Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 10

global marketing strategy and leaves opportunities open for local products

and brands.
Johny K. Johansson As the notion of integrated marketing
communications (see INTEGRATED MARKET-
INTRODUCTION ING COMMUNICATION STRATEGY ) suggests,
the ensuing consistency can have positive
A global marketing strategy (GMS) is a strategy revenue benefits because of reinforcement of a
that encompasses countries from several unique message, spillovers between countries,
different regions in the world and aims at co- and so on. But the main driving force behind
ordinating a company’s marketing efforts in the adoption of a GMS is the scale and
markets in these countries. scope of cost advantages from such uniform
A GMS does not necessarily cover all coun- marketing strategies. These cost advantages
tries but it should apply across several regions. include elimination of unnecessary duplication
A typical regional breakdown is as follows: of effort, savings on multilingual and same-size
Africa, Asia, and the Pacific (including Australia) packaging, use of the same promotional material,
Europe and the Middle East, Latin America, and quantity discounts when buying media, and so
North America. A ‘‘regional’’ marketing strategy on. The pros and cons of a GMS are given in
is one that coordinates the marketing effort in Table 2.
one region.
A GMS should not be confused with a global
production strategy. Outsourcing and foreign THE ORGANIZATIONAL CONTEXT
manufacturing subsidiaries, common features Firms typically contemplate adopting a more
of a global production strategy, can be used coordinated GMS, once they have significant
with or without a GMS for the finished prod- presence in several countries and regions. Since
ucts. local markets will never be exactly the same,
As listed in Table 1, GMSs can involve one a proposed global strategy will generally not be
or more of several activities. welcomed by the country managers. The existing
The coordination involved in implementing local operations will have to be convinced to
a GMS unavoidably leads to a certain level adopt the new global strategy. Thus, a GMS
of uniformity of branding, of packaging, of is always top-down, not bottom-up, and it is
promotional appeal, and so on (Zou and easy for antiglobalization sentiments to stir even
Cavusgil, 2002). This also means that a GMS, within a multinational company.
in some ways, goes counter to a true customer The typical solution to this problem is to allow
orientation (see MARKETING PLANNING). The country managers to be involved in the formu-
product and marketing mix are not adapted lation of the GMS, and to form cross-national
to local preferences, as a customer orientation teams to participate in the implementation. It
suggests. This is a potential weakness of GMSs, is also common to designate one country the
‘‘lead’’ market for the strategy, and use its current
Table 1 Components of a global marketing strategy as a starting point for the global strategy.
strategy. This lead country is typically one of the larger
markets and one where the firm has a strong
Items Listed in Order of Descending Occurrence market share. In multibrand firms, it is also
common to limit a global strategy to one or two
• Identical brand names brands, allowing the local subsidiaries to keep
• Uniform packaging control of some of their own brands.
• Standardized products
• Similar advertising messages GLOBAL SEGMENTATION AND POSITIONING
• Coordinated pricing
• Synchronized product introductions The firms most likely to engage in GMSs
• Coordinated sales campaigns are those present in global markets. Global
markets are those where customer needs, wants,

Wiley International Encyclopedia of Marketing, edited by Jagdish N. Sheth and Naresh K. Malhotra.
Copyright © 2010 John Wiley & Sons Ltd
2 global marketing strategy
Table 2 General pros and cons of global marketing strategies.
Pros Cons

• Revenue side Reinforced message, unique idea Culturally insensitive


Spillover of brand awareness Antiglobal target
Enhanced liking (mere exposure) Vulnerable to gray trade
• Cost side Reduces duplication, waste Requires managerial time
Uniform product design, packaging, Lowers morale in subsidiaries, agencies
advertising
Quantity discounts in media buy

and preferences are quite similar across the increase the chances of finding homogeneous
globe (see MARKET DEFINITION). Typical subgroups within each region. Often the first
product categories are technology products, step amounts to selecting a trade bloc, such
including consumer electronics, cameras and as the European Union. As research has
computers, branded luxury products, and documented, many global strategies are, in fact,
also apparel, personal care, and entertainment more regional than global (Rugman, 2005).
categories where, for certain segments, globally A GMS can also be successful if the firm has
standardized products are desired by all. By managed to change local preferences. A new
contrast, in multidomestic markets such as product entering a local market will usually
food and drink, where preferences are more change preferences to some degree, whether by
culturally determined, global coordination is new features, promotion, or price. This is the
less common (see CUSTOMER ANALYSIS). basis for the extreme standardization proposed
For example, ACNielsen’s cross-national data by Levitt in his seminal 1983 HBR (Harvard
suggest there are only 43 global brands in the Business Review) article, where he suggests that
consumer packaged goods categories found in ‘‘everybody’’ likes the same products. Examples
the typical supermarket (ACNielsen, 2001). of this abound. IKEA, the Swedish furniture
retailer, has changed the market for furniture in
Global segmentation. The need to target similar many countries – it uses a very standardized and
segments in different countries is an attempt to coordinated marketing strategy, focusing around
minimize the drawbacks of a coordinated global its simple and functional furniture, annual
strategy (see MARKET SEGMENTATION AND catalog, and warehouse stores. Starbucks, the
TARGETING ). A typical cross-national segment American coffee chain, also has re-created and
targeted with a standardized product is the enlarged a mature market in several countries
teenage and young adult segments, where pref- with its new coffee choices, novel store layouts,
erences are allegedly very similar even for food and wider menu. In other cases, changes in
and drink categories. Coca Cola uses the same the environment have affected preferences so
one-word slogan ‘‘Always’’ around the world. as to make standardization possible. ‘‘Green’’
Nike is positioned with a rebellious image in products are naturally targeting global segments,
many countries, even though the particular as are the lighter beers, the bottled waters,
sports associated with Nike differ by country. and the shift to wines. Such global segments
Technology brands such as the iPod have usually naturally induce companies to adopt GMSs.
even more coordinated global strategies, with
synchronized rollouts of new models across Global positioning. The main issue in global
countries. positioning (see POSITIONING ANALYSIS AND
Global marketers might use a two-stage STRATEGIES) is whether the product offering
approach to market segmentation (see MARKET should be positioned the same way everywhere or
SEGMENTATION AND TARGETING ), first not. Complicating the issue is the fact that even
grouping countries into similar regions to with complete uniformity of the marketing mix,
global marketing strategy 3
the arrived-at position may still differ between Nokia, Samsung, and Sony-Ericsson occupy
countries. A classic example are Levi’s jeans, quite different positions in each market.
whose rugged outdoors image places it in a main- The stage of the life cycle (see STAGES OF THE
stream American lifestyle segment, but becomes PRODUCT LIFE CYCLE ) is also likely to vary
a stylish icon in other countries. Also, as this across countries, affecting how well a particular
example illustrates, even if a brand wants to be position can be transferred. In the early stages,
seen as ‘‘global,’’ its position is typically affected with preferences still in flux, a strategy based on
positively or negatively by its country of origin. the positioning in a lead country may not be very
A fundamental factor affecting transferability effective in a new country. Thus, the first auto-
of a position is the actual use of the product. A matic single-lens reflex camera was introduced
food product such as apples might be consumed by Canon as a mainstream product in Japan,
as a healthy snack in the West (‘‘An apple a day but a specialty product for more professional
keeps the doctor away’’ as the saying goes). But in photography overseas. In emerging countries
Japan, apples are a favorite item in the gift-giving with their pent-up demand, however, even new
season, placing a premium on color, packaging, consumers aspire for the best products in the
and price – hardly the same positioning. leading markets. This is why some Western
Even without such dramatic usage differ- companies (such as Electrolux, the home appli-
ences, differences in economic development and ance manufacturer) will position themselves at
cultural distance, in general, are main factors the top of the market even in a country like
influencing the potential for an identical posi- Russia.
tion. A Ford car may be positioned as a functional The typical strategic assumption is that a
value product in Europe, but might be a status globally uniform positioning requires similarity
symbol in a poor country. First-time buyers in of culture, of competition, and of life cycle
emerging markets rarely view products the same stage. However, even in countries where one
way as buyers in the more mature markets, where or more of these requirements are not met, a
preferences are well established. For example, standardized global positioning may still work.
the successful Buicks offered to new customers For example, when global communications have
in China offer quite different benefits from those made the brand name already well known, a
offered Buick customers in the United States, global strategy may work even in a multidomestic
even though the product is largely the same. market. McDonald’s successful entry into many
The strength of local competition (see emerging markets is a case in point. And even
COMPETITIVE ANALYSIS) is also likely to where domestic competition is strong and would
vary across countries, affecting the positioning. suggest a niche positioning, external events
Where domestic competitors are strong, a may shift the market in favor of a newcomer.
foreign brand that is a mainstream brand at This happened, for example, when the Japanese
home will typically attempt to target a niche autos entered the American market and gained
abroad. This applies to many European brands strength during the 1970s oil crisis. But these
including Heineken, Illycaffe, and Volvo. In are exceptions and are certainly not automatic, as
other cases, a company with a niche position at Coca Cola learned in India when local ThumsUp
home may target a more mainstream position in rebounded (see the section Global Brands).
another market – an example is Japanese Honda
in the US auto market. In global markets, where
often the same global players compete in the THE GLOBAL MARKETING MIX
major foreign markets, positioning is more likely
to remain constant across the mature markets. Global products and services. Standardization
Examples include automobiles, with the global of the product or service is usually a major
players occupying very similar positions in feature of a global MARKETING MIX. ‘‘Product
most markets. This is less true for new product Standardization’’ means uniformity of product
categories that are still in the growth stage in or service features, design, and styling. There
many countries and the brands are not equally are several advantages to such standardization,
well known everywhere. Cell phone makers including those listed in Table 3.
4 global marketing strategy
Table 3 Advantages of product Table 4 Disadvantages of product
standardization. standardization.

• Cost reduction • Off-target


• Improved quality • Lack of uniqueness
• Enhanced customer preference

distribution. The BMW Z4 sports car is only


The advantages are mainly on the cost side – produced in South Carolina. Apple computers
scale economies from the larger number of iden- are all produced in Taiwan. In general, however,
tical units produced. But there are also quality the risks of local strikes and political conflict
advantages involved. With longer series, there is make most companies assign production to more
more reason to invest in specialized technology, than one site.
machine tools, components, and parts, yielding From a marketing perspective, a uniform
higher and more consistent quality. Finally, product or service is often less acceptable locally.
there is a possible positive demand effect on Of course, some localization is always necessary
customers. Because of the prevalence of the in any case – electric appliances face different
products and designs, the ‘‘mere exposure’’ of voltages and plugs, safety regulations differ
individuals to the products engenders a posi- between countries, and homologation require-
tive impact on preferences. This is an effect ments differ. But the more critical issues revolve
which partly depends on competitive imitation – around customer acceptance. What is seen as a
when most cell phones feature a built-in camera, good product or service in one market might not
consumers ‘‘want’’ a camera with their cell phone be acceptable elsewhere.
(see COMPETITIVE ANALYSIS). The fact is that there are relatively few prod-
The disadvantages of product standardization ucts and services that are identical around the
are mainly on the demand side (see Table 4). world. One would expect that products in global
Apart from the case of pent-up demand in an markets, such as technology products, would be
emerging country, standardized products rarely identical. But generally speaking, PCs and cell
manage to target precisely a specific segment in phones are smaller in Asia, automobiles have a
a new country market. They are at least slightly harder suspension in Europe than in the United
off target. This is not always such an obstacle to States, and even stereo speakers vary slightly
success. First, preferences may change – the stan- in bass level between North America (heavy
dardized product may offer features not offered on bass) and Asia (where smaller apartments
before in that market. Honda’s 1970s entry into places the listener closer). The classic failure
the US car market exemplifies this case, with the by Euro Disney to transfer its American theme
car offering both fuel efficiency and sportiness. park unchanged to France is a good example of
Second, a mispositioning may be overcome by a misguided standardization of a service product.
strong brand name. The McDonald’s entries in Despite the success of the strategy in Tokyo,
emerging markets fall in this category. Third, the Euro effort fell flat for many reasons, one
the entering product may well be sold at a of which was the no-alcohol rule inimical to
low price – its scale advantages can allow such Continental Europeans.
a strategy. This was the strategy followed by Luxury products are usually the same across
Samsung before its later drive toward a strong the globe, and utilitarian items such as automo-
global brand (Quelch and Harrington, 2004). bile tires, toothpaste, and kitchen utensils can
Since the typical multinational company does be standardized. But products such as sham-
manufacturing in a large number of country poos, soaps, and personal-care items need to
subsidiaries, the need for scale has sometimes take account of hair types, skin color, and
made it necessary to designate local production water quality to perform satisfactorily. Coca
sites as suppliers for the whole world. Toyota’s Cola’s level of sweetness differs across coun-
Kentucky plant produces the Camry for global tries, McDonald’s menu is adapted to country
global marketing strategy 5
preferences (partly to reduce antiglobalization Interbrew’s global ‘‘flagship’’ brand (Beamish
protests), and apparel manufacturers have to and Goerzen, 2000).
make adjustments for different body proportions Three definitions follow:
between Western and Asian peoples.
To deal with these adaptations while trying to • Global brands are brands that are well known
retain some scale economies, companies resort and recognized in all major markets of
to two solutions. One solution is to use the same the world. (e.g., Sony, Mercedes-Benz,
basic design or ‘‘platform’’ for the product, and Microsoft, Nokia).
then adapt by adding alternative features at the • Regional brands are brands that are the same
later stage of manufacturing. This is common across a region (e.g., P&G’s Ariel in Europe
in automobiles, where the platform involves the is Tide elsewhere; Acura is Honda Legend
chassis on which the body is then fitted. But in Asia).
the concept is also used in the manufacturing • Local brands are brands found in only one or
of electronic products, computers, and home two markets (e.g., Suntory whisky in Japan,
appliances. This is the solution adopted by Coca A&W root beer in the United States, and the
Cola and McDonald’s as well. Trabant car in former East Germany).
A second related option is to break up the
product into component modules that can
be produced in large series to gain the scale Strictly speaking, the brand may be global
advantages, and then produce different products although the product is not available every-
by different combinations of modules. This where – as happens to be the case for Rolls Royce
has become a very prominent manufacturing as well as for Coca Cola. This usually means
strategy for large companies, since it allows there may be a pent-up demand for some global
the different modules to be outsourced and brands, as was seen when McDonald’s entered
offshored. The manufacturing process then Russia in the 1990s.
becomes a simple assembly process, which can Global brands have received increased atten-
then be done locally, if necessary, to gain lower tion from top management in many multina-
tariff rates. This allows the company to ‘‘mix and tionals because of the importance of brand equity
match’’ features for different country markets, as a financial asset (see PERCEPTION OF BRAND
which helps adaptation to local preferences. It EQUITY ). Expanding into new markets is an
also helps to make the products in different obvious way of building further financial equity,
markets somewhat different, helping to limit which is usually calculated by simply aggregating
gray trade (more on gray trade below). projected revenues across country markets. Not
In the end, companies do not need to offer surprisingly, most top brands in terms of finan-
identical products everywhere in order to gain cial equity are global. But a strong brand not
the scale economies of product standardization. only needs reach across countries, it also needs
Thus, a company can develop a coordinated allegiance from local customers. As global brands
global strategy even without a completely stan- have stretched further to build financial equity,
dardized product. But it is almost impossible to local brands have been able to defend their turf
develop a GMS without a strong global brand. by staying closer to their customer and building
affinity, or what may be called soft equity (see
Global brands. Keeping the same brand name CUSTOMER EQUITY).
everywhere has become the signature feature Recognizing this, many global companies not
of a global marketer, and ‘‘global branding’’ only market their global brand in a country
has become an obsession among many multina- market but might also buy up a successful local
tionals. For example, the Interbrew (now InBev) brand and retain its brand name – and customers.
company’s analysis of the Heineken advantage One example is Coca Cola in India. After its
in profitability draws the conclusion that it reentry in 1993 (Coca Cola had exited India in
is the lack of a global brand that depresses 1977 instead of giving up its secret formula),
its own bottom-line performance. Hence, top Coca Cola acquired ThumsUp, a leading local
management has decreed that Stella Artois be producer, with the idea of replacing its brand
6 global marketing strategy
with Coca Cola. But after several efforts at with- Table 6 Advantages for local brands.
drawing ThumsUp and launching its own brand,
Coca Cola finally gave up and shifted marketing • Local brand affinity
resources to ThumsUp. The problem was that • Motivated local employees
Coca Cola was positioning itself as the young • Prodomestic (and Antiglobalization) sentiment
teenage drink, just as it had done in many coun-
tries, while in India, where alcohol consumption
is very limited for religious and cultural reasons, Global brands, as Naomi Klein claims, have
the main cola market was among young adults changed the playing field – but they have not,
who in other parts of the world were drinking as she claims, simply dominated local brands
beer. ThumsUp in India is a rebel’s drink, hardly (Klein, 2002).
the image of Coca Cola.
The most clear-cut advantages of global Global pricing and distribution. In GMSs,
brands are the cost efficiencies from scale and pricing, and distribution are more closely
scope. The typical benefits to global brands are connected than at home. The reason is
several (see Table 5). not that the costs involved in distribution
The cost efficiencies tend to come from the (transportation but also insurance and custom
ability to produce identical products and pack- duties) necessarily raise the final price to the
aging in long series, and also because global customer. Such straight ‘‘price escalation’’
brands can draw on uniform global promo- does not usually occur except in one-time
tions (more on this below). Demand spillover transactions. Many multinationals have strong
is a result of the increased exposure to the home market ‘‘cash cows,’’ and when faced with
same brand in many places, especially useful more intense competition in foreign markets
when customers are global. The growth of inter- they reduce prices by lowering transfer prices to
national tourism has been a strong driver of their subsidiaries. Some firms also use foreign
global brands. The status and esteem advan- markets as an easy way out of overcapacity,
tages have been shown by researchers, especially applying marginal cost pricing procedures
prominent in less-developed countries. While (although these can run afoul of dumping
some research has demonstrated a high quality laws). And the improved efficiency of global
perception for global brands, the more firmly transportation, thanks to global express carriers
established finding is that global brands tend to and consolidated shipment procedures, means
have a more consistent quality than local brands. that geographic distance is no longer the trade
The disadvantages of global brands become barrier it once was. Transportation costs are
advantages for local brands. Local brands can typically a small proportion of the total price
usually count on the advantages in Table 6. paid (see MARKETING CHANNEL STRATEGY).
Of course, none of these advantages come The strong connection between pricing and
without effort and disciplined application by the distribution rests more directly on another
firms, whether global or local. The arrival of phenomenon. The ease of transportation,
global brands into many markets has been a coupled with differing local prices and currency
challenge for many local brands who think that fluctuations, are what provide the margin
local consumers will automatically stay loyal. that allows for arbitrage opportunities for
customers to buy branded products cheaper
abroad. This is an instance of so-called ‘‘gray
Table 5 Benefits to global brands. trade’’ – the importation of branded products
through other than authorized channels (see
• Scale and scope economies MULTICHANNEL MARKETING). It is the rise
• Demand spillover of gray trade that force multinationals to decide
• Global customers pricing and distribution strategies jointly – and
• High esteem, status even multinationals that would otherwise not
• Consistent quality contemplate a global strategy, have to find a way
to align prices to avoid such trade.
global marketing strategy 7
Gray trade affects a number of multinationals. in relationship building with distributors, screen
For example, there are numerous stories of Asian orders carefully, and monitor shipments.
contract manufacturers who make branded prod- Because of pricing regulations, the multi-
ucts for Western multinationals on day shifts, national producer cannot usually dictate
and then produce an added batch of identical retail prices in local markets (see PRICING
products on the night shift. These products are STRATEGY). Nevertheless, to achieve the
then shipped abroad at low costs, distributed via desired brand position, they can use suggested
indirect channels perhaps from a third country, retail prices. These are the prices that have to be
and finally appear on the various markets in coordinated across countries because customers
the West. In other cases, gray trade involves can purchase the products anywhere in the
Western distributors (large European retailers, world. But to coordinate prices is difficult, for
for example) who acquire goods in a low-priced several reasons as shown in Table 8.
country and then sell it at higher prices at home. One single global price is unrealistic. Even
Britain’s Tesco chain sent buyers to Wal-Mart though a business-to-business company such as
stores in the United States to buy Levi’s for Boeing, the aircraft builder, quotes all its prices
resale at home, a practice that was stopped in American dollars, exchange rate problems still
by a European court. Another popular form of arise for its customers. For many global compa-
gray trade, ‘‘shopping tourism,’’ is what happens nies, the solution is to devise ‘‘pricing corridors,’’
when overseas trips are arranged for tourists to centered around a desired positioning price. The
buy products cheaper in a foreign country. ‘‘corridors’’ are the limits of prices between
The drivers of gray trade include the factors which the local price may vary without inter-
in Table 7. ference from headquarters. The price corridors
Gray trade is not usually illegal. By contrast, should reflect not only demand and competitive
trade in counterfeits (fake products) is illegal and pressure in the local market but also the differ-
vigorously opposed by multinationals that fear ences in exchange rates and likelihood of gray
the loss of revenue and dilution of their brand distribution – a very difficult balancing act. In
name. But there are similar negative effects addition to formal corridors with a centralized
from gray trade as from counterfeits. Gray positioning price, the global pricing coordination
trade strains the relationship with authorized typically involves informal coordination with the
channel members since channel members face local subsidiary to allow flexibility (Assmus and
intrabrand competition. There may be legal Wiese, 1995).
liabilities, usually involving warranties that
Global marketing communications. Next to
cannot be honored. There is also a risk of
global brands, the most visible aspect of a GMS
erosion of brand equity because of the lower
is perhaps global advertising. Global advertising
price in the market. Seiko, the Japanese watch
can be defined as media advertising that is
maker, has failed to establish itself as a strong
more or less uniform across many countries,
premium brand partly for this reason. And gray
often, but not necessarily, in media vehicles
trade complicates global coordination when one
with global reach. Although global appeals had
country realizes a sudden influx of gray goods.
been used previously in promotions – IBM’s
Even though companies cannot take legal action,
when faced with gray trade, they have to engage
Table 8 Why global coordination of prices is
difficult.
Table 7 Selected drivers of ‘‘gray trade.’’
• Currency exchange rates fluctuate
• Transportation is global and efficient • Local distributors are independent
• Trade barriers are low • Import prices to subsidiaries have to consider
• Products and brands are standardized tariffs, taxes.
• Communication is global • Local competition varies across countries
8 global marketing strategy
Table 9 Major drivers of global advertising. development of global advertising and promo-
tions that can be used effectively everywhere.
Supply Side There are cost savings in buying all media from
• Global ad agencies one consolidated source.
• Global media On the demand side, customers are increas-
ingly global. Consumers now travel much
Demand Side more than before as the lower cost of travel
• Global customers have made for many more tourists, and for
• Preference convergence business-to-business products, the customers
are often multinational companies. In addition,
with global communication producing spillovers
between countries, local preferences change
global ‘‘Think’’ slogan appeared as early as and allow the penetration of global brands
the 1920s – global advertising arrived with the in local markets using standardized appeals.
advertising agency Saatchi & Saatchi’s television Globally coordinated advertising thus becomes
commercial ‘‘Manhattan Landing’’ for British a natural complement to the global brand. It has
Airways in the early 1980s. With increasing given us the ‘‘Always’’ of Coca Cola, the ‘‘Our
globalization and the stress on global brands, Passion’’ of Microsoft, the ‘‘Do you dream
the momentum behind global advertising has Sony?’’ and ‘‘The Ultimate Driving Machine’’
been sustained despite antiglobalization and of BMW. Global Internet ads are now common,
prolocalization sentiments around the globe. with companies such as IBM and Heineken
One contributing factor has been the rise producing commercials on their Web home
of the Internet and the availability of many pages and repeated on the YouTube.
commercials on sites such as YouTube, where In the general case, however, not all the
even local advertisement campaigns potentially marketing communications of a global company
have global reach. is globally coordinated. First of all, media adver-
There are several forces behind the need for tising is only one of several promotional tools.
integrated global communications (see INTE- Many retail promotions such as POP (point of
GRATED MARKETING COMMUNICATION purchase), coupons, and free samples, are neces-
STRATEGY). One can distinguish between sarily more localized. Regulations vary across
supply-side drivers and demand-side drivers, as countries. Not all countries’ retail regulations
shown in Table 9. allow contests, for example, and in many cases,
On the supply side, the emergence of consoli- coupon redemptions are denied by stores. Even
dated global advertisement agencies has played a naturally global promotions such as sponsorships
significant role in generating more global adver- of the Olympics and the World Cup often require
tising. Although in many ways, the agency local input to leverage the promotion effectively.
globalization has been a response to the glob- In one notorious instance, Budweiser’s sponsor-
alization of the client firms – global managers ship of the World Cup in Germany in 2006
find it useful to deal with the same agency in encountered opposition from German brewers
different parts of the world – once established, and consumers. In an effort to appease German
the global agency will naturally want to leverage drinkers, Budweiser made a local deal to allow
its global capabilities (as in the Saatchi & Saatchi the German-made Bitburger beer to be sold in
case). The global agency can also claim superior stadiums, albeit in unmarked cups.
production values with a global campaign, since But even media advertising is rarely fully
more resources can be used for one television globalized. The motivation for local subsidiaries
commercial that is going to be shown around and their agencies to do their best creative work
the world. The emergence of global media – is enhanced with more autonomy. Not all media
the BBC, the Sky channel, the CNN, Financial are equally available in all countries, and the
Times, and so on – and their consolidation into costs vary considerably. Effectiveness also varies.
global media companies such as Viacom, Bertels- In poorer countries, print media are usually
mann, and Time Warner has also encouraged the less effective. By contrast, Europe on the whole
global marketing strategy 9
gives much greater weight to print than other a great idea can be used everywhere, a common
countries. The Internet, a new and naturally assertion in advertising circles.
global channel of communications, has still not But even in a global campaign there is usually
penetrated all corners of the world. some variety. The typical form of global adver-
In addition, the advertising message often tising in television follows what is known as
has to be adapted. Linguistic, cultural, and reli- pattern standardization. Here the advertisement
gious differences can prevent standardization of visualization is adapted to local culture and
advertising messages and render symbols inap- language, with recognizable local spokespersons
propriate. IKEA’s use of the Moose, successful and actors, and a story that has local appeal.
in Europe and Canada, was too provincial in the The brand name and logo are identical, and
United States, where a simpler blue-and-yellow the final slogan is usually translated directly.
logo is used. Product usage may not be the Instead of actors speaking, voiceovers allow local
same, making a uniform appeal miss the target. language to be superimposed on a commercial.
Ice cream is bought for its nutritional value in In this form, global advertising is becoming
poorer countries, not so in advanced markets. more common today, creating a unified image of
This means the local subsidiary and its adver- corporations and brands as well as countries and
tising agency usually have to do more than places.
merely translate a message. Not all local adapta- Summarizing, the advantages of global
tions work of course. A Nike advertisement with communications include those shown in
LeBron James, the American athlete, slaying a Table 10. The potential disadvantages are also
dragon turned out to be a failed local adapta- several, as shown in Table 11.
tion in China, where dragons are a force for In the end, most companies play it safe,
good. with some global uniformity but allocating the
Because of these issues, most companies dedi- majority of the funds for regional and local
cate only a portion of their total advertising adaptation of communications.
budget to a global campaign. An example comes
from Samsung, the Korean electronics maker CONCLUSION
who has moved ahead of Sony in global brand GMSs have become increasingly important
value in the last few years (see BRAND VALUE). with the internationalization of business and
In 2003 about 40% of above-the-line budgeting
was for global advertising. The remaining 60%
of a $1 billion budget was allocated to local Table 10 Advantages of integrated global
and regional subsidiaries for their nonglobal communications.
spending on specific products and markets.
While the localized campaigns may employ local • Consistency of brand communications
agencies, it is common for the global campaign • Media spillover
to be handled by one large global agency, FCB • Cost savings
(Foote, Cone, and Belding), in the Samsung • Improved production
case. • Leveraging a great idea
Most global companies place strict limits on
how their name should be portrayed, including
fonts and coloring. Sony requires all uses of their Table 11 The disadvantages of integrated
name and logo to be approved at headquarters in global communications.
Tokyo before release. There are a few identical
ads used, particularly in print advertising. The • Images and symbols might not be locally accept-
Marlboro cowboy can be seen around the world. able
The well known Absolut advertisements, with • Appropriate media might not be available
the shape of the bottle contoured in the adver- • Product usage is not the same
tisement, are used in many countries, sometimes • Local creativity can be stifled
localized. These are examples of the notion that
10 global marketing strategy
globalization of markets. Even though they Dawar, N. and Parker, P. (1994) Marketing universals:
are characterized by centralized coordination consumers’ use of brand name, price, physical appear-
and streamlining to achieve scale and scope ance, and retailer reputation as signals of product
quality. Journal of Marketing, 58 (2), 81–95.
economies, localization, and adaptation are
Ghemawat, P. (2007) Why the World isn’t flat. Foreign
becoming increasingly important as emerging
Policy, 159 (5), 60.
markets rapidly manifest culturally and ethni-
Holt, D.B., Quelch, J.A., and Taylor, E.L. (2004) How
cally differentiated consumer demand. Global
global brands compete. Harvard Business Review,
success depends crucially on striking the right 82 (9), 68–81.
balance between uniformity and local adapta- Klein, N. (2002) No Logo: No Space, No Choice, No Jobs,
tion. This balance, as we have seen, involves Picador, New York.
both top-down leadership and sensitivity to Quelch, J. and Harrington, A. (2004) Samsung Elec-
local markets – a true managerial challenge. tronics Company: Global Marketing Operations. Case
9-504-051. Harvard Business School, Boston, MA,
p. 32.
Bibliography Roth, M.S. (1995) The effects of culture and socioeco-
nomics on the performance of global brand image
ACNielsen (2001) Reaching the Billion-Dollar Mark: A strategies. Journal of Marketing Research, 32 (2),
Review of Today’s Global Brands. ACNielsen Inc., 163–175.
Chicago.
Rugman, A. (2005) The Regional Multinationals,
Alden, D.L., Steenkamp, J.-B.E.M., and Batra, R. (1999)
Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Brand positioning through advertising in Asia, North
Zou, S. and Cavusgil, T.S. (2002) The GMS: a broad
America and Europe: the role of global consumer
conceptualization of global marketing strategy and
culture. Journal of Marketing, 63 (1), 75–87.
its effect on firm performance. Journal of Marketing,
Assmus, G. and Wiese, C. (1995) How to address the gray 66 (4), 40–56.
market using price coordination. Sloan Management
Review, 36 (3), 31–42.
Beamish, P.W. and Goerzen, A. (2000) The Global
Branding of Stella Artois, Case 900A19. University
of Western Ontario, Ivey School of Business, p. 23.

You might also like