Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Control of A Micro Grid Supplied by Renewable Energy Sources and Storage Batteries
Control of A Micro Grid Supplied by Renewable Energy Sources and Storage Batteries
Φ
Abstract -- A micro grid supplied entirely by renewable of the load energy. In terms of power, the new system has
energy sources (photovoltaics and wind generators) and a to cope with a projected 50% increase of the load demand.
battery storage system is investigated. The battery converter is One or more of the conventional diesel-driven synchronous
controlled with variable-frequency, variable-amplitude
generators will be engaged only in case the battery is
sinusoidal PWM modulation. The system frequency is
determined by the state of charge (SOC) of the battery while empty. The conventional generator will operate as long as it
the voltage at the main bus is held constant. The PV inverter is takes to charge the battery and then it will be disconnected.
controlled as a current source following a reference active and The most significant challenge in a micro grid is the
reactive power with the active power being a function of the control of the load frequency and voltage, when renewable
system frequency. The induction machine of the wind and/or conventional power sources are used. Numerous
generator (WG) is directly connected to the grid. Detailed
control methods have been proposed with the majority of
simulation shows that with this type of control the grid voltage
and frequency remain within the limits specified by the EN them being based on the implementation of power-
50160 standard even under large variations in active and frequency (P-f) and reactive power-voltage (Q-V) droop
reactive power caused by the wind generator, the PV or the characteristics [1]-[7]. There are cases where battery
load. It is further shown that, by changing the operation mode storage is used [3], [5], [6] and cases where not [1], [2], [7].
of the battery converter to current-controlled, the system can In [5] and [6], WGs with induction machines participate in
provide, in case of faults, adequate current for the protective
the micro grid too, while the PV inverter is controlled as
devices to operate. Since the frequency is used as control
signal, a wireless communication among the renewable energy voltage source which adjusts the phase-angle of the
sources is achieved while the battery SOC and thus its state- terminal voltage. The aim of the various control methods is
of-health is continuously monitored. to keep the voltage and frequency of the micro grid
constant without, however, taking into account the SOC of
Index Terms-- Micro grid, stand-alone converters, PV the battery, which is usually considered as “sufficiently”
inverter, wind generator, power quality, harmonic distortion, large. In a micro grid like the one examined here, another
renewable energy sources
control method based on the battery state of charge (SOC)
is proposed. The battery converter is controlled with
I. INTRODUCTION
sinusoidal PWM modulation at variable frequency and
T HIS paper investigates the behavior, under steady-state
and transient conditions of a micro grid supplied
entirely by renewable energy sources and a battery storage
variable amplitude so that the voltage at the terminals of the
converter (which can be considered as the main bus of the
micro grid) follows a reference value. The PV inverter is
system. The grid studied is that of a small Greek island controlled as current source supplying a reference active
which, at present, is supplied by conventional synchronous and reactive power. The WG is assumed to operate on its
generators driven by diesel engines. There are three own control system following its wind-speed/power
generators each one rated at 220kVA, 400V, 50 Hz and one characteristic. To prevent battery overcharging an
generator rated at 90kVA, 400V, 50Hz. A 3km, 15kV, additional control system is superimposed, according to
overhead line connects the conventional power station with which, the battery converter changes the frequency of the
the load which is concentrated at the single town of the grid following a droop characteristic between frequency
island. Measurements of the load show that, during the and SOC of the battery. The frequency change is detected
summer period, its peak value is 350kW (15min average) by the PV inverter which varies the PV active power
while during the winter 70kW (hourly average). The annual according to a similar droop so as to compensate active
energy consumption is 1020 MWh. It is assumed, in this power fluctuations caused by the load or the WGs. Over-
paper, that the conventional diesel-driven generators are and underfrequency relays disconnect and connect the WG
replaced by a 230 kWp photovoltaic (PV) station and two when the frequency (and thus the battery SOC) exceeds
wind generators each one rated 275 kW. A battery storage specified limits. If the system frequency decreases below a
system of 7.3 MWh will keep the balance between the load certain level (indicating that the battery is empty) a
and the generated power. The energy produced by the conventional synchronous generator is engaged until the
renewable sources is calculated to cover -on average- 90% battery is charged.
The system is simulated with the Psim software and it is
This work was supported by European Regional Development Funds and shown that it operates well under steady-state and transient
Greek National Resources (Ministry of Education, Lifelong Learning Fund
and Religious Affairs, Greece) under Research Grant 09SYN-32-624 conditions. It is also shown that, by changing the control
(Research Program “Cooperation 2009”). mode of the battery converter to current-source, the battery
Emmanouil A. Bakirtzis is with the Department of Electrical and can supply a short-circuit current sufficiently high for the
Computer Engineering of the Aristotle University of Thessaloniki,
Thessaloniki, Greece (e-mail: emmanouil.bakirtzis@gmail.com ). protective means to operate avoiding thus the need for
Charis Demoulias is with the Department of Electrical and Computer rotating synchronous capacitors.
Engineering of the Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Thessaloniki, The single-line diagram of the micro grid is shown in
Greece (e-mail: chdimoul@auth.gr ).
Authorized licensed use limited to: Aalborg Universitetsbibliotek. Downloaded on September 18,2021 at 20:53:08 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
specific micro grid configuration, this short-circuit current
is 1500 A for 2 s (at 400 V level). Converters can usually
supply, for 2 s, 1.5pu of their rated current. Thus, the rated
current of the converter should be 1000 A, which leads to
850 kVA at rated voltage 400 V
2,20
Fig. 1 Single-line diagram of the investigated micro grid
2,15
Fig.1.
2,10
Voc, V
2,05
2054
Authorized licensed use limited to: Aalborg Universitetsbibliotek. Downloaded on September 18,2021 at 20:53:08 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
The reference frequency, fref, of thhe sine wave is was achieved with a switching frequency of 12 kHz and an
determined by the droop characteristic between
b frequency LC filter (L=0.2mH, C=20μF)) at the AC terminals of the
and SOC of the battery. When the SOC C of the battery is converter.
40% the battery is considered empty (perrmissible depth of
C. PV station
discharge 60%) and fref=49 Hz while wheen SOC=100% the
battery is considered full and fref=51 Hz. These frequency The PV station was modeeled as a current-controlled,
limits are dictated by the EN 50160 standdard [8] for island full-bridge, three-phase inverteer with constant dc voltage of
grids. 700 V as shown in Fig. 4. The model has two input values:
The amplitude of the sine wave is determined by a the active power and the voltagge at the terminals of the PV
feedback loop that controls the amplitudee of the ac voltage inverter which must be held constant at 400 V. A PLL
at the terminals of the ac LC filter. The aim is to hold the circuit captures the phase of the grid voltage (which is
voltage at that point (which can be consiidered as the main determined by the battery convverter).
bus of the micro grid) fixed at 4000V (RMS value) The reference value of the active power is equal to the
independently of the active and reactive power
p variations of minimum among: (1) the activve power determined by the
the load, wind park or PV station. Sinnce the converter maximum power point trackerr (MPPT) and, (2) the active
nominal DC voltage is sufficiently higgh (~900 V) the power determined by a powerr-frequency characteristic as
converter operates at the linear region even when the DC shown in Fig. 4. According to this characteristic the power
voltage drops to approximately 881 V when w the battery is of the PV system should bee set to zero if the system
completely discharged. frequency is equal to or largerr than 51 Hz, because at this
With this kind of control the converteer operates at four frequency SOC=100% as menntioned earlier. The battery is
quadrants, i.e., it can charge the battery when
w there is power assumed to be almost fulll when SOC=90% which
surplus or discharge it when there is activve power shortage. corresponds to system frequenncy of 50.67 Hz according to
It can also supply or absorb reactive poweer in order to keep the droop of the battery convverter. Thus, the PV system
the voltage at 400V. should start deteriorating lineaarly its active power from its
rated value to zero as the freqquency increases from 50.67
Hz to 51 Hz. From the instantaaneous currents and voltages
at the inverter terminals thhe actual active power is
calculated and compared to the respective reference value.
The error, through suitable PI P controller, determines the
active current component, ip.
The reference value of the reactive current component,
iq, is determined by
iq = min{iq1 , iq 2 } (2)
2055
Authorized licensed use limited to: Aalborg Universitetsbibliotek. Downloaded on September 18,2021 at 20:53:08 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
given in the injection of active power. of solar power is available. Let’s assume that at t=0.5 s the
From ip and iq the amplitude and phase of the reference SOC=93% (6.78 MWh or 7.54 kAh are available). The
current is determined. Then, the reference current is SOC of the battery is determined by the net electric charge
followed by means of a hysteresis band the width of which into or out of the battery. The variation of the electric
is selected to be 1% of the peak value of the reference charge between t1 and t2 is determined by
current. t2
The switching frequency of the PV inverter was selected Q( Ah) = ∫ I bat (t )dt (4)
to be 20 kHz so that the efficiency of the inverter is t1
between 0.93 and 0.98 according to its load. An LC filter A scaling factor of 1:21600 between real and simulation
(L=0.5mH, C=20μF) is used at the ac side of the PV time was assumed in order to reduce the simulation time.
inverter so that the current THD<4% at full load. Fig. 6 shows the variation of various parameters of the
D. Wind Generators micro grid. Since there is a surplus of 250 kW of active
The wind generators were modeled as an aggregate power the battery keeps on charging with the battery
converter increasing the system frequency (lower graph in
squirrel cage asynchronous machine with six poles, 400V
Fig. 6). The PV inverter compares the active power
and 550 kW rated power. The equivalent moment of inertia
is 200 kgm2 (referred to the generator speed) corresponding determined by its own droop characteristic with the power
set by the MPPT selecting always the smaller of the two.
to an inertia time constant of 2 s. The machine is directly
coupled to the grid which means that it operates as After 0.75s the power determined by the droop is the
constant-speed WG. The WG is assumed to follow its smaller one and thus the PV power decreases below 100
kW. Since the load and WG power remain almost constant,
wind-speed/power characteristic shown in Fig. 5 (for one of
the two WGs). At 3-13 m/s wind speeds the WG follows the battery power increases. When the system frequency
reaches 51 Hz at t=1.1s (SOC=100% or 8.11 kAh) the PV
the wind power while at larger wind speeds and up to 20
m/s it operates as constant power source adjusting power has been decreased to zero and the WG is
continuously its mechanical torque. An underfrequency disconnected by the action of an overfrequency relay. The
WG disconnection causes an abrupt decrease of frequency
relay disconnects the WG at 51 Hz since this frequency
indicates that the SOC=100%. To avoid a cycle of which engages the PV system again and the load is now
supplied by the battery and the PV. Since the PV power is
connections and disconnections, the WG reconnects when
lower than the load power, the battery starts discharging
the system frequency is 49.67 Hz, which corresponds to
SOC=60%. and the control system decreases the frequency. At 49.67
Hz the WG is engaged again by the action of an
E. E. Distribution Lines, Load and Transformers underfrequency relay, causing the battery charge and the
Since the load is concentrated in the single town of the system frequency to start increasing.
island it was modeled as constant impedance. The load is The open-circuit voltage of the battery changes
assumed to be three-phase and symmetrical. The according to the SOC. The same happens to the battery
distribution lines (35mm2 ACSR conductors) were modeled terminal voltage which depends on the open-circuit voltage
with their equivalent positive-sequence impedance of the battery and the charging or discharging current. By
0.6+j0.393 Ω/km. The 15/04 kV transformers were constantly adapting the modulation ratio of the dc/ac
modeled with their equivalent series resistance and leakage converter, the RMS value of the main bus voltage is held
reactance. constant near the nominal value (400 V) except for small
periods during the disconnection and reconnection of the
300
WG which causes abrupt changes in the reactive power.
250
It is thus shown that, with the proposed control method,
the micro grid maintains the frequency and voltage of the
200 system within the limits specified by the EN 50160
standard while at the same time prevents the battery
Power, kW
150
overcharge. Moreover, this is accomplished without any
100
communication between the RES because the frequency of
the system is acting as signal for their coordination.
50
B. Case 2
0
0 5 10 15 20
In this case the load is again assumed to be 400 kW,
Wind Speed, m/s
PF=0.8 lag. According to the MPPT of the PV system 100
Fig. 5. Wind speed/power characteristic of each of the two 275 kW, WGs.
kW of solar power is available. The wind speed is initially
assumed 8 m/s with the WG producing 300 kW and then (at
t=1s) it starts oscillating around this value with 4 m/s
IV. SIMULATION RESULTS
amplitude and a frequency of 1 Hz. At this range of wind
A. Case 1 velocities, the mechanical power of the WG follows the
In this case the load is assumed to be 400 kW with 0.8 wind power. Since the rotational speed of the WG is almost
lagging power factor (PF). The wind velocity is assumed 15 constant the variation of the mechanical power reflects to a
m/s which means that the WGs produce 550 kW constant respective variation of the mechanical torque given by
power. According to the MPPT of the PV system 100 kW Tmech (kNm) = −2.86 + 1.43sin(2 ⋅ π ⋅ t ) (5)
2056
Authorized licensed use limited to: Aalborg Universitetsbibliotek. Downloaded on September 18,2021 at 20:53:08 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Fig. 6. Variation of electric parameters for Case 1.
2057
Authorized licensed use limited to: Aalborg Universitetsbibliotek. Downloaded on September 18,2021 at 20:53:08 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
line voltage at its terminals drops below 300 V (RMS). The The PV system and the WG are disconnected from the
current supplied to the load increases to 1500 A resulting in micro grid at the appearance of the fault and are
the clearing fault after 2 s. The clearing of the fault causes resynchronized with the grid after the fault is cleared. The
the system voltage to rise. When the voltage rises above disconnection and reconnection are triggered by under- and
300 V overvoltage relays respectively.
V. CONCLUSIONS
It is shown that a micro grid with a PV station, a wind
generating system and a battery storage system, can
maintain the voltage and frequency within the limits
specified by the EN 50160 standard (for island grids) even
under large load or generating-power variations by
implementing a new control method which takes into
account the SOC of the battery. Since with the proposed
control method the system frequency acts as control signal
among the battery converter and the RES, there is no need
for wired communication among them. The battery
Fig. 8. Voltage at the main bus and load current before, during and after a converter determines the system voltage and frequency and,
short circuit. assisted by the PV inverter, takes care of the SOC of the
battery. By continuously monitoring the battery SOC, its
state of health can also be estimated. The induction WG
(RMS) the battery inverter switches back to the default
machine needs no electrical control except over- and
control method supplying the load with constant voltage.
underfrequency relays for its disconnection and connection
2058
Authorized licensed use limited to: Aalborg Universitetsbibliotek. Downloaded on September 18,2021 at 20:53:08 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
according to the battery SOC. During short-circuits the Proc. of 35th Power Electronics Specialists Conference, Aachen,
Germany, 2004.
battery converter is controlled as current source in order to [7] Caldon R., Rossetto F., Turri R., “Temporary islanded operation of
provide significant short circuit current for the grid dispersed generation on distribution networks,” in Proc. of 39th
protection systems to operate avoiding thus the need for Universities Power Engineering Conference (UPEC), 2004, Bristol,
UK.
rotating synchronous capacitors.
[8] Voltage characteristics of electricity supplied by public distribution
system, Standard EN 50160, 2004.
VI. REFERENCES [9] Charis Demoulias, “A new simple analytical method for calculating
the optimum inverter size in grid-connected PV plants”, Electric.
[1] Karel De Brabandere, Bruno Bolsens, Jeroen Van den Keybus,
Power. Systems. Research., 80 (2010) pp.1197–1204
Achim Woyte, Johan Driesen, and Ronnie Belmans, "A Voltage and
[10] Daniel Fregosi, Subhashish Bhattacharya and Stanley Atcitty,
Frequency Droop Control Method for Parallel Inverters,” IEEE
“Empirical Battery Model Characterizing a Utility-scale Carbon-
Trans. Power Delivery, vol. 22, pp. 1107-1115, July 2007.
enhanced VRLA Battery”, in Proc. Of Energy Conversion Congress
[2] Alfred Engler, “Applicability of droops in low voltage grids,”
and Exposition (ECCE), Arizona, USA, 2011.
International Journal of Distributed Energy Resources, Vol. 1, No.1,
(2005), pp.3-15
[3] Justin Au-Yeung, Greet M.A. Vanalme, Johanna M.A. Myrzik,
Panagiotis Karaliolios, Martijn Bongaerts, Jan Bozelie, Wil L. Kling, VII. BIOGRAPHIES
“Development of a Voltage and Frequency Control Strategy for an
Autonomous LV Network with Distributed Generators,” in Proc. of Emmanouil A. Bakirtzis (S’ 2008) was born in Serres, Greece. He
44th Universities Power Engineering Conference (UPEC), 2009,
received his Diploma in Electrical Engineering from the Aristotle
Glasgow, UK. University of Thessaloniki, Thessaloniki, Greece, in March 2010. He is
[4] Xueguang Wu, Yibin Zhang, Atputharajah Arulampalam, Nick
Ph.D. candidate in Aristotle University of Thessaloniki since February
Jenkins, “Electrical Stability of Large Scale Integration of Micro
2012.
Generation into Low Voltage Grids,” International Journal of His research interests are in the fields of power electronics, power quality,
Distributed Energy Resources, Vol. 1, No4 (2005), pp. 279-298.
electric machines, renewable energy sources and power system economics.
[5] F. D. Kanellos, A. I. Tsouchnikas, N. D. Hatziargyriou, “Micro-Grid
Simulation during Grid-Connected and Islanded Modes of Charis S. Demoulias (M’96, SM’11) was born in 1961. He received the
Operation,” in Proc. of the International Conference on Power
Dipl. and Ph.D. degrees in electrical engineering from the Aristotle
Systems Transients (IPST’05), Montreal, Canada, 2005, Paper No.
University of Thessaloniki, Thessaloniki, Greece, in 1984 and 1991,
IPST05 – 113. respectively. Currently, he is Assistant Professor with the Electrical
[6] S. Papathanassiou, D. Georgakis, N. Hatziargyriou, A. Engler, Ch.
Machines Laboratory, Department of Electrical and Computer
Hardt, “Operation of a prototype Microgrid system based on micro-
Engineering, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki.
sources equipped with fast-acting power electronics interfaces,” in His research interests are in the fields of power electronics, harmonics,
electric motion systems, and renewable energy sources.
2059
Authorized licensed use limited to: Aalborg Universitetsbibliotek. Downloaded on September 18,2021 at 20:53:08 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)