.
Looss's colleague, FM Sandwith, professor of medicine at the same hospital,
later in the year (1901), presented Looss's observations to the annual meeting
of the British Medical Association 177. (This caused some confusion and Sand-
with later had to specifically emphasize that it was Looss's and not his own
research to which he was alluding178.) In the ensuing discussion, GM Giles,
despite being opposed to Looss in the matter of heterogonic development of
hookworm, supported ardently the latter in this respect, and remarked that he
had examined Looss's histological sections when in Cairo a short while
before86. Patrick Manson, on the other hand, was somewhat more cynical:
I would deprecate premature interpretation of the fact as indicating a phase in the
normal life-history of the parasite or as a method of infection....Before the fact can be
accepted as more than a curiosity, further experiments....should be carried out.147
In view of the continued scepticism, Looss persuaded an hospital attendant
Hookworm Disease 509
was spilt upon the hand and produced immediate itching. The following day,
the area was grossly inflamed. After two days, axillary lymphadenitis was
present, then marked bronchitis succeeded on the third day. The stools became
positive 38 days after infection51. In 1933, Maplestone reported the successful
experimental infection of humans with A. ceylanicum 148.
Thus, there was no doubt that infection could be acquired percutaneously.
The next question concerned the relative importance of the oral and per-
cutaneous routes in human hookworm infection. Peiper in German East Africa
(1912) conducted a careful series of studies and concluded that although a
small proportion of infections may be acquired orally, either by drinking
contaminated water or by consumption of contaminated, raw vegetables, the
usual mode of infection was undoubtedly by way of the skin, with larvae being
either brushed off damp grass or taken up from infected soil by the feet165.
Finally, two other routes of infection have been suggested. In 1917, Howard
reported the discovery of ova in the stool of an infant only 14 days old102, then
de Langen found them in the faeces of a six day old infant122. The only possible
explanation other than that unclean habits on the part of an infected mother may
have introduced ova into the mouth, and that these passed through the gastro-
intestinal tract unchanged, was that prenatal, transplacental infection had
occurred. More recently, it has been suggested that hookworm larvae may be
transmitted in breast milk.
Having proven to his own satisfaction, if not to everyone else's, that larvae
penetrated the skin, Looss then turned his attention to examining the course of
migrating larvae within the body, and in the process of defining this remarkable
pathway, proved the truth of his theory beyond any doubt. For these
experiments, Looss used dogs and infected them with the hookworm,
A. caninum, which was able to complete its development in that host. First, he
infected some puppies percutaneously, and when they died nine days later,
found immature ancylostomes in the small intestine. He then infected a group
of puppies and killed them at various times after infection. Looss showed that
larvae entered the lymphatics in the subcutaneous tissues and passed via the
draining lymph nodes to the bloodstream, or else entered the veins and were
carried through the right heart to the lungs. He found larvae both in the
pulmonary capillaries and in the alveolar air spaces, although he did not see a
worm precisely in the act of escaping from a capillary to an alveolus. The
larvae then migrated quickly upwards along the surface of the bronchiolar,
bronchial and tracheal epithelium, then passed through the larynx to the
oesophagus. During their migration through the respiratory tree, Looss noted
that the larvae began to grow and became prepared for the third ecdysis,
Hookworm Disease 511
although that event did not take place until the worms had reached the intest-
ines. He then repeated this experiment with A. duodenale in dogs, and found
that the larvae penetrated the skin and passed to the lungs, but that in their
ascent of the airways, they grew less rapidly and that no trace of the provisional
mouth-capsule, which normally appeared prior to moulting, was present.
Furthermore, most of the larvae made their way into the tracheal mucosa and
very few reached the gut; those that did were passed in the faeces. Looss pre-
sented his findings to the International Congress of Zoology in Berne in 1904
and published his results in detail in the following year141.
Looss's observations were soon confirmed by other workers. Fritz Schaudinn
of the German Imperial Board of Health infected monkeys with hookworm
larvae percutaneously. The first animal died 13 days later and 36 worms were
found in the small bowel. A second monkey was infected on 11, 29 and 30 June
1904, then killed six hours after the last infection; worms were found in the
skin, heart, lungs and intestine181. In the following year, Lambinet produced
patent infections in dogs given A. caninum orally, percutaneously and
subcutaneously; he found that most of those given orally or subcutaneously
matured but that a proportion of those given percutaneously perished in the
process113.
In 1914, Friedrich Fülleborn reported an extensive series of investigations
on the migration of S. stercoralis and Ancylostoma in dogs. Fülleborn inter-
rupted the tracheo-oesophageal route by tracheotomy or oesophagotomy in
order to see whether this route was essential for the maturation of worms in the
gut. When the former operation was performed and a dog was then infected
percutaneously, larvae were found in the tracheal mucus 2-6 days later, but a
few eggs were seen in the faeces. When another dog underwent the latter
operation and was then infected subcutaneously, no hookworms developed in
the gut. Consequently, Fülleborn concluded that the vast majority of larvae
followed the pulmonary circuit78.
Soon afterwards, Miyagawa (1916) investigated the migratory route of
A. caninum larvae in dogs and confirmed the pulmonary-oesophageal route
after percutaneous infection. In addition, he showed that some of the larvae
given orally also followed this pathway after boring through the oesophageal
or gastric mucosa151. On the other hand, Yokogawa and Oiso repeated this
experiment with tracheotomized dogs some ten years later, and concluded that
the pulmonary route was not necessary for maturation 207. Nevertheless, both
Fülleborn 79 and Okada158 introduced A. caninum larvae into isolated loops of
small intestine and found mature worms in the normal bowel, thus indicating
that systemic migration must have occurred. The question remains incompletely
resolved, and the behaviour of A. duodenale and N. americanus in humans
after oral infection is unknown.
What is clear is that worms mature in the gut two to three months after
infection. A number of studies have been carried out on the persistence of
512 A History of Human Helminthology
In the first four patients found by Dubini, all the worms were located in the
intestinal mucus. In the next positive cadaver that he dissected (on 1 January
1845), however, he saw that "Two of them (the worms) were firmly attached
by their heads to the mucosa, and the mucosa was specked with small red
dots"70. Subsequently, Dubini found hookworms in many patients, either in a
free state, or sucking onto the intestinal mucosa. As a result of his accumulated
observations during many post-mortem examinations, he reached the following
conclusions about the worms:
- their exclusive habitat is the duodenum and the beginnings of the jejunum.
- the mucosa, to which the worms sometimes adhere by their oral cavity, may appear
to be normal or else slaty, greatly specked with black or red, or also simply
hypervascular.
- the variety of illnesses from which these people died does not permit us to establish
a relationship between the affliction and the presence of these worms70
Although he did not realize their significance, Dubini made two observations
necessary for a proper understanding of the pathogenesis of hookworm disease
- the attachment of worms to the small intestinal mucosa by their mouth and the
small haemorrhages around worms.
The person who was able to herald the pathological importance of hookworm
infection was Wilhelm Griesinger while working in Cairo. Many patients in
Griesinger's clinic suffered from severe anaemia, the syndrome being labelled
by Griesinger and his colleagues as Egyptian chlorosis. He sought the aetiology
of this condition without success for several months. During one of his last
autopsies (17 April 1852) before his return to Germany, much light was shed
on the matter. A twenty year old soldier died, apparently from diarrhoea. At
autopsy, all the organs were extremely anaemic, the heart was dilated and the
lungs were markedly oedematous. When Griesinger examined the intestines,
however, he found that:
the duodenum, the whole jejunum and even the upper half of the ileum were
completely filled with fresh, red, partly coagulated blood. Thousands of ancylostomes
were hanging in the mucosa of the small intestine, each with its own small petechia
resembling the bite of a leech.92
He concluded, therefore:
Hookworm Disease 513
It was clear that in every respect the deceased belonged to the 'chlorotics', and had bled
to death. Since then I have become convinced that the 'Egyptian chlorosis' is an
entozoal disease, above all an ancylostomiasis.92
Griesinger postulated that the daily loss of blood in the gastrointestinal tract
must result in anaemia. He asserted that such haemorrhage need not be visible
macroscopically, since not only did bleeding come from the upper small bowel,
but the faeces of Egyptians were copious and mushy as they consumed large
quantities of bread. Rather, he believed that the continuous extraction of blood
for their own sustenance by hundreds or thousands of hookworms over the
years would be sufficient to account for the development of anaemia. Griesinger
left Egypt shortly thereafter and was unable to prove his views statistically, but
had no doubt that subsequent investigators would confirm his hypothesis92. In
fact, his colleague, Theodor Bilharz, who carried on this work, came to the
same conclusions and published his observations 31 two years before
Griesinger's paper appeared.
Despite these tantalizing suggestions, little further attention was paid to the
subject until Otto Wucherer in Brazil recognized the same phenomenon. In
December 1865, he was called to see a slave in a sugar mill who was grossly
oedematous and markedly anaemic. The patient died within 24 hours and at
autopsy, Wucherer found many hookworms and the same features that Gries-
inger had described. In order to ensure that the association was not
coincidental, Wucherer made post-mortem examinations on twelve persons
with other diseases and failed to find any hookworms. Furthermore, since he
found subsequently the parasites in the bodies of five more patients who had
this syndrome (which he called hypoaemia or tropical chlorosis), he was
convinced of a causal relationship between the two events204,206. The publication
of Wucherer's findings led J R de Moura in Rio de Janeiro to examine the
bodies of patients with tropical chlorosis and he also found hookworms in
them153 . Subsequently, Grenet in the French colony of Comoros (1867) 91
,
Camuset in French Guiana (1868) 52, and Kérangel in the French colony of
Cayenne (1868) 108 confirmed Wucherer's observations.
The findings of Wucherer and de Moura were discussed at the Academy in
Rio de Janeiro and the general opinion was reached that hookworms were not
a primary and necessary cause of tropical anaemia, but rather a cooperating
agent in its production (cited in206). In his turn, Wucherer protested against this
view205. Thus was born a controversy which was to persist for decades. There
were two great questions: (1) did hookworm infection cause disease at all?; and
(2) how many worms were necessary to cause illness?
In 1878, Sangalli179 in Italy, like Dubini, cast doubt on the idea that
hookworms caused any significant disease when he showed that autopsy
examinations in the University of Pavia revealed that half of the cadavers were
infected with hookworm, but that the symptoms and signs of disease did not by
any means appear to be as serious as might have been inferred from previous
descriptions, particularly those of Griesinger and Bilharz.
514 A History of Human Helminthology
persons in whom there was a great abundance of parasites were robust and
healthy. Furthermore, in 15 cases of kala azar (which some persons had
postulated was caused by hookworm infection), there were only 0-36 hook-
worms, so Dobson concluded that hookworms had no great influence as a
factor in the genesis of disease, whether it be the "beri-beri of Assam" or
anything else69. Such views were echoed by Williams203 and by Zinn and
Jacoby208.
On the other hand, Kynsey in Ceylon (1887) 112 and Giles in Assam (1890) 83
were both convinced that the so-called "beriberi" of Ceylon and Assam or "kala
azar" of Assam were due to ancylostomiasis. This occasioned some confusion,
for "beriberi" was a rather elastic term including a number of entities such as
wet beriberi (cardiac failure) and dry beriberi (peripheral neuropathy) that are
now recognized as being due to thiamine deficiency, and kala azar is the name
now given to the disease caused by infection with Leishmania donovani.
Nevertheless, the disease then called beriberi in Assam and Ceylon was of the
wet variety in both cases and may well have been related to ancylostomiasis in
the form of marked hookworm-induced anaemia and consequent congestive
cardiac failure. An anonymous commentator in the British Medical Journal
came very close to the truth when he remarked in 1893:
In the healthy and robust native, with a liberal physiological margin to draw on, a few
hundreds of minute nematodes in the alimentary canal may be a circumstance of little
importance; but when the native has been half starved all his life, and is further
reduced by actual famine, by malaria, dyspepsia, enteritis, overwork, and other
conditions tending to diminish the amount of aliment absorbed, while at the same time
they tend to increase waste and destruction - in these conditions a daily steady drain
of blood by a swarm of anchylostomata, though it may after all be but a small one,
may prove to be the last straw which breaks the camel's back, the final factor which
determines the starting of the vicious pathological circle.7
Two events in particular which occurred around the turn of the century did
much to convince the sceptics that hookworm infection sometimes culminated
in serious disease. The first of these was the spread of ancylostomiasis from the
St. Gothard's tunnel and elsewhere to the rest of Europe. Miners and expatriates
returning from the tropics carried hookworms with them to the congenial sur-
roundings of the brickfields of Austria, Hungary and Germany, and to the coal-
mines of France, Belgium and England, where the parasites flourished in the
warm, damp, insanitary conditions underground8,77,159. This epidemic confirmed
the pathogenicity of the parasite, for many people developed severe anaemia,
and it stimulated many investigations into the habits of the larvae, the genesis
of anaemia, and means of prevention.
The second series of observations emanated from the Western Hemisphere.
In August 1899, a hurricane wreaked havoc in Puerto Rico. Bailey K Ashford
of the United States Army was put in charge of a temporary hospital to deal
with the thousands of sick, homeless, starving peasants who were mountain
dwellers of Spanish descent. When they were fed on the nourishing diet of the
516 A History of Human Helminthology
American soldier, they developed diarrhoea. When they left camp and returned
to their normal, bulky diet, the diarrhoea resolved but the anaemia with which
they were also afflicted did not. A search for malarial parasites as a cause of the
anaemia revealed the presence of a blood eosinophilia which in turn stimulated
inspection of the faeces for hookworm eggs. These were found in abundance
and on 24 November 1899, Ashford in Ponce sent a telegram to the chief
surgeon in San Juan: "Have this day proven the cause of many pernicious,
progressive anemias of this island to be due to Ankylostoma duodenale.
Ashford"14. He published his findings in the following year 15
. Several years
later, Ashford headed a commission for the study and treatment of anaemia; his
earlier belief that hookworm infection was a major cause of disease was
confirmed fully16.
As a result of these and other observations, the tide of opinion began to turn,
with Baker (1903) writing:
I firmly believe that ankylostomiasis is productive, both directly and indirectly, of far
greater mortality than the vast majority of medical men have any conception of. The
large number of deaths ascribed to unknown causes, the heavy mortality attributed to
general dropsy and debility, and the great loss of life occurring among paupers found
dying the streets of tropical towns, I am convinced, were in the past and are today in
no small measure due to ankylostomiasis. There are few things more remarkable in
the whole history of tropical medicine than the failure to realize and the reluctance to
admit, on the part of many medical men, the injurious tendency of an invasion of the
body by the parasite which gives rise to ankylostomiasis.25
Similarly, Boycott (1911) said in his Milroy lectures:
Taking the world as a whole, with the possible exception of the malarial organisms,
ankylostoma is, I suppose, responsible for more unhappiness and inefficiency than any
other parasite, and for the most part indirectly for no inconsiderable number of deaths.
Practically all tropical countries are permeated with the worm, and in places where the
conditions for its propogation are favourable it may reduce four-fifths of the
population to a continual state of chronic ill-health which is only terminated by the
premature decease, commonly with some secondary infection.37
Around this time, however, the pendulum began to swing even further away
from the point at which it had at one time stood. Far from saying that
hookworms were never pathogenic, some authors began to claim that hook-
worms always caused disease, even when the worm burden was small. This
was brought about by observations flowing from the campaign to control hook-
worm in the southern USA just before World War I. It seemed that hookworm
carriers, i.e. those with hookworm infection but with no apparent ill-effects
from the infection, improved in health and energy after treatment. This was
interpreted as an indication that they were not simply carriers, but that their
general ineptitude, which had been put down to laziness, carelessness, or race,
was in fact due to hookworm infection. Thus, Stiles in 1914 was induced to
write:
There still exist a number of persons who believe that light infections are of no clinical
importance....The view that infection with less than 100 or 50 worms is clinically
Hookworm Disease 517
unimportant is negatived by the fact that treatment of such cases has resulted in the
children in question having made greater improvement in certain respects, in a given
time, than has a control group of children who did not show hookworm infection and
a control group of children who did have the infection but were not treated.195
This view was echoed by Lane (1918). He quoted passages from the Reports
of the Rockefeller Sanitary Commission which, he believed, demonstrated that
the officials of the Commission began with the premise that light infections
were of little moment to the host, yet finished thoroughly convinced that even
very mild infections constituted a grave handicap. Similarly, he quoted letters
from managers of tea estates in Darjeeling, India, where there was widespread
but moderate hookworm infection, who were pleased with the effects of
anthelmintic treatment on the health of their labourers. This stimulated Lane to
write: "We seem then to have no option but to conclude that light infections are
of clinical moment to the individuals concerned"117. Lane later indicated that the
practical import of this view was that the only safe course was to regard no
infection as clinically unimportant until such time as the dividing line between
hookworm infection and hookworm disease had been defined scientifically 120.
As late as 1935, he proclaimed: "the host's interests demands complete
deworming"121. Stiles in the USA and Lane in the United Kingdom were the
most ardent, prolific and persuasive writers on this subject, expounding the
view either that light infections were important, or that, at the very least, it was
not proven that they were unimportant.
Not everyone accepted this belief, however, Boycott in 1911 drew a dis-
tinction between Ancylostoma infection and ancylostomiasis, defining any
individual who harboured parasites in his intestines but without having any
symptoms or signs of the infection as a "worm-carrier" and as the subject of
hookworm infection, whereas those infected persons who had dyspepsia or
anaemia as a consequence of that infection were deemed to suffer from ancylo-
stomiasis37. Similarly, Gordon in 1925 reported that his studies of West African
males revealed no effect by hookworm infection on haemoglobin level,
physique or mental alertness, and recommended that the effects of hookworm
infection on a particular population should be assessed by correlating
pathogenic effects with intensity of infection before embarking upon mass
treatment89. This information caused Harold Scott in his review of the paper to
write:
This article is of great interest and serves as a refreshing counterblast to exaggerated
records of the dire evils of hookworm infection....(which have been recorded as
ranging from) rheumatism to nyctolopia [night blindness].185
This idea was taken further by Smillie and Augustine (1926) in the USA who
divided children up into groups on the basis of hookworm numbers. They found
that no adverse effects upon clinical status or haemoglobin level were seen
when less than 100 worms were present, and more than 500 worms were
required for the full clinical disorder to be produced187. When they analysed
changes three months after treatment, they discerned no effects of this
518 A History of Human Helminthology
Amongst those who accepted that hookworms might cause anaemia, the quest-
ion arose as to how the anaemia was produced. The first and most obvious way,
as reported by Griesinger, was as a consequence of massive bleeding into the
gut. At one time, it was thought that only a few worms were necessary, for it
had been shown that when hookworms moved, they left wounds behind them
which continued to bleed, and this led one anonymous reviewer to write in
1889: "Hence it is easy to understand how a very few may cause fatal
anaemia"6. An alternative possibility was canvassed by Rake in 1894:
Is the anaemia the result of a simple drain of blood from the gut by worms, or is it, as
William Hunter contends, the result of excess blood destruction in the portal
circulation effected by the action of certain poisonous agents absorbed from the gut
through breaches made by the worms?172
The likely importance of this latter mechanism seemed to be heightened when
the authoritative and prestigious Looss declared that the epithelial cells of the
small bowel rather than blood provided the food supply of hookworms 140.
Before any proper understanding of hookworm anaemia could be gained,
however, the condition had to be differentiated from idiopathic pernicious
Hookworm Disease 519
While the clinical features of gross hookworm anaemia were clear, the other
manifestations of infection were rather more obscure. Dermatitis (ground itch
- see section on the proof of the percutaneous route of infection) was only
observed sometimes. Migration through the lungs was thought to produce
cough, wheezes and hoarseness in some patients10. Conflicting accounts were
published on growth retardation and mental sluggishness 89,187,188,200. The
gastrointestinal symptoms were also difficult to define because concurrent
infections with other gastrointestinal pathogens was so common. Experimental
infection with sole hookworm infections, however, provided some useful
information. Brumpt infected patients with hypertension or polycythaemia with
about 400 hookworm larvae and noted an initial dermatitis, subsequent upper
respiratory symptoms (but no indication of Löffler's syndrome), then
indigestion and diarrhoea. The abdominal discomfort soon cleared up but the
diarrhoea sometimes persisted for a month45. Similarly, experimental infection
with A. ceylanicum indicated temporary, but severe, indigestion, flatulence and
abdominal distension 202.
smears did not always detect light infections. The forceful opinions expressed
by some that light infections were of clinical significance generated intensive
efforts, particularly in the first third of this century, to develop concentration
techniques in order to permit detection of such infections. The various tests
designed up to about 1930 have been reviewed by Lane120, who himself
devoted many years to the problem. Later concentration techniques have been
described in chapter 9. In addition, Harada and Mori in 1955 described a
completely new method of cultivating hookworm larvae on moistened filter
paper which they believed was considerably more efficient than flotation
methods for detecting infection96. Quantitative techniques have permitted
counting of the number of eggs in the faeces and this has been widely accepted
as providing an index of the worm burden, although there have been a few
vocal opponents of this view121.
The identification of hookworm eggs in the faeces has been used in recent
times to confirm the antiquity of hookworm infection, although this test is not
able to differentiate between the species of hookworms. Hookworm eggs have
been seen in human faeces in Brazil dating from 430-3490 BP74.
A number of efforts have been made to develop immunological tests for the
diagnosis of hookworm infection. Ghedini (1907) found complement fixing
antibodies in the serum of patients with hookworm infection82. Pirie and
colleagues in 1929 reported a skin test for the diagnosis of hookworm
infection170. Such efforts, however, have been largely unrewarding as the
diagnosis is made relatively easily by parasitological methods except in
prepatent infections, and immunodiagnosis gives no indication of the worm
burden. Similarly, the blood eosinophilia in hookworm infection, first described
by Müller and Rieder in 1891154, is nonspecific and is merely a pointer to the
possible presence of infection.
The diagnosis is sometimes suggested by radiography. Krause and Crilly re-
ported that barium meal examination revealed alterations in the small bowel
mucosal outline which they called a "deficiency pattern"111. Finally, as
sophisticated gastrointestinal endoscopic facilities become more widely avail-
able, someone in the near future will undoubtedly report the diagnosis of
hookworm infection by the observation of adult worms during duodenoscopy.
carried out in India50. Mhaskar in 1922 reviewed the results and concluded that
of 54 substances investigated, oil of chenopodium, thymol and betanaphthol
were the most effective drugs150.
It was at this juncture that a new drug, carbon tetrachloride, was introduced.
In 1921, MC Hall of the US Bureau of Animal Industry published a paper
indicating that this agent was a useful anthelmintic in animals93. He then
swallowed some of the chemical himself without ill-effect, and suggested its
use in human hookworm infection94. A number of reports soon followed show-
ing that it was effective in human ancylostomiasis 24,124,157. Considerable
differences of opinion then ensued over the safety of the drug. Being aware that
prolonged use of fat solvents such as carbon tetrachloride, chloroform and
tetrachloroethane could cause severe liver disease, Nicholls and Hampton gave
carbon tetrachloride twice to a condemned murderer then examined the organs
after execution one to three weeks later. No signs of degeneration were found
and they concluded that when given in a single dose, carbon tetrachloride was
safe157. The drug became used widely and was employed with apparently few
side-effects by some workers. For example, Bishop administered the drug to
25,000 cases in Trinidad and Tobago with little report of illness33, while Khalil
claimed only one fatal result in 150,000 treatments 110. Nevertheless, these
reports must be viewed with some circumspection, since there may have been
a considerable latent period between the ingestion of carbon tetrachloride and
the appearance of liver failure which may have obscured the relationship
between the two events. On the other hand, some workers had sad experiences.
For example, Straub and Kouwenaar had 16 deaths and gave up using the
drug198, while Nag reported three deaths in 289 children 155
. With great
indignation, Lane (1930) condemned its use, particularly in mass treatment
campaigns where it had often not been shown that a particular individual was
infected:
For carbon tetrachloride....the fatal dose is [he should have said 'may be'] 1.5 c.cm.;
while the dose advised as effective is 3 c.c., or twice the fatal dose. This advised dose
has naturally killed a varying proportion of those who have taken it. Further, it has
been freely administered without troubling to discover whether any particular recipient
was infected, in which case it remains unknown whether the individuals so sacrificed
should have been treated at all.119
Carbon tetrachloride was soon followed by its relative, tetrachlorethylene.
This drug was introduced by Hall and Shillinger in 192595, and its effectiveness
was confirmed by Schapiro and Stoll two years later180. The advantage of tetra-
chlorethylene over carbon tetrachloride was highlighted when Lamson and his
colleagues in 1929 showed in experimental dogs that the hepatic necrosis
evident after the latter drug was administered was absent when tetrachlor-
ethylene was used115. In 1931, the same group of workers reported that hexyl-
resorcinol, an alkylated derivative of phenol and related to thymol, was
effective in ancylostomiasis 114, but this drug did not find a major place in
treatment.
526 A History of Human Helminthology
The merits and demerits of the various anthelmintics known at this time led
to contrasting views on the drug of choice in the treatment of hookworm
infection. Lane (1935) damned carbon tetrachloride and extolled the virtues of
thymol121, while Andrews (1942) espoused carbon tetrachloride and relegated
tetrachlorethylene as being less effective3.
The next major advance did not take place until 1958. In that year, it was
shown that a new series of quaternary ammonium compounds was active
against a broad range of nematodes parasitic in laboratory and domestic
animals58. Goodwin and his colleagues then showed in a trial in Ceylon that one
of these agents, bephenium hydroxynaphthoate, was active in human hookworm
infection. The drug was shown to have an effectiveness comparable with that
of tetrachlorethylene. Furthermore, it had the added advantages of less toxicity
and some activity against Ascaris lumbricoides 88.
In 1961, Brown and his colleagues described a new benzimidazole
derivative, thiabendazole44, then a number of authors showed that it eliminated
most nematodes from the intestines of sheep, pigs and horses. In the following
year, Bui Quoc Huong and colleagues reported that thiabendazole cured 85%
of humans infected with hookworm49, then many subsequent workers confirmed
the effectiveness of the drug.
In 1966, Austin and his colleagues discovered a new series of broad
spectrum anthelmintics. One of these, pyrantel pamoate was active against
mature and immature nematodes in animals20. Several years later, pyrantel
embonate was shown to be effective in human ancylostomiasis, with 84% of
patients being cured68. These findings were then confirmed by many other
workers. Finally, Chaia and Cunha in 1971 showed that mebendazole, another
benzimidazole derivative, was also very effective in hookworm infection54.
The discovery and use of agents directed specifically against hookworms has
not been the only way in which the problem of hookworm anaemia has been
approached. As long ago as 1866, and before the mechanism of hookworm
anaemia was defined and the biochemistry of anaemia due to blood loss was
understood, Wucherer remarked that patients seemed to do better with the
combined use of iron preparations and anthelmintics than when anthelmintics
alone were given. In 1914, Day reviewed his experience in treating over 300
patients with gross hookworm anaemia (the average haemoglobin concen-
tration was only 22% of normal), and showed that the addition of iron prep-
arations hastened the recovery from anaemia after anthelmintic administration 67.
As has already been indicated in the review of the pathogenesis of hookworm
anaemia, many subsequent studies confirmed the value of treating hookworm
anaemia with iron as well as giving anthelmintic therapy30,61,156,174.
More recently, Topley concluded that although all hookworms should ideally
be eliminated, this was most desirable in the most anaemic patients, and that for
less severely affected persons, particularly men, iron therapy alone was often
adequate. An anonymous writer in The Lancet concurred with this view:
Hookworm Disease 527
Ferrous sulphate is cheap, and now that iron-deficiency has been shown to be the
commonest cause of anaemia among these people, whether from hookworm disease
in men, or other causes in women, there seems every reason for training auxiliaries
to test for it, keep records, and distribute tablets. Patients with severe anaemia, and
those who did not respond to treatment, could be referred for more definitive
treatment. The final answer to the problem of hookworm disease probably lies in
environmental measures, but the use of oral iron could increase the economic
potential of many populations.13
Such comments as this would have sent shudders up the spine of Stiles and of
Lane, even if they did not cause them to turn in their graves, but they serve to
exemplify how far conceptions concerning the management of hookworm
infection and disease have swung.
Foundation was formed and its International Health Commission, later Inter-
national Health Board, undertook to become involved in hookworm control
campaigns in other countries. This extension was first begun in 1914 in certain
countries of the British Empire where the stability of government and the
official use of English facilitated work. The first countries to be tackled were
some of the West Indian islands, British Guiana, Egypt, Ceylon and Malaya.
The Commission then moved into Central American countries, Brazil and
China, until by the middle of the 1920's, campaigns were being carried out on
a more or less extensive scale in the majority of infected countries in the world.
The Foundation worked through, and cooperated with, governmental bodies
in the countries concerned, and began on a small scale in order to develop the
most appropriate strategy for that country. Two basic approaches were adopted.
The "Dispensary Method" consisted of the examination and treatment of people
who presented themselves, together with surveys of infection and sanitation.
This was replaced progressively, however, by the "Intensive Method" whereby
a defined area was examined systematically, the whole population was tested,
all those found infected were treated, and attempts were made to improve
general sanitation103. This was in turn modified at times, with some members
of the Board, such as Darling, urging mass treatment of heavily infected
populations without first verifying the diagnosis in individual persons. Further,
Darling asserted that it was sufficient to remove most of the worms from a
patient, without wasting time, funds, or generating toxicity by attempting to
achieve total eradication 64,65.
Unfortunately, and as many anticipated, evidence began to accumulate that
hookworm infection reappeared in populations which had undergone mass
treatment, albeit at lower intensities of infection, at least initially98,186. The
logical inference was that mass treatment had to be accompanied by effective
sanitary measures:
Mass treatment without coincidental soil sanitation is likened to bailing a
sieve-bottomed boat, universal use of a sanitary latrine constituting the only hope of
eradicating the infection.11
The validity of proper sanitary measures had been well shown in several
studies. Perhaps the most impressive of these was that of Baermann who built
well-constructed, ventilated, clean latrines in the Dutch East Indies, and whose
use was supervised. The overall mortality (to which hookworm was thought to
be a major contributor) fell over ten years from 40 per thousand to 4 per
thousand of population 23.
The use of footwear and other agents to protect the skin as a prophylactic
against hookworm infection has given conflicting results. Manson in 1904
recalled how a West Indian sugar planter had his coolies dip their feet in a
mineral oil tar coated with sand, but Dalgetty pointed out the difficulties of such
arrangements 63. Investigations in later years showed that hookworm larvae
easily penetrated wet canvas footwear, and most observers were not impressed
with the results of wearing the shoes that were commonly available in most
Hookworm Disease 531
endemic areas. Abdallah, however, did claim that the prevalence of infection
was diminished in a village where a cheap kind of footwear made from old
rubber tyres was used when compared with a neighbouring village in which
this was not the practice1.
Despite the vast efforts put into the control of hookworm infection in the
early parts of this century, it still remains a major problem. Universal, effective
sanitary systems which are actually used would eliminate the scourge, but this
seems unlikely in the foreseeable future. The only other prospect, as yet dim,
is the development and deployment of a powerful and durable vaccine.
REFERENCES
47. BUGNION E. On the epidemic caused by Ankylostomum among the workmen in the St.
Gothard tunnel. British Medical Journal i: 382, 1881
48. BUGNION E. L'ankylostome duodénal et l'anémie du Saint-Gothard. Revue Médicale de la
Suisse Romande 1:269-289, 405-440, 1881
49. BUI QUOC HONG, BUU HOI, TRAN LU Y, TANG NHIEP, NGUYEN VAN DICH, VU
DINH MINH. Activité anthelminthique du 2(4' thiazolyl) benzimidazole chez l'homme.
Chemotherapia 5: 326-331, 1962
50. CAIUS JF, MHASKAR KS. The correlation between the chemical composition of
anthelmintics and their therapeutic values in connection with the hookworm enquiry in the
Madras Presidency. Indian Journal of Medical Research 7: 429-463, 1919; 7: 570-609, 1920;
8: 125-130, 372-394, 1920; 9: 35-55, 191-209, 1921; 10: 343-360, 1922
51. CALDWELL FC. An accidental infection with Uncinaria. Parasitology 14: 51-52, 1922
52. CAMUSET L. De l'anémie tropicale observée à la Guyane française, Thèse de Montpellier,
pp 50, 1868
53. CASSEDY JH. The "germ of laziness" in the South, 1900-1915: Charles Wardell Stiles and
Progressive Paradox. Bulletin of the History of Medicine 45: 159-169, 1971
54. CHAIA G, CUNHA CA. Therapeutic action of mebendazole (R-17.635) against human
helminthiasis. Folha Médica 63: 843-852, 1971
55. CHANDLER AC. The rate of loss of hookworms in the absence of reinfections. Indian Journal
of Medical Research 13: 625-634, 1926
56. CHANDLER AC. Hookworm disease. Its distribution, biology, epidemiology, pathology,
diagnosis, treatment and control, MacMillan and Co., London, pp 494, 1929
57. CONCATO L, PERRONCITO E. Sull'anchilostomiasi. Osservatore, Torino 16: 144, 1880.
Also, Sur l'anchylostomiase. Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances de l'Académie des
Sciences 90: 619-620, 1880
58. COPP FC, STANDEN OD, SCARNELL J, RAWES DA, BURROWS RB. A new series of
anthelmintics. Nature 181: 183, 1958
59. CORT WW, PAYNE GC. An epidemiologic study of hookworm disease in a cacao estate.
American Journal of Hygiene 2: 149-161, 1922
60. CREPLIN FC. Nachträge zu Gurlt's Verzeichniss der Thiere, bei welchen Entozoen gefunden
worden sind. Archiv für Naturgeschichte 11J, 1: 325-330, 1845
61. CRUZ WO. Pathogenesis of anaemia in hookworm disease. Parasite carriers. Relationship
between the activity of the helminth and iron deficiency in the genesis of disease. Memorias
do Instituto Oswaldo Cruz 28: 391-486, 1934
62. DALGETTY AB. Water-itch; or, sore feet of coolies. Journal of Tropical Medicine and
Hygiene 4: 73-77, 1901
63. DALGETTY AB. The prevention of ankylostomiasis. British Medical Journal i: 17, 1905
64. DARLING ST. Suggestions for the mass treatment of hookworm infection. Lancet ii: 69-72,
1920
65. DARLING ST. The hookworm index and mass treatment. American Journal of Medicine 2:
397-447, 1922
66. DAVAINE C. Traité des entozoaires et des maladies vermineuses de l'homme et des animaux
domestiques, J-B Baillière et fils, Paris, pp 838, 1860
67. DAY HB, FERGUSON AR. The treatment of Ankylostoma anaemia. Lancet i: 82-87, 1914
68. DESOWITZ RS, BELL T, WILLIAMS J, CARDINES R, TAMARUA M. Anthelmintic
activity of pyrantel pamoate. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 19:
775-778, 1970
69. DOBSON EF. Notes regarding the prevalence of Dochmius duodenalis. Indian Medical
Gazette 27: 354-357, 1892; 28: 1-4, 40-43, 68-72, 1893
70. DUBINI A. Nuovo verme intestinal umano (Agchylostoma duodenale) costituente un sesto
genere dei nematoidea proprii dell'uomo. Annali Universali di Medicina 106: 5-13, 1843.
Translated in 107
71. DUVOIR M, BRUMPT LC. Le traitement des polyglobulies par l'ankylostomose provoquée
(apropos de cinq cas). Annales de Parasitologie Humaine et Comparée 20: 1-2, 35-42,
1944-1945
72. EBBELL B. The Papyrus Ebers, the greatest Egyptian medical document, translated by B
534 A History of Human Helminthology
145. MacDONALD JD. First Indian Medical Congress, 1890. Cited in 176
146. MALVOZ E. Dix années de lutte contre l'ankylostomasie des mineurs. Bulletin de
l'Académie Royale de Médecine de Belgique, series 4, 27: 264-278, 1913
147. MANSON P. Discussion of 177, British Medical Journal ii: 691, 1901
148. MAPLESTONE PA. Creeping eruption produced by hookworm larvae. Indian Medical
Gazette 68: 251-256, 1933
149. MHASKAR KS. Hookworm infection and sanitation. Indian Journal of Medical Research
8: 398-406, 1920
150. MHASKAR KS. Mass treatment of hookworm infection. Indian Medical Gazette 57:
208-210, 1922
151. MIYAGAWA Y. Ueber den Wanderungsweg der Ankylostoma duodenale innerhalb des
Wirtes bein Oralinfektion und ueber ihren Hauptinfektionsmodus. Mittheilungen aus der
medicinischen Facultät der kaiserlich-japanischen Universität zu Tokyo 15: 411-452, 1916
152. MOUAT-BIGGS CE. The treatment of ankylostomiasis in Venezuela. Transactions of the
Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 8: 216, 1915
153. de MOURA JR. Note sobre um caso de hypoemia intertropical terminado pela morte;
autopsia e verificação da existencia de entozoarios da especie - Anchylostomum duodenale.
Gazeta Medica da Bahia 1: 122-125, 136-138, 1866
154. MÜLLER H F, RIEDER H. Ueber Vorkommen und klinische Bedeutung der eosinophilen
Zellen, Erlich im circulirenden Blute des Menschen. Deutsches Archiv für klinische Medizin
48: 96-121, 1891
155. NAG SC. Notes on the use of carbon tetrachloride. Indian Medical Gazette 64: 683, 1929
156. NAPIER LE, DAS GUPTA CR, MAJUMDAR DN. The treatment of hookworm anaemia.
Indian Medical Gazette 76: 1-11, 1941
157. NICHOLLS L, HAMPTON GG. Treatment of human hookworm infection with carbon
tetrachloride. British Medical Journal ii: 8-11, 1922
158. OKADA R. Experimental studies on the oral and percutaneous infection of Anchylostoma
caninum. Fourth report. Japanese Journal of Experimental Medicine 9: 269-280, 1931
159. OLIVER T. Ankylostomiasis in Westphalia, Hungary and Cornwall. Lancet ii: 1635-1637,
1904
160. OZZARD AT. Life history of the Ankylostoma duodenale. Journal of Tropical Medicine and
Hygiene 5: 273-274, 1902
161. OZZARD AT. Life-history of Ankylostoma duodenale. British Medical Journal ii: 779-780,
1909
162. PAPYROS EBERS. Das hermetische Buch über die Arzeneimittel der alten Aegypter in
hieratischer Schrift. Herausgegeben, mit Inhaltsangabe und Einleitung versehen von Georg
Ebers. Mit hieroglyphisch-lateinischem Glossar von Ludwig Stern, W Engelmann, Leipzig,
two volumes, 1875. The Papyrus Ebers, translated from the German version by CP Bryan,
Geoffrey Bles, London, pp 167, 1930
163. PARONA E. L'estratto etereo di felce maschio e l'anchilostomiasi die minatori del Gottardo.
Osservatore, Torino, 17: 19-49, 1881
164. PEDUZZI R, PIFFARETTI JC. Ancylostoma duodenale and the Saint Gothard anaemia.
British Medical Journal ii: 1942-1945, 1983
165. PEIPER O. Über den Infektionmodus der Ankylostomiasis in Deutsch-Ostafrika. Archiv für
Schiffs- und Tropen-Hygiene 16: 537-570, 1912
166. PERRONCITO E. Helminthological observations upon the endemic disease developed
among the labourers in the Tunnel of Mount St. Gothard. Journal of the Quekett
Microscopical Club 6: 141-148, 1880. Also, Observations helminthologiques et recherches
experimentelles sur la maladie des ouvriers du Saint-Gothard. Comptes Rendus
Hebdomadaires des Séances de la Académie des Sciences 90: 1373-1375, 1880
167. PERRONCITO E. On the action of chemical agents and medicinal substances on the larvae
of Dochmius duodenalis and Anguillulae; including therapeutical considerations relative to
the cure of patients from Mount St. Gothard. Veterinarian 53: 824-828, 1880
168. PERRONCITO E. La malattia dei minatori dal S. Gottardo al Sempione: una questione
risolta, Carlo Pasta, Torino, pp 335, 1910
169. PFISTER F. Über die - - -Krankheit der Papyri Ebers und Brugsch. Archiv für Geschichte
538 A History of Human Helminthology
195. STILES CW. Report of the scientific secretary, The Rockefeller Sanitary Commission for the
Eradication of Hookworm Disease, Publication No. 2, New York, 1914
196. STILES CW. Recent studies on school children, with special reference to hookworm disease
and sanitation. New York Medical Journal 102: 906-907, 1915
197. STOLL NR. On the relation between the number of eggs found in human feces and the
number of hookworms in the host. American Journal of Hygiene 3: 156-179, 1923
198. STRAUB M. Tetrachloorkoulstofvergiftiging in twaalf gevallen. Geneeskundig Tijdschrift
voor Nederlandsch-Indië 65: 624-645, 1925
199. TOPLEY E. Common anaemias in rural Gambia. Hookworm anaemia among men.
Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 62: 579-594, 1968
200. WAITE JH, NEILSON IL. A study of the effects of hookworm infection upon the mental
development of north Queensland school children. Medical Journal of Australia i: 1-7, 1919
201. WELLS HS. Observations on the blood sucking activities of the hookworm Ancylostoma
caninum. Journal of Parasitology 17: 167-182, 1931
202. WIJERS DJ, SMIT AM. Early symptoms after experimental infection of man with
Ancylostoma braziliense var. ceylanicum. Tropical and Geographical Medicine 18: 48-52,
1966
203. WILLIAMS CH. On the prevalence of Ankylostomum duodenale in Madras. Lancet i: 192,
1895
204. WUCHERER OE. Sobre a molestia vulgarmente denominada oppilação ou cançaço. Gazeta
Medica da Bahia 1: 27-29, 39-41, 52-54, 63-64, 1866. Partly translated in 107
205. WUCHERER OE. Anchylostomos duodenaes. Gazeta Medica da Bahia ii: 150-151, 1868
206. WUCHERER OE. Ueber die Anchylostomenkrankheit, tropische Chlorose oder tropische
Hypoämie. Deutsches Archiv für klinische Medicin 10: 379-400, 1872
207. YOKOGAWA S. On the oral infection by hookworm. Archiv für Schiffs- und
Tropen-Hygiene30: 663-679, 1926. Also, YOKOGAWA S, OISO T. (Investigations on the
life history of Ankylostoma and Strongyloides stercoralis. On oral infection with
Ankylostoma.) Taiwan Igakkai Zasshi Nos. 241 and 243, 1925. In Japanese, with English
summary
208. ZINN W, JACOBY MJ. Ueber das regelmäsige Vorkommen von Anchylostomum
duodenale ohne secundäre Anämie bei Negern, nebst weiteren Beiträgen zur Fauna des
Negerdarmes. Berliner klinische Wochenschrift 33: 797-801, 1896
540 A History of Human Helminthology
1962 Bui Quoc Hong and his colleagues reported that thiabendazole was an
effective treatment
1970 Pyrantel was found by Desowitz and co-workers to be an effective
antihookworm agent
1971 Chaia and Cunha observed that mebendazole was highly active against
hookworm
__________________________________________________________________
Chapter 21 RETURN TO
SYNOPSIS
In the latter part of the ninteenth century, many French troops who had bee n
posted to Cochin China (Vietnam) were afflicted with severe diarrhoea which
was sometimes fatal. In July 1876, a number of patients were repatriated t o
France where they came under the care of Louis Normand, physician to th e
Naval Hospital of St Mandrier in Toulon. Normand examined the faeces o f
these patients and in some of them he found specimens of a worm which had
never been described before. The parasite was just visible to the naked eye ,
being about one quarter of a millimetre in length. Although they were ofte n
sparse, on other occasions worms were present in prodigious numbers with a
million or so being excreted during the course of 24 hours. When he examined
543
544 A History of Human Helminthology
In an addendum to this paper, Bavay reported that Normand had now found the
larvae of A. stercoralis at autopsy in the stomach and the whole length of the
intestine, as well as in the bile, pancreatic and hepatic ducts and in the gal l
bladder6.
Shortly thereafter, Normand also described the development of free-livin g
adult worms from larvae in faeces then observed the course of events whic h
occurred after eggs were liberated b y free-living female worms. Like Bavay, he
observed that when eggs were expelled, each one contained a distinct, motile
embryo within a membrane. After each egg had hatched, the released larva was
about 0.1 mm in length. These grew gradually to about 0.3 mm long, the n
developed a jagged border which gave them the appearance of a chain-saw ,
then moulted. Normand was unable, however, to obtain a second generation of
free-living worms 82, nor did Bavay have any such success 6.
Verification of Normand's discovery did not take long in coming, eve n
though there was scepticism on the part of some and incredulity on the part of
others. In early 1977, Alphonse Laveran (the discoverer of malarial parasites)
reported that, at an autopsy he performed on 28 January 1877, he had foun d
larvae which matched those d escribed by Bavay 66 in the intestines, then shortly
afterwards he reported finding four more such cases 67. Laveran was followed
by Libermann72, Roux95 , Chastang17 and Chauvin18 who found the worms in
patients that had been infected in China or in Martinique. With the exception
of Chauvin, however, these authors did not observe the maturation of larvae to
adult worms in the stools.
In the meantime, the situation had become somewhat more confused. In late
1876, Normand, at the autopsy of a man who had died from Cochin-Chin a
diarrhoea, found another worm, which appeared to be different from A.
stercoralis, in the intestines. He sent these worms to Bavay. The latter studied
them and those that were obtained from a further four post-morte m
examinations and concluded that they were a distinct species of worm. Again
through the agency of M Gervais, B avay published a description of the parasite
in February 1877, naming it A. intestinalis in order to reflect its discovery in
the intestinal tract 7. These worms were about 2.2 mm in length and all of the
200 specimens or so that he examine d were female. Bavay noted that Normand
had found that they were most abundant in the duodenum, less common in the
jejunum, and did not reach the ileum, but that in any case, they were much less
frequent than A. stercoralis.
In addition to describing this parasitic female adult worm, Bavay recorde d
that he and Normand had found a new type of larva which they believed was
the larval form of A. intestinalis:
In the stools of three diarrhoeic patients that we have kept in order to follow the devel-
opment of Anguillula stercoralis, we have found that after several days, they
contained certain larvae that were different from the first. They were longer, with a
cylindrical oesophagus which passed almost to the middle of the body, and a tail,
which instead of terminating in a fine point, was, on the contrary, apparently
546 A History of Human Helminthology
truncated. Although culture of these larvae could not be persisted with long enough
to establish in an irrefutable fashion their identity with Anguillula intestinalis, we
have hardly any doubt in this regard.7
Bavay went on to say that two of the patients who had had this form in thei r
stools had since died, and that post mortem examination had revealed adult A.
intestinalis. Moreover, he and Normand had looked in vain for these worms in
the body of a man who had returned from Cochin-China three years before and
in whom A. stercoralis was extremely abundant. Both the adult and larva l
forms of the parasite were illustrate d by Bavay in a publication which appeared
in July 18778. Although he did not realize it, Bavay had described the direc t
development of larvae excreted in the faeces into infective (filariform) larvae.
Similar worms were noted in the following year by Chauvin 18.
Thus, at this point, it was believe d that there were two distinct species. In the
case of A. stercoralis, larvae were found in the faeces and adult worm s
developed in the external environment. In the instance of A. intestinalis,
parasitic female adult worms were found in the gut, and they were thought to
produce larvae with the truncated tail.
In 1878, Grassi and Parona discovered A. intestinalis at a number of
autopsies in Pavla, Italy 49. Like Normand and Bavay, they observed that th e
parasitic worms were located principally in the lower duodenum and uppe r
jejunum. They found that these worms deposited eggs in the intestinal lumen
which hatched almost immediately after being laid. Further, they observed that
these larvae in the small intestinal lumen were identical with those excreted in
the faeces and these in turn appeared to be the same as the larvae described as
A. stercoralis by Normand and Bavay. When m oistened faeces containing these
larvae were cultured, the worms grew into forms about 0.75 mm long with an
oesophagus occupying half the length of the worm. Grassi and Parona realized
that these worms (now known as infective or filariform larvae) wer e
undoubtedly the same forms that Bavay, and after him, Chauvin, had believed
were the larvae of A. intestinalis. At no time did Grassi and Parona grow any
of the free-living adult worms which other workers had obtained when A.
stercoralis larvae had been cultured. Thus, the sequence of events seemed to
be that parasitic female worms ( A. intestinalis) produced larvae (now known
as rhabditiform larvae because of the similarity of the oesophagus with tha t
seen in the genus Rhadbitis) in the intestine, which in turn developed int o
filariform larvae in the free-living state. In 1879, Grassi erected a new genus
which he called Strongyloides, ( [STRONGYLOS] = "round" ;
[EIDOS] = "similar") because of its closeness to the genus Strongylus,
in which to place the worm 43, then later in that year in a review of his ow n
article, he indicated that the worm should be called Strongyloides
intestinalis 44.
Shortly afterwards, Eduardo Perroncito drew attention to the presence o f
these parasites, as well as Ancylostoma duodenale , in the intestinal tract o f
miners working in the St. Gothard tunnel (see chapter 20) 88. Initially, he
Strongyloidiasis 547
believed that both A. intestinalis and A. stercoralis were present, with the
former appearing in the faeces as eggs, and the latter as larvae. He described
the development and hatching of the so-called A. intestinalis eggs, then
recounted their subsequent development. He found that after 24 hours the y
doubled their length and underwent internal reorganization, particularly with
respect to the anatomy of the alimentary canal. As with A. duodenale,
Perroncito misinterpreted the moulting process as cyst formation, and described
subsequent calcification of the capsule. Similarly, he described the larvae of A.
stercoralis, indicated some differences from the larvae of A. intestinalis and A.
duodenale, and stated that after one day of life they too became encysted. Thus,
Perroncito persisted in the erroneous differentiation of two species o f
Strongyloides, believed incorrectly that A. intestinalis eggs were excreted in
the faeces, described some non-exi stent morphological differences between the
larvae, and became completely misled in ident ifying "encystment" of both forms
of larvae89.
Subsequently (1881), however, Perroncito succeeded in cultivatin g
free-living adult worms (which h e renamed Pseudorhabditis stercoralis ) from
rhabditiform larvae in the faece s, and described accurately their copulation, the
laying of new eggs, the hatching of these and the transformation of the second
generation of worms into filariform larvae 91. These filariform larvae were very
similar to those that Grassi and Parona had described as developing directl y
from A. intestinalis larvae. The situation was now very confused for filariform
larvae had been described as developing in two ways. According to Bavay and
to Grassi and Parona, filariform larvae developed from A. intestinalis whereas
Perroncito had demonstrated that they were produced by free-living adul t
A. stercoralis.
Perroncito's assertion that A. intestinalis eggs were excreted in the faeces led
to a spirited controversy with Grassi who eventually proved beyond doubt that
Perroncito had been dealing with hookworm eggs 45-48,92. Grassi insisted that the
rhabditiform larvae found in the faeces were direct descendants of the wor m
known as A. intestinalis. Furthermore, he postulated in 1882 that as thes e
larvae often developed in culture into freeliving adults called A. stercoralis,
then A. intestinalis, like Ascaris nigrovenosa was dimorphobiotic 45. By this, he
meant that the parasitic worm in the intestines was parthenogenetic o r
hermaphroditic and produced eggs which hatched rhabditiform larvae. H e
believed that when these escaped in the faeces, they developed into sexuall y
differentiated free-living male and female adult worms which in turn produced
descendants that were capable of develop ing again into parasitic mother worms
after ingestion by the host.
Rudolf Leuckart supported this view in the following year when he reported
his own observations on the development of A. stercoralis. A case of strong-
yloidiasis, which was studied by Seifert 102,103, occurred in Gerhardt's clinic at
Würzburg. The faeces contained large numbers of rhabditiform larvae typical
548 A History of Human Helminthology
rhabditiform larvae to develop directly into filariform larvae 46. In 1884, Golgi
and Monti in Pavia studied further cases and followed both the direc t
transformation of some rhabditiform larvae obtained from parasitic femal e
worms into filariform larvae, as well as indirect development of others through
the free-living sexually differentiated generation: they believed the forme r
course to be the commoner 40,41. This view was echoed later by Leichtenster n
who studied over many years cases of strongyloidiasis occurring in brick -
workers along the Rhine, as well as cases imported from the tropics. He tried
to vary the proportion of worms developing in each direction by altering th e
environmental conditions but failed to do so 68. He then suggested that strains
of temperate origin developed directly whereas those acquired in the tropic s
tended to develop indirectly69. That these different courses were not due to two
different strains of the worm was shown by Wilm s in Leichtenstern's laboratory,
for he infected a human with filariform larvae which had developed directl y
then showed that some of the rhabditiform larvae subsequently excreted in the
stools developed indirectly 119. Leichtenstern's suggestion of geographica l
variations in the form of free-living development was also not sustained when
Darling working in Panama 22 and later Sandground in Honduras 97 found both
modes of development with the indirect cycle predominating in the experience
of the former observer and direct transformation being most common in th e
hands of the latter investigator.
Uncertainty also surrounded the status of the parasitic adult worms found in
the intestinal tract. Bavay questioned whether the absence of male worms was
due to their rapid disappearance following fertilization, or whether the worms
were hermaphroditic with a female habitus 8. Shortly afterwards, Grass i
suggested that they may be hermaphroditic or parthenogenetic 45. Leuckart
concurred with these two last possibilities, and while expressing no fir m
opinion, inclined to the view that they were hermaphroditic 70,71. In 1888,
however, Rovelli concluded that the worms were parthenogenetic 96. On the
other hand, Sandground (1926) believed that the parasitic adult worm wa s
really hermaphroditic 98 but this view has not been sustained. The proble m
became even more controversial when in 1932 Kreis in Faust's laboratory in
New Orleans claimed to have found parasitic male adult worms in the faeces
of infected humans and dogs 61. Faust endorsed the view remarking:
occasionally parasitic females and males are passed in diarrheic stools....The rare
parasitic males are practically indistinguishable from the free-living males of the
indirect cycle.29
Faust then proceeded to compound the problem. He traced the development of
twelve strains of S. stercoralis (from humans, primates and a dog) in forty dogs
and declared that filariform larvae developed into "pre-adolescent" and adul t
male and female worms in the respiratory tract. Fertilization was then believed
to take place either there or in the lumen of the upper alimentary canal before
the fertilized females became embedded in the intestinal mucosa. He furthe r
proposed that fertilized eggs proceeded to direct development and unfertilized
550 A History of Human Helminthology
crypts, but also in the mucosa 107. This was confirmed by Askanazy in 1900 who
demonstrated the presence of female worms in the epithelium of the uppe r
small bowel and rhabditiform larvae in the mucosa associated with a chronic
inflammatory infiltrate. He also noted that eggs were often deposited in tunnels
in the mucosa. He summarized his findings:
The A. intestinalis bores into the intestinal wall, primarily into the mucosa and often
into the epithelium of its glands, in order to absorb food....But in this connection the
mother animals perform still another function, in that they deposit their eggs in the
tissue of the mucous membrane. These eggs change into embryos which then emerge
toward the intestinal lumen.3
Askanazy was in no doubt that the worm was pathogenic, for he conclude d
from studies using special stains that the adult worms fed on the juices of the
intestinal wall, and deposited their offspring in the midst of living tissue.
In 1905, Thayer reviewed the question of the pathogenicity of the parasit e
and summarized the position in the following way:
The weight of evidence appears to be in favour of the view that, while the parasites
may exist in the intestine for long periods of time without ill effects, they are by no
means, as Grassi says, 'innocent commensals of man'. It would seem probably that this
parasite alone may be the primary agent in many cases of chronic diarrhea. 113
The precise location of parasitic adult worms, however, continued to be a
matter of argument. Whereas Ask anazy3 and others 38,63 were of the opinion that
the parasites frequently entered the stroma of the mucous membrane, other s
disagreed. Thus, Ophüls (1929) wrote:
I have been unable to convince myself that either the mother worms or the
rhabditiform embryos ever enter the stroma of the mucous membrane. They cause,
however, much epithelial destruction.85
Recent observations using transmission electron microscopy in infecte d
animals suggest that Ophüls was correct.
With the discovery of autoinfection and overwh elming infection with S. sterc-
oralis, as will be described shortly, it became absolutely clear that infectio n
with this parasite could have devastating consequences. The means by which
these effects are brought about, however, remain uncertain. Many earl y
observers assumed that the effects were purely mechanical 40, while Askanazy
suspected that the worm may produce a toxin 3. A few years later, Thira
suggested that bacteria may enter the tissues through the portals in the mucosa
left behind by the invading worms and thus exacerbate the illness 114.
When Blanchard in 1890 reviewed the probable means by which infection oc-
curred, he remarked that the possibilities were not too difficult to conceive .
Water had been incriminated, but samples taken from the Mekong river in a
heavily endemic area had been examined without finding any Strongyloides
larvae. He presumed, therefor e, that the most likely method of infection was by
552 A History of Human Helminthology
Normand may have unwittingly app reciated the possibility of autoinfection, i.e.
the multiplication of worms within the body of the host without passing to the
external environment, for he noted that although worms may persist in the gut
for years without causing undue inconvenience, anything which tended t o
diminish the patient's resistance often resulted in an exacerbation of symptoms
to produce the clinical picture of Cochin-China diarrhoea 82,83. This idea was
reinforced by Grassi in 1883 when he pointed out that immature specimens of
S. intestinalis were not infrequently found in the cadavers of patients who had
remained in hospital for several months and in whom oral infections were most
unlikely. When this observation was taken in conjunction with th e
demonstration by Parona and himself that rhabditiform larvae could develo p
directly into filariform larvae, and that the free-living adult forms were absent
from the bowel, Grassi deduced that direct transformation of rhabditifor m
larvae into parasitic adult worms must be taking place within the host without
the interpolation of a sexually differentiated generation 46. Grassi undoubtedly
envisaged that moulting and maturation of worms from the rhabditiform larval
stage through to adult worms took place in the gut, but such concepts remained
shadowy and vague until the routes of infection and migration of worms were
established. A clue was provided in 1895 when Teissier claimed that he ha d
found larvae in the peripheral blood of a patient with strongyloidiasis. From his
description, however, the worms must have been rhabditiform larvae (which
is most unusual); possibly he was dealing with a different parasite 112. In any
event, the significance of the observation was not appreciated.
As already indicated, Wilms had shown that infection could be acquired by
ingestion of infective larvae, and van Durme had demonstrated that larvae had
the capacity to penetrate the skin. Furthermore, Looss had shown that afte r
hookworm larvae had penetrated the skin, they passed to the lungs where they
escaped into the airways, ascended the respiratory tree and passed to th e
intestine where they completed their development (see chapter 20). In the light
of all these observations, Friedrich Fülleborn in Hamburg, Germany began to
investigate the migratory route of S. stercoralis larvae in 1911. In his initia l
experiment, Fülleborn performed a tracheotomy on a dog then infected i t
percutaneously. Three days later, large numbers of larvae, some of whic h
appeared to be moulting, appeared in the viscid tracheotomy mucus; the y
continued to be passed until six days after infection. In this artificial situation
which restricted worms to the trachea, some of the larvae moulted and became
female adult worms. Furthermore, despite interruption of the pulmonary -
oesophageal circuit, a few rhabditiform larvae were found in the faece s
beginning eight days after infection. In a second experiment, another dog had
554 A History of Human Helminthology
its oesophagus excised and was also infected percutaneously. Two days later,
numerous larvae were recovered from the dog's saliva (the mouth was washed
out with water), then on the following day, larvae were discharged from th e
upper oesophageal fistula and continued to do so for the next three days .
Between eight and twelve days after infection, rhabditiform larvae originating
from female worms were found in the tracheal mucus. Fülleborn conclude d
from these experiments that "the majority of Strongyloides....larvae are
eliminated after interruption of the tracheo-oesophageal tract but even so, a
slight infection occurs" 34. In order to determine whether the slight infection that
he had noted might result from larvae which passed through the lungs the n
embolized to the small bowel in the systemic circulation, Füllebor n
tracheotomized a dog then injected larvae which had been obtained from th e
tracheal mucus of another dog directly into the duodenal artery. Six days later,
the animal was killed and female adult worms were found in the duodenum ,
while the lung was free from infection. In another experiment in which free -
living filariform larvae were injected directly into the stomach of th e
tracheotomized dogs, the resul ting infection was minimal, whereas if filariform
larvae obtained from tracheal mucus was injected, a severe intestinal infection
developed. He concluded that in spite of only minimal morphological alter -
ations, the filariform larvae were altered biologically during their systemi c
migration and became resistant to destruction by the gastric juices. Fülleborn
summarized all these experiments thus:
Chief results of the series of experiments on percutaneous infection: These proved
that the normal route of infection of percutaneous penetrating....Strongyloides was
from the lung to the intestine via trachea and esophagus. A small number of
parasites....may pass from the lung veins and the left heart and reach the intestine by
embolism via the intestinal arteries.34
In this series of infections, Fülleborn so metimes found filariform larvae in the
kidneys and liver, and supposed that they reached this site via the systemi c
circulation. In 1920, however, Yos hida reported that after oral infection, larvae
were found in the abdominal and p leural cavities within 24 hours, and that they
appeared within the abdominal cavity and viscera within a similar period when
placed on the abdominal skin. These findings led him to suggest that the larvae
migrated directly through the connective tissues 121.
Concurrently with studies on the migration of larvae, further evidence began
to accumulate gradually that was suggestive of the phenomenon of repeate d
infection or autoinfection. As already mentioned, Askanazy 3 then von Kurlow 63
found larvae in the deeper layers of the intestinal wall. In 1911, John Gage in
the United States reported his observations on a 48 year old alcoholic patient
who presented with an acute pneumonia. On examination of the sputum, Gage
was surprised to find S. stercoralis filariform larvae. The pneumonia resolved
but the patient's course continued downhill and he died two months later; larvae
were found throughout the wall of the intestine and in the lungs 38. Gage
canvassed the ways in which autoinfection could occur. He rejected Grassi's
Strongyloidiasis 555
died. In the early part of the present centu ry, it was realized gradually that there
was a group of individuals who acquired a chronic illness with minimal o r
moderate symptoms. Fülleborn in 1926 mentioned the instance of one of hi s
patients who had been followed by him for 24 years and remarked that thi s
probably represented the "welt-rekord" 35. Since that time, many patients have
been reported with even longer durations of infection. Thus, infection was still
present in a group of Australian former prisoners-of-war between 34 and 3 7
years after removal from an endemic area 50. Why some patients shoul d
eradicate the worms while others tolerate their presence has not yet bee n
discovered. Sandground showed many years ago that dogs infected exper -
imentally acquired some resistance to reinfection but this finding does no t
necessarily extrapolate to all humans 100. There may well be genetic variations
in susceptibility to infection and the capacity to mount a completely effective
immune reaction but these have not yet been defined. Certainly, some patients
appear to be unable to eliminate all the worms yet are able to contain the m
within bounds and prevent their excessive multiplication.
It has been recognized increasingly over the last 25 years, however, that this
relatively happy state of affairs is not always sustained. It has become apparent
that overwhelming infection, otherwise known as hyperinfection, massiv e
infection, or disseminated strongyloidiasis, in which there is a greatl y
heightened multiplication of worms, could supervene if patients becam e
immunosuppressed for one reason or another (see next section), with con -
sequent breakdown of resistance to the parasites. That these effects were not
simply due to massive exposure to infective larvae in the environment wa s
confirmed when dogs were infected experimentally with a defined number of
worms, immunosuppressed, then a vast number of worms recovered 52. Con-
sequently, the prognosis of strongyloidiasis is uncertain, with all patients being
at risk from severe disease, even though the probability of such an outcom e
may be small.
Normand in 1876 reported that the symptoms associated with infection wit h
this parasite were variable, but he was in no doubt that this infection coul d
cause a severe and at times fatal disease. He described four clinical categories:
Some patients who are afflicted with diarrhea of Cochin China suffer a less intense
infection; the causal agent disappears quickly;....recovery comes quickly....Other
patients, more heavily infected, relapse easily, even after the diarrhea has been
arrested....After some time, more than a year after infection, the patient may recover.
The diarrhea sometimes ceases suddenly and, little by little, he recovers a degree of
vigor and weight. At other times, the disease evolves progressively into a terminal
condition. This third group of patients develops enterocolitis, either after an intense
infection or after a long period of alternating recovery and relapse....inflammation
558 A History of Human Helminthology
was claimed to be a much more effective tool for diagnosis by some authors 87,
but not by others19. In 1970, Beal and his colleagues described a simplifie d
method for obtaining duodenal fluid by means of a string coiled in a gelatin e
capsule9. In many modern centres, duodenal fluid may now also be obtained at
upper gastrointestinal endoscopy and may reveal parasites 50.
The diagnosis has also been made from time to time by recovering larva e
from other body fluids and secretions. These include urine 37, sputum38,84 ,
vomitus105, cerebrospinal fluid 78 and ascitic fluid 4.
Radiological studies may suggest the diagnosis and provide an indication of
the severity of intestinal damage. Deschiens and Taillandier describe d
thickening of the duodenal wall on barium meal examination of the uppe r
gastrointestinal tract 24.
Gage in 1911 recounted a case of Dr AC Eustis who in 1907 had shown that
the patient had strongyloidiasis and an eos inophilia of 56% 38. The first recorded
case of eosinophilia in strongyloidiasis, however, was probably that of Daland
who in 1908 reported a patient who had a blood eosinophil level of 38% 21. The
incidental finding of an eosinophilia on routine examination of blood smear s
has not infrequently stimulated a search for S. stercoralis 13. Indeed, de Langen
in 1928 realized that the condition which he had previously reported a s
"idiopathic hypereosinophilia" was in fact due to S. stercoralis infection64,65.
Nevertheless, it is now realized t hat most patients with chronic strongyloidiasis
either have no eosinophilia or, at most, a mild increase in blood eosinophi l
levels50.
Attempts have been made to develop immunoassays of strongyloidiasis a s
experience has shown that infection is often hard to diagnose parasitologically
in chronic cases. These immunodiagnost ic techniques, include skin testing with
Strongyloides antigen36 and the demonstration of antibodies in the serum 12.
The first therapeutic regimen which Normand tried was to put his patients on
a "rational diet" of milk. He believed this often suppressed mucus production
and caused disappearance of parasites (this was undoubtedly coincidental) .
Nevertheless, many patients failed to respond to such therapy and he wrote that
he was currently experimenting with santonin, mercury and arsenic, and then
proposed to try essential oils, sulphurs, quinine and mineral waters i n
"rebellious" cases81. In the following year, he reported that large quantitites of
olive oil were useful because o f its mechanical action 82. Perroncito 90 and others
after him considered that ethe real extract of male fern was valuable, but Seifert
did not agree and believed that thymol was better 102. Grassi, however, asserted
that no known anthelmintic was of any value 46; this view turned out to be quite
correct. Similarly, new agents introduced for the treatment of hookworm such
as oil of chenopodium, betanaphthol, carbon tetrachloride an d
tetrachlorethylene were found to be ineffective in strongyloidiasis.
Strongyloidiasis 561
Perroncito (1880) was perhaps the first person to point out an associatio n
between infection with S. stercoralis and with hookworm 88,89. Similar
observations have been made by many investigators since that time. Con -
sequently, the factors determining the prevalence of strongyloidiasis are very
similar to those already described for hookworm infection. Strongyloidiasis is
but one of a number of soil-transmitted helminth infections, and no attempt s
have been made to control it in isolation. The toxicity and ineffectiveness o f
most anthelmintics has militated against mass treatment programmes. The most
effective control measures have been the installation and usage of safe waste
disposal systems, but these are unavailable in many endemic areas.
S. FUELLEBORNI
REFERENCES
1. ADAM M, MORGAN O, PERSAUD C, GIBBS WN. Hyperinfection syndrome with
Strongyloides stercoralis in malignant lymphoma. British Medical Journal i: 264-266, 1973
2. ARTHUR P, SHELLEY W. Larva currens. A distinctive variant of cutaneous larva migrans
due to Strongyloides stercoralis. Archives of Dermatology 78: 186-190, 1958
3. ASKANAZY M. Ueber Art und Zweck der Invasion der Anguillula intestinalis in die
Darmwand. Centralblatt für Bakteriologie, Parasitenkunde und Infektionskrankheiten,
Abteilung originale 27: 569-578, 1900. Translated in 58
4. AVAGNINA MA, ELSNER B, IOTTI RM, RE R. Strongyloides stercoralis in
Papanicolaoustained smears of ascitic fluid. Acta Cytologica 24: 36-39, 1980
5. BARLOW N. Clinical notes on infection with Strongyloides stercoralis intestinalis, based
upon a series of twenty three cases. Interstate Medical Journal 22: 1202-1208, 1915
6. BAVAY A. Sur l'Anguillule stercorale. (Presentée par M. P Gervais) Comptes Rendus Hebdo-
madaires des Séances de l'Académie des Sciences 83: 694-696, 1876. Partly translated by DI
Grove
7. BAVAY A. Sur l'Anguillule intestinale (Anguillula intestinalis), nouveau ver nématoïde,
trouvé par le Dr. Normand chez les malades atteints de diarrhée de Cochinchine. (Presentée
par M. P Gervais) Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances de l'Académie des Sciences
84: 266-268, 1877
8. BAVAY A. Note sur l'anguillule intestinale (Anguillula intestinalis) nouveau ver nématoïde
trouvé par le Dr. Normand chez les malades atteints de diarrhée de Cochinchine. Archives de
Médecine Navale 28: 64-67, 1877
9. BEAL CB, VIENS P, GRANT RG. A new technique for sampling duodenal contents: demon-
stration of upper small bowel pathogens. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene
19: 349-352, 1970
10. BLACKIE WK. A helminthological survey of Southern Rhodesia. London School of Hygiene
and Tropical Medicine, Memoir Series, pp 91, 1932
11. BLANCHARD R. Traité de zoologie médicale, J-B Baillière et fils, Paris, two volumes, pp
1691, 1885-1890
12. BRANNON MJ, FAUST EC. Preparation and testing of a specific antigen fordiagnosis of
human strongyloidiasis. American Journal of Tropical Medicine 29: 229-239, 1949
13. BRAU P. De l'Anguillula intestinalis en Cochinchine et de son diagnostic hématologique.
Bulletins de la Société de Pathologie Exotique et de ses Filiales 6: 262-264, 1913
14. BRETON. Note sur les parasites de la dysenterie et de la diarrhée dite de Cochinchine.
Archives de Médecine Navale 31: 441, 1879
15. BROWN RC, GIRARDEAU MH. Transmammary passage of Strongyloides sp. larvae in the
human host. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 26: 215-219, 1977
16. BROWN HD, MATZUK AR, ILVES IR, PETERSON LH,HARRIS SA. Antiparasitic drugs.
N-2-(4'thiazolyl)-benzimidazole, a new anthelmintic. Journal of the American Chemical
Society 83: 1764-1765, 1961
17. CHASTANG E. Diarrhée dite de Cochinchine. Quelques notes sur son origine parasitaire et
son traitement par la chlorodyne. Archives de Médecine Navale 30: 29-39, 1878
18. CHAUVIN. L'anguillule stercorale dans la dysenterie des Antilles. Archives de Médecine
Navale 29: 154-155, 1878
19. COUTINHO JO, CROCE J, CAMPOS R, AMATO NETO V. Estudo comparativo entre a
pesquisa de larvas de Strongyloides stercoralis no suco duodenal e nas fezes. Folia Clinica
et Biologica, São Paulo 18: 125-131, 1952
20. CRUZ T, REBOUÇAS G, ROHA H. Fatal strongyloidiasis in patients receiving
corticosteroids. New England Journal of Medicine 275: 1093-1096, 1966
21. DALAND J. Strongyloides intestinalis in Philadelphia. New York Medical Journal 87: 761,
1908
22. DARLING ST. Strongyloides infections in man and animals in the Isthmian Canal Zone.
Journal of Experimental Medicine 14: 1-24, 1911
23. DESCHIENS R, BENEZ J. Essais expérimentaux et cliniques de traitement de l'anguillulose
intestinale par le sous-nitrate et par le carbonate de bismuth. Bulletin de la Société de
Pathologie Exotique 50: 70-74, 1957
564 A History of Human Helminthology
1879
50. GROVE DI. Strongyloidiasis in Allied ex-prisoners of war in southeast Asia. Britis h
Medical Journal i: 598-601, 1980
51. GROVE DI. Effects of 22,23 dihydroavermectin B 1 on Strongyloides ratti and S.
stercoralis infections in mice. Annals of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology 77: 405-410,
1983
52. GROVE DI, HEENAN PJ, NORTHERN C. Persistent and disseminated infections with
Strongyloides stercoralis in immunosuppressed dogs. International Journal fo r
Parasitology 13: 483-490, 1983
53. HARADA Y, MORI O. A new method for culturing hookworm. Yonago Acta Medica
1: 177-179, 1955
54. HARTZ PH. Human strongyloidasis with internal autoinfection. Archives of Pathology
41: 601-611, 1946
55. HARTZ PH. Strongyloidasis wit h internal autoinfection in children. Documenta Medicina
Geographica et Tropica 6: 61-68, 1954
56. HINMAN EH. A study of eighty five cases of Strongyloides stercoralis infection, with
special reference to abdominal pain. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropica l
Medicine and Hygiene 30: 531-538, 1937
57. INTERNATIONAL COMMISSION ON ZOOLOGICAL NOMENCLATURE .
Nematode and Gordiacea names placed in the official list of generic names (Opinion 66),
Smithsonian Institution Publication 2359, Washington DC, pp 171-176, 1915
58. KEAN BH, MOTT KE, RUSSELL AJ. Tropical Medicine and Parasitology. Classi c
Investigations, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, pp 677, 1978
59. KELLY A, LITTLE MD, VOGE M. Strongyloides fülleborni -like infections in man in
Papua New Guinea. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 25: 694-699,
1976
60. KOSUGE I. Histologische Untersuchungen ueber das Eindringen von Strongyloides
stercoralis in die Haut von Versuchstieren. Archiv für Schiffs- und Tropen-Hygiene 28:
15-20, 1924
61. KREIS HA. Studies on the genus Strongyloides (Nematoda). American Journal o f
Hygiene 16: 450-491, 1932
62. KUDICHE R. Neue Verfahren zur Untersuchu ng und Prüfung von Wurmmiteln. Versuche
an Finnen und Strongyloidesl arven. Archiv für Schiffs- und Tropen-Hygiene 29: 189-197,
1925
63. von KURLOW MG. Anguillula intestinalis als Ursache akuter blutiger Durchfalle beim
Menschen. Centralblatt für Bakteriologie, Parasitenkunde und Infektionskrankheiten ,
Abteilung originale 31: 614, 1902
64. de LANGEN CD. Anguillosis en het ziektebe eld van de "idiopathische hypereosinophilie".
Geneeskundig Tijdschrift voor Nederlandsch-Indië 68: 973-990, 1928
65. de LANGEN CD. Postscript about anguillosis and eosinophilia. Mededeelingen van den
Dienst der Volksgezondheid in Nederlandsch-Indië 18: 310-314, 1929
66. LAVERAN A. Note relative du nématoïde de la dysenterie de Cochin-Chine. Gazett e
Hebdomadaire de Médecine et de Chirurgie 14: 42-43, 1877
67. LAVERAN A. Deuxième note relative aux auguillules de la diarrhée chronique d e
Cochinchine. Gazette Hebdomadaire de Médecine et de Chirurgie 14: 116-117, 1877
68. LEICHTENSTERN O. Ueber Anguillula intestinalis . Deutsche medicinisch e
Wochenschrift 24: 118-121, 1898
69. LEICHTENSTERN O. Zur Lebensgeschichte der Anguillula intestinalis . Centralblatt für
Bakteriologie, Parasitenkunde und Infek tionskrankheiten, Abteilung originale 25: 226-231,
1899
70. LEUCKART R. Ueber die Lebensgeschichte der sogenannten Anguillula stercoralis und
deren Beziehungen zu der sogenannten Anguillula intestinalis . Bericht über die
Verhandlungen der königlich sachsischen Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Leipzig .
Mathematische-Physische Classe (1882) 34: 85-107, 1883. Partly translated in 113
71. LEUCKART R. Die Parasiten des Menschen und die von ihnen herrührenden Krankheiten.
566 A History of Human Helminthology
Ein Hand- und Lehrbuch für Naturforscher und Aertze, CF Winter'sche Verlagshandlung,
Leipzig, volume 1, pp 1009, 1879-1886. The parasites of man and the diseases whic h
proceed from them. A textbook for students and practitioners. Natural history of parasites
in general. Systematic account of the parasites infesting man, translated by WE Hoyle ,
Edinburgh, pp 771, 1886
72. LIBERMANN. Diarrhée de Cochinchine. Gazette des Hôpitaux, Paris i: 237-238, 1877
73. von LINSTOW OF. Strongyloides fülleborni n. sp. Centralblatt für Bakteriologie ,
Parasitenkunde und Infektionskrankheiten, Abteilung originale 38: 532-534, 1905
74. LOOSS A. Die Wanderung der Ancylostoma- und Strongyloides Larven von der Haut
nach dem Darm. Comptes Rendus du Sixième Congrès Internationale de Zoologie, Berne,
pp 255-233, 1905. Partly translated in 38
75. LOOSS A. The anatomy and life h istory of Agchylostoma duodenale Dub. A monograph.
Part II. The development in the free state. Translated from the German by M Berhard .
Records of the School of Medicine, Egyptian Ministry of Education, National Printin g
Press, Cairo 4: 163-613, 1911
76. MacCOWN MC, CALLENDER ME, BRANDT MC. The anthelmintic effect o f
dithiazinine in experimental ani mals. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene
6: 894-897, 1957
77. MARTIRANI I, RODRIGUES LD. Ensaio clinico com o cambendazole, uma nova droga
na terapeutica anti-helmintica (nota praevia). Revista do Instituto de Medicina Tropical de
Sao Paulo 18: 71-75, 1976
78. MELTZER RS, SINGER C, ARMSTRONG D, MAYER K, KNAPPER WH .
Antemortem diagnosis of central nervous system strongyloidiasis. American Journal o f
Medical Science 227: 91-98, 1979
79. NISHIGORI M. (The factors which influence the external development of Strongyloides
stercoralis and on autoinfection with this parasite.) Taiwan Igakkai Zasshi No. 277, p p
1-56, 1928. In Japanese. Partly translated in 58.
80. NOLASCA JO, AFRICA CM. A fatal case of paralytic ileus associated with sever e
Strongyloides infestation suggesting internal autoinfection. Journal of the Philippin e
Islands Medical Association 16: 275-283, 1936
81. NORMAND L. Sur la maladie dite diarrhée de Cochinchine. (Extrait d'une lettre adressée
à M. le President par M. le vice-amiral Jurien de la Gravière). Comptes Rendu s
Hebdomadaires des Séances de l'Académie des Sciences 83: 316-318, 1876
82. NORMAND L. Mémoire sur la diarrhée dite de Cochinchine. Archives de Médecin e
Navale 27: 35-55, 102-133, 1877
83. NORMAND L. Du rôle étiologique de l'anguillule dans la diarrhée de Cochinchine .
Archives de Médecine Navale 30: 214-224, 1878
84. NWOKOLO C, IMOHIOSEN EA. Strongyloidiasis of respiratory tract presenting a s
"asthma". British Medical Journal i: 153-154, 1973
85. OPHÜLS W. A fatal case of strongyloidiasis in man, with autopsy. The life cycle o f
Strongyloides intestinalis in man. Archives of Pathology 8: 1-8, 1929
86. PAMPIGLIONE S, RICCIARDI ML. Experimental infestation with human strai n
Strongyloides fuelleborni in man. Lancet i: 663-665, 1972
87. de PAULA e SILVA GS. Estrongyloidiase duodenal. Brasil-Medico 52: 835-839, 1939
88. PERRONCITO E. Observations helminthologiques et recherches expérimentales sur l a
maladie des ouvriers du Saint-Gothard. Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances de
l'Académie des Sciences 90: 1373-1375, 1880
89. PERRONCITO E. Helminthological observations upon the endemic disease developed
among the labourers in the tunnel of Mount St. Gothard. Journal of the Queket t
Microscopical Club 6: 141-148, 1880
90. PERRONCITO E. On the action of chemical agents and medicinal substances on th e
larvae of Dochmius duodenalis and Anguillulae: including therapeutical considerations
relative to the cure of patients from Mont St. Gothard. The Veterinarian 53: 824-828 ,
1880
91. PERRONCITO E. Observations sur le développ ement de l'Anguillula stercoralis (Bavay)
Strongyloidiasis 567
1876 Normand discovered larvae (in retrospect, rhabditiform), which were then
named Anguillula stercoralis by Bavay, in faeces of French troops returned
from Indochina, and proposed the parasite as a cause of Cochin-China
diarrhoea
1876 Bavay described the development of free-living adult worms from faecal
larvae and the subsequent appearance of larvae (rhabditiform) [He observed
the indirect cycle of development]
1876 Normand, at autopsy, discovered parasitic adult worms in the intestine; this
was at first considered to be a distinct species and was named A. intestinalis
1877 Normand and Bavay found larvae (in retrospect, filariform) in faeces which
had been kept for several days. They believed that the larvae were the
offspring of the worm found by Normand in the intestines of a patient
[Although they did not realize it, they had observed the direct development of
rhabditiform into filariform larvae]
1878 Grassi and Parona showed that the larvae produced by A. intestinalis in the
gut were identical with A. stercoralis larvae, and observed their further
development in vitro into filariform larvae but not into free-living adults (the
direct cycle)
1880 The parasite was found to infect miners working in the St. Gothard tunnel
1881 Perroncito cultivated free-living adults from rhabditiform larvae, then
observed the laying of eggs and the hatching of rhabditiform larvae which
developed into filariform larvae (the indirect cycle)
1882 Grassi postulated that the parasitic adult worms were parthenogenetic
1883 Looss observed both direct and indirect development in vitro simultaneously
in the same preparations but did not report the fact
1883 Leuckart concluded that A. intestinalis and A. stercoralis were the same
parasite and that there was an alternation between the parasitic and free-living
generations
1883 Grassi suggested that autoinfection with direct transformation of rhabditiform
to filariform larvae may take place in the gut
1884 Golgi and Monti reported that rhabditiform larvae could undergo either direct
or indirect development
1891 Sonsino described the presence of parasites in the mucosa of the small
intestine
1897 Wilms produced a patent infection in a human volunteer 17 days after
ingestion of filariform larvae
1901-2 van Durme described the penetration of Strongyloides (probably S.
fuelleborni) filariform larvae through the skin of guinea pigs
1904 Looss produced a patent infection in himself after placing larvae on the skin
of his forearm
1905 S. fuelleborni was described as a parasite of monkeys and apes
1911 Fülleborn showed using dogs with a tracheotomy or oesophagostomy that the
majority of migrating filariform larvae followed the tracheo-oesophageal route
described for hookworm by Looss
1911 Gage found filariform larvae in the sputum of a human
1919 Thira produced patent infections by rectal administration of filariform larvae,
570 A History of Human Helminthology
SYNOPSIS
IN HUMANS
571
572 A History of Human Helminthology
gritty nature of the specks leading to rapid blunting of the scalpels. These
specks had been regarded as bone spicules in the muscles, or else were thought
to be caused by deposition of earthy matter.
In the dissecting room at the time was James Paget, a 21 year old first year
medical student. It is uncertain whether Paget himself was the first to observe
the specks in this patient. Certainly, Owen thought so, for he wrote in his paper
printed later that year: "it was observed by Mr. Paget, an intelligent student,
that the muscles presented an uncommon appearance" 76 and also: "Mr.
Paget....first observed the worms in the Italian"74. On the other hand, Paget
himself recalling the events 31 years later wrote: "The report soon ran through
the dissecting room that there was another body with spiculae of bone in the
muscles"80, thus suggesting that another dissector may have first noticed the
abnormality. What is clear, however, is that Paget did not rest content with the
explanation of bony spiculae, or else wished to see them in more detail for
himself, for he examined the specks with a lens and found that they were cysts.
Moreover, almost immediately afterwards, he found that a small worm was
coiled up within nearly every cyst. Being desirous of investigating these
creatures further, he sought a microscope with which to them examine them
more closely. Unfortunately, no such instrument was to be found in the hospital
at that time, so he repaired to the only scientist he knew in London, one Mr.
Children, principal keeper of the natural history collection at the British
Museum. Children had no microscope either, so he took Paget to the celebrated
botanist, Robert Brown. Paget himself has recounted what then happened:
I remember that when Mr. Children entered his room, he said 'Brown, do you know
anything about intestinal worms?' and answer was, 'No, thank heaven - nothing
whatever.' Mr. Brown at once lent me his simple dissecting microscope, with which
I soon observed structures within the worm which were before invisible. He
dexterously pulled a worm from a cyst, and I believe I still possess my sketch of it.80
Thus began a saga which has remained a subject of interest, controversy, and
at times, acrimonious debate, even to the present day.
A number of factors must have contributed to the successful outcome of
Paget's tenacious search. He was clearly of an energetic nature and enquiring
mind. There is no doubt as to his intellectual ability for he won the prizes in
medicine, surgery, chemistry and botany in 1835. Finally, he was well-
acquainted with the biological world, for despite his youth, he had already
published together with his brother Charles a book on the natural history of
Yarmouth. Paget himself attributed his success to the fact that he "looked-at"
and "observed" the specks rather than merely "saw" them as others, both
teachers and fellow-students, had done83.
As the discoverer of the entozoon, Paget was invited to communicate his
findings to the Abernethian Society which was the medical students' society at
St. Bartholomew's Hospital. This he did on 6 February 1835 with Dr. Arthur
Farre in the chair, the salient features being recorded in the Minute Book of the
Society101. Paget's presentation met with sufficient approbation that he was
Trichinosis 573
that:
(the specks) having been again remarked....by Mr. Paget, a student of the hospital,
who suspected it to be produced by minute Entozoa. The suspicion was found to be
correct, and Mr. Owen was furnished with portions of the muscle and made the
following observations.75
In the account printed in the following December, Paget is patronized as an
"intelligent student"76 and this time a footnote, the antithesis of clarity, is added:
The existence of the entozoon was at the same time satisfactorily determined by Mr.
Paget with the assistance of Mr. Brown and Mr. John Bennett at the British
Museum.76
The clear implication of this, of course, is that Owen claimed for himself the
priority of independent discovery of the parasite.
Why should Paget have given way to Owen like this? Many years later
(1866), Paget wrote: "The admirable memoir of Professor Owen (was) much
more complete and exact in zoological detail than anything I could have
written"80. This suggestion that Paget was incapable of writing an expert
zoological description does not stand up to critical analysis. When Paget's and
Owen's texts are both examined, the former compares quite favourably with the
latter. Indeed, Paget did not make the two blunders that Owen did when he
called the tail of the worm its head and denied the existence of an alimentary
tract in the parasite. This question has recently been discussed intensively by
Campbell26 who has also published two letters written by Paget soon after the
discovery. In writing on 11 February 1835 to his brother Charles, Paget said:
You will be interested in learning that I have lately discovered a perfectly new
animalcule, infesting in myriads the human muscle, during life....and the account is
to be published either in the Transactions of the Zoological or the Medico-Chirurgical
Society. I do not yet know whether I shall write the description myself, or whether Mr.
Owen, our lecturer on comparative anatomy will do it - I should rather think the latter,
as he having used far more powerful microscopes than I had, has been able to make
out their organization more clearly. Whichever be the case, I have taken care that I
should receive at least some credit for the discovery, though this was not to be had
without some trouble.81,82
In a subsequent letter two weeks later, he added:
I think I have done rightly in not publishing this account for the folln. among many
reasons. It is a subject with which I was PREVIOUSLY entirely unacquainted, and
I might very easily have fallen into error as to the affinity of species - as well as to their
peculiar structures....I should probably have been obliged to send it to some (minor?)
periodical, or the Society at which the description might have been read, would not
have printed it in their earliest transactions, giving preference to papers by members.
Besides the subject....comes so near the marvellous that it required some good name
to authenticate it to prevent its being....utterly disbelieved. You may add perhaps, self
interest, (wh.?) said that it would in the end be best not to stand too far forward, but
I fear not modesty....I am very well contented that in the papers which will probably
be published....I shall be mentioned as the first observer of their existence.81,82
From all of this, Campbell26 has distilled four likely reasons for Paget's actions.
First, despite his explicit denial, modesty seems a strong factor for he was but
Trichinosis 575
question of its discovery was rekindled. When a writer in the Pall Mall Gazette
in England indicated that the history of Trichinella "was not yet clearly made
out". Spencer Cobbold thought it his duty to write to The Times to put forth the
facts. This led to a spirited exchange in the columns of both that paper and The
Lancet. This included a letter from Paget himself making plain his view of the
facts80 and a communication from "Two former presidents of the Abernethian
Society"101 who quoted an extract from the Society's minute book of 6 February
1835 which described Paget's talk. Cobbold summed it up by writing in The
Lancet:
In the interests of truth, I rejoice that our knowledge of the circumstances connected
with the discovery of the fleshworm is now complete. The letters....unequivocally
establish Mr Paget's priority in this relation.32
Perhaps not surprisingly, Owen remained uncharacteristically silent publicly
during this period, although he was to comment sixteen years later. It may be
that senility impaired his judgement or his memory when he took up the cudgels
again in the correspondence columns of The Lancet in November 1882, and
once more claimed to be the discoverer of the T. spiralis 78. Indeed, his own
communication did little to advance his cause, for he quoted the note from
Wormald which accompanied the specimen of muscle:
Dear Owen, - I send you some sort of organised being, as I believe, which occupies
the muscle of a subject under dissection at St. B. H., and, as I know you are a keen
hand for parasitical things, from 'crabs' downwards, I send the enclosed for your
inspection.109
Not only does this note imply that it was already known that the specks were
of an animal nature, but the apparent spontaneity of the missive does not square
with Owen's own account in 1835 when Owen declared that he had sought the
material from Wormald. This last letter of Owen's stimulated another exchange
between Cobbold34,35 and Owen79, with the latter's incomprehensible circum-
locution doing nothing to change Cobbold's conviction that Paget had
discovered the parasite.
Paget's discovery and Owen's promulgation of awareness of the parasite
raised many important questions. These included the nature of the organism and
its cyst and its significance for the host. But first it was critical that the initial
observations be validated by finding the same parasite in other people. This
was not long in coming from a number of quarters. In St. Bartholomew's
Hospital itself, a second patient was found to be infected just two weeks after
the initial discovery74 and yet a third patient from that hospital was described
later that year by Farre41. Cases were then reported by Harrison in Ireland,
Knox in Edinburgh and by various observers in continental Europe and in
North America.
Uncertainty surrounded the nature of the cyst enclosing the spiral worm.
Owen thought it was a single layer of host origin, saying: the cyst is
adventitious, foreign to the entozoon and composed of the cellular substances
of the body infested, morbidly altered by the irritation of the worm"76. On the
Trichinosis 577
IN ANIMALS
In 1846, Joseph Leidy, a 23 year old American doctor was at home eating a
slice of pork when he noticed some minute specks in the meat which reminded
him of the trichinous spots that he had seen in the muscles of a human cadaver
only a few days previously. When he examined a portion of the flesh under the
microscope, he found that it was teeming with chalky cysts, each containing a
coiled worm; fortunately for him, they had all been killed by cooking62. Leidy
could detect no difference between this parasite and the T. spiralis observed in
human muscle and duly communicated his findings to a meeting of the
Academy of Natural Sciences in Philadelphia. A brief abstract was prepared by
578 A History of Human Helminthology
the secretary of the society and was published in its minutes61. Despite its
annotation in a British journal and in a German publication, the implications of
this observation for an understanding of the epidemiology of trichinosis were
not realized. In fact, Diesing in his Systema Helminthum in 1851 classified the
worm found by Leidy as T. affinis 39 on the assumption that T. spiralis was
peculiar to humans.
Trichinellae had in fact been observed in a non-human host a year earlier
than Leidy had seen it. In August 1845, Ernst Herbst had found large numbers
of trichinellae, which corresponded exactly with those described by Owen, in
the voluntary muscles of an old cat. Herbst then extended these observations in
1848 by finding similar worms in the muscles of a dog. Neither of these
discoveries were reported until 185153 by which time, Guret (1849) had
recorded his discovery of trichinellae in a cat48. Subsequently, a wide range of
mammals was found to be infected in nature, and others were shown in the
laboratory to be susceptible to infection with this organism33,37,45.
When von Siebold declared in 1844 that trichinellae in human muscle were
larvae, he suggested that they were an intermediate stage awaiting transfer to
another host95. This idea followed naturally from the recent publication by
Steenstrup of his theory of the alternation of generations (see chapter 2).
Nevertheless, von Siebold could see difficulties with this postulate; in the
current state of civilisation, the eating of human flesh was not a common
occurrence, and transmission of the parasite this way must have been rare
indeed. The discovery of trichinellae in pigs, cats and dogs opened the way for
exploration of these ideas and it was Herbst who had the initiative and
perseverance to follow it through.
When Herbst found trichinellae in a cat in 1845, he first attempted to transmit
the infection directly by inserting 30 cysts containing live larvae between the
skin and muscles of another cat. On examination four weeks later, the cysts had
attached to the connective tissues and the muscles, but the encapsulated worms
were dead. The second experiment followed his discovery of trichinellae in a
badger. Herbst had kept this badger in captivity for one and a half years and had
fed it partly on vegetables and partly on the remains of animals that he used in
his work. When the badger died in November 1850, Herbst found a
considerable number of trichinellae in its muscles. This time, he fed the flesh
to three dogs that were six weeks old. One animal was sent to the country and
left free to roam while the other two were retained. Three and a half months
Trichinosis 579
later, abundant worms were found in the muscles of both dogs. The third dog
was examined one year after eating infected badger meat and multiple
trichinellae were found in a biopsy of one of its muscles. Herbst was convinced
of the source of infection in these dogs and speculated that, in some as yet
undetermined fashion, eggs were liberated in the gut and passed via the
bloodstream to the muscles: "there can be no doubt that their growth in the
aforementioned three dogs had resulted from the intake of badger meat"53.
These findings were greeted with considerable scepticism, principally
because the trichinellae of animals were regarded as being distinct from those
found in humans, but also because Herbst's descriptions of the worm were
inaccurate and it was believed that he may have confounded some other species
of roundworm with trichinellae. A number of years were to pass before similar
experiments were repeated and Herbst's observations were confirmed and
extended.
Three figures - Leuckart, Virchow and Zenker - were to play leading roles in
the next phase of discovery. They each undertook investigations independently
and almost contemporaneously in the mid 1860's. Heller has remarked that it
is not easy to determine the merits of each one from his publications,
particularly as Virchow106 and Zenker112 felt compelled to defend their positions
against Leuckart who was constantly appearing in print with incomplete
notices. The account which follows generally approximates the conclusions that
Heller made after a careful examination of the literature51. To Virchow must go
the credit for first finding the adult worms in the intestines, while Zenker
hammered into place the final link in the chain of events by explaining how
human infections were acquired. But these achievements only came after a false
start induced by a theory of Friedrich Küchenmeister.
Küchenmeister, who had recently shown that cystic worms, previously
thought to be distinct species, were in reality immature stages of tapeworms,
carefully examined the anatomy of T. spiralis and other nematodes found
commonly in humans. He came to the conclusion that T. spiralis was an
immature form of the intestinal whipworm, Trichocephalus dispar (now
known as Trichuris trichiura). By the same token, Küchenmeister believed it
likely that the trichinellae found in the pig were identical with T. spiralis and,
with a modicum of misguided foresight, thought that humans might possibly
become infected with T. dispar by consumption of pork beset with trichinellae.
Alternatively, he suggested that ingestion of Trichuris eggs by humans might
result in liberation of larvae which then bored through the intestinal wall and
migrated to the muscles where they encysted as T. spiralis 58.
Rudolf Leuckart took up the question and fed T. spiralis cysts to rabbits, cats
580 A History of Human Helminthology
and dogs; he searched without success for Trichuris adults that might have
developed from ingested trichinellae. In 1857, however, he reported that when
he had examined the intestinal mucus of mice shortly after ingestion of such
cysts, he had found that the larvae had escaped from their capsules and doubled
in size63 . In 1859, Leuckart fed trichinous flesh to pigs, but on this occasion
waited five weeks before examination of the intestines. He found a dozen
mature Trichuris in the bowel and, in accordance with Küchenmeister's
hypothesis, Leuckart took these to be the sexual form of T. spiralis. He
despatched word of this observation to PJ van Beneden in Louvain, asking him
to communicate these results to the Academy of Sciences in Paris. This van
Beneden undertook to do, but, in translating Leuckart's letter from the German,
inadvertently mistook "duizend" (dozen) for dutzend (thousands), and thus it
was printed on 26 September 185964.
In the meantime, Rudolf Virchow had not been idle. In July 1859, he fed
trichinous meat to a dog; three and a half days later it died. When the intestines
were examined macroscopically at autopsy, the only parasites apparent were
tapeworms. On microscopical examination of the mucus, however, Virchow
found swarms of lively nematodes 1-2 mm long within which he could see eggs
or sperms. These parasites did not resemble Trichuris at all, but in view of
Kuchenmeister's assertions, Virchow merely concluded cautiously that muscle
trichinellae are able to continue their development in the intestinal tract of a
carnivorous animal. Since he was about to leave for Norway, Virchow made
known his results at a meeting of the Berlin Medical Society on 1 August
1859 102 then sent a written account to the Academy of Sciences in Paris.
According to Reinhard88, however, there was difficulty in deciphering his
handwriting and a French version was not published until 7 November 1859103.
His detailed paper followed the next year104
On receipt of this information, and in a true spirit of scientific enquiry,
Leuckart repeated his studies and infected a number of dogs and cats. He found
the fullgrown worms described by Virchow in the intestines of these animals
and, in an exemplary and forthright fashion, Leuckart declared that Virchow
was absolutely right65.
At the same time as Leuckart confirmed Virchow's observations in
experimental animals, Zenker independently found adult worms in the small
intestine of a human111, as will be described later. Zenker sent portions of
trichinous muscles from this person to Leuckart, Luschka and Virchow, and all
four of them began experimental studies using this material.
elastic, but solidly formed particles representing worm eggs have been able to enter
the blood vessels from the intestinal cavity, since the ample, simultaneous, and equal
distribution of the trichinae through all voluntary muscles justifies the assumption that
their eggs have been carried to the respective places of settlement by means of the
blood circulation.53
The discoveries of Virchow, Leuckart and Zenker provided the clue to the
solving of this question. In his series of experiments, Leuckart made two further
important observations. Firstly, he found that in contrast to muscle larvae, adult
worms were mere transients in the bowel. For example, by the twelfth day after
infection, adult worms had moved from the small intestine to the colon prior to
expulsion. Secondly, Leuckart discovered that female adult worms were
viviparous and released minute filariform embryos that immediately penetrated
the intestinal mucosa then passed to the muscles. There, he found that the
worms penetrated the fasciculi and within the space of 14 days acquired the
size and structure of the well-known T. spiralis 66. Unfortunately, Leuckart
blotted his copybook by declaring that it could scarcely be doubted that Man
acquired his trichinellae, like echinococci, from the dog.
Meanwhile, Virchow was independently pursuing his own studies. Initially,
he fed trichinous flesh to rabbits and found that they died five to six weeks later
as a consequence of muscular degeneration. He passaged the worms through
five successive generations and found that the severity of illness and the
likelihood of death was dependent upon the size of the inoculum of infective
larvae. Like Leuckart, Virchow observed that trichinellae were larviparous and
found larvae within seven days of ingestion in the mesenteric glands and the
serous cavities, but he could not find them in the bloodstream. He then studied
the development of larvae and showed for the first time that they were located
not between the muscle fibres, as had been previously thought, but within them.
In addition, he noted that the cyst was first seen four to five weeks after
infection and that the muscle fibres then atrophied105.
Although the development of adult worms in the gut and of infective larvae
in the muscles was fairly well understood, there was considerable doubt as to
the manner in which larvae passed from the gut to the muscles. Leuckart66 held
that the larvae reached the muscles via the connective tissues and, because of
his great authority, this view held sway for many years. Nevertheless, there
were voices of dissent. Virchow105 had found larvae in the mesenteric lymph
nodes, thus suggesting that the worms might find their way into the
bloodstream, although he was not able to prove this point. This view was
supported by Zenker111 and sustained by Fiedler43 who found larvae in the right
heart of experimentally infected rabbits. Final proof that larvae may travel via
the bloodstream was provided by Herrick and Janeway who in 1909 found
newborn larvae in the blood of a woman suffering from trichinosis 54.
Uncertainty has surrounded the relationship between intestinal adult worm
numbers and muscle worm burdens. It has never been defined clearly in
humans how many muscle larvae are produced for each adult worm in the gut
582 A History of Human Helminthology
In his discussion of the two patients who were found to be infected in the St.
Bartholomew's Hospital dissecting room in 1835, Owen remarked that al-
though there were vast numbers of parasites in the voluntary muscles, neither
person had any symptoms referable to the muscular system. He concluded that
"it is not improbable that in all cases the patient himself will be unconscious of
the microscopic parasites which are enjoying their vitality at his expense"76.
Paget, on the other hand, was more cautious, noting in his private letter to his
brother Charles on 11 February 1835 that "their immense numbers may prove
important when more cases have been found and compared, so as to see
whether they accompany any particular illness"81.
Publication of Owen's paper induced Henry Wood, a practitioner in Bristol,
England to challenge Owen's view and describe a patient who in retrospect may
well have had symptomatic trichinosis. A 22 year old man had been admitted
to the local infirmary in October of the previous year with "acute rheumatism"
of the trunk and extremities. He died a few days later and post-mortem
examination disclosed pneumonia, pericarditis and multiple punctate lesions
in the muscles. Despite observing the latter with a microscope, Wood was
unable to make out their nature. When he read Owen's paper, however, Wood
wondered whether the patient had had trichinosis. He therefore suggested that
it may "be well to ascertain....(if) there was any symptom or inflammation of
any kind in the muscular system"108 in retrospect in patients in whom
trichinellae were found at autopsy.
Nevertheless, Wood's was a voice crying in the wilderness and Farre in 1850
expressed the consensus of opinion when he wrote that trichinellae:
have been found equally in the diseased and in the healthy; in those who have died
from chronic diseases attended by atrophy; and in those who have been cut off in
robust health by some violent accident. No symptoms have been in any case
manifested during life which could lead to the supposition of their existence; and in
all cases, the individuals themselves appear to have been unaware of their presence.42
Trichinosis 583
months21. This was despite the continuing presence of infective larvae in the
muscles which may remain viable for many years. For example, calcified,
encysted trichinellae were found at autopsy in the muscles of a man who had
died in the Vienna Krankenhaus (Hospital). Enquiry revealed that 26 years
previously he had suffered from a severe attack of "rheumatism" that had kept
him confined to bed for several months. When these cysts were fed to rabbits,
trichinellae developed in the gut and muscles100.
unsuccessful until Campbell and Cuckler in the early 1960's showed that the
new benzimidazole, thiabendazole, eliminated intestinal worms and killed many
muscle larvae in infected pigs27,28. This drug was then used on an infected
woman who, whether coincidentally or not, improved96. Nevertheless, a
controlled trial of thiabendazole in human trichinosis does not appear to have
been done. In any case, it is doubtful whether any agent effective against muscle
larvae will be of much benefit as much of the damage will already have been
done before the diagnosis is made and treatment instituted85.
An alternative approach was tried by Salzer in 1916 who gave serum from
previously infected persons to two patients; he claimed that this procedure
produced a fall in temperature and in the level of eosinophilia 94. This was
followed by experimental studies in trichinous animals50, but immunological
treatment has not found a place in the management of trichinosis. The
realization that the inflammatory reaction around muscle larvae was responsible
for producing many of the ill effects of trichinosis led to trial of ACTH69 and
corticosteroids 90 in the alleviation of symptoms. Although some success was
claimed at first, the value of such therapy is probably small, particularly as it
may inhibit immunological expulsion of worms from the gut and thus lead to
even greater numbers of muscle larvae. This could probably be overcome by
the simultaneous administration of thiabendazole, but the value of such a
regimen remains to be proven.
When Zenker found mature worms in the intestines of his patient, he realized
that trichinellae go through their whole cycle of development in one and the
same host. He reasoned, therefore, that infection was likely to have been
acquired by consumption of trichinous meat. Consequently, he went to the
nearby village of Plauen, (East) Germany where the dead woman had come
from and interviewed the owner of the estate. The farmer indicated that he had
ordered a pig to be slaughtered on 21 December but could not say whether the
servant girl had eaten any raw meat, although he was aware that she was fond
of picking at food. Further enquiry revealed that the owner of the estate and the
housekeeper had both been ill with an abdominal complaint in early January
and the the butcher had been extremely ill, being confined to his bed for three
weeks with fever and a paralysing weakness. Fortunately, some of the original
ham was still available and on microscopical examination of it, Zenker found
numerous encysted T. spiralis larvae111. Thus, it became clear that humans
were infected by eating trichinous pork and that infection presumably passed
from pig to pig by consumption of trichinous scraps.
Sporadic cases of illness or death attributed to trichinosis were reported
following Zenker's detailed description and a mild epidemic was recognized in
Trichinosis 587
Plauen in 1862, but it was not until 1863 that the full import of trichinosis
impressed itself upon the minds of both the medical profession and the public
at large. In October of that year, an outbreak of trichinosis occurred in
Hettstadt, a small town of about 6,000 inhabitants near the Hartz mountains in
(East) Germany. Just over 100 people attended a dinner in a hotel in the town
in order to celebrate the fiftieth anniversary of the battle of Leipzig. Included
on the menu were Röstwurst und Gemüse (roast sausages and vegetables). The
Röstwurst had been ordered from the butcher a number of days previously in
order that it could be properly smoked. The butcher went to a neighbour and
bought a pig from his steward. Unfortunately, the steward sold a sickly pig
contrary to his employer's instructions. The pig was duly killed and the pork
worked into sausages which were then smoked and delivered to the hotel where
they were in turn fried and served to the guests at the dinner table. On the
following day, several persons who had been at the dinner were attacked with
diarrhoea, abdominal discomfort, prostration and fever. The number of persons
so afflicted rapidly increased and there was great alarm and apprehension that
an epidemic of typhoid fever was impending. When some of the patients
developed pneumonia and evidence of muscle inflammation, Zenker's report
was remembered. The remnants of the sausages were examined
microscopically and found to be swarming with encapsulated trichinellae.
Muscle biopsies were taken from several of the victims and larvae of T. spiralis
were found in all stages of development. Most of the diners became ill and over
20% of them died. A number of others in the town were also infected with this
pork; eventually nearly 150 became ill and 28 persons died, the diagnosis of
trichinosis being confirmed at autopsy1,3.
Awful though this was, even worse was to befall the town of Hedersleben in
Germany two years later in 1865. In this small village of 2,100 people, 398
persons, most of them young, fell ill and 102 of them died4,8,57. A visitor to the
town soon afterwards has described the scene, saying that:
the place was almost deserted, the manufactory closed, and that 90 orphans were
weeping over the graves of their parents. Upwards of 200 convalescents were
wandering about without work, and bearing in their features traces of the fearful
malady.8
The background to this outbreak has been recorded most graphically:
All this havoc has been caused by one trichinous pig! The butcher, having recognised
the abnormal appearance of the meat of this pig, had carefully disguised it by mixing
it with the meat of two healthy pigs, or added it in small pieces to larger joints of pork
to make up weight. He made this confession shortly before his death, which was
caused by trichinosis contracted from his own meat. His wife also died of the disease.8
Following the outbreak of trichinosis in Hedersleben, a review was made of
the epidemic which had occurred in 1849 in Wegeleben, a community located
about half a mile away, in which 160 persons had been affected and 30 had
died. Biopsies of muscles from some of these people who were still alive
showed that that epidemic had also been caused by T. spiralis 93. A number of
588 A History of Human Helminthology
fragments of meat between two plates of glass and searching for parasites with
the aid of a magnifying glass or the low power lens of a microscope. In one
instance, the Supreme Court of Prussia found a butcher guilty of manslaughter
because he sold trichinous meat which caused the death of a person, the meat
not having been examined microscopically 11.
There were some, however, who remained sceptical. Reinhard88, for example,
believed that not only was microscopical examination inaccurate, but that the
frequency of trichinosis in swine was so small as to not justify the effort made
at its detection. A vivid demonstration that microscopical examination could
not be relied upon occurred at Emersleben in Germany in 1883. In September
of that year, a butcher bought a pig, killed it on the 12th and sold its flesh from
the 13-19th of that month. Out of a population of 700 persons, 250 were
attacked and 42 died. Although incompetent, there is little doubt that the
inspector, a barber, acted in good faith for both he and the butcher partook of
the infected meat and suffered in consequence 15.
In the 1870's, it became apparent, following several epidemics of trichinosis
in humans and the demonstration that 3-16% of the pigs in Indiana were
infected, that trichinosis was not uncommon in the United States of America10.
Much of this pork was exported to Europe in the form of hams and sides of
bacon. Despite being strongly salted and dried, some worms remained viable
as was indicated by the outbreak of trichinosis which occurred in Bremen,
(West) Germany, after consumption of sides of imported American pork. In
1879, ordinances were passed in Austria, Hungary and Italy prohibiting the
importation of porcine products from the United States, then a similar decree
was proclaimed in the following year in Germany, Norway, Portugal and Spain.
By the end of the decade, the majority of European countries forbade the
importation of American pork. The economic consequences of these actions
were such that the United States Congress in 1890 passed an act requiring
microscopical examination of all pork destined for export. Between 1896 and
1906, more than 8 million carcasses were examined and 1.4% were eliminated
as being trichinous 46. On subsequent examination of the remaining certified
pork, German inspectors found that another 1% were still infected.
Consequently, Germany reinstated the prohibition which had been repealed in
1890 on the initiation of testing.
Extensive post-mortem surveys were undertaken in the USA to define the
prevalence of infection in humans and in swine. Sixteen per cent of 11,000
human cadavers examined between 1931 and 1942 were infected. Studies of
swine showed that the frequency of pigs infected with this parasite depended
upon the method of feeding them; those fed on cooked garbage or allowed to
forage in the open fields and woods, 0.5%; those fed principally on grain,
1-1.5%; those given uncooked garbage, 4-6%; and those permitted to feed on
slaughter-house offal, 10-20% 46. In 1952, a severe epidemic of vesicular
exanthema, a viral infection of swine, broke out which led to legislation
requiring that pigs grown for commercial use be fed cooked garbage or grain.
Trichinosis 591
REFERENCES
75. OWEN R. Description of a microscopic entozoon infesting the muscles of the human body.
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London, part 3, pp 23-37, 1835. Identical with 74;
very similar to 76, 77
76. OWEN R. Description of a microscopic entozoon infesting the muscles of the human body.
London Medical Gazette 17: 472-478, 1835. Identical with 77; very similar to 74, 75
77. OWEN R. Description of a microscopic entozoon infesting the muscles of the human body.
Transactions of the Zoological Society 1: 315-324, 1835. Identical with 76; very similar to
74, 75
78. OWEN R. The discovery of Trichina spiralis. Lancet ii: 869, 1882
79. OWEN R. The discovery of Trichina spiralis. Lancet ii: 989, 1882
80. PAGET J. On the discovery of Trichina. Lancet i: 269, 1866
81. PAGET J. Cited in 26
82. PAGET J. Cited in 56
83. PAGET J. Cited in 84
84. PAGET S. Memoirs and letters of Sir James Paget, Longmans, Green and Co., London, pp
438, 1901
85. PHILLIPSON RF, KERSHAW WE. The production, deposition and growth of the larvae of
Trichinella spiralis and their significance in the chemotherapy of the infection. Annals of
Tropical Medicine and Parasitology 54: 250-251, 1960
86. RAILLET A. Quelques rectification à la nomenclature des parasites. Receuil de Médicine
Véterinaire 3: 157-161, 1896
87. RANSOM B H. Effect of refrigeration upon larvae of Trichinella spiralis. Journal of
Agricultural Research 5: 819-854, 1916
88. REINHARD. Statistiche Rückblicke auf die Trichinen-Epidemien im Königreich Sachsen.
Archiv für Heilkunde 18: 241-250, 1877. Abstracted in British Medical Journal ii: 492-493,
1877
89. REINHARD EG. Landmarks of Parasitology. II. Demonstration of the life cycle and
pathogenicity of the spiral threadworm. Experimental Parasitology 7: 108-123, 1958
90. ROSEN E. Cortisone treatment of trichinosis. American Journal of Medical Science 223:
16-19, 1952
91. ROTH H. Experimental studies on the course of trichina infection in guinea pigs. I. The
minimum dose of trichina larvae required to produce infestation of the muscles; with an
account of the productiveness of the female trichina. American Journal of Hygiene 28:
85-103, 1938
92. ROUPELL G. Cited in 76
93. RUPRECHT B. Eine Besuch in Hedersleben. Berliner klinische Wochenschrift 2: 503-507,
1865
94. SALZER BF. A study of an epidemic of 14 cases of trichinosis with cures by serum therapy.
Journal of the American Medical Association 67: 579-580, 1916
95. von SIEBOLD CT. Parasiten. In, Handwörterbuch der Physiologie mit Rücksicht auf
physiologische Pathologie, R Wagner (Editor), Braun Schweig, 2: 641-692, 1844
96. STONE OJ, STONE CT, MULLINS JF. Thiabendazole - probable cure for trichinosis.
Report of a case. Journal of the American Medical Association 187: 536-538, 1964
97. STRöBEL H. Die Serodiagnostik der Trichinosis. Münchener medizinische Wochenschrift
58: 672-674, 1911
98. TIEDEMANN F. In, Froriep's Notizen aus dem Gebiete der Natur und Heilkunde, p 64,
1822. Partly translated in 31
99. TOPHAM J. Notes of interesting cases occurring in medical practice. Lancet i: 45-46, 1850
100. TURNER DF. Trichinosis. Lancet i: 934, 1889
101. TWO FORMER PRESIDENTS OF THE ABERNETHIAN SOCIETY. On the discovery
of Trichina. Lancet i: 270, 1866
102. VIRCHOW R. Futterungverswuch mit Trichina spiralis. Deutsch Klinik 11: 430, 1859
103. VIRCHOW R. Recherches sur le développement de la trichina spiralis (Ce ver devient adulte
dans l'intestin du chien). Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaire des Séances de l'Académie des
Sciences 49: 660-662, 1859
104. VIRCHOW R. Helminthologische Notizen. 3. Ueber Trichina spiralis. Archiv für
Trichinosis 595
pathologische Anatomie und Physiologie und für klinische Medicin (Virchow) 18: 330-345,
1860. Abstracted in British and Foreign Medico-Chirurgical Review 26: 515-516, 1860
105. VIRCHOW R. Note sur le Trichina spiralis. Résultat de ses nouvelles expériences. Comptes
Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances de l'Académie des Sciences 51: 13-16, 1860. Abstracted
in British Medical Journal ii: 563-564, 1860
106. VIRCHOW R. Trichinosis. Archiv für pathologische Anatomie und Physiologie und für
klinische Medicin (Virchow) 32: 332-371, 1865
107. WILKES S. The discovery of trichinae. British Medical Journal i: 190; Lancet i: 269-270,
1866
108. WOOD H. Observations on the Trichina spiralis. London Medical Gazette 16: 190-191,
1835
109. WORMALD T. Cited in 78
110. ZEDER JG. Erster Nachtrag zur Naturgeschichte der Eingeweidewürmer von JAE Goeze mit
Zusätzen und Anmerkungen herausgegeben von J G H Zeder, Siegfried Lebrecht Crusius,
Leipzig, pp 320, 1830
111. ZENKER FA. Ueber die Trichinen-krankheit des Menschen. Archiv für pathologische
Anatomie und Physiologie und für klinische Medicin (Virchow) 18: 561-572, 1860.
Translated in 56
112. ZENKER FA. Beiträge zur Lehre von der Trichinenkrankheit. Deutsche Archiv für klinische
Medizin 1: 90-124, 1866
113. ZENKER, WALDECK. Cited in 59. Abstracted in British Medical Journal ii: 402-403, 1862
114. ZIMMERMANN WJ, BRANDLEY PJ. The current status of trichiniasis in U.S. swine.
Public Health Reports 80: 1061-1066, 1965
115. ZIMMERMANN WJ, STEELE JH, KAGAN IG. The changing status of trichinosis in the
United States. Public Health Reports 83: 957-966, 1968
596 A History of Human Helminthology
1835 Paget discovered larvae in the muscles of a human and Owen reported the fact
1845 Herbst found larvae in the muscles of a cat but did not report the observation
1846 Leidy observed larvae in pork
1851 Herbst infected dogs by feeding them infected badger flesh
1857 Leuckart observed that cysts hatched larvae in the small intestine of mice
1859 Virchow found adult worms in the small intestine of a dog fed with trichinous
meat
1860 Leuckart confirmed Virchow's discovery and found newborn larvae
1860 Zenker proved that T. spiralis may cause a severe illness in humans, found
adult worms in the small intestine of a human, demonstrated that muscle
larvae were located intracellularly, and connected acquisition of infection with
consumption of uncooked trichinous pork
1863 First major epidemic, with high mortality, of trichinosis recognized in
Hettstadt, Germany
1865 Another major outbreak of trichinosis in Hedersleben, Germany in which 102
persons died
1909 Herrick and Janeway found larvae in the blood
1911 Ströbel described a complement fixation test
1963 Treatment with thiabendazole suggested
___________________________________________________________________
Chapter 23
SYNOPSIS
In July 1862, an 18 year old man, originally from Havana, Cuba, presented to
a hospital in Paris with a left-sid ed scrotal tumour. A trocar was inserted by the
surgeon, Jean-Nicolas Demarquay and whitish-yellow fluid similar to milk was
aspirated. In August of the following year, the patient returned with a similar
problem on the other side of the scrotum. Demarquay again inserted a trocar,
aspirated some 100 ml of thick, bluish-white fluid, ascertained that the testi s
was normal and demonstrated that the fluid had been located in the tunic a
597
598 A History of Human Helminthology
found similar worms in the urine of another lady with haematuria. Wuchere r
wondered whether they came from the vagina, but this idea was negated when
some time later he found the same parasites in the chylous urine of a man:
They were alive and were making very brisk, wavy motions. They had the diameter
of a white blood corpuscle and their length exceeded that of the latter, 60 or 70
times.239
Wucherer could find no reference to similar parasites in the works of Küchen-
meister, Cobbold or Davaine, but he did not report them as a new species .
According to Manson-Bahr 173, Wucherer sent specimens of the worm preserved
in glycerine to the renowned parasitologist, Leuckart in Leipzig, Germany, but
the latter dismissed them as being of no importance, considering the parasites
to be members of the family Strongylidae.
Wucherer's observations were confirmed several years later by Timoth y
Lewis in India and by Jules Crevaux of the French Navy 65, the worms found by
the latter also being described by Corre 63. In March 1870, Lewis, apparentl y
unaware of Wucherer's discovery, fo und the worms in the chylous urine of a 25
year old East Indian. When he examined the urine, Lewis found delicat e
filaments which he at first thought were fungi. On continued observatio n
though, he saw that they coiled and uncoiled and realized that they wer e
worms131. Subsequently, Lewis found the same worms in somewhere between
15 and 20 patients 132.
As with many other important discoveries in medical helminthology, there
was the odd pretender to the throne. Spencer Co bbold claimed that in July 1870
he had found similar worms in the urine of a South African girl wit h
schistosomiasis. Cobbold did not publish news of this observation until 1872,
when he also asserted that the worms found in the urine of a patient in 1868 by
Salisbury in the United States 207, and which that observer had called Trichina
cystica, were in reality filariae 54. Lewis's co-investigator, Cunningham ,
disposed of this latter instance by showing that the patient was a 55 year ol d
rheumatic woman suffering from cystinuria, not chyluria, and that the parasites
were almost certainly those of Enterobius vermicularis , then expressed the
same view about the worms found in Cobbold's patient 67. Despite these cogent
arguments, they were not accepted by Cobbold 60. Even more remarkable was
the letter by WO Priestly written to the British Medical Journal :
As long ago as 1857, I described a case of chylous urine, in which the milk-like fluid
passed from the bladder was found on microscopical examination to contain
innumerable linear vibrios, or filariae which moved in every direction across the
microscopic field.195
This was demolished summarily and in caustic fashion by a correspondent:
The 'active linear vibrios' common in decomposing fluids....have, of course, nothing
to do with these nematoid filariae; unless, indeed, we adopt very advanced views on
transmutation not of species, but of classes.197
Meanwhile, the original discovery by Demarquay and his colleague s
remained unappreciated. Two authorities, Cobbold and da Silva Lima, in their
historical reviews in 1878 of the discovery of this parasite were ignorant o f
600 A History of Human Helminthology
Demarquay's contribution, with the former writing "the larval forms firs t
described by Wucherer" 60 and the latter remarking "Dr Wucherer....the firs t
investigator who proclaimed the existence of a new human entozoan, demon-
strating its embryos in chylous urine" 220. It was not until 1888 that Demarquay's
contribution became widely known when his countryman, Lanceraux i n
Guadeloupe, pointed out with som e acerbity that not Wucherer but Demarquay
had first found the parasite 125.
Two years after Lewis found organisms in chylous urine, he made a much
more important further observation. In July 1872, while examining the blood
of a patient with diarrhoea who was under the care of Dr Chuckerbutty in the
Medical College Hospital in Calcutta, Lewis "observed nine minute Nematoid
worms in a state of great activity, on a single slide" 132. He showed them to his
colleague, Douglas Cunningham, who co ncurred with Lewis's opinion that they
were the same as those that had been seen earlier in chylous urine. On th e
following morning, Lewis went back to the Hospital to review the patient' s
clinical history, but found to his intense disappointment that the patient ha d
discharged himself one hour earlier. All attempts to find him, even invoking the
aid of the police, proved fruitless. Several days later, however, Lewis agai n
found worms in the urine of a woman with haematochyluria. Perhaps burned
by his previous experience, L ewis visited her that same evening. In view of the
subsequent discovery of the nocturnal periodicity, i.e. the transient surge o f
microfilariae into the bloodstream at night after a complete or almost complete
absence during the day, this was undoubtedly a fortuitous event, for "O n
pricking her finger with a needle, and distributing a drop of blood over several
slides, I found that Filariae were present in it also" 132. Lewis kept her under
observation for about two months, and found that although there was littl e
change in her clinical condition and there was only a slight reduction in worms
in the urine, the numbers of worms in the blood diminished markedly (blood
samples were presumably taken during the day):
the numbers obtainable by pricking the fingers or toes certainly decreased and
eventually, out of half a dozen or more slides, not more than one or two
Haematozoa could be detected; on a few occasions several slides were examined
without any being found.132
Shortly afterwards, Lewis encountered a third patient, a 22 year old Eas t
Indian who spent most of his time employed as a cook on a lighter lying in the
mouth of the River Hooghly. Lewis was amazed to find:
that no matter at what portion of his body the circulation is tapped with the point of
a needle, numerous active, well-developed Haematozoa are invariably obtained; on
one occasion I observed as many as 12 of these creatures on a single slide....the
number infesting his whole body may be imagined. 132
Indeed, Lewis calculated that one patient was host to some 140,000 of th e
parasites. Nevertheless, he noted that this was not a common occurrence and
that it was often necessary to examine several of the slides before the parasite
could be found, each slide taking about 15 minutes to complete.
When Lewis went to the Government Printing Es tablishment to examine the
Filariasis 601
galley proof of his report on the discovery of microfilaria in the blood, he was
astounded to find that the man setting up the type was none other than the first
patient in whom he had found microfilaria in the urine. Enquiry revealed that
he was healthy and examination of his blood disclosed the presence of sparse
numbers of worms 132.
Lewis described the morphology of the parasite and discerned the sheath,
indicating that it was an extremely delicate tube closed at both ends, withi n
which the worm was capable of elongating and shortening itself. This feature
led him to surmise that the pa rasite had no means of perforating the tissues and
that its normal habitat was the blood. In addition, he noted a bright spot at the
blunt end of the worm which was suggestive of a mouth.
Lewis's long paper was published as an appendix to the Annual Report for
1871 of the Sanitary Commissioner 132 and was abstracted later in The Lancet 7,
but news of his discovery was first revealed in an annotation in The Lancet of
31 August 1972 5. The same commentator noted that the nature of the worm had
been determined by George Busk , who stated that the helminth belonged to the
genus Filaria of Müller179 and that Busk had also suggested a name for th e
parasite:
A specimen of the embryo of the chylous-urine worm has been submitted to Mr.
Busk, who considers it to be some kind of Filaria; and it may not be inappropriate
to christen the new entozoon 'Filaria sanguinis hominis'.5
The name, of course, meant that the filar ia had been found in human blood. The
name "filaria" was a modern Latin derivative, "filarium" indicating "ball o f
thread", of the Latin word "filum", meaning "thread".
Nematodes and flukes had been found in the blood of molluscs, fish, frogs,
birds, rats and dogs, but this was the first occasion on which multitudes o f
worms had been found in the general circulation of humans, although schisto-
somes had been found in the portal vein and its tributaries by Bilharz in 1851
and it was suspected that Trichinella spiralis larvae might migrate to th e
muscles through the bloodstream. The discovery by Lewis of worms in th e
blood, which he termed haematozoa, caught the imagination of the Englis h
medical world in particular, and became the subject of a multitude of paper s
and letters. An editorial writer in the British Medical Journal remarked:
That organisms so high in the scale as nematoids should be found to swarm as
parasites in this situation is not a little surprising, though it is perhaps still more
astonishing that they should produce such a comparatively trivial amount of
inconvenience.6
Lewis's discovery was confirmed by Sonsino in Egypt on 1 February 1874
while searching for schistosomes in peripheral blood:
I put a drop of blood (from the finger of the boy) under the microscope, placing it
directly under the objective glass, when with astonishment I discovered a living
organism in the midst of haematic globules. The nematoid had the shape of an
Anguillula. It glided amongst the blood globules, which were tossed to and fro by
lively movements.221
Also in 1874, Rowland 206 and then Bancroft22 , both in Australia, foun d
602 A History of Human Helminthology
WUCHERERIA BANCROFTI
parasites in the right side of the heart of a boy who had died from a n
undisclosed illness. It is possible they were immature Dirofilaria immitis,
although de Magalhães 150 sent a copy of this account, including figures, t o
Joseph Bancroft in Brisbane who accepted them as a female and male Filaria
bancrofti, noting that this was the first time in which the male parasite had been
described 21. On the other hand, Daniels considered the parasites distinct ,
giving them quite different dimensions 71.
Several other names apart from Filaria sanguinis hominis and Filaria
bancrofti have been used to describe these parasites. Manson called it Filaria
nocturna in order to distinguish it from the microfilaria which had a diurna l
periodicity (which turned out to be Loa loa)165, and Manson-Bahr proposed the
name Wucheria pacifica for the aperiodic form of the parasite 172. In 1877, da
Silva Araujo called the worm which he found in a lymph scrotum "Wuchereria
Filaria"218, but whether he meant to use "Wuchereria" as a true generic name is
doubtful; more likely he was refer ring to "Wucherer's filaria". In any event, two
years later, da Silva Araujo called the same worm Filaria wuchereri 219. In
1921, Seurat formally separated this pa rasite from the other filarial parasites on
zoological grounds and adopted da Silva Araujo's Wuchereria as the generic
name, the worm henceforth being known as Wuchereria bancrofti 216.
micrographs in Ashburn and Craig's paper and concluded that it was possible
that they had described microfilaria malayi 172. If this is true, then the correct
name for B. malayi would be Brugia philippinensis.
Be that as it may, microfilariae morphologically indistinguishable fro m
Brug's worm were recognized increasingly in parts of Southeast Asia an d
southern India, beginning with Korke in India 123. The resemblance betwee n
these microfilariae and those of Loa loa led to some speculation that the parent
worm of these microfilariae may resemble the latter worm. In 1939, Poynton
and Hodgkin indicated that they had found similar microfilariae in a Kr a
monkey (Macacus irus)194. In the following year, Rao and Maplestone reported
the recovery of the parent worms of microfilaria malayi from a patient with a
lymphatic cyst on the forearm. The female specimens were quit e
indistinguishable from those of W. bancrofti, but those authors detected some
slightly more substantial differences in the male worms, so they included them
in the genus Wuchereria. Nevertheless, they believed that the morphological
appearance of the microfilariae and their development in different species o f
mosquitoes justified specific status, so they designated the worms Wuchereria
malayi 198. Their views were confirmed soon afterwards by Bonne and hi s
colleagues35, then a more complete description of what was presumed to be W.
malayi was provided by Buckley and Edeson with material recovered from a
monkey47. On the basis of a study of these specimens, Buckley erected a new
genus, Brugia, in honour of Brug, to house B. malayi and two closely related
worms, B. pahangi of cats, dogs and monkeys in Malaysia, and B. patei of dogs
and cats in East Africa 45,46.
In 1955, Buckley and Edeson described Wuchereria pahangi, a parasite of
cats47. As already mentioned, this worm was subsequently renamed Brugia
pahangi by Buckley46. That the parasite was capable of infecting humans was
proven by Edeson and his colleagues in 1960: two volunteers were infected ;
both experienced episodes of lymphangitis and lymphadenitis, then on e
developed microfilaraemia 84 days after inoculation 80.
In the early 1960's, HL David observed that two kinds of microfilariae were
present in the blood of military recruits in what was then Portuguese Timor .
One was microfilaria bancrofti and the other resembled microfilaria malayi. In
1965, David and Edeson published their finding that this latter worm was a
distinct microfilaria which they named Timor microfilaria 72. Eventually,
Partono and his colleagues fed Aedes togoi on people with this microfilaraemia
in a village on Flores, Indonesia, infected Mongolian gerbils with the infective
larvae, then recovered and described the adult worms which they designate d
Brugia timori 190.
In 1971, Ash and Little described Brugia beaveri, a parasite of the
raccoon15. Six human cases of infection in the United States with this or a
closely related parasite have been published, the first being reported b y
Rosenblatt and colleagues 203.
606 A History of Human Helminthology
In 1873, some microfilariae that had been discovered in the blood by Lewi s
were exhibited at a meeting of the Pat hological Society of London. This excited
considerable interest and in the ensuing discussion consideration was given to
the possible life cycle of this parasite. Cobbold, basing his argument upon the
recent demonstration of the role of crustaceans in the transmission o f
Dracunculus medinensis, extrapolated this to conclude that an intermediat e
host was always required for nematodes. While this would prove to be false as
a general rule, it turned out to be true in this particular case. Cobbol d
postulated that either adult worms which produced these forms were normally
present but unnoticed in humans or that they we re the progeny of an adult worm
which had strayed into humans from some carnivorous animal 55. Bastian and
Harley objected to any idea that man could be an intermediate host; they could
not believe that tens of thousands of these worms could get in from the external
environment, so inferred that adult worms must live within the human body 31.
All of these ideas remained mere speculation, however, until Patric k
Manson entered the fray. Manson had practised for eight or nine years in the
Orient and had seen many cases of elephantiasis and lymph scrotum. When he
returned to Britain on furlough in 1875, he acquired both a microscope an d
knowledge of Lewis's discovery. 1876 saw him back in Amoy, China, and he
soon found microfilariae in the blood of a number of patients. He was puzzled
about the fate of these larvae and determined to try to ascertain their destiny.
Since a person might harbour hundreds of thousands of larvae, Manson thought
it most unlikely that they matured withi n the human body, otherwise they would
kill the host and thus prevent transmission to another host. This was clearl y
untenable as it would lead to extermination of the parasite. He postulated that
the larvae must escape from the host, then develop further, either in a
free-living state, or in some intermediate host where they matured befor e
ingestion by another person. Manson dedu ced that the most likely means of exit
was via a blood-sucking insect, so he considered the possible roles of fleas ,
bedbugs, lice, mosquitoes and sandflies. In blissful ignorance of the almos t
world-wide dissemination of mosquitoes, he selected these insects as th e
probable candidates because he thought their geographical distributio n
coincided most closely with t hat of the parasite. In order to test this hypothesis,
he procured some mosquitoes and fed them on 10 August 1877 on the blood
of his gardener, Hin-Lo, who had a marked microfilaraemia, then examine d
their abdominal contents at daily intervals. In an almost banal fashion, Manson
wrote:
I found that my idea was correct, and that the haematozoon which entered the
mosquito a simple, structureless animal, left it, after passing through a series of
hightly interesting metamorphoses, much increased in size, possessing an alimentary
canal, and being otherwise suited for an independent existence. 156
Filariasis 607
Manson's true feelings on that day in 1877 may be guessed better from a
speech which he later gave and which was reported in the Daily Telegraph:
I shall not easily forget the first mosquito I dissected. I tore off its abdomen and
succeeded in expressing the blood the stomach contained. Placing this under the
microscope, I was gratified to find that, so far from killing the filaria, the digestive
juices of the mosquito seemed to have stimulated fresh activity. And now I saw a
curious thing. The little sac or bag enclosing filaria, which hitherto had muzzled
it....was broken through and discarded.169
The bare bones of his find have been recorded in his diary:
Hin-lo brought me four mosquitoes which he had caught this morning in his
mosquito net and which were distended with his blood. I examined them this
morning.
No. 1. Blood corpuscles not distinct....Several cylindrical bodies of a pale grey
colour and distinct outline. These were about the size and might have been embryo
filariae dead.
No. 2. Blood corpuscles also digested and two bodies one of which had a distinct to
and fro movement of the head half of the body and the appearance of ciliary current
at the mouth.
No. 3. and 4. Blood corpuscles distinct - in both live active filariae and in one of
them ten specimens. Different from those in man's blood in being perhaps more
active. Tail not well seen; anterior head loop often very distinct, oral movements
very apparent. Perhaps an oesophagus developing. Double outline and transverse
striation on the integument most distinct.168
In his original paper, Manson noted that the mosquitoes took only a minute
or two to become engorged with blood and seemed to have the capacity t o
concentrate microfilariae fro m the bloodstream. He then described the changes
in the appearance of the microfilariae. Thirty six hours after ingestion by th e
mosquito, the larvae ceased their movements and entered a "sort of chrysalis
condition" and became shorter and fatter s o that by the third day they resembled
a sausage. A mouth and intestinal tract then appeared and the worms grew in
length. Manson had great difficulty in observing these later stages, whic h
occurred around the fourth to the sixth day because most of his mosquitoe s
died. Out of hundreds of mosquitoes that he watched, only four lived beyond
this stage, and in one of these he saw a gradation of forms from the passiv e
chrysalis to an active larvae between 0.5 and 1 mm in length. Because of the
paucity of specimens, he was uncertain of the details of this stage o f
metamorphosis but found that the alimentary tract became distinguished more
clearly and thought that the worm may have a boring apparatus on its head.
Manson remarked that these processes always took place within femal e
mosquitoes, for he had never seen a male mosquito engorged with blood .
Further, he stated that his studies were always performed with the mor e
common of the two mosquitoes prevalent in his region, a dingy brown insect
about 8 mm in size (C. quinquefasciatus, while the other species was probably
Aedes aegypti). He observed the replete mosquitoes fly off to near stagnan t
water, remain there for several days, then deposit eggs, following which, h e
assumed, they died. Manson surmised that the life cycle of the worm wa s
608 A History of Human Helminthology
Adequate recognition has not been given t o Bancroft in this regard. Manson
was lucky while Bancroft was unlucky. Manson chanced upon an efficien t
vector of the parasite (C. quinquefasciatus) for use in his studies. According
to Cilento53, Bancroft in April 1877, before Manson had begun his studies, fed
some Aedes vigilax, a poor vector as it turned out, on an infected person bu t
was discouraged by the negative results.
In March 1878, Cobbold communicated formally Manson's account i n
which the latter characterized the mosquito as a "nurse" of the worm, to th e
Linnean Society in London. In the discussion that followed, Manson's opinions
were accepted by a number of eminent authorities. The publication 157 which
followed Cobbold's verbal report was the same as the parasitological com -
ponent of Manson's Custom's Report 156 except that the illustrations of th e
various forms of developing larvae were omitted. It was not until June of that
year, however, that the British Medical Journal was constrained to publish an
editorial entitled "Is the mosquito the intermediary host of the Filaria sanguinis
hominis?"8. This article was stimulated by the publication by Lewis in Calcutta
of the results of his attempts to repeat Manson's experiments. At first Lewi s
was in considerable doubt, for in contrast to Manson who had squashed th e
whole of the posterior portion of the mosquito and assumed that the variou s
events took place within the gut, Lewis removed the alimentary canal an d
examined it separately, and saw fe w parasites after the third day. Subsequently,
however, he found that the same worms "actually perforate the walls of th e
insect's stomach, pass out, and then undergo developmental stages in it s
thoracic and abdominal tissues" 135. Lewis's conclusion was very cautious ,
although it left open the possibility of mosquitoes being the intermediate host
of filariae:
With regard, however, to the inference that the mosquito is the particular
intermediary host of nematoid haematozoa, it cannot be said that even these later
observations are sufficiently conclusive to warrant a positive statement being made
at present; for though, assuming that of the various parasitic forms which have been
seen several are actually transitional stages in the development of one and the same
entozoon, it is to be noted that even the most advanced stage hitherto observed is
still a very immature one . . and every attempt hitherto made by myself to obtain a
more advance condition has been unsuccessful. Further observation, however, may
overcome or explain this want of success.135
In the middle of 1878, da Silva Araujo in Brazil also confirmed Manson' s
observations when he found W. bancrofti larvae in mosquitoes fed on the blood
of a French priest who had a microfilaraemia 219.
While Cobbold accepted Manson's views unreservedly, and Lewis did not
altogether dismiss them, Leuckart appeared to pay no attention at all to them.
Manson's biographers, Manson-Bahr and Alcock, have remarked that Leuckart
was initially an unbeliever and seems never to have given Manson's discovery
anything but a grudging and disparaging a cknowledgement 175. This seems a fair
comment, for in the 1886 edition of his Parasites of Man, Leuckart discourses
610 A History of Human Helminthology
and live with her parents for three months. In contrast to Manson who ha d
found filariae in various stages of development within the one mosquito ,
Bancroft observed that all of his larvae were at the same stage of development.
Moreover, 16 days were required in warm temperatures for development to be
completed, then no further changes occurred for the next six weeks. In view of
these findings, Bancroft suggested that the rare, fully-developed larvae which
Manson had seen seven days or so after feeding must have been derived from
an earlier blood meal, for Manson had caught wild mosquitoes. Bancroft first
published notification of his findings in the Australasian Medical Gazette in
189925. In that letter he noted that infective larvae were not killed by bein g
placed in water, and suggested that infection for the human host via thi s
medium should be confirmed experimentally on life-sentenced prisoners and
offering them a free pardon as a reward. In his more detailed report published
later that year, however, Bancroft modified his earlier statement and reported
that the larvae died three to four hours after immersion in water. This led him
to cast doubts of the water-transmission theory, and he wrote in an addendum
dated 1 June 1899:
It has occurred to me that young filariae may gain entrance to the human host whilst
mosquitoes bearing them are in the act of biting. The entrance of warm blood into
the mosquito may excite the young filariae in consequence of which they pierce the
oesophagus and pass down the proboscis into the human skin. In this way, injury
from human digestive agents would be avoided.26
Bancroft then sent some filariated mosquitoes that he had prepared t o
Manson in London who in turn passed them on to George Low who was work-
ing under his direction at the London School of Tropical Medicine. Thes e
mosquitoes were fixed in celloidin and histological sections were cut. In June
1900, Low published some magnificent figures of larval filariae in the abdomen
and thorax then illustrated their passage past the salivary glands into th e
proboscis, pushing forward between the labium and hypopharynx: "Here I have
frequently found them stretching along almost the entire length of th e
proboscis, the head being invariably in advance" 140. With masterly
understatement Low then wrote:
It is difficult to avoid the deduction that the parasites so situated are there normally,
awaiting an opportunity to enter the human tissues when the mosquito next feeds
on man.140
Many commentators have given Low the credit for discovering the tru e
manner of transmission of filariasis from mosquito to man. Nevertheless, h e
was but the technician who made the final but inevitable observation. Thomas
Bancroft determined the underlying conditions necessary for carrying out the
experiment, prophesied the outcome, and actually prepared the mosquitoe s
from which the sections were made. If he had had the appropriate technica l
resources at hand, he would undoubtedly have followed the whole proces s
through to its logical conclusion.
Much credit must also be given to Captain SP James of the Indian Medical
612 A History of Human Helminthology
of my own and think that science will not lose much if the papers by him and Dr.
Noè on filariasis are similarly excluded from monographs on that subject. 204
Meanwhile, Thomas Bancroft in 1901 used D. immitis as a model to show
clearly that larvae escaped through the labe lla at the tip of the labium 27. Further,
in a well-controlled experiment on 30 December 1902, he exposed a thre e
week old uninfected pup to 183 filariat ed mosquitoes, two of which bit the dog.
Nine months later, microfilar iae appeared in the peripheral blood, then the dog
was killed and 16 male and 16 female adult D. immitis were recovered from the
right ventricle and the pulmonary artery 28. Thus, there seemed little doubt that
a similar mechanism was involved in human filariasis.
Basic knowledge of mosquito biology was poor in those early years. No t
only were the behaviour and natural history of mosquitoes dimly understood,
but many species were undiscovered or unnamed. Neverthless, mosquitoe s
were observed, categorized, and their ability to permit development o f
microfilariae determined experimentally. In 1900, 110 species of mosquitoes
were known. By 1922, more than ten times that number had been described 81.
The original mosquitoes which Manson had used in his experiments wer e
proven more than 50 years later to be Culex quinquefasciatus (= fatigans)
when some mosquitoes that he had filariated and sent to Cobbold wer e
discovered in bottles at the Royal College of Surgeons in England 174. In 1900,
James in India reported that Anopheles rossi was a vector of W. bancrofti 116,
then he was followed by Annett, Dutton and Elliott in Nigeria in 1901 wh o
showed that Anopheles costalis was a vector 3 and then by Bahr in Fiji wh o
worked with Aedes variegatus (= pseudoscutellaris = polynesiensis)19. By
1922, Edwards was able to list seven species in which complete development
of W. bancrofti microfilariae had been shown. In addition, 23 species were said
to allow partial development 81. In 1930, Brug and de Rook reported that th e
newlydiscovered B. malayi completed its development in Taeniarhynchus
annulipes (= Mansonia annulipes = M. dives) and T. annulatus (= Mansonia
annulata)43, then several years later, Feng showed that the major vector of this
parasite in Huchow, China was Anopheles hyrcanus var. sinensis 85. When
Sasa came to write his review of filariasis in 1976, hundreds of species o f
mosquitoes were known to be transmitters of this infection, although wit h
varying degrees of efficiency 211.
During 1876 and 1877, Manson noticed that microfilariae could not always be
found in patients whom he knew from previous observations to be infected .
Eventually, he trained two Chinese a ssistants to make blood examinations. One
of these persons worked during the day and the other laboured at night. Manson
was struck by the fact that the night worker found more parasites than did the
614 A History of Human Helminthology
daytime attendant but he did not arrive at the correct explanation. In 1879 ,
however, he gave directions for a particular patient's blood to be examine d
daily and found that on some days there were abundant microfilariae whereas
on others there were none or ve ry few. Closer analysis of these results revealed
that more microfilariae were found on busy days when the blood examination
had to be left to the evening. This reminded him of the earlier discrepancie s
with his two assistants, so he made a series of systematic examinations every
few hours on this patient and in a number of others. He wrote to Cobbold in a
letter dated 27 February 1880:
The young escape into the circulation at regular intervals of twenty four hours, the
discharge commencing soon after sunset and continuing till near midnight, from
which time till the following noon their numbers gradually decrease. By 2 or 4
o'clock till 6 they are nearly completely absent....It is marvellous how nature has
adapted the habits of the filariae to those of the mosquito. The embryos are in the
blood just at the time the mosquito selects for feeding. 168
Manson confirmed his observations on further patients and published th e
results in the Customs Report 159. In addition, Cobbold presented Manson' s
communication to the Quekett Microscopical Club on 27 February 1880 160.
Manson was very thankful for the efforts, for he later wrote to Cobbold:
I am very grateful to you for the trouble you have taken in bringing these forward
and cannot but feel that unless for your kind assistance, my work would lie
entombed in the 'Customs Gazette' of little use to anyone. 160
Cobbold's presentation of Manson's finding was greeted with astonishment
by some and with downright disbelief by others, with one wag enquirin g
"whether the filariae carried watches" 9. In 1881, however, WW Myers o n
Formosa (Taiwan) confirmed Manson's observations 180, then the scoffers were
silenced when Stephen MacKenzie in London in the same year not onl y
demonstrated microfilarial periodicity in a 26 year old patient who had acquired
the infection in India but, at the suggestion of Vandyke Carter, succeeded i n
reversing the periodicity by persuading the patient to sleep by day and stay up
at night146.
On hearing about MacKenzie's experiment , Manson repeated the procedure
in three patients and found partial or compl ete reversal four days later 162. Mean-
while, Manson had wondered whether th e microfilariae died each day and were
replaced by a new brood, or whether they hid themselves during the day. H e
tried to investigate this with a dog inf ected with D. immitis, which he found had
partial periodicity. The animal was killed with prussic acid and Manson found
that most of the microfilariae were in the lungs 163. Many years later, he had an
opportunity to prove that the same phenomenon occurred in humans. On 1 9
February 1897, a man who had been known to have a microfilaraemi a
committed suicide with prussic acid and died almost instantly at 8.30 in th e
morning. Following a post-mortem examination, Manson concluded:
Filaria nocturna during its temporary absence from the cutaneous circulation is
present in the larger blood vessels, particularly the arteries, that a few are found in
Filariasis 615
the capillaries of the muscles and brain, a few in the vessels of the kidneys, a
considerable number in the muscle of the heart; but the majority are lodged in the
blood vessels of the lungs.166
The mechanism by which this phenomenon occurs has attracted a great deal of
attention since those early days but still remains a mystery. The central thesis
proposed by Lane 126 was that there was a cyclical release of embryos from adult
worms, but most other authors fro m Manson on 14,108,171 have thought it far more
likely that periodicity depends upon an interaction between the microfilaria e
and the host, with microfilariae retiring to the viscera during the daytime.
In 1896, Thorpe reported that the microfilariae seen in Tonga in the south
Pacific exhibited no nocturnal perio dicity, being found in the blood both by day
and by night228, then this observation was confirmed by Lynch in Fiji145 . In
1912, Fülleborn showed that this aperiodic form of W. bancrofti was present
only eastwards of approximately 140oE longitude. Whereas he found aperiodic
W. bancrofti in Samoan troops stationed in Hamburg, Germany, when h e
visited northeastern New Guinea and parts of eastern Indonesia, onl y
nocturnally periodic W. bancrofti was seen93.
Lichtenstein in 1927 showed that the new microfilaria in his area, late r
named B. malayi, was nocturnally periodic, like that of W. bancrofti 137. In
1957, Turner and Edeson 230, then Wilson and his colleagues 236 , reported that
there were two distinct patterns of microfilarial periodicity in B. malayi
infections in Malaya. In addition to the previously recognized periodic for m
which was transmitted by Anopheles mosquitoes and was endemic in open rice
fields and swamp areas, a subperiodic form (i.e. microfilaraemia occurre d
throughout the 24 hours with a mild peak at night) was seen among inhabitants
of forested areas. This strain was shown to be transmitted by Mansonia
mosquitoes, and was found to be a zoonosis, occurring in wild and domesti c
animals, especially cats and monkeys 79,124.
Swollen legs have been recognized since an tiquity. While the commonest cause
of subacute cases of this condition is conges tive cardiac failure and even though
relatively frequent problems such as deep vein thrombosis and rare conditions
such as Milroy's disease (congenital absence of the lymphatics) and Dercum's
disease (lipomatosis) may have accounted for a proportion of patients wit h
chronic enlargement of the limbs, the most common cause in endemic areas has
undoubtedly been filarial parasites. In gross cases with thickening of the skin,
the resemblance of the limb to that of an elephant's leg led to the description of
the condition as "elephantiasis". Similarly, there are many causes of hydrocele,
but again, the majority of such cases in endemic areas, especially whe n
associated with lymphatic thickening of the scrotal tissues have probably been
616 A History of Human Helminthology
the next section. To this constellat ion of disorders, some authors gave the name
"filariasis", a term which Cobbold damned, bellowing that "this vague and too
comprehensive sort of nomenclature cannot be allowed to stand" 62. His
opposition, however, was doomed.
During the second world war, an opportunity arose to study the clinica l
manifestations of early filariasis in detail. Several hundred American service-
men stationed in the south Pac ific, particularly in Samoa, became infected with
W. bancrofti. Acute inflammatory lesions were seen in persons who had been
in the endemic area for three months or more. Lesions in a limb usually began
as a lymphadenitis which then spread in a retrograde or centrifugal fashion ,
while genital involvement was indicated by a highly characteristic scrotal lesion
with funiculitis and epididymitis. There w as a tendency to multiple involvement
and recurrence, the attacks generally lastin g for a few days and being associated
with fever in about 20% of cases 76,119. The minds of not a few United State s
servicemen were distressed by the possibility that these symptoms were a
harbinger of hideous deformity yet to come. Babione in 1945 wrote a
reassuring article entitled: "A few facts about filariasis for folks who fear that
filaria-infected fellows will fetch f ilariae from the front" 18 in which he predicted
that few individuals would suffer serious consequences and divined tha t
development of microfilaraemia and secondary transmission was unlikely. He
was eventually proven correct, for when Trent reviewed these patients 15-16
years later, he found that only less than 1% had a swollen leg or genita l
complaint, and none of them had either elephantiasis or microfilaraemia 229.
When infection with Brugia malayi was differentiated, the symptomatology
in malayan filariasis was found to be broadly similar to that seen in bancroftian
filariasis, although there were differences in emphasis. Lichtenstein in 192 7
observed that acute filarial disease was infrequent and that even thoug h
elephantiasis was common, this was generally restricted to the lower lim b
without involvement of the genitals 137. His views were echoed by Brug 41 and
many subsequent workers, although acute inflammation was recognized from
time to time and genital disease was seen occasionally.
was "a sort of dropsy" 154. On his return to China after furlough in Britain ,
Manson examined 190 local people who were selected randomly, the onl y
requirement being that they were willing to have a finger pricked; he foun d
microfilariae in the blood of 15 of them. Manson noted that some of thes e
infected persons were in perfect health but that others had evidence o f
lymphatic obstruction with lymph scrotum, elephantiasis, or recurrent attacks
of fever accompanied by oedema which was not due to heart disease or renal
failure155. During 1877, he confirmed his investigations and found parasites in
62 of 670 persons. Among these individu als were patients with lymph scrotum,
elephantiasis of the leg or genitalia, chyluria and inguinal lymphadenopathy ;
some 60% of these patients had microfilaraemia compared with less than 10%
of the normal population. Although the tests of experimental infection an d
post-mortem examination were wanting, Manson was convinced that he ha d
proven that these diseases were due to the worm, and like Lewis, conclude d
that the essential feature was obstruction of the lymphatics by these parasites.
Nevertheless, he appreciated that ther e were two unresolved problems - the not
infrequent presence of microfilaraemia without disease, and the somewhat less
common reverse situation. Manson thought that the former merely indicate d
that the disease was merely an accidental side-effect, and explained the latter
on the basis that the worms h ad either died, the infection was unisexual, or that
the adult parasites had become encysted so that the larvae could not escape .
These clinical findings were published, together with his observations on the
development of larvae within mosquitoes, in the Customs Reports 156, then
reprinted in the Medical Times and Gazette 158.
In the meantime, confirmation of the existence of lymphatic pathology was
provided by Bancroft's discovery of an adult worm in a lymphatic abscess, and
was consistent with his subsequent recovery of them from hydrocele fluid 20.
Nevertheless, there were still opponents of these ideas. Dr Tilbury Fox, a
London dermatologist, published a pa per in 1878 denigrating the work of these
"recent writers"90. Following a presentation of two cases of elephantiasis b y
Joseph Fayrer at a meeting of the Pathological Society of London 84, Fox again
asserted that evidence linking filarial infections with elephantiasis was ver y
weak, claimed to have seen cases of elephan tiasis in patients who had never left
England, and emphasized the abs ence of microfilaraemia in some patients with
elephantiasis or chyluria, and cont rasted that with the extremely high frequency
of microfilaraemia that Manson had observed in China. Furthermore, Fo x
claimed that it was not proven that elephantiasis and lymph scrotum were the
same disease, and argued that the escape of chyle in the urine and effusion of
lymph into the tissues were two quite different matters. To this, Fayrer replied
that while he did not stand up as the champion for the filarial theory of th e
disease, the association was of great interest and he considered, moreover, that
the observations of men working in the tropics should not be disparage d
because it was a very different thing researching in China and India compared
with similar undertakings in London 91.
Filariasis 621
been produced experimentally, and the record by Maxwell in 1901 177 that he
had found remains of adult filariae in only one of 23 abscesses, despit e
microfilaraemia being present in almost al l of the patients. Prout postulated that
bacteria produced the acute inflammatory lesions and that recurrent attack s
caused the obstruction of lymphatics. Despite formidable opposition fro m
Manson170 and others including Low and Manson-Bahr 143, this concept slowly
gained ground. Indeed, in 1915, Dutcher and Whitmarsh announced th e
"discovery" of a bacterium similar to Bacillus subtilis which they called
B. lymphangiticus and which they believed was "the cause of those disease s
grouped under the designation of 'filariasis'" 77.
Meanwhile, Wise and Minett in British Guiana (Guyana) had studied care-
fully 28 abscesses and had found evidence in favour of both helminthic an d
bacterial causation. Complete worms or pieces of adult filariae were found in
the advanced pus in 22 patients, and 21 abscesses grew streptococci in pur e
culture, four grew Staphylococcus aureus, and three were sterile 238. In contrast,
Anderson and his colleagues working in the same country a few years late r
found adult worms in only one of 48 abscesses, streptococci in 41 patients, and
staphylococci in 22 cases 1.
Consequently, the Royal Society and the London School of Tropica l
Medicine in 1926 launched an investigation into the bacterial complications of
filariasis in British Guiana. The report published a few years later concluded
that a "filarial attack" was really lymphangitis, the usual cause of which was a
beta haemolytic streptococcus. It was opined, however, that neithe r
lymphangitis nor elephantiasis occurred to any great extent in the absence of W.
bancrofti 98. The role of the worm was thus relegated to that of a foreign body
which acted as a focus for the opera tion of bacteria. In the 1930's, however, the
pendulum began to swing back in favour of the parasitic cause of the problem.
In 1931 McKinley reported the results of a study designed to answer th e
question: "Can we have acute filarial lymphangitis without bacteria l
infection?"148. He investigated 39 cases of acute filarial inflammation and found
that blood cultures and microbiological studies of aspirates from inflame d
tissue were uniformly negative whereas bacteria were always isolated from a
control group of non-filarial abscesses 148. FW O'Connor then re-emphasized the
correlation between the presence of insect vectors of W. bancrofti and these
complaints, the lack of correlation between chronic filariasis and bacteria l
infections, the failure of McKinley to aspirate streptococci in filaria l
lymphangitis, and his own pathological studies in which serial sections o f
involved tissues revealed large numbers of parasites but no evidence o f
bacteria. He concluded that adult worms and their larvae were entirel y
responsible for the acute inflammation and chronic obstructive changes see n
in filariasis. More importantly, he believed that living worms produced n o
serious pathology but that the tissue reactions were usually in response to death
of the worms and were probably allergic in nature 185. This belief in an
Filariasis 623
Somewhat more specific were the immunologic al tests that were developed,
beginning with skin testing using Dirofilaria immitis antigen, as described by
Taliaferro and Hoffman in 1930 225, and the independent development of th e
same test as well as an assay for c omplement fixing antibodies by Fairley in the
following year82. Much effort was made to improve the sensitivity an d
specificity of these assays by fractionating Dirofilaria antigens213,214 and by
using W. bancrofti 113 and B. malayi 101 antigens. More promising, since they
differentiate between past and present infection and may provide an index of
intensity of infection, have been recent attempts to measure filarial antigens in
tissue fluids or circulating in the peripheral blood 105,199.
Morphological demonstration of the worms, however, is the most definitive
means of proving a diagnosis. Experience of early, inflammatory filariasis i n
American troops during World War II indicated that the diagnosis could b e
made in many patients by biopsy of inflamed lymphatics 76,107,119,232. The
commonest practice over the years, however, has been to examine for th e
presence of microfilariae in one or more drops (20 µl) of blood smeared on a
glass slide. The development of concentration techniques has assisted greatly
in the demonstration of microfi lariae in the peripheral blood. One of the first of
these techniques used in filariasis was that of de Beaurepaire Aragão who i n
1919 described mixing 0.5 ml of blood with 5 m l of a solution containing acetic
acid (which haemolysed the erythr ocytes) then inspecting the centrifuged pellet
for parasites32. This technique had, in fact, been used five years earlier in both
loiasis and filariasis by Smith and Rivas as is described in chapter 24. Possibly
independently, Suganumu in Japan described essentially the same method i n
1921224. The same principle was employed by Haga in Indonesia 103; he used a
preparation of the locally available soap fruit ( Sapindus rarak, which contains
saponine) to haemolyse red blood cells. This was also the basis for the much
publicized "Knott's technique" which did not require (in his origina l
description) centrifugation: 1 ml of blood was added to 10 ml of 2% standard
aqueous formalin in a measuring flask and was allowed to stand for 12-2 4
hours - a compact pellet containing microfilariae formed under the action o f
gravity121. More recently, filtration of venous blood through variou s
microscopic filters has become popular in view of its simplicity an d
effectiveness 33,74.
Nevertheless, countless inve stigators have burnt the midnight oil and hundreds
of papers describing the distributio n and intensity of filarial infection in various
communities have appeared since Low's time. These have all given rise to the
same general conclusions, namely that human s are the only significant reservoir
of W. bancrofti but that subperiodic B. malayi is a zoonosis, the prevalence of
microfilaraemia in endemic areas increases with age or plateaus in adult life,
the prevalence of disease with chronic lymphatic obstruction increases wit h
age, and that vectors of filariae in clude species of Aedes, Anopheles, Culex and
Mansonia. There are a number of physiological forms within the W. bancrofti
complex, however, which differ in their capacity for development in variou s
mosquito vectors211. Furthermore, it became clear that the transmission o f
infection is remarkably inefficient. Hairston and de Meillon 104 first drew
attention to this in 1968 when they showed that bites by an average of 15,500
mosquitoes carrying infective larvae were necessary for the production of each
new case of microfilaraemia i n Rangoon, Burma. Furthermore, less than 1% of
mosquitoes carried infective larvae. Infection only occurred because th e
average person was bitten by around 100,000 mosquitoes per year.
The distribution of filariasis is not static. The infection was probabl y
brought to the Western Hemisphere by the transportation of infected slave s
from Africa 212 and was introduced into the sugar canefields of Queensland by
infected labourers from the south Pacific islands. With improving standards of
living, the worm has disappeared from some developed countries such as in the
southeastern USA212 and northeastern Australia147 . On the other hand, rapi d
urbanization and industrialization without concurrent provision of wast e
disposal systems has lead to an increased breeding of culicine moquitoe s
(especially Culex quinquefasciatus) which, when coupled with immigration of
infected persons from endemic areas, has resulted in the inception of, or a n
increase in, transmission of the infection 200.
Means of preventing the exit of microfilariae from the host became obviou s
when the uptake of microfilariae by mosquitoes was shown by Manson. These
ways were either the eradication of the mosquitoes or the prevention of inter-
action between the insect and the human. The first was frequently impossible
but there was hope for the latter with the us e of mosquito nets and the screening
of houses. It was not obvious, however, that the same measures would prevent
infection until it was discovered that infective larvae entered the host directly
from the biting mosquito rather than by being ingested in water. Fortunately,
these same measures were effective in the prevention of malaria and yello w
fever, and it was fear of the latter devastating infections that usually stimulated
the installation of antimosquito measures. Nevertheless, filariasis in its ow n
right has also been the subject of control efforts. As early as 1900, an attempt
628 A History of Human Helminthology
TROPICAL EOSINOPHILIA
In 1939, Meyers and Kouwenaar described a series of seven Javanese men who
had lymphadenopathy and a marked eosinophilia. When the lymph nodes were
biopsied, eosinophilic granulomas surrounding microfilariae were found .
Nevertheless, observation for as long as three years failed to reveal an y
microfilariae in the peripheral blood, n or were any adult filariae seen in excised
glands. The patients had no evidence of lymphatic obstruction but two ha d
asthma and two had haemorrhag ic nephritis so the authors suggested that these
syndromes were possibly allergic reactions to filariae 178. In the paper
immediately following this report, Bonne, in the same journal, describe d
finding extraordinary eosinophilic granulomas with giant cells around micro-
filariae in the spleen of a Javanese man killed in a motor vehicle accident .
Bonne thought that this condition was similar to that described by Meyers and
Kouwenaar and suggested that the finding represented either an undescribe d
phase in the life cycle of one of the common filarial species or a manifestation
of an unusual filarial parasite 34. In 1942, Dhayagude and Amin in Bomba y
reported a further 11 cases of microfilarial granuloma 75.
Meanwhile, in 1940, Frimodt-Möller and Barton had described a series of
175 patients with what they termed a "pseudo-tuberculous condition" charact-
erized by dyspnoea, eosinophilia a nd extensive, persistent mottling of the lungs
on chest X-ray92. In 1943, Weingarten reported a condition which he had seen
in 81 cases, and which he believed to be a new disease entity, that he calle d
tropical eosinophilia. The illness was characterized by fever, paroxysma l
cough, dyspnoea, wheezing, splenomegaly and eosinophilia while chest X-ray
examination of the lungs disclosed a distinctive, disseminated mottling. I n
contrast to Löffler's syndrome, the illness persisted for weeks or months an d
responded to treatment with arsenicals 235. Weingarten could find no cause for
the condition but noted that it was common in coastal regions. The relationship
with the conditions described by Meyers and Kouwenaar and by Bonne was not
immediately apparent and there was considerable speculation to its cause ,
although a parasitic aetiology seeme d likely. In 1944, Carter and his colleagues
postulated that the cause was the cheese mite 51. In 1955, Winter suggested that
tropical eosinophilia may be regarded as an accentuated state of sensitivity in
persons infected with filariae 237.
In 1957, Gault and Webb reported that liver biopsies in four children with
tropical eosinophilia (including the typical pulmonary symptoms) showed a
striking eosinophilic infiltration in the portal triads, then found similar changes
together with granulomatous foci around nematode larvae in a surgical biopsy
from a further patient with hepatomegaly 94. In the following year, Danaraj and
his colleagues in Singapore noted that W. bancrofti microfilariae occurred in
Chinese, Indians and Malays, but that eosinophilic lung was virtually confined
to Indians. Furthermore, these latter patients had high titres of antibodies to D.
immitis antigen and responded well to tr eatment with diethylcarbamazine. They
630 A History of Human Helminthology
postulated, therefore, that the illne ss was due to infection with a filarial parasite
of animal origin which could n ot complete its development in humans 69,70. This
view seemed to be supported when Buckley reported that the condition wa s
evoked in a human volunteer infected with Brugia malayi then B. pahangi 44.
In 1960, Webb and his colleagues demonstrated the presence of microfilarial
granulomas in lung biopsies of patients wi th tropical pulmonary eosinophilia 233.
In 1979, Ottesen and his colleagues reported that patients with this condition
had evidence of immediate hypersensitity reactions to filarial antigens 189.
Although it remains unproven, the consensus of opinion now is that W.
bancrofti and B. malayi are the most probable causes of the affliction, th e
differences from the usual manifestations of filariasis resulting from a failure
of microfilariae to evade the host's immune responses so that the parasites are
screened out in the lungs, spleen and liver.
REFERENCES
47. BUCKLEY JJ, EDESON JF. On the adult morphology ofWuchereria sp. (malayi?) from a
monkey (Macaca irus) and from cats in Malaya, and on Wuchereria pahangi n. sp. from a
dog and a cat. Journal of Helminthology 30: 1-20, 1956
48. BURNELL AC. The voyage of John Hughen van Linschoten to the East Indies, Hakluyt
Society, London, volume 1, pp 307, 1885
49. CARME B, LAIGRET J. Longevity of Wuchereria bancrofti var. pacifica in mosquito
infection acquired from a patient with low level parasitemia. AmericanJournal of Tropical
Medicine and Hygiene 28: 53-55, 1979
50. CARNOCHAN. Cited in 151
51. CARTER HF, WEDD G, D'ABRERA V. The occurrence of mites (Acarina) in human
sputum and their possible significance. Indian Medical Gazette 79: 163-168, 1944
52. CHOPRA RN, RAO SS. Chemotherapy of filarial infection. Indian Journal of Medical
Research 27: 549-592, 1939
53. CILENTO R. Tropical diseases in Australia, second edition, W R Smith and Paterson,
Brisbane, pp 461, 1942
54. COBBOLD TS. On the development of Bilharzia haematobia; together with remarks on the
ova of another urinary parasite (the so-called Trichina cystica of Dr. Salisbury) occurring in
a case of haematuria from Natal. British Medical Journal ii: 89-92, 1872
55. COBBOLD TS. Cited in 191
56. COBBOLD TS. Verification of recent haematozoal discoveries in Australia and Egypt. British
Medical Journal ii: 780-781, 1876
57. COBBOLD TS. Discovery of the adult representative of microscopic filariae. Lancet ii: 70-71,
1877
58. COBBOLD TS. On Filaria Bancrofti. Lancet ii: 495-496, 1877
59. COBBOLD TS. Discovery of the intermediary host of Filaria sanguinis hominis (F.
Bancrofti). Lancet i: 69, 1878
60. COBBOLD TS. The life-history of Filaria bancrofti, as explained by the discoveries of
Wucherer, Lewis, Bancroft, Manson, Sonsino, myself and others. Journal of the Linnean
Society (Zoology) 14: 356-370, 1878
61. COBBOLD TS. Parasites: a treatise on the entozoa of man and animals including some
account of the ectozoa, J&A Churchill, London, pp 508, 1879
62. COBBOLD TS. Introduction to observations on filariae by Drs. Patrick Manson, John R.
Somerville, Joseph Bancroft, J.F. da Silva Lima, J.L. Paterson, Pedro S. de Magalhaes and J.
Mortimer-Granville, communicated, with an introduction by the President. Journal of the
Quekett Microscopical Club 6: 58-60, 1880
63. CORRE A. Note sur l'helminthe rencontré dans les urines hématochyleuses. Revue des
Sciences Naturelles, 1872
64. CORTESÃO A. The Suma Oriental of Tomé Pires, Hakluyt Society, London, pp 578, 1944
65. CREVAUX J. De l'hématurie chyleuse ou graisseuse des pays chauds, Thèse de Paris, pp 64,
1872
66. CROSS JH, PARTONO F, HSU MK, ASH LR, OEMIJATI S. Experimental transmission of
Wuchereria bancrofti to monkeys. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 28:
56-66, 1979
67. CUNNINGHAM DD. The haematozoon; notes on its discovery and its relation to the canine
filaria. Lancet i: 835-837, 1873
68. CURTIS CF, FEACHEM RG. Sanitation and Culex pipiens mosquitoes: a brief review.
Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 84: 17-25, 1981
69. DANARAJ T. The treatment of eosinophilic lung (tropical eosinophilia) with
diethylcarbamazine. Quarterly Journal of Medicine 27: 243-263, 1958
70. DANARAJ TJ, da SILVA LS, SCHACHER JF. The serological diagnosis of eosinophilic
lung (tropical eosinophilia) and its etiological implications. American Journal of Tropical
Medicine and Hygiene 8: 151-159, 1959
71. DANIELS CW. Discovery of the parental form of a British Guiana blood worm. British
Medical Journal i: 1011-1012, 1898
72. DAVID HL, EDESON JF. Filariasis in Portuguese Timor, with observations on a new
microfilaria found in man. Annals of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology 59: 193-204, 1965
Filariasis 633
73. DEMARQUAY JN. Note sur une tumeur des bourses contenant un liquide laiteux
(galactocèle de Vidal) et renferment des petits êtres vermiformes que l'on peut considérer
comme des helminthes hematoides à l'état d'embryon. Gazette Médicale de Paris 18: 665-667,
1863. Translated in 117
74. DENNIS DT, KEAN BH. Isolation of microfilariae: report of a new method. Journal of
Parasitology 57: 1146-1147, 1971
75. DHAYAGUDE RG, AMIN BR. Microfilarial granuloma of the spleen. American Journal of
Pathology 18: 351-361, 1942
76. DICKSON JG, HUNTINGDON RW, EICHOLD S. Filariasis in Defense Force, Samoan
Group. Preliminary report. United States Naval Medical Bulletin 41: 1240-1251, 1943
77. DUTCHER BH, WHITMARSH PL. The results of blood cultures from thirty six individuals
with their possible bearing on the etiology of the so-called filarial diseases; and description of
a new parasitic bacillus, believed to be the causative agent of filariasis. American Journal of
Tropical Diseases and Preventive Medicine 3: 69-74, 1915
78. EARLE KV. The use of sulphonamide compounds in filarial complications. Medical Journal
of Australia ii: 200-202, 1941
79. EDESON JF, WHARTON RH. The experimental transmission ofWuchereria malayi from
man to various animals in Malaya. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine
and Hygiene 52: 25-38, 1958
80. EDESON JF, WILSON T, WHARTON RH, LAING AB. Experimental transmission of
Brugia malayi and B. pahangi to man. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical
Medicine and Hygiene 54: 229-234, 1960
81. EDWARDS FW. The carriers of Filaria bancrofti. Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene
25: 168-170, 1922
82. FAIRLEY NH. Serological and intradermal tests in filariasis. A preliminary report.
Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 24: 635-648, 1931
83. FAYRER J. Naevoid elephantiasis. Indian Annals of Medical Science 19: 76-80, 1865
84. FAYRER J. Elephantiasis arabum. Transactions of the Pathological Society of London 30:
488-503, 1879. Abstracted in Lancet ii: 267-268, 1879
85. FENG LC. Some experiments with mosquitoes and Microfilaria malayi in Huchow
(Chekiang) China. Transactions of the Ninth Congress of the Far Eastern Association of
Tropical Medicine, Nanking 1: 491-494, 1934. Abstracted in Tropical Diseases Bulletin 32:
647, 1935
86. FINLAY CJ. Anales de la Reale Academia de Ciencias Médicas Físicas y Naturales de al
Habana 18: 147-169, 1881
87. FISHER G. Die Behandlung der Elephantiasis arabum mittelst Ligatur oder Compression der
Hauptarterie. Archiv für pathologische Anatomie, Physiologie und für klinische Medicin
(Virchow) 46: 328-350, 1869
88. FITCH R. Cited in 139
89. FLINT A. A case of Filaria sanguinis hominis, with chyluria, successfully treated with
methylene blue. New York Medical Journal 61: 737-739, 1895
90. FOX WT. Clinical lecture on a case of elephantiasis arabum. Medical Times and Gazette ii:
427-429, 1878
91. FOX RT. Discussion of 84
92. FRIMODT-MÖLLER C, BARTON RM. A pseudotuberculous condition associated with
eosinophilia. Indian Medical Gazette 75: 607-613, 1940
93. FÜLLEBORN F. Über Mikrofilarien des Menschen im deutschen Südsee-Gebiet und deren
"Turnus" nebst Bemerkungen über die klinischen Manifestationen der dortigen Filariasis.
Archiv für Schiffs- und Tropen-Hygiene 16: 533-547, 1912
94. GAULT EW, WEBB JK. Tropical eosinophilia. Hepatic lesions related to presence of
nematode larvae. Lancet ii: 471-472, 1957
95. GODFREY F. On a case of elephantiasis scroti. Lancet i: 352-353, 1851
96. GOODMAN G. Report of a case of elephantiasis scroti with successful operation. Lancet i:
889-890, 1876.
97. GORTER AJ. De operatieve behandeling van elephantiasis der onderste extremiteiten.
Geneeskundig Tijdschrift voor Nederlandsch-Indië 77: 1236-1242, 1937
634 A History of Human Helminthology
98. GRACE AW, GRACE FB. Researches in British Guiana 1926-1928 on the bacterial
complications of filariasis and endemic nephritis, with a chapter on epidemic abscess and
cellulitis in St. Kitts, British West Indies. Memoir Series of the London School of Hygiene
and Tropical Medicine, No. 3, pp 75, 1931
99. GRASSI B, NOÈ G. The propogation of the filariae of the blood exclusively by means of the
puncture of peculiar mosquitoes. British Medical Journal ii: 1306-1307, 1900
100. GROVE DI. Selective primary health care: strategies for the control of disease in the
developing world. VII. Filariasis. Reviews of Infectious Diseases 5: 933-944, 1983
101. GROVE DI, CABRERA BD, VALEZA FS, GUINTO RS, ASH LR, WARREN KS.
Sensitivity and specificity of skin reactivity to Brugia malayi and Dirofilaria immitis
antigens in bancroftian and malayan filariasis in the Philippines. American Journal of
Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 26: 220-229, 1977
102. GULLAND GL. The condition of the blood in filariasis. British Medical Journal i: 831-832,
1902
103. HAGA J. Filariasis-onderzoek over dag. Geneeskundig Tijdschrift voor Nederlandsch-Indië
63: 864-884, 1923
104. HAIRSTON NG, de MEILLON B. On the inefficiency of transmission of Wuchereria
bancrofti from mosquito to the human host. Bulletin of the World Health Organization 38:
935-941, 1968
105. HAMILTON RG, HUSSAIN R, OTTESEN EA. Immunoradiometric assay for detection of
filarial antigens in human serum. Journal of Immunology 133: 2237-2242, 1984
106. HANDLEY WS. A prospective cure for elephantiasis. Lancet i: 31-33, 1909
107. HARTZ PH. Contribution to the histopathology of filariasis. American Journal of Clinical
Pathology 14: 34-43, 1944
108. HAWKING F. The 24-hour periodicity of microfilariae: biological mechanisms responsible
for its production and control. Proceedings of the Royal Society, Series B 169: 59-76, 1967
109. HAWKING F, LAURIE W. Action of hetrazan on filariasis and onchocerciasis. Lancet ii:
146-147, 1949
110. HAWKING F, SEWELL P, THURSTON JP. Mode ofaction of hetrazan in filariasis. Lancet
ii: 730-731, 1948
111. HEWITT RI, KUSHNER S, STEWART HW, WHITE E, WALLACE WS, SUBBAROW
Y. Experimental chemotherapy of filariasis. Journal of Laboratory and Clinical Medicine 32:
1293-1329, 1947
112. HOEPPLI R. Parasitic diseases in Africa and the Western Hemisphere. Acta Tropical
Supplementum 10, pp 240, 1969
113. HUNTER GW. Skin testing for filariasis with homologous antigen. Proceedings of the Sixth
International Congress of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology 2: 479-483, 1948
114. JACHOWSKI LA, OTTO GF, WHARTON JD. Filariasis in American Samoa. I. Loss of
microfilaria in the absence of continued reinfection. Proceedings of the Helminthological
Society of Washington 18: 25-28, 1951
115. JAFFE HL. Evaluation of roentgen therapy in filariasis. American Journal of Roentgenology
and Radium Therapy 53: 483-490, 1945
116. JAMES SP. On the metamorphosis of theFilaria sanguinis hominis in mosquitos. Especially
with reference to its metamorphosis inAnopheles rossi and other mosquitos of the Anopheles
genus. British Medical Journal ii: 533-536, 1900
117. KEAN BH, MOTT KE, RUSSELL AJ. Tropical medicine and parasitology. Classic
investigations, Cornell University Press, pp 677, 1978
118. KENNARD CS. Filaria and mosquitoes. British Medical Journal ii: 754, 1900
119. KING BG. Early filariasis diagnosis and clinical findings: a report of cases in American
troops. American Journal of Tropical Medicine 24: 285-298, 1944
120. KNOTT J. The periodicity of the microfilaria of Wuchereria bancrofti. Preliminary report
of some injection experiments. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and
Hygiene 29: 59-64, 1935
121. KNOTT J. The treatment of filarial elephantiasis of the leg by bandaging. Transactions of
the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 32: 243-252, 1938
122. KONDOLÉON E. Die operative Behandlung der elephantiasischen Ödeme. Zentralblatt für
Filariasis 635
151. MAITLAND J. Elephantiasis and allied disorders, Government Press, Madras, 1891
152. MAITLAND J. A case of "filarial disease" of the lymphatics in which a number of adult
filariae were removed from the arm. British Medical Journal i: 844-846, 1894
153. MAITLAND J. The operative treatment of lymphangiectasis of filarial origin. British
Medical Journal i: 188-189, 1902
154. MANSON P. Description of operation for elephantiasis of the scrotum. Customs Gazette,
Medical Reports, Shanghai, 13: 26-33, 1872
155. MANSON P. Filaria sanguinis hominis. China Imperial Maritime Customs. Medical
Reports for the half year ended 31st March 1877, 13th issue, pp 30-38, 1877
156. MANSON P. Further observations of Filaria sanguinis hominis. China Imperial Maritime
Customs. Medical Reports for the half year ended 30th September 1877, 14th issue, pp 1-26,
1878
157. MANSON P. On the development of Filaria sanguinis hominis and on the mosquito
considered as a nurse. Journal of the Linnean Society (Zoology) 14: 304-311, 1878
158. MANSON P. On Chinese haematozoa. Medical Times and Gazette i: 220-223, 249-250,
304-305, 1878
159. MANSON P. Additional notes on Filaria sanguinis hominis and filaria disease. China
Imperial Maritime Customs. Medical Reports for the half year ended 30th September 1879,
18th issue, pp 31-51, 1880. Abstracted in British Medical Journal ii: 891, 1880
160. MANSON P. Further observations on microfilariae, with descriptions of new species,
communicated (with a prefatory note) by the President. Journal of The Quekett
Microscopical Club 6: 130-140, 1880
161. MANSON P. Additional notes on Filaria sanguinis hominis and filaria disease. Discovery
of adult F. bancrofti. China Imperial Maritime Customs. Medical Reports for the half year
ended 30th September 1880, 20th issue, pp 13-15, 1881. Reprinted as: Lymph scrotum
showing filaria in situ. Transactions of the Pathological Society of London 32: 285-302,
1881
162. MANSON P. Notes on filaria disease. China Imperial Maritime Customs. Medical Reports
for the half year ended 31st March 1882, 23rd issue, pp 1-16, 1882. Abstracted in British
Medical Journal i: 675-676, 1883
163. MANSON P. The Filaria sanguinis hominis and certain new forms of parasitic diseases in
India, China and certain warm countries, London, pp 186, 1883
164. MANSON P. The metamorphosis of Filaria sanguinis hominis in the mosquito.
Transactions of the Linnean Society of London, series 2, 2: 367-388, 1884
165. MANSON P. The geographical distribution, pathological relations and life history of Filaria
sanguinis hominis diurna and Filaria sanguinis hominis perstans in connexion with
preventive medicine. Transactions of the Seventh International Congress of Hygiene and
Demography, London, August 10-17, 1891 i: 79-97, 1892. Abstracted in Medical Press and
Circular 103, new series, 52: 202-205, 1891 and Semaine Médecine 11: 342, 1891
166. MANSON P. On filarial periodicity. British Medical Journal ii: 644-646, 1899
167. MANSON P. Cited in 60
168. MANSON P. Cited in 174
169. MANSON P. Cited in 175
170. MANSON P. Discussion of 196
171. MANSON-BAHR P. The mechanism of filarial periodicity. Lancet ii: 45-47, 1929
172. MANSON-BAHR P. The nomenclature of the filaria of the Pacific region producing
non-periodic embryos (Wuchereria pacifica). Tropical Diseases Bulletin 38: 361-367, 1941
173. MANSON-BAHR P. The story of Filaria Bancrofti. A critical review. Journal of Tropical
Medicine and Hygiene 62: 53-61, 85-94, 106-117, 138-145, 160-173, 1959
174. MANSON-BAHR P. Patrick Manson as a parasitologist. A critical review. International
Review of Tropical Medicine, DR Linicombe (Editor), Academic Press, New York, pp
77-129, 1961
175. MANSON-BAHR PH, ALCOCKA. The life and works of Sir Patrick Manson, Cassell and
Co., London, pp 273, 1927
176. MARCH HN, LAIGRET J, KESSEL JF, BAMBRIDGE B. Reduction in the prevalence of
clinical filariasis in Tahiti following adoption of a control program. American Journal of
Filariasis 637
202. ROGERS L. Preliminary report on the intravenous injection of antimony in filariasis. Lancet
ii: 604-608, 1919
203. ROSENBLATT P, BEAVER PC, ORIHEL TC. A filarial infection apparently acquired in
New York City. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 11: 641-645, 1962
204 ROSS R. Some recent chicanery in science. Lancet ii: 775, 1902
205. ROSS R. Cited in 223
206. ROWLAND. Cited in 21
207. SALISBURY JH. On the parasitic forms developed in parent epithelial cells of the urinary
and genital organs, and in their secretions. American Journal of Medical Science 110:
371-380, 1868
208. SAMBON LW. Remarks on the life-history of Filaria bancrofti and Filaria immitis. Lancet
ii: 422-426, 1902
209. SANTIAGO-STEVENSON D, OLIVER-GONZALEZ J, HEWITT RI. Treatment of
filariasis bancrofti with 1-diethylcarbamyl-4-methylpiperazine hydrochloride ("Hetrazan").
Journal of the American Medical Association 135: 708-712, 1947
210. dos SANTOS F. Filaria bancroft, verificação no Brazil da descoberto de Bancroft, no
Australia. Progresso Medico, Rio de Janeiro 2: 95-100, 1877
211. SASA M. Human filariasis: a global survey of epidemiology and control, University Park
Press, Baltimore, pp 819, 1976
212. SAVITT TL. Filariasis in the United States. Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied
Sciences 32: 142-150, 1977
213. SAWADA T, SATO K. Studies on skin test antigen FST for immunodiagnosis of filariasis.
III. Separation and characterization of FST3-1 by isoelectric focusing technique. Japanese
Journal of Experimental Medicine 39: 533-539, 1969
214. SAWADA T, SATO S, MATSUYAMA S, MIYAGI H,SHINZATO J. Intradermal skin test
with antigen FST (FSCD1) on individuals inendemic area. Japanese Journal of Experimental
Medicine 38: 405-414, 1968
215. SCHACHER JF, SAHYOUN PF. A chronological study of the histopathology of filarial
disease in cats and dogs caused by Brugia pahangi (Buckley and Edeson, 1956).
Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 61: 234-243, 1967
216. SEURAT LG. Orthogénèse des filaires. Bulletin de la Société d'Histoire Naturelle de
l'Afrique du Nord 12: 28-37, 1921
217. SIBTHORPE. On the adult male Filaria sanguinis hominis. British Medical Journal i:
1334-1335, 1889
218. da SILVA ARAUJO AJ. Caso de chyluria, elephancia do escroto, escroto lymphatico,
craw-craw e erysipela em um mesmo individuo, descobrimento da Wuchereria Filaria na
lympha do escroto. Tratamento pela electricidade com excellentes resultados. Gazeta Medica
da Bahia, second series, 2: 492-504, 1877
219. da SILVA ARAUJO AJ. Caso de chyluria, elephancia do escroto, escroto lymphatico,
craw-craw e erysipela em um mesmo individuo, descobrimento da Filaria wuchereri na
lympha do escroto. Tratamento pela electricidade com excellentes resultados. Gazeta
Medica da Bahia, second series, 4: 455-465, 1879
220. da SILVA LIMA JF. The late Dr. Wucherer and the filaria bancrofti. Lancet i: 440-441,
1878
221. SONSINO P. Ricerche intorno alla bilharzia haematobia in relazione colla Ematuria
endemica dell'Egitto, e nota intorno ad un nematoideo trovato nel sangue umano. Rendiconti
dell'Accademia delle Scienze Fisiche e Matematiche, Napoli, 1874. Partly translated in 60
222. SONSINO P. La Filaria sanguinis hominis osservato in Egitto, e gli esperimenti intorno al
suo passagio nelle zanzare e in altri insetti ematofagi. Giornale della Reale Accademia di
Medicina de Torino, third series, 32: 365-380, 1884
223. SONSINO P. The life history of Filaria bancrofti in the body of the mosquito. British
Medical Journal ii: 328-329, 1900
224. SUGANUMU S. (On the count of microfilaria.) Chugai Iji Shimpo No. 994, 1921. In
Japanese. Abstracted in Japan Medical World 1 (8): 24, 1921
225. TALIAFERRO WH, HOFFMAN WA. Skin reactions to Dirofilaria immitis in persons
infected with Wuchereria bancrofti. Journal of Preventive Medicine 4: 261-280, 1930
Filariasis 639
226. TANON L, GIRAUD G. Traitement des filarioses sanguines par les injections sous-cutanées
d'hectine. Revue de Médecine et Hygiene Tropicale 12: 82-86, 1920
227. THETFORD ND, OTTO GF, BROWN HW, MAREN TH. The use of phenyl arsenoxide
in the treatment of Wuchereria bancrofti infection. American Journal of Tropical Medicine
28: 577-583, 1948
228. THORPE VG. Filaria sanguinis hominis in the South Sea Islands, with photomicrographs
from Tonga and the Friendly Islands. British Medical Journal ii: 922-924, 1896
229. TRENT SC. Re-evaluation of World War II veterans with filariasis acquired in the Pacific.
American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 12: 877-887, 1963
230. TURNER LH, EDESON JF. Studies on filariasis in Malaya; the periodicity of the
microfilariae of Wuchereria malayi. Annals of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology 51:
271-277, 1957
231. WARDEN AA. Note on the treatment by radium of lymphatic obstruction (cervical,
submaxillary and axillary) in a patient suffering from Filaria nocturna. Lancet ii: 224-225,
1909
232. WARTMAN WB. Lesions of the lymphatic system in early filariasis. American Journal of
Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 24: 299-313, 1944
233. WEBB JK, JOB CK, GAULT EW. Tropical eosinophilia; demonstration of microfilariae in
lung, liver and lymph nodes. Lancet i: 835-842, 1960
234. WEBBER RH. Eradication of Wuchereria bancrofti infection through vector control.
Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 73: 722-724, 1979
235. WEINGARTEN RJ. Tropical eosinophilia. Lancet i: 103-105, 1943
236. WILSON T, EDESON JF, WHARTON RH, REID JA, TURNER LH, LAINGAB. The
occurrence of two forms of Wuchereria malayi in man. Transactions of the Royal Society
of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 52: 480-481, 1958
237. WINTER H. "Tropische Eosinophilie" als symptomarme Filariasis. Zeitschrift für
Tropenmedizin und Parasitologie 6: 99-105, 1955
238. WISE KS, MINETT EP. Report of tropical diseases research in the Government
Bacteriological Laboratory, British Guiana, for the six months October 1911 to March 1912.
Report of the Advisory Committee of the Tropical Diseases Research Fund for the Year
1912. H.M. Stationery Office, London, pp 108-114, 1913. Abstracted in Tropical Diseases
Bulletin 2: 93-94, 1913
239. WUCHERER OE. Noticia preliminar sobre vermes de una especie ainda não descripta,
encontrados na urina de doentes de hematuria intertropical no Brazil. Gazeta Medica da
Bahia 3: 97-99, 1868. Translated in 117
640 A History of Human Helminthology
SYNOPSIS
Since the adult Loa loa is several centimetres in length and moves from time
to time through the subconjunctival tissues of the eye, this worm must hav e
been recognized by people living in endemic areas for many centuries past. The
name of the first European to see and describe this worm, however, has been
a matter of some dispute. When the Frenchman, Guyon, described a case i n
1864, he reviewed the literature and believed that the first recorded evidence
of this parasite was a certain copper engr aving which he interpreted as showing
the extraction of Loa loa from the eye48. This engraving, which had been drawn
by the engraver and publisher, JT de Bry, appeared in 1598 in the secon d
volume of a two volume work called Collectiones peregrinationum in Indiam
orientalem et occidentalem (known as India Orientalis for short) 14. The text
was concerned in part with the travels to Asia of the Dutchman, Huighen van
Linschoten, and included, amongst other things, his description o f
dracunculiasis on Hormuz island in the Persian Gulf (see chapter 26), an d
recounted how the king blinded his relatives to prevent assassination an d
rebellion. The first volume, which had appeared in 1597 in German and was
641
642 A History of Human Helminthology
cornea, beneath the conjunctiva, causing very little if any, irritation....neither of the
dracunculi when extracted were found to exceed two inches in length. 62
Worms were encountered by many surgeons subsequently, but it was not until
1895 that the British ophthalmologist, Argyll-Robertson, in collaboration with
Manson, provided the first detailed descriptions of the male and femal e
parasites5. Further detailed descriptions were then provided by Looss 63 and by
Huffman and Wherry 51.
Many of the early French writers referred to the worm as a "dragonneau "
(i.e. dracunculus or guinea worm), but it soon became clear this parasite was
a different creature from Dracunculus medinensis . In 1845, Dujardin placed
the worm in the genus Filaria of Müller78 and named it Filaria oculi humani 26,
then Dubini called it Filaria lacrymalis 25, Gervais and van Beneden designated
it Filaria oculi 40, and Guyon labelled it Filaria subconjunctivalis48 . The
French naval surgeon, Guyot, who had seen several cases while cruising off the
coast of Angola in 1778 mentioned, in his description of the parasite man y
years later, that the local native name for the parasite was "loa" meanin g
"worm"49. This term was adopted by Cobbold who combined it wit h
Dracunculus to name the worm Dracunculus loa 19. Nevertheless, many other
authors retained it in the genus Filaria and following the lead of Aitken i n
18661, the worm was known as Filaria loa for many years. In 1905, Stiles and
Hassall placed the parasite in the subgenus Loa of the genus Filaria 89, then
Castellani and Chambers in 1913 erected the genus Loa to house the worm
which has since that time been known as Loa loa 16.
mental disorder. On examination of this patient's blood, only the smaller forms
were found, thus proving that one type of microfilaria was not a transitiona l
form of the other. Manson then examined the blood of two blacks from Ol d
Calabar who were patients of Dr Grattan Guiness. In one, he found the small
forms, but in the other he saw bot h of the types that he had seen in Mandombi's
blood. As with that patient, microfilariae were circulating in the blood during
the day. Manson scrutinized parasites from this patient very carefully, looking
for differences from those of microfilaria bancrofti (this was before the
introduction of Romanowsky stains) but found only minor variations, bot h
forms being of the same size and provided with a sheath. However, Manso n
now thought that the large microfilariae from the African subjects wer e
different from those of microfilaria bancrofti in that the sheath was mor e
delicate, the oral movements were more marked, and that there was an absence
of granular material around the middle of the body. He examined the periodicity
of these microfilariae in detail. In both patients, the smaller worm could b e
found throughout the 24 hours, but in the patient with the large microfilariae,
these parasites reached a peak in the middle o f the day and were absent at night.
Manson wrote:
the law of periodicity for the appearance of the major embryo is just the reverse of
that which has hitherto been found to apply to the filaria sanguinis hominis of
Lewis.67
As a result of all these observations, he concluded that "man is liable to be the
host of at least two, if not three, distinct species of filarial haematozoa" 67.
Manson may not have been quite so definite in his remarks, however, if these
observations had been made after the discovery of the diurnal periodicity of W.
bancrofti in the Pacific by Thorpe in 1896. In order to differentiate these new
microfilariae from the Filaria sanguinis hominis of Lewis, Manson called them
Filaria sanguinis hominis major (i.e. bigger) and Filaria sanguinis hominis
minor (i.e. smaller)67. Later that year at the Seventh International Congress on
Hygiene and Demography held in London he renamed these parasites on th e
basis of their periodicity. Filaria sanguinis hominis became Filaria sanguinis
hominis nocturna, Filaria sanguinis hominis major became Filaria sanguinis
hominis diurna, and Filaria sanguinis hominis minor became Filaria
sanguinis hominis perstans to reflect night-time periodicity, daytim e
periodicity, and persistence of microfilaria throughout the 24 hours ,
respectively 68. These names subsequently became shortened to Filaria
nocturna, F. diurna and F. perstans.
Although it was apparent that there was at least one and probably two new
species of microfilariae, the nature of the parent worms was not immediately
clear. With the perspicacity of a true savant, Manson suggested that Loa loa
was a likely candidate, although he made one important error initially. Afte r
recalling that the subcutaneous and subconjunct ival migrations of this worm did
not seem propitious for transfer of t he parasite to a new host and noting that the
embryos in the circulation might have a much greater opportunity of migrating
Loiasis 645
recover any worms from either the peripheral or lung blood 38. Gönnert in
Hamburg took this idea and collected 160 ml of blood from a patient from the
Cameroon with a heavy Loa microfilaraemia and injected it intravenously into
his own bloodstream almost immediately. He calculated that he transferre d
1,640,000 microfilaria loa and 112,000 microfilaria perstans. He suffered from
an unanticipated transfusion reaction but examined his blood at intervals and
found that a definite diurnal periodicity persisted over the next few days .
Clearly, the periodicity was dependent upon the microfilariae themselves, o r
upon an interaction between them and the host rather than upon the adul t
worm41.
The manner of transmission of Loa loa was a complete mystery to the earl y
observers who saw the adult worm. When Manson first described the micro-
filariae that eventually turned out to be those of Loa loa, he predicted that the
vector would be a blood-sucking insect of limited distribution in Africa an d
with day-biting habits. He wrote: "Some naturalists may be able, even at this
early stage of the investigation, to indicate these animals" 67.
The failure to find microfilariae in the blood of many such patients ,
however, misled other investigators into thinking that some other mode o f
transmission must be operative. Thus, Argyll-Robertson postulated tha t
embryos may be ingested in contaminated water, although he cautioned that:
the chief difficulty consists in determining how these embryo filariae escape from
the bodies of those affected with the disease, and get deposited in the impure water
and thus propagate the disease....Possibly the embryo parasites may be discharged
along with some of the excreta from the body, and from faulty sanitary
arrangements find their way into drinking water. 5
Argyll-Robertson must have later changed his mind, possibly after conversation
with Manson, however, for he recorded in a subsequent report that his patient,
who had returned to Old Calabar, had sent specimens of mosquitoes an d
sandflies which he and Manson had examined but had failed to detect an y
developing filarial larvae 6. Subsequently, Manson 72 then Sambon 84 suggested
that the intermediate host of Loa loa should be looked for amongst the larg e
blood-sucking flies of the family Tabanidae which bite by day and were known
popularly as mangrove flies or horse flies. Fülleborn reported in 1912 that he
had tried to infect mosquitoes with Loa loa but to no avail 38. In the latter part
of that year, Robert Leiper, funded by a bequest to the London School o f
Tropical Medicine by the late Lord Wandsworth, went to West Africa an d
undertook a series of studies designed to identify the vector of Loa loa. He fed
the bedbug, Cimex rotundatus, the flea, Pulex irritans, many species of
mosquitoes, and various other flies including Stomoxys calcitrans, S. migrans,
648 A History of Human Helminthology
whorls in the musculature, particularly of the abdomen. Ten to twelve days after
infection, larvae migrated towards the head, accumulated at the root of th e
proboscis and the labium and exited via the labella. Finally, evidence wa s
procured which indicated that flies could remain infective for five to si x
days22,23. Soon afterwards, however, they had to modify these comments since
histological sections of infected flies prepared by Dr AC Stevenson had made
it clear that most of the larvae were not in muscles but in fatty tissue, th e
so-called "fat body". Connal and his wife concluded that the forms found b y
Kleine in abdominal fatty tissue were almost certainly, as he presumed, stages
in the development of Loa loa 24.
This question was re-investigated many years later by Lavoipierre and by
Lebied. The former author considered that the young larvae invaded the cells
of the fat body then, after bursting o ut of them, migrated to the thorax, neck and
head58, while the latter believed that fatty cells in the haemocoele surrounded
the larvae and fused to form a syncitium 59.
Gordon and Crewe studied the mechanism of feeding of C. silacea and
C. dimidiata and concluded that they fed from a pool of blood formed in th e
deeper layers of the skin as a result of several thrusts of the fascicle, durin g
which action the anticoagulant in the insect's saliva prevented clotting. The y
showed that the infective larvae escaped from the proboscis during the act of
feeding44 then Lavoipierre indicated later that the infective larvae escape d
through a rupture in the delicate labio-hypo-pharyngeal membrane 58. Gordon
and Crewe also reported that the infective larvae could not penetrate the intact
skin, and presumably entered through the wound made by the biting fly.
Although Loa loa has never been transferred to humans experimentally ,
Orihel and Moore in 1975 infected two patas monkeys ( Erythrocebus patas)
and a baboon (Papio anubis). They used infective larvae obtained fro m
C. silacea that had fed on a patient in the British Cameroons and found a
prepatent period of 146 days in the baboon and 135 and 148 days in th e
monkeys. Microfilaraemia persisted for more than 40 weeks in the monkeys but
began to decline after three months in the baboon 80.
pain, occasionally causing the eye to become bloodshot, and the eyelids to swell and
blacken slightly.5
Furthermore, the patient noticed that she was troubled much more when sh e
was febrile (from malaria) or remained indoors in a warm room or sat near a
fire, and that the worm seemed to disappear to the deeper parts when her face
was exposed to the cold. Finally, Argyll -Robertson was able to observe a worm
in the eye after the application of a warm cloth to her orbit:
I observed the worm moving in a tortuous, wriggling manner under the conjunctiva,
the surface of which became slightly elevated as it moved along. It passed with a
pretty quick movement over the surface of the sclerotic at the distance of about
5mm from the outer margin of the cornea. There was increased lachrymation and
slightly increased injection of the conjunctiva.5
Argyll-Robertson also drew attention to the other characteristic feature of
loiasis which came to be known as "fugitive swellings" or "Calabar swellings".
He remarked that his patient complained of:
ill-defined swellings under the skin of the forearm a little above the wrists, over the
dorsal surface of the radius, more marked generally in the right arm. The surface of
the swellings was not quite uniform, but did not give one the idea of being produced
by a coiled-up worm. The swellings measured about half an inch in diameter. They
were not painful, but occasioned a feeling of stiffness....The swellings occurred at
irregular intervals.5
Moreover, his patient told him that the natives of Calabar and others who had
been resident there for some time were also subject to these swellings on the
forearms and wrists; they were termed " ndi tot" meaning "swelling" by the local
populace5.
The pathogenesis of these lesions was a matter of considerable debate .
Argyll-Robertson managed to extract an adult Loa from deep within the tissues
of a similar swelling in the temple of a patient 5. Manson (1910) thought i t
unlikely that the mere presence and movement of worms caused these lesions
for he cited a patient whose blood was teeming with microfilaria loa and who
amused himself by harpooning adult worms with a needle as they wriggled their
way under the skin of his chest or abdomen, yet who rarely suffered fro m
Calabar swellings. Manson postulated that the oedema might be caused b y
lymphatic obstruction, the secretion of irritating glandular products, th e
excretion of faecal material by the worm, or the periodical emptying of th e
contents of the uterus of a gravid female worm into the connective tissues of the
host. Of these various hypotheses, he favoured the last, and supported thi s
thesis by instancing his discovery of microfilariae in an aspirate of one of these
lesions70. This could not be confirmed by Low, however; he aspirated swellings
of two patients who, in contrast to Manson's case, did not have a microfil -
araemia, and failed to find any embryos; he thought it more likely that th e
lesions were due to a toxic reaction to the worms, possibly dead ones 65.
Less definite were the suggestions of an association between Loa infection
and cerebral disease. The patient in whom Manson first observed the micro -
filariae died of sleeping sickness and the second patient was insane, so Manson
Loiasis 651
canvassed the possibility that the two conditions were connected 68. Later
authors12,87 described a variety of neurological problems in patients with Loa
infections, but these turned out to be coincidental, while trypanosomes wer e
shown to be the cause of sleeping sickness. Other conditions which have been
associated with loiasis include endomyocardial fibrosis 52 and nephrotic
syndrome93.
Several reports have been given by physicians of their own, personal ,
naturally-acquired infections. Rogers described fugitive swellings, especially
around the joints, which were painless yet occasioned stiffness, and recounted
the migratory habits of the adult worm 82. Similarly, Johnstone recorded his own
experiences:
I first noted the gradual onset of a swelling above the right wrist. This was
pronounced to be a sprain, but the swelling gradually spread to involve the whole
of the right hand, and writing for more than a few minutes caused cramp....playing
any games which involved holding a handle was impossible. At this stage, and
lasting about ten days, a severe neuralgia in the distribution of the right median
nerve came on every night and at no time....did I manage to sleep more than 20
minutes at a time....The swelling of the wrists and hand persisted for at least 6-8
weeks. Within a few weeks of the appearance of the first swelling, a regular crop of
swellings kept coming and going. In one week....I had 16 swellings, 3 coming on
in one day. At times they were irritating and the overlying skin red; at other times
they appeared to be situated more deeply, causing an ache which usually felt like a
bruise and lasted 24 hours. By far the greatest number developed on the forearms,
but few parts of my body have so far escaped.54
Johnstone then went on to recount the removal of an adult worm from his eye
on four separate occasions 54.
It was noted that the natural history of this infection may occupy man y
years. A number of months usually passed after exposure before the first sign
of infection appeared. Meinhof reported the case of a female German mission-
ary who went to the German Cameroons in 1903 and developed Calaba r
swellings two years later. These recurred, together with headaches, for another
six years until an adult Loa was first seen 74. On the other hand, Dyce Shar p
demonstrated that clinical manifestations (Calabar swellings) could appea r
soon after exposure, for he recounted a case in which such problems began 61
days after the earliest conceivabl e date of infection and one week after the most
probable infective date 34. The adult worms may be very long-lived fo r
instances have been recorded in which adult worms have persisted for at least
17 years73,95.
action, but instead of coming out through the aperture I had made, it passed to the
side and went to the region opposite the incision. Seeing that this tentative method
was not of any use, I grabbed hold of it at the middle of its body with small forceps
as well as the conjunctiva; I then made a small hole at the side of its body with the
point of a lancet, and with an ordinary needle, I pulled it out; after this operation, the
negress was well within 24 hours.8
A century later, when local anaesthesia was available, Argyll-Robertso n
recounted his technique:
I at once placed my finger on the surface of the globe in such a manner as to prevent
the parasite passing backwards until the conjunctiva was pretty well anaesthetised
by the application of cocaine. I then got my friend Dr. Maddox, who was present,
to apply his finger while the necessary preparations were hastily made for an
operation. She was placed on a couch and the speculum applied, when the pressure
of the finger having been removed the wriggling movements of the worm resumed,
as briskly as before application of the cocaine. I now grasped with a pair of toothed
fixing forceps a good fold of conjunctiva over the centre of the wriggling worm,
taking care to include in the fold all the structures superficial to the sclerotic. I next
made with a pair of scissors an incision through the conjunctiva a little nearer the
cornea, in such a manner as to lift up a small flap of conjunctiva, and after a little
careful separation of the tissues, found one extremity of the worm, which I seized
with a pair of iris forceps. On now relaxing the fixing forceps, the parasite came
away readily.5
In the following year, Roth told of his unfortunate experiences. He tried many
times to remove a worm from the eye of a 15 year old girl, but never succeeded
in catching the elusive creature. The same sequence befell his next tw o
patients, and he remarked rather optimistically that they had probably bee n
cured by his application of cocaine 83. Roth noted in passing that it was a
common practice amongst the local inha bitants to treat the infection by packing
small pieces of onions around the eye; this was said to either retain the worm
on the sclera where it could be picked off with a needle, or drive it away (and
he postulated that it passed through the nasal duct and was then eithe r
swallowed or spat out!).
A number of drugs were tried in loiasis. Aubert and Heckenroth (1913 )
investigated the actions of aniline, vari ous arsenicals and tartar emetic in loiasis
but found them to be useless7. Although most authors agreed that there was no
effective drug for the medical treatment of this infection, evanescent claim s
were made for salvarsan (arsenic) 76, anthiomaline (antimony) 17 and picric
acid77.
In 1947, diethylcarbamazine was introduced for the treatment of bancroftian
filariasis (see chapter 23), then this drug was soon tried in loiasis. A number
of investigators reported clinical improvement in many but not all patients with
loiasis79,86,88,90. Some patients developed an itchy morbilliform or urticarial rash
after treatment (possibly due to concurrent occult infection with Onchocerca).
Most of these patients had no Loa microfilaraemia. In Murgatroyd and Wood-
ruff's series, for example, only three of the 17 patients had microfilariae in the
bloodstream, and no mention was made of the longterm effects of the drugs on
654 A History of Human Helminthology
the microfilaraemia 79. Woodruff later reported the liver biopsy finding in a
patient in whom diethylcarbamazine treatment had caused the parasites t o
disappear from the peripheral blood; microfilariae in the biopsy wer e
surrounded by phagocytes, thus suggesting that the action of the drug was t o
sensitize the microfilariae which were then destroyed by the cells of th e
reticulo-endothelial system 94. Subsequent experience has shown that although
this drug may be useful in patients with loiasis, it cannot be relied upon t o
eradicate the infection.
Although cases of loiasis were described initially from both Africa and fro m
South America, its universal occurrence in black slaves in the latter area and
its spontaneous disappearance from that regi on indicated that Loa infection was
endemic only in parts of West and Central Africa. The factors influencing the
distribution and intensity of infection could b e ascertained only when the central
role of Chrysops flies in the transmission of infection had been ascertained .
Sporadic attempts were made over the next few decades to both define th e
prevalence and severity of disease in infected populations, and to study th e
habits of the vectors, but the most intensive efforts were made during the late
1940's and the 1950's.
Gordon and his colleagues reported their investigations in a town in th e
British Cameroons in which a quarter of the population were infected .
C. siliacea and C. dimidiata were both found, though the former was muc h
more common. They observed that the female flies bit once every two weeks
or so, usually between the hours of 8.30 a.m. and 4.30 p.m., were found indoors
as well as outdoors, hunted probably by sight, preferring the well-lighte d
houses of Europeans to the d ark houses of the Africans, and had infection rates
of up to 12%. Chrysops larvae were found in densely-shaded streams, localized
in the stagnant parts and in mud beneath decaying vegetation 43,45. It became
clear that infection was limited chiefly to the rain forest or its immediat e
environs56 with the adult flies occupying the canopy of the forest. Furthermore,
monkeys in those forests were infected with a strain of Loa loa which, although
it had certain morphological differences and had nocturnal periodicity, wa s
possibly transmissible to man 27,42. Duke then showed that smoke from woo d
fires increased greatly the biting rate and may be an important factor i n
attracting flies from the forest to feed in houses28, and also suggested that the
flies were attracted by movement 29.
Loiasis 655
REFERENCES
1. AITKEN W. Parasitic diseases. In, Science and practice of medicine, London, volume 1,
pp 799-900, 1866
2. ANNETT HE, DUTTON JE, ELLIOT JH. Report of the malaria expedition to Nigeria
of the Liverpool School of Tropical M edicine and Medical Parasitology. Part II. Filariasis.
Thompson Yates Laboratory Reports, volume 4, 1901. Abstracted in Journal of Tropical
Medicine and Hygiene 5: 111-112, 1902
3. ANONYMOUS. Filaria loa. British Medical Journal i: 39-40, 1913
4. ANONYMOUS. Filaria loa and its insect host. Lancet i: 606, 1921
5. ARGYLL-ROBERTSON DM. Case of Filaria loa in which the parasite was remove d
from under the conjunctiva. Transactions of the Ophthalmological Society of the United
Kingdom 15: 137-167, 1895
6. ARGYLL-ROBERTSON DM. Note of the further history of the case of Filaria loa
previously reported to the Society. Transactions of the Ophthalmological Society of the
United Kingdom 17: 227-232, 1897
7. AUBERT P, HECKENROTH F. Action de divers médicaments sur les Microfilari a
perstans et diurna. Bulletins de la Société de Pathologie Exotique et de ses Filiales 6 :
457-459, 1913
8. BAJON B. Mémoires pour servir à l'histoire de Cayenne et de la Guyane française etc.,
Paris, two volumes, pp 878, 1777-1778. Partly translated by DI Grove
9. BLANCHARD R. La filaire sous-conjonctivale ( Filaria loa Guyot). Progrès Médical ,
Paris, series 2, 4: 591-593, 611-612, 1886
10. BLOT. Cited in 47
11. BRUMPT EJ. La Filaria loa Guyot est la forme adulte de la microfilaire désignée sous
le nom de Filaria diurna Manson. Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires de la Société d e
Biologie 56: 630-632, 1904
656 A History of Human Helminthology
12. BRUNETIERE. La filaire de l'oeil (Filaria loa) peut-elle déterminer des complications
cérébrales? Gazette Hebdomadaire des Sci ences Médicale de Bordeaux 34: 351-353, 1913
13. BRUYNOGHE G. Recherches sur les propriétés antigeniques des microfilaires d e
Dirofilaria immitis. Annales de la Société Belge de Médecine Tropicale 19: 335-353 .
1939
14. de BRY D, de BRY J. India orientalis, two volumes, Frankfurt, 1597-1598
15. BURROWS D. The relationship of microfilaria diurna to Filaria loa. Journal of Tropical
Medicine and Hygiene 13: 49-50, 1910
16. CASTELLANI A, CHALMERS AJ. Manual of tropical medicine, second edition .
Bailliere, Tindall and Cox, London, pp 1747, 1913
17. de CHOISY H. Observation d'un cas de microfilariose Loa traité par
l'antimonio-thiomalate de lithium. Revue de Médecine et Hygiene Tropicale 29: 294-296,
1937
18. CLOT A. Dragonneau. Archives Générales de Médecine 30: 573, 1832
19. COBBOLD TS. An introduction to the study of helminthology with reference, mor e
particularly, to the internal parasites of man, Groombridge and Sons, London, pp 480 ,
1864
20. COCKIN RP. Commentary on 57. Tropical Diseases Bulletin 7: 362, 1916
21. CONNAL A. Observations on filaria in Chrysops from West Africa. Transactions of the
Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 14: 108-109, 1921
22. CONNAL A, CONNAL SL. A preliminary note on the development of Loa loa (Guyot)
in Chrysops silacea (Austen). Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and
Hygiene 15: 131-134, 1921
23. CONNAL A, CONNAL SL. The development of Loa loa (Guyot) in Chrysops silacea
(Austen) and in Chrysops dimidiata (Van der Wulp). Transactions of the Royal Society
of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 16: 64-89, 1922
24. CONNAL A, CONNAL S L. (The development of Loa loa [Guyot] in Chrysops silacea
[Austen] and in Chrysops dimidiata [Van der Wulp].) Correspondence. Transactions of
the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 16: 437, 1923
25. DUBINI A. Entozoografia umana per servire di complemento agli studii di anatomi a
patologia etc. Annali Universali di Medicina gia Compilati dai Dottore Annibale Omodei,
Milano, 35: 502-578, 1850
26. DUJARDIN F. Histoire naturelle des helminthes ou vers intestinaux, Librairi e
Encyclopédique de Roret, Paris, pp 652, 1845
27. DUKE BO. The development of Loa in flies of the genus Chrysops and the probable
significance of the different species in the transmission of loiasis. Transactions of th e
Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 49: 115-121, 1955
28. DUKE BO. Studies on the biting habits of Chrysops. II. The effect of wood fires on the
biting density of Chrysops silacea in the rain-forest at Kumba, British Cameroons. Annals
of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology 49: 260-272, 1955
29. DUKE BO. Studies on the biting habits of Chrysops. III. The effect of groups of persons,
stationary and moving, on the biting density of Chrysops silacea at ground level in the
rain-forest at Kumba, British Cameroons. Annals of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology
49: 362-367, 1955
30. DUKE BO. Studies on the chemoprophylaxis of loiasis. I. Experiments on monkeys with
special reference to diethylcarbamazine (Banocide). Annals of Tropical Medicine an d
Parasitology 55: 447-451, 1961
31. DUKE BO. Studies on the chemoprophylaxis of loiasis. II. Observations o n
diethylcarbamazine citrate (Banocide) as a prophylactic in man. Annals of Tropica l
Medicine and Parasitology 57: 82-96, 1963
32. DUKE BO, MOORE PH. A trial of Banocide as a means of controlling the transmission
of loiasis on a rubber estate in Nigeria. Annals of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology 55:
263-277, 1961
33. DYCE SHARP N A. Filaria bancrofti and Loa loa. A note on some methods o f
Loiasis 657
77. MÜHLENS. Zur Behandlung der Filariasis. Archiv für Schiffs- und Tropen-Hygiene 25:
247-248, 1921
78. MÜLLER OF. Verzeichniss der bisher entdeckten Eingeweidewürmer, der Thiere, i n
welchen sie gefunden Worden, und besten Schriften, die derselben erwähnen .
Naturforscher, Halle 22: 33-86, 1787
79. MURGATROYD F, WOODRUFF AW. Loiaisis treated with Hetrazan (Banocide) .
Lancet ii: 147-149, 1949
80. ORIHEL TC, MOORE PJ. Loa loa: Experimental infection in two species of Africa n
primates. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 24: 606-609, 1975
81. RODHAIN J, DUBOIS A. A contribution to the study of intradermal reactions in human
filariasis. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 25 :
377-382, 1932
82. ROGERS W. A note on a cas e of Loa loa. Annals of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology
7: 363-365, 1913
83. ROTH F. Filaria loa. Lancet i: 764-765, 1896
84. SAMBON LW. Remarks on the individuality of Filaria diurna. Journal of Tropical
Medicine and Hygiene 6: 26, 1903
85. SCHOFIELD FD. The complement-fixation reaction in loiasis and Acanthocheilonema
perstans infections. Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 60: 170-172, 1957
86. SHOOKHOFF HB, DWORK KG. Treatment of Loa loa infections with Hetrazan .
American Journal of Tropical Medicine 29: 589-593, 1949
87. SMITH AJ, RIVAS D. Notes upon human filariasis ( Filaria loa Guyot, and Filaria
bancrofti Cobbold). American Journal of Tropical Diseases and Preventive Medicine 2:
361-377, 1914
88. STEFANOPOULO GJ, SCHNEIDER J. Essais de traitement de la filariose à F. loa par
la 1-diéthyl-carbamyl 4-methylpipérazine. Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances
de l'Académie de Biologie 142: 930-931, 1948
89. STILES CW, HASSALL A. The determination of generic types, and a list of roundworm
genera, with their original and type species. Bureau of Animal Industry, United State s
Department of Agriculture, Bulletin 79, pp 1-150, 1905
90. WANSON M. Essai de traitement avatif de la filariose à Loa loa et de la filariose
apériodique par les dérivés de la pipérazine. Annales de la Société Belge de Médecin e
Tropicale 29: 73-80, 1949
91. WARD H B. The earliest record of Filaria loa. Zoologische Annalen 1: 376-384, 1905
92. WILLIAMS P, CREWE W. Studies on the control of vectors of loiasis in West Africa.
V. The effects of DDT, dieldrin, aldrin and gamma-BHC in the mud of natural tabani d
breeding-sites in the rain-forest of the Cameroons. Annals of Tropical Medicine an d
Parasitology 57: 300-306, 1963
93. WILLIS AJ. Adult nephrotic syndrome at Ibadan; aetiological considerations. Journal of
Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 71: 513-517, 1968
94. WOODRUFF AW. Destruction of microfilariae of Loa loa in the liver in loiasis treated
with Banocide (Hetrazan). Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and
Hygiene 44: 479-480, 1951
95. ZIEMANN H. Ein Fall von Filaria-loa-I nfektion mit mindestens 17 jähriger Dauer. Archiv
für Schiffs- und Tropen-Hygiene 30: 626-628, 1926
660 A History of Human Helminthology
SYNOPSIS
In 1874, John O'Neill, a British n aval surgeon attached to HMS Decoy at Cape
Coast Castle in the Gold Coast (Ghana) became intrigued by an irritating and
intractable skin disease somewhat resembling scabies which afflicted man y
people living in parts of the West Coast of Afr ica. He determined to look for the
cause of this peculiar condition, which was known locally as "craw-craw", by
studying a number of patients in Addah Fort Hospital under the care of D r
Thompson of the Glover Expedition. The condition was characterized b y
papules, vesicles and pustules. O'Neill examined the contents of pustules and
vesicles under a microscope but found nothing other than leucocytes. When he
turned his attention to papules, success attended his efforts for he found a n
organism which he had no doubt was the cause of the complaint. He reported
in 1875:
I was induced to bestow much time on its microscopic examination, and succeeded
at length in discovering a filaria which I believe to be the immediate cause of the
complaint.102
When specimens were examined in a drop of water under a microscope ,
microfilariae that were easily detectable by virtue of their violent contortions
661
662 A History of Human Helminthology
The discovery and publication of the finding of the adult O. volvulus was a
strange and tortuous affair. It 1890, an unnamed German doctor working in the
Gold Coast (Ghana), West Africa, removed two tumours, each about the size
of a pigeon's eggs, one from the scalp and the other from the chest, from two
of the local inhabitants. On examining the specimens, he found that the y
contained worms and sent them to Rudolf Leuckart in Germany for identific-
ation. Both tumours contained several female and male worms, the forme r
being about 6-70 mm in length and the latter about half that size; they wer e
coiled together to form a ball which was very difficult to unravel. This mass of
worms was situated in a cavity which contained fluid laden with embryos .
Leuckart did not publish news of this discovery, but informed Patrick Manson
in a personal communication 82. It was left to Manson to publish a skimpy notice
of the parasite, with due to acknowledgem ent to Leuckart, in a chapter he wrote
on skin diseases in the tropics for Davidson's book Hygiene and disease o f
warm climates89. The section on this parasite was labelled Filaria volvulxus,
the latter apparently being a mistranscription of "volvulus" (from the Lati n
"volvo volvere" = to roll or turn round ); whether this was Leuckart's or Manson
designation was not indicated in the text, but was presumably intended to draw
attention to the twisted and coiled intertwining of the worms.
Leuckart had also sent Manson an histological section containing a
fragment of the uterus of one of the worms. Manson remarked:
It was stuffed with outstretched embryos, resembling in shape and dimensions
F. diurna and F. nocturna. Possibly, compared to these parasites, the embryo of
Onchocerciasis 663
F. volvulxus was somewhat shorter, and also somewhat broader proportionately, and
more abruptly truncated at the cephalic end....One important feature of F. diurna
and F. nocturna I did not see represented in the embryo of F. volvulxus, viz., the
sheath. Professor Leuckart makes the same remark. 89
On the basis of the absence of a sheath, Manson concluded that these worms
were not the parental forms of microfilaria diurna (i.e. loa), and were certainly
not the mature W. bancrofti. He made no mention of the micro-filaria e
discovered in skin by O'Neill nearly 20 years earlier, and may well have been
unaware of the report. Somewhat wistfully, he concluded:
beyond the facts just stated, we possess very little information on the subject.
Observations on this and allied matters are very much wanted. From the numerous
discoveries, notwithstanding very limited opportunities, made in recent years in
African pathology and helminthology, it is evident that many novelties await the
investigator of diseases in that country.89
Six years later (1899), Labadie-Lagrave and Deguy described a youn g
female worm found in a nodule removed from a French soldier who had been
on an expedition to Dahomey in West Africa; they called the parasite F.
volvulus 78. In 1901 Prout described the worms recovered from tumour s
removed from two frontier policemen by Dr Hood, District Surgeon in Sierra
Leone. Prout examined the blood and aspirates from a lymph node of th e
second of these patients, but was unable to find any microfilariae. Concerning
the tumour, he wrote:
The tumour was about 1 in. in length by about 3/4 in. in breadth. On making an
incision, a greenish, semipurulent-looking fluid about the consistency of cream
escaped from the cyst. This, on microscopical examination, was found to contain
numerous filarial embryos. The capsule of the cyst consisted of dense fibrous tissue,
lined internally by a layer of soft, caseous-looking material, which could be easily
scraped off. This was composed of granular material, flat nucleated epithelial cells,
and contained free embryos. The interior of the cyst was filled with adult filariae,
lying in loops twisted up in the most confusing fashion, entering the cyst wall,
running along shallow tunnels, and re-entering the cyst. Owing to this and the
softness and brittleness of the worm, it was a matter of the greatest difficulty to
dissect it out, and I found it impossible to do so without breaking it. Eventually,
however, I succeeded in isolating a complete unbroken adult male, and the head, tail
and intermediate fragments of a female. These two worms formed the whole
contents of the cyst.108
Prout then went on to give the first detailed description of the male and female
adult worms, and described t he microfilariae. Further examples of onchocercal
infection with recovery of adult worms were reported by Brumpt (1904) 25,
Fülleborn (1908) 52 and Parsons (1908) 107. Parsons had in fact seen five patients
and wrote:
very little was known or taught of this particular nematode when (in 1903)....I
became a government official in Northern Nigeria. While other members of the
Filaridae have received a good deal of attention during the present decade, Filaria
volvulus seems to have been comparatively ignored. I am inclined to think, however,
that this Filaria is far more common in certain parts of Africa than is generally
664 A History of Human Helminthology
supposed.107
In 1910, Railliet and Henry111 transferred the worm from the genus Filaria
of Müller98 to the genus Onchocerca which had been erected by Diesing i n
1841 to house O. reticulata, a parasite of the horse, donkey and mule i n
Europe42. The name Onchocerca was derived from a combination of the Greek
words (ONCHOS) meaning "hook" and (KERKOS, CERCOS)
meaning "tail".
In 1916, Rodolfo Robles in Guatemala removed a tumour from the forehead
of a boy and on opening it found that it contained:
a fine worm, white and ball-shaped, with the characteristics of a filaria....The
dissection of the parasite was extremely difficult because it seemed to be sewn into
the tumor itself. Extremely fragile, it broke at the slightest pull. However, after a
laborious effort, I extracted a whole piece that measured almost 30 cm (sic)....The
thick cuticle and the very obvious transverse striations made me think it was of the
genus Onchocerca; however, not having the head, the tail, or a male, I was unable
to identify the parasite fully.114
Subsequently, Robles removed other cysts and obtained isolated worms b y
digesting them in a dog's stomach for five hours. Although he thought that the
worm resembled O. volvulus, he thought that some characteristics did no t
coincide exactly. His discovery was first reported in a newspaper, La
Republica, on 29 December 1916, then the formal description appeared in La
Juventud Médica in 1917114. Most of the copies of the issue were destroyed in
an earthquake, but the article was republished in French in 1919 115. In an
accompanying article, Brumpt gave a detailed description of the parasite, and
after comparing it with the specimens collected by him in the Congo, decided
that it was a different species which h e named O. caecutiens to indicate that the
parasite caused blindness (from the Latin "caecus" = blind) 26. Calderón 34
concurred with this opinion. Fülleborn believed that O. volvulus and O. caec-
utiens were morphologically indistinguishable, but considered that there were
differences in the clinical manifestations caused by the two parasites 54,55.
Subsequent studies by Sandground 125 in which more material was examined,
however, showed that there were considerable variations among the specimens
and that no consistent differences existed between the American and African
forms of the worm. An editorial in the British Medical Journal in 1935
describing the latter's work, undertaken as part of the Harvard Department of
Tropical Medicine expedition to Guatemala, accepted this opinion:
Another important result of the expedition has been the final decision, after careful
examination of numerous adult filariae removed from the tumours, that the Central
American form does not differ in any way from the long-known type from the old
world, a conclusion which means that the name O. caecutiens is merely a synomym
of O. volvulus.3
When O'Neill in 1875 first described microfilariae in the skin of patients with
craw-craw, the microfilariae of Wuchereria bancrofti had been discovered only
13 years before, Lewis had de monstrated their presence in the blood only three
years earlier, and the parent worm of microfilaria bancrofti was still unknown.
Furthermore, none of the other microfilariae which may be found in human s
(Loa loa, Mansonella perstans etc.) had at that time been discovered. Th e
microscopical facilities and staining techniques available during that perio d
were not advanced sufficiently to permit a detailed description of th e
morphology of these parasites. The major difference between the microfilaria
described by O'Neill and that found by Lewis was the presence of a sheath in
the latter's case. O'Neill's omi ssion of any mention of the absence of this sheath
in the skin microfilariae that he saw 102 implies that he had not seen Lewis' s
paper and may well have bee n unaware of it. This is not particularly surprising
since he was a naval surgeon on the high seas and away from current librar y
facilities. Leuckart and Manson 89 were the first to recognize this characteristic
absence of a sheath in O. volvulus microfilariae, but failed to speculate on the
relationship between O. volvulus and the parasite described by O'Neill. Many
years were to pass before such a relationship was established definitely.
When Prout described the morphology of adult O. volvulus in 1901, he also
compared in tabular form the salient diagnostic features of microfilaria diurna
(= loa), microfilaria nocturna (= bancrofti), microfilaria perstans and the
Onchocerca microfilaria; he showed that they were all distinct from each other
in one respect or another 108. Like Manson, however, Prout did not relate these
worms to the microfilariae of craw-craw that had been described by O'Neill.
In 1913, Ouzilleau reported that in the re gion of Mbomu, French Equatorial
Africa, O. volvulus infections were very common (as were Loa loa and
Mansonella perstans, but Wuchereria bancrofti was absent). This provided an
opportunity for examining a large number of patients with onchocerciasis .
Ouzilleau confirmed Prout's observation that microfilariae were not present in
the blood; he found a microfilaria similar to those aspirated from a n
onchocercal cyst only once in 200 blood examinations, but did find them o n
many occasions in lymph node aspirates 103. This finding was criticized by Low
who felt that they must have been W. bancrofti microfilariae 83, but Ouzilleau
was supported later that year by Fülleborn and Simon56. Simon had found large,
unsheathed microfilariae in the inguinal lymph nodes and in the blood of a
patient with large onchocercal nodules on the superior iliac spine. He believed
that they might be microfilariae of O. volvulus so submitted them to Fülleborn
who could discern no differences between them and those prepared from O.
volvulus adult worms. This observation was confirmed when Simon the n
obtained lymph nodes from another patient with onchocerciasis who wa s
operated upon for a femoral hernia. Careful measurements of the size an d
666 A History of Human Helminthology
instances, all their patients with filarial itch had onchocercal tumours, and that
all persons with one of these nodules had the eruption characteristic of filarial
itch94. This failed to convince Brumpt who again asserted that any role for O.
volvulus in the causation of filarial itch was doubtful 28.
In the following year, Ouzilleau and colleagues in the Congo (Brazzaville),
studied a village in which 16 of the 27 inhabitants were afflicted wit h
onchocercal nodules, with five having cutaneous lesions in addition. Thes e
investigators examined the skin lesions and concluded that subjects infecte d
with O. volvulus nodules always had microfilaria volvulus in the dermis, and
that these parasites elicited an inflammatory reaction which caused th e
cutaneous lesions, yet unaccountably, they did not consider that "craw-craw "
was connected with onchocerciasis 105. This elicited another response fro m
Montpellier and Lacroix 96 who discussed the advisability or otherwise o f
retaining the term craw-craw as a dis tinct condition. They reiterated their belief
that the skin lesions were due to itching whereas Ouzilleau and colleagues had
ascribed the skin reactions directly to the action of the microfilariae. In fact ,
both groups of investigators were probably partly right, with microfilaria e
stimulating an inflammatory reaction which, amongst other things, cause d
itching and scratching which in turn exacerbated the condition. Th e
observations of the French workers were confirmed by Macfie and Corson in
Accra, Ghana. They found that not only were O. volvulus microfilariae present
in the skin of patients with Onchocerca nodules, but that examination of skin
biopsies taken from 50 health y men selected at random revealed larvae in 34%
of them. Finally, MacFie and Corson showed at autopsy of three infecte d
individuals that parasites were p resent in widely separated areas of the skin but
were absent from the mucous membranes and internal organs 86.
Thus, by the middle of the 1920's, it was becoming clear that th e
unsheathed microfilariae in lymph node aspirates which looked the same a s
those obtained from O. volvulus adults were indeed derived from that parasite,
as were the same microfilariae seen in th e skin. Finally, despite the reservations
of some sceptics such as Brumpt, it seemed c ertain in retrospect that the filariae
seen in the skin 50 years earlier by O'Neill were indeed O. volvulus
microfilariae.
When Manson first described O. volvulus, he wrote that "Judging also from the
absence of sheath, it may be that the life history of this parasite is somewha t
different in character from that of F. diurna or F. nocturna" 89. Nevertheless,
Manson probably had in mind the likelihood that infection was transmitted by
some blood-sucking insect in the same way as he had shown with W. bancrofti.
668 A History of Human Helminthology
forehead and chest. Unfortunately, Robles did not catch and dissect these flies,
but he wrote: "I believe I can hypothesize that these are the intermediate hosts.
At any rate, it is necessary to demonstrate this, and it has not been done" 114.
In 1923, the Briton, Donald Blacklock, began to investigate the mode o f
transmission of onchocerciasis in Sierra Leone. Since the microfilariae were not
in the blood but in the skin, he postulated that any arthropod capable o f
transmitting the worms must be able to da mage the skin and dislodge the larvae
in its efforts to reach blood. Accordingly, he first looked at the Congo floo r
maggot, Auchmeromyia luteola , which was common in the houses, but n o
signs of the parasite were found. In December 1923 and January 1924, h e
observed that the blackfly prophetically named Simulium damnosum was biting
viciously and in great numbers near the streams supplying several of th e
villages in an endemic area. Furthermore, he noticed that the insect was slow
in drawing blood, which reinforced his idea that it must be inflicting sever e
damage. He therefore caught 100 specimens and examined them for larvae in
the gut, but finding nothing, abandoned the search temporarily. In 1925, h e
resumed this operation at another vill age, this time with success. 780 flies were
captured while biting randomly selected boys and 2.6% of the insects contained
larvae morphologically identical with O. volvulus microfilariae in their gut .
Thereupon, he submitted two men who were known to have O. volvulus
microfilariae in their skin, bu t were not infected with any other filarial parasite,
to the flies and found that 17% of Simulium contained microfilariae in thei r
intestinal tract. When flies were then permitted to bite only on a 4 inch ban d
around the patients' body, this area in cluding nodules near the trochanters, 80%
of the insects became infected. Meanwhile, 1,320 wild Simulium were
dissected and 1.1% were found to contain developmental forms of som e
nematode, which was in all probability the larva of O. volvulus, in the thorax.
Wild flies were then fed upon infected persons and kept alive for as long a s
possible, with the result that up to 82% were found harbouring larvae in th e
thorax, although only one worm was found in the head. In 1926, he undertook
a further series of experiments to study the development of filariae within the
flies. He found that development took about ten days to complete an d
summarized his findings:
The skin forms taken into the gut of Simulium accumulate at the margin of the
blood coagulum lying between this and the gut wall. They are very active and the
majority pass out of the gut within 24 hours and may be found in the posterior part
of the thoracic muscles in 48 hours. They have altered completely in shape....they
have also lost a great deal of their mobility. Several moults appear to occur before
the form is reached which is capable of invading the head. 20
Blacklock found that when worms reached the proboscis they entered th e
labium where they remained coiled up waiting for an opportunity to emerge. He
then inoculated two monkeys with infective larvae, one intradermally and the
other subcutaneously, the first in the flank and the second in the head, but was
unsuccessful in transmitting infection. Details of Blacklock's work wer e
670 A History of Human Helminthology
SKIN DISEASE
of nodules in the body with 30% being locate d over the trochanters, 29% on the
iliac crests, 21% on the sides of the thorax and 19% either on different or two
or more sites 43. Similar findings were then found by many investigators, with
the distribution of nodules tending to follow more the pattern described b y
Dubois.
Desoil and Benoit studied the histological appearances of an excise d
onchocercal nodule and found a granulomatous inflammatory reaction around
the adult worms and microfilariae migrating throughout the tissues of th e
"tumour"40. Similar observations, with the addition of oedema, eosinophili c
infiltration, endothelial proliferation and fibrosis were noted by subsequen t
investigators90,101. From time to time, nodules became infected secondarily with
bacteria and presented as abscesses, the original problem being realized only
when onchocercae were recovered from the abscess contents 77,122.
While the relationship of O. volvulus to nodules was clear, considerabl e
controversy surrounded the role of O. volvulus microfilariae in producing other
skin lesions. As has already been recounted, it was not until 1920 that O' Neill's
description of filarial worms in craw-craw was exhumed from the librar y
archives and equated with O. volvulus by Montpellier and Lacroix. O'Neil l
described craw-craw as an itchy, papulo-vesiculo-pustular eruption which was
most marked in the clefts of the fingers, front of the wrists, and back of th e
elbows. This distribution is classical of scabies as he himself remarked, and it
may well be that he was dealing with a dua l infection. O'Neill discoursed on the
natural history of the condition:
The papules arise singly and at irregular intervals, increase to the size of a pin's head,
feel firm to the touch, and appear of the same colour as the surrounding integument.
In some cases, the papules arrange themselves in a crescentic form, like
ringworm.....In about two days' time the papule becomes converted into the vesicle,
with very little increase in size, and in the course of a couple of days the pustule is
developed, rapidly enlarging, and uniting with those in its immediate
neighbourhood. In the height of his suffering the patient tears the pustules, and their
liberated and dessicated contents produce large and unsightly crusts. 102
It was the itching and consequent scratching which led to the rediscovery b y
Montpellier and Lacroix of microfilariae in the tegument 95. In addition to the
papules, vesicles and pustules, Ouzilleau and his colleagues in 1921 recognised
thickening of the skin variously described as pseudo-ichthyosis, ichthyosi s
simplex and lichenization. Their histological studies of these lesions revealed
the presence of microfilaria volvulus in the dermis and subdermal tissues ,
infiltration with mononuclear cells, hyperkeratosis of the epidermis, often with
infiltration of the basal layers by leucocytes, enlarged dome-like papillae i n
lichenoid zones and in pruriginous regions with the addition in the latte r
location of blisters and ulceration. In leucodermic areas, the pigment wa s
lacking, the horny layers of skin were thinner than usual and there was a n
increase in fibrous tissue with an absence of blood vessels and glands 105. In
contrast, Montpellier and Lacroix 95 did not emphasize the inflammator y
672 A History of Human Helminthology
reaction, nor did Dyce Sharp who found that microfilariae were not usuall y
associated with inflammation, although there was sometimes a layer of definite
inflammatory change49. These differences in severity were probably due t o
biopsies being taken from areas of skin with differing severities of disease .
Harris summarized the natural history of the skin lesions by remarking that the
first skin affection was an itching rash which then either became elephantoid,
often with enlarged lymph nodes, or became atrophic 65.
One of the major objections which Brumpt had raised about th e
onchocercal nature of these lesions was the frequent absence of onchocerca l
nodules. Although these criticisms were no longer tenable when man y
investigators demonstrated the unequivocal presence of microfilariae identical
with those of O. volvulus in the skin, explanations were furnished by th e
discovery in autopsies of two humans of clinically occult adult worms whic h
were free in the tissues unencumbered by a fibrous, nodular reactions15, then
the realization that nodules might be located in the deep, inaccessible tissues.
Another problem which was the subject of some controversy was whether
or not onchocercal infection caused elephantiasis. Ouzilleau (1913) had found
that up to 3% of the populati on he surveyed had this condition, yet Wuchereria
bancrofti was absent, only O. volvulus, M. perstans and L. loa being present.
Since he had found O. volvulus microfilariae in aspirates from enlarged lymph
nodes, he suggested that this parasite may be the cause of elephantiasis 103.
Ouzilleau was supported by Dubois who proved onchocercal infection in over
90% of 53 patients with elephantiasis 43. Ouzilleau returned to this theme i n
1923104, then was echoed by Dyce Sharp who found O. volvulus microfilariae
in hydrocele fluid 49. In order to explain the pathogenesis of elephantiasis i n
Onchocerca infection, Rodhain put forward the hypothesis that obstruction to
lymph flow was caused by microfilariae in the lymphatic capillaries 118. On the
other hand, Dubois eventually modified his views and concluded that while O.
volvulus favoured the appearance of elephanti asis, W. bancrofti was its primary
cause44. Nevertheless, Kirk (1947) found that hydrocele and scrota l
elephantiasis were very common in patients with onchocerciasis in the Sudan
in an area where bancroftian filariasis was rare 76, so that the matter is not yet
completely resolved. Finally, a form of pseudoelephantiasis called "hangin g
groin", in which a sac of atrophic skin containing sclerosed glands in a matrix
of connective tissue and lymph exudate, was described by Nelson as bein g
frequent in persons heavily infected with Onchocerca in Uganda99.
Variations on these themes were seen in onc hocerciasis in Central America,
perhaps partly due to the light skin colour of many of the infected persons and
the biting habits of the vectors. In Guatemala, there was a condition known as
"Erisipela de la Costa" (erysipelas, i.e. red skin inflammation of the coast). In
1915, Robles was consulted by a woma n concerning recurrent erysipelas of the
face which was accompanied by fever, a burning sensation, pruritus and poor
vision, but he did not know the cause. Afterwards he saw a boy with the same
features:
Onchocerciasis 673
There was edema of the eyelids, the forehead, and the superior lip. The cheeks were
puffed up with shiny, dry, scaly lesions that resembled chronic eczema; also there
was a greenish coloration of both cheeks as you would see in ecchymosis of several
days' duration. When touched, the edema was hard leaving no digital impression.
The ears were much increased in size with the external ear pushed forward; the lobe
was edematous, scaly, dry and whitish.114
On his forehead was a tumour the size of a cherry; it was this nodule tha t
Robles excised and first discovered the adult Onchocerca in the Americas and
later remarked: "I understood then that the 'erysipelas' lesions surely were due
to the presence of this parasite" 114.
Robles collected a large series of patients and noted that the nodules were
found most commonly on the head. They were generally situated in the sub -
cutaneous tissues but were occasionally tethered to underlying structures .
Indeed, in four of 500 patients on whom he operated, the nodules ha d
perforated the cranium and were resting on the meninges. He noted too, that the
adult worms could be long-lived, for he found living worms in a cyst which he
removed from a patient who had been living out of an endemic area for seven
years.
Apart from the skin nodules, Robles observed two forms of skin disease .
Some patients developed acute inflammation in which the skin became:
smoothy, shiny, red, tense and warm simulating erysipelas....After three to four days
the fever falls slowly and the patient enters a chronic stage. The swellings persist
much longer, for days, up to months in the same stage; but usually at the end of 20
days they diminish notably.114
In the chronic stage, however, he wrote that when the face was involved:
the cheeks are always indurated, the skin eczematous, pigmented and lustrous, with
an absolutely typical greenish livid color; elephantiasis of the ears, which are
doubled in size, bent forward with skin wrinkled and scaly.....On the limbs of the
body there is a uniform swelling with induration as seen in the elephantiasis of the
Arabs. However, the typical greenish color suggests the diagnosis instantaneously.114
Robles observations were confirmed by Calderón 34 and by Strong 131,132. A few
years late, Goldman and Ortiz classified the dermatitis into three forms :
pigmentation dermatitis or "mal de morado" (= purple disease) in which th e
skin became purplish in colour, a lic henoid form, and an eczematous dermatitis
in which the lesions were papulo-vesicular, excoriated, papillomatous an d
hyperkeratotic62. Although Robles had commented upon elephantiasis of th e
limbs, subsequent investigat ors were agreed that this condition was very rarely
seen in American onchocerciasis.
EYE DISEASE
presence of microfilariae were necessary for the production of eye disease 142.
At this point, so much uncertainty and controversy surrounded the question of
onchocercal eye disease, that a reviewer in The Lancet in 1963 wrote:
The relation between infection with these worms and damage to the eyes is by no
means straightforward....Everyone agrees that microfilariae invading the cornea may
cause conjunctivitis and keratitis, both punctate and sclerosing; but such lesions
rarely cause complete blindness. Blindness is likelier to be due to lesions in the
posterior part of the eye, but opinions differ as to whether such lesions are really
caused by microfilariae or whether they arise from genetic effects and excessive
inbreeding.5
Choyce in 1964 then compared the ocular manifestations of onchocerciasis in
endemic areas in Central America, in Africa, and in expatriates in Britain. He
now concluded that in American onchocerciasis blindness was due to anterior
lesions, posterior lesions being rare, while in the African form of the disease
choroidoretinal lesions were present as well as anterior eye involvement .
Nevertheless, Choyce still held that the posterior eye lesions were due to other
factors such as vitamin B deficiency or inheritance 39. On the other hand, Quere
and his colleagues in Africa, from observations of a large series of patients ,
concluded that both anterior and posterior regions of the eye were involved in
a typical sequence of inflammatory processes caused by the microfilariae 110.
This view is now generally accepted.
reaction which was well marked in 16 hours. There was usually swelling, oedema
and tenderness of the skin, especially of the buttocks and thighs. Sometimes the
prepuce, penis and scrotum were swollen. Intense itching was always widespread.
Sometimes there was a thick papular rash over the trunk and limbs. The
lymph-glands were generally enlarged and tender....There was always pyrexia. 66
The initial encouraging reports with suramin and with diethylcarbamazine
were followed by comparative trials 33 and with the combination of the tw o
drugs37,126. Although each drug has had its advocates, suramin has largely been
abandoned because of its occasional severe toxicity, especially on the kidneys,
even though it kills adult worms, while diethylcarbamazine suffers from th e
twin disadvantages of having only a transitory effect and producing unpleasant
side-effects associated with killing of the microfilariae. Attempts have bee n
made to improve the effectiveness of the latter drug, for example, b y
administering the drug in a skin lotion 6, but these efforts have bee n
unrewarding. Duke in 1981 summarized the difficulties:
The outstanding problem in onchocerciasis remains in the treatment of patients,
particularly those whose eyes are at risk. We are still dependent upon two drugs,
DEC-C (diethylcarbamazine citrate) and suramin whose actions were discovered
more than 30 years ago and which are far from satisfactory in use....What is now
needed above all is a non-toxic drug, which has a convenient dosage schedule and
which can kill or permanently sterilise the adult worms of O. volvulus without
producing a microfilaricidal reaction.48
Duke then remarked that towards this end, The United Nations Development
Fund/World Bank/World Health Organization Spec ial Programme for Research
and Training in Tropical Diseases has set in train a programme to develop new
filaricidal drugs effective against O. volvulus, which:
Given adequate funds, sufficient brains, patience, and some luck, it is hoped...may
pay off within the next 10-15 years developing a new drug to improve the prospects
of treatment of those threatened with or suffering from ocular onchocerciasis. 48
While these words were being written, a promising drug was bein g
developed. In 1978, Blair and Campbell had reported that ivermectin, a
macrocyclic lactone derived from a new species of actinomycete, Streptomyces
avermitilis, had exceptional potency against the nematodes Ancylostoma
caninum 21 and Dirofilaria immitis 35. In 1982, Aziz and his colleagues showed
that the density of skin microfilari ae was greatly reduced in Senegalese patients
treated with ivermectin 12. Subsequent double-blind studies in West Africa have
compared ivermectin with diethylcarbamazine and placebo in patients wit h
high skin microfilarial density, most of whom had ocular involvement .
Ivermectin was shown to be superior to diethylcarbamazine in both safety and
efficacy; ivermectin resulted in a more sustained microfilaricidal effect, wit h
skin microfilarial levels 12 months after treatment being 2-10% o f
pre-treatment levels compared with a value of 10-45% for patients treated with
diethylcarbamazine 9,63,79.
Onchocerciasis 681
different strains of both parasite and vector in those two regions 47.
In many parts of Central America, onchocerciasis is often associated with
the growing of coffee. The infection was first described in Guatemala, as has
already been recounted. In 1923, Fülleborn suggested that onchocerciasis may
also be present in Mexico 53, then this was confirmed by Larumbe80 .
Subsequently, foci of infection were reported in other parts of northern South
America.
Two hypotheses have been promulgated concerning the origins of oncho-
cerciasis in America 70. The first postulates that the infection did not exist in the
Western Hemisphere prior to its introduction by infected persons from Africa.
The most obvious source of such infection is among the negro slaves carried
from West Africa124, but other suggestions have been made. For example ,
Torroella considered that the infection may have been introduced into Mexico
by a battalion of Sudanese troops sent to assist the French invasion troops of
Napoleon III in 1862 136. The alternative hypothesis is that onchocerciasis i s
autochthonous to the Americas. This seeme d quite tenable when Brumpt's view
that O. caecutiens was different to O. volvulus was accepted. This idea wa s
supported by Diaz who found a small number of pre-Columbian skulls wit h
erosions and perforations which he attributed to onchocercal nodules 41. This,
of course, was a non-specific finding, as are the various examples of earl y
Spanish literature citing regions where blindness was common, that have been
quoted by Figueroa Marroquin in support of this latter thesis 51.
Although natural infections with O. volvulus have been found in the gorilla
in the Congo and in the spider monkey in Me xico, there is no evidence that they
are a significant reservoir of zoonotic onchocerciasis.
REFERENCES
1. ADAMS AR. A case of onchocerciasis (filarial blinding) with manifestations developing
in Britain. Lancet i: 545-548, 1938
2. ALI-KHAN Z, MEEROVITCH E. The first reported case of a zoonotic Onchocerca sp.
in Man. 48th Annual Meeting of the Ameri can Society of Parasitologists, Toronto, 29 June
1973
3. ANONYMOUS Study of a filarial infection, British Medical Journal i: 1271-1272, 1935
4. ANONYMOUS. Ocular lesions in onchocerciasis. Lancet i: 1165-1166, 1958
5. ANONYMOUS. Control of filarial worms. Lancet i: 589-590, 1963
6. ANONYMOUS. Diethylcarbamazine citrate lotion and onchocerciasis. Lancet ii :
1232-1233, 1980
7. ANONYMOUS. Onchocerciasis Control Programme enters a third phase, Parasitology
Today 2: 81, 1986
8. ASHBURN LL, BURCH TA, BRADY FJ. Pathologic effects of suramin, hetrazan and
arsenamide on adult Onchocerca volvulus. Boletin del Oficina Sanitaria Panamericana 28:
1107-1117, 1949
9. AWADZI K, DADZIE KY, SCHULZ-KEY H, GILLE S HM, FULFORD AJ, AZIZ MA.
The chemotherapy of onchocerciasis XI. A double-blind comparative study of ivermectin,
diethylcarbamazine and placebo in human onchocerciasis in Northern Ghana. Annals of
Tropical Medicine and Parasitology 80: 443-450, 1986
10. AZAROVA NS, MIRETSKY OY, SONIN MD. (The first instance of detection o f
nematode Onchocerca Diesing 1841 in a person in the USSR.). Meditsinskay a
Parasitologiya i Parasitarn e Bolezni 34: 156-158, 1965. In Russian
11. AZIZ MA. Ivermectin vs. onchocerciasis. Parasitology Today 2: 233-235, 1986
12. AZIZ MA, DIALLO S, DIOP IM, LARIVIERE M, PORT A. Efficacy and tolerance of
ivermectin in human onchocerciasis. Lancet ii: 171-173, 1982
13. BEAVER PC, HORNER GS, BILOS JZ. Zoonotic onchocerciasis in a resident of Illinois
and observations on the identification of Onchocerca species. American Journal o f
Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 23: 595-607, 1974
14. BEQUAERT J. The insect carrier of Onchocerca volvulus in Liberia. Proceedings of the
Onchocerciasis 685
1960
38. CHOYCE DP. Some observations on the ocular complications of onchocerciasis and their
relationship to blindness. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine an d
Hygiene 52: 112-121, 1958
39. CHOYCE DP. Ocular onchocerciasis in Central America, Africa and British Isles (with
a note on equine periodic ophthalmia). Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropica l
Medicine and Hygiene 58: 11-36, 1964
40. DESOIL, BENOIT. Considérations sur l'onchocercose à propos d'un cas observé dans une
tumeur du fascia lata chez un soldat nègre. Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances
et Mémoires de la Société de Biologie 83: 685-687, 1920
41. DIAZ F. Oncocercosis de Robles. Boletin de la Oficina Sanitaria de Guatemala 6: 1020,
1027, 1935
42. DIESING C. In 67
43. DUBOIS A. Le rôle pathogène de Onchocerca volvulus , Leuckart. Bulletins de la Société
de Pathologie Exotique et de ses Filiales 9: 305-309, 1916
44. DUBOIS A, FORRO M. Contribution à l'étiologie de l'éléphantiasis congolais. Annales
de la Société Belge de Médecine Tropicale 19: 13-21, 1939
45. DUKE BO. The reappearance, rate of increase and distribution of the microfilariae o f
Onchocerca volvulus following treatment with diethylcarbamazine. Transactions of th e
Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 51: 37-44, 1957
46. DUKE BO. The effects of drugs on Onchocerca volvulus . I. Methods of assessment ,
population dynamics of the parasite and the effects of diethylcarbamazine. Bulletin of the
World Health Organization 39: 137-146, 1968
47. DUKE BO. Onchocerciasis. British Medical Bulletin 28: 66-71, 1972
48. DUKE BO. The six diseases of WHO. Onchocerciasis. British Medical Journal ii :
961-962, 1981
49. DYCE SHARP NA. A contribution to the study of Onchocerca volvulus Leuckart, with
some observations on its prevalence in Nigeria. Transactions of the Royal Society o f
Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 19: 373-388, 1926
50. ENZER J. A preliminary report on the treatment of onchocerciasis. East African Medical
Journal 19: 134-135, 1942
51. FIGUEROA MARROQUIN H. Historia de la enfermedad de Robles en America y de su
descubrimiento en Guatemala. Separata anticipada de la obra enfermedad de Robles de la
Academia de Ciencias Médicas Fisicas y Naturales de Guatemala, 1963
52. FÜLLEBORN F. Ueber Filaria volvulus Leuckart. Archiv für Schiffs- un d
Tropen-Hygiene 12: 295-307, 1908
53. FÜLLEBORN F. Kommt "Kusten-Erysipel" und Onchocerca caecutiens ausser in
Guatemal auch in Mexiko vor? Archiv für Schiffs- und Tropen-Hygiene 27: 386-390 ,
1923
54. FÜLLEBORN F. The "blinding filaria" of Guatemala ( Onchocerca caecutiens , Brumpt
1919). Proceedings of the International Conference on Health Problems in Tropica l
Countries, United Fruit Company, Boston, Mass., pp 241-255, 1924. Abstracted i n
Tropical Diseases Bulletin 22: 484, 1925
55. FÜLLEBORN F. Zur Onchocerca-caecutiens-Frage. Archiv für Schiffs- un d
Tropen-Hygiene 30: 189-195, 1926
56. FÜLLEBORN F, SIMON. Untersuchungen über das Vorkommen der Larven vo n
Onchocerca volvulus in Lymphdrüsen und in der Zirkulation. Archiv für Schiffs- un d
Tropen-Hygiene 17: 501-514, 843-844, 1913
57. GARNHAM PC, McMAHON JP. The eradication of Simulium neavei Roubaud, from an
onchocerciasis area in Kenya Colony. Bulletin of Entomological Research 37: 619-628,
1947
58. GARNHAM PC, McMAHON JP. Final results of an experiment on the control o f
onchocerciasis by eradication of the vector. Bulletin of Entomological Research 45 :
Onchocerciasis 687
175-176, 1954
59. GIAQUINTO MIRA M. Sulla presenza delle microfilarie di " Onchocerca caecutien s
Brumpt" nel nervo ottico. La Riforma Medica 50: 858, 861, 1934
60. GIAQUINTO MIRA M. Contributo agli studi dul problema della transmissione dell a
onchocercosi nel Guatemala. Annali d'Igiene 47: 109-125, 1937
61. GIBBINS EG, LOEWENTHAL LJ. Cutaneous onchocerciasis in a Simulium
damnosum-infested region of Uganda. Annals of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology 27:
489-496, 1933
62. GOLDMAN L, ORTIZ LF. types of dermatitis in American onchocerciasis. Archives of
Dermatology and Syphilis 53: 79-83, 1946
63. GREENE BM, TAYLOR HR, CUPP EW, MURPHY RP, WHITE AT, AZIZ MA ,
SCHULZ-KEY H, D'ANNA SA, NEWLAND, HS, GOLDSCHMIDT LP, AUER C ,
HANSEN AP, FREEMAN SV, REBER EW, WILLIAM S PN. Comparison of ivermectin
and diethylcarbamazine in the treatment of onchocerciasis. New England Journal o f
Medicine 313: 133-138, 1985
64. GUERRERO P. Juicio critico sobre el estudio de la onchocercosis Guatemalteca. L a
Juventad Médica 19: 460-467, 1922
65. HARRIS BP. Clinical aspects of onchocerciasis in the South Kavirondo district of Kenya
Colony. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 34 :
233-249, 1940
66. HAWKING F, LAURIE W. Action of hetrazan on filariasis and onchocerciasis. Lancet
ii: 146-147, 1949
67. HERMANN J. Trichina bei einem Pferde gefunden. Osterreichische medicinisch e
Wochenschrift, pp 199-200, 1841
68. HISSETTE J. Sur l'existence d'affections oculaires importantes d'origine filarienne dans
certains territoires du Congo. Annales de la Société Belge de Médecine Tropicale 11 :
45-46, 1931
69. HISSETTE J. Mémoire sur l'Onchocerca volvulus "Leuckart" et ses manifestation s
oculaires au Congo Belge. Annales de la Société Belge de Médecine Tropicale 12 :
433-529, 1932
70. HOEPPLI R. Parasitic diseases in Africa and the Western Hemisphere. Acta Tropic a
Supplementum 10, pp 240, 1969
71. HOFFMANN XX. Ueber Onchocerca im Süden von Mexico und die Weiterentwicklung
ihrer Mikrofilarien in Eusimulium mooseri. Archiv für Schiffs- und Tropen-Hygiene 34:
461-472, 1930
72. van HOOF L. Serological reactions in onchocerciasis. Transactions of the Royal Society
of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 27: 609-617, 1934
73. van HOOF L, HENRARD C, PEEL E, WANSON M. Sur la chimiothérapie d e
l'onchocercose (Note préliminaire). Annales de la Société Belge de Médecine Tropicale
27: 173-177, 1947
74. KEAN BH, MOTT KE, RUSSELL AJ. Tropical medicine and parasitology. Classi c
investigations, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, pp 677, 1978
75. KERSHAW WE, DUKE BO, BUDDEN FH. Distribution of microfilariae of O. volvulus
in the skin. Its relation to the skin changes and to eye lesions and blindness. British Medical
Journal i: 724-729, 1954
76. KIRK R. Observations on onchocerciasis in the Bahr-el-Ghazal province of the Sudan .
Annals of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology 41: 357-364, 1947
77. KULZ L, BACH FW. Beiträge zur Kenntnis von Onchocerca volvulus Leuck., 1893.
Centralblatt für Bakteriologie, Parasitenkunde und Infektionskrankheiten, Abteilun g
originale 23: 321-326, 1913
78. LABADIE-LAGRAVE, DEGUY. Un cas de Filaria volvulus. Archives de Parasitologie
2: 451-460, 1899
79. LARIVIERE M, VINGTAIN P, AZIZ M, BEAUVAIS B, WEIMANN D, DEROVIN F,
688 A History of Human Helminthology
377-382, 1932
122. ROUBAUD E, JAMOT E. Présence d' Onchocerca volvulus dans un abcès suspubien.
Quelques précisions morphologiques sur l e parasite. Bulletins de la Société de Pathologie
Exotique et de ses Filiales 13: 252-254, 1920
123. RUIZ REYES F. Tratamiento experimental en la oncocercosis con el "Naphurid e
sodium". Medicina, Mexico 27: 475-477, 1947
124. RUIZ REYES F. Datos historicos sobre el origen de la onchocercosis en America .
Revista Médica Mexicana 32: no. 645, pp 49-56, 1952
125. SANDGROUND JH. Part II. In, Onchocerciasis, with special reference to the Central
American form of the disease, by R P Strong, J H Sandground, J C Bequaert and M M
Ochoa, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachussetts, pp 234, 1934
126. SARKIES JW. Antrypol in the treatment of onchocerciasis. Transactions of the Royal
Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 46: 435-436, 1952
127. SIEGENTHALER R, GÜBLER R. Pararticuläres Nematodengranulom (einheimische
Onchocerca). Schweizerische medizinische Wochenschrift 95: 1102-1104, 1965
128. SILVA R. Ocular onchocerciasis. Southern Medical Journal 25: 113-117, 1932
129. da SILVA ARAUJO AJ. Memoria sobre a filariose ou a molestia produzida pro um a
nova especie de parasita cutanea, Bahia, pp 36-86, 1875
130. van SOMEREN VD, McMAHON J. Phoretic association between Afronurus and
Simulium species, and the discovery of the early stages of Simulium neavei on
fresh-water crabs. Nature, London 166: 350-351, 1950
131. STRONG RP. Onchocerca investigations in Guatemala. Report of progress of th e
Harvard expedition. New England Journal of Medicine 204: 916-920, 1931
132. STRONG RP. Part I. In, Onchocerciasis, with special reference to the Central American
form of the disease, by R P Strong, J H Sandground, J C Bequaert and M M Ochoa ,
Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachussetts, pp 234, 1934
133. de la TORRE I. Sur l'onchocercose au Mexico. Bulletin de l'Office International e
d'Hygiene Publique 23: 2017-2020, 1931
134. TORRES ESTRADA A. Ophthalmoscopic observation of microfilariae in the vitreous
of patients infected with onchocerciasis. American Journal of Ophthalmology 25 :
1445-1448, 1942
135. TORROELLA JL. Contribución al estudio de la onchocercosis de sus manifestiaciones
oculares. Anales del Instituto de Biología. Universidad Nacional de Mexico 1: 201-203,
1930
136. TORROELLA JL. Batallon del ejercito fraces , como probable origen de la onchocercosis
de Mexico y Guatemala. Salud Publica de Mexico Epoca V, vol. 6, no. 3, May-June ,
1964
137. VARGAS L. Algunas consideraciones sobres el desarrollo de Onchocerca volvulus en
los Simulidos. Revista del Instituto de Salubridad y Enfermedades Tropicales, Mexico
3: 57-65, 1942
138. WANSON M. L'Hetrazan dans la période d'invasion de l'onchocercose. Annales de l a
Société Belge de Médecine Tropicale 29: 85-89, 1949
139. WANSON M, COURTOIS L, LEBIED B. L'éradication du Simulium damnosu m
(Theobald) à Leopoldville. Annales de la Société Belge de Médecine Tropicale 29 :
373-403, 1949
140. WANSON M, HENRARD C. Habitat et comp ortement larvaire du Simulium damnosum
Theobald. Recueil des Travaux des Sciences Médicales au Congo Belge 4: 113-121 ,
1945
141. WANSON M, HENRARD C, PEEL E. Onchocerca volvulus Leuckart. Indices
d'infection des simulies aggressives pour l'homme. cycle de développement che z
Simulium damnosum Theobald. Recueil des Travaux des Sciences Médicales au Congo
Belge 4: 122-138, 1945
142. WOODRUFF AW, BARNLEY GR, HOOLAND JT, JONES DE, McCRAE AW ,
Onchocerciasis 691
McLEAN DS. Onchocerciasis and the eye in Western Uganda. Transactions of the Royal
Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 57: 50-63, 1963
1875 O'Neill discovered microfilariae in skin biopsies in West Africans with a skin
condition known as "craw-craw"
1893 Manson reported the personal communication to him by Leuckart of the
discovery by a German doctor in Ghana of adult worms in nodules removed
from the subcutaneous tissues
1916 Robles discovered Onchocerca infection in Guatemala
1917 Robles postulated on epidemiological grounds that Simulium flies may be the
vector of Onchocerca in Guatemala, and suggested a relationship between this
infection and eye disease
1920 Montpellier and Lacroix in Africa once more drew attention to the presence
of microfilaria volvulus in the skin and related this infection to dermatitis
1925 Silva observed a microfilaria in the eye with an ophthalmoscope
1926 Blacklock in Africa described the development of microfilaria volvulus into
infective larvae in S. damnosum, but failed to transmit infection
experimentally to monkeys
1928 Ochoterena demonstrated histologically the presence of microfilariae in the
eye and optic nerve
1930 Torroella observed microfilariae in the cornea and anterior chamber with a slit
lamp
1930 Hoffman showed that species of Simulium were the vectors in Central
America
1931 Hisette emphasized the ocular manifestations of onchocerciasis in Africa
1947 Van Hoof and his colleagues showed that suramin killed adult worms but
various workers found this drug to be very toxic
1948 Mazzotti and Hewitt reported that skin microfilarial density fell after treatment
with diethylcarbamazine, although adult worms were not killed
1948 Mazzotti suggested that the precipitation of a rash by diethylcarbamazine
could be used as a diagnostic method
1949 Garnham and McMahon eradicated flies from a limited focus in Kenya by
applying DDT to streams
1982 Aziz and his colleagues indicated that ivermectin greatly reduced the density
of skin microfilariae
___________________________________________________________________
Chapter 26
SYNOPSIS
Guinea worms have been known since antiquity in parts of Africa and th e
Middle East. The parasite is probably mentioned in the Egyptian Papyrus
Ebers (c.1550 B.C.) 99. Thus, Hoeppli49 believed that the following selectio n
from this papyrus is possibly a description of the treatment of an infection with
Guinea worm; "-----" represents the lesion and cannot be translated wit h
certainty:
If thou examinest a swelling of ----- in any limb of a man, then thou shalt apply a
bandage to it. If thou findes that it goes and comes, piercing through the flesh which
is under it, then thou shalt say concerning it; ----- has entered (?). Thou shalt
perform an operation for it, the same being split with a....knife and seized with an
....instrument (forceps); that which is in its interior is seized with a forceps and then
thou shalt remove it....That which is like the head is seized. 29
It is certainly true that dracunculiasis was endemic in Egypt at the time for the
calcified remains of a Dracunculus have been identified in the mummy of a
693
694 A History of Human Helminthology
one at the side of the other, but one situated at one end, the other one at the other
end, as in some caterpillars. 2. Always one of the two heads appears dead, whereas
the other one appears alive.3
Linnaeus recognized it as a worm and in 1758 in his Systema Naturae, class-
ified the parasite in his Class Vermes, Order Intestina, naming it Gordius
medinensis 71. The specific name, as already inferred, was derived from it s
prevalence around the Arabian city, Medina, as was recorded by Avicenna :
"The disease is commonest at Medina, whence it takes its name" 8.
In the revision by Gmelin of Systema Naturae (thirteenth edition) published
in 1788, the worm was transferred from the free-living species of Gordius to
the genus Filaria of Müller (see chapter 23) and it became known as Filaria
medinensis for some years 43.
Any lingering doubts as to the animal nature, specifically the helminthi c
nature, of the parasite should have been dispelled by the discovery in the early
nineteenth century of the embryos (lar vae) released by the parent worm (as will
be described later). The first detailed description of the worm's anatomy was
published in 1868 by the Englishman, Henry Bastian, and put paid to an y
lingering reservations that D. medinensis was in fact a worm. He examined six
specimens which had been taken from the lower extremities of a Britis h
surgeon in Bombay by a native of that Indian city. The parasites varied i n
length from 18 inches to three feet and macroscopically were:
of a milk-water colour....mostly quite smooth,....cylindrical, more or less flattened
laterally and tapering gradually towards both extremities. About 1/20 of an inch
from the posterior extremity the body becomes more abruptly narrowed, and
terminates usually in a sharply curved tail or point....No vulva discoverable; and
aperture doubtful....The integuments are so elastic, that the worm may be stretched
to nearly twice its natural length.10
Bastian then described the appearance under the low power microscope of the
small head, the lamellar nature of the chitinous integument, four powerfu l
longitudinal muscles, two delicate ganglionated chords extending the whol e
length of the worm, four longitudinal "circulatory vessels" and the gut. All the
worms were female and viviparous. He found th at the reproductive organs were
huge:
The genital apparatus consists of a large, highly organized sac or uterus, distended
with young Filariae and a little fine granular matter. It occupied the whole of the
peritoneal cavity....except from one to two and a half inches from the anterior
extremity and about a quarter of an inch or less from the tail. Both anteriorly and
posteriorly, this sac terminated abruptly in a small tube twisted several times around
the intestine, or forming a knotted glandular-looking mass. 10
In 1879, Fedchenko improved upon the description of the anatomy of the
worm. He found a basal granular layer in the hypodermis which formed th e
outer layers of the integument, discovered some transverse muscle fibres ,
discussed the morphology of the head, excretory system and gut, layin g
particular attention upon the oesophagus and surmising that the worm ingested
food, and concluded that the uterine appendages were ovaries 36.
Dracunculiasis 697
Bastian was intrigued by the failure to find any male worms and speculated
that either the males never attained any great size and therefore failed to attract
attention whereas the enormous development of the genitalia of the female s
made them so large that they became palpable in superficial situations, o r
possibly, that the male worms, in contrast to the females, never entered th e
body. The former hypothesis was proven correct when RH Charles at las t
discovered the male worm. During an autopsy in Lahore, India in 1892, h e
found two nematode worms in the subperitoneal tissues which he regarded as
immature D. medinensis. He went on to say
On examining two....I was struck by seeing something growing from the side of
each of them. This 'something' I found to be a roundworm with the characters of
that to which it was attached. On drawing upon it with forceps I found, to my
astonishment, that it was possible to pull it out of the body of the larger worm from
a small opening near its middle....I did not completely pull it out and only withdrew
it about 1 cm.18
Charles was of the opinion that the "something" was a male Dracunculus but
failed to provide convincing evidence to support his case. A contemporar y
commenator wrote in the British Medical Journal :
Before subscribing to Dr. Charles's views, we should like to see a more detailed
account of the structure of this "something"....Dr. Charles gives no account of the
head, tail, testicle, alimentary canal, spicules, papillae, or any of those features
characteristic of male nematodes. Until these are fully supplied we suspect that
helminthologists will be inclined to regard Dr. Charles's supposed male filaria
medinensis as being probably a hernia or the uterus or alimentary canal of the
female....It is quite possible however, that Dr. Charles in right of his views; but in
bringing them forward the least he could have done, in justice to himself and in the
cause of science, was to use every means in his power to justify the position he
assumes and to make it unassailable. It is not too late yet if he has the interesting
specimens he so meagrely describes in his possession. 7
Subsequently, Leiper (1906) found two male worms about 22 cm long in
an infected monkey 61. Surprisingly, he never provided a detailed description of
their morphology yet he did not encounter the censure that Charles ha d
received. The first substantial account of the morphology of the mal e
Dracunculus was provided in 1937 by Moorthy 86.
In his discussion of the anatomy of the Guinea worm in 1863, Bastia n
remarked that he doubted the propriety of considering the worm as a species
of the genus Filaria. Of the many names which had been used to designate the
worm previously such as "de vena medinensis" 133, "de dracunculo Persarum" 57
and "de verme medinensis" 46, two of these "dracunculus" (derived from th e
Latin word "draco" meaning "snake", "serpent" or "dragon") and "medinensis"
were adopted into binary nomenclature (i.e. Dracunculus medinensis ) by
Cobbold in his text book of the following year 20. In 1915 by Opinion 66, th e
International Commission on Zoological Nomenclature approved this name ,
Dracunculus medinensis being the type of species of the genus Dracunculus 53.
The first person to use the name "Dracunculus" after 1758 (the starting point
for binary nomenclature following the appearance of the tenth edition o f
698 A History of Human Helminthology
Linnaeus's Systema Naturae) had been Reichard in 1759 115, and it was this
name which was given official sanction. This was later disputed by Leiper ,
however, on the ground that Reichard only used it in a vernacular sense in his
thesis. Leiper applied the same criticism to the use by Gallandat in his thesis in
177342 of the term "medinensis" to modify "dracunculus". Despite Leiper' s
objections and his attempt to change the name to Füllebornius medinensis 65,
the official name Dracunculus medinensis (Linnaeus 1758) Gallandat 177 3
still stands.
With respect to its common name of Guinea worm, Sir James Tennent ,
Colonial Secretary of the British Government in Ceylon (Sri Lanka) wrote:
these pests in all probability received their popular name of Guinea worm from the
narrative of Bruno or Braun, a citizen or surgeon of Basle, who about the year
1611, made several voyages to that part of the African Coast, and on his return,
published amongst other things, an account of local diseases. 127
The belief that Guinea worm was acquired from water was embedded deeply
in the folk-lore of the inhabitants of many endemic areas. This was accepte d
and reported by a number of European adventurers who began visiting suc h
regions in the sixteenth century. The Dutch navigator, Jan van Linschoten ,
journeyed to the East Indies and on his return to Holland wrote a number o f
books which became very popular and were translated into many Europea n
languages. In 1584, he had visited Hormuz (Ormus, Ormusz) in the Gulf o f
Oman (Persian Gulf) and wrote: "There is in Ormus a sickness or commo n
plague of wormes, which growe in their legges, it is thought that they proceede
of the water they drink"73. Van Linschoten also noted that the place was so hot
that the inhabitants slept at night immersed except for their heads in troughs of
water and "Thus it comes about that they are infected by worms, which grow
in their legs, and are two or three feet long" 73. Thus, not only did Linschote n
recognize an association with water, but he appears to have canvassed the two
ideas which were to become a recurring theme over the next three centurie s
concerning the acquisition of infection - ingestion of worms and penetration of
worms through the skin.
About the middle of the seventeenth century, Monseigneur de la Mott e
Lambert, Bishop of Beirut, undertook a pastoral tour of the Middle East and a
record of his experience was published. He found that in the town of Lau i n
Persia (Iran):
the water....is very bad and the cause of severe and mortal diseases. To this bad
water supply throughout the country between Lau and Gomeron may be attributed
worms of a prodigious length which engender in their thighs and legs 12
In the latter part of the same centu ry, a British traveller to the East Indies stated
in the Philosophical Transactions , concerning the Guinea worm with whic h
he had been afflicted: "These worms are bread by the water, between Gomroom
Dracunculiasis 699
In the three years between 1868 and 1871, The Russian naturalist, Alekse j
Fedchenko, and his wife lived in Turkestan , Samarkand and Tashkent in central
Asia. It was during this period that he made his original observations on D.
medinensis. Fedchenko made arrangements in 1869 with one of the loca l
doctors to provide him with Guinea worms extracted recently from infecte d
persons. His first attempt to study the fate of the embryos failed when he killed
them by adding fresh well water which was rather cold and was rich in lim e
salts. He then told how:
an incident helped me in my research....On the 5th of July, in the small bottle in
which (the doctor) had brought a guinea worm, I noticed a pair of small water
crayfish - the Cyclops. Placing them under the microscope, I saw in each one several
familiar looking embryos of the guinea worm.36
In order to convince himself that the embryos of the Guinea worm reall y
entered the Cyclops, he performed an experiment. He punctured a Dracunculus
and placed the embryos in a watch glass. He then added water and Cyclops
which he had assured himself were free of any larvae. Although he did no t
succeed in determining whether the embryos were ingested or whether the y
penetrated the cuticle of the Cyclops, he discovered that "after several hours a
significant number of embryos appeared in most of them, especially in males
and particularly in young specimens" 36. Fedchenko found that there wer e
usually five or six larvae lodged in the body cavity of each minute crustacean.
He watched the evolution in the appearance of the worms over the succeeding
weeks. During the first few days, the gut became more developed, then afte r
two weeks the larva moulted and lost it s tail. By three weeks, the differentiation
of the internal organs had become more pronounced with the rudiments of the
reproductive organs appearing. Finally, Fedchenko provided an illustration of
a larva after a sojourn of one month in the crustacean. He presented his findings
to a meeting of the Imperial Society of Friends of Natural Sciences ,
Anthropology and Ethnography in Moscow on 21 January 1870, his pape r
being published later that year in the Proceedings of the Society 36
Fedchenko wrote that at the beginning of his studies he had placed Drac-
unculus larvae in a small aquarium containing different water animals in th e
hope that Guinea worm, like so many other parasites, would live first in some
such animal then pass on to man. He made no mention in his paper, however,
that he had been advised by others to follow any particular line of enquiry .
Indeed, by recounting the incident of 5 July, he implies that his initia l
observation with Cyclops was serendipitous. This does not seem to be a n
accurate portrayal of the preceding events, however, for Leuckart 67 remarked
that he had met Fedchenko in 1868 and had advised him to look for th e
development of D. medinensis in Cyclops because of the similarity between its
Dracunculiasis 703
embryo and that of Cucullanus elegans, a parasite of perch, the life cycle o f
which Leuckart had already work out and publis hed in 1865. Cobbold, who had
met Fedchenko when the latter visited London in 1873 later wrote:
It is only fair to add that the Russian traveller was led up to his discovery by the
previous investigations of Leuckart concerning the young of Cucullanus. The
Leipsig helminthologist had, indeed, specially instructed Fedschenko as to the
probable source of Dracunculus. It is often thus that science makes its clear
advances, since a master-mind is needed to set others on the right track. 21
A more important, but undoubtedly erroneous, criticism of Fedchenko' s
contribution was expressed by Manson-Bahr in his textbook in 1966 when he
wrote:
Fedchenko (1869) is credited with the discovery of the transmission of the guinea
worm, but probably Manson was the original observer (1895). Leiper believes that
the stages figured by the former are those of Cucullanus (a parasite of fish), not of
D. medinensis.83
In fact, Leiper had been much more circumspect than this. He had merel y
observed that Fedchenko's paper, published in Russian in 1870, was ver y
inaccessible and that two of the illustrations of purported Dracunculus given
in Leuckart's textbook 67 were undoubtedly based upon a specimen of a
Cucullanus larva66. Manson-Bahr's statement brought forth a response fro m
Hughes in defence of Fedchenko. He arranged for Fedchenko's paper to b e
translated and summarized it by saying that w hatever the defects in Fedchenko's
drawings, his written account was convincing enough 52. Final confirmation of
the validity of Fedchenko's discovery was provided shortly thereafter whe n
Muller published a reproduc tion of Fedchenko's original drawings and showed
that it undoubtedly represented a D. medinensis third stage larva 92.
Although Fedchenko discovered that D. medinensis larvae grew and
moulted in the crustacean, Cyclops, he was unable to complete the cycle o f
transmission. He posed a rhetorical question, then went on to postulate, with
accurate foresight, the subsequent course of events:
What then happens to the embryos at a later stage? It seems to me that, taking into
consideration the known facts concerning the development of other roundworms,
one can state the following: Cyclops, with the embryo, enter the stomach of man
through drinking water; here, under new conditions, further development occurs
pertaining primarily to the genitals. The differentiation of males and females occurs,
and copulation takes place. Thereafter, the males die; however, the females, to
develop their offspring, take off by unknown means, toward the skin where they
place themselves subcutaneously.36
In support of this hypothesis, Fedechenko drew attention to a multiplicity
of diverse observations: all specimens studied so far were female; Pruner i n
Egypt had discovered a worm in the liver; the head of the worm pointe d
towards the skin; the fact that in Asia the infection occurred only where th e
inhabitants were forced to drink stagnant water and that these people, i n
contrast to the Hindus of India, did not go barefoot and rarely bathed but, i n
accordance with Muslim custom, washed their face and hands five times each
704 A History of Human Helminthology
a full-grown female worm from the calf of a gibbon 15. Four years later, Issajev
in the Soviet Union reported that in a series of experiments between 1927 and
1932, he had infected 42 dogs orally and obtained female worms from 27 o f
them54. In 1936, Moorthy and Sweet confirmed this result by indicating tha t
they had produced patent infections in a number of dogs. Furthermore, the y
recovered a large number of male and female worms 88,90. It was this latter
experiment which finally provided a definitive description of the male worm,
thus completing all the major links in the life-history of D. medinensis.
It remained to define the route of migration of worms within the body of the
definitive host. Onabamiro (1956) could find no trace of worms in dogs until
43 days of infection, when he found them par ticularly in the axillae and inguinal
regions, thus suggesting that they may have migrated there via the lymphati c
system97. Muller then investigated the early route of infection in dogs, cats and
monkeys; he found larvae in the duodenal wall 13 hours after infection, in the
abdominal mesentery for up to twelve days, then in the thoracic and abdominal
muscles at two weeks. He thought it likely that a moult took place and th e
worms migrated to the axillary and inguinal subcutaneous tissues. The mal e
worms died between three and five months after infection and became encysted
while the female worms began moving down the extremities between the eighth
and tenth months 93,94
infections in two Englishmen who had been exposed in the Sudan twelve plus
or minus several months previously 82. In the following year, Powell reported an
event in which 16 Indians were exposed during a three day period from 20-22
April 1902. The first worm appeared in the first patient on 3 April 1903 (h e
discharged eight more over the next three months). Six more of the party were
similarly afflicted between 1 May and 20 May 1903, giving incubation periods
ranging between 345 and 437 days104. A somewhat shorter pre-patent period
was reported by Wurtz and Sorel. In March 1911, they paid a visit of thre e
hours to a village in the Ivory Coast where they noticed many cases of drac -
unculiasis; 260 days later, two of their se rvants were found to be infected 134. All
these observations left little doubt that a period of approximately one year was
required between acquisition of infection and the presentation of the adul t
female worm.
The clinical manifestations of dracunculiasis have been apparent for all to see
since time immemorial. At the beginning of the second millenium AD ,
Avicenna succinctly described the condition:
The signs of this condition are as follows. A pustule first appears and swells up, but
afterwards contracts down again to a mere bleb. Soon, however, the bleb perforates
and dark red matter is continuously exuded. In the meanwhile a vermicular move-
ment can be distinguished beneath the skin. For the most part it is the legs that are
involved, but I have seen cases in which the hands and even the sides are affected....
Should the worm be ruptured, much pain and trouble ensue, and even if rupture
does not take place, the condition is tiresome enough. 8
In the late seventeenth century, Lister, an English traveller recounted vividly his
own experiences. He related that he had known some sufferers who had been
bed-bound for up to ten months, and that there were some who had lost their
legs, or even their lives. He recognized that the severity of the disease wa s
increased enormously if the worms were broken during their extraction:
A few days after my arrival....the fruit of my journey showed themselves; for a little
below the instep of my left foot, a worm put out his head....When mine first came
out, for about 40 to 50 days, it came out every day little by little, without putting me
to too much pain, but that I could go up and down till it was come out about a yard
and a quarter; but afterwards, one day stirring too much, I hurt the worm and
enraged him, so that he broke off of himself, and going in, caused my foot and leg
(up to the calf) to swell till the skin was ready to burst, which kept me sleepless and
cast me into a fever. I had a chirurgeon and kept my bed for about 20 days in which
time I had several fits of the said fever.74
One thing above all struck most observers, and that was the remarkabl e
frequency with which the worms presented in the feet. In 1805, McGregor in
India reported that in 87% of h is series of 181 patients the worms were located
in such a situation78, and this observation has more or less held true in al l
708 A History of Human Helminthology
in India and found almost 30% infected. Nearly two thirds of these people had
had more than one attack, and 10% of them had had ten or more attacks over
the years112. Similarly, Reddy and colleagues studied 10,000 villagers in th e
South Indian Deccan where infection rates ranged between 11 and 53%. They
found that multiple infections, reinfections, and superinfections were frequent,
thus suggesting that no immunity developed 113.
The diagnosis of Guinea worm infection is usually obvious when the wor m
makes it appearance in the ulcer. If any doubt remains, some fluid exuded by
the worm can be obtained and examined microscopically for the pathog -
nomonic larvae. Patrick Manson in 1895 described the remarkable manner in
which such a collection may be obtained:
Squeeze a little cold water from a sponge so that the stream should fall on the sound
skin within an inch or two of the guinea-worm ulcer; at the same time watch the
little hole....at the centre of the ulcer. In a few seconds a droplet of whitish fluid will
be seen to well up in the little hole, or a delicate tube will be protruded from it for
an inch or more, and then suddenly rupture.81
Manson believed that the worm pro lapsed a portion of its uterus an inch or two
at a time through the mouth then it burst but Leiper denied this, saying that the
uterus protruded through an opening just outside the circumoral ring o f
papillae62.
Diagnosis in the stage before rupture of the blister and presentation of the
head of the worm may be made, as was done by Turkhud in his experimental
infections of a human, by aspiration of fluid from the blister then examining it
for the presence of larvae 131.
Calcified worms may be seen on radiographs as shown by Connor 23 and by
Dimier and Bergonie 25, both in 1918, but localization of living worms i s
unsatisfactory as they are radiolucent. Hudellet (1919) rendered them radio -
opaque by injection of 10% collargol into the worm 51, then Roussel achieved
a similar effect by the injection of lipiodol 120.
As in other systemic helminth infections, eosinophilia is characteristic o f
dracunculiasis, this first being shown by Billet in 1896 11. A variety of
immunological assays have been described, with Ramsay introducing an intra-
dermal test in 1935 110 and a complement fixation test being described i n
1940126.
patient unbearably thirsty, but the dehydration made it easy to wind out th e
worm unruptured 117. In 1919, Jeanselme gave three intravenous injections of
novarsenobenzol to a young Senegalese soldier then a few days later a dea d
worm was extracted. He was uncertain whether the arsenic had a direct action
on the worm, however, as no trace of the metal could be found in the worm 56;
arsenicals did not prove subsequently to be effective. Macfie (1920) though t
that intravenous injections of tartar emetic (sodium antimony tartrate) recently
introduced for the therapy of schistosomiasis had a beneficial effect 77, but
Fairley and Liston later showed that the drugs had no action on either the adult
worm or the embryos contained therein 34. In 1942, Elliot claimed that injections
of phenothiazine (which had recently been recommended for the treatment of
enterobiasis) each week for four weeks assisted in the removal of worms 30, but
this therapy did not become generally accepted either.
No significant advances were made until Raffier in 1965 showed that oral
niridazole cured 70% of 71 patients on the Ivory Coast within seven days 106,107.
Two years later, he also showed that thiabendazole was useful in the treatment
of 234 patients in the same country 108. In 1970, Pardanani and Kothari found
that metronidazole appeared useful 100. Muller then investigated the actions of
these drugs and found that the worms appeared normal on histologica l
examination and that the larvae developed normally in Cyclops. He concluded,
therefore, that their effective ness was due to an anti-inflammatory action which
facilitated the mechanical removal of the worms 95. More recently, Shafei
showed that mebendazole was effective in dracunculiasis, but that its actio n
differed from the other drugs because it killed the worm 123.
Many of the epidemiological observations o ver the past several centuries which
led to the formulation of various theories on the mode of transmission o f
dracunculiasis have been discussed. These occurrences became comprehens-
ible with the demonstration that Guinea worm infection was transmitte d
through the agency of a water crustacean. Although species of Dracunculus
closely related to D. medinensis have been described in various animals ,
humans seem to be the only important host of this worm.
Dracunculiasis is now restricted to parts of Africa, the Middle East and the
Indian subcontinent. In former times, however, it was prevalent in the Wes t
Indies and parts of South America. Hirsch (1885) wrote concerning thes e
countries:
All the authorities....agree that dracontiasis was quite unknown before the
importation of the negro. With the suppression of the slave trade, the disease fell to
a minimum or disappeared altogether.48
The first person to draw attention to the infection in the Western Hemisphere
appears to have been Don Diego Rodriguez de Valdes y de la Vanda, Spanish
712 A History of Human Helminthology
REFERENCES
from the abdominal cavity of man. Scientific memoirs by medical officers of the Army of
India 7: 51-56, 1892. Abstracted in British Medical Journal ii: 1151, 1892
19. CHISOLM C. An essay on the malignant pestilential Fever introduced into the Wes t
Indian Islands from Boullam, on the coast of Guinea as it first appeared in 1793, 1794,
1795 and 1796, second edition, two volumes, pp 105, 1801. Also, On the Mali s
Dracunculus or Guinea-worm (in Grenada). Edinburgh Medical and Surgical Journal 11:
145-164, 1815
20. COBBOLD TS. Entozoa: an introduction to the study of helminthology with reference,
more particularly, to the internal parasites of man, Groombridge and Sons, London, p p
480, 1864
21. COBBOLD TS. Parasites: a treatise on the entozoa of man and animals including some
account of the ectozoa, J&A Churchill, London, pp 508, 1879
22. COLE J. Buried treasure. British Medical Journal ii: 1412-1413, 1979
23. CONNOR FP. Notes on cases of surgical interest. I. Inflammatory conditions due t o
calcified remains of Guinea-worms. Indian Medical Gazette 53: 297-299, 1918
24. DICK F. The treatment of Guinea-worm. British Medical Journal ii: 207-208, 1880
25. DIMIER, BERGONIE J. Recherche du filaire de Médine par la radiographie. Archives
d'Électricité Médicale et de Physiotherapie 26: 337-341, 1918
26. DUKE J. Note on the symptoms of Filaria medinensis or Guinea worm. Indian Medical
Gazette 30: 64-65, 1895
27. DUNCAN A. Observations on Dracunculus. Transactions of the Medical and Physica l
Society of Calcutta 7: 273-281, 1835
28. DUTT C. Cited in British Medical Journal i: 488-489, 1880
29. EBBELL B. The Papyrus Ebers, the greatest Egyptian medical document, translated by
B Ebbell, Levin and Munksgaard, Copenhagen, pp 135, 1937
30. ELLIOT M. A new treatment for dracunculiasis. Transactions of the Royal Society o f
Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 35: 291-301, 1942
31. FAIRLEY NH, LISTON WG. Studies in the pathology of dracontiasis. Part I. India n
Journal of Medical Research 11: 915-932, 1924
32. FAIRLEY NH, LISTON WG. Studies in the transmission of Dracunculus medinensis -
a negative experiment. Part II. Indian Journal of Medical Research 12: 93-104, 1924
33. FAIRLEY NH, LISTON WG. Studies in dracontiasis. Part IV. The clinical picture. An
analysis of 140 cases. Indian Medical Gazette 12: 351-367, 1924
34. FAIRLEY NH, LISTON WG. Studies in dracontiasis. Part V. Observations an d
reflections on intravenous medication with special reference to tartar emetic. India n
Medical Gazette 12: 369-374, 1924
35. FAULKNER AS. Electrolysis in the treatment of Dracunculus. British Medical Journal
ii: 1280-1281, 1883
36. FEDCHENKO AP. (Concerning the structure and reproduction of the Guinea wor m
[Filaria medinensis L.].) Izvestiia Imperatorskago Obshchestva Liubitelei Estestvoznaniia
Antropologii i Ethnografii - Mo skva, 8 columns 71-81, 1870. In Russian. Translated in 58
37. FERG. Jahrbuch der deutschen Medicin p 151, ?1801. Cited in 48
38. FORBES D. Extracts from the half yearly reports of the diseases prevailing at Dharwar
in the 1st grenadier regiment, N.I. for the year 1836. Transactions of the Medical an d
Physical Society of Bombay 1: 215-225, 1838
39. FORBES JG. Medical report of the Anglo-French Boundary Commission on the western
frontier of the Gold Coast Colony, Janu ary 1902-May 1903. Saint Bartholomew's Hospital
Reports, London 39: 171-187, 189-205, (1903) 1904
40. FOX T. Notes on unusual or rare forms of skin disease. I. Case of Guinea-worm disease.
Lancet i: 330-331, 1879
41. GALLANDAT DH. Lettre sur le dragonneau, ou veine de Médine et sur l'usage d u
sublime corrosif dans cette maladie. Journal de Médecine, Chirurgie, Pharmacie etc. 12:
24-28, 1760
42. GALLANDAT DH. Dissertio de dracunculo sive vena medinensis. Nova Act a
716 A History of Human Helminthology
66. LEIPER RT. Landmarks in medical helm inthology. Journal of Helminthology 7: 101-118,
1929
67. LEUCKART R. Die menschlichen Paras iten und die von ihnen herrührenden Krankheiten.
Ein Hand- und Lehrbuch für Naturforscher und Aertze, CF Winter'sche Verlagshandlung,
Leipzig, volume 2, pp 882, 1867-1876
68. LIND J. An essay on diseases incidental to Europeans in hot climates, with the method of
preventing their fatal consequences etc., T Becket and PA de Hondt, London, pp 348 ,
1768
69. LINDBERGH K. Dracunculose en Iran. Archiv für Schiffs- und Tropen-Hygiene 40 :
330-342, 1936
70. LINDBERGH K. Dracunculose dans l'état de Djodhpour (Radjpoutana), Inde. Bulletin de
la Société de Pathologie Exotique 39: 318-328, 1946
71. LINNAEUS C. Systema naturae per regna triae naturae, secundum classes, ordines ,
genera, species, cum characteribus, differentiis, synonymis, locis, tenth edition, L Salvii,
Holmiae, two volumes, pp 823, 1758
72. LINNAEUS C. Cited in 91
73. van LINSCHOTEN JH. Vera descriptio regni par s Indiae Orientalis in qua Johan. Hugonis
Linstscotani navigatio in Orientem. Teucrides Annaeus Lonicer, Frankfort, 1599. Original
Dutch edition, Voyage ofte Schripaert van JHLvL naer Oost ofte Portugaels Indiens etc.,
Amstelredam, 1596. Partly translated in 124
74. LISTER M. Part of a letter from Fort St. George, in the East Indies, giving an account of
the longworm which is troublesome to the inhabitants of those parts. Philosophica l
Transactions of the Royal Society of London 19: 417-418, 1697
75. McCLELLAND. Remarks on Dracunculus. Calcutta Journal of Natural History 1 :
359-371, 1840
76. McCONNELL RE. Dracontiasis or dracunculias is: a review. Journal of Tropical Medicine
and Hygiene 17: 337-340, 1914
77. MacFIE JW. Intravenous injection of tartar emetic in Guinea-worm infections. Lancet i:
654-655, 1920
78. McGREGOR J. A memoir on the state of health of the 88th regiment, and of the corp s
attached to it, from the 1st June 1800 to the 31st May 1801 as originally presented to the
Medical Board, Bombay. Edinburgh Medical and Surgical Journal 1: 266-289, 1805
79. MACKAY G. The Guinea-worm. British Medical Journal i: 610, 1880
80. MAISONNEUVE JG. Note sur un dragonneau observé à Paris, et présenté à la Société
de Chirurgie. Archives Générale de Médecine 6: 472-480, 1844. Abstracted in Lancet i:
153-153, 1845
81. MANSON P. On the Guinea-worm. British Medical Journal ii: 1350-1351, 1895
82. MANSON P. The life-span of Filaria medinensis . British Medical Journal ii: 10, 1903
83. MANSON-BAHR PH. Manson's Tropical diseases, sixteenth edition, Baillière, Tindall
and Cassell, London, pp 1131, 1966
84. MEYER. Cited in 91
85. MILNE J. In, Extracts from a correspondence on the Filaria medinensis among some of
the medical officers of the Honourable East India Company's service at Bombay; with a
letter from Dr. Robert Grant, professor of comparative anatomy in the University o f
London. Edinburgh Medical and Surgical Journal 35: 112-118, 1831
86. MOORTHY VN. A redescription of Dracunculus medinensis . Journal of Parasitology 23:
220-224, 1937
87. MOORTHY VN. Observations on the development of Dracunculus medinensis larvae in
Cyclops. American Journal of Hygiene 27: 437-460, 1938
88. MOORTHY VN, SWEET WC. A note on the experimental infection of dogs wit h
dracontiasis. Indian Medical Gazette 71: 437-442, 1936
89. MOORTHY VN, SWEET WC. A biological method for the control of dracontiasis. Indian
Medical Gazette 71: 565-568, 1936
90. MOORTHY VN, SWEET WC. Further notes on the experimental infection of dogs with
718 A History of Human Helminthology
BC Guinea worms have been known since antiquity in endemic areas but their nature was
controversial. Mechanical extraction was practised
1819 Rudolphi described the larvae (embryos) of Dracunculus
1834 Jacobson rediscovered the first-stage larvae
1868 Bastian made a detailed description of the anatomy of the adult female worm
1869 Fedchenko observed that embryos developed with the body cavity of the crustacean,
Cyclops
1880 Mackay described an epidemic of dracunculiasis in Indian troops and suggested that the
incubation period was 8-12 months
1892 Charles claimed to find male adult worms in the retroperitoneal tissues at autopsy
1894 Manson confirmed Fedchenko's observations on development withinCyclops
1906 Leiper showed that hydrochloric acid, simulating gastric juice, stimulated the activation
of larvae and their release from Cyclops
1906 Leiper fed infected Cyclops to monkeys and recovered 3 immature female and 2 small
male Guinea worms at autopsy 6 months later
1914 Turkhud administered infected Cyclops to 5 volunteers; one person developed
dracunculiasis one year later
1937 Moorthy provided the first detailed account of the male adult worm
1956 Onabamiro studied the route of migration of parasites in experimentally infected
animals
1965 Raffier showed that niridazole assisted the extraction of worms
1967 Raffier showed that thiabendazole assisted the extraction of worms
1970 Pardanani and Kothari reported that metronidazole assisted the extraction of worms
1976 Shafei claimed that mebendazole kills Guinea worms
___________________________________________________________________
Chapter 27
This Capillaria-like parasite of the skin and nasal mucosa of monkeys in Asia
and Africa was discovered by Swift, Boots and Miller in 1922 and name d
Trichosoma cutaneum 327. In 1958, it was renamed Anatrichosoma cutaneum
by Chitwood and Smith 67. A human case of creeping eruption of the skin due
to infection with this worm was reported by Morishita and Tani in Japan i n
1960225.
A. BRAZILIENSE
This parasite was first recovered from the intestine of dogs and cats b y
Gomes de Faria in Brazil in 1910 who called it Ancylostomum braziliense 130.
With the acceptance of Ancylostoma as the generic name for this group o f
hookworms, it became known as Ancylostoma braziliense . For many years,
there was controversy concerning the relationship between this worm an d
A. ceylanicum, with the eventual acceptance that they were different specie s
(see chapter 20).
Contrary to A. duodenale, A. ceylanicum and Necator americanus,
A. braziliense does not complete its development in humans, but it is the major
cause of the clinical syndrome called cutaneous larva migrans. This syndrome
appears to have been first described by Robert Lee in an address to the Clinical
Society of London in 1874, although the worm involved in that particular case
will never be precisely known:
The morbid appearance consists of a fine line on the left side of the abdomen, which
stretches in a convoluted manner across the side. It appears to consist of a narrow,
reddish, slightly-elevated line, much resembling to the touch what would be
produced by a bristle underneath the epidermis....It was said to have begun as a fine
line on the right ankle, which gradually travelled up the thigh on to the abdomen,
where it was at first in the right side, and during the last three weeks has travelled
across to the left.172
The anonymous reporter in The Lancet who wrote the above also commented
that this was:
721
722 A History of Human Helminthology
a remarkable case of Skin Disease in a child, the nature of which had given rise to
much diversity of opinion amongst those who had seen it, and on which there was
not much light thrown by the members of the Society. 13
and concluded that a commission had been appointed to investigate the cause.
In 1892, Crocker also in England, saw a similar case and, suspecting that an
insect larva may be the cause, proposed the term "creeping eruption" 80. In
1895, Samson-Hammelstjerne showed that the larva of the fly, Gasterophilus,
was one cause of this condition 292.
The disease was particularly prevalent in the southeastern United States of
America and in 1926, Kirby- Smith and his colleagues held a clinic in Jackson-
ville, Florida and saw 179 cases in the space of ten days. More than half o f
these patients were thought to have acquired their infection at the beach. A
larval nematode was seen in skin biopsies; they named it Agamonematodium
migrans pending the discovery of the adult worm 162. The histological sections
were submitted to Ransom at the US Bureau of Animal Industry and he gave
the guarded opinion that they were third-stage larvae of the super-famil y
Strongyloidea. White and Dove then implicated A. braziliense as the cause of
the condition by studies in animals and by applying A. braziliense larvae to
human skin experimentally 345, then this was confirmed by Shelmire wh o
infected 18 volunteers experimentally 303. The distribution of infection on th e
body noted many years before by Lee was typical, for Dove (1932) reviewed
301 cases in Florida and showed that the lo wer limbs were afflicted in 76%, the
hand and arms in 14% and the trunk in 9% of cases. He noted that movement
of the larvae was very slow, each one moving only several millimetres per day,
and sometimes continuing for weeks or months 97. In 1953, Muhlesein reported
that eventually the cutaneously-migrating larvae may pass to the deeper tissues
and cause pneumonitis 228.
Initially, the condition was treated, usually with success, by freezing o r
cauterizing the skin overlying the advancing larva. In 1943, Smith claimed that
antimony (Fouadin) was effective in a child with multiple infections 309 but
Blank could not confirm this observation 40. Burks and Kingery believed tha t
chloroquine was valuable 48 but it was supplanted by thiabendazole when th e
efficacy of this drug was demonstrated by Stone and Mullins in 1965 321.
A. CANINUM
A. MALAYANUM
This hookworm was first recovered from a bear and described as Helarctos
malayanus by Alessandrini in 1905 7. Infection in humans has been reporte d
once357.
ANGIOSTRONGYLIASIS
ANGIOSTRONGYLUS CANTONENSIS
In 1935, Chen recovered thi s worm from the respiratory tract of a rat caught in
Canton, China and named it Pulmonema cantonensis 64. In 1946, Dougherty
transferred it to the genus Angiostrongylus of Kamensky158 naming it
Angiostrongylus cantonensis 96. The generic name is derived from a
combination of the Greek words (ANGEON) and
(STRONGYLOS) meaning "vessel" and "round", respectively. The life cycle
was first described by Mackerras and Sandars in Australia in 1955. The y
reported that eggs hatched in the lungs of the rodent host then the larva e
migrated up the trachea and were swallowed then expelled in the faeces. The
larvae then infected a molluscan intermediate host within which they became
infective larvae in about two weeks. When ingested by the definitive host, the
infective larvae migrated to the brain and moulted twice. The young worm s
about 2 mm long, then migrated to the lungs and began laying eggs about four
weeks after infection 196. Many species of slugs and several species of lan d
snails as well as a planarian, crabs, fresh-water prawns and frogs have bee n
found infected with third-stage larvae, these non-molluscs serving as paratenic
hosts. Most human infections are thought to have been acquired by ingestion
of undercooked specimens of the giant African land snail, Achatina fulica.
The first infection in a human was repo rted by Nomura and Lin (as Haemo-
strongylus ratti) in Taiwan in a 15 year old boy with suspected meningitis from
whom six young adult worms were identif ied in the cerebrospinal fluid, but this
report was buried in the Japanese literature for many years 28,238. The first
well-documented fatal case in a human was reported by Rosen and hi s
colleagues in 1962287 following the investigations of Rosen into the cause o f
eosinophilic meningitis in Tahiti and Hawaii. The circumstances surrounding
the implication of A. cantonensis in this condition have been a subject of recent
controversy8,286. By 1979, 259 cases were known to have occurred in Taiwan 63.
The worm is a common cause of eosinophilic meningitis, most cases having an
incubation period of about three weeks and being relatively mild in severity and
self-limiting in duration. Occasionally, worms have been visualized in the eye,
either in the anterior chambe r or vitreous 260. Rarely, worms have been found in
human lung355, but patent infections with production of eggs and excretion of
larvae have not been reported thus far. The diagnosis is best made by recovery
724 A History of Human Helminthology
of the worm. Alicata and Brown were of the op inion that skin testing was useful
in ruling out the diagnosis but that a positive reaction could not be relied upon
because of cross-reactivity with other helminths 9. Treatment is largely
symptomatic, headache often being relieved by removal of cerebrospinal fluid
at lumbar puncture. Thiabendazole was reported as being active against these
worms in experimental animals 82, but did not seem to be effective in humans 152.
In any case, it has been suggested that killing the worms could exacerbate the
inflammatory reaction with undesirable consequences in infected patients .
Worms have been removed surgically from the eye.
A. COSTARICENSIS
uncertain since raw slugs are not generally eaten in endemic regions. They may
be consumed accidentally or possibly larvae may leave the slug in the mucus
and thus contaminate fruit and vegetables. Treatment with thiabendazole has
been recommended by Loria-Cortes and Lobo-Sanahuja 189.
ANISAKIASIS
CAPILLARIASIS
CAPILLARIA AEROPHILA
This common parasite of the respiratory mucosa of cats, dogs, foxes and some
other carnivores in many parts of the world was found in a fox and described
as Trichosoma aerophilum by Creplin in 1839 78. It was renamed Thominx
aerophila by Dujardin in 1845 99 then transferred to the genus Capillaria of
Zeder359 by Travassos in 1915 to become Capillaria aerophila 333. The generic
name is derived from the Latin word "capillus" meaning "hair'. The eggs ar e
coughed up, swallowed and discharged in the faeces; after six week or so they
become infective and infection of a new host occurs after their ingestion .
726 A History of Human Helminthology
C. HEPATICA
C. PHILIPPINENSIS
In 1963, eggs of a Capillaria species were found in the faeces of a man who
had been admitted to hospital in the Philippines with malabsorption syndrome.
He died three days later and autopsy revealed worms in the small and larg e
Miscellaneous Nematode Infections 727
intestines68. In 1967, an illness causing seve re disease and sometimes death was
reported in Ilocos Sur Province of the Philippines; subsequent investigations
revealed Capillaria eggs in the stools of most patients 49. This led to Chitwood,
Valesquez and Salazar in the following year describing the adult worms, 3-4
mm long, and naming the parasite Capillaria philippinensis 69. In 1973, a focus
of infection was discovered in Thailand 256. In 1972, Cross and his colleagues
indicated that monkeys had been infected experimentally by feeding the m
freshwater fish and suggested that autoinfection may occur 81. It was shown that
eggs passed in the faeces required almost two weeks to embryonate and tha t
development to the infective larval stage in the fish intestinal mucosa took at
least three weeks 35,81. In humans, the adult worms together with larvae and eggs
have been found in the small intestine, especially the jejunum, and in heav y
infections a severe enteropathy with malabsorption and wasting is produce d
which not infrequently leads to death in a few weeks to months 50,90. Whalen and
his colleagues showed that thiabendazole was partially effective in intestina l
capillariasis344, then Singson and co-workers found that mebendazole wa s
considerably more effective 305.
This genus was erected by Diesing in 1861 94. The worm has been recovere d
once from a human; it was found in a conjunctival nodule in a Filipino farmer 4.
In 1912, Railliet and Henry raised the genus Contracaecum to house certain
species of nematode parasites of reptiles and fish 275. In 1967, Schaum and
Müller described larvae, identified as Contracaecum osculatum , in an
eosinophilic granuloma in the intestine of a patient in Germany who ha d
symptoms of peritonitis. The infection was thought to have been acquired by
eating imperfectly cooked fish in the Baltic. Cure was obtained wit h
thiabendazole 298.
This hookworm parasite of the large intestine of rats was described by Adams
in Malaya in 1933 2. Infection in a human has been reported once 34.
728 A History of Human Helminthology
This parasite, commonly known as the giant kidney worm, was known t o
Redi279 but was described by Goeze in 1782 and called Ascaris renalis by
him126 . Goeze's specimen was recovered from a dog but the worm has sinc e
been found in many carnivores. In 1802, Collet-Meygret called it in a
vernacular fashion, a dioctophyme 77. Rudolphi in 1802 labelled it Strongylus
gigas 289 then in 1851 Diesing renamed it Eustrongylus gigas 93. It was known
by this designation for many years. In 1901, Stiles argued that it should b e
called Dioctophyma renale 318, and despite some opposition, his view event-
ually prevailed when it was endorsed by the American Society of Parasitol -
ogists in 1941 (Journal of Parasitology 27: 279, 1941).
Eggs are excreted in the urine and are ingested by aquatic oligochaetes in
which they develop to the infective larval stage. Mammals can be infecte d
directly by ingestion of infected oligochaetes, but more commonly they ar e
taken up first by amphibia or fishes which are in turn ingested by the definitive
host197.
Only a small number of humans have been infected with this worm which
measures up to a metre in length and is ab out 5 mm in diameter. In 1860, Beale
in his review of parasitic infections of the urinary tract wrote:
The parasite appears to have been found in the human kidney on one occasion,
although Küchenmeister comes to the conclusion that it has never been met with.
The specimen is preserved in the College of Surgeons. 23
Blanchard reviewed the literature in 1886 and regarded only nine human cases
as authentic. One of the first presumptive cases reported in the Englis h
literature was described by Cannon in 1887 51. Most proven cases have bee n
diagnosed at autopsy or a worm has been expelled through the urethra. On e
case has been reported in which an immature worm was identified in a nodule
on the chest wall 30.
The genus Dipetalonema was erected by Diesing in 1861 94. Immature worms
have been found in humans on several occasions including in an arm nodule 27
and in the eye26. These parasites may have been D. arbuta described by Highby
in 1943143 or D. Sprenti described by Anderson in 1935. In 1932, Owen and
Hennessey in Uganda reported the presence of small yellow nodules in th e
bulbar conjunctiva together with proptosis and periorbital oedema in som e
patients247. Poltera255 considered that these were Loa infections, but they may
have been Dipetalonema or Mansonella parasites 25.
Miscellaneous Nematode Infections 729
This genus was erected by Cobb in 1913 73 to house certain species of free -
living worms which live in decaying organic matter. Humans are infected very
rarely. Yokogawa found D. coronata in the urine of an elderly patient 356.
Chandler observed this species in the stomach contents of 9 achlorhydri c
patients58 who had presumably ingested them in decaying vegetable matter.
DIROFILARIASIS
DIROFILARIA IMMITIS
This worm was found in the heart of a dog and described as Filaria immitis by
Leidy in 1856 in the United States of America 173. The microfilariae reported in
dog blood by Gruby and Delafond in 1843 132 and later named by them Filaria
papillosa haematica canis domestica 133 may have been D. immitis 340,341 . In
1911, Raillet and Henry 272 erected the genus Dirofilaria and transferred the
parasite to it, it thus becoming known a s Dirofilaria immitis. The generic name
is derived from a combination of the Latin words "dirus" and "filarium "
meaning "cruel" and "ball of thread", respectively. It is transmitted b y
mosquitoes including Anopheles maculipennis 131 and Culex quinquefasciatus
(= fatigans)19. Occasional infections have occurred in humans with incomplete
development of the worm. Faust and his colleagues first described this in 1941
following the discovery of a worm in the vena cava of a woman in Ne w
Orleans111. In most cases since then, however, worms have been lodged in a
branch of the pulmonary artery and many have been found by a routine chest
X-ray70. They have rarely been found in the abdominal cavity 328, the eye95, and
subcutaneous tissues 37.
D. TENUIS
This parasite of the cutaneous tissues of the raccoon in the United States o f
America was described by Chandler in 1942 59. Many infections of the eye or
eyelid reported from the USA as due to D. conjunctivae may have been really
due to D. tenuis 241. In a number of other patients, the worms have presented as
subcutaneous tumours (reviewed in 115).
D. REPENS
This parasite of the subcutaneous tissues of dogs was described by Railliet and
Henry in 1911274. It is transmitted by mosquitoes such as Aedes aegypti33 .
Human infection was first reported b y Skrjabin and his colleagues in the USSR
in 1930; a worm was recovered from a subcutaneous nodule near the eye 307.
730 A History of Human Helminthology
Many cases of D. conjunctivae infections reported from Europe and Asia may
in fact have been D. repens infections.
D. URSI
GNATHOSTOMIASIS
GNATHOSTOMA SPINIGERUM
This parasite was discovered by Richard Owen in 1836 in the stomach wall of
a tiger which had died in the London Zoological Gardens. He erected a ne w
genus, Gnathostoma, derived from a combination of the Greek words
(GNATHOS) and µ (STOMA) meaning "jaw and "mouth", respectively,
to house this species which he named Gnathostoma spinigerum ; the specific
epithet reflects the rings of spines on the parasite's head 248.
Almost 100 years were to pass before inroads were made into an under -
standing of the life cycle of this worm. In 1912, Mitter found the parasite in a
cat, dog and leopard 212, then Chandler in 1925 reported finding the worm i n
10-30% of cats examined post-mortem in India 56. He also noted finding
encysted larvae in the mesentery of Indian snakes (rock python and cobra) 57.
Several years later, Heydon described the development in water of G. spini-
gerum eggs obtained from an infected cat and observed spontaneous hatching
of larvae142. In 1933, Prommas and Daengsvang in Thailand reported that they
had shown experimentally that Cyclops was the first intermediate host; th e
larvae forced their way into the body cavity of the copepod and moulted after
Miscellaneous Nematode Infections 731
10-14 days to become second-stage larvae 257. They were unable to infect cats
with infected Cyclops but showed that a second intermediate host was required.
When the freshwater fish, Clarias batrachus, ingested infected Cyclops, the
second-stage larvae escaped and migrated to the tissues where they moulte d
again to become infective third-stage larvae 258. They then completed the lif e
cycle experimentally by infecting cats with infected fish 259. Africa and his
colleagues in the Philippines then re ported (in a paper dated October 1936, but
which seems to have been published somewhat later since it did not arrive at
the Bureau of Hygiene and Tropical Diseases in London until 17 March 1938)
that they had found encysted gnathostome larvae in the flesh of three species of
naturally-infected freshwater fi sh, then recovered adult G. spinigerum from the
stomach nodule of a presumably "clean" cat which had been fed larvae obtained
from an infected fish, Glossobius giurus 5. Daengsvang and Tansurat i n
Thailand then showed that natural inf ections occurred in over 90% of the frogs,
Rana rugulosa, 80% of the eel, Monopterus albus, and 30-40% of the
freshwater fishes, Ophiocephalus striatus and Clarias batrachus, that they
examined86. Miyakazi indicated in 1954 that he had found infective larvae i n
crayfish, crabs, amphibia, reptiles, fish and many mammals that had eaten fish
flesh, but that the larvae only matured to the adult stage in the stomach of dogs
and felines after a migration through the tissues 213. The various hosts of
infective third-stage larvae, probably including man, may become infecte d
either by ingestion of infected Cyclops or by the consumption of anothe r
infected vertebrate (i.e. a paratenic host) 84. Humans are thought to be usually
infected by eating poorly-cooked infected fish or domestic birds (ducks an d
chickens). In Thailand, many living infective larvae are found in a kind o f
fermented food made from the raw flesh of freshwater fish which is a favourite
dish of Thai women 83, while in Japan, "sashimi", the sliced raw flesh of animals
or fish, is enjoyed frequently 214.
The first human infection with this parasite was described by Levinson in
1889. The worm was remove d from an abdominal tumour in a Thai woman by
Dr Deunzer in Bangkok and forwarded to Levinson who named it Cheir-
acanthus siamensis 183. It was transferred to the genus Gnathostoma, becoming
G. siamense, by Railliet in 1893 263, and was then shown to be synonymous with
G. spinigerum by Leiper180. The larvae may migrate throughout the huma n
body. Their presence may become manifest when they appear superficially ,
either causing an abscess 204,293, or migrating through the subcutaneous tissues
producing a form of cutaneous larva migrans 142,329 or migratory oedema 283. The
worm often attempts to extrude itself, often through the skin, but also via the
mucous membrane of the oral cavity 283, respiratory tract and urinary tract. I n
one patient who had transient swellings for seven years and then had a worm
removed from an abscess in his right hand, swellings continued intermittently
for another ten years until a second worm was extracted; Maplestone and Rao
thought it likely that the worm had lived for 17 years 205. In 1945, Mukerji and
Bhaduri reported the extraction of a worm from the anterior chamber of a n
732 A History of Human Helminthology
eye229, then the same patient seems to have b een described by Sen and Ghose 302.
When the parasites migrate through the deeper tissues, they may produc e
visceral larva migrans. The first fatal case recorded was described b y
Chitanondh and Rosen in 1967; a Thai woman developed a progressiv e
ascending paralysis and a worm was found in the spinal cord at autopsy 65.
Larvae may also migrate through the brain to produce an eosinophili c
meningoencephalitis 47,261.
The diagnosis is made by recovery of the worm but immunoassays, partic-
ularly skin tests, may be valuable 214. Treatment is by surgical removal. Effective
chemotherapy has not yet been demonst rated although ancylol, a compound not
available for human use, has been shown to be effective against migratin g
larvae in cats 85.
G. HISPIDUM
This species was first described by Leiper in 1909 who received the specimen
obtained from a human infected in Trinidad 177. The name is derived from a
combination of the Greek words (LAGOS), (CHEILOS), and
(ASKARIS, ASCARIS) meaning "hare-lipped" and "worm" ,
respectively; this reflects the deep median depression in each lip which gives
the parasite the form of a harelip. This worm has not yet been identified i n
animals and the life cycle is uncertain. The infection has been reported i n
humans a number of times. In most instances it has been recovered from th e
tissues of the head and neck with colonies of adult worms, eggs and larvae in
various stages of development being found in abscesses or nodules whic h
develop over months or years 42. Recently, a fatal case of encephalitis has been
described285. Variable success has been achieved with diethylcarbamazine 98,171,
thiabendazole 217,239 and levamisole 42.
This parasite of the upper respiratory tract of cattle and felines, commonl y
known as "gapes" was recovered from an ox and described by Railliet in 1899
who named it Syngamus laryngeus, the specific epithet reflecting its location
in the host265. In 1948, Rizhikov transferred the worm to the genu s
Mammomonogamus 282. The life cycle of this worm is uncertain. In 1913 ,
Leiper recorded the discovery by King in St. Lucia, West Indies of a male and
female worm which were coughed up by a woman, with a chronic cough .
Leiper named the parasite Syngamus Kingi 179,180. It was later considered to be
synonymous with M. laryngeus, although Buckley believed S. Kingi to be
synonomous with S. nasicola von Linstow, 1899 45. Hoffman in 1931 recounted
removing a red object from the posterior wall of the pharynx of a patient who
had had a continuous cough since visiting a farm several weeks previously; it
proved to be a pair of M. laryngeus in copula 144. Mornex and colleagues have
recently reviewed human Mammomonogamus infections and indicated that 78
cases have been reported, mostly from Central America and the Caribbean 226.
734 A History of Human Helminthology
MANSONELLIASIS
MANSONELLA OZZARDI
F. ozzardi concluded that they were one and the the same worm:
I am inclined to believe that all are filaria Demarquayii; that is to say, that the filaria
Demarquayii of St. Vincent, and that discovered by me in St. Lucia, and the
sharp-tailed form of filaria Ozzardi (British Guiana) are identical. 120
In 1899, Daniels reported finding an adult female worm and a portion of a n
adult male worm which differed from the adult F. perstans (which he had
described the previous year) at the autopsy of patient who had had microfilaria
perstans and microfilaria ozzardi in his peripheral blood. They were foun d
lying free in the subperitoneal connective tissues of the anterior abdomina l
wall. He described the parasites, comparing them with F. bancrofti and F.
perstans and concluded:
The differences observed both in the male and female are sufficient, I consider, to
differentiate this from the other described adult filariae. The name 'Filaria Ozzardi'
might be retained for the new species.89
Later that year Galgey found two parental forms of F. demarquayi in the
mesentery of an infected patient in St Lucia 121. He sent them to Ozzard i n
British Guiana for identification, but owing to imperfections in the specimens,
Ozzard was not able to come to any definite conlusion. In 1902, Low reported
that he had compared microfilaria demarquayi from St. Lucia, Dominica and
St. Vincent and microfilaria ozzardi from British Guiana, and had concluded
that they were identical 190. With the recognition that F. demarquayi and
F. ozzardi were synonymous, the correct name appeared to be Filaria
demarquayi since Manson had described this parasite first in his original 1897
paper. Since this name had already been used for W. bancrofti by Zune361,
however, Railliet proposed the designation F. juncea 266. Leiper pointed out,
however, that the second name given by Manson, F. ozzardi, had priority 180. In
1914, Biglieri and Araoz found a microfilaria in persons living in the province
of Tucumán in northern Argentina, and named it microfilaria tucumani 36; this
parasite was also later shown to be synonymous with microfilaria ozzardi 337.
In 1929, Faust erected the genus Mansonella in honour of Manson, with this
parasite as the type and only species 108. When Chabaud and Bain reclassified
the Dipetalonema group in 1976, they omitted M. ozzardi as they considered
it insufficiently known for taxonomic consideration 55. In 1982, Orihel and
Eberhard redescribed the species and redefined the genus using materia l
obtained by infection of experimental monkeys ( Erythrocebus patas)242.
Low in 1901 attempted to determine the vector of the parasite by exposing
infected patients to Culex fatigans (= quinquefasciatus), Stegomyia fasciata
(= Aedes aegypti), C. taeniatus and Anopheles albipes, but found that they
were refractory to infection. Subsequently, he caught and dissected a variety of
blood-sucking insects feeding on inhabitants in a heavily endemic area o f
British Guiana, but with negative results 190. In 1933, Buckley in St. Vincen t
indicated that microfilaria ozzardi was taken up by and developed in gnats of
the genus Culicoides 45, especially C. furens 46. Many years later, Nelson and
Davies showed that C. phlebotomus was a vector in Trinidad 231, while the
736 A History of Human Helminthology
M. PERSTANS
behind the abdominal aorta. Manson comp ared this with the nematode from the
Americas described by Daniels and determined that they were the one and the
same, thus proving that Daniels had indeed discovered the adult form of F.
perstans 14. This opinion was supported soon afterwards by Low 191.
Thereafter, changes in the nomenclature of this parasite became rather like
a game of musical chairs. In 1912, Railliet, Henry and Langeron 276 transferred
it to the genus Acanthocheilonema which had been raised in 1870 b y
Cobbold75, thus becoming Acanthocheilonema perstans . However, Yorke and
Maplestone357 considered that Acanthocheilonema was a synonym of Dipetalo-
nema erected by Diesing in 1861 94, so it became known as Dipetalonema
perstans. In 1935, Faust 109 described the genus Tetrapetalonema and Yeh354
then Chabaud and Bain in 1976 55 placed it in this genus, the worm thus being
described as Tetrapetalonema perstans . This fashion was evanescent ,
however, for in 1982, Orihel and Eberhard redefined the genus Mansonella
and transferred this worm into that genus 242; it is therefore known currently as
Mansonella perstans.
Analogy with other filarial parasit es suggested that this worm was probably
transmitted by insect intermediate hosts but a number of years were to pas s
before this was proven. An interesting but odd exchange over the transmission
of infection took place at the beginning of the present century. The unorthodox
Charlton Bastian postulated that F. perstans was really a member of the genus
Tylenchus which contained nematode parasites of plants, and suggested tha t
infection was acquired by eating bananas 20. This brought a fulsome response
from Low who may have thought that Bastian himself was bananas: "filari a
perstans has nothing to do with the genus Tylenchus nor do bananas play any
part in the distribution or spread of this filaria" 192. Not to be outdone, Bastian
returned to the fray adducing various arguments 21 which were once more
refuted by Low 193.
In 1908, Fülleborn succeeded in achieving some development of microfil-
ariae in Anopheles maculipennis 118. In 1921, Sergent and Gouillon reported
unsuccessful attempts to infect Culex pipiens 301, but in 1927 Dyce Sharp in a
preliminary note announced the development of F. perstans in Culicoides
grahami 103. In the following year, he provided a more formal and detaile d
description of the events, with the product ion of infective larvae eight days after
experimental infection of C. austeni 104. In 1952, Hopkins and Nicholas showed
that C. grahami was a possible but poor vector when compared with C.
austeni 146.
Initially, Manson ascribed no pathological consequences to M. perstans
infection, but then transiently entertained the idea that it might be the cause of
sleeping sickness200,201. This possibility was banished, however, when th e
different geographical distributions of the two conditions were established and
the trypanosomal aetiology of the illness was ascertained. In 1903, Low wrote:
Filaria perstans, like filaria Demarquayii, gives rise to no pathological symptoms, the
position of the worms in the connective tissues of the mesentery apparently causing
738 A History of Human Helminthology
no harm.191
Although there have been occasional claims to the contrary 71,219,227,323, most
commentators have upheld this view. The diagnosis is made by finding th e
microfilariae in the blood. Diethylcarbamazine has little action on the worm 139
but mebendazole may be active 338.
M. STREPTOCERCA
In 1922, JW Macfie and TF Corson on the Gold Coast (Ghana) found micro-
filariae in the skin of 22 out of 50 healthy adults which could be distinguished
from those of Onchocerca volvulus by having a slender body, crook-shape d
posterior end, and a blunt tail. Sections of the skin showed that they were lying
in the dermis and were surrounded by a slight degree of cellular infiltration .
MacFie and Corson placed these worms in the genus Agamofilaria of Stiles320
and named them Agamofilaria streptocerca 195. The same parasites were found
later by Dyce Sharp in 1927 in the British Cameroons (Cameroon) 102 then by
other observers in West and Central Africa. Like M. perstans, this parasite has
had a complex nomenclatural history. In 1949, Faust 110 transferred it to the
genus Acanthocheilonema of Cobbold 75 thus naming the worm
Acanthocheilonema streptocerca. Meanwhile, Peel and Chardome 251 in 1946
had reported the discovery of two female worms and a fragment of a mal e
worm in a chimpanzee (Pan paniscus) in the Belgian Congo (Zaire) and had
placed the parasite in the genus Dipetalonema of Diesing94, naming it
Dipetalonema streptocerca. In 1976, Chabaud and Bain 55 transferred it to the
genus Tetrapetalonema of Faust109 to become Tetrapetalonema streptocerca .
Finally, Orihel and Eberhard 242 in 1982 considered that Tetrapetalonema was
synonymous with Mansonella and renamed the parasite Mansonella
streptocerca.
The adult female worm was first di scovered in human tissue by Meyers and
his colleagues in 1972 209, then they found the adult male in 1977 211.
Chardome and Peel showed in 1949 that this parasite was transmitted by
Culicoides grahami 60, then Duke100 proved that C. milnei was also a vector.
The infection may be asympyomatic but some dark skinned persons presen t
with itching and hypopigmented macules. Meyers and colleagues reported that
diethylcarbamazine kills microfilariae in the tissues and produces degenerative
changes in adult worms 210.
In 1973 Orihel and Esslinger described Meningonema peruzzii which had been
collected from three monkeys (Cercopithecus talaporn )243. The generic name
is derived from a combination of the Greek words µ (MENINX) and
µ (NEMA) meaning "membrane" and "thread", respectively. The sam e
Miscellaneous Nematode Infections 739
worms had been reported by Peruzzi in 1928 in Uganda 253. Orihel240 then
suggested that these worms were the true cause of the meningoencephaliti s
attributed by Dukes and his colleagues to Dipetalonema (= Mansonella)
perstans 101.
M. BOLIVARENSIS
This unsheathed microfilaria was found i n the blood of American Indians living
in a remote part of Venezuela and reported by Godoy and colleagues in 1980 125.
M. RODHAINI
This infection was first described from the chimpanzees Pan paniscus and Pan
satyrus by Peel and Chardome in Zaire in 1946 251. Microfilaria indistinguish-
able from this parasite were seen in skin biopsies of people in Gabon b y
Richard-Lenoble and colleagues in 1982 281.
M. SEMICLARUM
In 1974, Fain reported the finding of a dis tinctive unsheathed microfilaria in the
blood of 52 inhabitants in three villages in Zaire. He named this parasit e
microfilaria semiclarum because it had a long, clear region on the posterior half
of the body106. The adult worms, reservoir host, and life cycle are unknown.
This species was described by Anderson and Bemrick in 1965 from thousands
of worms found in bilateral tu mours in the nares of a horse in the United States
of America 12. The generic name is derived from a combination of the Gree k
words µ (MIKROS, MICROS) and µ (NEMA) meaning "small" and
740 A History of Human Helminthology
This hookworm parasite of pigs was designated Necator suillis by Ackert and
Payne in 19231. Buckley in 1932 infected himself on 11 separate occasion s
with infective larvae (about 80 worms each time) prepared from eggs obtained
from N. suillis recovered from pigs at an abbatoir in Trinidad. Eggs were first
seen 54 days after the first application to his skin and continued to be passed
over the next four months. Only three adult worms were recovered afte r
treatment with oil of chenopodium 44.
cribed by Stossich in 1905 322; some of these may be synonyms of each other.
The first human infection was found in a person from the Omo River in East
Africa 268, then Leiper reported O. apiostomum infection in man after the
parasite was collected by Foy in Nigeria 178. More recently, Anthony an d
McAdam reviewed 34 cases seen in Uganda. The most common presentation
was as a mass in the ileocaecal re gion although nodes or abscesses, usually 1-2
cm in diameter, may be seen in other parts of the small and large bowel 15.
Operative intervention may be necessary to effect the diagnosis or to reliev e
intestinal obstruction. No anthelmintics have yet been shown to be effective.
Miscellaneous Nematode Infections 741
This worm was found in the ileum of a patient in the Caucasus and name d
Physaloptera caucasica by von Linstow in 1902 186. The generic name is
derived from a combination of the Greek words (PHYSALIS) and
(PTEROO) meaning "bubble" and "wing", respectively. In 1907 ,
Leiper also described a worm that had been removed from the stomach of a
person in Uganda and named it P. mordens 176. He later suggested that monkeys
may be the reservoir of infection180. The worms, 2-10 cms long, live with their
head embedded in the mucosa of the alimentary tract anywhere between th e
oesophagus and the ileum, but they may also be found in the liver. The infection
is rare in humans although Vandepitte and colleagues in 1964 reported finding
five cases in Zaire in one year. These patients complained of vomiting an d
epigastric pain and eggs were found in their faeces336. Another patient has been
described recently in whom worms that were probably Physaloptera caused
gangrene of the distal small bowel 235. The life cycle of this worm is unknown
and the treatment of the infection is uncertain.
742 A History of Human Helminthology
This genus was erected by von Frölich in 1802 117. The worms are normall y
parasites of rodents and bats but an adult female worm has been seen in New
York in a human appendix 161.
This parasite of wolves and dogs was named Strongylus lupi by Rudolphi 291 in
1809 then transferred to the genus Spirocerca of Raillet and Henry 273.In 1959,
Biocca reported the case of an infection of a baby who had been born on e
month prematurely and had developed intestinal obstruction and peritonitis as
a consequence of worms embedded in her terminal ileum 38. It is believed that
the mother must have ingested an infected beetle while pregnant.
This parasite of the large intestine of several simian species was described as
Triodontophorus deminutus by Raillet and Henry 267 in 1905 then renamed
Ternidens deminutus by them in 1909 270. The generic name Ternidens is
derived from a combination of the Latin words "ter" and "dens" meanin g
"thrice" and "tooth", respectively, and indicates the presence of three complex
teeth in the buccal cavity.
Infection of a woman with this parasite was reported by Leiper in 1908 175.
In 1929 Sandground recovered T. deminutus-like eggs from the faeces of a
medical missionary who had spent 25 years in Africa, cultured larvae, an d
produced an experimental infection in a vo lunteer, although he failed to recover
adult worms after carbon tetrachloride treatment 294. In a subsequent survey in
Miscellaneous Nematode Infections 743
Southern Rhodesia (Zimbabwe), he found that in some regions more than 50%
of the population were infected 295. He attempted to transfer infection to more
humans and to subhuman primates but failed, as did Goldsmid many year s
later 127. Sandground used carbon tetrachloride and tetrachlorethylene i n
treatment. More recently, thiab endazole128 and pyrantel embonate 129 have been
shown to be effective.
This genus was erected by Leiper and Atkinso n in 1914 to house certain worms
collected by Atkinson during the ill-fated British Antarctic Expedition o f
1910-1913 led by Captain Scott 182. The genus was named after the ship (itself
named "Terra Nova" meaning "new land") which took the party to th e
Antarctic. The life cycle is probably similar to that of Anisakis.
The first human infections were reported in Japan in 1972 by Suzuki and
his colleagues who described 5 patients in whom a larva was seen penetrating
the gastric mucosa 325. Koyama and colleagues then described the morphology
of the larvae removed from these patients 166. The infections were thought t o
have been acquired by eating raw fish. A number of similar cases have bee n
reported since. Some of these may b e due to infection with Phocanema species
since the larvae of this genus, erected by Myers 230 in 1959, are
indistinguishable from those of Terranova.
T. CALLIPAEDA
This worm, 5-17 mm in length, which was found in a dog, was described b y
Railliet and Henry271 in 1910. The generic name is derived from the Gree k
word (THELAZO) meaning "to suck". In 1917, Stuckey 324 and
147
Houghton in China described infections of the human eye with a worm they
identified as Filaria palpebralis. Leiper, however, considered that the parasite
was almost certainly T. callipaeda 181, an opinion which was shared by Faust 107,
the latter describing the male worm for the first time and showing that rabbits
were a host. The life cycle is uncertain but other species of Thelazia use flies
(Musca, Fannia) as intermediate hosts. According to Kagei and colleagues, 30
cases have now been reported from Japan 155. The worm usually causes littl e
conjunctivitis but often stimulates marked tear production. Movement over the
corneal surface can cause corneal opacities. The worm may be removed with
forceps after anaesthesia of the eye.
744 A History of Human Helminthology
T. CALIFORNIENSIS
This species has been recovered from a number of animal and bird hosts i n
California. It was first described by Kofoid and Williams 164 in 1935 after two
worms, 10-13 mm long, were removed from the eye of a doctor wh o
complained of an irritation in his eye; he remembered that some flying insect
had hit his eye ten days previously. Several cases have been reported since.
TOXOCARIASIS
TOXOCARA CANIS
Institute of Pathology had described an ocular disease which she called nema-
tode ophthalmitis. She discussed a large series of cases, mostly of children ,
from whom an eye had been enucleated because of a suspected diagnosis o f
retinoblastoma. Histological examination, however, revealed eosinophili c
granulomas, and in 24 of 46 such specimens, nematode larvae were found in
serial sections. A number of the m were examined by BG Chitwood who wrote:
"So far as can be determined on the basi s of the material at hand, the specimens
are third stage hookworm larvae" 66. Wilder remarked sagaciously, however ,
that the fact that the larvae in these cases had been identified as being probably
those of hookworms did not rule out other nematodes such as Strongyloides
and Ascaris as possible causes of this endophthalmitis. Most of the childre n
came from the southeastern USA and Wilder concluded:
The findings of intraocular larvae by serial sectioning and the identification of the
specific pathologic reaction that they evoke has led to the conclusion that nematodes
play an important and hitherto unrecognized role in blindness in children 347
In 1952, Beaver and his colleagues, Snyder, Carrera, Dent and Lafferty, in
New Orleans described three patients with hepatomegaly, anaemia and eosin-
ophilia, in one of whom a larva was seen in a liver biopsy. Consequently, they
coined the term "visceral larva migrans" to distinguish it from cutaneous larva
migrans caused by larvae of Ancylostoma braziliense and other parasites in the
skin. By utilizing serial sections, it was pos sible to reconstruct almost the whole
of the worm and it was concluded that it "resembled the infective stage o f
Toxocara canis or T. cati" 29. Mice were thereupon infected with T. canis and
T. cati eggs and worms similar to that found in the human case wer e
demonstrated subsequently in histological sections 29. In the following year, "by
means of an experiment which cannot be commended" 349, Smith and Beaver
produced the disease experimentally in humans. They administered orally 200
embryonated eggs of T. canis to two mentally defective children aged two and
three years, respectively; both developed eosinophilia and some degree o f
hepatomegaly311. This result was confirmed in a human volunteer by Chaudhuri
and Saha in 1959 62. In 1956, Nichols re-examined five of Wilder's cases and
identified the larvae in the eyes as those of Toxocara 233,234, then in 1959, Irvine
and Irvine reported finding T. canis larvae in the eye of a child in California 150.
By 1981, over 1900 cases of toxocariasis had been reported from many parts
of the world and most of these have been due to T. canis but a few have been
caused by T. cati 124.
Infection in humans is usually acquired by ingestion of eggs in the soil .
Toxocara ova were found in soil samples of 45% of dooryards in New Orl -
eans140 and in 24% of public parks in Britain 41. Infection is therefore common
in children who ingest soil (pica). The diagnosis may be established by finding
larvae in biopsy specimens but this is often difficult. Immunodiagnostic assays
are therefore valuable. A precipitin test was described in 1956 by Heiner and
Kevy141 and a skin test a few years later 351. More recently, Matthes and Buch-
walder considered a microprecip itation test using live larvae as the most useful
746 A History of Human Helminthology
T. CATI
TRICHOSTRONGYLIASIS
In 1892, Giles in India recov ered a worm which he named Strongylus colubri-
formis from nodules in the intestine of a sheep 123. In the following year, Railliet
described S. instabilis 263 then in 1896 he also described S. probulurus 264. In
1905, Looss erected the genus Trichostrongylus, transferred S. instabilis and
S. probulurus into it, and described a new species, T. vitrinus 188. The generic
name is derived from a combination of the Greek words (THRIX)
[combining form - (TRICHO-)] and (STRONGYLOS)
meaning "hair" or "thread" and "round", respectively. In 1911 Ranso m
transferred S. colubriformis into the genus Trichostrongylus 278. Other species
described were T. axei 269, T. orientalis 153, T. skrjabini 157 and T. brevis 245. All
of the above species are now known to infect humans.
In 1925, Koino reported that T. orientalis infections in mice seemed t o
follow the same route through the lungs as do hookworms. Although infection
could be established percutaneously, he believed that oral infection was th e
usual and more efficient mode of infection 165. Monnig218 then Hasegawa137
Miscellaneous Nematode Infections 747
showed, however, that after oral infection, s ystemic migration did not occur; the
larvae migrated into the mucosa and matured in about three to four weeks.
The first human infection with a Trichostrongylus species was reported by
Looss in 1895 who described infection with the worm he named Strongylus
subtilis 187. Later Lane168 showed that S. subtilis was synonymous with S.
colubriformis described by Giles in 1892 123 so Looss's name lapsed in favour
of T. colubriformis. Initially, such infections were regarded as accidental i n
those who kept close proximity with animals. Eventually, however, it wa s
realized that human infection was much more frequent in many parts of th e
world than had hitherto been suspect ed. For example, Kalantarian found a 15%
prevalence in Armenia 156, Stewart showed that 70% of the population in one
part of Iran was infected 316, Lawless and colleagues reported a 70% infection
rate in an Egyptian village 170, and Otsuru observed a frequency of 40% in parts
of Japan245. Infection may persist for years; Sandground described one patient
in whom the infection had laste d for at least 8.5 years 296. These various surveys
revealed that in the vast majority of patients, infection produced no ill-effects.
The diagnosis of trichostrongyliasis is made by finding eggs in the faeces,
although specific identification depends upon recovery of the adult worms .
Otsuru showed in 1962 that bephenium hydroxynaphthoate was effective 245,
then thiabendazole 206 and pyrantel pamoate 122 were also found to be useful.
This hookworm parasite of dogs was described by Railliet in 1885 262. Patent
infections do not develop in humans but Fülleborn in 1927 showed by exper-
imental infection of his own skin that it may cause cutaneous larva migrans 119.
REFERENCES
1. ACKERT JE, PAYNE FK. Investigations on the control of hookworm disease. XII .
Studies on the occurrence, distribution and morphology of Necator suillis including
descriptions of the other species of Necator. American Journal of Hygiene 3: 1-25, 1923
2. ADAMS AR. Report on a collection of nematodes from the Federated Malay States .
Annals of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology 27: 1-13, 1933
3. ADDARIO C. Su di un nem atode dell'occhio umano. Annali di Ottalmologia, Milano 14:
135-148, 1885
4. AFRICA CM, GARCIA EY. A new nematode parasite ( Cheilospirura sp.) of the eye of
man in the Philippines. Journal o f the Philippine Islands Medical Association 16: 603-607,
1936
5. AFRICA CM, REFUERZO PG, GARCIA EY. Further observations on the life cycle of
Gnathostoma spinigerum. Philippine Journal of Science 61: 221-225, 1936
6. AFTANDELIANS R, RAFAAT T, TAFFAZOLI M, BEAVER PC. Pulmonary capillariasis
in a child in Iran. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 26: 64-71, 1977
7. ALESSANDRINI GC. Su di alcune uncinariae parasite dell'uomo e di altri vertebrati.
Bolletino della Società dei Naturalisti in Napoli, second series, 6: 23-48, 1905
748 A History of Human Helminthology
8. ALICATA JE. Priority in determining the cause and method of human infection in cases of
eosinophilic meningitis in Tahiti. Tropical Medicine and Hygiene News 35: 111-114, 1986
9. ALICATA JE, BROWN RW. Preliminary observations on the use of an intradermal test
for the diagnosis of eosinophilic meningoencephalitis in man caused by Angiostrongylus
cantonensis. Canadian Journal of Zoology 40: 119-124, 1962
10. ANDERSON RC. Description and relationships of Dirofilaria ursi Yamaguti, 1941 and
a review of the genus Dirofilaria Railliet and Henry, 1911. Transactions of the Roya l
Canadian Institute 29: 25-64, 1952
11. ANDERSON RC. Keys to genera of the superfamily Metastrongyloidea. CIH keys to the
nematode parasites of vertebrates, No. 5, Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux, Farnham
Royal, Slough, U.K., 1978
12. ANDERSON RV, BEMRICK WJ. Micronema deletrix, n. sp., a saprophagous nematode
inhabiting a nasal tumour of a horse. Proceedings of the Helminthological Society o f
Washington 32: 74-75, 1965
13. ANONYMOUS. Lancet ii: 803, 1874
14. ANONYMOUS. The parental form of Filaria perstans. British Medical Journal i: 429,
1899
15. ANTHONY PP, McADAM IW. Helminthic pseudotumou rs of the bowel: thirty four cases
of helminthoma. Gut 13: 8-16, 1972
16. ASAMI K, WATANUKI T, SAKAI H, IMANO H, OKAMOTO R. Two cases o f
stomach granuloma caused by Anisakis-like larval nematodes in Japan. American Journal
of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 14: 119-123, 1965
17. AUR RJ, PRATT CB, JOHNSTON WW. Thiabendazole in visceral larva migrans .
American Journal of Diseases of Children 121: 226-229, 1971
18. BANCROFT TL. On the whipworm of the rat's liver. Journal and Proceedings of th e
Royal Society of New South Wales 27: 86-90, 1893
19. BANCROFT TL. On some further observations on the life-history of Filaria immitis,
Leidy. Journal and Proceedings of the Royal Society of New South Wales 37: 254-257,
1903. Reprinted in British Medical Journal i: 822-823, 1904
20. BASTIAN HC. Note on the probable mode of infection by the so-called Filaria perstans,
and on the probability that this organism really belongs to the genus Tylenchus (Bastian).
Lancet i: 286-287, 1904
21. BASTIAN HC. The anatomical characters of the so-called Filaria perstans and on the
mode of infection thereby. Lancet i: 643-644, 1904
22. BAYLIS HA, PAN TC, SAMBON JE. Some observations and experiments in northern
Italy. A preliminary note. Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 28: 413-419, 1925
23. BEALE L. A course of lectures on urine, urinary deposits and calculi. IV. Third class of
urinary deposits: entozoa. British Medical Journal ii: 1007-1008, 1860
24. BEAVER PC. Zoonoses, with particular reference to parasites of veterinary importance.
In, Biology of parasites, E.J. Soulsby (Editor), Academic Press, New York, pp 215-227,
1966
25. BEAVER PC, JUNG RC, CUPP EW. Clinical parasitology, ninth edition, Lea an d
Febiger, Philadelphia, pp 825, 1984
26. BEAVER PC, MEYER EA, JARROLL EL, ROSENQUIST RC. Dipetalonema from the
eye of a man in Oregon, U.S.A. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 29:
369-372, 1980
27. BEAVER PC, ORIHEL TC. Human infection with filariae of animals in the United States.
American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 14: 1010-1029, 1965
28. BEAVER PC, ROSEN L. Memorandum o n the first report of Angiostrongylus in man, by
Nomura and Lin, 1945. American Journal o f Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 13: 589-590,
1964
29. BEAVER PC, SNYDER CH, CARRERA GM, DENT JH, LAFFERTY JW. Chroni c
eosinophilia due to visceral larva migrans. Pediatrics 9: 7-19, 1952
30. BEAVER PC, THEIS JH. Dioctophymatid larval ne matode in a subcutaneous nodule from
Miscellaneous Nematode Infections 749
a man in California. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 28: 206-212,
1979
31. BEHRER MR. Hypereosinophilia with eosino philic granuloma of the liver associated with
Ascaris infection. Journal of Pediatrics 38: 635-640, 1951
32. BELLINGHAM O'BRIEN. On an undescr ibed species of human intestinal worms. Dublin
Medical Press 1: 103-104, 1839
33. BERNARD PN, BAUCHE J. Conditions de la propogation de la filariose sous-cutanée
du chien. Stegomyia fasciata hôte intermédaire de Dirofilaria repens . Bulletins de la
Société de Pathologie Exotique et de ses Filiales 7: 89-99, 1913
34. BHAIBULAYA M, INDRANGARM S. Man, an accidental host of Cyclodontostomum
purvisi (Adams, 1933), and the occurrence in rats in Thailand. Southeast Asian Journal of
Tropical Medicine and Public Health 6: 391-394, 1975
35. BHAIBULAYA M, INDRANGARM S, ANANTHAPRUTI M. Freshwater fishes o f
Thailand as experimental intermediate hosts for Capillaria philippinensis . International
Journal for Parasitology 9: 105-108, 1979
36. BIBLIERI R, ARAOZ JL. Contribución al estudio de una nueva filariosis human a
encontrada en la Républica Argentina (Tucumán) ocasionado por la "Filaria tucumana".
Primera Conferencia de la Sociedad Sud-Americana de Higiene, Microbiología y
Patología, Buenos Aires, 17-24 Septiembre, 1916, Buenos Aires, 1917
37. BILLUPS J, SCHENKEN J R, BEAVER PC. Subcutaneous dirofilariasis in Nebraska.
Archives of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine 104: 11-13, 1980
38. BIOCCA E. Infestazione umana prenatale da Spirocerca lupi (Rud. 1809). Parassitologia
1: 137-142, 1959
39. BISSERU B, WOODRUFF AW, HUTCHINSON RI. Infection with adult Toxocara
canis. British Medical Journal i: 1583-1584, 1966
40. BLANK H. Use of fuadin in creeping eruption. Journal of the American Medica l
Association 123: 989-990, 1943
41. BORG OA, WOODRUFF AW. Prevalence o f infective ova of Toxocara species in public
places. British Medical Journal iv: 470-472, 1973
42. BOTERO D, LITTLE MD. Two cases of human Lagochilascaris infection in Colombia.
American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 33: 381-386, 1984
43. BRUMPT EJ. Précis de parasitologie, fourth edition, Librairie de l'Académie d e
Médecine, Paris, pp 1452, 1927
44. BUCKLEY JJ. Necator suillis as a human infection. British Medical Journal i: 699-700,
1933
45. BUCKLEY JJ. Some observations on two West Indian parasites of man. Proceedings of
the Royal Society of Medicine 27: 134-135, 1933
46. BUCKLEY JJ. On the development in Culicoides furens Poey of Filaria (Mansonella)
ozzardi Manson, 1897. Journal of Helminthology 12: 99-118, 1934
47. BUNNAG T, COMER D S, PUNYAGUPTA S. Eosinophilic myeloencephalitis caused
by Gnathostoma spinigerum . Neuropathology of nine cases. Journal of Neurologica l
Science 10: 419-434, 1970
48. BURKS JW, KINGERY FA. Treatment of creeping eruption with chloroquin e
diphosphate. A preliminary report. Southern Medical Journal 49: 1290-1292, 1956
49. CABRERA BD, CANLAS B, DAUZ U. Human intestin al capillariasis. III. Parasitological
features and management. Acta Medica Philippina, series 2, 4: 92-103, 1967
50. CANLAS B, CABRERA BD, DAUZ U. Human intestinal capillariasis. II. Pathological
features. Acta Medica Philippina, series 2, 4: 84-91, 1967
51. CANNON R. Case of Strongylus gigas. Lancet i: 264, 1887
52. CÉSPEDES R, SALAS J, MEKBEL S, TROPER L, MÜLLNER F, MORERA P .
Granuloma entéricos y linfáticos con intensa eosinofilia tisular producidos por u n
estrongilídeo (Strongylata: Railliet y Henry, 1913). I. Patología. Acta Médic a
Costaricensis 10: 235-255, 1967
53. CÉSPEDES R, SALAS J, MEKBEL S, TROPER L, MÜLLNER F, MORERA P .
750 A History of Human Helminthology
188. LOOSS A. Das Genus Trichostrongylus n.g., mit zwei neuen gelegentlichen Parasiten
des Menschen. Centralblatt für Bakteriologie, Parasitenkunde und Infektionskrankheiten,
Abteilung originale 39: 409-422, 1905
189. LORIA-CORTES R, LOBO-SANAHUJA JF. Clinical abdominal angiostrongyliasis. A
study of 116 children with intestinal eosinophilic granuloma caused by Angiostrongylus
costaricensis. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 29: 538-544, 1980
190 LOW GC. Notes on Filaria Demarquayii . British Medical Journal i: 186-187, 1902
191. LOW GC. Filaria perstans. British Medical Journal i: 722-724, 1903
192. LOW GC. Filaria perstans and the suggestion that it belongs to the genus Tylenchus
(Bastian). Lancet i: 420-421, 1904
193. LOW GC. "Filaria perstans:. Lancet i: 752-753, 1904
194. MacARTHUR WP. A case of infestation of human liver with Hepaticola hepatic a
(Bancroft 1893) Hall 1916, with sections from the liver. Proceedings of the Royal Society
of Medicine 17: 83-84, 1924
195. MacFIE JW, CORSON JF. A new species of filarial larva found in the skin of natives
in the Gold Coast. Annals of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology 16: 465-471, 1922
196. MACKERRAS MJ, SANDARS DF. The life-history of the rat lung-worm ,
Angiostrongylus cantonensis (Chen) (Nematoda: Metastrongylidae). Australian Journal
of Zoology 7: 1-21, 1955
197. MACE TF, ANDERSON RC. Development of the giant kidney worm, Dioctophyma
renale (Goeze, 1782) (Nematoda: Diocto phymatoidea). Canadian Journal of Zoology 53:
1552-1568, 1975
198. de MAGALHÃES PS. Note s d'helminthologia brésilienne. Neuvième série. Archives de
Parasitologie 12: 283-286, 1908
199. MANALANG C. Studies on ankylostomiasis in the Philippines. Transactions of the Sixth
Congress of the Far Easten Association of Tropical Medicine, Tokyo, pp 3512-368, 1925
200. MANSON P. The Filaria sanguinis hominis major and minor, two new species of
haematozoa. Lancet i: 4-8, 1891
201. MANSON P. The geographical distribution, pathological relations and life history o f
Filaria sanguinis hominis diurna and Filaria sanguinis hominis perstans in connexion
with preventive medicine. Transactio ns of the Seventh International Congress on Hygiene
and Demography, London, August 10-17, 1891, 1: 79-97, 1982. Abstracted in Medical
Press and Circular 103, new series, 52: 202-205, 1891, and Semaine Médecine 11: 342,
1891
202. MANSON P. On certain new species of nematode haematozoa occurring in America .
British Medical Journal ii: 1837-1838, 1897
203. MANSON P. A clinical lecture on sleeping sickness. British Medical Journal ii :
1672-1677, 1898
204. MAPLESTONE PA. A case of human infection with a gnathostome in India. India n
Medical Gazette 64: 610-614, 1929
205. MAPLESTONE PA, RAO SS. A case of gnat hostomiasis with some interesting features.
Indian Medical Gazette 74: 479-480, 1939
206. MARKELL EK. Pseudohookworm infection - trichostrongyliasis. Treatment wit h
thiabendazole. New England Journal of Medicine 278: 831-832, 1968
207. MATTHES HF, BUCHWALDER R. Untersuchungen zum Larvenprazysitationest mit
Ascaris suum- und Toxocara canis-larven. Angewandte Parasitologie 23: 1-8, 1982
208. MERCER RD, LUND HZ, BLOOMF IELD RA, CALDWELL FE. Larval ascariasis as
a cause of chronic eosinophilia with visceral manifestations. American Journal o f
Diseases of Children 80: 46-58, 1950
209. MEYERS WM, CONNOR DH, HARMANN LE, FLESHMAN K , MORIS R, NEAFIE
RC. Human streptocerciasis. A clinico-pathologic study of 40 Africans (Zairians) ,
including identification of the adult filaria. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and
Hygiene 21: 528-545, 1972
210. MEYERS WM, MORIS R, NEAFIE RC, CONNOR DH, BOURNLAND J. Strepto-
Miscellaneous Nematode Infections 757
233. NICHOLS RL. The etiology of visceral larva migrans. I. Diagnostic morphology o f
infective second-stage Toxocara larvae. Journal of Parasitology 42: 349-362, 1956
234 NICHOLS RL. The etiology of visceral larva migrans. II. Comparative larva l
morphology of Ascaris lumbricoides , Necator americanus, Strongyloides stercoralis , and
Ancylostoma caninum . Journal of Parasitology 42: 363-399, 1956
235. NICOLAIDES NJ, MUSGRAVE J, McGUCKIN D, MOORHOUSE DE. Nematod e
larvae (Spirurida: Physalopteridae) caus ing infarction of the bowel in an infant. Pathology
9: 129-135, 1977
236. NIELLY M. Un cas de dermato se parasitaire non encore observée en France ( Anguillula
leptodera). Bulletin de l'Académie de Médecine, Paris 46: 395-402, 1882
237. NISHIGORI M. (On the life history of Hepaticola hepatica . Second report). Taiwa n
Igakkai Zasshi No. 247, 1925. In Japanese, with English summary
238. NOMURA S, LIN H. (First clinical case of Hemostrongylus ratti Yokogawa in man.)
Taiwan No Ikai 3: 589-592, 1945. In Japanese. Translated in 28
239. OOSTBURG BF, VERMA AA. Lagochilascaris minor infection in Surinam. Report of
a case. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 17: 548-550, 1968
240. ORIHEL TC. Cerebral filariasis in Rhodesia - a zoonotic infection? American Journal
of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 22: 596-599, 1973
241. ORIHEL TC, BEAVER PC. Morphology and relationship of Dirofilaria tenuis and
Dirofilaria conjunctivae. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 14 :
1030-1043. 1965
242. ORIHEL TC, EBERHARD ML. Mansonella ozzardi: a redescription with comments on
taxonomic relationships. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 31 :
1142-1147, 1982
243. ORIHEL TC, ESSLINGER JH. Meningonema peruzzii gen. et sp. n. (Nematoda :
Filarioidea) from the central nerv ous system of African monkeys. Journal of Parasitology
59: 437-441, 1973
244. von OSTERTAG R. Ueber eine neue Strongylus-Art im Labmagen des Rindes .
Vorläufige Mittheilung. Centralblatt für Bakteriologie und Parasitenkunde, Abteilun g
originale 8: 457-460, 1890
245. OTSURU M. Trichostrongylus brevis sp. nov. from man (Nematoda :
Trichostrongylidae). Acta Medica et Biologica 9: 273-278, 1962
246. OTTO GF, BERTHROND M, APPLEBY RE, RAWLINS JC, WILBUR O .
Eosinophilia and hepatomegaly due to Capillaria hepatica. Bulletin of the Johns Hopkins
Hospital 94: 319-336, 1954
247. OWEN HB, HENNESSEY RS. A note on some ocular manifestations of helminthi c
origin occurring in natives of Uganda. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropica l
Medicine and Hygiene 25: 267-274, 1932
248. OWEN R. Anatomical descriptions of two speci es of Entozoa from the stomach of a tiger
(Felis tigris Linn), one of which forms a new genus of Nematoidea (Gnathostomata) .
Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London (47) part 4, pp 123-126, 1836
249. PANE C. Note sopra di un elminto nematoide. Annali dell'Accademia degli Aspirant i
Naturalisti di Napoli, series 3, 4: 32-34, 1864
250. PASYK K. Dermatitis rhabditosa in an 11-year old girl. A new cutaneous parasiti c
disease of man. British Journal of Dermatology 98: 107-112, 1978
251. PEEL E, CHARDOME M. Sur des filarides de chimpanzes "Pan paniscus" et "Pa n
satyrus" au Congo Belge. Annales de la Société Belge de Médecine Tropicale 26 :
117-156, 1946
252. PERLINGIERO JG, GYÖRGY P. Chronic eosinophilia. Report of a case with necrosis
of the liver, pulmonary infiltrations, anemia and Ascaris infestation. American Journal of
Diseases of Children 73: 34-43, 1947
253. PERUZZI M. Cerebral filariasis in five monkeys infected with trypanosoma l
meningoencephalitis. League of Nations Organization. Final Report of the International
Commission on Human Trypanosomiasis, pp 309-313, 1928
Miscellaneous Nematode Infections 759
254. PICKELLS W. Case of a young woman who has discharged and continues to discharge,
from her stomach, a number of insects in different stages of their existence. Transactions
of the Kings and Queens College of Physicians of Ireland 4: 189-214, 441-446, 1824
255. POLTERA AA. The histopathology of ocular loiasis in Uganda. Transactions of th e
Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 67: 819-829, 1973
256. PRADATSUNDARASAR A, PECHARANOND K, CHINTANAWONGS C ,
UNGTHAVORN P. The first case of intestinal capillariasis in Thailand. Southeast Asian
Journal of Tropical Medicine and Public Health 4: 131-134, 1973
257. PROMMAS C, DAENGSVANG S. Preliminar y report on the life-cycle of Gnathostoma
spinigerum. Journal of Parasitology 19: 287-292, 1933
258. PROMMAS C, DAENGSVANG S. Further report of a study on the life-cycle o f
Gnathostoma spinigerum . Journal of Parasitology 22: 180-186, 1936
259. PROMMAS C, DAENGSVANG S. Feeding experiments of cats with Gnathostoma
spinigerum larvae obtained from the second intermediate host. Indian Medical Gazette
23: 115-116, 1937
260. PROMMINDAROJ K, LEELAWONGS N, PRADATSUNDARASAR A. Huma n
angiostrongyliasis of the eye in Bangkok. American Journal of Tropical Medicine an d
Hygiene 11: 759-761, 1962
261. PUNYAGUPTA S. Recent knowledge on clinical gnathostomiasis. Journal of th e
Medical Association of Thailand 50: 686-695, 1967
262. RAILLIET A. Éléments de zoologie médicale et agricole, Paris, pp 586, 1885
263. RAILLIET A. Traité de zoologie médicale et agricole, second edition, Paris, pp 736 ,
1893
264. RAILLIET A. Sur les variations morphologiques des strongyles de l'appareil digestif, et
sur un nouveau strongyle du dromadaire. Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances
et Mémoires de la Société de Biologie 48: 540-542, 1896
265. RAILLIET A. Syngame laryngien du boeuf. Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires de s
Séances et Mémoires de la Société de Biologie 51: 174-176, 1899
266. RAILLIET A. In, Précis de parasitologie humaine. Maladies parasitaires dues à de s
végétaux et à des animaux, fo urth edition, M Neveu-Lemaire, (Editor), J Lamarre, Paris,
pp 712, 1908
267. RAILLIET A, HENRY AC. Le Triodontophorus deminutus , nouveau sclérostomie n
parasite de l'homme, et la cachexie africaine. Bulletin du Muséum d'Histoire Naturelle,
Paris 11: 269-272, 1905
268. RAILLIET A, HENRY AC. Encore un nouveau sclérostomien ( Oesophagostomu m
brumpti nov. sp) parasite de l'homme. Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances et
Mémoires de la Société de Biologie 58: 643-645, 1905
269. RAILLIET A, HENRY AC. Sur la classification des Strongylidae. I. Metastrongylinae.
Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires de s Séances et Mémoires de la Société de Biologie 66:
85-88, 1909
270. RAILLIET A, HENRY AC. Sur la classifica tion des Strongylidae. II. Ankylostomatinae.
Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires de s Séances et Mémoires de la Société de Biologie 66:
167-171, 1909
271. RAILLIET A, HENRY AC. Nouvelles observations sur les thélazies, nématode s
parasites de l'oeil. Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances et Mémoires de l a
Société de Biologie 68: 783-785, 1910
272. RAILLIET A, HENRY AC. Sur une filaire péritonéale des porcins. Bulletins de l a
Société de Pathologie Exotique et de ses Filiales 4: 386-389, 1911
273. RAILLIET A, HENRY AC. Helminthes du porc recueillis par M Bauche en Annam .
Bulletins de la Société de Pathologie Exotique et de ses Filiales 4: 693-699, 1911
274. RAILLIET A, HENRY AC. Recherches sur les ascarides des carnivores. Compte s
Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances et Mémoires de la Société de Biologie 70: 12-15,
1911
275. RAILLIET A, HENRY AC. Quelques nématodes parasites des reptiles. Bulletins de la
760 A History of Human Helminthology
MISCELLANEA
Imaginary parasites, usually worms, have been dreamt up and claimed as the
cause of disease in many societies until, and including, recent times. Worm s
were frequently found in the viscera and tissues of animals killed for culinary
purposes so it was a logical step to assume that similar worms must occur in
humans and were likely to produce illness. It was not until autopsies of humans
became commonplace that erroneous ideas of fantastic parasites wer e
expunged. In addition to these imaginary parasites, which were purely an d
simply figments of the imagination, pseudop arasites were also described. These
arose from misguided interpretations of pathological changes such a s
coagulated blood or necrotic tissue or secondary infestation of human tissues
and excretions by non-parasitic organisms.
IMAGINARY PARASITES
Imaginary parasites are well-described in the ancient literature. Thus, Ra, the
sun-god of Egypt, was supposed to have fallen sick when a worm arose from
his sputum and bit on the heel (cited in 24). The Indian medical work, th e
Sushruta Samhita, written around the first century AD, alleged that there were
three types of worms living in humans. Th e first arose in the faeces and of these
there were said to be seven varieties - some of these were undoubtedly real. Six
worms were thought to arise in the sputum. They were all imaginary, bein g
thought to be hairy with spots and tails; it was considered that they fed on the
bone marrow and penetrated into the eyes, palate and ears. Finally, seve n
imaginary worms arose from the blood, some of which were believed to feed
on the roots of hairs which fell out as a consequence 93.
A number of imaginary worms are detailed below. Undoubtedly th e
imaginary worms which were most widely held to exist were the toothworms,
but a number of others were frequently alleged such as eyeworms, earworms,
nasal worms, corpse worms, umbilical worms and echo worms.
Toothworms
The belief that toothache and dental disease are caused by worms in or around
the teeth goes back to ancient times. Perhaps the earliest literary reference to
765
766 A History of Human Helminthology
Anglo-Saxon leechcraft:
For toothworms, take acorn meal and henbane seed and wax of all equally much,
mingle these together, work into a wax candle and burn it, let it reek into the mouth,
put a black cloth under it, then will the worms fall on to it. 31
Other plants which have been recommende d from time to time included myrtle,
tamarisk, sumach, leeks, onions, raisins and roses. A seventeenth centur y
English poem mentions come of these:
If in your teeth you hap to be tormented,
By means some little wormes therin do breed,
Which pain (if heed be tane) may be prevented,
By keeping cleane your teeth, when as you feede;
Burne Francomsence (a gum not evil sented),
Put Henbane into this, and Onyon seed,
And with a tunnel to the tooth that's hollow,
Convey the smoke thereof, and ease shall follow. 8
In many instances, it seems that when seeds wer e heated, they cracked open and
plant embryos were scattered and mistaken for worms. Meanwhile, hyo -
scyamine and related drugs, constituents of henbane, dulled the pain.
As well as plants, various small animals including worms, caterpillars ,
weevils, ladybirds and small b eetles were used to "cure" toothache. This seems
to have been based upon the principle of "similis similibus curantur", i.e. that
the administration of worms or some such would cure the disease caused b y
worms in the teeth. Thus, the Assyrian sufferer from toothache was recom -
mended to crush a caterpillar on the afflicted tooth while a Greek physicia n
suggested that earthworms boiled in oil cured toothache.
An alternative ploy was to invoke charms and incantations. This approach
was based upon the belief that toothworm infection was associated wit h
invasion and possession by a demon which could be driven out by invocation.
For example, the pagan Brandenburgians supplicated the moon:
Little moon, decrease,
Go away from us,
Little worm, go away
And do me no more harm.9
Many of the toothache incantations had a Christian flavour:
Abraham said to Jesus Christ
As they walked on the slope of Bethris:
'I have not the power of walking
Or of riding because of toothache'
Said Jesus Christ to Abraham:
'Toothache will not be in that head;
Out of the toothache! Out of the toothache!
Known in heaven, known on earth.
Known to thy King is thy disease.
Toothworms and toothache to be placed under the earth.' 10
Besides being spoken, charms were sometimes written on paper or parchment
and worn as an amulet.
768 A History of Human Helminthology
There have been many descriptions of worms in the orbital, aural and nasa l
cavities. Some of these may not have been imaginary at all as it is well-known
that flies may deposit eggs in these places from time to time and the resultant
maggots may have been mistaken for worms. Indeed, some of those in the eye
may have been true worms (Loa, Thelazia). Many, however, were imaginary
and have been described by numerous authors since the time of Galen. In the
case of the orbit, for example, blepharitis (inflammation of the eyelids) ma y
have caused crusts which had the appearance of parasites. Moreover, som e
enterprising quack "eye-specialists" have been known to breed fly larvae then
insert them into the conjunctival sac thus permitting their removal from tha t
site16.
Many techniques have been described for flushing worms out of thes e
domains and indeed may be the means of producing objects resembling worms.
Thus, the Syriac Book of Medicine remarked concerning:
Worms in the ears....boil strong onions in the urine of children, and drop the liquor
into the ears. Or pound and mix together sumach, goat's milk, rings of
pomegranates, and raisins with honey, heat the mixture and drop it into the ears. .
Or pour juice of absinthe and old oil which is cloudy into the ears and the worms
will come out.101
Another popular method for driving out the worms was fumigation and i s
described under toothworms.
Urine Worms
Macroscopic worms have rarely been passed in u rine but sometimes coagulated
blood in elongated form has been mistaken for worms.
Umbilical worms
This worm was thought to live within the umbilicus of small children and cause
weakness and failure to thrive. Its presence could be "proved" by fastening a
small fish to the umbilicus in the evening then noting whether some of it had
been "eaten" in the morning. In reality, parts of the fish had been rubbed off by
the movements of the child. Andry in 1741 recounted Ettmuller's technique for
eradicating such parasites. Half of a nutsh ell containing a mixture of honey with
Miscellanea 769
powdered glass and juniper is fastened to the umbilicus then "the worm comes
as usual and attracted by the honey eats of this mixture from which it dies" 3. A
rather similar worm was the "Amao" described by Lusitanius (1575-1642 )
which was supposed to live in the intestinal canal of children and graduall y
consume their strength so they died if the worm was not expelled by the proper
treatment72.
Corpse Worms
Echoing Worms
In ancient China, it was sometimes believed that people were made sick b y
echoing worms which were supposed to produce an echo when the parasitized
person spoke. These worms were thought to be expelled or killed when th e
relevant part of the Chinese pharmacop oeia was read and the appropriate herbs
taken. For similar reasons, some Chinese anthelmintic prescriptions required
that silence should be maintained while preparing the medicines otherwise the
worm may hear and not be expelled 54.
This parasite was listed by Linnaeus in his Systema Naturae and discussed by
a number of writers including Solander 90 and Pallas79 . The parasite was
supposed to be a very small worm, the thickness of a hair, yellowish-white in
colour with one dark end, and have a single row of minute spines. It wa s
thought to be carried by the wind and be found in northern Sweden, Lapland
and Russia. It was said to attack humans, horse s and cattle in summer and cause
770 A History of Human Helminthology
a burning feeling like a mosquito bite. This was followed by the development
of a painless swelling, central necrosis and death within several hours to days.
It is likely that in fact the writers were des cribing a number of bacterial diseases
such as anthrax, glanders, tularaemia or plague 54.
PSEUDOPARASITES
PARASITOPHOBIA
Very few worms parasitic in humans we re known when printing became estab-
lished in Europe in the latter half of the fifteenth century. Initially, illustrations
were produced with the aid of woodcuts but during the seventeenth centur y
copper engravings which permitted the renderin g of finer details were gradually
introduced. In the early nineteenth century the new technique of lithograph y
was adopted.
SEVENTEENTH CENTURY
The liver fluke, Fasciola hepatica, was figured by Redi in 1668 82 then by
Ruyschius in 1691 86 and Bidloo in 1698 13. Velschius in 1674 showed Dracunc-
ulus medinensis protruding from various parts of the human body but gave no
details of the parasite 100. He also drew filariae obtained from birds. In 1683 ,
Edward Tyson illustrated the anatomy of Ascaris lumbricoides 97 then in the
same year he drew a Taenia saginata and reproduced the scolex of a dog tape-
worm98. In the following year, Redi described 108 different parasites an d
produced copper plates in wh ich he illustrated amongst other things Eustrong-
ylus gigas, Cysticercus pisiformis , the reproductive organs of Ascaris
lumbricoides, and the dog and cat tapeworms, each of the latter with a head 83.
In 1691, Tyson illustrated Cysticercus tenuicollis from the omentum of an
antelope99.
772 A History of Human Helminthology
EIGHTEENTH CENTURY
NINETEENTH CENTURY
Massage
Massage of the abdomen has been recommended for the treatment of intest-
inal worms in many countries but particularly in China. As a consequence of
this procedure, worms were supposed to be passed in the stools:
Abdominal pain in children accompanied by a palpable mass in the abdomen is due
to worms. In this case, no drug is necessary: simply advise the parents to massage the
abdominal mass for half a day. This kills the worms which will be passed out in the
faeces.25
Acupuncture
Acupuncture has been practised in China as a means of treating worms for
many years:
Heartache caused by the three kinds of worms is attended by profuse salivation and
inability to turn the body into a recumbent position. In this case, the pit of the stomach
is the proper place for acupuncture.56
This practice is based upon the theory that the inserted needles will transfe r
energy to different parts of the body along hypothetical lines or "meridians".
Moxibustion
In this procedure, cones of the plant Artemisia (worm-wood) are applied to
Miscellanea 773
the skin and ignited. The smouldering fire burns into the skin and produces a
blister. It was sometimes used in China as an anthelmintic measure 54.
Music
Music was advocated occasionally for the treatment of worms in Europe in
the eighteenth century. According to Goeze 48, tapeworms could be expelled by
the noise of a Jew's harp. Others believed that intestinal worms could sens e
sound and recommended the use of certain musical instruments to mollif y
tapeworms and thus relieve symptoms 21.
Magic
In diverse countries down the ages, magic in the form of incantations o r
charms has been invoked to induce the expulsion of intestinal worms. Many of
the incantations had quasi-religious overtones while charms were objects with
written or engraved magic signs or words.
For many centuries and in many parts of the world, the moon has been held to
have an influence on worms, particularly upon the efficacy of anthelminti c
therapy. One of the first authors to deal with this subject was Nicola s
Myrepsus, a Greek physician who lived in the thirteenth century. He advised
that anthelmintics be given only during the waning of the moon 76. Andry at the
beginning of the eighteenth century was sceptical at first about such an effect
but then, following an investigation, gave some credence to the phenomenon.
He treated 100 persons with intestinal worms during the days of the wanin g
moon and found that more than 80% were cured. In contrast, the result wa s
reversed if the therapy was given on the other days 2. Similarly, Hoffman55
advised giving anthelmintics when the moon changed its phase.
Such ideas were not confined to Europe. Some ea rly Chinese writers believed
that intestinal worms had their heads turned upwards during the first half of the
lunar month and downwards in the second half. Further, they thought tha t
anthelmintic therapy was more effective if the head of the worms was turned
upwards 54. In recent times in Ruanda in Africa, it has been the practice t o
administer anthelmintics when the moon is full 68.
Some authors believed that the moon also i nfluenced symptomatology. Rosen
de Rosenstein85 thought that the symptoms were worse in children wit h
tapeworm infections during the waning moon and at the time of the new moon.
Likewise, Wawruch 102 claimed that Taenia segments appeared in stools more
regularly at this period. Some authors contended that Ascaris was more likely
to be discharged around this time and believed that there may be a simila r
influence on Enterobius. Küchenmeister, who was infected with these las t
parasites, however, sought a relationship between the numbers of worm s
discharged and the phases of the moon but could find no connection 63.
774 A History of Human Helminthology
The roundworm, Ascaris lumbricoides, has from time time been a popula r
therapeutic device in both the Occident and the Orient. Pulverized, drie d
worms were commonly used by both the medical profession and the populace
at large in Europe as an anthelmintic. In China, worm extracts were recom -
mended for the treatment of a wide range of conditions such as ulcerativ e
blepharitis, painful ophthalmitis, anal fistula, cancrum oris and boils e.g. "An
Ascaris worm, washed clean, baked dry over a tile on a fire, and ground into a
powder will, when applied to pustules and furuncles, effect a quick cure" 26.
It was even used as an aphrodisiac:
Grind the above (Ascaris) into powder, mix with grease and roll into pills of the size
of barley seeds. Before coitus, introduce one pill into the urethra; it will help enlarge
and stiffen the penis and prolong its periods of erection. 89
and concluded that horses infect ed with a certain number of parasites gradually
immunized themselves against the actio n of the secretions of these worms. Five
years later, Fujinami in a paper entitled (in translation) "Immunity t o
macroparasitic disease: can it be acquired?" recorded the acquisition o f
immunity against Schistosoma japonicum in horses45. In 1921, the
development of acquired immunity against Trichinella spiralis was shown in
rats by Ducas38. Blackwell and Thompson in 1923 observed that immunit y
could be acquired by both man and animals against the larva of the tumbu fly,
Cordylobia anthropophaga, which causes cutaneous larva migrans 15. Whether
significant acquired immunity develops in most human helminth infections has
been a matter of intense debate ever since, with the probability being that i t
develops only to a limited degree 50. How worms manage to evade the host' s
responses and persist has been a subject of earnest but largely unproductiv e
speculation18. The possibility of developing vaccines against helminths has now
been floated for a number of years 6,32 but success has hitherto eluded everyone's
grasp.
The development of immune responses, particularly the appearance of anti-
bodies and skin reactivity has been put to diagnostic purposes for man y
decades. The era of immunodiagnosis in human helminthology was probably
ushered in by Isaac and von den Velden in 1904 when they reported th e
presence of a precipitin reaction in the serum of a person with Diphyllo-
bothrium latum infection and compared this with a negative in an uninfected
control individual57. In the same year, Fleckseder and von Stejskal 43
found
antibodies against Taenia saginata in the serum of immunized rabbits bu t
Langer65 could not find such antibodies in humans infected with T. solium or
T. saginata infections. In 1906, Ghedini described a complement fixation test
for antibody directed against fluid from human hydatid cysts 47. In the following
year, Fleig and Lisbonne 44 described a test for precipitating antibody i n
echinococcosis.
In 1911, Casoni described a skin test for echinococcosis in which delaye d
hypersensitivity reactions occurred in infected persons after intraderma l
injection of fluid obtained from a sheep hydatid cyst 23. Sophisticated
immunological techniques have been developed in recent years and are no w
frequently being employed in the immunodiagnosis of human helminthiases 7.
Reactions to ascarids were described by Miram, Cobbold, Huber, Leuckart,
Bastian, Railliet and many others in the nineteenth century. In 1910, Gold -
schmidt again described features r esembling hay fever after exposure to human
and horse Ascaris and recognized its allergic nature49. The relationship between
helminthiasis and the atopic d isorders, asthma, hay fever and eczema, has been
a thorny one for many years. Herrick in 1913 may have been the first t o
recognize an association between asthma and worm infection when he wrote:
Common to both bronchial asthma and Ascaris infection is an increase of the
eosinophils in the blood. One may well ask the significance of the eosinophilia in this
association.53
776 A History of Human Helminthology
Paul Erlich had described these peculiar white cells in 1879 then Müller and
Rieder in 189175 observed that they were increased in number in hookwor m
infection. Similar findings were then made in other worm infections. Neverthe-
less, little attention was paid to this association until Johansson in 1967 59
discovered a new class of immunoglobulin (initially called IgND, now IgE) and
found that increased levels were seen in the serum of patients with asthma. In
the following year, he observed increased levels of the same antibody i n
Ethiopian schoolchildren with Ascaris infection60. Similar elevations were then
seen in a variety of helminth infections. These discoveries provided a further
nexus between helminthiasis and atopy. A number of hypotheses wer e
advanced including a belief that worms caused asthma, the concept that worm
infection ameliorated asthma, and the proposition that atopic individuals ar e
able to generate increased resistance to worms 51.
The first major textbook of helminth immunology was written in 1929 b y
Taliaferro who produced a 414 page work entitled The immunology of
parasitic infections "94. This was followed in 1941 by Culbertson with hi s
Immunity against animal parasites "33.
Gongylonema and cancer in certain districts in Italy. This led to the concept of
"cancer houses" with the theory that Gongylonema was transmitted from
person to person by cockroaches, resulting in cancer 87. This hypothesis was
attacked by Leiper and a heated correspondence followed 11,67,88. In the event,
Leiper was proven correct when it was finally concluded that Fibiger's tumours
were in fact non-malignant 5.
Nevertheless, time has been a little kinder in favouring associations between
cancer and two parasites - Schistosoma haematobium and bladder cancer (see
chapter 8), and Clonorchis sinensis and carcinoma of the bile ducts (se e
chapter 6)
The Romans apparently had a god of worms and worm diseases name d
"Verminus". The little that is known about this deity derives from an inscription
on an altar found near Rome in 1876. The inscription said:
"Vermino
A. Postumius A.F.A.N Albi
Duovir lege Plaetoria"
which has been translated as:
"To Verminus
Aulus Postumius Albinus, son of Aulus
grandson of Aulus Duovir by the Plaetorian law"
Apparently, the increasing seriousness of worm infections had caused thi s
shrine to be erected and dedicated by the consul, Aulus 54.
REFERENCES
1. ALDROVANDI U. De animalibus insectis libri septem denuo impressum, Ferronius ,
Bononiae, pp 767, 1602
2. ANDRY R. De la génération des vers dans le corps de l'homme. Avec trois lettres sur les
sujets des vers, les deux premières....par M. Nicolas Hartsoeker et l'autre....par M .
Georges Baglivi, Laurent d'Houry, Paris, pp 468, 1700. An account of the breeding o f
worms in human bodies etc., translated by H Rhodes and A Bell, pp 266, 1701
3. ANDRY R. De la génération des vers dans le corps de l'homme, third edition, Lauren t
d'Houry, Paris, pp 1190, 1741. Partly translated in 54
4. ANONYMOUS. Helminths in cancer. British Medical Journal i: 777-778, 1920
5. ANONYMOUS. Fibiger's tumour of the rat's stomach. Lancet i: 735-736, 1938
6. ANONYMOUS. Immunisation against helminths. Lancet i: 685, 1960
7. ANONYMOUS. Immunodiagnosis in parasitic diseases. British Medical Journal 283 :
1349-1350, 1981
8. ANONYMOUS. Cited in 12
9. ANONYMOUS. Cited in 61
10. ANONYMOUS. Cited in 96
11. BAYLISS HA. Gongylonema and cancer. British Medical Journal ii: 503-504, 1926
12. BERDOE E. The origin and growth of the healing art. A popular history of medicine in
all ages and countries, Swan Sonnenschein and Co., pp 509, 1893
778 A History of Human Helminthology
36. DEMARQUAY JN. Helminthologie. Gazette Médicale de Paris 18: 665-667, 1863
37. DUBINI A. Nuovo verme intestinal umano ( Agchylostoma duodenale ) costituente un sesto
genere dei nematoidei proprii dell'uomo. Annali Universali di Medicina 106: 5-13, 1843
38. DUCAS R. L'immunité dans la trichinose. Thèse, Paris, Jouve et Cie, 1921
39. FIBIGER J. Ueber eine durch Nematoden ( Spiroptera sp. n) hervorgerufene papillomatöse
und carcinomatöse Geschwulstbildung im Magen der Ratte. Berliner klinisch e
Wochenschrift i: 289-298, 1913
40. FIBIGER J. Sur la transmission aux rats de la Spiroptera neoplastica (Gongylonema
neoplasticum). Méthode pour la production expérimentale du cancer. Comptes Rendu s
Hebdomadaires des Séances et Mémoires de la Société de Biologie 83: 321-324, 1920
41. FIBIGER J. Carcinome spiroptér ien de la langue du rat. Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires
des Séances et Mémoires de la Société de Biologie 83: 692-695, 1920
42. FISCHER JL. Taeniae hydatigenae in plexu chorioideo nuper inventae historia etc., J
Haasio, Lipsiae, 1789
43. FLECKSEDER R, von STEJSKAL K. Biologische Reaktionen mit Bandwurmextrakt.
Wiener klinische Wochenschrift 17: 793, 1904
44. FLEIG C, LISBONNE M. Recherches sur un sérodiagnostic du kyste hydatique par l a
méthode des precipitins. Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances et Mémoires de
la Société de Biologie 62: 1198-1201, 1907
45. FUJINAMI A. (Immunity to macroparasitic disease, can it be acquired?), 1916. I n
Japanese. Abstracted in China Medical Journal 31: 81, 1917
46. GEMMA C. De naturae divinis characterismis seu raris et admirandis etc., Antverpiae, pp
225, 1575
47. GHEDINI G. Ricerche sul siero di sangue di individuo affetto da cisti da echinococco e
sul liquid in essa contenuto. Gazzetta degli Ospedali et delle Cliniche 27: 1616-1617, 1906
48. GOEZE JA. Versuch einer Naturgeschichte der Eingeweidewürmer thierischer Körper ,
PA Pape, Blankenburg, pp 471, 1782
49. GOLDSCHMIDT R. Die Aska risvergiftung. Münchener medicinische Wochenschrift 57:
1991-1993, 1910
50. GROVE DI. Immunity in human helminth infections. In, Biology and control o f
endoparasites, L.E. Symons, A.D. Donald and J.K. Dineen (Editors), Academic Press ,
Sydney, pp 375-400, 1982
51. GROVE DI. What is the relationship between asthma and worms? Allergy 37: 139-148,
1982
52. GUERINI V. A history of dentistry from the most ancient times until the end of th e
eighteenth century, Lea and Febiger, Philadelphia, pp 355, 1909
53. HERRICK WW. Experimental eosinophilia with an extract of an animal parasite: it s
relation to anaphylaxis and certain clinical features. Archives of Internal Medicine 11 :
163-186, 1913
54. HOEPPLI R. Parasites and parasitic infections in early medicine and science, University
of Malaya Press, Singapore, pp 526, 1959
55. HOFFMANN FH. Opera omnia physico-medica etc. et supplementa, Genevae, pp 508,
1740-1753
56. HUAND-FU MI. (The classics of acupuncture and moxibustion.) In Chinese. Partl y
translated in 54
57. ISAAK S, von der VELDEN. Eine spezifische Präzipitinreaktion bei Bothriocephalus
latus behergergenden Menschen. Deutsche medizinische Wochenschrift 30: 982, 1904
58. JOERDENS JH. Entomologie und Helminthologie des menschlichen Koerpers etc., G A
Grau, Hof, two volumes, pp 473, 1801-1802
59. JOHANSSON SG, BENNICH H. Immunological studies of an atypical (myeloma )
immunoglobulin. Immunology 13: 381-394, 1967
60. JOHANSSON SG, MELLBIN T, VAHLQUIST B. Immunoglobulin levels in Ethiopian
pre-school children with special reference to high concentrations of IgE (IgND). Lancet
i: 1118-1121, 1968
780 A History of Human Helminthology
61. KANNER L. Folklore of the teeth. Dental Cosmos 67: 259, 1926
62. KEAN BH, MOTT KE, RUSSELL AJ. Tropical medicine and parasitology. Classi c
investigations, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, pp 677, 1978
63. KÜCHENMEISTER F. Die in und an dem Körper des lebenden Mensche n
vorkommenden Parasiten. Ein Lehr- und Handbuch der Diagnose und Behandlung de r
thierischen und pflanzischen Pa rasiten des Menschen, BG Teubner, Leipzig, two volumes,
pp 486, 1855. On animal and vegetable parasites of the human body. A manual of their
natural history, diagnosis and treatment. Volume 1. Animal parasites belonging to th e
group Entozoa, translated by E Lankester, The Syndenham Society, London, pp 452, 1857
64. KU CHIN YI T'UNG CHU'AN. Cited in 54
65. LANGER J. Zur Frage der Bildung spezifischer Antikörper im Organismus vo n
Bandwurmwirten. Münchener medizinische Wochenschrift 52: 1665-1665, 1905
66. LARGUS S. Cited in 52
67. LEIPER RT. Gongylonema and cancer. British Medical Journal ii: 504, 1926
68. LESTRADE. La médecine indigène au Ruanda. Académie Royale des Science s
Coloniales. Classe des sciences morales et politiques. Nouvelle série, tome VIII, fasc. l.
(Ethnographie), Bruxelles, 1955. Cited in 54
69. LEUCKART FS. Zoologische Bruckstucke, Stuttgart, Freiburg, three volumes, 1819
70. van LINSCHOTEN JH. Vera descriptio regni pars Indiae orientalis in qua Johann .
Hugonis Lintscotani navigatio in orientem etc., Teucrides Annaeus Lonicer, Frankfort ,
1599. Original Dutch edition, 1596
71. LOOSS A. The anatomy and life h istory of Agchylostoma duodenale Dub. A monograph.
Part II. The development in the free state. Translated from the German by M Bernhard.
Records of the School of Medicine, Egyptian Ministry of Education 4: 163-613, 1911
72. LUSITANIUS. Cited in 29
73. McCONNELL JF. Remarks on the anatomy and pathological relations of a new species
of liver-fluke. Lancet ii: 271-274, 1875
74. METCHNIKOFF E. The Harben lectures for 1906. II. The hygiene of the alimentar y
canal. Lancet i: 1554-1555, 1906
75. MÜLLER HF, RIEDER H. Ueber vorkommen und klinische Bedeutung der eosinophilen
Zellen, Ehrlich, im circulirenden Blute des Menschen. Deutsche Archiv für klinisch e
Medicin 48: 96-121, 1891
76. MYREPSUS N. De antid., sect. I, cap. 298. Cited in 35
77. O'NEILL J. On the presence of a filaria in "craw-craw". Lancet i: 265-266, 1875
78. OWEN R. Description of a microscopic entozoon infesting the muscles of the huma n
body. London Medical Gazette 16: 125-127, 1835
79. PALLAS PS. Einige Erinnerungen die Bandwürmer bettrefend: in Beziehung auf de s
zwölfte und vierzehnte Stück des N aturforschers. Neue nordische Beyträge physickalische
und geographische Erd- und Volkerbeschriften 1: 113-131, 1781
80. PARÉ A. Les oeuvres d'Amroise Paré, onzième edition. Avec les voyages qu'il a faits en
divers lieux: et les pourtraits & figures, tant l'anatomie que des instruments de chirurgie,
& de plusiers monstres, Chez Pierre Rigaud, Lyon, pp 854, 1651. Partly translated in 54
81. RANSOM BH. United States Department of Agriculture Bulletin No. 939, 1921
82. REDI F. Esperienze intorno alla generazione del'insetti, Carlo Dati, Firenze, pp 177, 1668
83. REDI F. Osservazione intorno agli animali viventi che si trovano negli animali viventi ,
Piero Matini, Firenze, pp 244, 1684
84. ROEDERER JG, WAGLER CG. De morbo mucoso liber singularis, quem nupe r
speciminis inauguralis loco ediderunt, B Bossigelium, Goettingae, pp 211, 1762
85. ROSEN de ROSENSTEIN N. Traité des maladies des infans etc. Traduit du Suédois par
Le Febvre de Villebrune, P G Cavelier, Paris, pp 582, 1778
86. RUYSCHIUS (RUYSCH) F. Observationum anatomico-chirurgicarum centuria etc., H
et T Boom, Amstelodami, pp 138, 1691
87. SAMBON LW. Observations and researches o n epidemiology of cancer made in Holland
and Italy (May-September, 1925). Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 29 :
Miscellanea 781
233-287, 1926
88. SAMBON LW. Refutation of statements made by Professor R.T. Leiper M.D., D.Sc.,
F.R.S., concerning African schistosomes, "American Gongylonemes", zoo vermin and
Italian cancer houses. Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 29: 314-322, 1926
89. SHÊH SHENG TSUNG YAO. (Essentials of Hygiene. A curious book on coitus.), 1638.
In Chinese. Partly translated in 54
90. SOLANDER DC. Furia infernalis, vermis et ab eo concitari solitus morbus, descripti .
Nova Acta Regiae Societatis Scientarum Upsaliensis 2: 44, 1775
91. SPIGELIUS (van der SPIEGEL) A. De lumbrico lato liber cum eiusdem lumbrici icone
et notis, L Pasquati, pp 88, 1618
92. SULTZER C. Dissertation sur un ver intestinal nouvellement découvert et décrit sous le
nom bicorne rude, JA Fischer, Strasbourg, pp 52, 1801
93. SUSHRUTA SAMHITA. An English translation, edited by Kaviraj Kunja La l
Bhishagratna, Calcutta, 1911
94. TALIAFERRO WH. The immunology of parasitic infections, The Century Co, Ne w
York, pp 414, 1929
95. THOMPSON RC. Assyrian medical texts, Pro ceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine
19: 29-78, 1926
96. TOWNEND BR. The story of the toothworm. Bulletin of the History of Medicine 19:
37-58, 1944
97. TYSON E. Lumbricus teres, or some anatomical observations on the round worm bred
in human bodies. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society 13: 153-161, 1683
98. TYSON E. Lumbricus latus, or a di scourse read before the Royal Society, of the joynted
worm etc. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society 13: 113-144, 1683
99. TYSON E. Lumbricus hydropicus: or an essay to prove that Hydatides often met with
in morbid animal bodies, are a species of worm, or imperfect animals. Philosophica l
Transactions of the Royal Society 17: 506-510, 1691
100. VELSCHIUS GH. Exercitatio de Vena Medinensi, ad mentem Ebnsinae sive dracunculis
veterum etc., Theophili Goebelli, Augustae Vindelicorum, pp 456, 1674
101. WALLIS BUDGE EA. Syriac anatomy, pathology and therapeutics or, "The book o f
medicines etc.", two volumes, Oxford University Press, London, 1913
102. WAWRUCH. Réflexions tirées de deux cent six o bservations de ténias. Gazette Médicale
de Paris 9: 633, 1842. Extracted from Medizin Jahrbuch des Oesterreich Staates
103. WEINBERG M, JULIEN A. Sub stances toxiques de l'Ascaris megalocephala . Comptes
Rendus Hebdomadaires des Séances et Mémoires de la Société de Biologie 70: 337-339,
1911
104. WYKOFF RE. Delusions of parasitosis: a review. Reviews of Infectious Diseases 9 :
433-437, 1987
Chapter 29
BIOGRAPHIES
783
784 A History of Human Helminthology
(1867) then ophthalmic surgeon (1870) to the Edinburgh Royal Infirmary until 1897
when he became consulting surgeon. He investigated the role of an extract of the Cal-
abar bean (physostigmine) in the treatment of certain eye conditions and in 1869 and
1879 published papers describing the pupillary changes in tabes dorsalis (syphilis) which
now bear his name (Argyll Robertson pupil). He described the appearances of the adult
Loa loa. He became president of the Royal College of Surgeons of Edinburgh in 1886
and was awarded the honorary degree of LL.D. by the University of Edinburgh in 1897.
He married Miss Fraser in 1882 but had no children. He was a keen golfer, archer,
shooter and fisherman. When he retired in 1904, he retired to the island of Jersey on
account of its milder climate. In November 1908 he travelled to India to visit an old
friend, the Thakur of Gondal. He died suddenly in Gondal on 3 January 1909. (Plate 3)
practised in Nottingham for five years. He was a keen naturalist and was for three years
president of the Nottingham Naturalists' Society. Because of illness (possibly nephrotic
syndrome), he moved to the warmer climate of Queensland, Australia in 1864, settling
on the outskirts of Brisbane in 1867. He became visiting surgeon to the Brisbane
Hospital in 1867 then in 1868 he was appointed house surgeon, a post similar to that of
medical superintendent. Two years later he resigned this post and became a visiting
surgeon once more and developed a thriving private practice. He wrote on a variety of
clinical topics, especially snake-bite, tick paralysis, typhoid fever, leprosy and filariasis.
He was a keen horticulturist and was intrigued by the medicinal possibilities of
Australian plants. He was interested in public health and was for a number of years
Health Officer for Brisbane. He was said to be a kindly and approachable man, yet on
the other hand it has been remarked that he was direct of speech and at times could be
rather irascible. He died suddenly from a myocardial infarction on 16 June 1894 aged
58 years. (Plate 7)
education at University College, London graduating with the degree of master of arts in
1861, bachelor of medicine in 1863 and doctor of medicine in 1866. Shortly after
graduation he was elected assistant physician to St Mary's Hospital and lecturer in
pathology at its Medical School. In 1867 he was appointed professor of pathological
anatomy then in 1887 professor of medicine and clinical medicine at University College
Hospital, a post which he held until 1897. He was also a physician to the National
Hospital for the Paralysed and Epileptic from 1882-1912. He was elected a fellow of the
Royal Society in 1868 when only 31 years of age for his contributions to parasitology,
having published two monographs on free-living nematodes in which he described 100
new species and investigated their physiology. His middle years were devoted to
neurology but in his early and later years he was primarily concerned with the origin of
life, being a staunch advocate of heterogenesis (spontaneous generation). This latter
story is a remarkable example of misguided moral courage and scientific enthusiasm in
the face of hopeless odds. He died at home on 17 November 1915 at Chesham Bois,
Buckinghamshire aged 78 years leaving his widow, Julia (née Orane), three sons, and
a daughter. (Plate 9)
esteemed for his high character and was the recipient of many honours, including being
elected president of the Royal Belgian Academy in 1881, a foreign corresponding
member of the Royal Society of Britain, and being made a Grand Officer of the Order
of Leopold in 1886. His son, Edouard, became professor of zoology at Liège in 1870;
he was an embryologist who discovered the phenomenon of meiosis. The elder van
Beneden died at Louvain on 8 January 1894, aged 84 years. (Plate 11)
an unwearying collector of facts, a devoted labourer in the paths of science, and cautious
in the conclusions he drew from his observations. He was a man of unaffected simplicity
and gentleness of character, without a trace of vanity, a devoted friend, and an upright,
honest gentleman". He died at his home in Harley Street, London on 10 August 1886,
aged 79 years. (Plate 16)
After several years of failing health he died on 27 October 1934, his wife having
pre-deceased him by several years. (Plate 18)
1872. He was said to be of a kind and affectionate disposition (although his often
dogmatic writings at times appear to belie this), made and kept many friends, was de-
voted to music, and possessed a remarkable alto voice. He died from cardiac disease in
London on 20 March 1886 at the age of 57 years. (Plate 20)
and although born of poor parents, died a millionaire. He was a man of literary pursuits
and possessed a very extensive library. He invented many surgical devices and published
papers on surgery, pharmacology and hypnosis. Because of his contributions, he was
made a Commandant of the Legion of Honour. He died in Longueval, having left Paris
two weeks earlier, of cancer of the stomach on 21 June 1875, aged 60 years.
Medical College in China in 1919. He remained there until 1928, rising to the rank of
associate professor of parasitology. During this period he wrote classic monographs on
clonorchiasis and schistosomiasis japonica. In 1928 he returned to the United States as
professor of parasitology at Tulane University in New Orleans, Louisiana. In 1947 he
was appointed professor of tropical diseases and hygiene in that institution. He is
perhaps best remembered for his text on helminthology which became incorporated into
Craig and Faust's Clinical Parasitology, still the bible of medical parasitology. He
married Lola Swift by whom he had one daughter. He died in New Orleans on 2
November 1978, aged 88 years.
fauna and ethnology of the Nyasa and Kinga mountains. This was to lead to books on
the Nyasa tribes and the people of Tanganyika (Tanzania). In 1901 he joined the
newly-formed Institute for Naval and Tropical Diseases in Hamburg, Germany. In
1908-9 he led an expedition to the South Pacific to make anthropological observations.
On the outbreak of World War I he was called up for military service and shortly
afterwards was severely wounded at Mons in France. Thereafter he was appointed an
expert on malaria and hygiene to the German troops operating in Macedonia. In 1920
he undertook research in the West Indies and South America while later travels carried
him to East Africa, India and Japan. In 1930 he was appointed director of the Hamburg
Institute and professor in the University of Hamburg. Fülleborn was a great raconteur
and linguist, a fine cook and a persistent smoker. He married relatively late in life and
died on 9 September 1933, aged 66 years. (Plate 29)
worms and received second prize (silver medal). He died in Quedlinberg on 27 June
1793 aged 62 years.
became head physician of the South Manchurian Railway Hospital in Dairen, then was
appointed the first director of the South Manchurian Medical School.
known of these was an apparatus for plugging the nostrils in epistaxis. He was one of
the first advocates of the official inspection of meat and meat markets. He investigated
the propagation and treatment of cholera, and the frequency of consumption in Saxony.
For some years he edited a journal of his own entitled Periodical of Epidemiology. He
popularized the treatment of diphtheria with lime water, investigated the toxins of
mushrooms and the grafting of fruit trees, and was an avid bee-keeper. His study was
said to be littered with theological texts and he was a masterly exponent of the scriptures.
He wrote papers on Luther's last illness and on the latter's famous hymn "A mighty
fortress is our God". During the last fifteen years of his life he came much before the
public eye as an ardent apostle of cremation; in Dresden in 1874 he began the practice
of the placement of ashes in urns. He gave the appearance of being a rough person, but
underneath he was said to have a heart of gold and, as a doctor, was much loved and
respected. He died in Dresden on 30 April 1890, aged 69 years. As he wished, he was
cremated at Gotha in the crematorium of which he was a founder. (Plate 41)
shopkeeper. In 1660 he received a sinecure office with the municipal authorities as City
Chamberlain of Delft. This employment provided him with ample leisure to indulge in
his scientific interests. He taught himself the art of lens grinding and used simple
biconvex lenses to magnify the world around him. It is said that, at his death, more than
400 microscopes and magnifying glasses were found. He was extremely jealous of his
inventions and never sold or lent them to anyone, although he did allow visiting
scientists to use them. He never received a formal scientific training and could not write
or read Latin, the medium in which most natural philosophers of his day published their
works. He communicated many of his findings in letters to friends and published many
of his original observations in the Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, of which
he became a foreign member in 1680. He made numerous observations of biological
interest, discovering spermatozoa, erythrocytes, the capillary circulation, Infusoria and
Rotifera in water, and was the first to demonstrate a parasitic protozoon when he found
Giardia lamblia in his own stools. He married Barbara de May, the daughter of a
merchant in Norwich, England in 1654, by whom he had five children. She died in
1666 then he married Cornelia, the daughter of a Calvinist minister, in 1671. He died
in Delft on 26 August 1723 at the great age of 90 and lies buried in the Oude Kerk.
(Plate 44)
minthology in the University of London; he held this position until his retirement in
1946. He founded and edited the Journal of Helminthology and Helminthological
Abstracts, was director of the Institute of Agricultural Parasitology at St. Albans, and
made many other contributions to helminthology, including discovery of the insect
vector of Loa loa. He was elected a fellow of the Royal Society in 1921 and was made
a Companion of the Order of St Michael and St George (C.M.G.) in 1941. He married
Ceinwen Jones in 1908 and had a son and two daughters. It has been said that he had
an unpredictability that was the delight of his friends and the despair of his opponents.
His biographers have written that he was a man of gentle voice and charm of manner
who had a great sense of humour, but also remarked that he did not suffer fools gladly
and that at times his criticisms could be acidulated. His dedicated and unparalleled career
over half a century inspired a fierce loyalty among his countless students and colleagues.
He died on 21 May 1969 aged 88 years. (Plate 46)
Majesty's Army, being promoted to surgeon in 1873 and surgeon-major in 1880. Lewis
and DD Cunningham, having received the highest marks for the British Army and
Indian Medical Services, respectively, were sent to Germany for 3 months then to India
to study the cause of cholera. He worked on this and other subjects in India from 1869
until 1883, usually in conjunction with Cunningham until the latter's appointment as
professor of physiology in the University of Calcutta. Many of his findings were pub-
lished as appendices to the Annual Reports of the Sanitary Commissioner with the
Government of India. In 1879 he married and had two children. In 1883 he was ap-
pointed assistant professor of pathology at the Army Medical School, Netley, England.
In 1886 he was recommended for election as a fellow of the Royal Society. Two weeks
later, on 7 May 1886, he died at his home in Woolston in Southampton, aged 44 years,
from pneumonia and septicaemia following an accidental wound which he received
while performing a post-mortem examination. (Plate 48)
country ennobled him, he took the name of von Linné. Illness progressively impaired his
powers from the 1750's, then during the eighth decade of his life he was subjected to
repeated strokes which dulled his intelligence and finally paralysed him entirely. He died
in Uppsala on 10 January 1778 aged 70 years, and is buried in its cathedral. Following
his death, there was an acrimonious dispute between his son, who had unfortunately
been appointed his successor, and the rest of his family over his herbarium, library and
correspondence. They were eventually sold to England where they were preserved by
the Linnean Society which was founded for that purpose. (Plate 49)
the eggs later recognized as Schistosoma mansoni in 1902. In 1898 the first edition of
his Manual of tropical diseases appeared; successive editions have continued to appear
down to the present day. Manson was the first president of the Society of Tropical
Medicine and Hygiene (now the Royal Society) and has been acclaimed frequently as
the "father of tropical medicine". He was made a Companion of the Order of St Michael
and St George (C.M.G.) in 1900 then was knighted in 1903. He was elected a fellow
of the Royal Society in 1900 and received honorary doctorates from the Universities of
Aberdeen (LL.D., 1886) and Oxford (D.Sc., 1904). For the last thirty years of his life
he was affected by recurrent attacks of gout. Manson was, by all accounts, a most
impressive man in appearance, intellect and personality who was universally mourned
after his death in London on 9 April 1922 at the age of 77 years.
(Plate 54)
Europe, increasing his knowledge and widening his collections. Upon his return to
Denmark, he married into money and thereafter was able to devote himself to scholarly
pursuits until his death at the age of 54 years in Copenhagen on 26 December 1784. He
was generally regarded as an amiable, kind-hearted but somewhat vain man.
of a music teacher. He enrolled in the Naval Medical School and became successively
a surgeon, third class (1855), surgeon second class (1861), physician first class (1865)
and principal physician (1878). His first appointment in 1855 was in the Naval Hospital
(Hôpital de la Marine) in Toulon. Between 1855 and 1880 he served on 20 warships.
He had 20 periods of service on land including at Toulon, Cherbourg, Paris, Marseille,
Rochefort and Lorient. He was made a Chevalier de la Légion d'Honneur (knight of the
legion of honour) in 1863. He served with distinction against two epidemics of yellow
fever on the Normandy and the Massena and took part in campaigns in the Crimea, Italy
and Mexico. He retired at his request in 1884 while based at Lorient and is thought to
have died in 1885.
town Public Hospitals. However great the demands of work, he always found time to
call in the aid of his microscope in the diagnosis of obscure cases. He lived a strenuous
life in a tropical climate, broken by attacks of grave illness. His last work was the
investigation of a severe epidemic of malaria in the upper reaches of the Demerara
River. Unfortunately he contracted the infection and he remained in poor health until
his death on 1 February 1929, leaving his widow, daughter, and two sons.
in the physical sciences in Paris at the École Normale Supérieure, from which he re-
ceived a doctorate of philosophy in 1848, and at the Sorbonne. In 1849 he was ap-
pointed professor of physics at the Lyceum in Dijon. In 1852 he moved to Strasbourg
as professor of chemistry. In 1854 he became professor of chemistry and dean of the
Faculty of Sciences in Lille. It was here that he studied fermentation and showed that
yeast cells were required for the production of alcohol. In 1857 he was recalled to Paris
to direct the scientific studies of the École Normale. It was during this period that he
established the causal relationship of micro-organisms with infectious diseases. In 1863
he was professor of geology and chemistry at the École des Beaux Arts, then from 1867
to 1899 he was professor of chemistry at the Sorbonne. When only 46 years of age in
1868 he had a stroke which left him partially paralysed on one side of his body, and with
impaired speech. As the years passed, he became more interested in infectious diseases,
identifying Staphylococcus aureus in boils and Streptococcus pyogenes fever, and
developed a vaccine against rabies. In 1888 the Pasteur Institute was opened as a
monument to Pasteur funded by public subscriptions. He died seven years later on 28
September 1895, aged 72 years, at the Chateau Villeneuve-l'Étang near Paris. (Plate 64)
to be the work of demons), and described cretinism, amongst many other observations.
He died in Basel on 28 July 1614, aged 77 years.
(Plate 66)
by flies on the meat. Some of Redi's experiments were inconclusive and he accepted that
certain intestinal worms and gall-flies may arise by spontaneous generation. According
to his translator, Bigelow, his "constant friendship for the Jesuits must have had a
maleficent effect on (his) mind, as it exacted blind faith and put a limit to his logic". Redi
never married. During the last nine years of his life he suffered much from epilepsy, and
his death occurred suddenly on the night of 28 February 1697 when he was with the
court at Pisa. He was accorded a public funeral and was buried in the church of San
Francesco at Arezzo, aged 71 years. (Plate 71)
Khedivial Laboratory. He worked heroically during the cholera epidemic of 1882, being
one of the few Europeans who refused to leave Cairo. He left Egypt in 1885 and
travelled as a ship's doctor to South America and eastern Asia. He then returned to
Africa to study schistosomiasis and in 1897 he once more visited Egypt. He finally
retired to Montepiano in Italy, where he died on 19 November 1901, aged 66 years.
(Plate 77)
823
824 A History of Human Helminthology
Kouwenaar 525, 629 Laveran 545, 550 Lewis 14, 55, 362, 599-
Koyama 743 Lavoipierre 649 601, 603, 606, 609,
Krabbe 322, 341-2 Lawless 747 619, 623, 665, 805
Krause 523 Laurie 679 Li 146-7, 302
Krehl 357 Lawrie 625 Libby 282
Kreis 549 Lawton 249 Libermann 545, 550
Krull 59, 116, 298 Le Bas 405-6 Lichtenstein 16, 302,
Küchenmeister 11-3, Le Clerc 38, 82, 771-2, 309
24-5, 46-9, 110, 118, 803 Lie 301
325, 327-30, 332-3, Leach 440 Lim 90
342, 364-70, 372-3, Leared 342 Lin 723
376, 388, 392, 400-1, Lebeder 335 Lind 699, 713
410, 432-3, 441, 445, Lebied 649 Linnaeus 1, 4, 18, 40,
448, 457-8, 481, 483, Lee R 721-2 105-6, 359, 362, 286,
500, 579, 584, 694-5, Leeuwenhoek 25, 33, 422, 440, 457, 469-70,
699, 706, 773, 802 36, 104-7, 803 696, 769, 806
Kudiche 85, 261 Leichtensern 54, 504-5, Linné von - see
Kuhne 589 507, 549, 618 Linnaeus
Kuipers 725 Leidy 128, 423, 577-8, Linschoten van 616,
Kumagawa 274 729, 804 641, 698, 710, 771
Kurata 281 Leiper 23-4, 56, 129, Linstow von 298, 473,
Kurimoto 264, 422 145, 190, 195, 201-4, 562, 740-1
Kurlow von 554 218, 220, 239-42, 255, Lisbonne 337, 775
Kuwabara 151 264, 272-4, 301, 305, Lister 707
Kwan 129 308-9, 406, 431, 440, Liston 708, 711
Kynsey 505, 515 470, 502, 506, 527, Little 605
647-8, 668, 697-8, Liu 89
Labadie-Lagrave 663 703-5, 709, 713, 731, Livois 325
Lacroix 666-7, 671, 677 733, 735, 740-4, 746, Lobo-Sanahuja 725
Laennec 325 776, 804 Locke 338
Laigret 668 Lemoine 598 Loeper 83
Lambert 87, 217 Lentz 447 Löffler 483
Lambinet 510 Leon 301 Logan 283, 645
Lämmler 89 LeRoux 288 Lombard 527
Lamson 86-7, 486, 525 Leske 432, 805 Loney 642
Lane 303, 309, 488, 502, Leuckart F 11 Looss 54-5, 129, 142-3,
517, 522, 524-6, 615, Leuckart R 48-51, 53-4, 163, 195, 197, 199-
747, 803 110-1, 113, 115, 120, 200, 218, 220, 236-40,
Langen de 86, 510, 560- 128-9, 161, 163, 325, 298, 301-3, 500, 502,
1 333, 357, 367, 369, 504-11, 518, 527, 548,
Langer 775 388-90, 400-1, 422-4, 552, 553, 643, 746-7,
Laning 280 427, 441, 446, 458, 774, 807
Lankester 127, 130, 803 472-4, 502-3, 547-8, Lopez 642
Lapage 741 575, 581-3, 609-10, Loria-Cortes 725
Lapierre 288 662, 665, 677, 702, Lortet 196-7, 199
Larumbe 682 805 Lotsy 212
Lasbrey 214 Levine 89 Low 55, 288, 611-2, 622,
Lautner 205 Levinson 731 645-6, 650, 665-6,
830 A History of Human Helminthology
836
Subject Index 837